HomeMy WebLinkAbout2021 11-29 CCP SpecialCouncil Special M eeting
V I RT UA L meeting being
conducted by electronic
means in accordance with
Minnesota S tatutes, section
13D.021 P ublic portion
available for connection via
telephone Dial: 1-312-626-
6799 Meeting I D:
85315419931# Passcode:
112921#
November 29, 2021
AGE NDA
1.Call to Order
The City Council requests that attendees turn off cell phones and pagers during the meeting. A
copy of the full City C ounc il packet is available to the public . The packet ring binder is loc ated at
the entrance of the council chambers.
2.Roll Call
3.Agenda Items
A.Continued discussion of Curfew Ordinance
B.Continued discussion of 2022 Budget
4.Adjourn
1
BR291-4-763891.v2
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER
EMERGENCY ORDINANCE NO. 2021-04
AN EMERGENCY ORDINANCE IMPOSING A CURFEW AND AUTHORIZING
THE EXTENSION OF THE CURFEW IF NEEDED
THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER DOES ORDAIN AS
FOLLOWS:
ARTICLE I. Preamble. The City of Brooklyn Center (“City”) experienced civil unrest in the
aftermath of the killing of Daunte Wright by police officer Kim Potter, who has since resigned
from the City’s police department (“Former Officer”). While the vast majority of those who
participated in the protests were peaceful, some took advantage of the situation to engage in a
range of criminal activities, including damage to property and looting. The City Council
reasonably anticipates the trial of the Former Officer will be occasioned by gatherings of citizens
wishing to exercise their First Amendments rights regarding the trial and the outcome. The City
is committed to protecting those expressions of free speech, while also protecting the safety of
residents and their property within the City. The City determines, based on information provided
by law enforcement and what has occurred in other communities during similar situations, there
is a high probability there will be gatherings near the City’s police station, and perhaps other
areas of the City, on the day the verdict is read. Such gatherings are anticipated regardless of the
outcome of the trial. The City Council determines it is necessary to establish a curfew associated
with the reading of the verdict in order to protect public health, safety, and welfare within the
City.
ARTICLE II. Legislative Findings. The Brooklyn Center City Council hereby finds and
determines as follows:
(a) The City Council is authorized by Section 3.06 of the City Charter to adopt emergency
regulations to protect health, safety, and welfare within the City.
(b) The trial for the Former Officer is scheduled to start on November 30, 2021. The City does
not know how long the trial will last or when the verdict will be read.
(c) It is reasonable for the City Council to anticipate that people will gather on the day the
verdict is read, and potentially in the days that follow, to express their First Amendment
rights regarding the trial and the verdict.
(d) The City has already experienced how some people attempt to take advantage of such
gatherings to foment social unrest that results in damage to property, threats to public safety,
and other unlawful activities. One of the purposes of establishing a curfew is to avoid, or at
least minimize, the types of harm caused to those living in the apartments across the street
from the police department during the unrest that followed the killing of Daunte Wright.
2
BR291-4-763891.v2
(e) The City Council reasonably expects gatherings will occur on the day the verdict is read and
determines it needs to act now to address the situation rather than waiting to call an
emergency meeting on the day the verdict is read in an attempt to react to the situation that
has already developed.
(f) Deciding in advance to impose a curfew allows the City to prepare and, more importantly,
allows those intending to gather to exercise their First Amendment rights to plan their
activities accordingly. The City desires to avoid the public confusion that occurs when a
curfew decision is not made until people have already gathered or shortly before the curfew
is to go into effect. Such delay also undermines efforts to enforce the curfew and increases
the potential for unwanted interactions between law enforcement and protesters.
(g) While the City Council can anticipate gatherings on the night the verdict is read, it is more
difficult to determine if, and for how long, those gatherings will continue. To avoid having
to call and act in multiple emergency meetings to address such a potential, and in order to
allow timely public notice, the City Council determines it is appropriate to authorize the City
Manager to determine, based on the criteria set out in this Ordinance, whether to continue the
curfew for additional nights.
ARTICLE III. Curfew.
Section 1. Imposed. A City-wide curfew for all persons within the City of Brooklyn Center
shall be imposed on the day the verdict is read in the trial of the Former Officer. The curfew
shall be in effect as of 9:30 p.m. and it shall extend until 6:00 a.m. the following day.
Section 2. Exceptions. The curfew imposed by this Ordinance does not apply to individuals
traveling directly to and from work or religious services, recognized members of community
groups authorized by the City to be present at the site of civil unrest to defuse protesters,
emergency services, law enforcement, people seeking medical care or fleeing danger, persons
experiencing homelessness, or the news media.
Section 3. Curfew Extended.
(a) Authority to Extend. The City Manager is authorized to extend the curfew imposed by
this Ordinance for up to four additional days if the City Manager determines, based on
the criteria established herein, that the continuation of the curfew is necessary to protect
public health, safety, or welfare. The curfew, if extended, shall be for the same period
and have the same exceptions as the first day of the curfew. The City Manager shall
separately evaluate the criteria each day the curfew may be imposed and, if the curfew is
extended, the decision must be made and announced in time to provide the public notice
required by this Ordinance. The City Manager shall immediately notify the City
Council whether the curfew will be extended. If the City Manager determines not to
extend the curfew, this Ordinance terminates on that day and cannot be relied upon to
impose any additional curfews.
3
BR291-4-763891.v2
(a) Criteria to Extend. The City Manager shall consider the following criteria to determine
whether to extend the curfew imposed by this Ordinance:
(1) The gatherings associated with the verdict that occurred the previous night
involved or resulted in:
(i) Multiple incidences of criminal activity including, but not limited to, assault,
theft, or property damage; and
(ii) The City was required to rely on outside law enforcement agencies to respond
to the activities arising out of the gatherings;
(2) Based on all information reasonably available to the City, the City Manager
determines it is probably the activities associated with the reading of the verdict
that occurred the previous night will continue that night; and
(3) The extension of the curfew is needed to protect public health, safety, and welfare.
Section 4. Notice. The City shall provide public notice of the period of the curfew no later than
1:00 p.m. on the day the curfew will be in effect. The methods of providing notice shall include
posting on the City’s website, sending messages on the City’s messaging platforms, and
notifying the news outlets in the area. If the City does not become aware that the verdict will be
read until after 1:00 p.m. on that day, the City shall provide notice as soon as it reasonably can
upon learning the verdict will be read.
Section 5. Enforcement. A violation of this Ordinance is a petty misdemeanor and is subject to
a fine of $50.
Section 6. Effect. This Ordinance shall be in effect on the day the verdict in the trial of the
Former Officer is read and shall end either upon the decision by the City Manager not to extend
the curfew, or four days after the reading of the verdict, whichever occurs first. The four-day
extension period shall begin on the day following the reading of the verdict.
Adopted this 22nd day of November, 2021 by a unanimous vote of the council members present.
____________________________
Mike Elliott, Mayor
ATTEST: _________________________
City Clerk
Date of Publication December 2, 2021
BR291-413-763686.v7
Member introduced the following resolution and moved its
adoption:
RESOLUTION NO. 2021-____
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA
A RESOLUTION BUDGETING FUNDS TO IMPLEMENT THE DAUNTE WRIGHT
AND KOBE DIMOCK-HEISLER COMMUNITY SAFETY AND VIOLENCE
PREVENTION ACT AND PROVIDING FURTHER DIRECTION TO THE
IMPLEMENTATION COMMITTEE
WHEREAS, the City Council acted at its May 15, 2021 meeting to adopt Resolution No.
2021-73 establishing the Daunte Wright and Kobe Dimock-Heisler Community Safety and
Violence Prevention Act (“Safety Act”); and
WHEREAS, the Safety Act directs the implementation of the Safety Act, including the
creation of an Implementation Committee, Community Response Department, Traffic
Enforcement Department, the Department of Community Safety and Violence Prevention, and the
hiring of a Director to head the Department of Community Safety and Violence Prevention; and
WHEREAS, the City has been working to implement the Safety Act, including partnering
with FUSE to secure, at little to no cost to the City, two full-time fellows that started on November
1, 2021 and are working with the City to assist with its data collection and community outreach
efforts related to implementing the Safety Act; and
WHEREAS, the City has secured other grants to support its efforts and the implementation
of the Safety Act; and
WHEREAS, the City has received well-researched information regarding the costs of
implementing the Safety Act and providing public safety services, including information from the
ACLU attached hereto as Exhibit A and information on the City’s police budget considerations
attached hereto as Exhibit B; and
WHEREAS, the City continues to seek financial assistance to implement the Safety Act,
but it is necessary to allocate funds as part of the 2022 budget in order to continue the work to
implement the Safety Act; and
WHEREAS, the City Council finds and determines as follows:
(a) Kerner Commission recognized more than 50 years ago that the deep social and economic
disparities that result from discrimination and racism must be addressed through massive
investments to actually achieve public safety;
(b) The City Council recognizes that its efforts at alternative response is important yet is still
reactionary and recognizes that preventative action and investment in social support is
proactive and necessary to attain true public safety and reduce the burden on or need for
emergency response systems, including Food Deserts, Transportation within the City and
BR291-413-763686.v7
access to current resources; political participation by marginalized communities; ways to
enhance current services and remove barriers to access; and
(c) Research has demonstrated programs that uplift, provide opportunities for health and
meaningful skills building and education effectively decreases crime; and
WHEREAS, allocating more funds than originally indicated in the proposed budget is
necessary to carry out the City Council’s commitment to putting in place the measures set out in
the Safety Act and for advancing its efforts to make the City a safer place to live and work for
everyone; and
WHEREAS, the City currently has more than $1,300,000 budgeted for positions that are
currently vacant; and
WHEREAS, the Implementation Committee is charged with the duty to develop and make
recommendations to the City Council on the implementation of the Safety Act. In carrying out its
work, it is important for the Implementation Committee to identify ways in which to build on
existing resources within the community, collaborate with a wide range of partners, identify ways
to ensure the continuity and sustainability of the programs it recommends, and to serve the needs
of the whole individual; and
WHEREAS, the City Council desire to provide further direction to the Implementation
Committee to help ensure the Safety Act is implemented in a manner that is consistent with the
City Council’s expectations.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by the City Council of the City of Brooklyn
Center as follows:
1. The City of Brooklyn Center’s proposed 2022 budget shall be revised to budget $1,220,000
from the general fund to the implementation of the Safety Act. The allocation of the budgeted
amount shall include the following:
Description 2022 Budget Amount
Department of Community Safety
and Violence Prevention
$950,000
Community Programming and
Supportive Programs
$350,000
Traffic Enforcement Department
and Pilot Study
$270,000
Implementation Committee $150,000
Director of the Department of
Community Safety and Violence
Prevention Position
$150,000
BR291-413-763686.v7
Sub Total $1,870,000
From Grants -$500,000
From CM Proposed Budget Line
Item
-$150,000
From Budget Unfilled Positions $1,220,000
2. The funds to be budgeted for Safety Act implementation under this Resolution shall, to the
greatest extent possible, be transferred from funds allocated to current City staff vacancies,
while ensuring the City maintains at least the current level of public services.
3. The City Manager is authorized and directed to revise the proposed 2022 budget to reflect the
budget allocations contained within this Resolution and to take all other steps necessary to be
able to present the revised budget at the public hearing scheduled for December 6, 2021, which
may be continued to December 13, 2021 if needed.
4. The Implementation Committee, in performing its work as directed in the Safety Act, shall
consider the range of issues that affect public safety including, but not limited to, the conditions
that drive, contribute, and lead to public safety issues; a framework for social and economic
justice policies and plans; youth and community programming in health, technology, financial,
and education; tutoring and mentoring options focused on a whole-person approach to provide
hope and critical crime prevention and healthy community supports; and a design for the City’s
public safety departments that identifies and integrates systems to address the whole needs of
the City’s residents in a comprehensive way.
November 22, 2021
Date Mayor
ATTEST:
City Clerk
The motion for the adoption of the foregoing resolution was duly seconded by member
and upon vote being taken thereon, the following voted in favor thereof:
and the following voted against the same:
whereupon said resolution was declared duly passed and adopted.
BR291-413-763686.v7
EXHIBIT A
ACLU Budget Testimony Dated November 12, 2021
[attached hereto]
Budget Testimony
To:Brooklyn Center City Council and other City Officials
From:ACLU of Minnesota and National ACLU
Date:11/12/21
Subject:Budget Proposal, Daunte Wright and Kobe Dimock-Heisler Community Safety Act
Summary
At the request of Mayor Mike Elliot, the ACLU is submitting this testimony providing
suggestions regarding the City of Brooklyn Center ’s funding for the Daunte Wright and Kobe
Dimock-Heisler Community Safety Resolution. We urge the Council to consider ways to
adequately fund this visionary Act to ensure it is as impactful as Council Members intended .
We suggest that Brooklyn Center commit at least $1.5m in the FY22-23 budget toward
implementing the most important policy goals as a foundation to the Resolution. $1.5m is 7% of
the City's overall budget1 and 15% of the City's overall policing budget.2 That amount is a
significant first-year commitment that will both result in (1) immediate impacts for Brooklyn
Center residents this year; and (2) allow BC to lay a strong foundation for the safe and successful
implementation of the Resolution for years to come.
One of the most famous quotes to come out of the uprisings and protests of the past year is that
“Budgets are Moral Documents.” What a city values, prioritizes, and the direction it is headed
can all be seen in the allocation of money and resources within its budgets.We strongly
encourage all Brooklyn Center city officials to take the legal commitments they already passed in
the Resolution seriously and to work to provide meaningful funding to build this far-sighted new
model of public safety. The City Council — and the residents they represent —
overwhelmingly supported the Resolution,3 and we’re confident you’ll now be equally
committed to funding it.
3 https://drive.google.com/file/d/1sYEkGfWIfeW0Q_bpjm0e8CTmDxJCIEEW/view
2
https://ccxmedia.org/news/brooklyn-center-approves-preliminary-budget-in-4-0-vote-mayor-elliott-abstains
/
1
https://www.hometownsource.com/sun_post/news/government/brooklyn-center-approves-1-3-million-preli
minary-budget-levy-increase-for-2022/article_87a30b74-2b6e-11ec-a20e-b71d4f4078fc.html
1
Funding Priorities:
Policy Objectives
Estimated
Cost
Policy
Objective 1:Fully fund Community Response Department
$823k
Policy
Objective 2:Funding for hiring a Director of Community Safety and Violence
Prevention
$150k
Policy
Objective 3:Funding for the Implementation Committee
$150k
Policy
Objective 4:Funding for Community Programming and Supportive Programs
$350k
Policy
Objective 5:Fund Traffic Enforcement Department Pilot Study
$20,000
The ACLU recommends that Brooklyn Center focus on the following five priorities for year one
funding:
1)Fully fund the new Community Response Department
a)The Community Response Team will serve a range of functions. Specifically, it
will provide critical and appropriate responses to situations that not only don’t
require armed law enforcement, but are too often escalated by armed officers
(including when a resident is primarily experiencing a medical, mental health,
disability-related, or other behavioral or social need).
b)The Community Response Team will work proactively with residents to offer
supports such as conflict resolution and suicide prevention, as well as providing
and connecting people with wrap-around services such as housing programs,
substance treatment, etc.
i)The Law Enforcement Action Partnership conducted a quantitative
analysis that examined, among other factors, the population in Brooklyn
Center and the cost of similar programs in cities like Denver, Colo., and
2
Eugene, Ore. LEAP estimated4 it would cost approximately $823,333 to
fully fund the program (which would include 24/7 in-person responder
teams with five teams of two), which is only 8% of the $9.6 million5
budget the city has allocated to the police department.
2)Hire a Director of the Community Safety Department
a)In order to effectively and successfully implement the resolution, the City must
budget for and hire a Director for the new Community Safety and Violence
Prevention Department, which will contain the two existing public safety
departments (fire and police) and the two new departments (traffic enforcement
and community response). Hiring the Director is paramount as the city begins to
develop, fund, and implement its new model of public safety.
3)Fund the Implementation Committee
a)The implementation committee is responsible for drafting any and all
amendments, ordinances, resolutions, policies, guidelines or other
recommendations for review, adoption, and/or implementation by City Council or
City Staff. It’s necessary to provide stipends to the residents and experts who will
sit on the committee and provide any additional resources the committee may
need (e.g. for research, data analysis, community outreach, etc.) in order for the
implementation to move forward in a timely and effective manner.
4)Provide Community Programs, Resources
a)Community-based, life-affirming, and supportive services such as housing,health
care,jobs programs,education,after-school programs,environmental design, and
violence interruption programs have all been proven to disrupt and reduce
violence. It’s imperative the City provide the Brooklyn Center community these
resources via community programming that residents need not only to survive but
thrive.
i)In particular, this funding should go to aiding the residents of Humboldt
Court and Stirling Square - for example, for youth programming, job
training, senior care services, and improving infrastructure and community
environments.
(1)This is to help address the issues of those (in Humboldt and
Stirling apartments) most affected by the Protests earlier this
spring.
5)Conduct a Civilian Traffic Enforcement Pilot Study
a)The resolution is ambitious and groundbreaking, and it’s already provided an
exciting opportunity for Brooklyn Center to serve as a model for the state and
5
https://www.hometownsource.com/sun_post/news/government/brooklyn-center-approves-1-3-million-preli
minary-budget-levy-increase-for-2022/article_87a30b74-2b6e-11ec-a20e-b71d4f4078fc.html&sa=D&sour
ce=docs&ust=1636581687365000&usg=AOvVaw1lW8K-MDnORyidUVewc2Jt
4 https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/10TXiTKlnk48xtcIxhe2BXcbvyBDMKthHaGg9A0vOn5Q/edit
3
nation. This multi-year effort will require studies and research. While cities
across the country are working on deploying civilian traffic enforcement teams,
most are still in the pilot phase, so there’s limited data. In order to develop and
build this department in Brooklyn Center, the City should first fund a pilot study
that will allow it to appropriately and accurately allocate money to fully fund this
new department.
Suggested Budget Model
1)Maintain current staffing level of Police Department
a)Transfer the previously allocated money for hiring more police to funding
the aforementioned policy priorities
b)City would then be able to divert approximately $1.5 million toward
resolution implementation
Since the Resolution explicitly requires the city to fully implement6 all of the components of
the resolution, it is incumbent that city officials work together this budget cycle to analyze the
current city and Police Department budget and determine where the best sources of funding
should come from. Since the majority of police funding comes from personnel costs, specifically
salaries and benefits, the best way to find additional funding is by simply not hiring for the
numerous open positions that exist and have been budgeted for.
The figure below illustrates the difference in the breakdown of the current 2022 budget and our
suggested model, which includes diverting approximately $1.5 million toward the varying
programs, services, and departments outlined in the resolution.( Graphic Below)
6
http://www.mediaaccess.info/brooklyncenter/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/Community-Safety-and-Violenc
e-Prevention-Resolution.pdf
4
Budget Considerations
1.As alternative programs, specifically the community response and traffic enforcement
departments, begin to function at full capacity,police officers will be asked to respond
to fewer incidents, thus decreasing the need for such high police staffing and funding.
2.Based on data from other cities that have implemented similar models,these alternative
programs could save the city thousands or potentially millions in ambulance and
emergency hospitalization costs alone.7
3.Increased police budgets do not correlate to safer communities8 and have no
connection to rates of violence9
4.However, inadequate social service funding increases rates of violence10
10 https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/7/10/e016379
9
https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2020/06/07/over-past-60-years-more-spending-police-hasnt-nec
essarily-meant-less-crime/
8
https://www.thedailybeast.com/fentanyl-guns-and-murder-mean-you-should-get-ready-for-a-bloody-summ
er
7 https://www.latimes.com/world-nation/story/2020-06-12/portland-eugene-defund-police-alternative
5
Conclusion
The Brooklyn Center City Council passed the Daunte and Kobe resolution and now has the
responsibility and the opportunity to ensure this resolution is fully realized. To make this
resolution as successful as possible, the ACLU of MN and ACLU National recommend:
●Brooklyn Center officials commit at least $1.5m in the FY22-23 budget toward funding
the Community Safety Act
●Ensure the five policy goals outlined above are deemed funding priorities that include,
but are not limited to, repurposing money from currently vacant Full-Time Employees in
the Police Department
●Council Members, staff or community members in need of a more comprehensive budget
analysis should instruct the City Manager or any other proper authority in charge of
budgetary functions to provide more information and analysis on all possible options.
The ACLU looks forward to continuing its work with the Council and community on
implementation of the resolution. We would be happy to submit additional testimony at the
request of Council and/or as additional budgetary and fiscal estimate data become available.
The Resolution and the public support behind it (as shown in this poll11) indicates a clear
mandate for the Council to act and follow through on their past commitments to the people of
Brooklyn Center to make all residents safe.
Thank you,
ACLU of Minnesota
National ACLU
11 https://drive.google.com/file/d/1sYEkGfWIfeW0Q_bpjm0e8CTmDxJCIEEW/view
6
BR291-413-763686.v7
EXHIBIT B
Brooklyn Center Policing Budget Considerations
[attached hereto]
11/22/2021
1
2022 Annual Preliminary Budget
Continued Public Safety Discussion
October 8, 2018
Review
City Council November 22, 2021
Dr. Reggie Edwards, City Manager
Presentation Purpose
•Introduction
•Need
•Strategies To Meet Need
•Police Cost
•Police Service Impact
•2022 Fiscal Direction
•Questions
2
11/22/2021
2
Introduction
Expertise
•Lived Experience
•Educated and Trained Experience
•Professional Management Experience
3
The Need (Beyond Brooklyn Center)
•Eliminate Systemic Racism
•Eliminate Inequalities
•Prevent the Lose of Life by Police
•Shift of Mindset, Structures, Patterns of Behavior Related to
Systemic Racism and Inequalities
•Build Community Trust Particularly Those Historically
Marginalized
•Feel of Safe and Protected
4
11/22/2021
3
Strategies Proposed To Address Need
Public Safety Act (Patterns of Behavior and Structure Change)
•Unarmed Personnel Non‐Motorize Traffic Offenses
•Community Response –Unarmed Mental Health and Social Worker Practioners Address
911 Calls for Mental Health, Social and Medical.
•Citation and Summons Instead of Arrest for Some Misdemeanor Offenses
•Personal Scenario
City Efforts Underway (Patterns of Behavior, Structure and Mindset Change)
•Public Health (i.e. Health on the Go, Mental Health, and Embedded Social Worker)
•Prevention ‐Youth Health Violence Prevention
•Fire Department –Medical 911 Calls
•Community Transformational Change Innovation Process (Evolving Brooklyn
Center – 2022 Year)
5
Police Services Cost
October 8, 2018
Review
11/22/2021
4
Cost of Policing in Brooklyn Center
7
Met Council 2019
City Est. Population PD Expenses General Fund Exp. Ratio Source
Shoreview 26,695 2,479,250.00 11,965,378.00 20.72%2020 final
Golden Valley 22,715 6,732,035.00 23,532,695.00 28.61%2021 adopted
Crystal 23,262 6,742,843.00 17,303,181.00 38.97%2021 adopted
Richfield 36,993 10,926,920.00 27,868,330.00 39.21%2022 proposed
Fridley 29,374 7,414,180.00 18,564,290.00 39.94%2021 adopted
Brooklyn Center 32,722 9,986,134.00 24,822,696.00 40.23%2022 proposed
White Bear Lake 25,362 5,002,617.00 12,115,591.00 41.29%2021 budget
New Hope 22,376 7,113,886.00 15,936,977.00 44.64%2021 adopted
Maplewood 41,738 10,413,750.00 22,673,770.00 45.93%2021 adopted
Roseville 36,644 8,811,445.00 18,022,285.00 48.89%2021 adopted
PD Represent Approx.
9‐10% of $100M Total
City Budget
Cost of Policing in Brooklyn Center
8
0.00% 10.00% 20.00% 30.00% 40.00% 50.00% 60.00%
Shoreview
Golden Valley
Crystal
Richfield
Fridley
Brooklyn Center
White Bear Lake
New Hope
Maplewood
Roseville
Ratio
Brooklyn Center 40.23%
of General Fund or Rank
6th Among Ten
Comparable Cities (2021
Budgets)
11/22/2021
5
Police Services Impact
October 8, 2018
Review
Rate of Violent Crime per 100,000 people
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500
Brooklyn Center PD
Brooklyn Park PD
Champlin PD
Columbia Heights PD
Crystal PD
Fridley PD
New Hope PD
St Louis Park PD
2018
2019
2020
* Violent Crime includes: Murder, Rape, Robbery and Aggravated Assault
11/22/2021
6
Rate of Property Crime per 100,000 people
0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500 4000 4500 5000
Brooklyn Center PD
Brooklyn Park PD
Champlin PD
Columbia Heights PD
Crystal PD
Fridley PD
New Hope PD
St Louis Park PD
2018
2019
2020
* Property Crime includes: Burglary, Larceny, Auto Theft, Arson and Human Trafficking
Rate of Part 2 Crime per 100,000 people
0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000
Brooklyn Center PD
Brooklyn Park PD
Champlin PD
Columbia Heights PD
Crystal PD
Fridley PD
New Hope PD
St Louis Park PD
2018
2019
2020
* Part 2 Crime includes: Other Assaults, Forgery, Embezzlement, Stolen Property, Vandalism,
Weapons, Prostitution, Other sex offenses, Narcotics, Gambling, Family offenses, DUI, Liquor
Laws, Disorderly Conduct and Other offenses (excluding traffic)
11/22/2021
7
BC Community
Survey
2012
What do you think is the
most serious issue facing
Brooklyn Center today?
13
BC Community Survey
2017
What do you think is the
most serious issue facing
Brooklyn Center today?
•DON’T KNOW/REFUSED......7%
•NOTHING................16%
•LACK OF JOBS...........11%
•LACK OF BUSINESSES......9%
•CRIME..................22%
•FORECLOSURES............7%
•HIGH TAXES..............8%
•DIVERSITY...............6%
•RUNDOWN PROPERTIES......6%
•LOW INCOME HOUSING......7%
•SCATTERED...............2%
14
11/22/2021
8
Community Survey 2008 - 2012
15
Community Survey 2017
16
11/22/2021
9
Police Department Budgeted Unfilled Positions
14 Positions
$1,303,284
17
18
11/22/2021
10
19
Policing Service Implications
•What don’t we get with the current level of 34 police officers:
•No community engagement
•Reduction in proactive law enforcement, including traffic stops (motorized or moving) and response related to crime trends.
•Patrol minimums vary throughout the day as calls for service increase and decrease. In summary, having 20
patrol officers would affect the schedule by forcing us to consistently be at minimum staffing until that
changes. It would be extremely challenging to train, allow for vacation, and officer wellness programs would
have to be suspended. There are always sick calls and this would have to be filled with overtime call‐backs
and forced overtime.
•Having four sergeants would mean time periods with no patrol supervision. There are four rotating 12 hour
shifts (two days and two nights) –if one shift is working the other shift is off. If one sergeant takes the day off,
has training, or is sick, we will have no supervision.
•The Street Crimes Unit is the group of officers dedicated to be law enforcement liaisons with business owners
and hotel managers. Without SCU there will be no proactive law enforcement liaisons in the business areas.
•Comparing the wages (savings) of a police officer to taking parking complaints, responding to abandoned
vehicles and similar calls for service as the previous presenter did very is misleading. The police department
doesn’t send police officers to those calls, but Community Service Officers (CSOs) who are unarmed, part‐
time staff with an average wage of $19/hour and non‐benefit earning.
20
11/22/2021
11
Policing Service Implications
Pre April 11, 2021
•Calls for service were holding for an average of 9 minutes 50 seconds.
•Average response times to the calls for service were 9 minutes 52 seconds.
As of September 1, 2021
•Calls for service were holding for an average of 17 minutes 58 seconds.
•Average response times to the calls for service were 10 minutes 47
seconds.
•The data above reflects an 83% increase for holding time and almost a 10%
increase for response time. The comparison data is from 2 months ago.
•Calls are not 1:1, police must respond to certain calls, and the type of call such
as violent crime require multiple police respondents.
21
2022 Fiscal Direction
October 8, 2018
Review
11/22/2021
12
Brooklyn Center Vision and Mission
Vision Statement ‐We envision Brooklyn Center as a thriving,
diverse community with a full range of housing, business, cultural
and recreational offerings. It is a safe and inclusive place that
people of all ages love to call home, and visitors enjoy due to its
convenient location and commitment to a healthy environment.
Mission Statement ‐The mission of the City of Brooklyn Center is
to ensure an attractive, clean, safe, and inclusive community that
enhances the quality of life for all people and preserves the public
trust.
23
Brooklyn Center Strategic Priorities
•Enhanced Community Image
•Resident Economic Stability
•Inclusive Community Engagement
•Targeted Redevelopment
•Key Transportation Investments
24
11/22/2021
13
2022 City Budget Priorities
•Equitable Operations‐Enterprise
Wide
•Innovation‐Enterprise Wide
•Public Health‐Community
•Tax Burden Relief
•Beautification and Cleanliness‐
Community
•Economic Stability‐Businesses
•Economic Stability‐Residents
•Engagement‐Enterprise Wide
25
26
City Council
Police
Department
Residents
Fire
Department
Office of
Inclusion, Equity
and Diversity
City
Manager
Department of
Administration
Public Works
Department
Department of
Community
Development
Office of
Prevention,
Health & Safety
Department of
Financial
Services e
Advisory
Committee
11/22/2021
14
Office of Community Prevention, Health and Safety
Mission –To provide leadership, programming,
coordination and evaluation of prevention, health
and safety across the enterprise and in the
community. Coordination of efforts within the
enterprise shall focus principally on all public safety
related departments.
27
Functions
•Prevention, Health and Community Safety Program
management and coordination
•Civilian Traffic Enforcement Division –Unarmed civilian
personnel response to non‐moving (motor not running)
traffic violations.
•Community Response Division ‐Community mental health
911 and community health response .
28
11/22/2021
15
Department Budget Highlights
•Initial start with coordination across the enterprise
•Pilot civilian traffic response grant funded for two years
•Pilot mental health 911 calls and community response
grant funded for two years
•Initiate data analysis and communication
29
30
Cities
Population (2020
Census)
Persons Below
Poverty Level (2015‐
2019 ACS)
Per Capita Income
(2019 dollars)
Median Housing Value
(2019 Dollars)
Champlin 23,919 5.00% $ 40,600.00 $ 237,800.00
Crystal 23,330 7.60% $ 33,800.00 $ 197,300.00
Fridley 29,590 9.60% $ 31,600.00 $ 198,200.00
Golden Valley 22,552 6.10% $ 57,600.00 $ 304,700.00
Maplewood 42,088 8.60% $ 33,800.00 $ 217,300.00
New Hope 21,986 10.00% $ 32,800.00 $ 225,100.00
Roseville 36,254 8.90% $ 38,700.00 $ 254,200.00
Shoreview 26,921 4.00% $ 48,800.00 $ 275,800.00
White Bear 24,883 5.70% $ 71,700.00 $ 226,000.00
Brooklyn Center 33,782 15.10% $ 24,900.00 $ 172,800.00
Brooklyn Park 86,478 8.40% $ 31,900.00 $ 224,300.00
11/22/2021
16
Department Budget by Program
31
Function 2022 2023
Office Manager and operations $154,850 $154,850
Pilot civilian traffic response grant funded $250,000 $250,000
Pilot mental health 911 calls and community
response grant funded
$250,000 $250,000
Community Transformational Change Innovation
Process (Evolving Brooklyn Center)
$225,000 $225,000
Total $879,850 $879,850
City Related 2022 –2023 Budget
32
Action 2022 2023
Implementation Committee Project Manager 80,000
FUSE Fellows 300,000
Office space Implementation Project Mgr./FUSE Fellows 10,000
Office of Prevention (i.e. Community Response Pilot, Traffic
Enforcement Pilot and Community Transformational Change
Innovation)
$879,850 $879,850
Cities United –Youth Gun Violence Prevention 30,000 30,000
New Health Focus Embedded in Recreation Department 50,0000 50,000
Office of Inclusion, Equity and Antiracism 150,000 150,000
Total Investment $1,499,850 $1,109,850
$2,609,700
Two Year
Investment
11/22/2021
17
2022 Proposed Budget Highlights
•Create Office
•Pilot Efforts
•Combine Mental Health Models
•Maintain Public Safety
•Transformational Change
•Fiscally Responsible and within the Means of the City
33
The preliminary budget is based on hearing the Council articulate a need
for policing service need, public health and well‐being and crime
prevention priorities.
The preliminary budget is based on strategies to address these multi‐
variate and dynamic priorities without diminishing the quality of service
delivery.
The preliminary budget is based upon seeking innovative strategies to
address the needs articulated by the Council in an innovative, cost efficient
and service outcome effective manner.
34
2022 Proposed Budget Highlights
11/22/2021
18
Questions ?
35