HomeMy WebLinkAbout2007 10-01 CCP Special Session SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
City of Brooklyn Center
October 1, 2007 AGENDA
L Call to Order
—The City Council requests that attendees turn off cell phones and pagers during the meeting.
A copy of the full City Council packet is available to the public. The packet ring binder is
located at the front of the Council Chambers by the Secretary.
2. Roll Call
3. Hearing for Brooklyn Center Leased Housing Associates, LLC
—Center Pointe Apartments, 2802-2834, 2900-2940 Northway Dr
4. Adjournment
MEMORANDUM
TO: Mayor and City Council
FROM: Curt Boganey, City Manager
DATE: September 28, 2007
SUBJECT: Brooklyn Center Leased Housing Associates, LLC
Recommendation:
A hearing has been set as provided in Section 12-910 of the City Code of Ordinances
(atta.ched). The ordinance provides that following a hearing of the facts, the Council may
revoke, suspend, or decline to renew any rental license issued under Chapter 12 of the
City Code of Ordinances. It is recommended that the Council hear the evidence
presented by each party and determine if the current license for the subject licensee be
revoked or suspended.
Background:
The license for the subject applicant was renewed in January of 2007 after a lengthy
inspection and re-inspection process. Subsequent to renewal, the applicant was notified
of several new and continuing violations of the City ordinance. On September 10, 2007,
the Council set a hearing date of October 1, 2007, to determine if the facts related to this
case warrant Council action to revoke or suspend the rental license for the subject
property. The licensee has been given written notice and alleged grounds for action
(attached).
At the hearing, staff will present evidence of the allegations and cause for Council action.
The licensee will be given an opportunity to show why Council action to revoke or
suspend should not be taken. Having heard all the evidence, the City Council will be
asked to make a finding of facts and determine the appropriate response to the staff
statements and evidence.
Section 12-910. LICENSE SUSPENSION, REVOCATION, DENIAL AND NON-
RENEWAL.
1. Every license issued under the provisions of this Chapter is subject to suspension or
revocation by the City Council.
2. In the event that a license is suspended or revoked by the City Council, it shall be
unlawful for the owner or the owner's duly authorized agent to thereafter permit any
new occupancies of vacant or thereafter vacated rental units until such time as a valid
license may be restored by the City Council.
3. Any person violating this section shall be guilty of a misdemeanor, and upon
conviction thereof shall be punished by a fine of not more than one thousand dollars
($1,000) or by imprisonment not to exceed ninety (90) days or both, together with the
costs of prosecution. Each day of each violation shall constitute a separate
punishable offense.
4. The Council may revoke, suspend or decline to renew any license issued under this
Chapter upon any of the following grounds:
a. false statements on any application or other information or report
required by this Chapter to be given by the applicant or licensee.
b. failure to pay any application, penalty, reinspection or reinstatement
fee required by this Chapter and City Council resolution.
c. failure to correct deficiencies noted in notices of violation in the time
specified in the notice.
d. failure to comply with the provisions of an approved mitigation plan
in the case of provisional licenses.
e. failure to operate or maintain the licensed premises in conformity
with all a�plicable state laws and codes and this Code of Ordinances.
f. any other violation of this Chapter.
5. Revocation, suspension and non-renewal may be brought under either this
Section or Section 12-911, or both.
6. A regular license may be revoked at the end of any six-month review period,
as described in section 12-901(2) or at the end of the two-year term upon a
finding that the licensed premises are only eligible for a provisionallicense as
provided in Section 12-913.
7. A decision to revoke, suspend, deny or not renew a license shall be preceded by
written notice to the applicant or licensee of the alleged grounds therefor and the
applicant or licensee will be given an opportunity for a hearing before the City
Council before final action to revoke, suspend, deny or not renew a license. The
Council sha11 give due regard to the frequency and seriousness of violations, the ease
with which such violations could have been cured or avoided and good faith efforts
to comply and shall issue a decision to deny, not renew, suspend or revoke a license
only upon written findings.
8. The Council may suspend or revoke a license or not renew a license for part or all of
a facility.
9. Licenses may be suspended for up to ninety (90) days and may, after the period of
suspension, be reinstated subject to compliance with this Chapter and any conditions
imposed by the City Council at the time of suspension. Licenses that are revoked
will not be reinstated until the owner has applied for and secured a new license and
complied with all conditions imposed at the time of revocation. Upon a decision to
o new a lication for the same facility will be
revoke den or not renew a license n
Y PP
accepted for the period of time specified in the Council's written decision, which
shall not exceed one year. A decision not to renew a license may take the form of a
suspension or revocation. A decision to deny an initial application for a new facility
will not take the form of a suspension or revocation unless false statements have been
made by the applicant in connection with the application. A decision to deny an
initial application shall state conditions of reapplication. All new applications must
I
be accompanied by a reinstatement fee, as specified by Council resolution, in
n to all other fees re uired b this Cha ter.
addrtio P
q Y
10. A written decision to revoke, suspend, deny or not renew a license or application
shall specify the part or parts of the facility to which it applies. Thereafter, and until
a license is reissued or reinstated, no rental units becoming vacant in such part or
parts of the facility may be relet or occupied. Revocation, suspension or non-renewal
of a license shall not excuse the owner from compliance with all terms of state laws
and codes and this Code of Ordinances for as long as any units in the facility are
occupied. Failure to comply with all terms of this Chapter during the term of
sus ension or non-renewal is a misdemeanor and grounds for extension
revocation, p
of the term of such revocation or suspension or continuation of non-renewal, or for a
ns on the eriod of
decision not to remstate the license, notwithstandmg any limitatio p
suspension, revocation or non-renewal specified in the City Council's written
decision or in paragraph 8. of this Section.
24 August 2007
VIA FACSIMILE 763.354.5519
and Registered U.S. Mail
Jack W. Safar
David L. Brierton
Armand E. Brachman
Paul R. Sween
Dominium Management Services
2355 Polaris Lane, Suite 100
Plymouth, Minnesota 55447
VIA FACSIMILE 763.413.5174
and Registered U.S. Mail
Kenneth Hertz
Hertz Law Offices, P.A.
3853 Central Avenue, N.E.
Columbia Heights, Minnesota 55421
RE: Centerpoint license suspension/revocation
Gentlemen,
A hearing upon the suspension/revocation of the rental license held by
Brooklyn Center Leased Housing Associates, LLP, will be held at 7pm on Monday
24 September 2007 at the Brooklyn Center City Hall.
Safar et a124 August 2007 p. 2.
Pursuant to City Ordinance 12-201, an owner of property is any person or
entity having a legal or equitable interest in the property. Pursuant to City
Ordinance 12-12-301, no owners shall permit or allow any tenancy unless the
premises are clean, sanitary, fit for human occupancy and comply with all
applicable legal requirements of the State of Minnesota and the City.
A rental license is subject to suspension or revocation upon several grounds,
including but not limited to, failure to correct deficiencies noted in violation
notices, failure to operate or maintain the property in conformity with all applicable
laws and ordinances and any violation of city ordinances.
The grounds for this action include failure of the owners to abide by the
compliance orders from the City, issued in November 2006, as a condition of
license renewal, failure of the owners to abate the violations noted by NI��'A,
failure to promptly pay for natural gas and water/sewer utilities, failure to pay the
year 2007 real property taxes, failure to maintain the premises in conformity with
Chapter 12, a major violation of which is the continuing lack of operating security
doors and locks, failure to properly conduct tenant background checks, as noted by
MHFA and the continued high rates of police calls for service and rates of premises
crime.
These very serious violations were brought to the attention of Asgher Jaweed
in a meeting with the City Manger, Building Official, Community Development
Director, Sergeant Roth and the undersigned in February 2007 to unmistakably
impress upon the owners the seriousness of the situation and in further hope that
the owners would recognize their responsibilities and ensure that the premises
would be operated and maintained in conformity with all laws.
The statistics as to calls for service and premises crime are set forth in the
Notice of Abatement, previously served upon you. Additional documentation of
these statistics is available at the Brooklyn Center Police Department and is
generally public information.
The failure of the owners to maintain the properiy in compliance with State
law and City ordinance and to correct deficiencies and abate code violations is
evidenced by the attached criminal complaints and compliance notices from the
City and MHFA. MHFA advises that these code violations have not been
corrected and
Safar et al 24 August 2007 p. 3.
tliat the owners have requested additional time to comply. Also attached are
reports documenting the failure of the owners to abide by the terms of the license
and applicable laws.
Sincerely,
CARSON, CLELLAND SCHREDER
William G. Clelland
cc City
GAI�SON, GLELLAND SGHl�EDEP�
ATTOPNEYS AT LAW
PROFESSIONAL LIMITED LIABILITY PARTNERSHIP
JEFFREY A. CARSON 6300 SHINGLE CREEK PARKWAY, SUITE 305 TELEPHONE
763 561-2800
WI�LIAM G. CLELLAND
MINNEAPOLIS. MINNESOTA 5 5430-2 1 90 FAX
ELLEN M. SCHREDER
(763) 561-1943
DAVID K. ROSS
DAWN E. SPELTZ
JOHN J. THAMES 1 October �o0 1
Mayor and City Council Meinbers
RE; Proposed action against the rental license held by Brooklyn Center Leased
Housing Associates, Limited Partnerslup for Centerpoint Apartments.
Dear Mayor and Council Members,
The City Staff has recommended that tlie Council consider action against the
rental license of Brooklyn Center Leased Housing Associates, Lunited Partnerslup,
pursuailt to the provisions of City ordulance Cha�ter 12 for the reasons outlined in
this �resentation, supported by e�iibits and testi�nony.
City ordinance 12-201 sets forth the purpose of Chapter 12 as providing for
the character and stability of buildings in the City, prevention and correctlon of al�
conditions likely to adversely affect tlie health, safety and welfare of persons
occupying buildings in the City, providing for minunum standards of habitability for
the welfare of the occupants and to preserve tlie maintenance of buildings and to
prevent the existence of slums and blight, thereby preserving the value of property.
Section 12-900 provides that the ptupose of licensing is to assure that rental housing
is decent and safe and operated such so that it does not become a nuisance in the
neighborhood or fosters blight or deterioration and operators of such properties have
tlle duty to take reasonable steps to assure, for the occupants, that they may have the
quiet enjoyment of the property in surroluldings wlucll are safe and secure.
To these ends, City ordinance 12-301 provides no person sllall let or allow
occupancy of any buildulg unless the premises are clean, sanitary, fit for humall
occupa.ncy and comply with all ap�licable legal regl.ilatioils of the State of
Mil�nesota and the City of Brooklyn Center.
1
Sections 12-304 tllrough 12-805 provide for minimlun but specific standards
of habitability and in particular, 12-408 requires safe and functioning locks and
lociced building entrances.
Chapter 19 prolubits a pro�erty owner from allowing a public nuisance on
land he owns or controls and Chapter 3, wluch adopts the State Building Code, in
section 3-102E, declares, as a public nuisance, any building wluch is hazardous to i
health, safety or public welfaxe by reason of inadequate maintenance or dilapidation.
Section 12-911 llnposes a.i1 affinnative duty upon tlle owner to prevent the
premises from becozning disorderly by reason of crune as does Minilesota Statutes
Section 617.81.
The evidence for you to consider is in tlie book before you and the testunony
you will hear and three videos you will see. These videos were taken in April,
May and June 2007 by the police. It shows you the actual conditions at Centerpoint
at tlus time. The disc containulg tlie video is included at tab 1.
You will also heax the chronology of how Centerpoint ca�ne to this
deplorable condition.
The timeline is that the Centerpoint license was due for renewal in late 2006.
I�z Oct 2006, Community Development conducted its usual unit by unit inspection
and found numerous housing maintenance and building code violations and issued a
lengthy compliance order which is at tab 2 and which required correction by 6
November 2006. Many code violations were made by the licensee and the license
was renewed in January 2007 but with an additional set of compliance orders, at tab
2.
The licensee did not address the issue of the premises crune and lugh levels I
of calls for service. I
The City Manager called a meeting witll Asgher Jaweed on 22 February
2007, attended by Building Official Larry Martin, Lt. Benner, Commwuty
Development Director Brad Hoffinan and Sgt. Roth, to personally discuss the
continuing lugh levels of crune and code violations and to hear lus plan for
abatement.
2
In May, 2007, the Mimiesota Housing Finance Agency, (MHFA), which has
regulatory authority over Centerpoint, conducted its own inspection of the premises
and found numerous and serious housing inaintenance violations, including the lack
of secure asld locking exterior doors, inissing smolce detectors, cockroach infestation
and the like. That report is at tab 3.
The City staff itself noted additional housing maintenance and code violations
and issued additional compliance orders, at tab 4.
Due to the lack of code compliance and nuisance abatement, criminal charges
were brougllt against Hyder Jaweed and Asgher Jaweed, the natural persons ownulg
i an interest u1 the licensee, set forth at tab 5.
A Notice of Abatement was also served Lipon Jaweed and his attorney did
provide what was described as a mitigation plan. Both documents are at tab 6.
One of the most significant housing code violations is tlie lack of secure and
lockuzg exterior doors. The evidence will show that in many cases, the locks are
broken or entirely inissing and the locks are suc11 that they can be jamm.ed by
insertion of a coin or paper. T11e police contend that the knowledge tliat any person
can enter the buildlllgs and commit crime is a maj or factor in the high levels of
crime and calls for service. Many notices of the high levels of crime and the lack of
secure exterior doors and working locks has been brought to the attention of the
owners, including Jaweed personally and these notices are attached at tab 7.
Further, when the licensee clauned that the locks and doors had been fixed, Lt.
Benner made a personal inspection on 9 August 2007 and he found that many
exterior door locks were actually missing or brolcen or disabled by insertion of coins
and tlie premises were fully open to any person. See lus report at tab 8.
Tlle lugh rates of critne have continued, despite numerous notices to the
licensee and Jaweed about the lugh levels of crime and their legal duty to prevent
tlus. At tab 9, are the statistical grids showing that the police keep statistics for 53
apartinent coinplexes of 5 uiuts or more and there are appro�nately 3,200
apartment units in tlus group. At 252 units, Centerpoint has 7.7% of tlus group but
accounts for 24% of all police calls to these 53 apartments. These statistics also
c m lexes of com arable size and a e and
com are Ceilte oint with tllree otller o g
P
P P
I show that the calls for service at Centerpoint axe consistently higher. These lugh
3
levels of crune have been a serious and persistent problem since 2004 and tlie
licensee has not roduced an reductions in these high levels of crime. •E
P Y
Homeline, a tenant's advocacy group, and Housing Preservation, an
organization dedicated to preservation of low i�lcome housing, advised that the
licensee had not been paying the natural gas utility and gas shutoff notices had been
posted at Centerpoint and Brookhaven, for natural gas shutoff by 10 August 2007.
The attorney for Jaweed provided a receipt on or about 8 August 2007, showing that
the natural gas coinpany, coincidently also named Centerpoint Energy, was paid
$69,000, thus averting the shutoff: At that tune, the licensee was delinquent in
payment of sewer and water utilities to the City, having ceased payments in
September 2006 and finally paid the City more than $76,000 for delinquent
payments for Centerpoint and more than $18,000. See tab 10. There will be l i,
evidence that the natural gas was shutoff at Brookliaven for a day in July 2007.
The City was just informed by the attorneys for US Bank, the Tnistee that
the licensee has defaulted with respect to payments due under the loan agreement
l
tab 1
and has demanded payments of $131,621.48, in part for tax escrows. See
At tab 12, is an order a.nd decision of the City of Minneapolis revoking the
rental license of a rental property there owned by Jaweed.
At tab 13 are the records of tlle City of Robbinsdale showing nwnerous code
violations at buildings owned by Jaweed.
The actual police and incident reports are at tab 14.
The proposed action against tlie license is based upon the facts recited supra and the
follow�g �-o�as:
1. Failure to abate preinises crime and disorder.
2. Failure to maintain the property in accordance with the habitability
requirements of Chapter 12 as to code violations found by M�-IFA.
3. Failure to comply witli compliaa.ICe orders issued by the City Building
Official in November 2006 wluch compliance was a condition of license renewal
and failure to coinply with the additional orders.
4
4. Failure to promptly and currently pay utilities and taxes and failure to escrow
real property tax payments.
5. Failt�re to provide locking and secure exterior doors.
6. Failure to pay the year 2007 bond adininistration fee.
There is no merit as to the objections to the hearing raised by counsel for the
owners. As even lus attaclunents show, the City has given the owner detailed
reasons for the proposed action at tlus hearulg and has provided all the documentary
evidence in advance. Many of these violations of law are previously known to the
owners as they have been given previous notice of these violations by the police and
through compliance notices.
City ordinances do not limit when inspection of premises can ta.ke �lace nor
can tlie ordinances be read to give a license holder a six mont�i period within whicll
he is free observiilg the applicable city and state laws. Ordinance 12-906 provides
that the holder of a license consents to inspections and section 3-102 provides for
the right of entry by city inspectors. Section 12-1000 requires scheduled
inspections only of living areas, not common areas.
Wlule the ordinance does not specify exact procedures, the owners have been
given specific reasons for the proposed action and documentary evidence prior
thereto and the owners shall have an opportunity for a meaningful reply to the
evidence and to offer such evidence as they wish as to why no action should be
taken.
Respectfully subinitted,
1 October 2007 ��.�i�
William G. Clella.nd
Brooklyn Center Prosecuting Attorney
5
Community Development
c;ry�r 6301 Shingle Creek Parkway 55430
BROOKLYN
CENTER Phone:763-569-3300 Fax: 763-569-3494
Building/Housin� Maintenance Com�liance Order
DATE: October 5, 2006«Date» First Notice
TO: Hyder Jaweed
3 Blue Spruce Court
St. Paul, MN 55127
LOCATION: Centerpointe Apartments«Location»
COMPLIANCE DATE: November 6, 2006
COMPLIANCE OFFICIAL: Larry Martin
The following violations of the Buildin� Maintenance and Occupancv Ordinance were cited
during a recent inspection of the above premises. These violations must be corrected by the
compliance date indicated. Reinspection to verify code compliance is scheduled for in the
Please contact us if this date creates a conflict.
Failure to correct violations or to make satisfactory arrangements to correct violations acceptable
to the compliance official may result in suspension or revocation of your rental dwelling license
if applicable. In addition, your failure to comply may result in the issuance of a citation, which,
upon conviction, is punishable by fine and/or imprisonment.
The City Council adopted Res. No. 99-172 which provides for a fee of $50.00 to be charged
for each reinspeetion necessary after the first reinspection. The reinspection fee(s) will be
payable at the time of license renewal for the property, prior to the license being issued.
Section 12-1202 of the Ordinance also provides for Right of Appeal, when it is alleged that a
Compliance Order is based upon erroneous interpretation of the Ordinance. The Appeal must be
submitted to the Community Development Department, in writing, specifying the grounds for
Appeal, within five (5) business days after service of the order, and must be accompanied by a
filing fee of $50.00 in cash or cashier's check.
MN Statutes 504B.211 requires a landlord to give a tenant reasonable notice that entry to the
rental unit may take place for the purposes of performing an inspection. Please notify your
tenants of the date and time of the inspection at least 48 hours in advance.
If you have any questions or comments, please contact me at 763-569-3344,
Monday through Friday, 8:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.
Centerpointe Rental Inspection 2006 Page
i
i
DESCRIPTION OF VIOLATIONS AND ORDINANCE SECTION
The following statements apply to all buildings:
1. Bedroom windows are a means of egress and must be able to remain open without
assistance. Repair or replace. 12-703
2. Scrap, prime and paint windows off the deck. .12-703
3. Re-certify all fire extinguishers in all units. Chapter S— Fire Prevention
4. Repair all exterior and interior damage from leaking A/C units including replacing sheet
rock and insulation. 12-702
Make repairs to the interior lighting to following buildings in entries and/or hallways:
2802, 2816, 2818, 2900, 2904
Make repairs to the following buildings to provide exterior lighting:
2802, 2806, 2810, 2814, 2818, 2819, 2822, 2830, 2834, 2908, 2912, 2931, 2940
Garages 2800 Bank
Repair structural damage to garages. 12-707
Replace downspout on the east end. 12-707
Remove debris from roof. 12-707
Repair or replace fence on the north end of property. 12-706
Garages 2900 Bank
Remove brush and debris from behind units. 12-707
Replace damaged overhead doors. 12-707
Clean debris from roo£ 12-707
Repair structural damage to garages. 12-707
General Site Landscaping
Clean up downed trees and remove all stumps. 12-317
Remove brush piles. 12-317
Roofs
Clean debris from roofs. 12-702
Prep, caulk, prime and paint or replace all metal flashings along roof perimeters. 12-702
Replace roof jacks as needed. 12-702
Submit copy of roof maintenance program. 12-702
Submit capital improvement plan for roof replacement. 12-702
Building 2802
General
Repair sill under west entrance. 12-703
Caulk exterior where needed. 12-702
Unit 101
Replace window screen in bedroom. 12-703
Unit 102
Replace window screen in living room. 12-703
Centerpointe Rental Inspection 2006 Page 2
Repair or replace vent fan cover in bathroom. 12-709
Repair or replace bedroom window so it closes, lock and latches properly. 13-703
Unit 103
Replace refrigerator shelf bar and handle. 12-402
Unit 104
Replace refrigerator shelf bar. 12-402
Repair or replace bedroom window so it closes, lock and latches properly. 13-703
Unit 20l
Repair or replace bedroom window so it closes, lock and latches properly and replace window
screen. 13-703
Repair or replace storm door screen. 12-703
Unit 202 OK
Unit 203
Replace shower head in bathroom. 12-405
Unit 204
Repair or replace bedroom window so it closes, lock and latches properly. 12-703
There is mold and mildew around bedroom window. Correct the problem. 12-703
Unit 301 OK
Unit 302
Repair or replace patio door screen. 12-703
Unit 303 OK
Unit 304
Repair or replace GFCI outlet in kitchen. 12-504
Repair or replace closet doors. 12-703
Replace bedroom heat register cover. 12-702
Building 2806
Unit 101 OK
Unit 102
Repair or replace bedroom window so it closes, lock and latches properly. 12-703
There is mold and mildew around bedroom window. Correct the problem, 12-703
Unit 103
Repair or replace broken window in the bedroom. 12-703
Unit 104 OK
Centerpointe Rental Inspection 2006 Page 3
Unit 201
There is mold around the tub and shower. Correct the problem. 12-703
Unit 202
Repair or replace toilet. 12-403
Repair or replace vent fan in bathroom. 12-709
Replace towel bar in bathroom. 12-403
Unit 203 OK
Unit 204
Clean stove and vent hood. Replace filter. 12-402
Repair bathroom ceiling. 12-704
Replace switch plate cover in bathroom. 12-504
Replace missing drawer in bathroom. 12-404
Unit 301
There is mold and mildew in the living room. Correct the problem. 12-703
There is mold and mildew in bathroom. Correct the problem. 12-703
Unit 302 OK
Unit 303
Hire a licensed pest exterminator to eliminate the infestation of cockroaches. 12-308
Repair bathroom ceiling and walls. 12-704
Unit 304
Hire a licensed pest exterminator to eliminate the infestation of cockroaches. 12-308
Building 2810
General
Paint sill at south entrance. 12-703
Caulk exterior where needed. 12-702
Unit 101- OK
Unit 102
Replace bathroom vanity door. 12-402
Unit 103 OK
Unit 104
Replace refrigerator shelf bar. 12-402
Repair or replace window screen in bedroom. 12-703
Replace or replace leaking fauc�ts in bathtub. 12-404
Repair bathroom ceiling. 12-704
Unit 201
Centerpointe Rental Inspection 2006 Page 4
Repair or replace leaking faucet in kitchen. 12-402
Repair or replace toilet. 12-403
Repair bathroom ceiling. 12-704
Unit 202 OK
Unit 203
Properly secure stove and vent hood. 12-402
Replace screen on patio door. 12-703
Unit 204
Replace refrigerator shelf bar. 12-402
Repair or replace windows in bedroom (s) so that they open, lock and latch properly and correct
problems with mold and mildew. 12-703
Remove items stored in front of windows in bedroom to allow means of egress. 12-703
There is mold and mildew in the bathroom around the bathtub. Correct the problem. 12-405
Unit 301
Repair or replace window screens in bedroom. 12-703
Unit 302 OK
Unit 303 OK
Unit 304
There is mold and mildew in the bedroom. Correct the problem. 12-703
Building 2814
General
Caulk exterior where needed. 12-702
Unit 101
Replace refrigerator shelf bar. 12-402
Repair or replace window in bedroom. 12-703
Unit 102 Vacant Being worked on
Unit 103 Vacant Being worked on
Unit 104
Repair or replace leaking faucet in kitchen sink. 12-402
Unit 201 OK
Unit 202 Vacant Being worked on
Unit 203 Unable to Gain Access
Centerpointe Rental Inspection 2006 Page 5
Unit 204
Replace storrn door screen. 12-703
Unit 301
Replace shelf bar in freezer. 12-402
Replace bedroom window screens. 12-703
Repair bathroom ceiling. 12-704
Unit 302 OK I
Unit 303 OK
Unit 304
Repair water damaged wall around air conditioner in bedroom. 12-704
Building 2818
Unit l O1 Vacant Being worked on
Unit ]02
Repair or replace vent fan in bathroom. 12-709
Repair or replace leaking faucets in bathroom. 12-405
Unit 103 vacant -OK
Unit 104 vacant -0K
Unit 201 OK
Unit 202 vacant OK
Unit 203 OK
Unit 204 OK
Unit 301 OK
Unit 302
Properly secure toilet. 12-403
Replace bedroom window screens. 12-703
Repair or replace storm door screen. 12-703
Unit 303 OK
Unit 304 OK
Building 2822
Unit 101
Replace window screen in living room. 12-707
Centerpointe Rental Inspection 2006 Page 6
i�
Repair or replace bedroom windows so they close, lock and latch properly. Replace window
screens in bedroom. 12-703
Repair or replace vent fan in bathroom. 12-709
Unit 102 OK
Unit 103
Replace front panel from bathroom cabinets. 12-402
Unit 104 OK vacant
Unit 201
Repair or replace patio door and storm screen. 12-703
There is mold and mildew around bedroom window. Correct the problem. 12-703
ni 202 OK
U t
Unit 203
Repair or replace vent fan in bathroom. 12-709
Unit 204
Tharoughly clean entire unit. 12-312
Repair or replace bedroom windows so they close, lock and latch properly. Replace window
screens in bedroom. 12-703
Remove from balcony and dispose of garbage. 12-312
Install GFCI outlets in the kitchen above the counter. 12-504
Unit 301
Repair or replace dishwasher. 12-402
Install GFCI outlets in the kitchen above the counter. 12-504
Unit 302
Install GFCI outlets in the bathroom. 12-504
Unit 303
Repair or replace vent fan in bathroom. 12-709
Make repairs to water damaged ceiling in the bedroom. 12-704
Unit 304 OK
Building 2826
General
Replace deteriorated wood at south entrance. 12-702
Repair exterior brick on corner of second floor, south side. 12-702
ill west entrance. 12-702
Replace deteriorated wood on upper window s,
Caulk exterior where needed. 12-702
Unit 101 OK
Centerpointe Rental Inspection 2006 Page 7
Unit 102
Unit 103 Vacant Being worked on.
Unit 104 OK
Unit 201
Repair or replace window screen in bedroom. 12-703
Repair bathroom ceiling. 12-704
Replace light switch in bathroom. 12-504
Unit 202 OK
Unit 203 Vacant
Install GFCI outlets in the bathroom. 12-504
Unit 204
Repair or replace bedroom windows so they close, lock and latch properly. Replace window
screens in bedroom. 12-703
Repair bathroom ceiling. 12-704
Unit 301
Replace refrigerator door gasket. 12-402
Caulk around bathtub. 12-405
There is mold and mildew around the bathtub. Correct the problem. 12-405
Unit 302 OK
Unit 303 OK
Unit 304 Vacant Being worked on
Building 2830
General
Replace mullion at south entrance. 12-703
Caulk around 1 St floor A/C box. 12-702
Caulk exterior where needed. 12-702
Unit 101 No comments
Unit 102
Install GFCI outlets in the kitchen above the countec. 12-504
Unit 103
Repair or replace toilet. 12-403
Repair or replace vent fan in bathroom. 12-709
Centerpointe Rental Inspection 2006 Page 8
Unit 104
Replace refrigerator shelf bar. 12-402
Install GFCI outlets in the kitchen above the counter. 12-504
Unit 201 OK
Unit 202
Repair bathroom ceiling. 12-704
Unit 203
Caulk around bathtub. 12-405
There is mold and mildew around the bathtub. Correct the problem. 12-405
Unit 204
Repair bathroom ceiling. 12-704
Unit 301
Replace refrigerator shelf bar. l 2-402
Repair or replace patio door so it locks and latches properly. 12-703
Unit 302
Replace window screen in bedroom. 12-703
Replace door knobs on main door and patio door. 12-703
Unit 303 Vacant Being worked on.
Unit 304
Repair or replace main door. 12-703
Building 2834
Unit 1 O 1— No notes
Unit 102
Replace refrigerator and freezer shelf bar. 12-402
Replace kitchen drawer. 12-402
Unit l 03 OK
Unit 104 Vacant Being worked on.
Unit 201
Repair or replace toilet. 12-403
Repair or replace leaking faucets in bathtub. 12-405
Unit 202 Vacant Being worked on
Unit 203
Repair or replace toilet. 12-403
i
Centei•pointe Rental Inspection 2006 Page 9
Repair bathroom ceiling. 12-704
Install GFCI outlets in the kitchen above the counter. 12-504
Repair or replace patio door screen. 12-703 C
Unit 204
Repair or replace window screen in bedroom. 12-703
Repair or replace closet doors in bedroom. 12-703
Install GFCI outlets in the kitchen above the counter. 12-504
Unit 301 OK
Unit 302 OK
Unit 303 OK
Unit 304
Repair or replace vent fan in bathroom. 12-709
Building 2838
Unit l O1 No comments
Unit 102 OK
Unit 103 Vacant Being worked on
Unit 104
Repair or replace tub faucet. 12-405
Unit 201
Repair or replace burners on stove. 12-402
Replace freezer shelf bar. 12-402
Repair or replace window in bedroom. 12 703
Repair or replace closet door in bedroom. 12-703
Remove items stored in bedroom blocking egress. Chapter 5— Fire Prevention
Repair or replace patio door knob so it locks and latches properly. 12-703
Unit 202
Replace freezer shelf bar. 1 Z-402
Unit 203
Repair or replace leaking faucet in kitchen. 12-402
Clean stove and vent hood. 12-402
Repair or replace toilet. 12-403
Repair or replace ceiling fan in bedroom. 12-504
Unit 203 No comments
Unit 204 —No Comments
Centerpointe Rental Inspection 2006 Page ]0
Unit 301
Replace refrigerator shelf bar. 12-402
Repair or replace window screen in bedroom. 12-703
Repair or replace toilet. l Z-403
Repair or replace leaking faucets in bathtub. 12-404
Remove items stored in bedroom blocking egress. Chapter 5— Fire Prevention
Unit 302
Replace window screen in bedroom. 12-703
Clean stove. 12-402
Unit 303
Replace refrigerator shelf bar. 12-402
Replace cabinet front on vanity in bathroom. 12-402
Repair or replace window and screen on patio door. 12-703
Unit 304
Repair or replace toilet. 12-403
Building 2900
General
Repair hallway lighting. 12-504
Repair or replace front entry doors. 12-703
Repair or replace exterior entry stairs. 12-406
Repair stucco on west exterior wall where it is pulling away from walls. 12-702
Repair and caulk first floor A/C units. 12-709, 12-702`
Replace handicap parking sign (west parking lot).
Repair, replace and clean dryer and combustion air vents on west side. 12-702
Replace rotten sill near east exit. 12-702
Remove and replace deteriorated caulk on exterior. 12-702
Unit 102 Unable to inspect power is shut of£
Unit 03
Repair or replace burners on stove. 12-402
Repair or replace dishwasher. 12-402
Repair bathroom ceiling. 12-704
Unit 104
Caulk around bathtub. 12-405
Repair or replace leaking faucets in bathtub. 12-405
Caulk tub spout and handles. 12-405
Unit 20l —�O�ce
Repair, replace and clean dryer and combustion air vents on west entrance. 12-702
i
Centerpointe Rental Inspection 2006 Page 1 I
Unit 202
Repair non-working smoke detectors. 5-204f
Unit 203
Repair or replace windows in bedroom. 12-703
Repair or replace leaking faucets in bathtub. 2-405
Repair bathroom ceiling. 12-704
Repa�r non-working smoke detectors. 5-204f
Unit 204
Repair or replace windows in bedroom. 12-703
Unit 302 y
Install globe on hallway light. 12-504
Repair or replace toilet. 12-403 i
Repair or replace vent fan. 12-709
Repair non-working smoke detectors. 5-204f I
Unit 34] OK
Unit 303
Repair or replace air conditioner. 12-709
Repair or replace toilet. 12-403
Unit 304 Vacant
Laundry/Mechanical Room
Display current boiler license. 12-301
Repair one hour wall. 12-704
Building 2904
General
Replace glass at north entrance and caulk around opening. 12-702
Replace brick on lower northeast corner. 12-702
Caulk around siding/brick at windows on east side and caulk at brick stucco. 12-702
Cut in flashing over two A/C units on east side. 12-702
Remove and re lace deteriorated caulk on exterior. 12-702
P
Unit 101
Repair or replace toilet. 12-403
Unit l02
Repair bathroom ceiling. 12-704
Repair non-working smoke detectors. 5-204f
Unit 103
Repair or replace burners on stove. 12-402
n dinin area. 12-704
lace floor coverin in kitche
Re air or re g
P P g
Centerpointe Rental Inspection 2006 Page 12
I�
Unit 104
Repair or replace vent fan, 12-708
Unit 201
Caulk around bathtub. 12-405
Repair or replace leaking faucets in bathtub. 12-405
Repair bathroom ceiling. 12-704
Unit 202 OK
Unit 203 OK
Unit 204 Vacant Repairs from fire damage being done.
Unit 301
Move items placed in front of bedroom window so window can be used as means of egress. 12-
703
Repair or replace toilet. 12-403
Unit 302
Repair door knob on patio door. 12-703
Clean grease laden surfaces in kitchen. 12-709
Move items placed in front of bedroom window so window can be used as means of egress. 12-
703
Repair or replace toilet. 12-403
Repair or replace leaking faucets in bathtub. 12-405
Bathtub is plugged. Correct the problem. 12-405
Unit 303 OK
Unit 304
Repair or replace toilet. I2-403
Repair or replace leaking faucets in bathtub. 12-405
Repair non-working smoke detectors. 5-204f
Building 2908
General
Repair or replace fire door on first floor hallway. 12-703
Replace door trim on back entry door. 12-703
Unit 101
Repair bathroom ceiling. 12-704
Repair or replace air conditioner. 12-709
Repair or replace toilet. 12-430
Unit 103
Centerpointe Rental Inspection 2006 Page 3
Repair or replace toilet. 12-403
Repair or replace leaking faucets in bathtub. 12-405
Repair bathroom ceiling. 12-704
Repair non-working smoke detectors. 5-204f
Unit 104
Unable to inspect
Unit 201
Vacant unable to isnepct s
Unit 202 OK
Unit 203
Replace missing front base cabinet door. 12-402
Move items placed in front of bedroom window so window can be used as means of egress. 12-
703
Unit 204
Replace patio door. 12-703
Repair or replace leaking faucets in bathtub. l 2-405
Re lace towel bar in bathroom. 12-403
P
Bathroom sink is plugged. Correct the problem. 12-405
Repair non-working smoke detectors. 5-204f
Repair or replace refrigerator freezer. 12-402
Unit 301
Caulk vanity/sink. 12-404
Repair or replace leaking faucets in bathtub. 12-405
Repair or replace toilet. 12-403
Unit 302
Repair or replace air conditioner. 12-709
Unity 303
Install globe on hallway light. 12-504
Repair or replace toilet. 12-403
Repair non-working smoke detectors. 5-204f
Unit 304
Repair or replace toilet. 12-403
Building 2912
General
Repair or replace front entry door. 12-703
Repair or replace heat detector in laundry room. Chapter 5— Fire Prevention
Repair or replace hallway lighting. 12-504
Repair, replace and clean dryer and combustion air vents on west side of building. 12-702
Centerpointe Rental Inspection 2006 Page 14
i�
Properly secure back entry door so it locks and latches. 12-703
Repair or replace stairs on west side of building. 12-406
Caulk around A/C units on east side of building. 12-702
Caulk exterior where needed. l 2-702
Unit 101
Repair or replace toilet. 12-403
Caulk around bathtub and handles. 12-405
Unit 102
Replace drawer front on kitchen cabinets. 12-402
Caulk around bathtub and handles. 12-405
Replace broken light switch in bathroom. 12-504
Repair non-working smoke detectors. 5-204f
Unit 103 OK
Unit 104 OK
Unit 201
Repair bathroom ceiling. 12-704
Unit 202
Repair bathroom ceiling. 12-704
Replace tile in tub. 12-405
Unit 203
Clean and shampoo carpet or replace. 12-704
Repair or replace toilet. 12-403
Repair bathroom ceiling. 12-704
Unit 204
Repair or replace burners on stove. 12-402
Repair or replace toilet. 12-403
Unit 301
Repair or replace toilet. 12-403
Unit 203
Caulk around bathtub and tub spout. 12-405
Repair or replace toilet. 12-403
Unit 303
Repair or replace toilet. 12-403
Replace missing cabinet drawers in bathroom. 12-404
Centerpointe Rental Inspection 2006 Page 15
Unit 304
Make repairs around A/C unit where there is mold. 12-704
Building 2916
General
Repair or replace hallway lighting. 12-504
Properly secure entry doors so they lock and latch. 12-703
Repair, replace and c(ean dryer and combustion air vents on west side. 12-702
Caulk exterior where needed. 12-702
Unit 101 Vacant Not ready for insp�ction
Unit 102 OK
Unit 103 Vacant Not ready for inspection
Unit 104 Vacant Not ready for inspection
Unit 202
Repair wall around air conditioner. 12-704 I
Unit 203
Caulk around bathtub handles and spout. 12-405
Unit 204
Stain kill and paint ceiling in living room. 12-704
Unit 301
Repair or replace vent fan in kitchen. 12-402
Caulk around bathtub and handles. 12-405
Repair or replace leaking faucets in bathroom sink and bathtub. 12-404
Repair or replace toilet. 12-403
Repair non-working smoke detectors. 5-204f
Unit 302
Repair wall around air conditioner. 12-704
Replace mrssing window screen from bedroom. 12-703
Re lace missin kick late from bathroom vanity. 12-404
P
g P
Re air non-working s
moke detectors. 5-204f
P
Unit 303 OK
Unit 304 OK
Building 2920
General
Post boiler license in boiler room. 12-709
Centerpointe Rental Inspection 2006 Page 16
Recertification is due on RPZ's. 12-709
Repair one hour walls. 12-704
Repair stucco pulling away from building. 12-702
Repair A/C unit on first floor, north side. 12-709
Replace broken glass at north entrance. 2-703
Repair or replace stucco on east side. 12-702
Caulk exterior where needed. 12-702
Unit 101
Install globe on hallway light. 12-504
Caulk around bathtub. 12-405
Unit 102 Vacant Not Ready for Inspection
Unit 103 OK
Unit 104 Vacant Not Ready for Inspection
Unit 201
Repair or replace toilet. 12-403
Repair or replace leaking faucets in bathtub. 12-404
Unit 202
Caulk around bathtub and handles. 12-405
Unit 203
Repair or replace toilet. 12-403
Repair or replace leaking faucets in bathtub. 12-405
Repair non-working smoke detectors. 5-204f
Unit 204 Vacant Not Ready for Inspection
Unit 301
Repair or replace toilet. 12-403
Unit �02
Replace light globe in kitchen/dining area. 12-703
Repair or replace closet doors in bedrooms. 12-703
Unit 303
Repair or replace burners on stove. 12-402
Unit 304
Repair or replace air conditioner. 12-709
Install globe on hallway light. 12-504
Repair non-working smoke detectors. 5-204f
Centerpointe Rental Inspection 2006 Page l7
Building 2924
General
Properly secure entry doors so they lock and latch. l 2-703 P
Repair fire door on second floor. 12-703
Reconnect dryer vent in laundry room. 12-709
Recertification is due on RPZ's. 12-709
Display current boiler license. 2-709
Secure access cover to boiler room. 12-709
Caulk exterior where needed. 12-702
Secure water faucet and caulk around openings on east side of building. 12-702
Repair exterior light over exit. 12-504
Unit 101
Repair or replace leaking faucet in kitchen. 12-402
ven not workin 12-402
e air o
r re lace s
tove oven o
R g
P P
Repair or replace vent fan in bathroom. 12-709
I n t ll C.O. cover behind toilet. 12-403
sa
Repair non-working smoke detectors. 5-204f
Unit 102
Repair or replace air conditioner and repair wall around air conditioner. 12-709
Hire a licensed pest exterminator to eliminate the infestation of cockroaches. 12-308
Unit 103 Vacant Not Ready for Inspection
Unit 104
Repair or replace ver�t hood ove.r stove. 12-402
Caulk around bathtub, handles and spout. 12-405
Unit 201 OK
Unit 202
Repair or replace air conditioner and repair wall around air conditioner. 12-709
Repair or replace toilet. 12-403
Caulk around bathrobe handles. 12-405
Re air or re lace ve
nt fan in bathroom. 12-709
P P
Unit 203
Repair or replace air conditioner and repair wall around air conditioner. 12-709
Re air bathroom ceilin 12-704
P g
Unit 204
Repair or replace toilet. 12-403
Caulk around bathtub. 12-405
Repair non-working smoke detectors. 5-204f
Unit 301
Stain kill and paint ceiling in living room. 12-704
I
Centerpointe Rental Inspection 2006 Page 18
I
Repair or replace toilet. 12-403
Repair non-working smoke detectors. 5-204f
Unit 302
Repair or replace air conditioner and repair wall around air conditioner. 12-709
Replace missing drawer front on cabinet in bathroom. 12-402
Repair non-working smoke detectors. 5-204f
Unit 303
Repair or replace dishwasher. 12-402
Replace missing drawer front from kitchen cabinet. 12-402
Replace light globe in bedroom. 12-504
Install globe on hallway light. 12-504
Replace ceiling fan in kitchen. 12-504
Unit 304
Replace missing switch plate cover in hallway/entry. 12-504
Verify GFCI outlets are working. 12-504
Building 2928
General
Secure front entry door. 12-703
Repair, replace and clean dryer and combustion air vents on west entrance. 12-702
Bury exposed cabie on west side of building. 12-302
Repair or replace stucco on east wall. 12-702
Caulk exterior where needed. 12-702
Unit 101
Repair or replace vent fan in bathroom. 12-709
Unit 102
Properly secure air conditioner. 12-709
Repair or replace windows in bedroom so that they open, lock and latch property. 12-703
Replace hard wire smoke detector. 5-204f
Unit 103
Repair bathroom ceiling. 12-704
Unit 104
Properly secure air conditioning units. 12-709
Repair or replace vent fan in bathroom. 12-709
Repair bathroom ceiling. 12-704
Replace smoke detector. 5-204f
Unit 201
Repair or replace toilet and properly secure. 12-403
Replace non-working smoke detectors. 5-204f
Repair bathroom cetling. 12-704
Centerpointe Rental Inspection 2006 Page l9
Unit 202
Repair or replace ceiling fan in kitchen. 12-504
Replace missing smoke detector in bedroom. 5-204f
Unit 203
Repair or replace air conditioner. 12-709
Repair or replace patio door so that is locks and latches properly. 12-703
Replace missing drawer front on kitchen cabinets. 12-402
Replace missing bedroom window screens. 12-703
Repair or replace toilet. 12-403
Repair or replace bathroom vent fan. 12-709
Repair bathroom ceiling. 12-704
Unity 204
Replace refrigerator shelf bar. 12-402
Caulk around bathtub and handles. 12-405
Unit 301
Repair or replace loose toilet and properly secure. 12-403
Unit 302
Properly secure toilet. 12-403
Unit 303 Unable to Gain Access ,I
Unit 304
Caulk around bathtub and handles. 12-405 I�
Properly secure toilet. 12-403
Building 2932
General
Properly secure front entry doors. 12-703
Repair or replace first floor fire door. 12-703
Repair or replace second floor fire door so it locks and latches properly. 12-703
Paint around south entrance. 12-702
Remove noxious weeds on west side of property. 19-103
Caulk exterior where needed. 12-702
Unit 101 OK
Unit 102 OK
Unit l03 I
Repair or replace refrigerator door gasket. 12-402
Replace ]ight globe in bedroom, 12-504
Replace missing smoke detector in bedroom. 5-204f
Hire a licensed pest exterminator to eliminate the infestation of cockroaches. 12-308
Centerpointe Rental Inspection 2006 Page 20
Unit 104
Repair bathroom ceiling. 12-704
Unit 201
Repair ceiling in living room. 12-704
Repair or replace vent fan. 12-709
Replace hard wire smoke detector. 5-204f
Unit 202 OK
Unit 203 OK
Unit 204 Unable to Gain Access
Unit 301 OK
K
Unit 302 O
I
Unit 303
Install globe on hallway light. 12-504
Replace missing switch plate cover in hallway/entry. 12-504
Repair or replace kitchen light and switch plate cover. 12-504
Replace non-working smoke detector. 5-204f
Unit 304
Instal batter o erated smoke detectors in ever b
edroom. 5-204f
1 y p y
Building 2936
General
Repair or replace leasing signs. 35-313
Repair second floor window sil] under window on SE side. 12-703
Caulk exterior where needed. 12-702
Repair l floor A/C on north side. 12-709
Repair stucco on east side. 12-702
Replace window in boiler room. 12-703
Caulk exterior where needed. 12-702
Unit 101 OK
Unit 102 Unable to Gain Access
Unit 103
Repair or replace non-working bathroom light. 12-504
Unit 104
Repair or replace toilet and properly secure. 12-403
Replace hard wire smoke detector. 5-204f
Centerpointe Rental Inspection 2006 Page 21
I
Install battery operated smoke detectors in every bedroom. 50-204f
Unit 201
Repair bathroom ceiling. 12-704
r
Unit 202
Clean grease taden surfaces in kitchen. 12-709
Repair or replace leaking faucets in bathtub. 12-405
Repair bathroom ceiling. 12-704
Repair or replace dishwasher. 12-402
Provide working fire extinguisher. 12-709
Unit 203
Repair or replace air conditioner. 12-709 I
Repair wall around wall air conditioner. 12-704
Unit 204
Repair or replace air conditioner. 12-709
Repair wall around air conditioner. 12-704
Caulk around bathtub. l 2-405
Properly secure toilet. 12-403
Replace non-working smoke detector. 5-204f
Unit 301
Properly secure toilet. 12-403
Unit 302
Repair wall around air conditioner. 12-704
Install globe on hallway light. 12-504 I
Replace non-working smoke detector. 5-204f
Unit 303 OK
Unit 304 Unable to Gain Access
Building 2940
General
Repair or replace first floor fire door so it closes, locks and latches properly. 12-703
Paint exposed wood on south entrance. 12-702
Caulk around dryer vent on north side. 12-702
Caulk exterior where needed. 12-702
Unit l Ol OK
Unit 102
Repair bathroom ceiling. 12-704
Repair or replace floor covering on kitchen/dining area. 12-704
Centerpointe Rental Inspection 2006 Page 22
Unit 103
Replace missing smoke detector(s). 5-204f
Unit 104 OK
Unit 201- Unable to Gain Access
Unit 202
Repair bathroom ceiling. 12-704
Unit 203
Repair or replace floor covering in kitchen/dining area. 12-704
Repair bathroom ceiling. 12-704
Properly secure toilet. 12-403
Unit 204
Replace outlet cover plate in living room. 12-504
Replace cover plate on A/C outlet. 12-504
Repair or replace closet door(s) in bedrooms. 12-703
Replace light globe in bedroom. 12-504
Repair or replace toilet. 12-403
Repair bathroom ceiling. 12-704
Replace hard wire smoke detector. 5-204f
Unit 301
Replace base cabinet door in kitchen. 12-402
Install globe on hallway light. 12-504
Unit 302
Replace missing battery operated smoke detectors in bedrooms. 5-204f
Unit 303
Repair or replace toilet. 12-4�3
Install GFCI outlet covers in the bathroom. 12-504
Unit 304
Repair leak to ceiling/roof around light fixture in bedroom. 12-704
Centerpointe Rental Inspection 2006 Page 23
Community Development
c'`y°f 6301 Shingle Creek Parkway 55430
BROOKLYN
cEn�TER Phone:763-569-3300 F�: 763-569-3494
Buildin�/Housin� Maintenance Comnliance Order
DATE: November 15, 2006 Fina1 Notice
TO: Hyder Jaweed
3 Blue Spruce Court
St. Paul, MN 55127
LOCATION: Centerpointe Apartments
COMPLIANCE DATE: December 8, 2006 i
COMPLIANCE OFFICIAL: Larry Martin
The following violations of the Buildina Maintenance and Occunancv Ordinance were
cited during a recent inspection of the above premises. These violations must be
corrected by the compliance date indicated. Reinspection to verify code compliance is
scheduled foi• December 8, 200G in the AM. Please contact us if this date ci•eates a
conflict.
Failure to correct violations or to make satisfactory arrangements to correct violations
acceptable to the compliance official may result in suspension or revocation of your
Q' failure to com 1 ma result in the i
rental dv� ellm license if applicable. In addition, your p y y
issuance of a crtation, which, upon conviction, is pumshable by fine and/or imprisonment.
The City Council adopted Res. No. 99-172 which provides for a fee of �50.00 to be
charged for each reinspection necessaiy after the first reinspection. The reinspection
fee(s) will be payable at the time of license rene�val for the property, pnor to the hcense
being issued.
Section 12-1202 of the Ordinance also provides for Right of Appeal, when it is alleged
that a Compliance Order is based upon erroneous interpretation of the Ordinance. The
Appeal must be submitted to the Community Development Department, in writing,
specifying the grounds for Appeal, within five (5) business days after service of the order,
and must be accompanied by a filing fee of $50.00 in cash or cashier's check. �I
MN Statutes 504B.211 requires a landlord to give a tenant reasonable notice that entry to
the rental unit may take place for the purposes of performing an inspection. Please notify
your tenants of the date and time of the inspection at least 48 hours in advance. I
y
If you have any questions or comments, please contact me at 763-569-3344,
Monday thi•ough Fi•id�y, 5:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.
DESCRIPTION OF VIOLATIONS AND ORDINANCE SECTION
The following statements apply to all buildings'
1. Scrap, prime and paint windows off the deck. 12-703
2. Re-certify all fire eltinguishers in a11 units. Chapter 5— Fire Prevention
3. Repair all exterior and interior damage from leaking A/C units including
replacing sheet rock and insulation. 12-702
Make repairs to the following buildings to provide exterior lighting:
2802, 2806, 2810, 2814, 2818, 2819, 2822, 2830, 2834, 2908, 2912, 2931, 2940
Gaa•ages 2800 Bank
Repair structural damage to garages. IZ-707
Replace do�vnspout on the east end. 12-707
Remove debris from roo£ 12-707
Repair or replace fence on the north end of properry. 12-706
Garages 290� Bank
Remove brush and debris from behind units. 12-707
Replace damaged overhead doors. 12-707
Clean debris from roof. 12-707
Repair structural damabe to garages. 12-707
General Site Landscaping
Clean up downed trees and remove all stumps. 12-317
Remove brush piles. 12-317
Roofs
Clean debris from roofs. 12-702
Prep, caulk, prime and paint or replace a11 metal flashings along roof perimeters. 12-702
Replace roofjacks as needed. 12-702
Submit copy of roof maintenance program. 12-702
Submit capital improvement plan for roof replacement. 12-702
Builcling 2802
GeneraI
Caulk exterior where needed. 12-702
TAX CREDIT COMPLIANCE MONITORING
nx a�
�w �y FINAL
�ou���g
��v=�<��_��-� ��=<:>u.���•�~;� INSPECTION REPORT- 2007
Pro�ect Name Center Pointe
Project Ci�y Brooklyn Center �:Pro�ect Counfy Hennepin
HTG; 95T006 Rile D2994
Owner Name. :I Brooklyn Center Leased Housing Associates, LP
Managemen�k Company Equity One Management
(`Physical Inspechon Conducted. By Monica Garcia Date: 5/23/2007
Maggie Demco
Judie VanderBosch
Renee Dickinson
HTC Cainphance Re_vie�v�r Monica Garcia Date: 5/23/2007
MaQgie Demco
Judie VanderBosch
;;I Renee Dickinson
The compliance review consisted of a review of twenty percent (20%) of the low-income units (tenant file
review and physical inspection) as well as an inspection of the site, building interior(s), building exterior(s),
cornmon areas and building systems. In addition, other pertinent documentation such as utility allowances,
resident selection plan, leases, etc., were reviewed. Under current reporting procedure, if noncompliance was
corrected by the owner prior to MHFA's review, MHFA is not required to report the violation(s) to IRS. Any
uch noncompliance, if observed, has been discussed with a representative of the owner or manager and is not
flected in this report. Unless othe�zuise clarified, violations noted on the Final Report will be repo��ted to Internal
evenue Service, wliether or not they have been corrected.
For NIHFA;Vse On1y
Date reliminar res onse received: 6 14 07 Date reviewed: 6/15/07
i P Y P
No violation(s) for fu1a1 report Un v for fi rep ort
Notes Preliminary Response:
i
I Management at Center Pointe Apartments faxed copies of the 72 Hour Critical Violation form indicat-
i ing that all violations had been "done 5/24/2006". This type of response is not sufficient. After the
inspection on May 23, 2007 our discussion was that responses to the critical violations were to be in
the form of work orders, receipts or photos showing correction of each violation. As of today all
critical violations are still noncompliance.
On 6/13/2007 Equity One management faxed copies of work orders showing correction of 72 hr
violations.
Date fin response received: �D revie
All violations clarified No 8823 required Uncorrected non-compliance 8823(s) required
All violati c orr ec ted 8 823( s) r�wr
E
lotes Final Response:
Center Pouite D2994 Brooklyn Center
Housulg Tax Credit Prograut 1 2007 Inspection ReporE (ver. 3-07)
Units InspecEed
1'his list was revised fi�o�n fhe oriAinal Unit List, where applicable, to reftect units actually inspectect.
Building ID Unit Move In
Number (BIN) Building Address Number Tenant Name Date
1 95-00017 2802 Northway Drive
2 95-00017 2802 Norfhway Drive
3 95-00017 2802 Northwav Drive
4 95-00018 2806 Northway Drive
5 95-00018 2806 Norfhwav Drive
6 95-00019 2810 Norfhway Drive
95-00019 2810 Norfhwav Drive
8 95-00019 2810 Northway Drive
9.
95-00020 2814 Northwc�y Drive
10. 95-00020 2814 Norfhway Drive
11. 95-00021 2818 Norfhway Drive
12' 95-00021 2818 Norfhway Drive
13.
95-00022 2822 Northway Drive
95-00022 2822 Northwdy Drive
15. 95-00022 2822 Northwav Drive
16. 95-00023 2826 Northwav Drive I
17 95-00023 2826 Northway Drive
18.
95-00024 2830 Northwa Drive
v
19. 95-00024 2830 Northway Drive
20 95-00024 2830 Norfihwav Drive
21' 95-00025 2834 Norfhwc�y Drive
22. 95-00025 2834 Northway Drive
23' 95-00026 2838 Norfhway Drive
24" 95-00026 2838 Northway Driue
25. 95-00026 2838 Norfhway Drive
26. 95-00027 2900 Norfhwav Drive
27 95-00027 2900 Norfhway Drive
95-00028 2904 Northwav Drive
L9 95-00028 2904 Northway Drive
Cenl Poulte D2994 Brooklyn Center
Housing Tax Credit Program 2 2007 Inspection Report (ver. 3-07)
30. 95-00028 2904 Norfhway Drive
Building ID Unit Move In
Number (BIN) Building Address Number Tenant Name Date
95-00029 2908 Northway Drive
32' 95-00029 2908 Norfhway Drive
33. 95-00030 2912 Norfhway Drive
34. 95-00030 2912 Northway Drive
35. 95-00030 2912 Northway Drive
36. 95-00031 2916 Norfhwav Drive
37 95-00032 2920 Norfhway Drive
38 95-00032 2920 Northway Drive
39. 95-00033 2924 Northwav Drive I
40. 95-00033 2924 Norfhway Drive
41. 95-00034 2928 Norfhwav Drive
42. 95-00034 2928 Northway Drive
43. 95-00034 2928 Norfhway Drive
44. 95-00035 2932 Norfhway Drive
95-00035 2932 Norfhway Drive
6 95-00036 2936 Norfhway Drive
47 95-00036 2936 Northway Drive
48 95-00037 2940 Norfhway Drive
49. 95-00037 2940 Norfhway Drive
50. 95-00037 2940 Northway Drive
Center Poulte D2994 Brooklyn Center
Housulg Tax Credit Progra�n 3 2007 I�lspection Report (ver. 3-0'�
Unit Violations
Fror�z tlte rtu�nbered list nbove, tlie following tcnits t•equire co�yectiou. In all cases, an atte�npt was mccde to ciefermi�2e whether
the icnit was brought back in to compliance. Owne�• must submit doc�.cmentation to clarifij (sacfficient documentation to establisli that
'�.e violation did not exist) or correct (provide sufftcient docuanentation that t)ze unit is back in coanpliance). Please organize ccnd
_u�nbel• your response to follow the order beiow:
i
BIN MN I Unit Tenant Name:
Date(s) Out of Compliance:
Physical Unit: 5/23/2007 Violahon of UPCS or local uispection standards
Violation details: Patio has broken railing. Leve13 liinits the safe use of tl�is area. I�ZOperable hot water faucet u1 tub.
Level 3, faucet cannot be used.
To correCt physical violations: Submit copies of completed signed and dated work orders, receipts, invoices, and/or photos, etc.
to show that noted items have been repaired/replaced.
For MHFA :tJse Qnly. The abov:.e viola.eion(s) Were clarihed tlus ui�ut was: not ou.:t of coinpliance as reported;
Have no:t been.corrected or unable ta deterirune correction
V�?ere corre�ted: Unitis bacic�n com�Tiance:�n
BIN: MN-95-00019 Unit Tenant Nnme:
Date(s) Out of Complianee:
Tenant File: 1/19/2006 Household income above income limit upon initial occupancy
(tenant files containing insufficient documentation to determine initial eligibility will
be reported under tlus category)
Violadon details: Employment is with fa�nily owned busviess. No check stub to support verification in file.
To correct tenant file violations: Provide documentation in the form of a check stub for employment with fanvly.
For MHFA Use Oiily The abou:e v�.olalion(s} Were clarahed th�s uiut was:zlot out ot comphanee as repoxted.
Have not bee� c4rrected ox tulable to deterirune �o�recnon
i :i �Vere corrected; Urutis back in coini�hvlce:on
BIN: MN-95-00021 Unit Tenant Name:
Date(s) Out of Compliance:
Physical Unit: 5/23I2007 Violation of UPCS or local inspection standards
Violation details: Missing appliances, leaking sinlc trap u1 kitchen, vv1y1 flooring coming up at entry, trip hazard.
Owner is not makulg reasonable attemnts to re-rent the u.iut. All Leve13
To correct physical violations: Submit copies of completed, signed and dated work orders, receipts, invoices, and/ or photos, etc.
to show that noted items have been re aired/re laced.
P II
P
ForMHFA Use Qnly The above �enalakion(s) YVere clar�fied ;tlus urut was nQk puk of compliance as reported.
Have no:E beerl corrected or uilable Eq deterin�x�e correction I
YVere norrected.; Unitis back�n couipliaiice:on j
BIN: MN-95-00021 Unit Tenant Name:
Date(s) Out of Compliance:
Physical Unit: 5/23/2007 Violation of UPCS or local inspection standards
Violation details: Infestation of ulsects, cockroaches. Leve13
To correct physical violations: Submit copies of completed, sigiied and datedwork orders, receipts, invoices, and/or photos, etc.
to show that noted items have been repaired/replaced.
For 1VIHFA :i�se Oiily: The above vzolatio�l(s) Were clarafied this uii�t vvas ilot out o� coinphazice as rQpoxted.
0 Have not been;corrected or iinable to dete:rinule correction
`❑�1?ere corrected; UmtiS bacl�:in coriipliance oil
Center Poulte D2994 Brooklyn Center
Housulg Tax Credit Prograut 4 2007 Inspection Report (ver. 3-07)
E�
BIN: MN-95-00022 Unit #104 Tenant Name: S. Jackson
Date(s) Out of Compliance:
Physical Unrt: 5/23/2007 Violation of UPCS or locai inspection standards
iolation details: Bathtub hot water faucet does ilot sllut off. Leve11 I
To correct physical violations Submit copies of completed, signed and dated work orders, receipts, invoices, and/or photos, etc.
to show that noted items have been repaired/ replaced.
Far 1VIHFA Use O�nly: Tl�e above viplation(s3 Were clarified tlus uriit was �1ot out of coinphance as reported.
Have not:been coxrected or u:iiable Eq deterinine coxrecti
VVere corrected.:' Unitis baelc�n compliance;on.
BIN MN Unit Tenant Name:
Date(s) Out of Compliance:
Plzysical Unit: 5/23/2007 Violation of UPCS ar local inspection standards
Violation details: Bathroom fan inoperable. Level 2
To correct physical violaHons: Submit copies of completed signed and dated work orders, receipts, invoices, and/ or photos, etc.
to show that noted items have been repaired/replaced.
For ]YIHFA IJse Orily Tlie above vsolation(s) Were clarified -tlUS uiiit vvas.rnot ov:t o� carii.phance as r�poxted.
Have not been cor.rected or uriable to deterinul� .corre�tion
;i INere corrected.:' Urutisbacic�sicoinpliance;on.
BIN: MN-95-00022 Unit Tenant Name:
Date(s) Out of Compliance:
Physical Unit: 5/23/2007 Violation of UPCS or local inspection standards
I Violation details Nonworkulg oven, 21eft side bunlers work soinetitnes. Leve13
o CorreCt phySiCal violations: Submit copies of completed, signed and dated work orders, receipts, invoices, and/ or photos, etc.
o s11ow that noted items have been repaired/replaced.
For �se Orily Tlie above:violakion(s)' W�re clarified :this uiiit was rnot ouf of cou�pliarice as reported:
C7 .Have no.t: been correct�;d or viiable to determule correchon
W�re co:rrected�: tJnrt:i� back:ul comphance;on
BIN MN Unit Tenant Name
Date(s) Out o
Physical Unit.• 5/23/2007 Violation of UPCS or local inspection standards
Violation details: Water damage on bathroom ceiling, saturation of water and bubbling. Leve11
To correCt phy5iCa1 violations: Submit copies of completed signed aild datedwork orders, receipts, invoices, and/or photos, etc.
to show that noted items have been repaired/replaced.
For1VMH�'A:Use On1y: Tlie above violation(s) �.YV.ere cla�afied thas uaut was nat.out of co�npliaa�ce as repoxted,
Haue no:t beetl;correcte.d or unable to deterinule .cqrrect�on.
Were corrected:; UruEis back`�n coui��ance:oz�
Center Pointe D2994 Brooklyn Center
Housuig Tax Credit Prograln 5 2007 I�lspection Report (ver. 3-0�
BIN: MN-95-0024 Unit Tenant Name:
Date(s) Out of Compliance:
Physiccrl Unit: 5/23/2007 Violation of UPCS or local inspection standards
ViolaHon details: No electricity in the unit at time of inspeckion. Owner is not inalculg reasonable attempts to re-rent
d1e unit. i
To Correct physiCal violations: Submit copies of completed signed and dated work orders, receipts, invoices, and/or photos, etc.
to show that electrical power is restored.
For.MHFA:Use On1y: Tlie above violaEi�n(s)",`: VVere clanfied.- t�us unit was,not out of coinphanee as reporteci.
Have not been:coxxe�ted or iulable ko detearmule corzection
V�?ere corrected< LJrut::is bacl�:;in com?�liance on
BIN: MN Unit Tenant Name
Date(s) Out of Compliance:
Physical Unit: 5/23/2007 Violation of UPCS or local inspection standards
Violation details: Vacant iuut is not 1labitable for occupancy. Owner is i�ot malculg reasonable attempts to re the
tuut.
To correct physical violations: Submit copies of completed, signed and dated work orders, receipts, invoices, and/or photos, etc.
to show that noted items have been repaired/replaced.
For MHFAUse Ozi.lyc Tlie abov.e vzolatioil(s) ❑.CNerQ clarified tlus uz�t was: ��ot out �f coinpl�aii,ee as zepoxted`.
Have i�o:t been Gorrected or ur►able to determule correction
V�1ere corre.cted: Unitls on
BIN: MN Unit Te
nant Name•
Date(s) Dut of Compliance:
Physical Unit: 5/23/2007 Violation of UPCS or local inspection standards
ViolaHon detail�: Bathroom has mold around tub, faucet leaks. Level 3
ro correct physical violations: Submit copies of completed, signed and dated work orders, receipts, invoices, and/or photos, et�
to show that noted items have been repaired/replaced.
For 1YIHFA:Use Oiily Tlie abov:e vio�ation(s) Were clarified this un�t waS not out of compl�ance as reportedi
L.Have nvt been:corxected ox ualable to determ.�r►e cozrECtiox�
❑.tiVere correct�d; LTnitisback;in com�liance on
BIN: MN-95-00030 Unit Tenant Name:
Date(s) Out of Compliance:
Physical Unit: 5/23/2007 Violation of UPCS or local inspection standards
Violation details: Bathroom door laiob loose. Level 3 Broken mirror, sharp hazard.
To correct physical violations Submit copies of completed, sigiied and dated work orders, receipts, invoices, and/ or photos, etc. I�
to show that noted items have been repaired/replaced.
For 1VIHFA LTse Only: The above violation(s) Were clanfied t�us uiut was not out of cainphatice as reported.
!i D Have i1o:t been.corrected or viiable :to deternvne :c�rrection
WQre..correct.ed> Uiut!is back ui conn�h�nce on
Center Pointe D2994 Brooklyn Center
Housulg Tax Credit Progra�n 6 2007 Inspection Report (ver. 3-07)
I
BIN: MN-95-00033 Unit TenRnt Name:
Date(s) Out of Compliance:
Physical Unit: 5/23/2007 Violatioii of UPCS or local inspectioii standards
iolation details: Low battery in smoke detector. Level 3
To correct physical violations Subinit copies of completed, signed and dated work orders, receipts, invoices, and/ or photos, etc.
to show that noted items have been repaired/replaced.
For _1VIHFA LJse O.rily: The above violation(s) C] YVere clarified klus uiiit uras ;i1ot otit of Coinpl�anGe as reported,;
Have rio beeri:correcte.d or u:nable .Eo deterinule caxrection.
Were.corrected:: Uiiitis bacicul coinpliazice;mi
BTN MN-95-00034 Unit Tenant Name:
Date(s) Out of Compliance:
Physical I�nit.� 5/23/2007 Violation of UPCS or local inspection standards
ViolaHon details: GFI ui kitchen doesri t test. Leve13
To correct physical violations Subinit copies of coinpleted, signed and datedwork orders, receipts, invoices, and/or photos, etc.
to silow that noted items have been repaired/replaced.
For 1VIHFA Use �xily The violat�ail(s).: Were clanfied -:thLS ui�it was i1oE out of coinplianee as reported;;
❑.Have not been:corrected or uilable to deterinule c�rrection
Wexe corrected: Uzuit:is back: u1 coni�Uance ox�
BIN MN-95-00034 Unit Tenant Name:
Date(s) Out of Compliance:
Physical Unit: 5/23/2007 Violation of UPCS or local inspection standards
Violation details: Tagged by city of Brooklyn Center as unfit for hwnan habitation.
o correCt physical violations: Submit copies of completed, signed and dated work orders, receipts, invoices, and/or photos, etc.
o show that noted items have been repaired/replaced.
For1VIHFA:Tjse Orily. The abov.e violation(s). i. W:ere clarified ;itlus uiutwas:not ou.t of coittpliance as reported.:
Have noE beeii:coirected or u:ilable E;q deter.inuze correct�:ijn
Were corrected: Umt�s ba��n com?�Iu�u1�e:Qn
BIN MN-45-00034 Unit Tenant Name:
Date(s) Out of Complianee:
Physical Unit.� 5/23/2007 Violation of UPCS or local inspection standards
Violation details: Entry door fra�ne cracked. Leve12 Missuzg refrigerator, missing tub stop. Owner is not makuig
reasonable attempts to re-rent the unit. Level 3
To correct physical violations Submit copies of coinpleted, signed and datedwork orders, receipts, invoices, and/or photos, etc.
to show that noted items haye been repaired/replaced.
For 1VIHFA!Use �iily. Tlie above violation(s) W;ere c1ar�Eied Elus u�ut was: not out of cpinphazlee as xeported;:
❑..Have no:t been corrected or unable to determ�ne correcti�on.
Q.4Vexe corrected: Uxu.t::is back in cov.inliance o�
I Center Pouite D2994 Brooklyn Center
Housulg Tax Creclit Progra�n 7 2007 I�ZSpection Report (ver. 3-07)
I BIN: MN-95-00035 Unit Tenant Name:
Date(s) Out of Compliance:
Physical Unit: 5/23/2007 Violation of UPCS or local inspection standards
Violation details: Windows and doors boarded up. DEA spray painted on boards. Owner is not making reasonable attempt
to re-rent the tuut.
To correct physical violations: Submit copies of completed, signed and dated work orders, receipts, invoices, and/or photos, etc.
to show that noted items have been repaired/replaced.
For1VIHFA:Use Ori1y. The abov.e violaEion(s) Were clarified -:this uiut was not o.ut of c�mphaiice as reported:
!❑..Have not been:cozxe�fed ox u:nable ta detexu�uie conrection,
VVere co:rrected.: Urut is back in comnliance on
BIN: MN-95-00035 Unit Tenant Name: I
Dcrte s Out o Com liance:
.f P
Physical Unit: 5123/2007 Violation of UPCS or local inspection standards
Violation details: Electrical hazard, resident reports use of oven or two stove burners trips and overheats breakers.
Leve13
To Correct phySiCal violations: Submit copies of completed, signed and dated work orders, receipts, invoices, and/or photos, etc.
to show that noted items have been repaired/replaced.
�or:;lY1H�A,Use Oiily Tkie above va.olatio�l(s) �I. Were.claxified �:tlus u:iut �vas not out.of coinphazi�ce as irepoxte�i:
C] Haue. not been:correcteti or uilable :to determule corre�tion
V1�ere corrected;: �hutrs back'in coixii�l�ance on
BIN: MN-95-40036 Unit Tenant Name:
Date(s) Out of Compliance:
Physical Unit: 5/23/2007 Violation of UPCS or local inspection standards
Physical Violation details: Water leaks into bathroom from uilit above. Tenant turned shut off valve for uiut above but
there is still leaking and sta�lding water on bathroom floor. Resident renorts water leaking from upstairs unit. Level 3
To correCt physical violatiolls: Submit copies of coinpleted, signed and dated work orders, receipts, invoices, and/or photos, et�'',
to show that noted items have been repaired/replaced.
Far;1VIHFA;Use Orily The aboye vialation�s) Were clarified =:this tui�t was not ou. of compl�aiice as reported;.
Have ngt been:corrected oruriable to detP�me:eorrectaan
tiVere_corrected:: Urut is backi� com;iliance on
BIN: MN-95-00037 Unit Tenant Name:
Date(s) Out of Compliance:
Physical Unit: 5/23/2007 Violation of UPCS or local inspection standards
ViolaHon details: GFI outlet in bathroom didn't test. Leve13
To correct physical violations Submit copies of completed, signed and dated work orders, receipts, invoices, and/or photos, etc.
to show that noted items have been repaired/replaced.
Fnr1VIHFA:LTse Only Tlie above violation(s� Were clari[ied =:this wcut was:not out of c�m hance as re orted:
P P I
0 Have 11ot beeri corrected or vnable to cletermine corrQCtion:
Wer� correCted,: :Uiut. is baCk u1 coinnhanC2 on
Center Pouite D2994 Brooklyn Center
Housutg Tax Credit Prograul 8 2007 I�ispection Report (ver. 3-07)
Building Violafions
The following violations were noted in the bticilding's exterior, common areas, and/or bacilding s�steans. Owner must submit
ciocumentation to ciczrifi� or correct all violations.
Number: IY�N-95-004�7 I' Address: 2802 �tortk�way Dr�ve
Building is out of compliance on 5/23/2007 due to violations of UPCS or local inspection standards
Violation details:
East entry to building door uloperable
Cutoff valve on boiler not shut off causing leakutg ul base pipe leadvlg to both boilers.
Missing latcl� on electrical box u1 electrical room. Door to electrical rooin is not seeured, broken lock.
Submit for correction of physical violations: Copies of signed and dated work orders, receipts, invoices, photo, ete. to show
that noted items have been repaired/replaced.
Repair/replace lock on entry door of buildin� and re�air cutoff valve on boiler unit to sto� leakin�.
For IvIHk'A Use Only The above vxolakion(s) Were conrected:Qn
Were clarified bwlding{�) were Yiot out: o.f compl�ance as reported
Have not been:correcEed or unable; tp detei�nme :correction
BZN;1'�uinber; MN-95=00018', �'Address, 2$06 Northway Drzve
Building is out of compliance on 5/23/2007, due to violations of UPCS or local inspection standards
Violation details:
North side of building security door inonerable, damage lock.
Submit for correction of physical violations Copies of signed and dated work orders, receipts, invoices, photo, etc. to show
that noted items have been repaired/replaced.
For MHFA. Use O�ly TJ.ie above violati�n(s) Were corrected oi1
Were clarified bwlding(s} �vere not out o:f compliance as reported
❑.I ia�e iiof been'corrected c�r unable:to deter�une correcti:on
BTN T�1u�nb.�r, MN-95 QQD19 Address 28:10 N;orthway Drive
Building is out of compliance on 5/23/2007, due to violations of UPCS or local inspection standards
Violation details: Inoperable entry security door, broken lock.
Submit for correction of physical violations: Copies of signed and dated work orders, receipts, invoices, photo, etc. to show
that noted items have been repaixed/replaced.
For1VIHFA:LTse Qnly: Tlie above violataon(s)::: Vifere corrected on
Were clariEied build�►�(s) �vere not ouk o:f Conipl�anC� as rep.arted
I: Ha�e n.o:t been: corrected.or uiiable dete.r�ule correctiion
BIN:Nunaber. MN .95-00021 Addr:ess. 2818 Narthway Drzve
Building is out of compliance on 5/23/2007, due to violations of UPCS or local inspection standards
Violation details: Entry security door broken door closer.
Submit for correction of physical violations Copies of signed and dated work orders, receipts, invoices, photo, etc. to show
that noted items have been repaired/ret�laced.
For:1VIHFA:iJse On1y: T11e aboue violafion(s) tNere corrected on
Were clar�ied building(s) were �?ot out o;f comp7�ancQ ?s reparted
Haue not beeii carrectied or unable ,to determule :correc�ion
Center Pouite D2994 Brooklyn Center
Housulg Tax Credit Program 9 2007 I�ZSpection Report (ver. 3-07)
j
�I
BIN:Number. MN-95-p0022 I Address: 282� Northway Drive
Building is out of compliance on 5/23/2007, due to violations of UPCS or local inspection standards f
Violation details: Two dryer vents are not hooked up properly leaving excessive amount of lint on the wall, fire
hazard. Einergency light goes out when tested on second floor landing also has a loose door knob.
Submit for correction of physical violations Copies of signed and dated work orders, receipts, invoices, photo, etc. to show
I that noted items have been repaired/replaced.
For.MHFA LTse Only The abov,e:�olation(s) Were corrected on
0 Were clarified bwldul s were liot out of compliance as reported
g(
❑.Have not been corrected or ui�able to detea�inule correctioil.
BIN Number MN=95-0Q023 I Address 282b Norrhway Dr�ve
Building is out of compliance on 5/23/2007, due to violations of UPCS or local inspection standards
Violation details: Dryer vents in laundry room are not vented properly leaving excessive amounts of lint on the wall,
fire hazard.
Submit for correCHon of physical violations: Copies of signed and dated work orders, receipts, invoices, photo, etc. to show
I that noted items havebeen reDaired/replaced
For 1VTHFA LTse Unly The above violation(s) `❑�Nere corrected:on
jNexe clarified bwldiilg(s) were not out of compllance as reported.
Have no:t bee�:coxxecCed or un�b�e ko dete.rmine correction
BIN Numb$r MN-95 Q0024 I Address �;830 Northway Drive
Building is out of compliance on 5/23/2007, due to violations of UPCS or local inspection standards
Violation details: Trip hazard froin torn and frayed carpet on stairs in common area, back side of buildulg. Dryers not
vented properly leaving excessive lint on wall behind dryer, fire hazard. Basement stairwell has loose hand rail.
I Submit for correction of h sical violations: Copies of signed and dated work orders, receipts, invoices, photo, etc, to show
P Y
that noted items have been renaired/replaced.
For 1VIHFt� Use Qnly The abov2 ��lakion(s) VVere �orreGtedi4n s
0 Were clarified bwlding(s) were no;t out of campliance as re�orted
Have not been e�rrected or iinable t� detei�nu►e earrecti�n 'i
1 �ddress .2900 i�Torthv,ra� Drive I
BIN Number 1VIN-95 .QOD27
Building is out of compliance on 5/23/2007, due to violations of UPCS or local inspection standards
Violation details: Dryer vents not vented broperly leaving excessive lult on wall be11u1d dryer, fire hazard.
Submit for correction of physical violations Copies of signed and dated work orders, receipts, invoices, photo, etc. to show
that noted items have been repaired/replaced.
For1VIHFA iJse Only T7ie above v�olal�on(s) Were corrected on
Were clarified bwlclin�(s) yvere no!t out of compliance as reported::
Have not beeii:coxrected or uixable xo detsirinule::cor�rQ:ction.
i
Center Povlte D2994 Brooklyn Center
Housulg Tax Credit Progra�n 10 2007 I��spection Report (ver. 3-07)
G
BZN;Num1ier. MN-95-Q0030 Address. 29�2 Northway Dr�v�
Building is out of compliance on 5/23/2007, due to violations of UPCS or local inspection standards
iolation details: In center courtyard inissulg haild rail at steps (more than 4). Laundry room has excessive lint on
valls, fire hazard. First floor einerQency horn han�inQ by wires.
Submit for correction of physical violations Copies of signed and dated work orders, receipts, invoices, photo, etc. to show
that noted items have been repaired/replaced.
For 1VIHFA iJse On1y: Tlie abov:e violaMon(s) Were corrected:�n
C� �'Vere �lai bui�ding(s) wer� not out o.f �ompliance as repozked;:
Have not been;corrected or uilable:fo dete.rnune ;correc�ion.
BIN:Number.. MN-95 QQ032 �!Address: 2920 Northway Drive
Building is out of compliance on 5/23l2007, due to violations of UPCS or local inspection standards
Violation details: North entrance security lnissulg door closer does not lock. Laundry room has excessive lint on wall
behind dryer due to improper ventulg, fire hazard.
Submit for correction of physical violations Copies of signed and dated work orders, receipts, invoices, photo, etc. to show
that noted items have been repaired/replaced.
F�r:iVIHFA'Use Oiily 1'lie above violation(s) tNere ccarrected!on
Wexe clarzfied bwil.duzg(s) �vexe �iot ou.t of coxnphance as repoxted
Have riot been corrected or u;nable Eo determine !correceion
BIN Numbez. MN-95-OQ033 Address. 29Z4 TTorthway Drz�e
Building is out of compliance on 5/23/2007, due to violations of UPCS or local inspection standards
Violation details Mold on wall in basement hallway Izear laundry room. Water heater rusting aild corroded on to�.
ubmit for correction of physical violations Copies of signed and dated work orders, receipts, invoices, photo, etc to show
hat noted items have been repaired/replaced.
For1VIHFA:Use Only Tlie abaue violation(sj 0 Were corrected: on
4Vere clarified building(s) tivere not out o'f coinpl�ance as re�orEed
Have_not been:correeted or iinable tp deterinule .correcti�n
BZ1eT'Numb;er M1V=95 QUO36 �;Addi 2936 Northwa: Drive.
Y
Building is out of compliance on 5/23/2007, due to violations of UPCS or local inspection standards
Violation details: Exterior wall has large cracks and is senarating from wall.
Submit for correction of physical violations: Copies of signed and dated work orders, receipts, invoices, photo, etc. to show
that noted items have been repaired/replaced.
For:IVIHFA TJse Qril Tlie above violation s Were correcte:d on
y
Were claxified builciing(s) ivere z1q;t out bf com.pliance as rep.orted
Have ii.o.t been:�orrected or uilable :ko deterin�le.;correction
BIN Number MN-95-OQ037 Address: 2940 Narthw�y Drive
Building is out of compliance on 5/23/2007, due to violations of UPCS or local inspection standards
Violation details: Entry security door has broken door closer.
Submit for correction of physiCal violations: Copies of signed and dated work orders, receipts, invoices, photo, etc. to show
that noted items have been revaired/replaced.
For MHFA Use Only The above violation(s) ❑.Were corrected on
0 4Vere clarified bwlding(s) were not out o;f.; coinpl�ance as reported
Have ilot been:corrected.or uilable to deterinule correctiqn.
Center Poulte D2994 Brooklyn Center
Housulg Tax Credit Program 11 2007 I�ZSpection Report (ver. 3-07)
Project Violations
The following violation(s) impact the entire property. These niust be clarified or corrected and evidence of correction supplied to I
MHFA. �i
'roject is out of compliance on 2/15/2007;
Owner's Certification of Continuin Program Compliance, HTC 12, certifies the following as out
g
of compliance.
Owner failed to provide violation reports of local health, safety or building codes.
Violation details
Per review of the 2006 Tax Credit Swnmary Report, the followulg uiuts are out of compliance:
MN-95-00018--2806-- 6/11/2006 Nonqualified full time student
MN-95-00019--2810-- 9/20/2004 Nonqualified full tiv.ne student
MN-95-00024--2830-- 6/29/2006 Owner authorized move-in without ulcome certification
MN-95-00025--2834--11/30/2006 Owner authorized move-u1 without income certificakion
MN-95-00032--2920-- 4/19/2002 Owner authorized move-in without income certification
MN-95-00033--2924-- 7/14/2006 Owner authorized move-u1 without incoine cerrification
MN-95-00037--2940-- 6/14/2006 Owner authorized move-in without income certification
MN-95-00021--2818-101--Unsuitable for occupancy as of 3/10/2006
2--2 04-204--Casualt loss due to fire on 3 1 2005
MN-95-000 8 9 y
Property should have 100% tax credit units.
The owner certified that the City of Brooklyn Center issued a report of a violation but did not provide a copy of the
report as required under item #8 of the Owner's Certification of Contuiuing Program Compliance. It is our
than 40 of the units are in com liance
t th it ins ected all of the units in the ro ert If less p
understandin tha e C
g Y P P P Y
with City codes, then the nroperry has failed its m;n;mum set-aside.
IZecommended correction:
All units will remain out of compliance until the current tenant becomes income eligible, an eligible
household moves in, and/ or the unit is suitable for occupancy. Submit the tenant income
.:ertification for a qualified occupant or evidence that the unit is suitable for occupancy, whichever
applies.
Provide a copy of the 2006 inspection report issued by the City of Brooklyn Center.
For 11rIHFA Use Qrilp: Tlie above viola�iori(s) Were ct�:rrecred-on
❑�Nere clar�fied bwlchxig(s) were nof: out of compliance �s rep.or:ted
r
Have no:f been correcte:d or uilable to. deterinule correction i;;:
Technical Deficiencies/General Comments
Tech�iical deficiencies are considered pa�oblems with a unit or errors in a tenant fite that are of concern to the inspector, but are not of a
nc�fure to cause a compliance violation. Any technical cteficiencies noted were discussed with the designated contact person during the
inspection de-briefing, and therefore rnay only be sicmmarized below. Technical deficiencies shoulcl be addressed throiagh routine
maintenance of units and tenant files c�nd managers should impletnent procedures to avoid these ttjpes of problems in the futtcre. It is
uot necessa�7,/ to sub�aiit a respo�ise to MHFA for tecli�cicc�l defzciencies. Please concertt�•ate yoics• effot on tlie
unco�7�ected nor�coanpliance identified above.
File Inspection Deficiencies Noted:
Certification and/or verification procedures do not always follow HUD Handbook 4350.3
and/ or MHFA Section 42 income determination and documentation guidelines:
Do not include rental assistance as income
Some or many files contained "retroactive" certifications. Management should implement
procedures to ensure recertification s are done timely.
Gross annual income and/ or income from assets not calculated correctly, but correct
calculation did not cause unit(s) to exceed eligiUility requirements.
Brookl n Center
nt r Poulte D2994 Y
Ce e
Housulg Tax Credit Prograin 12 2007 Inspection Report (ver. 3-07)
o Unit 2802-did not calculate overtime. HH well below income limits.
Unit 2806-calculated using incorrect anlount of weeks
Unit 2806-overtime was not calculated
Unit 2818-tax returns showed higher income than resident certified for self employment
hi her amount of hours than what
Unit 2912-mana ement calculated inco
me usin
g g g
verification states
Any changes made on signed documents (applications, verifications or required MHFA forms)
must be initialed Uy the person making the change.
Physical Inspection Deficiencies Noted:
Repair maintenance items considered technical deficiencies that were discussed after the
physical inspection.
Throughout property there are worn walking paths and bare patches where grass should
be,
Repair or replace cracked or missing crisper drawers and/or condiment shelves in
refrigerators,
Unit 2924-104 missing refrigerator handle
Repair all leaking faucets in units.
Replace or repair damaged towel bars
Replace or repair damaged blinds
Re air or re lace an dama ed li ht switches
p P Y g
g
Repair or replace damaged cabinet drawers and/or cabinet doors
Replace any missing molding in units and common areas.
Repair nonworking lights in unit closets
Unit 2826-103 water stains on ceiling in hall linen closet
Clean dirty grout in bathrooms
Clean or replace dirty carpets
Repair closet doors
Replace/repair any missing or damaged screens
Replace any missing light covers
Repair spalling sidewalk at southwest corner near office
Repair any holes in walls throughout property
Resident in unif 2932-104 reports mice in her unit. No mice or evidence of mice oUserved
by inspector but manager should inspect and treat if needed.
Address housekeeping issues with units identified and discussed after inspection
Detached downspout leaning against building at entrance of 2932 Northway Drive
Remove graffiti from;
2814 Northway Drive south side of building,
2912 Northway Drive on laundry room door
2920 Northway Drive in north hallway
2924 Northway Drive on laundry room door
Old water heater stored in 2936 Northway Drive
Center Povlte D2994 Brooklyn Center
Housui Tax Credit Pro a�n 13 2007 I�zspection Report (ver. 3-07)
Comments
Minnesota Housin is in receipt of a copy of the Notice of Abatement of Public Nuisances an��'
g
criminal complaints against the owners of the property (see attached) issued by the City of Brooklyn
a ate the nuisances and control and
v romised to b
Center. The Ci has noted that o
wners ha e
P
tY
operate the premises to avoid the crimes and nuisances and have failed to do so. Owners have failed
to implement security measures, including, but not limited to, adequately locking and securing
doors, providing adequate lighting, have failed to hire security staff, as promised, and have failed to
secure buildings from casual intruders.
It is our observation that the property would benefit greatly from on-site personnel living at the
property and either on-site or patrolling security personnel since there is currently no on-site
�resence other than during regular office hours. Minnesota Housing strongly recommends that
owner dedicate whatever number of units is necessary and reasonable for a property of this size and
configuration for on-site managers, caretakers, maintenance personnel, and security staff to ensure
the safety and security of residents as well as maintaining the property so that it meets the City's code
standards and the Uniform Physical Conditions Standards required for con�pliance with Section 42.
These units can be considered "common s ace" units, which are not included in either the numerator
P
or denominator of the applicable fraction pursuant to Revenue Ruling 92-61. The on-site staff does
not need to be income qualified if they occupy a unit that is so treated. Attached is a form entitled,
"Treatment of Common Space Unit Pursuant to Revenue Ruling 92-61," which can be submitted to
�otify Minnesota Housing of which units will be used for on-site staff.
It was noted during the file review that some residents apparently do not meet the propert�s
screening criteria for drug and crime free housing; however they have been allowed occupancy.
Owner should apply its screening criteria consistently to all applicants.
Tenants should be instructed through house rules or occupancy �olicy for the property on what is
expected in maintaining a�safe and clean unit. Maintenance staff commented that repairs cannot be
done in a timely manner if at all due to an insufficient maintenance budget.
Files were very well organized.
nt r Poulte D2994 Brooklyn Center
Ce e
Housulg Tax Credit Program 14 2007 I�ZSpection Report (ver. 3-07}
Corrununity Development
c;h�„r 6301 Shingle Creek Parkway 55430
131100KLf'N
CENTER Phone:763-569-3300 Fax: 763-569-3494
Buildin�/Housin� Maintenance Com��liance Order
DATE: Apri125, 2007 Notice of Remaining Items
TO: Hyder Jaweed
3 Blue Spruce Court
St. Paul, MN 55127
LOCATION: Centerpointe Apartments
COMPLIANCE DATE: Apri130; 2007
COMPLIANCE OFFICIAL: John Rued
The following violations of the Buildine Maintenance and Occunancv Ordinance were cited
during a recent inspection of the above premises. These violations must be corrected by the
compliance date indicated. Reinspection to verify code compliance is scheduled for April 30,
2007 in the AM. Please contact us if this date creates a conflict.
Failure to correct violations or to make satisfactory arrangements to correct violations acceptable
to the compliance official may result in suspension or revocation of your rental dwelling license
if applicable. In addition, your failure to comply may result in the issuance of a citation, which,
upon con��iction, is punishable by fine and/or imprisonment.
The City Council adopted Res. No. 99-172 which provides for a fee of �50.00 to be charged
for each i•einspection necessaiy after the first i•einspection. The reinspection fee(s) will be
payable at the time of license renewal for the property, prior to the license being issued.
Section 12-1202 of the Ordinance also provides for Right of Appeal, when it is alleged that a
Compliance Order is based upon erroneous interpretation of the Ordinance. The Appeal must be
submitted to the Community Development Department, in writing, specifying the grounds for
Appeal, within five (5) business days after service of the order, and must be accompanied by a
filing fee of $50.00 in cash or cashier's check.
MN Statutes 504B.211 requires a landlord to give a tenant reasonable notice that entry to the
rental unit may take place for the purposes of performing an inspection. Please notify your
tenants of the date and time of the inspection at least 48 hours in advance.
If you have any questions or comments, please contact me at 7G3-569-3344,
Monday through Friday, 8:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.
Page 1
DESCRIPTION OF VIOLATIONS AND ORDINANCE SECTION,
in a walk throuah ins ection of the common areas of the
The followin„ items were noted dur g b p
Properiy on February 8, 2007.
Building 280G
l. Third floor light globe—north side.
Building 2810
l. Repair/replace security entrance door and—south end.
Building 2814
1. Repair/replace east entrance door—not secure (on order).
Building 2818
l. Second floor fire door—north side.
Basement/Laundiy room
1. Laundry light globes—broken and/or missing.
Building 2838
1. Third floor fire door and latch.
Basement/Laundiy room
1. Basement/laundry room fire door missing.
Building 2912
1. Entrance door not secure-west side.
2. Exposed high voltage wiring at second floor landing near west entrance.
3. Entrance door not secure—north side.
Building 2920
1. Entry door not secure—north side.
Building 2924
1. Entrance door not secure (both the lock and latch)—south side.
BasemendLaundiy i•oom
1. Equipment access panel door not secured in basement/laundry area.
2. Basement/laundry area fire door and light.
Building 2940
1. First floor fire door—north side.
i
Page 2
Coinmunity Development
c;n-��r 6301 Shingle Creek Parkway 55430
11ROOKLYN
CENTER Phone:763-569-3300 Fax: 763-569-3494
Buildin�/Housing Maintenance Coma�liance Order
DATE: April 17, 2007 Notice of Remaining Items
TO: Hyder Jaweed
3 Blue Spruce Court
St. Paul, MN 55127
LOCATION: Centerpointe Apartments
COMPLIANCE DATE: Apri125, 2007
i
COMPLIANCE OFFICIAL: John Rued
The following violations of the Buildin� Maintenance and Occu�ancv Ordinance were cited
during a recent inspection of the above premises. These violations must be corrected by the
compliance date indicated. Reinspection to verify code compliar►ce is scheduled for in the
Please contact us if this date creates a conflict.
Failure to correct violations or to make satisfactory arrangements to correct violations acceptable
to the compliance officia.l may result in suspension or revocation of your rental dwelling license
if applicable. In addition, your failure to comply may result in the issuance of a citation, which,
upon conviction, is punishable by fine and/or imprisonment.
The City Council adopted Res. No. 99-172 which provides foi• a fee of �SOAO to be charged
for each reinspection necessaiy aftei• the first reinspection. 'The reinspection fee(s) will be
payable at the time of license renewal for the property, prior to the license being issued.
Section 12-1202 of the Ordinance also provides for Right of Appeal, when it is alleged that a
Compliance Order is based upon erroneous interpretation of the Ordinance. The Appeal must be
submitted to the Community Development Department, in writing, specifying the grounds for
Appeal, within five (5) business days after service of the order, and must be accompanied by a
filing fee of $50.00 in cash or cashier's check.
MN Statutes 504B.211 requires a landlord to give a tenant reasonable notice that entry to the
rental unit may take place for the purposes of performing an inspection. Please notif�� your
tenants of the d
ate and time of the ins ection at least
48 hours in advance.
P
If you have any questions oi� comments, please contact me 1t 7G3-5G9-3344,
Monday through Friday, 8:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.
Page 3
DESCRIPTION OF VIOLATIONS AND ORDINANCE SECTION
llo in items were noted durin a walk throu�h ins ection of the common areas of the
The fo w g g b p
Property on February 8, 2007.
Building 2802
1. Holes in wired glass first floor fire door—north.
Basement/Laund�y room
l. Fire door and holes in wired glazing.
Building 280G
2. Entrance door not secure—east side (adjust closure tension).
3. Third floor light globe—north side.
4. Entrance door closure—north side (adjust closure tension).
Building 2810
2. Repair/replace security entrance door and sidelight—south end.
3. Third floor fire door closure—south side.
Building 2814
2. Repair/replace east entrance door—not secure (on order).
3. First floor emergency light—north side.
4. Broken corridor light (may be bumt out).
Buildin
g
2818
2. Second floor fire door—north side.
3. First floor emergency light missing—north side.
Basement/Laundry room
l. Secure equipment access panel in basement corridor.
Building 2834
1. Entrance door not secure—west side. I
2. Graffiti at second floor landing (top of knee wall).
Basement/Laund�y room
2. Laundry light globes—broken and/or missing. I
3. Moldimildew on walls in corridor connecting the two buildings.
Building 2838
2. Third floor fire door and latch.
Building 2904
1. Second floor fire door.
Page 4
Building 2908
1. First floor emergency light and stair landing light—north side.
2. Second floor fire door—north side.
Basement/Laundiy room
2. Basement/laundry room fire door missing.
Building 2912
4. First floor hallwa5� light.
5. Entrance door not secure—west side.
6. Exposed high voltage wiring at second floar landing near west entrance.
7. Entrance door not secure—north side.
Basement/Laund►y room
1. Clean laundry room floor.
Building 2920
2. Entry door not secure—north side.
Building 2924
2. Entrance door not secure (both the lock and latch)—south side.
Basement/Laundiy room
3. Equipment access panel door not secured in basement/laundry area.
4. Basement/laundry area fire doar and light.
Building 2928
l. Second floor emergency light and stair landing light—north side (low battery).
Building 2940
2. First floor fire door and light north side.
3. Third floor light globe—south side.
Page 5
Community Development
IIROOKLI N 6301 Shingle Creek Parkway 55430
Phone:763-569-3�00 Fax: 763-569-3494
CENTER
Buildin�/Housing Maintenance Comx�liance Order
DATE: February 21, 2007 Fina1 Notice I
TO: Hyder Jaweed
3 Blue Spruce Court
St. Paul, MN 55127
LOCATION: Centerpointe Apartments
COMPLIANCE DATE: Mai•ch 5, 2007
COMPLIANCE OFFICIAL: John Rued
The following violations of the Buildin� Maintenance and Occunancv Ordinance were cited
during a recent inspection of the above premises. These violations must be corrected by the
compliance date indicated. Reinspection to verify code compliance is scheduled for in the
Please contact us if this date creates a conflict.
Failure to correct violations or to make satisfactory. arrangements to correct violations acceptable
to the compliance official may result in suspension or revocation of your rental dwelling license
if applicable. In addition, your failure to comply may result in the issuance of a citation, which,
upon conviction, is punishable by fine and/or imprisonment.
The City Council adopted Res. No. 99-172 which provides for a fee of $50.00 to be charged
fot• each reinspection necessaiy aftei• the fii•st reinspection. The reinspection fee(s) will be
payable at the time of license renewal for the properly, prior to the license being issued.
Section 12-1202 of the Ordinance also provides for Right of Appeal, when it is alleged that a
Compliance Order is based upon erroneous interpretation of the Ordinance. The Appeal must be
submitted to the Community Development Department, in writing, specifying the grounds for I
com anied b a
Appeal, within five (5) business days after service of the order, and must be ac p 5
filing fee of $50.00 in cash or cashier's check.
MN Statutes 504B.211 requires a landlord to give a tenant reasonable notice that entry to the
rental unit may take place for the purposes of performing an inspection. Please notify your
tenants of the date and time of the inspection at least 48 hours in advance.
If you have any questions or comments, please contact me at 7G3-569-3344,
Mond�y through Friday, 8:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.
Page 6
DESCRIPTION OF VIOLATIONS AND ORDINANCE SECTION,
The following items Fvere noted during a walk through inspection of the common areas of the
Property on February 8, 2007.
Building 2802
2. Holes in wired glass first floor fire door-north.
3. Emergency light-south side.
4. Second floor emergency light.
5. 'Third floor emergenc5� light-north side.
Basement/Laundry room
2. Dryer tops missing.
3. Broken fluorescent light globe.
4. Missing fluorescent light globe.
5. Equipment access panel in carridor not secure.
6. Fire door and holes in wired glazing.
Building 2806
5. Entrance door not secure-east side.
6. Third floor emergency light.
7. Third floor light globe-north side.
8. Entrance door closure-north side.
Building 2810
4. Repair/replace security entrance door and sidelight-south end.
5. Repair/replace security entrance door moulding-south end.
6. First floor emergency light-south and north.
7. Repair/replace door moulding-west entrance door.
8. Second floor emergency light-south end.
9. Third floor emergency light-south end.
10. Third floor fire door closure-south side.
11. Third floor emergency light-north side.
Basement/Laundiy room
1. Laundry room fire door and both door knobs.
2. Clean laundry room.
Building 2814
5. First floor emergency light-south side.
6. Repair/replace east entrance door-not secure.
7. First floor fire door-south side.
8. First floor emergency light-north side.
9. Entrance door not secure-north side.
10. Broken corridor light (may be burnt out).
11: Third floor emergency light-south side.
12. Third floor fire door /closure.
I 13, Third floor emergency light-north side.
Page 7
14. Repair/replace window screen at first floor apartment.
Buildin 2818
g
4. Entrance door not secure—south side.
5. Secand floor fire door—north side.
6. First floor emergency light missing—north side.
Basement/Laundty room
1. Broken light globe
2. Fire door not operating correctly—north side.
Building 2822
1. Entrance door not secure—east side.
2. First floor emergency libht—north side.
3. Entrance door not secure—north side.
Building 2826
1. First floor emergency light—south end.
2. First floor fire door not o eratin ro erl —south end.
P
gP P
Y
3. Verify that the heat sensor/smoke detector in the laundry room is functioning properly.
4. Third floor fire door not operating properly—south end. I
5. Third floor emergency light.
Basement/Laundry room
e an
el in basement corridor.
2. Secure e ui ment acc ss
q P P
s�
Building 2830
1. Fist floor emergency light south end.
2. Fire door knob.
Building 2834
3. First floor fire door—south side.
4: Entrance door not secure—west side.
5. Third floor fire doors—north and south sides.
6. Graffiti at second floor landing.
Basement/Laundty room
4. Laundry light globes—broken and/or missing.
5. Mold/mildew on walls in corridor connecting the two buildings.
Building 2838
3. Entrance door not secure—north side.
4. Second floor light globe
5. Second floor fire door closure.
6. Third floor emergency light.
7. Third floor fire door and latch.
8. Graffiti on wa11 at second floor landing.
9. Second floor emergency light—south side.
Page 8
i
10. Graffiti on glass at east entrance door.
1 l. First floor emergency light-south side.
12. Electric meter room door not secure/broken.
13. Low battery indicator on monitoring panel.
14. Entrance door not secure-east side.
Building 2900
1. Entrance door not secure-south side
2. Broken glass at security door/sidelight-south side.
3. Second floor emergency light-north side.
4. Entrance door not secure-east side.
Basement/Laundiy room
1. Equipment/appliance room door near laundry room-north side.
Building 2904
2. First floor fire door-south side.
3. First floor emergency light-south side.
4. Second floor fire door.
5. Third floor hallway light.
6. Third floor emergency light.
7. First floor fire doar closure-north side.
8. Entrance door not secure-north side.
Building 2908
3. First floor emergency light and stair landing light-north side.
4. First floor fire door-north side.
5. First floor stairway light.
6. Second floor emergency light-south side.
7. Third floor emergency light-south side.
8. Second floor fire door-north side.
Basement/Laundiy room
3. Basement/laundry room fire door missing.
4. Basement electrical room door.
Building 2912
8. First floor emergency light.
9. First floor hallway light.
10. Entrance door not secure-west side.
1 l. First floor stair light and emergency light.
12. Exposed high voltage wiring at second floor landing near west entrance.
13. Third floor fire door-north side.
14. Entrance door not secure-north side.
Building 2916
l. First floor fire door-north side.
2. Entry door not secure-east side.
I
Page 9
3. Third floor emergency light-south side.
4. Third floor fire door latch
5. Second floor emergency light.
6. First floor emergency light.
Basement/Laundry room
2. Repair hole in wall.
3. Repair washing machine.
4. Clean laundry room floor. i
Building 2920
3. Entry door not secure-north side.
4. First floor emergency light-north side.
5. 'Third floor hall light.
6. Entry door not secure-west side.
7. First floor fire door latch-south side.
Building 2924
3. First floor stair li ht and emer enc li ht-north side.
g g Y g
4. Entrance door not secure (both the lock and latch)-south side.
5. Second floor emergency light-south side.
6. Entry foyer lights-north and south.
7. Hole in the wall at second floor landinb north side.
8. Second floor emergency light and stair landing light-north side
m
Basement/Laundry i o
5. Equipment access panel door not secured in basement/laundry area.
6. Basement/laundry area fire door and light.
Building 2928
2. First floor emergency light and stair landing light-north side.
3. Second floor emergency light and stair landing light-north side.
4. Third floor emergency light-south side.
5. Second floor emergency light and/or battery-north side.
6. Second floor fire door-north side.
7. First floor emergency light-north side. i
Building 2932
1. Third floor fire door closure-south side.
2. Second floor fire door-south side.
Basement/Laundiy room
1. Secure equipment access panel in basement/laundry area.
Buildin 2936
g
l. Entry door not secure-north side.
2. Second floor emergency light-north side.
3. Third floor emergency light south.
4
i
Page 10
4. Damaged window screen on the ground at east side of building.
Building 2940
4. First floor fire door and light—north side.
5. Third floor light globe—south side.
6. Entry door closure—south side.
I
Page 11
oep ui ��s:�csa vvunam �ienana �vo o�u 0�4J (��L
Printed by: bc11410 �IlC1C�e11� R@�.?OP� Page 1 of S'
Prinfed date/time: 9/10/O7 12:06
BROOKLYt,I CEl�TER POLICE D[PT
6G45 HL1M80LDT AVE N
BF:OUKLYN CENTER, t�/IINNESOTA b5430
(763) 5&9-3333 Incident Number: BCQ7-0019ti7 f
Itaciden# Summarv
incident Type: CR{lv11NAL OFFENSE(S) 42eport Type: ASSAULT
Inc Occurred Address: 2900 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MN �543D Sector/Beat: lBC04
Inc Occurred 5tart: 04/0512007 10;3D In� Occurred End: Report Taken:
Domestic: N �ias MoEivation: Gang Related: U Su6stance: U
Contact Nature: Reported Date/Time: Q4l09/2007 10:DD
Reporting Oificer: OLSON, TERRY Primary Assigned Officer.
Case 5latus: CLOSED bisposition: GXCEPTIONAL CLEAP.ED Disposition Date: 04;11/20D7 12:32
Offenses
Statute Code: oD9-72 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: D�STURB-0150RDERLY COTIDUCT
Counts; 1 Statute Severi2y: MISDEMEANOR
Statute Code: 609-22d-1 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: .4SSA'JLT-STf DEGC01�1MITS, ATfEMPTS OR 7HP.EATS HARiti9
Counts: 1 Statuie Severily: NfISD�N�EANOR
Officers
Event Association Emp#� 8adge# Name Squadr�
F:EPORTING OFFICER 3214 i14 OLSON, TERRI'
INVES71GA-0R 3214 114 OLSON, TERRY
Persons Involved i'
Person#: OOo7 MNI: 71904 Can IQ Suspect; !�!o I
Event Association: VICIIM Contact �atelTime: 04/09/2007 10:00
Name: DAHLINE, HEATHER FlLI50N
DOB: 1 1 /1 211 97'E Age: 35 3� Sex: FEMALE Race: VdHiTE
Fleiyht: 5' 5" 5' 5" WeighL 13D 1301bs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
Addresst 14'I& E 22ND STREET MINNEAPOLlS, MINI�(ES07A 55404 SectorlBeat
Plione Type 1: NOME Phonetl 1: (612) 385-7II7$ Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Qccupation: EmployedSchool:
I Person#1: 0002 MNI: 88288D Can ID 5uspecf: No
Event Association: SUSPECT Contact Date/Time;
Name: LEONARD, RODNEY RUSSELL
DOES: 01/95:196.i Age_ 44 44 5ex: INALE Race; WHITE
Height_ 5' 11" 5' 11" Weight: Z00 200 Ibs Eye Color: HAZEL Hair Color. BROVVN
Address: 3911 65TH 2D5 BROQKLYN CENTER, MII�(JESOTN �5430 Sector/Beat:
Phone Type 1: HONiE Phone# 1: (612) 57Q-1345 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: V�iORK Phone�t 2: (952) 3BD-U635 Ext 2:
�ccupation: MAINTENANCE h1FlN EmployedSchooL• CEI�I'ER POINTE F,PARTMEN7S
Person Offenses
Siai�rle Code: 609-22d-1 Enhancers.
5tattste Desc: HSSAULT-5TH DEGCOMMITS, ATfEMPTS �R THREATS HARtJI
Gounts: 1 �i
Statute Code: 5U9-72 Enhancers:
Statute Desc; DIS7UR6-DISOP.DERLYCOIJDUCT
GoUnts:
s,
JC'J G/ Vf VU.�J�cl YYIIIICIIII V vICllciliU :JVJ UGV VJ`tJ N.J
Page 2 of 5
pr�n�e�+ ���,-,i� incident Reparfi
P[�inted date/time: 9;1Q107 12:D6
t3RO0KLYN CE�JTER POLICE DEPT
645 HUME30LDT AVE N
6ROOtCLYN CENTEP, MlNNESOTA 55430 �ncident Number: BG07-
(763) 569-3�93
P�rsons lnvalved
Person#�; 0003
MNi: 18169448 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association, MEf�"fIONED Contact Date/Time:
Narne: JAV'JEED, HYDER RAe'.A Race: VVHITE
DOB: 10/06!1976 Age: 30 30 Sex: MALE
Wei ht: 135 145 Ibs Eye Color. BROWN Hair Color: BLACI<
HeiyS�t: 6' 0" 6' 0" 9 Sector/Beat'
Address: 3 BLUE SPRUCE NORTH OAI<S, MINNESOTA 55127
1: 651 493-4721 Ext 1:
hone T e 1: HON1E Phone#
P YP
61� 414
-0397 Ezt 2:
Pfione T pe 2. WORK Phone# 2
Y
Occupa[ion: EmployerlSchool:
Can ID Suspect: No
PersonH: 0004 MNI: 19132107
Event Associafion: MEIJTIONcD Contact DatelTime:
Name; ALI, ASGHEP. RAZA
DOB: 06/08/1981 Age: 25 25 Sex: MALE Race: RACE
Nair Color.
Height: 5' 1U" 5' 10" Weight, 19D-190 Ebs Eye Colvr. BRO�,NN gector/Beat:
Address:
PE�one Type 1: Phone# 7: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
pccupation: EmployeclSchoaL•
Person€{: U005
MNi: 3519511 Can ID Suspect: Pdo
Event Association N1EN71�NED Contact Date(fime; 04/11/20D7 14:15
Name: SYTSMA, ERIC ANTI-IONY
DOB: D8/D1l9983 Age: 23 23 Sex: MALE Race: VVHITE
Weight: '16�i 164 Ibs Eye Color: HAZEL Hair Color. BROWN
Heigl�t; 5' 11" 5' 'I 1" Se.ctor/Beat� lBC�4
Address: 2900 NORTHWAY DR 20] �RO(�KLYN CENTER, IVIINNESOTA 5543�
Phone Type 1: WORK Phonef€ 1: (703) 561-9072 Ext 'E:
Phone Type 2: CELL Phone�€ 2: (612) 298-065� [xt 2;
Occupation: PROPERTY MANAGER Employer/SchooL' CEI�ITEP. POINTE APARi NIENTS
Narratives
Enlered.DatelTime; 04I11J2D07 12_36 Narrative Type: SYNOPSIS
Subject: SYNOPSIS Author: OL50N, TERRY
1,�ictirn made report of Assault (cause fear) and Disorderly Co�duct. The Viciim and Suspect v✓ere both rnembers
of the Property 11�lanagement Team at Genler Pointe Apartments and on-duty at the time of the incident.
,'r
JC�.I GI V/ VU.J✓Q �VVIIIIQIII V VIGIIQIIU ✓Vt! VLV V:l`Tw1 ��1•�T
Prinled by: bc114io �CICIC�C:CI� �epOl't Page 3 015
Prinled date/tinte: 9i10/07 1206
BROOI<LYH CENTER POLIGE DEPT
664b i-ILfMSOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CEN7ER, MINNESOTA fi5430
(763} 569-3333 IIIGIdeClt NUIllbef: BC07-001917
Entered DateFfime: 04/1112007 1238 Narrative Type: MAtN REPORT
Subject: ICR Aulh�r: OLSON, TERRY
On 0�-09-2007 at approximately 10:D0 hours 1 received a phone call from Victim Dahiine who reported an incident
involving Suspecl Leonard. Victim Dahline told me:
She was the Property Manager at Center Poinie Apartmenls.
Suspect Leonard was the lead Maintet�ance Man there.
5he'd asked him for a(ist of vacant units available for nevr tenanFs.
She'd been ashing for the list repeatedly ior several weeks.
Each time she asked Suspect Leonard became increasing(y hostile.
Because Suspeci Leonard did not provide the lisi she could not move new tenants in.
On 04-05-2007 at approximately 10:30 she again asked for the (ist of apartments.
She was in the ren�al office and alone with Suspect Leonard at that time.
Suspect Leonard became agitated and left, but returned several minutes later.
V1�hen he did so he ran across the office toward her while she was seated.
She put her hands up to stop him, believing he was going to run into her.
He stopped just before running into her and screamed at her using profanity.
He did so for several minutes.
Given his conduct she feared for her safery, believing he may hit or push her.
After several minufes he left.
She called
Entered Qate/Time: 04l11/2007 14:49 Narrative Type: SUPPLEI�lENTA� REPORT
Subje�t_ /�DDITIONAL INFORMATION Author: OLSON, TERRY
On 04-11-2007 I spoke with the new Property Manager at ihe Center Pointe Apartments, Eric Syfsma. He
indicated that he befieved that ihe camera system in the office was recorded to a location off-site. He agreed to
attempt to locate any video recordings which were made for review in conjunctian with this investigation. He also
agreed to contact rr�e with his findings in a timely manner.
I JC�.1 L! V! VU.:lJCi VVIIIIQIII V VICIICIIIIJ JV.J vLV vJ'Y.J
Printed by: bc11={to If1CIC��C1� RG�r}�i'� Page 4 of 5
PNn1ed dateltime: 9/1 D/07 12:06
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6545 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MiNflESOTA 5543Q
���3� 5se•sa3s Incident Number: BCa7-001917
Entered Uate(T�ime: 04/12/2007 94:'IB Narrative Type: SUPPLEh1ENTAL REPORT
Subject: ADDITIONAL II�fFOP.MATION Author: OLSOt�, TERRY
On 04-12-2007 I spoke with Suspect Leonard by telephone regarding the ailegations made by Victirn Dahline, He
#old me:
Ha learned that Victim Dahline had been crifical of his work through other empioyees.
He confronted her about this while in the rental �ffice.
He didn'i recail what day this took place but agreed that it happened at around 10:00.
He told her to iake her complainis about him up with him directly.
At that time he was standing approximately ien feet from her.
He did not raise his voice, use profianity, or approach her.
She responded by getling up from iler deslc and shouting at him.
She walked up to him and stood very close in a confrontational manner.
She shouted at him using profanity.
He denies Victim Dahline's characterization of the incident
He believes aciivities taking place in the office are recorded.
'fl he recordin to confirm his slatement.
She su ested I revi w t g
99
As of time o! this report J am waiting f�r informalion from the current Property Manager. Erick Sytsma, regarding
the existence and availability oF video evidence.
Entered DatelTirne: 44/30/2007 15:15 Narrative Type: SUPP! Et,AENTAL REPORT
Subject• DISPOSITION Author: O�SON, TcRRY
I have communicated with Eric �ytsma by telePhone and in writing several times since he agreed to deterrrtine
whether video documentation of the conirontalion exists and to make it availabfe lo me. In each instance he
assured me that he was war}cing on it, The last time I spoke with him he told me that Asghe� Afi, one of the
property awners, was checicing into ihis as we1[.
Since thaf time neither has refurned correspondence or calls confrming this repeated request. I had anticipated
tl�iis result as it is consisient with #heir response when dealing with City offcials over the course of several years.
I do not have enough inFormation to draf� a Search Warrant ior video evidence because I do not know that it
exists. Beyond ihis 1 do not know who passesses this evidence if it d�es eYisi.
TF�ere are no viable investigative leads a# fhis (ime. For this reason 1 da not anticipate conducting further
investigation.
The case is Closed Exceptionally Cleared.
oe� r v i vy.vva vvunai i i v �.ronai iu �v� v�v v✓w N•v
Page 5 of 5
Printed by: bc114to �I'1CFC�E'l"tfi �G�J�I�
Prmted dalellime. 9/10J07 12:fl6
BRO�KLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
G645 HUMBOLDTAVE N �i'
SROOKLI'N CENTEl2, MINNES07A 55430 �nC1d211t NUfi1E]2�:I3GO�T-OQ�g�
{763) 569•3333
Siqrtatures
Reporting Oificer Date
Date
Supen�isor I
JCI.I Gf VI VJ.VVQ vvllllalll v vlcllallu vv�J vcv �v✓
pL1
(iT ap
�����f1 j�� l� k
o���
�L:i� �MN
Police Depa�txne�t
Scott Bechthold, Chi.ef of Police
7une 1", 2007
iVfi Asgher Ali
Mr. Hy�er Ja�veed
3 Blue Spzuce Cot�rt,
I�orth Oaks, MN 55127
Gentlenl en:
I am m�aking an official requesC for inforniation contained in tlle Occupancy Register relatiug to tl�e Center
Poiiite Apartment Cornplet Drookl}rn Center, MN. Below is the text of City Ordinance 12-909. Failure
to cumply tivitL� this request is a criininal offense. I specif cally request that you provide a copy af ihe
cu.iTenf Occupancy Record imu�.lediately. If you cannot pro��ide a copy contact rne to schedule an
a�poinmlent at the L3roolciyri Center Police Departrrient to mal�e these records available for copying as per
the Ordinance.
Section 12-909 OCCUPANCY R�GISTER REQULRED.
E��ery o�vner of a licensed rental dwelling coiitaining three or more dwellit7g
units shall ]ceep, or cause to be kept, a current register of occupancy for each
d��vellin.g unit which provides the follo�ving inforrnation:
1. Dv��elling unit address.
2. I*Iumber of bedrooms in d�velluig unit.
3. I�rames of adult occu��ants and nu�nber of adults and children (under 18
years of age) currently occupyi�lg the dwelling units.
4. Dates renteis occupied and vacated dwelling ui�its.
5. A chranological list of eomplai�lts and requests fox repair by du�elling unit
occupants, which connplaints and requests a.re related to ihe pro��isions of tl�is
Ordinance.
6. sirnilar chronoIog�ical list of all corrections made in response to suc1�
requests and complaints.
�uch register shall be made availab]e for viewing or cop}zng by the
cornpliance official at all reasonable tunes.
5 incerely,
Officer Tei7•yOlson
I�lvesligafor P��oblern Oriei�ted Po�zcing Uilit
nroolcI}�:1 Center Police Deparhnen.f
•763-569-3333
IlrooklynCeieterPoliceDepartmeni AoliceDepartment 7G3-5G9-3333
1iG45 Hia�tboldt flventte I�'ortJi TDD 763-SGI-5710
Ilrookfy�n Cenrer, A-1N 55930-I�Y53 F.4X 763-SGl-0717
Crin�e Tips 7G3-SGl-6699
KI:NNFTh' H.EIlT7
z-��.�rz r��w o�rzcEs, p,�..
3$S3 CENTRA.L AVE. N.E.
CaLLIfvIBIA HE.IGHTS, MN 55421
O.FFTCE (G12} 325-1.161 FA7i (763} 413-5174
Au�u�t 08, 2007
Jack Cann
Tim Thoz�:xpsan
Housing Pr.eservataon PrQ�ect
570 A,sbury St.
Suite 105
St. Paul, MN 55104
:�ax #GSI-642-0051
Rc, your Ictter datEd July 31, 2007 to D�nvn�urn .Man�cznent re�ardYng Centezpoint ApartmEnts.
J]ear C�.zan and Mr. Thompsc�n;
The puipose of this Ictter is to re;�pond specificaJiy to your ��tter dated suly�31, 2007 �nd to I
addr�ss issues �vithin that letter. r�s a. precursar ta this letter,l. recerrtl.y met wiith M.ona Langston trom
yvur o�'i.ce to discuss this property on July �0, 2�07. 1 will address th.e issues in thE order they a��
i.dentified in your. letter,
The vwmers respanded to the City c,f F3rooklyn Center's {"City") notice of nuis�a.nce abatement
with a cauaprehensive plan submitted ta .Mr. Clelland on J�ne 28, 2p07. i enclose a copy af tbis plan
for your review. Thc Owner's have Followed thraugh with tl7is plan, The or�y fornaal respon�.Se thaz i
have r�ceived from Mr.
ClEll�nd to thi5
t�nwsal
a etter dated J 0
P une 3 20�7. in thzs Ietter, he
sugge�ts onl twa concerns both �#'which h
Y ave be�n :NuI)
,y compl�ed vv�th at this t�me. I and the avvniers
object t� any cla.im b_y Mr. Clelland and the City t)ia1 ttus plan ha,.a not been s��bmii�ted a.r►d that it does
not address tkze issues identified in ihe nc�tice. L►ltima.tcly, the Owners have the right t� defend their
post���., �is in.dicatecl to Ms. Langston, the crime at the prvperky largely stems from a bus stop located
a�jacent ta the property, I have a�terr�pted t� get assistancc in ad�lres�ing this issue but to date, no one
seems tfl caze. It i.s a shatne since the ctime stcm.ming i`rom this bus stop might be a#�'ecCing the pr.esent
ten�.nts. Thas issue needs to be c�ealt with 1,ry person.s uther than the owners since t�� vwr�crs �a�nar
pi>iice an arEa .not owne�l by •them: I would ���preciatc �.ny assistance or thoughts you may have on this
issue as the City appEars to have i��noreci ifi.
The owners have addressed the work orders issued by the MHFA. Ti�cy h�ve add.�res.sed aiI of
t.be imr�ediate lit'e and safety issue5 identif ed by the Mt-iFA and are in th.e process of addressing other
issues idet�.tified by the Nf�TFA in tirrtely m�nner, It is .rrry underst.axidin� that t}a�y ha.ve been given a
Pariod af tirrie to complete these items,
The m�intenance code atems issuecl by t:he City on April 34, 2007 have bee� add�ssed. Your
i
tetter �pes not speci which orders ,you are rEferring to in your letter but I arr.x assuming that you are
i.ndicating those issued by the City on that same dare, I en;close a copy af those ord.ers for your review.
Tl�e.re are 15 items on thi.s li�t. These ite�r,s were speciiicaliy inspected by tk�e City a�ad atl. abated. Zn a.
ineetin� in whicl7 I attended, Larry Martin, the City's buildin� official speciflr,ally �.ckn�wledged that all
:F'rfteen items on this list have been c�mple�ted anc[ abatecl. My elient has rtacumentation tc� suppr�rt t}ais.
My Glients knows of na ou.tstanding work orde.rs_ tn your letter you afso indicate �hat "ord�rs i.ssued
iast fa]l, a�td rr�adc a cvnclitit�n of issuance of ti�e rental lieense f�� the pmperty aast Nave�x�iaer ��,ve stiII
not bcen complied with." .l believe t}�at t1�is is an inlccuratE statcment. My client's spent a sigziificant
amaunt of money making exterior renairs to the pro{�erty durin� the zniddle of the winter, Baged on
the City's own, re�o.rds, this is not accurate. �lgain, please (ook at the A,pri� 34, 20Q7 list of"rem�zning
�tems." �-Iow can tt�Ere be a long li�t of outstanding items when pnJy 15 items were x on April
3Q, 20Q77
Cez�terPo�nt Ener�,y h�5 been paid in :ftilL I. enclose a recei.pt fvr th� payment of the vutstanding
gas bill_ AIl of the out�tanding water bills have been paid; .I ettc.lose copies of those r. ecezpts.
I am unaware of what is address�d on page 18 af the Tax Credii coznpli�nce report arad
theref.ore cannot address thesE issu�s. Please .provide mc a co�a,y of this so that I can review at.
Ta�. Summary, all utiiity hT1Is have been pazd at the pre��n.ises and �,l! compliancE orclers issued by
ihe C.ity hav� been ct►mplet�d and abated. T�astly, all w�rk order5 adetttifi�d by tk�e M.F-iFA are being
flddressed in a tirriely manner. Tfyou wish to discuss tl3'ts ftirther, ple�se feel .fr�e to contact me.
Sincer ly,
�:ennetih Hertz
Gc: Jack W. Safar, David L Bricrton, A,rmand E. Brachman, :Paul. �Z. Sweer� Dominium Maa�a,�er..��nt.
CT
RTH JUDICIAL DISTRI
STATE ��I' MINN�SOTA
I'OU
CC?UNTI' OF HLNNEPIN DIVISION II BROOKL�'N CENTER
Or MINN.�SOTA CUMPLAINT SUMMONS
Plaintiff, _WAI'•R�iNT
CALENDAIZ D�T�
Nan1e ASGHER RAZA ALI 06/08/81 CCR#:
fii•st middle ]ast Date of Birth
Address AKA ASGHER JAWEED 3 BLUE SPRUCE COURT Calendar Date
City/ N �RTH OAKS M N 55127
State Zip Code Drivei License No.
COIviPLr�II1T
Lieutenant Kevin Benner Complainant, being duly sworn, malces complaint to the above-named
Coui•t and states that there is probable cause to believe that the Defendant conunitl:ed the following offense(s).
The con�plainant states that the following facts establish PROBABLE CAUSE:
Your complainant, ICevin Benner, is a Lieutenant for the City of Broolclyn Center Police
Department and has made an investigation into the faets and circumstances of this case. Sn
the course of his investigation, your complainant has reviewed department records regarding
calls for service to the Centerpoint apartment complex and personally spolcen to Officer
Terry Olson, the department's officer in overall charge of operations for multi-unit
residences. Your complainant has also received information from Larry Martin, Building
Official for the City who has given information in the past which has lead to valid arrests
and convictions. Defendant is one of the owners and principals of Brooltlyn Center Leased
ing Associates which is the owner of the Centerpoint apartment complex located at
hway Driue and County Road 10, in the City of Brook_lyn Center, Hennepin County,
Minnesota which is residential rental property. The property consists of addresses of 2802,
2806, 2810, 2814, 2822, 2830, 2B34, 2838, 2900, 2904, 2908, 2912, 2916, 2928, 2932, 2�36
and 2940 Northway Drive.
The public nuisances of which the City complains are the repetitive behavioral incidents
of offenses and crimes involving the use/possession/sale of controlled substances, unlawful
use/possession of firearms, including robberies, crimes, including residential burglaries
and auto thefts, and unlawful use of alcoholic beverages. The public nuisances consist
of the following:
1. Calls for service to this complex, excluding domesfic assault and medicai/welfare
checics and non crimes, are as follows 93 from January 2004 �Con nued n Attachme�nt} from
�i'HEi2�T'OI�, Complai lt p�a�s that said offender 4�ay be arrested and dealt with aecording to law.
J` i Compllmant s Signatu� e
�l�e�izd
ti�'ill�arn G 20
S�von� to and suUscribed and eon�plained of befoi me t lis day of
seCtioll: 6Q9.745 and Brooklyn Cenier Cily Ordinances 19-1 D1, 19-106 and
19-105; 609.74 and Brooklyn Cenler City Ordinances 19-101, 19-105
C11�i1'ge: �ft1r���e of Public Nuisance; IJ�aintenance of Public Nuisance
Judge of District Court
��o�, rn,,.. in�oo� COA4PLAII�T
ASGHER RAZA ALI
nuary 20U5 to January 2006 and 3A for the first quarter of 2007, which properly projects
136 calls for the year.
2, Since March 2D07, behavioral incidents occurring on the hep t f f oc o curring on 21 Apri 1 2 0 0�
07 fel
on t
a 20 Y
auto theft occuriing on 1 M y
burglary occurring on 17 April 2007, non domestic misdemeanor ass�ult occurling on 16 April
ssault occurring on 5 April 2007, burgl�ry occurring on 7 'I
2007, non-domestic misdemeanor a ril 2007, repoited crimirial
theft and misuse of credit cards occurring on 2. Ap m�tor vehicle
ril 2007, 2007 felony
A rch
Ma
P
2
4
sexual conduct involving a juvenile victim occuiiing on
theft occurring on 17 March 2007, motor vehicle tampering and criminal darnage nt�
occurring on 16 March 2007, bur9nvolvoncucontgolled4substances7occubbeng on 2 May(sale), 27
offenses 9
rch 21
on 9 Ma 23 Marcri
rrin arch
c�u 9 24 M
27 March, I
ril
12 A ril (sale),
2 0 I-� P
'1 felon P onduct I
Ap111, 25 Apil Y
March, 15 March, 13 March, 10 March, behavioral incidents involving disorderly c
occurring on 21 Apri1 a gross misdemeanor Third Degree DWleveraLesnocourringpon16aApril and
f alcoholic b 9 i
use o
awful
lvin unl
cidents invo g oits of
r ln re
behatioral es Cha ter 13, p
ut
t to
the rovlsions of Minnesota Stat P
'ec P er
b nt
Su Ce
2007. J Biookl n
A iil the Y
27 p
at
these incidents are on file and available for public inspectlon
Police Department.
Said acts constitute the maintenance of public nuisance on property owned by the property
owner and permitting or suffering public nuisance by the property owner in violation of
Minnesota Statues Sections 617.81, 609.74 and 609.745 and violation of City Oi dinances
Sections 12-910 and Chapter 19.
property owners have been personally notified of these violations and notified in
�iting. The property owners have promised to abate Shanduhavecfailed tondoosoandTheerate
the premises so as to avoid these crimes and nuisanee measures, including but not
property owners have affirmatively �ailed to irnplement security restricted access to
limited to adequately locking and secure doors, adequate lighting,
the premises, have failed to hire security staff, as promised, have failed to keep an
accurate tenant register, as required by law,
have failed to secure the buildings from
casual intruders and have affirmatively allowed this premises to suffer this crime.
Further, the criminal activity originating aultedsinpviolent cpimes ovencl�udingmhomicidend
residential areas of the city, which has res
The property also suffers f r
om numerous housing maintenance defects and violations
according to the description of violations attached hereto and lncorporated herein. A
compliance notice was served at the above described address on 21 February 2007 requiring
compliance by 5 March 2007. Reinspection revealed that the not all violations had been
corrected whereupon a second compliance notice was sent on 17 April 2007, requiring
compliance by 25 April 2007. Reinspection revealed that violations still e�:isted whereupon
a third compliance notice was sent requiring compliance by 30 Rpril 2007 but reinspection
revealed that a number of code violations still exist including rnissing nor inoperable
common area lights, doors in need of repair, entrance doors which did not loc)t or could not
be secured, exposed high voltage wiring and defective fire doors. Said housing
maintenance defects also constitute a continuing public nuisance.
State laws and City Ordinances place a legal duty upon owners of resiclential rental
nroperty to aifirmatively avoid public nuisances and housing maintenance code violations
d further impose responsibility upon the owner to ensure that persons occupying the
iemises to be disorderly
�remises conduct themselves in a manner so as not to cause the p`
and disorderly is defined, in part, as the violations of unlawful possession, delivery or
purchase of controlled substances, disturbing the peace, and violations of laws relating to
filearms.
CHARGE(S) (Continued on /�ttachment)
ASGHER RAZA ALI
�unt 1
Charge Maintenance of Public Nuisance
In Violation Of: 6D9.745 and BrooYlyn Center City Ordinances 19-101, 19-106 and 19-1D5
Ma�:imum Penalty: 90 days, or $1,000, or both, plus assessment of a11 costs of al�atement
Wherefore, your complainant states that from Januar)� 2007 to the present, within the
corporate limits of the City of Brooltlyn Center, County of fIennepin, State of Minnesota,
Asgher Raza Ali, a person having control of real property, did willfully, wrongf ully and
unlawfully peimit said real property to be used to maintain a public nuisance or 1et the
same lcnovring it would be so used, in violation of Minnesota Statutes 609.745 and Sections
19-101, 19-105 and 19-106 of the Ordinances of the City�Of Broolclyn Center.
Count 2
Charge Maintenance of Public Nuisance
In Violation Of: 609.74 and Brooklyn Center City Ordinances 19-101, 19-105 and 19-1D6
Maximurn Penalty: 90 days and/or $1,000, plus assessment of a11 costs of abatement
Wherefore, your complainant states that from ,7anuary 2007 to the present, within the
corporate limits of the City of Broolclyn Center, County of Hennepin, State of Minnesota,
Asgher Raza Ali, by an act or failure to perform legal duty, did willfully, wrongfully,
intentionally and unlawfully maintain or permit a condition which unreasonably annoys,
injures or endangers the safety, health, morals, comfort or repose of any number of inembers
of the public or is guilty of any act or omission declared by statutory law, the common law
or ordinance to be a public nuisance or permits real property under his or her control to
used to maintain a public nuisance or rents the same lsnowing it would be so used, in
olation of Minnesota 5tatute 6ection 609.74 and Sections 19-101, 19-105 and 19-106 of the
Ordinances of the City of Brooklyn Center.
Community Development
c�r,-��r 6301 Shingle Creelt Parlcway 55430
I3NODKLPN
C�11'TLR
Phone:763-569-»00 Fax: 763-569-3494
$uildin�/�iousin� Maintenance Com�liance �rder,
D Fiilal Notice
�..�..o
TO: IIyder Jaweed
3 Blue Spruce Court
St. Paul, R�IN 55127
LOCATION: Centerpointe Apartments
COMPLIANCE DAT�:
COMPLIANC� OFFICIAL: John Rued
The following violations of the Buildin� Maintenance and Occu�ancv Ordinance were cited
during a recent inspection of the above premises. These violations must be corrected by the
compliance date indicated. Reinspection to verify code compliance is scheduled for in the
Please contact us if this date creates a conflict.
Failur
e to correct violations or to make satisfactory arrangements to conect violations acceptable
to the compliance.official rnay result in suspension or revocation of your renta1 dwelling license
if applicable. In addition, your failure to comply may result in the issuance of a citation, which,
upon conviction, is punishable by fine and/or imprisonment
The City Couneil adopted Res. No. 99-172 which provides for a fee of $50.00 to be charged
tion fee s will be
e' ns
ec
i
her
T
ec�ion p
for eacb reinspection necessary after the pirsp rey SP ior to the license being issued.
payable at the time of license i•enewal f�r the ro ert p
Section 12-1202 of the Ordinance also provides for Right of Appeal, when it is alleged that a
Compliance Order is based upon erroneous interpretation of the Ordinance. The Appeal must be
submitted to the Comrnunity Development Departn�ent, in writiug, specifying the grounds for i
Appeal, within five (5) business days after service of the order, and inust be accompanied by a
c.
filing fee of 3�50
.00
in cash
or cashier s checl
Si:atutes 504B.211 re uires a landlord to give a tei�ant reasoi�able ilotice i;hat entry to the I
MN �1
rental unii n�ay talce place for the purposes of perforining an ulspection. Please i7otify your
tenants of the date and time of the inspection at least 48 hours in advance.
If you Iiave any questions or connments, please contact me at 7G3-569-3344,
Monday through Frida3�, 5:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.
PaGe 6
DESCRIPTION OF VIOLATIONS AND ORDINANCE 5ECTION,
The following itiems were noted during a wallc through iuspection of the common areas of the
Property on February 8, 2007.
Building 2802
2, Holes in wired glass first floor fire door—north.
3. En�ergency lighf—south side.
4. Second floor emergency light.
5. Third flo�r emergency light—north side.
Basement/Laundry ronm
2. Dryer tops missing.
3. Broken fluorescent light globe.
4. Missing fluorescent light globe.
e t access
anel in corridor not secure.
5. Equipm n p
6. Fire door ai�d holes in wired glazing.
Building 2806
5. Entrance door not secure—east side.
6. Third floor emergency light.
7, Third floor light globe—north side.
8. Entrance door closure—north side.
Building 2810
4. Repair/replace secur entrance door and sideligh� south end.
5. Repair/replace security entrance door moulding—south end.
6. First floor emergency Iight—south and north.
7. Repairheplace door moulding—west entrance door,
8. Second floor emergency light—south end.
9. Third floor emergency light—south end.
10. Third floor fire door closure—south side.
11. Third floor emergeucy light north side.
�asement/Laundr}� room
L Laundry room fire door and both door• lcnobs,
2. Clean laundry room.
Building 2814
5, First floar emergezlcy light—south side.
6. Repair/replace east eutrance door—not secure.
7. First floor fire door—south side.
8. First flooz emergency light iiorth side.
9. Entrance door not secure ilorth side.
10. Brolcen conidor light (nlay be burnt out).
1 L Third floor emergency light soutll side.
12. Third floor fire door /closure.
e enc li ht north side.
oor em i
Third fl Y g
13 g
Page 7
14. Repair/replace window screen at first floor apartment.
Building 2818
4, Entrance door not secure—south side, i
5. Second floor fire door—north side.
6. First floor emergency light missing—nort1� side.
Basemeut/L�undry room
l. Brolcen light globe
2. Fire door not operating correctly—noi side.
Building 2822
1. Entrance door not secure—east side.
2. First floor emer•gency light—noi side.
3. Entrance door not secure—north side.
Bnilding 2826
1. First floor emergency light—south end.
2. First floor fire door not operating properly—south end.
3. Verify that the heat sensor/srnoke detector in the laundry room is functioning properly.
4. Third floor fire door not operating properly—south end.
5. Third floor emergency light.
Basement/LaundryJ room
2. Secure equipment access panel in basement corridor.
Building 2830
1. Fist floor emergency light—south end.
2. Fire door knob.
Building 2834
3. First floor fire door—south side.
4. Entrance door not secure—west side.
5. Third floor fire doors—north and south sides.
6. Graffiti at second floor landing.
Basement/Laundry room
4. Laundry light globes—brolcen aaid/or missing.
5. Mold/mildew on walls in corridar coiuiecting the two buildings.
Building 2�38
3. Entrance door not secure—nortl� side.
4, Second floor light globe
5. Second floor fire door closure.
6. Third floor emergency light.
7. Third floor fire door and latch.
8. Graffiti on �uall at second floor landiilg.
9. Second floor emergency light—south side.
Page 8
10. Graffiti on glass at east entrance door.
11. First floor emergency light-south side.
12. Electric meter room door not secure/brolcen.
13. Low battery indicator on inonitoring panel.
14. Entrailce door not secure-east side.
Bu��a���� ayoo
1. Entrance door not secure-south side
2. Brolcen glass at security door/sidelight-south side.
3. Second floor emergency light north side.
4. Entrance door not secure-east side.
Baseme�at/ ��!LI?�I'�' ?'�o!??
1. Equipment/appliance room door Iiear laundry room ilorth side.
Building 2904
2. First floor fire door-south side.
3. First floor emergency light-south side.
4. Second floor fire door.
5. Third floor hallway Iight,
6. Third floor emergency light.
7. First floor fire door closure liorth side.
8, Fntrance door not secure-north side.
$uilding 2908
3. First floor emergency light and stair landing light north side.
4. First floor fire door-north side.
5. First floor stairway light.
6. Second floor emergency light-south side.
7. Third floor emergency Iight-south side.
8. Second floor fire door-north side.
Basement/Laundry room
3. Basemeilt/laundry room fire door missing.
4. Basenlent electrical room door.
Building 2912
S. First floor einergency light.
9. First floor hallway light.
10. Entrance door not secure-west side.
11. First floor stair light and emergency light.
12. Exposed Iugh voltage wiring at second floor landing near west entraiice.
13. Third floar fire door-north side.
14. Ei�trance door not secure-nortll side.
Building 2916
l. Fixst floor fii�e door-north side.
2. Entry door not secure-east side.
Page 9
II�
Third floor emer enc li ht—south side.
3.
Y g
4. Third floor fire door latch
5. Second floor emergency light.
6. First floor emergeiicy light.
Basement/Laundry room
2. Repair hole in wall.
3. Repair washing machine.
4. Clean laundry roorn floor.
Iiuilding 2920
3. Entry door not secure—north side.
4. First floor emergency light ��orih side.
5. T11ird floor hall light.
6. Entry door not secure—west side.
7. First floor fire door latch—south side.
Building 2924
3. First floor stair light and emergency light north side.
4. Entrance door not secure (both the lock and latch}—south side.
5. Second floor emergency light—south side.
6. Entry foyer lights—north and south.
7. Hole in the wall at second floor Ianding north side.
8. Second floor emergency light and stair landing Iight north side
BPi��a�iliui" i v0iii
�ase� ,r
5. Equipment access panel door not secured in basement/laundry area.
6. Basement/laundry area fire door and light.
Building 2928
2. First floor emergency light and stair landing light north side.
3. Second floor emergency light and stair landing light north side.
4. Third floor emergency light—south side.
5. Second floor emergency light and/or battery—north side.
6. Second floor fire door—north side,
7. First floor emergency light north side.
Buildi�zg 2932
1. Tllixd floor fire door closure—south side.
2. Second floor fire door—south side.
Basement/Laundry room
l. Secure equipment access panel in basement/laundry a��ea.
�ualdi�g 29�6
l. Entry door not secure i7oi side.
2, Seconcl floor emergency light—north side.
3. Third floor emergei�cy light—south.
Page 10 I
4. Damaged v��indow screen on the ground at east side of building.
Bui}ding 2940
4. First floor fre door and light—north side.
5. Third floor light globe—south side.
6. Entry door closure—south side.
Page 11
I
Comr�.zunity Development
c,r,-�,� 6301 Shingle Creek Parkway 55430 I
ROOICLP n� p�1o11e:763-569-3300 Fax: 763-569-3494 I
F C�11'TER
Buildin�/�iousina Maintenance Com�liance Order.
DATE: �YO'0'� Notice of Ren�aining Itenls
TO: Hyder Jaweed
3 Blue Spruce Court
St. Paul, MN 55127
LOCATION: Centerpointe Apartmenis
ZS�}J ��L:,�11��� �Y��1��"�"� O�.�ti��
CO
lY�PLIANCE
OFFICIAL: John Rued
ccu ancv Ordinance were cited
enan
ce and 0
uildine Mauit
owm violatioiis of the B
The foll g ected b the
ese violations must be corr y
during a recent inspection of the above premises. Th or A ri130
f
eduled 9
'ance is sch P
de com h
comphance date mdicated. Reinspection to verif3 co p
2007 in the AM. Please contact us if this date creates a conflict.
P
ce
tabl.,
P orrect violations ac p
Failure to correct violatians ar to make satisfactory arrang�ments to c
'n license
t in sus ension or revocation of your rental dwelh g
ce official ma resul p
to the com han Y
P
1 ma result in the issuance of a citation, which,
i om
u r f a i l u r e t o c y y
i f a p p h c a b l e. v n a d d i t i o n, y o P
upon conviction, is punishable by fine and/or imprisonment,
i
Council ado ted Res. No. 99-172 which provides for a fee of $50.00 to be charged
The C P
�Y
for each reinspection necessary after the first reinspection. The remspection fee(s) will be
e
payable at the time of license renewal for the property, prior to the license being issu d.
A eal uThen it is alleged that a
s for Ri ht of
rovide pp
Section 12-1202 of the Ordinance also p g eal must be
on erron
eous inte i
�etation of the Ordinance. The App
ased u �P
Compliance Order is b p
submitted to the Corrnnunity Development Department, in writing, specifymg the grounds for
Appeal, within five (5) business days after sen�ice of the order, and must be accompaizied by a
shier s check.
a
filiilg fee of $50.00 in cash o1 c
a tenant reasonable notice that eiitry to the
MN Statutes 504B.211 requires a laildlord to give lotif our
Please
'ns ectioil Y Y
'n an 1
1 the ur oses of eifonni g p
talce lace fo P
rental unit may p P P
t'me of
the ins ection at least 48 h
ours
in advance.
e and i
teilants of the dat P
If you have any questions or comments, please contact me at 763-5G9-3344,
Mouday through Frida��, 5:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.
Page 1 i
DESCRIPTION OF VIOLATI�NS AND ORDINANCE SECTION,
s were noted durin a wallc through inspection of the common areas of the
Tlle following item g
Property on February 8, 2007.
Building 2806
1. Third fl�or light globe—north side.
Building 2810
1. Repair/replace security entrance door and—south end.
Building 2814
1. Repair/replace east entrance door---not secure (on order).
Building 2818
1. Second floor fire door—north side.
Basement/Laundry room
1. Laundry Iight globes—brolcen and/or missing.
Buildiug 2838
1. Third floor fire door and latch.
Basement/Laundry room
1, Basement/laundry room fire door missing.
Building 2912
1. Entrance door not secure—west side.
2, Exposed high voltage wiring at second floor landing near west entrance.
3. Entrance door not secure—north side.
Building 2920
1. Entry door not secure—north side.
Building 2924
1. Entrance door not secure (both the ]ock and latch)—south side.
Basement/Laundr}� room
l. Equipnlent aecess panel door not secured in basement/lauzidry area.
2, Basement/laundry area fire door and light.
�uald°an� 2940
1. First floor fire door-north side.
Page 2
ST OF MINNESOTA FOURTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT
COUI\'TI' U'F HENN�PIN DIVISION II BROOKLI'N C�NTER
�TE Or MINNESOTA COMPLAINT SUMMONS
vs Plaintiff, _ViJARI�NT
CALENDAR DATE
10i06/76 CCR#:
Name HYDER RAZA JAWEED Date of Birth
first middle last
Address 3 BLUE SPRUCE COURT Caleudar Date
City/ ST. PAUL MN 55127
State Zip Code Driver's License No.
COMPLAINT
Lieutenant Kevin Benner Complainant, being duly sworn, malces complaint to the aUove-named
Court and states that there is probable cause to believe that theBD�efLE CAUSE 1itted the following offense(s).
The compla�nant states that the following facts establish PRO
Your complainant, Kevin Benner, is a Lieutenant for the City of Broo)clyn Center Police
Department and has made an investigation into the hastreviewedrdepartment records regarding
the course of his investigation, your complainant
calls for service to the Centerpoint apartment complex and personally spo)cen to Officer
Terry Olson, the department's officer in overall charge of operations for multi-unit
residences. Your complainant has also received in whichLhasyleadtto validdarrests
Official for the City who has given informatio P
and convictions. Defendant is one of the owners and principals of Brooklyn Center Leased
N�using Associates which is the owner of the Centerpoint apartment complex located at
�hway Drive and Co�znty Road 10, in the City of Brooklyn Center,
Hennepin County,
l���nnesota which is residential rental property• T904pr2908ty2912S12916of29d8re2932 2936 02
2806, 2810, 2814, 2822, 2830, 2834, 2838, 2900, 2
and 2940 Northway Drive.
The public nuisances of which the City complainsionesale ofpcontrolledesubstancesncunlawful
of offenses and crimes involving the use/possess
use/possession of firearms, including robberies, crimes, including residential burglaries
and auto thefts, and unlawful use of alcoholic beverages. The public nuisances consist
of the following:
1. Calls for service to this complex, excluding domestic assault and medicallwelfare Januar 2005 103 from I I
chec)cs and non crimes, are as follows: 93 from January 2004 �Continued n AttaChment)
�F Coi11p ,�ihar .�.'a s that said offender nay Ue an�ested and dealt wii:h according to law.
i
,J�_ r./.� d� Complainant's Si�lature
William G. C�elland 20
d co
m
lained of before me tliis day of
ed an
Sworn to and subsciiU p
Secti017: 609.745 and Brooklyn CeMer City Ordinances 19-101, 19-106 and
19-105; 609.74 and Brooklyn Center City Ordinances 19-101, 19-105
CIla1'ge: @1�.1M@�e of Pubiic Nuisance; Maintenance of Pubfic Nuisance
Judge of District Court
�IC 43�2 (Rev 10/89) COA4PLAINT
i
HYDER RAZA JAWEED
nuary 2005 to January 2006 and 34 for the first quarter of 2007, which pioperly projects
136 calls for the year.
2. Since March 2007, behavioral incidents occurring on these premises include felony
auto theft occurring on 1 May 2D07, felony theft from auto occurring on 21 April 2007,
burglary occurring on 17 April 2007, non domestic misdemeanor assault occurring on 16 April
2007, non misdemeanor assault occurring on 5 April 2007, burglary occurring on 7
April 2007, theft and misuse of credit cards occurring on 2 April 2007, reported criminal
sexual conduct involving a juvenile victim occurring on 24 March 2007, felony motor vehicle
theft occurring on 17 March 2007, motor vehicle tampering and criminal damage to property
occurring on 16 March 2007, burglary occurring on 14 March 2007, robbery at gunpoint
occurring on 9 March, offenses involving controlled substances occurring on 2 May(sale), 27
April, 25 April (felony), 20 April, 12 April (sale), 27 March, 24 March, 23 March, 21
March, 15 March, 13 March, 10 March, behavioral incidents involving disorderly conduct
occurring on 21 April a gross misdemeanor Third Degree DWI occurring on 27 April and
behavioral incidents involving unlawful use of alcoholic beverages occurring on 6 April and
27 April 2007. Subject to the provisions of Minnesota Statutes Chapter 13, reports of
these incidents are on file and available for public inspection at the Brooklyn`Center
Police Department
Said acts constitute the maintenance of public nuisance on property owned by the property
owner and permitting or suffering public nuisance by the property owner in violation of
Minnesota Statues Sections 617.81, 609.74 and 609.745 and violation of City Ordinances
Sections 12-910 and Chapter 19.
e property owners have been personally notified of these violations and notified in
iting. The property owners have promised to abate the nuisances and control and operate
_ne premises so as to avoid these crimes and nuisances and have failed to do so. The
property owners have affirmatively failed to implement security measures, including but not
limited to adequately locking and secure doors, adequate lighting, restricted access to
the premises, have failed to hire security staff, as promised, have failed to keep an
accurate tenant register, as required by law, have failed to secure the buildings from
casual intruders and have affirmatively allowed this premises to suffer this crime.
Further, the criminal activity originating at these premises spills over to commercial and
residential areas of the city, which has resulted in violent crimes, including homicide.
The also suffers from numerous housing maintenance defects and violations
according to the description of violations attached hereto and incorporated herein. A
compliance notice was served on Defendant at the above described address on 21 February
2007 requiring compliance by 5 March 2007. Reinspection revealed that the not all
violations had been corrected .whereupon a second compliance notice was given Defendant on
17 April 2007, requiring compliance by 25 April 2007. Reinspection revealed that
violations still existed whereupon a third compliance notice was sent Defendant requiring
compliance by 30 April 2007 but reinspection revealed that a number of code violations
still e�:ist including missing nor inoperable co.mmon area lights, doors in need of repair,
entrance doors which did not lock or could not be secured, exposed high voltage wiring and
defective fire doors. Said housing maintenance defects also constitute a continuing public
nuisance.
State laws and City Ordinances place a legal duty upon owners of residential rental
roperty to affirrnatively_avoid public nuisances and housing maintenance code violations
nd further impose responsibility upon the owner to ensure that persons occupying the
remises conduct themselves in a manner so as not to cause the premises to be disorderly
and disorderly is defined, in part, as the violations of unlawful possession, delivery or
purch
ase of controlled
substances, disturbing the peace, and violations of laws relating to
firearms.
(Continued on Attachment)
HYDER RAZA JAWEED
CHARGE(S)
.,un t 1
Charge Maintenance of Public Nuisance
In Violation Of: 609.745 and Brooklyn Center City Ordinances 19-101, 19-106 and 19-105
Maximum Penalty: 90 days, or $1,000, or both, plus assessinent of all costs of abatement
Wherefore, your complainant states that from January 2007 to the present, within the
corporate limits of the City of Broolclyn Center, County of Hennepin, State of Minnesota,
Hyder Raza Jaweed a person having control of real property, did willfully, wrongfully and I
unlawfully permit said real property to be used to maintain a public nuisance or let the
same knowing it would be so used, in violation of Minnesota Statutes 609.745 and Sections
19-101, 19-105 and 19-106 of the Ordinances of the City Of Broo]clyn Center.
Count 2
Charge Maintenance of Public Nuisance
Zn Violation Of: 609.74 and Brooklyn Center City Ordinances 19-1D1, 19-105 and 19-106
I ximum Penalt 90 days and/or $1,000, plus assessment of all costs of abatement
Ma Y
Wherefore, your complainant states that from January 2007 to the present, within the
imits of the Cit of Brooklyn Center, County of Hennepin, State of Minnesota,
corp
orate 1 y
w n full
full ro
1
'd wil Y
t di 5
erform le al du Y
Hydei Raza Jaweed, by an act or failure to p g Y
intentionally and unlawfully maintain or permit a condition which unreasonably annoys,
injures or endangers the safety, health, morals, comfort or repose of any number of inembers
of the public or is guilty of any act or omission declared by statutory law, the common law
or ordinance to be a public nuisance or permits real property under his or her control to
used to maintain a public nuisance or rents the same knowing it would be so used, in
�lation of Minnesota Statute Section 609.74 and Sections 19-101, 19-105 and 19-106 of the•'
Ordinances of the City of Brooklyn Center.
i
i
i
I
I
E�
Cominunity Development
c�a��,r hin le Creelc Parlcway 55430
6301 S
g
4 4
IlR00KLI N ph�ne: 763-569-�300 Fax: 763 569 3 9
CE'N7E11
�ualdin�/�3[ousinQ Ti�aintenance Com�liance �rder
DA..+,_ ����r��0�7
Final Notice
TO: Hyder Jaweed
3 Blue Spruce Court
St. Paul, MN 55127
LOC�,'I'I�N: Centerpointe Apartments
COMPLIANCE DAT�:�°,�;��c ':S;:r''bO�F�'-
COMPLIANCE OFFICIAL; John Rued
The following violations of the Buildin� Maintenance and Occo 15 be correc ed by l the
during a recent inspection of the above premises. These violati
compliance date indicated. Reinspection to verify code compliance is scheduled for in the
Please contaet us if fhis date creates a conflict.
Failure to correct violations or to make satisfactory arrangements to con violations acceptable
to the compliance.official may result in suspension or revocation of your rental dwelling license
if applicable. In addition, your failure to comply may result in the issuance of a citation, which,
upon conviction, is puilishable by fine and/or imprisonment.
The City Council adopted Res. No. 99-172 v��hich provides for a ee�e ns� e�Ct�o l�fee(s) walgbe
for each reinspection necessary after the first reinspeo� the 1 cense being issued.
p a y a b l e a t t h e t i m e o� license renewal for the propei p
Section 12-1202 of the Ordinazlce also pro`�ides for Right ofe Ordilance1 The must be
Compliance Order is based upon erroneous interpretation of th
submitted to the Comrnunity Development Department, in writing, specifying the grouilds for
Appeal, within five (5) business days after service of the order, and must be accompanied by a
filing fee of �50.00 in cash or cashiez''s checic.
MN S1:atutes 504B.211 requires a landloz�d to give a tenailt reasonable notice that entry to the
rental unit may talce place for the purposes of perforiniilg an inspection. Please notify your
tezlants of the date and tiine of the inspection at least 48 hours in advance.
If Jou ha��e 2ny questions or comments, please contact me at 763-569-334
IYlonclay through Friday, 8:00 a.xn. to 4:30 p.m.
i
Page 6
DESCRIPTION OF VIOLATIONS AND ORDINANCE SECTION
Ze follou�in items were noted during a wallc through inspection of the coinrnon areas of the
T1 g
ert on Februar 8, 2007.
Plo Y
p Y
in 2802 I'
Build g
north.
ired lass fzrst floor fir
e
door
2, Holes in w g
3. Emergency •light—south side.
4. Second floor en�ergency light.
5. Third floor emergency light north side.
B�sement/Laundry ro�m
2. Dryer tops missing.
3. Brolcen fluorescent light globe.
4. Missing fluorescent light globe.
5. Equipment access panel in corridor not secure.
6. Fire door aa�d holes in wired glazing.
Building 2806
5. Entrance door not secure—east side.
6. Third floor emergency Iight.
7. Third floor light globe—north side.
8. Entrance door closure—north side.
Building 2810
ld sideli Qht—south end.
nce door ai D
4. Re
air/re lace secunt} entra
p P
S. R
e air/re lace security entrance door mouldinb south end.
I P p
and n
orth.
6. Firstfloor emergency light—south
7. Repair/replace door moulding—west entrance door.
e c li ht—south end.
8. Second floor emerg n y g
enc
Ii ht—south end.
d floor emer g
r Y
9. T g
10.
Third floar
fire
door closure—south side.
e.
north sld
li ht
d floor erner enc b
11
Thir g Y
Basement/Laundry room
l. Laundry room fire door and both door knobs.
2. Clea�� laundry room.
Building 2�14
5. First floor emergency light—soutll side.
ecuz'e.
ilot s
6. Repaii/replace eas
t eiltrance door
7. First floor fire door—soutll side.
8. First floor emergency light nortli side.
9. Entrailce door not secure—north side,
10. Brolcen conidor light (may be burnt out).
11. Third floor emergency light—south side.
12. Tlurd floor fire door /closure.
I3. Third floor emergency light north side.
Page 7
14. Repairheplace window screen at first floor apartment.
Building 2818
4. Entrance door not secure—south side.
5. Second floor fire door—north side.
6. First floor ernergency light nzissing—north side.
Basement/Laui�dry ro�m
l. Brolcen light globe
2. Fire door not operating con�ectly—north side.
Building 2822
1. Entrance door not secure—east side.
2. First floor emergency light north side.
3. Entrance door not secure—north side.
Building 2826
l. First floor emergency Iight—sou�li end.
2, First floor fire door not operating properly--south end.
3. Verify thai the heat sensor/smoke detector in the laundry room is functioning properly.
4. Third floor fire door not operating properly—south end.
5. Third floor emergency light.
�asement/Laundr3� room
2. Secure equipment access panel in basement corridor.
$uilding 2830
1. Fist floor emergency light—south end.
2. Fire door lulob.
Building 2834
3. First floor fire do�r—south side.
4. Entrance door not secure—west side.
5. Third floor fire doors—north and south sides.
6. Graffiti at second floor landii�g.
Baseznent/Laundry z•oom
4, Laundry ligllt globes—broken and/or missing.
S. Moldirnildew on walls ii1 corridor coruiecting the two buildiilgs.
Building 2838
3. Eiztrauce door not secure—noi side.
4. Second floor light globe
5, Secoizd floor fire door closure.
6. Thixd floor emergeilcy light.
7. Third floor fire door and latcli.
8. Graffiti on wall at secoild floor landing.
9. Secoiid floor emergency light—south side.
Page 8
10. Graffiti on glass at east entrance door.
11. First floor ernergency light-soutl7 side.
12. Electric n7eter roorn door not secure/brolcen.
13. Low battery indicator on monitoring paneL •I�'
14. Entrance door not secure-east side.
Building 2900
1. Entrance door not secure-soui:l� side
2. Brolcen glass at securii;}� door/sidelight-south side.
3. Second floor emergency light north side.
4. Entra�ice door not secure-east side.
B�semeLt/La�ndry ronm
l. Equipment/appliance room door near laundry room-north side.
Suilding 2904
2. First floor fire door-south side.
3. First floor emergency li�ht-south side.
4. Second floor fire door.
5, Third floor hallway light.
6. Third floor ernergency light.
7. First floor fire door closure-north side.
8. Entrance door not secure-north side.
Building 2908
3. First floor emergency light and stair laiiding light north side.
4. First floor fire door-north side.
5. First floor stairway light. i
6. Second floor emergency light-south side.
7. Third floor emergency light-south side.
8. Second floor fire door-north side.
Basement/Laundry room
3. Basement/laundry r�om fire door missing.
4. Basement electrical room door. I
Building 2912
8. First floor emergency light.
9. First floor hallway light.
10. Elltrance door not secure-west side.
11. First floor stair light and emexgency light.
12. Ex�osed lugh voltage wiring at second iloor landing near west entrance.
13. Third floor fire door-north side.
14. Entrance door iiot secure-north side.
Building 2916
l. Firsf floor fire door-north side.
2. Entry door not secure-east side.
Page 9
'41
3. Third floor emergency light—south side.
4. Third floor fire door latch
5. Second floor ernergency liglit.
6. First floor emergency Iight.
Basement/Laundry room
2, Repair hole in wa1L
3. Repair washing machine.
4. Clean laundry room floor.
BY�ilding 2920
3. Entry door not secure—north side.
4. First �loor emergency light—north side.
5. Third floor hall 1ig11t.
6. Entry door not secure—west side.
7. First floor fire door latch—south side.
�uilding 2924
3. First floor stair Iight and emergency light—north side.
4. Entrance doar not secure (both the locic and latch)—south side.
5. Second floor enlergency light south side.
6. Entry foyer lights—north and south.
7. Hole in the wall at second floor landing—north side.
8. Second floor emergency Iight and stair landing light—north side
�`�,'SPP.:°I�t��:.^u'.I32G�:"�' :'Q0:]2
5. Equipment access panel door not secured in basement/laundry area.
6. Basement/laundry area fire door and light.
Building 2928
2. First floor emergency light and stair landing light north side.
3. Second floor emergency light and stair landing light north side.
4. Third floor emergency light—south side,
5. Second floor emergency light andlor battery—north side.
6. Second floor fire door north side.
7. First floor emergency light—north side.
kiuilding 2932
hird floor fire door closure—south side.
l. T
2. Second floor fire door—soutl7 side.
Baseanent/Laundry room
l. Secure equipillent access panel in base111ent/laundry area.
�uabding �g36
l. Entry door not secl.ue north siae.
t 2. Second floor emergency Iight—noi side.
3. Third floor emergeilcy light—south.
Page 10
4. Damaged u�indow screen on the ground at east side of building.
Building 2940
4. Firsf floor fre door and light—north side.
5. Third flo�r lib hf globe—south side.
6. Entry door clost�re—south side. I
Page 11
t
�=--�r
Commuility Developn�ent
c;�,-�,r 6301 Shingle Creek Parkway 55430
�nooxLl�iv P11one:763-569-3300 Fax: 763-569-3494
C.CA'TL'R
�uildin�/�ousin� l�aintenance Comvliance �i°der,
DATE: �x� �r r���' Notice of Remaining Items
TO: Hyder Jaweed
3 Blue Spruce Court
St. Paul, MN 55127
LOCATION: Centerpointe Apartments
�C���P�7�L:��� ����P.��' �'�.,:�2�0;0�
COMPLIANCE OFFICIAL: John Rued
The following violations of the Buildina Maiiltenance and Occu�ancv Ordinance were cited
during a recent inspection of the above premises. These violations must be corrected by the
compliance date indicated. Reinspection to verify code compliance is scheduled for Ap�'i130,
2007 in the AM. �lease contact us if this date creates a conflict.
Failure to correct violations or to make satisfactory arrangements to correct violations acceptable
to the compliance official may result in suspension or reuocation of your reiltal dwelling license
if applicable. In addition, your failure to comply may result iii the issuance of a citation, which,
upon conviction, is punishable by fine and/or imprisonment.
The City Council adopted Res. No. 99-172 which provides for a fee of $�0.00 to be cha�
for each reinspection necessary after the first reinspection. The reinspection fee(s) will be
payable at the titne of license renewal for the property, prior to the license being issued.
Section 12-1202 of the Ordinance also provides far Right of Appeal, wheil it is alleged that a
eA
eal must be
Compliance Order is based upon erroneous ii7terpretation of the Ordlnance. Th pp
submitted to the Community Developnlent Department, in writing, specifyiilg the grouiids for
Appeal, within fve (5) business days after service of the order, and n�ust be accompanied by a
filing fee of $50.00 in cash or cashier's checic.
MN Statutes 504B.211 requires a landlord to give a teilailt reasonable i�otice that entry to the
rental unit may talce place for the �urposes of performing an inspection. Please notify your
tenants of the date and time of the iilspection at least 48 hours in advance.
If you l�ave any questious or comments, please contact me .at 763-5G9-3344,
Monday through Frida��, 8:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.
i
Page 1
DESCRIPTION OF VIOLATIONS AND ORDINANCE SECTION
The following items were noted during .a wallc tl�u inspection of the conunon areas of the
Property oi1 February 2007.
Building 2806
1. Third floor light globe—nortl� side.
Building 2810
l, Repair/replace security entrance door and—south end.
Building 2814
1. Repair/replace east entrance door—not secure (on order).
Building 2818
re door—north side.
l. Second floor fi
Basemeut/Laundry room
1. Laundry light globes—broken and/or missing.
Building 2838
1. Third floor fire door and latch.
Basement/Laundr3� room
l. Basement/laundry room fire door missing.
Building 2912
l. Entrance door not secure—west side.
2, Exposed high voltage wiring at second floor landing near west entrailce.
3. Entrance door not secure—north side:
Building 2920
1, Entry door not secure—north side.
Building 2924
l. Entrance door not secure (both the locic and latch)—south side.
Basement/Laundz•y room
1. Equipnlent access panel door not secured in basement/laundry area.
2. Basement/laundry area fire door and light.
�ui�d�ng 2940
1. First floor fire door ilorth side.
Page 2
I
FOURTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT
'I'ATr OF MINN�SOTA
DIVISION ZI BROOKLYN C�NT�R
'OUNTY OF H�NN�PIN Cp�,LA1T,T SUMMONS
OF MINN�SOTA W/�TZRANT
Plaintiff, CALENDAR DATE
10/06/76 CCR#:
1��»e HYDER RAZA JAWEED �1 Datie of Birth
middle G
�ddress 3 BLUE SPRUCE COURT
C1lendar Date
ST. PAUL MN �5127 Driver's License No.
Zip Code
:tate
COMPLAINT
Lauren
ce MarEin, Jr. Complainant, being efei� an�colnm�tl:ed the follow ng offe �se(s)1
�ourt and states that there is probable cause to believe that the
['he compllinant states that the following facts establish PP�OBABLE CAUSE: n center and has made an
'rcumstances of this case. In the course of his
Cour complainant is the Building Official for the City of BrooklYn Rued flousing Inspector
Lnvestigation into the facts and ci
investigation, your complainant has received in a o m Whi h hasmlead to valid arrests apd
als of Brooklyn Center Leased
Eor the City who has given information in the p
�onvictions. befendant is one of the owners and princip
of Brooklyn Center, Hennepin County,
Housing Associates which is the owner of thetCenterpoint apartment compleY located af 2802,
Northway Drive and County Road 10 in tnYO erty. The'property consists of addresses °2936
rental p P 2912, 2916, 2928, 2932,
M' esota which is residential 2838 2900, 2909, 2908,
�2990 2810, 2814, 2822, 2830, 2839, 200� revealed -.iumerous housing
Northway Drive. Housing inspections in January
ai. to Lhe descript?on of violations attached
maintenance deie� and violations according
hereto and incorporated herein. Defendant was given a compliance notice on 21 February
iveri Uefer�dant on
200� requiring compliance by 5 March 2007' Secondpcomplianceenot'�icehwastge not a�
violations had bePn corrected whereupo 2007. Reinspection revealed that
1/ April 'LUO�, requiring compliance by
lations still eyisted whereupon a thirc� comp vealed thatca nurnbernofDcodedviolat�ons1ng
vio ection re
compliance by 30 April 2007 but reinsp h�s, doors in need of repair,
did not lock or could not be secured, eyposed high voltage wiring and
still eyist including missinc, nor inoperable common area lig
entranee doors which
defectitTe fire doors.
CHARGE(S) (Continued on Attachment)
�+�rOI2�, Compla'i n pr �s rd��t said offender m:1}' be arrested and dealt wiih according to law.
v p tiJ
�����n�� Complainaut'sSignatur
Willi�m G. Clelland day of 20_
Sworn to and subsccibed and complained of before me ihi
Sectiotl: Brooldyn Center City Ordinance 12-1202 and 12-1205
Cj��t�be: Fail to abide by a compliance order j� Of j'jtsit'ict COUi�t
��o� rno„ 1n/5�91 COA'IPLAII�T
HYDER RAZA JAWEED
�unt 1
.,narge Fail to abide by a compliance order
In Violation Of: Brooklyn Center City Ordinance 12-1202 and 12-1205
Maximum Penalty: 90 days and/or $1,000
Wherefore, your complainant states that from January 2007 to the present, within the
corporate limits of the City of Brooklyn Center, County of Hennepin, State of 1Hinnesota,
Hyder Jaweed did willfully, wrongfully and unlawfully fail to abide by a Compliance Order
in violation of Sections 12-121 and 12-1205 of the ordinances of the City of Brooklyn
Center.
Community Development
c;r,-�,r 6301 Shingle Creelc Parkway 55430
I1Il00KLP phone:763-569-3300 Fax: 763-569-3494
cLn�T�n
�u�ldin�/�3[ousin� Maintenance Com�lian�e Order
2 Z Final Notice
DA� �1����,
TO: Hyder Jaweed
3 Blue Spruce Court
St. Paul MN 55127
CATION: Center ointe Apartrnents
LO P
COMPLIANCE DATEs��"a��iW�.� 0
COMPLIANCE OFFICIAL: John Rued
e followin violations of the Bl�ildin� Maintenance and Occu�ancv Ordinance were cited
Th g the
be c
orrected b
during a recent inspection of the above premises. These violations
rnust Y
compliance date indicated. Reinspection to verify code compliance is scheduled for in the
Please contact us if this date creates a conflict.
Failure to correct violations or to make satisfactory arrangements to correct violations acceptable
to the compliance.official may result in suspension or revocation of your rental dwelling license
if appiicable. In addition, your failure to comply may result in the issuance of a citation, which,
upon conviction, is punishable by fine and/or imprisonment.
The City Council adopted Res. No. 99-172 which provides for a fee of $50.00 to be charged
for each reinspection necessary after the first reinspection. The reinspection fee(s) will be
payable at the time of license renewal for the property, prior to the license being issued.
Section 12-1202 of the Ordinance also provides for Right of Appeal, when it is alleged that a
Compliance Order is based upon erroneous interpretation of the Ordinance. The Appeal must be
submitted to the Conlmunity Development Department, in writing, specifying the grounds for
Appeal, within five (5) business days after service of the order, and must be accompanied by a
filing fee of $50.00 in cash or cashier''s checic.
MN Statutes 504B.211 requires a laildlord to give a tenani reasonable izotice that entry to the
rental uuit may talce place for the purposes of performing an inspectioil. Please noi:ify your
teilants of the date and time of the inspection at least 48 hours in advance.
If you have any questions or comments, please contact me at 7G3-569-3344,
lYlonday through Friday, 8:Q0 a.m. to 4:3U p.m..
Page 6
DESCRIPTION OF VIOLATIONS AND ORDINANCE SECTION,
The following items were iloted during a wallc through inspection of the coil�unon areas of the
Property on February 8, 2007.
Building 2802
2. Holes in wired glass first floor fire door—north.
3. Einergency light—south side.
4. Second floor emergency light.
5. Third floor emergency liglit north side.
Basement/Laundry room
2. Dryer tops missing.
��'Y�n��''�`3'�'Brolcen fluorescent light globe.
4. Missing fluorescent light globe.
5. Equipment access panel in corridor not secure.
6. Fire door and holes in wired glaziug.
Building 2806
5. Entrance door not secure—east side.
6. Third floor emergency light.
7. Third floor light globe—north side.
8. Entrance door closure—north side.
Building 2810
4. Repair/replace security entrance door and sidelight—south end.
5. Repair/replace security entrance door moulding—south end.
6. First floor emergency light south and north,
7. Repair/replace door moulding—west entrance door.
8. Second floor emergency light—south end.
9. Third floor emergency light—south end.
10. Third floor fire door closure—south side.
11. Third floor emergency light north side.
Basement/Laundry room
1. Laundry room fire door and botll door lcnobs.
2. Clean laundry room.
Building 2814
5. First floor emergency Iight—south side,
6, Repair/replace east entrance door—not secure.
7. First floor fire door—south side.
8. First floor emergency light north side.
9, Entrance door ilot secure—north side.
10. Brolcen corridor light (may be burnt out).
11. Third floor emergency light—south side.
12. Third floor fire door /closure.
13. Third floor enzergency light north side.
Page 7
14. Repair/replace window screeil at first floor apartment.
Building 2818
side.
4, Entrance door not secure s
outh
5. Second floor fire door—north side.
6. First floor emergency ligllt missing—north side.
Basement/Laundry i•oom
1. Brolcen light globe
2. Fire door not operating correctly—north side.
Building 2822
1. Entrance door not secure—east side.
2. First floor emergency Iight north side.
3. Entrance do�r not secure north side.
Building 2826
ht—south end.
l.
First floor emergency hg
uth end.
o erl
so
2. First floor fire door not operating pr p y erl
ro
'f that the heat sensor/smoke detector m the laundry room is functioning p p Y
3 V eri
Y
uth end.
atin ro erl
so
4.
Third floor fire door not oper g p p Y
5. Third floor emergency light.
Basement/Laundry room
2. Secure equipment access panel in basement corridor.
Building 2830
1. Fist floor emergency light—south end.
2, Fire door lcnob.
Building 2834
3. First floor fire door—south side.
4. Entrance door not secure west side.
5. Third floor fire doors—north and south sides.
6. Graffiti at second floor landing.
Basement/Laundry room
4. Laundry light globes--broken and/or missing.
5, Mold/n on walls in conidor con�iecting the two buildings.
Buildiug 2838
3. Entrance door not secure—north side.
4. Second floor light globe
5. S
econd fl
oor fire d
oor closure.
6. Third floor emergency light,
7. Tliird floor fire door and latch.
8. Graffiti on wall at secoild floor landing.
9. Second floor emergency light—south side.
Page 8
10. Graffiti on glass at east entrance door.
1 l. First floor emergency light-south side.
12. Electric meter room door not secure/brolcen.
13. Low battery indicator on monitoring paneL
14. Entrance door iiot secure-east side. k
Building 2900
1. Entrance door not secure-south side
2. Brolcen glass at security door/sidelight-south side.
3. Second floor emergency light north side.
4. Entrance door not secure-east side,
B�sement/Lauvdry rooan
1. Equipineiit/appliance room door near laundry room north side.
Building 2904
2. First floor fire door-south side.
3. First floor en�ergency light-south side.
4. Second floor fire door.
5. Third floor hallway light.
6. Third floor emergency light.
7. First floor fire door closure-north side.
8. Entrance door not secure-north side.
Building 2908
3. First floor emergency light and stair landing light north side.
4. First floor fire door-north side.
5. First floor stairway light.
6. Second floor emergency light-south side.
7. Third floor emergency light-south side.
8. Second floor fire door-north side.
Basement/Laundry room
3. Basement/laundry room fire door missing.
4. Basenlent electrical room door.
Building 2912
8. First floor emergency light,
9. First floor hallway light.
nce
dooz� not secure-west side.
ntra
1
0. E
11. First floor staix light and einergenc�� lighi.
12. Exposed high voltage wiring at second floor lai7ding near west entrance.
13. Third. floor fire door-nor�h side.
14. Entrance door not secure-nortl� side.
Building 2916
1. First floor fire door-north side.
2. Entry door not secure-east side.
Page 9
3. Third floor emergency Iight—south side.
4. Third floor fire door latch
5. Second floor emergency light.
6. First floor emergency light.
Basement/Laundry room
2. Repair hole in wall.
3. Repair washing machine.
4. Clean laundry room floor.
Building 2920
3. Entry door not secure—north side.
4. First floor emergency light—north side.
5. Third floor hall light.
6. Entry door not secure—west side.
7. First floor fire door latch—s�uth side.
Building 2924
3, First floor stair light and emergency light—north side.
4. Entrance door not secure (both the locic and latch)—south side.
5. �Second floor emergency light—south side,
6. Entry foyer lights—north and south.
7. Hole in the wall at second floor landing north side.
S. Secoild floor emergency light and stair landing light north side
�asement/�,aundry room
5, Equipment access panel door not secured in basement/laundry area.
6. Basement/laundry area fire door and Iight.
Building 2928
2. First floor emergency light and stair landing light north side.
3. Second floor emergency light and stair landing light—north side.
4. Third floor emergency light—south side.
5. Second floor emergency light and/or battery—north side.
6. Second floor fire door—north side.
7. First floor emergency light north side.
Building 2932
l. Third floor fire door closure—south side.
2. Second floor fire door—south side.
Basemeut/Laundr3� room
1. Secure equipment access panel ii1 basemeni/laundry area.
�uflld�ng 29�6
1. Entry door not secure—north side.
2. Seconcl floor emergeilcy light—north side.
3. Third floor eznergency light—south.
Page 10
4. Damaged window screen on the �'ound at east side of building.
Building 2940
4. First floor fire door and light—north side.
5. Third floor light globe—south side.
6. Entry door closure—south side.
i
Page 11
Coznmunity Development
c<<,-�,r 6301 Shingle Creelc Parl�way 55430
IIRDOKLI phoz�e:763-569-3300 Fax: 763-569-3494
CL'h'TER
Suildin�/Housing Maintenance Com�liance Order
DATE: Notice of Remaining Ii:ems
TO: Hyder Jaweed
3 Blue Spruce Court
St. Paul, MN 55127
LOCATION: Centetpointe Apartnleni:s
'�Q �Z �C�� .��P m���� :pp
CaIYIPLIANCE OFFICIAL: 7ohn Rued
The following violations of the Buildin� Maiiitenance and Occu�ancv Ordinance were cited
during a recent inspection of the above premises. These violations musf be corrected by the
cornpliance date indicated; Reinspection to verif3� code compliance is scbeduled for Apri130,
2007 in the AM. Please contact us if this date creates a conflict.
Failure to correct violations or to make satisfactory arrangements to correct violations acceptable
to the compliance official may result in suspension or revocation of your rental dwelling license
if applicable. In addition, your failure to comply may result in the issuance of a citation, which,
upon conviction, is punishable by fine aa�id/or imprisonment.
ThQ City Council adopted Res. No. 99-172 which provides for a fee of $SQ.00 to be charged
for each reinspection necessary after the first reinspection. The reinspection fee(s) will be
payable at the time of license renewal for the property, prior to the license being issued.
Section 12-1202 of the Ordinance also provides for Right of Appeal, when it is alleged that a
Cornpliance Order is based upon erroneous interpretation of the Ordinance. The Appeal must be
submitted to t11e Conununity Development Department, in writing, specifying the grounds for
Appeal, u�ithin five (5) business days after service of the arder, and must be accompanied by a
filing fee of $50.00 in casli or cashier's cl�eck.
MN Statutes 504B.211 requires a landlord to give a tenant reasonable notice that entry to the
rez�tal unit n7ay talce place for the purposes of performing ai7 inspection. Please notify your
tenants of the date and time of the inspection at least 48 hours in advauce,
If you have any questians or comments, please contact me.at 763-569-3344,
IY.tonday tl�rough l+riciay, 8:GQ a.m. to 4:3t� p.m.
Page 1
DESCRIPTION OF VIOLATIONS AND ORDINANCE SECTION,
The following items were noted during a walk tlu inspection of the comrnon areas of the
Property on February 8, 2007.
Building 2806
1. Third floor light globe—north side.
Building 2810
1, Repair/replace security entrance door and—south end.
Building 2814
I 1. Re air/re lace east entrance dooi=not secure (on order).
P P
Building 2818
l. Second floor fire door—north side.
Basement/Laundry room
1. Laundry light globes—brol�en and/or missing.
Building 2838
1. Third floor fire door and latch.
Basement/Laundry room
1. Basement/laundry room fire doar missing.
Building 2912
l. Entrance door not secure-west side.
2. Ex osed hi h volta e wiring at second floor landing near west entrance.
p
g g
3. Entrance door not secure—north side.
Building 2920
l. Ent door not secure—north side.
lY
Building 2924
1. Eiitrance door not secure (both the locic and latch)—south side.
B�sement/Laundry room
l. Equipment access panel door not secured in basement/laundry area,
2. Basement/laundry area fire door and light.
�ivaid°ang �940
1. First floor fire door—north side.
Page 2
I,
NOTICE OF ABATEMENT OF PUBLIC NLTISANCES
TO ASGHER JAWEED AND HYDER JAWEED AND BROOKLYN CENTER
LEASED HOUSING ASSOCIATES PROPERTY OWNERS.
You are hereby notified, pursuant to Mi�ulesota Statues Sections 617.81, et
seq. that the undersigned, prosecuting attorney for the City of Brooklyn Center,
hereby intends to seek the abatement of all public nuisances e�sting at the buildings
and premises of buildings 2802, 2806, 2810, 2814, 2822, 2830, 2834, 2838, 2900,
2904, 2908, 2912, 2916, 2920, 2924, 2928, 2932, 2936 and 2940 Northway Drive,
Brooklyn Center, Hennepin County, Minnesota.
The public nuisances of which the City complains are the repetitive
behavioral incidents of offenses and crimes involving the useipossessionisale of
controlled substances, unlawful use/possession of fireanns, including robberies,
crimes, including residential burglaries and auto thefts, and unlawful use of
alcoholic beverages. The public nuisances consist of the following:
l. Calls for service to this coinplex, excluding domestic assault and
medicaUwelfare cllecks and non crunes, are as follows: 93 from January 2004 to
January 2005, 103 from 7anuary 2005 to January 2006 and 34 for the first quarter of
2007, wluch properly projects to 136 calls for the year.
2. Since March 2007 behavioral incidents occurring on these premises
I
include felony auto theft occurring on 1 May 2007, felony theft from auto occurring
on 21 Apri12007, burglary occurring on 17 April 2007, non domestic misdemeanor
assault occurring on 16 Apri12007, non domestic inisdemeanor assault occurring on
5 April 2007, burglary occurring on 7 Apri12007, theft and misuse of credit cards
occurring on 2 Apri12007, reported cruninal sexual conduct involving a juvenile
victim occurring on 24 March 2007, felony inotor velucle theft occurring on 17
March 2007, motor velucle tampering and criininal damage to property occurring on
16 March 2007, burglary occurring on 14 March 2007, robbery at gunpoint
occurring on 9 March, offenses involving controlled substances occurring on 2
May(sale), 27 April, 25 April (felony), 20 April, 12 April (sale), 27 March, 24
i
March, 23 March, 21 March, 15 March, 13 March, 10 March, behavioral incidents
involving disorderly conduct occurring on 21 April a gross misdemeanor Third
Degree DWI occurring on 27 April and behavioral incidents involving unlawful use
of a.lcoholic beverages occurring on 6 April and27 April 2007. Subject to tlie
provisions of Mimlesota Statutes Chapter 13, reports of these incidents are on file
and available for public inspection at the Brooklyn Center Police Department.
Said acts constitute the maintenance of public nuisance on property owned
by the property owner and pennitting or suffering public nuisance by tlle property
2.
owner in violation of Mitulesota Statues Sections 617.81, 609:74 and 609.745 and
violation of City ordinances Sections 12-910 and Chapter 19.
The property owners have been personally notified of these violations and
notified in writing. The property owners have proinised to abate the nuisances and
control and operate the preinises so as to avoid these crimes and nuisances and have
failed to do so. Tlle property owners have affinnatively failed to implement security
measures, including but not limited to adequately locking and secure doors,
adequate lighting, restricted access to the premises, have failed to hire security
staff, as promised, have failed to keep an accurate tenant register, as required by
law, have failed to secure the buildings from casual intruders and have affirmatively
allowed this premises to suffer tlus crime. Further, the criminal activity originating
at these premises spills over to corrunercial and residential areas of the city, which
I
has resulted in violent crimes, including homicide.
The property owners are notified tllat failure to completely abate the conduct
constituting these nuisances or otherwise resolve tllese nuisances with the
undersigned within 30 days of service of tlus notice upon you will result in tlle filing
of a complaint for relief in the District Court in and for Hennepin County which can
include the closuig of the buildulgs and pennanent injunction against the use of the
buildings for one year and in the case of tenants, cancellation of
3.
their leases.
The property owner is hereby infonned of the provisions of MulnesotaStatues
Section 617.85, a copy of wluch is attached hereto and incorporated herein.
Notice is also given to all interested parties, including tenants.
Dated tlus 14t'' day of May 2007
Willia.m G. Clelland
Prosecuting Attorney
Attorney Registration 0017280
City of Brooklyn Center
Carson, Clelland Scl�reder
Suite 305, 6300 Slungle Creek Parkway
Miruieapolis, Mimlesota 55430
FLAN FOR A.T]D�SSING iSSUES RI�iSED Tf�T TI-�E CITY OF B�ODK.LYI�1
CL�N'I'�R'S NOTI�E OF ABATEIV�NT OF PIJT3LIC I,�)ISANCE
T.he City af firoaklyt� Center's ("Czty"} n.otice dat�d May 14, 2U07 ("notice")
cont�ins the �ol.lowing allegatians of public nuisance at the premises lor.,�ted at 2802,
2806, 2810, 2814, 2822, 2830, 2834, 2838, 2900, 2904, 2908, 2912, 291�, 2920, 2924,
2928, 2932, 2936, a,nd 2940 Nortlhway :Dr., Brookiy�� Genter, Jv�N ("�rennises");
Increase in palice calls,
2. Certain beha.vioral itxciderr�s alleg�d to occur on the prpperty as identtlfied x� the
�aotice_
In additiozt, the �ity aIleges that the owners of the premises, Broo�lyn Center Leased
�Iousing Associates, LLC ("owners"}' have failed to
1) itnplem�nt secu�ity measures, including but not lirrzated tp adec�uately
Iocking and secure daors,
2) �dequate ii�hting,
3) res#ricted acc�ss to the prern.�ses,
4) failed to hire security staff;
failed ta k�ep an �cc�ara#e tenant register,
6} f�ailed to secure the buildings fram easual intruders
The fr�llowing plan attempts to address cach issue as raised in the City's notice.
By submitting tbis plan, t�,� ��wners do nat adnrait the a)l�gation.s zn the n.otice but are
attempting to act in partr�ershi� wi.th t.he City to resolve concex of the City_ Prior ta
submitting this plan, the Owner's attor��ey, Kenraeth Hertz, has heen in catatact vvith the
Gity's attozxzey, Wiili�m Clella.zad, attem.pting to b�tter defne the concerr�s af the City_ Ta�
11� Clelland's J'une 5, 2007 correspondence tc� Hcrtz, he su.gge;�t that the plan shou.ld
"reali.stically addzess two broad issues:
1, an im.z.nediate a,nd meaningful reduction zn the calls for sezvice wl�ich real.l.y
means redu�tican i.n the leve] of crime at thc premisES and,
2. an ir.rxaxi�diate and meaningful impravement in t�a� c�nd�tion o�t1z� physical
condition of the premises with the i.n.iiiai em.phasis on abati.ng lif�/safe�y issues.
FHXSICAL CONDIT�ON OF' THE PREMIS�
On �'ebruary 08, 2007, an inspeetio�. was conducted on behalf o#'th� City at the
premis�s, After receipt of the last af items to be cprrected, th� O�var�ers bega.n com.pleting
the items an the list. On A.pril 26, 2007 a. Jist idcntifying the rema,ining items on tbe Iist
was p.rovided; ik�is list contained 15 rcmainin.g items on the list. Subsequent ta �receivix�g
this list, tlae remainin� 15 items l�av� been com.pleted and the repairs ha.ve been
dacumettted.. The awners contactcd the City to conduct ars-inspectaon o�thc rez�nainin.g
Asgher daoveed a�.id Nyder Jsweed are nol the owners of the pxemises.
1
15 items but the City representative has declin.ed to do such an inspection. 'TJ.�e City
representative, Jahn Rued, ix►dicatcd tha.t he wa.s instructed �not to do this inspection by
La�xy Masrtin.. It seems disingenuaus for the City to request that the Qwners comgaete
certain l�fe and safe��y issues and wil] not re-inspect for their completion. Nonetheless, s.11
oFthe work rec�uired in the �ebruary 08, 2007 inspection has been completed artd
therefore ihis c�nc�rn o�the City has been aIleviated. See enclosed photos.
Since th.�ir purchase afthe premises, th.c Owner.s have put a substan.tial ann.our,t of
mor�ey and e#�ort into the property to maintair� it in good pY�ysical condition, Obviously,
b�sed an the sizc �f the commuzzity, this task is on gding and t.�e C�wz�ers ar� com�itted
to the con�tinued up[cEep of tha prope�ty. Prior to the crzrre.nt �wriers ownership of the
remi
p ses, there were numerous and cantinuous pcoblems with th.e conditian a�the
prvpez These owners have dedRCated resaurces to the znainten�nce pf the progerty a,nd
promise to do so in tt�e future,
GTtiME AT T�E PRENIISE�
1. 7'erminatic�n. oftenants that have been identified in tihe Ci�y's p�lice rep4rks
The City issued a series of letters which have addressed cot�cerns r,egarding
various tenants who have resi�ed at the prernises. The Owners have bean active in.
z'evi�wing those letters and termi..nating the leases for those �ir►volved in activiti.�s whrtch
wouid be a violation of. their leases. Many of the people identified iz� the letfets of
Qff�cer T�rry C?lsom, are not residents at the premis�s and tharefore there would be z�o
leas�s to termzn.ate far fhose tenants, Fo.r those tenants identified in th.e reparts for serious
issues, the Owncrs have ta�sn the following actia»s;
Aenise Gz�).espie. 2424 Nortl�way #2�X. An agreemetlt to tertttiz�a�e h.er tenan.cy was
obtainec� by the owners and Ms. Crillespie vacated the pz��mises on June 02, 2Q07. Ms,
Gillespae wa,s mentioned on numerous occ�sions in the police repo;rts 8,nd her un�t was
affiliated with nurr�erous iricidents, The eliznination ofMs, Crillespi� as a tenant t�as
eliminat�d many problems.
Caxetta Crookston, 2132 Northway #303. IvIs, Crookston was ai�iliated kvith Anto�nette
Skzznault, Daniel Harper and Barry Shin�ult. Thesc individ�als w�re i.denti$ed nvmerous
tim,es in th� reports, An agree.ment to termi.nate her tenanay was obtaizzed by tlxe ac+mers
and ivls. Croo�CSton vacated t}�e prem.ises ort April 30, 2007,
Vian�a Campbell. 28 S 1Vorthway #��04. Ms, Campbell was identi�ecl as a�rQbtem
ten�nt in the �eports. An agreement to tenn�nate hcr tenancy was abta�ned by the owners
and she ua.cated the premises an lv,[ay 31, 20�7
The following tenants have.��so been iden.tified in the r�arts as potentia] probl.ez�as.
Cynthia �innell, 2834 Northway #202,
L�.trice Clark, 292p Northway #102,
Andr�w Fete�son, 2932 Nprthway #304,
h
.�;I��
2
John ;IVXattsc�n, 2912 Northway #l. Q3
Annette Larsoa, 2834 Northway #2c�3,
M.innie Cap�hart, 2916 Northway #l02
�'or several ofthcse tenants, thEy have not been specifically id�nti�ed as prablems buX
havE been ��liated with in.dividuals wl�a are problems, Pursuant to Minr.z, Stat. §504B.,
fox each of these in.dividuals, an eviction action has been cp�menced in a� a�tempt to
evict them frozn the prerriises. 2 It will be tiie �ntent of the owners to reac�Z an a.greement
with ea�ch of these tenan.ts to vacate the p�Emises in as shortest period of time as p�ssibl�,
7"he rsmaining individuals identified i.n the rEport do not appsar to be tenants o�t seerrx
be involved in incidents which wi.Il be di�ficult tQ evict far. Iftlae City iderrtifies a
particular tez�ani they wish. to have evicted, the Orunez�s urill coo�erate in dozng sa laased
on the in:surance �rom the City that they will suppart the al}egatiores in t�e police r�ports.
2. Hir�n� ofa security afficer t� patrol the prem.is�s.
The Qwners Iiave retained the services of Grade ..A, Security Services ta provide
securit� at the premiscs. Enc.losed is a copy o�'the contract between the parties. �r�
Q�'tcer frorta t"irade A zs curren.�ly prvvidfng security fror�ri 7�00 p.m. un.til 3:00 a,m. on
Thursday, Fr�day and Saturday o� each wcek. T�.ese are the dates identi#ied as being the
problem dat�s, The Owner's counsel has inquired of �r, CIella.nd as to obtai� #�e City's
input as to the ad�c�uacy af providing secu.r.xty on these days and has nat received a
respar�se frorn anyone an this issue. Th� offieer on duty ma,�es a daily re�ozt o�th.e
activity £ar each night is� whic� a patrol is provided. ?�ae reparts indicate that tkze seeu,�ity
lev�1 pravi.ded at chis time is adaqi�ate and that progress is being rnade to re�oue ctirne at
the preaxiises. It is impa�tant to note tha.t one of the primary tasks of t�ae �a�rolling of.�'icer
�s to continUOUS�y znake sure that all dpors are kept secu.re and closed tight_ Additionally,
Grade A i�,as oammuz�icated with thc City and it is the Owner's understan,ding that Crrade
A has teceived the City an appropriate nt�tice to trespass for �h�se tivh�o are nr�t
legitirnately on the pra�erty a,nd codes tp commun.acaee with the City's police �hrou.gh,
their walky talkies, �rrade A has been iz,structed by the CJwners to pmvide copie� of any
execut�d trespass natices ta the City police so that they caal enfarce these notices.
FurChermvre, �rad� /•L has been instru.cted to provide a copy vf their report to the City in
re�ards to any crimrr,a! activity that ta.kes p.tace an the ptezz�ises. Crrade A h�.s indicated
to the Owne�s that thEy are pleased with the pro�ress rrxade to eliminafie cr.irne at� the
1�raP�`�5'�
3. Elimination c�f �'ofiee calls to the p�emises.
The Qt�aer wil2 provide copics of eviction com�laint upon rn,c�iiest
3 The contract indieatas rlti�t i.i is to sian on Juf}� 14, 2007; tluis is a mist2.ke as the seeurity bega.� on dune 14,
2007,
The Opvners also ha��c noticc t�f tre��ss th�t they .h��t�•e used in tt�e pasL and wAI1 cantinue ta e►se in the
future.
A� i��dieated abave, the Qwners k�ave rctained a security ofiycer to patrol the •'k
prer�ises. A,dditioraa11y, they have iermxnated the tenancy of sev�ral problezn residerits
and are in the process of attezn:ptin� to terminate other �dentified residents, ?i,e .prernises
is £ully lit so that a»y crimznal activity can be s�ot�ie�. T�� Owners beEzeve that Chese
activities have a.bated th� nurn.ber of calls t�r thc premises and wil.l cantinue to have a
positive effect on. the elirr�ination of crime at the property.
The Owners do dispute the inference withir� the notice regarding the number of
police calls to the pr�znises, �'irst, the City is attemptin� tQ rarctpare �he number of caZls
f�r one quarte.r ta the number for an en.tire year There is np cvidence to SuggBgt that
number o�'police calls can be �.ppropriately extrapoiated as the City has attempted to do
in its r�otice. Based on iz�formati.on received by the Owr.zers, ther.e has been n.o s�gnifcant
ch�a�ge in the z�umber of police calls at thE property over the last five years_ Moreover,
the Qwz�ers have b��n tc�ld by the City that aIl police calls zn the C�ty have increased do
t4 a change in s�rvicing of those calls and haw th�y are ea.lculated. �"he �w.aers believe
that the ]evel of police calls ta thE premises is not significan�ly higher tha� �as beez� �.t the
prcrnises fQr some timc, The Owners aim at reducing this number.
4. Adequate lightin�,
The �wne�s believe tha# adequate lighting exists on the properiy. Ea�h bu�lding
on the prezraises has typically thrE� to fpu.r �xterior lights which shine over the parlcing Iot
ar.td the res� o.f the groun.ds:, The Owners indicate that the area is very w�111it at nig�t at�d
do not believ� anythirtg more needs to be done to th� lightin.g at the p.roperty.. The
�ers believe that al] lights on the premises are functional a�.d the list of repairs fram
the City seesns to r�ftect this a$ there is only two in#eriar lights mentioned in the City
repart which have n.ow b�en fix�d, Th� �wners kr�ow of na ather requests £�am the City
regarding this i.ssue. See enclvsed pictures.
5. Elizr�inafie access tp the premises.
The City requested 1;hat two entrance points to the premises be closed and th�
awz�ers ct�mp�ied witb. this request. The Qwners know ofno other requests fr.am the City
regarding this iss�re.
6. Aceurate tenants .register,
The Qwaers have and oontinus to kcep an adec�uate tenant register which fu1(y
compHes with the r�quirements of City's ordinaz�ce, #].2-909, As the City knows, tia�
p�operty is znonitQred by the MF--�'A to de�ermine complxance, The Qwners believe thaC
that t�aeir files meet th.c requi.r.ements of the ordinar�ce.
7. 5ecuring the buildiz�gs from casual intruders.
With the size o.f the premises and the number of buildings invol.ved, tl�is is
obvious a diff.cult task. Obvioasly, the Qwners c�,nnc�t manitor every area Q�'ti�e
4
i'i
prenaises. U�fortunately; tenants or their guests wiit vio�ate th� terms af'fiJteir leasES at�d
the laws of the Cxty and the Sta�e. The owner. s be(i ev� witkx the added sece�rity they wil]
rec�uce the nunxber ofcas�aal i�itruders. Additionally, since aIl o�the exterior security
doors have be�n repaired sa that they close on thEir ov�ra, casual intruders wi11 nat be ab��
to access the praperty unless th� dopr is intentionally altered not to clase autat,aatieally,
T.�astly, the Owners have ass��ned one rrtamtena.nce wa�rker to make regula�r inspection
af�tl exl;eric�r doars on aIl buildings to make sure they are �vorl:ing properly a,nd wiU
close tight.
8, Screening of prospective tenants.
The Owners have always and wi.11 continuc ta tho.roughly scree�. all prospective
tenaats includin.g daing a thorough crimina! back�roun� ch�ck of, alt prospective tenants.
Tt zs abvious by the raports that the majority of the probl�ms are not can�aing fro.ncx actual
teRants ofthe premises bu.t from visitors of ienants ar just g�nerai Casual intrude.rs.
4. specific incidents i.dentif.ied in th.e notice.
The Owners have not partici�ated in any of the ia�idents identi�'ied ut�der nuz�ber
two in tlaa notiice which be i s on th
g za e bot#om of page onc and cvzitinues on page tw�)
and it does n.at condone any of t}�ese activities. Tl�e Orvners do nat beliE�e th�t th�y hav�
cammitted a nuisance as de�in�d in Mi�nn. Stat, §bI 7.81. Not�withstanding the above,
they are committed io reducin� the crim.e at the p.remises as indicat�d abo�ve,
i
Spec.fcally, they 1�ave no Icnowledge of ar�y incident that occurred orz the
p.reznises an Ma,y Ol, 2047 regardmg fe.lony auto thei�; the Own.ers have not bee.r�
pravided any report on this in�ider�t. Regarding thc April 17, 20q7 Uurglary, it appears
fro:�x� the repozt that this occurrec! near the MTC bus hub. Regardin� the April YG, Z007,
none of the Ietter received from th�� City appeared to contaxn this xn�cident xrtd th�r�fore
t6is is the first natice o?Fit_ Sirr�ilarly, after a revievv af. all o�ftb.e incide�ts identifed in.
this sectzon of the nc�tice, t cannot �ind that any of tk�em h�ve beer� identif�ed in any of the
iettez�s pra�ded by Off.tcer Terry Olson. Possibly, there h�s not been suiFficietzt
iz��'ormation provided within ihe vaz�ious letters to identify th�se in.c�dents but they app�a�
ta be differez�t from the incidents identified in the notice. T�e Oumers will cooperate in
any way to assist the City in the prosecution of these incidents, Withaut turther
infcsr.m�tion as ta r�vhere these i.ncidents occur.red ar�d wha a1l�gedly camr�itted t}tern, it i.s
n.at possib�e to respond ather �a rezterate that the Owners have not partieipated in any
in�ident and have not candoned an.y acti.v�ty.
GONCLUSION
TI�e Owners are coznmitted t� efiminating tl�e crime at the pz and hav�
taken appropriate steps to do so as andicated abpve. The Owners are open to sugg�stion,s
as t� how they can. further �liminate crime at the premises and pro�nise to wo�`k diligently
to make the �re.mises a safer piace,
t A.NVlII'V_ �:ZC�E?f��•iE•J.i.lf'11 R�C'ikt'w "''i�����i�'.:.
y. .:ii'f� ,�t..;
w.y �"""'t i
r n
.K1
r
�n, �.G
'�i''��"v .'�.—F-`r}-
�9t r I 1 1 II I'' �ls
����i,f i�`�� D �f S �1'� a s 3 +nt�
I.,, .�li� ;��LY'�r"'� �i.7Y.�'1�,� N
h. rat� i 4 a .l i ii i Y a a, m t `l� y �;�A�'�' c�'�• ii 7 i�i'
n J r },f�'�. 1 �r t ,A i...
;,t' �S ��ih� i �h 9 �i .��9�a+ r �h4
11 r �l�"� 1 1 i i k1i,�IF�. �G.
Z 1 j tr i °�r „n; f r,;.,>..
tf r i .2 t (4a2 5 f;t Y.
i��� x�' a��x�� y �-t— �.y�.
�r I It i i '��1 j�^J�d i I�'i i Y4�� k� .R� 7 r 1 u S, j�1.S F` �i
n F, iti�"'k^,�k, t 'y' t1 i i:�� �t �.ii i i '1� 11r"�)j.VM1li tr i Ir, 3�. a i� �'P
'F if�l Y 7"i f t 4� 4 �t I.. f. R
l e �'7 1 F i, ..1 I� t i d�_, i f� S, i L� i N r .,v',
A t yl yr i� y;a.' 1"r+�o t �H� r v r �v.S y�
I� 7� J� n f�i �u t� tt �M h nk5a�1� 3�� �Y'i7 K7 q t
f F'1 �r,�a� 1 tl r�� i i S �k �tit t�a �3 t!
{�c i .r tf
���'cs h+'��, 1 91 ���l�i tr`,•
v 1 'f i�S�.. M1 �yF,f.' !q r ;i;
�^:h 1��, 4 If r t tt�$it•'Ci�`���;,•: �.�J
r �.�a lri�� kl.ir �41 4r�.
f I{� i( i 1 1 7 �•�I �`�-:,,r
k� ���J}�t��' „t+'.- i.iq.: ����P+�
�i_ °`f,..�'� 'y� �ar°'1ali �v.�
r 1 n Y�'yr i�
�ti. S 4 �s I S r� r t L,
{Y.�L if h LA'��• 1 i �k 4' G 1
r"_?:3• `r
,s vY �i L
,1 x "t 7�.
.,r.t.:.r�,' ��.l�.�:� t5��4
r.' "'���'}„�t,,.,,
iI'GY i�' �}'��Fp!:�`'��':.' 1
iJj� h ����r
i
rw; �1��' a
�1 +q .��i�«.;�' t 1 �r"�
y:;:;��:�
'�h.
i
L L i 4�'a�.
u4.
�Y
1
�1! t 1' 1
C I
���tn 14 20�?'S:O1PM HP LRSERJ�T �Rk P
I, en# Ca
Agre�m tt#ra�Ear pzap� ses to £u�ish �Cristo;mer W�i� a an-,��ke �er
on tkte �c�vc c'�escr�'t�ed �ro 1�e serv�ioe w�ll can�ist �f ceguter
exeun�itstaan� c�f 6uilding �nd s es ovtline8 und�r s�cti,an #2
("Scope af Service"� herein.
2. Scape of Serv,P��s Cc�n�tn wi11 xuovid� the fo�iow2�tg �crviGc§ as �rt
aft�is agre�mea�t:
�ngtrra�H�un� �ar th� are�► ps�I o�r �n-�f�e affilc�r �hfeh �ncl�de�
�e �'oilaw3�g:
P��c3ic�ly ahc,�k e buiIding ext�riars attd interiars visualty
�lt�ck �Il t�utside� ar�C-�a, Iaatrot a�l parking lots, and �xnd to cel� as
�cd, U�eers ta�atso deal wi�t �uy w�aut�orizecf gersoxts oxt th�
P�p�3'+ �ssiSt guc'�t and empinp�B uPo�x re��ues�, Custozuex s�.t�csrize$
Contractor ta c�oz ae all M'uinesata State �'i�t�s, Cit3� Ordin�nccs �nd
aay and atl z�ules r,� i regulations sct by the O�rnes pr 4ea�eral M�aag�r af
t� �,rap�u'tp x�arnec� i�in,
�eea�ity o�t�.sfte eet•v�eee s� UoWS:
�n-�ite U�icer: c1a� pe� wic.......'�'ftrti-S�t......�1�.4e�5ar�r
6 hra Sl9.Op ��1,� ��r u�anth pins taxe�
3. +Contt�aet Te�rms Customer es t� oant�act vvit� C�t�actar wi,il beg�
����,?�E.�.� Fith.ar �trty has tb.e ri�rt t�
r��� �c �y w� a a� �m� ��m�� ��r
����i��.
4. Fee 3chetltile Custom.ar �xe�s to pe�y Cr.��.�acior th� fc�Ilovvia� rst�s for
s�rv�ce rc�dere+�:
Security �a1� �ervic�s �t' fl�t tr�e af p�n c��ur pivs
A�'Plic�b2e
Ct.tstarzt�rs a�grces tbat tk�e �lovving Iis� ofhalidays v►till lx b�11�d at
t'Ix tames tt� hawly c�vn tate ai�ave;
Ne� Yeaxg Ev�, N Ye�rs Day, E.sai�er,lV�morisl Dsy,
Ind+�pe.�dence Da�, Labar D�, T�,usk��,i'v�ng Da�
�b.rlsta�e L�va, �Ch�stm�e D�y.
CusSamer �r�es that fult y�enC on all iinv�ie�ss are duea due upan recc+lpt vf
invc�ice. Ct�stamer fi�i,�r �raee t,o FaY ��Y �rvice cb�srg� of I.��o ozt m�y
an.d a�X inv�ai�es ov�' (�Q) t1�Ys. Cu�tome� fi��#tter e� to pa3� far �ny aaci slt
�o��ec�.vn fees, �.r,�uciix�g ieg� �or incurrcd by C�r calldci�eg arn4c�,�t
due undcr t1� te�9 of'this ugeom,vr�,t. Ctx.qkan�r egx�es t��t gt !bv diar�ail of
�e Co�.tractor, exry ft�vt��t� over days old rnt�y be ov�' far �olle�,tiou pntl sla
�.�d wifi�iaat,naiice,
�un lt 20p7 8: o�Pt'I HP L..RSEiZ.7ET �Rf{ P. 3
S. Sbould traub�a d�v�eIqp r�gular cxaminaticm, Crmtr�ctor vvi12
aoa�erate with loca� �aw ent iKa detexmin�ng w�ra, wi� wh�re,
why at�d }aow an �ff�e upon e abave descrfbed pro�etty h�s oc�t,�red.
T1�ere wiill b� na ch�wrg� for gr,�cY P�tonc call sa�-viae perfozmed
durimr.g �gular wozlcing h�urs� �ss staled xn sectiGan i�� (�cnpa vf
Se�vf.ce). Ifca.tl back s�rvRCes uscd �ar o�er
th�t #he hours ant�
serviceffi
vtntlinod undcr
sec�on #2 �Scapa a� Sr.rvlte) hercis�, t�gui�r
l�ourly rate �.t 1a,me and a ha1P it] e�ply which wil� �iso be.inclvsive af
cim.e r�quired ta zetr�x� to th� lII3Llf8,t1� 3liV��t�8f:2011, CP� titll�, CtG
It is agrectl. thst the coatt'a�bor ioes nat �ssume poasessi�n ar coa�tx�a� r�f any
p�rt of eq�ipmeut or pro of the c�mers ��lua�ve]y. As the
owaer ar icssee t�tet�a#'. C ctor wilt a�at be Ii�bie for s�ty tose, damsge
d� dcla,� due W a�qy ca� 'bey c� .crixxr �e�nable canual fnclud�g, bttt aot
cr
limited to. Aats afgvvemrner� stty7ces,lockauts, mischiof, or �.ots c��God.
m"
U
x�t na ci�s wili e
Coratractor be �i�.bta
�r couseqnes�ia.l
dama�es.
7.' Thi� prnpnsal, w�ha� �car�ptCd y custorncrs, ac�t3��ri,�ed r�.prese�rta#ives
and approv,ed by th� Ca�q,t�t su�thnrixcd repr�sen�ive btlaw will
coztstitnbe t�e C�+niract be+twwe tieth �arrtaias.
S. �nntraGtox a��s for tl�e te�u >f tlxis coni�act 1� maia�t�in co�mme�ial
gen,�t�l liability iws�usaae af a•' laast t,OQO,t3t1Q.00.
i ,f
9, �o�h�actar a�rcGa to u1�ia�1n a t a lic�eASing wit�t 'Khb Bb�,
�rivate DetGCtive and Frsatecti� e Agent Servi�es.
lU. Atl se�urity a�i�rs'who cx� �irearms onWs�to mu�st be �rained by HCA
�ertifieci f�a`�ing ao�riemy.
Grade A Secnrit� A.pprovAp C�attter Poirite Apt� A�rprovai
��y��
y....,
e
—""Y�
o T.11�aore
G�Et)!�]!!�VATER
�)un OS Z007 �:giPM HP LRSERJET FH�
J;rN, 8.2@07 ���9PM CITY BR(�OVCLYN C�I`�TER Mp.i�� P.�C�'3
V �OS�I�� ���1 t
6�b� S3��ngle Crc� P'a�lsw�y �S�3i�
Phon,c:763-Sf4-334� �'�x:76��569-�4�4
,�1g,Ui�1� �aa�.�i�������
at�, �otxr rr�� �r�,� �m.
'X'�1: i�r Je�we�d
3 Slut a�qc� Court
5t. Pau], �T 127
I�dGG�A'1`Xt��V': �anb�rpointe l�p�
�QT�PLL'�iV'� bA�:
��1�'LIA�TCE t�F�+CxA�Lr 3o2m
The �nilowi�zg violatiat� af t�o �$.�pG� ����y t7rdi�cb wm'e citad
dnring 4 recent ��pe�an Qf t�� s�c�ve p�miaee, 'I7�$� vialatic� muat bo ccr�s�aated #�y tha
+ca�pl3�too da� in�3c�tc�d, �e�a�gemttoo, na �v�tgy ende �apapliaaee i� �ehednied tar �n t�e
�"taue �ant�t �s Itt3�ia dste creat� u canliicw
F�i�ra so ucrtect �o2at��tzs or ta z�anko ta�ary to s��ot vialas�att� aac�ptai�te
ta i�a ccutsplianac affi��i. me�y meu�tt itt sva�e+t�efo� c� revoaadvn of ranital dws�£n� aican�o
tt�lia�abin. Ia. a�fddfft�cns, ycinr �iilura to oa=etp�j+ mik raault the f�ru�7ce o� dt�tit��, ov�idr,�,
uq�aai oanviatic�, i,� �t�niahabla by $ste sndlor 3a�Itot�tt�n�.
T�a City �oU�l a�epted Na 99w17Z w1►��lr �t�avld� fee a�t S�0 to be r�ott��d
i�r r�a�pactt�a r�e�ui�'ry �1ber r�►e IIttt ra�p�tt��. The no��tir�n iba(�} �iII be
payabl� at �e time �f �ioa�ae r�ac�v� $ar the praP�Y► P�ar taa the ��,aimg f�ed.
��ti� i�.l�tl� c►� t4�e Q�d�naa�e a3ea prarTzdc� for R�lght cf A.ppcal. w'��rt �L io �Ila�a! t1�at a'
�om�X�moe Ch�er fdesrd u,patx ernrn��eaue �terpratatiaa af �o f:+r�ina�c�, T�a �,pp��t trnart bv
�.�n�a. c��� z��� D��, w�a�
,A�aG vv��hi�n a'YO (S} huN�,ese d8yw after �ervi.ce of t�Oa ard�� �d mwR b� a�ntipn�lad bst n
�ling #`ea o£$��.pQ ia a�b orcash�er`s oheck.
M�1 �tasutna 5Q4B.213 r�q�iltaa a� la�,d,lcyrd to gf.vo a ip»t r�onsbk xwtice �t entry ta dte
saat�i tuyit �ay #�ca pl�a tb� tbe pvrpase� of p�atnir� ea �s�ctian. �leaaa aa�if�+ Y�u'
tc�n�t� aP�e dat� ti�� c�f thr�it�erp+eoti�n at l�t �481�oltt'd iU ��ca.
Ii y�u ��ra a�y qa�tas� or coma�nnt�, �t�e�t �ont�ct t�►e �t 7f�S9-334i,
1►+.�o�da�► t.�r+an�h �'s'tdA,y, U.00 �.ta to �;Sd p.m.
P� j
�u� ud �007 8:4a�n HP LA5ERJ�T Fq� P.
JUIV. 8,20�lT 3:09F�l�I CITY BRdOKLYi�1 C�NTER N3� 1�13 P�3i3
�2TSCRtP�'[Ql�l' .dB'it3flLATYt]['QS A1�.ly Q�D�l4l�tGE.1i&��
The fbqowi�g item� vt�m aote4, d�arl�g �t �uq71c throng3t lt��p�o#ic¢r oF tive comaoaz� sres� ffi,e
�'rop�► an F�bre:ary $,1067.
Bufldla� �8D6
1. Tl�rd floc�t' �ght �Ic�ba--du� aida
�n�E�ag Z�1D
1. F.a,p�rhrep��cce aeaurit�r enA�nco daa� �c�--�aauth et�
S�dta� 2a14
I, Repa�r/rep�tax o�t �e door�aot �oours (on ordary.
Hnadil� �8�6
I. S,ee+�ad flc�nr.St� d+D�–north si�e.
B�me�ntl4�unr� raa�tn
1� �aa�ciry l�g,hti �t�abee-1�Ito�n shdlox misaia�.
B�a�ld�s� �6z8
I 'Y7� fu+or Sre daor �d
B�e�nen�uztdry xoor�
1, 8��au�c�r+y s�ara �re doo� a�fe�i��.
�fld�t� �93Z
�'ai�c �aar �ot soc�ua—v�ost �id�,
a, �aed htgb volte�e w�.t�ng �t �d tlaor 3�nC3,t�g �oar vv�o�t �ntr�ca
fan
3. :�ntr�aoe d4ot rwt eaaar¢-�-noxth eit�a.
�t�dt�� �0
1. E�rtry �ocrr t�t wcurn--�-z�ar�. �ride.
�u�idt�l� �iZ4
1. fl�x da�r s�ci aanrs� (bot'h tl�e laok s�i t�iab�-�ve�h sdaia
�IU�L'�t�'ilptit�► !'AQa'1
1. �c p��1 daor tlo� �,xrod 3a be�arnes,tlls��dr1► �re�.
2. �a�amsrn�latuxdry n� �ira �aua� a�,d li�t.
�tt�ld�ng �40
1. Pirst floor tite d�r--�nort6 ��Cle.
i�
�un U� 2007 6;41PM HP LASER��T FRX ��1
TuN, 8.�0p�? �:Q19PM CITY F3RObKLYN CENTE'h �{O.fA3 I',li�
�a����l+� fi�rar�
r �Cc��rmuo�lty t3eve���rnenfi
��cau�r; �3�'1 9�h��tg� �r�ek P�k�wy
I�hot�e '��►��=333�
�'��.n 1�� ���t ��-�E�9�33�t�
�.�.�..,�...Gr ,l�r�
i
�ug �8 �Q07 7:33pM HP LASERJET FAk p,i
a�•• r j� j t;Mc r• r r�i :..ri.
�y'X) ,ia•• FI�`r +�,�'�'1'� '!�+.'}f�� 9' �',Y 4' M Gf a a"�n" M} y~'.�
y.F 1 ti!4 �"7 I����.l
,y S ia' i er�yi:.:r �n+;�'f[ �hi �'i��� 4
y •y Y.� %w L:71, YV:n£-;i�r• r r wbTf 4;:�
�y,. `�a ���'�`i 1 i E y� �.tS�' F;� �:;S.F.���`•+t,� 1� f�
!•°„tr ti� �i� .Cr.
r l ^':.A.'11', `.•r: h"�Y i'': t''�
y '�F :t� s'"t;7i t r-f��'r�l{ i:
k`:�`l.`�+`` t .no .t7; L 11.�'� x:i{ f k'.J. f
i r� <�GA�'.'erytl fi r.-cX.�r�.
i� 1 a�:
li h• 1 l �J �I F J�...
ra 1 s Y4:�:. .y� t.Y'�. n 'l.�i tt��
ti V j� �ry. r� I S f.� ,yA���
�1� 3 V rf �i ;li'�:.r j�;
1
"if? y��.t. .�4 /'*�r r w .4;� Mm 9« r wT
h���,g�,ltW�� tl� r a,ii�iw:�:�
q}r:.. ��5�� �4,'�i.'� a 5 C .n .F a
q. r 9'yM k R 9+ y,b 7.�r p ,i
_i��.. !7'�!�yv �+lT�l;: t r� ��•n L f J r
►�S:e ti y 'i"`
.cq'� �fy �,1!'" n�'�� 4 'd I �i 9 fp'�:�`e•lti��-'C
iY�� ti .1����1•. `��ti,� ���f� v,�•1S�.ii:`.�yd��!��
l. y�,`.�,`•I��.,
''ir �x tf r „'x :�:k`�ii:�
.s ir .'t rt iri. �;w.,, u:. i�y`��
�'�4iG� 1 l 3 r �Y: ;l" i...•.
.-ti' 1 •',i .C� FI r f.7,� I
i y,, <k,,. �i a,��� t
i ����b y'�, �.�r �tx rh�
fc,� L �i�,`�!:r�S�+a .k'�,�./' t �r Y
!F✓. 1 �ila {q�t, ��,-L" �ri;
t s s ti a. t r d .'S�;!' y
�9:��._•:t lir��� ��x.'�• .4:[�i� '�f� ;jq;!'�r�� ,_^.r.�.: ;I.:�1�(..�:ri'�:
i'" `���J ��i,f ;4: YLS+� n
;�s?.' e����Y� �r ,y k „�.f. S r ,a' L wtq,� .�i .�Ec
Mv�r�",y{'. ••.•��J�. .�I`:� Pr�SP;.� ti w�� �l'y 'Y.�=r.,�� ;+:..y, u.
w�l; r 2 i�t;s �'..�i. „y'�.'�_
'`�i 'td �����ti �?�y '4c d '�d `.i. A 4t�r 7 .,ar:w
:lY:�;�s'� �'�N�' r n; �,�1 r �s "l •.L,.
�•y�. '9+��i,R ��i� rv yt
;i':.n.:,. a+• ;t;.#�'`
�,�1'� t�.�o-.Y' �'N�.':� �y';b y, �Q `J d� f 2 r
,•S�T.����!i." ii+�:•5A. R)'0?.f �y 3 l��'1�$ I �.t� F�T44:'�i1J�y�'�'.MI.((tr
�i�+ 2 /b Y i�t i :..:j
.;��r: n.��l� k i.r:e. y%� .r}ar. �".i_:-• 71•'�`' 6:;r'S*i..
y, q ry 3• r .(.n_ f. •1�'�'r iirf.
:�1w1^.Z i ��H nt���'"•y Sh��' "�'i�
�;.7 F .;'yl.. ���4�'+ �(�'�b� tisJ�'y� p 1 �:i'h.::.,; 4,z
p r f �T :l•1���d:;.��1,�_ ���n�r sA�;�+� +�'K���r;j
s`:��'.! ]:S 'i�rJo t rt o- �,7�, r �',�,y�.. t _�7: �i'e*•
r `i�d-' 3..�• .x:• y�
:�d,'� fi �Yi4� Y if.�'�� f::". l
y •L: �;c 6, i' �r`:
�:P'S' �!"t 1. 't� +,l t 3�` J: 'ly` j.1L i
���j.���.Y. .,T3`t+ 5 �4 j y t
�Yr 6 h i� k ik y rby{' ry,:.��' �4. i `�,`ri
f �lq. 'T r�� f'� .:}:!c%
'X'Cq�:Y SiUx`'l:.t'�f�(+�'�.�.77'�y.. v .:{�o�.• 1 V y N,ti ,'t
c� r;, i
;��h y�r,����'� .,;�;.r.: ��'�''a�:,� i• r�%
,aya(S�.IL e,�:.�a�gvt5.�i �.�f�� �K}���:" i H. �4 7 'f Fti4 ,+t a .i,
r.,Y, i t• aW y,: I:
Y�I'y` M-��} r j' r ���A i r
.�r? �I'�y� Y- r� t, ti ��.:�i• ��y.. tr�"
SI'':. �i'R1YRrti�iA;�� yi� t� �w:.j.�... .+����4�� 'Y r
�F, �'M �1 n '�`.i i'� Y'�''
F •+t! A' .ti' v c
il;� ,?�'t;-v°.'.. -tylrl t�. it� y�''p� ?'.y���:•: �•ti,
L.:.�L ��'�'S;?,�,�k^� ♦�'Lt'4 i r t::
��'4 Ji•'_ a 'Ya;
��i5 ,'9? i�j �,L�, c: r.�. I.
`.'rYr� r r, 3 .a:.•�y'3'•�0,,:�''';+ n
:i�Yh <'n)��r V�•�, fi✓�q:�r� i t "y i.
.1+ ��������:�i'4i��. d ���i� 1.
y. �sb ii. i '4yweal;.�'L: l 3,,� ti�� S. ,Y
:r
a:•'�� �,:'�Wk;�e"li%i;Y��i� S,'yt�*' F_h'.;-1e;• 4. 5 •7 a �i`K'�:i'•.^•,�Y`% 5
l� i,,yr �wi�'Y%�+�(,N �n:V%' •✓f' 'i'�';�r,°•�:i
•ln `i., �1�'�=.•. P"y� .5 y�ilf �yh �S11r�. 1
r7)i y, �C':`:
;,�'f:� ,t;•,::,. �',i,:�^ 7i Y+�' .t�'. :•r.. s�:+.�•
'rt, tS`' t ���•GJ:tij�n?(�:�.
.:'r?'�t'� .,i.f. F .y�r.
:.��'lf.' i ,�c t", {�J�;; .°�'�75i.�'. �y i'':.�.'?i,1
,k, +1�;.F�� ��;"��h�4'+=if=.t�;� f �i•. y
Y ,s'• Y•;
4h�P �v:!5;'+�l .e w
:f, Y y',, d�
aE+l�.' v .�M;ffy� �r 'i;!!�.: .l.� vt;'
e.,. .E•,'{.7 :.G••,
yi +.s a,}.; `��S'tr
�ry�,:•t :'siir:,�<�� i �"1 a �^i �+'�:N5 »�e �;x.
Ya y. `rJl' �"�'�'r �4:
-CF $n, L� r Y �r�' w,J�
't�;, ��.s r�1 AA i� l�� r �fi �G a�
.`i?:Y n�r �"�l �1 p a zr r S' r 11 �4
'{i•X� s Sy, ,.a:ra;�;�`)�t: Il i
'b' M l;�i aM .t�a.•`.�.
�,Y •f �:,•{.F�':g,�.r.,,a
;'ll�:.t �t` .":41 �ti� ���x�i; �;�:i�'� n i .I
::rta'.a ";<�;�1. 1 �1`� tqF
J� i �1.: 1-�
'Flr� 1" :.rC .,x�.'rY�.' ia'��.�
'L. i 'F. .3�
�'Y '�S� 1 �f•. A••+•
.5:� Jay ,1 i .kM.r ba, �y �i:.;. •4+ �'_F `�•�'+g ,L.�t
,i
I' r :�,1 ��x: �.y t �l'r'�
s42k 1 �y4+�Ew;�•� 1��'. P�' T: t d�,.' 4nr�' i� �'v,;.�.... ,y 7��Y,. e. i�
i `V P•� ,G,�..� i1� ,�y� L 3'�' �..t
7'; y y� y r�t�>i .;,�7 x2�• X� �5:
:?���,y... L, 3: �t t��._....�.:.
r �:.7w• I �r�,�� Yh`� 'Y'•� �y� •��J.?"�� '"d�.
a, �w� J V �y�'' V�i:��' X j
y l ti;:�,:• A s,. �..i Y:. f
1, va. t �t," c� .'�'�,•r, t �'::F''r �r: •af..;...
a e..; t. f+'�k:� =•a :I �r ,Y:
v'� u� Y'' �;�p�� J. l"+ a A�'� 1.. 4.'9 7i. 34•:
�.3. f: i� `ti. y�:,� �j �KY:.�.^•: wa �.,�o�:. �t�r,;� t+ +9, i�`:I�:.y��G::..H, eZ
a... .�Cti a t�,+�' MY� -0^r�.y.� f` t�i...•a,�,� j
tr i; aF�A ,r �y� '1�,J �f1:� T A,,• o.a.,�l.r' c,h;i�{�1.� 1
�f t•.• f }��5,'t��: n'nr.'�d:
�2[ �K .�4� ht S�"�, 5 fi._ �i� k� i4:? 1?.T.1�.�' r��;t,rJ:ati-�4
n�::�� n'�` '.-9"�• d 'T-
i
i
I
•f
CLTY Ok' BRDOKT�XN CfiNTER
Cash Recei�t
Receipt Date 8�7f2007
Receipt �1tamY�er 36546
CENTERPOIN'z'E ,APARTMENTS
2 8 02 NORTADJ�,X DR
60�.40-12].Q I'S, 488.I8
A1A.'Z'ER PA1'�7ENT
Total Receipt Amotuit 15,�8$,1B
122994 14:�.$:27
i
CITY OF HROOICi,YN CENTER
Cash Receipt
Rece:ipt Date 8/7/2fl07
�eceipt Number 38547
e�r�RPOZrrr� apTS
2 810 NOA�'HPTAY DR
fi0100-7,2].0 5, 7B1.d3
WATBR PAYM�
Tota1 kleGei�'t Amouzxt 5, 781.03
122994 14:19:16
1
Ii�
CITY OF BRO�KL�CDT CENTER
Cash Receipt
Receipt Date 8/7/2a07
Rece�pt Number 38548
CENTERPO:CNT� APT$
2 818 NQR'THWAY DR
60],00-1210 7,260.84
WATER P7a,'�'MENT
'I'otal Hec�ipt Rmount 7, 25.0.84
122994 14:ao:oi
i
cz�rx a�' �Raa�cz,rn� c�rrr�z
Cash Receipt
Rece:ipt Dat� 8/7/2007
R�cea�Ot Numbar 38549 i!
CENT��POZNTE A,PTS
a 6 2�_ NORTHWR,X DR
601�0-1210 6,986.56
WATEit PA1'M�NT
Total Receipt AmounZ 6,986.56
122994 14_20:50
i
i�
CI� OF BRqOKLYN CEN+�'�R
Cash �tecei�+t
kleCeipt Dat� 8f7/2Q07
Receipt Numbex 3855Q
CFN'I'ERPQTIVTE APTS
2 B 3 4 NOR:S'HWAY 17R
6010�-7.210 6,741.�,9
WA`T��2 PI�YNFENT
Total Receipt Rmvurat 5,741.19
122994 1g:21:32
1
i
CITX OF BRDOKL'.f�l' CENTER
Cash Rec�ipt
Recezpt Date 8f7J2007
Rec�;ipt Number 38557
CENTE�PpINTE ,a.P�,'S I
204 N'dR�FiWAY bR
60200-121,0 5,105.72
4+iATER PAYMEI�7�
�'ota]. Receip� ,Amotu'it 6,105.72
i22994 14:3'��Z1
CITY Q� BRaOFCI�YN C�NTER
Cash Receipt
Reo�xpt DRte e/7/�007
Racexpt Number 38554
CE'I�'I'ERPOTI�T'I'� APTS
2 9 0 8 1+IOR'THWAY D�i
60100-121,0 5, 905.'70
WATER FAY1u1EIJT
Total k�eCei�t Ampunt 5,945.70
122994 14:24:35
1
e
crrY o� $�oox�rN c�+rr�
Cash Receipt
Receipt Date B/7/20D7
Reeeipt Nttmber 38553
CENTFRPOINTE APTS
Z 916 NOR2'HWAY DR
60100-127,0 5,973.92
W�ITEF2 pAY�1ENT
Tota1 kieceip� A,mount 5,973.92
12�994 14:23:49
1
I�
CITX dF ERppKf,YN CENTER
Cash Fteceipt
R�cetipt Date S/7/2007
Rece�pt Numlaer 385.52
CENTEZtPOIN'�� 2�1pTS
2 9 Z 4 NORT�ItJ1�Y DR
601�0-1210 6,329.1.5
4JA'x'�SR PAY'�NT
Tata1 Receipt Ampuilt 6�329.15
122994 �.4:23:�2
1
a
4p
��TY pp
t': ifi.' �x�`�
��a1'tYl [4F�«
i,.:.1::�,'�'�.� F MN
v
Police Department
Scott Bechthold, Chief of Police
March 19; 2007
Ms. Heather Dahline
Property Manager,
Center Pointe Apartments
2900 Northway Drive,
Brooklyn Center, MN 55430
Ms. Dahline,
I am writing to make you aware of several recent investigations which have taken place on your property
and involved tenants, others living on the property but not on a lease, and their guests and visitors. I am
doing so for three reasons. First, police reports regarding these incidents are pending further investigation
and as such are not available for public release. Second, monthly printouts of calls for service to the
property generally do not include much of the information relevant to you with respect to these contacts.
Third, you will find the information provided useful in the effective management of your property as
many of the activities of the individuals involved constitute violations of the lease.
During February, 2007 Officer Peters received information indicating that several individuals were selling
marijuana from the entryway lobby at 2920 Northway Drive. Officer Peters was previously familiar
with three suspects meeting the description provided loitering there on a regular and ongoing basis but
noted that they left immediately when police were seen in the area. Officer Peters found the information
provided to be consistent with his own suspicions.
On March 8�`, 2007 Officer Peters and others noted three suspects meeting the description provided
loitering in the entryway at 2920 Northway Drive. As officers approached all three suspects fled on foot.
Two were caught and ultimately identified as Derek Lamont Leake DOB: 08-28-1986 and Bryan
Rashawn Hampton DOB: 02-27-1987. They are cousins whose grandmother, Denise Gillespie, lives
on the property at 2924 Northwav Drive. #201. They explained that they were there visiting their
grandmother at the time of the incident.
On March 9�` officers responded to a report of harassment which had taken place at the MTC Bus Hub,
across the street from your property. Through investigation they determined that the suspects involved
were last seen near 2920 Northwav Drive. Officer Peters and others entered the building via the back
door where they observed two males standing in the first floor hallway smoking marijuana. Officers
investigating the harassment complaint approached the building and as they did so a third male ran into
the first floor hallway, spoke very briefly with the two already there, then all three ran into apartment
#102. Officers knocked on the door at which time the resident, Latrice Lashwan Clark DOB: 04-18-
1983, answered. She was confrontational and impolite in that she shauted at officers using profanity in a
volume and manner likely to disturb other residents. She denied that anyone had just entered her
apartment and refused to allow officers inside to investigate further. Officers noted the strong odor of
burnt marijuana not only in the hallway but also emanating from within Clark's apartment and noted that
the air inside was smoky.
On March 10�' officers responded to 2932 Northwav Drive. #203. to investigate a report of two males
i ed off the
armed with handguns and attempting to rob the caller. When officers arrived the caller jump
balcony of the apartment and reported that the suspects were inside the apartment. Officers made contact
n detainin them all endin further investi ation. In the
with a number of people inside the apartme t, g p g g i
course of the investigation two suspects present were identified by the caller and ultimately arrested.
They were identified as Derek Lamont Leake DOB: 08-28-1986 and Vanesee Lawrence Johnson
DOB: 08-04-1987. Officers conducted a search of the apartment witk the renter's consent finding and
recovering a handgun. The caller reported that the suspects were allowed into the apartment after
knocking and did not force their way inside. Other detained suspects included Bryan Rashawn
Hampton DOB: 02-27-1987 and juvenile whose name I cannot release due to data privacy statutes.
That Juvenile lives elsewhere and I can confirm that Clark is not a close relative, if a relative at all. At
that time both identified their home addresses as Latrice Clark's apartment, 2920 Northway Drive, #102.
Also present were:
Christine Nicole 5app DOB: 01-16-1986 who is the renter of the apartment.
Darrell Deandre Webb DOB: 03-18-1988 who identified his home address as 2806
Northwav Drive, #304.
Kenisha Dee Green DOB: 09-30-1985 who identified her home address as 2928 Northwav
Drive_ #203.
Reginald Dwayne Clark DOB: 09-06-1982 who identified his home address as Latrice
Clark's anartment_ 2920 Northwav Drive. #102.
0-24-1985 —'who identified her home address as 6558 S.
1 rice Gautreaux DOB. 1
A ona Lat
h a Drive
Kin Drive Chica o Illinois in s rte of the fact that she s the renter at 2818 Nort w v
g g P
#3 02.
Later on March 10'� officers conducting foot patrol on the property observed a male later identified as
Ametzid Nijel Levells DOB: 04-15-1982 drinking beer outside of 2920 Northway Drive at which time
he fled on foot across the street to the MTC Bus Hub and hid behind a taxi cab. He was found to be
intoxicated and uncooperative. He told officers he had been visiting his girlfriend at 2904 Northwav
Drive, #102. He was cited for littering as a result of his throwing the beer he'd been drinking as he fled
on foot.
Later on March 10`�' officers investigated four individuals loitering in a vehicle at 2924 Northwav Drive.
They identified the occupants as Bryan Rashawn Hampton DOB: 02-27-1987, Michael Julise Farley
DOB: 07-26-1987, and two juveniles who cannot be identified due to data privacy statutes. Officers
found and recovered marijuana inside the vehicle. Bryan Hampton told officers he was again visiting his
grandmother, Denise Gillesnie 2924 Northwav Drive. #201, while Michael Farley told officers that he
lives with his mother at 2924 Northway Drive, apartment number unknown. (In a subsequent contact
Michael Farley told officers his family had been evicted from your property and were moving to Twin
Lakes Manor apartments soon).
On March 15 officers received a report of three males "packing up blunts" which is removing some of
the tobacco from a cigar and replacing it with marijuana in the lobby at 2940 Northway Drive. Officers
located and identified the three suspects as James Nyuesuah Talpeh DOB: 08-13-1977, Nya Suah
DOB: 12-20-1978, and Tettoh Addy DOB: 10-07-1978. James Talpeh was found in possession of
loose tobacco which is consistent with the original report while Tettoh Addy was found to be drinking
beer. All three told officers the were visitin 2940 Northwav Drive. #103. Officers made contact with .I�
Y g
the occupants of that apartment and found them to be uncooperative.
Later on March 15 officers identified a male loitering in a vehicle at 2806 Northwav Drive as the same
�uvenile detained during the robbery investigation at 2932 Northway Drive on March lOth. He was
uncooperative with officers and claimed that he was waiting for three friends who were inside visiting
#303. Three males believed to be associating with that juvenile were located. One of the three was
identified as Reginald Dwayne Clark DOB: 09-06-1982 and for a second time he identified his home
address as Latrice Clark's anartment_ 2920 Northwa� Drive. #102. Officers noted that the juvenile and
Reginald Clark had been associated previously with Darrell Deandre Webb DOB: 03-18-1988, who
identified his home address as 2806 Northwav Drive. #304 and as a result they believe Daniel Burgess
was either mistaken or lied about which apartment they were visiting.
There have been other law enforcement contacts, some with the same individuals, on the property but they
do not constitute either criminal or lease violations. Please call with any questions or concerns.
Sincerely,
Officer Terry Olson
Brooklyn Center Police Department
763-569-3333
Cc: File
Br•ooklyn Center Police Departmeni Police Deparhnent 763-569-3333
6695 Ha+m6oldt,�venue Nor�h TDD 763-561-.i720
Brookl}m Center, t1�IN �.i430-1853 F.9.Y 763-561-0717
Crime Tips 763-561-66=19
qpL1C
G �•(y p�.
1�1' Ff�
h
�.�:�����.�.�ie �a,�s �.«t!\ I
i;..�.,t.'.ii' i'��i Z::�� MN
-v
Police Department
Scott Bechthold, Chief of Police
March 20, 2007
Ms. Heather Dahline
Property Manager,
er Pomte A artments
Cent p
2900 Northway Drive,
Brooklyn Center, NIN 55430
Ms. Dahline,
I am writing to make you aware of two recent investigations which ha�e taken place on your property and
involved tenants, others living on the property but not on a lease, and their guests and visitors. I am doing
so for three reasons. First, police reports regarding these incidents are pending further investigation and
as such are not available for public release. Second, monthly printouts of calls for service to the property
generally do not include much of the information relevant to you with respect to these contacts. Third,
you will find the information provided useful in the effective management of your property as many of
the activities of the individuals involved constitute violations of the lease.
3r 2007 officers res onded to a re ort of a robber which took place outside of 2900
On February p p Y
Northway Drive (BCPD CN 07-586): As a result of this investigation officers identified the following
individuals:
Calvin (mm�) Ambrose DOB: 07-19-1956
o Victim
o Was in the process of moving in with his daughter's mother at 2834 #202
Antoinette Elicia Shinault DOB: 10-17-1980
o Witness
o Claimed to be the renter at 2932 #303
Barry Earl Shinault DOB: O1-13-1987
o Arrested at 2932 #303
o Identified the renter at 2932 #303 as his wife (Antointeet Shinault) I,
o Claim�d to live elsewhere
Daniel Dominic Harper DOB: 08-10-1985
o Arrested at 2932 #303
o Identified his home address as 2932 #303
Robert James Williams DOB: 04-10-1985
o?�rrested at 293 Z#3 03
o Claimed to live elsewhere
On March 9' 20Q7 officers responded to a report of several males armed with handguns intending to
commit a robbery (BCPD CN 07-1245). Officers responded and through investigation located and
detained suspects at 2932 Northway Drive, #204. See correspondence dated March 19�' for additional
information. Two suspects were arrested while several additional suspects were detained and identified.
They included:
Daniel Dominic Harper DOB: 08-10-1985
o Again identified his home address as 2932 #303
th r investi ated a re ort of four sus ects burning something at 2932 Northway
3 2007 office s
On March 1, g p P
Drive (BCPD CN 07-1341). Fire Department personnel located a small fire on the front steps of the
building. Officers checking inside the building located three suspects in the laundry room between the
2932 and 2936 buildings who were smoking marijuana. When officers approached all three suspects fled
on foot. One suspect was caught, arrested, and identified as follows:
Daniel Dominic Harper DOB: 08-10-1985
o Again identified his home address as 2932 #303
All three cases are pending further investigation and or criminal prosecution. Please call with any
questions.
Sincerely,
Officer Terry Olson
Brooklyn Center Police Department
763-569-3333
CC: File
Brooklvn Center Police Deparhnent Police Deparlrnent 763-569-3333
6695 Flumboldt Avenue North TDD 763-561-5720
Brooklyn Center, MN 55430-1853 F,9X 763-561-0717
Crinie Tips 7b3-561-6699
y oLlc
C �.ty
f l�S' d9i�
y y a yy h
R;�X�Y,/" �A T' itantirx CL�T�x
i, ��:aF .�F MN
v i
Police Department
Scott Bechthold, Chief of Police
March 28, 2007
Ms. Heather Dahline
Property Manager,
Center Pointe Apartments
2900 Northway Drive,
Brooklyn Center, MN 55430
Ms. Dahline,
I am writing to make you aware of a series of recent investigations which have taken place on your
property and involved tenants, others living on the property but not on a lease, and their guests and
visitors. I am doing so for three reasons. First, police reports regarding these incidents are pending
further investigation and as such are not available for public release. Second, monthly printouts of calls
for service to the property generally do not include much of the information relevant to you with respect
to these contacts. Third, you will find the information provided useful in the effective management of
your property as many of the activities of the individuals involved constitute violations of the lease.
icer investi ated four eo le loiterin in a vehicle lighting what they believed to
On March 21 2007off s g p p g
be marijuana. Officers noted the strong odor of burnt marijuana and observed one of the suspects conceal
a marijuana blunt on his person. Officers learned that three of the suspects were visiting the fourth, who
identified his residence as 2928 Northwav Drive. #203. where he lives with his grandmother, Veronica
Daniels. Officers spoke with Ms. Daniels at which time she confirmed that her grandson does in fact live
with her. The four suspects were identified as:
Jac�uan Demerius Watson DOB: 10-13-1985
o Identified his residence as 2928 Northway Drive, #203
Zachary Leon Redmond DOB: 08-22-1985
o Possessed Marijuana
Brandon Marius Jordan DOB: 12-13-1986
Anna Justine Davenport DOB: O1-16-1988
Later on March 21 2007 officers investigated a loud stereo at 2802 Northwav Drive_ #102. The made
contact with a male who stated that he lived in the apartment but was not on the lease. He was warned
about the loud music. He was identified as:
Clarence Tejan DOB: 08-09-1988
I
On March 23 2007 offieers investigated a suspicious person in front of 283Q Northway Drive. The
found that he was drinking beer and identified himself as a resident at 2802 Northwav Drive, #201. He
was identified as:
Valentin Constantin Rosu DOB: OS-20-1983
Later on March 23 2007 officers investigated a group loitering on the front steps at 2916 Northway
Drive. All indicated that they were visiting 2916 Northwav Drive. #102. Officers found a marijuana
"blunt" still burning on the steps and noted that one of the males was drinking beer. All denied
possessing the marijuana. Officers found no answer when they knocked on the door at apartment #102 at
that time. One of the suspects was arrested on a felony warrant and the rest were sent off the property.
Several hours later officers found another group loitering on the front steps at the same building. When
the investigated they noted loud music coming from apartment #102. The spoke with Minnie Capehart,
who identified herself as the renter and indicated that the group loitering on the front steps were her guests
and visitors. She was warned about the loud music and was cooperative in having her guests leave.
On March 24 2007 officers investigated a suspicious vehicle parked at 2822 Northway Drive. The
noted the strong odor of burnt marijuana from inside the vehicle. The driver admitted that her boyfriend
just smoked marijuana in the vehicle. She indicated that she was there to visit the renters at 2822
Northwav Drive, #202. Officers recalled having contacts with suspects detained in previous suspicious
activities on the property who were associated with the same apartment. The female in the vehicle was
identified as:
Deborah Maria Myers DOB: OS-11-1988
On March 24�', 2007 officers investigated a group of males loitering outside of 2928 Northway Drive. All
three indicated that they were visiting the renters of 2928 Northwav Drive, #102.
On March 27 2007 officers attempted to investigate a suspicious male in front of 2920 Northway Drive.
The male fled, but was apprehended. The suspect was arrested for the new offense of fleeing an officer
on foot, and on an outstanding felony narcotics warrant. He identified his residence as 2920 Northwav
Drive. #103. He was identified as:
Brian Lee Aultman DOB: 07-15-1959
Sincerely,
Officer Terry Olson
Brooklyn Center Police Department
763-569-3333
CC: File
BroolclynCenterPoliceDeparfinent PoliceDeparZnient 763-569-3333
6645HitmboldtAvemteNo�4h TDD 763-561-5720
Broolzlyn Center, MN 55430-18,53 FAX 763-561-0717
Crirne Tips 763-561-6649
y oLic
LI'T UP
11��' F93�
�F,����t,F=� ���LYi C4�S�4i
d"��� Ec V
j'
Police Department
Scott Bechthold, Chief of Police i
April 2 2007
Ms. Heather Dahline
Property Manager,
Center Pointe Apartments
2900 Northway Drive,
Brooklyn Center, MN 5 543 0
Ms. Dahline,
I am writing to make you aware of a series of recent investigations which have taken place on your
property and involved tenants, others living on the property but not on a lease, and their guests and
visitors. I am doing so for three reasons. First, police reports regaxding these incidents are pending
further investigation and as such are not available for public release. Second, monthly printouts of calls
for service to the property generally do not include much of the information relevant to you with respect
ou will find the information rov
ided useful in the effective management of
to these contacts. Third P
�Y
our ro ert as man of the activities of the individuals involved constitute violations of the lease.
y p P Y Y
007 officers investi ated a rou of suspicious males loitering on the property. One
28 2 P
arch g
On M g
indicated that he was visiting the renter at 2916 Northwav Dnve. #301. Another of the males told officers
that he lives at 2934 Northwav Drive, #202, with Cvnthia Finell. He told officers that he is not on the
lease, that he does not have to be on the lease, and that he could have anyone he wants to his apartment in
spite of the fact that he is not on the lease there. The third male was familiar to the investigating officers
and has been detained for engaging in suspicious activities on the property on several recent occasions.
He was trespassed from the property. The suspects were identified as follows:
Lewis Corey Williams DOB: 12-29-1975
o Visiting 2916 Northway Drive, #301
Andre Donnell Jackson DOB: 02-18-1987
o Lives with Cynthia Finell at 2934 Northway Drive, #202
Patrick Samah Kimba DOB: 10-OS-1985 I
o Trespassed from the property
Later on March 28`� officers attempted to stop two males seen running from the MTC Bus Hub onto the
property. One of the suspects cooperated while the other fled from officers but was apprehended and
hat offense an
d on an outstandin warrant. Both were identified and officers determined that
rrest
ed for t g
a
they were guests and visitors to 2806 Northwav Drive. #204. Officers contacted the renter, Thomas Cox..
at which time he confirmed that the suspects were his guests and visitors. He was cooperative and
expressed appreciation for the additional enforcement efforts on the property. One of the suspects is a
juvenile and as such I cannot release his identity. The suspect who was arrested was identified as:
Tyrone Demitrius Campbell DOB: 07-25-1986
On March 29 officers accompanied a Hennepin County Probation Officer in a visit to Denise Gilles�oie,
2924 Northwav Drive. #201, regaxding her grandson. She confirmed the identity of her grandson and
acknowledged that he visits her on the property on occasion. Officers have had severa.l recent prior
contacts with him on the property. He is:
Bryan Rayshawn Hampton DOB: 02-27-1987
On March 29'�' officers stopped a suspicious vehicle leaving the property: The driver, who officers knew
from several recent previous contacts on the property, lied about his identity and was booked for driving
without a license and providing false information to police. One of the passengers was also known to
officers from previous recent contacts on the property, has been regularly found in the company of Bryan
Hampton. The driver and two of the passengers are juveniles and as such I cannot release their identities.
The adult passenger was trespassed from the property. He is:
Michael Julise Farley DOB: 07-26-1987
�n Q s ace at 2834
30 officers checked an occu ied vehicle parked in a handicap parkin p
On March P
Northway Drive without a permit displayed. They identified the driver occupant as the resident of 2834
Northwav Drive. #103: They determined that she did not have a valid permit and she was cited. She was
identified as:
Alfreda Free Cooper DOB: 08-24-1987
Later on March 30 officers stopped a vehicle leaving the property and recalled having a recent previous
contact with the driver on the property. (That contact was documented in the letter I sent to you dated
March 19 In this instance the driver was found to have a suspended MN Driver's License. He was
cited and released at the scene after being identified as:
Tettoh Addy DOB: 10-07-1978
I
I
Sincerel
Y�
Officer Terry Olson
Brooklyn Center Police Department
763-569-3333
CC: File
Br•oolclyn Center Police Deparh7tent Police Depa���ient 763-569-3333
6645HTUnboldtAvenueNorth TDD 763-561-5720
Broolrlyn Center, MN 55430-1853 FAX 763-561-0717
Crime Tips 763-561-6649
c oLl�
•TY pp
.i�'�' �s�"
v
�F]y y
y ���CR
xS' y' �y ���1
•..':�rA"�.�.�.� _i t!i I
I I,
X..���
i; .�4'�+ 4 :aF �.d MN
v
Police De�artment
Scott Bechthold, Chief of Police
April 2° 2007
Ms. Heather Dahline
Property Manager,
Center Pointe Apartments
2900 Northway Drive,
Brooklyn Center, MN 55430
Ms. Dahline,
I am writing to confirm the nature of the issues we've discussed recently and to determine the status of
several requests we made of each other during those conversations.
You will recall that we discussed the additional patrol and enforcement we've been providing at several
locations within the city which have been identified as the busiest in terms of calls for police services and
crime reports, including your property.
During our conversations I agreed to:
Make information developed in this effort which is relevant to the effective management of
the property available to you in a timely manner.
Encourage officers working the detail to trespass individuals engaging in problematic
behavior on the property who have no legitimate reason for their presence there.
Fax you a copy of the proper trespass notice for use by your staf£
Support your efforts to effectively manage the property in every manner possible.
Since making those agreements:
o I have sent you four letters documenting various criminal activities and or lease violations.
o Officers working the detail have issued trespass notices whenever possible.
o I have faxed the trespass notice for use by your staf£
During our conversations you agreed to:
Provide a summary of the actions you have taken regarding the incidents documented in
the letters.
Provide a letter authorizing us to act as your agents in the issuance of trespass notices.
Call 911 for assistance in issuing trespass notices when your staff has safety concerns.
Provide copies of trespass notices your staff has issued.
•l
Since making those agreements:
o You have not provided any of the information or materials requested nor have you
requested assistance in the issuance of trespass notices or other matters.
You and I have known one another for nearly fifteen years. During that time we've worked together on
many occasions and have very effectively reduced crime and disorder at other troubled rental properties
to our mutual benefit. We did so through cooperation and the support of one another's efforts. Those
experiences have demonstrated that neither of us can accomplish working independently even part of
what we can accomplish working together.
I recognize that you're relatively new to your current position and that crime and disorder are not the only
issues requiring your attention. However, through experience we both know that the other issues relating
to the management of a rental property mean little when crime and disorder, particularly that which
occurs at the levels present on your property and in the surrounding area by extension, remain
unaddressed.
The manner in which businesses are operated has a profound effect on the rate of crime and disorder in
the community. It is my view, and that of the City, that business owners have a responsibility to operate
their business in a manner that minimizes any potentially negative impact on the rest of the community. It
is clear that the management practices used in the operation of a rental property have a much greater
effect on crime and disorder than the enforcement of the law. Gone are the days when crime and disorder
were problems held exclusively for law enforcement.
For these reasons I can't help but wonder why there isn't a greater interest, on your part and that of the
property owners, to support the efforts being made in the area. I ask that you honor the agreements that
have been made and that you provide a written response in a timely manner as to your position regarding
the content of this letter.
Sincerely,
Officer Terry Olson
Brooklyn Center Police Department
763-569-3333
CC: Hyder Jaweed, Asgher Jaweed, File
Broolilyn CenterPolice Department Police Depar�me�zt 763-569-3333
6645 Humboldt Avenate North TDD 763-561-5�20
Broolzlyn Certter, A�IJ 55930-1853
FAX 763-561-0717
Crime Tips 763-561-664�
y �L1cE'
Gt•tY pp
f ��l'F93�
i
���F��B,���� d .o
�lfA
��.+Y.'z;•''i?:eT..�.T:�:�� g MN
I 'f
Police Department
Scott Bechthold, Chief of Police
April 5�', 2007
Ms. Heather Dahline
Property Manager,
Center Pointe Apartments
2900 Northway Drive,
Brooklyn Center, MN 55430
Ms. Dahline,
I am writing to make you aware of a series of recent investigations which have taken place on your
property and involved tenants, others living on the property but not on a lease, and their guests and
visitors. I am doing so for three reasons. First, police reports regarding these incidents are pending
further investigation and as such are not available for public release. Second, monthly printouts of calls
for service to the property generally do not include much of the information relevant to you with respect
to these contacts. Third, you will find the information provided useful in the effective management of
your property as many of the activities of the individuals involved constitute violations of the lease.
On A ri14'�' 2007 officers investigated three males loitering in the second floor hallway at 2932
P�
Northway Drive. Two identified their home addresses as off the property and told officers they were
waitin for the renter of 2932 Northway Drive, #304 to return home. Officers recognized the third male
g
This time
and recalled that he'd previously identified his home address as 2920 Northway Dnve, #102.
he identified his address as 2932 Northwav Drive. #303. All three were trespassed from the property.
They were identified as:
Daniel Dominic Harper DOB: 08-10-1985
o Identified address as 2932 Northway Drive, #303
Mark Anthony Wilford DOB: 06-14-1985
Devonne Marvel Mayweather DOB: 10-12-1986
Sincerely,
Officer Terry Olson
Brooklyn Center Police Department
763-569-3333
CC: File
,,Y
Br�ooltlJn� CenterPolice Departnient Police Deparlrnent 763-569-3333
6645HumboldtA>>enueNorth TDD 763-561-5720
Brooltlyn Center, NIN 55430-1853 F,9X 763-561-0717
Crime Tips 763-561-6649
I�
4�
G �tY pp
f::;t�t' ds�"
�.,���+�.��z�� "„oa`�„�
u,a
i,.:;.t.'k;''�?:7F.:d�:�� MN
v
Police De�artment
Scott Bechthold, Chief of Police
April l l 2007
Mr. Asgher Jaweed
Mr. Hyder Jaweed
Center Pointe Apartments
2900 Northway Drive,
Brooklyn Center, N1N 55430
Gentlemen,
I am writing to make you aware of a series of recent investigations which have taken place on your
property and involved tenants, others living on the property but not on a lease, and their guests and
visitors. I am doing so for three reasons. First, police reports regarding these incidents are pending
further investigation and as such are not available for public release. Second, monthly printouts of calls
for service to the property generally do not include much of the information relevant to you with respect
to these contacts. Third, you will find the information provided useful in the effective management of
your property as many of the activities of the individuals involved constitute violations of the lease.
On April6 officers stopped a vehicle leaving 2932 Northway Drive for equipment violations. They
arrested the vehicle owner, who had been arrested on the property for Robbery previously (See letter
dated March 20�', 2007 fordetails), for no insurance. The vehicle owner identified his address as 2932
Northwav Drive. #303 and admitted that he is not on the lease there. He'd been arrested there for
robbery and at that time identified the renter as his wife but claimed that he lived elsewhere. He was
identified as:
Barry Earl Shinault DOB: 01-13-1978
Later on April 6�' officers investigated a suspicious vehicle and in doing so recognized the occupants from
recent previous contacts and an arrest for robbery on the property. Those contacts were described in
previous letters dating to March, 2007. One of the occupants, Derek Leake, is associated with Denise
Gillespie, 2924 Northway Drive, #201, who is his grandmother. At the time of this contact he identified
his address 2932 Northwav Drive, #203 and admitted that he is not on the lease there. The other
occupant, Vanesse Johnson, provided a false name and was arrested for this new offense and on
outstanding felony warrants for robbery and narcotics offenses. Both were trespassed from the property.
They were identified as:
Derek Lamont Leake DOB: 08-28-1986
Vanesse Lawrence Johnson DOB: 08-04-1987
On April l O officers observed a male on the property who had been previously issued a trespass notice.
They arrested him and in doing so learned that he was visiting 2834 Northwav Drive. #203. He was
identified as:
Patrick Samah Kimba DOB: 10-05-1985
As you review the letters I have submitted previously, six in total, and this one you will note that we are
having repeated contacts �vith the same relatively small group of individuals involved in serious criminal
or otherwise problematic behavior on the property a11 of which violates the terms of the leases your
tenants hold. You should be aware that the letters summarize activities which can be linked to specific
residents or apartments and do not include all of the enforcement activities we have undertaken on the
property. You should also be aware that many of the people officers have had contact with are
documented gang members. Most alarming in this trend is that many are members of rival gangs and it is
my feeling, based on training and experience, that it is simply a matter of time before gang related
violence takes place again on your property.
At some point you must acknowledge and meet your responsibility to effectively manage your property as
this is key in addressing the problems taking place there. We've provided you with the information and
support necessary to begin this process and have been largely ignored by you and your staf£ Your failure
to address the problems we've brought to your attention, and quite frankly those that you are aware of and
failed to address or report to us, has created an unsafe environment for your tenants, their guests and
visitors, you and your staff, others who frequent the property, and others in the general area of your
property.
We've been effective in addressing much of the problematic and criminal behavior on your property over
the past month. However, we cannot dedicate the time and resources necessary to maintain this
indefinitely nor should we have to. What will happen when we can no longer provide this very high
level of presence on your property? Unless you effectively address or displace problem residents and I
their guests and visitors the positive effects of our temporary effort cannot be sustained.
This does not have to be the case and you're not the first rental property owners to face the challenge of
regaining control of their property and their business. Ignoring the problem, which has been your
response to date, does not relieve you of your responsibilities or the potential civil liabilities associated
with your failure to effectively manage your property.
It is my hope that you will recognize and meet your obligations to your tenants and to the community. If
and when this is the case I will be very happy to work with you as long as you demonstrate your sincerity,
not through your words, but through your actions.
Sincerely,
Officer Terry Olson
Brooklyn Center Police Department
763-569-3333
CC: File
Broolclyn CeraterPolice Depar`tment Police Deparhnent 763-569-3333
6645 Hunrboldt Avenue Nor4h TDD �63-561-5720
B�•ookl}m Center, MN 55430-1853 FfiX 763-561-0717
G�i�ne Tips 763-561-6649
Q nL ce
�'CY O
.ti�x' f9,i� h
.6 e n cvF
4r s s
.Y i S� v
Police Department
Scott Bechthold, Chief of Police
April 16 2007
Mr. Eric Sytsma
Property Manager,
Center Pointe Apartments
2900 Northway Drive, #201
Brooklyn Center, NII� 55430
Mr. Sytsma,
I am writing to make you aware of a series of recent investigations which have taken place on your
property and involved tenants, others living on the property but not on a lease, and their guests and
visitors. I am doing so for three reasons. First, police reports regarding these incidents are pending
further investigation and as such are not available for public release. Second, monthly printouts of calls
for service to the property generally do not include much of the information relevant to you with respect
to these contacts. Third, you will find the information provided useful in the effective management of
your property as many of the activities of the individuals involved constitute violations of the lease.
On A ril 12 2007 officers observed two males leave 2818 Northway Drive in response to their arrival in
P�
the area. Approximately one hour later both males were seen at the MTC Transit Station. Officers
watched and observed them make a hand to hand exchange. Officers investigated, finding a felony
quantity of marijuana, a scale, and drug packaging materials, and currency on t�ie person of one of the
suspects, who was arrested. He admitted making sales of marijuana in the area and told officers that he'd
been visiting 2818 Northwav Drive. #203., when seen on the property earlier. The arrestee was identified
as:
Ali Omar Odeh DOB: 10-14-1986
Later on April 12�', 2007 officers investigated two males loitering in the lobby at 2830 Northway Drive.
a roached one of the sus ects fled on foot but was apprehended and ar
rested. H
e was found in
As the P
Y P
P
osses
sion o
f mari'uana a
cka ed for sale. He to
ld officers that he'd also been visiting 2818 Northwav
p J P g
Drive. #203. and confirmed that Ali Odeh was present in that apartment when he d been there earlier.
The arrestee was identified as:
Anthony Terrell Nelson DOB: 07-16-1987
Officers working the detail since early-March have noted trends occurring on a regular and ongoing basis
that I want to make you aware of. They are as follows:
,`r
Security doors are defeated or damaged and inoperable and are not repaired in a timely manner,
particularly in problematic buildings.
ed ino erabl
e and is not re aired in a timely manner,
is dama p
d eneral li htin
Security an g g g g� p
particularly in problematic buildings.
Human feces, urine, used condoms, gang grafitti, and evidence of drug use and sales in common
areas of the buildings and vacant apartments which have been broken into.
I have received a series of reports from tenants relating to building code and lease violations. In each
instance the tenant indicates a history of unresolved complaints made to former Property Managers and
the property owners. I am working to determine what role the Community Development Department
h se com laints and their resolution. Either way, you will be
are of t o
would like to play in making you aw p
made aware of the specific complaints shortly.
Sincerely,
Officer Terry Olson
Brooklyn Center Police Department
763-569-3333
i
CC: File •p
Brooklyn CenterPolice Depar(nient Police Deparinient 763-569-3333
6645HumGoldtAvenateNo��h TDD 763-561-5720
Br•oo/tlyn Center•, MN 55430-1853 FAX 763-561-0717
Crime Tips 763-561-6649
Y pLl
Gt'CY O
t` .t�t' �9�`
a�t �f
F
5 9 ItoaLfA C4Ft��
�F:,���f' L,�� O a
i;::.4.'<;'�':ei.:d�::ai� 4 MN
v
Police De�artment
Scott Bechthold, Chief of Police
April 24 2007
Mr. Eric Sytsma
Property Manager,
Center Pointe Apartments
2900 Northway Drive, #201
Brooklyn Center, MN 55430
Mr. Sytsma,
I am writing to make you aware of a series of recent investigations which have taken place on your
property and involved tenants, others living on the property but not on a lease, and their guests and
visitors. I am doing so for three reasons. First, police reports regarding these incidents are pending
further investigation and as such are not available for public release. Second, monthly printouts of calls
for service to the property generally do not include much of the information relevant to you with respect
to these contacts. Third, you will find the information provided useful in the effective management of
your property as many of the activities of the individuals involved constitute violations of the lease.
On A ril 19th, 2007 officers spoke with a male loitering outside of 2920 Northway Drive. He explained
P
his presence by admitting that he is living with his fiance, but is not on t he lease, a t 2 9 2 0 No rt h w a D r i v e.
#202. He admitted a previous gang affiliation an d a previous criminal conviction for homicide: He was
identified as:
David Deshawn Lee DOB: 07-09-1980
On Apri120 2007 officers investigated loud music heard from the balcony at 2838 Northwa� Drive.
#202. A male on the balcony described himself as a resident and was cooperative in turning the music
down. Based on rent roll records you provided previously it appears that he is not on the lease. He was
identified as:
Otis Spiller Weaver DOB: OS-25-1988
On Apri121 2007 officers investigated a male drinking alcohol in the parking lot at 2912 Northway
Drive. They identified the male as the lease holder and resident at 2912 Northwa� Drive. #103. and
arrested him on an outstanding warrant. After doing so several neighbors approached officers and
reported that the arrestee uses crack cocaine and complained that he defeats the lock on the security door
by inserting foreign objects so that his dealer can enter the building to make sales to him. He was
identified as:
John Allen Mattson DOB: 02-24-1966
On April 21�, 2007 officers responded to 2830 Northway Drive to investigate a report of a fight taking
outside the buildin one of whom (Antonio
place there. On their arrival officers observed a group g� d
Mckinney) was heavily intoxicated and waving a baseball bat around. Officers observed him strike an
knock over a hot barbecue grill with the baseball bat. He was arrested for Disorderly Conduct. He was in
the company of several other suspects. One of the suspects (Armond Henry) admitted living with his
girlfriend, Shavella Farmer 2834 Northwa�� Drive. #302. and admitted that he is not on the lease.
Another of the suspects (Andre 7ackson) identified himself as a resident at 2834 Northwa� Drive. #204.
and according to rent roll records you provided it does not appear that he is on the lease there either.
Another of the suspects (Eric Elm) claimed that he is living on the property and is on the lease, but
ided.
u rov
refused to identify his address. He is not listed as a resident in any of the rent roll records yo p
Two other suspects who claim to live elsewhere were identified and released. One of the suspects told
officers that a11 of the detained suspects are currently active gang members and that the fight was the
result of the desire of one of the suspects to leave the gang. The suspects involved were identified as:
Antonio Devin Mckinney DOB: 01-02-1979
Armond Lamont Henry DOB: 03-29-1976
Andre Donnell Jackson DOB: 02-18-1987
Eric Emmanuel Elm DOB: 02-17-1988
Louis Koree Williams DOB: 12-29-1975
Shawn Mirthiez Taylor DOB: 11-19-1976
In addition to these incidents officers investigated a report of robbery which took place in the roadway
between your property and the MTC Transit Hub. The victim reported being approached by four males in
a vehicle at which time one produced a handgun and robbed him. Four suspects were located and arrested
and all indications are that this was a founded complaint.
As you can see, the pattern of gang-related activities and crimes of violence continues to take place on
and near your property. This coincides with gang graffiti that our officers have found at many locations 'l
on your property, which I am sure you and your staff have noticed. You can also see that many of the
P rob
lem individuals encountered are living on the property but not on the lease, which has been a
significant trend for several years now.
I know that you must be very busy managing both the Center Pointe and Brookhaven properties. At the
same time ou have re eatedl told me that you would aggressively manage the property to address the
Y p Y
P
roblems that have been brought to your attention. You assured me that you would provide
hose efforts. You a r
eed to rovide a letter authorizing
firms t P
documentation which demonstrates and con g
members of our agency to trespass individuals engaging in problematic behavior who are without
n oin ass
ault
legitimate reason for their presence from the property. You and I discussed an o g g
investigation involving the former Property Manager as the victim and the current lead Maintenance
Technician as the suspect. You agreed to determine whether video evidence of their encounter, regardless
of the nature of that encounter, existed and to make it available to me for use in that investigation. You
assured me that the property owners were sincerely interested in regaining control of the property and that
you have been fully authorized to do whatever is necessary to do this. It has been more than two weeks
since you made this agreement and I have yet to receive any of the promised materials from you.
I'll re eat m revious concerns in telling you that criminal activities, particularly those of a violent
P YP
nature, will not only continue to occur but escalate with each day that you fail to regain control of the
property. It is readily apparent that the property ozvners, and you as their agent, are contributing to what
is clearly an unsafe environment through your management. practices.
The property owners, and you as their agent, have legal, moral, and ethical obligations to provide safe
housing of reasonable quality to your tenants and to be a good neighbor to those who live and work
nearby. If you are not motivated by any of these obligations you must at least consider the potential civil
liabilit that each of ou ma incur as a result of what is clearly a failure to effectively manage the
y Y Y
f a crime either takin lace on the ro erty or taking place nearby and related to
property. The victim o g p P P
the property, will have little difficulty in demonstrating the unsafe environment that exists given the
extensive law enforcement records and other materials which have been provided to you. The first place
e will o in determinin the strength of their position is the
erin civil liti ation of this t g
an one consid yp g
Y
g
g
local police department. Those records and materials are public data and as such will be made avarlable
to anyone making a request for them.
When you and I spoke several weeks ago you assured me that you and the property owners were sincere
in the desire to address the problems taking place on the property. I was perfectly blunt in telling you that
this has �een the property owner's assertion for several years. I made it clear to you that in spite of their
stated position their actions clearly indicate otherwise. In spite of this I still maintain the hope that they
will have a change of heart, for whatever reason, and support their words through their actions.
The first step in this process involves the development of a plan to mitigate the problems taking place on
the property. I would certainly have general advice and suggestions for a plan of this type, but it must
ultimately be developed, implemented, adjusted as necessary for maximum effectiveness, and maintained
by the property owners. Doing so would begin to repair the loss of credibility the property owners have
ises obli ations and res onsibilities to date.
f their failure to honor their rom g P
suffered as a result o p
Sincerely,
Officer Terry Olson
Brooklyn Center Police Department
763-569-3333
CC. File
olil iCenterPoticeDe artnterat
Police Department 763-569-3333
Bro yr p
ortJi
TDD 763-561-5720
6645 HLtn�boldtAi enue N
-56 -0717
Broolclyn Center, MN 55430-1853 FAX 763 1
3-561-6649
Crime Tips 76
t�Ll�r
d Lt'�V �F
f ,r�i' �s�"
'„a,
1F .��<:�8. 6 MN
Police De�artment
Scott Bechthold, Chief of Police
April 26 2007
Mr. Eric Sytsma
Property Manager,
Center Pointe Apartments
2900 Northway Drive, #201
Brooklyn Center, NIN 55430 I
I
Mr. Sytsma,
I am writing to make you aware of a series of recent investigations which have taken place on your
not on a lease and their uests and
1 ed tenants others livin on the ro ert but g
ert and invo v Y
prop y g P P
visitors. I am doing so for three reasons. First, police reports regarding these incidents are pending
further investigation and as such are not available for public release. Second, monthly printouts of calls
for service to the property generally do not include much of the information relevant to you with respect
to these contacts. Third, you will find the information provided useful in the effective management of
your property as many of the activities of the individuals involved constitute violations of the lease.
On April 24�, 2007 officers investigated two females drinking alcohol, playing loud music, and loitering
on the steps at 2920 Northway Drive. They recognized one of the females from previous contacts and
know her to be the resident of 2920 Northwav Drive. #102. The second female was found to be under the
legal drinking age. They were warned on the alcohol violation and released. They were identified as:
Latrice Lashawn Clark DOB: 04-18-1983
Toni Yolanda Jones DOB: OS-16-1984
On Apri125 2007 officers assisted members of the Anoka Hennepin Drug Task Force in the execution
of a narcotics Search Warrant at 2932 Northwav Drive, #304. When officers made entry they observed
one of the suspects (Haug) throw what was later determined to be MDMA (Ecstasy) tablets onto the
balcony. The possession of any quantity of NIDMA is a felony. They also found the renter (Peterson)
present in the apartment. During the search officers found and recovered a small amount of marijuana
present with clothing and other property determined to be Peterson's. The Search Warrant was obtained
after Haug made a recent sale of MDMA while at the apartment and in the presence of Peterson. Haug
was arrested and criminal charges are pending. They were identified as:
Andrew Sawyer Peterson DOB: 11-20-1986
Michael Stephen Haug DOB: 07-22-1986
'f�
Sincerely,
Officer Terry Olson
Brooklyn Center Police Department
763-569-3333
CC: File
Broolclyn Center Police Depm�bnent Police Departn�ent 763-569-3333
6645HumboldtAvenueNorth TDD 763-561-5720
Broolzlyn Center, MN 55430-1853 FAX 763-561-0717
Crime Tips 763-561-6649
4 L 1 CE'
1'tY p},
.�f fX,?'`� I''
I
�f�.�����-�����. .�a E�'�"
i .8if.`�E`��� �N
Police De�artment
Scott Bechthold, Chief of Police
May 7 2007
Mr. Eric Sytsma
Property Manager,
Center Pointe Apartments
2900 Northway Drive, #201
Brooklyn Center, MN 55430
Mr. Sytsma,
I am writing to make you aware of a series of recent investigations which have taken place on your
property and involved tenants, others living on the property but not on a lease, and their guests and
visitors. I am doing so for three reasons. First, police reports regarding these incidents are pending
further investigation and as such are not aVailable for public release. Second, monthly printouts of calls
for service to the property generally do not include much of the information relevant to you with respect
to these contacts. Third, you will find the information provided useful in the effective management of
your property as many of the activities of the individuals involved constitute violations of the lease.
A ril 27 2007 officers observed Shawn Taylor and a juvenile associated with Annette Lawson, 2834
On
P
2834 Northwa Drive. Ta lor was cited for
3 smokin
mari�uana in the lobb at y Y
Northwav Drive. #20 Y
g
possession of marijuana. Officers learned that he is dating Kristina Hently, 2834 Northwa� Drive. #102.
Officers believe Taylor is residing with Hently, but is not on the lease. You will recall that officers have
had previous contacts with Taylor and others living on the property as documented in the letter sent to I
you dated Apri124�', 2007. You will also recall that Taylor and his associates are believed to be active
gang members. On this occasion officers received information that one of Taylor's associates is being
sought by unknown suspects who possess firearms. Persons identified in this incident are:
Shawn Mirthiez Taylor DOB: 11-19-1976
Annette Lawson DOB: 09-OS-1967
Kristina Joanne Hently DOB: 04-20-1984
On April 27 2007 officers were walking the property when they heard extremely loud music coming
nr who is known to be residing
've #302. The made contact with Armond He y,
from 2834 Northwav Dri y
in this apartment but not on the lease. You will recall that officers have had a previous contact with
Henry as he is associated with Shawn Taylor and others. See the entry above and the related letter dated
April 24` 2007 for details. Persons identified in this incident are:
Armond Lamont Henry DOB: 03-29-1976
On Apri127 2007 officers again received information linking Vianca Campbell, 2818 Northwav Drive,
tion of controlled substances both on and off
#304, and others frec�uenting her apartment with the distribu
the property: You were informed that in two separate incidents suspects frequenting Campbell s
apartment were arrested on felony drug offenses as documented in the letter dated April 16 2007.
On May 2 2007 officers observed a male later identified as Ramadan Campbell walking between 2818
Northway Drive and the MTC Transit Station repeatedly. They observed Campbell make a hand to hand
transaction at which time they stopped him to investigate. In doing so they found that he possessed
marijuana which was packaged for sale. Campbell explained his presence on the property by identifying
his sister as Vianca Campbell, 2818 Northwav Drive. #203, and admitting that he'd been visiting her.
This is the third felony drug arrest occurring on the property which has been associated with Campbell's
apartment.
Sincerely,
Officer Terry Olson
Brooklyn Center Police Department
763-569-3333
Cc: File
Broolclyn CenterPolice Depa�-tment Police Deparlrrient 763-569-3333
6645 Htrnrboldt Avernte North TDD 763-561-5720
Brooltlyn Center, MN 55430-1853 FAX 763-561-0717
Crime Tips 763-561-6649
y o izc�.
�v�19�'•`i o
rr 8
ER �:�`�y��
BR40KLYN CENT
tlRO4yGYe ctTtFR,
POLICE DEPARTMENT
MEMORANDUM
TO: Willaim Clellend, City Prosecuting Attorney
FROM: Kevin Benner, Lieutenant
DATE: August 27, 2007
SUBJECT: Door Lock Inspections at Centerpoint Apts.
Centerpoint Inspection report-August 9, 2007
On August 9, 2007 at 10:30 am I received a letter from the attorney representing the owners of
Centerpoint apartments. In this letter it was described that the property owners had secured the
common doorways to each of the buildings. The securing of the common doors is a�ritical
component to discouraging trespassers from the property and this has been a long standing
problem at this apartment complex.
I immediately responded to the apartment complex at 11:00 am to validate the claim made by the
apartment owners. I began the inspection starting from the 2802 Northway Dr. building which is
the eastern most building at the complex.
Following below is my finding during a nine minute inspection. (The reason I timed this
inspection was to show how easy it would be for on-site staff to identify and resolve this
unlocked door matter.) Within that nine minute inspection, I stopped after I found that all five
separate east side buildings were accessible without the need of a door key. The statement from
the attorney was clearly incorrect regarding the securing of the common doors and any person
could enter any of the east side buildings without the need of a key.
Unsecured common entry doors:
2802 Northway South door no lock at all or housing for the lock on the door frame. This
clearly existed for quite some time as the door frame where the lock was weathered.
2806 Northway—Door would not close, the door and the frame did not match.
2814 Northway- North door lock was jammed open with a penny.
2818 Northway- South door would not close, frame and door did not match.
2810 Northway- West door lock broken
i 2826 Northway- West door lock broken
2826 Northway- South door lock broken
2834 Northway- West door lock broken
Secured common entry doors:
2814 Northway- East side door was lock and secure. (Three young children saw me standing at
the door and yelled down to me that the door was open on the other side if I needed to get in.
This was the 2814 North door which had a penny jammed in the lock.)
2822 Northway- East door secure. (I could get into this building from the south door of the 2818
building.)
2830 Northway- North door secure. (I could get into this building from the west door of the 2834
building.)
2834 Northway- South door was secure. (I could get into this building from the west door.)
2810 Northway- South door was secure. (I could get into this building from the west door.)
Note: This property has confusing address numbering and I have included an address map of this
property to help display the relation to the addresses and the five buildings. This inspection was
limited to the east half of the complex. There is an open courtyard dividing the east and west
sides of this complex.
•f
I
,,e,
i >`d,,�d>> t
o-. a
i14�i�< �s��.FZt �su3r,az'� lJrc�yi H��s
s �x
i.«�t .C. r
'r
-:.a...W'
w �y W �w
W
�{.i:ti"`?::::('�:Oiii::�::
•:.rr: •.v.�:.:�• rr.�• x:•:::.::�snv�{iirn:n::.x•.w:p•:.�:.j�
a•.:w�nt•r�n•:nw vrn•n•n•:n
.A...........R�!:P�:^4.•i{.4:F•;¢;{{:nwn��}iy,v,{.i.(
X::•.:�»:•::•::•::;•::.>
;+L�,:::: ::h' .:.{:i>'%: �'i•iiY:ii:•i:i�ii:•.
.....v............. ......o.�:::i?�:::•::<S;:?�:�::::�rS:�::•:. ...:i:::•::..
•:Y'::.,�. :.�f;•::•:::;::;:;:.::•::;�:
•r
•:;::�•::r::: r•::::., :^:.�:..r••x•:::: .:::::.::•::•3,. '�;�•�'G::!•:.........
,o, :;C�:��;
.t::::::.::�:••:::.--:::::..��:::::::�<:�.�::::•:::::.>•::::::.�:
w::::::::�•:�. :..y :r-0.•::::.�:,::qi:ii:vi:•:.::•::::.:�'ii:.. .�..i:::
5:�• ::::::::::::........:::::::::.�.;•::.i�:::::::.yj•::i:::::::::i.:.;:•:::::.i'i.y.�{::.;•.;•;.i':::: ��:K�::ii,:':�>i:-:�
r�cti;•R+,ee�aeAnxadlk9&.• +�.p
v i•a:
�W .::3f�°.�.��'':$:: `i:
t.
:;•:o+
i
;'•:3f� ,':ii':������������,�.'':>:'%%:;���
:::.>s:
r:;:
rr�+;
•w'::ii::i�'_...........i:i..
::.�:.�:..r.::::..
::...+::i•>:.;
.v::•:.`•?iS%�i
i:;iiY'•
�•iiiii,- :4�::
ir.
....w:. .:::n Nh.::::i.�:.� ...........r 'v:: y
p y w:::. n:. v:
..r:.: i:
...�:::::::::_.•.ii::::5.......n.� .::�::�:n'1.�:i�'+ .vv.....�4�:vi:. .:ri�+
:::::::...........n.....;...n.r:�.�:r:n:
w. R�{�ii: :i�:
vnR:n,,.r.r.w:Tii�r:i. .+biiii:i c>'�.::iiii::::�::�:::::U.i;':�.
�.;^'`f iiia?. y(� o:
u:4:i. Z' •n�•i
i�:�`:
.�1�:{i�i •".�::j;:
•i:.!:�
A:���
.�y
':v:'.,'.'�,�'.'�,.k .`:;'-::=::J•....
•�ii::$:
a::+:::::::::...
ii.
':::'::':i :':.Y.�:•:.� ;c...
..:.:'i:
...'C�.h...'�fi:.
.::tii�"'
:o.
:i�`i:�'::
:::::.�:..:>::::::•':.a::i•::•»:;:»:>:>::::::':•:::?•.�.�:.�.�::.y::�::.�:::::.�:::::::.� �..Si �o.
��:::::::::.N,.;:
..�c�r:.%`+'�'�'%��
,u::i::G:9
.�..p•::::: •::>::::Y::i<i::y.;•::::.:>:7:ii)::•>5:
:.:'n-0t??'::. +:•l.:
t'
.�..ti::
>;:v
:<J''1.::�':.....�
.Y.q n ..............v::::......,-
•v::::::<
^:i:i::::>;:>::
:;.:SS:i::>:;'.
�{1+ `r`
»n.:
.:y::: .......:.::J:::
........m.:�.}:�}i. ..y?
::::y::;
:a.::::••:.:,-'
.i'a$:•...........:::
ywi::�: �t ,u.....a 1 ::..:x�i.••..ti'�;:,
::b :t:•: ':i:::::+ .:�:x:. i`�i�� i .£k
3.. .�e:'.•": �.i�i�: i�::?:'.
e
�:�r.: x.' •'!•'•3c.:•: ,2:y.
.JO..nN�.4.vv.+..,
v.�y....:::.
�:::::::::_.r.
iii� .p`.• ii
:i
•ii>iY:::.:?:..:::n�
�:Ci:-ii:iii:t.....:iiii ��.T
::!:�ii
+s:: $%#y:`:,r
e':: i::i2�:�: :Fi:; V et•::
y;•;pi::.
��q '2;��t'3r_ �v..:•:::: w•: •:i::+ii':'i
Kii ?:'.:G:` S +M
o'b.• i+.•:..::.
rr....
:s:�t
c.: :i: c
"2'< •o:�.. o.
r:t 'k:: �t
k•: �Bt.........,._,.�,.., t�::,>,,: �.�;r:: �a:;i:?.;:;'.�'�''
M.. •i::Z
h:.:..
;:.�}i••:�
��iG::i::'"::i�?i::;�:`
�;:.:+R::.
a:�:.r::.
..::o:::.
::p:•»>:;:i�:r
�;r:•.'•:., ..:'g,..:;r:::.: ;;:.i.� .;•E�>:�>:;>s:ox
';`6Q.i
;.;rio�: ':i£�:�i'::.::;.... �.,•a..
..:Mr, v
.:i
3 :•:.a, .t8:z: ^x::�•
::::::.rr,,. t„
"^<c:�::. ;ir:;
;2:�:�
a�
+U.. 4: .::to. :5::i;::::::>:::
�t, ;:t�+.$
�i;',+5,e,i.�C..�,t:rri
.n
�.k., J,f .;.;�C .;::5;;-::::. r:::: a:::.
...,:5:
•;:�.'ry��''�''i.%>:.
r'.,
'%.L.
„<�x•:.,�..
rxa:,•:5:• i:'i::<2�:
C.t•
•v�:•::.::.,.• •i., ::�i:i.,�..;;,'i'.`'i:;:;i:ti:;?' ...3
v.
n�.�\ t;}t'
a�'
�tiG
i t r
ai'T::<i:;ii:i;:ii:
;i;;% i�i�y
i»s s:
�s:o:^::�::»>;>:-
,;::t. y.�::.
t
::::..<t;:
r.!•: J:,.;
.'t�.;.r.+ .:t�. '':2''• �e
'i:i��i::�:�: 5::;;<;;:
4
o
f
.:r
w.
<+.'�F�o-: :::3:•: <'y;:
•t
i.SJ'�.
,}%}'::i:�i:::?:
i}:i::�'! .�.:b.+.�'j.
+'p:
ii?iiii :J.4iiii:: v... n
:t� :.n::
y
i::�iii:iii:r
;,:c• r ••�A•:: ;:::�ii'^?;�.
.::�::+r•r:-3::�:i::�::�:...
e :::R�`�°•:`.
1
�f�:X'�::i:r::::.. �,��:?;�isi:�:�:%
�;:'k�',...
ii.. yni
.S •i::•:i .i:.,:..,.. i;�.+:. '4:•.
:i}'
.;'4::.y•
`:�i:" �i'::�i:
Y. ::i};:;:
t..r.' i):�'i�ii
�J:v..�.�.K...
.�1ti �:i::'f,w,':{i�:
.'Rr
;Yi:$:�.'•i::'..........
:::::::::...::.::i:<:�.�
J:�:s: o .•:t
c,::+'. `2
.+c+!;:,}.:, r,:
::o.:,.;;�.
�5:::: o::
'i';�`�.
a
;i.:;
�:�:tt�.�
•t.; �r.
;a>:�::o:
....»::i'ii:;';�:;v.
:::�»:o:
`;`i.:;:,:.,:i ,r.�::f5r.::+•'.:''iiiiE�iii7;:
K ��C,,�,: �2.... .'y';j::�i;>:;:
1 <:;;k- :>5;j::Sr�:.'+::
.:.,.•.;,�.v:•::... :::::::.:;:>•.:.v:
b .:::....::'::'•:':i::•i:•i:>:�:?:.:.. ..>'.:}:'.;...;F;.;3::;:?;'<±.}{•:!;: u ;j$+:.r.
�n. ..f.. ::•�v..:;" :ts.:.::.::• .::S��Si�[
•..r{::
•x•:x.
.t...
t.o.
..a.
:;.R,,:�:.?,:o
:+�i:i•:
rr.
•r.. �::::�:::�::::5.`•
:[:$5�':. �'i��;:;�. ...:,12_ y
•>f• 'tt>$c' ::;:?S'+'ii:.,
v.;;:;
ti
:::;r:z
r••
:#;S:t;i%:i?%'�::��:'r'•'•.3:::�r;i;:;': �:E::�ii°:>��;
x
•::or;;r».'•:;;:::;� r>::::y;::•:;: s
::rx•.
k:: �>::v:>;;;;.: :::.::..:::::.:::::;•:;.y........
i•'iC•iiiii::�il:i
ii>54...
xi>'
:iY
...��.�'.'�'.��`'.�i:�:i::::::G:>i.�:::t�• :'�i::::� �i:'::;�:;::;.: i::?i;';iC;?<:>
.r
;:�ib;':�: �i'ti'::"':i:=?:ii:ii�r i�:>:
:,:�;5 t
.e:.
+•a;:•:::cr:ss>:-.
%:%v;+:tii't:?�'b':�::: �p(��
a;:;iy:Y`,'
t�:::;%r:ry:�:'•.�:<;:::<.':::;p:
q ,%>;:;:�'ri:'
ax�::�:>:•:>;::::... ......��:::i:�::;;�•�:::::>'i:�i;y.:
...w .....:::::::::w::�:.:�:.��v:w:: v:�ir: �ii4:"
..l......�...... �::�S.;.T ..•Y..:
v. ::::.........n....
-::::.�:-:i.:
ii:v
::•Yr i.tvi�:�::�i:•i:ii :::::..i'�::::.
f r.:'�:••: .......�x?4eo�'.:.. y�::;:q
..::.�::.+:�:i.:.
�5i" •:S, N:>••:••:
.}e: v •::::v:"• y�+�n:!i:::4i:'i�� v:n�:.�......y... .....:��:%:1i::
K. �yp,� ,y .:':.::;ii:<`�i:
i:�•:(�:�:�: i::ti�:•:ii:;::
�:��%ii:>..i:^i.:. i
�%:ti{'{:i: ,'i,'e}:
y:::. �v::::�?•ir{�
...i'::}:: "{4i:
:�i' SS::i't�4i:..........r.r i��.F'• i
i i:. :}:i: ::i:: }i i}
n:Y
v'k... v ...........,.:rt............:..,l� ivi; .•.y:t.::::::•..... :.;:::.::::::V.�N:
n.. :::n :::::;:..i :�ii:i•i.w::v::::h:.i:r:.; ..A..�t':�:�i:�i:�:�
:i:%K
s: iiii' ya: :y;r.
7��. r�t�;•.:;•.:..
..�E.;::.::•;::•.�;:::•>;r:;r:t••r.•:s::i: <:?;:t:?"??".a:::�•:>::>::»:.;:
:::{v4:��:.:x:.!ii::;i.:i.:v:;..n
::+!}k.i'�':y.ti:v..> n::.::
�:"<:�i:. .;y
�K�'��•��
y .::;•:::�:>:+:v:::::.
�i;:?�:G::."
...........,.........t r A ...3:.:
r..:•. ^1�.2� 7J�°�'''"
:.�::•.�.�::•::•.:..v._..:.:..f:; ::::.kr;... .w:
�.4� ....�,�3,'.9'...
-::::::::::t•::::.�.
..........ut �::•r..::;<•sx:.::� a;:::•:: t::::;;:;•;:
....t�. ...t..........,,...
:r•:::
.................2�.�:::::.�::::.:
..........0 ::.:.:::n::�•::... .::�::::.�::::.:.....::..,•:::::.;.;»t•:i:•:::
.y:•%
:•;:l•:
;;::ic,
•::::.:::•::•.�r:..::
•:::::•::::<�:r;;:�:y:%'":':':;::;:v:r:;•::%`.;%:;:+.'•:::::.r>::t•':�:•i>;.;
:.:<ttr.�:v::�: »�:.:::c;
R
•::.•r�::�;:�:s:a:
o;�s. 5;:�;:+,
.c
v:::.�::.!i.:..:: ..:'i;�i:�:�:::::.�:::::::
v. .r.
n; �>i:
;i::t•:• o a.•: ........:................:...............:.:.::.::^--�•r;:::::�i:ii'•j•:�:v:::••::r
i
.r .....:1� ii:•T:'n:i...
��c� :n::....w+6'�'�:>::::::::::.+. .;�i:::.:::::b:•:�iiiii:?•ii:i;:::::�i:C�•ii::?::::tt+.t::`:X::;.::i:?o:i.�.•qv.:y;
.3:: ..,>+:i::�;:;;.::::o;;. w�b;<: ::•�:SsS;'•1•::� �':�::5:$
.....'Y++:.. {v::i•i ::i•i::r.: 'A:!::.:{•i:•S:Q::i: ��iY
y::
i .im:... v:
:..::i:
r p�,
4.�
y v., ti n::,::.:
•/r)..i:.;'.`...•. +c
,.�:r:. :.:i$:%� :4:...::•
w+:.:'•.
a::: '�:,>,;o...
��o• :..:3 �i..5..:.R•::.:.:•
w�.. :.?;q., n
.?eo:;.,•.S
:a. r :v:
..t:•.:::::::: •>'t '•'�:.i:.
...:::....:.r��.,,,::: ;•'r.',r
...:k�....
�:�;:i::`: i:i:
.k. .:.o�•.:k•::.•.wYt� -:.a,:.:.•:�G'��..`...t..:..::�...::.�::.. X t y
:::.x�:, v._: �-::::y::;>�......
,�:.::;:.;;.....:::.t•: ..:.,v::.,�. �::::.,r:::.>•;::.^•.::....,:
.,..t
f 'lh•::: v>
:;:<�:;:;�s.:.;
..n.. ....r... ....O.n....r............r. .r..................:M�.... 'Cs+.:.�:::.:
�.....v.r... .n ....�w.F.........
..M1.... .....u...� .n.��............n .....r: :..i:}?::j;:jO:C 'r:y
n.R.::.. y.i!ry.•.•:.+.v.v.xp.�::.�.�:; ................v............v...•.•:�:n..:...........
r..:..... ....i:r.r.r::�::
!!�iii:�::i'•::
I, :.y::::.:: 'x:::.i'li:::::'ii:L'.i:?F't'Fri%.'li::....n....l.v:'ii:::i':i:::::":fi:•'.�i:4ii:4::iiii::::
........:.:::•i:: v:
..5.:::...:::v.......
:......:..::::::::::v:::..:.i
II �':\":L.",: Z! 5 i:�iA
.Y
....Kq?.!!�!.'r'nLxY++�
v:.n•nwNV,n-.•.xvr.xv.-m+ri�.... .�,r,v±�,�,m,;a.....�.....�.xxn.r...,».,,;::�,s.;;,�.,,.x:a..��;........� ......iin'•iwiiYi;� ..vv».�
....;::r
..........�...�.....;,�.,w...
..,.:...»+�a+. ,�:•:•�-n:::::::::.•r>:•.•x;;::: t �j ..f..••.•':::�
s ..�::x..»^�e:<so�to:ax' •:::....c<... lr
„w.o....,
..f,..::•,:::•:::........::.,•:•:.r•:.�;•.::r::::.�::..•: �.'r,::;:r.w�.:
�:r>:.:•: .:.a.
::::::n �tvf ...v�:.�:r�:��..�...:.....::: n.... vt. w•..
�,�::n.. r....r. ..n ...r.
v�...n.v- ..F.•r....�.... v.�.:.:::�::r'......,
.r 1 p vi iin;
"".r /f ...L ...:::...r.�.. v:..:..y:':n4vnW.i'::�:•iSi'r'i�i:;w?i:::v:i:{•i:#dii::iii:i:;: :r%
....v :...y:•...:....... n.f........rv... kt �J... ..1..-.,r.. i'F>i:
.y. �.r... v �.nn. n �v.. .n. ..n4
..........n.. r....� {yF,•%ri•:'•iiYr:•i'Y tiSYW:i
r ..Y.. \N.� Y v......1�:i:::::: :yy..:. :v
Il i ..J.»� Y.K.t.K .:•.."Fiiii:.......... :.4�..vR. .r,•:.:..
q�;� {.:...r.4 v ...Swwi. r.{ .0 vv :v..... v :r;n:.� r. f...
v:.
::m:::?�::}:ri:: ::iiii........: :{4i:�::.%CCDi
�..R:,v. �>Y ::o�2a� �y�, ;,,•.kk� a\k •'i:::.• l.
�..,�..a,o:.. ,r .�c.......\„�.'. �a.,.k, �e ........,aoe�wwoea.....ne.......�ooa6ow�woowa........... oaaao,............
..t .a ....:.::::..................�000eoe000a�..x�.�.�......�..:.....�.�....,..............
�iS�;..w...�,sa�
Comparison: Four La�est Rental Properties
M
.:r ax� f.... .u� a f �+?i s C `n,.
:�:a .,...,�r. .n ....a ....�'rs. .aC:: 4. :..a �t .M .M�.. 9 -:y.;
..r. .,,...a.. ..T m ..i..�t .e. ...x s..._.: S. .z ..A v.,.>..
Fn .3 ,M '.'1'C �._.S.a 'k x
t...,:;r.> R, s„ ci, ,r.t�„n.:.a^'i�i ...........a"a.`7 ..8'.�S.r�..,.., 3
s r s �Y:,r .....,,�.�k��, i
N s a �x E� �o-
s
r w N <r�' 1'
51.VIANOR d :l Z,.4KE N(7RTH; M�'LROS C.�� TEST::
�'IR��'�TE'RISTICS�. ..GE'%1[TE'R Pd 1S/T'E, �Y.YJN''�:�I�LG'. TYY,�' r
PROPER�'3',CH a
a .a
-,�Q.< �a �7�_. ��,,��a.. ,�<.�.��r,<.��,>���,��.,.,:� ...,.,��o,� E.,�.��
s
����CONST�u�7E"D s i 968 1969 i 970 1970
F °¢�s
�i�' ad d�. 6'� F✓ y�,d 4 4' F� ro'� `xi
r BUILD�htGS� ��`�z 20 1 O 46 7
r �,o:�,�.� ,r,�,.s�;,,��_.
�rt� ilN�TS� �r;� 252 3 'I O 276 217
,.�.�....�_.,�r�
o w., y.,
F �.w
b,
s, �a, a.,. v,:_. w.
ts �.,.t�,. .x. ..�.e�1,�: S`,...r�. r, a.,. .e. f�
,a..�.,,,a, R ,s x .i. .n a ks.r.� .s r x �v ��a... �.�w.:
y tir x,. i
s; o .,,.,�3 .s. .r..3, u, k. n r�" ..�,z�
a� r-ra f y: s. a n. a,,.
a ..�c�F. AN�R l, `YY 15f. K' ,l �014T ,H. NT LROSE� +GATES..,
ROP RTY,S�TI4F.FING G�'/YT�R�POt/�T�"�E;� �IN,1�A�fL�' 1Y� ,LA
P. E u .7 t�' ,h
5 ,f. a .,y c
.ti�..�c .,.,x� .,r�+ ��,r� ^s.�.l.. ,,,.�...a. v a'�,_.. m ...;�r. .M k�, �v��s�.�� :aa,�..�� ��e�..b:?a�h. n„ s.�;��.� ,�;E� �r�. �.,,,3� ��..;�m�,.� <,�«fi:.. „<�on �,.x,. ��.�xr c�
r�" :ra: i s rs'�. 's�' ��.I .n__
�MA�l1/tI GER t I 1 PT I 1 FT I 'I FT I '1 FT
.�.,v� �,�x�
1 4// r+ ;�i n PT FT
�as g r iL:��J C l/Y .{�T��V��f�'s� R{ O !r`�
s
_t t, s��ti. „�s�� r.n
r E a'�,�5 v,���� e��, y
�u N M.�iNT�'hr�tyc,�'���� 4 �r 3 �r I 1 PT 2 Fr 3 �r
:,.s.,. a..,�E ...a.ro y F� .3£u� „a,.+ �.d e ...,�-i' h. ..'�'�x �3;s
�E CARET�KLR`� 1 'I 20 7
�__�.�..x.�.
O '1 FT (PAINTER) 1 PT (SOCIAL DIR.) O
T OT/`�'�R
P.;:.� ...,.b��`.,���..�t as d:�.�. ��s>�..�.,r�,.�- y'
°'j y ToT�tL� 5 8 i 4 6.5
f �✓3.� �3..
.b'S`t r l S S.a' �3 'f.k+n, P' ,e^ ^4`C` I
ST�IFF'PER�UNIT� 1 O.O i 9 0.025 0.050 0.029
v� N �u
w k,. 1.6 w
wH r k �k,
,...�..,t�a.t.._��`?.,....,. �a�. ,�e a:�.r.� ..rut<,.
a ..,:e� r z .,^'o r .,,,x,,
a 4 �s
.z��u• a F
x �.0 l�l R !V'TE T� ..�lY.�� S. �iYdR�, �'1� K�'��RT, EL1405�'G�T S�-
C.4L�S. FOR S.+E�RYlGE �CFSJ E �"L�'' �l°Ol y KE'
u y ,E
v,.,
.,'�2. .,ur �.'.�...�r�,.�:v. .�.�E. �.:.�:n���..s�s.�.�.R. a,> �u.�.,,�.a� c���; I.
..�..,r,. ,�.,,...��.�..�..�v...�e.,..�,s��'. .�r..�,.,..� ..��.F. ss.��,.....s
s;�; s.
t`� w.�`��A���.* 872 I 402 I 161 I 'I 09
E��r��' 654 560 129 'I37
1 .�.:��°�ti�.
:'S���� '"yHK�, q bs� 3'�.k a� F �abr�....r� 3r z�`
����.s'^ �:�,���QO�� �..`..��..�����,�..�y�. 544 6'IS 137 i 1O
���200...r z 683 577 1 i 6 i 36
.,�,'`.'s ..a y.�`., ..�..;�.,,J..�: ��.�s.��„��,..
k� y E s
�r� ��0�6��� 739 �27 '136 '16 i
r:�
�5>�YEA��A,��.� ��E 698 537 136 13 i
�2007: u�nr��� MARCHI� 202 180 43 42
����r ���as �f������o�.e,..,�:
��`007��P,RO�l,�E'CT:E� 808 720 'I�72 168
�a���a s��� ta�...�.�a,,,
Comparison: Four La yest Rental Properties
w, ,�r F F y
y a v w
R E� r.�
u as��,� a .r 9
e.s �s e, 4
z r.... i k <F,F,,, n s,� .1 .t s ..�v, y.�,
3 .�......,c. �,,:r.w. .rrw K� e. fi'�, A „3� �i€�.�., ,,i.
i t�.,,-�.. Y� �.�r :.'.�t F,. y a �:i''? :'rs� r�;
tk....., �a.� n,.w: n .a7' m,
'���s „�',g F s S r,� T�..... e
y F �rc� :��r �No ,..MEL�zas� �A��s
a..��� CFSi P.ER�U .IT �C 7�IT�' I�Q�NT� �JJJT N A R x
a� �,1. w �x .r„ ;s�. �p:,r���d*.�-�I>�,.�'"����F�"e.r....��r,��i,',,.I�.�� .?�u.f..�:� 5.
..,��a. .....e.<� �r, .e, :�d�`�ir��s�: s.�v���a.,,a,�,m �,�'.r+�,.. :.aa�,..+�'.'��..�,,� ��.,�cY�t�tr��s�.�i��.F.��. �±ra€, z��P�.
��t� ��0 3.46 '1.30 0.58 0.50
����t �wf.
���20�0��1 2.60 1.8 i 0.47 0.63
t�� .„;x� .�`.�,��u..�«� w�c#'�^� t�s.�.:r,���o�.,
����004�4� 3� 2. i 6 i .9g o.so o.s i
�g
"S x �.i3�t x r� r^
ZOO�� �������I 2.71 I i .86 I 0.42 0.63
�?s �w
1
a y a 2.93 1.70 0.49 0.74
5��'E.4�R,A'i�,E,R.�A��E��¢`�` y:�� 2.77 1.73 0.49 0.60
,���..���v��.�.�..��.��.��,n,�'r�Y.,�, .fi a��
�200� �✓Ai�°�Mixc`�3��� 0.80 0.58 0.15 O. i 9
�u� 5�"�,', ��3,� .�r..�' �r'�', �n,.m�,e�'.��ze
y ������;200�� Pr�o.iE �crED����� ��II 3.20 2.30 0.60 I 0.77
z ,.E
I
u
,N a,. q
Y h y �.z.,. r a
t ..�f ..s'�., ..,�x�.�.�... :��i...> .rz= ��'i�us� �,��.K„�:`�,.:�'. a�:�.��. ...�....t.�.. $1�'.F:s..d. ,._�.w�.�.e, �z;tt�#xa.��¢,...
s z _.�q �z s ::rs� :;4.. �x� u� r
s �:r�. t�� ,a'�� a :»i
i� L x�,- E�: s"w� x s e
ra, `e
au r x:� a
3 F.. 1 T 9�L:,� `�i'� A1�0 .1�/ E; .�R J'al �.E'LROSE G:4TES-:;
.�R!/�/NAL.lNClDEN�'S.(vl� C.� T�'f�/� ..YY1�. X`r
.,..�,.�]I, .s.:.n... .a�e .�;��:��««��*..��::�,5:.s�:l�?.��,a•�'�� ..�.-.��.�%?�.,.�..�.:r„€�w.�,���Im��:::,z�. ,..m�xn:.E::...�..�-rr��.
...ro'�£�.a..� ....�`+��,�z w�d'' �.��a�„� ...�.a,�� ,..st':� .,��....Mta _.x
�Z005p�`� 87 75 I i 8 I i 9
s-�.���,.t v
�s` �Y w.�z, ^p� ��S s �'i,� rr�r t '�''�y a���-�`
��2�006� h��`� 70 5 i 23 'I 9
���.e..�.� �a��.���� d,����� fr�,�,�����.
�����,2���''�E',�I� 79 63 2 i 19
���h
r
���;�����ZOO��.,����;�a���� 3� s 3� i s s
o- a r�� ���ss�� �Y�+�u
f f 3 y w w"k."z�`' a Y .F
�k�. 2'�OO����PRO�EG,T�E'�-�.� i 36 60 I 20 i 6
r q
r u. F ,�y r. u
s,�,a^_ €x.,'r. r v y r..,. ��t iz, a ti 3�3,a.. a.
v s a ��3 Y., ..,r x ..�u e„�� �r :x
x�:• ,x„ b.a, :.:3�`�' <.,,�t..� ,a.?:; .s�. ;�..'�.x,� nc �y g
3 }�4
u'k s�
.,5�...
4
a ,y f.
.y h y a au ,,e O'�
E'1'���0 NT IN`� K'Lc� 1 NAiSl'O ��TYY�N..LAK�`�1 �(O Tf� �E'L�R SL" EI?"E'
E... GI PE'R:. Ll�Vt7". E'
N.
x
e� s. x .,�a� .a F .K>„ �a�. ..r�.' x,.....:,,'�z.,a.c..�,� -ba..�:�: t�� ,,.Ir,,..r, .,�,'v-�. >z�.�.�.. ...�t,. ...:�s,�ea^y°"5` �,�._z. a�..z. .;sr�� ...:aa»r,�.. ,�,�,5��'��<
y�s �,r...,,.., s vx r ,:a...��z �c,'".�r,.,,_ �s„ .�.�.n��..�;_.__ s. �a z .se�..,�° .�,��.e. v...a.:.��
a�++G t�,` ..r� aa.�r '���`"`t,��"�r°+',�`��
't ��,���k s�� ��.�Ob��,� 0.34 I 0.24 0.06 I 0.08
w��.� �.���.�i,+�,+��c�?%� n�� �.r.���'...,� �s��;�ixsu�?�
f j H q �p £C^
F���oo`�� 0.2� o. i s o.o$ o:os
2-��.,��'�'� ..�����»'.a.�`>L'_�`.a�"�c�,+��.��-.- r ..��t. cxr„w.��;f��`�`'
�x' ��s� ��s �`c�� `s
�`'�f� �'�;2��`YE�tR�.� �E'�� ����w�` 0.31 0.20 0.07 0.08
b ,g� .��..�,�����°,.p�.
�p sr �1r u�v�
��"k� ���i►iAR�'� z. ��`�����,��f� 0.1.34 0.048 O.O i S O.O i S
1����' ����ooy���RO
0.53 O. 'I 9 0.07 0.07
i
Comparison: Four L�est Rental Properties
a :L
,.�r.:. asi-_
��.x .:s.: z i .,:t.. M,.:. a:�. z.,��.
t.x .._r. a^. c. ..z,, K :.:�r�� t a
x. .3 ..r,v.....,�. ....s. x. „....z�� .4'.,,.�..a ,.rr�i,'
�'.s v ,�y..r� ��.3_,:.;. a,,.,� �r, ,.y,�� „5�?...�..�r,.,. h�s: Y" 4 ..-1 .a.. :i
f r �,��z r "m:. .r v.
,,,3 n,
:.r�' ai >F r a, L;
:.F e .'t
k w.. N�� x�s hroR T'��.h►:,L.AxE: Nor��'t� �E�t�o F_G s�
CQDE' COMPLI�NCE".ORDL�'RS �G�EI�IT,E`R.P..�IISi�',L�' T��YI �[T
n s
3 K, �.x .e F...�. e..� r. �..'r.
:,.,�i n
i` k +5% �:Y i sa�.'. y
�r.� �4'�����., mt._, r:;;3 „r, ,sn..��- w. .�..:i.;. .4 z r, ,a„��,.a, ���:n,.'�s.:, sa....�� &A�,.��., r,,., �.>�,..v.� fi,�...3� .i:.. w r a S �.i _r,�, 4 .d�.�s s�� ...,.a" <„F
Z� 2002 ��h y ��II 1306 29
r
�,�F
`s�rT� 3i t W t�3' p Y. ,,,2 c3 y4 z.. p
X 1.,�� 5�Y ����OO�� ^3 J `zT�4 V
��s.,a�'�"a,, ,�,a,.�"�.��',�.�:., a%„�. z...'�a,
,,....�r
fi 4� �3 �;�`.3,' 13 4
a 200,� s 35 59 45
�-i a a'� H- a� r
�2006`�� 49 'I
�x,...
M k `,2007 132 'I i 'I 2 '154
I
,..�.>m,�., a. .�k�.
i
.a
i r::v^ a F
r.,- t 2"...
W:..... �z R E ,a �...s.. ;,e ,�.`i �t'�
.u�:..... ,_..x .,µr. �a" .,..3. �t „�.�a�...�3_.. �f� ,,.x,.. �d �''�.z., r�«?;�.... .,a°� ...a,.,
x �'X..
,,F r a :a.-
c. d.: `u
z
�-.'Lr bs... z Z x,
3 r �3
L�LK�S IVI�.AhT014.. !N'��.AffE �TOR7"H LE' .05 �G°�
M NAG.EM N_T� RA'CTIGES_, ��'NTL�'� hO �iT t!Y.N R Lc',,. A�'ES.,
A E P s M z
y r�Y .E
f
€n,,.�. ...,�.r ...x�,.taa�^.,�.:1'��..,..�,z� .�.,�.k�*_eE.:,....�». ..m�,�...,�M+...�.,,,...: s� z�,,.., y�.,,:.
.m.r,.x.:�.. �.,_...._n °a._< ,�x..,n�,s «..��.�'���a,� �^.....o n..,:.�..��, �,.P..
�r�� d rr z r� e
���LE'.4SE�DURATI01�1�����`�.� .;II 'I 2 MONTH I 6 OR 1 2 MONTH I 1 2 MONTH I 'I 2 MONTH
��CRIML�'y�DRUCrFREE`�IDE'N�7Ul�J� YES YES YES YES
N 3�< 3�
Y�RITTE'N RENTAL CR/TERlA YES YES YES YES
�t.. r
r,� s r�'t s f 2
r��� ���`/�lRO PAR��SCRE'E�/�fI�G�� SAFE RENT RENTAL RESEARCH RENTAL RESEARCH SAFE RENT
f ���re t� ���r
4 ��REFE'RENCES= WTERNAL WTERNAL RENTAL RESEARCH SAFE RENT
Z L��P,GOY/�fE'N, I
INTERNAL INTERNAL RENTAL RESEARCH SAPE RENT
r r ��tr �r
RE�lDE'N���� INTERNAL. INTERNAL RENTAL RESEARCH SAFE RENT I
�x.�
��GRIM/NAbL�BACKGRCSUND��"� ��M SAFE RENT RENTAL RESEARCH RENTAL RESEARCH SAFE RENT
.���'���MlNIMU1I1 GR�'D�l��SCORE'� ���y 3 550 (FLEXIBLE) FLEXIBLE FLEXIBLE
�x.
s� f v� a 9��
�,ECURlT�D�'POSI4T���a�����"`��� $300.00 $500.00 $4�50.00 'I MONTH'S RENT
a
„t. z y
,s,�,
s x, z
d....,M �s a:.. r r. x .v a
�r .F� fi= o.. 3 y ..uu- r�. ::s. F, W,,... ��f
F.,'�_ ,�4�... x� .,,,a?�: r �;t_.. aau. �sF�'° ..a� �2�Y��..
o �s Y v�.,.;z r,� i v�
r sx>;: ,a. f v �s r :r-
�s,: „k .�Fs'.., 2� r ;.�f ,c.a v �:n.n
_.n, c
BROQK G R� M r G� �T .:L� r ,I KE�. :�1S�O /5� 1'�f :O
LYN� ENT"E .r� ,R .;�x Fr ,E.��P E`� ...TI�Y T�'J�`„ L .E`,N R ,K ,M. f'LI405.Lc�C�s��E'S,,<:
3h
�..r a r
.....�.�r, ...5: �`u..aF> .i..i'�MNE,A2. ��..ee.Y6�. �_.....Ymw`e .�za.0!#'Yi.%?v�mA u.��1l.�c+3��RE� 4�S„�.�i.e�..�,`.F&}X'NI. .�..f,�"s15..��.�.i r...l�..�'.�.;5�+..��N� .J.e.n....�`L f�&�l4iu"i1a a..mrA1a`ax^�k` .A4�s�mer,,.� I"."o.„..'+.'�.'.,. ,Yn
s"� 13t'��' Y�g' aF z?�+"`�`" a
���._,����.R���e���..,��M YES I YES I YES I YES
���OI�fC�OING�PAR�I"IGiPATIOJ1� NO I NO I NO I YES
.>..�ae� �ri. �a�.`�u3s�t ��,.�a�.,�,� N s�u �t .+v�a�e�
Comparison: Four La �+est Rental Properties
�y.�
�5
w .a r z
q n k
.r. �.r> r s ,,,m r.:.w:� ��..,:d' ,,.r x �t, a. ,a� ..��.�'v:m. �t:.. �at x. �s �«s. g��„4 ,�:ss. I:� 3.,
�Z� �..:n,.,. y :r ;ge F. 5 ::...�'s�" s :e.:�
.r x��'�
��?a ;�,x z.��` r°� rr a,. .r.�, a n a.: ,3�. :t.
.Cl� ./HOUS NG� .:.0 N� �Ff�0I1Y�" �'il.til. K�� �INOR LIYF; .KE:�V�R�'H�. .,..1�'EL .OS;�' G, �TES:';
.r rCR/ME FI4E'.E' M 7' E �Y
,s� .,u
....s .�..�,.,...�����.a.�r�.:�..� ���������„�,�������x���. z�,.�,�,���,,..�, �,.,��,..��p��..l�_ f,,.,�.�:.� ��.,.�.,.4.,.m��'....�M,.r�,. ..s�,�_�. v,,.
,���CER�TIFICA7'IO/5C} ��N��R �����I NO I NO NO I NO
o .e w
<-m:.
x U.
,.3 s �e���g„s. x €3 a..���, r y ,n, �e� ��rc�z «s
,c,s.; �i,
s#'�. *';a:
,rs. 3�
s, o
�,;1 ��t w e s>�• i
u a,�
M�.? I R
..1... `V
s> 2 �r,.3
1�i ;s ;M,��� f�° rf �Yo RosE
:�:CPTED w '�El'�TE'R PlO" L�'� ,M. E 7 YY LA E. MEL ,?[�E�'
t:
s� :�s �x
<�r:... x.� �a:Z�,.,...W.,_, r.. ..,.,,n. r�.<r l a ��ra.a�:as5�,� :.+�.�a.�xs�. �r��-�*�.: a.�-=.fiss�a�s��Y S�:P�I':� s ..:.;.,,*l�a.r�^ha.%,�;: �cs:..a�c:?z, �k.:��.z�.���:p: I .�.�»:a��r. ,�.w�.�s-:a.�xs..�,�'
...»...._..w�., .z...,......
..-,ur«ae�s��s.��� I 1
t�LOGKS`ANlJ RELr�€T�D�"� �����,II NO I NO I YES I NO
M,?I��KII�(,C'��S NO YES YES YES
n YES YES YES YES
r a s ���A�� ..�.t �k�� �a�'r 3;�
y �l�INDSCAP/NG���� kI YES I YES I YES I YES
h.rs
::.r:t >.,,r. �a .;:y .,M.; ;ac
a r �.3 k, e 'F.'§�£.�.... Y
:.-,dfi. T "3...,.... ��'.F€ar5 �u':�. .u.� �a 1 .a� �a 2�.'. .:i4"� .Fs «ki '4" "'3k ':Y'. i" 4. gf e *t F.�," P t1 'D J
�.:wM i..<<,. Y£ r,. .'v": d, ..,Yf n _.....',a^`3c ..,,.ak.. .N;�<... ...�.4�i a� ..d,.�e"��A� ..-,M�-...,.Y..�:.
.�z A�, fi p .�r.. t
�r ?e., 1 rkK s
x
�r�: a
ww.�
-r, .�t r� .'t
z k.a �t .^�,J„ ,r'. a
,�r: as, v �;v� .,v ,�i`�; a
f KC 1? �T -77�W�'Il�`- K �4NO,R �:YKI O ROS Gs
GR NfE:YYAT .fl ro C�NTE'R ,L.� E' a T� 1'� KEhI l� ME'L E.. TL'S.
r 4 w
�w t r� �u �x �y�
'�..R.. w.��F.r�. ,.r_.,.. .,:�-o-",«,,,a:�•,'.;�.,.K... :.::x an,ax'.,a..r���k�l�w.��.€���m�,.,wT, .�.��5�....,.I,^'13 �,.,w i
r �,.�PARTIf`!f'A%5/T����.�� g YES NO YES NO I I
,r r. 4�,. ;�-:II I I I
a a x r
H. a .,,x
r,... .*'s ,�7... ..,W�,. x.
,....v. r n. ,..�_.F�� r. w P'.? ,,r _�.Y, t>.: `u .s...�- �.,.f .,�+,;:.3
v'" __.,.r a z. ,r�.;.�',»u. >_i�" �a ..o, ,.�¢�w �a ,r,°�.„x,��,. ,.�e'-�.#w.�. 4. a..�z*i�, r,=',c�.:'.: n�.,..;,
�i ksn..,:. w z
�rx b r.
g :a t' r,� ro` x �x�
t'
'SS .Cl:4-7�LCD� PC7G/"C COS�'3 C E'F�`,' ,O 1S�T i��, l �Al��"S� �15`�"OR .//�LAIfE �R EL ,ROS G'"
A o �.k r� c° F Es�
=73
MF. .r ,�Isi� N..v� .ry.
p::�. a,..�r;:<. 4�:;r: .3.z�, w`re,..:,.� �er.:4� ex,�.,tR�,�.�k�.>, �.2 3II�.,�„f�^s.��. a��m�3�s�,�'s: I a`.�...: r .s�F..,: w. �,.�.v. *�'�x :k'.:�^�..�:.r.. .,,I.: a. .:w.ft, .�.,.:�a-��a....+, z�.. �.��,.,,fi..+�.�i ��:a.' �»I'+,o-w�'.:r_ s a..#„d ,s .u;_.,.k���
5��'E�iRtiY'E'RA�E' G�"� ��Y- 698 537 'I 36 131 I
�����,���NITt.rIL`Pai�/C��R�E'�,i,?ONS���� 528 HOURS 406 HOURS 'I 03 HOURS 1 00 HOURS i
;.�i'�'�.�' fr 3w da j:. �.,r» x �§t I
�E; OFFIGE"R$ �i'EP�„RE�SE"�NT�� .44 OFFICERS .3� OFFICERS .09 OFFICERS .09 OFFICERS
I
i
City of Brooklyn �nter
All Calls for Police/Medical/Fire Service
Rental Property (more than four units)
2004
Total of CFS
Ja�z Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec CFS Units Per Unit
Basswood Apartments 0( 1 1 1 1 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 4 11 0.36
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 21 0.00
�Brookdale Manor I
Brookdale Towers 2 2 6 0 S 7 5 5 2 5 6 4 49 50 0.98
Brookhaven Apartments 2 3 7 3 6 12 2 5 1 1 3 5 50 54 0.93
Brookside Manor Apartinents 7 11 11 8 11 12 10 7 7 14 10 10 118 90 1.31
Carrington Drive Apartments I 8 7 10 9 13 10 16 5 7 8 12 10 115 128 0.90
Earle Brown Terrace 23 8 9 8 9 11 8 3 4 2 7 11 103 140 0.74
Eaxle Brown Farm Apartments 4 7 6 11 8 9 9 3 11 8 9 3 88 120 0.73
Emerson Chalet 9 5 2 9 4 6 1 1 0 0 1 0 38 18 2.11
Evergreen Park Manor 9 13 5 5 14 11 8 7 7 13 16 9 117 80 1.46
Ewing Square Townhouses 8 4 9 7 2 4 6 8 7 2 4 9 70 23 3.04 I
Garden City Court 10 19 9 13 17 31 13 18 8 7 6 2 153 72 2.13
Georgetown Park Townhouses 12 12 17 13 24 14 18 14 8 23 12 11 178 92 1.93
Humboldt Courts 3 5 7 5 7 4 11 0 0 0 7 7 56 36 1.56
Humboldt Square Apartments 0 0 0 0 0 2 2 0 0 0 2 2 8 �.18 0.44 I
Lake Shore Apartments 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 6 0.00
Maranatha Place f 6 4� 3 3 2 6 3 1 0 0 0 0 28 65 0.43
Marvin Gardens 3 3 4 4 3 6 3 5 0 0 0 0 31 52 0.60
Melrose Gates 8 5 13 6 5 12 15 6 11 12 10 7 110 217 0.51
River Glen 13 12 17 17 16 14 25 16 1 20 24 19 194 128 1.52
Riverwood Apartinents 13 15 13 16 11 9 14 11 11 9 5 10 137 84 1.63
Shingle Creelc Tower 12 3 10 6I 3 I 8 g 6I 9 I 6 9 g gg 122 �•�2
Sominerset Apartments 10 9 5 10 10 8 9 5 1 6 2 1 76 36 2.11
Sterling Square Apartments 17 15 15 22 17 20 19 23 24 18 14 13 217 54 4.02
Centrepointe Aparhnents 5 8 44 3 9 49 43 42 62 48 34 31 3 8 5 6 544 252 2.16
Total of ':'FS
Jan Feb Mar Apr Ma Ju�z Jul Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec CFS Units ��r Unit
The Crossings at Brookwood 5 2 3 1 5 3 3 13 2 3 4 3 47 138 0.34
The Lilacs 2 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 22 0.23
The Pines of Brooklyn Center 27 14 18 16 12 12 23 20 22 20 13 21 218 102 2.14
Twin Lake Manor 39 33 46� 54� 37� 50� 69� 58� 49� 64� 52� 67� 618 310 1.99
Twin Lake North Apartments 5 7 1 l 18 11 12 12 16 12 17 9 7� 137 276 0.50
UnityPlace 12 8 21� 19� 19� 17� 20� 14� 14� 8� 10� 14� 176 112 1.57
Victoria Townhouses 7 6 8 6 10 10 21 8 8 16 4 8 112 48 2.33
Willow Lane Apartments 6 3 9 10 3 1( 5 5 1 2 4 8� 57 58 0.98
3401, 3413 47 1 2( 1� 0� 0� 0� 3� 2� 1� 2� 0� 0� 12 22 0.55
3501 47 0 0 0� 0� 0� 0� 1 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 1 11 0.09
3513 47 0 1 1� 0� 0� l� l� l� 0� 3� 1� 2� ll 11 1.00
3601 47 7 5 5� 0� 1 1 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 19 11 1.73
361347 0 0 0� 0� 3� l� 3� l� l� 3� 1� 3� 3 11 0.27
3701 47 2 o 2� o� 1 o� o� 2� o� 1 o� o� s ii 0.�3
3713 47 0 0 0� 0� 0� 2� 1 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 3 ll 0.27
3725 47 0 0 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0 11 0.00
4819 Azelia 0 0 1 1 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 2 12 0.17
6101 Beard 11 10 4� 3� 11� 4� 1� 3� 8� 1� 1� 4� 61 24 2.54
6331, 6401, 6425 Beard 3 5 2� 4� 3� 6� 6� 0� 0� 0� 0� 3� 32 36 0.89
6037BB 0 2 1� l� l� 0� 1� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 6 11 0.55
7018BB 0 1 1� 2� 1� 5� 1� 1� 1� 0� 1� 0� 14 8 1.75
5240Drew 8 9 13� 14� 6� 3� 6� 9� 4� 4� 1� 4� 81 10 8.10
5301 Dupont 6 2 l� 3� 5� 1� 1� 0� 0� 1� 0� 0� 20 6 3.33
4715 France o o o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o s o.00
5500 Bryant Avenue N 1 0 2 0 2 1( 0 0 0 0 0 0 6 8 0.75
5843 Fremont 1 0 2� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 3 7 0.43
7230,7250WRR 0 4 3� 3� 3� l� 7� l� 2� l� 5� 0� 30 8 3.75
7240 WRR 0 0 1� l� 0� 0� 0� l� 0� 0� 1� 1� 5 7 0.71
5207Xerxes 1 0 0 0 0 1� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 2 12 0.17
5209 Xerxes 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 3 3 1 0 10 12 0.83
5211 Xen�es 1 0 0� 0� 0� 2� 2� 1 1 2� 2� 4� 15 12 1.25
Total CFS Rental (more than four units) 383 321 375 382 366 392 455 354 282 336 307 346 4286 3,312 1.29
T _,F
City of Brooklyn �nter
All Calls for Police/Medical/Fire Service
Rental Property (more than four units)
2005
Total of CFS
Ja�i Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec CFS Units Per U�zit
Basswood Apartinents 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0� 0 0 0 0 11 0.00
Brookdale Manor 0 0( 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 21 0.00
Broolcdale Towers 2 7 8, 8� 3 S 6 1 3 6 4 8 61 50 1.22
Brookhaven Apartments 5 4 4 5 10 4 3 6 7 0 3 9� 60 54 1.11
Brookside Manor Apartments 5 12 7 8 5 9( 9 5 6 12 6 8 92 90 1.02
Carrington Drive Apartments 7 11 17 15 11 16 12 11 9 12 7 5 133 128 1.04
Earle Brown Terrace 3 3 5 12 11 11 19 12 18 14 10 22 140 140 1.00
Earle Brown Fann Apartments I 3 5 7 4 7 4 4 3 5 7 9 13 71 120 0.59
r t-
4 0 4r' 18
a et 3, 0' 7 T C 5 5 1 2 28
Emers onCh 1 3�...� ,._,3a..��. x..
_.'v, R ,.e .eo i!.�.�..w �3L�..�. t>.x„� -+.s�. .:a_ �3 ..�,��z
Evergreen Park Manor 11 19 11 11 9 10 7 17 18 17 17 9 156 80 1.95
r ����3,,„
3 S Q 5,��� 8 7 7 9 5�7 ;23 2 48�
Ewing S.quare Townhouses .s:. 3 ,r r
Garden City Court 5 7 4 1 3 5 6 7 4 4 3 4 53 72 0.74
Georgetovv�z Park Townhouses 13 25 11 J 14 20 20 9 16 16 7I 7 8 166 92 1.80
Humboldt Courts 4 I 3 I 4 5 6 8 7 8 5 2 1 0 53 36 1.47
Humboldt Square Apartments 1 2 1 2 0 3 0 2 0 4 2 0 17 18 0.94 I
Lake Shore Apartments o o o o o o o o o� o o o o 6 o.00
Maranatha Place 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 65 0.03
Mas vin Gardens 1 0 0 0 0 0 4 7 4 4 2 2 24 52 0.46
Melrose Gates 5� 12 19 8� 12 11 11 13 13 17 9 6 136 217 0.63
River Glen 21 20 21 27 18 22 25 18 24 18 16 31 261 128 2.04
Riverwood Apartments 4 1 2 7 4 3 6 12 13 6 12 8 10 115 84 1.37
s
ar...-: ..:Y v.1.,
u���. �a a .'�'i. a.s;. ..y.,
...�t. I ...9 d.c. e a a ..f v� i�
a y:... a�. -r„ ,..z�.:.,:;., ..,v_.W._
_,z� z..,. r ..w ,�.r r.
r .a+s I �a .....x ,w... s
h,.r v�=F .F t �r ,.....>L ....;r„
3�, 3 ,u. 5 n'3
:::l�i' tr�e' '�,m .�.L,.: 5 .-r `F'
.z. r j 1 I �'ar::
S.x, 1 5 3 _10 ..7 11 r11 _l .112 �8 1.1�.
Vaew Polnte. at Shin le, �reek: 6. �0 w.
a va,��..:.av..v, ..o.. ,.vs... �i,�`^_,.c4.�I.c� ,...s..b,_IT.�n;� I.:�..�a.i.1..,1�i..�,..,...w.. �.�1 Fl..,,......,.,s. ,..�o'...... ,I.� ..sl ..s':> .,.i:,�.. ..�.nvc.. ro....-.e.... ...a.,.,....
.n.. l I. a �s I ..k s ':a�
Sommerset Apartments 5 8 4 5 3 3 8 11 7 6 8 3 71 36 1.97
Sterling Square Apartments 23 12 25 30 14 18 37 20 18 35 24 16 272 54 5.04
v: F:,
,a.....; fi �4t :F.0 ....n. e �!Y 2}a' �s 1 x x„3L
.A_ u.'��
r r 3 �i i,�, ..1' i ..s r
entr.e o nte a me 3 4�.: 46 �:8 59 N93 7 �0 _:�t� �6 �683 2�� .s. 2:7�.
C i A rt nts 9 x 9
p,.. .0 s .,.�d �.I �.I :I I v,,�,l ..1 7.. I I �,r I.�. I ,r„ I I�, I .I sl r)
Total of `;FS
Dec CFS U11ltS �r U�iit
The Crossings at Brookwood 5 6 7 7 5 4 5 7 5 4 5 4 64 138 0.46
�Tl�e Lilacs o o o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o I 22 o.00
The Pines of Brooklyn Center 13 13 17 17 14 18 10 14 14 8 14 9 161 102 1.58
Twin Lake Manor 59 49 61 47 54 41 44 48 46 43 31 54 577 310 1.86
Twin Lake North Apartments I 9 I 9 7 8 12 12 11 17 10 7 5 9 116 276 0.42
Unity Place 19 10 21 17 23 9 21 20 22 16 5 12 195 112 1.74
V ictoria Townhouses 3 4 9 7 6 8 8 6 3 14 8 9 85 48 1.77
Willow Lane Apartments 2 3 6 4 6 0 3 2 4 5 9 3 47 58 0.81
3401, 3413 47 1 0 3� 1! 1� 3� 0� 0� 1� 3� 0� 2� 15 22 0.68
3501 47 0 0 0� 0� 1 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 1 11 0.09
3513 47 0 2� 3� 0� 0� 3� 4� l� l+ 1� 0� 1� 16 11 1.45
3601 47 0 0 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0 11 0.00
3613 47 4 2 4� 6� 3� 3� 4� 0� 3� 3� 2� l� 3 11 0.27
3701 47 2 2� 3� 3� 0� 4� 3� 4� 0� l� 1� l� 24 11 2.18
3713 47 0 0 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0 11 0.00
4819 Azelia 0 0 1 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 1 12 0.08
6101 Beard 2 5 4� 3� 1� 6� 5� 7� 4� 7� 3� 5� 52 24 2.17
6331, 6401, 6425 Beard 0 1 0� 4� 9� 3� 3� 6� 5� 9� 9� 0� 49 36 1.36
60�� BB o o o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o) o� o 11 o.00
7018BB 1 0 0� 0� 4� 4� 6� 3� 0� 1� 1� 0� 20 8 2.50
5240 Drew Rental license provisional 5 1 0 2 0 2 7 2 2 6 9 3 39 10 3.90
5301 Dupont 2 1 0� 0� 0� 1 1 0� 1 0� l 0� 7 6 1.17
4715France o o o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o s o.00
5500 Bryant Avenue N o o o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o s o.00
5843 Fremorit 0 0 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0 7 0.00
7230, 7250 WRR 1 1 0� 4� 2� 1� 0� 1� 1� 3� 3� 1� 18 8 2.25
7240 WRR 0 5 0� 0� l� 2� 1� 0� 0� l� 2� 1� 13 7 1.86
5207 Xences o o o o o o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o i2 o.00
5209 Xerxes 2 1 2 4 2 1 3 2 2 1 2 3 25 12 2.08
5211 Xe�es 0 4 1� 0� 1� l� 0� 0' 1� 1� l� 0� 10 12 0.83
Total CFS Rental (mare than four units) 299 329 374 361 344 381 400 418 385 403 317 335 4314 3,277 1.32
i
__r
Cit of Brookl n �nter
Y Y
All Calls for Police/MedicaUFire Service
Rental Property (more than four units)
2006
Total of CFS
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Ju�z Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec CFS U�zits Per U�zit
Basswood Apartments 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 11 0.00
Brookdale Manor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 21 0.00
Brookdale Towers I 4 I 2 4 3 6 6 4 9 3 0 48 50 0.96
Brookhaven Apartments 4 6 7 1 15 12 9 6 4 4 7 8 83 54 1.54
Brookside Manor Apartments 8 9 5 15 9 5 7 11 16 10 11 8 ll4 90 1.27
Carrington Drive Apartments 6 11 29 11 9I 5 I 8 18 25 1 Z 12 20 166 128 1.30
Earle Brown Terrace 9 8 9 19 15 12 10 19 15 10 13 14 153 140 1.09
Earle Brown Farm Apart�nents 7 11 12 11 8 10 7 21 8 15 11 5 126 120 1.Q5
��W,
ii �,e r �I J4 r ,3 1 Z J
�me�souC�alet ..�I� :I ,���I ���I��,�,���I ��I ,�:,,.�?I �I �sl. ��I ,F 31�.. ���1� I I.,.,
Ever reen Park Manor 10 15 15 10 11 13 9 16 13 11 15 20 158 80 1.98
g
y �a 3�� ,F a.i
Ewing.Square Townhouses x ..I �:'I �D� ;��,..�3� ���,:5�,, 3� ..-�2� ,��'.x �.�..r�: �1. 6�,.. .,23 2,74
..g �;.�g
Garden City Court 0 4 6 5 3 9 5 4 1 3 I 1 I 1 42 72 0.58
Georgetown Park Townhouses 12 6 8 8 7I 13 25 25 16 21 11 16 168 92 1.83
Hulnboldt Courts 0 1 0 0 0 2I 4I 6I 2 5 6 33 36 0.92
Humboldt Square Apartments 1 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 18 0.17
Lake Shore Apartments 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 6 0.00
Maranatha Place 0 0 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0 65 0.00
Marvin Gardens 6 1 5 2 6 2 3 1 0 4 5 4 39 52 0.75
Melrose Gates 22 8 17 20 10 13 6 23 13 6 10 13 161 217 0.74
�RiverGlen 28 15 30� 26� 19� 25� l� 4� 0� 6� 12� 19� 185 128 1.45
Riverwood Apartments 11 I g I 4 I 1 g 2 6 2 1 3 4 66 84 0.79
n. K 3 f
i .n �i a l '3.. .:e d..,. ...s� L r 55
s,. r,n �,..:.v_ .:x p,.. ra�_' k:.::�
1., ,.:.�^9 3. m m�.... F,.S I a 3�f
u
xi..: -3 '5�.,� r� J a;' o d x
a I Ss:au�,. l. 1.'t Ra:,.: .k...,�., y;
.e.... i ..2a� ...v T" 4.,
.s_ ,l'4� 4_ r 7 7 r 11 �17 8 l b 10 7 21 �6 ,98
View Point at Sl�n�le �r�e�� ,s r �,n�.�.�� m o_� n_� .r. w__, .r u..._ a �ng,,.
r..:
Soinmerset Apartments 10 9 11 11 6( 12 15 13 20 9 8 7 131 36 3.64
Sterling Square Apartments 16 23 11 8 9 13 14 13 8 6 8 4 133 54 2.46
..a x.. r
a.
f
r n.� .t� x
„.t.. 3 v..,. a�' ::..vw. T- .a� x ..r.. 3 a'� _,i.i rv,
Y I 2. '3 3
.�"v. ..9. '3:� .w�. a r E
a 4 E 5� �5� 3�6 �5 ���5 90 7 7� 6"� .739 2�2 �3�
Centrepoi�te_�partm�nts�, �a��.� a. ri �R 3,,;�1� ���a
s.
Total of "FS
Jan Feb Mar Apr Ma Jurz Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec CFS Units ��r Unit
The Crossings at Brookwood 7 4 9 5 5 4 6 6 4 5 7 7 69 138 0.50
�The Lilacs 0 0 0� 0� 0� 0� 0) 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0 22 0.00
The Pines of Brooklyn Center 12 16 12 13 5� 17 7 23 5 1 9 14 134 102 1.31
�TwinLakeManor 27 48 38I 47� 35� 52� 55� 62� 35� 44� 43� 41� 527 310 1.70
Twin Lake North Apartments 15 7 14 6 9 14 11 10 16 10 12 12 136 276 0.49
Unity Place 13 15 8 17 14 24 19 45 22 10 16 11 214 112 1.91
V ictoria Towi�liouses 3 2 14 6 10 5 8 5 7 4 4 4 72 48 1.50
Willow Lane Apartinents 0 6 2 1 2� 7 7 1 3 5 9 7 50 58 0.86
3401, 3413 47 3 2 1� 1� 0� 4� 1� 4� 0� 6� 3� 2� 27 22 1.23
3501 47 0 0 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0 11 0.00
3513 47 1 2� 1� 3� 1� 2� 5� 1� 16 11 1.45
3601 47 0 0� 0� 0� 0� 0 11 0.00
3613 47 3 1 0� l� 0� 2� l� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 8 11 0.73
3701 47 0 1 2� 2� 2� 0� 0� 3� 2� 1� 0� 0� 13 11 1.18
3713 47 0� 0 0 0 11 0.00 'I
4819 Azelia 0 0 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0 12 0.00
6101 Beard 5 3 3� 4� 5� 4� 7� 6� 7� 4� 8� 6� 62 24 2.58
6331, 6401, 6425 Beard 0� 2 2� 3 1 1 2� 12� 1 1 0� 2� 27 36 0.75
6o��BB I o I o I oi ol ol ol ol ol ol o� o� o� o I 11 O .00
�ols ss I o o o� o� o� 1� o� 1� o� o� 2� 2� 6 s o.�s
5240Drew 0 3 10� 14� 5� 2� 1� 0� 2� l� 3� 0) 41 10 4.10
5301 Dupont 0 4 0� 1� 1� 2� 1� 1� 0� 1� 1� 2� 14 6 2.33
4715 France 0 0 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0 5 0.00
5500BryantAvenueN 0 0 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0 8 0.00
5843 Fremont 0 0 0� 0� 0� 0� OC 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0 7 0.00
7230, 7250 WRR 3 1 1 1 5 2 3 5 4 0 1 3 29 8 3.63
7240 WRR 1 1 1 1 2 2 2 6 2 1 I 1 I 20 7 2.86
5207 Xerxes I o o o o o o� 1 o� o� o� o� o� i I�2 o.os
5209 Xerxes l 2 1 2 1 2 0 1 4 3 7 0 24 12 2.00
5211 Xerxes 3 0 0� 0) 1� 1� 1� 0� 5� 4� 4� 5� 24 12 2.00
Total CFS Rental (more than four units) f 325 321 374 358 304 381 326 484 380 336 359 366 4314 3,277 1.32
City of Brooklyn �nter
All Calls for Police/Medical/Fire Service
Rental Property (mare than four units)
200�
Total of CFS
Ja�z Feb Mar Apr May Ju�z Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec CFS Units Per U�iit
Basswood Apartments 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 11 0.00
Brookdale Manor 0 0 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0 21 0.00
Brookdale Towers 3 3 3 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 11 50 0.22
Brookhaven Apartments 15 14 10 6 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 45 54 0.83
Brookside Manor Apartments 9 8 9 10 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 36 90 0.40
Carrington Drive Apartments 13 14 18 17 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 62 128 0.48
Earle Brown Terrace 11 9 10 14 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 44 140 0.31
Earle Brown Farm Apartments 7 8 11 15 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 41 120 0.34
Emerson Chalet 4 3 4 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 13 18 0.72
Evergreen Park Manor 6 9 21 6 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 42 80 0.53
Ewing Square Townhouses 8 4 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 15 23 0.65
Garden City Court 9 3 0� 2� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 14 72 0.19 I,
Georgetown Park Townhouses 17 16 16 24 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 73 92 0.79
Humboldt Courts 7 13 8 17 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 45 36 1.25
Humboldt Square Apartments 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 18 0.00
Lake Shore Apartments 0 0 0 0( 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 6 0.00 I
Maranatha Place 0 0 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0 65 0.00
Marvin Gardens 5 4 3 6 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 18 52 0.35
Melrose Gates 13 13 16� 15� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 57 217 0.26
River Glen 19 19 22� 16� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 76 128 0.59
Riverwood Apartments 2 3 2 5 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 12 84 0.14
Shingle Creek Tower 12 11 20 24 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 67 122 0.55
Sormnerset Apartments 13 17 2 10 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 42 36 1.17
Sterling Square Apartments 11 13 14 9 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 47 54 0.87
Centrepointe Apartments 59 63 80 90 0 0' 0 0 0 0 0 0 292 252 1.16
Total of !'FS
Ja�z Feb Mar Apr Ma, Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec CFS U�zits �r U�zit
The Crossings at Brookwood_ 7 6 8 5 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 26 138 0.19
The Lilacs 0 0 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0 22 0.00
The Pines of Brooklyn Center 16 8 8 9� 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 41 102 0.40
Twin Lake Manar 65 54 61 60i 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 240 310 0.77
Twin Lake North Apartments 14 15 14 17 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 60 276 0.22
Unity Place 16 14 17� 15� -0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 62 ll2 0.55
Victoria Townhouses 8 12 12 12 0 0 0 0 0( 0 0 0 44 48 0.92
Willow Lane Apartments 4 5 9� 12� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 30 58 0.52
3401, 3413 47 3 5 2� 2� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 12 22 0.55
3501 47 0( 0 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0 11 0.00
3513 47 0 1 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 1 11 0.09
3601 47 0 0 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0 11 0.00
3613 47 0 f 1 1 2� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 4 11 0.36
370147 3 2 l� l� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 7 11 0.64
3713 47 0 0 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0 11 0.00
4819 Azelia 0 0 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0 12 0.00
6101 Beard 3 4 6� 7� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 20 24 0.83
6331, 6401, 6425 Beard 2 0 l� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 3 36 0.08
�o3�BB I o o o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o 11 o.00
�ols BB I o o o� 3� o� o� o� o{ o� o� o� o� 3 g o.3s
5240Drew 1 1 1� 3� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 6 10 0.60
5301 Dupont 1 1 2` 3� 0` 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 7 6 1.17
4715 France 0 0 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0 5 0.00
5500 Bryant Avenue N 0 0 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0 8 0.00
5843 Fremont 0 0 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0 7 0.00
7230, 7250 WRR 3 2 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 5 8 0.63
7240 WRR 1 0 2� 4� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 7 7 1.00
5207 Xerxes o o o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o i2 o.00
5209 Xerxes 2 0 1 1 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 4 12 0.33
5211 Xerxes 2 1 4� l� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 8 12 0.67
Total CFS Rental (more than four units) ti 394 f 379 422 447 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1642 3,301 0.50
City of Brooklyn (�'�ter
All Calls for Police/Medical/Fire Service
Rental Property (more than four units)
200�
Tota[ of CFS
Jan FeG Mar Apr May Jac�i Jul Aacg Sep Oct Nov Dec CFS Units Per U�iit
Basswood Apartments I 0) 0 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0 11 0.00 I
Broo lc d a l e M a n o i 4 0 4� 0 0( 0 5 0 0� 0 0 0 5 21 0.24
j BroolcdaleTowers 3 3� 3� Z� 3� 2� 2� 0� 18 50 0.36
Broolchave�l Apartments I 15 14 10 6 9 9� 11 18 0 0 0 0 92 54 1.70 I
Brookside Manor Apartments I 9 8 9� 10� 10� 8� 14� 11 0� 0� 0� 0� 79 90 0.88
Carxington Dz Apartments 13 14 1�8 17 23 21 28 23 0� 0 J 0 0) 157 128 1.23
7 Earle Brown TeiYace 11 9 10 14 20 12 19 13 0� 0� 0� 0� 108 140 0.77
EarleBrownFanllApaz 7 8� 11� 15� 21� 7� 23� 20� 0� 0� 0� 0� 112 120 �,0.93
Emerso�l cl�alet I 41 3 1 4 1 sl ol 3 1 6 l ol ol ol ol z� ls l.so
Everg�-eei1 Park Manor 6� 9 21) 6� 8� 17� 18� 6� 4� 0) 0� 0� 91 80 1.14
i Ewing Square Townhouses 8 4 3� 6� 7� 4� 2� 0� 0� 0� 0� 34 23 1.48
ty Garden City Court 9 3� 0 2 3 1 10 4 0 0� 0� 0� 32 72 0.44
GeorgetownParkTowi�l�ouses 17 16 16� 24� 24� 29� 33� 34� 0� 0� 0� 0� 193 92 2.10
r Humboldt Courts 7 13 8� 17� 12� 10� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 67 36 1.86
Humboldt Square Apartinents 0 0 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0 18 0.00
e Lake Sl�ore Apartrnents 0 0 0 0� 0 0 0 0 0 0� 0 0 0 6 0.00
Maranatha Place 0 0 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0 65 0.00
Ma� Gardeiis 5 4 3� 6� 9� SJ 14� 8) OJ 0� 0� 0�� 54 52 f 1.04
MelroseGates 13 13 16� 15� 21� �14J 21� 23� 0� 0� 0� 0�� 136 217 0.63
RiverGien 19 19 22� 16� 21� 23� 26� 22�� 0� 0� �0� 0� 168 128 1�.31
Riveitivood Apartn�ents 2 3 2� 5� 1 4� 0� 16� 0� 0� 0� 0� 33 84 0.39
y z Shingle Creek Tower 12 11 20 24 22 20 14 16 0 0 0 0 139 122 1.14
Soi�imersetApartments 13 17 2� 10� 13� 12� 14� 10� 0� 0� 0� 0� 91 36 2.53
�Sterling Square Apartinents 11 13 14� 9� 13� 18� 13� 11� 0�� 0� 0� 0� 102 54 1.89
j Centrepointe Apartments 59 63 80 I 90 73 53 53 74 0 0 0 0 545 252 2.16
I
Total of CFS
Jan Feb Mar Ap�• Mn, Jun Jail Aacg Sep Oct Noi� Dec CFS U�iits a� Unit
The Crossi�lgs at Brookwood I 7 6 8) 5� 5� 3� 10� 9� 0� 0� 0� 0� 53 138 0.38
T L;la o o o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o) o� o� o zz o.00
The Pines of Broolclyn Center 16 8 8 9� 9 9 10 10 0 0� 0 0 79 102 0.77
Twin La1ce Mazlor 65 54 61.� 60� 67I 68� 67� 55� 0� 0� 0� 0� 497 310 1.60
Twin La1ce North Apartments 14 15 14 17 17 26 15 7� 0 0 0 0 125 276 0.45
UnityPlace 16 14 17� 15� 31� 38� 37� 2$� 0� 0� 0� 0� 196 112 1.75
VictoriaTowi�l�ouses 8 12 12� 12� 14� 15� 7� 6� 0� 0� 0� 0� 86 48 1.79
Willow Lane Apartments 4 5 9� 12) 7� 0� 5� 6� 0� 0� 0� 0� 48 58 0.83
�3401, 3413 47 3 5 2� 2) 4] 4� 1 J 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 21 22 0.95
3soi4� I o o o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o) o( 11 o.00
3 3513 47 0 1 0� 0� 1� 4� 0� 2� 0� 0� 0� 0� 4 11 0.36
3601 47 0 o o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o il o.00
3613 47 0 1 1� 2� 1� 2� 3� 1� 0� 0� 0� 0� 11 11 1.00
g5 374147 3 2 1� 1� 0� 3� 1� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 11 11 1.00
3713 47 0 0 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0 11 0.00
L �4819 Azelia o o o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o i2 o.00
��z 6101 Beard 3 4 6� 7� 3� 12� 7� 8� 0� 0� 0� 0� 50 24 2.08
73 6331, 6401, 6425 Beard 2 0 1� 0� 6� 2� 2� 4� 0� 0� 0� 0� 17 36 0.47
6037BB o o o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o il o.00
�ols BB o o o� 3� o� s� o� o� o� o� o� o� s s r.00
w 5240Drew 1� l� l� 3� 3� 4� 3� 5� 0� 0� 0� 0� 21 10 2.10
4�� 5301 Dupont 1 1� 2� 3� 0� l� 1� 0� 0� 0� 0� 0� 9 6 1.50
4715France o o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o s o.00
5500 Bryant Avenue N o o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o g o.00
�5843Fremont o o o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o o.00
t �7230, 7250 WRR 3 2 0� 0� 4� 4� 2� 6� 0� 0� 0� 0� 21 8 2.63
�z �7240 WRR I 1� 0 2� 4� 3� 5� lI 4� 0� 0� 0� 0� 20 7 2.86
�7 �5207 Xerxes I o I o I o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o� o ��2 o.00
szo9 xe�es I 2 I o I 11 1� 6� 3� 2� o� o� o� o� 22 ��2 1.g3
5211 Xeixes f 2 1 4I 1� 4� 8� 4� l� 0� 0� 0� 0� 25 12 2.08
Total CFS Rental (more than four units) 394 379 422 453 496 488 502 473 0 0 0 0 3607 3,301 1.09
12-913 CALLS FOR SERVICE
CEN
TER POINTE
y
�o
N LL
w V N
n
N b0 V
fO i OG N �n J
01 'a u L O Q
L pp .Q
C SC Q "'Q O a�+ IT f0 !p t0
0 O' f9 LA y 7 tn x p� p�
L co o a' o v s o 0
a a a" m o 0 0� c� o���
September 2006� a 1 1 11 3 s( 1 I I� I 29 I 90 I
October 2006� I 1 I 4 I 3 I 1 I 1 I I I 1 I 11 I 79 i
Novem b e r 2 0 0 6 I I 1 5 1 I a I I 1 I 1 1 I 2 I 15 I 7z I
December 2006� I I I 1+ 2 I 2 I i 6 I 66
I January 2007� I 1 I 1 I 1� 4 I 3( I I 4 I 14 I 59
I February 2007I I I I I I 3 I I 9 I I I I 1 I 1( 3 I I 1� I 63 I
I March 2007I I I 1 I Z I 1 I 1 I 2 I 3 I I 1 I 3 I Z I 1 I 1( I 18
Apri12007I I I 1 I 2 I I 4 4 I 9 I I I I I I z I Z2 I 90 I
I May 2007I I I I 1 I z I 2 I I I I I 6 I 11 I 73 I
I June 2007� 1 Z 4( 1 1 9 I 74 I
luly 2007� I i I z I 6 I i I I 1 I 11 I 53 I
I A u g u s t 2 0 0 7 I I 1 I I 2� 5 I I 6 i I I 1 I 1 I 1 I 17 74 I
0 0 I 8 I 10I 7 43) 15I 51I 0 I 0 I 3 I 4 7 I 4 I 26 2� 180 I 873 I
�n A N N hA dA i' L LL L�i..
3 L tp c� p y V
O 7 L t/) O U
(�6 i c�i� pp fC O .Q V u a M J
v� Q'^ L c E o a o a a
Q Q m 0 LL N
3 p o
.a? �a F-
v V
3
0
a
180 Total 12-913 CFS
252 Units
OJ1 CFS per Unit
23.35% Percent of Totai 752 CF5 for 53 complexes
9l16/(1]
G
Cit o Brooklyn Center
yf
A Millennium Community
Remit To I NVO I C E 52U5
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER
6301 SHINGLE CREEK PARKWAY Invoice Date 5110/2007
BROOKLYN CENTER MN 55430 Due Date 5l31/2007
Billing Address: 121680
BROOKLYN CENTER HOUSWG LLC
3 BLUE SPRUCE CT
ST PAUL MN 55127
item Remark Amount
001 BOND ADMINISTRATION FEE 8,181.25
Total Amountinvoiced 8,181:25
8,181.25
Balance Due
An 18% APR finance charge wi// be app/ied to al/.amounts not paid by the due date.
P/ease �efu�n one copy with you�payment.
6301 Shingle Creeh Parkway Recreation and Community Center Phone TDD Number
(763) 569-3400
Brooklyn Center, MN 55430-2199 F� (763) 569-3434
City Hall TDD Number (763) 569-3300
FAX (763) 569-3494
.,;t,�r�f),rnnl+)1'tt('217.1.C!'.01'L1
1 b`��
�7,500,000
City of Brooklyn Cente�c, A�inneso�a w f
Rental �Housing �.eveszue Bonds
(Center Court Apartments Project) C� r• Y Cj', 4
Series 1994
Distrabution List,
Issuer Underwriter's Counsel
City of Brooklyn Center Best Flanagan
6301 Single C.reek Parkway 4000 First Bank Place
Brooklyn Center, MN 55430 601 Second Avenue South
02
M
N
554
innea
olis
Gerald S hnter 569 3300 M P 3gg-7121
P
son
Dan
N
e.
Fax. 569 3494 Fax: 339-5897
BaPrower TPUStee
Dominium Management Services, Inc. First Trust National Association
3140 Harbor Lane, Suite 102
Minneapolis, MN 55447 180 East Fifth Street, 2nd Floor
Jack Safar 559-1495 St. Paul, MN 55101 244-0713
Paul Sween Fax: 559-1783 Tim Sandell
Fax: 244
Bor�ower's Counsel,
�631fl `f�6 0 ,6 D �e ea��
Winthrop Weinstine ao o o
3000 Dain Bosworth Plaza
6� 5outh 6th Street gb3�,5'D
Minneapolis, MN 55402
Todd Urness 347-0657 Z o S y q3.7s
Fax: 347-0600
Z� �S3`�3,�7..�
Bond Counsel
Zd�� ��g�,7�
Holmes Graven, Chartered Zo 7
470 Pills�ur�,� Center
Minneapolis, MN 55402 Zv�g
Barbara Portwood 337-9213
Fax: 337-9310 ZOD 9
Un.derw�iter Z�
o 1
Piper Jaffray Inc. o
222 South 9th Street, 15th Floor
Minneapolis MN 55402
Terry McNellis 342-6665
Fax: 342-6966 o r t c.�: �r
n
$i0 C -c.r C-�r�t i
15�� �es.d b�L�s
(7roek\y� C�e_��-e� �',tc,�� LLC...
t-l-C.. r t C--�
ELY76029
BR290-12 �0.u,� 1 �h SS
i�
.r �CCOUNT HISTOR�
Account Number: Phone:
_�CCOUNT LOOKUP SCREEN(M)
Account Addr
Number Status Address Type Customer Name
505013000302 AC 2810 NORTHWAY DR �S�&''f, G�_� S CENTRE POINTE APTS
505018000802 AC 2908 NORTHWAY DR j 17 S CENTRE POINTE APTS
505019000702 AC 2924 NORTHWAY DR b S CENTRE POINTE APTS
505020000402 AC 2916 NORTHWAY DR �Sc� ~ya�,c��, S CENTRE POINTE APTS
505012000402 AC 2802 NORTHWAY DR 4�� S CENTRE POINTE APTS
505014000202 AC 2818 NORTHWAY DR r7,���,�`[�. S CENTRE POINTE APTS
505015000102 AC 2834 NORTHWAY DR b,��,,, S CENTRE POINTE APTS
505016000002 AC 2826 NORTHWAY DR S CENTRE POINTE APTS
i
1
:",CCOUNT LOOKUP SCREEN (M)
Press a function key Modifying
I r�, I
�,i. G �1,'� o c� J°1'�� I r�--
i�� —I-z ���-L�`���
�—�"1 p
��.IL
�fi��
p
fi �'l ct �C c� c.�.�l�>
�t Uc.�i�'�.�
f �1 C:5 �..��3 1���-'� n
Gt.�.I {�'l� '1
,T C� (.G o
�i�� C�- `�-�j�
c�
-rt�-��
V��+ c� -e., l l ac lz�
i��ta�'�
l S e��
i �o
��i a f�'��,�-I�,��e�
C
7�CCOUNT HISTOR�
1
Account Number: Phone:
_TCCOUNT LOOKUP SCREEN(M)
I Account Addr �,f�
Number Status Address Type Customer Name
505017000902 AC 2904 NORTHWAY DR ��'�d S CENTRE POINTE APTS
505021000302 AC 2932 NORTHWAY DR S CENTRE POINTE APTS
505022000202 AC 2940 NORTHWAY DR y3��a� s CENTRE POINTE APTS
T_�.,�, __T_nm
.y:. T�
VL. t`'11.. LJV it .���.r.,� ii��ii
-aa
c�., ���j.���� ���,�i� L�"'•Ci7�
L 1 l� L i l �^�J L�1����0 ��Y� i �ip T y� m I
�'�������4� o
L 1'>� L�.i a�
r_
:�CCOUNT LOOKUP SCREEN(M)
Press a function key Modifying
I
City of Brooklyn Center
Ij.,
i
A Millennaum Community L� b
41 fi.�'�
F�"�,�
b
January 12, 2007
CENTRE POINTE APTS
2900 NORTHWAY DR
BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55430-2466
SUBJECT: Delinquent utility bill:
Account number: 505017000902
Service address: 2904 NORTHWAY DR
Amount due.: $1,877.46
This letter serves as notice to you that the City is preparing to begin the process
of assessing your unpaid utility bill against your property taxes. If the amount
listed below is not paid by February 7, 2007, it will be included in this process.
You may have a current bill with a larger amount due. This letter deals only with
amounts which are delinquent.
A$30.00 certification charge will be added to your account if it is not paid by
February 7, 2007. This is to reimburse the cityfor the cost of assessing it to your
property taxes. After February 7th, you will have the option of paying your
balance, including the $30.00 certification charge. If not paid, it will be added to
your 2008 property taxes along with the $30.00 certification charge and
additional interest.
To make payment now, return this letter with a check payable to the City of
Brooklyn Center, in the amount of $1,877.46.
If you have questions regarding your balance, please call Julie at 763-569-3390.
I encourage you to pay your bill now to avoid these additional charges and
interest.
,301 Slii�igle Creel� Par7zway Recr•eatiori a�id Commu�zity Ce�ater• Plaone TDD Number
Broolzlyn Ce�tite�; MN 55430-2199 (763) 569-3400
City Hall TDD Number (763) 569-3300 FAX (763) 569-3434
FAX (763) 569-3494
www. cityofb�•oolzlylticenter.org
City of Brooklyn Center ,�Y
A Millennium Community
February 16, 2007
CENTRE POINTE APTS
2900 NORTHWAY DR
BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55430-2466
Subject: DELINQUENT UTILITY CHARGE
Account number: 505016000002
Service address: 2826 NORTHWAY DR
Amount to be certified: $2,039.57
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING ON P
ROPOSED SPEC
IAL ASSESSMENTS
Notice is hereby given that the City Council of the City of Brooklyn Cei�ter, Minnesota, will�meet in
City Council Chambers at City Hall, 6301 Shingle Creek Parkway, on Monday, March 12, 2007, at
approximately 7:00 P.M., or as soon thereafter as the matter may be heard, to hear and pass upon all
objections, if any, to the proposed assessments.
It is proposed to assess public utility charges (water, sanitary sewer, storm drainage, street lighting
and recycling) to those tracts or parcels where such charges were delinquent as of December 31,
2006, and after due notice to the property owner, remain unpaid, pursuant to City Ordinances,
Sections 4-105 and 4-201. The amount certified includes an added charge of $30.00 to pay for the
certification process. The amount listed above is due Friday, March 9, 2007.
PROCEDURAL INFORMATION FOR OBJECTIONS TO SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS
An owner may appeal an assessment to district court pursuant to Minnesota Statutes, Section
429.081 by serving notice of the appeal upon the Mayor or City Clerk within 30 days after the
adoption of the assessment and filing such notice with the district court within ten days after service
upon the Mayor or City Clerk. No such appeal as to the amount of an assessment as to a specific
parcel of land may be made unless tlie owner has filed a written obj ection to that assessment, signed
by the affected property owner, with the City Clerk prior to the hearing or has presented such a
written objection to the presiding officer at the hearing.
These assessments are now on file at City Hall and open to public inspection. Written or oral
objections to the proposed assessments will be considered at this meeting, but the City Council
may consider any objection to the amount of a proposed individual assessment at an adjourned
meeting upon such further notice to the affected property owners as it deems advisable.
s
i
.;301 Shingle Creelz ParJzway Recreation and Co�nmu�aity Center� Plaone TDD Nuniber
Broolzly�i Ce�a.ter, MN 55430-2199 (763) 569-3400
City Hall TDD Number (763) 569-3300 FAX (763) 569-3434
FAX (763) 563-3494
www.cityofbrooklyncenter.org
i
City �f �rooklyn Center
A Millennium Community
.;ui
July 6, 2007
CENTRE POINTE APTS
2900 NORTHWAY DR
BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55430-2466
SUBJECT: DELINQUENT UTILITY BILL
Account number: 505017000902
Service address: 2904 NORTHWAY DR
Amount due: $3847.57
This letter serves as notice to you that the City is preparing to begin the process of
assessing your unpaid utility bill against your property taxes. If the amount listed
below is not paid by August 8, 2007, it will be included in this process. You may have
a current bill with a larger amount due. This letter deals only with amounts which
are delinquent.
A$30.00 certification charge will be added to your account if it is not paid by August
8, 2007. This is to reimburse the city for the cost of assessing it to your property
taxes. After August 8, 2007, you will have the option of paying your balance,
including the $30.00 certification charge. If not paid, it will be added to your 2008
property taxes along with the $30.00 certification charge and additional interest.
To make payment now, return this letter with a check payable to the �ity of
Brooklyn Center, in the amount of $3847.57.
If you have questions regarding your balance, please call the water department at 763-
569-3390. I encourage you to pay your bill now to avoid these additional charge�s and
interest.
6301 Shin le Creelz Parizway Recreatio�z and Com�nunity Center Plaone TDD Number
g
763 569-3400
ti Ce�zte�° MN 55430-2199
Br•oolzly�
City Hall TDD Numbe�• (763) 569-3300 FAX (763) 569-3434
FAX (763) 5
69-3494
www. cit��ofbroolaly�acenter.org
��:1� I`43 1 �c"
J 7 Fkz� �!�G r C Z� Vtdfi
3 iLi 1, ti��i� f�rv
4� fff i l� S+.�r�� i� v i:
t t dt'^ 1X
7i �3j�1 ....:i:� c �o.»zt
)!f.'v'�.1 :'i��3. �r 7 <3:
t.3:s�i3' ii::�:1a ..)i�,l
1'�3.Ei .r t�) .�co� 1...3;7
�'��ao.. tcla3D �.�.ji.: ur.....:.:_>rs.
:)i.'�l�vl'1�,.?L �t�
t�!��:C���;,:8.` �8
1.�9:t?t)�_.ZL: �'.�.�.t�;r I_:.x�i:�. ii>>:::,!. �:,�i�i:�ui� i'7 a 4..1�'���i�'$2 �3 ;�1�.A.I.. ���.T�.�C:��,x�
J iN��t.�ti:��.3ti� i�1�i� I�.� C".E;.[;�'1 �1�
�.}���tii:t��ti31.. l �,�i��k��<:,`T,3..I' 1 �c. Y �k:i5 I�i..,
1`:-�{ �ii'la�>> 1 z3:t3�, �iiitt l'�,_'<
�4�; i a>�<:��is, 1:�ti t
Lf�1l ��<l� ix>i3�;�st l+;i'? �'.,133:1i���
�`li;� 3 l7,. t'i71�,.:t"� �':�'9. �+�:r"��� •.:��.�x<� �:���CS�
-�1���,.�.<F14t�'�� 3.��t`l:.k�t �[{<.���t�'�'�����
�'ti�S� 3^��l.niiif�., <1�, ~J =�!r3� ��i�.7�
.:iF 22'3 'i�t�.� i�.Li3i �'jG� c� t. FL3i34 t�}���<� �.YLi 4t��f3 E. 1�;�' Q� ��i'SFit��� �i3
i .:i'i1#�S ;:�i�if1l3. i31E� �i�'i`<?���L7: �.�:'1f�i ::L 1��.'L�,�rC1L1alI7�.Y. `�.S'+t>1.3s'LGS;
J:l3�tfl�f.i�'a L :'S1'i�.��ti.�iL �..Ucrl ..tis.1`.I' E:3 Ef.3�I f���'s �L?1;�5�I���t L:3f,,'
c��: ��at �;.:l�i t t�^�i�ta �'tixllif �Ji€ kr3� ��f;E�i��<i 1���<:�ri�;�
l�:i�*�� �..�f�t��.� <.:istiit4 rt��:��� l?��vg��t) L�:�`��;; l:t)t) sr� :ti��c 1
�.�.£:<).r .L�J:f'�d3.t1..?1:: LiJi
c�jt, u .,���z3:.�...�S:t{3 :�:7..�.333�: ;`i3T�ft;�u :��;''�+..'�{;1;a?'ltl� clS <ItiS'lN:� 'a;�`v�..i ��3f�'Lo,At4�4....
�li.��L'T�.,i,(:•: i3� �.,1,3:1v� C��t�;Ci� c3�;1)� �L13 1 �3+��.1'e'�`v11::� 18.' 1�:.�e .��.�1{�L7� �1.''1'1 �.1,3��L'a ����7i�C'S<?.:.`°:
t �'l:l t� t�l.;: 11, ��C;y'.' �C±`<? ..11>l s I :r'v iY.itz1.3� �.�Si)a�dl.Jti�'J �i�].:: "F.TiC�.l;t3�{lf.: �}"llU
�'�Sii., �itz
�.:-`�t�f Z�7I�'s"1 �:]3'i ti lt�l��% t ���21T}.?:.E',iC,dtltSii a li{? 7i l�l.; `I Ttt�Ct.:;' �.fl i�7 �.�s`112If�i�lh� `fT�3 ��J17:�? 3<�i?t13i1 t�i£�
��ii., i33iC�t�3 t'3.�::� k.� 1 t�i�t32).,f.:t.
itl[: �20
i�r£�(��C1�1�: C{n.�r �a.:+�s� ltC.�tiSiti�?. tLSS<J{'.i<3rS.y L13"�1�� t�< I't3,T3'i��iy7i1� (il c. `L �3t�3rai�k'l �i�7c� �i�
�I":r �1,3J.�.�� �<3 �"si'3:3) .���'T'L`C:417L`J�. �TXlt� l I £i' t �ff�11'�t�.',c'nL:; ��,�.•E3.J'L�.L �i3_,`!.''.�E3��C3"l� i'ii3i: f'1�-313'£'t-
1j�o>t1Cf1�;�: `�`t�<�t� i7i�,.3 t'r:l'�i ��U��.3�� d:� r'��i3;,_.?��JlllZC:d: :13� ,�ZL'.. �3}���:� G iSL.:, t �..f1 dS ta�:� �3.�i1'' ��'�`�7:
f l�'11 �4�E3I�' 3..,a.�.:� C: �74� 1:s C �1f�:3k� <3'1is�T ��1., f)JI7 .�.`�.�iCLfI:1 I3� clll"� S�`��31�E��:i�t(` �d<<� "��.C.i7.
t�\L 2.Z. ��l�l'1S{..�'. ll 1k.�V�.) ti.441.1S:LV S�A�i� ��lV�a�`�11 i1��'3L� �):t�ACJt �u�� $i4A�L,V�� L�1��•2D t{���Y,t..
1 i:l:`L,fi3 c7.,7i$ T�� f!t�,4J1.:%� �3��<.j+::.� 1'` �.�7w T�3'�..' �`S zly�'�,IC �ui`� t�i1�?S i� t€�i° t7:3.I� 'tLYf��:11L3'31.
F� .F,1� --1 E 1 �:�9 f� <i
�.3Ti3�3��� L �.d?:it�. �I��Li�lll�; °i;��us. ��t�s �r
't �#c�t� .���i �r>i,r�i��
..,�n3
�i�.'s1c,f 1�>vl li �f3ft,
}'•St£'s�
���fs L.�t_t3t"�`dJ ;11 i�L cttt��'1111:.�il.:i.�3�. tGil T.�i 0.�� l� �.�t� 11i 1`i�rtitlY)t;I�t 3i7L:�li(,�3i7b;: #�3� �E3�'f1rV3�"3�?
t �:t 1 x
i?.-i.. .7.i r
s �.Yi.a�.1i3...,:�.�<..il3..to
�x� 1 5i.),.1 i
3 fiil ���.a it� �i��ic`It >7a��!�z rt� �ait��s;.iat�� T�3 ��zct��3� 'f�?��3,
t.i 1:31� II{ SIi3t�'�� t7ct�r j'`L!I'3li,�i33 i�J `��.i:�1i.�1 ��;<3}�Y3�
i�i� ��1�t13't::it� �lt�lf;� �)cl�F;£�5,�3+J�ll.o If3 u11a��11i�I� A� �i ,�'.�i 3F)I' ii:� li<^, lt`c .��t f
iC� �'�u1.�iicl� t'i23C� �YCa� i,Ti7t1 Ci:tf�i� L� ciY i'��
t� �uii��i r` ;lti ��3'tL-�� j7:'3; t�L�Sf�°i3�� 111 c111)U�JI��S 1 �f'1t �t'{� f. :C's L�1LZ3:1 fil ck:o 3.1.. °TL'c. `�.`�.:xi"
�:<1 �y t�l'1L1I1t� t3f iii�s.t'cl;3t S. i t:�3313 ZL� �"i7'iC L�'t '�'�i?i"� ;>li'�' <i31��: i
i.' cM i �'i 3. tila t'?: !f's�i[ C; ){�"t �U'^IL"<. '�i't'°i, iJ� tifT�li 8€�,� I I
,7 �ili L .1ct t�. �.)S, o E3 �l. f l t�+
:;:i17,S ��S,f ��.���..�x �i J� LC)7i5:[1lt].iL <3.J3 vtil C z�l�# .t73 <��&`•C3tY�d39s;f i'�rl �3 fiicGl]f"se
i�l�' 1tS...S�.; �.t::•1't,t� T�i;u� sd��.74�t39L� :Ot3 t�1�::� ni31� '�i"i�.i' 'f�3<:}� tti'S27 •':3�i Z�1 t:�3' �'��<3.� Tis I
r Flrl�::3>
4 I
�I) `1��1,'.;i1��'�t� �l it ��t3. ��.►�:.��i�.l $>a�s�clxlc c�� o� 1: fir �t�.:r��
Ilt,�ia )i;�� i�l3�x`"t}�.�� �c'S},'?c.C� �73t2�t.1�3.i� cIT"G� i SIl "�'f. i�.�3:� L>�) lc�� 3�i�.��:c jx;7�Fi� �f"S�tS�y�
•-e t7 i 3 ;1�+;' dxl� l'� II I
i �3l `l t�i ��v a� c3��� i ��a at�i� rs c 4��3izz��
'n �`.t�� ��r t�i{ 'I
r
Y3tlt� �:iS� t.�£it ��.1��1 i"S��?.'C.�. .tt) i`�`cl� p �i(��}Lrtl r�?S,� ����.3��3i3"#iiS
:1T1�4ISxlT1J..�' istit3 -�3'; j�3�.��3'1Ti l?:�' ��1L'. �S�t�itt;ittisi, ,llct�
1 "iI� .��i
�=31 :`�1 '��3�3 t���i i� t�uc;arzri �s�;�.�k�14 r.� �f tl� ,��i�:��f r�va �v�fl�f::r�s}��c;t i�. d,,�;s,
<FI9r �z��A�t�i3 a��i� ft��sa.c,�it����i1.��3��<� �.,u������zt io Cz�li�3: S�3' �'3c' t:t��t�.�.�,r�:w���%� I
a�rit� ��:ct�vn t�ic I�tY�� At� ��.s.�i :ar�c1 �;;�.i�t,.�:: �..,iz� ��`�c� 1'�z�t�s�s��:��
tJ� i�1L �:.OT31�}ui.;,1
ITI'a�ti1? tt.�' {I l�l�:'�i��t,lt3_1 t�� ``J-.� y �,tt�:� �ii� i'4�� aL�1 �`.UU t}3 l�: j7c3J' ITt111]Lt��:�3�t'�} t�l� �:Ti3. f.:
��'1 i�L�L; .�►.k'il�, l�E.. f�!''3�?�il1�' ti3�� ��L i�'3Gll �,J �?l.\ �.�i� ��Ll�scl,�`�lj <l�] T�'<'�ti(�('F3��f'. ��.0 ,�)�{,�t t,.1.]3t'31�L� U�
t. Y .r o t :�r r .11{�T23.L ��:3{i Lcl3t3i1�i YIf �L'C'S c7:1'3l�
�.�iC l 14'�.�f: i3i`ti Icli7l,:�1 C i�Lc1U12 �a:>Y�ic 1 cl.11 ��,tL�TTS 31I.., ]i�
i
r� 7 C^, l��i�. {�7�iS1.�:j�:�.'Si7 �(3.��� �.�'S�.id1�� 1L� C�iC)i3 J:� 0� �I3�' e�iifl �:�9��Ji LIef:1�,�
�.:Y� I7 ac.,, C<3t 1 t
C3'l�+.rl� E,s'�3t' j.,i.F>lt r�1{?i�Y�Ilc`i?�;
r
a a t r Y s :C C.� �l�;tt �'.:ciS tl� ��3c. t'ci1�.�::���i'�s��� �}ic, IIx�Ji11.Ii�V
1 l�c ,�t���4c�� it��. ar�3 3�a�ifs �a51 �ts. ..t��t 1
a:�:����7 }�:i�1s�s ��i <,11i., C:i:}I?t ��1'�3�' #31S' �3 l> �'`�s��z�i#� ��f:�r�:�c����.� Lai�d �;it���,� �=��t�� ;t�,�i�;�� it� tl��
�ft3i�Iy s�:� ��:_.�,y���t i�?;:t1�� �3�rri� T��x��l �.�:e ai: t��� t�i�t �i.�yj nf ,�a�li �3i{�r�sl�, ra,;t �r a��:.��ai��
Q'�(3 fi(*ry::�t� �ti ti7wtl�� L�C��Li,�,1 sC� �L�L �.1'� S,.d>if�<�i7� *�'�i.:�Lt'` �`?3 L��lc'. i3'� 0�;�}1� �J L�<3 ts�
i
`1. S�
N H F l<#_ +I
.�3�°���kl C"f i�iei I �a��.� �;�iisisti� �'�.���.,...��tr;4
�.i:�����ct:� T'azi��t.i��l<i
'�;<�lcz��?�'�
#'�i��
",iiL�i JIFs.',�l�.�l� 1$9 i11�1�11.�1� <i1�C� i�' c� T39��33��7�� :i�i'��{�C�:I L� l�-iG �L �?..£TS nS"ii�
>.Z�� ,<3tCt11£1 j� 1111i� L�tlu f5 �r� i�i!. �f3`a� L�f,}� t�� �'�}i:�7 F31I�S1"11�� 11 �`.i� ct13iL?!I1 f L�� �r' �J�.
��C."i7��11Ti�.'.}�`�Si 3i �1�3�t ���1�:23�31L p� l�c i1I31C}1131�'- GC�'i?:iI7 cF�"SO� L,` �i�lw�L'i. T3�); �:3IL, t tll�;%
c�.i3j i�.. ;LC� iJt `�Li.�.+.3X1 �'i LJf �sIC:,� <)clll _;�.f.yt��.l?7L133 't2 `�`'i C�,IQ£1 I
l�;�tr.t, rt C:jSr.����1s;i ti s ta]1� c�t).^t�3 �'kC'�i ��l �1:5�31i3���.J3 1'f.� itt'3 3:L� :lhf. �3txF�i�S L?��t i�1s: itiy°c:�,
i:5c3"� L:�::i 1'1';�1� iL t�� :�,C9 ,�f �i3i� l Tii:. �33 <it� l<<.ic 3.3 I�1.�. �<;:tC�c�.i�tiGf��� i�� 13r 1I ;��'f]C��:is:�i.3lv° i)�
v:1 L�v�vl�� t,}� 1 lt' t�.�::ii3l3�c t=t� ��ll°s:1]�)iTL� :.�L� .i?'i;' s7111f)' ���.I�l�l�li.`(;�`��' I(.��1 SiC�C� j�`�i3tsGiii:t �s
i.�:•�'�i �..i)3,;�.;•L. ��:f=ss„�lfli.Tf'. �,s.t„t?7> ���3t:.L��?9r.t'# t:�T .�'��?3'€�r'3� :.:0� i�.€�i�`i �'��h.1131��'� ,f3� ii3 �1T 31'3s�`i�L:ljz�:'1tTi
�,�:t1 ts ��:,:t�ct-, d;;��l��.ctls�cI; �l.l:�, �'3c�i:i�1 �)�'.�t'Tlcill5'�
�.�3C �3 �:z3i�r.�,.;E �t4,� :'.�lt k.C.113(.11� ili"�,i.� '1�Vf��?w'S;L <1�:� �'�311' t3tBt}'I:f3C11�� :'C�c1�3I1£? �t� `��:y ��tii?��ti
I"t;37i t�t t>3 'i3�� t:C>�ft i ���t;t7 Si�3 41�.L<Ti'i�i3;livL 1'��il�i �jit,I:J' vJ"�f..;111c�� �.L7Tii'� t�si �iLi:�t�':. .3T3�'c,� T?i.�
t'SE t.,itt,I'itci is� li1l.:;��U113]t�i S^, �.��i3:� ialt' ci �:lS� �'`�15�3 �ts EjC��.�l 5.< 1� L�f'�L1S':<l, ��Si L1�
L�L��ti?i�t3�iJi' �3�t :�1, f l:;:i 11�.i �3J: 7.,� i,°11�;Y �S �lltj� 'Li i�7 ;�l t�'3'_iS�iE U� �1fi1��.:UT fili 3�£i� '1� 1iU'� ,�.�>,>�i3 LLii;
�S�i:4£i��� Lf?fi.�Till�t., r3 "i:` iFi' 13�. 117?C�ti '`��:t10t) t?f f:?:5f fi�l�) �1,��'i'f.i 1c13s:t�] �t'C£]t)i7 i.�
<J���'��C' ��f'l��c �ti�� Z :£'�t�l Jt53'1 #,�3 �.�lt;L�i'�civ��;�.5 S 'Ii.I'C 1+ �C�::'s�L�S�.._f�7E�C 1=f�c��' i�r:T3�ir a%S il�`.�
y t 2�� c�� n��r i St tq Z f
t�l:cl� ��c?tt:�� y� 3>.t�cii�t :�1 1��?l�� C�. �.3i'�� tll;' ��13�, >rj i�3 ��i< Ivlll L �.�l:t� 3L.t. ;il 4�i��> ::#,�t� �c3���,d< ��3'
`1311C lt{)il� ��c�;£`23�t� t��vi 1� L�:1 t�+ ��.£3�t
''30��.�it�4 31#<�li3l�i� 1.17 �.�1'S �.E,k�.£.� �i� 7iil�Iit �:'J CTL'�1�, G013ti�1[l��C ,3 '�3,.i31�3;: I7"'�#�}:�li'3�7f�
?Y3IiliC�t31�'li icil�:Cti �0��1:c.�.i� �73i;�" �j ��ia. i1.3S�i.t �2�?i7T1 �'31'.`.v�lt. �:E'�dll�� i}I L�C.il�. U� i�C.�zi�t� ;4>..�iC�.���1
{'(3V' t'�.I�i'13�aY E�1`�'l�,i'E.,.1�`GT i?' FkiJly; Uf` Lt� £Ei1y Uf i��:11��1�� ia.�iC� �.L�'1i lil1���.� >�3 �sl1� �,�11c:�13�3L'3��:S,
4I�' �.1�7�s C��'d'.1� i11C� �'al��'k11L�1 �12'�Ti�t2 1L7�3 ii:l� cfi7C� rt�� S'3b;}3� i.ti" ��TI3'"t�?t.'� iii i:L�tl#3�'t 1'�,t��l
��t;,'�t i'1��;��; t�G� i�i:J3.S ���c�.::i)Zii}' i3t>t'S t�t,iic,l f'.�.�{,f ��it�:1� 13i3C��3` �(�t �t11 3.� (351 C)� `3�'i3.�� �1�,�'i1:�
i>
.�i�s� �..i�i�;{���,�s.�t►'� i��tc�y����i'��,13�.3'�.� :ii.
i Li'; #ri1.�� v��U���
A
t
r r d t r Jr 7
i��-���� :c3
;�?�:1:�1.,.1L
x' F 1:;1 �-�I I r
h x
�t't`)� �1;� C t,.''3il�,t" �'cl.�L� �T 73.i^�1i1L; �Lu'-{3�.i�1f�:5
L;l i3l i�t'� :��`�?1"f I t�i'
i:
�'J4� 1t. Ss, ?()i);.
r�:;� :i�L �s� �XL.�tt�Il'�i �,ra���, �1����s�-�t���. �a;t' '�]atl�
i�:��� ��1:13$3�`�G {''I�c'.�� �y <3\'
�'i:�i�: �i �'31 L'1 i{ I �`�71:1I3i.���f.'s:i: "�-�..�i�
�-��J. �,�1�1 ��ci!"lu�
,��'i}z:.i �a��"��r, "t>. �x�i<;>7 J.�. �.�1 «I f
�;;"}�t''riC;i'.�;!.1 i1�� i
'i; 3 t ,�f3:
9 3t
;t r:'��lt.$'�d?'f3'i_f,Y?T
.Id�: 1. 33..
L �iiat�,i,.� S'�3 £lft l �3.�i ��..3.iS111:? �1 i 1:� ..i �.1!' t� �Y�ciit ��L.�.il� 11 iLLi� ���LS tS..`-'.�.L
;'�t r1f r
.�>�:�tar�� l: ;t3 r� 1 }t}:
y'�,.iS3;.ii.�3 1��'� ��::'1>�i..�
�rf3����lvz� �"L����r �1;t�.i����f�, �;tL' ��t�;�ta;� _#ic.�� P��ai� �'Z�.�i�ia� t*ci
t ��its� �x >s� C <�iii ��a I�,.�,� ���1 �t�.� t�"�� �:�d ti�� :�.rt� i��
f,
'�LJt13.L}c��'�, �,�'ta <i .::tll'^�37�i.'litrd131 is4 3E)� (;S37ilj
5�11" rs'�f?�k�'1 3.1.'� cvf�'•.
?�Zl l.�(� .C7✓� I3 )+l(i:f'i
.i
ry�'��a'�`�'�<
i
U,��"�
����n��� �i� !��r�r���� ���a�r����
t��
:�u�u�x ��aa�
To P��I►e ����ty� i���u����ry ��r�r�c�s ��ri`arn����, k#�� #��a��r��ale Dc�r� ��r��i��
�hasr��r���i
}��i�r�`�t t� �ik�- �r�€�t���(
��ib,��ct �.�r�t�I �wr�tl��r� L��e€��� 3�Yr��a�csr�_��a� �^��r��� �E
�yd�:r ���r�e�l, ��helr ����e� ar�r�-�"�c� L;, F�����;dk�� �(�r�����t�
A,par���r��� ��r���r►� A��c��re� I
R+e�i�rrry�ras�atit��. �n ��afy �1�C� �te�a w�� Yt��r� k�� �h� ���t��t �i����e ����'�i c�f
�a.����l� PtrrS�ar��_�� S��M�ar� ��F�! 196�, ��j �f t�h� M�t€���palt� �t���-���r��nanc�
i��'�1 f�����1Se °,�ard �fi,��ip�a�� is r�c�€��s�rr�� �pArC+�r�l�ftb�t�'k�� �itjr����n�l� ft�C"���
r��a�a�1�r� tC�� �t:�nta� C?��iii�g-�.tc.���� ��i�; by �Ytl�r 3�u��ed �s�f��r �a�a��` a�� �'�r� L:
i��r�i�: t�����ap�t�� �partrr��n�51�a€�5i�� As����a��5 I. 7��,��' ���t��t�
.���`J°���� 5�;�1�'�1' �x�1f'�� �'�i� ��tl ��iFll� ��K>� �{('Ei��l�1��15 a'��3�I`��"t£,.'�'!� �"�t71lSIl'�E„� �1�5�3�kc���
L�.� ��c[�d ��i��t��(��y Y�c�� t�� r��iatre��t��s �f t`'d�����p,�1i� �,��t��t�a��s ��3��
����#�s� an 1..�����d ���rr�i���.
T�� ����fi���� t�f ����ct��r�� r�e�����ds �h� �ty��o�n�ti �pp,a�+� t�� R����� ����'t�t�t�
��a� ���e�€� ��rt���� �nd r��i��Ce �h� r�nt�l `�i�v�611r�� EE+'��Se f��l� �Y �Y�er �a:���tl,
�sc�ti���"��a��e�� ���;7'��'r L 1��r,1�:�b�,�rn�����is� �l��;�'t�'��€�� ��u�3�� �4��a��a��� ��r
�h� �a��r��se� a��7�� 8 t��tn�ae er���rased �rrdan�s
�ir��u�s �#ori�
�r�G,are� ��;,5�� �t�� hy .7ar�i�,e A�cfi�is�rt, :Ca�strtc� S���rvl��r �73 3�1.5
3
��.�r����
��7�h3�'�'��t1�, �£�[7�'� �B3'�:�t{7��" �t'fi�S3fl� ��5,�3�C�I�►la ��t'JIC�Sr
r J�
.��pr�v�d la�
r
�i�tt�� R��rne�'� I�[r� �f 1ns��ctions
t.
A r�iued b
�?.R
�v�ca �na���, A�����n�. Ci;�y Cr�ar�inat�r
�'f'�''� �F l�k��1�A�fL4}'�i[�l�'
I�i+::t�'�"��'��ti��f�E�T�� LI���.��� ��}�'�R� t3�` �#�'P���'�'�
�n ��ic ���tt�r #h�:I�.��ifa�
�v��i�� ���e��� held b?�
'1���1ne������;�ip�r�e�r#s ��u��n�
S k 4n' ��:i�
�,�diC�l3�L`.� 7��.,,{. �xk�` ��"''���`hi'�i� ��.�r� I
�'"1'�:3111SE�C a� 1�,�'��[1k' ��1���'�.t�����. t���
i��n�te� �"I��. �Iix����ota R�?Ct��rt�'��t'��lr��.'I�`}�:
s
l`�s ��ex �,�zi �ae��'ui� ���r� t�� �.��f� .��c�z�� B;t��� ������3�
��t 1.�� p ��i. �i� �ut��T`�� ��lQG ��c�rn °�2(� c�f ��I�r�i���`��� G�� �.�i 1c���.�� aC.���
�ti��t. ��a�� t'�i�.z� ����a ����a� �r�s.d�� :b��t� xri�r.��fa�rs px����t ��C��t�d �'�i��:
hc�ir�� �j�ir�c�s, I)aas�� ��csr�,. ���v� �c������ ����z�� �'�i���r� ���rr�
��ha�t,r�n re�u���.�i���:��� �`r�°� �ar�ic�pa���n �n'the h����z�. �zns� ��7�� �ac� ��°E. �n��d��[��i�
t���.h� zn��i�r: �.s�i�E��� ����F r�.�.tr��a��� �t �ils�r�n `�iras �r�s€�nt as ra��x�t �.�sua���l tt�'Ch�
��s�r�. I �c- ��r��� ����.�X�t �i�t�er►�� r.e�zr:���.�t� ����r�z���t�� c��' �.�c��+�
T�'����, �{�.�n��� �"�h.�i �a.ed r e�irf� �nG�t� -�r �uic� �:���vi ���ua�c��, ��'�����5+.� �,�����t!'��. I
��',�c�� 1����'�� 1a�+1�e�, ���i��� �C� c�t' �iae �rc���t� ��ii�r�4���i���s ����e:��� �r��,t��xi�
,�Ss��c��at��i .I I�1,� ��.��t�l�� �erv��� �o�c�r��t��ri ��1;{� �:���,r�c� ac �e 1��,��za�
re����x���c� ��.���i ]��.��a's��3 ��'�,fi�t�rn� �`�'�.��s�ne ,P�� I
���tI�I�G�
i:. ��nii��pc�li� ���t���i�s_����usii�.� ��.���,����r�gr� l�� ���r�s ���tt�i� ����ll�tig
�r��tt:s� €i�� ���e ���2i���� b��' l��aci�ii� �:ia #�ie �it;r �t ����x��a�tsiis, �s.s�,��� `�a������ �:s
�y+id���.e� ���t �.h� .�:c�rpar�lzca� a�id �ac��s�ir�r ��e+���� ��dr��itt��� ��i �ea���.� ��=�I1 l�a� .�?.�,�ri�
t�stii��rr�,�, �s a �z�a�t��l;, �'+7t�� ��S hrt��1'i�r ��}���r 1r���=�cd Mi������p�li� ����r�i'�t�n��
Housing Association I LLC. Minneapolis Apartments Housing Association I LLC hoads a
ciurent iental license for the subject property, acquued the property in November of 2005,
and is listed in propetty records as the applicable ffixpayer of the propetty. Minneapolis
Service Corporation LLC is ihe listed owner of the properry. By teirns of' the appeal
notification submitted in this matter the license holder concedes that both firms az•e the
operating owners of the subject property and that the Jaweeds are tUe pc�incipals of each firm.
The rentai license for the p�operty on file with the City of Minneapolis contains the notarized
signature of Terri Kanis accepfing responsibility as the property manager responsible for the
maintenance and management of the renta] property as required under M.GO. 244.1840(3):
Every applicant, whether an individual, paztnership, or coiporation, shall identify
in the application, by name, residence DI' tlllSlllC3S street addiess, telephone
number, and date of buth, a natural pecson who is actively involved in, and
iesponsible for, the maintenance and management of the premises. Said natural
person shall, if other than the owner, �x his or her notaiized signature to the
application, thereby accepting joint and several responsibility with tha owner
(including any potential ci•iminal, civil, or administrative liability) foc• the
maintenance and management of the premises.
2. This matter w�as commenced by the SAFE unit of'the Minneapolis Police
Department and the Department of Inspections to revoke the rental dwelling license held by
Minneapolis Apartrnents Housing Association I LLC for ihe property at 729 S�h Avenue SE,
under Minneapolis Code of Ox�dinances (M.C.O.) 244,2020. Section 244.2020, "Conduct
on Licensed Premises", requu�es a rental licensee to tuke appropiiate action following conduct
on the piemises defined as disorderly under Section 244.2020(a). Specifically included
witUiu the ambii of' disoidezly use is "conduct by tenants andtor their guests on the licensed
premises which is detetmined to be disocderly, in violation of (provisions] which prohibit the
unlawful sale or possession of cont�•olled substances."
2
i
i
3.. Notice of the iecommendation to revoke the license was mailed to Minneapolis
Apat'tments Housing Association LLC, Minneapolis 5eivice LLC and Teiri Kanis at their
supplied mailing addresses on May 23, 2006.
4. On January 27, 2006, Minneapolis Police officers and the Metro Gang Suike
Force executed a narcotics search warrant in Unit #10 at 729 S�' Avenue SE. The seaz�ch
wazrant was obtained based on a successful conh•olled putchase from the aptutment of a
quantity of a substance that tested positive as crack cocaine on January 17, 2006. Cocaine is a
schedule II controlled substance as defined by Minn. Stat.. 152.02, Subd_ 3(d)). Possession
of cocaine violates Minn. Stat. 152.025, Subd, 2(1) and the sale of cocaine violates Minn.
Stat. 152.024, Subd, 1(1). When the officers made entry to Unit #10 they encountered Che
tenant, Raynard Relfry, and numerous other individuals. Duc•ing the subsequent search of the
premises va�ious crack pipes, metal pushers and btunt spoons were seized. Foui' tablets of a
presc2iption medicine were located without a prescription or bottle. Several of the individuals
in the unit admitted to smoking crack cocaine. Duting the execution of the wanant, three
additional pazues walked into the apartment and Nu. Belfry asked how long the officets had
been watching lum before admitting that he regularly smokes crack cocaine. Mr. Belfry and
three other occupants ofthe unit were cited on misdemeanor disorderly house charges under
Minn, Stat. 385.170,
S. On Febivazy 7, 20D6, Crime Prevenrion Specialist Carol Osterhuis of the
Minneapolis Police Department mailed a First Notice of Conduct on Licensed Premises to the
listed owner and iicense holder of the huilding, pursuant w M,CA. 244.2020. This notice
informed the rental license holder that there had been an instance of disorderly use at the
premises of 729 8w Avenue SE, Unit #10 culminating on January 27`� involving possession
3
of nazcoflcs, The notice was rewrded as a first notice of disoidec•ly use of the premises,
informed the license holder that steps should be taken to prevent fiu4her violations, and.noted
that fiuther disorderly use could result in the denial, revocation, non-renewal or• suspension of
the rental dwelling license. The notice oited M_CA_ 244.2020(a), infoiming the license
holder that it is a licensee's affirmative responsibiliry to take appropriate action following
disorderly use by persons occupying the premises.
6.. The first notice was mailed via certified mail to Mi�uieapolis Service
Corporation LLC as well as to the owner address that Hyder Jaweed supplied on his rental
license application. Certified mail receipts were ret�ed conficming the delivery and receipt
of the notices.
7. On March 27, 2006 Minneapolis Police officers and the Metro Gang Strike
Force seived a nazcotics search wan'ant in Unit 1 at 729 8�' Avenue SE_ The search wazrant
was obtained a8er a confidentiat reliable informant provided extensive infom�ation regarding
narcotics storage and trafficking at the premises. Additionally, police officets i'eceived
numeivus complaints reguding tbe alleged pervasive nazcotics deaiing upon the premises and
conducted surveiilance which eorroborated the information ptior to obtaining a search warrant
from the distc•ict court. Upon setving the wari•ant in the unit, officers entered the premises and
encouniered two ocoupants- Terrence Ervin was discoveied in the kitchen with a quentity of' a
substance that tested positive as cocaine in his front pockek. A male was encountered
in the living room and a quantity of' a substance that tested positive as cocaine was seized next
to him on a sofa. $95.00 in ctuT�ency was seized from his person and an additional $95.00 was
seized finm the love seet. Both parties admitted to knowing the tenant of the unit, Angeia
Lee. Upon fiuther questioning Mr. Eivin conceded that he utilized the apaztrnent to sell crack
I
a
I
I
cocaine. Both occupants were az2�ested on narcotics chaz•ges pursuant to Minn. Stat. Ch� 152.
Cocaine is a schedule II controlled substance as defined by Minn. Stat. 152.02, Subd. 3(d)).
Sale of cocaine violates Minn. Stat. 152.024, Subd. 1(1).
8, On March 28, 2006, Crime Prevention Specialist Cacol Oosierhuis of the
Minneapolis Police Department mailed a Second Notice of Conduct on Licensed Pi�emises to
the owner and iental license holder as well as to Teni Kanis, the appointed property manager,
via certified mail and pursuant to M.C.O. 244-2020. Although the notices were correctly
addressed to Minneapolis Service Cotporation LLC and to ihe address peisonally supplied by
Ms. Kanis on the notarized and executed rental license application, the no6ces were retwned
unclsimed. CP5 Oostethuis additionally telephoned Ms. Kanis and a�ranged a meeting which
occuned on Maz•ch 28, 2006 with Ms. Kanis and the owners at which time they wete
personally informed of'the incidents, the notices and the requirement to submit an approved
management plan.
9. The second notice advised the license holder and property manager that a
second incident of disorderly use had occiuied at the subject property and that they were
required to respond to the Mumeapolis Police Deparmient within ten Q 0) days with a written
management plan detailing all actions taken to respond to disorderly use and to prevent
fiuther disordetiy use of the premises. M,C.O. 2442020(d) &(e) provides:
If another instance of disorderly use of'the liaensed premises occuis within eighteen I
(18) months, if the premises contains betrveen one (1) and six (6) distinct and
sepazate residential units, or within twelve (12) months, if' the pi�emises contains
more than six distinct and sepazate cesidendai units, of an incidcnt for which a
norice in subsection (c) was given, the responsible SAFE team shall notify the
licensee by mail of the violation. The licensee shall submit a wtitten management
plan to the SAFE team within ten (10) days of receipt of the nouce of' disordeily use
of the piemises� The wiitten manasement plan shall detail all actions taken by the
licensee in response to all notices of disorderly use of the premises within thc
preceding twelve (12) months, The written management pian shall also detai! ail
5
t
actions taken and proposed to be taken by the licensee to prevent further disorderly
use of the premises. The notice provided to the licensee of the violation shall inform
the licensee of the requirement of submitting a written management plan That notice
shalI fiuthet infotm the licensee that failure to submit a written management plan
may result in the city council tal:ing action to deny, refuse to renew, revoke, or
suspend the license...
(e) When required by paragrapL (d), ihe rental dwelling license for the premises
m$y be denied, revoked, suspended, or not rcncwed if the licensee faiis to
submit a written management plan that satisfies the requirements set forth in
paragraph (d).
10. No representaUve of the licensee submitted a written management plan in
response to the Second Notice of Conduct on Licensed Premises.
i 1. Additional police narcotics-related incidents occurced on the renial premises on
Apri16, 2D06 (narcotics search warrant executed in Units #2 and #1Q cocaine i•ecovered) and
May 8, 2006 (narcutics seazch wazrant executed in Unit #2, cocaine recovered).
12. On May 23, 2006 a Notice of Revocauon, Denial, Non-Renewal, or
Suspension of Rental License oc Provisional License was sent to the license holder of the
premises via the owners of the building and the rental property manager. The notice advised
that both the Inspections Division and the Minneapolis Police Departinent would recommend
to the City Council that his iental dwelling license for• 729 8�' Avenue SE be revoked. The
recommendation was made puisuant to M.C.O. 244.2020(d), based on the conduct on
licensed premises inoidents and the failure of the licensee to submit a written management
plan. The notice was served via certified mail and a receipt was i�etutned confiiming the
delivery and receipt of the notice by Teai Kanis and Minneapofis Apardnents Housing
Associates I LLC.
13.. On June 7, 2006 the licensee filed a proper appeal of the revocation
recommendation via a wiitten submission from Minneapolis Apartments Housing Associates
I LLC and Minneapolis Setvice LLC signed by Hyder Jaweed. The Licensee, in its appeal
6
I
i
and in testimony adduced at the hearing in this matter, conceded that the disorderly uses of the
premises had occun•ed but claimed that they pursued eviction and voluntary termination of
tenancies. The evidence indicated that these actions were not undertaken unGl after the
underlying incidents had occumed and after the 10-day timefrarne had expired in which the
licensee was required to submit a wcitten management plan.
14. The incidents of disorderly use that occurred on and about January 17 27, �I
2006, and March 27, 2006 are instances of disorderly use within ihe meaning of M.C.O.
Fucthermore the licensee failed to submit a timely vv�itten management plan in II I
244.2020(a)
relation to these incidents, as required by M.C.O. 244.2020(e).
CONCLUSIONS
1. Two incidents of conduct determined to constitute a disoideily use and defined
ts occurred on the remises of
as disorderl in M.C.O. 244.2020 a by tenants and/or gues P I
Y
729 B�' Avenue SE for which pmper notices of disorderly use were issued,
2. The licensee failed to take timely, appropuate action in response to notices
from the Minneapolis Police Department concexning disorderly incidents on the premises of
729 8�' Avenue SE.
3. The Minneapolis Police Depaztment and the Inspections Division followed the
appropriate procedural steps and provided the necessary notices as required under the
Minneapolis Code ofOrdinances.
4. The licensee failed to comply with the requuement of M.C.O. 244.2020(d) i
(e) which requires submission of a written management plan within ten days of issuance of' a
second notice of' disoTder•ly use. This failure pinvides an independent basis for adverse
I
i
,i
license action, specifically inclusive of revocation, against the rental dwelling license held by
the licensee at 729 8`� Avenue SE.
5. The subject propeity has been the source of repeated criminal, disorderly and
nuisance activiry. The activities aY this property have had a substantial negative impact on the
surrounding community, es evidenced by the testimony and documentation admitted from
neighboiing residents and community members and the occutrence of numerous additional
police responses to narcotics aclivity at the premises.
7, The rentai dwelting license held by Minneapolis Apaztments Housing
Association I LLC for 729 8�' Avenue SE is subject to revocation or suspension under M.CA.
244.2020(e). Revocation of the xeferenced rental dwel(ing license is the appropiiate
adverse license sanction.
RECOMMENDATION
That the cental dwelling license held by Miuneapolis Apartments Housing Association
1 LLC for the premises at 729 8`� Avenue SE, in Minneapolis, Minnesota be revoked.
l
Bcian Bushay
Chair,
Rental Dwelling License Boacd of Appeals
8
Request for City Council Committee Action
from the De artment of. Re ulator
S
ervices
p 9 Y
Date January 3, 2007
To Public Safety Regulatory Services Committee, the Honorable Don Samuels,
Chairperson
Referral to City Council
statement-729 8 Ave SE Owner Dr.
Rein
Sub'ect Rental Dwellin License
9
5yed Raza, University Courts apartments, LLC
Recommendation: �n August 9, 2005 the City Council revoked the rental dweliing license I
held by Hyder Jaweed, Asgher Jaweed, and Teri L. Kanls dba Minneapolfs Apartments
Housing Associations I, LLC, for the property located at 729 8 Avenue SE. pursuant to
Section 244.2020 Conduct on Licensed Premises, The property was recently purchased by
Kara A. Bronner; University Court Apartments, LLC..
The Director of Inspections recommends that the City Council reinstate the Rental Dwelling
License at 729 8 Avenue SE to Dr. Syed Raza; University Court Apartments, LLC. Dr. Syed I
Raza has corrected all housing maintenance violations and has submitted an acceptable
management plan to CCPSAFE. The property now meets all required Minneapolis Housing
Maintenance Code standards. (See enciosed inspector, CCPSAFE statements).
Previous Directives None
Prepared or Submitted by Janine Atchison, District Supervisor 673-3715
APproved by:
JoAnn Velde, Deputy Dir�., Housing Inspection Serv. Date
Approved by:
Henry Reimer, Director of Inspections Date
Approved by:
Rocco Forte, Assistant City Coordinator Date ;''I
Permanent Review Committee (PRC) Approval Not Applicable XX
Note: To determine if applicable see htto://insite�nance/nurchasino/oermanent-review-committee-overview.aso
1
Policy Review Group (PRG) Approval Date of Approval Not Applicable XX
Note: The Policy Review Group ls a committee co-chaired by the City Clerk and the City Coordinator
that must ceview all requests related to establishing or changing enterprise policles.
Presenters in Committee (name, title)
Financial Impact (Check those that apply)
XX No financial impact (If checked, go directly to Background/Supporting Information).
Action requires an appropriation increase to the Capital Budget or Operating
Budget.
Action provides increased revenue for appropriation increase.
Action requires use of contingency or reserves.
eusiness Plan: Action is within the plan. Action requires a change to plan.
Other financial impact (Explain):
Request provided to department's finance contact when provided to the Committee
Coordinator.
Community Impact (use any categories that apply) Not Applicable
Neighborhood Notification
City Goals
Comprehensive Plan
Zoning Code
Other
r I
Permanent Review Cammittee (PRC) Approval Not Applicabie XX
Note: To determine if applicable see htto:lfinsite/Finance/ourchasinolaermanent-review-committee-overview.as�
Policy Review Group (PRG) Approval Date of Approval Not Applicable XX
Note: The Policy Review Group is a committee co-chaired by the City Clerk and the City Coordinator
that must review all requests related to establishing or changing enterprise policies.
Presenters in Committee (name, title)
eck t
hose that a 1
Financial Impact (Ch pP Y)
XX No flnancial impact (If checked, go directly to Background/Supporting Information).
Action requires an appropriation increase to the Capital Budget or Operating
Budget
Action provides increased revenue for appropriation increase,
T Action requires use of contingency or reserves.
Business Plan; Action is within the pian. Action requires a change to plan,
Other �nancial impact (Explain):
Request provided to department's finance contact when provided to the Committee
Coordinator.
Community Impact (use any categories thet apply) Not Applicable
Neighborhood Notification
City Goais
Comprehensive Plan
Zoning Code
Other
Background/Supporting Information Attached
See: Findings of Fact
j
i
F d Cl
ty of Robbinsdale
4100 Lakeview Avenue North
Robbinsdale, Minnesota 55422-2280
Phone:(763)537-4534
Apri121, 2004 Fax: (763) 537-7344
www.robbinsdalemn.com
HJ 22 LLC
#3Blue Spruce Court
North Oaks, MN 55127
Attn: Mr. Lee Jaweed pE�OY
Dear Mr. Jaweed: �t
i
The City of Robbinsdale has become awaze of an uncorrected or insufficiently repaired
violation to the Housing and Maintenance Code (IIlVIC) at Robinwood apartments at
3848-52 West Broadway. Also, as of yesterday, there were no copies of the rental
dwelling license posted in each building as I directed you to do recently.
The incomplete repair is at 3852 Unit 3. The problem involves water damaged tile and
materials behind the tile in the plumbed wall at the bathtub surround. The material behind
the tile has deteriorated from water resulting from either a failure to keep the tiles sealed
adequately, or perhaps a water or drain line leak. Subsequently, about 10-15 tiles are very
loose and will fall out exposing framing to water when the tub is used. Repairs have been
started but not completed in a timely manner.
The access panel for the tub plumbing is warped and needs re laceme
currently off. Repairmen allegedly came to this apariment with no prior not ce at 9 PM
recently and were denied access because of the late hour and no prior notice to the
occupant.
Please refer to the enclosed copy of HMC 425.21 Subd 4.
Please remove aIl loose tiles and repair the backing material with annroved tile backin�
material at 3852 Unit 3. Renair or renlace all water damaeed or decaved wood or other
materials. Verifv that anv nast leak has been located and repaired. Install tile. and then
reQa the affected area, sealinQ all eans in the tile surround. Install a new plumbin�
access nanel in the adiacent closet. Due 10 davs.
Also, please refer to the enclosed copy of HMC 425.31 Subd 7. Please nost a conv of the
rental dwellin� license ner 425.31 Subd 7. Due 10 davs.
The underlined sentences above constitute a Housing Order from the City of
Robbinsdale. You may appeal the order. Appeal information is enclosed.
An inspection is required to verify compliance with both of the above. I request that you
meet me at the property to show me the corrections and the posted license locations you
prefer. I reserve the right to reject them and require other locations.
One reason I would like to meet you onsite personally, is that since your purchase of the
property, the City of Robbinsdale has` received a variety of compla.ints about the
management from city residents who:.. ]�v,� there, These include: failure to respond to
complaints, failure to repair :in a time ly �anner, }�ia bi li t y, to contact a res ponsible repair
or management person, failure to respon d to..gener a l inquiries about your management,
e+tG'. r�
I would like ta review with you the method by which you prefer to be contacted when the
City of Robbinsdale does get involved with complaints that may not be resolved in a
timely manner.
..4 Yi I.
Please ca11 Eileen Keener at (763) 53�1" �68 within the next 10 days to set up a time for
me to meet with you, discuss these iss���a�nd verify the completed corrections.
'.p �:��u_
.a �'_qj. ��a��.: C.A....
Thankyou, t.,Y
..:�e����.
Brian Ringham f„=�:
Housing Tnspector
City of Robbinsdale s
-�r.=.
k=
�;'t�
r �..}T
t t� p
aalt� MFF4���. 7.��
.L�
..i:l�
I.
4 1..,��..
iE
�i
-rP�-
r
MEMO FILE INFORMA.TION
3848/50/52/54 West Broadway.
COMMENT
"H:\demo photos\brkn block.jpg"aum#6 3854 763/ 533 6615.
nope. she cleans only.
instead:
Tim blake at sunshine mgmt. 3850 #6 tim blake and
?wendy? 533 2600. ALSO: 300
johnson pkwy st paul, 55106. all these new as of
5/04. BR
evelyn at 535 1979 relays complaints from
residents. she calls increasingly as
things fail to get done. BR verified trash
accumulation from 3-4 residents,
learned that no pickup by randys in 2 weeks.
randys told BR there was a hold on
service. possibly not paying the bill. now
essentially no caretaker onsite and
no mgmt to contact. phone mail box is full
continuously. owners may be out of
country with no person in charge here. another
renter today wanted to move in
and could find no one to give her a key.
allegations of d hecks bouncing
at rnove out.BR 8/31/�
10/5/04 several CC meetings with unresolved
complaints as important issue. CC
considered and decided to hold off on revocation
of lic. BR directed to sum up
conditions imrovement of situation at apts every
two weeks. there have been
some but at latest CC�mtng CC became fed up with
contd complaints and ordered
marcia to contact city atty and one lingering
plumb repair to be resolved within
48 hrs. no rep from mgmt at this CC mtng.BR
suggestion that if no revoke, then
maybe as condition of renewal (assuming progress
on repairs) apt by apt
inspection 8 months early 100% of units be done
prior to any renewal. CC didn
not require that.
t,� 1` homeline and mgmt join forces to stop city being
�v
first to hear of com laints.
P
winter of 04/05 had several rubbish problems some
ended up with citations to
jaweed.
2/28/05 caller reports overcrowding at 3850 #6
with those apt kids running amok
in halls. reports 5 living in a 1 bdrm apt. BR
7/10/05 callers report stench at 3rd floor 3850,
laundry room with missing
flooring for 2 months, loose handrail at ext
steps, failure to repair minor
items, standing water in stariwell after heavy
rain, etc. only some is true
after BR went to see. times exagerated. mgmt still
has problems, call by amy
gonyea who is stepping in to help mgmt respond
and correct problems better. her
I 612/290 6680.
repeat calls re: 3852 #14 about sewer back up in
kitch and sewage at carpet.
smells, rec'd call from caseworker re: same unit.
meeting out there the next
day on 6/27/05 to assess carpet cond after
I cleaning. see compliance order dated
today
1/31/06 ken hertz atty 612/ 325 1161 3853 central
av NE colombia heights, MN
55421 represents owner. requests duplicate app
after owner has rented w/out
license durng january 2006. mailed 1/31. disputes
double fee. $1590 w/ fire insp
I fee
rather than dispute need foz double feewe are j
issuing license fo�..one year. on
back of licesne issued is additional quarterly
inspection req'd during 2006.
��1.
�v ���cy;
n�
�-r���
I
City of Robbinsdale
4100 Lakeview Avenue North
tember 1, 2004 Robbinsdale, Minnesota 55422-2280
Phone:(763)537-4534
Fax: (763) 537-7344
www. robbinsdalemn.com
HJ 22 LLC
Attn: Lee Jaweed
Box 120728
New Brighton, MN 55112
Dear Mr. Jaweed:
The property you own, lrnown as Robbinwood Apariments which is located at 3848-54 West Broadway
remains in violation of the Robbinsdale Housing and Maintenance Code (HMC).
Several past housing orders for various units have not been corrected and are overdue for inspections to
verify completed repairs.
The issue of repeated non compliance for past orders is especially troubling due to the fact that most
current uncorrected issues are longstanding complaints from residents and not from past renta.l inspections.
T'here has been a succession of onsite managers at the property as well as long periods with no effective
onsite management.
Some examples: a metal flue cap that still sits atop one building visible from West Broadway. It weighs at
least 5 lbs and could be blown by wind off the roof only to fa1125 feet down to a sidewalk and eniry door. I
asked you in April to have it re secured to the existing flue. The correction would take a maintenance man
about 5 minutes. It has not been done in about 5 months. Several onsite managers have been made aware of
it during that time.
Apartment 3852 #6 has had a missing bath ceiling and electrical problems for perhaps 6 weeks. When the
toilet above is flushed, toilet runoff comes into his bathroom below. The current onsite manager you hired
recently had never been advised of the problem or my order for repair within 10 days until I asked about it.
By that time the work was overdue and as of yesterday, no effort had been made to begin corrections.
Because of such unresolved problems and the failure to manage the property according to HMC standards,
the Robbinsdale City Council will consider the suspension or revocation of your rental license at their next
meeting.
The meeting will be held at 7PM on September 7`�, 2004 at Robbinsdale city hall. You may wish to present
reasons why such a move should not be taken at that meeting.
Sincerely,
Brian Ringha.m
Housing Inspectar
City of Robbinsdale
City of Robbinsdale
4100 Lakeview Avenue North I
Robbinsdale, Minnesota 55422-2280
Phone:(763)537-4534
Fax:(763)537-7344
www. robbinsdalemn. com
September 2, 2004
Lee Jaweed
HJ 22 LLC
Box 120728
New Brighton, MN 55112
Dear Mr. Jaweed:
The Robbinsdale City Manager has determined that the accumulated rubbish at the
Rpobbinswood apartment complex located at 3848-54 West Broadway constitutes an
emergency situation under Robbinsdale City Code section 2021.01 Subd. 6.
There is no appeal period in such a case, and an abatement of the rubbish accumulation
has been ordered to take place immediately.
The owner will be billed for all related costs. If the invoice is not pa.id by the due date,
then the amount shall be a lien against the property and the amount plus an administrative
fee shell be collected as a special assessment as provided for by Minnesota Statutes, I
chapter 429.
Thank you,
Brian Ringham
Housing Inspector
City of Robbinsdale
SE P. 13. 2004 3: 39PM RANDYS_SAN I TAT lON N0, 033 P. 1
4351 U.S. Hw�,�. 12, S,E. Randy Sandy Roskowiak
P.O. Box i 69 (763) 972-3335
Delano, MN 5:;h328 Fax (763) 972-6042
��itit�tlOtY
INC. i
r ����...k-
\J���
r' I
FA� M.ESS,AG�,
1 t
�o: �oe. �1��
Cox.�n par�y: �i f�� o� �o G�
Fa�c� 7�3 5,37 73
Fro�-,m: K exri Jon es
Da .�Fe: 9� 1�3 -D
T�e (,�OCUmenL accompany��g this fax con�atn co�z�dential in�ormation which as legally pr�veleged.
If yo�,i are noc the intended tectpient you are hereby nori ,ed that any disclosure, copying or
distri<<>ution f che concez�u o�this celecopied ir�formatior� exce�t �ts direa delivery to the intended
recrpia�nt ,�amed above is strictly prohibited.
�Tatal number of pc�ges: o�
.n'lessa E��: �6�nwc�d,
C` OF R D p
��.,:,1'
,..�1`�
JU
���0�1�
If a,(I pag�u are not recezved or f document(s) are r�ceived zn error, please eo,�tac� person Iisted above.
lt's a plensure doing business with you!
i
�R�amtly Owned Operated Since 1979
RESiD.t�NTiAL COMMERCIA�. ROLL-OF�S RECYC�(NG
A�aaSEP. 13, 2044 3:40PM RANDYS_SANITATION �ttE, N0. 033 Q/l3P� 2 Page 1
!)se�:-e�ecttt CtJSTUh�R ClfARSE 6ET'AFL 16:1Rt24 Oataset: RS
Cc-Cust�: i-OI05658 C:ITT DF ROBBINSDALE Periadt F�o� 9,+0210A To 9/10/Q�
Auto 81t1
te__ TYee Fnva;j�e� 5z Cg �esc�tetton______ Qty Mnnth5 dnauat User____ Peri�
U
410210� CN� 72�524 YK AP 1�A5NER� DA1�ER� REFBI6ERATOR 3.00 120.00
9103/04 CI{6 72;�52� WO �WIP Z-¢�'D F� TRASH TAEQKS 8 Blll
9l03/44 CNE 72"a�5Z4 FX f!1 OUMP 21bYD FL 145{1 �,44 115,00
4fQ3/W CH6 7Y�,52� HENN CO!lNTY 5NIl61 FEE 15.75
4I03104 CH� 72a;524 qN 90LI� WA5TE 1l6ItT TAX 17,Ob
9l03l04 CN6 7Za'".5Z4 FR E6, YpISI EXTAA 6AABAGE b,00 T0.50 a�I
4/Q3/44 CH6 7Ze:524 f�EtN CDt?NTY 5iIN6�t FE� 6.��
4/03J0� Cff6 72�`5?9 !f� SOLID iiASTE �96MT TAX 6,81
9/42/P4 CHG 7Z�`53�+ MQ DU14P 6-�b6 CARTS TDDAY AND $XI,C
4/QZl04 Ctf6 T2Z"��0 RX MI b-906A1 CARTS �.00 3A,40
4lQ2/04 CN6 77.�'S�Q HENl9 CDURTY 5N1l6T FEE q,gp
9l�2/04 CH6 72�:�30 �t11 SOLID iiASTE fl6�4T TAX 4,BB
4�02iO4 CH6 7z�'�30 RX E6 YDt5} EXTRA 6AABA6E 3,00 35.25
4�42lQ9 C}i6 71l;530 HENN C�3UNTY S F
�A
6T �E
3�f7
9(�02lQ4 CH6 72��30 MPI SOLIfl NASTE IS61lT 3'Ax 3.44
9/02lA9 CfE6 7z�;�30 RX !91 I�iAIR d DESk 1.00 39.44
910210; CN6 7'2x!SIO HENk COUN�Y Si1MCT FEE 3.5�
4/OZl04 CHS 722!i30 MM SQLID wASTE h6MT TAX 3.A0
554.Q6 Cu�rent
TR7Al; �559.08
.�Y., F� 4 �I�
��r
�i�
City of Robbinsdale
Request for an Invoice
Bill To: Robinwood Apartments Date 09/15/04
Address 3848/54 W. Broadway Cust 5470
Robbinsdale, MN 55422
Company
(Finance will complete.)
Pending Special
Assessment (Y/1� NO Finance Dept Info: If yes G/L Offset PEND
AmouIIt t0 be Bllled Remark (Will be printed on the Invoice) Revenue Account
559.08 Garbage Pick Up for 9/2 9/3/04 (Emergency Abatement) 5470.4512
50.00 Administrative Fee 5470.4516
Attachment Info: Faxed to Toni Gaines Burgundy Ridge Apts. 651-776-9533 (9/15/04)
(Can be printed on Invoice if
requestedJ
(Attach addieonal sheet if
necessary.)
Requested By Engineering Date 09/15/04
Give to Finance to bi1L
i:\forms\Request for an Invoice Nuisance Abatement 3848-54 W. Broadway (9-15-04 Emergency Trash Abatement)
":itti s�( [in!>l�i��scl;ile
PAYMENT REQUEST
PAY TO: Randy's Sanitation, Inc. VENDOR
ADDRESS: P.O. Box 169
4351 U.S. Hwy 12, S.E.
Delano, MN 55328
AMOUNT ACCT NUMBER DESCRIPTION INVOICE INV DATE''
120.00 5470.6334 Garbarge Removal; (W/D, Refrig) 722529 9/2/2004
I 291.53 5470.6334 Garbar�e Removal 722524 9/3/2004'
147.55 5470.6334 Garbarge Removal; 722530 9/2/2004
Robinwood Apartments 3848154 W. Broadway
559.08
H RIZED SIGNATURE
AUT O
TOTAL
DUE DATE RELATE CODES (1099) CK 99
SEP CHECK DIVISION AP DISB
F
City of Robbinsdale
4100 Lakeview Avenue North Robbinsdale, Minnesota 55422-1898
Phone (763) 537-4534 Fax (763) 537-7344
September 3, 2004
Robbinwood Tenants
On Tuesday, September 7, 2004 at the 7 p.m. City Council meeting, the City Council will
receive information regarding our action this week to have the gazbage collected at your
building. There were also some concems earlier in the week regarding the building utilities
which if not addressed could cause the city to revoke the building's rental license.
At this point, it is our understanding that arrangements have been made with the gas company.
The city is not planning on shutting off your water service. As long as vital services aze
available to the building, the city would not make you leave your homes.
The city has rental license inspection that requires certain basic services including provision of
heat, water, electric, and basic life/safety matters. It does not address cosmetic maintenance
issues or other non-life/safety issues. Our inspector did tour the building today with your
building manager to view progress on work orders. Outstanding work orders aze for units that
are not currently available for rent. Those units cannot be rented until the work is completed..
Our expectation is that at the Council meeting, the council will detemune whether additional
action is necessary to help maintain essential services to your homes. There is no consideration
of condemning your homes.
The meeting on September 7�' is open to the public. It is held in the Council Chambers at City
Hall located at 4100 Lakeview Ave N. It is also televised on cable channel 16.
Sincerely,
2Gcc.�
Mazcia Glick
City Manager
;1
%�3Z l
CITY OF ROBBINSDALE RENTAL HOUSING INSPECTION
COMPLIANCE ORDER
3848-54 West Broadway 1
Date of Inspection: 9/15/2005
Items below are due completed within 60 davs unless otherwise indicated. See
Notes below.
Items in bold type are safety or health related. Corrections are due
immediately.
•**Items are primarily the responsibility of the renter. Corrections are due within
10 davs unless otherwise indicated.
Please call (763) 531 1261 within 60 davs to schedule a reinspection to verify
that corrections due are completed.
Apartments inspected with no HMC violations: 3848-16, 3848-19, 3848-7, 3848-
4, 3854-19, 3854-18, 3854-13, 3854-14, 3854-11, 3854-7, 3854-1, 3854-3, 3854-
6, 3848-21, 3848-18, 3852-20, 3852-16, 3852-7, 3852-9, 3852-13, and 3850-20.
3850-9, 3850-1, 3850-4.
6 Units have not been inspected as of 9/15/O5: 3850-17, 3850-7, 3850-18, 3850-
10, 3850-13, 3850-3. These are to be scheduled as soon as nossible durine
Sentember. Any corrections needed will be then sent by mail to owner
�.��t��
Repair loose plumbing blocking for tub spout (3848-18) i
2) Locate and repair roof leak over front door. Due 10 davs. (3848-18)
3) Replace worn, missing, c�ogged, or to� (foam) air filters at apartment bathrooms.
(All units). Due 30 davs. i
-�j-"Tighten up loose handrails at stairs. �xamples: 3848 north mid level, 3848 Y
south lower level,
S�`�tepair replace smoke detector (3848-20) 1C `�c N lZ i�
4
4 6j--£lear stopped bath drain. (3848-20) Due 3 davs. Work order in progress.
��z�i> =��---�istall missing fixture globe at kitchen light. (3848-20) ��b,��;�'� �i�-��-' +�i4`;���
$�-�Remove, replace ar tighten up loose ceiling fan. (3848-20) Due 10 davs.
Replacement with a light fixture is acceptrble.
Install deadbolt lock at entry. (3848-1) Due before occunancv.
Remove stains from bath tub. (3848-1) Due before occuvancv.
Repair smoke detector. (3848-1) Repaired during inspection
-�Repair or replace hallway light. (3848-1) Due before occunancv.
l�'`*Clean bath floor and all plumbing fixtures to a sanitary condition. Due 10 davs.
3848-2)
l�j"**Clean interior exterior of kitchen appliances, countertop, and adjacent walls
and floor to a sanitary condition. (3848-2) Due 10 davs.
1?- 3} Repair replace t -2)
`L r Y r�`.� k
I, �,1,, =^°r L�� i k-5 ?l;' L, y v
i
1,
i�
��rim back expanding foam at toe kick of kitchen cabinets to be flush, then install
trim piece or caulk to cover any remaining gap. (3848-2)
��}-Repair replace smoke detector. (3848-3)
��rj-Replace leaking water heater at boiler room. Plumbing permit required.
(3848) Unit is corroded throu h�t its base and seepage on slab below was
observed. i`4 ti:,� ,.l r; L'
19 Locate and repair water leak abov„ stained tile at lower level hallway ceiling of
3848. A coin sized dark hole in tile is soft from water damage. See Notes.
�6 jRepair several broken or disconnected gutter downspouts. Examples: SW corner
of 3854, NE corner of 3850, several at central yard, etc. j� �"l 4
3��-jRepair replace damaged front door. (3$54-15) Due before occuuancv.
Repair trap leak at kitchen sink. (3854-15) Due before occunancv.
�Repair replace hallway light (3848-15) Due before occunancv.
Repair replace smoke det�ctor. (3848-15) Repaired during inspection.
2�5 Repair damaged kitchen power vent. (3854-20)
�KjRepair replace smoke detector. (3854-20)
**Continue and complete the recently started cleaning of kitchen appliances,
plumbing fixtures, utensils, food preparation surfaces, adjacent walls and floors,
insides of cupboards and drawers to a sanitary condition. (3854-16). Due 30 davs.
Repeat violation from last inspection 2003 See 28-31.
24}**Continue and complete the recently started cleaning of bath plumbing fixtures
and adjacent wall and floor surfaces to a sanitary condition. (3854-16) Due 30
davs.
=-�9} **Vacuum all carpet. (3854-16) Due 30 davs.
-�}**Remove excessive storage. (3854-16) Examples: stacked boxes and storage
that prevents nopmal room maintenance, blocks access to windows and outlets,
impedes the movement of air and operation of doors, An estimated 85% of the
floor area was covered with some type of storage and rendered rooms unusable.
The bedroom could not be entered due to excessive storage. Due 30 davs.
**Remove extensive rubbish from apartment floor and storage areas such as
closets. (3854-16) Due 10 davs.
32) Locate and repair roof leak that reportedly seeps into kitchen cabinets.
(3854-17) See Notes v Mr
G ��Replace wax ring at toilet. (3854-17) Sec� also 41 below. `�Z�� l,�<�•ic-� i-��
3� Repair replace reconfigure adjust reinstall the windows, seals or weather
strip at living room.. (3854-17) Due 2�J davs. Windows allow rain to enter
F �,.�apartment, r. rt
t; ;z water damage�d l. Repair any damaged drywall below the window
(Storage and birdcage blocked view ofsonze damage.)(3854-17)
-�,j Install3 missing cover, plates. (3854-17)
�7�Repair replace smoke detector. (3854-21)
--38 Reinstall grill at kitchen power vent. (385�-21)
39 Re air re lace smoke detector. 3854-22
t ti` P P
-�#8) Install trip waste cover plate at tub. Seal gap at tub spout to tile. (3854-10)
r�4�� Repair bath ceiling damaged by water. (38�4-9) See 33 above Due 10 davs.
��j Replace damaged hallway door. Upper level3 floor north 3854. r
y
1`�t3 �i\\•�'ri.� t,nt; �1LL
v`
•-��.,ocate and repair water problem at cold water line to kitchen sink. (3854-8) Due
20 davs and before anv new occut�ancv. Renter vacancy renortedlv imminent.
Pressure is dramatically reduced after 3-S seconds of operation of cold only. A
similar pressure drop is reported at the shower but was not confirmed.
44 Repair bath ceiling damage from prior leak. (3854-12) '�r G�'�� G�� ►�T'��i�
45 **Remove excessive storage from apartinent. (3854-5) Due 10 davs. Examples:
jeep topper, car doors, car top carrier, multiple bicycles, car tires, numerous
boxes and containers stacked against ►valls and piled on floor in a way that
prevents: access to outlets, windows, and normal room maintenance.
�4 **Remove extension cord wiring used :n lieu of permanent wiring. (3854-5)
v 47 Repair replace smoke detecto.. (3854-�2) Repaired during inspection.
t
*Clean spilled and driea food from kitchen range, adjacent walls, counter tops,
refrigerator exte: and power vent. Due 10 davs. (3854-2)
��*Clea.n interior shelves and walls of refrigerator to a sanitary condition. Due 10
da
-�8) Replace smoke detector. (3854-4) Alarm sound is too fain�
�-1�°Reattach loose kitchen faucet. Due 20 davs. (3848-17)
�5� **Clean spilled food from range top and burner shelf below it. Due 10 davs.
(3848-1�7) ��t-���'�" �I
53}S�op water leak at kitchen cold tap. (3�848-15)
-�4) Repair /replace leaking refrigerator. Due 30 davs. (3848-11)
--55� Re lace broken control knob at radiator heater. (384$-11)
p
-36 Re air replace torn carpet (hole) at n�rth mid level step at landing 3848.
P
��Repair leaking windows. Due 20 davs. (3848-6) See Notes `�n"�
-�.,.��Refinish damaged window sill. (3848-6)
y 59 Clear all roof scuppers blocked by leaves and leaves and debris. Due 3 davs. See
Notes k
�Repair F loose or disconnected electricai conduit bushings on roofs. Damaged
bushings were observed at both roofs walked upon.
Repair replace torn or partially disconnected exterior flue metal at boiler flues.
Due 30 davs. Defects were visible at all buildings except 3848 from atop other
buildings. All flues should be inspected for adequate connections due to
past repairs that appetrr to have deteriort�ted.
Replace torn toilet seat. Due 3 davs. (3852-22)
�63 Repair drip leak at hot tap at bath tub. (3852-22) �i z�i.� r�V; ���c.�n�i� i
:�4�Replace bath GFI outlet. (3852-18)Uriit did not rip wherl tested with GFI
tester.
-�-Replace broken ceiling tile in hallway near entry to 3852-18.
-bb) Repair loose blocking for tub spout. (3852-21)
Install grill for kitchen power vent. (3852-17)
f�) Repair steady stream leak at bath faucet. (3852-17)
`6 Repair trip waste at bath tub. (3852-19)
�70 Repair replace kitchen range. Oven fails to ignite. (3852-15)
�1)Repair small living room wmdow and refimsh damaged sill. (3852-15) Window
reported to leak during rain. See Notes t< k
`f°���z`
i -,�:�k`� j,� �...d, iZl�-! t� t� i�.,( i7 �,-�j�,,i� C��:
°y 4 4 �1..� 4 "�4�u�G �ti"!'�
l
j
�ii
t` �.�(7� Repair damaged bedroom window. (3852-15) Sash drops hard when raised.
Books were used to prop it open. Children live in apartment.
�Reset rocking toilet. Due 10 davs. (3852-15)
l '�4}Scrape and paint (portions) of peeling bath ceiling. (3852-15)
i�r�;;
75 Locate and repair source of repeated water leaks at living room windows and also
living room ceiling. Refinish water damaged sill and portions of ceiling. (3852-
w �a� 11) See Notes. �ri�_`, L t; t,�`_:=
�}Patch open holes in sidewalk between 3850 and 3852 around manhole cover. Due
30 davs.
Replace carpet and pad at dining room. Clean and seal concrete floor of dining
room prior to r' stallation if odors penetrate to slab. (3852-14) Due before anv
new occunancv. A ight musty odor is claimed to linger in this area despite
carpet cleaning and d'e�dorizing by contractor. A plugged kitchen drain that
backed up in recent past c2z�r�sed the damage. Clean up was delayed for several
days at the time of the back Contractor's efforts have proven inadequate
although no damage is visible. A�'�quntertop with odors and water damage was
replaced rather than repaired per ciry�r�dder. Apartment is to be vacated soon per
manager. Seaming new (dining area) carp�o as to avoid replacement of living
room carpet is acceptable to city inspector.
��'j' open gas line at kitchen range under replacement. (3852-10)
Complete toilet installation in progress. (3852-10) Due before occunancv.
j�? �=$0 Replace damaged hallway ceiling tiles near entry to 3852-13.
�-Repair leak at bath faucet. (3852-12)
-�}Install missing grill at kitchen power vent. (3852-12)
$-3}Caulk large gap at rear of tub surround(3852-8)
-�4� Install electrical outlet to bath per State of MN Electrical Code. (3852-8) Due 30
davs.
Scrape and paint bath ceiling. (3852-5)
�j Scrape paint repair deteriarated ceiling access panel over bath tub. (3850-11)
t�` Repair drip leak at tub. (3850-11) i r„ t t� t.�
�..��5�8 �-.t �.,�i �-t e� \�s�����t_,�c�
�-8�&}-�tepair flatten replace metal tack strip that penetrates carpet at entrance
to kitchen and bath. (3850-15) Resident has other longstanding carpet issues
that were brought up during the inspection but are not actual HMCviolations.
��epair adjust replace living'room windows that are hard to operate and cannot
lock ar tilt without excessive fore being used. (3$50-15) Due 20 davs.
-98j-�ither patch tile at tub where soap dish is broken off so it is water tight, or install
a new soap dish and caulk grout as needed. (3850-19)
-9-�-�) Add an electrical outlet to bathroom per State of MN Electrical Code. (3850-19)
Due 30 davs.
Repair smoke detector. (3850-19) Repaired during inspection. 'ti'�
9�`) **Clean interior refrigerator shelves of spilled and dried food. Also clean food
splatters from exterior of appliance, adjacent counter top and adjacent rear walls:
(3850-16) Due 10 davs.
Tighten up loose GFI outlet at bath. (3850-21) Unit wobbles in its electrical
box.
I ti �.��`t, t �c.t�,� i L t;
d
ins immediatel inside an
Locate and repair any leak above dry ceiling sta y
outside apartment entry door in hallway. Refinish affecte� axeas to match •;t
surrounding materials. (3850-22) See 1Votes.
ree up 2�f 4 windows that do not operate properly. (3850-14) Due 20 davs.
4 ��Repair living room windows. (3850-12) Due 20 davs. Sash falls from track and
operation is diff cult. ;1;�� ��C� %t�L"�� �t, w�"
-9$rj Reinstall cover plates off for painting, Adjust and clean ceiling fan. (3850-6) Due
before occupancv. Vacant unit with repairs in progress.
with faint alarm soun
d. Re air
-�Repair-�at bath tub. Rep��e�-smoke detector p
refinish da�aggd living room wall. Due before occu�ancv. (3850-2) Cap open
gas line at kitchen range. Due immediatelv. (3850-2) Vacant unit with repairs
in progress.
3'68}�-*Clean toilet, adjacent floor and walls to a sanitary condition. (3852-2)
-�9�1� Complete floor refinishing project at laundry room 3850.
ric�r ti�c�-��� Clean and reattach loose dryer venting at laundry room 3850. a s
����Scrape and paint bath ceiling. Re texture of affected ceiling is not required. (3850-
6)
3�4-)Repair replace smoke detector outside bedroom #2. (3850-6)
OS eplace smoke detecto�r with faint alarm. (3850-3) A flammable plywood I
splatter board with burn marks was wedged between the kitchen range and the
refrigerator. It was removed from the apartment by the housing inspector as
considered a fire hazard. ``�Z�� �r' k�
i
Notes: Building roofs may have some roof leaks due to deterioration or back ups
clogging scuppers. Conditions appeared to mdicate Either as side flashing appeared to
show interior layers. Professional evaluation of roof condition may be warranted after
scupper backups are cleared.
Numerous windows leaks were reported by some occupants. Many apartments were
vacant and may have same problem although no one was present to report it during
inspection. Window operation was tried only when problems were reported. Owner
should take this into consideration when in apartments doing corrections.
Owner is encouraged to bleed air from radiators especially at top floor in advance of 'I
2005-06 heating season as needed. Air bubbles had resulted in reports of lack of heat I
during 2004-OS season.
Thank you,
Brian Ringham
Housing Inspector
City of Robbinsdale
r`
City of Robbinsdale
4100 Lakeview Avenue North
Robbinsdale, Minnesota 55422-2280
ITY OF ROBBINSDALE RENTAL HOUSING INS�,zs��
COMPLIANCE ORDER W �-robbinsdalemn.com
3848-54 West Broadway ��INSPF�Td��: 1 ��7
Date of Inspection: 9/23/2005
Items below are due completed within 60 davs unless otherwise indicated.
Items in bold type are safety or health related. Corrections are due immediately.
**Items areprimarily the responsibility of the renter. Corrections are due within 10 davs
unless otherwise indicated.
Please call (763} 531 1261 within 60 davs to schedule a reinspection to verify that
corrections due are completed.
Three apartments were inspected with no HMC violations: 3850-3, 3850-8, and 3850-10.
Several aparlments were inspected today because they could not be on 9115/O5: 3850-
17, 3850-8, 3850-18, 3850-10, and 3850-13.
Two units were inspected today due to recent or continued plumbing backups reported to
the City of Robbinsdale: 3854-4, 3852-14.
l� 1' 1 L u C� C"�, iv�l �its�J' a�t`.,�
1�Locat�nd repair water leak that has damaged the living room wall. Replace water
damaged drywall then prime, paint and refinish to match surrounding. 3850-18. Leak
appears to originate at AC condensate drain.
�'j' Replace bath tile or missing soap dish. Regrout to match surrounding. 3850-17.
3) Repair replace kitchen range. 3850-13. Oven reportedly will not ignite. Service or
replacement is reported scheduled per maintenance person. 1 v$'`� �'w+ f�;� `�G E�
4) Install missing bedroom window screen. Due 20 davs.
5) Repair living room windows. Sashes are out of tracks and they also drop hard when
lifted. Due 20 davs.
•�--Remove several grocery carts from dumpster area. Due 10 davs.
Repair loose (short) handrail at 3854 south entry.
8) Clear any obstructions or make any repairs needed at drains, vents at this apartment or
�-�E�� any adjacent apartment to eliminate kitchen sink back up problem. 3854-4. Due 3 davs.
t��" This unit and one above had sinks ftlled with water, and then drain plugs were pulled.
Inspector observed back up of soiled drain water into 3854-4 sink as it slowly drained.
Reported iwice by resident. See Note.
Note: A bath tub back up was reported at 3852-14 similar to item 8. Inspector and maintenance
person were not able to recreate the reported back up by running water into tubs at #14 and unit
above running 10-15 gallons of water total. Despite this, mechanical drain cleaning on a
building wide basis by a professional contractor seems warranted. The volume of drain backup
related complaint calls to the City of Robbinsdale has increased in the past few years especially
during 2005. A more proactive, regular drain maintenance program is strongly recommended to
avoid similar problems and interior damage. Also see item #77 from 9L15/OS inspection.
Thank you,
Brian Ringham
Housing lnspector
City of Robbinsdale
"1
City of Robbinsdale
4100 Lakeview Avenue North I
Robbinsdale, Minnesota 55422-g280
Phone:(763)537-4534
Fax: (763) 537-7344
CITY OF ROBBINSDALE RENTAL HOUSING INS�+
COMPLIANCE ORDER
3848-50-52-54 West Broadway
Date of Inspection: 6/23/2006
Items below a�e due completed within 60 davs unless otherwise indicated.
Items in bold type are safety or health related. Corrections are due
immediately.
•**Items are primarily the responsibility of the renter. Conections are due within
10 davs unless otherwise indicated.
Please call (763) 531 1268 to schedule a reinspection to verify that corrections
due are completed or apartment(s) indicated have become accessible. I
Reinspection time is tentatively set aside for 10:00 on July 6 Notify residents
with corrections due below of scheduled reinspection at least 24 hours in advance.
Units inspected today include: 3848-2, 3848-3, 3848-10, 3850-3, 3850-4, 3850-
13, 3850-17, 3850-10, 3852-2, 3852-8, 3852-19, 3854-5.
1) Remove urine soaked newspapers on. floor then clean all bathroom surfaces-
walls, floor, fixtures, cabinet, etc. to a sanitary condition. Ventilate room as
needed to remove odor. Clean with TSP or equal then prime with Kilz or equal •'�I,
then repaint roor� if needed to remove odor. Due 10 davs. (3848-2)
2) **Remove excessive newspapers stored in bags and piled up in entry area and
bedroom so that floors are cleanable walkable with access to outlets and
windows not impeded by storage. (3848-2) See Note below. Due 10 davs.
3) Repair smoke detector. (3848-10)
4) **Make apartment accessible to apartment manager by reinspection date. 3850-4.
Key lock had been changed by resident and o,fficer manager had no access.
5) Repair leak at cold tap at tub. (3850-17)
6) Locate and repair electrical short inside bath light or its electrical box, then I
replace fixture. Install a new electrical outlet in bathroom if new Gxture does
not contain an electrical outlet. Install missing cover plate at entry light
switch. (3850-13)
7) **Remove all storage from floor, vacuum carpets and broom clean all hard floors.
(3852-2) Due 10 davs. Spilled, spoiled, cooked uncooked, and dried food, cat
food, cat droppings, dirt, soiled kitchen utensils, excessive storage and piled
clothing blocking access across rooms, and blocking operation of some doors was
observed in the apartment. No litter box was observed. See Note below.
8) **Clean all kitchen surfaces including exterior interior of appliances,
countertops, walls adjacent to them, interior of drawers, utensils, etc. to a sanitary
condition. (3852-2) Due 10 davs. Reinspection of this apartment will include
inspection of kitchen drawer interiors and undershelf (below burners) of kitchen
r�ange, operation of kitchen and bath plumbing, verification of proper operation i�'�
and grounding of kitchen and other outlets, etc. None were accessible at
inspection due to conditions present at the time.
—9) **Remove stored furniture that blocks the route to bedroom windows and outlets.
Remove all storage from central hallway and in front of closet door. (3852-2)
Due 10 davs.
10) Auger out the slow flushing toilet. Replace toilet if augering fails to clear
slow flushing problem. (3850-19)
I1) **Complete the overdue removal of excessive storage in apartment. (3854-5) Due
10 davs. Closet door and radiator were blocked from access. Windows at living
room could not be reached. Some outlets were still not accessible. An estimated
80-85% of the of living room floor area is used for storage.
Note:
Please find enclosed copy of Robbinsdale Housing and Maintenance Code (HMC) 425.11
Subd 24 (i) refers to overcrowding of apartments with storage.
Laundry appliances are inoperable in 3850. Replacement is pending per manager. Please
ensure that operable appliances are present and available to residents before the
reinspection.
Thank you,
Brian Ring�ham
Housing Inspector
City of Robbinsdale
I
G
I
s,.5� r
'k,� ,.,,{"`�F �o- .��"c*' ;�r s�
f ��I�
NY��
�a� �"7�k�� `����C :1 b 5� j u��y'�' t t t
a y �Am r.? r
a "4� ��a t t h w.� i
i
r "�Y��� ,-y y„
C w. �s
ri� �"�s.
F y
b �'�,'`,_�.y�' f`� 5
�i
.uk_ 7 ,t' '=�'m '�2S
i a �+u�, �'i .�r r rvr
aa� r s J v
�7:� �'r ;ax �?.9:��f �t��t�sr'a Y �tsID� �"t�" s
a��-� .7 �.,e+.w y Y� �'t 8 f t
i 1 z� `7 N �q v
T
�r ���f-�d r� i
fi
�et�
c�
a.t;; a
n, t y Y9
,r ,t'�,�
s
r: t
�Lf
i�
"�'�'�i
t,�
�.�.:3
a- ,,,,.�,.a� fi F
..s r�' r `1
d w f t 1
a
o,
,e5'#. �F*.� a �i M yny
K �'j M1
d4°
f p r c +.5�_�� �+A t �S�. P at h '`�l �p i
w� e" dy'i°vM�� ry ��u�Y� P
i 5 k�f a
a �u�'� &e r 6:
�fi� t S r
i k #a� „�,�1� F
t a.:�
6
a
I r
i
y
n °C a r �r,€- a 1
'a Y ��'�a.. F i�" r a �e.i f
u
�i
I �j 1
.�.�y� s �����'o
Y ;e A` d q k� q �,�1� ��u�{'i
w i
�.3vY }r. y :P' },Y�
N
y
7 �y�,
4 M+
ew^ u
y I i�
s
u
es>
.t
r' r
"�a
1 W4 Y
4
:ef 1,�,_ z y �,{,e Sil I
x
�k k�tn
k
Ws�~
4 3
�VF' a �i
1 i�'
W
�I` s k�r� i
i
b
f r
N
Y k l" NtiYr. y
't�`� ��S 3
if .'.'�4 .:i�. ,�4akYe
P. YM F. 1:y S y-'� �ax "�X b" h�P"�, s r y n.y'
�'P J N i" T�L ie�X q N; K�IF
g� a; l �4 t
,;�u 9 m�s cr�
k ,C;�,�� j� f
Y
�z,. 2 S 4° kr 3��'1r 5 z�� W it 4: �`��,k��' t rf.� d-e r,..
t!?��' -r,� 2`t� s �x,x s�S�r
.,z, r rz' �����a u�������, i
:r...
t fi '�k
r y k'�'{.l��f� k7 a''} t i
s i a 3 ✓s. g s aTS. �C
p o n y c
W �r 3 k A �.h�+��8 ��C� 1���� :L3 "i,�
f
y ��s�� .c����
s N t c �i t
3 N f 3 `.f if�r-�'
'��.��,°'T,�`����'1�� r
Kfi
�R N
t ����t �E'
'�'I �'G �4 `5'�.
t
F T MT`U�i
d4�� 4 f�
��t �x- t
)i 5Y 7 �.s�
k�, d
d
r,fbl
z� s' x��,�� ��,������a�"�' F
�a rt w�? a �r„���- ��r
3
'��,�c��'r
i
d�fl�9Y,�F �t r ...i..
S "1+�� �1� H.
����?��F��
s
w �r
t
m v ,�w i �s5 r
��''�i
5 e�; z� a� �w a����
i�T y ��`S Y .�y. w���` i� 1P r.
`3 t .X+Y-
4 .�-5
y I l ,y Ip
r ,�„4�� raza a,,��'" I �I
a° a�� �.s
k�s� r��
7 4 SF t (f�' �Y
P L Y
b W
,'i" "6 s t, 'z k
s �kk S, t
t
s
N Y 3� Y"�c��4 �y,a P�v �W"
L
��n y:[ 'TC^n,f d'.€��' i 1
F f
Y P ��A3�
e)�
PV"�
�b:.ik: f
i�� ����I��������� �I�I§"
i j i y,I�� I�
1 I il �i
y R 8
Z�`�
y����,.
krc a
I
i
I
sea I
c u i xx
M,,. a if a
I
�u
<4 a
E
n j
i
d x^+.+�
.Ai•t ar y '�y.
q,,, �s� �.,�"�`'..m' '�L.,� ��'S+
dt
.r
d t
a
x 4 Y' A
1
c� 4.� s a' r
e
a w g �2
"'x x' k
4
a� �r
a'
CF iR�T 3 .C�' 'P'
.k b
f Y' `sf J -4 r
�f v �z
r p
q+ f X �r� 3
a y 2
i �4 F ,4 g Y' T4�� �dl"
t .y�� �'�t�� t� c7 g'Gaa,N,'��
f 1 V' f''` }v- 'L" �J I T Y
4 ,x -I�i a ��'����a2v..�,�r���t
�'tS�3 S s �£z} �`s y,ara #h. i�
i q rR" r 1 R `w a 9.:.
f �f F w �T �a���� �4
y ,#E I y N z
ay
'R 1 k 4 f r� i a Y !h-�� "�i `2t �t �k. S�- y e
�Z
t +,f t '�r��'cY �"�k' `#�x
�5 e�' g,
f {s^ s a" r r ."°�N�' �'x�
i x i i F� i� M
F +3 F i �S 3 4g^ ka� t'� t �i��
t t #'3�r� a '�`+`f'
-c�a ,x
�j� t,, x' s- a t t� •'3�,�, 4 s
4 �Gq a� Kji�.r. a..e i a*- „4" x f �t9,�� 2��-...
7 �"�'WF i i j S. �t,�k �'Y;�� V
k ���€r 3 �c.�
y{ f ��a {3� f�� 5' x ax"'�` ''�'E�u "-k,� 1.3+��'i+"��`��a�.
�d t t �r 3�� 5 �i 5�k� a a� �s�:
r e k s.�����Z� "t� 'Yl a i� 4
Y y� y �"�s,� r H .��d k a� a �+t'�
tr.' s t` t ��T�' :r 9 t x
N Y �5 S"� 4 Fs t t�r.'§ [.r�.
y s' �y u,: Ra h`� a �ts'
.yb¢ i �'����+�f t
t:� t ;i� �'�'i c� ac`a.
1. �4s a cK 'k{�f'��S
y� 1S T, ^,�4�' `.t'`�«
y a fr t d i
�C Y �S 4 y� t
F 4 {p t y L �'�3 9
q
x I f x� ��."w�3k• t
1 d �'4 1. g li'%�'
L 3�N �,�'4
3 j t �f""'� y �-i'-&�4�"
iy�yr{ 4�f`"'r� e ��..��t a��axZ x�
y t a�# ti �'�a� 9�`�� 9 p �r
b` n a r�� y�� 3 t
p��� �ktrs -��Sp�'�-^x,�'�'��s� �2 t�d� k'x
i y t r,° s°� �R� -r �ya, M �r.
��x x�i �y?k y t
g r x y� '�5 ,n"�-;
,,p�ais�a``I3 ,r� F ��"i���� 1 �s ���4i3;
s� w 7�'�
S '4£ q Sy }K �`4��x��' �tr �'3T� �.E Q �f
E x x c�` d Wy �k"� "r'1
r r4 -x�.t',*��Fx ss .st ^"x
+a zfta rt��� "'s���v�� �s�`; x `s�' r�r 'a�'�,}"'�` -a
w a
�4 ,�'�S.' k h�' �Sr y r Y Y A
y
x,
>f ��'.t,s i�
4 �C. W N Y f n. 'y� �n
�bdv
�E "�`r.,
E
�e`a�°;� t�- s, �s�`� �s,�
x �v y y eF 'L�.
s *r r F y b.. t �.�'1k:� r
t �e P�. a M,� ta ra r f l, 4
�ti w r,,. t ��,_t
1v y?js. k d,l f ,�4 x ;a .t
�f rw,�
j r�
�'�y� ���F�� 1
rk�r` r�" �f 1i'�I Jr f s
t f t R f �,�'�p�./�^' 1
4.�� P s 3 tf.., i 1 a i
4��
k. 1 f t i y
p §,�j e �,�F '`R ,�N ".y". ;f
{i .`Y Y�, "a
4 Y �y'+� ti
V ry
yy py� a... k p�
ir
'P,
k Y
u
h.
�t.,
.a C' .7
x h� �ii� .C� ti�`
q�
j r �&�r 1
t f p'�
k, e
M "4f' �t*.." .ik, y=
t '1. {i v y
f'd?.. T7 I
4
r
��z�`�� r
1Y� J
a �e� yj/ 1
��`��}i i t �4�e�",p�a�al+.`� M..�
q, h
4 A '�4 l5) #4
r.� Ty Y 9;'.
4+. rA�:" y f i
Y t "E li 11
Qr. t r t�.; a I
��v��l
k l� y
P y� �6 w
A �pr�,
-0
A.' y X
"r i �,�y.' �x
�Y
T"p°i i
gm±; r t i I
a*.q C ar n y, �u.
`�G"S?,r. .a. 0.�4,�'
�k
y �M
k �FS'sE SFi� f ��y,,. 2 5 �I 14 i
a
z F "'br 4
�M-y�{.� W� 9.E� 4 Y
JP a,�` °4k' x ,k: s.
Po a �YT
4 �������5. �'�'�YG
��kM w�
;'i�
9
u�,
�r
y i`jn��
i x
b�.e so�;;,�`�, k
r.
��i
:::�7,,�
W
F
i
.F�.�;�
s *sy, F
a���� r .�,�yv
t�..� c`
��r�., t l�
�a
,e�: `��A,
�m._
..�y-
;rt
�':3
3
'e
r
t
a4«�''.
4" �e
l
��x
x
r
I,�-
�kzz��s;��f t f t
i''``�
i
T` �'t�
�`.t- ,"i.._ i %i_ i
v`f
`t, ._,c C. i'.`��., f-
c,�.i a
F
1. ..=.1 t:
+�!�1`
I
Joe Yancey
�ubject: 3850 West Broadway
Status: Not Started
Percent Complete: 0%
Total Work: 0 hours
Actual Work: 0 hours �+��G
Owner: Joe Yancey 1�"j �1 0�
Robin Wood Apts. A�'i"�, ��T
Per Evelyn c�r �"k'�� C 0 IZiZ��
They removed the carpet in the laundry room and there is still mold on the floor
Smells
r
��_,k „�`;L
t r 4',
c °e"
1 aµF
1
`�,7
i
I.
�f
CITY F `OBBINSDALE RENTAL HOUSING INSPECTION
3848-54 West Broadway �.ao�
Summary of Incomplete Corrections Q�
Date of Reinspection 2/7/06 a
�lz�`tz�r�
R ..�'L 4,
f
Symbol means correction is incomplete.
Italics are notes from 2/7/06 or as other dates irzdicate.
resident is responsible rather than the owner
Added 2/7/06: Some new HMC violations were observed 2/7/06.
symbol indicates incomplete corrections that affect more than one apartment
such as water leaks.
Repair loose plumbing blocking for tub spout (3848-18)
Added 2/7/06: Repair kitchen power vent, replace unsafe AC cord, repair I replace
leaking showerhead (3848-20)
Added 2/7/06: Repair replace counter top. Locate and repair water leak (faucet)
causing damage. Clean repair replace damaged materials inside sink cabinet
and wall behind. (Photo) (3848-2)
Added 2/7/06: Plumbing permit application required for new water heater
installation at boiler room by contractor. Remove old heater and dispose of it.
(3848)
Repair damaged kitchen power vent. (3854-20)
Locate and repair roof leak that reportedly seeps into kitchen cabinets. (3854-17)
(Photos) Repuir crew was deniec� for a time �er mgmt. No rnof repciirs have been
done. Note photo of deterioruted prumbing soil vent cup which mcry not be related
to this leczk bu.t needs replacement.
Replace wax ring at toilet. (3854-17) Uriit clirectly above is (3857-9)
Refinish water damaged sill. Repair any damaged drywall below the window.
(3854-17) Correction begun but incomplete 2/7/06.
Repair replace smoke detector. (3854-22)
Added 2/7/06: Reattach loose ceiling panel access to bath tub trap for apartment
above. (3854-10)
Repair bath ceiling damaged by water. (3854-9) Ceiling repuir rvas begun nnd
remains incom lete be ore the loose tvilet was reset at upartment ubove. (Photo)
P f
Added 2!7/06: Resident complaint that windows leak in rain and wood sill is
decayed (Photoj
Repair bath ceiling damage from prior leak. (3854-12) (Photo) Ceiling repair not
uccepted and leak has occurred since repair.
I
•**Remove excessive storage from apartment. (3854-5) (Photos) Note: occupant
was never notified by the building owner of the violation 9/OS and came in to
discuss issue w/ inspector. An additional 30 clays was extended.
•**Remove extension cord wiring used in lieu of permanent wiring. (3854-5)
Additional 30 days due to recon�guration removal of storage.
Repair replace smoke detector. (3854-2) Repaired during original inspection
9/O5. Detector was disabled again on 2/7/06.
•**Clean spilled food from range top and burner shelf below it. (3848-17) Note:
same condition on 2/7/06. Resic�ent refused and claimed that condition was there
when he rented unit 18 months ago. He considers it owners' responsibility.
(Photo} Warning notice issued and left in icnit prior to receiving this resident
information about move in conditions.
Repair leaking windows. (3848-6) 1 of 4 windows sashes dropped hard when
opened 2/7/06.
Clear all roof scuppers blocked by leaves and leaves and debris. (Photos)
Repair drip leak at hot tap at bath tub. (3852-22) Shower water diverter
malfunction observed 2/7/06.
Added 2/7/06: Restore heat system to operate as designed. (3852-22) Rac�iator
fan is inoperable. Resident using oven to heat apartment. Manager rvas awure
and awaiting parts or service technician.
Added 2/7/06: Repair replace smoke detector. (3852-22)
Repair trip waste at bath tub. (3852-19) (Photo)
Repair replace gas oven. (3852-15) Pilot is on but gas burner failed to ignite on
2/7/06.
Repair damaged bedroom window. (3852-15) Sash clrops hard when raised. Same
condition as 9/O5.
Locate and repair source of repeated water leaks at living room windows and also
living room ceiling. Refinish water damaged sill and portions of ceiling. (3852-
1 I) Observed spray paint 2/7/06 at ceiling spots that 12ac1 water stains, and no
attempt to repair water damaged sill.
Added 2/7/06: Locate and repair tub trap leak at apartment bathtub above.
(3852-11)
Replace damaged hallway ceiling tiles near entry to 3852-13.
Added 2/7/06: Repair 1 of 2 damaged dryer vents at laundry room 3852.
Repair living room windows. (3850-12) Sashes still drop hard and would full in
operation 2/7/06.
Clean and reattach loose dryer venting at laundry roam 3850. (Photo) Repair not
accepted 2/7/06.
Replace smoke detector with faint alarm. (3850-3) Note from 9/O5: A flammable
plywood "splatter" board with burn marks was wedged between the kitchen
range and the refrigerator. It was removed from the apartment by the housing
inspector as consiclered a fire hazard. Note from 2/7/06: Key was not available so
no access. Unit needs 1" reinspection.
1
Locate and repair water leak that has damaged the living room wall. Replace water
damaged drywall then prime, paint and refinish to match surrounding. (38�0-18)
Resic�ent request for clelayed reinspec.tion until ur�it is vacant 3/ 0 6.
Repair replace kitchen range. (3850-13). Note 9/O5: Oven reportedly rvill not ignite.
Service or replacement is reported scheduted �er maintenance person. Note 2!7/06:
Occupant pushed against unlocked door and would not allow management inspector
access or speuk with them despite posted reinspection notice. Unit needs 1�" reinspection.
Repair living room windows. (3850- 17, or 8, or 18, or10, or 13) Do not have correct
unit number in my notes. I
Clear any obstructions or make any repairs needed at drains, vents at this apartment or
any adjacent apartment to eliminate kitchen sink back up problem. (3854-4) Apartment
had kitchen sink back up when apt sink above was drained. Not reinspecte�l.on 2/7/06
and needs to be in attempt to confirm correction. Aparttnent manager could not confirm
repair was done.
fi
::.,r-
o �r
CITY OF ROBBINSDALE RENTAL HOUSING INSPECTION
COMPLIANCE ORDER
3848-50-52-54 West Broadway
Date of Inspection: 6/23/2006
Items below are due completed within 60 davs unless otherwise indicated.
Items in bold type are safety or health related. Corrections are due
immediately.
•�'*Items are primarily the responsibility of the renter. Corrections are due within
10 davs unless otherwise indicated.
Please call (763) 531 1268 to schedule a reinspection to verify that corrections
due are completed or apartment(s) indicated have become accessible.
Reinspection time is tentatively set aside for lO:OQ on July 6` Notify residents
with corrections due below of scheduled reinspection at least 24 hours in advance.
Units inspected today include: 3848-2, 3848-3, 3848-10, 385Q-3, 3850-4, 3850-
13, 3850-17, 3850-10, 3852-2, 3852-8, 3852-19, 3854-5.
1) =r* Remove urine soaked newspapers on tloor then clean all bathroom surfaces-
walls, floor, fixtures, cabinet, etc. to a sanitary condition. Ventilate room as
needed to remove odor. Clean with TSP or equal then prime with Kilz or equal
then repaint room if needed to remove odor. Due 10 davs. (3848-2)
2) a`*Remove excessive newspapers stored in bags and piled up in entry area and
bedroom so that floors are cleanable walkable with access to outlets and
windows not impeded by storage. (3848-2) See Note below. Due 10 davs.
3) Repair smoke detector. (3848-10)
4) *�Make apartment accessible to apartment manager by reinspection date. 3850-4.
Key lock had been clianged by resiclent und o�cer niunager hacl i2o ctccess.
5) Repair leak at cold tap at tub. (3850-17)
6) Locate and repair electrical short inside bath light or its electricai box, then
replace �xture. Install a new electrical outlet in bathroom if new fixture does
not contain an electrical outlet. Install missing cover plate at entry light
switch. (3850-13)
7} �*Remove all storage from floor, vacuum carpets and broom clean all hard floors.
(3852-2) Due 10 davs. Spilled, spoilecl, cooked uncooked, and driec� fvod, cat
food, cat rlroppings, dirt, soiled kitchen utensils, excessive storage an�l piled
clothing blocking access ucross rooms, and blocking operation of some doors was
ohserved in the apurtmerit. No litter box rvrls observe�l. See Note below.
8) **Clean all kitchen surfaces including exterior interior of appliances,
countertops, walls adjacent to them, interior of drawers, utensils, etc. to a sanitary
condition. (3852-2) Due 10 davs. Reinspection of this cepartment will ificlude
inspection of kitcheii �lrawer interiors cand undershelf (below burners) of kitchen
range, opernti�n of kitchen and bath plumbing, verificntion of pro�er operatio�i
r��
and grounding of kitchen and other outlets, etc. None were accessible at
inspection due to conclitions present at the time.
9) **Remove stored furniture that blocks the route to bedroom windows and outlets.
Remove all storage from central hallway and in front of closet door. (3852-2)
Due 10 davs.
10) Auger out the slow flushing toilet. Replace toilet if augering fails to clear
slow flushing problem. (3850-19)
11) **Complete the overdue removal of excessive storage in apartment. (3854-5) Due
10 davs. Closet door and radiator were blocked from access. 4Vindows at living
I room could not be reached. Some outlets were still not accessible. An estimated
80-85% o the o livin roam oor area is used or stora e.
f f S f S
Note:
Please find enclosed copy of Robbinsdale Housing and Maintenance Code (HMC) 425.11
Subd 24 (i) refers to overcrowding of apartments with storage.
Laundry appliances are inoperable in 3850. Replacement is pending per manager. Please
ensure that operable appliances are present and available to residents before the
reinspection.
Thank you,
Brian Ringham
Housing Inspector
City of Robbinsdale
January 19, 2007
West Broadway Court LLC Attn: Mr. Jaweed
3 Blue Spruce Court
North Oaks, MN 55127
Dear Mr. Jaweed:
Based on my inspecrion reinspection yesterday at apartments 111 and 110, the following
le Housin
and
Housing Order is issued under section 425.33 Subd. 5. of the Robbinsda g
Maintenance Code (HMC) on the next page. There is no provision for appeal under this section
and correction is to commence immediata�ly.
To recap the problem, there appears to be one or more breaks in various sewer lines, perhaps
e caused re eat backu s over the course
of the
other drain waste vent abnormalities that hav p �p
m
nse was as
late
ast week. Initial res onse was tardy, being reported on the 11 or 12 and respo
P
P
at the 16�' with carpet not pulled up adequately to dry materials as late as the 18�`.
T'he actual extent of dama e is unlrnown and ma have preceded your purchase of the properry,
S Y
re orted b a licensed lumber. Your
drains have been seen b video camera and y P
but dama ed y P
g
contractor(s) have cleared the lines but no damage has been repaired yet. Residents have had
carpet and padding pulled up and it is being dried, but the problem could re occur any time, and
plumbing repairs are the current priority. Backups did reoccur 2 days apart.
Other apartments may have damage. Residents may need to have apartments assessed and also
ma need to minimize or sto water use during repairs. Notice to other residents should start
Y
P
immediately.
Enclosed (by fax) is a list of plumbing contractors that are licensed to work in Robbinsdale. Any
plumber you contract with that is not on this list must obta.in a city license prior to application for
the repair permit.
If you have any vacant apartments you may need to use them so residents affected have access to
plumbing facilities during repairs. Other facilities may need to be provided for your residents.
T'here was no rental license posted n the entry of 4259. The 2007-08 rental dwelling license was
mailed to you a week or so ago and is required to be in the lobby.
I would like to be kept informed daily by your contractors to (1) ascertain the extent of damage,
and (2) be kept abreast of the repairs once they commece so that additional requirements that may
be needed are lrnown to the Building Official and so that resident inconvenience is minimized. I
informed Eric, your representative, of the basic requirements yesterday as we left the building late
in the day.
I am required by ordinance to inform you that failure to correct will result in penalties described
under HMC 425.37.
Thank you,
I
Brian Rin ham
g
Housing Inspector
City of Robbinsdale
Do not remove this notice
Housin� Order for 4259 West Broadway.
All items due immediately unless indicated otherwise
1) Video drain waste vent lines (DWV) to ascertain breaks, bend, dips, or
other abnormalities that are causing, or may cause, sewer backups or drain
leaks. Extent of damage may affect apartments other than #110 and 111.
Natify residents as needed.
2) Under permit, have a licensed contractor open walls floor slab to locate and
repair all damage so all DWV work as originally designed. Follow all
inspection requirements per permit.
3) Ensure that HMC 425.17 Subd. 1 and 425.25 Subd. 2, 3, 4 are met for all
residents of 4259 West Broadway during repairs.
4) Remove all water damaged carpet, pad and wood tack strip as directed by
the Robb
insdale Housin Ins ector. Reinstall new material on OK from City
g P
Inspector. Reinstall acceptable e�sting floor covering on OK from City
Inspector. Expose underside of existing materials as directed prior to any re
use.
5) Reglaze broken window at #110. Correction is overdue. Repair time extended
for 10 days. Tape required over jagged edges immediately.
6) Post rental dwelling license for 2007/08 or copies showing ownership
information in both entry lobbies. Maintain license posting during 2007/08
license period.
Thank you,
1/19/07
Housing Inspector
City of Robbinsdale
•W,
CITY OF ROBBINSDALE RENTAL HOUSING IN5PECTION
COMPLIANCE ORDER
4259 West Broadway
Date of Inspection: 3I27/2007 REVISED ITEM #7 4/11107
Items below are due completed at reins�ection (see below) unless otherwise indicated.
Items in bold type are safety or health related. Corrections are due immediately.
**Items are primarily the responsibility of the renter. Conections are due within 10 davs
unless otherwise indicated.
Please call (763) 531 1261 within 30 daUS to schedule a reinspection.. Apartments 212,
portions of 209, #108, and 105 are required to be accessible and will be inspected at that
rime. The interior of all garages are required to be accessible and will be inspected at that
time also. Notifv all residents of reins�ection date. Key problems resulted in inability to
inspect the areas listed above on 3/27.
The property owner was contacted by phone and informed regarding unit 201 (gas leak)
and #103 (plumbing problems) during the inspection.
1 R air broken door lock at rear entry. Due 3 davs.
2) Remove all rubbish from the property extenor. Due 10 daUS. Examples:
accumulations near dumpsters, behind garage, north property line from West
Broadway to alley, parking lot loose trash, papers, cans, etc.
3) Eit6er remove or repair rear entry iron handrail to original condition.
4) Repair replace glass roofs an �Q e slid out o the position Fasteners are
vertical wall and sloped roof glass .f
loose or missing.
5) Clear debris and leaves blocking any roof scuppers.
6) Repair replace damaged AC exterior cover at north side near gas meters, or
remove and finish off interior exterior using standard at item 86 below.
�e��€s. Reattach 2 loose cable TV box covers at exterior. Due at
reinst�ection.
8) Replace door knob at garden level exit door to West Broadway. Due 3 davs.
9) Complete repair of front entry brick planter. Overdue from 2005 ins�ection.
No anneal.
10) Replace deteriorated or damaged shingles at mansard roofs. Due 7une 2007.,
11) Repair any torn screens and install any missing screens. Due Mav 2007.
Ca��C i� �t�t��
t �t:
G �r
t,;,
•4
12) Install locking de.vices at all garden level apartment windows that will
comply with Robbinsdale Housing and Maintenance Code (HMC) section
425.19 Subd. 3. Existing clamping devices provided by prior owner have
proven inadequate. Occupants reported inability to secure sliding windows to
city inspector.
13) Remove any nests or animals from garage soffits or apartment mansard roo�
spaces. Due 10 davs.
14) Reattach loose soffit or fascia materials, then scrape and stain or prime paint
exterior wood trirn on garages. Due June 2007.
15) Replace missing downspout at garage reaz. Due June 2007.
16) Repair replace cracked, damaged or loose stucco at garage. Due June 2007.
17) Repair numerous exterior wood windows, exterior trim, sills, and brick
mortar sills. Prime and paint all peeling, flaking or blistered exterior wood
trim including mansard (plywood) returns. Due June 2007. Cracks, gaps,
decay and missing mortar were observed at numerous exterior sills at all
sides.
18) Gas line requirement: Have a licensed mechanical contractor evaluate
and repair apartment and laundry gas lines for loose mounting, loose
connections, approved soldering and installation methods, proper valves,
presence of gas regulators in apartments, approved flexi6le gas lines,
proper connection of gas lines to framing, leaks, kinked lines, etc. Prioritv
is to be Qiven to anartment 201 where a gas leak had been recently re,naired
with black electricians tane and lack of a kev nrevented immediate revair. A
mechanical permit is required for gas line repairs. Full e.ztent of repairs
will not be known until evaluation is completed.
19) Repair comrnon walls where extra handrails have been removed at several
stairs.
20) Tighten up several loose iron 6andrails at stairs.
21) Repair damaged ceiling from past roof leak. (304) Overdue from 2005
insnection. No anpeal.
22) Replace cracked bath sink. (304)
23) Reattach loose cabinet door laminate. (305)
24) Install missing cover plate behind stove (305).
25) Relevel uneven range. (305)
26) Install missing cover plate behind kitchen range. (306)
27) Replace deteriorated toilet seat (306). Due 10 davs.
28) Remove old caulk and recaulk backsplash to wall at bath sink. (306)
.i
29) Repair replace deadbolt lock. (303)
30) Repair replace slow bath fan. (307)
31) Replace broken outlet at bedroom, numerous missiag cover plates, and
damaged fuse holder at electrical panel. (30'n
32) Repair replace damaged door. (307)
33) Repair replace slow bath fan. (307)
34) Install missing cover plate at living room. (308)
35) Replace leaking toilet. Repair any damage to floor flange or sub floor
(permit) that may be encountered. (308)
36) Install wood blocking as needed to tighten up loose tub faucet controls at
#308. Remove damaged materials then cut an appropriate access for repairs,
then reinstall plumbing access panel at storage closet opposite plumbed wall
of #308. Access panel was found on floor with nail points sticking up. Nails
were flattened by city inspector.
37) Replace broken bath light lens. (302)
38) Reset loose toilet. (302) Due 10 davs.
39) Remove extension cord wiring from living room. (302) Repeat violation.
Cord will be removed if present at reinspection. Notify resident.
40) Terminate garbage disposal wires properly in a box fastened to wall or
cabinet and install an appropriate cover plate. (301)
41) Repair replace reattach seal grout loose tiles at tub surround. (301)
42) Replace cracked bath sink. (301)
43) Repair replace loose toilet seat. (301) Due 10 davs.
44) Complete the unfinished replacement of bath fan. (312)
45) Repair damaged closet door at hallway and realign closet door at bedroom.
(309)
46) Replace missing glass from kitchen window sash. (310) Due 3 davs.
47) Repair replace damaged bedroom door. (210)
48) Remove deadbolt from bedroom door and provide access at reinspection.
(209)
49) **Clean accumulation of dirt from ceiling fan blades at kitchen. (209)
50) **Clean spilled and dried food from top of kitchen range. (209)
51) Repair replace operating and damaged bath fan. (201)
52) Repair damaged drywall over bath tub.(201)
53) Reattach loose tiles then seal gaps at bath tub tiles. (208)
54) Repair damaged electrical fuse holder. (202) I
55) Tighten up loose ceiling fan blades at kitchen. (202)
56) **Remove accumulation of dirt and lint from blades at three ceiling fans and
also from clogged bath ceiling fan grill. (202)
5'� Install missing cover plate at living room. (ZO'n
58) Repair replace clogged shower head. (207)
59 **Remove dried food then clean microwave oven to sanitary condition.
Remove food spills then clean freezer and refngerator intenor to a sanitary
condition. Clean walls adjacent to the appliances and exterior of appliances to
a sanitary condition. (203)
60) **Remove dresser from hallway. (203)
61) Install a pull string at hall closet light fixture. (203)
62) Replace cracked toilet seat. (203) Due 10 davs.
63) Replace cracked bath sink. (203)
64) Remove shattered mirror (bedroom) from apartment and dispose of it.
(203) Due immediatetv.
1 condition and ori inal
store d all below the bath sink to origina g
65) Re ryw
level of fire protection. (203)
66) Replace leaking kitchen sink drain trap. (206) Due 3 davs.
67) Repair replace kitchen light fixture. (204)
68) Repair replace bath fan. (204)
69) Repair damaged bath cabinet door. (205)
70) Clean carpet or replace it. (101) Due before occunancv of vacant unit.
71) Replace noisy bath fan. (112)
72) Remove all rubbish carpet and pad (sewer backup debris) and other rubbish.
109
Due
befor
e occuoancv o
f
Replace any loose or odorous tack stnp
vacant unit.
73) Replace deteriorated toilet seat. (109) Due before occunancv.
74) Install numerous missing cover plates. (109)
75) Clean, adjust, and tune both boilers. Purge air from heating system as needed.
Work is to be done by a licensed heating or mechanical contractor. Ensure that
boilers are posted with name of contractor and date of service. Due before
reinsnection.
76) Repair damaged drywall at several areas in boiler room to original level
of fire protection.
77) Resecure loose entry threshold at boiler room.
��p
iS
i
�I
78) **Clean accumulation of dirt from ceiling fan blades. (102)
79) Tighten up loose ceiling fan blades. (102)
80) Clean debris accumulation and stain from bath tub. Verify adequate drainage
and clear drain line as needed. (107) Due 10 davs.
81) Provide documentation of plumbing repair for damaged vertical kitchen drain
between apartment #211 and 111 during late 2006. Repair under permit was
required and no reliable information on repair was received. Overdue.
82) Reset loose toilet and remove accumulation of stool mounting debris from
bath floor. Repair any damage to plumbing drain flange that may be
encountered. (103) Toilet completely loose with no bolted connection to
flange.
83) Repair replace wall thermostat. (103) Verify operation.
84) Clear clogged tub drain. (103) Stopped water was observed.
85) Reattach loose counter top edge at small countertop. (103)
86) Either repair replace the wall AC or remove the unit, fill void, insulate and
side exterior, finish interior to match existing wall. (103)
87) Correct run on toilet. (104)
88) Clear slow bathroom drains. Due 3 davs. (104)
89) Replace missing fuses at numerous electrical panels. Incomnlete and
overdue from 2005 insnection. Examples: 305, 306, 307, 302, 301, 312,309,
211, 208, 202, 207, 206, 204, 104.
90) Repair replace broken or malfunctioning smoke detectors. Examples:
304, 305, 306, 301, 309, 311, 310, 209, 201, 208, 207, 205, 103, 107, 103,
104.
Thank you,
Brian Ringham
Housing Inspector
City of Robbinsdale
i
•i Iq
June 1, 2007
West Broadway Court LLC
Attn: Mr. Jaweed
3 Blue Spruce Court
St. Paul, MN 55127
Dear Mr. Jaweed:
The rental reinspection far 4259 West Broadway, Coachlight Apartments, remains
incornplete because some corrections are incomplete. The remaining corrections need to
be done by the end of June and verified by me or any of several legal actions will be
taken including citations, formal complaint ta the Robbinsdale City Attorney, etc.
Most simple, low cost corrections have been done. Laura and Jim, the manager and repair
person, have done a good job and made a sincere effort to comply with city requirements.
To the best of my knowledge, the remaining incomplete items from the original 3/27/07
inspection include 12 items. #9, 10, 1l, 12, 13, 16, 17, 18, 45, 70, 72, 81. The original
inspection was done with Rebecca Starkey of VIP Management.
Item 75 will be omitted if documentation of service within the past 3 years can be shown
to me, otherwise it will not be. There was no indication of recent servicing and boiler
repairs on 3/27/07. Item 7 was omitted earlier and you were notified.
Yesterday I went to reinspect Coachlight for the second time hoping for completion.
Instead, Laura had no keys to gain access through the main entry doors. She had also
been given no keys to garages. I did verify a few items completed however. Your
manager should have keys on hand when a city re inspection is scheduled.
With regard to item 12, I will inspect Garden Level apartment windows at random for
locking devices.
With regard to item 13, I either need to verify with a qualified (wildlife) contractor that
animal nests are removed or see for myself on ladders or lift equipment, provided by you,
that this item is complete. I can show up on short notice during animal extraction. A copy
of an invoice describing removal of nests will suffice.
With regard to item 17, exterior repairs, I want to verify the methods and materials to be
used earlv on during wood repair. Expanding foam is not acceptable to repair exterior
decay, and all decayed wood is to be removed, not merely covered up and painted.
;.s
With regards to item 18, I have asked at least 6 times for a copy of the invoice for $4000
from your repair contractor and have not received a copy. No permit was obtained for the
gas line and gas valve work.
With regards to item 81, I have asked several times for some indication such as an
invoice that drain line repairs between apartments 211 and 111 were done, as ordered last
winter, by a licensed plumber. To date, you have provided your verbal assertions that no
problem exists. The City requires a professional opinion that is more credible due to past
flooding and water damage observed by me, and descriptions of inaction and cleanup by
your staff from former residents.
With regards to apartments 101, 103, and 109; be advised, do not rent them without an
inspection after "turnover" when they are ready to rent. These apartments sustained
significant damage from flooding or resident vandalism. 103 has kitchen cabinets to
replace that are "damaged beyond repair" per my order during a reinspection, and
replacement is required. 109 smells due to management failure to remove besotted carpet
and pad from a bath tub in the 4-5 months since plumbing mishaps and flooding. These
apartments do not have to be ready to rent at any certain time.
Simply do not rent them until I inspect their condition. Any schedule for this is up to you.
They can be posted by me (if needed) to assist any new staff you may hire from making
the mistake of allowing occupancy in these units too soon.
With regards to rubbish, I will continue to issue citations for rubbish as needed. It took
over a month to remove some furniture including a console TV. Photos prove this.
Moving your blue dumpster to an area to prevent exiting to the alley would solve two
problems. One problem is the dumping off of trash by other city residents who may drive
away into the alley rather than West Broadway. The other problem is trespassing by your
residents onto private Sawhorse Company property. Laura is aware of this issue and the
inexpensive possible solution.
I will be out of town from today through June 11` I encourage you to begin immediately
to complete these 12 remaining items and avoid the need for legal action by the City of
Robbinsdale. At any time you may contact Joe Yancey, the Robbinsdale Building
Official, regarding the gas line repair invoice, or any other issue. All garages are to be
accessible by me at reinspection. Hire a locksmith if needed to gain garage access at
reinspection.
Brian Ringham
Housing Inspector
City of Robbinsdale
i
v�
�'-On 7/10/07 Citation 2070276163 was issued to Hyder Raza Jaweed for rubbish,
failure to repair shingles, peeling painted trim, broken screen, and broken lock on rear lot
entry door at Coachlight Apartments 3759 West Broadway, Robbinsdale.
The 3 violations on the citations were of eity code 605.07, 425.15 Subd. 1, and 421.21
Subd. 5.
�1 t����
�r��
z t�
c
�I
_i
�f
*'y
1,,.
l,
4
p�,
d
�.4
i AI
:y:.
a
"��n
v.. w
t
c �.n wlu k
d
4 2�'"",J
a'
u P
a
f
i s y
r "��M 7 44�a�.F- ;1�i
y� e �k� ..xAy
7 J
k t
1
�i� �s f R�
we
a i
a �F
�'A1;
f
n
c Y t�� f r�
ad° s „c
Y af�
..r""� r
��.,,r"��
a
j y r'
,A
v'
a
a r 4
,r
a�r.:;, �.:.n
'S 5 t ��F�,���s�'��o#.��;��'�^�
y i
i�
�.,�MYry11M1��,
t
i gf
ldh ��n' "Y`a ;t t -04 «n, apir�rvp•.
t ����"Y• k�
�ar��A,..r �+a+�+��
�r�.��: �"�"��i �r„�•'�'��� �z:i
�...w r t ���.4 t� m n �sr,.w� a �:'ro•� e� �l�A�� �Y alt
�u eaa .�mr�^." sra�°i'' 1 k m '"'rmb�i!.+c�' A 5
�.�5 t d&'�
q ��7�
j. r 4 5 �L 4��� �C �c �ia
i rr�'� F: r t� xa `y'�+,��' �rfi'`!"s�'i�i
ti s q '�+`ya���£
r a s a a r h t.
z, t .:t t
y ?"t b"
r.y5ai�.
�nr.+
�,u
��'k'a i�a" w tt;Jr-ti: �'w a.4. p,�'''nK �A��;;;
i J b. tc l} T,,
W""�'e �C1H�e!^r
���t�
r
r� "3.
f' i... �,a �,yi '�,rt
's?!
:u q
s, E
d M
_p
v p -a a��
°.s+Kt•
i l 4
^�+"'�,a.
a s i
j Y
'SF n s
��w, i i g
x l i I I o
iH� i
y 4 i
+s-•
I
i�
4
�w.
w.
s
i
�#f I,.
s �i.
y 'm� r`�t'� ..n�
j '�`.ka��
t�,
t=� �.�f 1
s
5
I y
..:v r �x
s-�•. r
r�_. i..- �w"
a .a
3
F£
fi
;fi, -t:�
-s. a y m .�,Ft�-�
wF'=` s S�' t
c-�"� -x. �t
r ��*r�. a� ,u' q, a��" �s.
dt a y 3 �e �k�
�`r�:'
tr �,"N t �z 9�-':
a 's 4
s3�4 nP g,Y. C 1t
�3 �.9 Z a s�4_ h �3' ��y WA�eI
`Y fiu y�f YA .2 'J
K .c.1e,Y`}�.! `f>
k i .7{,�, 'rY G' 1r �L pt P tz�v
A y
t t s4 K't' W' c-
,a -a e�., v.� �`a„ e ,k .c N ,,.d'�
�-iz- k 3� k �'��`Ye�
''�n k j s� a.� r+`�,'""v'S� a
�r' s r v, F .,,�y
3 fr 4 s 'x
'a r �+s A
t
�n _.ro^" a :k S �w-3 C §?ssaM iF �.t� A
��R'?� .�.�iw r���'� (b ��r=
a
'���9
..xi�.,.,«�...�,. rw r���a
r
S�
1
l y
y "ti`�ti E w} r
r� N
r $�I�, J 3 3
+,1 J 3 i �J�*���
"���a. a„ 4 r *��`.,,��G
�F. d a �J t. i
��a,����� s�l� k. q d' F s r .a
��+i� .'1 t ��e E�°�'.'�E"a' +ei h �s Z S
.���ka' F a� a-'� 3 p
«r�' �r ��c�r
2:. F r� r..� �,a�-py'����n
'f„ a`
a x�� r��'�S `�'.��c �.r� x ��q�'� r,
z; u��"�,�u" .,�.'�,�,,,',e�j� -,z �w� .r,.„�'�.c� �.sm.�* y �.;a�' r �;ri
J N
k{a
.�„�y�.��,s n��, s
-5 sw ti hx
�,��aC; 4 r "f�
a .r�' i J a..
°`rz �g ..r' �a� e' t ,c Y t
�n'� u"� '��s�' -£„k+��'�'��
'ry �X'�-�f�� r r ?'y.
$'',�����f" �"�"G^'s'"1 x �r
k 3z.�.�� ���:�9k�'^t ,r s�_.�
'4, r j
a'�
i
�x z
a s�'��
2 -:a�s" s�
�n
v. 'h�'
X
r
v°
,x
"�.'S�
«sx�'i 3�
avG�
f f 1�
g *3.j}
3�
a�6- au
.,3
r
...e�y5-
h1 ht'� i NS v'✓
�ro�� ,sse e 5 i 5�ry rt ��t'� v i y
e.
p W q
S s €5"t
^3 r 'r��
Y 4 1 R I
3 �4d�
y„�`
c
f
r".. .TT,. a� e
.,:tr a
'�'a 'm �.,..i'..=a✓uar.v
�.,'.i-.
•n .:.a�
I
�I�
I
i.l
8/29/07 Ms. Occupant called to report a roof leak and damage to food in cabinets after a
big storm. Unit 3854-17. is on top floor.
BR went to see and took photos. There were signs of water stains at upper cabinets and
at separation header between kitchen and LR. Went to top of stairs door to roof and tried
to take photo of approximate area above this apt. The roof top mechanical unit flashing is
close to azea of leak.
Photos show blocked scuppers and ponding at this other roofs. Maintenance to clear
scuppers has been deferred virtually every time I have seen Robbinwood roofs. No pond
appeared to be directly above leak. Roof has wear and tear at curbing. Mesh exposed in
places.
I was told that this occupant would not let maintenance staff enter her apartment and she
may now have moved on. Water stains in photo are not dramatic but they were present
3854 has poorest roof condition of all 4 roofs when BR was on them for last rental
inspection. Owner did get roof repair estimate some years ago but has not done anything
with it. I was told this exceeded $40K by one mgr at one time.
Scuppers in photo were cleared (reportedly) after suggestion made to current manager
when roof issues in general were discussed.
Summarv: The owner defers maintenance of roofs until there is a problem or order.
Presence of trees, acorns, branches, past history of clogged scuppers does not ensure any
owner action towards roof maintenance. No actual roof repairs ever have been done to
my knowledge during Jaweed ownership.
Also saw old hallway trash chute secured with duct tape. I am certain this was ordered
secured better in the past. Screws may have been removed by residents and owner is
unaware or uninterested.
�t f� G `����5 �.i� v�,c��
a�� r �rvt
v
�z�c�i��-rc'�
ti!_.
g :lS ,c..
E .r r A
L� �.ts '"�,?,q
}�i; }�3 a
g F` x a.
J
�x .i:
t h t 1
,�t s;�'
t.�
t��t�� Z �itl5 p 4 �t ,y,y y
t
F
E4"�' �e 3` ut 0.�'",^C£'�
y I :SM u 1�j..
r z,e
,'.5-.4-
s I
n�: i� F q n
A
A1�+`X �$pµ�Y
1 !y `i
t ���Y�4� i i ,b I
z �I,
I'�
x
a�� l�r,. y y�',.
s
qy� i
��i k.� 1P iS
P
i
1.'
N
I
f� lv �i"t.5 Y
�.+E r 2 ��e:.. k 3
f
I t
g��% g w 7 4i y�
fi S
w�^ Y
5
S4 4 p
t
h
b A a "�'s 5 Y
4 p; ,s
'}�i jk15 ,Fi +l h f �6 =F
l rv
L':.F XS;� i=F y t��'� M�
Y
t.
3 .��.�.,yCt. �1 t
t!
e
1 hd a Ji i� �R+ r'�.
g `>va w t `�d�
;f 3�.
�°.e`g t �',�`.3.
5
��"{p �'ES'35'�
x ��k�� n'�� 4
a�� i�t�t 4'�. n
i�t f' 4
y
r. �a
y
J
V
�t fl'
r f,.h
t
r d7
M F 1
1 t� Y
t�«��
r
j4 3f
�i`v�t*� '.E't Y
�4 �r_ t �•#•*f H "rs k�
y.. :l �SI
uyy
N 1
z
t, �n�'r,�. e �I
t,}�. ?-'�c�i �ts. w�'
�n��Y. p �u x I u�
�°^�Z'a���a`��ds t?�
I
I� a
,��Y..
d.
y
c.
i
4�i
�Fr'v� 6r.� y
�g w�
k
i �'3"7 ar _n.m...FM.u. a., ti t _,.-:'t �f, 7.
d
tY ..4.. {u- i3 ufa'�.Y 3t%t3. t&�.
�j
�1 q
�.,r,� `y�¢'
x R l'�t
'�')�k �F ,f, y �A���M
5'a.+��� a �(����,�`.'z�t'. 5 r .:R'�.
Aa R x x
�F J x 4 �y �a
v �i� d� a rt�`.a,�,�
ti'
t �i� .F`�
a i'; ti
w�" u
a y
5 i
K ;C.
J
!Kn �h� T.
S k.. 3
�3
t
1�� 5 t�1
y :�v
n y
n�
1. k
lF
T��
t i nt
a i
�y�• T
�Y x
u
x
r
r
i
�'"�°y f�t
c �"�i
i �r�
+�t
l Y' T.
"SC
u
�¢����'�T����v�
5'
Y y y
7 3 3 y '.i
t �'L .ti°',..
a i ..T
�F� 4y. �r
?S a,
i�" h
x a t t';
°a �.�wS
r
�`t n 1
Y y
p t, 7
�1�*h ,�TS i.
4 A� a i
�SV�
r y
�i
G
I r+� t y T c.
t I i e�
�''���f���
i i
��"v�s��'
4 b Yl
f x f 3
kt
j a�,�r,d
�r 9 a� t.;ky�b.��'S ."��II��
7 s r'��' P
d r�
�,�a�,�
k Y ,,�y 1����
4� g�
6 �`I y yi
t Y k f
k a b.i 7 T I} 4 l f Y'.
t '�F I
r ��s a�� },4
ro s
z'�'.
z
ru1�,k� C
�k
rt i ��'�fi `�e�M s� r �S;�t
�:�.�sa a`.
I
j 4', Y 1e fip z'����� i rw
a� `s rt �v� t, S �"'�t�^,� tf
�i.,. .n_, �r�.
r ^z
�f
9�. a
r x. .r
I I, t
,�g. q ��sFrnr� k �,#��t
n Y
t �j y' S Y..
3t{ t� z} �.ar-�
r�rY:� r�`- s i
s
..,,t `'L'x6t�&� ��n A t'^ „�Y f�
�g s� Y
�'�i�,���_��.,'�� �'1' ��F��";� ��f.;: yF i
x y �,�a� vi� 4f
}��.3 7
1n a k: *K
y�+
s�
-e
t
w
4�v' S S� y!r rje„ 4 �F8��.��}^�,,� g �•�H
4�},3 u� y
e
n �'�5���} w�
I
I
`��5 k,� C'
4 �9k, t" s.i
r
°��?Xa
r
k
f 3 z
�s t xS �a
r�'�� F
..�i,��
3
S
y
a. y
t +�F
+�kt
h�
p�
k
I M
d�.
ih 'N;S;
i
f.
r3 �a
q
r
J x;�^,'
u
7
.a
I 4.
a
�x
y r
�a
t'�������+�'c�,
ss
6
`S"* a 4`
y, u
X f.#"�b t 1 3 i.. 4
Y
S
w ,y�Y-0 �i
4 •�y .`q SY�
P y, ,i
^T� �,ys n34�V
�i� i t�' �S. 7�� �4�
�ak �a'� t 4a J �1,
�ji Y g a u�e� �µF �f �"'�,d"�
y a�. m, t�.n��",.����r� r s �r�+�� L�,�
ur �"�y'�'�Fy ,��"y����,��€� i��'��'r �5t���' �'�r
'�w a��ti��",� z, ti r
I
m
�cC�� i�b
t t��
t�
rte
v,����':
Occupant J called numerous times during 2006 w/ report of ignored water leak and wet
spot on floor in hallway of 3854-4.Photos show (1) newspaper demonstration of wet
carpet and also (2) wet spot on my 2" or 3rd visit when I felt it was time to start
documenting the problem. Suspected mold growth at one time was about 2-3 sq. ft.
The maintenance man at that time, Mr. V said that he had to wait 3 weeks for water
lines he requested or to get to buy them. He had tried to fix the problem during that
time. Mgr L was present and verified this.
There was a toddler in the apartment and plastic film was kept on the wet spot all the
time, which only helped to keep it wet.
Over several months the problem happened again and again. The occupant called many
times to report to the city that the owner kept failing to stop the leak and dry out the
carpet. We simply could not figure out what it was.
On one visit after Mgr L had quit and Mgr K was present, 10/19/06 the problem seemed
resolved. The carpet was dried up and cleaned. Then the leak happened again.
It turned out that the overweight renter tended to lean back on the toilet tank and kept
breaking or opening up the rubber seal between tank and bowl. Stopping this practice
stopped the leak. The occupant had always claimed a tub or faucet leak as the cause. For
a time a crack in the drain line below the concrete floor slab was suspected.
Despite the simple correction and incorrect original diagnosis, the important facts are: (1)
The owner and various managers left wet carpet on the floor for weeks at a time and lost
interest unless city orders were issued. (2) They failed to pull back the carpet to view or
dry the floor adequately until a city order to do so. They failed to replace decayed, rotting
carpet tack strip and left that tack strip exposed at hallway and bedroom closet with a
small child present for weeks at a time in the apartment, once the carpet was removed. (3)
They failed to find out what the odd problem really was over a period on months. (4) The
efforts to dry the carpet never were professional.. I saw common house fans used not true
floor drying fans. I do not think any extraction of water was ever done.
Summarv: The owner was never really determined to get to the bottom of this lingering
problem and only dealt with it when city orders and citations threats were issued
following a repetitive resident complaint.
1?�;=
t., �Z.c�'�'� �t�
t-� t.i�4
�y Occupant J called numerous times during 2006 w/ report of ignared water leak and wet
spot on floor in hallway of 3854-4.Photos show (1) newspaper demonstration of wet
carpet and also (2) wet spot on my 2" or 3rd visit when I felt it was time to start
documenting the problem. Suspected mold growth at one time was about 2-3 sq. ft.
The maintenance man at that time, Mr. V said that he had to wait 3 weeks for water
lines he requested or to get to buy them. He had tried to fix the problem during that
time. Mgr L was present and verified this.
There was a toddler in the apartment and plastic film was kept on the wet spot all the
time, which only helped to keep it wet.
Over several months the problem happened again and again. The occupant called many
times to report to the city that the owner kept failing to stop the leak and dry out the
carpet. We simply could not figure out what it was.
On one visit after Mgr L had quit and Mgr K was present, 10/19/06 the problem seemed
resolved. The carpet was dried up and cleaned. Then the leak happened again.
It turned out that the overweight renter tended to lean back on the toilet tank and kept
breaking or opening up the rubber seal between tank and bowl. Stopping this practice
stopped the leak. The occupant had always claimed a tub or faucet leak as the cause. For
a time a crack in the drain line below the concrete floor slab was suspected.
Despite the simple correction and incorrect origina] diagnosis, the important facts are: (1)
The owner and various managers left wet carpet on the floor for weeks at a time and lost
interest unless city orders were issued. (2) They failed to pull back the carpet to view or
dry the floor adequately until a city order to do so. They failed to replace decayed, rotting
carpet tack strip and left that tack strip exposed at hallway and bedroom closet with a
small child present for weeks at a time in the apartment, once the carpet was removed. (3)
They failed to find out what the odd problem really was over a period on months. (4) The
efforts to dry the carpet never were professional.. I saw common house fans used not true
floor drying fans. I do not think any extraction of water was ever done.
Summarv: The owner was never really determined to get to the bottom of this lingering
problem and only dealt with it when city orders and citations threats were issued
following a repetitive resident complaint.
��;3
.�..s.s„N_��,su:�a,. a�.�r»x,-„
Y...�
F�
3 �'R'
�6�
R�
4s
Y
;�,,L Rc' e*
x
y d
d X�
rs"� i
Y j f "y .V
E 3",� ,�r�
,ra^ C !y
a. '�'Y. �ri�� ���:t�'� t
K er��,����"'� zu f
Yf��
�'�:r
t n f�' q
1 X14S�' r, 4' 'f..
'�'�4`i,t �'a'� a
y ��x� N v x r 'Ya„� �4 t'
x a^
i p� x t g�$ sr �p�..�.wwc�?�
z e pa7-X3�
a.; 7w.; S'^ '��w�.� F-�'l
4 F y"iP
z ,.c� r `n�' s�
a t
s� s w a 1` x s r�,.��
r r a�� I
,rY s a '4 r N' x 4 Y t t
3 ,A S h a"'K '�`'t�" E F k m
1 t E �-ri� s
s¢ �y r F�' "�,i� .n
'.7 i .E '{ta �fi� b 2 y
z �r".�,� '+�r� fi t, s r x�
c.`: �.�-�F��.. s��'` u, �a ei
n
u
r�,�'< n�� `�m.
z �ti
.,��R���°
s t r
.,f s r�"'�
p.
Y!i
+i��'r�,v{j,"#uTt��
��s '�I
�y t �y.�
t
s'�" ,fg��
�x'Qe,:� ��x�. ,'-u.t'."+Y..M1d,a��.. s
q 5�
y y s��
��'1 D fi
y�4 3 y.��
��c t
'q. r
�rr
��..,h
4 i
✓3..^. ^'w_ �Y3r
A
p�?
g
,i;'
ar
,�s� zf'
x'�
f.
4
y
"�''�s�°.�.3�f� e: t
s
e
i�� i
IA
'a_'
X
s
m C
p
:�'i,.
January 19, 2007
West Broadway Court LLC Attn: Mr. Jaweed
3 Blue Spruce Court
North Oaks, MN 55127
Dear, Mr. Jaweed:
Based on my inspection reinspection today of 3854-4 West Broadway, please complete the following
before Monday at 4:30 PM. Please notify resident and other residents as needed, ahead of
time.
1) Remove all water damaged carpet, pad, tackstrip, drywall, 3 pieces of wood baseboard in the bath
hallway, and at rear of the bedroom closet.
2) Call for my reinspection the area before any new material is installed.
3) Remove black material at underside of toilet tank and clean tank exterior with bleach and water
mixture.
There may be additional requirements once my reinspection is done Monday PM. Call (763) 531 1268 to
schedule Monday. Estimated labor time for the above is 30 minutes including cleanup, so iYs a small job.
The violation present is of HMC 425.13 Subd 2(e) using the definition of nuisance at 425.11 Subd. 23 b, e,
g, f, and h.
To recap this issue, there is an ongoing, unresolved wet floor problem that has damaged building material
and finish flooring. The cause is unknown at this time but the problem dates back at least a month or two.
Eric and I pulled back addirional carpet and pad this PM and exposed wet tiles and slab. Failure to remove
wet materials in a timely manner so far, has prevented finding a cause and thus a solution. I regret that your
resident has been inconvenienced for so long. I had thought the problem was solved by Jeff, the
maintenance man, earlier. Regardless of cause, the water damaged materials are a nuisance.
The goal of the requirernents is to remove all materials that are water damaged or stained and attempt to
ascertain what gets wet first if the problem continues. Carpet pad was not pulled back far enough unril
today to see the real extent of deteriorarion due to moisture. There have been both water line and drain
leaks in the apartment for several months. They seem to have been repaired but the water damage persists. I
cannot rule out any cause. A solurion is long overdue. The avartment if vacated. should not be rented aQain
until I am satisfied that there is no loneer an�� twe of leak or seenage somewhere.
I am required by ordinance to inform you that failure to correct will result in penalties described under
HMC 425.37.
In attempting to verify that the power vent was not blocked I removed a clogged, dirty foam filter and it
tore. I gave Eric $1 cash for the damage, which I suspect may be an ina.dequate amount. I would be happy
to pay any addirional you may suggest, and apologize for the damage. The fan worked adequately once the
clogged filter was removed. You have my cell phone and may also call with 30 minutes notice on Monday.
Thank you,
Brian Ringham
Housing Inspector
City of Robbinsdale
CC: Resident u�f 3854-4
C
Mr. Sullivan from 3850-2 Robbinwood called and asked me to look at his apt after a leak
from above had been essentially ignored for over 10 days. A missing water line at the
vacant apartment above was not replaced after bemg taken for another apartment water
'ntenance man at the time, Mr. Q. had to borrow the water line
line r air. T
he mai
s had re uested.
because the owner of Robbmwood had failed to provide part Q q
The water was turned on b an unwitting person or leake
d over time before the borrowed
Y
line was replaced and Mr Sullivan's apartment below was flooded while he was out of
town.
The owner responded with a(staf�} one time inadequate wet vacuum cleanup. It was a
premature and totally inadequate effort. No carpet was pulled up and no fans were
installed to dry out. Water from above continued to enter the apartment from above.
Mr. Sullivan returned, reported the problem, dried out his belongings including clothing,
bedding, and furniture as best he could. His ceiling fan shorted out and failed to work.
Water seeped in from above from the wet apartrnent and he had to repeat these efforts. A
clothes rod broke from weight of wet clothes after already being laundered
and cleaned
once per Mr. Sullivan.
Suspected mold began to grow over ensuing days despite the occupants contiunued
efforts. He reported the continued problem multiple to the apartment manager and Q. at
the time with little response. Q. came to city hall with Mr. Sullivan to back up the
reported conditions as he felt only city involvement would result in owner actions. Q,
Sullivan and the city inspector were present at an inspection with photos taken.
One photo shows shoes with suspected mold growth on heels left on floor. Numerous
photos show stains and suspected mold at many walls and corners. Stains below electrical
parts indicate the presence of water in electrical devices. Photos were taken and order to
correct was issued when the Housing Inspector became awaze of conditions on 9/27/06
Complaint 1517 was filed and the due date for removal of carpet to assess the interior
further was 10/14/06. Mr Sullivan was allowed out of his lease (his main goal) and
moved.
T'he apartment had a very strong smell when the photos were taken and Mr Sullivan was
unable to reside there.
Summarv: The owner failed to provide needed plumbing parts for Q, who was told to
take parts from a vacant unit. This resulted in the accidental flooding of an occupied I
apartment below. The cleanup that followed was unprofessional and inadequate. Water
entered electrical devices in an occupied apartment and the owner did not prioritize and
investigate that issue. Suspected mold growth that damaged personal belongings, entered
finish materials, and odors resulted. No actions by the owner other than the ineffective
original response occurred until the city inspector became involved. The owner never
reported a thorough cleanup after the unit became vacant. •c
i
9 y r�...� "N.
x
y�� 4 ec I
t f�
�,f(iE;C''4 4.'rda
4 4:�t'
I
L �i
P k
a`Itet�"u ��;,£�L �"�j f �s ,r'�"�t at�^ ��i�"'
i �rin m sF�„ �a�3w 1 a �.9�"!v"� 1 x�r t i k� �a� r i
y r� S .r�� m-sk��'ky k xt i� �fi�e �Z��-� t 4- 6
r s 1 r i a a t� 3 i b ti �r7�-,hE�� er `r, xf'��, '�,FN�r
rr� S� c 1 S t� R f "'}y �.t�i �'e £t-� g�'i� g �y
1 t x� L t k i: K N:� �r��I( ���4iJ' h4� �,,�:1G��,7x�?3��.�' 3��� 1
�e �h F �u�+��� Yt��, a b t r r•£t,��`'-�"I�.+Ei��R��
r,a ti i �-4r� Lty �8r�`a y r s� P� ��'�tu� H t xy ���.��.�i±�" -a G
x t y s a A h S �r h k i ��."a' r
k"r A� 2`�k7� "'tp' a
z �y 4� `�n z i ue t*" t fi ���Y t
z� i��� �t�''�''�'n, �'��'�n�� z6�t F k_ m�". v
r '�stt ,��a� ,?a `�'{i��t� q �i i t r i s n �e a
t� �1" y f a��`��_ Fk,�,u.�,''�+�.�c"�k,�t�`�,�' zc+;? �,���k�8 x 5� A 'r
t r �d 4 i r t {�e
xf� rr'a �+r .��a n tt" rs t�� 5���,� i h �'i
t }�'hk� 8� �"A 1 I �4"�+&�,. Y�.�S 1 k�.��� �rF �4._
Y j- f
�y'' w� r�.y r'�`� s ip i n 't' fi. c n.,G
`ttu�' T�.:`� �'is��'"�� G L S ry^ 4 't� i�
q iJ,+,�-��a�i h�t�r���������"�`������ T aci'�rt��t'j� i �r a� i k���
s.� c:l�„s +Hrr S k ar r 4.�. "`.kv .�ar ¢SZ.w
r b` r y ,.t a r �y. k tl t'�" P�
t C� �r +`�'.��af�.kr. u. y2 r x
�t� �"3n�' .w.�'� s '�r� "��,�u' n�u�'� t n
�'{`��+�'���r��� ���'�`�a w i� �r��
u�x t �a���� ���rt����`a��?S,��a� 3 t�"�� �'�k r
e� :�r'^ "a�, a R'�' ��t �^e„� ,��'�r 4 �sj t�;�. 5�
��'S 1A k �s \�yr, �19a' 4cA t�.�xa C1' r
e� "�zi"�"�4 Y1 t": x'� y F s
1
W� v ���"^�i '�'P�` a h
ti
a� ��i v r a
R s fir "�''���'"P�,'��* 'x"�'�"�
"�a 3 n ��,r r i� k y i i
t y� y
��N �N c 3 tt' �1�'� 4.�� sl
a h�, a r 7 �s ��iv�t ,�e, s
.�'�t�,' �j 7� ti a .s�
y�r t �t '�"��G a �g� ��"+�'yx
L k`�i'F"�.l'n v��� k +�s x �R,�n 3 '���.y,`�.���}?'� i
n
�*kfM :�d V �i �a��s" a t�5 �nv" t i �d r ��i �„ns.h� i. �ri
���5� m'� F7 y
�.^a ii ,f �d� u�.ih h8 j 5 5 �a: �ai a� F F J f
s atxJw� T} �r 3- `��e hld"�� i-�:,. q 1 aa a� ��"5m� 6:l'U `�y 4 E y y q �;q ''�v .'�ci7
i t i ��,•#�.r a �"��,,;�ta a�` '��`U�` se a s 3, 5�.,$S� i 'S, i r r�'�� 3
a �"5 r t r d t 9 tn,�'�C '�'�.'i'. x 3 say �Fe .r 7, t
�rr 3 r ,�a�'?k t4�s'' �y� -s�� i �,5�"a���� r
iwP"+s't33 t�'r���'k2�� .•4 prr b,� �e�, 3` �}�.ty
yn m r ti� a K j.,�'^ t�.q,� 'Sa a �:#Y.�S ��''4 �.,i"� x
.+.s;��d�� r `79�,{�'Cby.��' �',,�a'"Fai ,�er,.,.'�, vs k'�''s ,��a+...��,��t b+� e.�%sy� ��1�:� .a�e t.:
'!v. s€ .c F �1 xs t �c. f r *�.�>33 �'�AX a o,
�'�`�,v;nA. 3�k,_ 5��' �e u k���J�� �'r` T �k..�v, r s�._� �s �.r,'��,,��?:��:�`.
�b �.�'b t M,�2�•s•'� !S` Sr E r+,�'r��' y� ,,q�S���i�'3���,�,�� sy r:`�i �7 x���� .�S
Yr �k e. w�.�� 7� x t� 1 .n a'?' �r�..� ��k� J �"ati, kR��,,.,yp .f'� :e
;,a� r� �a��.r� <�ai�;:.i�c, z7= '��t,� rn��' «K�,��� :.�a� i x �E.r, 'a 7 �,�p m���'��-��-�,,
��"M`l�'.. e �g,�,�.'�1+..� t W,�� .�a�.���. ���'9s. n� y �.�#1<��
�iar "�q��` ��ra �s"�mw� �v,�'F wi,ai �m�l� r-�y.. ��,�„a
'f ^v+ s xl��.,l"�'�:.�9 tb� n.�. e:i� 2�,„"p�..,��y� zp h �'�'�k�.�Y t ��::._i�i �.��;3�„'�'?'
��.�,s... ��i� k� "N w�3..;: r, 5 i ti„�„ re 7 E�+ri �R"fi 1 F7 :�G. p r s. �.:q ��y;�
w��1 �''r. �t ,:,h t r �-`�.yx.+�, r'�'rx r� �„'a5 r 3� e n' x,. p.�'
t s C xa� �r `'i!r- N��A L
t r s �m� aJ' t o :x*�'v wa S .k�
�'�'�.'Y ^i:p��.�,'�'�. r ��.a y t p �i �a "Ye,�.� �l� .d. s i rFiwR ,s irt
�'s,�„"��_� iN a ,i��� S:�r:,°ti,.,�".`�+�ys�� �"�''�aw� Y �h- i� ��i t. 4:.
+R4y �1 1 r a �.t l�„+^�M 4. l-ryr 2 ��.,�'n t i y �.q� x -1 .�Mu
r l
4 t rl 'sr{ f U t 2
�,�.ii��;.,i1 .il ,.:r t�' ���i�"�` �'��:"��„�Th,�y�, 'ua��,. ��i�. {a Z �::a�,wv �s
�a'nc�'`vt �,sr f„��r�i:�a�c k` 5°h ���+',1,�'�k�.:.�` �,fa �r:�" A y 5 t�� i� �,�u,�Yla"`"::'�',�'�,,"y,nc��:
aL a 1^r �"J� Y� rt:�'� �.'rt�,, �R a arn ai
i �p u 3 ��s� 4 i. �xt x a i 'x h� .wS �A.+ ��s F,� ��v� r�'
i� „v :M. T�,.a�p� a rti 4' �x�.srtri +Z t t r t"� �*��,�C�.
r �i a m�k� y. k T s r r d
r `�a r if a 1 h r`� i� t e a 5
r
�"�h�� �Y f s� r� t i i t 7� x ti c �i K'�
2 '4•g ���n�'� a. r y t �4. i��; fre
tk S� v 3 m 2�' ti x r"� r��� x
r i_
xi i 'I
'�r: t, i 1 ";.S
4 A
wl f r
a y j
t
i a
i�-�E`c.��'rk,
i� F Fcl
i- r w. r sr.
u�..,..i..��.,
e
1 •ti
+u t s a �4
n
y 4
t r
R�
y q
i"'�ti� �d
r i� 2
f� t f 3��I+i
a y�.,�
1��,�`' h stik�i
r� �k�,�# `�.r
�Fa�`
r{ x�ti a a�'
i�
.p.1 a
fl i
s
k a M `T" Y-"'
5�
5
C t
�A^`.� �uX �r,-1}A.
i w
i
I
�=s�.
F2
I
u
L 1
r x
..Y V"� Y AS
t r L
`N
�3, �sk. r.
4
�w
r�
�t���
T
r,
r��
i ��.9 x t �,.�.�"`a�„�.���--
f
-t �a r�
g
i z" �2�-,�"�� $.�',c�
.�:�,��r..�.v*-.:_'`�:..f.a}�``.
�5," �3^ a"�'
r�
�'x� r�� s r-,�`"`�
#.�a`s.-,.� �^a��'�"�""w� m'��
7 z �;y �a. ;w'��
�+P°��'�£4�`
A� �,'�s
�.r
f
a r�
r �r
r.==
rr
f
�F
7
��P
T
+�r
sa
a 3 a
w �"5����..
'a,. f� i
s�..'�`'
t
tt Rit
a
M. .b.�i t
L
i 1��
3
I
l
'�F
I
�tt.�
q
o-,`�t"
`�e'�� k 6
�e
r 7 s` Y`h.`
t
Y
a
t
��.qra F a
x i�.,. .a,�' ��s��.��
k
s .n s�t
r
�t
1'x' k.g
w�
T" 7� ,�L4� �'ht
a 3 d'd���'�„�
k
4 y F i
z;.
�r r
�'a'j,�'°��l.L'J.� i4`i.:.
1� e.;,�.�h.� x.
�e f
�h ,s 'fl�2 c 2 4 aw� fY, yt p( ^�v`' S
C5�"� i
a
5
w��
f
3 t��,,� �.�s��'��" x
3 r m
3
n 1 y.
SY S
a F F b2�
5 y �<s� �rraa�. ,�r z
a!��.,^ 7 Y`!F s �r
x .9" a F3 e
x
c� i
a fr �i�,
�A' i d� �r-�'D A�, A� s i 4 p t lp�' 1�. r $51
,$e.k �A ��,f�� '�re�'3� R^���"�ra]�;Q'p"�, Z
d
Md �i� 5 a� j
w`'yh:. R�.��4 db
1
wY s
d
r 1 taK "".4 �S
t�S�� d� �X��
k 3 ln�
�.R
v
Y
�7 S
Y 4�'°n j^ t
r
S y
f
nkY 1j
�Y 5
M
e 7
d� r j 3�'y�' ��a,iWM1
a t
y R'.,
n ��e`a 3.. y�
xw
t.. �f w n- `�2�'�..'.
i r� r r k yv
k Y`�,} µ�'4
t �i
y d
v'n.-
9 eu r
�4 ���Vq�� 4 y j
f y.F 7.�d} 1+�k
�,FW'��a�'+� 3 k_
��,...,n., x h r f k ,a
µa t ,,s p ro` r
�a�f ��'��Rw¢r e 'b
r .u'� �7
i�� w� r� 7 sfi
Y t�� 3 '1`'�YS�, 4i F a i.. �k
I
i VF n? t �d
t �'"��6� i y $�'�t�� e��}
�Sfi�" n b f
�S a
S '�u'`.5��'M1S�r .y,�� ,xq .p, p�.
45 'm 6i f �vixl*r�tx'+ �'�i f d� s `3 n. I
I
ry a r
s y x
t k s r
K��'
u
"��F' s c
n
r ��+ct�s 9 a
�'�u` a r
t
w a�" ���p�s�m��
�f�`
�'Sx"�� ��t'1�4 t �Y L
i `4 Z 4
��s h�s� ,��sr �F 5x� ���',t,'='f� ie s
�'hM�,�,��ai �9� i
t `�y��a'� i" a e�`i� ��M�� kar �r
y a c�`'S7` Y l��u �'a a s r
x r'r�. .�,a„����� t �'T 4 w
t �tiL"^�.t sx� `k ��w' �i l.
7 �A�'��
��y��".r�z v
�t��„�,p"�c�� a y
��f b T Y
z
y i
�,s. t t E nt
n;
t 4
s q M1�,
t
r �f.� �1�, f r
L r
�p d t
m s T F y.
,i.
i s
'F t A� E s a y f
�5�� 0
j
a y �i�n
'4 d�e S t k i
,y f
d
q� q aa B�� a
5
z �+��s����.� 5 f ��m t
�E �d ,r �t i ti "�,ti�i�p�� .B
y�-g�p,� �.s�' }y,+�,�i .r'��'
o- v w� t ��F x
a s r r L'��r f '.s� a' ��w� n d���t
Y.t r}'�' L� i ,�nt n? M� �;i'a y �ry� k.
i �,°d �"c �s, ��'�'�r i
M1hit A t �11' t�V' ,�ra�� iC
d', d'�A
x
s? �x z, k, z
'Y s ir�'J���� �s ry �q�.
s 3 �n� �;�'R� &b
��.w
��t�, iib �i� f�k�.3 o
k7������� t
t' �r� s ti
�q ,a f' F p x
�4 �{4 �'"��r�" ry k
rei k�T
a<' r
�r�rt� r r a
n' �1� i
�4 7
�"����,uy� t ir b ���6 t
$.3,�,� w d
µr 4 d y
i 4.:-qs< �yu �h `�i x
»a `"xi�" s.�`
'p,� r�� x ��r" n
��i s wr -w r
C"'�t, 'j+' S
�ip�`�t i g�� y a a �i
n t c s�� L'� s a
r�'t u x f
��z��,��� x S�' s��w r
r r x 7
i
��5""� t 4si i n, ,w'��'� i a v
s
t y �y,� i �t i� �a X ��i E r 3
c i` >��3 r r �,7 a r 4 ,S
'�`'„e� 3^���YXt
,.s R Se,� ?t
��z'Y! S I
j6 r�' t� r'� r p 9 4
F� `3 u t
5
v� L
f
't a�J'Yr a�a"�`'f e �e t u a`,E r i
�r �p�' c i q �e+�a d��.."w �S 7 .tf 4� r F r =r
���,.��7��*��G�` 4� '�,�-�'+�a'' *�a'``�'i i 1
z�.y� P�*t5�� n v�" r„%�* '�d'4. ti h�"�" Q $'ss t
��t��' `�,.S�v.�7�, 5+1#� 5 r
F 1 L' F d�T +`�4A F z �t� ns P 3
k 2 i :�',�}�y t
q i,.
�'1'� r -r .o,
s
a
,a�y
i, t
i
p
�;`�+a�
���x rv
�'y� x
�i" w�"��
p� b
�{�2��
x
��Y��
y
i t p
�3@
�k
F 7
Y d F Y� Yf�N
y T 4 '�3�'' �5 E �S ��d x .f
�^7�' 9 i 9'�'���`�4t��"
�t �t
i 4 j '��S'3` y+��5'�t
1 �x
z'�' '�a• �"+''��`�-*�6'�
3 v� �4 t i
y ��'Au �s r�
f
r �'q, c t t
ti x
.�;v,�r`-
}*Zr�Y�����M4�� ;Lb
t 1 9�1 yF� r�f Pr
PC r�
A f t F
�N,� t n, �`t�u.
,tti� t r �a,��
t �r a
SAC�S�e�r� 'C,.! _"a�� .,k+=",
6 p
1 '49
x
s �`y
bd
g `Z f
a E ��ta F x
��i.��a�
y x
e
:Y# x �u
?r a h
F 'r i f
K
Y
Y I
t .3 r t x
y` �tr;,E J r :i x t
t r
r�+"�� j ��y ��t�, s
iU� 3 6 4 ���1 hr'
rt"� g k
r,
Y
Y'':.'.�
d i T s w t"� v r �w ��"ra` xs t r �S.,u,�y ';e''�F,I tS r i
t� d� y' r s +x ��u� �w
us S a ,ui.�� t �a� �ra a�- a e .a,,�y�'�«�`4z�sx` .�a
s
,7 �,i t x r 1 i k k r�''� �A'��'! K q
1 �u a�
z�� 3 u i !�F �,.d�y, 4 3 ��'S' W e
i v ;fi i d f 5 r ys P �,4�� 3 .Sm��
k F,+ a R„ .r �q. i t t a�' t ��t� x C
y t e F �".y 4 e
fi a
e a ,*"q t ,i n r�� u�,S ""e 3.
I Y 6 ���+5`7Y Mt��
a�,a& 'a I k h �y� t������'�.����,A L
�t�� 4 o u f �M� "bya'��4
d j ��r�s\ x�.�,��`�`+�4
r,�� c f ��S 1� '�r
fi S r r S ts e 4 �Ar �3?� '�'��,�'��"�i��� ��-��g�15
�'k y fi i i *t Y d ,,,rr t a z fr �i .,q�s������
6 4 Zb}�i'?�1��a��4�,�yxo"„���.�{rv"�. ,.r....
a�� r a �1 r F��Ci3�s�7��v ��t �v A��f3�
�''rM x t 2� r�'1,
h 4 ��a a: a. va ..+�tt� j q� '�''a `'3������ y f
r. r r Sa r rr� i r t�
�T f.. �t4�'t� �"'��w.c sd` 5 1*.�t'��.d�:
t i'� r" 3 5 t S R, 4t t ^�+.5�'
h Q `1 ��t G a� ``"�Y;ai
r s t „r d £3 h �3' w T E'�+�.
ix'� r ti r'� v l� T �#w4'�"`�`� e }����5�"�t a
a r{� t 7 4 k -.4 k.�, F" z �tr.ey�*"` �#7� ,M y
v �d r s d
�i "{4 S .�,4xY' .�x�F�' Sir,�,� tk�z�"'t �f2�'�`}�""a
h� x,. �a r �s u �.�4 ��.�v
i e ,a �p�..�� P',� s iY a ha'���ea�fx� 3mi��� �'�r� �s
v, d� A°
F,° ;,F a y e ,s.. x 5.,�'' A�u���� h,
f'��� s x, r, 3: vd ,k^'� 3 5,2 f a �k� u �'h� i� Y"� r�z� �kM�z'3� A ''r
S °M 'Y 5
S i c '�,�i �n i. Sa'- �R'��`*����n� s
N d e i w t t a^v a �f tb u
Y�;' s���,+ r s v 3 �a �S �.�'pSk.�' r M��, �,�rs
S x a- n ��."u€ ..r� a '7�
F s' �r E ��'}�r��
$�,5�, q. w i` c
g x t x�IW-�'t{mr ��,�7 k
a;f' k,a j W h r
x '�,i 2 V w w. e b c u�, ��+e�
�a� e4',��� ,r y� z t 5 h m�
�r '�.,Mei T` f rr .��'s
�y t A �r»�: fr l*'�4 ;r
3� ti �i� ��������k�����
.�p€ p�«�' �'G t" �i i�: t' �f ,r s
i�R 4 �,i� y 1;,�, F a ..���r��rd zt�`r�t*��� xwt9;5W
t d �7 i 4 a i 's x s -rit� �s �'s��ki k
���i:+ t �k i x+ t t y� ,�1 �y,�r �s �7 -d'P�'��. 3
f w�: �r 3 'e i 3@ V 1 i t .�'�T
�.;9� t .t �i ..'r �k�` �a'�k.�' ��ks q�;� �.'n
t� �a k W Y x
a t �t{; i t Ts �Cr� 'YR
x 's r a �s�c c a�
a �°�o u�"�`� t r, t uY�r, v r� ��+�a
a i.;; �ti��� 1 t a u �,.s"''� �"ti�"�'�G� a
�i' �5'3� k`' K C'�'�
f t al�� n i �t �t' k �5�� M�
a v +M t .k r� r�� G��'��,�y��:
r{✓+4 t r v q I �`k�"�a f k�s xr f q�''F��"
t
H :y �'aN�i�§ 1.= a L r i h g�"��4�;�
9
di 7
q P y C+ n a�3ayt�3
W �k,� 5r;�
y .��a r� �.a a
l f k t� 4 l �r�{'� h
h F.
t.
a
x y
6 s .�.z.
,.t t n
�z
4
k Y M I r
o p �d 1� i �ro.�.r o r t e� t e l.
�t t�r A� 'C��4�"�t ta����
�tt..t��i L�
t
�c.,
In 2005, apartment 3854 XX had several kitchen si auc aufilll �/tlJV1V111A 1.110.t w�,� not
corrected for weeks despite orders. One apartment would drain dirty dishwater and the
apartment below would get a sink overflow of black dirty sewage. The vinyl floor, nearby
carpet, countertop and drawers were filthy and smelly. The management at the time was
in turmoil with staff turnover and no effective repairs, cleaning of drains, or carpet
cleaning was done.
In addition, the resident (K a) refused to perform basic cleaning of food prep surfaces
and also would not admit repair persons when it was inconvenient. The counters,
drawers, flor was filthy and a toddler lived in the household. The management gave up on
attempting corrections quite easily because of the occupants refusal to admit repair
persons.
At the same time, new carpet throughout the entire apartment was demanded. The
Housing Inspector had to intervene with these two parties who refused to cooperate and
issued specific orders with short deadlines and threats of citations to both occupant and
owner to correct. Housekeeping cleaning surfaces (resident) and plumbing carpet
counter top replacement (owner) were ordered. One section of carpet was ordered
removed and replaced when shampooing proved inadequate. The occupant was incensed
that the owner was allowed to merely cut and re seam one section of damaged carpet.
The owner did not provide the proper equipment for his staff to try to clear the drain
initially and backup re occurred. The owner waited until the 11�' hour to replace uplifted,
deteriorated countertop, complete clearing of drains, and replace damaged carpet. The
owner repairs were overdue at reinspection and only with threat of citation, were
completed.
Summarv: An uncooperative occupant should have resulted in greater owner effort to
solve unsanitary conditions caused by failure to perform basic apartment maintenance
and instead, it resulted in foot dragging and delays by owner. The sink backup complaint
involved two apartments and the owner did not respond adequately initially and gave up
repair efforts too easily.
On 12/11/06 I received a call from the pohce dispatcher that 3850 apt XX had no heat
since 12/7, 4 days prior. She also referred a complaint of a strong sewage smell in several
apts and ponded water in laundry. Our phones were on the fritz so The Housing Inspector
did not get this info until2PM on 12/11.
I called this resident who confirmed calls to police and that problem remained
unconected after 4 days. Called Terri Kanis (mgr at the time) who said problem was
being fixed and that boiler needed a pump part. She said heat should be on by end of day.
Called resident back to inform but went to property anyway due to the complaint about
,r
ponding sewage water. As I pulled up, owner Jawed got in car and drove off rather than
s eak with me. Resident met me on walk and said that the owner had said nothing to I�
P
them, only spoke briefly w/ Jeff the onsite maintenance man at that time.
Police calls will confirm calls re: no heat on 12/7. Residents had been unable to get thru
using the Robbinwood emergency pager phone. Jeff, the maintenance guy reported that
he only heard of problems above at 9AM on 11`�. He started to work on it immediately.
Note: the phone number for Robbinwood residents to call the management, (763) 533
2600 would roll over to Terri Kanis at Centerpoint Apts in Brooklyn Center 200+ units at
that time because the new Robbinwood mamager had quit suddenly.
Photos show ponded sewage in laundry and boiler room. Snaking out the drain by hand
held augur was ineffective. I had seen ponded water several times before in this area of
laundry. It now appears related to sewer backups in adjacent boiler room.
bu electric heaters to sta warm
Two residents in the hallway told me about havmg to y Y
over the past few days. One resident described then windows that drop hard, another
consistant problem at Robbinwood. All such windows were supposed to have been fixed.
Some were not discovered at previous rental inspection because resident furniture
blocked access to them. Another resident described of a water leak from ceiling on their
top floor unit. I do not have unit nuxnbers from these residents in 3850 bldg
Before I left at 4:30, I called the owner to order an emergency correction under HMC
425.33 subd 5(emergency) that due to combination of strong sewage smell, no heath,
inability of residents to open windows /ventilate, cold weather, e�c, that by noon on 12
next day the drains must be cleared, odors gane, floor cleaned up, cleanout plug in place,
and heat restored every unit. I have zero confidence this would all have been done
without the verbal order and threat of cita.tion.
Summarv: The Police and Housing Inspector had to get involved to ensure response and
completion of a routine maintenance repair that got out of hand due to being ignored.
Phone problems at city hall and also the failure to monitor the owners emergency pager
system caused further delay. Basic communication between owner mgr and resident has
been nil at times because of owner phone system shortcomings.
The owners response to complaints about strong sewage smells, inability to use the
laundry, ponding drain water on the floor, and lack of heat during winter was tardy. The
ted maintenance staff to attm t work that was beyond their capabilities or
owner ex ec P
P
tools provided.
Instead of doing preventative maintenance to keep drains clear, the owner tends to
respond late to clogged drain problems and uses professional contractors only as a last
resort. Residents have to wait and endure unsanitary problems with this slow motion
approach. Robbinwood Apartments has a history of numerous clogged drain issues with
this owner.
Note: The previous owner had none during 2000-2003 that resulted in calls to the City
Inspector.
The drain cleaning contractor (Viking) used by this owner told me that many times he
has told current (jaweeds) owner that the cost for scheduled, preventative maintenance is
%z that for emergency drain cleaning.
The owner has a history of failing to supply parts that are requested for repairs or money
for parts. Sometimes the owners will supply a fraction of the parts required or ordered for
repair and some employees have purchased them on their own then had to wait for
reimbur
sement.
Note: It is common (reported to me) that maintenance staff must take installed parts from
a vacant apartment to use for a repair, rather than be able to buy new parts needed.
The owner avoided the Housing Inspector on 12/11/06 and drove away when he saw him
at the property and had a chance to discuss the problem and provide information on
resolution. He failed to speak with his residents about the lack of heat and sewage smells
unaddressed for 4 days when confronted by his residents in the hallway. The owners
failure to respond resulted in residents deciding to purchasing electric heaters to stay
warm in mid winter.
The owners actions or management style may be interpreted by the reader as to regard for
Robbinwood residents and the city ordinance under which the apartment complex is
licensed to operate.
A boiler was replaced without a permrt in another building at Robbinwood. I was told by
the contractor who later obtained a permit that the owner preferred he install the new
equipment without a permit because it would cost less. The contractor advised against
this but did the work reluctantly. See photos of boiler tear out debris and permit record.
t..,Q
7.
y f r
0
Y
r `��:�'4 4.. u�n ::'*�..Fe xi p5a..
t
k
YFt� MenY Mfey, p
'�TY .,t.0 F �s $'e.+ ;"5.7+
�r'
��"i—��--
v�
�.N
M1
N J,
�5
y:, ��1�`I
4'.
r !'Y� �p 4
4
F P aY� r $4 k
r 7iz M
R ��.R
z
z
v h,�� d y
y y
mi c sv J
z i', k 4 ,3
5"
ty t' R� $.:"„b 4
P
k� �Y� 3
I
k s t
a4
ir i 4 S
Ad �l Y
d� ,r
��y: b
s
M.
r r nR d j
1F f sp �4. 't
j
r �Z x`
y�
P T i
,Y�� a"'� �t� 1 �"�.,1�i`"�. F 3a
t ka�"
#�w�;'t�, i� r���
,��a' �b�
s
,s �4._�°�
r 7w 2 R_
S i C� f 5^ �."�v{ tA.
fi'�e,��- +4
��9' �0,.�� C.. i P^�
g�s
A Y>
�f` J'�
:A!
µf
i
t�
h iN
T
5
r
m a i
fi �f
���a �p M
k
Q a i h ��i�
.:t.,.
�'H
5
1 S
t
j
t' t`
�r
Si �'''m.
r`�
d
r
.V Ss eh" k 4'r
c: �k. 5""���, T� k 7 t'�,� u�'k ��r ^i d g��".k'
�,Y�: �rx a :b x.t. .�,4. «tt k� a:�.���a35t.r p ta�5:�
3 t� t'.'.
Y .{t� �3 a �s 3�t�a ,.m rv��r .,1�;. �.-ts t. 5 :�hr s r,�;. Y e 1. ,,.i,
'd' �a. ra�.�..a� ��c r' .n :u�.� �s ..r: �.;'s M s �rr.:, t.' ,a� t`a r,.�,.
�r t
v i. �Y't S .....i ..'?�i:,�: t �L t n r �i .'�:;i.r t d� r r., t'+
,r�,.,:l�.�., .t.. i .v ....,t,:�` h�.:, A.. ,e. .r .,:�.-\l a�.,: F .a_......'�"�� k�:� P ;it
,z,.. �K 1,,� t.� a .e, a<.. ,f, r r; ,�:'i
._a., s ,n a f �t a k
rol.�._ ��•x .'v,. �r�a <s ...e. "��.���,t: a.. ..'T t,�,. .r,.,,,.. ..s .tS �u_.,c S�, .t.��u�
v....,�,.
r.h. i.. �s.. ,N f e 1: a s ...�,.3� t� �r [Y` :.:z ,s.. ��,t; 1 x
,F.� .....k.,ce �+.>E, ;:«t� _.u.-... .�,fi; �sxc�
s.. ��hn'. ,..z... k t..r�?. .,.r. l.a. a.a3�( F a ..,s. ,u� ^"z
a .,5, J.,�, lr* c a ..`,z'� e .1�.:r, i ..k.:. v x.t. a �+t��
i.. n�� i,.K.4 n k ��....'4A. t-. M t ."1. ...r k y
.at. .s.. �i...V� �:a� 3�. we.. :h� vab. Y ..f. R
w� .�"k�i t t, t .�..a. vfi'.., .s. a�t., .i`� k�..e.. .s... �..-.t s �.ia: x.
..r �m� t ..,,e M t, r
�,,E �s,.:r�: �.t.!�. .r:. tt. r z .:.�..4:. ro�.r�sa'��.�. �.c K c::. ���r
.tiv, b t �.1F T, .N;�:TM.� ts :i?,, 3a `�l n:.:. .5 7}.�... �.4�ib 4 .,i:. ry..�:�... Y. �k'$+�+..,... K h'�.. :7''n !f'
x s s:w M�. s ,u,• 5 "�?a. ,�'nr= t c y r.,:, r �i e w
M .,;Fr.. �r,v°.. .?..-a s.
n „::..+a�:�.t t� x.,. �w. t ti "�:t�',v .�z+, e a-`� 15 m '4 i a�.k,..": .�a r;� x
sF t ye. ri .,,�.:t��.., .r�_ .r
.''1 .:r: "ro�. ._L�. re �{r e; s x i, :pz s r �r7 3 t .:t
.f^�, +,t b ,a. +�5 t. rv r�c r t k r a 3x v
,n. ,._...w W.. z _i n s �r� x C �;t� a x 3 +,�r, P�.. b a�.:.r .�s
t ..:*,u �.15�� i E;n r... t.u�., c� y M1 k��,.: �,C, t.. :..n
a. ig. �r�`3' �n,� 3 .v x„u r k a at::., r i.. .'a; t� ._t,, s a. s.r_
�a'� r �x'S ._'�ha �n .t^ 1" yt �t s� rz r c t,..
t n�; r y�:J,�r, E �in 5 �3 w .w e, 1 t x? a� a: .e �if S
�a o'��,�;in T�'� i�: '�,�`':r r r*f .ir �.�k r,�4�.;. c�. a
ui ,(1� '��4 f h.. k� Y �.75 kE.'�j� 4 i X4 4 ,:R
y�T'r!�'' 1 r �ra��,, 'i?, i i :w�� ���k z nx t l�' �i� s
�€a ��;��-�r °G` i m a a.
a�� a x r� a
��a� L ��it� s
s a p
o- s
x
i 77 p� i ��1'
{�i� `Y�^� 4 rk �i
��ayY17.M 'S i d S I
V l
5,y y� �'1"i
i �r Y y p }`j
p $b'� A'`. +w4.
t g
7
t
�4y �ma' �d 1
t s� m.A
p� �tJi._ Y'j 1
I
y� 4� t b(
q
y x�
Y
i
Summarv of Problems at Robbinwood and Coachlinht Aoartments. Revised 9/26/07
Rubbish Problems: Rubbish problems started soon after the current owner purchased
the Robbinwood Apartments and at Coachlight Apartments when that proerty was
purchased. The former owner of Coachlight had received an order to increase frequency
of service and had not done so. The former owner of Robbinwood never had any rubbish
problems from 2000 to the sale of the property 2003.
In September 2004, the City Manager approved an emergency abatement of accumulated
rubbish at Robbinwood because the owner's failure to pay for sanitation services resulted
in stopped service by the contractor. The amount was attached to property taxes under
State of MN Statutes. The pile of rubbish stacked around the overflowing dumpsters was
10-12 cubic yards, had a stench, and was visible for blocks.
There have been numerous times when the owners failure to keep sanitation accounts
current resulted in "stopped service". Onsite dumpsters overflow and residents have to
put up with it. Many days the view from County Road 81 of Robbinwood has been full
dumpsters with scattered debris on the ground. The owners' failure to pay vendors
resulting in stopped service and staff limitations to monitor the grounds is generally the
cause of this eyesore. Many times rubbish has been left on the ground until city order or
citation is issued. An unintended consequence of this failure to maintain the grounds is
illegal dumping by non residents. That rubbish then belongs to the apartment owner.
The Hqusing Inspector has issued citations for rubbish accumulation at both properties
with no advance notice in the past year of so. They result in mmor fines paid at Distnct
Court with no marked change or improvement in property management. This problem is
chronic and repetitive with both Jaweed owned LLC properties. The enforcement
measures can be ineffective. A key factor seems to be who is a site manager (if any) at a
given time. If the owner has none, ar has an ineffective one, problems develop. Turnover
seems frequent.
The owner has his employees, and not sanitation contractors, pick up rubbish on the
ground. Sometimes this can take weeks. Photos document a period when it took weeks to
get rid of a console TV and other rubbish at Coachlight despite citatio�s.
Randys Sanitation stopped service at Robbinwood a number of times before canceling it
altogether prior to the September 2004 emergency abatement.
As of this writing, (7/27/07) the latest sanitation company to refuse service, Aspen Waste,
is again refusing service for lack of payment. General Manager Marvin Vikla (612) 884
8000 provided the following information on 6/21/07, and can provide additional
information if requested. I
Aspen Waste has stopped service a total of seven times at Jaweed owned properties for
failure to pay for services since 2lO5. Aspen has contracts at various Jaweed owned
:�.r�
s
P s�
x
i R
�'I..
apartments in several metro cities so while some these stoppages may not be in
Robbinsdale they indicate an owner management style. At one point in July 2007 the
unpaid Aspen Waste bill was over $2000. At other metro properties Mr. Vikla described
similar or greater amounts in that time period.
Per Mr. Vikla, Aspen refuses to remove their two 6 yard containers from Robbinwood
without a written request from the property owner.. Mr. Vikla stated that he has never
once received payment for services unless there is a city order involved, or unless his
staff has gone to the owners' home demanding immediate payment. Aspen containers
currently sit unused, and adjacent to Allied Waste dumpsters at Robbinwood. Allied
currently services both properties.
The two padlocked Aspen 6 yard containers remain unused (9/26/07) at Robbinwood
awaiting some resolution to the non payment issue. In mid July 2007 the Housing
Inspector peered into one with heavy flies buzzing and found it 1/3 full of garbage and
other trash with active maggots boiling away. The container had been locked before it
was emptied apparently. The manager at Robbinwood (Laura) was notified and tried to
find a way for her staff to cut the padlock and remove the contents by hand
Importantly, until this situation was brought to the owners attention and a verbal order to
empty the unused dumpster was issued by the Housing Inspector, the owner and staff did
nothing.
Basic Utilities Heat and Plumbing Issues: Warning notices from the gas utility have
been issued multiple times for failure to pay the bills. Currently (7/24/07) Robbinwood
has been notified that gas shut off is imminent for non payment. There is one gas meter
for each building of 22 units so residents must count on the owner for gas service.
Robbinwood residents are regularly subject to the unnecessary concern and worry of gas
shut off to their home by the owners failure to keep current with payments for gas
service. Individual electric meters mean that residents pay their own electric bill. Note:
(9/26/07)Gas shut off was averted in 8/07.
Unpaid amounts for city sewer and water have reached into many thousands of dollars at
times in the past. The city will assess the unpaid amount to taxes rather than shut off
service.
Boiler problems are fairly frequent at Robbinwood. Every winter there are calls regarding
"no heat" situations. They are usually minor adjustments due to air in the radiator lines.
Preventative maintenance prior to cold weather has been recommended for years. Failure
to respond to renters in a reasonable time means these calls inevitably come to city hall.
The owner had boilers removed and new ones installed by a contractor in the past yeaz.
This was done with no permits, but permits were applied for after the Building Official
became aware.
Slow drains and backed up toilets are common at Robbinwood and the problem has
happened at Coachlight also. When there is a plumbing backup, the three conditions that
i
seem consistant from the perspective of the Housing Inspector axe slow response,
inadequate removal of carpet and padding, and inadequate fans to dry out the area
affected.
Instead of fans with the CFM needed to dry out wet areas, puny residential fans are used.
On more than one occasion no fans were available because a fan was stolen from another
o urchase one
property and the owner had none available, nor was money forthcoming t p
quickly per maintenance employees or sub contractors.
Inspections Reins�ections: At one recent rental inspection at Coachlight, the Housing
Inspector was accompanied by a person from a new management company, VIP
management. Among other HMC violations, about 15 or so kinked and (one) leaking gas
lines were observed. The leaking one had been repaired with electricians tape. T'hey wer,e
ordered repaired immediately under permit. It took about a month or so for repairs to be
done. There was no mechanical permit pulled by the contractor, Aarons Plumbing. The
total invoice was reportedly around $4000.
At reinspection, when the unpermitted work was observed, the City Of Robbinsdale
eed for
re uested a co of the r air mvoice so the Building Official could discuss the n
q PY
permits with the contractor. In writing, verbally and multiple times, requests for tlus gas
line repair invoice have been made to the owner. It has never been provided.
A good start on corrections had begun under VIP but they shortly discontinued their
relationship with Jaweeds for reasons unknown. The garages at Coachlight were required
to be unlocked as they have never been inspected in 7 years. VIP could not get keys. As
of today, (9/26/07), there has been no garage access and the 2007 rental dwelling
reinspection remains incomplete because the owner has failed to make an appointment to
continue it.
Other Cities: Rental licenses held by this owner have been either revoked or revocation
has been considered for similar practices and failure to maintain similar structures in a
number of other cities including: Colombia Heights, Fridley and Brooklyn Center.
Inspection staff in these cities will confirm that outstanding orders are ignored, or
describe failure to correCt by due dates. A chronic lack of parts or money for apartrnent
staff to buy parts to accomplish repairs is typical. Again, the pattern �or style of
management by the owner is consistent city by city.
Summarv: Conditions described in HMC 425.01 and 425.05 that provided the original
rationale for starting the Housing and Maintenance Code in Robbinsdale, and that are
eliminate are found during
cted to revent or
Ins ector is d�re
conditions the Housing p P
rental inspections at these owners' properties, or are revealed when resident complaints
are investigated, and they axe generally not corrected promptly. Corrections generally
start late, and aze generally preceded by denial that there actually is a problem, or that the
ownership is being singled out or penalized somehow. Appeals are given with each order
i
I
4
to correct. The owner has never appealed any repair order. The owner has paid citations
fines but not altered the management practices that resulted in them.
The owner has numerous staff turnovers and rents apartments that are not clean and ready
for new residents. Reinspections that axe required to verify corrections ordered, are often
not scheduled without reminders or threats of citation. Delays for parts or delays in
authorization for repair or money for parts is a common complaint. Without reinspection
the Housing Inspector has no confidence that this owner will complete any type of repair
or cleanup.
Excessive (city) staff time is spent at times resolving or monitoring ongoing problems
either as Housing Inspector, or as Code Enforcement Officer at these two properties.
Reducing that time would result in worsening conditions for city residents and complaints
from neighboring properties.
Preventative maintenance is rarely done and residents who request maintenance report
poor response, or none at all at times unless there is a.ri order to correct from the city.
C �J e w .t. i C
1
,L� �k C,��� 1
j'1 f\i, ikL' �1.`"` -t� �e.
r� �-�r' ,�C' T;§�?'� 'C ..�y"h�:, i
�i.7 :J� �v
I �1`��' 4` L J «-'C `�j
1 C,� �t`��, Uv ry
t yt�\
y
4�
�v
c
Z
t ►swy`+o :-z
3c
L
t
g
y
mS���'t� ri R' r^ a�
ir 'r a3°.. ,fi o -0'��� �y
i �.f,;
.�s�� i G, �l Y ``,w,_. w
j
G
N i
I �"u' �n: �r� Y`� l 1 G'� T �t
w, I C �a a�
y y a�k M F a �J °n Pf��
f M 1G �k+s�"�� �8w �YYke�k�
I
C1�' g +�'"""`"^^S� k ��)S� �'S�+.. ".�+�i"E'kr, W�.
S' A a7d'NY 4s'.� rc.� t'��f�&' 8'r�43� �a�4
i r' `�n
a i q
t� �'s i `w4 W�-,.xe 4rmkty w.�'� a `5RS �a .-�w,.i
s� 'u xir�� �w.a=���&� ,r��� ��+l�,u.�,�«��
4 ����r+��� ����44�$�� ",<A$��
st.�-°Lht`" x i �:.>r'Y �.�Y �'��'e q 1
st;
y�? d ro�'�t �kv ik�.' F� rs '�,s, z�ae. s�t+nv�
r,
�x vli �w�r� l�,e�,."�
.a �3 �s�d�?a'��4'k�LMw�c, ul �ifa�,�"
s t�e k�{Itc'rF",
`:ni� 98+,aF'�� I'�`��k"�',g$s�l a
�Y g A"F l
v P ,�,�,�,{���"+M1 4�
y
���Ye�y
��!,�r?i:.VyJskn�
9 e`na�
y s
.,:::.e;da
r.��»'�:alk�«� ��.0
k� 4 3 rw:" 4 .A��
��,t ��r�* C� t�s'd u_ a u y
s
K �a
a
n r, n
p ��u
f y �I 'wW
j e{^�,�" i,°
El f �.3�.�.
rY�r� Y��!'Y. M r� Y k Y
M
A m
a
r e�t,. F '.W
K
k
A
�o'M're" s� '�kv''. .`t
i ..x.
^k, d m
L q 4
+!C' �w6v.w"7 a'�h.X
y
�'r 9
m
c
;1 4
'm�r f
fe
V
x.p:
6
r
r ��w"��
x
x
�w�
�s�' r
q �i&� "°II�4`� aT W
v �'Y°s h wX",�, "�'�ii"
Y�+al`",��A'�}�
�^�.�y�j ,��s� 4 �'T �j�����' m'^�� '"n n
u n,�'� �S''�'4�1� k r
s
1 i'A �c 4 u'
F di
i 4_' �d� �!�r:
M !f
ti*c
l_
4 e
,r u
�p
.c 9 S.. r
a n� s 8 6 .>..;5 t 9�' A�, n.
r� .w ,�..N..�... ::.,wY
i
w r r. -.:�d: �;c'�. :t
r
'k
a ,-z,
s x�"�',��� r�� Rµ
3
r I .b«� dF 3Xa-�
I �4M i�•
3.'�� M
s s�� r'€�
�s
w. s� a.
aa��
ar' *4 g,,;;.
L
c c f��i n_�
C` t+ r` r:� I
{7'� �(��:l�fi{���'
r f2 D1 i l e
R-�- d; i� d''t�! i I
�I�
W a,
•jk, Q�.N s F�''�;.. t
f
s% z
r� w
i3*
i
f �k
r
r• aw
%-w i
a ?{�x
r.a t yi
i
r,,r;. 'f'. ,ils
�i�
�s�*��
A.%y
ti
,z
:a s
�:�+%'m�
.o
g ia y.�
r
r:� �r
,z m:
r
�}-C+� t`� R v�i -1'-, I �i 1-t `7 ��C
�A-°� U 1C �T
�t�.=�.,-� ���tc�t�E
i
�R,
W
�i�
i
.a�l� .d'�.,
4" t �.i' 'S
�'k:
s..'Cs'.' YJ
1`
s �.t��n�., H ����r�
q*.: .a u`
il I
I �a
wdu
I�k
r
y-,
.,.,y
p
r
TM�
i
i
j t
Y
Ik�� r I .,�_.�i.
�Y Y x� I
3 T•�
y�
.Fn. 1 '4�.
i. a�
e
A 2A t,' �=-f S y r'
'r+ �4'6. "e, a.k�,'_', sLAU` .�"b r�'.
�^"Fk� t�` ":"f� .W` a�'�t�4
k r-' tlf°� 34
z
F ��s k f a a-� -�.6 �`-+�--r -.�:.r .:s tx 5,�=�.,.��
1
b
k 1
r'
t
t p.
.Q x"'+
_�r+.�hn�.-
is
Z i�i �i'�
�t4t�"�����
Y f r,
I�
rt�r_ 5 t4� �Pb«i ia �`.r" ��p ti ��1` y�
��.x i p� rwt� f '�`Y i
i�e��`�1�� w a L f `���'�'��"w� e �p t a'��`�'�i�
F r �A 4 i,d Lf e �r:�.l �44 j!
t�,s s" ��f t h '��;R ir 6 a �t t r
��9, s E 4. �'.v y
+A,�i';:': L� i.�t, f r f�e �1� 7 4 i`.' 7,
tl �r �t 3 y`��,Lc�
i' s�� `iN$ w�,
I C �N.. k Za '4� 7 .�E j f ��f ¢-A
5„ t t�1�'� Y l�i i ,,1 +F�� �ti 4y �Fa 1f
o-�
u- �y,� t a r t 1 1 �a� �.5
s 1d 1 1 1" i �'t� "1 V4
S k5 �r; t 7 i, t M 1
�1 �i y �ajy �,�i�yfi�i in a �.r 1
1�� i�} #.�.�r a.,�;,� l��E i �viA��Ya��+
�.I gr r� 3 i� y ftti 9 i
4 1f �v k�'�.� "1 sz a 1� a.. F,�� t+�� 4 t
t a A'�` �1,�;! t T 1s� 4�'
S4, ���+,+t h a� C� t o r��:
1 '1 Y
e �i J` �'4'��� ff
y 5�,�, /I��i�'�yk{'4y1 'r T �kl�.� 4`�78 i� 4� t x� ;f� 4
�k�� 4 .a a ^I S.�A 1 �5 a a ,y
y�y r e4 •.Y.� �t t�` .t�� t�ti
i ��t�'Y#��F a i t Y A Rt
c 4
1 3 `....,,u 3 �'Yyr,4� r t� �Y �"r
'�M y �y 1� S'; #f k�:� �y�
i ryya S M����,� a. t. .il"',
9 �j
C i��'t.1i� xY���1� 1s 4 x aY x
a 1, 8` �55 n �a�����tF ry1.��Se -��1 f�' J
�A �X Y�x��� 4 4 a �r.t y =5� R .�����4� E �5 l t
t Y«.::� 5 6E S sxi4? 4 i y
M1 4 Y1�. 'i' 1 V
�5 j� i�. d 4 t _A �1
'�,,.r. '1� Y r��,�`�'k� c�` i A. �r zy� y
i �k5 4�� 5� t sr s y t� r r $a� i7�t7
r
��3 f n e� s kp�t���' ��{�`��r,
J.,, ;1 y R l P'�
t "R f' l
��ts�j� �+���I����,�p Y Ci .e� y ����a
�q y� �i 3 ..f. 1� J }y`� "s
f
a i s y �v r x� '�e•
�1����� �s t°� 'I�R �f��,4 ti�� i�f j �1
f� y.�f y l�"r i Yq a. 1 e Y l 5
"l�� 'I�1S .l F r S
L
��'�'�ly��� ��''�,��,t ��i�'"tt 1 t r ��t
t 1 1 1 S a
1 �'r ti 5,� i e
Y y �t l e' V' t�� y't!�ry
f �t ti ��"v ��y�' 6 .1
9�i ,f�� i 7 r �'i�'� Y i t l y �i 3a�i�4
A E
W�"# 7 sM�..�! r 6 A
�r��A i�' i.'k
'�i t St, �f d�� 1�.�� 1��i� j f,
�y �'��<�'i}lY�� f" i et e t ��'Ut,"
y� "�V a��� fi a{S�w ti ��'i� ti�� P �-�a i�{'
ry ,�'r� ���Q� 3 l r lf 5;
A t+� �a
J �r �M ,a t y q i f
F7 1 4�Y T, b l R i i4s M
��'�t �'1 5 e�� x�
���R ����.�ryt f E l 3�' 1
��i�� ��,Jit#�" �r�s:���,��t i i.SFh ^�,1'�..�
,,y j,
�������t C y 1�� 4� ��S �i k'
t., t i� f
L �N
y�. ��S i t �rt
'"��t w �ti1l .�4 a�`qtr �t v
t y M w� vY
��t��„a •�b�,'T t�'�� x �,ki`+�
,;a�.. s: r rive tIk A� t1 t a r t� u 3�.
Q� f k E 1 ]y s, '4 �h�� t �M� fi4
7 tiY�" ��t� �v��r� iX'`TM t•y��.w. j ,�S! r �t t��"� y y,� fi I�','��
t t ily�`�L �•v l Z a +C' ��tY� s +t`(
�1 �t attK4{ a f s �i
1'"�. ��t� a +e, i ��`a l "�,:ij..
7- ��FM1 1 1 w c -4��
e owfi k a i ro ^4 8 T� r�
iN.�. t� �q,' a 1 ..p 3,
k,.�' 1 i 2�;� �2 a
s��, �+d�� �'po r� r t t,:�
'i. r ��t� i:,'�i fe��,�„� 5�.�
��k�' t A'� �i h}��f:'� 'e r�� 1 a ✓4
9� �hti f ��a;,,j i,
j a
1����� �M'Ir����} y t
C'• q• F t� g i��k� i� aJ.� 4T d ��q`y
1 �ii4' 4 1?' ��`,4 Y P} h` 1W e,g. gt& t f'. i t
e ��wl� `�i Ati� ��t��'�.
'Y 5 4 +i �,b 7 t y ���1 f 1' �'��A" y �r
1� r �x ��1 '';�l .i`'ati'�' r �i
�;�i� 1 a S� wr t 3'� i b' �°a�
�t��� SRt' Y� �`+3' ii�,.; e���'t
r i �s+� n t`� °i
�x z �r��"
i �tt r 3
a; :.t���� r �i� S� .�i�,��,� }°S �i�,��f
�e�� Z j, y?i��t t
��;t� s�+4 �,l��'iP� y e �F,�
t x t 4 i4
S c� �.�3 n a
,�.�.z
�s
w f \{/�J
n 'i�'2P 1'1,. 1 �-Y ',1"' G;;Z�_ 1 r i
O
r_ ��i a r'
�s�� a. z�, �.,�,1
�k��� i
i�n�� N_:��� i� 0 N.1
�_l� �s��
�t:
d
t�� ���'ly'
`:�sb
.�w
,.'�W'� ��,A m�$�r.�� r�+ ���,"at�� �t`�� o-.�� k x�.
e.e
xr
,.x n
.-,f.»
y
fi
F -i `:$�.i
T�' t`t" =4 I&r sl� a
�y� l
t
s
a
5� y
sy' Y
R t
r v
�v �r:
�t``� z �G?
�F�`S 'T K-a
5
.a �6�
fi �y a 4 `c
j4x .�,5`� f j� 'Y'
�.J
y`t '*r- ,5�. l.<
7
5
_k� t S� 4 5 4��
W
3 �'x e
.a. s s
a t x
"N y f+, .ew'���
�'n P�'�� s�` 3�c" r x�r-�-�� k
r `T- y 7 f r'"�_
c
y -.��s s 's�Ff �w �+�i�'
r kw"N%"r j w-
r a fi�'
a a .z� 7
7`" a r T
��z;_ s t y
,�s �t a e. x 5,'�+ v y y i
y..� E .A. :r y
a�� s p 3 ;x ffi �r
s ..�-�r�- :`s�
s� S 1 Y a si 1 V g 3� ,�a ��s k'` t*, i
0 F�, e s
r t�. s� y
�,r. ,7
��,t a�'` 't�"� a
-a'�s
y t
�.a��� r r r
r•?' �.�t i 1:A- r, iYi^ ,t fi. Y
•c�:. v h, o a r'`
3 z fi s a�' e� �GY��' y#�, t 3" �3
x `a�.�" :t �i�4 a' _s3,,� s�.
�F r 9 �.�2
.,y` sts r r e �'�ms,
�i'"�".� „t�+ a` R r r� ��v f'a.
�S� �Z ,r G e
a t�s� ,r.��d.� x �t: Y �.�t R h rt�c
p� 3 s.-
r 3 z -4 a �S� F ,�,r a' a
fi a I 3 �y a `4
_r 1 A,.�,. �'a"' k 4.
f r -c� 7 y `a:+�
x d
ry ��,�m y }��i r
c�_ .y,^"id q 33 s.�� z ���,-s;,�? r� T a'�. a
G z x
.s e� y x
-.�t� c�.,
;�^s
i�
r _____f
;;C s 1�
t w I� N
p Y
A 's s
��tA-f��
y T
s�
�1y� rc'�C.� y� 1�
i k
�t x
r 3 Y�
�1 t
F �'A(R�.n d�q W! x t�'�� S
W
x
�s.N.i A, a�,� _..a �a
r %,���z�� i
x
t �:�a M
rr
'.+k�� �.'�?w5�� k t
3q 3 M
a Z ��'�r
1 W f�n�' p�4 v: 1�'^
�a��..
J �.i_.
a s
4 j
a.:� �#y '.X. d,
y ��e��t��"�� y. 7 r rC�
l A 6 +Yk '�i f a, Y 4 I..�
j' x r'� x.J>,k� j
,r a C. 1 s, �,4< �c"
�i �r c��. v r,
v ��,s� z'� fi x
y a. �,s� k �"d
s r��t` �.'a�
;��5« r i x `�a S
J �i�' N F 1 YY 7° iR'� t�
a s v �f �z[ y�� 'x t '�dy
,.+r r a r r k q x t v
11�� ,.�„��'j �`tx` M" h�.'
f i j�na `r h �s j x w
P w 9k "'F y f 'w 'L y, r`� r x
x t �,f�a{ ,r'" rk���W.. P'��� S f� '�,i0?� '4'S#t�`;:�
`y �k '�E g .v� E <w
S 'Q M
y 3 Y 9! �..t �1' y q
E� 3 l at� ��P w y h k.' c i P
tl x 4k A� ..�ry 2"� 7 q
•�w Y W 9 4 ey: s tS
r �k a fl �"V a A S t N fi W i y
1 ^q �k Y Y
a �M+,y �F �r w .r, �4 M
i� +.r "p��,t 7 �'l��,+�' p
t n �7 ,r 7r 1 y rW',,t z a "C Y f
J A g
y �'y d`Y,y ��w�� k g �F
r p M
r k�
f a� r s 1��� *M��
7 3/+k�ff��.�y'7' t Y.,
j q
Y` d
V F I
f, d
Y
d p r �.y s
a 3 a., n ��s+
Frk' t s il j V4
3 Y'� 7 t 1r
i s �M ffl� M y�p x
,j se� i y �s j �i� i, l
a
p: y} b T a'Sp.� �l�` r I V
i
y t t� us x.. z
t aC ,a 'S
r r 'r j'.,. r
i ���t y F i °ri x� �h
U y
t r� t�. 1 s t x Y� Y F'��� H�
9
'z
'k` a
a#�, t +r y .�br; k:
a t r�. S t� v �y.�
i
S 'r� t '7 4� ..s....; 'A`�r?
t�
b n A r F 1
t y �4 3 M1' h fr�
J� p
a f
f s� "9 fr a a� g�+! d'
y '.t ,W y .k �a x r
a�. r a. '�'�r'r„� s 1
b r �as a �8d x r 4 a a 7
��'�it�� 4 z q �v,� '��yr���,S,��
v b
e��� h R��� a �Po ��$�t.w�. v%�� k V
R� d
Y �2
4.
t
p k f ^s t
I T
i j �4 y� g
�d 6
�jJ 7aE
W l r., 7
4
r
,t s?�`�
r'
fry�. r
4 `1 �i 3
t w 4 6 r
t r x �,i�+,t m s d
�r m*,:m p r d >�rt,
i k Y f
ti M c 1 ,�tv rj rt 3 ���a,� r' t
.g i ts
i t U j
F 8 ��a#'�r.. y .��a� �l"
f y
i TM u t Y i t 4'S i' �B.l
i 1 �f T d
1
V 1 y
.Y g'"t 1.'� r �4j�k 1 F b
d 4 Y i
i „'t
i
�g� �§�,'�n 1sF,�� w u,� Y�� W �s�. Y
a� L
.l' a�i P '�k r.
�6i k, `S aC�! y r t'�, N
f ,k�e��� V l�
t t ��r ia t.
i a.�F'k� g t »��P. a
P z i a
a
a 4 orc y ��s�i r 'r�y. �k"�
y t l��Jr F
ti x 6 1 I
g 9r�,1 r -�k t5
J T i� t '3�.4`�a t��,3°t� A t i �er Y.
J 7 �Ii%' T� 0 a A
«�ti r� t r
1' h� Y�yJ f� 'Y+. f
4 j"" ��z, �1��,���r i �r.
t ,s� y k�,a Y�k k h �7 7
f� na'� �e A iw7��; A s i a
t p Y t u A
i 4 {�F� ��fL�. i
.5 jF ��Y�F�f �y�v" ���y �9 c�� K`��+r z
wM
I 3 .1 4,� h. U�.�'�T 1 P9 'a b. ,A
4 Rk (1 �,'S� J"{..k*�h �h t
t 2 s�ln F SM�l��fi� �t r X 1
ti
4 i a fi�
h �'A Y $i t�� Yf ML I4 P t a.
�C' t r 9 'k�. �y .3XT d
�,�li r s� a
t n'', f �+7� ��r x's �E x g j�.� a 4
5 f 1, P�, k s6�2� f
2 7 1�-0 x A MT'�
t:: i k r� h+" y u' a'
i S�a k, �`J��" i� w
Y c t r t g�� Y
r a. 3 �;+YP t �a
y
t
s
r
a I,
�^�s .t s
dy t`b� ,�4
�W�.�`����
ki r� p �t d
t� L Sa�;� k J;�
J y� t t K-� r S„; §3
__J
���t ..w:
sx
r a -a
5 Ca���`������'����m r0' r x
��:4 t���'�i �^��'�54� e°"�
r. 3 '��,r� �,ti� p���� 1 r t .�,,Q�
y Y`�'� y �x� a+ z e
i t� .�f. i �a4.fi E wd'�4 It �.1 ��r
t �w�#�t���, t�"' �h�'" P
9 a� s c m��,°'� n s s xi
1 ����`����',*k�.� ��9�i r �4��x t��} ��V ia M��
c' ���f� �F a��
a� v�yw t
r
9 t�
aY��,
G "^at F t �6 ,v'� r yr�� �.F�� �i v g v y „�3
a z6 .r P u` j yrµ
R Y$ �"`n'ti Y �r�` s r 4
t i i F' l°n x v t a y e
S if� ."4� `�1 e� �,t. r t w
a 4 �����5 k
a ;a
:�.',k a t f,,� �a ;r 9 .4
j.�.. a r�'�i4���� Y� ��k .f�$ t a h
2 a s, '��'c� �'A w�, t� 4'� N
1 t y� ,7 sb, x^� q
q�l� y �a N s�t���� y+l�,�"�'4 z �S'`""��� ���h ir ,.Y ��.k� q
R°
d. 2 i� Ck A� p 1 d H �lJ`
'�t £iJ�l 3 i� �l �J�Y64 %��3P�����'MI ft� _W .�i.
g� Wi�' .�.a
n 'SM i d �'i w`� Y��'7•. �tN# �a t, k �.r..,.
r;� i t!, �i� a �n nF�
..+J.. t w a,t KA .-et
;3 4 ��,a v�
�Z"'. a �y.
a ip 4 N2� I S 9 k. y"� M�� ��J
t �.f k ja� ,�Ta.v ,v �T �"er�
J Y �x
�.a� b ;d �a z
F i� Rp F y �-i. Y
5 s� t ;�',cf-'""x" r .F i Y '��r`� �'4a r�A r�' a
x
i� i'.�5� .,�n c,� y i
,,.n u, d
f d i �C�'w'� e �i r
.,e r rY i
h xr"�'".+.�^;a" E`,,�Y.,a` q a "r '�'r
P t xy
µ.a x r-�, :�e�-�� �2 4 �^'fr�
*s-i j w �'�t��sx
m�f t��"�� �,x ;W,.�,�,w +s: k �:w V ;w c �+?a
�f�' w... 2 J `�lY�'
��'�-�tt _a� �a 7
7 p p Steut t 4 t a t
A Y ,y 7 1� k "K
ln in 4 �h'���'� aR` a t J 4
a e AS j �t
x r 1� 4' �l 4� t K�A
f .i� i i
t q�.nr^^ w t t f, R a
�.��4�r' '4r. x
�C�� dk�` �''.r,. S y+ .Y
I t s
..a"Ft yS l�ii�a� S rr y e 4 r b� 3�� o� 9� s i
tr E d k t x 4 5 tn;
�k Y;
��;�ui� 4 r �t'�
y t Y
�s'��w 4 a�''� �"a��
,y ,l F �4 y
M'�' M i�. `"S yp�N n v
���u*��� ���'�'k�t?d e� �ny w� ��p�
t,;� f,�������� a S ys r 4 r `'Mr��li �;'�.S''�
Y
�'4 y hH f a �17 i� 3'� .a a a
������������t 5 5i� �.����rd-�� �fL:.
q �.�yP �.i'��Y X F ,x,'" 1* 3��
i
f� .i �F ro� �+�'�1��rc .�J 6 1% r��
s
.v v a�.a n
y k� t k Y�' #ti
r d y r
j 4
"5" r 4" 3 �t rS��r�'.
Y� AY 9 $,�!"1 dk u�` �0. kr� j i J tdsa�V k �Y
s t ��t '"r u.� �p,� r '4 y9 S k
n x��t� ,�t �f �t, ..t Y k y k k� 4 i tz•
a d, ��4s a A� t� <s n� �t g 4
x, v.��� �sr�'���, `+4+rw��- i` r� Y�
�a 0 �x�,
t R u �7 ���!!!CCC x# ��"4 1 x
�4 F �Y f F
�U�F�� g hIY�
��.�y��� 3.: �k, t -r ��x�"`"��, 7 {�.f� q' ���4� 9
r �s� 9 RY t� +�X fl.
r T Pjc `�fL. 'p� fr t f d `�r�� +�r ,��y �yr ,'k�,gt k i fs
"t' a �`.t' i�
a,��'�y Ya. -�i"e, ti t� a*�'r a '1n+:.k' r 3- �'�:��c
t� K� �e:ti� nis �i s, r� .t� �'w G f� el'.,, 5 3 va.w. e 7�� I
't �«.t, k.:
�t, a
I
Y� iYr. Y
f a4�
4'�� k
'k ry �i11P` o- Y
p a• a p 1.
k� r �1 M+' Y
i y r W
w �6y�� f, .:4" .,r
sr v
t '*r°
a
L, 7 'r �y A
�4 1
Y {i t1
��y b ��Y 6 4
,r ��k k R" p S 4�� a
1� a �i' �fi�� Fg� a�
�t
s W
"�;k.�'4z� 4 a�
't
W ,r
f t;; 9 ti 4k����-�'�� r tkv�,+�x1+ q5�?�
r r 1 y�r,fr��'�'*- `y
,q 2 q
z k
ry �C b 5���: 1�. �t w
S V
d E.� �p� fW'' F y
b
x
'C. 1 �)'r.
4 j i� J� yi
l e# �y Y` 1 t `M �,�It a p
4
x k .Y.'. w .y
kF;
9 '�x��� t r �f rl o a'k
a M s >3t x
a rtp M� C {�'S� r I I
I' I ,�p ��pkik� a
d F 4 �i� R
x a t
3 s
1 Y T� �b1� 7 t� I p K I`
Y Y
�'�2.' ��5� t ,i �1 L a 4k-� a.
i ��+�qs i s y
t A 4 i "S�t t 4.F F y M. 7�
d W 'J n.��D"} V }�"��'i' t qs�J i}�� 'il l.�
t :d z j.�p�.`
�s. A �t Y
u {p x x� �y�Y ��f� j �i�
it ta
4 y i
r
I r
r e r c a t
k 4 kx$ 4e p� p +�Y s m t
4k t y
w. v t c,
t',� 3 a a� i �^r'
y 1 a fi i''�t����� �p� nr .w
s�s y i �'�'`����..yYS�}"��� ��C�"� xa `'qt 'M
F i �3+ �''�}t,p t �rl
,r t �.�-�'r s�' f, 1 p i' �.��i 8
W �S,
s a uir��r
3 F �v� 4r���,�'���.( V� e�
f J 4 y t �`�9�'�+i "�k R�
�$9 z w�"1 G"�*'i;i a i.����C i i�
y r t d 4
�i'�� F o t s4 j� Y
1 �r
l viy�liVM y� ��!_s
y�. +�i 1 i� k �k
i $4 e Fk a> q Y b
�e�ue �S" �}t�" d y
c"� k�' h a n °n
�f �g "�y�:��� t� i
4
a ��y`Vi*�`.,b`,�"`k*��' ��r h kr. .a.�
P _Y I
�I
�;y
�6,� r. r,;
x
s
k i
i�4� r R� Q' S�
t t;"
�,s t i
e
a..
°�k� a ?i ��y r� i 9 'b.� ��.'x
s p, d
a x y t� „a
*.",p�1J ,y► a 4 M F �3
n �+�i f
T�[ �I'� i �,oM""�y�," �:F,
h P 'ki:'
i
��ra
�':e,r� a �#�fc ��n� i�'�'
3kusi,��e` w�as r?
x
�7,�� �„��-����f m '"�����a"
fi
.�3k r .Fr r �uh�k'J� �'r t
....�a wff se:.,�: .�:y 4�r,. .„�Y.....5 .r
�-'�4 .;tir.�
c
x._., ..a ,v q�
.�t �f
e
2i
y.,... J Y�," :�i k �a� vY C:..
a� rs v
A v +Z. fi ��p
"�t.....�.: i �:����v a
.c .i...
I ...r.. -F��.
e .i1.. i:: .0
..l'� .t.
1�sN jC:..:�..
.:m..; F r 3
`y'��,��': �r t��,,,��d ����a, t a, r �ca i a ;t
4 F 5 a .r a tt
9si ka ��kY U� A'� t� ty t M '�d Y �!z a� r s#`1' i k�
y��� �v:� ��``57.�+�'� f�S r d Y +a''� r y q� a� 4
a t uyY' 'S b o a� y nI `y t x ^Y q i! u'N� i a..�e ek a
.g r t �F�4 s� F� g t i M Y t
'sy°A dF'� i <x x i
a o� �r4 1 w e a
y, Y., ly n a i
�ef {�'AW A S v'. C
1 Ei tY
�P E t e
9. r r
n��t.�� t
r �i t'�� m, w
w a e
s k���'� a
a �,x �,.K C
i N ^'Y9� H '3T i iC. 'N 4
a�q+�.3�t �r r
s x 4 s r4,���z�� �t r y,:
r .M�� Yh h �if T.�.
a
p A •tl.
F 1 i' �t 1 '�F �n l .r8 2��-
f k yq 'F t. p� ��1 (�`�7' 4 �e�
���,r�����'� try h �F
i q
2
a S �1.� �,�P ��i x x r::� i 4 4
t c` y ra= �i a
y r�"R� 4
F
t
k ha� ��j� 4 �I
tr y �A� I
a d ��5� i 4 y
�,a ������r.��' i �'�'�`�'�m�':,��'-{f i
c t 1 '�i ��`t ,�{:TT.M k 'Y
a ¢4 v �a �k r���a +x b �k'�T%�"
a, ,8� 7 u,��' e��f�'� i �f���'`�,�'��a4 5 t'�'� t� �i-��.� tt�n� p� S �y j,�k,e
x�: ��ti p'+,�J'���}`�'��� b'�f���ti��' J7 �f�'��P; f"`�'��'�,����'�t'���:t�a,����7Y��:Y{ F �t�� x
�.n�� ry.s�W� rf .�i�'+'°�,yr �S'^,.� �5 �xv d r t���C�i°'��� r i y s a
7 s�` =x xgT� y v� 6 �tj d�f t S x r� t x t.
s� a d c a a °+b� t r"'''
t��' `�'F�� i ,��5� "tt I� u��
Lt���t A���.�` s aW e t r.�� �:r� a
a F A4
da
r
i ...�,W.
x 7�
�r t r
a 6'°"�' :t r .4 �s ,��e
,�v��c R fF� y i
�1 w� r +�N' t r �P' �k
i `�w y '`Q
s i ��a,,,. v r+�.. �F� :17�'''�k' ��+r��
za a f w i 'r 'k .w
s�� 4��'' Kq
w �o- s �d�.at' rg� x q�
w °kw� f�`�,', �..E, r '�w
�R n a
a '�1 "�R h'; �,�c� r �,�w M
�0b ��F��.at� `,e� i t�
�,t .�f�
s 5
f r
m.p� I�m� �M -.1'����
��4 ,i� t 7µe
4 i. 4f�1R it
l w
m d �++�F-� w S 4 R �j�i` !d:
ti%,a?�� �i q '`b l��� �'�5.��
�����F a v �p�
��Yrvr�' W,'r l:'� �r, �.s-�,.
e r �y�,�� 4� y"
�i ro 5,�@ 3 3..
p
'ci,�� "�y c�'��! �t`"i �'t ,a s. k
y y v�4` �i °4 i r
���u �k� �S
3. i�k� �.'r v erK Aa'..
S
rt p
a a w
,A r� AF• 4r.
s r
�d`� �t �d`�r ��R� �n� x �a�� r�.. M"
r +t c-�'^"7 ,iv as ket b
q x
x ���6; '�.t v +e
r ��;t��� t� r a },�,r k
fi �a'� �x �4 w�` a t �a*
..x� h f e a F
i a 7�;
�KY a T "f'� ��`4. �k� „y �W�.,* 'L S' d�� �yf'` '4�' '�4.� f
�tt T ��,�,6 G�? �I*` 4 �5 s
'���"'�`#°�'t t �4� 7�`�"''k�C*"� M. "�Y.�, 4 {�a�*��',,.-
n�uc' ;n��� g ',y �'�t $tr W �V"� a F
�e ��I',C �Yr M4 y 1 �P T.�„rx� �i.k �M a �h
s w� N'Y 1� �'F� �e, E' `a' Nr r
r yy
4. S x t a r� t T �f i T .�f. S t t G�
��r k��' .'j s s i" F"a na� r 4 s
fA� Y �4� d� il S d����*", 4.� x� 1 y
A h�+�'� scn +:�n� tn �Y e� ��Cs r� h y�� k y, e x
.h' b 9 IM1y f� 1 tl 4���s N� S�IFi i
�k� i.. q r i y
"F �e i� A �j �^4�li v��q i. d k 5d^aN"�, ae
A
,x t �a r'� w p" t �„�d' i'
r! Y �p �r r�r +w r F� ��i r T` e
y y �fi�� R ,fl*� �t y� k 3� r 4�� k r� F'
3 �4i a'�4 C T ��4 t '9�� a.
mw� Wr.rti+�+ a qa� .h�h v'� n., i �e i �t i z ti °^k
�yz:.�u t �7 i�t 4� �,d�.re� P �1p
,�,�,„���f4y� s��a i,iq� k E k#fi';'M ��w d k b
a�; a� {g s��1 t i 7 y v m a r F Ge j i t 8 i 4�
�'tw ���v'''"��`� `*�rt'��.�Zw£�«e u �t �u: �{'3,'�J �t �fi,�,�•...y,
a� i�i.p� 3,2�,�°�.�,��r`'y r. s �kJ'i vi �i �i a �'9'��� wa, f .s,- Y�
il t a S i �a,� �x i e
`h5 F� �n, 4 y r r� .x t� ,n� +2
c �r
4 �"fnr��. `'s�t nen, a 1�,.
g.+. �"�n�� �'t
+u c ,s t
I r 4
�,y��'� a
ry
m �..a
f
J A v
f ry
1 e y
3 y '��.N' 8..ra�'�.
y
x�
�'r.�,�t;,
y:
rt
r h t
t
,.r��.
,.s._��
s;. 'r�
rc.
:i`a
y
aF
.a.�.,:
,r
r.��
t
�.a-
x.: z.;
a-
x
Z Y
x
i.y i,�
F +.t
r
A$ �'f r.P`�.�� K+.r 6
�F i�.,.Y ;k. ..n� 'Y��'ys
y'��� �"'PNI, 5 j
°y; �v ��r�` "�''ari,� .�'s�+'�
,r.
�^Y ��a�' y fY�`��:L�t�� dA r ,�,.4T
3 e K i T i,� ��+is'. a tA �i� l
v s g g
�pX �i :sxA� r"s 3 i¢� t
�.s�' r�3k` 'w� ..�4sg. -si�� tr ���.��"i�
2�� F ��i�+�1�!r��'
v `T'd�r t'�'4, ,�'��w,� .,i s w f�ht�k�'�,
7�� N �t t i t yq
�r *y �a� c �"r4F ��,Yl�`"�k t d
��a� p
r,"� x d r a �p
q ���a.� a� k 13.Year�Y-
�4��:
4
0 F Y�,�
s
F� t� �h� a#a„�,��,� Vf �,�ry�� mb��
c
311 i+ �c��" *.Y,r�
�eh =1
"�.u_.+�r� Y
:1� HRtY v... +.wyh� 3�A '�5 4
1 s� fY
a.
i f
H M
4 �i,
+."rn
i f
A
8. ty�R p{�` L j�
S A a
3n.�5 �FG
i i d d
'IZr� .�y ac. `y# it
��t t�'� r
�a c ,.z r +E
la°� ti�
�'��v yy, p 4
1 t
�"��������fP�"������x'���.'�� 4
r"J-a�* �'��'a'�' L� �.,�`�k.�
�'s* �z�'�`:.+�i� '��w
5 a t i
p '4 ��p 1��
�§q ,�yyW 4 d
T t`3 t "�'�k. S@
,�i3� k .4
e
t
F '9i'� �t��'2- r Y
.�'1,
r�, t
3 nt
S?.� r Er"' r ta�' �?y�'6ar�
44 y±� t� 'i�'h t f4.E i �N�
+1 1 +�5�' 'd "�R
�a t
i C'w2
fi} "�"9�s R a "'�e7. ,w :A
y 4 s" Yq� yf5�� 7
�1 F� �x
tz�.G'� �c
���',k.� f ��y p
5x
n. .t" �`M ��F��<$��
p ,xt y 'J�v" N t ,�.�A "�'Y��
k �S.0 /�y, d� iE
f
.-..L� mr s� �t,' �4 r�*f.''
i 's�. 31 r _:ual...
w r
�h
�r c �e�.�� ��r
K ,�'c� �i 7 x nt� t i i a
t ^`��'fa�.+� L�q,�}�,� �`�k y`�" i �i y �"�q 7 3� �t� r u
�i k l f t i'� 9 �I
A R F e y y t xx j
a
f�
r my dL�.�� ��1'X'�� �ki Fti ,y Z r y y z�
'A i n S t �7 j
z a
�„w« ��9�� y 4�, y �.1`�¢� g;
y �:r�'" �uy x s a y d
f srt 3 M iM i A51
r e'^�„",��,�� x� ,�r F r e rm`` _j
4 i 4 �V �{e "@t'° 5 x
"`�'AY' k t ,er' C Y f �r I� ,r
1
f
ww. s�C 4 7 x ary�p.F �{"k� i "��a'
r� a i s t� �*"k",,'� fi r r y �'r�i�� j�� i�
.:m, t t Ati �yY� r ���'`°i p$ Fe'� i� �a+n#r
'ta""� '�'"�+r 'G 4 u. k �4a §H� i�* r a�
�3 a ;�7 �r s����� N,��a�� h
2 t� e,t��'%`'��g�a�'��"� o- 1h�
b
r j t :���t��� �s �����Y x h .�i h ,�y��� y+ �rr�
^a1
c����ir'# a�c,��sv.aw. v ,k` a .�r� �v-
i
h
Y
1
"��'u.,r ����a T�
u '��t;�k' 4 c ,t�s z 5
r -a �r -�t s.;�*:���
t x u..
s A#
i;
I
i.,``���..`..
l.�-? V'.� �J�
F
4':
.5 u i..
t
1�
?'I:.� l yw i
x
w'�.�. af x sx»'� 'Ya^'"' �ne` F .r-
�fi�� y 'a
F
G '��..Y
K
x
4 4�
J
M
x t t ;d t�i" x �.�`e� c�-t�� ,j. ��^S�
n T-c, r.£ �s�Y
.r vz'.:
''d.,,��ay' �w+.� i�` G 1
t .;-p Y �4 7
y t
k+p'„ �Y ..S .H
k Y
c 5+�� y�
s
y u .f 5'° -�c �FR"
�1.„, m �It'
c
g 'L %w t�>z
e :V t
.r 'r�'�
ic: v y; r s" t�. t*Y�`�� t' a
!M '�L `�g,.
.F g '�4k'f
re 3 y
a F-':
r ''�',r -�s°
i i, v'
ti
r:. u
t.
e
r
k ti
b S i
r
�x n.
.-a�.:
t k .F F 5
w' Yri
j
r
4
a
i
.p P 4 ,...u. .'ritD;'� "�i" "t '�Bn'YI
I 't
I
I
d, �r I
�k��� 5,�
.�..R
�i�
Y p
�v. S H'` Y: `��y �8
"vb t b 1:� p`4r'¢ 'i�
-,M�� r� ��Fj �p �r^t q,
r ,p f� g'� x y yU(
j��i. nv '�I T wr�y Y' i 2 2
I�Y 4 x f q� J 1 �.y. q, t a.
II :...1 i'Y t I k •�y' y 4^ S z'�'K y p
t iM� z �a;� 5 S�� b rraM� tr *c
a �u4 a 4y#�n �Y!akrt�#�? e i T N 9 s+ wk `�1 4 x S .r
�.,H F f k „'u a y,�k Y ��'�rt� �r� a a °G €r y a�S �r� t
t #y �+�r" y s'��, F G�� �j� �.''t��"� ��'t
y v z �k 3 �4 9
�'Y 1" Y �a.� a 4 '44� „e'`.`�x,��`'��' k"` YA �:f i-.;�'� �`n �i
,d
�z'� d� v��� �I z�-"'�x p y �'-i
s� rj�' M-.. x t a''r 3t 3 rt r f r
..r w ,�a S rq, ?h F: r�,1`
Z W ?J 3�'� �s '4 M
s�
p� r �a y r t r w y g p
`z x r P '''S' q2 Ar `�'i e�Y x Z 1 5
t �R w g
K t q ,7 �t ''�9. M `�i 9
,�t 9 a.n� f t �g v �i aY�'� 2� 1 ,�pr� �;r {4 a
r��' �r s
�3 x F a E
k srk. s wr t r ��s k �5�� �y a' r
a e� S Ye 'L, X 3" 3' :�-s a�y s� F 1
i a 1 g "tl.r��+. ��c cx C s r m k �t'�µ�
s x t 5 31 S�� ...qqq r k yy a� Y"t r. x.t �v�
M b 43 �k& 1 ty,y
y y �w�"�'' s a i a x �p �',y�,y �'i�+
p y t� r i �x�
3 4 e ,��'y x �.��h�s�� .vy z,?��S �Rx� a�� 1
k �:,i�a�Y s ,��i� �3 ��t��`v.r��r� i �4 `.a:
p F x y;'. b. a�� v. '1� �f t y
d r ,5 i 3� �a �i���� �tP
y 'Y� ��izM`x� s�� �"y�`�,�'.sP$�G�.�. ta� A'9� £'"�a. $"'1� �'�`��d�
3 aro ti+ �`�'�t�t' ��,x c�"��x'��' r r-� K r`� '�r� "�"t i
a ;,Y �C� +Ue '��"�r�s�,�� �t� q u na� G L
t a�w�� �r� r
a t *2� x� �'z� a t �r
3 ��y �+t,#�'x+aµ��y�`�`, `S.Y'�21` t 3� n� j� .y e
Y ti �,"�",,s n.�','�1���'� �j$� �eE�y 1€ p#
.,x q t �Sk r ��r'�[ ��n.d� ���t`T�'� p,�-0.. �t��'�
y a
s�. m r a.
,�'���'r5: �n�' 5r� -s`� -..t�a
3� ?k* j.
f 4 t ��������6�a�"������������ kM�t.y
u t fi�` k'� �h� ti k x 7 9
Y"�p�� o-''�,�� 5�' x
r e s
�°rt� `�'.s as s }t ��a. Si�E �k .�'�r",} 3 i �xk�,��'� k �rq
p�i,�,i�,i� �`�,�is}� �uz ...s»rw.�.rw5e. „w�.�
�r,^^�+ft�� e ���6�� 9 a ��s �b� 2
0 �n i s a q r'�b r� �.t tk F w �t
r r t o� �w� �e' a� y
t
�d. i �FM f 73y��'� ?S`�'4,"�.,�, ��v�" �y�„ d ,fi6'r� R
:iM �',v I a t��Lt rr q
x�' t a �r�� 1 �'?ip4T�� S
t `�p 4�r k���, ����'����t �'���k��t �a.�t�'
t a ,��r�� �y �Y
.we i e syad �"�pb�p��c����,3�'�43.�'1�'�'��� y�� ����g�i� v�,�,.�� rt
a: i �-�'r r a
i��� �5' ���t�� q ���a� �f �.�r 7
6 �p Rtf t.g� YR' aE' t�^�`� g r S
a d.n: i ,t �k� J �'M1r .T o- P i 6�a�� s,nb� r
�p ��F��� y .fi, d y `a� 2 µt� sV a s�
f+,L f 4 P N£�b�"$ �2 f�ik�?
ix ;'�iN� c Y i 'br.'�'� k �j
r �'��y G� y a �r �r� �k C �A� ��#R `�y °f�d v
"�`����r �s �F y
8 .+t, f�� Y ��Y� �,QC I
�fi 4 3 +�le q r m �'4��
o r fi'�M ib
F
t� z J e�' i
t ��p� A� ^5 v
N fi �q k��� �,k+��' t... Y
y,�,. .r. 1
.we.� �o.,,, *�sb�a w�.,, �4 ,��it an ,�„"A �r.��,� vah7 d k g s i$ ��a`� �fici� �i
w� `�yy���'s��
�t �§'i �k., i 1 s s j� k k t
r M s. �y a iiPdF �e
5u r t u.'c !r M� r'�"h+& .�*r �'3 M1 `�'t�tir ss� s
1 Gti N s r a ..r l: y t
3 u-7 �r wu ,*a i� dtI i��t4y''� �'�h Y°�"��« �`�K`Y y t
'r t i $s v�§� r�.� ���,����s
y S i m �sM�� �'�.���a�� i
t�
'���'��'>,�r�z �f u� �r I
�M„ ,,y f r:
���'a F� h y
,�'�,r7:* w,,. k e�
1.r r b 3�cf �d '�y ��a�.
i
a 1 F �3��� N 4 �i. -k p �sV��:.
�r,5 r �.t r rn I�S�se�"x
�a n u� a sa t �q N ,z a i
t���,� t J n �J�� 7. i s�
�ta��xownu.�w.�—.. `��*b v,�w' a. :�t �`�"1 1� q .a�k.G..:. Fe'a���' a ��t 4 ��r�.`
�wih�� `�"tP` �.?C�
ro k �J� i k f '?9� 1. r�.,
.�a �t3�
a'h�`"�' t,' t h
1 W` "4 r'��
�T p ��S`�°
w���
ad +�a'`' q,,,y k� t'
w� x l� ti
v t i'�* .it p
'4 w.
�'��i.� r�
a
Q �w P'. ��+l5p F.
k Srwt 4 F.,
a d v a�+ r �`°k-..��w0 w`,15�:
t p t# p i y"�� r1
'u "F'.^A.... r}� 4 pJ
iy a� 4 ��t
J Y. P` vY t I��ISa� 4 Y �,4 i
es I
S q
r l )t
b �5e I
j y f �J`Mr .�,k.. vy ,�t��.
{�A' F��� `ry ,r?'.�� �a::. '�y`p, �.�'t k y J Li a
3�' p ;t g�:
3 +d t 'i'�� 't
a�a��t a*��` d
n
d'' ;`a e �"t� j�i�'R�h����� jt�
��.�L�+ y $r �cry 'Mir y i
4 Y Y Y v
y
,M a��°"j�l 1 i R a
%�h� V A
�}�,t ,a. S� �^MR�ii� �.u', r'� i y
F W w 3m�r
�,<A..,wi'.� oSwier�+, b'.�. 4 y "cR l A
f� F A�.
`'A „A" w.. a�
�'�''.,,�4iy,� �3�5
's �9„ �u�.a��s+, n
g „w,�,,,,<�'�"TM'� t
,rr
F�„d Y^�,"�
�'s v
a .Y���"'p�� Q
�.M�t "_a 1 .�r� ��a r. ��t
&V k
t $gj A 0
�'FY,,'�•,,,e h.+� x
,�r' 7�'"�
,E, a
4 ne
F v�r M� r 4�.��'
,.:L� a�'y�,4; r r ��a,�,,�.�'r i v. �r r�.
rv3�Y4k ��1✓���'�� I y.
tt M K F
,�„j�' r Y "ryI
v d r °tf'
u EL'
jM ��Ga'
2 v f I
e n 1
e
y ._n.�.i.i,�
r .e.
U�.; 4 ��,qgx9iNt5rAMti�NklN.a.F���x s�'�. ��4 �a`�:
,t�r dr4.,:� s ��4r�;F�`
r «�����j�.. J
.e.�w+„+^ce��1.,,..�.
.f..�r..^" x y `�-F
j ,.�y
p�-�'�°' d'•>
6t
�ei1�y��
�.:f °�"l.-��;.
K ~t!
v
;,�°s�«
,��.+a .,,.xa� r
'a..""`� fi/'
.Nw.�. �.r
����x t u:� �'�r
.rv't�'n,�.'� ����/y�
s
i a
a
,s
m�s�,
�t
�,r x a r�„
i,� �4�`
«s. "3..
k
i�!: 5 a f 'i-� a
7.
i��
�l
-e x.'„
h, SY
a�'.3��� �"��-x�
es ��sa a�
f `�$J`-�-y�2.z�'t���� ��-��a4� rd
-aa' a 8
�,,,�i f+'Fj E 3 3 't .-�,t z s4 y
x .A
F ����.r �t
ti��{v� �-&`k F�, �4
7 f a
fiT¢�������w 2 ��3 �'v��'�"''v, 4
a
d �:r s ���"�*b
a� i �#„'s'�
�'_.s3+�, r -�x�.,r. .fl
r�
k
�n 5� 4��
K+X... i4
:s �b�L.'� Y,,�� 5`�h�"���
�f`.��u. i, t
r
�i.r v
�3
���',�a�.��i x is'�, "'k
'�rvsFt k
y r4s 4.,
i'f4z.. p
s, t
i �f��
u �1
�i t t �r
�`C Y
t '1: '`a ",aM
t
t
l �J F �'M' H f
3sp �EfN'..�.. t`� i"�' 'f^ .1� .'1'
I
k ,.y��� i� 4 'P r J W:
k �'4.� F. Y t j C y
I#�Y' z C �t 4' v"
4 i F3j
I T
1 n i
l
w :F i y k
�i r Xa
r
4 Z�S{ �r 7
d 1
T"�"�fi,"� 5 1 M Y. ,'R A
9 Y
y §T��91"�y�1�-� Y S ��x
.r h� .yypr� i%1 C'� t F
F As,�. d 3��
��3t�„�y}a* a 'M v
t r .�y ti
e� ��''n �e b y
iTM dn; t t
c
t
aiw..,.. y, �,x rX+ .r v
g� 'J
P
r
w
4 y i
�i� x� r
i
y
1
I
I
��,f4 ''tiw, �iS, s
w +yV
t
I�
.I �I
�I
4 �i �n
av
..n,"?
�t
r
t�
t
a �T y
4 N
a
e
1
l� '�i`��' t
��.�c
r F E 4 V 4 A kR5
q ika'. a z, k f s j
y L n
�.u6+ y
�'�'�Y� y a
`frs"' „z rv h
d '�4 4 k
r 4 fi' j F, 4 tl�
'S v 101�(°. ik �'Y .I
n ..a,i 4:
n`
r-
t
f
z �a
4
�x<
s
n
��s� s r
r� f,»�F
�v-
+-r �4
r �a �c rt� r x
r.: r-�* r rz�'� .sM "x ,y a �.a. �i
b
.veT�„ z t°�.
r ��s.�,� F
r yt -11� y �.Y�� 5
=�i
y 2-� o
r e x
'Y l�
-.�9'y��
y ��f�h.'
F r I"
1 '3e�+„
.c ,t '2)Yn
i r
I li
rwg.
"`v++'w•
a i
I
n
Y
'A`_�`ta' t{�'."'sv';s�.
,€�,rv., .M!'- cy I 1"
«y i� t
-.:n
a.
Q
'i� x`
y Pfr
n�
y
...r
W
e
y
t
-<w
i
+z a
�x .µn
I va. r:
`��',t `e��� X g�
:a,
R.'a h b'
vTr u '+gl
t��
�ti� �a
I
r t,r: q� i;-.z.. t I
i
J r
l
i
1 1
s
'4
Citv of Robbinsdale
4100 Lakeview Avenue North
Robbinsdale, Minnesota 55422-2280
September 1, 2006 Phone: (763) 537-4534
Fax:(763)537-7344
www.robbinsdalemn.com
Tallen and Baertschi Law Of�ce
Attn: Paul Baertschi
4560 IDS Center
$0 S. E St. �c=
Mpls. MN 55402
Dear Mr. Baertschi:
The City of Robbinsdale has ongoing rubbish issue at the 88 unit Robbinwood Apartments, 3845-
50- 52 -54 West Broadway. The current owner, Hyder Raza Jaweed, seems to regularly fall
behind in payments for services from sanitation companies.. The refuse always includes food
waste. The result is stopped service, which soon means overflowing dumpsters, causes resident
and neighbor complaints, and the inability of residents to dispose of trash properly. This reduces
the enjoyment of their apartment homes. The unsightly, unhealthy conditions are also vie���ed
from Hwy 81 as thousands of cars pass by daily, and a negative impression of the ciry is the
inevitable result
In September, 2004, the City Manager determined that the situation had reached the point �vhere
an emergency existed under city code 2020.01. The City paid the sanitation contractor f�or
emergency waste removal, and then billed the owner.
Mr. Jaweed failed to pay in fime, so the amount ended up as a special assessment to 2005
property taxes. He appears• to have a habit of leaving the country for extended trips abi
leaving significant unpaid bills and no one authorized to make payments in his absence. This is
the case now and was also the case in 2004.
Only by the voluntary action (today) of Aspen Waste Company, who will set aside their company
"stop service" order is the current problem being taken care. However, in as little as one �veel:'s
time, the same condition is anticipated, again caused by the owner's failure to complete payment
for services that are required by city code. Other properties in other cities served by Aspen 11ave
the same problem with Mr. Jaweed.
I do have all information needed to issue citations to Mr. Jaweed. The frequency of service is 3
times per week at Robbinwood. This is adequate as long as service is not interrupted. I can orde►
more frequent service, if needed, under eode section 605.03.
What follows is a list of the documents currently in our rental files that relate onlv to the 2Q04
rubbish problem. A review of the entire file would flesh out a more complete understanding of
Mr. Jaweed's management style. Additional city records are may be available from other city
departments.
Thank you,
Brian Ringham
Housing Inspector
C�ry of Robb�nsdale
City of Robbinsdale
4100 Lakeview Avenue North
nuary 30 2007 Robbinsdaie, Minnesota 55422-2280
Phone:(763)537-4534
Fax: (763) 537-7344
www.robbinsdalemn.com
Paul Baertschi
4560 IDS Center
80 South 8" St.
Mpls. MN 55402
Dear Mr. Baertschi:
Please start a formal complaint against the owners of the Robbinwood Apartments, 384�-54 West
Broadway. The ownership entity on the rental license application is Robbinsdale Housin�
Associates I LLC. The mailing address is 3 Blue Spruce St. St. Paul, MN. 55127 (North Oaks)
To the best of my knowledge, two brothers own the property, Mr. Hyder Raza Jaweed, .and Mr.
Ashkar (Lee) Jaweed.
The violation of rubbish accumulation at the parking lot aroupd two dumpsters has continued
since my letter to you on 9/1/06. That letter described an emergency city abaternent to dispose of
a large accumulation of rubbish in 2004.
The rubbish issues continued at Robbinwood Apartments last fall and into DecemUer. At the time
when the Jaweeds bought another 36 unit building in the city, I confirmed with Aspen Waste, that
the sanitation contract at Robbinwood was specific in that no rubbish on the b� was to be
piciced up by Aspen drivers.
December 2006 citations were issued as follows: On l2/11/06- citation 2060201932 and letter.
On 12/12/06- citation 2060201965. On 12/13/06 citation 2060201999. None of these have
been paid per court clerks as of today.
On 1/29/07, rubbish was piling up andAspen Waste confinned to me that they had stopped all
service to Robbinwood on 1/25/07. They said the property o�vners had not paid for their services
since 10/19/06 and had a]arge balance due. Citation 2070260696 was issued on 1/29/07 and
today I issued citation #2070260704.
Phatos document the conditions on the days citations above were issued and copies are enclosed.
Conversations with the owner on this issue have become pointless and repetitive. Daily citations
have an immediate effect for a few days, but no long tenn effect.
The violation specified on the citations is ciry code 605.03. It may be that a violation of HNIC
425.13 Subd. 2(b) and also (e), exists because aparhnent residents cannot dispose of their trash
and garbage effectively. I would ask for your judgment on that. Robbin���ood residents have
complained to me about the stopped collection service in the past.
Please let me know if there is anything else I can do to expedite this complaint.
Thank you,
Brian Ringham
HoLising Inspector
Citv of Robbinsdale
d Printed by: bc114to �nCIC�@Ilt R@pOf� Page 1 of 4
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:54
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 InCldent Number: BC07-001260
Incident Summarv
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: ARREST
Inc Occurred Address: 2920 NORTHWAY DR BROOKIYN CENTER, MN 55430 Sector/Beat: 4/BC04
Inc Occur�ed Start: 03/10/2007 19:20 Inc Occurred End: Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: Y.
Contact Nature: Reported Date/Time: 03/10/2007 19:20
Reporting Officer: GABLER, RICHARD Primary Assigned Officer.
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: ADULT ARREST/FORMAL COMPLAINT Disposition Date: 03/12/2007 10;24
Offenses
Statute Code: 609-487-6 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: FLEEING POUCE OFFICER NOT IN VEHICLE
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: MISDEMEANOR
Statute Code: 609-68 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: HEALTH SAFETY-LITTERING
Countr. 1 Statute Severity: MISDEMEANOR
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3228 147 GABLER, RICHARD
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 19147210 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: ARREST Contact Date/Time: 03/10l2007 19:20
Name: BLAKE, RISHARD WILLIAM
DOB: 05/12I1977 Age: 29 29 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
Height: 5' 7" 5' 7" Weight: 150 150 ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
Address: 2904 NORTHWAY DR 102 BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 Sector/Beat: /BC04
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/School:
Person Offenses
Statute Code: 609-487-6 Enhancers
Statute Desc: FLEEING POUCE OFFICER NOT IN VEHICLE
Counts: 1
Statute Code: 609-68 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: HEALTH SAFETY-LITTERING
Countsr 1
Printed by: bc114to �nCldent Rep01� Page 2 of 4
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:54
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 It1Cld@11t NUt71b@C: BC07-001260
Propertv Involved
Propertv 0001 Evidence: No I
Event AssoGOrig status: EVIDENCE Original Status Date: 03l10/2007 19:20:00 Original Value: $0.00
Current Status: EVIDENCE Current Status Date: 03/10/2007 19:20:00 Current Value: $0.00
Property Type:
Description: BEER BOTTLE
Make/Brand: ModeL•
Color. Quantity: 1
Serial/Lot#: Owner Applied#:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Cancelled:
Narratives
Entered DatelTime: 03/12/2007 10:03 Narrative Type: SYNOPSIS
Subject: SYNOPSIS Author: GABLER, RICHARD
On 03/10/07 at 19:20 hours, I, Gabler, assisted Hennepin County Sheriff s Deputies in stopping a male who had
fled from them on an attempted subject stop. One adult male was arrested for fleeing the police on foot and
littering.
r�
Printed by: bc114to IIICICI@Ilt RGpOI"t Page 3 of 4
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:54
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-001260
Entered DatelTime: 03l12l2007 10:04 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author: GABLER, RICHARD
On 03/10/07 at 19:20 hours, I, Gabler, was patrolling the Centre Point Apartments in the 2900 block of Northway
Dr., when I heard over the radio that Hennepin County Sheriffs Officers Clark and Hagen were attempting to stop
a subject on foot and had the subject run from them around the 2920 building. I was in the area of the mailboxes
at the 2900 block of Northway Dr. and I observed a male running from the back of the 2920 building. I noticed the
male then run toward the bus hub. The male kept looking back over his shoulder, both to his left and to his right. I
was in undercover plain clothes at the time and identified myself as a police officer, advising the male to stop,
however, he kept running over into the bus hub at 2900 Co. Rd. 10.
I noticed the male then speak with a cab driver. I noticed that while the male was speaking to the cab driver, he
was still looking and appeared to be checking his surroundings very carefully. I then approached the male, who
was still talking to the cab driver. It appeared as though the male did not see me approach him. I again identified
myself as a police o�cer. I heard the male say, "oh, shit." I advised the male to place his hands on top of his head,
as I was quickly going to pat him down for any type of weapons for officer safety purposes. I did not find anything
illegal while patting the person down.
I then placed the male in handcuffs with his hands behind his back. I gapped and double-locked the handcuffs. I
advised the male that at this point he was not under arrest, however, he was going to be detained at the time,
because he had fled police on foot when they were trying to approach him to talk to him.
Then Officers Clark and Hagen arrived back at the Metro Transit Bus Hub. They did identify the male that I had
detained as the subject who had run from them. In speaking with deputies Clark and Hagen, they stated that they
approached the subject because he appeared to be underage and he was holding a Miller Genuine Draft bottle,
which is an alcoholic beverage. They stated they were just going to stop and identify him to make sure that he was
of age and should be consuming alcohol. Deputy Hagen stated that he did observe the male throw what appeared
to be the Miller Genuine Draft beer bottle into the snow while running away from them. It should be noted that
Deputies Clark and Hagen were in uniform and driving a marked police car and the subject should have known
that it was police officers attempting to approach him and talk to him.
After the subject was ptaced in the back of a squad car, he was identified as Rishard William BLAKE, DOB
05/12/77. It was at that point when officers found out that he was of age to be consuming alcohol. When I asked
Blake why he was running away from the police, he stated he just did not want to be hassled. I advised Blake that
the only reason why he was going to be stopped was just to make sure that he was of age to be consuming
alcohol. I asked what Blake was doing outside drinking in the apartment complex and he stated that he was just
going out to take out the garbage and go back into the 2904 Northway Dr. building. He stated he was associate
with apartment #102, however, t did observe by checking the Centre Point rental list, which is current as of
03/08/07, that he is not on the lease to 2904 Northway Dr. Apt. #102.
Upon checking Rishard far any warrants, I found that he was clear of warrants. Deputies Clark and Hagen went
back to the area where they first initially tried to stop and speak with Rishard. It was there that they found a Miller
Genuine Draft bottle, which did still have contents of alcohol in it. I could also smell a strong odor of an alcoholic
beverage emanating from Blake's mouth. He did have bloodshot eyes, however, he was speaking clearly and did
appear to be walking fine. I advised Blake that he would be receiving a citation for fleeing the police on foot, as he
attempted to evade police officers by running from them when they were trying to conduct an investigatory stop. I
also advised him that because he threw a beer bottle into the snow while running, he would also be charged with
littering.
I completed a Hennepin County Release Receipt for the charges of Fleeing Police on Foot and Littering. I gave
Rishard a Division II Court date of 04/02/07 at 0830 hours, Division II Court House, 6125 Shingle Creek Pkwy. I
explained the Release Receipt to Rishard. Rishard said he did not understand why he was receiving a citation
when he didn't do anything wrong. I advised him that he had run from the deputies when they were trying to talk to
him and then he threw a beer bottle onto the ground. He stated "yeah, that was a stupid thing to be running."
Printed by: bc114to �nCIC�@Ilt R@p01"t Page 4 of 4
Printed date/time: 5!9/07 13:54
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
i (763) 569-3333 InCident NUmber: BC07-001260 b
1 had Rishard step out ot the squad car. I removed the handcutts. Rishard then signed his Hennepm County
Release Receipt. I asked if he had any questions; he stated he did not have any questions regarding the citation.
He was given the pick copy of the citation and stated that he would agree to appear for his court date. Rishard
was then released, as he stated that he had people that he was going to go stay with at 2904 Northway Dr. Apt
#102.
Gabler/ss
03/12/07
Sianatures
Reporting Officer Date
Supervisor Date
i
Q
Printed by: bc114to Incident Report Pa ,°f z
Printed dateltime: 5/9/07 14:02
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-001867
Incident Summarv
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: ARREST
Inc Occurred Address: 2932 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55429 Sector/Beat: 4/BC04
Inc Occurred Start: Inc Occurred End: Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported Date/Time: 04/06/2007 21:17
Reporting Officerc GABLER, RICHARD Primary Assigned Officer.
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: ADULT ARREST Disposition Date: 04/11l2007 07:01
Offenses
Statute Code: 609-605-1-B-4 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: TRESPASSING-BUILDING OR DWELLING
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: MISDEMEANOR
Statute Code: 340A-503-1-A-2 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: LIQUOR-UNDERAGE CONSUMPTION 18-21 YEARS OF AGE
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: MISDEMEANOR
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3228 147 GABLER, RICHARD
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 17664930 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: ARREST Contact Date/Time: 04/06/2007 21:17
Neme: COOPER, OTHELLO
DOB: 10/04/1988 Age: 18 18 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
Height: 5' 6" 5' 6" Weight: 160 160 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
Address: 1121 46 ST E MINNEAPOLIS, MINNESOTA 55407 Sector/Beat:
Phone Type 1: NOME Phone# 1: (763) 533-7935 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: STUDENT Employer/Schooi: PARK CENTER HS
Person Offenses
Statute Code: 609-605-1-B-4 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: TRESPASSING-BUILDING OR DWELLING
Counts: 1
Statute Code: 340A-503-1-A-2 Enhancers
Statute Desc: LIQUOR-UNDERAGE CONSUMPTION 18-21 YEARS OF AGE
Counts: 1
Businesses Involved
Business 0001
Event Association:
Business Name: CENTER POINTE APARTMENTS Business Type: APARTMENTS
Address: 2932 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55429 Sector/Beat: 4BC04
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Y _f a
Printed by: bc114to �1'1CIC�@11t R@p01� Page 2 of 2
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:02
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 111CId@ttt NUtYlbel': BC07-001867
Narratives
Entered Date/Time: 04/11/2007 07:01 Narrative Type: SYNOPSIS
Subject: SYNOPSIS Author: GABLER, RICHARD
On 4/6/07 at 2117 hours, I, Officer Gabler, was on Foot Patrol at 2932 Northway Drive when i observed one male
sleeping in the stairwell. I arrested one adult male for Trespassing and Minor Consumption.
Entered DatelTime: 04/11l2007 07:13 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author: GABLER, RICHARD
On 4/6/07 at 2117 hours, 1, Officer Gabler, was working a Violent Crimes Task Force Detail in plain clothes with
Officer Peters conducting a Foot Patrol at the Center Pointe apartments.
Officer Peters and I entered the 2932 building and, upon walking down the stairs from the second floor to the first I
observed an African American male sleeping on the steps. I woke the male, had him stand up, patted him down
for weapons and asked him for identification. The male was identified as Othello Cooper, 10/4/88.
I recognized Cooper's name from prior contacts at the Center Pointe apartments. I observed Cooper's eyes to be
bloodshot and I could smell the odor of an alcoholic beverage emanating from his mouth. I asked Cooper if he
had been drinking and he stated he had not.
I checked Cooper for Warrants who was Clear and then contacted the Brooklyn Center Police Department SSO
and had them check for a Trespass Notice on Cooper. There was a Notice trespassing him from the Center
Pointe apartments from 4/11/06 to 4/10/07. I asked Cooper what he was doing in the apartment and he stated it
was cold out and he wanted to warm up. I brought him out and placed him in the rear of one of the Hennepin
County Sheriff s Deputies cars. Deputies Clark and Hagan were working in connection with Officer Peters and me
and were in uniform and marked squad cars.
I administered a Preliminary Breath Test on Cooper, serial #055668, last calibrated 10/27/06 by Sergeant Roth.
Cooper gave an adequate sample which showed .058. Cooper is under the age of 21. I filled out a Hennepin
County Release Receipt for Misdemeanor Trespass and Minor Consumption and provided him a court date of
4/30/07 at 0830 hours at Brookdale court and explained it to Cooper who signed it and was given a copy. Cooper
was then driven to the Super America at 57th Avenue North and Logan Avenue North where he wished to be
transported to, stating he lives in that area.
No further
Gabler/km 4/11/07
Siqnatures
Reporting Officer Date
Supervisor Date
w Printed by: bc114to Incident Report Page 1 of 2
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:56
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(�ss) sss-ss3s incident Number: BC07-001341
InCident Summarv
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: INCIDENT
Inc Occurred Address: 2936 NORTHWAY DR PARKING LOT BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55430 Sector/Beat: 04/BC04
Inc Occurred Start: 03/13l2007 18:26 Inc Occurred End: Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: Y
Contact Nature: Reported DatelTime: 03/13/2007 18:26
Reporting Officer: WONG, CARLOS Primary Assigned Officer:
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: ADULT ARREST Disposition Date: 03/15/2007 14:08
Offenses
Statute Code: 609-487-6 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: FLEEING POLICE OFFICER NOT IN VEHICLE
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: MISDEMEANOR
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 32832 32832 WONG, CARLOS
Associated Events
Association: Event Type: Event#: Event Date (Start): Event Date (End): Agency:
INCIDENT TO ARREST ARREST BC07-001341 03/13/2007 18:26:00 BC
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 19136491 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: ARREST Contact Date/Time: 03/13l2007 18:26
Name: HARPER, DANtEL DOMINIC
DOB: 08/10/1985 Age: 21 21 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
Height: 5' 11" 5' 11" Weight: 150 150 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
Address: 2932 NORTHWAY DR 303 BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 Sector/Beat: 4/BC04
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 566-1164 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: CELL Phone# 2: (612) 518-5190 Ext 2:
Occupation: UNEMPLOYED fmployer/School:
Person Offenses
Statute Code: 609-487-6 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: FLEEING POLICE OFFICER NOT IN VEHICLE
Counts: 1
Narratives
Entered DatelTime: 03/15/2007 13:54 Narrative Type: SYNOPSIS
Subject: SYNOPSIS Author: WONG, CARLOS
Went to a call of kids burning something in a building and found an unrelated group smoking marijuana who ran.
One of the three parties was caught and tab charged.
Printed by: bc114to �nCIC�@Ilt R@p01� Page 2 of 2
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:56
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number BC07-001341
C
Entered DatelTime: 03/15/2007 13:55 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT I
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author: WONG, CARLOS
On 03/13/2007 at 1818 hours, I was dispatched to 2932 Northway Drive in regards to four juvenile males buming
what appeared to be a�cloth inside or outside the building. The Fire Department arrived on scene and found the
source of the fire which was a small cloth that was being bumt by the front steps of 2932 Northway Drive. I had
decided to go inside of the building to see if anybody was there. I went through the 2936 No�thway Drive building
which connects to the 2932 Northway Drive building where I smelled the strong odor of marijuana and saw three
black males at the bottom floor. As soon as they saw me and I approached them they took off running. I yelled,
"Stop, police" but they continued to run. Once they ran through the laundry room and got to one of the outside
doors on the west side of 2936 they began to run in different directions. I again yelled, "Stop, police". HARPER
did look back at me but continued to run. I continued to chase after him. When we got to 59th and Xerxes,
Harper then finally stopped at which point I took him into custody by handcuffing him, double locking and gapping
the handcuffs. Harper told me that he was stupid to run because all they were doing was smoking a little weed
and he didn't have anything on him. 1 did take Harper into custody with no incident after a little run. We then
walked back to my squad which was located in the 2936 Northway Drive parking lot. I did identify Harper through
the computer since he did not have picture ID on him. He advised me that he had his wallet stolen not too long
ago. Once he was positively identified, I did issue him a court date with a court date of 04/09/2007 for fleeing on
foot. Harper told me that he knew what he did was stupid. I then took the handcuffs off of him. He signed the tab
charge and I gave him a copy and released him on scene.
Harper was wearing a white shirt with a number 18 on the back. On reviewing his criminal history, he did have a•
previous aggravated assault as well as a Brooklyn Center case from 02/03/07, case 07-586 for simple robbery.
Wong/vc
Sianatures
Reporting Officer Date
Supervisor Date
I��
Printed by: bc114to �1'1CId@Ilt RepOrt Page 1 of 5
Printed dateltime: 5/9/07 13:59
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07 -001643
Incident Summa
rv
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: INCIDENT
Inc Occurred Address: 2920 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55430 Sector/Beat: 4/BC04
Inc Occurred End: Report Taken:
rred St rt: 03/27/2007 20�30
Inc Occu a
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported Date/Time: 03/27/2007 20:30
Reporting Officer: GABLER, RICHARD Primary Assigned Officer.
Case Status: ACT�VE Disposition: PENDING/OPEN Disposition Date: 03/28/2007 08:39
Offenses
Statute Code: MISIMP Enhancers:
Statute Desc: MISC OFCR VEHICLE IMPOUND
Counts: 1 Statute Severity:
Statute Code: MISWA Enhancers:
Statute Desc: MISC OFCR WARRANT ARREST
Counts: 1 Statute Severity:
Statute Code: 152-092 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: CONT SUBST-POSS-DRUG PARAPHERNALIA
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: PETTY MISDEMEANOR
Statute Code: 771-24-3 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: TRAF-DRIVING AFTER CANCELLATION
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: MISDEMEANOR
Statute Code: 609-487-6 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: FLEEING POUCE O�FICER NOT IN VEHICLE
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: MISDEMEANOR
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3228 147 GABLER, RICHARD
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 859158 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: SUSPECT Contact Date/Time: 03/27/2007 20:00
Name: AULTMAN, BRIAN LEE
DOB: 07/15/1959 Age: 47 47 Sex: MALE Race: WHITE
Height: 5' 7" 5' 7" Weight: 135 135 ibs Eye Color: BLUE Hair Color: BROWN
Address: 21 DEAN AV N CHAMPLIN, MINNESOTA 55316 Sector/Beat:
Phone T e 1: CELL Phone# 1: 612) 865-0943 Ext 1:
YP
Phone T e 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
YP
Occupation: EmployeNSchool:
Printed by: bc114to �nCIC�@Ilt R@pOrt Page 2 of 5
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:59
BROOKLYN CENTER POUCE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(�ss) sss-ssss Incident Number: BC07-001643 'k
Vehicles Involved
Vehicle#: 0001
Event Assoc: TOWED Vehicle Status:
Vehicle Type: A Year: 1994 Make: GEO Model: PRIZM
VIN: 1Y1SK5363RZ104664 License#: HCZ102 State: MN Expires On:
Style: 4-DOOR Prim Color: GREEN Sec Color: Ter Color:
Status DtlTm: Status Value: Recovered Date: Recovered Value:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Cancelled:
Registered Owner Name: AULTMAN, KELLY R
Address: 2920 NORTHWAY DR #103 BC, MN Phone#:
Narratives
Entered DatelTime: 03/28J2007 14:47 Narrative Type: SYNOPSIS
Subject: SYNOPSIS Author. GAB�ER, RICHARD
On 3/27/07 at 2000 hours, I, Officer Gabier, attempted to stop an aduit male on foot at 2920 Northway Drive. I
arrested one adult male for Felony Warrants, Flee Police on Foot, DAC-IPS, and Possess Drug Paraphernalia.
I
i I
Printed by: bc114to ICICIC�@Ilt R@ Ort Page 3 of 5
Printed dateltime: 5/9/07 13:59 p
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 InCident NUmbeC: BC07-001643
Entered DatelTime: 03/28/2007 14:48 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author. GABLER, RICHARD
On 3/27/07 at 2000 hours, I, O�cer Gabler, was in the Napa and Pizza Hut parking lot across the street from the
Center Pointe apartment complex working a Plain Clothes Violent Offender Detail in an unmarked Brooklyn
Center Police Department mini van. I was conducting surveillance on the 2920 building because there is heavy
suspected narcotics activity coming to and from that building.
I observed a dark colored 4-door vehicle pull into the parking lot of 2920 at a high rate of speed, stop abruptly, and
then corner back into a parking space in that lot with the front of the car facing out toward the lot.
I observed a white male in blue jeans and flannel shirt exit the vehicle alone and walk into the lobby of the 2920
building without using a key, entering through the unsecured door. There were two African Americans standing
inside the building, one male and the other unknown.
The white male stood in the lobby for approximately 5-7 minutes and talk to the two African Americans in the
lobby. I maintained a constant visual on the white male who did not go up or downstairs and stood talking to the 2
African Americans in the lobby. I observed him through binoculars as he conversed for awhile before I advised
Hennepin County Sheriff's Deputies Clark and Hagan, who were in patrol uniforms and driving a marked Hennepin
County squad car, that I was going to go around the north side of the 2920 building and come in through the north
door and advised them that, when I tell them to, approach through the south door of the 2920 building.
I entered the 2920 building from the north and advised by Nextel that I was in position on the north side of the door
at which time they immediately approached from the south side of the 2920 building parking lot. As soon as I
entered the lobby area I observed the 2 African Americans we�e gone. I observed the white male whom I had
seen pull into the parking lot was walking very slowly westbound from the 2920 building and past the car he had
driven into the lot. I advised Deputies Clark and Hagan to stop the male because I was suspicious of his behavior
and activities.
Deputy Clark ordered the male to stop and come back. I observed the suspect look back several times and then
pick up speed to a slight jog. Deputy Clark again told the male to stop and turn around and come back toward
Officers. The male then began running, cut across Northway Drive and was now in the Napa and Pizza Hut
parking lot with Deputy Clark still chasing. I then gave pursuit on foot as well, chasing after the suspect who
tripped on the curb, rolled onto Xerxes, got up, continued running, and was finally detained by Deputy Clark on the
west side of Xerxes.
I assisted Deputy Clark in placing handcuffs on the suspect behind his back, gapping and double locking the
handcuffs prior to conducting a Pat Search of the suspect while he was on his stomach. The suspect was then
stood up at which time I could smell fhe strong odor of an alcoholic beverage emanating from his mouth. A
Search Incident to Arrest of the suspect revealed in a pocket a silver pipe which was burnt on one of the ends,
consistent with that of narcotics paraphernalia. I observed in another pocket a metal pin, also suspected to be
used for narcotics paraphernalia. I also observed on the ground next to the male was a Michefob Golden Draft
beer can, blue in color, inside a beer cozy.
The suspect was positively identified as Brian Lee Aultman, 7/15/59, by DVS website. I found Aultman was
Cancelled IPS and had a 100% score on a Felony Warrant for Fifth Degree Felony Controlled Substance. I
observed Aultman's hair was uncombed, he had watery, glassy eyes and his pupils were pinpoint and did not react
to light by contracting or dilating when he opened and closed his eyes.
I asked Aultman if he had been using any type of narcotics today and he stated he had not. When I asked
Aultman how much he had to drink he advised me the one beer he was carrying. I asked Aultman whose car he
drove up in and he stated he was not driving. It should be noted when I searched Auttman I located 2 sets of
keys. I did maintain possession of the keys.
Aultman was transported to the parking lot of 2920 Northway Drive where I observed the vehicle I observed
Printed bc114to IIICIC�ellt R@pOCt Page 4 of 5
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:59
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(�ss) sss-asss Incident Number: BC07-001643
Aultman drlve into the lot, Mlnnesota HCZ102. I asked Aultman whose vehicle it was and he stated it was his
sister's. I asked him what he was doing at the apartment complex and he stated visiting his sister in 103 of the
2920 b�ilding. I located the partial last name of Aultman staying in #103 of 2920. I asked Aultman if his sister was
home and he stated she was not. I asked him how he got there and he stated his friend 'AI' dropped him off. I
asked where AI was and Aultman stated he left and he does not know AI's last name.
I tried one of the keys from Au�tman's pocket in HCZ102 and the key did unlock and lock the vehicle door. Upon
touching the hood of the vehicle I found it to still be warm. I observed a brown dog in the front driver's seat of the
vehicle and an open 12 pack of Michelob Golden Draft in the back seat. Aultman had been carrying a Michelob
Golden Draft beer can when he fled police.
I asked Aultman for the telephone number of his sister to advise her she left her dog in the vehicle. He stated he
did not have a phone for her. Since there was no one in the apartment to leave the dog with therefore I called for
CSO Logan to impound the dog.
Because I had to impound the vehicle Aultman had been driving I did conduct a Search Incident to Impound on
HCZ102 at which time I found several plastic baggie tear offs, consistent with narcotics use. I counted the beer
cans in the 12-pack and found one missing.
I administered a Preliminary Breath Test on Aultman with #55668, last calibrated on 10/27/06 by Sergeant Roth of
the Brooklyn Center Police Department and checked Aultman's mouth and did not find anything foreign prior to my I
administration of the test which revealed a.007, consistent with a person who has had approximately one half to
one whole beer and there was only one beer missing from the 12-pack in the vehicle. While searching the vehicle
I noticed there were photos of Aultman inside. I removed the vehicle license ptates and had the vehicle
impounded by North Suburban Towing and filled out a Notice and Order of License Plate Impoundment and
property inventoried the plates, the crack pipe and the push pin.
Aultman was transported to the Hennepin County Adult Detention Center on his Felony Warrant. His Criminal
History revealed several DWI offenses and prior DAR, DAS, DAC, and Driver License violations.
I am requesting Aultman be charged by Formal Complaint for DAC-IPS, Possess Drug Paraphernalia, and Flee
Police on Foot.
No further
Gabler/km 3/28/07
Entered Date/Time: 03/30/2007 10:27 Narrative Type: NOTE
Subject: ANIMAL IMPOUND DOG 2179 Author: LOGAN, THOMAS
CAGE: 31
SEX: Male
COLOR: Brown
BREED: Lab/Retriever
COLLAR: Yes
SIZE: Large
APPR. AGE: Young Adult
REASON FOR IMPOUND: Owner Arrested
Must be claimed on or before 6 o'clock PM on April 2nd, 2007.
Julie Howe claimed dog on 03-28-07 at 1710 hours.
Printed bc114to IIICICI@llt R@pOCt Page 5 of 5
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:59
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 If1CIdeClt NUt11b@I": BC07 -001643
Siqnatures
Reporting O�cer Date
Supervisor Date
I Printed by: bc114to �nCldent RepOrt Page 1 of 4
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:04
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-002014
Incident Summarv
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: DRUG OFFENSE
Inc Occurred Address: 2830 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55430 Sector/Beat: 4/BC04 I
Inc Occurred Start: 04/12/2007 22:30 Inc Occurred End: 04/12/2007 22:30 Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: Y
Contact Nature: Reported DateRime: 04/12/2007 22:30
Reporting Officer: GABLER, RICHARD Primary Assigned Officer.
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: ADULT ARREST Disposition Date: 04/13/2007 07:58
Offenses
Statute Code: 152-025-1 Enhancers
Statute Desc: CONT SUBST-5TH DEG SELL-MARIJUANA
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: FELONY
Statute Code: 609-487-6 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: FLEEING POLICE OFFICER NOT IN VEHICLE
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: MISDEMEANOR
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3228 147 GABLER, RICHARD
BACK-UP 3219 142 PETERS, BRIAN
INVESTIGATOR 3216 113 GRUENIG, TONY
Associated Events
Association: Event Type: Event#: Event Date (Start): Event Date (End): Agency:
ARREST TO INCIDENT ARREST BC07-002014 04l12/2007 22:30:00 04/12/2007 22:30:00 BC
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNL• 19053723 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: ARREST Contact Date/Time: 04/12/2007 22:30
Name: NELSON, ANTHONY TERRELL
DOB: 07/16/1987 Age: 19 19 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
Height: 5' 2" 5' 2" Weight: 145 145 ibs Eye Color. BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
Address: 6190 104 CIR BROOKLYN PARK, MINNESOTA 55448 Sector/Beat:
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 425-8922 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/SchooL•
Person Offenses
Statute Code: 152-025-1 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: CONT SUBST-5TH DEG SELL-MARIJUANA
Counts: 1
Statute Code: 609-487-6 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: FLEEING POLICE OFFICER NOT IN VEHICLE
Counts: 1
i��
2
Printed by: bc114to Incident Report Page 2 of 4
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:04
BROOKLYN CENTER POUCE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(�ss) 5ss-ssss incident Number: BC07-002014
Businesses Involved
Business 0004
Event Association: LOCAT�ON
Business Name: CENTER POINTE APARTMENTS Business Type: APARTMENTS
Address: 2830 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55429 Sector/Beat: 46C04
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Propertv Invoived
Propertv 0001 Evidence: No
Event AssoclOrig status: EVIDENCE Original Status Date: 04/12/2007 22:30:00 Original Value: $0.00
Current Status: EVIDENCE Current Status Date: 04/12/2007 22:30:00 Current Value: $0.00
Property Type: DRUGS/NARCOTICS
Description: MARIJUANA
MakeBrand: ModeL•
Color: Quantity: 7.1 GRAMS
Serial/Lott#: Owner Applied#:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Cancelled:
Narratives
Entered Date/Time: 04/13l2007 07:58 Narrative Type: SYNOPSIS
Subject: SYNOPSIS Author: GABLER, RICHARD
On 04-12-07 at 2230 hours, 1, Officer Gabler, stopped a suspected trespasser at 2830 Northway Drive. One adult
male was arrested for 5th degree controlied substance with intent to sell and fleeing the police on foot.
i
t
Printed by: bc114to �nCldent Rep01� Page 3 of 4
Printed dateitime: 5/9/07 14:04
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 IllCldent NU111beC: BC07 -002014 i
I Narrative T e: MAIN REPORT
a 04/13l2007 07:58 YP
Entered D teiTime�
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author: GABLER, RICHARD
On 04-12-07 at 2230 hours, I, Officer Gabler, was assisting Sergeant Mike Reynolds of the Brooklyn Center Police
Department. Sergeant Reynolds advised me that he had two detained for underage consumption at the bus hub
at 2900 County Road 10. He stated that two males left very quickly and went northbound from the bus hub to the
Center Pointe Apartment Complex. Sergeant Reynolds stated that one of the males he believed was Deandre
Latron SMITH. I was aware of the fact that Smith was heading towards heading the Center Pointe Apartment
Complex which is on the north side of the bus hub. I also previously trespassed Smith from the Center Pointe
Apartment Complex. Sergeant Reynolds stated to me that the party whom he believed to be Smith was a younger
looking black with a black hat and a brownish coat. It should be noted that I have had several contacts in the
recent weeks with Deandre Smith and has given him multiple underage consumption charges and had also
previously trespassed him from the Center Pointe Apartment Complex. Officer Peters and I who were in plain
clothes driving an unmarked Brooklyn Center Police Department detective vehicle began checking the Center
Pointe Apartment Complex for the person whom we had believed to be Deandre Smith. I went into the north lot of
the Center Pointe Apartment Complex where I did see in the 2830 building in the lobby which faces north two
African American males. I could tell that one of them had a darker colored coat and a black hat and both parties
did appear to be African American.
Officer Peters and I then began walking up to the 2830 building from the north. J did observe as we were walking
up that the two males then exited the 2830 building and began walking westbound in the Center Pointe Apar.tment
Complex. Upon getting closer to the males I did observe that one of them did have a brownish colored jacket as
well as a black hat and did appear to look younger and again, was an African American male. This description did
match that of the one given to me by Sergeant Reynolds.
Officer Peters and I had our badges out around our neck. We were approximately 50 to 100 feet away from the
subjects. We advised them that we were the police and we would like them to come back towards us so we could
ID the suspects as we believed one of them to be Deandre Smith, a party whom is currently trespassed from the
Center Pointe Apartment Complex. I noticed that one of the males had stopped and the other one looked back
es at olice officers then be an runnin
over his shoulder several tim 9 9
P
art w
ho was r
un
nin awa from olice officers on foot.
Officer Peters and
I the
n ave chase on foot to the 9 Y P
P Y
9
the fact that we were in hot ursuit of the sus ect running, we did not stop or detain or �dentify the other
Based on P
P
party that had stopped when officers ordered him to. Officer Peters and I gave chase westbound in the Center
Pointe Apartment Complex. We advised the male several times to stop. We then observed the male run into the
2908 building on the south side of the building. Officer Peters then stood by the door on the 2908 building in case
the male doubled back and came out that door. I ran around to the north side of the building. I observed the male
run out of the 2912 building stumbling over the stairs and then ran eastbound back towards the open courtyard
area. The male ran towards the courtyard area and then began running no�thbound before he raised his hands
and stated, "I give up, I give up." I then ordered the male to get on the ground. The male then. did so. I then
placed the male in handcuffs while he was on his stomach on the ground. I conducted a quick search of the
immediate waistband area for weapons not finding anything illegal on the person. It stiould be noted that male
was freely able to run into the 2908 building as the security doors were open and they were not locked.
Officers Peters then arrived to my location where I had the suspect detained. Officer Peters and I then stood the
male up. The male was very winded and appeared to be out of breath. I was then able to find a Minnesota
identification card which gave the name of Anthony Terrell NELSON, DOB 07-16-1987. At this point I advised the
male that he was under arrest for fleeing the police on foot as we were attempting to conduct an investigatory stop
as we believed the suspect to be Deandre Smith; however, he took off and began running away from police before
we were able to identify him. Upon searching the male's jacket I did find a plastic bag. I noticed inside the bag
were several smaller plastic bags. I took out all of the smaller plastic bags in the large plastic bag and observed a��;
green leafy substance in the bag and upon sniffing all of the bags I found there was an odor of marijuana coming
from all of the bags. There was a total of seven bags of marijuana all together. All the bags were packaged in the
same way and appeared to be packaged with intent to sell. Upon a further search of Nelson I did not find anything
illegal on his person. I asked Nelson why he was running from the police and he stated because he had weed.
4 Page 4 of 4
Printed by: bc114to I ncident Report
Printed dateltime: 5!9/07 14:04
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
ROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-002014
Nelson was then placed in the bacK ot Hennepin Counry Sheritt's Deputy CIarK's squad car. Upon domg a warrant
check on Nelson I found him to be clear of any warrants.
I advised the male that based on the fact that the marijuana was packaged individually and appeared to have
intent to sell, that he was under arrest now for 5th degree controlled substance sales as well as fleeing the police
on foot.
Deputies Clark and Gottwaldt then transported Nelson to the Brooklyn Center Police Department. All officers
arrived at the police department. I did print out a criminal history for Nelson finding him to have no prior adult
arrests. Upon doing a custodial search in the Brooklyn Center Police Department Jail of Nelson I found nothing
illegal on his person. I then filled out all the necessary booking paperwork in the Brooklyn Center Police
,Department Jail. Nelson was booked and fingerprinted in the Brooklyn Center Police Department Jail. Nelson
stated to me that he would not be willing to give a formal taped statement as he did not want to�speak to officers
about the incident. In further speaking with Nelson he stated to me that on tomorrow, 04-13-07, he was leaving to
go back to Chicago where he's from. Based on this information, I felt that there was a substantial likelihood that
Nelson would fail to respond to any citation or court date given as he would be leaving the state to go to Illinois. I
then filled out all the necessary paperwork for Nelson to be booked at the Hennepin County Adult Detention
Center. Nelson was given his property back and Deputies Clark and Gottwaldt then transported Nelson down to
the Hennepin County Adult Detention Center.
I then went into the property inventory room at the Brooklyn Center Police Department and I weighed all the bags
of marijuana and found a total of 7.1 grams of marijuana. I also inventoried all seven small bags that the
marijuana was contained in as well as the bigger plastic bags which contained the marijuana and smaller plastic
bags. Nelson was fairly cooperative throughout the�entire arrest process except for the part where he ran from
officers on foot.
At this time I am requesting that Nelson be charged with 5th degree controlled substance with intent to sell felony
and misdemeanor fleeing the police on foot.
Gabler/re
04-13-07
Siqnatures
Reporting Officer Date
Supervisor Date
Printed by: bc114to �nCICI@Ilt R@p01't Page 1 of 4
Printed dateltime: 5!9/07 14:11
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-002185
incident Summarv
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: DRUG OFFENSE
Inc Occurred Address: XERXES AV N& NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55430 SectorlBeat:
Inc Occurred Start: 04/20J2007 22:05 Inc Occurred End: Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: Y
Contact Nature: Reported DatelTime: 04/20/2007 22:05
Reporting Officer GABLER, RICHARD Primary Assigned Officer:
Case Status: PENDWG FORMAL Disposition: PENDING/OPEN Disposition Date: 04/22/2007 00:02
Offenses
Statute Code: 152-025-1 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: CONT SUBST-5TH DEG SELL-MARIJUANA
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: FELONY
Statute Code: MISWA Enhancers:
Statute Desc: MISC OFCR WARRANT ARREST
Counts: 1 Statute Severity:
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3228 147 GABLER, RICHARD
BACK-UP 3219 142 PETERS, BRIAN
INVESTIGATOR 3216 113 GRUENIG, TONY
I
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 18965101 Can ID Suspect No
Event Association: ARREST Contact Date/Time: 04/20l2007 22:05
Name: SMITH, ISAAC JECOBER
DOB: 09/13/1987 Age: 19 19 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
Height: 5' 8" 5' 8" Weight: 128 128 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
Address: 4052 ALDRICH AV N MINNEAPOLIS, MINNESOTA 55412 Sector/Beat:
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 561-5183 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/SchooL•
Person Offenses
Statute Code: 152-025-1 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: CONT SUBST-5TH DEG SELL-MARIJUANA
Counts: 1
Statute Code: MISWA Enhancers:
Statute Desc: MISC OFCR WARRANT ARREST
Counts: 1
'I
Pr�ncea b b�i �ato 111Cident Report Pa9e z of a
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:11
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(7s3) sss-3sss Incident Number: BC07-002185
Propertv Involved
Propertv 0001 Evidence: No
Event Assoc/Orig status: EVIDENCE Originai Status Date: 04/20l2007 22:05:00 Original Value: $O.OU
Current Status: PROPERTY INVENTORIED Current Status Date: 04/20/2007 22:05:00 Current Value: $0.00
Property Type: DRUGS/NARCOTICS
Description: 17.5 GRAMS OF MARIJUANA PLUS PACKAGING
Make/Brand: ModeL•
Color: Quantity:
Serial/Lot#: Owner Applied�:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Cancelled:
Narratives
Entered Date/Time: 04/21/2007 23:09 Narrative Type: SYNOPSIS
Subject: SYNOPSIS Author: GAB�ER, RICHARD
On 04/20/07 at 2205 hours, I, Gabler, stopped a suspicious male in the intersection of Xerxes Avenue North and
Northway Drive. I arrested one adult male for 5th degree possession of a controlled substance with intent to sell
and two misdemeanor warrants.
I
Printed by: bc114to I1lCIC�@Ilt R@pOrt Page 3 of 4
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:11
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 i
(�s3) sss-3s33 Incident Number: BC07-002185
Entered DatelTime: 04/2112007 23:13 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author: GABLER, RICHARD
On 04/20/07 at approximately 2145 hours, I observed a biack male on a bike. I observed that the male did have a
black hat, a blue jean shirt as well as a black hooded type sweatshirt. I observed the male come from the west
side of 2900 County Road 10 and bike across the street from thebus hub to the Centre Point apartment complex.
I observed the male approximately five minutes later bike back to the bus hub and bike around the bus hub. I then
observed the male go back to Centre Point apartment complex and approximately 2-5 minutes later headed
towards back to the bus hub area. It should be noted that I was working with Officer Peters of the Brooklyn Center
Police Department. Officer Peters and I were in plain clothes in an unmarked police minivan. Officer Peters and I
were working as Violent Crimes Task Force which focuses on narcotics, robberies and other violent types of
assaults and we were surveying the Transit Center at 2900 County Road 10 and the Centre Point apartment
complex. Both locations have been identified as major areas for narcotics and robbery activities.
Officer Peters and I were sitting in the Pizza Hut inside the Napa parking lot watching both the Center Point
apartment complex as well as the transit station. This is where we were when we observed this suspicious male.
I observed the male bike around the bus hub and bike onto Northway Drive and go westbound on Northway Drive
and then began going southbound on Xerxes Avenue North. Based on the suspicious activity that I had observed
male bikin back and forth to a
reas of hi h narcotic activities a
s well as areas
known
for robberies and
that the g 9
assault, I advised Hennepin County Sheriff Deputies Clark and Gottwaldt who also were working the Violent
Crimes detail. Both Deputies Clark and Gottwaldt were in Hennepin County Sheriff Deputy marked squad and
were in police uniform. I was updating the deputies on the subjecYs movements through a Nextel. I advised the
i ious activit that he was bikin back and forth
I ed on the sus c 9
t sto the ma e bas
de uties that I would like them o p Y
P
P
and was appearing to rrot be going anywhere in particular, and was loitering around the bus hub and the Center
Point complex. Deputies Clark and Gottwaldt then approached the male by
the TCF Bank o
n Xerxes Avenue
North and Northway Drive. I advised the deputies to approach the male because they were in police uniform and
the were in a marked squad car that would possibly eliminate any confusion as to who is approaching�the subject.
Y
Officer Peters and I then posed behind the deputies' squad car in a minivan. It should be noted that no
emergency lights were activated and no spot lights were shined on the subject. When I arrived, I began speaking
ted he lives somewhere in C stal and not giving us a
'ect where he lives� he sta rY
to the sub'ect. I asked the sub
1 1
specific address. I asked what he was doing at the bus hub; he stated he was waiting for his girlfriend to get off
the bus. He stated that he did not know what bus number and could not give a specific time as to when he
thought the bus would arrive; he just stated it should be there any minute. When I asked him why he was biking
between the bus hub and the apartment complex, he stated that he was just killing time. I asked him if he had any
identification with him; he did give me a MN picture identification card with states the name Issac Jecobec SMITH
with a date of birth of 09/13/87.
I had the Sheriff deputies do a warrant check on Smith. Upon doing a warrant check, officers found Smith to have
two misdemeanor warrants. The warrants were then confirmed to be good active warrants. I then placed Smith in
handcuffs with his hands behind his back. 1 gapped and double locked the handcuffs. Upon doing a search
incident to arrest, I did find underneath Smith's baseball hat that he was wearing a plastic bag which contained
several smaller bags with green leafy substance. I took a sniff of one of the bags. I found it to have an odor
consistent with that of marijuana. Upon concluding the search incident to arrest of Smith, I found nothing illegal on
ds
uad car.
his erson. I then laced Smith in the back of the Hennepin County Sheriff Deputies marke q
P P
I then counted all the individually packaged bags in the big plastic bag and found the total of 12 bags which all
looked the same and had what appeared like marijuana. I also observed that all bags were of the same size.
Some bags appeared to have more marijuana than others; however, they all appeared to be roughly packaged
with the same amount of marijuana.
'i'
I explained to Smith at this point that he's now under arrest for possession of a controlled substance with intent to
sell. Smith never refused the fact that he was selling marijuana and Smith at that point began becoming very
uncooperative and arguing why we Frad initially stopped him. I did advise Smith again that we had stopped him
based on his suspicious activity. Smith then became uncooperative Smith was then transported to the Hennepin
'E�
Printed by: bc114to IIICICI@11t RG�p01� Page 4 of 4
Printed datettime: 5!9/07 14:11
BROOKLYN CENTER POUCE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 ItlCideilt NUIl1beP: BC07-002185
County Adult Detention Facility on his two warrants as well as the telony PC charges ot 5th degree possession ot
controlled substance with intent to sell; however, I did mark that Smith could be released pending complaint on the
new controlled substance charge.
I then advised the CSO of the Brookl n Center Police Department that we need a bike impound. CSO
Y
riv and he im ounded Smith's bic cle at the city garage. I went back to the Brooklyn Center
Whittenbur then ar ed p Y
9
Police Department where I property inventoried all the marijuana. Upon weighing all the marijuana, I found the
total weight of the marijuana to be 17.5 grams. I observed that the smallesf weighed bag was .9 grams and the
largest weighed 2.2 grams. Again, however, there were 12 separate individually wrapped bags, all weighing within
1 gram of each other. I also property inventoried the large plastic bag which contained all of the several smaller
bags. I also filled out an Offender Tracking Form. I looked up a criminal history of Smith. I found that he did not
have an adult criminal history. I did observe that he was suspended MN driver's license. It should be noted that
Smith did have a total of $16.00 on his person at the time of the arrest. At this time Smith is being held at the
Hennepin County Adult Detention Center for two misdemeanor warrants. I am also recommending that Smith be
charged via formal complaint for 5th degree possession of controlled substance with intent to sell which is a
felony. It should be noted that the recovery of the marijuana was not found until after a confirmed two active
warrants for Smith's arrest. The marijuana was recovered on a search incident to arrest. Again, the basis for
doing a subject stop on Smith was that he was loitering and biking between two high narcotic activity areas and
did not appear to be going anywhere in particular, the Center Point apartment complex nor the transit station. It
should also be noted that several buses had come and gone to which I did not observe Smith attempt to get on
the bus nor did he appear to stop any of the buses.
Upon speaking with Smith, he stated that he did not know anybody nor did he stay at the Center Point apartment
complex. Therefore, he should not have had any business over there if he did not know anybody or lived there.
GABLER
Ja 04121/07
Siqnatures
Reporting O�cer Date
Supervisor Date
Printed by: bc114to �1'1CIC�@Ilt R@p01� Page 1 of 5
Printed dateltime: 5/9/07 14:14
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-002451 e G
Incident Summarv
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: DRUG OFFENSE
Inc Occurred Address: 2900 CO RD 10 MTC TRANSIT STATION BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 554i Sector/Beat: 5BC54
Inc Occurred Start: 05/02/2007 22:15 Inc Occurred End: Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: Y
Contact Nature: Reported Date/Time: 05/02/2007 22:15
Reporting Officer: GABLER, RICHARD Primary Assigned O�cer.
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: ADULT ARREST Disposition Date: 05/03/2007 21:40
Offenses
Statute Code: 152-027-4 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: CONT SUBST-POSS OR SELL-SMALL AMT MARIJUANA
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: PETTY MISDEMEANOR
Statute Code: ORD E�hancers
Statute Desc: ORD LOCAL ORDINANCE VIOLATIONS
Counts: 1 Statute Severity:
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3228 147 GABLER. RICHARD
Associated Events
Association: Event Type: Event#: Event Date (Start): Event Date (End): Agency
ARREST TO INCIDENT ARREST BC07-002451 05/02/2007 22:15:00 BC
CITATION TO INCIDENT GTATION BC07-000366816 05/02/2007 22:1.5:00 BC
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 19163695 Can ID Suspect: Yes
Event Association: MENTIONED Contact DateITime: 05/02/2007 22:15
Name: WEBB, DARRELL DANDRE
Sex: MALE Race: BLACK NOiV-HiSPANiC
03/18/1988 A e: 19 19
DOB 9
Height: Weight: Eye Color: Hair Color:
Address: Sector/Beat:
Phone T e 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
YP
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: EmployerlSchooL•
Person#: 0002 MN1: 19163696 Can ID Suspect: Yes
Event Association: MENTIONED Contact DatelTime: 05/02/2007 22:15
Name: MCKINNEY, ANTONIO DEVW
DOB: 07/02/1979 Age: 27 27 Sex: MALE Race; BLACK NON-HISPANIC
Height: Weight: Eye Color: Hair Color:
Address: SectoNBeat:
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/SchooL•
Printed by: bc114to �11CIC�ellt R@p01"t Page 2 of 5
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:14
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
ROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07 -002451
Persons Involved
Person#: 0003 MNI: 932771 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: ARREST Contact Date/Time: 05/02/2007 22:15
Name: CAMPBELL, RAMADAN HAKIM
DOB: 03/06/1985 Age: 22 22 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK WITH HISPANIC
Height: 5' 11" 5' 11" Weight: 172 195 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
Address: 1826 PENN AV N 1 MINNEAPOLIS, MINNESOTA 55411 Sector/Beat:
Phone Type 1 c Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ezt 2:
Occupation: Empioyer/SchooL•
Person Offenses
Statute Code: 152-027-4 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: CONT SUBST-POSS OR SELL-SMALL AMT MARIJUANA
Counts: 1
Statute Code: ORD Enhancers:
Statute Desc: ORD LOCAL ORDINANCE VIOLATIONS
Counts: 1
Person#: 0004 MNI: 19095905 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: MENTIONED Contact DatelTime:
Name: CAMPBELL, VIANCA MONIQUE
DOB: 09/27/1987 Age: 19 19 Sex: FEMALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
Height: Weight: Eye Color: Hair Color:
Address: 2818 NORTHWAY DR 203 BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 SectorlBeat: 4IBC04
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ezt 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/Schooi:
Businesses Involved
Business 0001
Event Association: LOCATION
Business Name: METRO TRANSIT BUS HUB Business Type: SERVICE RELATED
Address: 2900 CO RD 10 MTC TRAN5IT STATION BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOT� Sector/Beat: 56C54
Phone Type 1: WORK Phone# 1: (612) 349-7415 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Propertv Involved
Propertv 0001 Evidence: No
Event Assoc/Orig status: EVIDENCE Original Status Date: 05l02/2007 22:15:00 Original Value: $0.00
Current Status: PROPERTY INVENTORIED Current Status Date: 05/02/2007 22:15:00 Current Value: $0.00
Property Type: DRUGS/NARCOTICS
Description: 20 INDIVIDUALLY WRAPPED BAGS OF MARIJUANA
MakeBrand: ModeL•
Color: Quantity: 27 GRAMS
Serial/Lot#: Owner Applied#:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCfG#: NCIC Cancelled:
Printed by: bc114to IIICICI@Ilt R@pOrt Page 3 of 5
Printed dateltime: 5/9/07 14:14
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 I
(�ss) sss-s3ss Incident Number: BC07-002451.
Narratives
Entered DatelTime: 05l03/2007 21:41 Narrative Type: SYNOPSIS
Subject: SYNOPSIS Author: GABLER, RICHARD
On 05/02/07, at 2215 hours, I, Officer Gabler, stopped three suspicious males for loitering at 2900 Norway Drive.
I cited one adult male for loitering with intent as well as possession of a small amount of marijuana.
I Printed by: bc114to IIICICIeCIt R@pOrt Page 4 of 5
Printed dateltime: 5/9/07 14:14
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
ROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
is3) sss-3333 Incident Number: BC07-002451
Entered Date/Time: 05I03/2007 21:43 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author. GABLER, RICHARD
On 05IO2/07, at approximately 2215 hours, I, Officer Gabler, observed an African American male wearing a white
long sleeve t-shirt and blue jeans walking from the bus hub at 2900 Co Rd 10 to the Center Pointe apartment
complex. I did observe that the male was with two other African American males.
It should be noted that I had seen the same male with a white long sleeve shirt and shorts loitering at the bus hub
earlier in the night. I observed the male at the bus hub earlier in the day for approximately one hour without
attempting to get onto a bus. I observed the male at a later time back at the bus hub. It should be noted that this
was the third time I did observe this same male at the bus hub in an approximate four hours time.
Based on the fact that the male was loitering at a high narcotics and high crime area I decided to approach the
male. It should be noted that I did not recognize the two other people that the male was with. I did stop and speak
to the three males in the parking lot at 2900 Co Rd 10. I began talking to the males and began speaking with the
male suspect with the long sleeve t-shirt whom I identified as Ramadan Hakim CAMPBELL, dob 03/06/85. I
identified the other two males as Darrell Dandre WEBB, dob 03/18/88, and Antonio Devin MCKINNEY, dob
07/02/79. It should be noted that all three males were identified by Minnesota picture ID cards and were all found
to be clear of warrants.
I asked Campbell what he was doing at the bus hub so many times today. He stated that he was up there visiting
people. I asked him if he had ever gotten on a bus. He stated that he had not. I asked him where he was going
now. He stated his sister's apartment on Northway Drive. I patted Campbell down for officer's safety purposes. I
asked the male prior to patting him down if he had anything illegal on him. He stated in a hesitant manner, "well,
no I don't have anything like guns or anything illegal on me like that. I then asked the male if he had anything
illegal on him at all to which then he gave no response. I began patting the male down.
Campbell asked what my probable cause for stopping him was. I explained to him that I had seen him at the bus
hub on three separate occasions within the past four hours, it was a high narcotic area at the bus hub and that he
did not appear to be getting on a bus at any point. I then felt in the male's front left pocket what felt like several
small individually wrapped bags. I noticed that while feeling the items in his front left pocket the male began
twisting and turning away. I asked the male what he had in his pocket and he again asked me what my basis for
stopping him was. I asked him if that was something illegal in his pocket which he did not give an answer.
Based on the fact that I felt that the items in his pocket might be some type of narcotic I then placed my hand in
the pocket and pulled out several individually packaged bags of a green leafy substance which appeared to be
that of marijuana. I noticed that all the bags were the same size and upon my feeling them they had the same
approximate weight. I asked the male if he had anything else illegal on his person. He stated that he did not and
that he wanted my badge number immediately. I asked the male what he was doing with the marijuana. He
stated that he just bought it at the bus hub.
I then placed the male in the back of the squad car. I then weighed the bags of marijuana and found that they
were approximately 27 grams of marijuana, counting 20 individually wrapped bags of marijuana.
I then issued a Hennepin County citation #2070366816 for loitering with intent and possession of a small amount
of marijuana for Campbell. I asked the other two males, Webb and McKinney, that they were free to leave. The
two males then left. I then gave Campbell a citation. I explained to him that he could call the Division II court
office to set up a court date or determine what the fine was. The male was very uncooperative throughout the
entire process and again stated that he wanted everyone's badge number.
It should be noted that when I asked Campbell if he had anything illegal on him he never did give me a yes or no
answer, was very hesitant in his answers and attempted to turn away from me when l was feeling his pocket which
raised my suspicion that there might be something illegal in the pocket. The male was also loitering for long
periods of time in a high narcotic trafficking area.
Printed by: bc114to IIICICIeIIt R@pOrt Page 5 of 5
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:14
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(�s3) sss-33s3 Incident Number: BC07-002451
I did issue Campbeli a notice and order ot trespass also tor the Center Pointe apartment complex based on the
fact that he did not live there and that narcotics were found in his pocket. I asked Campbell who he was going to
visit and he stated his sister, Vianca CAMPBELL. It should be noted that officers have made other prior arrests
for marijuana for people coming and going or otherwise associated with Vianca Campbell in the Center Pointe
apartment complex.
Gabler
pr 05/03/07
Sianatures
Reporting Officer Date
Supervisor Date
Printed by: bc114to Incident Report Pa ,°f 2
Printed date/time: 5/9l07 13:56
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-001340
Incident Summarv
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: BURGLARY
Inc Occurred Address: 2810 NORTHWAY DR 302 BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55430 Sector/Beat: 4/BC04
Inc Occurred Start: Inc Occurred End: Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported Date/Time: 03/14/2007 19:20
Reporting Officer: PEASLEY, TROY Primary Assigned Officer:
Case Status: INACTIVE Disposition: INACTIVE/OPEN Disposition Date: 03/30/2007 14:09
Offenses
Statute Code: 609-582-3 Enhancerr.
Statute Desc: BURGLARY-3RD DEG-ENTERS BLDG INTENT STEAL COMMIT CRIME
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: FELONY
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3227 116 PEASLEY, TROY
Persons Invoived
Person#: 0001 MNI: 19153266 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: COMPLAINANT Contact Date/Time: 03/14/2007 19:20
Name: RADMER, TINA MARIE
DOB: 01/03/1981 Age: 26 26 Sex: Race:
Height: Weight: Eye Color: Hair Color:
Address: 2810 NORTHWAY DR 302 BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 SectorlBeat: 4/BC04
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (612) 408-1421 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: EmpioyerlSchooL•
Businesses Invoived
Business 0001
Event Association: LOCATION
Business Name: CENTER POINTE APARTMENTS Business Type: APARTMENTS
Address: 2810 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55429 Sector/Beat: 46C04
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Propertv Involved
Propertv 0001 Evidence: No
Event AssoclOrig status: STOLEN WITHIN JURISC Original Status Date: 03/14/2007 19:20:00 Original Value: $894.00
Current Status: STOLEN WITHIN JURISDICTION Current Status Date: 03/14/2007 19:20:00 Current Value: $894.00
Property Type: OTHER
Description: CASH
MakelBrand: Model:
Color: Quantity: 1
Serial/Lot#: Owner Applied#:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCiC#: NCIC Cancelled:
Printed by: bc114to Page 2 of 2
Incident Report
Printed date/time: 5!9/07 13:56
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
��ss) 5ss-3sas Incident Number: BCO7-001340 I
Narratives
Entered DatelTime: 03/30/2007 14:22 Narrative Type: MAfN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author: PEASLEY, TROY
On 03/14/07 at 1855 hours, I, Officer Peasley, was dispatched to 2810 Northway Drive apt#302, on a report of a
burglary. Upon arrival, I made contact with the complainant Tina Marie Radmer-01-03-81. Radmer stated that
sometime between 1430 hours and 1830 hours, someone entered her apartment and stole $894.00 in cash.
Radmer believes the suspect(s) possibly climbed the railing all the way up to the 3rd floor onto her balcony and
then made entry into the apartment through the side door. Radmer thought she locked the side door this
aftemoon before she left, however because there were no signs of forced entry into the apartment she was not
100% sure. Radmer stated that $394.00 in cash was taken from inside of a plastic bag that was hidden
underneath a couple items on a shetf inside the entertainment center located in the living room. Radmer stated
that and there was an additional $500.00 in cash hidden underneath two mattresses inside of her back bedroom
that was taken. Total amount of loss $894.00 in cash. No suspecf information at the time of this report.
Sianatures
Reporting Officer Date
Supervisor
Date
Printed by: bc114to �nCldent RepOrt Page 1 of 2
Printed dateltime: 5/9/07 13:57
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 incident Number: BC07 -001401
Incident Summarv
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: THEFT
Inc Occurred Address: 2802 NORTHWAY DR LOT LOT BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55429 Sector/Beat: 4/BC04
Inc Occurred Start: 03/16/2007 00:00 Inc Occurred End: 03/17/2007 12:11 Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported Date/Time: 03/17/2007 12:11
Reporting Officer: HOLMSTROM, DWAYNE Primary Assigned Officer:
Case Status: INACTIVE Disposition: INACTIVE/OPEN Disposition Date: 04/05/2007 10:08
Offenses
Statute Code: 609-595-2 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: CRIMINAL DAMAGE PROPERTY-3RD DEG-$251 TO $500
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: GROSS MISDEMEANOR
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3238 130 HOLMSTROM, DWAYNE
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 19159452 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: COMPLAINANT Contact Date/Time: 03/17/2007 12:11
Name: ROBISON, SHIRLEY V
DOB: 08l30/1933 Age: 73 73 Sex: FEMALE Race: WHITE
Height: Weight: Eye Color: Hair Calor:
Address: 2802 NORTHWAY DR 202 BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55429 Sector/Beat: 416C04
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 566-0841 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/School:
Vehicles Involved
Vehicle#: 0001
Event Assoc: DAMAGED Vehicle Status:
Vehicle Type: A Year: 1993 Make: CHEVROLET Model: CAPRICE
VIN: License#: MWF549 State: MN Expires On:
Style: 4-DOOR Prim Color. BIUE Sec Color. Ter Color:
Status DUTm: Status Value: Recovered Date: Recovered Value:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Cancelled:
Registered Owner Name: ROBISON, SHIRLEY V
Addres5:2802 NORTHWAY DR 202 BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55429 Phone#: (763) 566-0841
Businesses Involved
Business 0001
Event Association: LOCATION
Business Name: CENTER POINTE APARTMENTS Business Type: APARTMENTS
Address: 2802 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55429 SectorlBeat: 4BC04
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
u�,.
Printed by: bc114to Page 2 of 2
Incident Report
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:57
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N e',
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
{763) 569-3333 InCldent NUmber: BC07-001401
Propertv Involved
Proaertv 0001 Evidence: No
Event Assoc/Orig status: DAMAGED Original Status Date: 03/17/2007 12:11:00 Original Value: $200.00
Current Status: DAMAGED Current Status Date: 03/17/2007 12:11:00 Current Value: $200.00
Property Type: AUTO-OTHER
Description: PASSENGER FRONT WINDOW
Make/Brand: CHEVROLET Model: CAPRICE
Color: Quantity: 1
Serial/Lot#: Owner Applied#:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Cancelled:
Propertv 0002 Evidence: No
Event Assoc/Orig status: DAMAGED Original Status Date: 03/17/2007 12:11:00 Original Value: $200.00
Current Status: DAMAGED Current Status Date: 03/17/2007 12:11:00 Current Value: $200.00
Property Type: AUTO-OTHER
Description: STEERING COLUMN
MakeBrand: CHEVROLET Model: CAPRICE
Color: Quantity: 1
Serial/Lot#: Owner Applied#:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Cancelled:
Narratives
Entered Date/Time: 04/19/2007 15:42 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author: DESTICHE, JAMES
Vehicle was parked overnight in apartment lot where owner lives. When owner came out to vehicle in the morning
she found the passenger window had been smashed and the steering column damaged. I observed the fresh
broken glass and damage. No items varere missing from inside the vehicle and I suspect this to be an attempted
auto theft. There are no suspects.
Sianatures
Reporting Officer Date
Supervisor Date
Page 1 of 2
Printed by: bc114to Incident Report
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:57
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 ItlCldeflt NUf11b@t': BC07 -001415
Incident SummarW
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: AUTO THEFT
Inc Occurred Address: 2904 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55429 Sector/Beat: /BC04
Inc Occurred Start: 03/17/2007 19:45 Inc Occurred End: 03/18/2007 00:15 Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported DatelTime: 03118/2007 00:15
Reporting Officer: SCHULTZ, JAMES Primary Assigned Officer:
Case Status: ACTIVE Disposition: PENDING/OPEN Disposition Date: 03/19l2007 13:16
Offenses
Statute Code: 609-52-2-1 Enhancers
Statute Desc: THEFT-VEH MOTOR VEHICLE
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: FELONY
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3229 106 SCHULTZ, JAMES
List of Attachments
Type: Report ID: Report Date: Report Summary:
OTHER Stolen Vehicle Report
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 3946543 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: REPORTING PARTY Contact Date/Time: 03/18/2007 00:15
Name: JAMES, PAMELA ANNETTE
DOB: 09/16/1958 Age: 48 48 Sex: FEMALE Race: BLACK
Height: Weight: Eye Color. Hair Coior:
Address: 2904 NORTHWAY DR 303 BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 Sector/Beat: iBC04
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 585-4530 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: CELL Phone# 2: (612) 990--831 Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/SchooL•
Person#: 0002 MNI: 19149529 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: OWNER Contact DatelTime:
Name: STEPHENY, JUDITH SHERALD
DOB: 11/13/1942 Age: 64 64 Sex: FEMALE Race:
Height: Weight: Eye Color: Hair Color:
Address: 2904 NORTHWAY DR 303 BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 Sector/Beat: /BC04
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 585-4530 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: EmployedSchooL•
Printed by: bc114to Page 2 of 2
Incident Report
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:57
BROOKLYN CENTER POUCE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N I
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(�ss) sss-3s3s Incident Number: BC07-001415
Vehicles Involved
Vehicle#: 0001
Event Assoc: STOLEN WITHIN JURISDICTION Vehicle Status: STOLEN WtTHIN JURISDICTION
Vehicie Type: A Year: 1993 Make: DODGE Model: CARAVAN
VIN: 1B4GH2538PR155902 License#: 03 18 07 00 15 State: MN Expires On:
Style: VAN/MINI VAN Prim Color: WHITE Sec Color: Ter Golor:
Status Dt/Tm: 03/18/2007 00:15 Status Yalue: $2,000.00 Recovered Date: 03/18/2007 06:22 Recovered Value: $2,000.00
NCIC Date: 03/18/2007 06:01 NCIC Reported By: YARPHEL, SONAM
NCIC#: V790425485 NCIC Cancelled: 03/18/2007 06:22
Registered Owner Name: STEPHENY, JUDITH SHERALI
Address: 2904 NORTHWAY DR 303 BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55430 Phone#: (763) 585-4530
Siqnatures
Reporting Officer Date
Supervisor Date
E�
L
Printed by: bc114to �nCldent Rep01� Page 1 of 2
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:01
BROOKLYN CENTER POUCE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number BC07-001759
I
Incident Summarv
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: THEFT
Inc Occurred Address: 2932 NORTHWAY DR 203 BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55430 Sector/Beat: 4/BC04
inc Occurred Start: Inc Occurred End: Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported Date/Time: 04/02/2007 14:58
Reporting Officer: LEYK, SARA Primary Assigned Officer:
Case Status: INACTIVE Disposition: INACTIVElOPEN Disposition Date: 04J06/2007 09:58
Offenses
Statute Code: 609-52-3-5 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: THEFT-OTHER PROPERTY-VALUE LESS THAN $250
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: MISDEMEANOR
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3221 150 LEYK, SARA
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 3646892 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: Contact Date/Time:
Name: SAPP, CHRISTINA NICOLE
DOB: 01/16/1986 Age: 21 21 Sex: FEMALE Race: BLACK
Height: 5' 2" 5' 2" Weight: 106 106 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BROWN
Address: 2932 NORTHWAY DR 203 BROOKLYN GENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 Sector/Beat: 4/BC04
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# L(763) 486-6149 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: WORK Phone# 2: (952) 854-5644 Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/School: FOOT LOCKER
Propertv Involved
Propertv 0001 Evidence: No
Event Assoc/Orig status: STOLEN WITHIN JURISC Original Status Date: 04/02/2007 14:58:00 Original Value: $100.00
Current Status: STOLEN WITHIN JURISDICTION Current Status Date: 04/02/2007 14:58:00 Current Value: $100.00
Property Type: OTHER
Description: EBT CARD
Make/Brand: ModeL•
Color: Quantity: 1
Serial/lot#: Owner Applied#:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Cancelled:
s 6
Printed by: bc114to �nCldent RepOrt Page 2 of 2
Printed date/time: 5l9/07 14:01
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 incident Number BC07-001759 r
Narratives
Entered Date/Time: 04/06/2007 10:06 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author. LEYK, SARA
On 04/02/07, Christina called to report that her EBT card was used this moming without her permission. She
called, but did not want to meet with an officer. I went to the address she gave dispatch, and told her I needed to
meet with her to get information. She met me in the hallway of 2932 Northway, with no attempt to go to her
apartment. She reported that she had several people over this morning, however she was sleeping. She said that
when she went to use her card, there was no money in her account. She looked into it, and found someone had
withdrawn $100.00 at 0937 hours. She would not give information on her quests, only that she trusts all of them,
and suspects no one. I attempted contact with TCF to see if we could view tapes, but they needed to check into
that per their policy. The only information Sapp would give me was that 5 black males were at her house, and
should be noted I could not find record of Sapp in the Minnesota Department of Transportation files to verify her
information.
Siqnatures
Reporting O�cer Date I
Supervisor Date
Printed by: bc114to Page 1 of 4
Incident Report
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:02
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
ROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-001889
Incident Summary
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: BURGLARY
Inc Occurred Address: 2810 NORTHWAY DR 303 BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55429 Sector/Beat: 4/BC04
Inc Occurred Start: 04/07/2007 12:00 inc Occurred End: 04/07/2007 18:00 Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported Date/Time: 04/07/2007 18:06
Reporting Officer: JOHNSON, MYCHAL Primary Assigned Officer:
Case Status: INACTIVE Disposition: INACTIVE/OPEN Disposition Date: 04/17/2007 17:00
Offenses
Statute Code: 609-582-2 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: BURGLARY-FORCED-RES-DAY
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: FELONY
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3215 146 JOHNSON, MYCHAL
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 19158653 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: COMPLAINANT Contact DatelTime: 04/07/2007 19:10
Name: MARTINEZ, ASHLEY MARIE
DOB: 09/11l1983 Age: 23 23 Sex: FEMALE Race:
Height: Weight: Eye Color: Hair Color:
Address: 2810 NORTHWAY DR 303 BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55429 Sector(Beat: 4/BC04
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (612) 521-1311 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: EmployerlSchool:
Businesses Invoived
Business 0001
Event Association: LOCATION
Business Name: CENTER POINTE APARTMENTS Business Type: APARTMENTS
Address: 2810 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55429 Sector/Beat: 4BC04
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Pho�e# 2: Ext 2:
Propertv Involved
Propertv 0001 Evidence: No
Event Assoc/Orig status: STOLEN WITHIN JURISC Original Status Date: 04/07/2007 18:06:00 Original Value: $1,000.00
Current Status: STOLEN WITHIN JURISDICTION Current Status Date: 04/07/2007 18:06:00 Current Vatue: $1,000.00
Property Type: COMPUTER TERMINAL
Description: COMPAQ DESKTOP COMPUTER
MakeBrand: ModeL•
Color: Quantity: 1
Serial/Lot#: Owner Applied#:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Cancelled:
Page 2 of 4
Printed by: bc114to Incident Report
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:02
BROOKLYN CENTER POUCE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 It1Cid@ilt NU171beP: BC07-001889
(763) 569-3333
Propertv Invoived
Proaertv 0002 Evidence: No I
Event AssoGOrig status: STOLEN WITHIN JURISC Original Status Date: 04/07/2007 18:06:00 Originai Value: $50.00
Current Status: STOLEN WITHIN JURISDICTION Current Status Date: 04/07/2007 18:06:00 Cu�rent Value: $50.00
Property Type: PRINTER (ALL TYPES)
Description: HEWLETT PACKARD PRINTER
MakeBrand: ModeL•
Color: Quantity: 1
Serial/Lot#: Owner Applied#:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Cancelled:
Propertv 0003 Evidence; No
Event AssoclOrig status: STOLEN WITHIN JURISC Original Status Date: 04/07l2007 18:06:00 Original Value: $50.00
Current Status: STOLEN WITHIN JURISDICTION Current Status Date: 04/07/2007 18:06:00 Current Value: $50.00
Property Type: OTHER-ALL OTHER
Description: QWEST DSL BOX
Mai�eBrand: ModeL•
Color. Quantity: 1
Serial/Lot#: Owner Applied#:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Cancelled:
Propertv 0004 Evidence: No
Event Assoc/Orig status: STOLEN WITHIN JURISC Original Status Date: 04/07/2007 18:06:00 Original Value: $75.00
Current Status: STOLEN WITHIN JURISDICTION Current Status Date: 04/07/2007 18:06:00 Current Value: $75.00
Property Type: GAMING-OTHER
Description: PLAYSTATION 1
Make/Brand: Model:
Color: Quantity: 1
Serial/Lot#: Owner Applied#:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Cancefled:
Proae�tv 0005 Evidence: No
Event AssoclOrig status: STOLEN WITHIN JURISC Original Status Date: 04/07/2007 18:06:00 Original Value: $30.00
Current Status: STOCEN WITHIN JURISDICTION Current Status Date: 04/07/2007 18:06:00 Current Value: $30.00
Property Type: DVD
Description: DVD PLAYER
Make/Brand: ModeL•
Co�or: Quantity: 1
Serial/Lot#: Owner Applied#:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Cancelled:
I
I
r Page 3 of 4
Printed by: bc114to �11CIC�@Ilt R@pOft
Printed date/time: 5l9/07 14:02
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07 -001889
Proaertv Involved
Propertv 0006 Evidence: No
Event AssoGOrig status: STOLEN WITHIN JURISC Original Status Date: 04l07/2007 18:06:00 Original Value: $0.00
Current Status: STOLEN WITHIN JURISDICTION Current Status Date: 04l07/2007 18:06:00 Current Value: $0.00
Property Type: STEREO RECEIVER
Description: SONY STEREO
Make/Brand: Model: MHCEC70
Color: Quantity: 1
Serial/Lot#: 6409046012 Owner Applied#:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Cancelied:
Propertv 0007 Evidence: No
Event Assoc/Orig status: STOLEN WITHIN JURISC Original Status Date: 04/07l2007 18:06:00 Original Value: $60.00
Current Status: STOLEN WITHIN JURISDICTION Current Status Date: 04l07/2007 18:06:00 Current Value: $60.00
Property Type: TELEPHONE (PHONE)
Description: CORDLESS PHONE
Make/Brand: ModeL•
Color: Quantity: 1
Serial/Lot#: Owner Applied#:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Cancelled:
Narratives
Entered Date/Time: 04/17/2007 16:42 Narrative Type: SYNOPSIS
Subject: SYNOPSIS Author: JOHNSON, MYCHAL
Officers were dispatched on a report of a burglary, spoke with the victim and took report.
Printed by: bc114to �nCIC'@Ilt R@p01� Page 4 of 4
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:02
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-001889
Entered Date/Time: 04/17/2007 16:44 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author: JOHNSON, MYCHAL
On 04/07/07 at 1806 hours officers were dispatched to 2810 Northway Drive, apartment 303, on a report of a
burglary.
I arrived and spoke with the victim Ashley Martinez who said that her apartment had been burglarized sometime
between 1200 and 1800 hours. I asked if she knew how the person had gained entry into the apartment to which
she said she was not exactly sure. She said when she had arrived home at 1800 hours she found that her front
door was still locked and no damage was done. She said that she first noticed as she walked in that her computer
was missing off the table, and further walking through the apartment finding that several other items were missing.
She said that she did check the patio door which appeared to be damaged.
I did inspect the patio door frame finding that it was split down the middle of the door frame and was easily opened
with the door not locked. Martinez said that when she did find that door that it was locked but appeared to have
been pushed open. I asked Martinez if she had touched the knobs to the door to which she said yes she had, and
I advised that due to her touching the knobs we would not be able to obtain prints. I did take photos of the
h oor frame.
dama e done to t e d
9
I asked Martinez to go through the house and explain to me what was all missing to which she said missing was a
Compaq desktop computer which was a value of approximately $1000; a Hewlett Packard printer, value of $50; a
Qwest DSL box, value $50; a PlayStation 1, value $75; a DVD player of unknown make, value $30; a Sony stereo,.
model MHCEC70 which she said she did have a serial number for which was 6409046012; and also a cordless
phone of an unknown make, value $60.
I asked her if anybody had seen the burglary to which she said no, they did not. At this time there is no suspect or
witness information.
Johnson/bg i
04/17/07
Sictnatures
Reporting Officer Date
Supervisor Date
�i�
Printed by: bc114to Incident Report Page 1 of 1
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:03
BROOKLYN CENTER POUCE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-001888
Incident Summary
Incident Type: STATUS OFFENSE(S) Report Type: TOW
inc Occurred Address: 2940 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55430 Sector/Beat: 4/BC04
Inc Occurred Start: Inc Occurred End: Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported DatelTime: 04/07/2007 19:19
Reporting Officer: GABLER, RICHARD Primary Assigned O�cer:
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: ASSISTED/ADVISED Disposition Date: 04/09/2007 08:28
Offenses
Statute Code: MISIMP Enhancers:
Statute Desc: MISC OFCR VEHICLE IMPOUND
Counts: 1 Statute Severity:
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3228 147 GABLER, RICHARD
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 3925559 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: REGISTERED OWNER Contact DatelTime:
Name: HARRIS, CYNTHIA DENISE
DOB: 02/27/1964 Age: 43 43 Sex: FEMALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
Height: 5' 8" 5' 8" Weight: 140 140 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BROWN
Address: 4755 WELCOME AV N CRYSTAL, MINNESOTA 55429 Sector/Beat: /CY16
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 537-9086 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: WORK Phone# 2: (763) 780-5604 Ext 2:
Occupation: HEALTH CARE ASST Employer/School: INTREPID
Vehicles Involved
Vehicle#: 0001
Event Assoc: TOWED Vehicle Status:
Vehicie Type: A Year: 1994 Make: BUICK Model: PARK AVENUE
VIN: License#: LYJ741 State: MN Expires On:
Style: 4-DOOR Prim Co�or: BLACK Sec Color: Ter Color:
Status DtlTm: Status Value: Recovered Date: Recovered Value:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Cancelled:
Siqnatures
Reporting Officer Date
Supervisor Date
Printed by: bc114to �nCldent Re,p01�'� Page 1 of 5
Printed datettime: 5/9/07 14:03
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-001917
Incident Summarv
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: ASSAULT
Inc Occurred Address: 2900 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55430 Sector/Beat: /BC04
Inc Occurred Start: 04/05/2007 10:30 inc Occurred End: Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported Date/Time: 04/09/2007 10:00 i
Reporting Officer: OLSON, TERRY Primary Assigned Officer:
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: EXCEPTIONAL CLEARED Disposition Date: 04/11l2007 12:32
Offenses
Statute Code: 609-72 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: DISTURB-DISORDERLY CONDUCT
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: MISDEMEANOR
Statute Code: 609-224-1 Enhancers
Statute Desc: ASSAULT-5TH DEGCOMMITS, ATTEMPTS OR THREATS HARM
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: MISDEMEANOR
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
REPORTWG OFFICER 3214 114 OLSON, TERRY
INVESTIGATOR 3214 114 OLSON, TERRY
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 71904 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: VICTIM Contact Date/Time: 04l09l2007 10:00
Name: DAHLINE, HEATHER ALISON
DOB: 11/12/1971 Age: 35 35 Sex: FEMALE Race: WHITE
Height: 5' S" 5' 5" Weight: 130 130 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
Address: 1416 E 22ND STREET MINNEAPOLIS, MINNESOTA 55404 Sector/Beat:
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (612) 385-7878 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: EmployerlSchooL•
Person#: 0002 MNL• 882880 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: SUSPECT Contact Date/Time:
Name: LEONARD, RODNEY RUSSELL
DOB: 01/15/1963 Age: 44 44 Sex: MALE Race: WHITE
Height: 5' 11" 5' 11" Weight: 200 200 Ibs Eye Color: HAZEL Hair Color. BROWN
Address: 3911 65TH 205 BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 SectorlBeat:
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (612) 574-1345 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: WORK Phone# 2: (952) 380-0635 Ext 2:
Occupation: MAINTENANCE MAN EmployerlSchooi: CENTER POINTE APARTMENTS
Person Offenses
Statute Code: 609-224-1 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: ASSAULT-5TH DEGCOMMITS, ATTEMPTS OR THREATS HARM I
Counts: 1
Statute Code: 609-72 Enhancers
Statute Desc: DISTURB-DISORDERLY CONDUCT
Counts: 1
Page 2 of 5
Printed by: bc114to �11CIC�@Ilt R@p01't
Printed dateltime: 5/9/07 14:03
BROOKLYN CENTER POUCE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(�ss) 5ss-3ss3 Incident Number: BC07-001917
Persons Involved
Person#: 0003 MNI: 18169448 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: MENTIONED Contact Date/Time:
Name: JAWEED, HYDER RAZA
DOB: 10/06/1976 Age: 30 30 Sex: MALE Race: WHITE
Height: 6' 0" 6' 0" Weight: 195 195 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
Address: 3 BLUE SPRUCE NORTH OAKS, MINNESOTA 55127 Sector/Beat:
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (651) 493-4221 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: WORK Phone# 2: (612) 414-0397 Ext 2:
Occupation: Empioyer/SchooL•
Person#: 0004
MNI: 19132107
Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: MENTIONED Contact Date/Time:
Name:. ALI, ASGHER RAZA
Race: RACE
DOB: 06/08/1981 Age: 25 25 Sex: MALE
Wei ht: 190 190 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color:
Hei ht: 5' 10" 5' 10" g
9
Sector/Beat:
Address:
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/School:
Person#: 0005 MNI: 3519511 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: MENTIONED Contact Date/Time: 04/11/2007 14:15
Name: SYTSMA, ERIC ANTHONY
DOB: 08/01/1983 Age: 23 23 Sex: MALE Race: WHITE
Height: 5' 11" 5' 11" Weight: 164 164 Ibs Eye Color: HAZEL Hair Color: BROWN
Address: 2900 NORTHWAY DR 201 BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 Sector/Beat: /BC04
Phone Type 1: WORK Phone# 1: (763) 561-9072 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: CELL Phone# 2: (612) 298-0650 Ext 2:
Occupation: PROPERTY MANAGER Employer/School: CENTER POINTE APARTMENTS
Narratives
Entered DatelTime: 04/11/2007 12:36 Narrative Type: SYNOPSIS
Subject: SYNOPSIS Author: OLSON, TERRY
Victim made report of Assault (cause fearj and Disorderly Conduct. The Victim and Suspect were both members
of the Property Management Team at Center Pointe Apartments and on-duty at the time of the incident.
Printed by: bc114to �nCldent RepO� Page 3 of 5
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:03
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 ItlCidellt NUPTibe� BC07-001917
Entered Date/Time: 04/11/2007 12:38 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: ICR Author: OLSON, TERRY
On 04-09-2007 at approximately 10:00 hours I received a phone call from Victim Dahline who reported an incident
involving Suspect Leonard. Victim Dahline told me:
She was the Property Manager at Center Pointe Apartments.
Suspect Leonard was the lead Maintenance Man there.
She'd asked him for a list of vacant units available for new tenants.
She'd been asking for the list repeatedly for several weeks.
Each time she asked Suspect Leonard became increasingly hostile.
r vide the list she could nof move new tena
nts in.
Sus ect Leonard did not o
Because p p
On 04-05-2007 at approximately 10:30 she again asked for the list of apartments.
She was in the rental office and alone with Suspect Leonard at that time.
Suspect Leonard became agitated and left, but returned several minutes later.
When he did so he ran across the office toward her while she was seated.
She put her hands up to stop him, believing he was going to run into her.
He sto ed just before running into her and screamed at her using profanity.
PP
He did so for several minutes.
Given his conduct she feared for her safety, believing he may hit or push her. 'i
After several minutes he left.
She called
Entered Date/Time: 04/11l2007 14:49 Narrative Type: SUPPLEMENTAL R�PORT
Subject: ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Author: OLSON, TERRY 'I�
On 04-11-2007 I spoke with the new Property Manager at the Center Pointe Apartments, Eric Sytsma. He
indicated that he believed that the camera system in the office was recorded to a location off-site. He agreed to
attempt to locate any video recordings which were made for review in conjunction with this investigation. He also
agreed to contact me with his findings in a timely manner.
I
•i
Printed by: bc114to �1'1CId@Ilt R@p01� Page 4 of 5
Printed dateltime: 5/9/07 14:03
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-001917
Entered DatelTime: 04/12/2007 14:18 Narrative Type: SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT
Subject: ADDITIONAL INFORMA710N Author: OLSON, TERRY
On 04-12-2007 I spoke with Suspect Leonard by telephone regarding the ailegations made by Victim Dahline. He
told me:
He leamed that Victim Dahline had been critical of his work through other employees.
He confronted her about this while in the rental office.
He didn't recall what day this took place but agreed that it happened at around 10:00.
He told her to take her complaints about him up with him directly.
At that time he was standing approximately ten feet from her.
He did not raise his voice, use profanity, or approach her.
She responded by getting up from her desk and shouting at him.
She walked up to him and stood very close in a confrontational manner.
She shouted at him using profanity.
He denies Victim Dahline's characterization of the incident.
He believes activities taking place in the office are recorded.
She suggested I review the recording to confirm his statement.
As of time of this report I am waiting for information from the current Property Manager, Erick Sytsma, regarding
the existence and availability of video evidence.
Entered Date/Time: 04/30/2007 15:15 Narrative Type: SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT
Subject: DISPOSITION Autfior: OISON, TERRY
I have communicated with Eric Sytsma by telephone and in writing several times since he agreed to determine
whether video documentation of the controntation exists and to make it available to me. In each instance he
assured me that he was working on it. The last time 1 spoke with him he told me that Asgher Ali, one of the
property owners, was checking into this as welL
Since that time neither has returned correspondence or calls confirming this repeated request. I had anticipated
this result as it is consistent with their response when dealing with City officials over the course of several years.
I do not have enough information to draft a Search Warrant for video evidence because I do not know that it
exists. Beyond this I do not know who possesses this evidence if it does exist.
There are no viable investigative leads at this time. For this reason I do not anticipate conducting further
investigation.
The case is Closed Exceptionally Cleared.
Printed by: bc114to �11CId@Ilt R@p01� Page 5 of 5
Printed date/time: 5!9/07 14:03
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-001917 I
I Sianatures
Reporting Officer Date
Supervisor Date
i'�
Printed by: bc114to Incident Report Pa ,°f s
Printed date/time: 5/9l07 14:09
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 InCident NUmber: BC07-002084
Incident Summarv
incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: USE OF FORCE
Inc Occurred Address: 2920 NORTHWAY DR LOT LOT BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55429 Sector/Beat: 4BC04
Inc Occurred Start: 04/16/2007 01:35 Inc Occurred End: 04/16/2007 01:35 Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported DatelTime: 04/16/2007 01:35
Reporting Officer: PETERSON, MICHAEL Primary Assigned Officer.
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: ASSISTED/ADVISED Disposition Date: 04/19l2007 15:18
Offenses
Statute Code: 609-224-1 Enhancers
Statute Desc: ASSAULT-5TH DEG-COMMITS, ATTEMPTS OR THREATS HARM
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: MISDEMEANOR
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3226 148 PE7ERSON, MICHAEL
BACK-UP 3221 150 LEYK, SARA
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 3949830 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: REPORTING PARTY Contact Date/Time: 04/16/2007 01:45
Name: FARKARI.UN, CORRINNE ROSE
DOB: 11/17/1963 Age: 43 43 Sex: FEMALE Race: INDIAN/ ALASKAN NATIVI
Height: 5' 1" 5' 1" Weight: 240 240 ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
Address: 2924 NORTHWAY DR 302 BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55429 Sector/Beat: 4/BC04
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (612) 379-3105 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/School:
Pe�son#: 0002 MNI: 936943 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: MENTIONED Contact Date/Time: 04/16/2007 01:37
Name: FARKARLUN, TRISHA KUMBA
DOB: 08/28/1985 Age: 21 21 Sex: FEMALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
Height: 5' 2" b' 2" Weight: 150 150 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color. BLACK
Address: 4407 MORGAN AV N 2 MINNEAPOLIS, MINNESOTA 55412 SectorlBeat:
Phone Type 1: HOME Phor�# 1: (612) 359-0251 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/Schooi:
Printed by: bc114to IIICiCI@Ilt R@pOrt Page 2 of 6
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:09
BROOKIYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 G
(763) 569-3333 InCldent NUmber: BC07-002084
Persons Involved
Person#: 0003 MNi: 19052352 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: MENTIONED Contact Date/Time: 04l16/2007 01:30
Name: WINTERS, TRACY DENISE
DOB: 03/18/1986 Age: 21 21 Sex: FEMALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
Height: 5' 4" 5' 4" Weight: 120 120 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
Address: 2101 VINCENT AV N MINNEAPOLIS, MINNESOTA 55411 SectorlBeat:
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 537-9608 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
I
Occupation: EmployerlSchool:
Businesses Involved
Business 0001
Event Association: LOCATION
Business Name: CENTER POINTE APARTMENTS Business Type: APARTMENTS
Address: 2920 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MWNESOTA 5543D Sector/Beat: 4BC04
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Narratives
Entered DatelTime: 04/19/2007 14:37 Narrative Type: SYNOPSIS
Subject: SYNOPSIS Author: PETERSON, MICHAEL
Officers were called to an assault. Upon arrival parties had been separated and were found to be intoxicated but
refused to press charges against each other. Two parties initially did not cooperate with officers and had to be
restrained.
L
Printed by: bc114to IIICICI@Clt R@pOrt Page 3 of 6
Printed dateltime: 5/9/07 14:09
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 111CId@Ilt NUI'Ylb@I': BC07-002084
Entered DatelTime: 04/19/2007 14:39 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author: PETERSON, MICHAEL
On 04-16-07 at 0135 hours, I, Officer Peterson, was dispatched to 2924 Northway Drive for an assauit that had
just occurred. While I was en route dispatch relayed information that the victim told them that her daughter was
with the party who had assaulted her and that they were walking towards Cub Foods from the Center Pointe
Apartment building. They were described as two black females in their mid-twenties. I arrived in the area sho►tly
after that information was sent out over the air and I looked in the area between Cub Foods and Center Pointe.
In the vacant lot that used to be Jerry's Market I observed two females standing in the northeast corner of that lot
close to the intersection of Xerxes and Northway Drive. As I looked further these two parties appeared to be
either embracing each other or possibly fighting with each other.
pu{led my vehicle onto Northway Drive just west of Xerxes and I shined my spotlight on them. I did have my
window rolled down when I drove up there and as I put my spotlight on the two parties one of the females who was
later identified as Tracy Denice WINTERS, DOB 03-18-1986, stated to me, "Can I help you?" I asked the two
parties to walk over to my direction as I was walking towards them so that I could talk to them. Winters again
stated, "Can I help you," "What do I need to talk to you for?" I stated that I just needed to find out what was going
on with them. As 1 continued walking towards them they continued walking to the east and Winters stated that
they were just there waiting for the bus. At that time I observed that she was on the phone with somebody and
she said that the cops were out here hassling her and they were arresting her for no reason. I asked her to please
hang up the phone so that I could talk to her and she did not. She told the party that she was talking to on the
other line that they needed to hurry up if they were close because the police was there and we were going to hurt
her. I then told her to hang up the phone as I did not know who she was talking to or how close they were and I
did not want anyone else coming to the scene for everyone's safety. She still did not comply with my demand to
hang up the phone so I reached with my right hand and grabbed the phone from her right hand as it was up to her
head.
As 1 began to pull the phone away from her, the other party who was later identified as Trisha Kumba
FARKARLIlN, DOB 08-28-1985, lunged in my direction. Officer Leyk, who was on scene with me, then grabbed
on to her to keep her from attacking me. Both Winters and Trisha grabbed on to each other and I was not sure if
they were starting to fight or if they were trying to help each other get away from officers. I told them that they
needed to stop resisting and to place their hands behind their backs and neither would cooperate. Trisha then
ended up closer on my side as they were struggling back and forth between Officer Leyk and myself and I
attempted to grab her left arm and try and apply an arm bar to get her to the ground. As I did both Winters and
Trisha lost their balance and they fell to the ground.
Once on the ground both parties continued to hold one another while still trying to elbow and kick officers. I
repeatedly�told them to stop fighting, to stop resisting and to place their hands behind their backs but they
continued to struggle. After approximately a minute of them struggling on the ground, I did step back pulled my
taser from my belt and I turned it on and told them that if they did not cooperate they would both be tased. At that
time they both stopped resisting and they both placed their hands behind their backs and both parties were cuffed.
Please see Officer Leyk's supplemental report for further information.
I then escorted Trisha over to my marked squad #324 and asked her what was going on. She stated that they
were about to get jumped by some people from Center Pointe and that they were scared that we were the people
who were doing it. I told her that I clearly was in a marked police car, I put my spotlight on them, and I identified
m y s e l f a s t h e p o l i c e a n d I w a s a l s o i n u n i f o r m. I n t a l k i n g w i t h h e r I r e a l i z e d t h a t s h e s eemed to be intoxicated and
I asked her what had actually happened that night. She stated that she had been out drinking with Winters who is
B 11-17-1973 at Blondies
girlfriend and her mother who was later identified as Corrinne Rose FARKARLUN, DO
in Brooklyn Park. They were dropping Corrinne off at 2924 Northway Drive and wanted to make sure she was
going to get in okay when both Corrinne and Winters started assaulting each other. I
Printed by: bc114to IIICICI@Ilt R@pOrt Page 4 of 6
Printed dateltime: 5!9/07 14:09
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-002084
asked all three parties it they needed medical attention and none of them said that they did. It should be noted
that at this time myself and Officer Leyk had transported Trisha and Winters over to the parking lot of 2920
Northway Drive where we found Corrinne standing out in the parking lot. As soon as Trisha had calmed down I
informed her that I would take the handcuffs off if she was not going to continue with officers or other people. She
stated she wouldn't; therefore, I took the handcuffs off Trisha.
I then spoke with Corrinne who was standing in the parking lot and on my initial contact with her I could tell that
she was intoxicated as I could smell the odor of an intoxicating beverage emanating from her and she was having
a hard time standing and she was slurring her words. I asked her if she had anything to drink tonight and she
stated that she had been drinking. I asked her what happened and she stated that Winters who she knows as her
daughter's girlfriend hit her over the top of the head. She does not know if an object was used but believes it was
n. I asked her if she hit Winters back and she stated that she did not. It should be noted that Corrinne
J t her ha d
us
is a niuch larger woman than Winters is. Again I asked Corrinne if she needed medical attention and she stated
that she did not.
I went over to speak with Winters who was in the back of marked squad #322 driven by Officer Leyk and told her
that she needed to settle down as she was still very agitated in the back of the squad car and I told her that as
soon as she did calm down I would take the handcuffs off of her. 1 asked her what happened and she stated that
they had been drinking up at Blondies in Brooklyn Park and they were just dropping off Corrinne at the apartment.
The two of them started arguing verbally in the car when they were almost at the apartment complex and then
they started physically fighting once there. Winters stated that she did not wish to press any charges against
Corrinne.
I went back and talked to Corrinne about what happened and she then admitted that they were both fighting and
she no longer wished to press charges against Winters as long as Winters left immediately. There were family
members of Winters' on scene and I did take the handcuffs off Winters and had Officer Leyk let her out of her •!i
squad car to go with her family. All parties then went their separate ways.
Peterson/re
04-20-07
Printed by: bc114to I1ICICI@Ilt R@pOrt Page 5 of 6
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:09
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-002084
Entered DatelTime: 04/19/2007 15:12 Narrative Type: SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT
Subject: SUPP1 SL 4/16/07 0249 Author: LEYK, SARA
On 4/16/O7 at 0135 hours, I, O�cer Leyk, was dispatched to 2924 Northway Drive on the report of an Assault.
Upon arrival in the area Dispatch advised the two suspects fled on foot toward the Cub Foods lot. I responded
westbound on County Road 10 for Cub Foods when I observed two females on the corner of Northway Drive and
Xerxes who appeared to be walking through the field.
I turned eastbound and Officer Peterson advised he would be out with the two females. Upon my arrival, Officer
Peterson was ordering the girls to stop and they were walking in the opposite direction of him. I pasitioned my
squad in front of the girls and Officer Peterson ordered the girls again to stop and for the one girl to get off her
phone.
Neither of the females acknowledged Officer Peterson nor attempted to stop their movement. Officer Peterson
attempted to grab one of the girls by the arm. The female stated, "Fuck you. I know my rights." and grabbed her
friend by the neck and attempted to flee. In the process she ended up taking Officer Peterson and the other
female to the ground with her and I assisted Officer Peterson in an attempt to detain the female.
Her right arm was wrapped tightly around the other female's neck and I was unable to unlodge it. I brought the
arm up for Officer Peterson to handcuff at which time he secured the cuff and I attempted to pull the other female
out from under her. The other female then ran toward Officer Peterson who was still struggling on the ground with
the other female. I took her down to the ground using the Arm Bar technique and ordered her to place her hands
behind her back and she complied. I handcuffed her and Officers Mike Coleman and Toohey assisted in
transporting the females to our squads.
I Pat Searched one female and placed her in the rear of marked squad #322 at which time I properly identified her
as Tracy Denise Winters, 3/18/86. Winters was agitated and using vulgar language. She told me she had been
assaulted by the parties standing in front of the Center Pointe complex. She pointed in the general direction and
we escorted the two females by squad to where the repor�ing party was.
Officer Peterson spoke with the reporting party who stated Winters had assaulted her. I entered my squad to ask
Winters what happened and she stated she was just defending herself. There was a strong odor of alcohol
emanating from Winters' person as well as that of the reporting party and the female in Officer Peterson's squad.
Both Winters and the reporting party stated they did not wish to press charges and just wanted to go home. After
conversing with all parties, all females were released.
It should be noted Winters was released to her mother on scene, a sober responsible adult.
All parties claimed no injuries and refused medical attention.
No further
Leyk/km 4/19/07
i
Printed by: bc114to �nCldent Rep01� Page 6 of 6
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:09
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 It1Cld@Ilt NutllbeC: BCO7-002�084
Siqnatures
Reporting Officer Date
Supervisor Date
I�
c
Printed bc114to IIICICI@Clt R@pOCt Page 2 of 3
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:10
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-002106
Persons Involved
Person#: 0003 MNI: 3690220 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: VICTIM Contact DatelTime:
Name: GREEN, CHRISITA KAY
DOB: 02/23/1970 Age: 37 37 Sex: FEMALE Race: BLACK
Height: 5' 6" 5' 6" Weight: 180 180 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
Address: 2928 NORTHWAY DR 204 BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55429 Sector/Beat: 4/BC04
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 205-5368 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/SchooL•
Propertv Involved
Propertv 0001 Evidence: No
Event AssoGOrig status: STOLEN WITHIN JURISC Original Status Date: 04/17/2007 13:22:00 Original Value: $0.00
Current Status: STOLEN WITHIN JURISDICTION Current Status Date: 04/17/2007 13:22:00 Current Value: $0.00
Property Type: COMPUTER LAPTOP
Description: LAPTOP COMPUTER
MakeBrand: APPLE NOTEBOOK ModeL•
Color: BLRCK Quantity: 1
Serial/Lot#: Owner Applied#:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Cancelied.
Narratives
Entered Date/Time: 04/19/2007 13:20 Narrative Type: SYNOPSIS
Subject: SYNOPSIS Author: KNIGHT, MELONEY
I, Officer Knight, was called to 2928 Northway Drive, #204, on a burglary.
Printed by: bc114to IIICICI@Ilt R@pOrt Page 3 of 3
Printed dateltime: 5!9/07 14:10
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number BC07 -002106
Entered Date/Time: 04/19/2007 13:21 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author: KNIGHT, MELONEY
On 04/17/07 at 1322 hours, I, Officer Knight, was called to 2928 Northway Drive, #2fl4, on the report of a burglary.
Upon my arrival, I met the complainant, Kenisha Diane GREEN, DOB: 09/30/1985. Green stated that her and her
mother left the apartment at 1130 hours and everything was fine. Upon returning at 1322 hours, they realized that
the laptop was missing from Green's mother's bedroom. Green stated that she got the laptop as a gift. She
stated it was an Apple notebook, black in color. She does not have a serial number and she does not know how
much it costs and stated that the charger is white and that is also missing with it. Green stated that she believes
her baby's father is responsible for this because he has always wanted a laptop he stated to help him look for a
job. Green stated her child's father is Thomas Fritzgerald WESTBROOK, JR., DOB: 05/26/1986. Green stated
she does not know where Westbrook lives, he only comes by once in a while, but she does have a cell phone
number for him of 763-843-4872. Green's mother is Christia Kay GREEN, DOB: 02/23I1970. Christia Green
stated that Westbrook did call her cell phone at approximately 1235 hours to ask where they were and Christia
and Kenisha Green feel that he did that to see if they were home. They stated they locked the apartment door
however they never locked the balcony door and they believe he jumped up on the balcony and entered through
the balcony door since they left that unlocked. There is no sign of forced entry on the apartment.
Kenisha Green stated that a male friend of theirs saw Westbrook on the property and that is why they feel that he
is the one who stole the laptop.
I did call Westbrook's cell phone. He stated he was on property and he did talk to a male in the courtyard area
and that is because he asked if he knew where Christia or Kenisha were so he could play with his son that they
have together. Westbrook stated that Kenisha does not even own a laptop, that she's lying about the whole thing,
and he said that we could come and search his stuff, that he does not have a Iaptop.
At this time it is unknown exactly who may have taken the laptop if there is a laptop missing.
ITEMIZED LIST OF LOSS:
1 possible Apple laptop notebook, black in color w/white charger unknown amount
Knight/vc
Siqnatures
Reporting Officer Date
Supervisor Date
i
I
I�
inted b: bc114to Page 1 of 4
Pr y
Printed date/time: 5!9/07 14:13 Incident Report
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
ROOKLYN CENTER, MiNNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 InCident NUmbeC: BC07-002345
incident Summarv
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S} Report Type: FRAUD
Inc Occurred Address: 2920 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55430 Sector/Beat: 4/BC04
Inc Occurred Start: 04/21/2007 12:00 Inc Occurred End: 04l21/2007 23:59 Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported Date/Time: 04/28/2007 16:44
Reporting Officer: TOOHEY, PATRICK Primary Assigned Officer:
Case Status: INACTIVE Disposition: INACTIVE/OPEN Disposition Date: 05/07/2007 10:12
Offenses
Statute Code: 609-52 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: FRAUD-ALL OTHER
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: FELONY
Statute Code: 609-52-3-5 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: THEFT-FROM VEHICLE-VALUE LESS THAN $250
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: MISDEMEANOR
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3222 143 TOOHEY, PATRICK
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 19164372 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: VICTIM Contact Date/Time: 04/28/2007 16:44
Name: TAYLOR, ANTOWE JAVON
DOB: 12h0/1984 Age: 22 22 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
Height: Weight: Eye Color: Hair Color:
Address: 2920 NORTHWAY DR 304 BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 Sector/B�eat: 4/BC04
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: (763) 561-2421 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/School:
Vehicles Involved
Vehicie#: 0001
Event Assoc: VICTIM Vehicle Status:
Vehicle Type: A Year: 1997 Make: FORD Model: TAURUS
VIN: License#: PTZ306 State: MN Expires On:
Style: 4-DOOR Prim Color: BLUE Sec Color: Ter Color.
Status Dt/Tm: Status Value: Recovered Date: Recovered Value:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Cancelled:
Printed by: bC114to II�ICICI@Ilt R@pOrt Page 2 of 4
Printed dateltime: 5/9/07 14:13
BROOKLYN CENTER POUCE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 IllCld@Ilt NUt11beC: BC07-002345 i
Businesses Involved
Business 0001
Event Association:
Business Name: CENTER POINTE APARTMEN7S Business Type: APARTMENTS
Address: 2920 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 SectorlBeat: 4BC04
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Propertv Involved
Propertv 0001 Evidence: No
Event AssoGOrig status: STOLEN WITHIN JURISC Original Status Date: 04/28/2007 16:44:00 Original Value: $0.00
Gurrent Status: STOLEN WITHIN JURISDICTION Current Status Date: 04/28/2007 16:44:00 Current Value: $0.00
Property Type: CREDIT/ATM/BANK CARD
Description: BOSTON SCIENTIFIC CREDIT CARD
MakelBrand: ModeL•
Color: Quantity: 1
Seriai/Lot#: Owner Applied#:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Cancelled:
Printed by: bc114to ICICIC,@Ilt R@pOl� Page 3 of 4
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:13
BROOKLYN CENTER POUCE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-002345
Crime Scene
Investigator: Investigation Results:
Photography
Black White Negatives Exposed: N
Color Negatives Exposed: N
Photography/Other.
Fingerprints
Latent Print Processing Conducted: N
Latent Fingerprints Lifted: N
Latent Palmprints Lifted: N
Latent Fingerprint Results:
Latent Palmprint Results
Latent Prints/Other:
Weapon/Projectiles
Projectiles Recovered: N
Casings Recovered: N
Cartridges Recovered: N
Weapons Recovered: N
Weapons/Other.
Impressions
Footware Impressions: N
FootwarelTire Casting: N
FootwarelTire Photographed: N
Tire Impressions: N
Original FootwarelTire Surface Recovered: N
Footwear/Tire Impressions/Other:
Body Fluids
Blood-like Substances Recovered: N
Body Fluid Controls: N
Body Fiuids/Other:
Tootmarks
Original Toolmark Surface Recovered: N
Tools Recovered: N
Tooimark Casting: N
Toolmarks/Other:
Refer to Property Report: N
Crime Scene Description:
Printed by: b�„a►o Incident Report Page 4 of 4
Printed dateltime: 5/9/07 14:13
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(�s3) sss-ss3s Incident Number: BC07-002345
Narratives
Entered DateITime: 05/07/2007 10:17 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author: TOOHEY, PATRICK
On 4/28/07 at approximately 1713 hours, I, Officer Toohey, was dispatched to the lobby of the Brooklyn Center
Police Department on a report of a theft. Upon arrival, I met with Taylor who stated he had his credit card stolen
and someone had used his account. Taylor stated on 4/21/07 he had gotten the mail at his apartment complex,
2920 Northway Dr and had seen his credit union, Boston Scientific, had sent him a new credit card which he
stated he did not need. Taylor stated he left it in the car under the center arm rest and went out to run errands.
Taylor stated he went to locations in Brooklyn Center along with North Minneapolis. Taylor stated at
approximately midnight he went to check the balance on his account after returning home and found that he was
negative $400, which he stated was an error. Taylor stated when he called the credit union he was told there had
been three transactions made at ATM's, involving his Credit/Debit card. Taylor stated he had his card still but then
remembered about the new card and when he checked the vehicle the card was gone. Taylor had no further
m tion about the transactions other than there were two in the amount of $200 and one for $100. I did ask
infor a
how they got his PIN number and he stated they must have mailed it with the card. I instructed Taylor to try to get
more information regarding the transactions. 'I
I have no further information at this time and am considering this case closed as inactive.
Siqnatures
Reporting O�cer Date
Supervisor Date
Printed by: bc114to �nCldent RepOrt Page 1 of 2
Printed dateltime: 5/9/07 14:14
BROOKLYN CENTER POL{CE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 (11CId@i1t NUfYtbeP: BC07-002469
Incident Summarv
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: AUTO THEFT
Inc Occurred Address: 2834 NORT4iWAY DR LOT LOT BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55429 Sector/Beat: 4iBC04
Inc Occurred Start: 05/01/2007 00:00 Inc Occurred End: Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported DatelTime: 05/03/2007 19:40
Reporting Officer: DESTICHE, JAMES Primary Assigned Officer:
Case Status: ACTIVE Disposition: PENDING/OPEN Disposition Date: 05/04/2007 15:01
Offenses
Statute Code: 609-52-2-1 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: THEFT-VEH MOTOR VEHICLE
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: FELONY
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
pRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3224 115 DESTICHE, JAMES
List of Attachments
Type: Report ID: Report Date: Report Summary:
OTHER LAW ENFORCEMENT AGENCY REF Auto Theft Report
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 19163949 Can 1D Suspect: No
Event Association: REGISTERED OWNER Contact DateRime: 05/03/2007 19:40
Name: FISCHER, KENNETH WAYNE
DOB: �2/15/1978 Age: 29 29 Sex: Race:
Height: Weight: Eye Color: Hair Color:
Address: 223 CO RD 5 ISANTI, MINNESOTA 55040 Sector/Beat:
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 291-2617 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: Emptoyer/SchooL•
Vehicles Involved
Vehicle#: 0001
Event Assoc: STOLEN WITHIN JURISDICTION Vehicle Status: STOLEN WITHIN JURISDICTION
Vehicle Type: A Year: 1997 Make: MAZDA Model: 626
VIN: 1YVGE22C4V5620793 License#: MAK426 State: MN Expires On:
Styie: 4-DOOR Prim Color: BLACK Sec Color: Ter Cofor.
Status DtlTm: 05/03/2Q07 19:40 Status Value: $6,290.18 Recovered Date: Recovered Value:
NCIC Date: 05/03/2007 20:19 NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: V540596164 NCIC Cancelled:
Registered Owner Name: FISCHER, KENNETH WAYNE
Address:223 CO RD 5 ISANTI, MN 55040 Phone#: (763) 291-2617
Printed by: bc114to Incident Report Pa 2°f 2
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:14
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
200KLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
�/63) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-002469
Businesses Involved
Business 0001
Event Association: LOCATION
Business Name: CENTER POINTE APARTMENTS Business Type: APARTMENTS
Address: 2834 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55429 Sector/Beat: 4BC04 I
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2 'I
Narratives
Entered Date/Time: 05/04/2007 15:05 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author: DESTICHE, JAMES
Girifriend tives at Center Pointe. Someone stole keys while hanging out in her apartment. She did not report theft
of keys.
Sianatures
Re ortin O�cer Date
P 9
Supervisor Date
I
I
t
Printed by: bc114to Page 1 of 2
Incident Report
Printed date/time: 5/9lO7 13:58
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 incident Number: BC07-001534
Incident Summary
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: WARRANT
42 SectorBeat: 4/BC04
Inc Occurred Address: 2916 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55 9
Re ort Taken:
Inc Occurred Start: 03/24/2007 17:55 inc Occurred En
d: P
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported DatelTime: 03/24/2007 17:55
Reporting Officer: GABLER, RICHARD Primary Assigned Officer:
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: REFERRED TO OTHER AGENCY Disposition Date: 03/24/2007 22:18
Offenses
Statute Code: MISWA Enhancers:
Statute Desc: MISC OFCR WARRANT ARREST
Counts: 1 Statute Severity:
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3228 147 GABLER, RICHARD
Persons involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 167058 Can ID Suspect: No
03/23/2007 17:55
Event Association: WARRANT ARREST Contact Date/T�me•
Name: JOHNSON, ROGER ALLEN
DOB: 01/17l1970 Age: 37 37 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK
Height: 5' 9" 5' 9" Weight: 202 202 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
Address: 657 MARSHALL ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55104 Sector/Beat:
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (000) 000-0000 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: WORK Phone# 2: (000) 000-0000 Ext 2:
Occupation: Empioyer/Schooi:
Person Offenses
Statute Code: MISWA Enhancers:
Statute Desc: MISC OFCR WARRANT ARREST
Counts: 1
Narratives
Entered DateITime: 03/24/2007 22:25 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Author: GABLER, RICHARD
Subject. MAIN REPORT
On 03/07/07, at 1800 hours, I, Deputy Matt HAGEN, along with O�cer Gabler, observed six males sitting outside
2916 Northway Drive consuming alcohol on the concrete steps.
Officer Gabler and I made contact with the males who did not live at the complex. WE ran all males through
dispatch and Johnson came back with a 100% score on a felony warrant out of Dakota County. The warrant was
confirmed and Johnson was transported to the Hennepin County jail.
pr 03/24I07
Page 2 of 2
Printed by: bc114to Incident Report
Printed dateltime: 5/9/07 13:58
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(�s3} sss-s3ss Incident Number: BC07-001534
i Siqnatures
Reporting Officer Oate
Supervisor Date
I
i
Printed by: bc114to IIICICI@Ilt R@pOrt Page 1 of 5
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:13
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
ROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07 -002329
Incident Summarv
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: DWI
Inc Occurred Address: NORTHWAY DR&XERXES AV N BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55429 Sector/Beat: 4/04
Inc Occurred Start: 04/27/2007 22:20 Inc Occurred End: Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: Y
Contact Nature: Reported DatelTime: 04/27/2007 23:20
Reporting Officer: NADEAU, SCOTT Primary Assigned Officer:
Case Status: PENDING FORMAL Disposition: PENDING/OPEN Disposition Date: 04/28/2007 08:27
Offenses
Statute Code: 169A-20-1-1 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: TRAF-DUI 3RD DEGREE
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: GROSS MISDEMEANOR
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3203 011 NADEAU, SCOTT
BACK-UP 3207 117 REYNOLDS, MIKE
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNi: 19002308 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: SUSPECT Contact Date/Time: 04/27/2007 23:30
Name: AGBOGA, HENRY ISIMEME
DOB: 03/23/1954 Age: 53 53 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
Height: 6' 1" 6' 1" Weight: 166 166 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
Address: 2826 NORTHWAY DR 204 BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55429 Sector/Beat: 4/BC04
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 561-2487 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: CELL Phone# 2: (612) 327-7765 Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/SchooL•
Person Offenses
Statute Code: 169A-20-1-1 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: TRAF-DUI 3RD DEGREE
Counts: 1
Vehicies involved
Vehicle#: 0001
Event Assoc: IMPOUNDED Vehicle Status:
Vehicle Type: A Year: 1994 Make: JEEP Model: CHEROKEE
VIN: 1J4FT27S1RL160883 License#: PWM329 State: MN Expires On:
Prim Color: RED Sec Color: Ter Color:
Style: SUV Recovered Value:
Status Dt/Tm: Status Value: Recovered Date:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Cancelled:
Registered Owner Name: AGBOGA, HENRY ISIMEME
Address:2826 NORTHWAY DR 204 BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55429 Phone#: (763) 561-2487
Page 2 of 5
Printed by: bc114to Incident Report
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:13
BROOKLYN CENTER POUCE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 ItlCidetlt NU171beP: BC07=002329
(763) 569-3333
Narratives
Entered DatelTime: 04/28/2007 08:28 Narrative Type: SYNOPSIS
Subject: SYNOPSIS Author: NADEAU, SCOTT
hours I Lieutenant Scott Nadeau, observed a vehicle driving erratically. The
On 04 27 07 at approximately 2220
vehicle was stopped and one adult male was arrested for 3rd degree DUI.
i
Printed by: bc114to �i'1CIC,@Ilt Rep01� Page 3 of 5
Printed dateltime: 5/9/07 14:13
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 InCldent NUmber: BC07-002329
Entered Date/Time: 04/28/2007 08:28 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author: NADEAU, SCOTT
On 04-27-07 at approximately 2220 hours, I, Lieutenant Scott Nadeau, along with Sergeant Michael Reynolds
were on a proactive detail in the area of Center Pointe Apartments driving unmarked gray Ford Taurus squad
#300. O�cers were in the area because of continuing criminal activity and were performing plain clothes
proactive patroL
At that date and time I noted the suspect vehicle in this case, a red 1994 Jeep Cherokee two-door, bearing
Minnesota license PWM-329, as this vehicle backed out of a parking spot near the apartment building at 2826
Northway Drive. My attention was first called to this vehicle as I was in the same parking lot and I noticed that the
vehicle's operator after starting the vehicle grinded the gears in what was apparently a manual transmission upon
attempting to back the vehicle up. Nadeau saw that the vehicle lurched backwards and then proceeded to move
forward where it traveled for approximately ten yards and I saw that the vehicle was jerking forward and eventually
the engine died. Nadeau saw that the operator restarted the engine and continued out of the parking lot onto
Northway Drive where he then made a right hand turn without signaling onto Northway Drive out of the parking lot.
I noted that as the vehicle left the parking lot making its right turn onto Northway Drive the vehicle drove over the
curb on the right side so that both of the passenger side tires went up over the curb in what was obviously a
misjudged turn by the vehicle's operator. Having these observations, I followed the vehicle onto Northway Drive
and made a traffic stop on the vehicle in the 2900 block of Northway Drive.
After affecting my emergency lights and stopping the vehicle, I approached the vehicle and met with the driver of
the vehicle who was also the�sole occupant of the Jeep. After identifying myself as a police officer and informing
the driver of the reason for the traffic stop, I requested to see a driver's license and proof of insurance. As I spoke
with the driver he did give me a Minnesota driver's license which identified him as the defendant with an address
of 5100 Howe Lane in Brooklyn Center, 55429. In speaking with the driver, who was identified as Henry
AGBOGA, I detected a strong odor of alcoholic beverage on his breath. I asked Mr. Agboga if he had been
drinking and he initially stated that he had not. I then told him that I smelled the odor of an alcoholic beverage on
his breath and I also noted that his eyes were watery and bloodshot. At that time Agboga stated to Nadeau that he
had made a mistake in driving as he had one shot of Brandy prior to dri�ring. He told me that he would not have
been driving except that his wife had called and ask that he come pick her up from work. I asked Mr. Agboga if he
had any prior DWIs and he stated that he had had a DWI in 1997 or 1998 in the state of Kansas. I asked Mr.
Agboga to step out of his vehicle and perform some Field Sobriety Tests which he did agree to do.
The first test which I asked Mr. Agboga to perform was the Finger to Nose Test and in this test I asked him to
stand with his feet together and while extending his arms at his sides and tilting his head back with his eyes closed
to touch the tip of his left index finger to the tip of his nose. I demonstrate to Mr. Agboga how this test was to be
done and when he closed his eyes and tilted his head back I saw that he began to sway quite a bit. In attempting
the test with his left index finger Mr. Agboga did touch the tip of his nose. In attempting to perform the same test
with his right index �nger, Mr. Agboga touched his upper lip on the right hand side.
The next test I asked Mr. Agboga to do was the One Legged Stand Test and in this test he was asked to keep his
arms down at his sides and while lifting one foot approximately three inches off of the ground count slowly
backwards from 100. Mr. Agboga first tried to perform the test with his left foot raised and in doing so, got from
the number 100 to the number 94. I would point out that during the test Mr. Agboga was having a great deal of
difficulty in maintaining his balance and he was swaying quite a bit. In attempting to do the test with his right foot
raised, Mr. Agboga started at 100 and then counted 99, 98, 96, 97, 98 before putting his foot back down. Again
Mr. Agboga demonstrated poor balance on this test as well as getting the numbers out of sequence.
The next test which I asked Mr. Agboga to perform was the Heel to Toe Walk and Turn Test and I demonstrated
this test for Mr. Agboga explaining to him that I wanted him to take ten steps in an imaginary straight ►ine heel to
toe and then turn and take ten steps back in the direction in which he had come. Mr. Agboga was able to walk
heel to toe but when he went to turn and take the ten steps back I noted that he did stumble and had to catch his
balance at one point looking like he was going to falL
Printed by: bc114to �nCldent Rep�rt Page 4 of 5
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:13
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-002329
I would point out that dunng the entire Field Sobnety Tests, 5ergeant Reynoids was present and dunng tne Field
Sobriety Tests, Hennepin County Sherriff's Deputy Gottwaldt, badge #384, did arrive and also witnessed the Heel
to Toe Walk and Turn Test.
I then requested Deputy Gottwaldt to give Agboga a PBT and Gottwaldt did retrieve a PBT from his car which I
noted was serial #0394271. Gottwaldt did administer the Preliminary Breath Test to Agboga and Gottwaldt
N deau the re
sults of the PBT Test and it was a 0.127 blood alcohol concentration.
wed a
sho
n of the drivin behavior and fai�ure of the Field Sobriety Tests as well as the PBT
N tl0 S
Based on my obse a 9
I. At that time 1 did handcuff him
results, I informed Agboga that he was going to be placed under arrest for DU
making sure to double-lock the handcuffs. Agboga was then searched and transported to the Brooklyn Center
Police Department by Deputy Gottwaldt.
I met Deputy Gottwaldt at the police department and Agboga's mouth was checked and it was found that he did
not have any objects in his mouth while at the police department. It should also be pointed out that Agboga's
mouth was checked in the field prior to the PBT Test.
The State of Minnesota Implied Consent Advisory was read to Agboga by Deputy Gottwaldt with this advisory
being started at 2238 hours and being completed at 2252 hours. During the Implied Consent Advisory Agboga
stated that he did understand the Implied Consent Advisory and that he did wish to speak with an attomey. A
ived a ho
ne cal
I
telephone was made available to him at 2240 hours and at approximately 2248 hours he rece p
from an attorney and then spoke to that attorney for a couple of minutes. After he had completed the phone call, I
heard Deputy Gottwaldt ask Agboga if he had spoken to an attorney and Agboga stated that he had. Depury
Gottwaldt asked him if he wished to speak to any other attorneys and he stated that he did not. Deputy Gottwaldt
then asked Agboga if he would take a breath test to which he answered, "Yes sir." It should be pointed out that
the entire Implied Consent Advisory was audio taped and that audio tape is being retained as evidence in this
case.
Deputy Gottwaldt did administer the Intoxilyzer 5000 Test which was begun at 2255 hours and completed at 2305
hours. The reported value was a 0.14 blood alcohol concentration which was in excess of the 0.08 limit and the
results of the test were explained to Agboga who stated that he understood.
In checking Agboga's criminal history I did find that he did have a previous DUI arrest with that arrest being on
11-05-1997 by the Kansas State Highway Patrol. While the criminal history did not show whether or not there was
a conviction Agboga stated to me that he had been convicted of that offense and that he had given a sample
which was over the legal limit at that time.
Due to the fact that there was an aggregating factor with the prior DWI, Agboga was booked with 3rd degree DWf
in this case.
Agboga's vehicle was impounded and he was given a Notice and Order of License Plate Impoundment in
reference to the license plates being removed from his vehicle. This form was explained to Agboga by Deputy
Gottwaldt and Agboga stated that they he understood. Agboga was also issued a Notice and Order of Revocation
for his driver's license in reference to the DUI charge and he did sing that form indicating that he had received the
form and understood the license revocation.
At approximately 2305 hours, I read Agboga his rights per Miranda off of the Brooklyn Center Police Department
Alcohol Influence Report and after the Miranda Advisory, Agboga clearly stated that he understood his rights and
did not wish to have a lawyer present during the questioning. Agboga then answered a series of questions off of
the Alcohol Influence Report and I would refer the reader of this report to that form for the questions which were
asked and the responses which were given. A summary of the responses given by Agboga were that he had
been drinking brandy although he had only had one drink prior to driving. He stated that he did not feel at the time
#hat he was driving that he was impaired but that he felt it now. He stated that he knew why he was stopped as hi�
car had died in the parking �ot and because of hitting the curb. The Miranda Advisory and subsequent questioning
was also audio taped and that audio tape is being preserved as evidence in this case.
Agboga was released pending Formal Complaint in reference to the DUI charges in this case and a copy of this
report should be forwarded to the Brooklyn Center City Attorney's Office for Formal Complamt charges against the
defendant.
Printed by: bc114to IIICICI@Ilt R@p01� Page 5 of 5
Printed dateltime: 5/9/07 14:13
BROOKLYN CENTER POUCE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07 -002329
Nadeau/re
04-28-07
Sipnatures
Reporting Officer Date
Supervisor Date
Printed by: bc114to IIICICI@Ilt R@pOrt Page 1 of 2
Printed dateltime: 5/9/07 13:54
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
Incident Number: BC07-001263
(T63) 569-3333
Incident Summary
F E
NSE S
Report Type: ARREST
Incident Type: CRIMINAL O F O
I 4/BC04
Inc Occurred Address: 2928 NORTHWAY DR LOT BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55430
SectorlBeat
Inc Occurred Start: 03/10/2007 20:10 Inc Occurred End: Report Taken:
N Bia� Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Domestic.
Reported Date/Time. 03/10/2007 20:10
Co
ntact N
ature.
Prima Ass
i ned Officer:
i RICHARD rY
9
ER
Reporting Officer. GABI
ion Date: 03/12/2007 11:24
Dis osit
T/FOR
MAL C
OMPLAINT p
Case Status. CLOSED D�sposit�on. ADULT ARRES
Offenses
Statute Code: 609-506-1 Enhancers
Statute Desc: GOV'T-FALSE NAME TO POLICE OFFICER-MISD
unts: 1 Statute Severit MISDEMEANOR
Co Y
I WA
Enhancers:
MS
Statute Code•
Statute Desc: MISC OFCR WARRANT ARREST
Counts: 1 Statute Seventy:
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3228 147 GABLER, RICHARD
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNIc 18510339
Can ID Suspect: No, I
Event Association: ARREST Contact Date/Time: 03/10/2007 20:10
Name: SAYONKON, JOHNSON SUPERBOY
DOB: 06/10/1983 Age: 23 23 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
Height: 5' 6" 5' 7" Weight: 150 162 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
Address: 3219 KNOX AV N MINNEAPOLIS, MINNESOTA 55412 SectorBeat:
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 205-9683 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: CELL Phone# 2: (612) 990-3472 Ext 2:
Occupation: EmployerlSchooL•
Person Offenses
Statute Code: 609-506-1 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: GOV'T-FALSE NAME TO POLICE OFFICER-MISD
Counts: 1
Statute Code: MISWA Enhancers:
Statute Desc: MISC OFCR WARRANT ARREST
Counts: 1
Narratives
Entered DatelTime: 03/12/2007 10:58 Narrative Type: SYNOPSIS
Subject: SYN
OPSIS Author. GABLER, RICHARD
On 03/10/07 at 20:10 hours, I, Gabler, assisted Hennepin County Sheriff s Deputies at 2928 Northway Dr. on a
subject stop. I arrested one adult male for Misdemeanor Faise information to Police Officer, a gross misdemeano�
warrant and two misdemeanor warrants.
Printed by: bc114to Page 2 of 2
Incident Report
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:54
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
ROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 It1Cid@Ilt NU1'Y1beY: BC07-001263
(763) 569-3333
Entered Date/Time: 03/12/2007 11:02 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author. GABLER, RICHARD
On 03/10/07 at 20:10 hours, I, Gabler, was advised by Hennepin County Sheriff s Deputies Hagen and Clark that
they were at the 2928 building and had made a subject stop and would like assistance. I then went over to the
2928 Northway Dr. building, where I spoke with the subject that they had detained. I spoke with Deputies Clark
and Hagen and they stated that they had approached the subject because he was hanging out in the haltways at
the 2928 Northway Dr. building and loitering, w hic h is agains t t h e C e n t r e P o i n t A p a r t m e n t c o m p l e x p o l i c y to just be
loitering. The male stated that he did not live in the complex. The male did not have identification with him,
however, gave the name of John Johnson, DOB 06/10/84, stating that he lived at 4319 Knox Ave. N. Subject
stated that he did have a identification card. Upon running that name, John Johnson, with that birth date of
06/10/84, I found the name to come back not on file. I advised this to the sUbject, that his name is not on file and
that he either did not have an identification card or he was giving me a false name. I patted down the male, found
nothing illegal on his person, and placed him in the back of a Braoklyn Center squad car.
After further speaking with the male, the male then gave me a name of Johnson Superboy SAYONKON, DOB
06/10/83. I noticed that the name given itself was very different than Sayonkon's real name, however, the date of
birth was 06/10/84 that was 06/10/83, making it just one year different. Upon checking the MN Drivers and
Vehicle Services website, I did observe that Johnson Superboy Sayonkon did have a MN driver's license. Upon
looking at the picture, I did see that the picture which popped up on the DVS website matched that of the subject
in the back of the car. Upon doing a warrant check on Johnson Superboy Sayonkon, I did find him to have a gross
misdemeanor warrant and two Hennepin County misdemeanor warrants. Those warrants were later confirmed.
ed a Henne in Count Release Receipt for Misdemeanor False Information to Police for the name that
I then issu p Y
was given to me by Sayonkon, which was not of another real person. I issued Sayonkon a•Division II Court date of
04/02/07 at the Division II Court House, 6125 Shingle Creek Pkwy. at 08:30 hours.
After explaining the Release Receipt to Sayonkon, he acknowledged it by signing it and was given a pink copy. I
then placed Sayonkon in handcuffs with his hands behind his back, gapping and double-locking the handcuffs.
Deputies Clark and Hagen then transported Sayonkon to the Hennepin County Adult Detention facility for his
warrants.
Gabler/ss
03/12/07
Sianatures
Reporting Officer Date
Date
Supervisor
Frinted by: bc114to Incident Report Page 1 of 2
Printed dateltime: 5/9/0713:55
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-001267
Incident Summarv
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: WARRANT
Inc Occurred Address: 2932 NORTHWAY DR LOT LOT BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55429 Sector/Beat: 4BC04
Inc Occurred Start: 02/10/2007 23:30 Inc Occurred End: 02/10l2007 23:30 Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported Date/Time: 02/10/2007 2330 I
Reporti�g O�cer: VALLEAU, CHARLES Primary Assigned Officer:
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: REFERRED TO OTHER AGENCY Disposition Date: 03/22l2007 08:48
Offenses
Statute Code: MISWA Enhancers: 'i
Statute Desc: MISC OFCR WARRANT ARREST
Counts 1 Statute Severity:
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3230 141 VALLEAU, CHARLES
Persons invoived
Person#: 0001 MNL 268549 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: WARRANT ARREST Contact Date/Time: 02/10/2007 23:30
Name: MCCLAIN, JEHOVAH JIRAH
DOB: 10/24/1983 Age: 23 23 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC•
Height: 5' 10" 5' 10" Weight: 165 1651bs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
Address 207 65 AV N 1 BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 SectorlBeat: 2/BCO2
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (612) 240-7737 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: Empioyer/SchooL•
Person Offenses
Statute Code: MISWA Enhancers:
Statute Desc: MISC OFCR WARRANT ARREST
Counts: 1
Vehicles Involved
Vehicle#: 0001
Event Assoc: SUSPECT Vehicle Status:
Vehicle Type: A Year: 2000 Make: OLDSMOBILE Model: INTRIGUE
VIN: License#: FJC688 State: MN Expires On:
Style: 2-DOOR Prim Golor: WHITE Sec Color. Ter Color:
Status DtlTm: Status Value: Recovered Date: Recovered Value:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Cancelled:
Registered Owner Name: MCCLAIN, JEHOVAH JIRAH
Address:207 65 AV N 1 BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55430 Phone#: (612) 240-7737
II!
f�rinted by: bc114to �nClC�ellt R@pOrt Page 2 of 2
Printed dateltime: 5/9l07 13:55
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-001267
Businesses Involved
Business 0001
Event Association:
Business Name: CENTER POINTE APARTMENTS Business Type: APARTMENTS
Address: 2932 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55429 Seator/Beat: 46C04
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Narratives
Entered DatetTime: 03i22/2007 09:03 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Sub'ect: MAIN REPORT Quthor: VALLEAU, CHARLES
J
On 03/10/07 at 2330 hours my attention was drawn to 3 males crouched down in a vehicle running outside 2832
Northway Drive. I ran the registration MN FJC688 and learned the registered owner had a warrant out for his
arrest. I walked up to the vehicle and took the driver Jehovah Jirah Mcclain 10/24/83 into custody. I confirmed his
warrant and transported him to county jail.
Sipnatures
Reporting Officer Oate
Supervisor Date
Pc�nted by: bc114to �nCldent RepOrt Page 1 of 2
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:55
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 I
(763) 569-3333 It1Cid@tlt NUI'Tibei': BC07-001328
Incident Summarv
incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: WARRANT
Inc Occurred Address: 2920 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55430 Sector/Beat: 4/BC04
Inc Occurred Start: Inc Occur�ed End: Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported DatefTime: 03/14/2007 01:45
Reporting Officer: GABLER, RICHARD Primary Assigned Officer:
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: REFERRED TO OTHER AGENCY Disposition Date: 03/30l2007 10:48
Offenses
Statute Code: MISWA Enhancers:
Statute Desc: MISC OFCR WARRANT ARREST
Counts: 1 Statute Severity:
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3228 147 GABLER, RICHARD
Persons involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 3937702 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: WARRANT ARREST Contact Date/Time: 03/14/2007 01:45
Name: MONTGOMERY, REGINALD DEROYCE
DOB: 07/09/1986 Age: 20 20 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC•
Height: 6' 0" 6' 0" Weight: 150 150 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BROWN
Address: 6133 79 BROOKLYN PARK, MINNESOTA 55443 SectorlBeat:
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 560-7338 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/Schoof:
Vehicles Involved
Vehicle#: 0001
Event Assoc: ARREST Vehicle Status:
Vehicle Type: A Year: Make: CHEVROLET Model: MALIHU
VIN: License#: TXU707 State: MN Expires On:
Style: Prim Color: WHITE Sec Color: Ter Color:
Status Dt/Tm: Status Value: Recovered Date: Recovered Value:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Cancelled:
I
I[�
Printed by: bc114to �nCIC�@Ilt RepOrt Page 2 of 2
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:55
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
763 569-3333 IllCldellt NUtllb@P: BC07 -001328
Narratives
Entered DatelTime: 03/30/2007 10:51 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author: GABLER, RICHARD
On 3/14/07 at 0145 hours, I, ofc Gabler, stopped a vehicle at 2920 for suspicious activity. Montgomery was a
passenger in the vehicle. Montgomery was found to have a confirmed hc Warrant. Montgomery was transported
to hc Jail.
Siqnatures
Reporting Officer Date
Supervisor Date
Printed by: bc114to �nCldent Rep01� Page 1 of 2
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:56
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 5693333 Incident Number BC07-001345
Incident Summarv
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: WARRANT
Inc Occurred Address: 2908 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55430 Sector/Beat: 416C04
Inc Occurred Start: Inc Occurred End: Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported Date/Time: 03/14/2007 22:40
Reporting Officer: GABLER, RICHARD Primary Assigned Officer:
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: REFERRED TO OTHER AGENCY Disposition Date: 03/30/2007 08:54
Offenses
Statute Code: MISWA Enhancers:
Statute Desc: MISC OFGR WARRANT ARREST
Counts: 1 Statute Severity:
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3228 147 GABLER, RICHARD
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 1369409 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: WARRANT ARREST Contact DatelTime: 03/14/2007 22:40
Name: SMITH, BRANDON LEON
I DOB: 03/16/1984 Age: 23 23 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC•
Height: 6' 1" 6' 1" Weight: 180 180 Ibs Eye Color: HAZEL Hair Color: BLACK
Address: 2908 NORTHWAY DR 303 BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 Sector/Beat: 4/BC04
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 503-5143 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: CELL Phone# 2: (612) 695-2844 Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/SchooL•
Person Offenses
Statute Code: MISWA Enhancers:
Statute Desc: MISC OFCR WARRANT ARREST
Counts: 1
Narratives
Entered DateiTime: 03/30/2007 08:56 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author. GABLER, RICHARD
On 3/14/07 at 2240 hours t Gabler stopped GET-118 in the parking lot of 2908 Northway Drive for suspicious
activity. Smith was the driver and was found to have a confirmed Division 2 hc Warrant. Smith was able to post
the $150.00 cash bail. Smith was given a Division 2 court date of 3/28/07 at the Div 2 courthouse. Smith signed
his Release Receipt and was given a copy. Smith was then released.
i�
Printed by: bc114to �nCldent RepOrt Page 2 of 2
Printed date/time: 5/9l07 13:56
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 InCldent NUmber: BC07-001345
Sianatures
Reporting Officer Date
Supervisor Date
i
Printed by: bc114to �nCIC�@Ilt R@pOrt Page 1 of 4
Printed dateltime: 5/9/07 13:58
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
,dROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 c
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BCO7-001520
Incident Summarv
Incident Type: ACCIDENT Report Type: ACCIDENT
Inc Occurred Address: 2900 NORTHWAY DR LOT LOT BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55429 Sector/Beat: 4/6C04
Inc Occurred Start: 03/22/2007 21:25 Inc Occurred End: 03/22/2007 21:25 Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported DatelTime: 03/22/2007 21:25 I
Reporting Officer: PEARSON, MONA Primary Assigned Officer:
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: ASSISTED/ADVISED Disposition Date: 03/23/2007 13:37
Offenses
Statute Code: ACPDPD Enhancers
Statute Desc: ACC-POLICE PROPERTY DAMAGE
Counts: 1 Statute Severity:
Officers I
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3209 029 PEARSON, MONA
List of Attachments
Type: Report ID: Report Date: Report Summary:
OTHER LAW ENFORCEMENT AGENCY REF State Accident Report
Persons Invoived I
Person#: 0001 MNI: 19151165 Can I� Suspect: No
Event Association: DRIVER Contact Date/Time: 03/22/2007 21:25
Name: NELSON, PATRICK IVAN
DOB: 10/13/1965 Age: 41 41 Sex: MALE Race:
Height: Weight: Eye Color: Hair Color:
Address: 325 MAIN ST ANOKA, MINNESOTA 55303 SectorlBeat:
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/Schoot: ANOKA
Person#: 0002 MNI: 3951292 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: DRIVER Contact DatelTime: 03/22/2007 21:25
Name: GRUENIG, TONY LEE
DOB: 07/21/1973 Age: 33 33 Sex: MALE Race: WHITE
Height: Weight: Eye Color: Hair Color:
Address: 6645 HUMBOLDT AV N BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 SectorlBeat: 2BCO2
Phone Type L• Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: WORK Phone# 2: (763) 569-3333 Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/School: BCPD
Printed by: bc114to IIICIC�@Ilt RepOrt Page 2 of 4
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:58
BROOKLYN CENTER POUCE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-001520
Vehicles Involved
Vehicle#: 0001
Event Assoc: ACCIDENT Vehicie Status:
Vehicle Type: A Year: Make: FORD Model: EXPEDITION
VIN: License#: UNP689 State: MN Expires On:
Style: SUV Prim Color. BLACK Sec Color: Ter Color:
Status Dt/Tm: Status Value: Recovered Date: Recovered Value:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Cancelled:
Vehicle#: 0002
Event Assoc: ACCIDENT Vehicle Status
Vehicle Type: A Year: 2005 Make: GENERAL MOTORS CORP Modei: SIERRA
VIN: License#: UNP568 State: MN Expires On:
Style: PICKUP Prim Color: BLUE Sec Color: Ter Color:
Status DtJTm: Status Value: Recovered Date: Recovered Value:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Cancelled:
Narratives
Entered Date/Time: 03/23/2007 13:29 Narrative Type: NOTE
Subject: NOTE Author: PEARSON, MONA
See State Accident Report
Entered DatelTime: 03/23/2007 15:28 Narrative Type: SYNOPSIS
Subject: SYNOPSIS Author: GRUENIG, TONY
This case involves my unmarked police vehicle being struck by another unmarked police vehicle.
i
Printed by: bc114to IIICICI@flt R@pOl"t Page 3 of 4
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:58
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 i
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-001520
Entered DatelTime: 03/23/2007 15:29 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author: GRUENIG, TONY
On 3/22/07 I, Officer Gruenig, was working in a plain-clothes, unmarked capacity in my unmarked 2005 GMC
Sierra pickup, license plate UNP568. In this capacity I was trying to apprehend a suspect wanted for the sale of
cocaine.
While doing so I was traveling eastbound on Northway Drive in the eastbound lane. I was approaching the 2900
block almost directly out in front of the 2900 building of Northway Drive. As I was doing so, Detective Pat Nelson
in his unmarked police vehicle, that being a 2002 Ford Expedition, UNP689, was traveling in reverse eastbound in
the westbound lane. As I met and went past Detective Nelson, he backed his vehicle up into the eastbound lane,
striking my vehicle in the right driver's side quarter panel directly above the rear driver's side tire. It caused a white
mark on my quarter panel and a very small dent.
I was actively trying to pursue a suspect who was fleeing on foot from us at the time, and therefore did not stop. I
was not injured in any way. I assisted and completed the task of apprehending the suspect, taking him into
custody. Detective Nelson and I then checked our vehicles for the extent of the damage.
I then contacted sergeant Pearson immediately after the suspect was taken into custody and the extent of the
damage was revealed to me. I advised her of the situation and gave her the necessary information. I also took
photographs of my vehicle, as well as Detective Pat Nelson's vehicle. Neither of us was injured in any way. This
is all the information I have at this time.
Gruenig/bg
03/23/07
Printed by: bc114to ICICIC�@Ilt R@pOrt Page 4 of 4
Printed date/time: 5/9l07 13:58
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07 -001520
Entered Date/Time: 03/23/2007 15:30 Narrative Type: SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT
Subject: SUPP1 MP 03/23/07 0045 Author. PEARSON, MONA
On 03-22-07, I was notified by DTF Officer Gruenig that he as well as other DTF Officers had been in the area of
the 2900 building of Northway Drive in Brooklyn Center, MN in reference to a controlled substance buy. Officer
Gruenig stated that during the incident the suspect ran through the apartment complex and that he and other DTF
Officers were attempting to catch him. Officer Gruenig stated that he was traveling eastbound on Northway Drive
in front of the 2900 building towards the fleeing suspect. He stated that DTF Officer Patrick Nelson who was
driving UNP-689 had his vehicle facing westbound on No�thway Drive in front of the 2900 Northway Drive building.
Officer Nelson put his car in reverse to head eastbound also towards the fleeing suspect at which time his vehicle
and Officer Gruenig's vehicle collided. Officer Gruenig described the damage as very minimal and consisting of
damage to his GMC Sierra, license plate UNP-568, located in the rear portion consisting of several scrapes. He
further described the damage to the Ford Expedition, license UNP-689, as a broken taillight in the rear left quarter
panel.
I learned that DTF Officers were busy at the time as well as myself at the original time of the accident. I did speak
with Officer Gruenig via telephone regarding the accident to get the information. Officer Gruenig stated that he
would be able to take photographs of both of vehicles as well as complete an ICR report. I did complete a State
Accident Reporf as well as faxed the information over to the Brooklyn Center Finance Department. See Officer
Gruenig's report for further information.
Pearson/re
03-23-07
Sictnatures
Reporting Officer Date
Supervisor Date
I
i
Printed by: bc114to IIICICI@Ilt R@p01"t Page 1 of 5
Printed date/time: 5/9l07 14:00
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333
Incident Number: BC07-001643
Incident Summarv
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: INCIDENT
Inc Occu�red Address: 2920 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55430 Sector/Beat: 4/BC04
Inc Occurred Start: 03/27/2007 20:30 Inc Occurred End: Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported Date/Tlme: 03/27/2007 20:30
Reporting Officer: GABLER, RICHARD Primary Assigned Officer:
Case Status: ACTIVE Disposition: PENDING/OPEN Disposition Date: 03/28/2007 0839
Offenses
Statute Code: MISIMP Enhancers:
Statute Desc: MISC OFCR VEHICLE IMPOUND
Counts: 1 Statute Severity:
Statute Code: MISWA Enhancers:
Statute Desc: MISC OFCR WARRAN7 ARREST
Counts: 1 Statute Severity:
Statute Code: 152-092 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: CONT SUBST-POSS-DRUG PARAPHERNALIA
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: PETTY MISDEMEANOR
Statute Code: 171-24-3 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: TRAF-DRIVING AFTER CANCELLATION
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: MISDEMEANOR
Statute Code: 609-487-6 Enhancers
Statute Desc: FLEEING POLICE OFFICER NOT IN VEHICLE
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: MISDEMEANOR
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3228 147 GABLER, RICHARD
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNL• 859158 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: SUSPECT Contact Date/Time: 03/27/2007 20:00
Name: AULTMAN, BRIAN LEE
DOB: 07/15/1959 Age: 47 47 Sex: MALE Race: WHITE
Height: 5' 7" 5' 7" Weight: 135 1351bs Eye Color: BLUE Hair Color: BROWN
Address: 21 DEAN AV N CHAMPLIN, MINNESOTA 55316 SectoNBeat:
Phone Type 1: CELL Phone# 1: (612) 865-0943 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/School:
i�
Printed by: bc114to ��'1CIC�@Ilt R@pOrt Page 2 of 5
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:00
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 lncident Number: BC07-001643
Vehicles Involved
Vehicle#: 0001
Event Assoc: TOWED Vehicie Status
Vehicle Type: A Year: 1994 Make: GEO Model: PRIZM
VIN: 7Y1SK5363RZ104664 License#: HCZ102 State: MN Expires On:
Style: 4-DOOR Prim Color. GREEN Sec Color: Ter Color:
Status DtlTm: Status Value: Recovered Date: Recovered Value:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Cancelled:
Registered Owner Name: AULTMAN, KELLY R
Address: 2920 NORTHWAY DR #103 BC, MN Phone#:
Narratives
Entered Date/Time: 03/28/2007 14:47 Narrative Type: SYNOPSIS
Subject: SYNOPSIS Author: GABLER, RICHARD
On 3/27/07 at 2000 hours, I, O�cer Gabler, attempted to stop an adult male on foot at 2920 Northway Drive. I
arrested one adult male for Felony Warrants, Flee Police on Foot, DAC-IPS, and Possess Drug Paraphernalia.
s
Printed by: bc114to �nCldent Rep01� Page 3 of 5
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:00
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 l;
(�s3) sss-3sss Incident Number: BC07-001643
Entered DatelTime: 03/28/2007 14:48 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author: GABLER, R�CHARD
On 3/27/07 at 2000 hours, 1, O�cer Gabler, was in the Napa and Piva Hut parking lot across the street fcom the
Csnter Pointe apartment complex working a Plain Clothes Violent Offender Detail in an unmarked Brooklyn
Center Police Department mini van. I was conducting surveillance on the 2920 building because there is heavy
suspected narcotics activity coming to and from that building.
I observed a dark colored 4-door vehicle pull into the parking lot of 2920 at a high rate of speed, stop abruptly, and
then corner back into a parking space in that lot with the front of the car facing out toward the lot.
I observed a white male in blue jeans and flannel shirt exit the vehicle alone and walk into the lobby of the 2920
building without using a key, entering through the unsecured door. There were two African Americans standing
inside the building, one male and the other unknown.
The white male stood in the lobby for approximately 5-7 minutes and talk to the two African Americans in the
lobby. I maintained a constant visual on the white male who did not go up or downstairs and stood talking to the 2
African Americans in the lobby. I observed him through binoculars as he conversed for awhile before I advised
Hennepin County Sheriff s Deputies Clark and Hagan, who were in patrol uniforms and driving a marked Hennepin
County squad car, that I was going to go around the north side of the 2920 building and come in through the north
door and advised them that, when I tell them to, approach through the south door of the 2920 building.
I entered the 2920 building from the north and advised by Nextel that I was in position on the north side of the door•
at which time they immediately approached from the south side of the 2920 building parking lot. As soon as I
entered the lobby area 1 observed the 2 African Americans were gone. I observed the white male whom I had
seen pull into the parking lot was walking very slowly westbound from the 2920 building and past the car he had
driven into the lot. I advised Deputies Clark and Hagan to stop the male because I was suspicious of his behavior
and activities.
Deputy Clark ordered the male to stop and come back. I observed the suspect look back several times and then
pick up speed to a slight jog. Deputy Clark again told the male to stop and turn around and come back toward
Officers. The male then began running, cut across Northway Drive and was now m the Napa and Pizza Hut
parking lot with Deputy Clark still chasing. i then gave pursuit on foot as well, chasing after the suspect who J
tripped on the curb, rolled onto Xerxes, got up, continued running, and was finally detained by Deputy Clark on the
west side of Xerxes. �I
I assisted Deputy Clark in placing handcuffs on the suspect behind his back, gapping and double locking the
handcuffs prior to conducting a Pat Search of the suspect while he was on his stomach. The suspect was then
stood up at which time I could smell the strong odor of an alcoholic beverage emanating from his mouth. A
Search Incident to Arrest of the suspect revealed in a pocket a silver pipe which was bumt on one of the ends,
consistent with that of narcotics paraphernalia. I observed in another pocket a metal pin, also suspected to be
used for narcotics paraphernalia. I also observed on the ground next to the male was a Michelob Golden Draft
beer can, blue in color, inside a beer cozy.
The suspect was positively identified as Brian Lee Aultman, 7/15/59, by DVS website. I found Aultman was
Cancelled fPS and had a 100% score on a Felony Warrant for Fifth Degree Felony Controlled Substance. I
id not react
observed Aultman s hair was uncombed, he had watery, glassy eyes and his pupils were pinpomt and d
to light by contracting or dilating when he opened and cfosed his eyes.
I asked Aultman if he had been using any type of narcotics today and he stated he had not. When I asked
Aultman how much he had to drink he advised me the one beer he was carrying. I asked Aultman whose car he
drove up in and he stated he was not driving. It should be noted when I searched Aultman I located 2 sets of
keys. I did maintain possession of the keys.
Aultman was transported to the parking lot of 2920 Northway Drive where I observed the vehicle I observed
P�
r
Printed by: bc114to IIICICIeIIt R@ 01� Page 4 of 5
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:00
p
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-001643
Aultman drive into the lot, Minnesota HCZ102. I asked Aultman whose vehicle it was and he stated it was his
sister's. I asked him what he was doing at the apartment complex and he stated visiting his sister in 103 of the
2920 building. I located the p.artial last name of Aultman staying in #103 of 2920. I asked Aultman if his sister was
home and he stated she was not. I asked him how he got there and he stated his friend 'AI' dropped him off. I
asked where AI was and Aultman stated he left and he does not know AI's {ast name.
1 tried one of the keys from Aultman's pocket in HCZ102 and the key did unlock and lock the vehicle door. Upon
touching the hood of the vehicle I found it to still be warm. I observed a brown dog in the front driver's seat of the
vehicle and an open 12 pack of Michelob Golden Draft in the back seat. Aultman had been carrying a Michelob
Golden Draft beer can when he fled police.
I asked Aultman for the telephone number of his sister to advise her she left her dog in the vehicle. He stated he
n one in the a a
rtment to leave
the do with therefore
I called for
did not have a hone for her. Since there was o 9
P
P
CSO Logan to impound the dog.
Because I had to impound the vehicleAultman had been driving I did conduct a Search Incident to Impound on
HCZ102 at which time I found several lastic ba ie tear offs, c
onsistent with narcotics use.
I counted the beer
P 99
cans in the 12-pack and found one missing.
I administered a Preliminary Breath Test on Aultman with #55668, last calibrated on 10/27/06 by Sergeant Roth of
the Brooklyn Center Police Department and checked Aultman's mouth and did not find anything foreign prior to my
administration of the test which revealed a.007, consistent with a person who has had approximately one half to
one whole beer and there was only one beer missing from the 12-pack in the vehicle. While searching the vehicle
I noticed there were photos of Aultman inside. I removed the vehicle license plates and had the vehicle
impounded by North Suburban Towing and filled out a Notice and Order of License Plate Impoundment and
property inventoried the plates, the crack pipe and the push pin.
Aultman was transported to the Hennepin County Adult Detention Center on his Felony Warrant. His Criminal
History revealed several DWI offenses and prior DAR, DAS, DAC, and Driver License violations.
I am requesting Aultman be charged by Formal Complaint for DAC-IPS, Possess Drug Paraphernalia, and Flee
Police on Foot
No further
Gabler/km 3/28/07
Entered Date/Time: 03/30/2007 10:27 Narrative Type: NOTE
Subject: ANIMAL IMPOUND DOG 2179 Author. LOGAN, THOMAS
CAGE: 31
SEX: Ma1e
COLOR: Brown
BREED: LablRetriever
COLLAR: Yes
SIZE: Large
APPR. AGE: Young Adult
REASON FOR IMPOUND: Owner Arrested
Must be claimed on or before 6 o'clock PM on April 2nd, 2007.
Julie Howe claimed dog on 03-28-07 at 1710 hours.
Printed by: bc114to IIICICI@I�t R@pOPt Page 5 of 5
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:00
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N I'
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number BC07-001643
Siqnatures
Reporting Officer Date
Supervisor Date
II I
I
I�
I
Printed by: bc114to Incident Report Pa
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:01
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
��s3) sss-3ass Incident Number: BC07-001682
Incident Summarv
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S} Report Type: BURGLARY
Inc Occurred Address: 2936 NORTHWAY DR 101 BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55430 Sector/Beat: 4BC04
Inc Occurred Start: 03/29/2007 12:49 Inc Occurred End: Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported Date/Time: 03/29/2007 12:49
Reporting Officer: LORENTZ, STEVE Primary Assigned Officer:
Case Status: ACTIVE Disposition: PENDING/OPEN Disposition Date: 04/02/2007 08:37
Offenses
Statute Code: 609-582-1 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: BURGLARY-1ST DEG-OCC DWELLWG
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: FELONY
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 3468790 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: VICTIM Contact Date/Time: 03/29/2007 12:49
Name: SCHALL, EDWIN FREDRICK
SSN: DOB: 07l09/1939 Age: 67 67 Sex: MALE Race: WHITE
Height: 5' 10" 5' 10" Weight: 250 250 Ibs Eye Color. BROWN Hair Color: BROWN
Address: 2936 NORTHWAY DR 101 BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 Sector/Beat: 4/BC04
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 560-1851 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
DL State: MINNESOTA DL#: N564117741715 DL Exp. Date:
Occupation: Employer/School:
Propertv Involved
Propertv 0001 Evidence: No
Event AssoclOrig status: STOLEN WITHIN JURISC Originai Status Date: 03/29/2007 12:49:00 Original Value: $1,000.00
Current Status: STOLEN WITHIN JURISDICTION Current Status Date: 03/29/2007 12:49:00 Current Value: $1,000.00
Property Type: COMPUTER LAPTOP
Description: LAPTOP COMPUTER
MakelBrand: APPLE ModeL•
Color: Quantity: 1
Serial/Lot#: Owner Applied#:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Cancelled:
r
Printed by: bc114to �nCIC�@Ilt R@p01� Page 1 of2
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:09
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N II
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number BC07-002065
Incident Summarv
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: INCIDENT
Inc Occurred Addressc 2912 NORTHWAY DR 203 BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55430 Sector/Beat: /BC04
Inc Occurred Start: 04/15/2007 02:00 Inc Occurred End: Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported DatelTime: 04/15/2007 02:00
Reporting Officer: COLEMAN, MICHAEL Primary Assigned Officer:
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: ADULT ARREST Disposition Date: 04/16/2007 2125
Offenses
Statute Code: 19-1202 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: NOISY GATHERWG DISTURB PEACE OF RESIDENTS
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: MISDEMEANOR
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTWG OFFICER 3237 149 COLEMAN, MICHAEL
BACK-UP 3229 106 SCHULTZ, JAMES
Associated Events
Association: Event Type: Event#: Event Date (Start): Event Date (End): Agency:
ARREST TO INCIDENT ARREST BC07-002065 04l15/2007 02:00:00 BC
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 7550174 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: ARREST Contact Date/Time: 04/15/2007 02:00
Name: MAYO, DEN�SE
DOB: 04/15/1968 Age: 39 39 Sex: FEMALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
Height: Weight: Eye Color: Hair Color.
Address: 2912 NORTHWAY DR 203 BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 Sector/Beat: /BC04
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 208-7549 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/Schooi:
Person Offenses
Statute Code: 19-1202 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: NOISY GATHERING DiSTURB PEACE OF RESIDENTS
Counts: 1
Narratives
Entered Date/Time: 04/16/2007 20:53 Narrative Type: SYNOPSIS
Subject: SYNOPSIS Author. COLEMAN, MICHAEL
On 04/15/07 at approximately 0200 hours, Officer Mike Coleman was dispatched to 2912 Northway Drive
apartment #203 for a noise comptaint.
i
Printed by: bc114to Incident Re�port Pa 2°f 2
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:09
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-002065
Entered DateITime: 04/16/2007 21:24 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author: COLEMAN, MICHAEL
I heard from Hennepin County Dispatch, prior to my arrival, that officers had been to that apartment earlier on my
shift on 04/14/07 for the same complaint on a report of loud music playing inside of the apartment.
Upon my arrival, along with Officer Schultz, we entered the second level of the apartment building and I was able
to distinctly hear loud music which I determined was coming from apartment #203. The music was so loud that,
while I was standing in the hallway, I was able to distinctly make out all the lyrics of the music clearly. I knocked
on the apartment door and a female, who t later identified by MN pictured driver's license as Denise MAYO (dob
04/15/68), answered the door. She identified herself as the renter of the apartment and I noticed that there were
approximately 6-10 other individuals inside of the apartment. I did ask Mayo several times to turn off the music
which she finally did. Mayo told me that it was her birthday party and that they were just trying to have a good
time. She stated to me that the music was turned down from the last time that officers were out there and stated
that she thought the music was low enough. I explained to Mayo that officers were out there previously in the
night for the same compfaint and her failure to comply with o�cers' request at that time the result of her receiving
a citation for noise abatement. Mayo stated that she understood, that she was sorry, and that she would be
turning off the music for the rest of the night.
1 issued Mayo a Hennepin County Release-Receipt for noise abatement with a court date of 05/07/07 at Division II
Court located at 6125 Shingle Creek Parkway. Mayo signed the tab charge acknowledging receipt. I issued her a
copy of it.
COLEMAN
Ja 04/16/07
Siqnatures
Reporting O�cer Date
Supervisor Date
Printed by: bc114to �11CIC�@rlt R@p01� Page 1 of 2
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:11
BROOKLYN CENTER POUCE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-002201 f
Incident Summarv
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: WARRANT
Inc Occurred Address: 2912 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55430 Sector/Beat: 4/BC04
Inc Occurred Start: Inc Occurred End: Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Re{ated: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported Date/Time: 04/21/2007 19:20
Reporting Officer: GABLER, RICHARD Primary Assigned Officer:
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: ADULT ARREST Disposition Date: 04l23/2007 13:17
Offenses
Statute Code: MISWA Enhancers:
Statute Desc: MISC OFCR WARRANT ARREST
Counts: 1 Statute Severity:
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3228 147 GABLER, RICHARD
Persons involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 874878 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: WARRANT ARREST Contact Date/Time: 04/21/2007 00:00
Name: MATTSON, JOHN ALLAN
DOB: 02/24/1966 Age: 41 41 Sex: MALE Race: WHITE
Height: 5' 6" 5' 6" Weight: 124 124 Ibs Eye Color: HAZEL Hair Color: BROWN
Address: 4719 BRYANT AV N 2 MINNEAPOLIS, MINNESOTA 55430 Sector/Beat:
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (612) 434-6017 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: EmployerlSchooL•
Person Offenses
Statute Code: MISWA Enhancers:
Statute Desc: MISC OFCR WARRANT ARREST
Counts: 1 I
Businesses Involved
Business 0001 I
Event Association:
Business Name: CENTER POINTE APARTMENTS Business Type: APARTMENTS
Address: 2912 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55429 Sector/Beat: 4BC04
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Narratives
Entered Date/Time: 04/23/2007 13:24 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author: GABLER, RICHARD
See Original Report
Printed by: bc114to �nCIC�@Ilt R@pOrt Page 2 of 2
Printed date/time: 5!9/07 14:11
BROOKLYN CENTER POUCE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 It7Cid@Ilt NUlllb@�: BC07-002201
Sianatures
Reporting O�cer Date
Supervisor Date
Printed by: bc114to �nCIC�@Ilt R@p01't Page 1 of 2
Printed dateltime: 5/9/07 14:12
BROOKLYN CENTER POUCE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 I
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07 -002254
Incident Summarv
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: WARRANT
Inc Occurred Address: 2904 NORTHWAY DR LOT LOT BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55429 Sector/Beat: 4BC04
Inc Occurred Start: 04/23/2007 22:40 Inc Occurred End: 04/23/2007 22:40 Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported Date/Time: 04/23/2007 22:40
Reporting Officer: RATAJCZYK, JOHN Primary Assigned O�cer:
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: REFERRED TO OTHER AGENCY Disposition Date: 04/25/2007 08:45
Offenses
Statute Code: MISWA Enhancers:
Statute Desc: MISC OFCR WARRANT ARREST
Counts: 1 Statute Severity:
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3243 105 RATAJCZYK, JOHN
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 1369409 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: WARRANT ARREST Contact Date/Time: 04/23/2007 22:40
Name: SMITH, BRANDON LEON
DOB: 03116/1984 Age: 23 23 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC i',
Height: 6' 1" 6' 1" Weight: 180 180 Ibs Eye Color. HAZEL Hair Color: BLACK
Address: 2908 NORTHWAY DR 303 BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 Sector/Beat: 4/BC04
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 503-5143 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: CELL Phone# 2: (612) 695-2844 Ext 2:
Occupation: EmpioyerlSchooL•
Businesses Invoived
Business 0001
Event Association: LOCATION
Business Name: CENTER POINTE APARTMENTS Business Type: APARTMENTS
AddresS: 2904 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55429 Sector/Beat: 46C04
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
I�P�
Printed by: bc114to �11CIC�@Ilt R@pOrt Page 2 of 2
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:12
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-002254
Narratives
Entered Date/Time: 04/25/2007 08:47 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author: RATAJCZYK, JOHN
On 04/23/2007 at 2240 hours, i Officer Ratajczyk and Officer Gabier observed SMITH in the parking lot of 29Q8
Northwa Drive. We observed SMITH drivin MN LIC/GET188 from Northway Drive to the parking lot. Through
Y 9
prior contacts with SMITH I along with Gabler knew SMITH had previously held a suspended driver's ficense.
Officer Gabler inquired with SMITH as to if he had corrected his suspended license status and SMITH replied that
he had not but was working it.
In running a license and warrant check on SMITH, it was determined that he was wanted by the Hennepin County
Sheriff's Office on a misdemeanor warrant.
SMITH was arrested and transported to the Hennepin County Jail where is being held on $500.00 baiL
Sictnatures
Reporting O�cer Date
Supervisor Date
i
Printecf by: bc114to �nCIC�@Ilt R@pOI� Page 1 of 2
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:12
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-002297
incident Summarv
Incident Type: CR�MINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: WARRANT
Inc Occurred Address: 2924 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MN SectorlBeat: BC04
Inc Occurred Start: 04/26/2007 16:10 Inc Occurred End: Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported Date/Time: 04l26/2007 16:10 il
Reporting Officer: ROGNSTAD, CHRIS Primary Assigned Officer:
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: ADULT ARREST Disposition Date: 04/28/2007 14:47
Offenses
Statute Code: MISWA Enhancers:
Statute Desc: MISC OFCR WARRANT ARREST
Counts: 1 Statute Severity:
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3246 109 ROGNSTAD, CHRIS
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNf: 19161918 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: WARRANT ARREST Contact Date/Time: 04/26/2007 16:10
Name: WILLEY, JAMELLE JOSEPH
DOB: 07/19/1987 Age: 19 19 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC•
Height: 6' 2" 6' 2" Weight: 185 185 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
Address: SectorlBeat:
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/SchooL•
Person Offenses
I Statute Code: MISWA Enhancers:
Statute Desc: MISC OFCR WARRANT ARREST
Counts: 1
Printe� by: bc114to Incident Report Page 2 of 2
Printed date/time: 5!9/07 14:12
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number BC07-002297
Narratives
EMered Date/Time: Q4/28/2007 14:56 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author: ROGNSTAD, CHRIS
On 4I26/07 at approximately 1600, o�cers were called to check on two males on the steps of 2924 Northway
Drive. This call was from the complex management offiee. The two men were reported to be smoking marijuana
and believed to be selling it also. When officers were arriving in the area, this reporting officer observed the
defendant and a second male sitting on the step outside of 2924 Northway Drive. Once officers parked, exited
their squads and approached the area of the steps, the two males had begun to walk away from officers. Officers
drove squad cars around the building to find that the two males had turned away and walked back toward their
original location. Officer caught up to the males and asked them why they were at the complex and to produce
some form of photo ID. The defendant verbally identified himself and the second male had photo ID. Both males
were checked for warrants. This officer was notified of the warrant for the defendant. Defendant had tattoos
matching the information in the warrant. Defendant told officer that he had never been in Georgia. The
defendant's Georgia photo ID would later be found in his sock. Both males were given Notice of Trespass and
instructed not to return to complex.
ROGNSTAD
Ja 04/28/07
SlqllatUt'@S
Reporting Officer Date
Supervisor Date
Printed by: bc114to Incident Report Pa °f'
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:15
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N i
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 111CId@�t NUtflb@1': BC07-002487
Incident Summarv
Incident Type: STATUS OFFENSE(S) Report Type: TOW
Inc Occurred Address: 2802 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55429 Sector/Beat: 4/BC04
Inc Occurred Start: Inc Occurred End: Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported Date/Time: 05/04/2007 20:50 I,�
Reporting Officer: GABLER, RICHARD Primary Assigned O�cer:
L ED Dis osition: ASSISTED/ADVISED Disposition Date: 05/07/2007 08:19
Case Status: C OS p
Offenses
Statute Code: MISIMP Enhancers
Statute Desc: MISC OFCR VEHICLE IMPOUND
Counts: 1 Statute Severity:
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3228 147 GABLER, RICHARD
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 912465 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: REGISTERED OWNER Contact DatelTime:
Name: SHEPARD, NAKIA CHIARESSE
DOB: 01/12l1977 Age: 30 30 Sex: FEMALE Race: BLACK WITH HISPANI�
Height: 5' 6" 5' 6" Weight: 165 165 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
Address: 3835 5 AV S MINNEAPOLIS, MINNESOTA 55409 Sector/Beat:
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (612) 537-3697 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
I
Occupation: UNEMPLOYED Employer/SchooL•
Vehicles Involved
Vehicle#: 0001
Event Assoc: TOWED Vehicle Status:
Vehicle Type: A Year: 1992 Make: CADILLAC ModeL•
VIN: License#: TNV870 State: MN Expires On:
Style: 4-DOOR Prim Color: TAN Sec Color. Ter Color:
Status DtlTm: Status Value: Recovered Date: Recovered Value:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Canceiled:
Registered Owner Name: SHEPARD, NAKIA CHIARESS
Address: 3835 5 AV S MINNEAPOUS, MN 55409 Phone#: (612) 537-3697
Siqnatures
Reporting Officer Date
Supervisor Date
i
Printed by: bc114to �nCident Rep01� Page 1 of 6
Printed date/time: 5!9/07 14:09
BROOKLYN CENTER POUCE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-002084
Incident Summarv
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: USE OF FORCE
Inc Occurred Address: 2920 NORTHWAY DR LOT LOT BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55429 Sector/Beat: 4BC04
fnc Occurred Start: 04/16/2007 01:35 Inc Occurred End: 04/16/2007 01:35 Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported Date/Time: 04/16/2007 01:35
Reporting Officer: PETERSON, MICHAEL Primary Assigned Officer:
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: ASSISTED/ADVISED Disposition Date: 04/19/2007 15:18
Offenses
Statute Code: 609-224-1 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: ASSAULT-5TH DEGCOMMITS, ATTEMPTS OR THREATS HARM
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: MiSDEMEANOR
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3226 148 PETERSON, MICHAEL
BACK-UP 3221 150 LEYK, SARA I
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 3949830 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: REPORTING PARTY Contact Date/Time: 04l16/2007 01:45
Name: FARKAR�UN, CORRINNE ROSE
DOB: 11/17/1963 Age: 43 43 Sex: FEMALE Race: INDIAN/ ALASKAN NATI
Height: 5' 1" 5' 1" Weight: 240 240 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
Address: 2924 NORTHWAY DR 302 BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55429 SectorlBeat: 4/BC04
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (612) 379-3105 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/SchooL•
Person#: 0002 MNI: 936943 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: MENTIONED Contact Date/Time: 04/16/2007 01:37
Name: FARKARLUN, TRISHA KUMBA
DOB: 08/28/1985 Age: 21 21 Sex: FEMALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
Height: 5' 2" 5' 2" Weight: 150 150 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
Address: 4407 MORGAN AV N 2 MINNEAPOUS, MINNESOTA 55412 Sector/Beat:
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1; (612) 359-0251 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/SchooL•
I
Printed by: bc114to Page 2 of 6
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:09 Incident Report
BROOKLYN CENTER POUCE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 ICICid@Ilt NUttlb@I': BC07-002084
Persons Involved
Person#: 0003 MNI: 19052352 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: MENTIONED Contact Date/Time: 04/16/2007 01:30
Name: WINTERS, TRACY DENISE
DOB: 03/18/1986 Age: 21 21 Sex: FEMALE Race: B�ACK NON-HISPANIC
Height: 5' 4" 5' 4" Weight: 120 120 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
Address: 2101 VINCENT AV N MINNEAPOUS, MINNESOTA 55411 Sector/Beat:
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: {763) 537-9608 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: EmployeNSchooL•
I Businesses Involved
Business 0001
Event Association: LOCATION
Business Name: CENTER POINTE APARTMENTS Business Type: APARTMENTS
Address: 2920 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 Sector/Beat: 4BC04
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Narratives
Entered Date/Time: 04/19/2007 14:37 Narrative Type: SYNOPSIS
Subject: SYNOPSIS Author: PETERSON, MICHAEL
Officers were called to an assault, Upon arrival parties had been separated and were found to be intoxicated but
refused to ress char es a ainst each other. Two arties initiall did not cooperate with officers and had to be
P 9 9 P Y
restrained.
I�
Printed by: bc114to �nCld@Ilt R@pOrt Page 3 of 6
Printed dateltime: 5/9/07 14:09
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
Incident Number: BC07-002084
(763) 569-3333
Entered DatelTime: 04/19/2007 14:39 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author. PETERSON, MICHAEL
On 04-16-07 at 0935 hours, I, Officer Peterson, was dispatched to 2924 Northway Drive for an assault that had
'ust occurred. While I was en route dis atch rela ed information that the victim told them that her daughter was
1 P Y
with the party who had assaulted her and that they were walking towards Cub Foods from the Center Pointe
r a shortl
tw ntie 1 arrived in the a e
rtment buildin Th w ibe a tw I k f m le in their mid e s
A a e ere descr d s o b ac e a s
P 9 Y Y
that inf r ti n r th ir i t r etween Cub Foods and Center Pointe.
aft r o ma o was sent ut ov e a and I looked n he a ea b
e o e
In the vacant lot that used to be Jerry's Market I observed finro females standing in the northeast corner of that lot
close to the intersection of Xerxes and Northway Drive. As I looked further these two parties appeared to be
either embracing each other or possibly fighting with each other.
I pulled my vehicle onto Northway Drive just west of Xerxes and I shined my spotlight on them. I did have my
window rolled down when I drove up there and as I put my spotlight on the two parties one of the females who was
later identified as Tracy Denice WINTERS, DOB 03-18-1986, stated to me, "Can I help you?" I asked the two
parties to walk over to my direction as l was walking towards them so that I could talk to them. Winters again
stated, "Can I help you," "What do I need to talk to you for?" I stated that I just needed to find out what was going
n Winters stated that
i t t e east a d
w'th them. As I contin w Ikin owards them the continued walk n o h
on i ued a t g
9 Y
r' t was on the hone with somebod and
the we e ust here waitin for the bus. At that time I observed that she
P
Y
Y 1 9
she said that the cops were out here hassling her and they were arresting her for no reason. I asked her to please
hang up the phone so that I could talk to her and she did not. She told the party that she was talking to on the i
other line that the needed to hur u if the were close because the olice was there and we were going to hurt 'J
Y rY P Y P
h r. I then told her to han th e as I did not kn w who she was talkin to or how close the were and I
e g up e phon o g y
did not want anyone else coming to the scene for everyone's safety. She still did not comply with my demand to
hang up the phone so I reached with my right hand and grabbed the phone from her right hand as it was up to her
head.
As I began to pull the phone away from her, the other party who was later identified as Trisha Kumba
FARKARLUN, DOB 08-28-1985, lunged in my direction. Officer Leyk, wha was on scene with me, then grabbed
on to her to keep her from attacking me. Both Winters and Trisha grabbed on to each other and I was not sure if
fr m officers. I told them that the
the were startin to fi ht or if the w re t in to hel each other et awa o
e
Y
9 9 rY 9 9 Y
Y Y P
th
er te. Trisha en
d to sto r i ti i h n neither would coo a
neede es s n and to lace the r ands behind their backs a d
P 9 P P
n m self and I
u clo r r en O�cer Le k a d
ended se on m side as the were stru lin back and fo th betwe
P Y Y 99 9 Y Y
t t r the round. As I did both Winters and
attem ed o ab her left arm and t and a I an arm bar to et her to
P 9 PP Y 9 9
rY
Trisha lost their balance and they fell to the ground.
Once on the ground both parties continued to hold one another while still trying to elbow and kick officers. I
repeatedly told them to stop fighting, to stop resisting and to place their hands behind their backs but they
continued to struggle. After approximately a minute of them struggling on the ground, I did step back pulled my
taser from my belt and I turned it on and told them that if they did not cooperate they would both be tased. At that
time they both stopped resisting and they both pfaced their hands behind their backs and both parties were cuffed.
Please see Officer Leyk's supplemental report for further information.
I then escorted Trisha over to my marked squad #324 and asked her what was going on. She stated that they
were about to get jumped by some people from Center Pointe and that they were scared that we were the people
who were domg it. I told her that I clearly was m a marked police car, I put my spotlight on them, and I iden
tified
myself as the police and I was also in uniform. In talking with her I realized that she seemed to be intoxicated and
I asked her what had actually happened that night. She stated that she had been out drinking with Winters who is
girlfriend and her mother who was later identified as Corrinne Rose FARKARLUN, DbB 11-17-1973, at Blondies
in Brooklyn Park. They were dropping Corrinne off at 2924 Northway Drive and wanted to make sure she was
going to get in okay when both Corrinne and Winters started assaulting each other. I
Printed by: bc114to �nCident RepOrt Page 4 of 6
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:09
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-002084
asked all three parties it they needed medical atSention and none ot them said that they did. It should be noted
that at this time myself and Officer Leyk had transported Trisha and Winters over to the parking lot of 2920
Northway Drive where we found Corrinne standing out in the parking lot. As soon as Trisha had calmed down I
informed her that I would take the handcuffs off if she was not going to continue with officers or other people. She
stated she wouldn't; therefore, I took the handcuffs off Trisha.
I then spoke with Corrinne who was standing in the parking lot and on my initial contact with her I could tell that
she was intoxicated as I could smell the odor of an intoxicating beverage emanating from her and she was having
a hard time standing and she was slurring her words. I asked her if she had anything to drink tonight and she
stated that she had been drinking. I asked her what happened and she stated that Winters who she knows as her
daughter's girlfriend hit her over the top of the head. She does not know if an object was used but believes it was
just her hand. I asked her if she hit Winters back and she stated that she did not. It should be noted that Corrinne
is a much larger woman than Winters is. Again I asked Corrinne if she needed medical attention and she stated
that she did not.
I went over to speak with Winters who was in the back of marked squad #322 driven by Officer Leyk and told her
that she needed to settle down as she was still very agitated in the back of the squad car and I told her that as
soon as she did calm down I would take the handcuffs off of her. I asked her what happened and she stated that
they had been drinking up at Blondies in Brooklyn Park and they were just dropping off Corrinne at the apartment.
The two of them started arguing verbally in the car when they were almost at the apartment complex and then
they started physically fighting once there. Winters stated that she did not wish to press any charges against
Corrinne.
I went back and talked to Corrinne about what happened and she then admitted that they were both fighting and
she no longer wished to press charges against Winters as long as Winters left immediately. There were family
members of Winters' on scene and I did take the handcuffs off Winters and had Officer Leyk let her out of her
squad car to go with her family. All parties then went their separate ways.
Peterson/re
04-20-07
Printed by: bc114to IIICIC�@Ilt R@pOrt Page 5 of 6
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:09
BROOKLYN CENTER POUCE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-002084 i'
Entered Dateffime: 04/19/2007 15:12 Narrative Type: SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT
Subject: SUPP1 SL 4/16/07 0249 Author: LEYK, SARA
On 4/16/07 at 0135 hours, I, Officer Leyk, was dispatched to 2924 Northway Drive on the report of an Assault.
Upon arrival in the area Dispatch advised the two suspects fled on foot toward the Cub Foods lot. I responded
westbound on County Road 10 for Cub Foods when I observed two females on the corner of Northway Drive and
Xerxes who appeared to be walking through the field.
1 tumed eastbound and Officer Peterson advised he would be out with the two females. Upon my arrival, Officer
Peterson was ordering the girls to stop and they were walking in the opposite direction of him. I positioned my I
squad in front of the girls and Officer Peterson ordered the girls again to stop and for the one girl to get off her
phone.
Neither of the females acknowledged Officer Peterson nor attempted to stop their movement. Officer Peterson
attempted to grab one of the girls by the arm. The female stated, "Fuck you. I know my rights." and grabbed her
friend by the neck and attempted to flee. In the process she ended up taking O�cer Peterson and the other
female to the ground with her and I assisted Officer Peterson in an attempt to detain the female.
Her right arm was wrapped tightly around the other female's neck and I was unable to unlodge it. I brought the
arm up for Officer Peterson to handcuff at which time he secured the cuff and I attempted to pull the other female
out from under her. The other female then ran toward O�cer Peterson who was still struggling on the ground with
the other female. 1 took her down to the ground using the Arm Bar technique and ordered her to place her hands •''I
behind her back and she complied. I handcuffed her and Officers Mike Coleman and Toohey assisted in
transporting the females to our squads.
I Pat Searched one female and placed her in the rear of marked squad #322 at which time 1 properly identified her
as Tracy Denise Winters, 3/18/86. Winters was agitated and using vulgar language. She told me she had been
assaulted by the parties standing in front of the Center Pointe complex. She pointed in the general direction and
we escorted the two females by squad to where the reporting party was. I
Officer Peterson spoke with the reporting party who stated Winters had assaulted her. I entered my squad to ask
Winters what happened and she stated she was just defending herself. There was a strong odor of alcohol
emanating from Winters' person as well as that of the reporting pa�ty and the female in O�cer Peterson's squad.
Both Winters and the reporting party stated they did not wish to press charges and }'ust wanted to go home. After
conversing with ail parties, aN females were released.
It should be noted Winters was released to her mother on scene, a sober responsible adult.
All parties claimed no injuries and refused medical attention.
No further
Leyk/km 4/19/07
r�
Printed by: bc114to �nCIC�@Ilt R@p0� Page 6 of 6
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:09
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-002084
Siqnatures
Reporting Officer Date
Supervisor Date
i
Printed by: bc114to �nCIC�@Ilt R@p01� Page 1 of 3
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:10
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 117Cidellt NUIt1beP: BC07-002106
Incident Summarv
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: BURGIARY
Inc Occurred Address: 2928 NORTHWAY DR 204 BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55429 SectoNBeat: 4/BC04
Inc Occurred Start: 04/17/2007 11:30 Inc Occurred End: 04/17/2007 13:22 Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported Date/Time: 04/17/2007 13:22
Reporting Officer. KNIGHT, MELONEY Primary Assigned O�cer:
Case Status: INACTIVE Disposition: INACTIVE/OPEN Disposition Date: 04/19/2007 13:34
Offenses
Statute Code: 609-582-2 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: BURGLARY-NO FORCE-RES-DAY
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: FELONY
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3241 136 KNIGHT, MELONEY
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 18985962 Can ID Sus ect: No
P
Event Association: REPORTING PARTY Contact Date/Time: 04/17l2007 13:22
I
Name: GREEN KENISHA DIANE
DOB: 09/30/1985 Age: 21 21 Sex: FEMALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC•
Height: 5' 2" 5' 2" Weight: 140 140 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
Address: 2928 NORTHWAY DR 204 BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55429 Sector/Beat: 4/BC04
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 205-5368 Ext 1:
Phone Type T. Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: EmployeNSchooL•
Person#: 0002 MNI: 894285 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: SUSPECT Contact Date/Time: I
Name: WESTBROOK JR, THOMAS FRITZGERALD
DOB: 05/26/1986 Age: 20 20 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
Height: Weight: Eye Color: Hair Color.
Address: 2701 DOUGLAS DR CRYSTAL, MINNESOTA Sector/Beat:
Phone Type 1: CELL Phone# 1: (763) 843-4872 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: WORK Phone# 2: (612) 545-3747 Ext 2:
Occupation: EmpioyedSchooL•
I'
j
Printed by: bc114to �1'1CIC�@Cit R@p01� Page 2 of 2
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:11
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-002201
SIqClatUl'@S
Reporting Officer Date
Supervisor Date
t
Printed by: bc114to IIICICI@Ilt R@pOrt Page 1 of 2
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:12
BROOKLYN CENTER POIICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT QVE N II
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-002254
Incident Summarv
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: WARRANT
Inc Occurred Address: 2904 NORTHWAY DR LOT LOT BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55429 Sector/Beat: 4BC04
Inc Occurred Start: 04/23/2007 22:40 Inc Occurred End: 04/23/2007 22:40 Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported Date/Time: 04/23/2007 22:40
Reporting Officer. RATAJCZYK, JOHN Primary Assigned O�cer:
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: REFERRED TO OTHER AGENCY Disposition Date: 04/25/2007 08:45
Offenses
Statute Code: MISWA Enhancers:
Statute Desc: MISC OFCR WARRANT ARREST
Counts: 1 Statute Severity:
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3243 105 RATAJCZYK, JOHN
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 1369409 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: WARRANT ARREST Contact Date/Time: 04/23/2007 22:40
Name: SMITH, BRANDON LEON
DOB: 03116/1984 Age: 23 23 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
Height: 6' 1" 6' 1" Weight: 180 180 Ibs Eye Color: HAZEL Hair Color: BLACK
Address: 2908 NORTHWAY DR 303 BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 Sector/Beat: 4/BC04
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 503-5143 Ext 1:
Pfione Type 2: CELL Phone# 2: (612) 695-2844 Ext 2:
Occupation: EmployeNSchooL•
Businesses Involved
Business 0001
Event Association: LOCATION
Business Name: CENTER POINTE APARTMENTS Business Type: APARTMENTS
Address: 2904 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55429 Sector/Beat: 4BC04
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Printed by: bc114to IIICICI@Ilt R@pOCt Page 2 of 2
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:12
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-002254
Narratives
Entered DatelTime: 04/25/2007 08:47 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author: RATAJCZYK, JOHN
On 04/23/2007 at 2240 hours, I Officer Ratajczyk and Officer Gabler observed SMITH in the parking lot of 2908
Northway Drive. We observed SMITH driving MN LIC/GET188 from Northway Drive to the parking lot. Through
prior contacts with SMITH I along with Gabler knew SMITH had previousiy held a suspended driver's license.
Officer Gabler inquired with SMITH as to if he had corrected his suspended license status and SMITH replied that
he had not but was working it.
In running a license and warrant check on SMITH, it was determined that he was wanted by the Hennepin County
Sheriff's Office on a misdemeanor warrant.
SMITH was arrested and transported to the Hennepin County Jail where is being held on $500.00 bail.
Sianatures
Reporting O�cer Date
Supervisor Date
Printec! by: bc114to �nCIC�@Ilt R@p01� Page 1 of 2
Printed dateltime: 5/9107 14:12
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N k
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 f
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-002297
Incident Summarv
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: WARRANT
inc Occurred Address: 2924 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MN Sector/Beat: BC04
Inc Occurred Start: 04/26/2007 16:10 Inc Occurred End: Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported Date/Time: 04/26/2007 16:10
Reporting Officer: ROGNSTAD, CHRIS Prlmary Assigned Officer:
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: ADULT ARREST Disposition Date: 04/28/2007 14:47
Offenses
Statute Code: MISWA Enhancers:
Statute Desc: MISC OFCR WARRANT ARREST
Counts: 1 Statute Severity:
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3246 109 ROGNSTAD, CHRIS
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 19161918 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: WARRANT ARREST Contact Date/Time: 04/26/2007 16:10
Name: WILLEY, JAMELLE JOSEPH
DOB: 07/19/1987 Age: 19 19 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
Height: 6' 2" 6' 2" Weight: 185 185 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
Address: SectorlBeat:
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2
Occupation: EmployerlSchooL•
Person Offenses
Statute Code: MISWA Enhancers:
Statute Desc: MISC OFCR WARRANT ARREST
Counts: 1
Printe.i by: bc114to Incident Report P 2°f 2
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:12
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-002297
Narratives
Entered DatelTime: 04/28/2007 14:56 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author. ROGNSTAD, CHRIS
On 4/26/07 at approximately 1600, officers were called to check on two males on the steps of 2924 Northway
Drive. This call was from the complex management offiee. The two men were reported to be smoking marijuana
and believed to be selling it also. When officers were arriving in the area, this reporting officer observed the
defendant and a second male sitting on the step outside of 2924 Northway Drive. Once officers parked, exited
their squads and approached the area of the steps, the two males had begun to walk away from officers. OfFicers
drove squad cars around the building to find that the two males had turned away and walked back toward their
original location. Officer caught up to the males and asked them why they were at the complex and to produce
some form of photo ID. The defendant verbally identified himself and the second male had photo ID. Both males
were checked for warrants. This o�cer was notified of the warrant for the defendant. Defendant had tattoos
matching the information in the warrant. Defendant told o�cer that he had never been in Georgia. The
defendant's Georgia photo ID would later be found in his sock. Both males were given Notice of Trespass and
instructed not to retum to complex.
ROGNSTAD
Ja 04/28/07
Siqnatures
Reporting O�cer Date
Supervisor Date
Pa e1of1
9
Printed by: bc114to Incident Report
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:15
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 IC1CId@I1t NUI'Tlb@I' BC07-002487
Incident Summarv
Incident Type: STATUS OFFENSE(S) Report Type: TOW
Inc Occurred Address: 2802 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55429 Sector/Beat: 4/BC04
Inc Occurred Start: Inc Occurred End: Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported Date/Time: 05/04/2007 20:50
Prima Assi ned O
fficer:
Re ortin Officer. GABLER, RICHARD �'Y 9
P 9
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: ASSISTED/ADVISED Disposition Date: 05/07/2007 08
:19
Offenses
Statute Code: MISIMP Enhancers:
Statute Desc: MISC OFCR VEHICLE IMPOUND
Counts: 1 Statute Severity:
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3228 147 GAB�ER, RICHARD
Persons involved
0 1 MNI: 912465 Can ID Suspect: No
Person 0 0
Event Association: REGISTERED OWNER Contact DatelTime: I
Name: SHEPARD, NAKIA CHIARESSE
i
DOB: 01/12/1977 Age: 30 30 Sex: FEMALE Race: BLACK WITH HISPANI�
Hei ht: 5' 6" 5' 6" Wei ht: 165 165 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
9 9
Address: 3835 5 AV S MINNEAPOUS, MINNESOTA 55409 Sector/Beat:
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (612) 537-3697 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: UNEMPLOYED EmployerlSchooL•
Vehicles Involved
Vehicle#: 0001
Event Assoc: TOWED Vehicle Status:
Vehicle Type: A Year: 1992 Make: CADILLAC ModeL•
VIN: License#: TNV870 State: MN Expires On:
Style: 4-DOOR Prim Color: TAN Sec Color. Ter Color:
Status Dt/Tm: Status Value: Recovered Date: Recovered Value:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Cancelled:
Registered Owner Name: SHEPARD, NAKIA CHIARESS
Address:3835 5 AV S MINNEAPOLIS, MN 55409 Phone#: (612) 537-3697
Siqnatures
Reporting O�cer Date
Supervisor Date
'i�
4
Page�1 of 2
Printed by: bc114to ncident Report
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:10
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
�6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 Incident Number: BC07-002160
(T63)569-3333
Incident Summary
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: WARRAN�
Inc Occurred Address: 2802 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55429 Sector/Beat: 4/BC04
Inc Occurred Start: Inc Occurred End: Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported DatelTime: 04/20/2007 00:30
Reporting Officer: GABLER, RICHARD Primary Assigned Officer:
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: ADULT ARREST
Disposition Date: 04/23/2007 14:18
Offenses
Statute Code: MISWA Enhancers
Statute Desc: MISC OFCR WARRANT ARREST
Counts: 1 Statute Severity:
Officers
Event Association
Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3228 147 GABLER, RICHARD
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 19117667 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: WARRANT ARREST Contact Date/Time: 04/23/2007 00:30
Name: SMALLEY, MICHAEL LEROY
DOB: 08/26/1988 Age: 18 18 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
Hair Color: BLACK
Height: 5' 10" 5' 11" Weight: 175 175 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Sector/Beat: /BC04
Address: 2802 NORTHWAY DR 203 BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 227-9263 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/SchooL•
Person Offenses
Statute Code: MISWA Enhancers:
Statute Desc: MISC OFCR WARRANT ARREST
Counts: 1
Vehicles Involved
Vehicle#: 0001
Event Assoc: SUSPECT Vehicle Status:
Vehicie T e: A
Year: 1988 Make: CHEVROLET ModeL• GAPRICE
yp Ex ires On:
VIN•
License#: JYV167 State: MN P
Ter Color:
Style: 4-DOOR Prim Color: BLACK Sec Color:
Status Dt/Tm:
Status Va
lue: Recovered Date: Recovered Value:
NCIC Re orted By:
NCIC Date:
P
I
NCIC#:
NC
IC Cancelled:
II
Printed by: bc114to �nCldent Rep01� Page 2 of 2
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:10
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT 'I
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 (IlCld@tlt NUtllbet': BC07-002160
Businesses Involved
Business 0001
Event Association:
Business Name: CENTER POINTE APARTMENTS Business Type: APARTMENTS
Address: 2802 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55429 SectorlBeat: 4BC04
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Narratives
Entered Date/Time: 04/23/2007 14:25 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author: GABLER, RICHARD
On 4/20/07 at 0030 I Gabler stopped MN# JYV-167 for a cracked windshield in the lot of 2802 Northway drive.
Smalley was a passenger and was found to have a Middemeanor Warrant. Warrant was confirmed and Smalley
was transported to Hennepin County JaiL
Siqnatures
Reporting Officer Date
Supervisor Date
I
Page 1 of 4
Printed by: bc114to �nCldent R@p01�
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:04
BROOKLYN CENTER POUCE DEPT
645 HUMBOLdT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 II1CId@Ilt NuI'Y1bet': BC07-001979
(763) 569-3333
Incident Summary
Report Type: ARREST
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) SectorlBeat: /BC04
Inc Occurred Address: 2924 NORTNWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55430
Inc Occurred Start: 04l11i2007 19:30 Inc Occurred End:
Report Taken:
Domestic; N Bias Motivation:
Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported Date/Time: 04/11/2007 19:30
Reporting O�cer: GABLER, RICHARD Primary Assigned Officer:
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: ADULT ARREST
Disposition Date: 04/12/2007 22:59
Offenses
Statute Code: 609-605-1-B-4 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: TRESPASSING-BUILDING OR DWELLING
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: MISDEMEANOR
Officers
Em Badge# Name Squad#
Event Association p
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3228 147 GABLER, RICHARD
Associated Events
Association: Event Type: Event#: Event Date (Start): Event Date (End): Agency:
ARREST TO INCIDENT ARREST BC07-001979 04/11/2007 19:30:00
BG
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001
MNI: 18978108 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: ARREST Contact Date/Time: 04/11/2007 19:30
Name: HAMPTON, BRYAN RASHAWN
DOB: 02/27/1987 Age: 20 20 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
Hair Color: BLACK
Height: 5' 11" 5' 11" Weight: 190 190 ibs Eye Color: BROWN Sector/Beat:
Address: 4621 OLIVER AV N MINNEAPOLIS, MINNESOTA 55412
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/SchooL•
Person Offenses
Statute Code: 609-605-1-8-4 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: TRESPASSING-BUILDING OR DWELLING
Counts: 1
Businesses Involved
Business 0001
Event Association: LOGATION
Business Name: CENTER POINTE Business Type:
Address: 2924 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 Sector/Beat: 46C04
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# Z: Ext 2:
Printed by: bc114to Page 2 of 4
Incident Report
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:04
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 InCident NUmber: BC07-001979
Narratives
Entered Date/Time: 04/12/2007 22:59 Narrative Type: SYNOPSIS
Subject: SYNOPSIS Author: GABLER, RICHARD
On 04/11 /07, at 1930 hours, I, Officer Gabler, was doing a walk through of 2924 Northway Drive and I arrested
one adult male for trespassing.
Page 3 of 4
Printed by: bc114to Incident Report
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:04
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 Incident Number: BC07 -001979
(763) 569-3333
Entered Date/Time: 04/12/2007 23:02 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author: GABLER, RICHARD
On 04/11/07, at 1930 hours, I, officer Gabler, was working a violent crimes task force and I was working the
Center Pointe apartments in plain clothes. I did have my neck badge around my neck so I would be identified as a
police officer.
I was working the violent crimes task force based on the violent crimes the City of Brooklyn Center has been
receiving throughout the city. The Center Pointe complex is one of the focus points of this detail based on the
high volume of calls for service and violent crimes which do occur on the apartment complex.
I was doing a walk through with Hennepin County Sheriff Deputies Gottwaldt and Clark. I was standing in the
lobby of the 2924 building when I noticed a male walk down from the 2nd floor. I recognized the male from
several prior contacts as� e� alsoeecalled that Hampton was trespassed�f om Center PoB apa�tment
HAMPTON, dob 02/27/
complex.
I asked Hampton for his identification card and he did give me his identification card and it did confirm his identity
as Bryan Hampton. I quickly patted Hampton down for weapons for officer safety purposes and found nothing
illegal on his person. I asked Hampton what he was doing in the apartment complex and he stated that he was
visiting his grandma in apartment 204.
It should be noted that officers have had several prior contacts with Hampton and Hampton states at prior
contacts that he does not live at the residence and his grandma lives at 2924 Northway Drive, #204. Har�pton
has been associated with several narcotic citations as well as has had his name mentioned in prior robbery
reports as welL
I then checked with the Brooklyn Center station service officer for any active trespasses for Hampton on file. The
station service officer did a�dmi }n Center Po nte apartment comp ex fo�a period of one yea assad sed that
Hampton, dob 02/27/87, f
this trespass notice was still active.
placed Hampton in handcuffs with his hands behind his back, gapping and double-locking the handcuffs.
laced in the back of a squad car. I then filled out a Hennepin County release receipt for
ton was then use at
Ham p ion II court ho
P t the Divis
trespassing. I gave Hampton a Division II court date of 05/07/07, at 0830 hours a
6125 Shingle Creek Parkway in Brooklyn Center. The citation again was issued for criminal trespassing, a
misdemeanor.
I explained the release receipt to Hampton, Hampton began arguing and stated that we were just, "picking on him
because he was black and this was grimy of us to do." I explained to Hampton that he was previously given a
trespass notice, trespassing him from the Center Pointe apartment complex. He stated that he knew nothing
about ttie notice and had never been given one. I advised him that there was an active one on file and that he
should be aware of the trespass.
Hampton became very argumentative and uncooperative, however, I did remove the handcuffs from Hampton and
he did acknowledge the release receipt by signing it and was given a copy. Hampton was then arguing and yelling
as he was leaving off the property.
It should be noted that Hampton is currently on probation in Anoka County for burglary.
Gabler
pr 04/12l07
Page 4 of 4
Printed by: bc114to �1'1CId@11t R@pOrt
Printed date/time: 5/9l07 14:04
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N e'
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 r
Incident Number: BC07-001979
(763) 569-3333
Siqnatures
Date
Reporting Officer
Date
Supervisor
I
I
Page 1 of 4
Printed by: bc114to Incident Report
Printed dateltime: 5/9/07 14:12
ROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 Incident Number BC07-002280
(763) 569-3333
Incident Summary,
Report Type: DRUG OFFENSE
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Sector/Beat: /BC04
Inc Occurred Address: 2936 NORTHWAY DR 304 BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55430 Report Taken:
Inc Occurred Start: 04/25/2007 19:40 Inc Occurred End: Gang Related: U Substance: Y
Domestic: N Bias Motivation:
Reported DatelTime: 04/25/2007 19:40
Contact Nature:
Primary Assigned Officer:
Reporting Officer: GRUENIG, TONY Disposition Date: 04/30/2007 20:35
Case Status: PENDING FORMAL Disposition: PENDING/OPEN
Offenses
Enhancers
Statute Code: 152-025
Statute Desc: CONT SUBST-S-UNK ACT-UNK DRUG-UNK
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: FELONY
Officers syuad#
Event Association Emp#
Badge# Name
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3216
113 GRUENIG, TONY
List of Attachments
Type:
Report ID: Report Date: Report Summary:
AUDIO
VIDEO
PHOTOS
P@1'SOIIS �IIVO�V@C�, Can ID Suspect: No
Person#: 0001 MNI: 19044371
Event Association: SUSPECT Contact DatelTime: 04/25l2007 19:40
Name: HAUG, MICHAEL STEPHEN qge: 20 20 Sex: MALE Race: WHITE
DOB: 07/22/1986
Hair Color: BLACK
Height: 5' 11" 5' 11" Weight: 160 160 Ibs Eye Cotor: BROWN Sector/Beat: BC04
Address: 2936 NORTHWAY DR 304 BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
Phone Type 1: CELL Phone# 1: (651) 78&2306 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2:
Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Employer/School:
Occupation:
Person Offenses
Statute Code: 152-025
Enhancers
Statute Desc: CONT SUBST-5-UNK ACT-UNK DRUG-UNK
Counts: 1
Can ID Suspect: No
Person#: 0002 MNI: 19162489
Event Association: MENTIONED Contact DatelTime: 04l25/2007 19:40
Name: PETERSON, ANDREW SAWYER A ge: 20 20 Sex: MALE Race: WHITE
DOB: 11/20/1986 Hair Color:
Weight: Eye Color:
Height: Sector/Beat: /BC04
Address: 2936 NORTHWAY DR 304 BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTAE b410
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 503-3888
Phone Type 2:
Phone# 2: Ext 2:
EmployerlSchool:
Occupation:
Page 2 of 4
P���cea b���ato Incident Report
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:12
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N i
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 It1Cid@Ilt NUt11beP: BC07-002280
I (763) 569-3333
Narratives
Narrative Type: SYNOPSIS
Entered Date/Time: 04/30/2007 19:43
Subject: SYNOPSIS Author: GRUENIG, TONY
This case involves an execution of a narcotic search warrant at the residence of 2936 Northway Drive #304,
Brookiyn Center.
I
I
�I
I
1 Page 4 of 4
Printed by: bc114to �nCldent Rep01�
Printed dateltime: 5/9/07 14:12
BROOKLYN CENTER POLfCE DEPT
645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 111CId@11t NU111b@I': BC07-002280
(763) 569-3333
The ecstacy tablets in the 5coa1 container was recovered by myselt and property inventoried on scene.
Michael Stephen Haug was transported to the Brooklyn Center Police Department by Hennepin County Sheriff
Deputies assisting in the Violent Crimes detail where he was booked, fingerprinted and photographed. While at
the police department, I did interview Michael Haug and read him his rights per Miranda. This was audio and
video taped. The following will be his paraphrased statement. I did read him all of his rights, he understood all of
his rights and he did agree to speak with me. Michael said he was sitting on a couch and heard knocking on the
door and then a loud bang. He stated he stood up and could not remember what happened after that and never
remembered being handcuffed. Michael stated repeatedly he was under the influence of a controlled substance
but would not tell me what the controlled substance was. I asked Michael what the last thing was that he
remembered; he stated that he was sitting on a couch trying to figure out something about insurance when he
heard a loud bang and then blacked out but then remembers being on the couch again. I asked Michael if he
remembered throwing the Scoal can out of the patio door onto the ground outside; he did not remember that as he
blacked out on that incident. I asked Michael if his fingerprints would be on the Scoal can; he said that his
fingerprints would not be the only one on there. When I asked Michael if his DNA would be on the Scoal can, he
became argumentative and uncooperative at that point.
A�I of the evidence which were recovered by other detectives at the scene were turned over to me at the scene.
Please see their supplemental reports for additional details. I did take these items and property inventoried them
at the Brooklyn Center Police Department in locker #6.
It should be noted that the probable cause I used to obtain the search warrant was a confidential reliable informant
or CRI who obtained Michael Haug's cell phone that being 651-788-2306. The CRI called Michael and met him in
front of his apartment that being 304 where Michael served or sold narcotics to the CRI. Michael also gave the
CRI his cell phone number that being 651-788-2306 the phone which was found on or near his possession and
which Michael readily admits was his phone.
No further information at this time.
GRUEN
Ja U
Sianatures
Reporting O�cer Date
Date
Supervisor
I'�`
Page 1 of 8
Printed by: bc114to �nCldent R@pOrt
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:11
ROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 cident Number: BC07-002203
In
(763) 569-3333
Incident Summary,
ARRE
ST
Report Type.
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) SectorlBeat: /BC04
Inc Occurred Acidress: 2830 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55430 Report Taken:
Inc Occurred Start: 04/21/2007 22:45 Inc Occurred End: Substance: Y
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: Y
Reported DatelTime: 04/21/2007 22:45
Contact Nature:
Reporting Officer. GABLER, RICHARD Primary Assigned Officer:
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: ADULT ARREST
Disposition Date: 04/23/2007 15:51
Offenses
Statute Code: 609-72 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: DISTURB-DISORDERLY CONDUCT
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: MISDEMEANOR
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge#
Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3228 147 GABLER, RICHARD
Associated Events
Event Date (Start): Event Date (End): Agency:
Association: Event Type: Event#: BC
04/21 /2007 22:45:00
INCIDENT TO ARREST ARREST BC07-002203
Persons involved
Can ID Suspect: No
Person#: 0001 MNI: 3927204
Event Association: ARREST Contact Date/Time: 04/21/2007 22:45
Name: MCKINNEY, ANTONIO DEVIN Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
DOB: 01/02l1979 Age: 28 28 Sex: MALE
Height: 5' 9" 5' 9" Weight: 211 211 ibs Eye Color: BROWN
Hair Color: BLACK
Address: 2830 NORTHWAY DR 302 BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55429
Sector/Beat: 4/BC04
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 502-6656 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: OTHER Phone# 2: (763) 503-6169 Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/School:
Person Offenses,
Statute Code: 609-72 Enhancers
Statute Desc: DISTURB-DISORDERLY CONDUCT
CouMs: 1
Can ID Suspect: No
Person#: 0002 MNI: 19076086
Event Association: SUSPECT Contact DatelTime:
Name: HENRY, ARMAND LAMONT Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
DOB: 03/29/1976 Age: 31 31 Sex: MALE
Hair Color: BLACK
Height: 6' 0" 6' 0" Weight: 160 160 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN gector/Beat: 4/BC04
Address: 2834 NORTHWAY DR 302 BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 535-5917 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: UNEMPLOYED
Employer/SchooL•
I
Page 2 of 8
Printed by: bc114to Incident Report
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:11
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 Incident Number BC07-002203
(763) 569-3333
Persons Involved,
MNI: 19076085 Can ID Suspect: No
Pe
rson#: 0003
Co�tact DateiTime:
n: SUSPECT
Event
Asso
ciatio
I'
Name: FARMER, SHAVELLA T Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
MALE
1
A
e: 25 25
Sex: FE
DOB: 11/22/198 9
Weight: Eye Color: Hair Color.
Height: SectorlBeat: 4/BC04
Address: 2834 NORTHWAY DR 302 BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
763 535-5917 Ext L•
Phone# 1.
T e 1. HOME
Phone yp
Phone T e 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
i
YP
Occupation: UNEMPLOYED EmployerlSchooL•
Person#: 0004
MNi: 3928036 Can ID Suspect: No
Contact Date/Time:
Event AssociaUon. SUSPECT
Name: ELM, ERIC EMANUEL
LACK
A e: 19 19 Sex. MALE Race: B
OB: 02/
17/1988 9
D
CK
'r Color. BLA
e
Color: BROWN
Hai
s E
Ib
so so y
ht.
Height. 5 9 5' 9" We1g SectorlBeat:
OKL
YN PA
RK M
INNESOTA 55445
KENTUCKY CIR N BRO
Add
ress. 7749
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 425-5561 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
i n• O
SSE010TH EmployerlSchool:
Occu at o
p
MNI: 3947411 Can ID Suspect: No
Person#: 0005
i e.
SUSPECT
Contact DatelT m
ion
Event As
sociat
Name: JACKSON JR, ANDRE DONELL
DOB: 02/18/1987 Age: 20 20 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK
Weight: 140 160 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color. BROWN
Height: 5' 9" 5' 11" Sector/Beat:
Address: 3128 5AV S MINNEAPOLIS, MINNESOTA 55408
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (612) 822-1419 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation:
EmployerlSchooL•
Person#: 0006
MNI: 165641 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: SUSPECT Contact DatelTime:
Name: WILLIAMS, LOUIS KOREE
DOB: 12/29/1975 Age: 31 31 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK WITH HISPANIC C
Wei ht: 175 175 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
Height: 5' 9" 5' 9" g Sector/Beat:
Address: 901 2ND ST NE MINNEAPOLIS, MINNESOTA 55413
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (612) 379-7244 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: EmployerlSchooL•
i
Page 3 of 8
P��nteaby: b���4to Incident Report
Printed dateltime: 5/9/07 14:11
ROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 Incident Number: BC07-002203
(763)569-3333
Pe
rsons Invol
ved
Can ID Suspect: No
Person#: 0007 MNI: 232063
Event Association: SUSPECT Contact Date/Time:
Name: TAYLOR, SHAWN MiRTHEEZ
DOB: 11/19/1976 Age: 30 30 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK
Height: 6' 6" 6' 6" Weight: 190 190 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN
Hair Color: BLACK
Address: 1767 W 76 ST R1CHFfELD, MfNNESOTA 55423
SectorlBeat:
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/SchooL•
Printed by: bc114to �nCldent Rep01�'� Page 4 of 8
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:11
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 ItlCide�t NU117beC: BC07-002203
Modus Operandi
Against Persons: �N
Against Property: N
Occupied: N
General Premise 1:
General Premise 2:
Specific Premise:
Surrounding Area 1:
Surrounding Area 2:
Surrounding Area 3:
Relationship to Suspect 1:
Relationship to Suspect 2:
Weapon Type 1:
Automatic: N
Weapon Type 2:
Automatic: N
Weapon Type 3:
Automatic: N
Crime Against Property
of Premises Entered: Suspect Action 1:
Entry Point: Suspect Action 2:
Exit Point: Suspect Action 3:
Entry Loc 1: Suspect Action 4:
Exit Loc 1: Suspect Action 5:
Entry Loc 2: Additional Factor 1:
Exit Loc 2: Additional Factor 2:
Entry Method 1: Additional Factor 3:
Exit Method 1: Additional Factor 4:
Entry Method 2: Additional Factor 5:
Exit Method 2: Security Type:
Entry Tool 1: Victim Location:
Exit Tooi 1: Electronic Locks: N
Entry Tool 2: Video Serveillance: N
Exit Tool 2: Maid:
Vehicle Entry: Inspectress:
Safe Entry:
I Crime Against Persons
Pre-incident Contact 1: Suspect Action 1:
Pre-incident Contact 2: Suspect Action 2:
Pre-incident Contact 3: Suspect Action 3:
Victim Condition 1: Suspect Action 4:
Victim Condition 2: Suspect Action 5:
Sex Crime 1
Victim Condition 3:
Victim Condition 4: Sex Crime 2:
Victim Condition 5: Sex Crime 3:
Suspect Solicited 1: Sex Crime 4:
Suspect Solicited 2: Sex Crime 5:
Suspect Pretended to Be: Vehicle Involvement 1:
'de involvement 2:
Vehi
Printed by: bc114to �nCldent RepOrt Page 5 of 8
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:19
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
Incident Number: BC07-002203 I�
(763)569-3333
Crime Scene
Investigator: Investigation Resuits:
Photography
Black 8� White Negatives Ezposed: N
Color Negatives Exposed: N
Photography/Other:
Fingerprints
Latent Print Processing Conducted: N
Latent Fingerprints Lifted: N
Latent Palmprints Lifted: N
Latent Fingerp�int Results
Latent Palmprint Results:
Latent Prints/Other: 'i
Weapon/Projectiles
Projectiles Recovered: N
Casings Recovered: N
Cartridges Recovered: N
Weapons Recovered: N
Weaponsl0ther:
Impressions I
Footware Impressions: N
FootwarelTire Casting: N
FootwarelTire Photographed: N
Tire Impressions N
Original Footware/Tire Surface Recovered: N
Footwear/Tire Impressions/Other:
Body Fiu�ds
Blood-tike Substances Recovered: N
Body Fluid Controls: N
Body FluidslOther.
Tooimarks
Original Toolmark Surface Recovered: N
Toois Recovered: N
Toolmark Casting: N
Toolmarks/Other:
Refer to Property Report: N
Crime Scene Description:
i�
Printed by: bc114to �nCIC�@Ilt R@p01"t Page 6 of 8
Printed dateJtime: 5/9/07 14:11
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
Incident Number: BC07-002203
(763) 569-3333
Narratives
Entered DatelTime: 04/23/2007 15:05 Narrative Type: SYNOPSIS
Subject: SYNOPSIS Author: GABLER, RICHARD
On 04/21/2007 at 2245 hours, i, Gabler, was dispatched to a large fight calt in between the 2830 and 2834
Northway Drive buildings. One adult male was arrested for disorderiy conduct and was transported to special care
detox.
i
Printed by: bc114to Page 7 of 8
Incident Report
Printed date/time: 5/9l07 14:11
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
�6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 Incident Number: BC07-002203
(763) 569-3333
Entered DatelTime: 04/23/2007 15:17 Narrative Type: MA►N REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author: GABLER, RICHARD
On 04/21/07 at 2245 hours, I, Gabler, was dispatched to a fight between the 2830 and 2834 Northway Drive
buildings. Upon arrival, I did arrive from the south of the complex to watch around the back. I did arrive at the
same time on scene with Officers Mike Johnson and Deputies Pat Clark and Bill Gottwald of the Hennepin County
Sheriff's Department. I did walk around the 2802 building and then walked closer to the grassy area between the
2020 34 building. I did hear Deputy Clark yell, "Get on the ground; get on the ground". I then quickly ran to the
area between the 2830 and 2834 building. I did see an African American male running and had a bat raised over
his right shoulder as if he was possibly ready to strike somebody. I did notice several people including children
were trying to run away from the male. The male did not appear to be attempting to go after anybody in particular.
I noticed the male did kick over a small grill which did have the coals still burning and I noticed there was food on
the grill which was also knocked onto the ground. All officers then pointed their guns at the male as again he still
had the bat raised in a threatening manner. The male then, after several verbal commands to drop the bat, finally
dropped the bat. The male was then instructed to get down on his knees. 7he male paused for a few minutes
and then got down on his knees and was then instructed to get down on his stomach. Again after several verbal
commands he finally got down on his stomach. The male was then placed in handcuffs with his hands behind his
back, double locked. The male as then quickly searched. Nothing illegal was found on the male. The male then
stood up. The male was then escorted to the Hennepin County Sheriff Deputies Clark and Gottwald's squad car.
I then began speaking with the male. I could smell the strong odor of an alcoholic beverage emanating from the
male. I did observe bloodshot,`watery eyes on the male. The male then stated that he was not afraid of officers
and to take off the handcuffs so he could show us "what's up." The male was then placed in the back of the
squad car.
I identified the male as Antonio Devin MC KINNEY, DOB: 01/02/1979. I found the man to be ID only and clear of
any warrants. I then administered a preliminary breath test, Alco Sensor #055669, last calibrated on 10/27/06 by
Sgt. Frank Roth of the Brooklyn Center Police Department. The male did give an adequate sample into the PBT
and gave a reading of .159. It should be noted that I did check the male's mouth visually and vocally prior to
administering ihe preliminary breath test and found nothing in the male's mouth.
I then began speaking witfi several of the people outside by the grill area regarding the incident. They stated the
male, McKinney, had gotten into a fight with somebody else. They stated McKinney then left to go into his
apartment in the 2830 building and came out with a bat. All the grillers stated that the person he had gotten into
the fight with previously that he was presumably going after with the baseball bat had left and was no longer
present at officers' arrival. Nobody outside stated that they were threatened by the male with the bat ruling out any
possible assault charges.
I then spoke with McKinney again. McKinney stated that yes he had gotten into a fight with somebody else earlier.
He stated that the male was in the 2834 building, Apt. #302. He stated the male had braids and a white shirt. It
should be noted that I did not observe anybody matching that description outside. I did not observe any injuries or
marks on the male. McKinney stated that both he and the other male were exchanging punches. McKinney
stated he did not wish to pursue any charges on the assault by the other male. McKinney then stated that he did
wish to go to Detox.
I felt that based on the actions that I witnessed on McKinney's behavior, the fact that he had kicked over a grill and
was running around with a baseball bat in a threatening manner, that he was acting disorderly and I issued a
Hennepin County Refease Receipt for disorderly conduct. 1 explained the Hennepin County Release Receipt to
i McKinney. He acknowledged the release receipt by signing it and was given a court date of Q5/14/2007 at 0830
hours in the Division 2 courthouse, 6125 Shingle Creek Parkway. McKinney was then given a copy and was
transported to Hennepin County Medical Center Special Care where he did wish to be detoxed.
It should be noted that nobody, McKinney or anybody else outside related to the fight sustained any injuries nor did
fhey wish any medical attention and, according to everybody that I spoke with, all the witnesses, nobody said that
they felt threatened by the actions of McKinney in order to file any assault charges.
Printed by: bc114to Incident Report Pa a°f 8
Printed date/time: 5/9l07 14:11
BROOKLYN CENTER POUCE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 It1CIdellt NUFt'lbef: BC07-002203
Gabier/vc
Entered DatelTime: 04/25/2007 14:05 Narrative Type: SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT
Subject: ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Author: OLSON, TERRY
Officers with the Brooklyn Center Police Department and the Hennepin County Sheriff s Office have been working
a proactive enforcement detail with a focus on crimes of violence taking place at five locations within the city which
have been identified as representing the highest numbers of calls for service and reported crimes, particularly
crimes of violence. One of those locations is the Center Pointe Apartment Complex, located on the 2800 and
2900 blocks of Northway Drive. In the course of the detail o�cers have kept records of contacts and criminal
intelligence that has been developed.
On 04-23-2007 I reviewed those records and noted that in the course of this investigation officers had contact with
not only the arrestee, but several others he was associating with at the time of the original call. They include
HENRY, ELM, JACKSON, WILLIAMS, and TAYLOR. In the course of this investigation o�cers learned that all
are active members of the Gangster Disciples, which is a criminal organization known to have originated in
Chicago, IL. Officers leamed that the fight that took place was gang-related in that one of the participants was
attempting to leave the gang, which was the reason for the dispute initially. Through investigation HENRY was
ro ert O
ffic
ers workin the de
tail ha
ve noted a
n on the 9
r of that or a
nizatio
rankin membe P P Y
identified as the 9
9
sharp increase in gang-realted grafitti on the property recently, much of which is consistent with the Gangster 1
Disciples.
HENRY told officers that he resides with SHAVELLA FARMER at 2834 Northway Drive, #302 and is not on the
lease there. I found a previous contact involving FARMER and HENRY wherein FARMER is identified as a victim
of a 2nd degree assault and HENRY is identified as the suspect. I found another previous contact identifying both
si nts at the Northwa Drive address in 2006 and relating to child neglect.
as re de Y
I checked finding that ELM is the only of the suspects who is currently on probation and under superivison. I
Probation Officer via email, informin them of this contact.
contacted his 9
I prepared a cover letter sent to the Property Manager at the complex as those involved in the fight were the
guests and visitors of FARMER at the time of the incident and HENRY is living with FARMER but not on the
lease. Both are violations of the lease.
Siqnatures
Reporting Officer Date
Supervisor Date
i
Printed by: bc114to �11CIC�@Ilt R@p01� Page 1 of 2
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:15
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07 -002493
Incident Summarv
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: ARREST
Inc Occurred Address: 2932 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55430 Sector/Beat: 4/BC04
Inc Occurred Start: 05/05/2007 01:00 Inc Occurred End: Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported DatefTime: 05/05/2007 01:00
Reporting Officer: GABLER, RICHARD Primary Assigned Officer.
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: ADULT ARREST Disposition Date: 05/05/2007 19:08
Offenses
Statute Code: 609-605-1-B-4 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: TRESPASSING-BUILDING OR DWELLING
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: MISDEMEANOR
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3228 147 GABLER, RIGHARD
Associated Events
Association: Event Type: Event#: Event Date (Start): Event Date (End): Agency:
ARREST TO INCIDENT ARREST BC07-002493 05/05I2007 01:00:00 BC
CITATION TO INCIDENT CITATION BC07-000004675 05/05/2007 01:00:00 BC
Persons Invoived
Person#: 0001 MNI: 19164121 Can ID Suspect: Yes
Event Association: MENTIONED Contact DatelTime: 05/05/2007 01:00
Name: BROWN, HERBERT EARL
DOB: 05/09/1985 Age: 21 21 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
Height: Weight: Eye Color: Hair Color:
Address: Sector/Beat:
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/School:
Person#: 0002 MNI: 19136491 Can tD Suspect: No
Event Association: ARREST Contact Date/Time: 05/05/2007 01:00
Name: HARPER, DANIEL DOMINIC
DOB: OS/10/1985 Age: 21 21 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
Height: 5' 10" 5' 10" Weight: 165 165 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
Address: 8331 NEVADA AV N BROOKLYN PARK, MINNESOTA 55445 Sector/Beat:
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/School:
Person Offenses
Statute Code: 609-605-1-B-4 Enhancers
Statute Desc: TRESPASSING-BUILDING OR DWELLING
Counts: 1
Printed by: bc114to Incident Report Pa 2°f 2
Printed dateltime: 5/9/07 14:15
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-002493
Narratives
Entered DatelTime: 05/05/2007 18:54 Narrative Type: SYNOPSIS
Subject: SYNOPSIS Author: GABLER, RICHARD
On 05/05/07 at 0100 hours I, Gabler, stopped the suspected trespasser in the parking lot of Cub Foods. I arrested
one aduit male for trespassing.
Entered DatelTime: 05/05/2007 18:56 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author: GABLER, RICHARD
On 05/05/07 at 0100 hours I, Gabler, was driving through Northway Drive and I observed two males walking to the
Center Pointe apartment complex at 2932 Northway Drive on Center Pointe apartment property. I recognized one
of the males as being Daniel Dominic HARPER whom I have arrested on prior occasions for trespassing at Center
Pointe apartment complex. I stopped the person whom I believed to be Harper and his friend at the Cub Foods
h other male as
parking lot. I did identify bne of the males as being Dominic Harper (dob 08/10/85). I identified t e
Herbert Earl BROWN (dob 05/09/85). Both males were clear of warrants. I did check with the Station Service
Officer who was working at the Brooklyn Center Police Department. She did confirm that there was an active
trespass notice on file trespassing Harper from Center Pointe apartment complex.
Harper was issued a Hennepin County Citation (Citation #5070004675) for misdemeanor trespassing. There I,
were no charges for Harper's friend-Brown. Harper was given a copy o f t he ci ta tion an d w a s a d v i s e d t o c a l l t h e
number on the citation to set up a Division 2 court date or to arrange a way for him to pay the fine. Harper was
then reieased on scene.
GABLER
Ja 05/05/07
Siqnatures
Reporting Officer Date
Supervisor Date
l
Printed by: bc114to Incident Report Pa °f 2
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:04
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 II1CId@Ilt NUfTIb@Y: BC07-001980
Incident Summary
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: ARREST
Inc Occurred Address: 2932 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55429 Sector/Beat: 4/BC04
Inc Occurred Start: Inc Occurred End: Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported Date/Time: 04/11/2007 19:50
Reporting Officer: GABLER, RICHARD Primary Assigned Officer.
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: ADULT ARREST Disposition Date: 04/12l2007 09:10
Offenses
Statute Code: 609-605-1-8-4 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: TRESPASSING-BUILDING OR DWELLING
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: MISDEMEANOR
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3228 147 GABLER, RICHARD
Associated Events
Association: Event Type: Event#: Event Date (Start): Event Date (End): Agency:
ARREST TO INCIDENT ARREST BC07-001980 BC
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 19136491 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: ARREST Contact DatelTime: 04/11/2007 19:50
Name: HARPER, DANIEL DOMINIC
DOB: 08/10/1985 Age: 21 21 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
Height: 5' 7" 5' 7" Weight: 140 140 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
Address: 2327 IRVING AV S MINNEAPOLIS, MINNESOTA 55411 Sector/Beat:
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 566-1164 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: CELL Phone# 2: �'612) 518-5190 Ext 2:
Occupation: UNEMPLOYED Employer/SchooL•
Person Offenses
Statute Code: 609-605-1-B-4 Enhancers:
Statute Oesc: TRESPASSING-BUILDING OR DWELLING
Counts: 1
Businesses Involved
Business 0001
Event Association:
Business Name: CENTER POINTE APARTMENTS Business Type: APARTMENTS
Address: 2932 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55429 SectorfBeat: 4BC04
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Printed by: bc114to ncident Report Pa 2°f z
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:04
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 I
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-001980
Narratives
Entered DatelTime: 04/12/2007 09:10 Narrative Type: SYNOPSIS
Subject: SYNOPSIS Author: GABLER, RICHARD
On 4/11/07 at 1950 hours, I, Officer Gabler, was doing a Walk Through at the 2930 Northway Drive building where
I
I arrested one adult male for Trespassing.
Entered DatelTime: 04/12/2007 09:11 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author: GABLER, RICHARD
On 4/11/07 at 1950 hours, I, Officer Gabler, was working a Violent Crimes Task Force which focuses on violent
crimes, narcotics dealing, and assault in the City of Brooklyn Center. The Center Pointe apartment complex is one
of the main focal points of this detail based on its high call volume, robberies, narcotics activities, and assaults. I
was working with Hennepin County Sheriff's Office Deputies Gottwaldt and Clark, who were in uniform and I was
in plain clothes. 'i
The Deputies and I walked in the south door of the 2932 Northway Drive building where I immediately smelled an
odor of ma�ijuana in the lobby area. I walked up to the second floor for a Walk Through and I recognized a male
knocking on one of the apartment doors as the male I previously Trespassed from Center Pointe. I recognized
him as Daniel Dominic Harper, 9/10/85, and instructed him to walk toward
me. I asked him if he kn
ew he had
been Trespassed and he stated yes. I asked what he was doing back on the property and he stated he was
thin ille al on him. I verified
not find an
tt him down and did g g
irthda a
.I u
ickl
a ed Y
attendin his cousm s b y p rty q y p
9
Har er in handcuffs with his
which ex ires 4/4/08. I laced
there was an active Trespass Order on file for Harper, p P P
hands behind his back and gapped and double locked the handcuffs before I placed him in the back of the squad
car and issued him a Tab Charge for Trespass with a court date of 5/7/07. He signed the Tab Charge and
a co rior to be
in escorted from the ro ert
received P Y
PY P 9
P
Harper has been arrested at Center Pointe for Robbery. He is not listed on a lease at this complex.
No further
Gabler/km 4/12/07
Si4natures
Reporting Officer Date
Supervisor Date
C�
Printed by: bc114to ��'1CIC�@Clt R@pOrt Page 1 of 2
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:03
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 ItlCldeflt NU�flb@Y: BC07-001960
Incident Summarv
Incident Type: CRIMINAI. OFFENSE(S) Report Type: ARREST
Inc Occurred Address: 2834 NORTHWAY DR LOT BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55430 Sector/Beat: 4/BC04
Inc Occurred Start: 04/10/2007 21:17 inc Occurred End: Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported Date/Time: 04/10/2007 21:17
Reporting Officer: GABLER, RICHARD Primary Assigned Officer:
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: ADULT ARREST/FORMAL COMPLAINT Disposition Date: 04l11l2007 15:38
Offenses
Statute Code: 609-605-1-B-4 Enhancers
Statute Desc: TRESPASSING-BUILDING OR DWELLING
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: MISDEMEANOR
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING O�FiCER 3228 147 GABLER, RICHARD
BACK-UP 3219 142 PETERS, BRIAN
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 19026186 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: ARREST Contact DatefTime: 04/10/2007 21:17
Name: KIMBA, PATRICK SAMAH
DOB: 10l05/1985 Age: 21 21 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
Height: 5' 5" 5' 6" Weight: 145 154 ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
Address: 5806 EMERSON AV N BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 Sector/Beat: 1/BC01
Phone 1'ype 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 566-3241 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/SchooL•
Person Offenses
Statute Code: 609-605-1-B-4 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: TRESPASSING-BUILDiNG OR DWELLING
Counts: 1
Businesses Involved
Business 0001
Event Association:
Business Name: CENTER POINTE Business Type: APARTMENTS
Address: 2834 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, Sector/Beat: BC04
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Printed by: bc114to Page 2 of 2
Incident Report
Printed dateltime: 5/9/07 14:03
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-001960
Narratives
Entered DatelTime: 04/11/2007 15:24 Narrative Type: SYNOPSIS
Subject: SYNOPSIS Author: GABLER, RICHARD
I
On 04/10/07 at 2117 hours, I, Gabler, approached a possible trespassing suspect at 2834 Northway Dr. I arrested
one adult male for trespassing.
Entered Date/Time: 04/11/2007 15:25 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Sub'ect:
MAiN REPO
RT Author: GABLER, RICHARD
J
On 04/10/07 at 2117 hours, I, Gabler, was doing a walk-through of the Center Pointe Apartments, the 2834
building. l was working plain clothes, along with Officer Brian Peters, and I was working a Violent Crimes Task
Force. I did have my badge around my neck to identify myself as a police officer. I then noticed the male walk
through the front door of the 2834 Northway Dr. building. I recognized the male as being trespassed previously
from the Center Pointe Apartment complex. I identified myself again as a police officer to the male and asked the
male for his identification. I identified the male as Patrick Samah KIMBA, DOB 10/05/85. I then for o�cer safety
purposes patted Kimba down and found nothing illegal on Kimba's person. I did a warrant check of Kimba, finding
him to be clear of warrants. I then contacted the Brooklyn Center Station Service O�cer, who was working the
front desk at the Brooklyn Center Police Department. t asked the Station Service Officer if there was an active
n Se
rvice O
�cer
te A artment com lex. The
Statio
n file tres assin Patrick Kimba from the Center Poin p p
trespass o p 9
itin Kimba from bein at the Center Pointe
was an active tres ass on file, prohib g 9
then stated to me that there p
ued on 03/28/07 and was
as advised that the Notice and Order of trespassing
was iss
Apartment complex. I w k. I a ed and
behind his bac
cuffs.
I han
dcuffed his hands 9 Pp
active unt�l 03/28/08. I then p
laced K
imba in hand
double-locked the handcuffs and I transported him out to a marked squad car. I then issued a Hennepin County
Release-Receipt for trespassing. I gave Kimba a Division II Court date of 04/30/07 at 0830 hours at the Division U
Court Nouse, 6125 Shingle Creek Pkwy. I explained the Release-Receipt to Kimba. I then removed the handcuffs
from behind Kimba's back. Kimba acknowledged the Release-Receipt by signing it and was given a copy of his
Release-Receipt. Kimba was then transpo�ted across the street to the transit hub at 2900 Co. Rd. 10.
i
Gabler/ss
04/11 /07
i
Sianatures I
Reporting Officer Date
Supervisor Date
h
F
Printed by: bc114to IIICICI@11t R@pOP'� Page 1 of 4
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:58
BROOKLYN CENTER POUCE DEPT
645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 ItlCide�t Nul'Ylb@P: BC07 -001520
Incident Summarv
Incident Type: ACCIDENT Report Type: ACCIDENT
Inc Occurred Address: 2900 NORTHWAY DR LOT LOT BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55429 Sector/Beat: 4iBC04
Inc Occurred Start: 03/22/2007 21:25 Inc Occurred End: 03/22/2007 21:25 Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported DatefTime: 03l2212007 21:25
Reporting O�cer. PEARSON, MONA Primary Assigned O�cer:
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: ASSISTED/ADVISED Disposition Date: 03/23l2007 13:37
Offenses
Statute Code: ACPDPD
Enhancers:
Statute Desc: ACC-POLICE PROPERTY DAMAGE
Counts: 1 Statute Severiry:
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3209 029 PEARSOPI, MONA
List of Attachments
T Report ID: Report Date: Report 5ummary:
OTHER LAW ENFORCEMENT AGENCY REF State Accident Report
Persons Invoived
Person#: 0001 MNI: 19151165 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: DRIVER Contact DatelTime: 03/22/2007 21:25
Name: NELSON, PATRICK IVAN
DOB: 10113i1965 Age: 41 41 Sex: MALE Race:
Height: Weight: Eye Color: Hair Color:
Address: 325 MAIN ST ANOKA, MINNESOTA 55303 SectodBeat:
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: EmployerlSchool: ANOKA
Person#: 0002 MNI: 3951292 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association• DRIVER Contact Date/Time: 03/22/2007 21:25
Name: GRUENIG, TONY LEE
DOB: 07/21/1973 Age: 33 33 Sex: MALE Race: WHITE
Height: Weight: Eye Color: Hair Color.
Address: 6645 HUMBOLDT AV N BRQOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 SectorlBeat: 2/BCO2
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: WORK Phone# 2: (763) 569-3333 Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/School: BCPD
I Page 2 of 4
F� Printed by: bc114to Incident Report
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:58
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number BCOT -001520
Vehicles Involved
Vehicle#: 0001
Event Assoc: ACCIDENT Vehicle Status:
Vehicle Type: A Year: Make: FORD Model: EXPEDITION
VIN: License#: UNP6S9 State: MN Expires On:
Style: SUV Prim Color: BLACK Sec Color: Ter Color.
Status Dt/Tm: Status Value: Recovered Date: Recovered Value:
NCIC Date: NCtC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Cancelled:
Vehicle#: 0002
Event Assoc: ACCIDENT Vehicle Status:
IERRA
CORP
Model: S
ENERAL MOTORS
ke. G
Vehicle Type. A Year. 2005
Ma
VIN: License#; UNP568 State: MN Expires On:
Style: PICKUP Prim Color: BLUE Sec Color: Ter Color:
Status Dt/Tm: Status Value: Recovered Date: Recovered Value:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Canceiled: I i
Narratives
Entered DatelTime: 03/23/2007 13:29 Narrative Type: NOTE
Subject: NOTE Author: PEARSON, MONA
See State Accident Report
Entered Date/Time: 03/23/2007 15:28 Narrative Type: SYNOPSIS
Subject: SYNOPSIS
Author: GRUENIG, TONY
ein stru
ck b another unmarked olice vehicle.
k d olice vehicle b P
ves m u
nmar e
This case invol 9 Y
Y P
I
�I
Printed by: bci14to �nCIC�@Ilt R@p01� Page 3 of 4
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:58
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
B 07-001520
763 569-3333
Incident Number. C
1
Entered DatelTime: 03/23/2007 15:29 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author: GRUENIG, TONY
On 3/22/O7 I, Officer Gruenig, was working in a plain-clothes, unmarked capacity in my unmarked 2005 GMC
Sierra pickup, license plate UNP568. In this capacity I was trying to apprehend a suspect wanted for the sale of
cocaine.
While doing so I was traveling eastbound on No�thway Drive in the eastbound lane. I was approaching the 2900
block almost directly out in front of the 2900 building of Northway Drive. As I was doing so, Detective Pat Nelson
in his unmarked police vehic(e, that being a 2002 Ford Expedition, UNP689, was traveling in reverse eastbound in
the westbound lane. As t met and went past Detective Nelson, he backed his vehicle up into the eastbound lane,
striking my vehicle in the right driver's side quarter panel directly above the rear driver's side tire. It caused a white
mark on my quarter panel and a very small dent.
I was actively trying to pursue a suspect who was fleeing on foot from us at the time, and therefore did not stop. I
was not injured in any way. I assisted and completed the task of apprehending the suspect, taking him into
custody. Detective Nelson and I then checked our vehicles for the extent of the damage.
I then contacted sergeant Pearson immediately after the suspect was taken into custody and the extent of the
damage was revealed to me. I advised her of the situation and gave her the necessary information. I afso took
photographs of my vehicle, as well as Detective Pat Nelson's vehicle. Neither of us was injured in any way. This
is all the in�ormation I have at this time.
Gruenig/bg
03/23/07
Printed by: bc114to IIICIC�@Ilt R@p01� Page 4 of 4
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:58
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 f
(763) 569-3333 Incident Numbe� BC07-001520
Entered Date/Time: 03/23/2007 15:30 Narrative Type: SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT
Subject: SUPP1 MP 03/23/07 0045 Author: PEARSON, MONA
On 03-22-07, I was notified by DTF O�cer Gruenig that he as well as other DTF Officers had been in the area of
the 2900 building of Northway Drive in Brooklyn Center, MN in reference to a controlled substance buy. Officer
Gruenig stated that during the incident the suspect ran through the apartment complex and that he and other DTF
O�cers were attempting to catch him. Officer Gruenig stated that he was traveling eastbound on Northway Drive
in front of the 2900 building towards the fleeing suspect. He stated that DTF Officer Patrick Nelson who was
driving UNP-689 had his vehicle facing westbound on Northway Drive in front of the 2900 No►thway Drive building.
Officer Nelson put his car in reverse to head eastbound also towards the fleeing suspect at which time his vehicle
and Officer Gruenig's vehicle collided. Officer Gruenig described the damage as very minimal and consisting of
damage to his GMC Sierra, license plate UNP-568, located in the rear portion consisting of several scrapes. He
further described the damage to the Ford Expedition, license UNP-689, as a broken taillight in the rear left quarter
paneL
I learned that DTF Officers were busy at the time as well as myself at the original time of the accident. I did speak
with Officer Gruenig via telephone regarding the accident to get the information. O�cer Gruenig stated that he
would be able to take photographs of both of vehicles as well as complete an ICR report. I did complete a State
Accident Report as well as faxed the information over to the Brooklyn Center Finance Department. See Officer
Gruenig's report for further information.
Pearson/re ;''I
03-23-07
Sianatures
Reporting Officer Date
Supervisor Date
'r�
Page 1 of 5
Printed by: bc114to Incident Report
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:59
OOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
45 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 Incident Number: BC07-001546
(763) 569-3333
Incident SummarN
Report Type: CHILD NEGLECT
Incident Type: CRIM�NAL OFFENSE(S) SectorlBeat: /BC04
Inc Occurred Address: 2932 NORTHWAY DR 103 BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55430 Re ort Taken:
Inc Occurred Start: 03/23/2007 20:07 Inc Occurred End: 03/23/2007 22:10 Substance: U
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U
Reported DatelTime: 03/23/2007 20:07
Contact Nature:
Reporting Officer: GABLER, RICHARD Primary Assigned Officer:
Case Status: CLOSED
Disposition: REFERRED TO OTHER AGENCY Disposition Date: 03/29/2007 23:59
Offenses
Statute Code: 609-378-1 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: FAMILY OFFENSE-CHILD NEGLECT
Counts 1 Statute Severity: GROSS MISDEMEANOR
Officers
Squad#
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3228 147 GABLER, RICHARD
BACK-UP 3219 142 PETERS, BRIAN
INVESTIGATOR 3217 111 KONCAR, BILL
�ersons Involved
Person#: 0001
MNI: 19153078 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: VICTIM Contact DatelTime: 03/23/2007 20:07
Name: Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
DOB: 03/05/2002 Age: 5- 5 Sex: MALE
Wei ht Eye Color: Hair Color:
Height: g Sector/Beat: /BC04
Address:
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 561-0530 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: EmployerlSchool:
Can ID Suspect: No
Person#: 0002 MNI: 18954462
Event Association: PARENT/GUARDIAN
Contact Date/Time: 03J23/2007 22:10
Name: Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
DOB: 03/07/1976 Age: 31 31 Sex: MALE
Height: 5' 9" 5' 9" Weight: 200 200 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN
Hair Color: BLACK
Sector/Beat: BG04
Address
Phone Type 1: HQME Phone# 1: (763) 561-0530 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/School:
Person Offenses
Statute Code: 6�9-378-1 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: FAMILY OFFENSE-CHILD NEGLECT
COURfS: 1
Page 2 of 5
Printed by: bc114to Incident Report
Printetl dateltime: 5/9/07 13:59
'ROOKLYN CENTER POUCE DEPT
45 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 ItlCldetlt NUt71beC: BC07-001546
(763) 569-3333
PePSOIIS �t1VO�V@d, Can ID Suspect: No
Person#: 0003 MNI: 18953750
Event Association: PARENT/GUARDIAN
Contact Date/Time: 03/23/2007 22:10
Name:
DOB: 12/15/1978 Age: 28 28 Sex: FEMALE Race: BLACK WITH HISPANIC
Hair Color:
Height: 5' 4" 5' 4" Weight: 165 165 Ibs Eye Color. BROWN Sector/Beat: /BC04
Address
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 561-0530 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2:
Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Employer/School:
Occupation:
Person Offenses
Enhancers:
Statute Code: 609-37&1 ,I
Statute Desc: FAMILY OFFENSE-CHILD NEGLECT
Counts: 1
Businesses Invoived
Business 0001
Event Association: LOCATION Business Type: APARTMENTS
Business Name: CENTER POINTE APARTMENTS Sector/Beat: 4BC04
OKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55429
s. 2932 NORTHWAY DR BRO
Addres
hone T e
Phone# 1: Ext 1:
P Yp
Phone Type 2:
Phone#'2: fxt 2.
Narratives
Narrative Type: SYNOPSIS
Entered Date/Time: 03/29/2007 23:59 GABLER, RICHARD
Subject: SYNOPSIS
Author:
On 03123/07, at 2007 hours, I, Officer Gabier, was dispatched to 2920 Northway Drive regarding a found c
hitd.
The parents and child were later reunited.
Page 3 of 5
Pr;�ted by: b���4to InCidertt Report
Printed dateltime: 519/07 13:59
OKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
45 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 Incident Number: BC07-001546
(763} 569-3333
Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Entered DatelTime: 03/30/2007 00:00 Author: GABLER, RICHARD
Subject: MAIN REPORT
On 03/23/07, at 2007 hours, I, Officer Gabler, a tmentp o eex and was observed bang ng doors a cryi in
found wandering around the Center Pointe ap P
din
the hallway in the 2920 buil g
Upon arrival I met with the reporting party who stated that he had found a five-year-old child whom he had seen
walking around the apartment complex and then observed banging on apartment doors in the 2920 building and
ockin on his apartment in the 2920 building.
stated that he had been kn g
The reporting party stated that there was the ct�i dh I ob e ed tha�t ch Id d'd pp a to beea'ppeoximately 5293
2
building, I then met with I first observed
years old. He stated that his birthday was March 5,
2002 and stated that his name was
a ear
ed to be nervous and scared. t observed that he had mismatching shoes. hey were also of
t the child
tha PP were both left-footed shoes.
differe
nt sizes and had no shoe laces and
I asked the child where his parents were. He stated that he did not kn knocked fosapp oxemately 5 to min�ut��
then walked me into the 2932 building and pointed t
on the door and did not get anybodyen walked out de of the 2932 building and observed that the n�dows to
found that door was locked. I th
ere dark suggesting that nobody was home.
I then saw other people in the building and a eceatl h and stat thaWth se n the fest time ch Id's been
stated that they had not seen them around r y
locked out of his apartment. They stated that this happens quite often and even on occasion they have seen the
child sleeping in the hallway of the 2932 building.
I then asked the child if he had any other friends in the build�{hen walked me ove� o 2802 bu Id ng an up to a
friend on the other end of the complex. The child,
where he stated that this was where his friend stayed at. then began knocking on that door,
however, found that there was nobody home. I knocked on the door for approximately 5 to 10 minutes with no
response from anybody in the apartment.
I walked outside and looked up on the third floor where I believed
windows to be and observed
that all the lights in the apartment were off, suggesting that nobody was home.
I then walked back with the child to the 2932 building, knocked on ts ca d fo�the pa�rents to call Brooklyn utes
and observed that nobody came to the door. I then left my busmes
Center Police Department when they should return home.
I then transported �o the Brooklyn Center Police Department to wait with the station service officer until
the parents called looking for the child. The nd he the calal went back to the 2932 bup di�g and began
hours after my initial contact with
knocking on r� Again I found that the door was locked and upon knocking on the door for
a roximately 5 to 10 mmutes there was nobody answering the door and the apartment lights, upon viewing the
PP
apartment windows from the outside of the building, were still off.
this time I had seen several more neighbors who also appeared to have a growing concern for the child. These
At
other neighbors, who were different fro com le xu bsuperv sed by ny or guardians several t mes and had
child just walking around the apartment p
observed him locked out of his apartment. None of them stated that they had ever seen him s►eepmg rn the
hallway but again that they had seen him unsupervised several times.
�,-ho�kP�i with Hennepin County dispatch and was informed that still nobody had called regarding Douglas being
Page 4 of 5
Pr��ted b b���4to Incident Report
Printed dateltime: 5/9/07 13:59
�ROOKLYN CENTER POUCE DEPT
,45 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 IllCideflt NUtTlbel': BC07-00154
(763) 569•3333
missing. Upon turther speaKing with the neighbors they stated that the parenYs vehicle was outside. They stated
that it was a white SUV. I began checking the white SUV in the parking lot of the 2920 building to make sure that
there was nobody unconscious or any medical problems with anybody inside the vehicle. I obse�ved that the
vehicle was unattended.
As I was looking in the window two people then walked up to me and asked what I was doing The fem I
advised them that I was a police officer and asked them if they were the p s�ets of id ntified the female as
that she was mother and the male stated that he was They stated
nd I identified the ste -dad as
tha ey a so did live at
I asked them where their son was. They stated that they had at the Brookl n Center Police Department and a
don't know where he is currently. I advised them that he was Y
concerned resident had called because Was wandering around the apartment complex. They stated that
this should not be the case because they dropped him off at a friend's house in the apartment complex.
I advised them that if that was the case then there was a misco 2802 bu Iding and nobody was home there d any
of �friends and we did check out one apartment m the
I then explained to both �and �that this was not right because if whoever was watching their kid left
they should have picked up their child or somehow have been a e�don'gea ve our kid w h Am people and
child. responded, "well, we're not too worried because the name of the person they had left him with
we trus who we had left him with." I asked both �and�
and they stated that they did not know the name.
Neither. parent appeared to be concerned about tme lext I then asked both parentspol'showpmetwhere they had
found wandering the Center Pointe apartment co p ust walked into her
taken �to be watched while they went out and ran errands. I noticed that
apartment in the 2932 building and did not ai to speak with the people whom she ha left her child with. She
did not appear to be bothered by the fact a
It
should
b
e no
te
d that the 2802
Kamara walked over to the 2802 building and began buzzing had walked us over
building, was the apartment that officers had checked and that when
there stating that this was his friend's house and at 2007 hours nobody was i�� d g on the door
answered the buzzer. Upon entering the building and going up to�
nobody answered the door either.
I asked �the name of the peop �name of the a ers e on t whom 'I hey had left chad h� I asked i they had
be noted that neither parent knew the P
any phone numbers for this person. They stated no, that they did not.
ry g g middle name. He stated that it was
I was t in to et full information. I asked �or
however, he did not know how to spell his step child's middle name. He stated that his last name was
I asked him for his step-child's date-of-birth and he did not know his own step-child's date-of-birth and
ppeared to have very limited information about his own step-son.
I then advised to follow Officer Peters, who was ho Wta�g ml waiting w'th the s at ce offi�er at the
Center Police epartment so he could pick up S W
Brooklyn Center Police Department.
out to the lobby. Immediately before
Upon arrival at the Brook�yn Center Police Department I brought or leavin the eo le who were babysitting him
asking if he was okay�began blaming� g p p eared to
and wa ing around the apartment complex and began ing im to never do that again p �g out
have very little, if any, concern for his S atphe n olice I depar9me n app aeed to be when he found out that
to his step-dad he seemed very happy p
he had to go back to his parents.
to
th
e Bro
okl n Center Police Department to pick up her child
did no
t o Y
r 9 ad
mothe ste d
that the of his p
It should be noted over into the custodv
..,,�o +h�t hA� �n��c� was safe and okav. I then tumed
Page 5 of 5
Printed by: bc114to �nC�dent Rep�rt
ted dateltime: 519/07 13:59
OOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
45 HUMBOLDT AVE N
r3ROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
Incident Number: BC07-001546
(763} 569-333
�and they both left the Brooklyn Center Police Department. as found wandering in is one of
It should be noted that the Center Pointe apartment complex in which the child w
centrated areas in Brooklyn Center for crime, specifically violent crimes such as robbe arou d�
the highest con ear-old child to be walking
assaults as well as drug trafficking and is an overall unsafe place for a 5-y o should be
es de artment, specifically the child protection division for further
I also filled out a suspected chitd maltreatment report form which is included with this report. This rep
forwarded to the Hennepin County human servic p
follow up•
Gabler
pr 03/29/07
Sianatures
Date
Reporting Officer
Date
Supervisor
Page 1 of 4
Printed by: bc114to �C1CIC�ellt RepOrt
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:00
RROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT 3
i45 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 111CIdetlt NUt17beC: BC07-00166
(763) 569-3333
�i1CIC�@Ilt $UIl'lillal"'�f Report Type: JUVENILE ARREST
CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Sector/Beat: 5/BC54
ent T e: ER MN 554
Inc►d yp
urred Address: 2900 CO RD 10 MTC TRANSIT STA7ION BROOKLYN CENT Report Taken:
Inc
Occ
ed Start: 03/28/2007 20:07 Inc Occurred End. Substance: U
Occurr d: U
e
inc �lat
G
an Re
Bias Motivat�on: g
Domestic: N Reported DatelTime: 03/28/2007 20.07
Contact Nature: primary Assigned O�cer:
Reporting Officer: GABLER, RICHARD Disposition Date: 03/2912007 12:03
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: JUVENILE ARREST
Offenses Enhancers:
Statute Code: 19-201
Statute Desc: LOITERING
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: MISDEMEANOR
Officers squad#
vent
As
so
ciation
Emp# Badge# Name
E D
14
7
GABLER, RICHA
R
2
8
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 32 pETERS, BRIAN
BACK-UP
3219 142
Associated Events, Age��y:
Event Date (Start): Event Date (End):
Association: Event Type: Event#: gC
03/28/2007 20:07:00
INCIDENT TO ARREST ARREST BC07-001668
Persons Involved, ca„ sUSpe�c: Yes
Person#: 0001 MNI: 19152864
Contact DatelTime: 03l28/2007 20:25
Event Association: PARENT/GUARDIAN
Name: HARRIS, CYNTHIA Age: Sex: FEMALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
DOB: Hair Color:
Weight: Eye Color:
Height: Sector/Beat: /CY08
Address: 5608 VERA CRUZ AV N CRYSTAL, MINNESOTA 55427 Ext 1:
eT
e 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 537-9086
Phon yp xt 2:
E
0
ne T
e 2:
Phone# 2.
Ph p
I
Y
Em loye
r/Sch
00
I:
P
Occupation:
Can ID Suspect: No
Person#: 0002 MNI: 18963562
Event Association: JUVENILE ARREST
Contact DatelTime: 03/28/2007 20:25
Name: qge: 15 15 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
01/09/1992 BLACK
DOB lor.
BROWN
Hair Co
Weight: 160 160 Ibs Eye Color.
Height: 5' 9" 5' 9" Sector/Beat: /CY08
Address: Ext 1:
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 537-9086
Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Phone Type 2:
EmployerlSchooi: TASK
Occupation: 8TH GRADER
Person Offenses Enhancers:
Statute Code: 19-201
Statute Desc: LOITERING
Counts: 1
Page 2 of 4
Printed by: bcl�4to �t1CIC�etlt RepOt�
Printed dateltime: 5/9/07 14:00
�OOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
;45 HUMBOLD7 AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 Incident Number: BC07-001668
(763) 569-3333
Narratives,
Narrative Type: SYNOPSIS
Entered DatelTime: 03/29/2007 10:51 Author: GABLER, RICHARD
Subject: SYNOPSIS
On 03/28/07 at 2025 hours, I, Gabler, stopped a suspicious male on a bike in front of 2920 Northway Drive. I
arrested one juvenile male for Lurking with Intent.
Page 3 of 4
Printed by: bc114to Incident Report
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:00
4ROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
i45 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 �nCldetlt NU11lbe1': BC07-00166
{763)569-333
Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Entered DatelTime: 03/29/2007 10:53 Author. GABLER, RICHARD
Subject: MAIN REPORT
On 03/28/07 at 2025 hours, I, Gabler, was in an unmarked Brooklyn Ce'a nr othes acti e o I
was sitting in the parking lot of NAPA and Pizza Hut. I was working a p P
detail which focuses on robberies and other violent assaults. ve assaults n the city of B ooklyn Center. I was
surveying, was one of the top five hot spots for robbenes and
monitoring the 2920 building which has rea k t �ants and black z p up hood sweatshirt on a dark coloeed I
African American male with a black hat, d p
observed the male bike from on front of the e9Wa Noo n t go back and bike across Northway Dr� e00
Co. Rd. #10. I observed the male bike all th y
and bike around the 2920 Northway D�h�au��Dr e back to he at 2900 Co. Rd #10t� ob erved he
anywhere bike across back across. No y
for a second time bike all the way arou� Henne in County S�eriff's Depu�es CL d HAGEN who were fa a
the bus hub for a second time, I advise p
Hennepin County Sheriff s Deputies squad car and were in police uniform of the suspicious activity. I advise
them to co
me in the area and assist in making a stop as they were in a marked car.
They did stop the male in front of the 2920 building after he had crossed Northway Drive for a third time. After•
the had made the stop, I then began speaking with the male. The malh d have al i� of P�k
y
DOB: 01/09/1992. He did not have an ID with him, however,
w ic i bear his name. The items were various suspensions from h� Stated to me that he d d ha �e BB gun I in
his name on it. Upon doing a pa t s e arch for wea pons of as laced in handcu ffs wi t h his h a nds
his front pocket. I did remove a sitver colored gun. Imme ia e y P
behind his back. I gapped and double �e ed that the gun at the tim I d d not know if i�s eal or fakea It did 9
further illegal on his person. It should b
not appear to have any markings which Wo Wei b hin�i in hand a�ealB a dgun and was shaped like athing
else. The handgun did have the feel upon g 9
handgun. It did have a slide on. d�the rna azine f omahe handle of the gun and foundbhat t ere was h ng
a h a m m e r b e h i n d t h e s l i d e. I r e m o 9
in the magazine. The magazine did have the texture and the hand or 9n the maga ine i t h t h a t o f a r e al firearm.
Again, I did not observe any live rounds in the chamber of 9
U on speaking with other officers, they did observe that it did have thS eal not and he stated thag t was a BB
P if the un wa
appear very similar to a real handgun. I asked 9
gun. I did not observe any serial numbers on th nguu Nd'dh vould poss bly make that conOstent a pel e
rin in the back of the ha dg
observe there was a sp g
gun.
I did a warrant check on �finding him to be clear of warrants.
I asked� what he was doing at the Center Pointe complex. team t He t said he d d notave or know an
mother ana biked away from his house in Crystal to let off some s
in the Center Pointe complex.
I spoke on the telephone with mother, a
She did confirm the story that they did have an
argument and that ad left on his bike in an unknown direction or to an unspecified location.
dl stated tha the gun was fake.
re eate I
P Y
I did explain to him that t ssaults t He stated Phat he knew p a bad p a however did not k ow it was illegal
c o m p l a i n t s a n d v i o l e n t a oint or threaten
for him to be carrying the gun. It should b�h o�ed�aS i d �ey bg hirrm. a l d d ad�� se�at t aat Po nt however that
anybody with the firearm during the time
he was under a�rest for lurking with �r Poin era�artmentncomplex.r He stated he not know anybody and wasn ot
ho h,�� h��h or Cente p r
Page 4 of 4
Printedby: bc114to �f'1CIC�@Ilt RepOrt
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:00
OOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
�45 HUMBOLDT AVE N
.iROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 IllCldetlt NUfYlbel': BC07-001668
(763) 569-3333
waiting tor anybody and I telt as fhough he may be possibly watching the area tor someone to commit a robbery
upon.
�was cooperative throughout the arrest process.
�was transported to the Brookly {e e ol ce bo gepaperwork her�as then booked a d finger pnnted
fill out all the necessary Brooklyn Cen p
then read his rights per Miranda and in a tape recorded statement he said he understood his rights owever
did not wis to speak to me regarding today's inci fcall r ment oned disorderly conductnh wevergl did not f�
stated he has been arrested in the past. He spec y
anything on his juvenile criminal history.
I did issue a Hennepin County Juvenile citation for Lurking with Intent, a misdemeanor. I did give his copy.
was then trans orted by Hennepin County Sheriff s deputies back home to his house at
I then property inventoried the spring gun in the Brooklyn Center property room and it was retained as evidence.
was cooperative throughout the tuall e aive at pro eal eason why he h d the BB gun on hWm in I the first
have the BB gun on him and did not ac y g Y
At this time �is being charged by Hennepin County Juvenile citation (#87501) for Brookfyn Center City
Ordinance Lurking With Intent, 19-201, a misdemeanor, and was released at his house to his mother,�
Gabler/vc
Siqnatures
Date
Reporting Officer
Date
Supervisor
Page 1 of 4
Printed by: bc114to �IICIC�ellt Re'p01�
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:00
1 ROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT i
345 HUMBOLDT AVE N C
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 I11Cideflt NU171be1": BC07-001670
(763)569-333
�t1CiC�Etlt $UI'Ylll'lal'�J Report Type: ARREST
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) 5ectorlBeat: 4/BC04
Inc Occurred Address: 2806 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55430 Report Taken:
Inc Occurred End: Substance: U
inc Occurred Start: Gang Related: U
Domestic: N Bias Motivation:
Reported Date/Time: 03/28I2007 22:00
Contact Nature:
Primary Assigned Officer:
Reporting Officer: GABLER, RICHARD Disposition Date: 03129/2007 13:41
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: ADULT ARREST
Offenses
Enhancers:
Statute Code: 609-487-6
Statute Desc: FLEEING POUCE OFFICER NOT IN VEHICLE
te Severit MISDEMEANOR
1
Statu Y
Counts:
Enhancers:
Statute Code: MISWA
Statute Desc: MISC OFCR WARRANT ARREST
Counts: 1 Statute Severity:
Officers squad#
Event Association
Emp# Badge# Name
147 GABLER, RICHARD
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3228 pETERS, BRIAN
BACK-UP 3219 142
Pel'SOt1S �t1VO�V@C� Can iD Suspect: No
Person#: 0001 MNI: 3851041
Event Association: SUSPECT
Contact DatelTime: 03/28/2007 22:00
Name: A e: 17 17 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK WITH HISPANIC
DOB: 08/31/1989 9 Hair Color: BLACK
Weight: 140 141 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN
Height: 5' 9" 5' 9" SectorlBeat: /6C04
Address: Ext 1:
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 503-3844
Phone Type 2:
Phone# 2: Ext 2
EmployerlSchool: BROOKLYN CENTER HIGH SCHOOL
Occupation: STUDENT
I
Page 2 of 4
Printed by: bc114to �11C1[�e�'lt R@pOrt
Printed datettime: 5/9/07 14:00
�OOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
�45 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 Incident Number: BC07-001670
(763) 569-3333
P@CSOIIS �IIVO�V@C�, Can ID Suspect: No
Person#: 0002 MNI: 8109931
Event Association: ARREST Contact Date/Time: 03/28/2007 22:00
Name: CAMPBELL, TYRONE DEMETIRUS q9e: 20 20 Sez: MALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
DOB: 07/25/1986
Hair Color: BLACK
Height: 5' 9" 5' 9" Weight: 190 190 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Sector/Beat:
Address: 412 12 ST MINNEAPOLIS, MINNESOTA 55403
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 208-8087 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2:
Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: REGINA BURNETT
EmployerlSchool:
Person Offenses
Statute Code: 609-487-6
Enhancers
Statute Desc: FLEEING FOLICE OFF�CER NOT IN VEHICLE
Counts: 1
Enhancers:
Statute Code: MISWA
Statute Desc: MISC OFCR WARRANT ARREST
Counts: 1
.Narratives
Narrative Type: SYNOPSIS
Entered DatelTime: 03/29/2007 13:42 GABLER, RICHARD
Subject:
SYNOPSIS Author:
On 3/28/07 at 2200 hours, I, Officer Gabler, stopped two suspicious males in front of 2806 Northway Drive and
arrested one adult male for a Misdemeanor Warrant and for Fleeing the Police on Foot, a Misdemeanor.
Page 3 of 4
Printed by: bc114to �11CIC�@Ilt RepOrt
Printed date/time: 5!9/07 14:00
'�ROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CEN7ER, MINNESOTA 55430 Incident Number: BC07-001670
(763) 569-3333
Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Entered DatelTime: 03i29/2007 13:49 quthor: GABLER, RICHARD
Subject: MAIN REPORT
On 3/28/07 at 2200 hours, I, Officer Gabler, was in an uu ve Ila ce on a bui deng nthe 2800 baock of
working a Proactive Violent Crimes Detail, conducting s
Drive in plain clothes, with Officer Peters, who was in the driver's seat of the mini van.
I was observing two males in the lobby of one of the buildn g from the a� a the�Bus Hubaoc at County
observed two African American males at a slow �og, com g
Road 10. While both males were�� 9�9an Dr bu Iding when I obseeved th m wa k past he nmarked m n van
p a r k i n g t o t i n f r o n t o f t h e 2 8 0 6 N o y
which O�cer Peters and I W served the 1 males wa k orthbound towa d he� door� to the 806 r Northway Dr ve y
recognized us and I then ob
The males then went from traveling northbound to walking southbound around a few vehicles, look
in in
uild ild
b bu
06
9 28 9
around suspiciously, and then continue to walk northbound
tow
ard the
Based on their suspicious activity and the fact the Center Poin{{errpaed to cond c a Subject Stop with thebwo S
violent assault, and narcotics trafficking, Officer Peters and I a p
suspicious males on fooC when they Wa n�arked th ol ce mini van d the males picked p spe d bega� nd I
turned on the emergency lights in the u p •'I
walking faster toward the 2806 Northway Drive building.
Officer Peters and I drove over the sidewalk and onto thel�9e office s One of males s opped and got
badges ou t an d i de n t i f y i n g o u r s e l v e s s e v e r a l t i m e s a s p o
ground and the other male begaa ain him was a ce off cer, teli ng h m o t�op and to o a me k back
looking back suspiciously and g
toward me. The male then began fn be an look ng around for a ay to�eavelahrew some hPg h s pe son to
get into the building. The male the g
and then got on the ground.
No force was used on either suspect. Both a S u ck Pat Search of s spect who ran�from me chebked
gapped and double locked, and I conducted q
the immediate area of that suspect and l t l on the aoun b dentifed hi Tyron Demeteus Ca pbell, 7/25/86.
believed the suspect threw before he g 9
I identified the other suspect as Nothirrg illegal was found on their person. When I
asked Campbell why he ran from me he stated he was not r Where and d'd n t I'ge� gthe bui d ng Powell�stated
When I asked
him w
here he lived h
e
stated he d
id not know
he lived at 2806 Northway in
in with both suspects I observed a male on the sec�nd floor of the 2806 build 9 e a me one of
k a
ea te
s inu
ile m
Wh 9 a
P him in
im I wou
Id
s ea
k
with
told h P
oin on. I laced in
t was ere
onto his patio and ask wha g 9
the suspects was his son and pointed to Other squads arrived on scene and both suspects w p
the back of separate Brooklyn Center squa cars.
the renter of the� and
I went and spoke with the male on t{o s e out nto the yard and he I came own o speak with me. I as e him
�father. I asked P
how he knew we were out in the front yard ande comin d f om the fron't lobby a ea. stated he then saw ou eard
the front door shaking violently and a loud nois 9
emergency lights. He stated he was father but that he did not know who the other suspect was. I
advised him�would be release s ortly and he stated he would wait. �Was Clear and was
cooperative and was released to his father.
Cam bell had a 100% score on a Misdemeanor Order For Protection Vi F l oot be au I was attempting to 'I
..p him a NP�nPnin Countv Tab Charge for Fleeing on �I
Page 4 of 4
Printed by: bc114to Incident Report
Printed dateftime: 5/9/07 14:00
OOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
45 HUMBOLDT AVE N
aROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 Incident Number BC07-001670
(763) 569-3333
conduct an Investigatory Subject 5top Campbell ran trom Utticers and attempted to get mto the 2806 building
where I believe he would have continued to flee if he had gained entry. I gave him a court date o 4/23/07 at
Brookdale and explained it to Campbell who acknowledged and signed before receiving his copy. He was then
transported to the Hennepin County Adult Detention Center for his Warrant. Campbell's Criminal History revealed
his highest conviction levet was a Misdemeanor.
No further
Gabler/km 3/29/07
Siqnatures
Date
Reporting Officer
Date
Supervisor
Y Printed by: bc114to Page 1 of 2
Incident Report
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 14:11
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
lROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 4
(7s3) 5ss-33a3 lncident Number: BC07-002227
Incident Summary
Incident Type: STATUS OFFENSE(S) Report Typec RUNAWAY
Inc Occurred Address: 2928 NORTHWAY DR 204 BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55429 Sector/Beat: 4/BC04
Inc Occurred Start: 04l22/2007 00:00 Inc Occurred End: Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: U
Contact Nature: Reported Date/Time: 04/22/2007 14:00
Reporting Officer: HOLMSTROM, DWAYNE Primary Assigned Officer:
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: EXCEPTIONAL CLEARED Disposition Date: 04/24/2007 08:24
Offenses
Statute Code: 260G143 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: JUV-RUNAWAY
Counts: 1 Statute Severity:
Officers
Squad#
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name
PRIMARY REPORTWG OFFICER 3238 130 HOLMSTROWI, DWAYNE
List of Attachments i
Type: ReportlD: Report Date: Report Summary:
OTHER LAW ENFORCEMENT AGENCY REF Missing Person Report
Involved
Persons
Person#: 0001 MNI: 19134828 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: RUNAWA� Contact DatelTime:
Name:
DOB: 03/05/1991 Age: 16 16 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
Height: 5' 7" 5' 7" Weight: 115 115 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
Sector/Beat: 4BC04
Address
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 205-5368 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: EmployerlSchool:
Businesses Involved
Business 0001
Event Association: LOCATION
Business Name: CENTER POINTE APARTMENTS Business Type: APARTMENTS
Address: 2928 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 5429 SectorlBeat: 4BC04
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Narratives
Entered Date/Time: 04/23i2007 15:00 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author. HOLMSTROM, DWAYNE
Right-handed, thin buiid, no illnesses. Last seen wearing green hoodie, white t-shirt, light blue jeans.
I
Page 2 of 2
Printed by: bc114to �nCldent RepOrt
Printed date/time: 5/9I07 14:11
ROOKLYN CENTER POUCE DEPT
45 HUMBOLDT AVE N
3ROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 Incident Number: BC07 -002227
(763) 569-3333
Entered Date/Time: 04/23/2007 15:22 Narrative Type: SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT
Subject: SUPP1 KG 04/23/07 1522 Author: GAGNON, KRISTEN
On 04/23/07 152 mother called to notify us that her son had just returned home: She
said she did not wish o have him cited.
He was cleared for NCIC and our Daily Builetin.
Siqnatures
Reporting O�cer Date
Supervisor
Date
Page 1 of 11
Printed by: bc114to Incident Report
Printed dateltime: 5/9/07 13:59
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
:45 HUMBOLDT AVE N
dROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESO7A 55430 Incident Number: BC07-001577
{763) 569-3333
�t1ClC�@tlt $UCY1111at"�/ ReportType: INCIDENT
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) SectorlBeat: 4/BC04
Inc Occurred Address: 2904 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55429 Rg ort Taken:
inc Occurred Start: 03/24/2007 18:00 Inc Occurred End: 03/25/2007 09:34 Substance: U
Domestic: Y Bias Motivation: Gang. Related: U
Reported Date/Time: 03l25/2007 09:34
Contact Nature:
Primary Assigned Officer:
Reporting Officer: KNIGHT, MELONEY Disposition Date: 03l26/2007 09:54
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: JUVENILE ARREST
Offenses
Statute Code: 609-2242-1
Enhancers
Statute Desc: ASSAULT-DOM ASSAULT-MISD
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: MISDEMEANOR
Enhancers:
Statute Code: 609-505
Statute Desc: GOV'T-FALSE REPORTING CRIME-FALSE REPORT
Counts: 1 Statute Severity:
OffiCers Squad#
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name
136 KNIGHT, MELONEY
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3241
INVESTiGATOR 3213 132 BECKER, CORINNE
Associated Events
Association: Event Type: Event#:
Event Date (Start): Event Date (End): Agency:
WCIDENT TO ARREST ARREST BC07-001577 03i24/2007 18:00:00 03/25/2007 09:34:00 BC
Persons Involved, can io sus�e�c: No
Person#: 0001 MNI: 19085155
Event Association: PARENT/GUARDIAN
Contact Date/Time: 03/25/2007 09:34
Name: Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
DOB: 06/05l1962 Age: 44 44 Sex: MALE
Hair Color: BLACK
Neight: 6' 3" 6' 3" Weight: 220 220 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Sector/Beat: /NHNE
Address
Phone Type 1: HOME
Phone# 1: (612) 216-1949 Exf 1:
Phone# 2: (612) 919-2959 Ext 2:
Phone Type 2: CELL
EmployerlSchooL•
Occupation:
Can ID Suspect: No
Person#: 0002 MNI: 3898468
Event Association: MENTiONED Contact DateiTime: 03/25/2007 09:34
Name: Race: BLACK
DOB: 11/13/1988 Age: 18 18 Sex: FEMALE
Ibs
E e Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
0 120 Y
12
Wei ht:
Height. 5 4 5' 4 9 Sector/Beat:
Address:
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 566-4391 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2:
Phone# 2: Ext 2
EmployerlSchooL•
Occupation:
i
Page 2 of 11
Printed by: bc114to �nCldent R@�301�
Printed date/time: 5/9I07 13:59
OOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
45 HUMBOLDT AVE N
,ROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 �dent NUt7lbef: BC07-001577
Inc
(763) 569-3333
P@CSOIIS �I1VO�V@C� Can ID Suspect: No
Person#: 0003 MNI: 3937365
Event Association: MENTIONED
Contact Date/Time:
I Name: Race: WHITE
Sex
FEMALE
e: 18 18
A
DOB. 09/25/1
988 9
Hair Color: RED
Height: 5' 2" 5' 2" Weight: 160 160 Ibs Eye Color: GREEN SectorBeat: /BC04
Address: 2814 NORTHWAY DR 'f01 BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 566-A391 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
I EmployerlSchooL•
Occupation
MCDONALD'S EMPLOYEE
Can ID Suspect: No
Person#: 0004 MNI: 8603737
Event Association: MENTIONED Contact Date/Time: 03/25/2007 09:34
Name:
DOB: O6/15/1992 Age: 14 14 Sex: FEMALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
I S E e Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLAC
K
Height: 5' 8" 5 8" Weight: 145 945 Ib Y
SectorlBeat:
Address:
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2:
Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occu ation: STUDENT Employer/School: FACES GROUP HOME
P
Can !D Suspect: Yes
Person#: 0005 MNI: 19019944
EventAssociation: JWENILEARREST
Contact DatelTime: 03l25/2007 09:34
Name:
DOB: 08J14/1990 Age: 16 16 Sex: FEMALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
Hair Color: BLACK
5' 5" Weight: 120 120 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN NE
Hei ht: 5' S" or/Beat: /NH
9 Sect
Address:
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (612) 216-1949 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2:
Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: STUDENT 9TH GR EmployertSchoof: COOPER HIGH SCHOOL
Person Offenses
i S
tatute Code: 609-505 Enhancers:
PORT
Statute Desc: GOV'T-FALSE REPORT(NG CRIME FALSE RE
Counts: 1
Printed by: bc114to Page 3 of 11
Incident Report
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:59
BROOKLYN CENTER POI.ICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N I
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 Incident Number: BC07-001577
(763) 569-3333
Persons Involved
Person#: 0006 MNI: 7633339 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: SUSPECT Contact Date/Time:
Name:
DOB: 01l23/1992 Age: 15 15 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
Height: 5' 0" 5' 0" Weight: 100 100 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
Sector/Beat: /CY14
Address:
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 537-1893 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: STUDENT EmployerlSchool: COOPER HS
Person Offenses
Statute Code: 609-2242-1 Enhancers
Statute Desc: ASSAULT-DOM ASSAULT-MISD
Counts: 1
Narratives
Entered Date/Time: 03/26/2007 08:12 Narrative Type: SYNOPSIS
Subject: SYNOPSIS Author: KNIGHT, MELONEY
f a'uvenile runawa that changed stories to a juvenile falsely
I w a s c a l l e d t o 2 9 0 4 N o r t h w a y D r i v e o n a r e p o r t o Y
reporting a crime of abduction to now her being a victim of domestic assault.
Printed hy: bc114to II'1CICI@Cit R@pOrt Page 4 of 11
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:59
BROOKLYN CENTER POUCE DEPT
645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(�s3) 5ss-ss33 Incident Number: BC07-001577
Entered Date/Time: 03/26J2007 08:26 P�arrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author: KNIGHT, MELONEY
On 03/25/2007 at 0934 hours, DOB: 06/05/1962, called Hennepin County Dispatch wanting to
report his daughter as a runaway. Squads were unable to get to 2904 Northway Drive due to call volume until my
arrival at 1031 hours. Upon my arrival, I could not see that there was an apartment number to 2904 Northway
Drive so I immediate asked Hennepin County Dispatch what apartment number and they indicated that�
would be waiting in the parking lot for me. Moments later I was approached by a black male who i en ified
imse as DOB: 06/05/1962, and his daughter was with him who identified herself as�
nd.stated that they reside together at
Hill told the story that she and her sister, were to meet at the
transit hub in Brooklyn Center yesterday, 03/24/2007. indicated that she had left her house in Crystal at
approximately 1535 hours and arrived at the transit cen� at approximately 1551 hours. When she got there she
realized her sister was not there so she indicated she borrowed a friend's home by the name of �who is a
14 year old female who lives at Center Pointe Apartments to call her sister, apparently is staying
at St. Joseph's Home for Children at a group home because her biological father, a James Clifford ROBERTS,
was shot in a homicide at Stand Up Frank's last summer in Minneapolis and their biological mom who �and
share is an unfit mother and uses narcotics and they have not seen her since the death of
father. As �borrowed�cell phone to call the group home where� was staying, s e
realized that she didn't even leave yet and she didn't arrive to the transit center on bus #5 until approximately 1700
to 1800 hours. �and�were going to go back to house in Crystal, however, the bus they need t�
a
take from the transit center they'd have to stop and take the obbinsdale bus to get to Crystal. This bus runs
every hour and they happened to miss the first bus so they had to wait another hour for the second bus. While
they were standing outside,�indicated that around 6:00 P.M. a group of approximately five to six males around
ages 14-18 years of age, about 5'10" all wearing black hoodies, one had a black foam half face mask over his
face came and grabbed ��f and when �ried to say to get their hands off her sister Chey started
punching her and put her arms behind her back, and threw her down to the ground. believes tha
knew the youngest boy. She stated he was the smallest, approximately 14 years old, and he approached
because they believe that they went to the same school together at Edison. Of course she could not remember
what his name was and when she got herself up off the ground she realized that the unknown suspects emptied
out her purse, took all her money (one $10.00 bill that was folded up in severa! folds to be the size of
approximately a quarter, one $20.00 bill, her Chap Stick and her perfume and left with her sister, �towards
Center Pointe Apartments. Hill kept walking around the transit center crying wondering where her sister ad
gotten kidnapped to when she met up with a girl who she only knew by the name of who lives in Brooklyn
Park who came to her aid. She is approximately 15-16 years of age, a light skin black female approximately 5'5".
This unknown girl, then helped her cross the street towards Center Pointe Apartments to look for
�stated that she and did not go in any apartment building, they just stayed around the outside
of each apartment unit at Center ointe. They then kept going back and forth across the street from Center
Pointe Apartments back to the transit hub. Finally they walked over to Cub Foods where they met up with two
Africans who drove a gray brand new style car that looks like a truck approximately at 1:00 a.m. They felt it was
comfortable to drive around with these two male Africans because they had girls with them. She had a phone
number of one male whose name was Moses and they started walking around the apartments to help them look
for They left the males around 4:00 a.m. and headed back to house. Once at�
house, ey ai down for two hours before she woke up to call her dad around 6:00 a.m. At 7:00 a.m. her dad
came to get her at� house. She did not know where �lived, somewhere in Brooklyn Park, but stated
that her dad should nk ow where the address was since he picked her up there. She stated that her dad is not
married yet but is engaged to a Theresa Lynn JONES. She stated her birthday should be May 18th and she is a
i white female 26-27 years of age.
Things weren't making much sense since the times kept changing as she was trying to clarify what was going on
and kept tafking to all kinds of individuals in the Center Pointe Apartment complex. He then stated
that he got word that was not at 2904 Northway Drive and that she is with some guy by the name
of FO at 2810 Northway Drive, #303. At that point I alerted other officers to assist me and Officer Trout and I
wa Drive #303, and ot no answer. As we exited
inson to res ond. We went up to 2810 North y 9
asked for Sgt _Rob p
Printed by: bc114to IIICICI@Ilt R@pOl� Page 5 of 11
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:59
BROOKLYN EENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
SROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 5543Q 4
(�ss) sss-s3ss Incident Number: BE07-001577
that buiiding, Uttfcer frout checked the balcony area and also saw no movement commg trom the balcony area
As we were checking around fhe exterior of the building, �pointed out 2814 Northway Drive, where
there was an open window and one other window was cracked and shattered. While looking through the window,
it appeared that that was a vacant apartment. The carpeting was pulled up and there was no fumiture inside the
apartment. Officer Trout and I, Officer Knight, did enter the apartment through the ground floor window and
confirmed that it was 2814 Northway Drive, We did not see anyone inside the apartment. The apartment
inside door was dead bolted locked. There were several used condom wrappers and a used condom on the floor,
and two cigarettes that were used in the toilet. There was one silver hoop earring, a$10.00 bill folded up several
times to be the approximate size of a quarter and one ring that was a butterfly with multiple colors. �and her
father, were outside the window to the apartment when i held up the butterfly ring to ask if this was
one of the rin� was wearing since �indicated she has multiple rings on her fingers like
she does and since she has several earrings in each ear they should more or less be stud earrings. She did not
remember if she had a hoop on or not. Since the butterfly ring was a match that aindicated�should be
wearing, Officer Trout stayed on scene and we requested Hennepin County Crime Lab to process the scene since
we did not know it we had a possible sexual assault or abduction since there was also a role of duct tape inside
that apartment.
I then canvassed the whole first floor area of 2814 Northway Drive, knocking on Apt. 02, 103, and 104 with no
answer. I also was hearing alking to people on the third floor balcony. I went up to Apt. #301 and
talked to and her roommate
and indicated aroun 00 hours on 03/25/2007 they hear a o o anging own
on the first floor area but t ey di not think much of it. They heard someone yell, "Come on" and "You don't need
this." They believe that that ap,artment was vacant when they moved in back on 02/28/2007 but indicated they did
not see anything else.
to the Bro
okl n Cente
r Police De artment.
'r ted b S t. Robinson to trans ort the 5ister, Y P
I was then di ec y g p
r m in the Brookl n
r nd I id a ta ed statement f o Y
Detective Becker was called in and Detective Becke a p
Center Police Department.
then tried to tell Detective Becker part of the same story that she first told me, that she was first
supposed to meet up with her sister who lives at St. Joe's which is a group home. She left her house (this time
she indicated that she had got a ride from her step mom to the transit hub) and her step mom left her there
because she knew�would be on her way shortly. Detective Becker kept coming in and out because she
kept getting phone calls with better information. Detective Becker was getting leads indicating that Mwas lying.
�kept trying to stick�to her story that she was assaulted and her sister was possibly abducted by 4-5 black guys
with dark hoodies over their head and she kept indicating that she wanted her dad there and she just wanted to
know where her sister was. A short time later, Detective Becker did call �dad back, realized that
made it home, and that story was different than�story and Detective Becker let �try and ta to
her dad at which point she refused to talk to her dad.
At that point Deteetive Becker placed handcuffs on gapped and double locked those handcuffs, and directed
me, O�cer Knight, to escort �down to the Brooklyn Center booking room and charge her with burglary. While I
started the booking process with she began crying stating that she did not do the burglary, she did lie, and she
is willing to talk to Detective Becker now and she would tell the whole truth. I then called Detective Becker who
came to the Brooklyn Center booking area and read �her rights per Miranda at which time she understood her
rights and agreed to give Detective Becker a statement.
This time indicated that she did meet up with her sister at the transit hub. She was there with her girlfriends,
�and They missed the first bus to get to the Robbinsdale Center and while they were there she saw
her ex-boyfriend whom she said she was three months pregnant with his child. She knew his name of
RAYSHAWN. Rayshawn approached her as she was on the cell phone. He was smiling and came up close to
her as she was on the phone, pushed her up against the wall and told him to get away and he pushed
At that point� yelled, "Get your hands off her." At that point it appears that Rayshawn and his
brothers and four to five�riends left the transit center. They ended up re-connecting back with them around the
tall weight building which was described as 5701 Shin le Creek Parkway which is to the east of the transit center
on Northway Drive. At that point Paris, who is girlfriend, left to go to Burger King between 6:00 and 7:00
P.M. and they ran into Rayshawn and began argumg. �and hen disappeared and began walking
towards the gas station which was described as the Marathon gas sta ion on Bass Lake Rd and Xerxes and they
never came back. �stated that she knew she'd be in trouble if she returned home without her sister �so
Printed by: bc114to �nCIC�@Ilt R@p01� Page 6 of 11
Printed dateltime: 5/9J07 13:59
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
3ROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-OU1577
she began to try to look for her sister. That was when she ran back into Rayshawn around the 5701 Shingle
Creek tower on Northway Drive. At that point they got into a physical fight where Rayshawn kept punching and
kicking She indicated she did not know how it occurred but she said she fought back so he should have
scratches to his face and a bite mark to his chest. She indicated that's how she got a swollen forehead, a swollen
right eye, a sore right knee, bruising on the middle side of her left back and road rash on her right shoulder. She
indicated the road rash came from when she was down on the ground on her back. He grabbed her legs and
started dragging her down the street. She indicated that Rayshawn has assaulted her in the past but she had
never reported anything. He should be with �baby's father by the name of "LOON" (spelling unknown),
another black male by the name of LOCO and some other unknown male who she stated was a"big dude." She
indicated that she knew the apartment was vacant over on Northway Drive in the 2814 building because her
girlfriend, �was willing and had four guys give her two pills and she had sex with four different guys willingly
either Wednesday or Thursday. They knew that apartment was vacant and entered through the window. She
knew one of the guys by the nickname "CHOP CITY". She was with another girl however the other girl just sat
around, she didn't participate in the sexual activities and so she indicated that the butterfly ring may have been
however, and her all have butterfl rings. butterfly ting is blue, one other's is pink
and� others c ange fro~reen to pick or blue. �oes not remember last name but stated now
a coup
�fives in Srooklyn Center but she doesn't know her a dress but she has recentfy moved her from Atlanta.
She is a black female with long hair and light skin.
After #rying to get to the bottom of this story, it was determined that was not abducted, that she
left willingly with another girlfriend and failed to come home for the evening, so did Therefore the abduction
and kidnapping were unfounded and with �trying to report a crime that didn't occur, �was arrested for falsely
reporting a crime. As per the domestic assault, she was the victim with Rayshawn BROWN. I contacted Project
Peace at 1508 hours and spoke with Kelly and gave her the information of the incident. Since �did not know
Rayshawn's exact last name, Detective Becker checked the Brooklyn Center data base and got a booking photo
of Rayshawn in the Hennepin County Juvenile Center and identified the Rayshawn as Rayshawn mm� BROWN,
DOB: 01/23/1992. Detective Becker then asked that I put out an Attempt to Locate, 5th degree Domestic Assault,
on Rayshawn Brown. �also wanted to show me that she was wearing a feminine napkin and she did have
blood stains on it. She indicated that she feels she may have miscarried her child approximately 2-3 days ago at
which point I asked her if she needed an ambulance but she refused. I strongly encouraged her to go back to the
same doctor that stated she was pregnant so she could have an exam again.
At this point we are charging I�with falsely reporting a crime and charging Rayshawn Brown with 5th Degree
Domestic Assault.
Knight/vc
i
Printed by: bc114to �nCl�ent Rep01� Page 7 of 11
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:59
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
;645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
3ROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-001577
Entered DatelTime: 03l26/2007 10:36 Narrative Type: SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT
Subject: SUPP1 03 25 07 15 30 Author: ROBINSON, STU
On 3/25/07 at approximately 1030 hours I was requested to assist Officer Knight on a call at 2810 Northway Dr.,
#303. The original call waS that of a runaway. While en routeJ was advised that it appeared as itmay be an
abduction of a 15 yr old and the apartment where she may be, 2810 Northway, #303, was where a known gang
member was believed to be.
I arrived and found that there had been no contact. I learned from Officer Knight and that the
female, 06-15-92 had been declared a ward of the state and had been living at St. Joe's
home for children because her biological father had been murdered in Mpls. last summer and her biological
vi it an adult male in
mother, was a crack addict and not around. She had been given a pass to s
Crystal, had beec� married to �at one time and had a daughter with
(pronounced de-are-a} �08-14-90. �appears to be the only stable adult influence in life.
�and�are close and they were to take the bus from the bus hub to �house!�(sta es she
got physically separated from by a large group of B/M's at the bus hub about 2000 hours. She claimed
that she got punched in the face and knocked to the ground and was one. She mentioned a male known
as "Foe" who we have dealt with and is a gang member as being with thinks and treats
as a daughter so he was very upset when it appeared that �had been possibly abducted.
Our attention was brought to 2814 Northway Dr., #101. This apartment was pointed out by ��s a place she
was told that �and�s had been. It was obvious that this apartment was vacant and was unsecured.
There is a continuing problem of empty apartments in this complex being broken into and then used for drugs
activity, sexual activity and other crimes. Officer Trout'made entry through a window that was cranked open on the
NE corner of the bldg. Trout found evidence of drug activity, condoms and a ring and an earring. saw the
ring and stated it was �At this point �became convinced his "daughter" had beer� abducted. There
was also cash found on the floor.
At this point I contacted Detective Becker, the on call detective to come in and begin investigating this as I �i
abduction. I also ordered crime lab to the scene to process the apartment. I also contacted Lt. Benner the Duty
Command Officer and kept him apprised during this investigation.
I had Officer Knight transport �to the police department to meet with Becker when she arrived. Officer Trout
secured the apartment until Crime Lab arrived.
07-1577
I had a conversation with �prior to the transport and she told me that after being hit and knocked down she
sought out a uniformed Hennepin Deputy about being assaulted and her "sister" being abducted. She also spoke
to a Brooklyn Center Police Officer in plain clothes and told him the same thing. She stated they did not do
anything. This did not sound right to me as HCSO and BCPD have 4 officers assigned to a pro active detail; one
of the places it works is this apartment complex. I did not see how the officers wouid not take any action. There
was no information in call logs of anything of this sort on the previous shift. I
I had a conversation a short time later in the police department lobby with �who was concemed that his
daughter �was not being truthful about what had happened. He told me that�mentioned that
money had been found in the vacant apartment and so was hers. He thought how would her money get in the
apartment when she denied being in the apartment.
Printed by: bc114to �nCldent RenO� Page 8 of 11
Printed dateltime: 5/9/07 13:59
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
ROOKLYN CEt3'TER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-001577
1 passed this information on to Detective Becker and was later advised that it was found that �was mad at
because �was supposed to take the bus with her to Foster's house but "ditched" her and they had
some argument over a male. �also was assaulted by her ex-boyfriend who she is pregnant by. While
was being interviewed called and spoke to �and also spoke to Becker, stating she was well and
would be retuming to house.
was booked for GM false report and held awaiting release to her father. For further details please see
Detective Beckers and Officer Knights reports.
i
i
Printed by: bc114to ICICId@I�t RepOrt Page 9 of 11
Printed dateltime: 5/9/07 13:59
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
��s3) 5ss-3333 Incident Number: BC07-001577
Entered DatelTime: 03l26/2007 14:57 Narrative Type: SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT
Subject: SUPP2 CB 3/26/2007 Author: BECKER, CORINNE
On 3/26/2007 at approximately 1100 hours, I, Detective Becker, was notified of this incident. I learned there was
possibly a 15 year old female who had been kidnapped and was missing. I responded to the Brooklyn Center
Police Department and met with Officer Knight and Sergeant Robinson regarding what they had learned. As I was
gathering initial information, I learned that the father of the juvenile female who was
reporting that her sister had been dragged off, suspected that she was not being honest about the incident.
Officer Knight and I interviewec� as a witness in the Investigation Division interview room. I audio and video
vidence in this case. Prior to staring the interview, I leamed�
t eta esase
'in h
w ater fil
ie I
recorded the interv g p
icer about her sister bein
th s olice off 9
nd later
told a lam clo e
e ties a P
a air of d u
down P
claimed to have flagged p p
etail and does cur
re
ntl
abducted. The Brooklyn Center Police Department is conducting an intensive saturation d Y
have two plain clothes officers and two Hennepin County deputies assigned. They were working the night of this
incident. I contacted Officer Peters, one Brooklyn Center plain clothes officer assigned to the detail. He was
unaware of the incident. He indicated that CenterPoint apartments; where the incident was said to have taken
place, was unusually quiet. He advised there was a log of the detail available and I determined there were no
detail contacts similar to the incident �was reporting. I was also able to confirm there were no police calls for
senrice at Hennepin County Dispatch that would have been generated if police had surrounded an apartment
building..
laimed she fla ed
�told me her story from the beginning. When she got to the part about the deputies, she c g9
them that her sister had been 'ust abducted. She said she pointed at a group of guys who she
them down and told 1
he said the and some lain clothes officers then
rd them. S P
believed had her sister and the deputies drove off towa Y
surrounded a CenterPoint apartment building. She said they took down just her name and birth date, then told her
to leave a"they had it under control." �said she walked back to the Transit Hub and mainly remained there for
the next four hours.
She said she only saw one set of Transit Police the entire time she was there and that she did not talk to them
about her abducted sister.
I was able to contact Transit Police in a effort to obtain video of the parking lot. I was advised accessing that would
involve calling in an employee. I advised I would contact them if that became necessary. �claimed to have been
held down on the ground in the parking lot by a black male as another dumped her purse out on the pavement
near the taxi stand at the Transit hub, taking all of her money, her medical card and social security card.
After speaking to �for more than an hour, I leamed that the missing girl had contacted her father,
and that she was on her way home. I learned from �that she said she had never been abducted.
suspected that I�had been with her ex-boyfriend, Rayshawn Brown, inside of the apartment with the broken
window. He suspected she had been drinking and having sex with Brown, I
I confronted �about the fact that there was no documentation to support her claim of talking to the police. I
confronted her about her father's accusations that she was the one who broke into the vacant apartment. I
confronted her about her failure to find true assistance for her "abducted" sister. �r'emained adamant that she
was telling the truth.
I was put into phone contact with the missing sister, She said she had never been abducted. She said
she left the area in a car with some girls. She claimed to have tried to get back to the group home but forgot the
wa She had no excuse when I asked why she did not go to house.
Y
I was aware that fingerprints had been recovered by Hennepin County Crime Lab on the glass that was broken to
the abandon apartment. I spoke with �and advised him I would like to book �or burglary and compare her
fingerprints with those recovered. He was in full agreement.
Printed by: bc114to �nCldent RepOI� Page 10 of 11
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:59
BROOKLYN CENTER POUCE DEPT
645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
ROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 InCldent NUmbeC: BC07-001577
I placed �under arrest and Utticer Knight escorted her to the Brooklyn Center Pollce Department booking tacility
for processing. As I was completing my investigation, Officer Knight called me, stating tliat �wished to tell the
truth. I took a second taped interview with I read the �the Miranda Warning and she agreed to speak to me.
Madmitted she made up the story about her sister being abducted. She said her sister left her at the Transit hub
and she tried to find her. She said she had been assaulted but it had been Brown who hit her, causing her right
eye to swel{. �said she knew she wou4d be in trauble with her father if she came home without her sister.
After completing the interview, I learned that Transit did have video of the girls and boys at the hub. There was no
video of the assault as, we learned, it took place away from the hub. Officer Knight completed a Juvenile Citation
for the charge of Misdemeanor False Report to a Police Officer.
On 3/26/2007, I received a phone call from She said she and her father had a talk with the mother of
Rayshawn Brown. She said her father did not wish to pursue prose,cution for her being assaulted. advised that
would be decided by the Hennepin County Attorney's Office.
This case is being forwarded to the Hennepin County Attor�ney's Office for review of charges against Brown who
has not been located as of the time of this report.
This case is CLOSED/JUVENILE ARREST.
Nothing further.
Entered Date/Time: 04/04/2007 12:00 Narrative Type: SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT
Subject: SUPP3 JT 03/29/07 0825 Author: TROUT, JOE
On 03/25/07, I responded to Center Pointe apartment complex to assist Officer Knight in attempting to locate a
missing juvenile female. When I met Knight, she was out with the sister and father to a
14-year-old black female. The sister of �informed Knight that she believed her sister,� was taken
2814 Northway Dr. Apt. #101. When we responded to this apartment, we found the windows of the apartment
open. The apartment was vacant and condoms and jewelry belonging to were laying on the floor.
It was at that time that I secured the apartment after searching- it and Hennepin County Crime Lab was ordered.
Crime Lab Technician Barnes responded and took photos and collected evidence and took prints. I gathered
property left on the floor of a$10 bill, a yellow colored ring, and a white hoop earring. I gave these items to
Detective Becker. Before going to meet with Detective Becker to give her the items I found, I overheard a
conversation between Sgt. Robinson and�,{ father, where `father believed that
the story that sister was telling was not true. He believed that had just run away and the sister
was covering or her. I also spoke to an unidentified black male while at the scene, waiting for Crime Lab. He told
me that he believed the two sisters were both in the apartment on their own free will and with some young black
males. He also told me that he believed that �and her sister had been physically fighting over a boy.
Later on that day, I received a phone call from a party who identified herself as mother, stating
that' was f'ine and she was never abducted, and that sister had made up the story.
No further at this time.
Trout/ss
04104/07
Printed by: bc114to II�CICIeI�t R@pOrt Page 11 of 11
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:59
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
I S645 HUMBOLDT AVE N •,i
3ROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 �I
(763) 569-3333 (tlCldellt NU111beP: BC07-001577
Siqnatures
I
Reporting O�cer Date
Supervisor Date
I
i�
Printed by: bc114to Page 1 of 5
incident Report
Printed date/time: 5!9/07 13:55
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
45 HUMBOLDT AVE N
ROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
t�s3) 5ss-33s3 Incident Number: BC07-001266
Incident Summary
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: DRUG OFFENSE
Inc Occurred Address: 2912 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MN 55430 Sector/Beat:
Inc Occurred Start: 03/10/2007 22:45 Inc Occurred End: Report Taken:
Domestic: N Bias Motivation: Gang Related: U Substance: Y
Contact Nature: Reported DatetTime: 03/10/2007 22:45
Reporting Officer: GABLER, RICHARD Primary Assigned Officer:
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: JUVENILE ARREST Disposition Date: 03/12/2007 22:17
O#fenses
Statute Code: 152-027-3 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: CONT SUBST-POSS-MARIJUANA IN MV
Counts: 1 Statute Severity: MISDEMEANOR
Officers
Event Association Emp# Badge# Name Squad#
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3228 147 GABLER, RICHARD
BACK-UP 3219 142 PETERS, BRIAN
Associated Events
Association: Event Type: Event#: Event Date (Start): Event Date (End): Agency:
ARREST TO INCIDENT ARREST BC07-001266 03/10/2007 22:45:00 BC
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 19147437 Can ID Suspect: Yes
Event Association: DRIVER Contact Date/Time: 03/10/2007 22:45
Name: FARLEY, MICHAEL JULISE
DOB: 07/26/1987 Age: 19 19 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
Height: Weight: Eye Color. Hair Color.
Address: 3200 DUPONT AV N MINNEAPOLIS, MINNESOTA Sector/Beat:
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/SchooL•
Person#: 0002 MNI: 19147438 Can ID Suspect: Yes
Event Association: PASSENGER Contact Date/Time: 03/10/2007 22:45
Name: HAMPTON, BRYAN RASHOWN
DOB: 02/27/1987 Age: 20 20 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
Height: Weight: Eye Color: Hair Color:
Address: 2924 NORTHWAY DR 202 BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 Sector/Beat: /BC04
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/School:
Printed by: bc114to Page 2 of 5
Incident Report
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:55
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
'645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
sROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number BC07-001266 i
Persons Involved
Person#: 0003 MNI: 19147439 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: JUVENILE ARREST Contact Date/Time: 03/10/2007 22:45
Name:
DOB: 05/0211991 Age: 15 15 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
Height: 6' 1" 6' 1" Weight: 135 135 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
SectorlBeat:
Address
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (612) 377-2146 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/SchooL•
Person Offenses
Statute Code: 152-027-3 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: CONT SUBST-POSS-MARIJUANA IN MV
Counts: 1
Person#: 0004 MNL• 19147441 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: JWENILE ARREST Contact Date/Time: 03110/2007 22:45
Name:
DOB: 08/25/1989 Age: 17 17 Sex: MALE Race: BLACK NON-HISPANIC
Height: 6' 0" 6' 0" Weight: 145 145 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN H
air Colo
r: B
LACK
Address: Sector/Beat:
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (612) 377-2146 Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
Occupation: Employer/SchooL•
Person Offenses
Statute Code: 152-027-3 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: CONT SUBST-POSS-MARIJUANA IN MV
Counts: 1
Vehicies involved
Vehicle#: 0001
Event Assoc: MENTIONED Vehicle Status: NONE
Vehicie Type: A Year: 2000 Make: DODGE Model: DURANGO
VIN: License#: KVL526 State: MN Expires On:
Style: 4-DOOR Prim Color: BLUE Sec Color: Ter Color:
Status Dt/Tm: Status Value: Recovered Date: Recovered Value:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Cancelled:
i
Page 3 of 5
Printed by: bc114to �nCldent RgpOrt
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:55
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
ROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 Incident Number: BC07 -001266
763 569-3333
PropertV Involved
Propertv 0001 Evidence: No
Event AssociOrig status: EVIDENCE Originai Status Date: 03/10/2007 22:45:00 Original Value: $0.00
Current Status: PROPERTY INVENTORIED Current Status Date: 03/10l2007 22:45:00 Current Value: $0.00
Property Type: DRUGS/NARCOTICS
Description: 18.2 GRAMS OF MARIJUANA
Make/Brand: Model:
Color: Quantity:
SeriallLot#: Owner Applied#:
NCIC Date: NCIC Reported By:
NCIC#: NCIC Cancelled:
Narratives
Entered Date/Time: 03/12/2007 21:16 Narrative Type: SYNOPSIS
Subject: SYNOPSIS Author: GABLER,RICHARD
On 03/10/07 at 2245 hours, I, Gabler, stopped a suspicious vehicle in the parking lot of 2912 Northway Drive and
arrested two juvenile males for possession of small amount of marijuana in a motor vehicle.
Page 4 of 5
Printed by: bc�l4to �nCldgnt R@pOCt
I Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:55
BROOKLYN CENTER POUCE DEPT
�645 HUMBOLDT AVE N I,
3ROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 Incident Number: BC07-001266
(763) 569-3333
Entered Date/Time: 03/12/2007 21:19 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author: GABLER, RICHARD
On 03/10/07 at 2245 hours, I, Gabler, was in the parking lot near the 2912 Northway Drive building when I drove
past a Dodge Durango which appeared to be occupied at least 2-3 times and that the vehicle had MN registration
KVL526. I parked in a parking spot approximately 120 feet from the vehicle. I was in an unmarked minivan at the
time. I observed the vehicle for approximately 10-15 minutes. I did not observe anybody enter or exit the vehicle.
Based on the fact that the area in which the vehicle was at is an area high in narcotics activity and the fact that
nearly 10-15 minutes nobody entered or exited the vehicle and was running without its headlights on, I then
approached the vehicle-KVL526. I conducted an investigatory stop to figure out what the parties in the vehicle
were doing.
Upon approaching the vehicle in the driver side at the back pf the driver seat, a male appeared to be getting
around making assertive movements in the back seat. When the driver rolled down the window, I could smell an
odor of marijuana emanating from the vehicle. I also observed between the two front seats in the cup holder there
dob 07/
26/87 With that name and
el Julise FARLEY
was a silver can of beer. I identified the d
river as Micha
date of birth given, I realized that Farley was not 21 years of age and, as far as the alcohol container. goes, it
should not have been in his vehicle. He stated that it was his aunt's vehicle. I had Farley step out of the vehicle
and also the front passenger step out of the vehicle. He was identified as Bryan Rashown HAMPTON (dob
02/27/87). I identified the rear passenger side occupant as ��(dob 08/25/89). I also
identified the other rear passenger side occupant of the vehicle as dob 08/25/89). I
concluded, upon identifying all occupants of the vehicle, that they were all underage and should not be in
them stand b De uties
vehicle. I had Y p
possession of any type of alcohol. All occupants w
ere removed
from the
Hagen and Clark while Officer Brian Peters of the Brooklyn Center Police Department and I conducted a search of
the vehicle.
A search of the vehicle was based on the fact that the occupants were all of underage, that there was at least one
of the containers of alcohol opened and there was an odor of marijuana emanating from the vehicle. �p n lea ving
hunks of a ree fy i
eared to be small c 9
id observe what a
Ham ton ste out of the front passenger seat, I d PP
P
P e back
on searchin in th
na. U 9
substance, which in my experience as a police officer, consisting of that of marijua p
tic ba which contained se
veral smaller
seat underneath the back seat of the vehicle, I did observe a large plas g ubstance in the ba had an odor
of mari'uana. The s 9
t nce which a eared to be that
reen lea subs a pp
bags of a g fy
that th
ere were 7 ba s believed to be of marijuana. I
ri'uana.
I counted
the ba
s an
d found 9
with ma 9
consisting
observed that all bags were tied up in knots and appeared to be of the same size and, upon feeling them,
appeared to have the same weight.
nd Ham ton. I first s oke with Farley separate from everybody else. I
he front occu ants Farle a p P
I ke with t Y
I spo P d in the
whose mari'uana that was in the car and
he stated he did not know. I asked him if he saw anybo y
asked 1
vehicle that was using marijuana and whom it might be. He stated that he kn�ws Hamrton well enough and,
according to him, that he does not believe he would be involved in any type of marijuana as he has never seen
him smoke or use it. I asked Farley if it was his marijuana and he stated that it was not. It should be noted that
where the bags were found it appeared to be out of reach of Farley if you were to hide it underneath the back seat
firom where he was sitting in the driver side.
Upon speaking with Hampton, separate from everybody, he stated that he does not touch that stuff and does not
I use mari'uana at all and did not even know that it was in the vehicle. I asked him why there was some type of
1 re. He
a tha
t it w
as
the
he had no ide
marijuana residue on the floorboard where he was sitting and he stated
stated "if you thought anybody was using it, it was somebody in the back seat".
I then s oke with I asked as to whose marijuana that was in the vehicle. did give I
me very evasive answers stating that he does not even do that and that he did not know that there was any in the
vehicle and he doesn't smoke. I asked him why the bag of marijuana would have been found within his reach and
was possibly in his possession. He stated that he had no idea that it was even there. Again, he was very evasive
with his answers and was looking away from me while he was talking to me.
i
i
Printed by: bc114to �nCldent RepOrt Page 5 of 5
Printed date/time: 5/9/07 13:55
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
ROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763) 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-001266
I then spoke with and asked him it it was his weed. �Was also very evasive. He stated
he has not used marijuana by himself and that he did not have any idea why that marijuana would have been in
the vehicle. �Was also looking away from me when I was inquiring as to whose marijuana it was.
It should be noted it is most likely that the only two people in the vehicle that would have been able to hide the I
marijuana underneath the rear bench seat of the vehicle would have been both
observed that #he area where the marijuana was found it was most likely out of reach from Farley and Hampton.
I spoke with Farley again as he stated that the vehicle was his aunYs. I asked him if his aunt was using marijuana
at all and he stated that it was his mother's car. I asked him if his mother had used or sold marijuana and he
stated absolutely not, that she would not have had that in there.
tt should be noted that, while conducting my interviews with Farley and Hampton, they were looking at me straight
in the eye and appeared to be very confident that that was not their marijuana and were much more
straightforward in giving answers than both Based on the information that I had, I
issued two Hennepin County Juvenile Citations to for
possession of a small amount of marijuana in a motor vehicle. They were both given the citations and released. I
also released both Farley and Hampton.
I then went back to the Brooklyn Center Police Department where I weighed the marijuana. Upon placing all 7
bags on the scale, I observed that collectively all 7 bags weighed 18.2 grams. I property inventoried the 7 bags
separately. I also weighed each separately. Item #1 was property inventoried as 2.9 grams; item #2 as 2.9
grams; item #3 was 3:1 grams; item #4 was 2.6 grams; item #5 was 2.6 grams; item #6 was 3.0 grams; and item
#7 was 2.7 grams. Upon weighing all the bags separately, I concluded that all the bags were packaged to be
roughly of the same weight and all appeared to be wrapped in a package individually for sale. I also property
inventoried the other bag the bag which contained items 1 through 7. I inventoried that as item #8.
GABLER
Ja 03/12/07
Siqnatures
Reporting O�cer Date
Supervisor Date
Printed by: bc114to Page 1 of 2
Incident Report
Printed dateltime: 5/9/07 14:00
BROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
6645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNE50TA 55430
(763) 569-3333 ItlCidetlt NU�'ibeC: BC07 -001647
incident Summary
Incident Type: CRIMINAL OFFENSE(S) Report Type: JUVENILE
Inc Occurred Address: 2920 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER; MN 55430 SectoriBeat: 4/BC04
Inc Occurred Start: 03/27/2007 20:30 Inc Occur�ed End: 03/27/2007 20:30 Report Taken:
nce: U
Substa
Domestic: N
B�as M
otrvation: Gang Related: U
Contact Nature: ReN�rte�
ate/Time: 03/27/2007 20:30
Reporting O�cer. GABLER, RICHARD Primary Assigned Qfficer:
Case Status: CLOSED Disposition: JUVENILE ARREST Disposition Date: 03/28/2007 06:52
Offenses
Statute Code: 340A-503-1 Enhancers:
Statute Desc: LIQUOR-MINOR CONSUMPTION UNDER AGE 18 I
Statute Severit MISDEME
ANOR i
Counts: 1 y
Officers 4
S uad#
Name
9
Event Association Emp� ����e
PRIMARY REPORTING OFFICER 3228 147 GABLER, RICHARD
Associated Events
Association: Event Type: Event#: Event Date (Start): Event Date (End): Agency:
ARREST TO iNCIDENT ARREST BC07-001647 03/27/2007 20:30:00 03/27/2007 20:30:00 BC
List of Attach
ments
Type: Report ID: Report Date: Report Summary:
I AGENCY REF Juvenile Offense Report
C ENT
OTHER LAW ENFOR EM
I
Persons Involved
Person#: 0001 MNI: 18174246 Can ID Suspect: No
Event Association: JUVENILE ARREST Contact Date/Time: 03127/2007 20:30
Name:
DOB: 11/05/1989 Age: 17 17 Sex: MALE Race: BI.ACK NON-HISPAN�C
ht: 6' 1" 6' 1" Weight: 150 150 Ibs Eye Color: BROWN Hair Color: BLACK
Hei
9
/CY14
Sector/Beat
Address
Phone Type 1: HOME Phone# 1: (763) 535-4960 Ext 1:
Phone T e 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
YP
Occupation: STUDENT Employer/School: ARMSTRONG HIGH SCHOOL
Person Offenses
Statute Code: 340A-503-1 Enhancers: i
Statute Desc: UQUOR-MINOR CONSUMPTfON UNDER AGE 18
Counts: 1
Businesses Involved
Business 0001
Event Association: LOCATION
Business Name: CENTER POINTE APARTMENTS Business Type: APARTMENTS
Address: 2920 NORTHWAY DR BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430 SectorlBeat: 4BC04
Phone Type 1: Phone# 1: Ext 1:
Phone Type 2: Phone# 2: Ext 2:
I
Page 2 of 2
Printed b bc114to
Y
Printed date/time: 5!9l07 14:00 �1'1CIC�@Ilt R@p01't
ROOKLYN CENTER POLICE DEPT
645 HUMBOLDT AVE N
dROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA 55430
(763} 569-3333 Incident Number: BC07-001647
Narratives
Entered Date/Time: 03/28/2007 06:54 Narrative Type: MAIN REPORT
Subject: MAIN REPORT Author: GABLER, RICHARD
�was running away from police in the Center Pointe Apartment Complex. smelled like alcohoi
ana gave a PBT reading of 0.077.
Siqnatures
Reporting O�cer Date
Supervisor Date
STATE OF MINNESOTA
COUNTY OF HENNEPIN
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER
In Re: October 1, 2007
Special Meeting Of The
Brooklyn Center City Council
OBJECTI4NS OF BROOKLYN CENTER LEASED HOUSING ASSOCIATES
LIMITED PARTNERSHIP TO THE OCTOBER 1. 2007 SPECIAL MEETING
OF THE BROOKLYN CENTER CITY COUNCIL
1. The City of Brooklyn Center ("City") Has Failed To Provide Brooklyn
Center Leased Housing Associates Limited Partnership (`BCLHA") With
Sufficient Written Notice Regarding The Alleged Grounds For The October
1, 2007 Special Meeting and "Proposed License Action." (See, e.g., Section
12-910(7), U.S. Const. amend. XIV, l, Minn. Const. art. I, 7)
2. The City Has Failed To Identify The Manner In Which The City Council
Will Conduct The October 1, 2007 Special Meeting And The Applicable
Standard Of Review The City Council Will Apply. (See, e.g., Section 12-941,
12-910, U.S. Const. amend. XIV, 1, Minn. Const. art. I, 7)
3. City Attorney William Clelland ("Clelland") Is Operating Under A Contlict
Of Interest. (See, e.g., U.S. Const. amend. XIV, 1, Minn. Const. art. I, 7,
Minnesota Rules of Professional Conduct)
4. The City Has Failed To Disclose To BCLHA Its Ex Parte Communications
With The City Council Prior To The October 1, 2007 Special Meeting. (See,
e.g., U.S. Const. amend. XIV, 1, Minn. Const. art. I, 7)
5. The City Has Failed To Comply With Its Ordinances Prior To The October
1, 2007 Special Meeting. (See, e.g., Section 12-901(2), Section 12-910, Section
12-911, U.S. Const. amend. XIV, l, Minn. Const. art. I, 7)
6. The City Intends To Rely On Improper, Misleading, Inaccurate And Illegally
Acquired "Evidence" To Support The "Proposed License Action." (See, e.g.,
Section 12-913, Section 12-905, Section 12-1001, U.S. Const. amend. XIV, 1
and amend. IV, Minn. Const. art. I, 7 and art. I, 10, Camara v. Mun. Ct. of
City and County of San Francisco, 387 U.S. 523, 528-29 (1967))
1 All Ordinance citations are to the City of Brooklyn Center City Code of Ordinances,
Chapter 12 Building Maintenance and Occupancy Ordinance.
BCLHA'S OBJECTIONS TO THE OCTOBER 1. 2007 SPECIAL MEETING
BCLHA hereby puts the City Council on notice regarding a number of procedural
and substantive objections that BCLHA has to the October l, 2007 special meeting and
"proposed license action[.]" (See Exhibit I attached hereto.) BCLHA urges the City
Council to carefully consider BCLHA's objections before taking unwarranted, ultra vires
or arbitrary actions to improperly and unfairly deprive BCLHA of its rental license for
the Center Pointe property without due process of law and upon less than substantial
evidence.
1. The City Has Failed To Provide BCLHA With Sufficient Written
Notice Regarding The Alleged Grounds For The October 1, 2007
Special Meeting and "Proposed License Action."
The City Ordinance explicitly requires the City to provide BCLHA with written
notice of all alleged grounds for the suspension or revocation of the Center Pointe rental
license prior to the October l, 2007 special meeting. Specifically, Section 12-910(7)
provides that "[a] decision to revoke, suspend, deny or not renew a license shall be
preceded bv written notice to the applicant or licensee of the alle�ed �rounds therefore
and the applicant or licensee will be given an opportunity for a hearing before the City
Council befare final action to revoke, suspend, deny or not renew a license." (emphasis
added).
Here, despite Clelland's August 28 assurance that "a comprehensive list of
reasons for the proposed license action and supporting documentation will be nrovided in
sufficient time" (see Ex. E) the City has failed to provide BCLHA with the promised
2 These preliminary objections are necessarily incomplete because the City has failed to
provide BCLHA with proper written notice regarding the alleged grounds for the
proposed license action. BCLHA will raise additional objections at the special meeting
and afterwards, as appropriate and necessary.
i2sa�6.z 2
comprehensive list of the alleged grounds for the proposed license action. This failure to
provide BCLHA with proper notice of the grounds supporting the City's contemplated
license action seriously prejudices BCLHA and prevents it from adequately preparing to
defend itself at the special meeting. Indeed, all that BCLHA has received are vague
letters from August/September 2007 which attach documents that purport to be "hearing
exhibits" although no documents are labeled as such or are organized in any
perceivable manner. (See, e.g., Exs. A, C, E, G, H, I, J attached hereto (without
attachments).) The August/September 20071etters from Clelland fail to indicate with any
specificity what the grounds for the "proposed license action" are. (See Exs. A, C, E, G,
H, I, J.) None of the letters cite to any Ordinance that has allegedly been violated and
none even attempt to list in a coherent fashion the specific grounds underlying the
proposed license action. (See Exs. A, C, E, G, H, I, J.)
Due process requires that BCLHA must be given adequate time to investigate the
specific allegations against it and to prepare its defense. Because the City has failed to
provide BCLHA with proper written notice regarding the "proposed license action," in
violation of Section 12-910(7} and applicable law, the City Council should not proceed
with the October 1, 2007 special meeting.
2. The City Has Failed To Identify The Manner In Which The City
Council Will Conduct The October 1, 2007 Special Meeting And The
Applicable Standard Of Review The City Council Will Apply.
In addition to failing to provide BCLHA with appropriate notice of the alleged
grounds for the special meeting, the City has failed to inform BCLHA of the procedure
the City Council will follow during the special meeting on October 1 and the standard of
iass�6.z 3
review the City Council will utilize when making its decision regarding the Center Pointe
rental license.
The City Ordinances impermissibly fail to provide any guidance on these issues.
See, e.g., Sections 12-901, 12-910. Moreover, the arbitrary nature of the October 1
special meeting is highlighted by Clelland's September 5 letter, which states that the
hearing "will take several hours, will be open to the public, that [Clelland] will call
witnesses, including Building Official Laurence Martin, his staff, Officer Terry Olson
and Renee Dickson of MFHA, who will be under oath and subject to cross examination.
I expect rebuttal witnesses as well. The Rules of Evidence do not apply to a hearing such
as this. It will be tape recorded." (See Ex. G.) Clelland's letter raises many questions
including, for example, what role Clelland will take at the hearing will he be acting in a
prosecutorial fashion or as a presiding city officer? Who will act as the "judge" to make
legal and factual findings? Who will control the ability to interview and cross-examine
the witnesses? Who will determine the proper scope of examination and testimony?
Who will determine how and when rebuttal witnesses will be allowed? Who will
determine what evidence is properly before the City Council? How will the credibility or
sufficiency of evidence be challenged or authenticated? The ambiguous procedural
format of the October 1 special meeting prejudices BCLHA's ability to prepare for and
properly defend itself from allegations of wrongdoing.
In addition, the City has failed to provide to BCLHA a list of the specific
witnesses it plans to call at the hearing and the expected issues upon which the specific
witnesses will testify. (See Exs. A, C, E, G, H, I, J.) For example, Clelland's
September S letter states that Laurence Martin's "staff' will be called as a witness. (See
iz,as�6.2 4
Ex. G.) The failure of the City to specifically identify all of its witnesses and the issues
upon which they will testify prior to the special meeting has prejudiced BCLHA's ability
to prepare for the hearing and to prepare its defense. It has also, perhaps by design,
revented BCLHA from contactin the otential witnesses and discoverin the substance
P g P g
of the witnesses' expected testimony prior to the special meeting.
Similarly, the City Ordinances fail to address the standard of review the City
Council will utilize to determine whether it is appropriate to suspend or revoke the Center
Pointe rental license. For example, it is unclear if the City Council's decision is wholly
arbitrary or if the City Council will be following any prescribed guidelines. Particularly
in light of the fact that Clelland has proposed a hearing during which he apparently
intends to call numerous witnesses and rebuttal witnesses, it is manifestly improper for
the City Council to take any action without identifying the standard of review under
which it will consider and assess the evidence presented. Due process requires that
BCLHA must be given adequate time to investigate the specific allegations against it and
to prepare its defense. BCLHA's ability to defend itself and present its evidence is
senously pre�udiced by the City's apparent failure to operate pursuant to any discernible
standard of review and procedural process.
3. City Attorney William Clelland Is Operating Under A Conflict Of
Interest.
The need for clarity regarding Clelland's role at the hearing i.e., as a prosecutor,
presiding city officer or "judge" is amplified by Clelland's conflict of interest and the
appearance of impropriety created by the many hats Clelland wears in his crusade against
Center Pointe.
i2sa�6.a 5
For example, Clelland, as a prosecuting attorney on behalf of the City, brought
criminal charges against Hyder Jaweed ("Jaweed") in May 2007 and again in June 2007.
These charges seek to hold Jaweed criminally responsible for purported conditions at
Center Pointe, despite the fact that Jaweed is not an "owner" of Center Pointe. In
addition, in August 2007, Clelland on behalf of the City brought similar criminal charges
against Asgher Ali ("A. Jaweed") asserting that he is an "owner" of Center Pointe
(although the City's own records demonstrate that A. Jaweed has no ownership interest in
Center Pointe, BCLHA or even BCLHA's general partner, Brooklyn Center Housing,
LLC). Without explanation, the criminal complaint against A. Jaweed was not served
until September.
Clelland is also a defendant in BCLHA's lawsuit against the City, Clelland, and
others. (See Complaint attached hereto as Ex. K.) The Complaint alleges, among other
things, that Clelland has defamed BCLHA, Jaweed, and A. Jaweed, threatened
prosecution that is not supported by law, undertaken improper and illegal acts of
harassment and intimidation, tortiously interfered with contractual relationships, and
subjected the City to vicarious liability for his wrongful acts and omissions. (See id.)
The criminal prosecutions, BCLHA, Jaweed and A. Jaweed's civil action and the
October l, 2007 "proposed license action" all arise out of the same or related
3 On September 12, 2007, BCLHA, Jaweed and A. Jaweed filed a Complaint in
Hennepin County District Court against the City, Clelland, and others, asserting claims
for breach of contract, tortuous interference with contractual relations, libel and slander,
violations of the Minnesota Human Rights Act, Minn. Stat. 363A.001-.41, trespass,
declaratory judgment regarding the absence of a nuisance, and vicarious liability. (See
Ex. K.) The Complaint seeks redress for the City and its representatives and agents'
improper and illegal actions and seeks damages, declaratory relief, injunctive relief and
any other relief that will cause the City's harassment of BCLHA, Jaweed and A. Jaweed
to end.
izss�6.z 6
circumstances, and Clelland's many overlapping roles create an impermissible conflict of
interest and the appearance of impropriety. Clelland may not exercise his discretionary
function in the criminal actions or his as of yet undefined lead role in the special
proceeding (see Ex. G) in an evenhanded manner in light of the related civil action and
allegations of individual wrongdoing raised by BCLHA, Jaweed, and A. Jaweed. The
City Council's apparent reliance on Clelland to take a primary role during the special
meeting is unfairly prejudicial to BCLHA in light of the conflict of interest and
appearance of impropriety his many roles have created.
4. The City Has Failed To Disclose To BCLHA Its Ex Parte
Communications With The City Council Prior To The October 1,
2007 Special Meeting.
Despite BCLHA's August 21 request for a copy of all information that "has been,
or in the future is provided to the City Council in anticipation of this meeting" (see Ex.
B), to date, the City has failed to provide to BCLHA any af its ex parte communications
with the City Council, particularly the information that it or related parties have provided
to the City Council in anticipation of the hearing. (See Exs. A, C, E, G, H, I, J.) The
City's failure to fully disclose to BCLHA all relevant information and ex parte
communications with the City Council the ultimate decision maker prior to the
special meeting is improper and highly prejudicial to BCLHA.
Presumably, the City Council's decision to notice a hearing on September 24 and
then a special meeting on October 1 regarding a"proposed license action" was not purely
arbitrary and had some sort of an evidentiary basis. It can also be presumed that there
have been numerous ex parte communications between the City and its representatives
(such as the City Attorney and police department) prior to the October 1 special meeting.
i2ss�6.z
Yet, despite BCLHA's request, the City has not provided BCLHA with copies of a� ex
parte communications and all information that the City has provided to the City Council
in anticipation of the October 1"proposed license action."
Due process requires that BCLHA must be given adequate time to investigate the
specific allegations against it and to prepare its defense. The City's failure to disclose to
BCLHA the ex parte information that it has provided to the City Council in advance of
the special meeting and all information that the City Council is relying upon for its
"proposed license action" is improper and prevents BCLHA from appropriately
challenging that information and from properly preparing to defend itself at the special
meeting.
5. The City Has Failed To Comply With Its Ordinances Prior To The
October 1, 2007 Special Meeting.
Finally, the City has failed to comply with its own Ordinances prior to the special
meeting. Far example, Section 12-901(2) provides that "[r]egular licenses will be issued
for a period of two years. All licenses, regular and provisionai, will be reviewed everv
six months after the be�innin� of the license term to determine the license status."
Further, under Section 12-910(6), a rental license may be revoked "at the end of any six-
month review period under 12-901(2)[.]" (emphasis added). Thus, review of the
November 30, 2006 license could not have occurred until May 30, 2007. Nevertheless,
on February 8, 2007, the City conducted an inspection of Center Pointe that resulted in
new compliance orders identifying a laundry list of alleged deficiencies. Now the City
has scheduled a special meeting to address a"proposed license action" on October 1,
2007 yet October l, 2007 is clearly not at the end of any six-month review period. The
City has violated Section 12-901(2) and 12-910(6) by beginning its review of the rental
izss�6.z g
license prior to May 30, 2007, by starting to take actions to revoke the license prior to
May 30, 2007, and by taking "proposed license action" at a time that is not at the end of
any six month review period. The City's actions are improper and unauthorized.
Simiiarly, the City has failed to comply with Section 12-911, which applies to
conduct on licensed premises. Under Section 12-911(3), if licensed premises are used in
a disorderly manner (as described in Section 12-911(1)), the City Manager shall give
notice to the licensee of the violation and direct the licensee to take steps to prevent
future violations. If another instance of disorderly use occurs within three months of a
prior incident, the City Manager shall notify the licensee of the violation and require the
licensee to submit a report of the actions taken and proposed actions to prevent future
disorderly use of the premises. If a third instance of disorderly use occurs within three
months after the prior two instances, under Section 12-911(5), the rental dwelling license
may be denied, revoked, suspended or not renewed. The City Manager shall initiate such
action by giving the licensee written notice of a hearing. The written notice must
"specify all violations of this section, and shall state the date, time, place and purpose of
the hearing. The hearing shall be held no less than ten (10) days and no more than thirty
(30) days after giving such notice." Section 12-91 l(5).
To date, the City Manager has not complied with the procedure set forth in
Section 12-911, including the requirement of written notice "specify[ing] all violations of
this section" and a hearing scheduled no mare than 30 days after giving written notice.
Therefore, any attempt by the City Council to rely on Section 12-911 as a basis for the
suspension/renewal of the Center Pointe license would be improper and unauthorized.
Other violations of the City Ordinances are likely, however, the vagueness of the specific
128876.2 9
II I
grounds for the "proposed license action" prevents BCLHA from identifying all
violations prior to the special meeting.
6. The City Intends To Rely On Improper, Misleading, Inaccurate And
IIlegally Acquired "Evidence" To Support The "Proposed License
Action"
Any decision of the City Council based upon the evidence thus far disclosed by
Clelland on behalf of the City cannot constitute substantial evidence because some of the
alleged "evidence" that Clelland intends to introduce is impermissibly inaccurate,
incomplete, misleading and/or improperly and illegally procured.
For example, on September 21, 2007, Clelland provided BCLHA with an
inaccurate hearing exhibit that purportedly summarizes the Section 12-913 calls for
service to Center Pointe. (See Ex. J.) The September 2006 Ordinance Tracking Sheet for
Section 12-913 calls that the Brooklyn Center Police Deparhnent provided to Center
Pointe explicitly identifies 15 Section 12-913 calls during September 2006. Yet,
Clelland's summary hearing exhibit (with no supporting materials) shows a total of 29
Section 12-913 calls for service in September 2006. This "summary hearing exhibiY' is
inaccurate and should not be reiied upon by the City Council.
Another example of improper evidence is found in Clelland's August 28, 2007
letter. (See Ex. E.) In that letter, Clelland states that the hearing exhibits include
compliance orders from October 5, 2006 and November 15, 2006. The City Ordinances,
however, do not permit prior past compliance orders to serve as a basis for a license
revocation or suspension. On January 10, 2007, the City of Brooklyn Center issued a
two-year rental license for the Center Pointe complex, effective as of November 30,
2006. Pursuant to Section 12-905, a new rental license could not have been issued
izss�6.a 10
"unless the rental dwelling and its premises conform to the Ordinances of Brooklyn
Center and the laws of the State of Minnesota." Thus, in issuing the new rental license,
the City conclusively certified that, as of January 10, 2007, BCLHA was in compliance
with all applicable ordinances and laws and as such, any pre-January 10, 2007
compliance orders are irrelevant. Clelland's apparent intent to introduce the October and
November 2006 compliance orders as evidence at the special meeting can only be
designed to improperly prejudice the City Council. The October and November 2006
compliance orders should not be considered by the City Council in connection with the
"proposed license action."
Yet another example of improper evidence was disclosed by Clelland on
September 21, 2007. (See Ex. J.) On that date, Clelland provided BCLHA with a
compact disc that shows video of police officers, on three separate occasions, using a key
to access the Center Pointe property and inspecting the Center Pointe property.
Section 12-1001 explicitly provides that inspections must occur on a scheduled basis. It
is clear from the video that the three inspections were not scheduled. More importantly,
the police officers did not have consent from Center Pointe to conduct their random
unannounced searches or use of a key to access the Center Pointe property. The police
officers likewise were not acting pursuant to an investigatory or administrative search
warrant or an order to inspect issued by a court of competent jurisdiction. The police
officers' actions were illegal and unconstitutional, and as such, the illegally acquired
evidence the video should not be considered by the City Council. See, e.g., U.S.
Const. amend. IV; Minn. Const. art. I, 10; Camara v. Mun. Ct. of City and County of
San Francisco, 38� U.S. 523, 528-29 (1967).
t2ss�6.a 11
CONCLUSION
BCLHA urges the City Council to carefully consider BCLHA's objections to the
October 1, 2007 special meeting before taking any "proposed license action" that could
result in the unwarranted and improper deprivation of BCLHA's rental license for the
Center Pointe property without fair and due process under the City's Ordinances and the
overnin law. Due rocess re uires that BCLHA be rovided ad uate notice and a
g g P �1
P q
meaningful opportunity to be heard before its rental license is revoked or suspended. See
U.S. Const. amend. XIV, l; Minn. Const. art. I, 7. Unless the procedural and
substantive irregularities and objections described above are addressed and rectified by
the City Council, BCLHA will not receive due process at the October l, 2007 special
meeting.
ANTHONY OS
TLUND BAER P.A.
Dated: Se tember 27 2007 B: 1\ �/`M-��. �'i o,.
p y
Norman�r (#163715)
Mark D. er (#217736)
Shannon M. Awsumb (#343389)
90 South Seventh Street
Suite 3600
Minneapolis, MN 55402
(612) 349-6969
ATTORNEYS FOR BROOKLI'N
CENTER LEASED HOUSING
ASSOCIATES LIMITED
PARTNERSHIP, HYDER JAWEED,
AND ASGHER ALI
(A/K!A ASGHER JAWEED)
I
I
i2aa�6.a 12
HU I�{ u; V"I:GGp VViniam G Glelland 505 $20 6943
p.1
G.,A.�.SOxv, GL�LLAND SG�REDFR
LTTOIt:G��$ AT I.A,W
�°ROpE9910NA1_ L�MiTrP L�ABILITY PAqTivER�NIP
J�_FFqEY A. C11aEON 63D0 $NING_E CRQ6R PARKUI'rY� SU TE �Oti TELEnNdNE
W144�AM CIE��ANJ
ELICN M. SCHR6DE4
MINNFAPQ��.g, MINNF$OTA 5�a3Q-Z�HO $91
C1nVi0 K_ ROSy r nX
OAWI'� C. SfE_T7. C763 SFi
��Mh T'��/�M=9 14 A,ugust 20fl7
VT.A FACSTMILE 763.354.5519 ar�d U.S. Mail
.�ack W. Sa.f�
Dav�id .Z,. Htzez
Ar,r��zand E. Sz
Pau1 R. Sween
TJominiurrm Mana�exment Ser.vices
2355 Pt�lar.i.s Lane, Suite 100
Pl.�znouth, M.innesota 55447
�'Ui Ft�CSIlvIILE 763.4I3.5174
Ke�neth Hert�
I Law O�ces, I'.�.
3853 Central Avenue, N�.
Col�u.mbia l�ez�tts, Mi�ta.esota �5421
R�: Centzr.point
Gentlem etl,
'You are hereby �toti�ied th.at ths $rook.�yn Ce�ter Cxty Council wxll hold a
h�aTing as to t�e suspensionlr�vocatio� of the z�enta�, license held by Brooltlyn
Center Leased Hous�g Associates, LLP, fo� the Centerpoint property, o.a th,e 24th
day of Septe�b�r 2007 at 7pm. Wnitten reasons for the license action will
subsequent�y mailed to you.
S in��rely,
CA�SON, C�.�LL,t�1�D SCL�ED�R
t
i lxa�m G e� aud
EXHIBIT A
f
A NT}i OSTLLIND i�AEx;� PA.
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
NORMAN BAER
Email: nbaer@aoblaw.com
AUgLISt 21, 2���
iVIA �A�'SIti1ILE and U.S. MAIL
William G. Clelland, Esq.
Carson, Clelland Schreder
6300 Shingle Creek Parkway, Suite 305
Minneapolis, MN 55430
Re: Center Pointe Apartments
Our �i�e No.3109-1
Dear Mr. Clelland:
Please be advised that the undersigned, and the firm of Anthony Ostlund Baer, P.A., have
been retained ta represent the owner of the Center Pointe Apartment complex, Brooklyn Center
Leased Housing Associates Lir�ited Partnership, with respect to any and all disputes with the
City of:Brooklyn Center. In addition, we have been retained to represent Hyder Jaweed and
Asgher Jaweed, personally, should the need arise.
I have seen a letter dated August 14, 2007 in which you state that ihere will be a hearing on
September 24, 2007 at 7:00 p.m. "as to the suspension/revocation of the rental license" for
Center Pointe. Please immediately provide me with a written statement of all of the reasons for
that hearing, and any documents purportedly supporting fhose reasons. If information has been,
or in the future is provided to the City Council in anticipation of this meeting, please provide a
copy fi.o me. Yaur efforts to make this a"fair" hearing will be appreciated.
Also lease advise as to whether there is a wa to avoid the Se tember 24th hearin M client
P Y P g Y
is anxious to work wit� the City to address any legitimate concerns the City may have abont
Center Pointe. As I'm sure you realize, Center Pointe plays an important role providing decent
housing for those who have few apfions. If there are issues that need to be addressed, my client
woulc] prefer to d� so now rather tllan waiting a month.
Finally, it has also come to my attention that you {and others :at the City) have beer�
communicating about my elients with others with whom my clients have business relationships.
At least some of those communications seem to have been far the purpose of interfering with my
90 SOUTH SEVENTH ST T SUI E 3 0 MWNEAPOLIS MN 55402
REE T 60
vu
Telephone (612) 349-6969 Facsimile (612) 349-6996 www.aoblaw.com �^n'�'T B
I
William G. C1elland, Esq.
August ZI, 2007
Page 2
clients' business. Your assistance in seeing to it that such communications are stoppecl
immediately will also be appreciated.
Very truly yours,
ANTHONY OSTLUND BAER, P.A.
N���
Norman J. aer
1�JB/jmb
cc: Kenneth Hertz, Esq:
Hyder Jaweed
Asgher Jaweed
G�SON, GLELLANI3 8� SG�X�D��
ATTOBNE�S AT LA.W
PROFESSIONAL lIM�7BD LIA61l�'�'Y aqRTNERS�+�P
.JEFFREY A_ CARSON 8300 3N�NGLB CRCEK PARKWA`�, 9U�7'E 305 TEf„EaHQNE
WILI�AM C. CtEt4AND (763) 56LZ60Q
MINNCAPOI�1.�� MINNe30Ta.5 5 430-2 1 9 0
E��Ew M_ SGr9REDHR F X
pAVtD K. ROSS i 763 SBI-1943
oaWtv E_ SPELT2
JOHN J. THAt�ES
24 August 2007
VIA FACSIlV�Q,E 6 �2.349.6996
Norman J. Baer
.A,nthony, Ost�und Baer, �.,A..
Attomeys at Law
90 South Sevez�tb� Str�et, Suite 3600
�ix�neapolis, Minnesota 55402
Centerpoivat
bear Mr_ Baez,
VVe wAll certainly coznpZy with City ordiz�a�aces which requ�re disclosure o£
the xeasons for the pxoposed license action and provide tk�at documenta�ion
supporting tk�e praceeding. �uch of the data as to calls for sez�vic� is pub�c data
�ra�a �ie police department and �s quite voluminous but is subject to a Minnesota
Statutes Chaptez �3 xequest fror� �rou.
Couversations �xr�itlz other exsons necessa� have talfem lace and w,�l take
P Y
P
plac�_ Oth�r governzxzentai agenc�es, such as 1V1��FA, have oversight aud
enforcez�aent respoz�sibilities regarding Centerpoint. M�A., on its own initiative,
��spected the premise and issued its o�m complia.c�.ce orders azxd City ordia�anc�s
require co�anpliance �vith those orders, as well as City orders. Otb�er groups �a�'e
made inquiries ta w�aich we are obliga.ted to respond, as required by Chaptez 13.
Commun�icarion with thes� perso�s is intended only to azd enforcement of Xaws and
far no other pu�pose.
Sincezely,
S ER
i' eand
1'd l�6� 'ON EXHIBIT C S'� a� Wd95 Z l LDOL 'trl '9f1�
k40/L401�j xe} F N0�'�VVl80daXY�iNQB� XY�I IQ=ZI L04ZI�Z�80
A NTHONY OSTLLIND BAER, P.A.
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
NORMAN f BAER
Emait: nbaer@aoblaw.com
August 27, 2007
VIA FACSIMILE and U.S. MA�L
William G. Clelland, Esq.
Carson, Clelland Schreder
6300 Shingle Creek Parkway, Suite 305
Minneapolis, MN 55430
Re: Center Pointe Apartments City of Brooklyn Center
Our File No.3109-1
Dear Mr. Clelland:
I am in receipt of your letter of August 24. While I appreciate the information you have
provided, you did not respond to my specific request dated August 21, 2007, to "immediately
provide me with a written statement of all of the reasons for that hearing, and any documents
purportedly supporting those reasons." You also failed to respond to my request that you advise
me as to whether there is a way to avoid the September 24 hearing. Again, I note that my client
and I are interested in working to resolve difficulties with the City, rather than playing games.
We are unable to take those steps if you, on behalf of the City, refuse to provide us with the
requested inforrnation.
Very truly yours,
ANTHONY OSTLUND BAER, P.A.
�ct�a.�
Norman J. Baer
NJB/jmb
cc: Kenneth Hertz, Esq.
Hyder Jaweed
Asgher Jaweed
90 SOUTH SEVENTH STREET, SU[TE 3600, MINN£APOLIS, MN 55402
Telephone (6]2) 349-6969 Facsimile (612) 349-6996 www.aobiaw.com EXHIB�T D
Aug 28 07 10:04a William G C�elland 505 820 6943 p.1
GAPSON, GLELIy��7D 8� SGHR�DEP
.c�,TTOR� E YS AT I..�W
PROFESSIONAL l_1MITE7 LIABILITY PARTNERSHIP
JEFF"REY A, CARSON 63�C $HINGLE GREEK PARKWAY, SUITE 3C5 7ELE?HONE
V��ILLIAM1t G- GLELLANC <763: �61-2BOO
MI�INEA MtNNESOTIa 5 54 30-2 1 90 F4X
ELIEN M. SCHRE7ER
OAYID K. ROSS t763 561-I°43
DAW V E. $�El
JOHN J. THAMES
28 August 2007
VIA FACSIMILE 612.349.6996
and documents via COURIER
Norman J. Baer
Anthony, Ostltu�d $aer, P.A,
Attorneys at Law
90 South Seventh Street, Suite 3600
Miruieapolis, Minnesota SS4Q2
RE: Centerpaint
Dear Mr. Baer,
The entire exten# of your c3ier�Ys default under applicable state taws and city
ordinances has not been determined but a comprehensive list of reasons for the
prflposed license action and su�porting documentation will be provided in
sufficient time for you and your clients to prepare for the hearing.
VVithout limitation, the reasons for the proposed license action include
failure to compiy with �the October/November 2006 compiiance orders, issued as a
conditxon of license renewal, fa.ilure to comply with the 25 April 2007 compliance
orders, fa.iiure to mainta.in cwrrent utility payments, failure to pay taxes and
assessments currently, failure to pay the year 2047 bvnd administration fee,
faituxe to comply with the orders from 1VIHFA, failure to sec�re the buildings by
repair or replacement of exterior doors and/or locks and failure to abate premises
crime and disorder.
Your clients have long had copies of these compliance notices and orders
and based upon current €nformatian provided tv me the first half year 2(}07 real
property taxes are unpaid. City ardinances require that the real property owner
must be current on payment of taxes, assessments and utali�ies, at all times, as a
condition of the license and this includes current payments on ail other renta.l
EXHIBlT E
Aug 28 07 10:05a William G Clelland 505 820 6943 p.2
B aer 28 August 2007 g. 2.
properties the owner has in the city. Yoza.r clients a�lowed the natural gas utility
payments to come into such arrears that gas shutoff was unminent_ I am advised
that natural gas was shutoff at Brookhaven for a day un�ii �ayment.
Until recently paid, your clients allowed utility payments to the City to
become delinquent for Centerpoint in an amounY more than $76,000 and
de�inquent for $rookhaven ir� an amount more than $18,000.
While our clients claim the e�erior doors have been secured, see the
Y
report of Lt. Benner who u�spected the premises immediately after this ctaim was
made and who found numerous violations and buildings not secured by adequate
locking doors.
Due to the volume of docu.ments, rnany are being sent via courier and you
should have them this week. Other city documents, as to utility and band
delinquencies, will be delivered next week.
I think you can expect this hearing to go forward.
Sincerely,
CARSON, CLELLAND SCHREDER
f
C�t,��
iam G. C elland
via courier
Report of Lt. Benner
Compliance orders from City
Compliance ordezs from MI-�A
ANTHONY OSTLUND BQER, P.A.
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
NORMAN f BAER
Email: nbaer@aoblaw.com
September 4, 2007
VIA FACS�NfILE and U.S. MAI�
William G. Clelland, Esq.
Carson, Clelland Schreder
6300 Shingle Creek Parkway, Suite 305
Minneapalis, MN 55430
Re: Center Pointe Apartments City of Braoklyn Center
Our File No. 3109-1
Dear Mr. Clelland:
I write in anticipation of the hearing scheduled for September 24 regarding the rental license for the
operation of Center Pointe.
As you know, this hearing is now scheduled.for less than three weeks from today. Thus far, despite
my requests, and earlier requests by my client, the City has not provided a complete list of the
reasons for the meeting. Likewise, despite requests, the City has not disclosed the documents or
other information it intends to rely upon. I again ask that you cure those deficiencies.
After a careful review, I note that the City's ordinances do not provide any guidance regarding
procedure for this hearing. Please provide me with a written description of the detailed procedure
that will be followed. Among the questions are the following: Will this hearing be open to the
public? Who will preside at the hearing? Will witnesses be placed under oath? Will evidentiary
rules be followed? Wi11 there be an opportunity for examination and/or cross-examination? How
long will be allowed for this hearing? Will there be a court reporter present to make a record of the
proceedings? Will City employees be made avaiIable for testimony? If so, which employees are
you planning on having present?
lY1y client obviously has-a very significant property interest in the rental license and, accordingly, I
urge the City (apparently at your direction) to take all of the steps neeessary to be sure that my
client has been afforded due process. Please provide the information requested in this letter
immediately. If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me.
Very truly yours,
ANTHONY OSTLUND BAER, P.A.
I f��� 1
Norman J. Ba
NJB/
J
ce: Hyder Jaweed Asgher Jaweed
90 SOIITH SEVENTH STREET, SUITE 3600, MINNEAPOL(S, MN 55402
Telephone (612) 349-6969 Facsimile (612) 349-6996 www.aoblaw.com EXHIBIT F
GA�SO�T, GLELL.AtND 8c SG��'EDEA
ATTO$N�"it'S AT LAw
GROFESSiONAL L�MITEO LIAHILtT' PARTNER$HIP
JSFFREYA. CARSON 6300 SH�NGLE CREEK PARKWAY, 3U�TE 305 TEtEPMONE
WILLIAM G. CIEtLAND (7631 Set
ELLEN M. SCHREOER MINN6AP0��9. MINNESOTA 55�30 FAX
DAVID K. ROSB (763) 56�-�943
DAwN E_ SPE�'R
JOMN J. THAMES
5 Septem.beT 2007
VZA, TACSIlvIlLE 612.349.6996
and docum�nts via C�URT.ER
Noxxnan J_ Baer
Anthony, Os�iund �aear, PA.
Attox;�eys at Law
90 South 5eventh �ixeet, Stute 3600
Minneapolis, Min.nesota. 55402
RE: Centerpoint
Deaz �it'. Baer,
It is untrue, as you assert in you�r �ost zecent let�er, that th� City has not
identified the reasoz�s �ar the proposed license actio� nox pxov�ided the hearing
exlubits. I sent you a Iett�r by fa� last week, agaan identifying the basis foz the
proposed acdoz�, supplementi.ng the letter I pr�'s�iausly se�:t to Aominium and the
attamey for J'aweed, datied 24 August 2007. Furtl�er, I sent documents �sria cowniez
last week, consisting of the zepozt of Lt. Benner as to fihe eondition �f tb�e ext�exio�
doo�rs az�d the compliance ord�rs from the City' and MHFA I am delivering, by
courier, toda� documents s�iowing your client's d�faui� in fa�il:tng t� pay the bond fee
abid the delinquencies as to utilities and 'c�v'ill de��ve�r to your o�ce tomorrow or
Ftiday the rema�an,g k�earing e�ibits
Y'au should note tb.at almost all of these exhibits are docuxnent�, �n tlae form
o� coz�unication between the Cif.y and your c�i�ents andlor their agants, as to
delinquent �tili�, bvnd fees aa�d tax payments and complxaz�ce oxdez� and regular
coYrespondence from Officer Texry 41son as to premises crime. 7n fact, you�r c�iemts
have long been Yn poss�ssion o�fihese documents.
I arn m�eting �i� Czty o�cials T�ursday but anticipate that tl�is hearing will
take several hours, will be open to the public, that I will call witnesses, inciudi.ng
I d 9ti5 'ON S '8 Wd65�l1 LOOl �S_
aoo�GOO� xE� f EXHIBIT G io� ��vieov�xv��NOa� xv�z bo=z� �_oozic�_r�n----
f
�Baer 5 S�ptember 200� p_ 2
Building Q�fiicza� �au.rence Martin, his staff, O�icez Tenry Olson and Renee
Dicianson of M��FA, wb�a wiill be under oath and subject to cz examination. I
e�ect rebuttal witnesses as we�. The Rules of Evidence do not apply to a hearing
such as this. �t �vvill be tape recorded_
Sincerely,
CARSON, CLEL�,AND SCHREDE�.
S�I�v���
illiam Cr. Clellan.d
z'd 4b5 'ON S�d Wd65 Z l tQ4Z 'S 'd3S
zoo�zoo x�� F wo� r�v�eove�xv�iNOa� xu�z bo-z� zooz��ofsa
GAl�SON, GLFLLAND SGHREDEl�
ATTOPNEYS A.T L��W
PROFESSIONAL LIMITED LIABILITY PARTNERSHIP
JEFFREY A. CARSON 6300 SH7NGLE CREEK PARKWAY, SUITE 305 TELEPHONE
WILLIAM G. C�ELLAND 763 561-2800
MINNEAPOLIS, MINNESOTA 55430-2i90
ELIEN M.SCHREDER FAX
DAVID K. ROSS (7631 56t-1943
DAWN E. SPELTZ
JOHN J. THAMES
7 September 2007
VIA COURIER
Norman J. Baer
Anthony, Ostiund Baer, P.A.
Attorneys at Law
90 South Seventh Street, Suite 3600
Minneapolis, Minnesota 55402
RE: Centerpoint
Dear Mr. Baer,
I enclose additional hearing e�ibits.
Sincerely,
CARSON, CLELLAND SCHREDER
��✓vl
V�i iam G. Clelland
SEP o 7 200
BAER
ANTH�AiY OSTLUN
EXHIBIT H
�.��a.soz�r GL�]:.LAN77 Pc SGHI��DE1�
�►.xroax��s AT ]GA�'
PROFE5510NAL L�MITEO 11AB�LITY PART�ERSHIP
JEFRREY A. CAR30N TELE�HONE
630D 6HIN66E CREEK PARICWAY. SU�TE 305
763 5� 1-2800
WILLIAM �i. CLELLANO r��NNEAPC4�s. MINN6GOTA5bd39-2�
P.�JC
Et�EN M. SCHREDER
(763 561-19d3
6aVID K- ROSS
pAwN E. SPELTZ
�ptint J. THAMES 13 Septeu�ber 2007
VTA FA.CSINIILE 6X2.349.6996
Noz�aaan Baer
.Anthony, Os�.und Baer, P.A.
Attorn�ys at La�vv
90 South Saventh Street, Suite 3640
Nfinneapolis, Minnesota 5�4Q2
RE: C�nterpoint
Dear Mr. �aer,
The hearing as ta the proposed license acti.on has been moved to a special �aa,eeting at
6pn� on 1 Octobe�r 2007.
Sincerely,
CA�tSON, CLE�.LA1�T17 SGHRE�7ER
i��► n
William G Glelland
W tb
l 'd �lC'ON S WdZl�ll LOOZ'£l'd3S
�oo��oo� x�� E EXHIBIT I 7���v�aove�xa�iNOa� xv�z z��oG �ooz�e�isv
GAP�SON, CLLLLAND SGHL�EDEF�
�.TTOtzrrEYS ��T raw
PROFESSIONAL LIMITEO LIABiLITY PARTNERSHIP
JEFFREY A. CARSON 6300 SHlNGLE CREEK PARKWAY, SUITE 305 TE�EPHONE
WILUAM G. CLELLAND 763 561-2800
ELLEN M. SCHREOER MINNEAP011S, MINNE507A 55430-2�90 FAX
DAVID K. ROSS (7631 56i-i943
DAWN SPELTZ
JOHN J. THAMES
21 September 2007
VIA COZJR.�R
Norman J. Baer
Anthony, Ostlund Baer, P_A.
Attorneys at Law
90 South Seventh Street, Suite 3600
Mit�ieapolis, Mirulesota 55402
RE: Centerpoint
Dear Mr. Baer,
I enclose additional docum�ntary evidence and e�iibits. As to potential
witnesses, in addition to the police officers naxned in the reports disclosed to you,
and the police and sheriff personnel participating in the videotaping, the City may
aiso call Barb Anlcrum, manager of the office building adjacent to Centerpoint and
tenants of Centerpoint.
Sincerely,
CARSON, CLELLAND SCHREDER
vl�illiam G. �elland
#�E�Ei1/ED
SEP 2 1 Z��7
l �l�l+l�
ANTHONY OSTLUMD 8� BAER
EXHIBIT J
STATE OF MINNESOTA DISTRICT COURT
COUNTY OF HENNEPIN FOURTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT
CASE TYPE: Miscellaneous Civil
Brooklyn Center Leased Housing Associates Court File No.
Limited Partnership, a Minnesota limited
partnership, Hyder Jaweed, and Asgl�er Ali
(aJk/a Asgher 7aweed),
Plaintiffs,
v. COMPLAINT
City of Brooklyn Center, Teiry Oison, Kevin
Benner, William G: Clelland and Carson,
Clelland Schreder, a general partnership, and
John Does 1 through 10,
Defendants.
For their Complaint against the Defendants, Plaintiffs Brooklyn Center Leased Housing
Associates Limited Partnership (`BCLHA"), Hyder Jaweed and Asgher Ali (a/k/a A. Jaweed)
state and allege as follows:
INTRODUCTION
i. BCLHA owns and operates the Center Pointe apartment complex in Brooklyn
Center, Hennepin County, Minnesota. The complex, formerly known as Summerchase, provides
252 affordable housing units for its tenants, including many families, the vast majority of whom
are Black, African American or members of other racial minority communities.
2. For more than a decade, elected and appointed officials affiliated with the City of
Brooklyn Center ("the City") have undertaken various schemes designed to harass the owners of
the Center Pointe/Summerchase property in an obvious effort to make operation of the apartment
complex economically untenable. The City's ultimate goal is to force a shu#down of Center
128137.1
EXHIBIT K
Pointe and thereby to drive its largely poor, minority tenant population out of Brookiyn Center.
The City's attitude has been exemplified by the statement of one high ranking official, who
described the City's issues with the complex by stating: "Probiein is, you have too many
niggers."
3. The campaign of the City and its representatives has included filing unwarranted
criminal charges against Hyder Jaweed, Asgher Ali, and the principals of Dominium previously
associated with BCLHA; filing unsubstantiated claims of ordinance violations, even after City
officials have verified that no such violations exist; sending uniformed police officers to enter
apartments and look for ordinance violations after City inspectors reportetl that no such
violations existed; and seeking to penalize Plaintiffs for actions alleged to have been taken by
people over whom Plaintiffs have no control. In addition, Defendants Terry Olson ("Olson"),
Kevin Benner ("Benner") and Wiliiam G. Clelland ("Clelland"), the City Attorney, have taken it
upon themselves to contact Plaintiffs' tenants and business associates, including other
municipalities, lenders and contractors, and make false and defamatory statements regarding
Plaintiffs, a11 aimed at destroying Plaintiffs' business and reputation.
4. This lawsuit seeks relief for the improper and unlawful acts and omissions of the
Defendants that have occurred after December 4, 2002, the date that a settlement agreement took
effect between the City and the owners of the Center Pointe. Although Plaintiffs do not seek
relief for acts and omissions that occurred before the effective date of the settlement agreement,
facts from the time preceding the agreement are relevant to this action because (a} they piace the
Defendants' current actions in context, {b) they show a continuing pattern of abuses and (c) they
show that the uniawful and improper treatment being meted out to Plaintiffs by the Defendants is
not a matter of mistake or coincidence.
2
5. The heavy-handed, unlawful conduct by Clelland, the City and some of the City's
police officers has a long history. The same tactics led to multiple lawsuits between the City and
the former operators of Summerchase. Ultimately, that litigation led to a settlement that required
the City to cease and desist from harassing Summerchase and its owners for three years, subject
to a court order. That agreement generally was honored, but as soon as the three years had
passed, the conduct of harassment resumed. In fact, the pattern of harassment is what ultimately
led members of the prior general partner of BCLHA to sell their interest and withdraw from any
involvement with this housing complex.
'ff el under the state law of Minnesota. In articular,
6. Plainti s seek relief sol P
Y
Plaintiffs seek damages, declaratory relief, injunctive relief and any other relief that will cause
the Defendants' unlawful harassment to stop. The Center Pointe apartments provide decent,
affordable `housing to people who need it.
PARTIES
7. Piaintiff BCLHA is a Minnesota limited partnership. Its general partner is
Brooklyn Center Housing, LLC, a limited liability company.
8. Plaintiff Hyder Jaweed ("Jaweed") is the sole member of Brooklyn Center
Housing, LLC. Jaweed is of Indian descent.
9. Plaintiff Asgher Ali ("A. Jaweed") is the brother of Hyder Jaweed and has been
actively involved in the management of the Center Pointe apartments. A. Jaweed is also of
Indian descent.
10. The City is a Minnesota municipal corporation.
i 1. At times relevant to this lawsuit, Olson was a City police officer with
responsibility for Center Pointe.
3
12. At times relevant to this lawsuit, Benner was a City police officer with
responsibility for Center Pointe.
13. Clelland is, and at all relevant times has been, the City Attorney for Brooklyn
Center.
14. Carson, Clelland Schreder ("CCS") is a Minnesota general partnership engaged
in the practice of law. CCS previously was registered as a limited liability partnership but,
according to the Minnesota Secretary of State's Internet website, CCS allowed that designation
to lapse, becoming a general partnership as a matter of law. Upon information and belief, the
general partners of CCS are Clelland, Jeffrey A. Carson and Ellen H. Schreder. Upon further
information and belief, CCS is under contract with the Ciry to provide City Attorney services.
15. John Does 1 through l0 are unknown Brooklyn Center police officers andlor
other officials who; without authority or permission, or exceeding any authority or permission,
unlawfully entered onto BCLHA's property and harassed BCLHA and its tenants. The conduct
by John Does 1 through 10 includes, without limitation, seizing possession of BCLHA's
emergency fire key and using the key to make unauthorized entry into Center Pointe buildings in
search of ordinance violations. Plaintiffs intend to amend their Complaint to specifically identify
John Does 1 through 10 after conducting discovery to determine their identities.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
16. Center Pointe consists of 21 buildings containing a total of 252 apartment units.
The Center Pointe complex provides "affordable" housing for low-income or no-income tenants.
'The rent of many of the Center Pointe tenants is subsidized pursuant to Section 8 of the Housing
and Community Development Act of 1974 ("Section 8") or other governmental programs.
4
17. More than 90 percent of Center Pointe's 252 units are rented by tenants who are
members of the African American, Black or other racial minority community. The U.S. Census
Bureau reports that as of 2000, the year of the last formal census, 4,110 of Brooklyn Center's
29,172 residents, or 14.1 percent, were African American or Black. With an estimated 500
people living at Center Pointe, and upward of 90 percent of those tenants being Black or African
American, approximately 11 percent of Brooklyn Center's total African American or Black
population resides at Center Pointe.
18. The Center Pointe property is located at 2900 Northway Drive in Brooklyn
Center, directly across 57th Avenue North from Brookdale Center, which despite years of
decline and neglect remains the City's largest shopping mali. The Center Pointe property is
immediately adjacent to the area that the City has designated as its future "central business
district." City o�cials have repeatedly blamed the existence and location of Center Pointe for
the City's failure to attract new economic development.
19. The Center Pointe development was acquired by BCLHA in 1995. At that time,
BCLHA was an affiliate of the Dominium group of companies, which speciaiizes in
development and management of multi-family residential properties.
20. BCLHA has qualified for, and in the past received, low income housing tax
credits pursuant to Section 42 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 {"Section 42") for its
operation of the Center Pointe property. Although Section 42 t� credits are provided pursuant
to federal law, the tax credit programs are administered by the states. In Minnesota, the
Minnesota Housing Finance Authority ("MHFA") administers and distributes Secfion 42 tax
credits to approved and qualified housing providers such as Center Pointe.
5
21. Like all apartments that provide subsidized housing to low-income tenants, Center
Pointe is subject to rigorous and frequent inspections pursuant to federal law. The apartments,
common areas of the apartment buiidings, and the grounds must pass inspection before any
tenant is approved to live in Center Pointe and receive Section 8 rent subsidies.
22. Center Pointe also is required to renew its rentai license through the City every
two years. Part of the renewal process is a certification by the City that the property is in
compliance with all the City ordinances and the laws of the State of Minnesota. The City makes
this certification only after conducting thorough property inspections.
23. Additional inspections are required by MHFA in light of the Section 42 status of
the Center Pointe compiex. As a result, the Center Pointe apartments have been repeatedly
inspected since BCLHA took over ownership in 1995.
24. Beginning in the mid 1990s but escalating thereafter, the City has undertaken a
campaign to impose increasingly onerous obstacles to the operation of Center Point. Upon
information and belief, this tactic is motivated by the City's desire to remove the members of the
Black, African American and other minority communities who reside in the apartment complex.
25. The volume and type of regulatory actions taken by the City at Center Point are
unique among the City's oversight of residential property. Upon information and belief; the City
actively conducts very little, if any regulation of single- and dual-family homes. Upon further
information and belief, the only muiti-family apartment complexes subject to intense scrutiny by
the City are those with predominantly minority tenants, but no other complex in Brooklyn Center
faces the heavy-handed and arbitrary treatment that the City affords to BCLHA and Center
Pointe.
6
26. The City's actions in harassing BCLHA and imposing major obstacles to
operation of the complex are causing very significant costs, which ultimately must be passed
i
along to tenants in the form of higher rents. Even more significantly, the City's overreaching
conduct threatens the economic viability of Center Pointe, making it increasingly likely that the
complex cannot survive as a going concern and hundreds of Black, African American and other
minority tenants will be forced to seek housing elsewhere. That is exactly what the City wants.
27. 111e Defendants' mistreatment of Plaintiffs, and the resulting interference with the
operation of Center Pointe, are having a disparate negative impact upon BCLHA's community of
tenants, the vast majority of whom are Black, African American or otherwise members of racial
minorities.
28. One tactic employed by the City has been to criticize the operators of Center
Pointe (and the previous operators of Summerchase) for having a relatively high number of
police calls to the property. City records indicate, however, that alleged criminal conduct at
Center Pointe has never reached the level defined by the City's own ordinances as necessary to
downgrade Center Pointe's rental license to provisional. The same records indicate that much of
the criminal conduct attributed to Center Pointe is, in fact, actions taken by persons who are
neither tenants of Center Pointe nor guests of the tenants.
29. Beginning in 1998, the City became extremely aggressive in trying to find
ordinance violations at the Center Pointe property (then known as Summerchase).
of
30. In 1999, the manager for Suininerchase met with the Crty s Director
Community Development and asked what could be done to satisfy the City. The Director
I responded by stating that although he would deny ever saying this, the probiem is you've
got too many niggers living here."
7
31. In the fall of 2000, in connection with the renewal of the Summerchase rental
license, the City inspected the apartment complex. At the completion of the inspections,
Summerchase's management was given a list of maintenance issues that needed to be addressed
before the City would renew the rental license.
32. All required work was completed and, in April 2001, the City inspector signed off
on the entire apartment complex. Accordingly, on May 14, 2001, the City Council renewed the
rental license. Under the City's own ordinance, the granting of the license constituted a
certification by the City that the entire complex conformed to all applicable laws and ordinances.
33. Nonetheless, beginning that same month, the City conducted weekly "vehicie
swee s" of the Summerchase arking lots to identify cars with expired license tabs. This was
p P
part of the City's effort to find some basis upon which to assert criminal charges against the
"owners" of the apartment comple�.
34. Summerchase had never previously been subjected to such vehicle sweeps and,
upon information and belief, the only places that similar vehicle sweeps have been conducted are
Suimilerchase, Center Pointe and other affordable housing complexes whose tenants primarily
wee s continued throu out the
are members of racial m�nonhes. At Summerchase, the vehicle s p
summer of 2001 and into the fa1L
35. Initially, the City directed BCLHA to remove all offending vehicles within 14
days of receiving notice of violations uncovered in the vehicle sweeps. When BCLHA met that
requirement, the City changed the rules and required offending vehicles to be removed within
seven days.
36. On A ril i7 2002 Cit rosecutor Clel
land threatened criminal action against
p YP
Dominium's principals based upon a theory that they were "owners" of Summerchase. This
8
occurred 11 months after the City had issued a new rental license, certifying Summerchase's
compliance with City ordinances, and seven months before the rental license was set to expire.
37. Clelland's April 17, 2002, threat of prosecution stated that the City would seek to
hold 5ummerchase's "owners" criminally liable for what he alleged were ordinance violations.
Clelland further informed BCLHA that the City would no longer provide notice of purported
violations of the City building ordinances.
38. Clelland carried through on his threat and filed unfounded criminal charges
against Dominium's principals. The charges included such "offenses" as allowing inoperable or
unlicensed cars to be parked in the Suminerchase parking lot and allowing trash to be on the
premises. The oniy criminal charge ever to come to trial resulted in the Hennepin County
District Court granting a motion for acquittal after Clelland �ested the City's case.
39. Clelland uitimately dismissed the rest of the criminal charges, so that no "owner"
of Surninerchase or Center Pointe has ever been convicted of any offense related to operation or
ownership of the property. That fact, however, has not prevented Clelland and the City from
filing the same or similar charges against Jaweed and A. Jaweed in 2007, and threatening to
bring criminal charges against other people that the City arbitrarily dassifies as"owners" of the
property, even though those persons have no role in either owning or operating Center Pointe.
40. In 2001 and 2002, besides.instituting criminal charges, Clelland and the City
directed BCLHA to undertake several measures that Clelland admitted were not required by any
law but that Clelland and the City insisted had to be done to reduce crime at the apartment
complex.
41. Ultimately, the members of the general partner of BCLHA concluded that the
City had gone far beyond any reasonable effort to enforce its ordinances and instead had
9
embarked on a course of conduct intended to make operation of Summerchase so expensive and
burdensome that the owner might abandon the project rather than spend time and money
standing up to the City's bullying tactics.
42. The City's strategy did not work, however, as the individuals whom Clelland had
charged criminally and BCLHA refused to back down and instead commenced a series of
lawsuits against the City and some of its officials.
002 "2002
ated December 4 2
la suits were
settled in an a eement d
43. Those w
Settlement Agreement"). The 2002 Settlement Agceement imposed restrictions upon the City
and included provisions requiring the City to act more reasonably toward BCLHA.
44. By way of example, and not limitation, the 2002 Settlement Agreement imposed
the following conditions and limitations:
a. Section 6 provides that with regard to any future inspections of the
apartment compiex no party to the agreement is obligated to exceed the
requirements established by statute, code or ordinance.
b. Section 7 requires any and all future compliance orders regarding alleged
deficiencies at the apartment complex to be in writing. Section 7 also
obligates the parties to act in accordance with the 2002 Settlement
Agreement going forward and reiterates that no party is required to exceed
legal requirements established by statute, code or ordinance.
c. Section 8 provides that the City cannot consider any past acts or omissions
in determining any licensing or regulatory matter relating to the Center
Pointe property.
d. Section 9 requires the City to give BCLHA enough advance notice of any
planned inspection of the buildings so that BCLHA can give its tenants at
least 24 hours notice. Section 9 further requires tenant permission before
the interior of any apartment is inspected.
e. Section 13 provides that the releases given in Yhe 2002 Settlement
Agreement apply only to claims that could have been asserted on or before
December 4, 2002.
10
f. Section 20 provides that if any party seeks to enforce the agreement, the
prevailing party shall be entitled to reasonable attorneys' fees and costs.
45. The 2002 Settlement Agreement designated Hennepin County District Court
Judge Ann Leslie Alton to have continuing jurisdiction to enforce the agreement for a period of
three years.
46. For a period of time, the 2002 Settlement Agreement produced an uneasy truce
between BCLHA and the City, but by 2004 the Dominium principals who had been charged
criminally realized that friction inevitably would recur because of the prior personai hostilities
and the City's commitment to driving out the racial minority tenant families concentrated at the
Summerchase/Center Pointe location.
47. The Dominium principals decided they had enough and, effective January 1,
2005, Brooklyn Center Housing, LLC, of which Jaweed is a member, acquired the general
partner interest in BCLHA and assumed control over Center Pointe.
48. For the first several months after acquiring control, Hyder Jaweed's brother, A.
Jaweed, served as manager of Center Pointe. During that time, A. Jaweed had many visits from
City inspectors and other City employees engaging in unusually aggressive inspections of the
apartment complex and imposing maintenance demands that were far more stringent than
anything required of other dwellings in Brooklyn Center.
49. One City inspector told A. Jaweed on more than one occasion that the City's
ultimate objective was to force the Center Pointe complex to be closed.
50. The overbeaxing and intrusive conduct by the City began to increase in 2006,
which not coincidentally marked the expiration of Judge Alton's continuing jurisdiction over the
2002 settlement agreement.
11
51. Meanwhile, BCLHA was preparing to compile the necessary paperwork to submit
for renewal of its Center Pointe rental license, which was scheduled to expire on November 30,
2006. Under City ordinances, the owner was required to apply for renewal at least 90 days
before the expiration date. However, when BCLHA tried to apply, the City, acting in
contravention of its own ordinance, insisted that it would only accept an application from a
natural person and not an entity. Accordingly, the application was filed in Jaweed's name rather
than the name of the actual owner, BCLHA, or the owner's general partner, Brooklyn Center
Housing, LLC.
52. After the BCLHA renewal application was filed in August 2006, the City
conducted inspections of a11252 units at Center Pointe. On October 5, 2006, the City issued a
compliance order that claimed more than 800 ordinance violations and that demanded that all
violations be cured within 32 days, by November 6, 2006. By contrast, upon information and
belief, the 310-unit Twin Lake apartment complex, owned and operated by Caucasians, was
given more than six months to correct alleged deficiencies identified by the City.
53. BCLHA did nczt agree with the City's list of alleged defects at Center Pointe, but
in order to get the license renewed and in an effort to try to improve the relationship with the
City, BCLHA spenf hundreds of thousands of dollars and undertook very substantial efforts to
address as many of the alleged defects as possible in the limited time allowed.
54. While BCLHA was undertaking all of the maintenance demanded by the City,
Defendant Clelland decided to add to Plaintiffs' burden by issuing threats.
55. On October 10, Clelland sent a"reminder" to Jaweed and "Brooklyn Center
Leased Housing, LLC" (an unknown entity with no connection to Center Pointe) that non-
12
I
compliance with the maintenance arder would put the Center Pointe rental license at risk, and
that there might also be criminal prosecutions.
56. Clelland knew that his threatened prosecution was not supported by iaw, having
been the prosecutor whose criminal claims against the Dominium principals had been thrown out
of court in 2002. Not to be deterred by a Court Order, however, Clelland made the same threats
against Jaweed that he had tried unsuccessfully against the Dominium principals.
57. On November 15, 2006, after a follow-up inspection to determine BCLHA's
compliance with the October 5 maintenance order, the City issued a new compliance order with a
vastly diminished list of items that still needed to be corrected.
58. Soon thereafter, repairs were made and the City's inspectors determined that all of
the requirements of the compliance order had been met. Accordingly, a new two-year rental
license was issued to BCLHA on January 10, 2007, effective as of November 30, 2006.
59. Pursuant to Section 12-905 of the City's Ordinances, a new rental license could
not have been issued "unless the rental dwelling and its premises conform to the Ordinances of
Brooklyn Center and the laws of the State of Minnesota." Thus, in issuing the new rental
license, the City conclusively certified that as of November 30, 2006 (or at least as of January 10,
2007 when the license was actually issued), BCLHA was in compliance with all applicable
ordinances and laws.
60. Nevertheless, on February 21, 2007, the City issued another compliance order that
again included a laundry list of alleged deficiencies. Again, BCLHA undertook to have repairs
and maintenanee performed, even if the work actually exceeded the requirements of the
ordinance_
13
61. Thus, a pattern of conduct emerged. The City would issue a compiiance order,
BCLHA would respond by causing the demanded maintenance and repairs to be performed, and
the City would counter with another compliance order.
62. Eventually, the City's own inspection staff tired of the City's transparent strategy
to harass Plaintiffs and try to drive BCLHA out of business. As a result, the inspectors declined
to re-inspect what already had been inspected, re-inspected and re-re-inspected multiple times at
Center Pointe.
63. Not to be deterred by the lack of cooperation from its own inspectors, the City
responded by having uniformed police officers conduct inspections. In addition, after one
occasion when City inspectors determined that BCLHA was in compliance with a prior
repairlmaintenance order, the City had police officers going door-to-door during evening hours
to ask Center Pointe tenants whether the repairs and maintenance had been completed to their
satisfaction.
b4. On more than one occasion, City police officers and other officials gained entry to
BCLHA's property by seizing, without a warrant and without other authority, the emergency fire
key that is secured on site and using it to unlock entrance doors to gain access to common areas.
In every instance, this was done without notice to, or permission from, BCLHA.
65. The City's police officers then used the results of their unauthorized "inspection"
to force a City inspector to issue a new compliance order to BCLHA.
66. The City's use of police resources to conduct building inspections was not
intended to deter serious crime or promote safety and security. Rather, the City decided to use
unsolicited visits by uniformed police officers to intimidate the mostly minority Center Pointe
tenants and to try to create friction between landlord and tenant.
14
67. The use of uniformed police officers to make nighttime visits to apartments
occupied primarily by Black and African American tenants constituted a deliberate attempt to
intimidate persons of color in a community whose local government has made its hostility
toward minorities patently obvious.
68. After the City's repeated abuse of the compliance order process failed to achieve
the desired result of driving Center Pointe out of existence, the City and Clelland chose to return
to the tactic of bringing frivolous criminal compiaints, just as they had done unsuccessfully in
2001-02.
69. Under Cit Ordinance Section 12-201(18), an "owner" is defined as anyone who
Y
a le al or uitable interest in the com lex and, to the extent such owner is a corporation or
has P
g �l
partnership, the "owner" is also defined to include general partners and corporate officers.
70. Despite BCLHA having its license renewed, and despite satisfying repeated
compliance orders, and despite the fact that City inspectors refused to participate in the City's
charade, the City and Clelland brought criminal charges against Jaweed in May 2007 and again
in June 2007. These charges seek to hold Jaweed criminally responsible for purported conditions
at Center Pointe, despite the fact that Jaweed is not an "owner" of Center Pointe even under the
City's overly expansive definition: In addition, in August 2007, the City and Clelland brought
similar criminal charges against A. Jaweed asserting that he is an "owner" of Center Pointe
although the City's own records demonstrate that A. Jaweed has no ownership interest in Center
Fointe, BCLHA or even BCLHA's general partner, Brooklyn Center Housing, LLC. Without
�xplanation, the criminal complaint against A. Jaweed was not served until September.
71. Also in May 2007, Clelland dredged up another tactic that had failed in Z001-02
and served BCLHA with a Notice of Abatement, pursuant to Minn. Stat. 617.8 L Under this
15
statute, if the "nuisance" cited in the Notice is not cured within 30 days, the �ity can commence
a civil action to close the buildings. The City distributed the Notice of Abatement to all of the
Center Pointe tenants and also made sure it was provided to various tenant advocacy
he u ose of the Cit 's tactic was to assert more pressure on BCLHA to
or anizations. T y
g P
abandon its.efforts at providing affordable housing in Brooklyn Center. Having created the
desired commotion, the City has not commenced an Abatement action although the City still
asserts that the problems alleged in the Abatement Notice have not been cured.
72. Upon information and belief, the City never had any intention of trying to prove a
"nuisance" at Center Pointe because (a) the facts and law do not support such an allegation and
harass Jaweed and
(l�) the Crty s and Clelland s true motivation is simply
tQ intimidate and
BCLHA by driving a wedge between them and Center Pointe's tenants.
73. The City and Clelland undertook further acts of harassment and intimidation in
August 2007 when Cleliand wrote ta the Dominium principals and others engaged in business
relationships with BCLHA and Jaweed (including at least one banker) alleging the existence of
poor conditions at the Center Pointe complex and threatening that criminal charges could be
brought against anyone, including bankers and business associates, whom Clelland and the City
decided fit within the expansive definition of "owner" found in the City's ordinances.
74. Clelland's statements to third persons about the BCLHA, the Jaweeds and their
operation of the Center Pointe property were blatantly faise, and Clelland knew they were false
when the statements were made.
75. 'The criminal complaints that Clelland ca�sed to be initiated against the Jaweeds
and the Notice of Abatement make reference to not only the physical condition of the Center
16
I
Pointe complex, but also to alleged crimes occurring at Center Pointe and the number of police
calls to the complex.
76. The City's Ordinances purport to make it a crime to be an "owner" of a property
where crime occurs or where an excessive number of police calls are made. The Ordinances
contain no exceptions for crimes committed by non-residents_ The Ordinances further make no
exceptions for whether the police calls were reasonably necessary. Finally, the Ordinances make
no exception far whether the "owner" had any knowledge of or ability to prevent the alleged
crime or incident giving rise to a police call.
77. On June 14, 2007, in response to City cornplaints about alleged crime and police
calls, BCLHA hired Grade A Security, a private security firm, to provide guards to patrol the
Center Pointe complex on weekend evenings. The City was informed of the guards being hired.
Plaintiffs also asked the City if there were additional steps that should be taken at Center Pointe
to help reduce crime, but the City offered no suggestions.
78. After the City was informed of BCLHA hiring security guards, Defendant Olson,
a police officer for the City, called Grade A Security and falsely and maliciously told the
company that it should stop providing guards at Center Pointe because Jaweed had absconded
with tenants' rent receipts and BCLHA would not pay for Grade A's security services.
79. Thus, after directing the owners of Center Pointe to increase on-site security, the
City followed up by teliing the company providing security officers that it should no longer do
so. Obviously, the City's action to discourage security was not taken iri furtherance of any
interest in public health and safety.
80. The City engaged in similar defamatory conduct when police officer.Benner
falsely and maliciously told residents of another Brooklyn Center apartment complex owned by
17
an entity in which Jaweed has an ownership interest, that Jaweed had fled the country and the
complex's utilities were about to be shut off.
81. The City and its police officers have displayed their hostility and lack of
cooperation in other ways. For example, when Center Pointe has sought to evict tenants who the
police alleged had engaged in unlawful acts, the City's police department refused to cooperate by
arranging to have the investigating officer appear in court to testify at the eviction proceeding.
As a result, eviction attempts based on purportedly illegal conduct have been unsuccessful.
82. On another occasion in early 2007, a Center Pointe manager called police for
assistance after she tried to enforce the complex's rules and was confronted by unruly tenants.
The City responded to her call by asking why the police should bother to respond when the
Center Pointe complex was going to be closed and torn down in another month.
83. On yet another occasion, a candidate for a job as an onsite manager at Center
Pointe called the City's police deparhnent to ask about the apartment complex, and the police
department responded by stating that it would be unwise to accept employment when Center
Pointe would be closing in the near future.
84. The foregoing facts make clear that the City's interest is not in ensuring safe and
comfortable living conditions for the residents of Center Pointe. Rather, the City's goal is to
make aperation of Center Pointe so expensive and so painful that the owners will walk away
from the business and hundreds of Black, African American and other minority tenants will be
forced to seek housing elsewhere.
85. The City's conduct in these matters confirms the accuracy of the statements of the
City inspector who told A. Jaweed that the City's ultimate objective was to force the Center
Pointe complex to be closed.
18
86. Additional facts support the same conclusion. Before this lawsuit was
commenced, the City refused to communicate with the attomey who was trying to help BCLHA
and Jaweed comply with the City's demands. In addition, various City officials have told the
Jaweeds that it is not the province of these City officials to solve the problems regarding Center
Pointe. One official said there was nothing he could do, but he added sarcastically that he might
be able to help if Jaweed and/or BCLHA hired the official as a consultant.
87. On August 14, 2007, the City served notice upon BCLHA and Jaweed that the
City will hold a hearing on September 24 regarding the suspension or revocation of the rental
license for the complex. This is the same license that, as a matter of law under City ordinances,
could only be issued if the apartment complex was in compliance with a11 state and local
requirements.
88. The City's notice to BCLHA and Jaweed that the rental iicense was at risk gave
no reasons for the City's proposed license suspension or revocation. The letter merely stated that
the reasons would be mailed at some later date.
89. When A. Jaweed discussed this issue with the City's Community Development
Director on August 16, he was told that the City did not have any suggestions about what could
be done to avoid the hearing or solve the problem. Subsequently, despite due demand from
Plaintiffs' representatives, the City has refused to provide a list of particulars regarding alleged
violations or misconduct that would warrant a license revocation.
90. City ordinances provide that if a rentaT license is suspended or revoked, the
landlord is prohibited from filling any vacancies until the license is reinstated.
91. Typically, an apartment complex needs to have an occupancy rate of 85 percent or
higher to pay all of its expenses and remain economically viable. As a result, the City's
19
proposed prohibition against new leases inevitably would drive Center Pointe toward
unprofitability and ultimately push BCLHA toward insolvency and a discontinuation of
operations.
92_ All of these facts, taken together, make it clear that the City, Clelland, Olson,
Benner, John Does 1 through 10 and others affiliated with the City have embarked on a
campaign to harass and regulate BCLHA out of business in hopes of driving out the low-income
Black, African American and other minority tenants who reside at Center Pointe.
COUNT ONE
Breach of Contract
93. Plaintiffs reassert and incorporate by reference the allegations set forth in
Paragraphs 1- 92 of the Complaint.
94. The 2002 Settlement A�'eement is a binding and enforceable contract among the
City, BCLHA and the other original parties' successors and assigns.
95. The City has breached the 2002 Settlement Agreement by conduct including, but
not necessarily limited to, conducting inspections without proper notice; requiring BCLHA and
Jaweed to engage in work that exceeds the requirements of any ordinance, code or statute;
failing to properly document all compliance orders; and using events that occurred before
December 4, 2002, to justify the harsh treatment being afforded to BCLHA.
96. As a direct and proximate result of the City's breaches of the 2002 Settlement
Agreement, BCLHA and Jaweed have been damaged in an amount exceeding $50,000, with the
precise sum to be proved at trial.
97. In the alternative, Plaintiffs are entitled to an order of specific performance,
requiring the City to cease and desist with any and all conduct that violates the terms of the 2002
Settlemen# Agreement.
20
COUNT TWO
Tortious Interference with Contractua( Relations
98. Plaintiffs reassert and incorporate by reference the allegations set forth in
Paragraphs 1- 97 of the Complaint.
99. Jaweed and BCLHA have contractual relationships with their bankers, Center
minium's rinci als.
Pointe s tenants, Grade A Secunty, Domimum and Do p P
100. At all relevant times, Clelland, Olson, Benner and the City have known of
Plaintiffs' contractual relations with their tenants and other business associates, including their
rade A Securit Dominium and Dominium's principals.
bankers G
Y
101. Clelland, Olson, Benner and the City have intentionally undertaken to interfere
with Plaintiffs' contractual relations with the Plaintiffs' bankers, tenants, security provider, and
other business associates, including Dominium and Dominium's principals. The City and John
Does 1 through 10 further have interfered with BCLHA's prospective contractual relations by
knowingly and intentionally making false statements about Plaintiffs in order to drive off a
candidate for ern loyment at Center Pointe.
P
102. The acts of interference by Clelland, Olson, Benner, the City
and John Does 1
tlirough 10 have caused performance of Plaintiffs' contracts to become more burdensome. In
addition, the conduct of the City and John Does 1 through 10 in making uninvited, unauthorized
inspections of apartments has violated tenants' contractual rights to quiet enjoyment and to be
free of uninvited intruders.
103. The acts of interference undertaken by Cleiland, Olson, Benner, the City and John
ted b an rivile e.
Does 1 through 10 were intentional, improper and not protec y y p g
21
104. As a direct and proximate result of Defendants' tortious interference with
Plaintiffs' contractual relations, Plaintiffs have been damaged in an amount exceeding $50,000,
with the precise sum to be proved at trial.
COUNT THREE,
Libel and Slander
105. Plaintiffs reassert and incorporate by reference the allegations set forth in
Paragraphs 1- 104 of the Complaint.
106. Clelland, Olson, Benner and the City have made false and defamatory statements
about Plaintiffs to Plaintiffs' bankers, security provider, tenants and other business associates,
including Dominium and its principals.
lso Benner
and the
lse and
defamato statements made by Clelland, O n,
107.
The fa rY
rofession.
usiness or
ui BCLHA Jaweed and A. Jaweed in their b P
Ci were of and concern g
tY
Accordingly, the false and defamatory statements by Clelland, Olson, Benner and the City
constitute libel per se or slander per se.
108. The false and defamatory statements made by Clelland, Olson, Benner and the
City were not uttered for legitimate purposes and are not privileged in any manner. On the
contrary, the false and defamatory statements by Clelland, Olson, Benner and the City were
made intentionally and with reckless disrega.rd for the truth, and for the rights of Plaintiffs.
109. As a direct and proximate result of the false and defamatory statements by
Cleliand, Olson, Benner and the City, Plaintiffs have been damaged in an amount exceeding
$50,000, with the precise sum to be proved at trial.
22
I
COUNT FOUR
Minn. Stat. 363A.001-.41 Minnesota Human Rights Act
110. Plaintiffs reassert and incorporate by reference the allegations set forth in
Paragraphs i- 109 of the Complaint.
111. I# is the public policy of the State of Minnesota, as expressed in the Minnesota
Human Rights Act ("MHRA") to protect persons in the State from discrimination in housing or
real estate based on race, color, national origin or status with regard to public assistance.
112. The provisions of the MHRA are to be construed liberaIly to accornplish the
purposes of protecting persons in the State from discrimination in housing or real estate based on
race, color, national origin or status with regard to public assistance.
113. Under the MHRA, it is an unfair discriminatory practice for a person to coerce,
intimidate, threaten, or interfere with a person's exercise or enjoyment of the rights protected by
the MHRA. It also is an unfair discriminatory practice for a person to coerce, intimidate,
threaten, or interfere with a person as retaliation for that person having aided another in their
exercise or enjoyrnent of the rights protected by the MHRA.
114. By the foregoing conduct, Clelland, Olson, Benner and the City have coerced,
intimidated, threatened and interfered with efforts by the tenants of Center Pointe to exercise and
enjoy their rights protected under the MHRA. Glelland, Olson, Benner and the City further have
coerced, intimidated, threatened and interfered with Plaintiffs because of the Jaweeds' national
origin and as retaliation for Plaintiffs' aiding Black, African American and other minority tenants
seeking to exercise their hosing rights at Center Pointe.
115. It also is a violation of the MHRA to aid and abet another in the violation of the
MHRA's provisions. Clelland, Olson, Benner and the City also have violated this provision by
aiding and abetting each other in their violations of the MHRA.
23
i
1 i 6. It further is an unfair discriminatory practice under the MHRA for a person who
has violated the MHRA's provisions to engage in reprisals against a person who has opposed a
practice forbidden under the MHRA or who has associated with persons of a different race,
color, or national origin.
117. Clelland, Oison, Benner and the City have engaged in reprisals against Plaintiffs
as a result of Plaintiffs' opposing the Defendants' discriminatory practices and as a further result
of Plaintiffs associating with Black, African and other minority tenants at Center Pointe.
118. Clelland, Olson, Benner and the City further have retaliated against BCLHA for
publiciy challenging the defendants' unlawful and discriminatory conduct as part of the prior
litigation among the parties.
119. In engaging in and promoting all of the foregoing acts, Clelland, Olson, Benner
and the Ciry have violated the MHRA by engaging in disparate treatment of BCLHA, the
Jaweeds and BCLHA's #enants when that disparate treatment was based on the race of the vast
majority of tenants at Center Pointe.
i 20. In addition, or in the alternative, all of the foregoing actions of Clelland, Olson,
Benner and the City are having a disparate impact upon BCLHA, the Jaweeds and the mostly
minority tenants of Center Pointe because (a) other residential rental property is not treated the
same way; (b) the Defendants' actions are making operation of Center Pointe unreasonably
difficult and expensive; (c) the financial burdens caused by Defendants' .conduct ultimately will
be passed along to Center Pointe's largely minority community of tenants; and (d) the negative
impact of BCLHA and Center Pointe being driven out of business would fall dispropartionately
upon Black, African American and other minority tenants at Center Pointe.
24
121. As a direct and proximate result of Defendants' violations of the MHRA,
Plaintiffs have been damaged in an amount exceeding $50,000, with the precise sum to be
proved at trial. By statute, Plaintiffs further are entitled to awards of costs, attorneys' fees and
punitive damages as a result of Defendants' violations of the MHRA.
COUNT FIVE
Trespass
122. Plaintiffs reassert and incorporate by reference the allegations set forth in
Paragraphs 1- 121 of the Complaint.
123. BCLHA is the owner of real and personal property at Center Pointe and, as such,
has a right to control access to the property.
124. The City and John Does 1 through 10 trespassed upon BCLHA's property by
taking possession of personal property and entering into real property either without the owner's
permission or by engaging in conduct that exceeded any authorization to possess BCLHA's
personal property or enter upon BCLHA's real property.
I 125. As a direct and proximate result of the trespass by the City and John Does 1
through 10, BCLHA has been damaged in an amount exceeding $50,000, with the precise sum to
be proved at trial.
COUNT SIX
Declaratory Judgment Absence of Nuisance
126. Plaintiffs reassert and incorporate by reference the allegations set forth in
Paragraphs 1- 125 of the Complaint.
127. In May 2007, Cielland and the City served BCLHA with a Notice of Abatement;
pursuant to Minn. Stat. 617_81. Under this statute, if the "nuisance" cited in the Notice is not
cured within 30 days, the City can commence a civil action to close the buildings.
25
'L_
128. The City distributed the Notice of Abatement to all of Center Pointe's tenants and
also made sure that the notice was provided to various tenant advocacy organizations.
129. After providing notice to BCLHA and sharing its unfounded accusations with
Center Pointe tenants and others, the City has not commenced an Abatement action although the
City still asserts that the problems alleged in the Abatement Notice ha�e not been cured.
130. There is a live and actual controversy between BCLHA and the City because the
City claims that a nuisance exists at Center Pointe and that allegation is denied by BCLHA.
13 i_ A judicial declaration of the facts and law would resolve the dispute between
BCLHA and the City regarding the existence or non-existence of a nuisance. In addition,
because no nuisance actually exists, a judicial declaration wauld help BCLHA to begin to
undertake remedial action to clear its name and cure some of the harm caused by the City's
reckless action.
132. Because the City has taken steps to commence an Abatement proceeding but has
intentionally failed to go forward with its unfounded claims, BCLHA is entitled to a declaratory
judgrnent that no nuisance exists, so that BCLHA can get out from under the cloud created by the
City's reckless conduct.
COUNT SEVEN
Vicarious Liability
133. Plaintiffs reassert and incorporate by reference the allegations set forth in
Para a hs 1-132 ofthe Com laint.
P p
134. The acts and omissions of Clelland, 01son, Benner and John Does 1 through 10 as
described in this Complaint were pursued in the course and scope of their roles as employees or
agents of the City. Likewise, the acts of Clelland were undertaken in the course and scope of his
role as a partner of CCS.
26
135. The City knew of and approved the above described acts and omissions by
Clelland, Olson, Benner and John Does 1 through 10, inasmuch as those acts and omissions were
in furtherance of the City's policies and customs. Likewise, CCS knew and approved of the
conduct of Clelland, acting on behalf of CCS.
ct of Clelland Olson, Benner and John Does 1
136. The City is liable for the condu
through 10, and CCS is responsible for the conduct of Clelland, under the doctrine of respondeat
superior. CCS is liable for the tortious conduct of Clelland as a matter of partnership law.
137.
Plaintiffs are entitled to have the City be held jointly and severally liable for the
wrongful acts and omissions of Clelland, Olson, Benner and John Does 1 through 10, pursuant to
the doctrine of respondeat superior. Plaintiffs also are entitled to have CCS and its partners held
jointly and severally liable for the tortious conduct of Clelland, acting as a CCS partner.
PRAYER FOR RELIEF
WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs pray for the following relief
1. That judgment be entered in favor of Plaintiffs and against Defendants on all
claims.
all d
ama es and enalties allowed by law.
2. That Plamtiffs be awarded g P
3. That Plaintiffs be awarded temporary and permanent injunctive relief against the
unlawful conduct of Clelland, Olson, Benner, John Does 1 through 10 and the City.
4. That Plaintiffs be awarded their costs of suit, including reasonable attorneys' fees.
27
�I
5. That Plaintiffs be awarded such further and additional reiief as tl�e Court deems
just and equitable.
ANTHONY OSTLUND BAER, P.A.
Dated: September 12, 2007 By: �����'�^Gu-�
Norman J�er (#163715)
Mark D. Wisser (#217736)
Shannon M. Awsumb (#343389)
90 South Seventh Street
Suite 3600
Minneapolis, MN 55402
(612) 349-6969
ATTORNEYS FOR PLAINTIFFS
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The undersigned hereby acknowledges that costs, disbursements and reasonable attomey
and witness fees may be awarded pursuant to Minn. Stat. 549.211, to the parties against whom
the ailegations in the Suznmons and Complaint are asserted.
28
470 U.S. Bank Plaza
Offices in
200 South Sixth Street av
Mlririeap011S Minneapolis, MN 55402
Sa1nt Paul �612) 337-9300 telephone
(612) 337 f�
St. CIOU(� http://www.kennedy-graven.com
C H A R T E R E D Affirmative Action, Equal Opportunity Employer
I
CHARLES L. LEFEVERE
Attorney at Law
I?irect Dial (612) 337-9215
EmaiL• clefevere@kennedy-graven.com
October 1l, 2007
William Clelland Norman J. Baer
Carson, Clelland Schreder Anthony Ostlund Baer, P.A.
6300 Shingle Creek Parkway #305 90 South Seventh Street, Suite 3600
Brooklyn Center, MN 55430 Minneapolis, MN 55402
I Curt Boganey
City of Brooklyn Center
6301 Shingle Creek Pkwy
Brooklyn Center, MN 55430
Re: Center Pointe Apartment License Proceedings
Gentlemen:
This will confirm the decision made by the City Council at the close of the hearing on the above
referenced matter that counsel for the licensee and counsel for the City staff will simultaneously
serve each other and the City with post-hearing briefs by the close of business on Tuesday,
October 16, 2007.
I will forward the briefs received to the City Council for distribution.
Reply briefs from each party will be served simultaneously on each other and on me by the close
of business on Tuesday, October 23, 2007.
Attached with this letter to Mr. Clelland and Mr. Boganey is a copy of the transcript of
proceedings forwarded to me by Mr. Baer. Curt, I would appreciate it if you could make and
distribute copies of the transcript to members of the Council.
Thank you.
Very truly yours,
C
Charles L. LeFevere
CLL:peb
Enclosure
322591v1 CLL BR291-20
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page Page 3
7 1NDEX
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER 2
2 OPENING STATEMENTS:
SPECIAL CITY COi1NCIL MEETiNG 3
3 BY MR CLEILAND 19
4 4 By MR. BAER
27
1 ,r 6
WiTNESSES:
6
7
7. tIEUTENANT KEVIN BENNER PAGE
Brooklyn Center Leased Housing Associates, LLC 8
OIRECT EXAMINATION BY MR. CLELIAND 44
9 9 CROSS-EXAMiNATION BY MR. BAER 76
Center Poinie Apartments REDIRECT EXAMINATION BY MR CLELLAND 103
'10 2802-2834, 2900-2940 Northway Drive
9 1 2 OFFICER TERRY OLSON
12
DIRECT EXAMINATION SY MR. CLELLANO 113
3 i 2 CROSS-EXAMINATfON BY MR. SAER 131
14 13
5 3. LAURENCE MARTIN
14
js HEARING DIRECT EXAMINATION 8Y MR. CLEILAND 163
15 CROSS-EXAMiNATION BY MR. SAER 180
18 Taken October 1st, 2007 76
19 Commencing at 6:02 PM 4. MICHAEL BUSCH
20 17
21 DIRECT EXAMINATION BY MR. $AER 194
22 18 CROSS-EXAMINATION SY MR. CLELLAND 2fl5
REPORTED BY: EIiZASETH J. GANGI, RPR j PATRICiA TODD
23 20 DIRECT EXAMINATION BY MR. BAER 275
PARADIGM REPORTING CAPTIONING iNC. 23
24 1400 RAND TOWER, 527 MARQUETTE AVENUE SOUTH 23
MINNEAPOLIS, MINNESOTA 554fl2-1331 24
25 612/339-0545 1/800/545-9668 Fax: 612/337-5575 25
Page 2 Page 4
i Heanng held October 1st, 2007, commencing at 7 GTY EXHIBITS:
6:02 p.m., at the Brooklyn Center City Hall, Council {Marked pnor to hearing)
2 Chambers, 6301 Shingle Creek Parkway, Brooklyn Center, p
Minnesota, before Elizabeth J. Gangf, Registered MARKED O�FEREfl RECEIVED
3 Professionai Reporter and Notary Public of a�d for ihe 3
State of Minnesota. 7 DVD inspections ot Center
4
4 Pointe...._..._........_ 50 52
S
5 2 Compliance Orders 56 59
6 6 59 59
APPEARANCES 7 3 MHFA documents 168 768
7 8
8 4 Compliance Orders 172 173
On Behalf of tfie City: 9
9 5 Cnminal Complaints 65 &6
WiNiam G_ Cielland, Esq. 10 172 173
10 Carson, Clelland 8 Schreder 11 6 Notice oi Abatement of
6300 Shingle Creek Parkway, Suite 305 Public Nwsances 125 127
11 Minneapolis, Minnesota 55430-2190 12 175 176
763-561-280 13 7 CoRespondence to CeMer
Pointe property managers 130 i30
13 On Behalf of Brooklyn Center Leased Housing Associates �q
Limited Parfiership: 15 8 Memora�dum Door Lock
14 Inspections 69 70
Norman J. Baer, Esq. 6
15 Shannon M. Awsumb, Esq. 7 7 9 Rental property comparisons 7 78 119
Antho�yOstlund&Baer,P.A �26 �Z�
76 3600 Wells Fargo Center 7 8
90 South Seventh Sheet 70 Bond fees, �tilitybiiis 176 776
17 Minneapolis, Minnesota 55402 �g
612-349 6969 11 Notice of Default 177 177
78 20
19 12 City of Minneapolis Request
20 27 Por Action 177 180
NOTE: Onginai hanscdp� and copies will be delivered 22
21 2o Norman Baer for distribuGon to all paRies 13 City of Robbinsdaie
zz 23 coRespondence 177 180
23 24
z4 i4 Incident Reports 125 127
2$ 25
1 {Pages 1 to 4)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
b 12-339-0545
Public Hearing i 0/ i/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 5 Page 7
1 BROOKLYN CENTER IEASED HOUSING ASSOCIATES EXHIBITS: 1 city OrdiilanC2S pTOVid2S FOr a 1ice�Se SuSpB�SiOh,
2
MARKED OFFERED RECEIVED 2 revocation, or denial of renewai for a rental license
3 3 under if certain conditions aren't met. This hearing
1 Objections._..._ 17 19 19
a 4 has been scheduled at the request of #he city staff in
2 ord;na�ce t2-9t3 �reckir,g 5�esponse to issues tha# have been raised related to the
5 Sheet, September 2006 136 149 749
s 6 8rooklyn Center Leased Housing Associates, LLC, Center
3 Ciry ordinance Chapter s 7 Pointe Apartments, located on No�thway Drive_
7 Section 5 141 149 149
8 8 Mr. Mayor, City Council Members, the City
4 12-9t3 Cans for Service 9 attomey, Mr. LeFevere, wiil provide tfie City Council
9 Rental Property 200? 143 149 149
10 10 with an outline, an averview oi the process that we 11 be
5 �2-9i3 caus comparison ia5 ias tas 11 following this evening, and wMak the expected outcome of
11
P 2:2m Z�: ��ff�, fr�m rnay�: 12 ihi� he2ring shp��l�i ha_.
�2 ofRochester 197 �9� �9� �3 MR. LEFEVERE: Mr. Mayor, Council Members,
13
7 Paramark Ietter from 14 this Council, or at least some member to the Council,
ta Rochester Buildi�g Safety 15 have not been through a hearing process. There are no
Inspecior.. 197 ]98 198
15 16 adopted iormal rules of procedure, so feel free to
1fi 8 Tax Credit Compiiance
Moniforing Inspection Report 17 question me as we go along and expfain. i'm going to
i� Response 200 20� 20� 18 recommend some things about your hearing procedures but
8 19 you can vary from that as long as we meet the
9 Paramark le#ter from MHFA 200 201 20!
t 20 requirements of procedural due process and due
�o agenda for Speciai C;ty 21 #undamental fairness to al1 fhe parties.
20 Council Meeting, 10/1/07 231 231 231
21 22 Brooklyn Center City Code before 1 even do
22
23 23 that. Just fior the record, i wonder if we shouid note
24 (Original BCLHA exhibits attached to originai transcripY, 24 appearanC2s. Start with Bil1?
exhibit copies retumed to City of Brooklyn Center.) 25 MR. CLELIAND: Certainly_ Good everting,
25
Page 6 Page 8
3 MAYOR WILtSON: Call the meet+�g to order. 1 Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, 1'm William Cleiland,
2 The City Council requests that attendees turn off a11 2 your prosecuting attomey. On behalf of the city staff
3 ce11 phones and pagers during the meeting. A fuil copy 3 and police department 1 will be presenting the evidence
4 of the Cify Councit packet, the packet we just received 4 for your consideration and action this meeting_
5 this evening, is on that cor�er in a packet ri�g binder 5 MR_ BAER: Good evening. Norman Baer on
6 located in front of Ms. Worley. And if you would, 6 behalf oi the land ownec With me is Shannon Awsumb.
7 piease, Ms. Worley, the roll call? 7 We've also asked that a cou�t reporter be here tonight to
8 MS_ WORLEY: Councii Member O'Connor? 8 record the proceedings, and she's set up and working fiere
9 COUNCIL MEMBER O'CONNOR: Here. 9 so there wiA be a record of everything that's done.
10 MS. WORLEY: Councl Member Ryan? 10 MR. LEFEVERE: Thank you. Mr. Mayor, the
11 COUNCiI MEMBER RYAN: Here. 11 Brooklyn Center City Code of Ordinances requires that
12 iNS. WORLEY: Counci! Member Yelich? 12 rental housing be licensed. it aiso imposes certain
13 COUNCIL MEMBER YELICH: Here. 13 obligations on the licensee. If the iicensee fails to
14 MS. WORLEY: Mayor WiUson? 14 meet those obligations, the code provides for sanctions.
15 MAYOR WILLSON: Here. 15 One of the possible sanctions is the suspe�sion or
1fi MS. WORLEY: Council Member Lasmar is 16 revocation of a license under City Code Section 12-91Q
17 abse�t. 17 which ihe manager just referred to. The Council cannot
18 MAYOR WlLLSON: Which leads us into item 18 revoke or suspend a iicense without written notice of an
19 Number 3, hearing far Brooklyn Center Leased Housing 19 aNeged ground, and a hearing must afford the #undamentai
20 Associates, LIC, Ce�ter Pointe Apartments, 2802-2834, 20 tenets of procedural due process before it takes ac6on
21 2900-2940 Nortfiway Drive. 21 on such an important matter as taking away a business
22 And, Mr. Boganey, if you will, please. 22 iicense of this type.
23 MR. BOGANEY: Yes, Mr. Mayor, Ci#y Council 23 The overail procedure; the Councif is acting in
24 Members. This evening is being heid under Section 12-9'!0 24 a quasi-judiciai capacity here. You're actfig in the
25 of the City's Code of Ordinances. That section of the 25 nature of a judge. You are required to provide in this
2 (Pages 5 to 8j
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 9 Page 1 1
1 proceeding the elements ofi procedural due process before 1 itself, and perhaps us as well.
2 a decision is made. To do that you must be an impartial 2 As #ar as the rules of evidence are
3 tribunai, and you must base your decision o� the evidence 3 concerned, you are not limited to the rules of evidence
4 in the record of tha proceeding before you in this 4 of districi court. Nevertheless, you should consider the
5 hea�ng; not oufside, not what you have heard before or 5 credibiiity and reliabiiity of the evidence thaYs
6 hear duri�g the course of the proceedi�gs outside of the 6 presented Yo you. We do have a cour# reporter here, but
7 proceedings, but shouid limit your decision to evidence 7 1 would request that we also have a tape-recording, and
8 thaYs presented here at this hearing. 8 iPs important that should we want a writien record o#
9 After the hearing is completed you may 9 this proceeding at some future date, that it be clea� and
10 deiiberaie among yourselves. Your decision finaliy can, 10 i�teliigible To someo�e who is oniy reading the written
19 if you decide to suspend or revoke, ca� only be made upon 11 word, so that people should speak slowly and cleariy,
12 writ�Qn fin�inss_ Tha_refn�e, y��� I! githgr �a ra��irg�i 2 gfanri anri nr raiga ttigir hanr! tp ha rc��q�niZo`i c� #hat
13 to prepare findings or direct that findings be prepared 13 oniy one person is speaking at a time, and identify
14 consistent with your wishes and your decisior�. if the 14 themselves when #hey're speaking so Yhat the record,
15 hearing cannot for some reason be completed tonight, it �5 whoever is preparing a transcript, the court reporter or
1& can be continued to a future date, and that couid be the 16 somebody else, can recreate the record. Are there any
3 7 hearing itself could be continued to a future date, it 17 questions about that?
18 could be conYinued for certain addi#ional evidence or at 18 COUNCiL MEMBER O'CONNOR_ Mr. Mayor?
19 the request ofi parties, either of the pa�ties for some 19 MAYOR INILLSON: Councii Member O'Connor.
20 reason, or you couid, if you're able to close the hearing 20 COi1NCIL MEMBER O'CONNOR: This handout
21 tonight, you ca� continus your deiiberations tonight, or 21 here, this is from Carson CleHand Schreder, coRect?
22 if iYs too late or you wish to have time to consider 22 Do we get any handout #rom the other side?
23 before you do that, the deliberation can be scheduled for 23 Mft. LEFEVERE: That will be up to the other
24 a later meet+ng as welL 24 side. This was at your desk when you arrived here, I
25 For the pracedure at the hearing, what 1 would 25 believe_ At th+s point it hasn't been introduced into
Page 10 Page 12
1 recommend is that, first of all, in terms of the roles, i evidence, iYs merely the document tMaYs in front ofi
2 Mr. Clelland will be presenting evidence of the alleged 2 you. I believe Mc Cielland will be working from this
3 violation on behaff of the staff but wiN not be advising 3 document.
4 the Ciry Cou�cil. He sfiould be seen as an adversary and 4 Is fhat correct?
5 noY your legal advisor. I will act as counsel to the 5 Mft. CLELIAND: Yes.
6 City Councii and assist you with any questions and 6 MR. LEFEVERE: But at this point, iYs not
7 procedures generaity. The Mayor wiH preside, and the 7 evidence. You haven't received it or accepTed it. 1fs
8 Cou�cil as a whoie wili act as a decision maker. The 8 just waiting for Mr. Gelland to proceed, I guess.
9 wiYnesses will testify under oath. The oath will be 9 COUNCIL MEMBER O'CONNOR: Then other
10 adminisiered by the assistant clerk. 10 question. You said that Mr. CIelland is our adversary?
11 And what I would recommend is thai the 11 MR. LEFEVERE: You should regard him as an
12 proceedings, the order of proceedings be essentially the 12 adversary rafher than your legal counsel. He's
13 same as they are in district court, because lawyers are 13 presenting the case for the state for the staff. But
14 familiar with thaY, and the case would start with 14 you should, you should not take his advice or his
15 Mr. Geiland cailing his first witness_ The witness 35 arguments as legai counsel to you or legal advice to you.
16 wo�id be swor�, give testimony. Mr. Baer would have an 96 COUtVCIL MEMBER O'CONNOR: So they're bott
17 opportunity to cross-exami�e the witness, Mr. Cielland 17 equal #o us?
18 wouid have a chance to reexamine fiis witness to cover 18 Mft. LEFEVERE: Correct.
19 additionai, or items that were brought up on 19 COUNCIL MEMBER O'CONNOR: Thank you.
20 cross-examination, and when that was done, then 20 NIAYOR W1LtSON: Any questions? Hearing
21 Mr. Cleliand would caU his second witness and so on 21 nothing, I believe we'll turn it over to Mc CIelland.
22 until Mr. Cleitand has compieted his case. Then counsel 22 MR. BAER: Mr. Mayor? Excuse me,
23 for the licensee would have an opportuniry to do the same 23 Mc Clelland. On behaif of the owners i filed
24 thi�g, cali his witnesses, subject to cross-examination 24 objections.
25 by Mc CIelland, and so forth until {haY process exhausts 25 MAYOR W1LlSON= Before you dq though, i
3(Pages 9 to i 2)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc_
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/i/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 13 Page 15
1 would Iike to have you state your name and address for 1 MR. CLELLAND: 1 don'f have an objection to
2 the record. 2 these being stated at the outset, no.
3 MR. BAER: Sure. My name is Norman Baer, I 3 Mft. LEFEVERE: Then, Mr_ Mayor, 1 guess
4 live at 1465 island Drive in Golden Valley. 4 whaf fd recommend is that the Councii receive these
5 MAYOR WILLSON: And then woufd you state 5 objections and take them under consideration and proceed
6 your point, please? 6 with the proceedings, unless there are certain objections
7 MR. BAER: Pardon me? 7 that you wish to iake up ai this time.
8 MAYOR WILLSON= State your point, please. 8 COUNGL MEMSER O'CONNOR: Mr. Mayor?
9 MR. BAER: My point is that we have fiied 9 MAYOR WiLISON: Council Member O'Co�nor.
i0 objections with the Counci! about the process that has 10 COUNCiL MEMBER-0'CONNOR: is this a public
11 been employed thus far into the proceedings, and I wouid 11 meeting thaf needed Yo be iisted in our official
2 iike to h�ve ruling on those o4iections before we 12 newspaper?
13 continue. Tfiose objections deait with, among other 13 MR. LE�EVERE It is under the open
14 things, whether proper notice had been provided for this i 4 meeting law, ap your proceedings are required to be open
15 praceeding. And before we proceed with the proceeding 15 unless there is some exception_ This does not fit under
16 itself, it would be appropriate, in my opinion, that the 16 any of those exceptions. Therefore, it is an open pubiic
17 Council make a defermination of what to do with those 17 meeting, and the hearing therefore is open to the pubiic.
18 objections_ 18 However, it is not an open, it is not a public hearing
19 MAYOR WILLSON: if you wouid like? 19 for the purpose of tak+ng public testimony. There is no
20 Othetwise i'm jusi going to go forward with the process. 20 notice to #he pubiic and should not necessarity be any
21 MR. LEFEVERE: Okay. i guess I would Jike 21 notice #o the ublic. The ublic is no# invited fo
P P
22 to ciarify. i received by a roundabout way the 22 attend or to participate or present evidence.
23 objections io which Mr. Baer is referring. 1# Mr. Baer 23 Evidence that, the peopie cailed to present evidence will
24 wouid like to make those objections a part of the record 24 be called by counsel e+ther for the staff or counsel for
25 of proceedings, we shoufd perhaps say so at this point. 25 the licensee.
Page 14 Page Ib
1 Mr. Baer? 1 This is a procedural due process
2 MR. BAER: Thank you, Mc Le�evere. I 2 considenng important property rights of the licensee.
3 would like to m2ke those objections part Of the 3 It is not a legislative decision where public input, as
4 proceedings. We've created copies that I car� pass out 4 public input, is reievant or appropriate, so in answer to
5 and provide one to tfie court reporter if thafs the way 5 your question, it's an open public meeting but iPs not a
6 you wouid like to proceed. 6 public hearing as you wou�d have, for instance, on an
7 MR. IEFEVERE: Now this is not evidence or 7 ordinance or a public, public improvement.
8 introduced as evidence at this time, is that correct? 8 COUNCiL MEMBER O'CONNOR: Were they sent a
9 IYS simply an obyection? 9 letter saying there would be a hearing on Octobef 1st and
10 MR. BAER: lT is not introduced as evidence 10 was it sent in time? !s there any time limit where they
11 but it is introduced as an objection, and as you know, I 11 have to be given 30 days or something before a hearing?
12 need to keep a full record of what we do here, and thafs 12 MR. LEFEVERE: No time is specified in the
13 why we made the copies and we're having it reported. 13 ordinance. The objections inciude an averment that the
14 MR. LEFEVERE: ThaYs why t wanted to see 14 notice given to the licensee was not sufficient for due
15 whether you wanted it in the record. 15 process purposes, that it did not state the grounds a�d
16 Mr. Mayor, would recommend that it be i6 so forth_ It would be my advice thai that decision
17 received for that purposa of stating objections, not for 17 cannot be made ai this poinT because, ro the best of my
18 purposes o# evidence. 18 knowledge, you have not seen the notice that was given to
19 Mc Clelland, do you have any comments on 19 the iicensee, you do not know what grounds Mr. Clelland
20 that? 20 is goi�g to state, you do noi know what evidence is going
21 MR. CLELLAND: i do, and I'm going io 21 to be presented, and so there's no way of making a
22 address these objections in my opening statement. 22 determination whether that �otice is adequate.
23 MR. LEFEVERE: I'm sorry, the only tfiing 23 Following the proceedings you'il know those
24 i'm asking for is commenis on whether it should be 24 things, and it will be possible to evaluate whether the
25 received as a� objecTion for the record. 25 licensee is in some way prejudiced by a lack ofi proper
4 (Pages 13 to 16)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page l7 Page 19
1 notice of the charges to be brought. At this point, 1 COUNCIL MEMBER O'CONNOR: t�lay.
2 frankiy, 1 don't see how you can possible rule on that. 2 MAYOR WiL�SON: Motion carries #hree to
3 There is nothing before you upon which you can make that 3 one. Mr_ C1eNand?
4 decision. 4 MR. CLELLAND= Mayor and Members of the
MAYOR WILLSON: From our perspective, 5 Council, as Mr. LeFevere wiU advise, it is traditional
6 Mr. LeFevere, we had duly noticed a public meeting of the 6 for counsel of the parties to deiiver an opening
7 City Council and this particufar speciai meeting, and 7 statement, and I would like to do that at this t+me,
8 that was the done a few weeks ago, and it was posted as 8 atter which then I will present the testimony in
9 weil as an o�ciai meeting of the City Councii, so from 9 evidence. 1 want to first speak to the objections.
10 that perspective in the open meeiing law, then we �0 MR. LEFEVERE: Mr. Mayor?
11 complied with all oi those issues. 13 MAYOR WlLLSON: Yes?
12 MR. LEFEVERE: Correct. �2 n4R. LcG�VcftE: �on't bal;2ve it be
1 3 MAYOR WILLSON= Mr_ Baer, I believe you're 13 appropriate to hear a response to the objections at this
74 going to introdvice something? 14 pant if you haven't considered the object7ons.
MR. BAEft: Thank you. I am, Mr. Mayo�. 15 MAYOR W1lLSON: 1 agree.
16 Mr. Mayor, if I might be heard briefly on these 16 MR. LEFEVERE: It should be either
17 objections_ You've heard Mr. �eFevere's explanation for 17 two-sided or no# at atl.
18 them, but 1 would tfiink it would be appropriate for you 18 MAYOR WiLLSON: if you want to just start
19 to hear my explanation as to why you ought to deal with 19 presenting the case.
20 them now. 20 MR CLE�LAND: Ali right, 1 will. AT some
2 MAYOR WILLSflN_ ThaYs in this document? 21 point i wil! ask you to consider that because I think
22 MR. SAER: The object+ons are stated ir� 22 there are certain documents and matters that wiii be a
23 that documenY that just passed out, which we'll mark as 23 part of your consideration and They can be submitted
24 Exhibit 1 on behalf of the respondent. 24 later in writing. The city staff has asked us to bring
25 (Respondent Exhibit No. 1 marked.) 25 this proceeding before the Council because of the utter
Page 18 Page 20
1 MAYOR WILLSON: Generaiiy in the process we 1 faiiure of the Jaweeds, the natural persons who own and
2 hear from the City side first. I'm kind of leaning 2 operate Center Pointe, #rom operating the premises in
3 towards that direction and the� if you wisfi to make 3 compliance with law. There are profound failures in
4 comments then, I'd be okay with that. Is that 4 terms of rights o# premises crime, very high premises
5 acceptable? i mean rather than drag the process out, i'm 5 crime, disproportionateiy Migh premises crime and
fi sure fhere's going to be objection at points across the 6 disorder, housing maintenance violations that not or�ly
7 board. 7 have been noted by the city staff but also by the
MR. LEFEVERE: Well, you're noY required to 8 Minnesota Nousing Finance Agency, MHFA, which is a state
9 respond to these objections. Tfiey have been made in 9 agency that fias oversight regulation over Center Pointe,
10 writing; and you can go on to consider them if you wish 90 many complaints from tenants, tenants' advocates and
11 to do so at this point, you can put it off until a Iater 19 othe� inieresfed parties. A�d the evidence with which I
i 2 time when you have more information, or you can simply 12 will begin are going to be videotapes. !'m not going to
13 move on with the case that the City is presenting. You 13 show them to you in their entirety because they
14 can reserve judgment on iMe objeciions_ 14 coHectively run about 45 minutes, buY we've reproduced
1 COUNCIL MEMBER YELICH: Mr. Mayor? 15 the tapes at Tab i. IYs a CD for you to iook at as you
16 MAYOR WILISON: Council Member Yelich. 16 deliberate and consider this matter.
1 COUNCIL MEMBER YELICH: I would move that 17 These tapes will put you at Center Pointe
18 we accept Ihese objections as part of Yhe record and move 18 in Aprii, Iv1ay and June 2007. They witl show you
19 on wi{h the proceeding. 19 precisely tMe conditions that ihe police see and the
2d MAYOR WILLSON: !s there a second? 20 conditions in which the tenants have to live. They show
21 COUNGL MEMBER RYAN: would second that. 21 dear and unmistakable repetitive violations of law.
22 MAYOR WlLLSON: Any further discussion? 22 We wiN show you at Tab 2 a series of
23 Hearing none, seeing none, a�l in favor say aye. 23 compliance orders issued by the cfty staff, the
24 COUNCIL MEMB�RS: Aye. 24 complia�ce of which has been incomplete by the Jaweeds.
25 MAY�R WILLSON: Opposed say nay. 25 At Tab 3 we wiit offer into evidence the
S (Pages 17 to 20j
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Pub,tic Hearing 10/i/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 21 Page 23
1 inspection of the premises by Minnesota Housing Finance 1 coin or a wad of paper. Criminals know they can gain
2 in fate May 2007, and the notation o€ very serious and 2 access to Center Pointe and it is a piace where they ca�
3 uncorrected violations, the most important and serious of 3 disappear. The evidence before you wili show that these
4 which are lack of secured exterior doors and laundry 4 buildings are linked by common areas and underground
5 doors that aliow unrestrained access to the premises by 5 passageways, and persor�s who enter can disappear
fi aH persons, but particuia�ly those who commit crimes and 6 committing crimes. The palice wiil tell you they enter
7 i�tend to do so. And the police wiil testify as to the 7 the compiex and they can't be apprehended. Lieutenant
8 very strong correlation between the failure of the 8 Bennes wi11 testifiy that the reason he made this
9 Jaweeds to secure Yhe buiidings, thereby protecting 9 inspection was he received written confirmation from tfie
10 tenant safety, thereby contrrbuting to the "10 owners that aii of the exterior doors were fixed and the
91 disproportionately high leveis of police calis at this 11 buildings were secured, and his report indicates that he
12 premises. 12 inspected the premises aad found vi�tuailv all of the
13 At Tab 5 you wili see the criminal 13 doors disabied, broken, and not securing the build+ngs at
'!4 complaints that I have brought as the citq prosecuting 14 all. His report was made on the 27th of August.
15 attomey against the Jaweeds for their failure to operate 15 We �e going to offer, through Officer
16 the premises in compliance with law. 16 Olson, crime statistics that are at Tab 9. It will first
'17 At Tab 6 you wiH see a Notice of Abatement 17 show a comparison between Center Pointe, Twin Lakes
18 that 1 issued as prosecuting attomey, which is a process 18 Manor, Twin Lakes North and Melrose Gates, which are the
19 by Minnesota statute designed to clearly bring to the 19 four farges# apartment complexes in the city, and they're
20 attention of the owner violations of law and to require a 20 comparable as to the year in wfiich they were built,
21 mitigakion ptan. Attached is a response by one oi tfie 21 they're comparable in size. it shows a dramatic contrast
22 Jaweed aitomeys, Mr_ Ken Hertz, submitted as a 22 between tfie total cails for police service for CenYer
23 mitigation plan. As to notice, the evidence wiil show 23 Pointe vis-a-vis these other four_ Based on current
24 thaY the police department and city staff have 24 statistics, the police expect ihat their calls in the
25 continually advised the prope�ty owners and their agents 25 year 20fl7 to tfiis complex may approach 1,000, and thaYs
Page 22 Page 24
1 of the serious and uncorrected violations, and at Tab 7 1 based upon calls for service through August, 2007. At
2 there wiU be testimony from Officer Terry Oison 2 the latter part of Tab 90 is a compilation o# pol+ce
3 supporting the, and identifying and laying fou�dation for 3 statistics to which Officer Olson will testify. It shov✓s
4 ali of these letters that were sent to the owners and to 4 that not only the catls at Center Pointe i should back
5 the owners' agents advising them of the continued, 5 up.
fi persistent and uncorrected vioiations of code and state 6 This model here is based on a model of 53
7 apartment complexes in khe city. IYs 53 apartment
8 You wiH also hear testimony that in an 8 compiexes that have five or more units. it represents
9 effort to avoid ai1 these proceedings, and in an effort 9 slightly more ihan 3,200 apartment units in the ciYy.
10 to be fair to the Jaweeds, the city manager hosted a 10 Since Center Pointe has 252, Center Pointe has 7J
11 meeting in late February 2007 with Asgher Jaweed at which 11 percent of the apartment units in the city, but it
12 time the city manager presided, and in attendance were 12 consistently accounts for 24 perceni of ail police calls
13 Committee Deveiopment Director Btad Hoffman, Building 13 to this group, and it has for years. Thai is an
14 Officia! Larry Martin, Lieutenant Benner and Sergeanf 14 extraordinary drain on poiice resources. And far from
15 Roth of the police department, and unmistakably it was in 15 decli�ing, these sYatistics will show you that calls for
16 that meeiing of considerable duration that the city 16 service have i�creased from 544 in 2004, 683 in 2005, 739
17 manager and other department heads advised Mr. Jaweed of 17 in 2006, and the extrapolation that it might be 900 or so
18 the serious and uncorrected violations at this premises 18 in 2007.
19 and eiicited from him certain promises for corrective 19 There has been a fi�ancial failure of the
20 actio�, none of which have been fulfilled. 20 Jaweeds as weil. The City records ai Tab 10 will show
21 At Tab 8 is the latest report on [he most 21 you that they sYopped paying tfie City sewer and water
22 serious violations at Center Pointe, and tfiai is the 22 utilities in September 2006. Your ordinances require
23 exterior doors do not secure the buildings. Many of the 23 owners to pay utilities and taxes on a current basis for
24 Iocks are broken, many of the locks are actually missing. 24 ail properties they own in #he city. The evidence here
25 The iocks are so flimsy they can be jammed open with a 25 will show that in August 2007 they finally made the
6 {Pages 21 to 24)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/i/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 25 Page 27
1 payments, but by that #ime the utilities due the City for 1 like to be heard.
2 Center Pointe amounted to more than $76,000, and the 2 Good evening, iadies and gentlemen of the
3 utilities for Brookhaven, their other property, amounted 3 Council_ 1 want to note first that i appreciate the
4 to more than $18,000. Tfiese records will show you that 4 opportunity to be here and speak on behalf of my client,
5 they owe the City an annual bond fee of $8,181.25. The 5 Brookiyn Center Leased Housing Associates. I want to
6 last invoice 1 have seen here {hrough the end of May 6 note second that the procedural objections we filed were
7 shows #hat this is stiA unpaid. The evidence wiN show 7 not for the purpose of delaying this process but to make
8 that the Jaweeds failed to pay CenterPoint Energy, the 8 sure that the process was done correc#iy so that my
9 natural gas company, such that nat�rat gas shutoffs were 9 clients received the appropriate procedura! due process
10 imminent this summer, and there wiil be testimony that 10 and so Yhat Yhe Court of Appeals does not send tfiis back
11 the gas was shut off at Srookhaven for a day. 11 to be redo�e after we've done it once.
12 At Tab 11, we just received a teYter irom i2 My goal here is to make sure that ihere's a
13 the trustee advising that the owners are delinquent i� 13 fair hearing and that the proper evidence is considered
14 #fieir underiying financing payment by more than $131,000. 14 and that improper evidence, including much ofi what
15 The concern o# the City is thaY these payments escrow 15 Mr. Cleiland went over with you, is not considered. 1
16 taxes, and if the payments aren't made, the tax escrow 16 disagree respectfully wi#h Mr. LeFevere in his suggestion
17 won't be su�cient to pay the taxes, which is a 17 that you won't be able to decide objeci+ons until aKer
18 requirement of holding a license. 18 Yhis heari�g is compiete, and I submit to you that by the
19 At Tab 12 is the order of the City of 19 time this hearing is comptete, you will be so tainted
20 Minneapolis revoking a rental license for the Jaweed 20 with the improper argument and evidence that Mr. CleHand
21 property in 2006 because of uncorrected drug activity. 21 is going to produce thaf it wiil be impossible for you to
22 At Tab 93 are the records from the City of 22 separate that out and make the decisions after the fact,
23 Robbinsdale for the Jaweed property there showing 23 and that begins with the very process of our being here.
24 repeated, unco�rected housing code vio�ations from 2004 24 Mr. Cleiland, under the ordinance strike
25 to 2007, and a recommendafion of the city manager that 25 that_ The City, the City under the ordinance has an
Page 26 Page 28
9 the city prosecutor unde�take prosecution. 1 obligation to give my client due notice, not just of the
2 1'm offering al! these documents, and there 2 time and place of this hearing, but of all of the reasons
3 is going to be testimony ihat wili commence shortly in 3 for this hearing. And 1 asked also tha# Mr. GeHand
4 support of all of these. Most of these documents i'm 4 provide us with copies of the evidence that he was going
5 asking you to review, and on the basis of which the city 5 to produce, and yet 1 go through this notebook and there
6 staff is asking you to make your decision, are matters of 6 are a number of things that I've never seen before
7 public record. In many cases they are matters that have 7 because Mr. Clelland didn't produce them. Ne was able to
8 aiready been decided. !n fairness to the defendants, 8 get it together for you but he didn't provide it to me
9 they have received continued, sustained notice from the 9 and, there#ore, my clients haven't had a fair opportunity
10 City as to these violations, repeated requests and 10 to prepa�e to respond to the aliegations that apparent�y
11 invitation for corrective action, including the direct 11 are going to be made against them. i respectfuily
12 intervenfion of our city manager, and the reason we're 12 request that you co�sider these objections now at the
13 here tonight, the reason for this criminal prosecution is 13 outsQt and as we proceed, if it's your decision to
14 there has been, far from a reduction in the caHs of 14 proceed.
15 service for crime, an actual, perceptible increase. i 5 That said, the City's authoriry ta regulate
16 I would like leave to address the 96 rental housing is �imited. lt is not a wide-open
17 objections at any time the Cou�cil thinks is approp�iate. 17 authority. You can only regulate to the extent that the
i 8 i do have some important matters to speak to that. Bui 18 State has ceded that authority to you, and I would submit
19 concluding my opening statement, unless Mr. Baer wishes 19 you can also only regulate to the extent that your
20 to give his at this time, 1'm going to proceed to show 20 ordinances speil out your regulations. It would be
21 you portions of the videotape and then proceed with 21 improper for you to regulate in a fashion that is not
22 testimony from the police and city staff. 22 described in your ordinances. Ordinance 12-900, which 1
23 MAYOR WILLSON: Mr. Baer, would you like to 23 note was noi in the packet you were provided today ihat
24 make your apening statement at this time? 24 Mr. teFevere was kind enough to send to me, i2-900 sets
25 MR. BAER: Thank you, Mr. Mayor, I would 25 out the purpose of your ordinance that relates to rental
7 (Pages 25 to 28j
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing� 10i1i2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 29 Page 31
1 housing, and there is nothing in 12-900 that says that 1 get away with procedure that no court wiil iet him get
2 the purpose of this fype of proceeding is to penalize a 2 away with, and thaf directiy impinges on my clienYs
3 prape+ty owner for past offenses. Instead, your 3 righis, and ihey're valuabie rights. So again i
4 ordinance says, "1t is the purpose of tfiis sectio� to 4 respectfully ask that you pay atten#ion to those issues
5 assure that residential housing in {he city is decent, 5 this evening.
6 safe and sanitary, and is so operated and maintained as 6 WeYe gang to focus on the steps that have
7 to not become a nuisance to the neighborhood or Yo become 7 been taken to cure the problems, we're going to talk
8 an influence that fosters blight and deterioration or 8 about our plan fo� moving forward, and we`re going to
9 creates a disincentive to reinvest in the community," and 9 submit evidence that revocation or suspension of Yhe
10 it goes on from there. But take a look at that, and 10 rentai iicense at Center Poinie is not goi�g to cure any
19 you li see that there's nothing in the ordina�ce ihat 11 problem; indeed, it wili cause the problem to get worse.
12 says that your purpose this evening is to punish someone 12 Revocation or suspension of that Iicense mea�s one thing
13 for past bad acts. 13 under your ordina�ce; means that they can't re-!et any
14 Mr. Cielland has demonstrated, through the 14 empty apartments. it means tfiat as people naturally move
15 notebook he provided you, from this opening that he just 15 out of the apartments, they can't be re-let_ !t rr+eans
16 gave, Mr. Cleitand has demonstrated that his focus is 16 that over 6me the revenue stream that is necessary to
17 going to be on the past. He didnY say a thing about the 17 the operation and maintenance of that facility dries up.
18 condition at tfie Center Pointe Apartments now. Our #ocus 18 Md I ask you to consider that when you're deciding
19 is going to be on what has occurred to get these 19 whether thaYs what you want to have happen, or do you
20 apartments in good conditio� and our plan for going 20 wa�t the property #o get batter, and in order #or it to
21 forward from this point, induding a new management 29 get better ii needs revenue, it needs the cooperation of
22 company thaPs been in Alace for a month and has been 22 the officiais of this city.
23 worlcing wiYh city officials over the last month to find 23 If at the end of the day you determine #hat ifs
24 out specificalty, to the extent they ca�, what are the 24 necessary for you to do someThing, and if you determine
25 City's concems so that they can be addressed. With some 25 tfiat the process that has been foliowed to arrive there
Page 30 Page 32
1 of the city officiais we've received cooperatio�; with 1 has been fiair, then at most 1 ask you to consider
2 others, including Mr. Ciella�d, we've received no 2 imposing conditions that have to be met going forvvard
3 cooQeration_ We asked whai is the probiem, and what 3 with the proposed penalty if those conditions aren't met
4 we've been told, since the end of August when this 4 of revacation or suspension_ If you want to controi this
5 meeting was first noticed, aibeit for a differenY day, 5 prope�iy, do it, but do it right, do it in a fashion that
6 what we've been told is, well, you're just gang to have 6 the property is going to get better, not worse.
7 to go Yhrough this process and we just have to see how it 7 Anrf 1 ciose again wi#h fhe notion that you
8 tums out, instead of having the cooperatian that says, 8 ought Yo consider now, I submit, whether this hearing is
9 here's the concems, IeYs see i# we can get them 9 proper at all, given the procedure that was foAowed by
90 addressed. 10 Mc Clelland in getting us ail here. Thank you.
11 I submit to you there's a reason that 11 MAYOR WILLSON: Any comments? 1f not, we
12 thaPs been the response, and ihe reason is that 12 can move forwatd_ Mr. LeFevere?
13 Mc CIeUa�d went around with this property before, back 13 MR. LEFEVERE: 1 do have one comment, I
14 in 2002, and he wasn't happy about the result a�d so now 14 guess just a suggestion. I don't know how the Councii is
15 he's going to go around again, but he's not going to go 15 going ta want to deal with these issues as they come up
16 around in front of the couRs where he tried and lost 16 or whether you will, bui at some point you should be
17 last time, where he has sa'sd that he's going to try tfiis 17 presented by one of the parties with a copy of the notice
�8 time by giving a notice of abateme�t Yhat is properly 18 that was given so that you can make the kinds of
19 resoived through a court proceeding, by giving criminai '19 judgments that you're going to have io make at some point
20 charges that he wants to put in front of you as evidence. 20 in these proceedings_ Maybe sooner, maybe later, but I
21 Charges, allegations that he's going #o submit tonight as 21 don't know if thaPs part of anybody's plan. The Council
22 evidence? But he hasn't submitted them to a judge and a 22 does nof have a copy of the notice of charges at this
23 jury to 1et people that are supposed to decide those 23 point.
24 charges make a decision on khem. Mr. Clelland has chosen 24 MAYOR WILLSON: Not that 1'm aware of.
25 this forum because he thinks that you folks will let him 25 MR CLELLAND: i'm prepared to do it now or
8 (Pages 29 to 32)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
b 12-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 33 Page 35
1 as a post-hearing submission, but 1 assert to you that as 1 forth the reason for the hearing. Even in the letter
2 disinterested partiss here, you will look at my letters 2 submitted by Mr. Baer from me to him on the 28th af
3 to Mr. Baer that advised him of the specific reasons, and 3 August, iYs a two-page letter deYailing specifically
4 the letters from me to him conveying documents_ Every 4 every ground for this hearing, and tha#'s failure to
5 document that you have here has been in his possession 5 compiy with the October, November 2406 compliance orders
6�or some time, and many of these documents have been in 6 issued as a condition of license renewal, failure to
7 the possession of his cGents for months. I want to make 7 comply with the 25 Aprii 2007 compliance orders, failure
tMat plain fo you, whether we do it at the outset here 8 to maintain cuRent utifity payments, failure to pay
9 or, and maybe as Mr. LeFevere suggested, a�d 1 think is 9 taxes and assessments currently due, failing to pay Yhe
10 reasanabie, in a post-hearing submissio�. 10 year 2007 bond administration fee, #ailure to comply with
13 MAYOR WILISON: Was Yhat your suggestion? 11 the o�ders of MHFA, failure to secure the buildings by
12 MR_ IE�EVERE: No. 12 repair or reolacement of exterior doors and/or iockc,
13 MAYOR WlLISON: I don't ihink I heard you '13 failure to abate pfemises crime and disordec Tfie letter
14 say that. 4 goes on to remind him that his clients have had copies of
15 MR. LEFEVERE: That was a possibility. 15 these notices for a long time. 1 don i know how mucfi
16 MR_ CLELLAND: Oh, okay. 16 more specific we have to be in terms of due process ihan
17 MAYOR WILLSON: Mr. Baer? 17 to identify in paragraph 2 of this letter the precise
98 MR. BAER: Mc LeFevere has me�tioned 18 grounds for this hearing. This absoiuteiy advises them
19 notice of charges, and I think 1'm using your words 19 of the precise grounds. And if you look at my written
20 correctly, a couple oF times, and 1 will submit to you 20 submission to you tonight, we don't choose other grounds
21 that there isn't one. i've never received one, there is 21 than these. These are the grounds. How can it be said
22 no notice of charges, and of course Mr. LeFevere is 22 that they can't prepare #or a hearing when we've
23 right, there ought to be. IF you're going to have a 23 identified the various documents whicfi show them
24 hearing, an adversarial proceeding, then Mc Clelland 24 violations of law. I thi�k this leYter alone is
25 ought to have put us on notice of what was going to be 25 dispositive that they have received adequate notice.
Page 34 Page 36
discussed at thls adversariai proceeding, whai the 1 And if you fook at the additionai letters
2 charges are, and 1 submit that we haven't received ihat, 2 supplied by Mr. Baer in his submission, letYer after
3 which is why 1've been saying lhat this is not a proper 3 letter after letter shows that i have been send+ng him
4 proceeding. 4 documents by courier. There is no document here that he
5 MR. IEFEVERE: Mr. Mayor, better clarify 5 hasn't seen, and so because ('m accused of an unfaimess
6 myself here before this goes too much longer. I did use 6 here by him, I want a chance to respond, whether you
7 that term, I was quoted correctly by counsel. What the 7 consider it at the outset or you give us leave to show
8 ordinance says is that the decision musi be proceeded by 8 you ihe documents and provide test+mony subsequentiy. I
9 writte� notice to the applicant of the alleged grounds. 9 don't want the Cauncil to be concerned that there wasn't
10 I don'1 know if the distinction between "grounds" and 10 faimess here, either by city staff, either by the city
11 "charges" is going to be germane in the case here, but 11 manager or by me as your prosecuting attorney. I think
12 the question is wheiher adequate notice has been given of 12 the written record is indisputable that there has been
3 the grounds for ihe proposed license revocation, and 13 fair notice here and adequaie notice, and Yhat they can
14 ihaYs not necessarily stated as charges if a person 14 and they should be prepared.
15 couid reasonably understand the statement to be a basis 15 So I also take issue with the fact that I
16 or a suggestion as to what Yhe grounds are or may be for 16 brought this. I am represeniing the city staff and the
i 7 the proposed iice�se sanction. 17 poiice department. It is your city staff and police
1$ MR. CLELlANO: Mr. Mayor, 1 ihink this is 18 depa�tment who bring this recommendation to you. 1 am
19 easily resolved. !f you iook at Tab E in the objections 19 {heir spokesperso�. So whether we do it at the outse[
20 filed by Mr. Baer 20 or, as i suggest, and maybe counsei agrees, as a
21 COUNCIL MEMBER RYAN= Excuse me, which tab? 21 post-hearing submission, 1 wauid like to proceed with the
22 MR. CLELL4ND: Tab E, as in echo. You 22 testimo�y.
23 first of al! have in your counsel packet a letter 1 23 MR. BAER: May I respond?
24 addressed io one of the atiomeys for Jaweed and the 24 MAYOR WILLSON: Please do but, you k�ow
25 personnel aT Dominium dated the 24th of August that sets 25 MR. BAER: I'll keep ii short.
9 (Pages 33 to 36)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1I2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 37 Page 39
1 MAYOR WILLSON: bantering back and forth 1 with the City of Brookiyn Center. As a lawyer,
2 is going to take ail night just getting through Yhis part 2 Mr. C1eUand knows that if a party has counsel and he
3 of it. 3 wants to commurricafe wiih that party, he has to
4 MR_ BAER: I understand. The Council 4 communicate with their counsel, me. 1 aiso asked
5 packet that was se�t out to you ail today was provided to 5 Mr_ Cletland in this Ietter to advlse me about this
6 me, as i said earlier, by Mr. LeFevere, and 1 appreciate 6 hearing. At that time it was scheduled #or
7 that. it indudes a letter 7 September 24th.
8 MAYOR WtLLSON: lfs this one? Which 8 1f you wilt turn to ihe next tab, Tab C in
9 packet? Oh, this one, the big one? 9 Exfiibit 1, you wifi see on August 24 Mr. Clelland wrote
10 MR. BOGANEY_ The oneyou received overihe i0 back saying, "We wi11 certainly comply with City
11 weekend. 1 i ordinances which require disciosure o# the reasons for
12 DEPUTY CtERK WORLEY: The one you received 12 the proposed license action and provide that
13 Friday. 13 documentation supQorting Yhe proceeding." This is the
14 MR. LEFEVERE: The normai agenda packet. 14 24th of August 2007. 1Ys the same day that he
15 MAYOR WILLSON_ Okay, I just want to be 15 apparently wrote this letter that was sent to you thai
16 ciear on which one we're #alking abouf. 16 never came to me, and he doesn't teli me in this tetter
17 MR. BAER: Thank you, sir. want to be 17 of August 24th whaf the reasons are_ He says we'll get
18 clear, so let's make sure we're aU on the same paga 18 it to you.
9 Mr. LeFevere wrote to me today and said that he 19 Then turn to Exhibit D, ifie one that
20 represented the City and wouid be participating in this 2D Mr. Clelland stood here and talked about. I wrote
21 hearing as the City's cou�sel, and he responded briefly 21 again i'm sorry, this isn't the one Mr. Ciel�and spoke
22 to my objections_ He then sent me a second e-mail at 22 about, he spoke about E. D is my letter to Mr. Clelland,
23 12:41 this afternoon, and ihe text of that e-mail to me 23 after receiving his of August 24, saying you didn't
24 said, °Mr. Baer, as a follow-up to my e-mail to you of 24 answer my questions_ His response that came by tax the
25 earlier today, attached is an e-mail containing the 25 foilowing day is under Tab E, Augusi 28, and how does he
Page 38 Page 40
1 agenda packet for tonighYs meeting that was sent by the 1 start this letter? And this is the problem with the
2 city manager to the Council Members," and 1 was of the 2 process. Quote, "The entire extent of your ciient's
3 impression that went to you today, but maybe it went to 3 default under appGcable state laws and city ordinaaces
4 you earlier. 4 has not been determined." How ca� he stand here today in
5 Inc�uded within that was a four-item agenda with 5 front oi you and say this was the notice ofi the reasons
6 one substantive item, a memorandum from the city manager 6 for this hearing when whak he told me in Yhe opening
7 to the Mayor ar�d City Cour�cil dated September 28, 2007, a 7 sentence was we haven't determined yet what aH we're
8 copy of Sectfon 12-9i0 of your ordi�ances, but no other 8 going to charge you with. And then he goes on in the
9 sections, and a Ietter dated 24 August 2007 that was sent 9 second paragraph and how does he start? "Without
10 by facsimile and registered maii #o gentlemen named 10 limitation." What does that mean? lt means he�e's some
11 Safar, Brierton, Brachman and Sween at a company called 11 of the things we're going to complain about but there are
12 Dominium Ma�agement Services, and also by facsimile and 12 going to be more, and he �ever provided us with the more.
13 registered mail to Kenneth Hertz at Hertz law Offices, i 3 He never provided us with what is the full list ofi
14 and t ask you to note the daie, 24 August 2007. In this 14 aliegations that my client needs to be prepared to
15 nokice, not sent to my office, Mc Clelland sets out the 15 respond to.
16 grounds that the city staff, or that he, on behalf of the 16 And then we come here this evening and
17 city staff, intend to use tonight. That letter did not 17 Mr. Clelland, before introduc+ng any of this evidence,
18 come to my clients, Brooklyn Center Leased Housing 18 places it ai� in front of you so that you can review it
19 Associates, and d+d not come to my dients' lawyer. 19 as he stands here and talks_ 1Ys not been introduced
20 And now if you would tum to what we marked as 20 but you've got it, you were looking at it, at least some
21 Exhibit 1, ihaY is my objections that 1 sent to you alt 21 of you we�e, while he was talking. And what's in hete?
22 last week, Tab B is a le#er dated August 21 in which I 22 Well, he says i've seen aB this before, but IYI
23 notified Mr. Clelland quite ciearly that 1 was 23 guarantee you i haven't, and if you want to put me under
24 representing Brooklyn Ce�ter Leased Housing Associates 24 oath and have me testify to that, i'd be happy to.
25 Limited Par#nersfiip w(th respect to any and all disputes 25 First, under Tab S, he's got crimina!
10 (Pages 37 to 40)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/i/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 41 Page 43
3 complaints. These are allegations made by Mr. Ctelland 1 COUNClL MEMBER YELICH= 1 would move thai
2 as a prosecuting attomey. 2 we proceed with hearing {Me evidence.
3 Under Tab 9 he has staYistics apparently 3 MR. LEFEVERE: lvlr_ Mayor, it probably isn't
4 compiled from some records without telfing us what the 4 necessary to have motions or� every step of the
5 records are that they're compiied ftom, and without 5 proceeding. i guess what i would recommend, since you
6 providing me with those records, as I requested. 6 have a pane! here, is that the Mayor sort of run
7 Under Tab 1 i, he's provided you with a Notice of 7 meetings, run the meeting wifh Council Members making
8 Default that was served on September 18th. Thafs sure 8 suggesTions, and if somebody says 1 don't agree with
9 not referenced in any of his letters to me or to anyone 9 that, I would like to have a vote, then you can have a
10 else. And incidentaUy, he forgot to provide you with 10 vote on the procedure going forward. But I wouid just
1 the Notice of Cure. 11 take that process a little bit more informally and let
1 2 Under Tab 12 he has a requesf for City 12 the Mayor preside an� makQ tt�� Y ���y�, ;�5jecf
13 Councii Committee Action from the Depa�tment of Public 13 to suggestions that you think you wisfi to make but
14 Safety Regulatory Services Committee of the City of 14 without motions.
15 Minneapolis_ ThaPs never been provided to me. 15 MR_ YELICH: woutd suggest.
�fi U�der Tab 13 he has, I'm nat sure what, but 16 MAYOR WILLSON: Thank you_ Mr. Cielland?
17 iYs not related to Brookiyn Center, and it is not '17 MR. CLELLAND: Thank you very much, Your
38 anything that was ever provided to me. We weren't 18 Honor. Mr. Mayor, Council Members, we'U call as our
19 provided fair notice of what The issues were to be at 19 first witness Lieutenant Kevin Benner.
20 this proceeding_ We weren't provided with the evidence 20 Lieutena�t Benner, if you would come fonvard and
2� that should have been provided to us so thai we knew how 21 be sworn, piease?
22 to prepare and respond to tMese allegations_ And 1 22
23 submit to you as a resuit this is an improper process, 23
24 and the proper course of action would be for the City 24
25 Council to table this, direct Mr_ Cleiland to do what 25
Page 42 Page 44
1 he's required to do under your ordinances, and set it on 1 UEUTENANT KEViN BENNER,
2 for a hearing at a time when proper notice and proper 2 duly sworn, was examined and testified as follows:
3 procedure has been foliowed so that we don't go through 3 DiRECT EXAMINATiON
4;his process for nothing and come back here after the 4 BY MR. CLELLAND:
5 Court of Appeals has dealt with it. 5 Q. tieutenant Benner?
6 Mft. LEFEVERE: Mr. Mayor? 1 don't want to 6 A. What 1 have here is a VCR tape that was done b�
7 prolong the discussion_ We can't #ry this case before 7 Of#icer Brian Peters on 4/12 of'07 of the housing
8 any evidence is in. The questian is not whether the 8 conditions at Center Pointe Apartment complex, while
9 licensee has seen any particular document or every 9 Officer Peters, who is narrating as he's videotaping
10 document, iYs not whether a letter wer�t to the wrong 10 throughout the compiex, the things that he sees durirx�
11 atforney, it's not whether the question is whether the 11 this time.
12 Iicensee received notice of the grounds that staff is 12 Q. Lieutenant Benner, at whose request is this
13 going to present evidence on, and until staff presents 13 video made?
4 evidence, you're r�ot going to know whether they received 14 A. 1 made this request
15 notice of those grounds or not. 15 Q. There are actuatly three tapes that will be
16 The Council can't determine wheiher, or at feast i 6 offered #o the Council Taken in April, Nfay and June 2007,
17 I wouldn't know how to advise you to try to determine 17 is that correct?
18 whether anyone received a fair notice of the issues 98 A. Yes, that is correct.
19 before we know wfiat the issues are, and I think we have 99 Q. Okay. I'm going to ask you to run about the
20 to gei into the issues to find out whether issues are 20 first seven or eight minutes of this tape from Aprit
21 presented af which licensee did not have notice. We 21 2007, and is this a true and correc# original of this
22 can't rule on evidence thaYs not in. If there aren't 22 tape?
23 any questions about that, I think you're free to proceed 23 A. This is the original VHS tape. You have copies
24 if you wish to. 24 in your packets on DVD.
25 MAYOR WILtSON: Council Member Yelich? 25 Q. This has not been aitered in any fashion, is
ll (Pages 41 to 44�
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 4S Page 47
1 that correct? 1 adopts the buiiding code and residential housing
2 A. ft has not. 2 maintenance codes. 12-906 provides that "the holder oi
3 Q. Okay, would you run the April #ape, please? 3 the license consents to inspections, and iF the owner
4 NiR. BAER: i have an objection, Mr. Mayor, 4 objects to an inspection, the owner must affirma#ively
5 and that is that apparentiy this tape was prepared by an 5 withdraw that consent," and there is no evidence of that.
6 Officer Brian Peters. I should have an opportu�ity to 6 The only scheduled inspections that have to be made are
7 cross-examine Mr. Peters since he's apparently going to 7 of the dwetling units. ThaYs a mirror of state iaw
8 testify on this tape, that is, he's going to give a 8 because of the privacy of the tenants, except if the
9 n�nning commentary. Without Mr. Peters here, the tape is 9 tenanY invites it. So there is a basis here, I would
10 improper. 10 sugges# that we proceed. We probabiy couid make a
11 Furthermore, this tape was obtained illegally. 11 post-hearing submission to you on any of these points.
12 That is, Mr. Peters, whoevef was out there, entered into 12 but in view of ihe hour we wouid like to oroceed.
13 the premises, the private premises that belong to my 13 MR. BAER: Mc Mayor, in addressing
14 dients without a warrant, without any suspicion of 14 Ms_ O'Conno� s question, perhaps Mr. Cieliand would have
15 immi�ent illegal activity, and wiYhout permission from 15 been so kind as to actually read the section of the
16 the property owner. Accordingiy, the tape is improper 16 ordinance that he refers to. Section 12-906 does state
17 and should not come in. 17 that "no operating license shall be issued or renewed
18 MR. CLELLAND: May I repiy? Under Chapter 18 unless the ow»er of the re�tai unit agrees in his
19 12, it is a condition of holding a renfal Gcense that 19 appiication to permit inspections pursuant to Section
20 the owner consent Yo inspections. Now the owner can 20 12-i001_" Pursuant to Section 12-9001_ So then go to
21 affirmatively withdraw that but there is no evidence they 21 Section 92-1001, and it says that "the city manager and
22 did. The Jaweeds, as a condition of receiving a license 22 his designated agents shail be the compiiance o{ficiai
23 from this Councii, agreed to inspections, and these tapes 23 who shall adminisier and enforce provisions of this
24 will sfiow the inspections of the common areas as weli as 24 ordinance and who is hereby authorized to cause
25 individual apartments by invitation oi the tenant. There 25 inspections on a scheduied basis for �entai dwelling
Page 46 Page 48
1 is noihing illegal about that at ali. 1 units." It doesn't authorize the police department,
2 Chapter 3 also gives the city staff the righi to 2 wikhout a warrant, to enter into private property.
3 inspect to enforce the building and housing maintenance 3 That's what happened here.
4 codes. There is legal authority for the legit+macy of 4 COUNCIL MEMBER RYAN: Mr. Mayor?
5 this tape. i would ask that you take it under advisement 5 MAYOR WILLSON: Counci! Member Ryan.
6 s+nce O�cer Peters couldn't be here tonight_ He can 6 COUNCIL MEMBER RYAN: It ii wouid not delay
7 always testify ai any subsequsnt hearing. Subject to the 7 these proceedings, I would like a brief comment from the
8 objection thaYs been noted, I would &ke the Cou�cil to 8 city attomey on that point, because we're straying into
9 see this tape. 9 some issues that may take us far afield.
10 COUNCIL MEMBER O'CONNOR: Mr. Mayor? 10 MR. tEFEVERE: Well, we've got a coup�e
1 MAYOR WILLSON: Council Member O'Connor. 11 issues before you. Counsel objected to the fact that
12 COUNCJL MEMBER O'CONNOR: Could we know the 12 Officer Peters was not here. He was kind enough to
13 chapter 1Mat says that the City can inspeci the property, 13 explain the reason for the objection in lay terms. He
14 and doesn't that chapter say that the, they should go to 14 was talking about a hearsay objection. You7e not bound
15 the owner first? 15 by the formal rules of evidence. Mr. Baer raised points
16 MR. C�ELLAND: No. 16 that you should consider in deciding whether this
17 COUNCIt MEMBER O'CONNOR: Could we know 17 evidence, if you decide to accept it, is reliable or not.
18 what chapter iYs in? 18 The faci ihat O�cer Peters is not here subject to
19 MR. CLELLAND: Yes, I do. First of ail, I 19 cross-examination may, in your view, affect the
20 don't have my ordina�ces in front of ine, but let me just 20 credibility or reiiability o# that evide�ce. It may not,
21 consult my notes. 21 depending on what the evidence is. But that is an
22 Chapier 3-102 provides that "city 22 objection that should be noted by the Council and taken
23 inspectors," that inctudes the police, they have code 23 under considera[ion.
24 enforcement for this project, "provides for right o# 24 ln terms of the inspection, I guess it
25 entry by city inspectors," that's the building code, and 25 seems to me that tfie ordinance secYions that are cited
12 (Pages 45 to 48)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing lfl/1I2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 49 Page 51
1 are subject to some interpretaYion. I wouid irnite the 1 deputies in the viole�t crimes and fraud division_
2 parties to brief that if #hey think it's germane to the 2 MAYOR WILLSON: Okay, thank you.
3 question before the Council, which is whether the 3 MR. BAEit: Mr. Mayor, since the motion has
4 violations occurred or not, and thaYs something Yhat 4 now been formally made for you to receive this evidence,
5 could be done following the hearing if the Cou�cil wishes 5 1 want to renew my objection on tfie basis of hearsay, as
6 to proceed and hear the evidence aT this iime. 6 Mr. leFevere said it. What it means is 3 don't get an
7 COUNCIL MEMBER RYAN: Mr. Mayor? 7 opportunity to cross-exami�e. IYs not only Mr_ Peters,
8 MAYOR WlLLSON: Council Member Ryan_ 8 but ihese other two o�cers that were there apparently_
9 MR. RYAN: Thank you, Mr_ LeFevere, thaYs 9 No one can show up for this hearing tonight? And then
10 the impression that I got, but !'m not an attorney. 10 Mr. Peters managed to make reference to discussions that
11 Perhaps we couid proceed the� with testimony, and if 1 i he had with o#her people who aiso aren't here for me to
12 cou�sel wishes to address that in briefs subsequently 12 talk to. He, for example, told you what a contractor
13 they could do so. 13 supposedty toid him. I don't get to taik to either
14 MAYOR WiLLSON: Mr. Benner, if you wouid 14 Mr_ Peters or the contractoc ThaPs a vroiation of
15 like to proceed, please? 15 process. I shouid have an opportunity to examine Yhose
16 BY THE 1NITNESS: 16 people, 1 should have an opportunity to talk with
17 A. Ail right. That's the camera in the hallway. 17 Mr. Peters about what else he saw, what eise he did at
18 (Video playing.) 18 the time that he made this taps, and by admitting that,
9 SY MR. CIELLAND: 19 if you do, you're violating my ciienYs rights to a fair
20 Q. LeYs move forvvard to the 20 process here. And so I renew my objection and ask that
21 A. Okay, we'ii move forward fo tfie May 10. 1'm 29 you not admit this tape_
22 taking small bits of this as the motion of the camera c. -d2 MAYOR WiLLSON: Thank you, Mr. Baer, duly
23 cause people a Iittle bit of stomach discomfort. The 23 noted. Mr. Cleliand, if you please?
24 next tape was taken o� May 1fl, again by O�cer Brian 24 MR. CtELLAND: Yeah, I think it speaks for
25 Peters. 25 itseif. iYs showing you what the conditions are. There
Page 50 Page 52
1 (Yideo playing.) 1 isri t any chailenge to Ihe, reaily to the authenticity of
2 MR. CLELLAND: Mr. Mayor, I wiU show you 2 the tape here. As Mc LeFevere said, you don't operate
3 just briefly the June tape, and then we'll offer the CD, 3 under any strict rules of evidence as a court would. 1
4 which is a reproduction of aii this, so you need not see 4 submit khat tfie tape is among the most important evidence
5 the entire footage tonight. 5 you wili see, and 1 ask you to accept that into evide�ce.
6 (Video playing.) 6 MAYOR WILLSON: I was moving forward,
7 MR. CLELLAND: Mr. Mayor, at this point, in 7 Mr. Clelland, so can you move on to ihe next item and we
8 the interests of brevity, we'fl terminate this. But I 8 wili accept that? I have no problem wi#h #hat at all.
9 would ask you to receive in evidence Disc 1, which is a 9 MR. CLELLAND: Thank you.
10 compilation of all ihese videos, and ihen we can proceed 10 SY MR. CLELLAND:
1� to addit+onal testimony. 11 Q. Lieutenant Benner, if you take the stand there,
12 MAYOR WILLSON: I do have a question, 12 I will resume my queslions for you. How many times
13 though, Mr. Clelland. 13 MR. LEFEVERE: I'm sorry, excuse me. I'm
14 MR. CLELi.AND: Yes. 14 going to try to remember to do this as we go along now.
15 MAYOR WILLSON: Mr. Peters, what is his '15 The mayor accepted
16 status wiih the City? Is he an o�cer? 16 MR. CLELLAND: The disc at Tab 1.
17 THE WITNESS: Officer Brian Peters, yes, 17 MR. LEFEVERE: Which is Tab 1?
18 he's a police officer of the City. He's currently in 18 MR. CLELLAND: It's referred to as Exhibit
19 Mexico right now. �g
20 MAYOR WILLSON: And he's the plainclothed 20 MR. IEFEVERE: ThaYs ail thaPs in Tab 1?
21 person here or the officer in uniform? 21 MR. CLEILAND: Yes_
22 THE WITNESS: Actually fie's in plaindothes 22 MR. LEFEVERE: Thank you, i'm sorry.
23 with the camera, and the person that was with fiim, on one 23 BY MR. CLEILAND:
24 occasion ii was O�cer Rick Gabler, and the Hennepin 24 Q. Lieutenant Benner, how iamiliar are you with the
25 County Sheriffs Office aiso assisted us with two 25 physical conditions of the premises at Center Pointe,
l3 (Pages 49 to 52)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
I Page 53 Page 55
1 particularly the condition of the exterior doors and the 1 Q. Okay. You were aware that the city stafF
2 laundry room doors? 2 undertook a unit-by-unit inspection of the Center Pointe
3 MR. BAER: Excuse me, Mr. Cleliand, i think 3 Apartment compiex?
4 that this is in ali of our i�terests. The word was that 4
5 we're going to have sworn witnesses. 1 don't believe 5 Mr. Ciella�nd. 8e o�e we move o this'_m sorry again,
6 this o�cer has been sworn. 6 MR. CLELLAND: Jfs not an exhibit.
MR_ CLELLAND: Yes, he was. 7 MR. LEFEVERE: Oka
MAYOR WiILSOTl: Yes, he was, at the Y. just for illustrative
8 purposes?
9 beginning of the proceeding, Mr. Baer.
g Mft. CLEILAND: It is, yes.
MR. BAER: 1'm sorry. 10 MR. LEFEVERE: The map that was being, the
11 BY N1R. CLELLAND: 11 overhead map that was referred to is not being
Q. My question was how familiar are you wi{h the, 12 introduced?
13 over the last several years, of the condition of the 3
14 Center Pointe ApartmeMs, particu�arly the exterior doors 14 obviousty�t e t stimonyD bout this and 1 j st wanted
15 and the lau�dry room doors? 15 to orient the Council as to the interco�nec#ion between
16 A. I've been a potice o�ce� for i8 years in 16 these buildings. Okay.
17 Brookiyn Ce�ter 17 BY MR. CLELLAND:
(Discussion held off tfie record.) 18 Q. Now you were aware that o� tMe 5th of Oc#ober
79 A. i'm very familiar with the property after 38 19 2006, a 23-page compliance order noting and ordenng the
20 years of service. I know the
I ro ert due
i P P Y to the volun �3 correction of housing maintenance defect
21 0# calls there an s was senk to
dlhaveb
een to that property we11 21 Hyder Jaweed, isYhat correct?
22 into the thousands of times_ 22 A. That is correct.
23 Q. Okay. Would you put on the screen the 23
24 bird's-eye view of the compiex Yo show the layout? 24 Tab 2�,s that the 23 page document at the beginning of
25 A. {Witness complies.) 2b A_ did not prepare that book.
Page 54 Page 56
Q- Now this shows the layout of the buildings, each 1 Q. Just lake a look and confirm that?
2 one of which is numbered by an address, is that correct? 2 A. {Examining document.) Yes that has.
3 A. That is correct. 3 MR. CLELLAND: And I would offer as
4 Q. Now how are ihese buiidings tied together 4 Exhibii 2A, 1 guess, at Tab 2 the 23-page compliance
5 underground? 5 order to Hyder Jaweed of October 5, 2006.
6 A. There are laundry rooms that connect some of the g
7 buiidings. There's 11 buildi� s at this ro ert five MAYOR WILLSON: Mr. LeFevere, thaYs item
g P P Y, 7 No.2?
8 on your east side, six on your west side. Tfie 8 MR. LEFEVERE: 7ab 2. That would be item A
9 underground laundry system cor��ects the buildings that 9 under Tab 2, I guess.
10 appear aboveground to be not connected, but actually, if 10 MR. BAER: Mr. Mayor, if 1 might be heard?
19 you go through Yhe laundry system maze, you can actuali y11 MAYOR WILLSON: Mc Baer.
12 come up in otfier buildings. 12 MR. BAER: The Ciiy's ordinances specify
1 Q. So if sameone enters the premises here, he can 13 that when a license, a rental license is granted, it can
14 iraverse one building, if the laundry doors are not 14 only be granted if the property is in compliance with all
15 iocked he can get in the lau�dry room and then out into a 15 oF the state laws and ciTy ordinances. A lice�se was
�6 completely different building? 16 granted for this property after October 5 of 2006, so by
17 A. That is correcf, you can take one of several
17 the Council's action in granting that license, it has
18 exits. 18 conclusively resolved that the prob�ems, i# they existed
1 9 Q. Okay. How often over tMe years have the i 9 on October 5, 2006, were resolved when the license was
20 exterior doors and the laundry doors of this premises 20 granted: tt is improper for the Council to now consider
21 been in disrepair such that they do not provide safe and 21 events occurring prior to ifie granting of that license.
22 secure locking? 22 That's one of the objections that was stated in the
23 A. would say in the last two years is when it has 23 written objections that I provided you on Friday, and 1
24 become very obvious, so 1 will say September 2005 24 want to renew that objection and ask that the Councii not
25 forward.
25 accepT evidence with respect to events occurring and
14 (Pages 53 to 56)
Paradigm Reporting Capiioning Inc.
b12-339-0545
Pubiic Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page S7 Page 59
1 complaints existing prior to the grant of that license 1 Q. And both of these are ordinary business records
2 because, by your own ordinance, those issues were 2 of the City, is that correct?
3 resolved. 3 A. To my knowledge, yes.
4 MAYOR WILLSON: Tfia�k you, Mr. Baer, duly 4 MR. GLELIAND: A!1 r+ght, t wou{d offer
5 noted. Mr. Clella�d? 5 Section 8 of Tab 2.
6 COUNCIL MEMBER O'CONNOft: Mr. Mayor? 6 MR. BAER: Same objections, Mr. Mayor.
7 MAYOR WiLLSON_ Gouncil Member O'Connor. 7 MAYOR WILLSON: 7hank you, Mr_ 8aer, duly
COUNCIL MEMBER O'CONNOR: Mr. Boganey, did 8 noted. i would receive and fi�e at this point in time_
9 we approve their license in January of 2007? 9 Mr. Cfelland, if you would like to move on?
10 MR. BOGANEY: Council Member, I'm not aware 10 MR. CLELLAND: Thank you.
91 of the specific date that the license was granted, but a 11 BY MR. CLELLAND:
12 license was granted_ 12 Q. Officer Benner, whaf traditio�al
13 COUNCIL MEMBER O'CONNOR: After this date? 13 responsibilifias did the police department have for code
1 4 MR. BOGANEY: Subsequent to these 14 enforcement up through and including the summer of 20fl7?
15 violations bei�g idenYified_ 1 S A. The police department was tasked by having the
1s COUNGL MEMBER O'CONNOR: And tha2 was a 16 person called the neighborhood liaison officer up until
17 two-year renewal of their Iicense? 17 May of 2007. The responsibility of tfie neighborhood
18 MR. BOGANEY: The Iicense had a two-year 18 liaison officer was to do exYerior code violation
19 ierm, that is correct. 19 inspections, both at residential properties and at
20 COUNCIL lNEMBER O'CONNOR: Thank you. 20 multifamily complexes.
21 MR. CLELLAND: The relevance and importance 21 Q. Now you attended a meeting that the city manager
22 of the October orders are several. First, owners of 22 called with Asgher Jaweed on the 22nd of February 2007,
23 property, especially residential property, have an 23 is #hat carrect?
24 affirmative duty to prevent and correct violations even 24 A. That is correct.
25 before the City finds them_ This never should have 25 Q. What was the purpose for which our city ma�ager
Page 58 Page 60
1 occurred_ The owners never should have allowed 23 pages 1 cal�ed the meeting?
2 of code violations, whicfi directly and impo�ta�tly affect 2 A. From the police perspective, our role was to try
3 the tenants, to ever occur. Further, we're going to show 3 to find out how we could reduce the poiice calls to
4 you Yhat tfie license that was issued was conditioned upon 4 service and make it a safer place #or tfie residents Yo
5 compliance with orders dated the 15ih of November, 2006, 5 live.
6 and there wili be testimony that there wasn'# comptiance 6 Q. Who attended that meeting?
7 with those orders, which were a condition of license 7 A. 1 had Sergeant Frank Roth from the police
8 issued. Further, we're going to show you a co�sistency 8 department, myself, the city manager Curt Boganey, Larr
9 of vioiation, because many of the violations noted in the 9 8arton from Community Development, Brad Hoffman fro� a
10 October orders are what you've seen; doors that don't 10 Community Development, and Asgher AJi.
11 operate properly, premises that are insecured ihat 11 Q. Also known as Asgher Jaweed?
12 direcUy relate to the high rate of crimes, and that 12 A. Yes, that is correct.
13 probletn consiste�Yly surfaces in the reports of MHFA and 13 Q. Okay. What information was conveysd by aN of
14 the City within three or four months of license issuing. 14 tMe city officials, +ncluding the city manager, to
95 So it is relevant, you can give it the weight that you 15 Mr. Asgher Jaweed in this meeting?
16 wish, bu# I ask you to receive the dctober orders as part 16 A. The concerns were what were the obvious problerrs
17 of Tab 2. 17 that were stili in existence at the property from each of
18 MR. MAYOR: Mc Clelland, you have another 18 the departmenYs perspeciive; the police, community
19 section here that you wish to address? 19 development and city offices.
20 MR_ CLELIAND: Thank you. 20 Q. Now wfien ihe license was renewed in January
21 BY MR. CLELLAND: 21 2007, what reduction, if any, did the police department
22 Q. Officer Benner, looking at the iast seve�a! 22 find in the cafls for service and the high rates of
23 Qages of Tab 2, can you identify these as additional 23 premises crime?
24 compliance orders as a condition of code compliance? 24 A. We did not have a reduction in caUs for
25 A. Yes, these are code compiiance issues. 25 service. We had an increase in calls for service at the
15 (Pages 57 to 60)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2fl07
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETiNG
Page 6l Page 63
I 1 Center Pointe Apartment comptex_ 9 week of service jus! to try to help reduce the crime and
2 Q. Now what specifically did you contribute to the 2 identify who in that area was causing crime to help rid
3 meeting in telling Asgher Jaweed about the serious and 3 them from the property.
4 persistent violations of Iaw at the Center Pointe 4 Q. What was the connection beiween that surge +n
5 premises? S robberies and the Center Poi�te complex?
6 A. From the poiice deQartment perspective, we were 6 A. ii was a direction of flighi from aimost every
7 Iooking at trying to provide inFormation to assist him in 7 suspecY.
8 making his compfex a safer place fior people to live 8 Q. Describe that, please.
9 through environmental design. Environmental design 9 A. The suspect, if we had an incide�t either at
10 i�cludes having secured, locked doors, making sure you 10 Center Pointe Apartment comptex, the Metro Transit bus
11 have exterior Iighting, and also, importa�tly, making 11 hub, which is rigfit across the street �ight here,
12 sure that you know who is livi�g at your property and wh 92 Brookdale Matl would be right here if you're continuinq
13 is not living at your property, on-site management beyon� I 13 south, and then you have Cub Foods, which would be morE
14 4_30 in the day. 14 io the west about two blocks_ It's not on the map but
15 Q. Whe� you talk about all of Yhese concepts to 15 ifs very close and iYs within running distance. When
16 secure a remises a
p nd make it safer for tenants what is
36 there was a street robbery, the direction of travel was
17 one of the sources of all of this property strategy? 17 often �orth from these areas. This is res+dential
I 18 A_ !Ys the Minnesota Crime Free Muitihousing. 18 property here, never had them come south. They atways
19 Q. What fype of document is that? 19 ran north and disappea�ed into here and i�to here
20 A. IYs acivatly, they have a website, but it 20 {indicating).
21 provides landbrds with the best, most recognized 29 Q. Now once they enter #he buildings, how are ihey
22 techniques in the country for having safe environments 22 abie to avoid apprehension?
23 for tenants. 23 A. Either Lfiey k�ow somebody in the building thaYs
24 Q. How was Asgher Jaweed advised of this protocol 24 allowi�g them into the apartment, they have no front door
25 and what promises did he make to abate the code 25 security, they have no fencing around the property, they
Page 62 Page 64
1 violations and bring down the high rates of premises 1 can ru� in anywhere and come out a�y one if they ran
2 crime? 2 ln this door here, they could come out of any one of
3 A. Two most important, notable conversations I had 3 these doors here and then go into this buildi�g
4 was tfiat there would be hiring of security and the re ai 4 indicatin and c
P ome out so b the tim
9) y e my ofFicer,
5 of the locked doors at the property and ihe im roved 5 even with
a te�-sec�n� resp�nse, would get there in Yhe
6 lighting. 6 area, the suspect could have fled out one of these
7 Q. When did Mr. Asgher Jaweed promise to have 7 directions or been in any one of these apartments.
8 security at the premises? 8 Q. In the cases where these street robberies
9 A. Beginning of March. 9 occurred and the perpetrators fled into the comptex and
10 Q. And thafs March 2007? 10 entered the Center Pointe buildings, how successful were
11 A. That is March 2007. 11 the police in making apprehensions?
�2 Q. When, to the best oF your knowledge, was 12 A. Very limited, even with K9 response in many
13 security first hired and operating at Center PaMe in 13 cases.
14 20fl7? 14 Q. By tMe late sp�ing of 2007, did you, as the
15 A. It was nowhere near that time. It was many 15 complainant, sign several criminal complai�ts by which
16 months aRer that. 16 Asgher Ali, aiso known as Asgher Jaweed, and Hyder Jaweed
97 Q. In the intervening months, what became of the 17 were charged with misdemeanor crimes of allowing property
18 high leve) of premises crime? 18 under their control fo become a public nuisance and
19 A. The
robberies in the area, both from Center 1
9 maintenance of public nwsance?
20 Pointe Apartmsnt complexes and that area around it, h< �0 A. Yes, l did.
21 a� increase in robberies, street robberies and violen
t 21 Q. Are those complaints repfoduced, those two
22 crimes to the oi
p nt that the poiice department dedicate i22 complaints against those two parties that you signed,
23 two officers full-time to ihat area, as well as requested 23 reproduced at Tab 5?
24 assistance from the Hennepin County Sheriffs Office tc 24 A. (Examaning document.) Yes.
25 have two deputies to patrol that area with 960 hours pei 25 Q. You've seen these two now?
16 (Pages 61 to b4)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 1011/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 65 Page 67
1 A. Yes. 1 MR. LEFEVERE_ Excuse me, did 1 miss 3 and
2 Q. Ail right. And those are tMe two complaints you 2 4 or are we coming back to that?
3 signed before a judge of the distnci court? 3 MR. CLELLAND: ThaYs coming through
4 A. That is correct. 4 another witness_
Q. Wfiy was it [hai fhe complaint against Asgher Ali 5 MAYOR WILLSON: That was going to be my
6 was detayed? 6 question as we�i. think 3 and 4 get skipped and 5,
7 A_ Both compiaints were signed by the jadge fhe 7 this was actually 5.
8 same day, both complaints were signed by me in front of 8 BY MR. CLEILAND:
9 the judge and furned inio the court, Division 2 Court. 9 Q. Lieutenani 8enner, you made a personal
10 Somehow Oivision 2 Court losi one of ihe compiaints, that 10 inspection of the Center Pointe Apartment compiex on the
11 would be Asgher's compiaint. They believe that they 11 27th of August. 2007, specifically to inspect Yhe
12 could have been attached together, because the complai�ts 12 exterior doors, is that correct?
93 were almost identical in context with the exception of 13 A. Actually it was August 9, 2007, and that was a#
14 fhe name. Whatever the case was, they did not know that 14 11 a.m.
15 it had been lost. i 5 Q. For whaf purpose did you make a specific
Q ka Y 1fi inspection oi the doors, the exterior doors of ihe
17 MR_ CLELIAND: Offer those two complaints 17 complex?
18 at Tab 5. 18 A. I had received a letter on that same day, half
3 9 MR. BAER: Mr. Mayor, ihe property owner 19 hour earlier before my trip, and was excited to hear
20 objects to these complaints on the grounds tfiat they are 20 that the property, according to the attorney that had
21 just that, they are criminal complaints. And if there is 21 sent the letter, had been repaired and the doors were
22 no other procedural due process right that this Council 22 locked.
23 wili support, 1 hope thai it would at least support the 23 Q. Which Jaweed attorney sent you that letter?
24 right to be presumed innocent until proven guilty. 24 A_ believe it was ihe Attomey Hertz?
25 ANegatior�s in a criminal complaint don't establish 25 Q. Kenneth Hertz?
Page 66 Page 68
1 anything except for the poiice made an allegation. This 1 A. Kenneth Hettz, that sounds correct.
2 is whoily improper and should not be considered by the 2 Q. The potice department actually had some meetings
3 Council. These crimina! compiain#s will have their day 3 with Kenneth Hertz over the summer on behalf of his
4 in court, and a judge and jury wiH make a determination 4 client, the Jaweeds, is that correct?
5 as to whether they were proper in the first place, mucfi 5 A. 7hat is correct.
6 less whether the aliegations can be proven. 1t is just 6 Q. Now what information did Mr. Hertz, as attomey
7 simply improper to use criminal complaints as evidence of 7 for Yhe Jaweeds, specificalty convey in this letter
8 anything, other than the fact that a complaint was filed, 8 regarding the exterior doors?
9 a�d i ask you to reject thaY offer by Mr. Cielland. 9 A. That they were repaired.
10 MR. CLELLAND: And the presumption of 10 Q. AH right.
13 innocence doesn't prevent you from accepti�g this in 1 i A. And functional.
12 evide�ce and giving ii any weight that you, as a 92 Q. What did you then do, when did you do it, and
13 deliberative body, shoutd give it, but it is evidence 13 describe both the inspection you made of the exterior
14 that there was probable cause established to be�ieve 14 doors and what you found?
15 Yhat. it doesn't mean they're guilty_ Their guilty will 15 A. Okay. 1 immediately went down there because
1fi be resolved by a jury verdict at some point, but that 16 there fiad been alle ations that th
g e door locks would
b
i 7 doesn t prevent you from accepting this and using this 17 broken immediately after being repaired. i was
i8 evidence and giving it the weight you think is due. 18 optimistic and hoping that the door locks were repairet
1 9 COUNCIL MEMBER O'CONN012: Mr. Mayor? 19 When i goi there, the first building 1 went to is the
z� MAYOR WILLSON: Council Member O'Connor. 20 2802 building, and 1 started on the east side. This is
2'1 COUNCIL MEMBER O'CONNOR: f think we should 21 the first door 1 walked into, and the lock mechanism on
22 dele#e this as part of the evidence. 22 that door was not only broken, it wasn't there. I�
23 MAYOR WILLSON: Any other comment? hearing 23 looki�g at the frame of tfiis, it had dust, it had debris
24 none, seeing none, we'll accept it and move on. 24 and build-up on it. It teNs me this had not been
25 MR. C�ELLAND: Thank you_ 25 repaired for quite some time, or they have a process of
17 (Pages 65 to 68j
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 69 Page 7i
3 aging the door lock. And as 1 continued through the 1 to recite some of the most serious crimes to have
2 property, l#ound that this entire east side ofi the 2 occurred either on the Center Pointe Apartment compiex
r
3 o ert i
could
P P etinto
Y g any buildin with no ke 1
9 Y 3 or, as he wdl descrabe it, havmg a connection with
4 did noY have a fire knock box key, did not have a key 4 Center Pointe, that is, a sa�ctuary #or someone who
5 to any of the doors, but was able to access every 5 escaped, a sanctuary for someone to ptan or perpetrate
6 buiiding without �estriction. 6 the crime.
7 Q. Did you put your findings together in a 7 8Y MR. CLE�tAND:
8 memorandum which is set forth at Tab 8? 8 Q. if you'd proceed, piease?
9 A. That is correct. g MR. BAER: Perhaps, Mr. Mayor, we could
90 Q. !s khis a true and accurate account of the 10 have tt�at as iwo questions? i would fike to know, and I
19 condition of the doors and the door iocks as you #ound 11 think the Council would iike to know, whaYs happening
12 them that morning after receiving the assurance of 12 with the Center Poinie te�ants, if thaYs pa�t of the
13 Jaweeds' attomey, Kenneth Hertz, that the buildings and 13 question, whaYs happening on the Center Pointe property,
14 the doors had alt been secured?
14 it thaYs part of Yhe question, and what s happening
15 A. In my nine-minute i�spection the reason I 15 elsewhere if someone fleeing onto ihe property. 1 think
16 timed it for nine minutes was 1 wanted to show how easy 16 if we get it al1 garb�ed together iYs not going to be
17 it would be for a maintenance person to simply go througM 7 helpful for any of us.
18 and puli pennies or fix the door locks relativeiy easify. 18 MR. CLELLAND: My suggestion is, first of
'!9 I noted this in my notebook and put it into the memo, 19 ail, ihat can be a matter of crass-examination_ We're
20 which you have in f�ont of you, and it is accurate. 20 entiUed to elicit this testimony. Mr. Baer will have
21 MR. CLELLAND: Ofier the repoR at Tab 8. 21 the right to ask those questions by cross-examination.
22 MAYOR WILLSON: Thank you. 22 This is directty tied to the Notice of Abatement, which
23 BY MR. CLELLAND_ 23 is a# Tab 6, and it specifically recites a number of very
24 Q. Now what are 24 serious crimes that have a connection with Center Pointe,
25 MR. LEFEVERE: i'm sorry? 25
includin homi i
g c de, so the question is relevant. I
Page 70 Page 72
1 MAYOR WILLSON: Tab 8. 1 submit you should hear it and Mr. Baer can engage in any
2 MR. LEFEVERE: That was offered. 2 cross-examination on the subject.
3 MR. BAER: No objection, Mr. Mayor. 3 MAYOR W1tLSON: Mr_ Benner, if you would
4 MR. LEFEVERE: Is #hat received then? 4 please7
5 Tab 8 was received? 5 BY MR. CLELIAND:
6 MAYOR WILLSON: 1 was assuming so, but i 6 Q. Go ahead.
7 had not calied for any objecTions. 7 A. Okay. Of the 1,500-plus calls that 1 had to
8 MR. LEFEVERE: i'm sorry, sometimes these 8 choose from in the last two years ihat were connected w
9 things get let by. 9 this property, I'm going to siart with the most serious,
10 MAYOR WlLLSON: Very good, I'll try to 10 and thaPs homicide. On 10-5 of '04 October Sfh
at
11 remember to do that after each tab. 11 3:10 in moming, Dennis Winfieid (ph) was murdered. F�MP
12 8Y MR_ CLELLAND: 12 was murdered by Andre Hall, who has been successful y
93 Q. Lieutenant Benner, what are some of the most 13 convicted of that crime. What fiappened, 1'll make this
'14 serious crimes to have occurred most recently in the city 14 very quick, Andre Hali was staying with his girlfriend
15 connected with and as a part of the Center Pointe 15 and his girlfriend's sister at the Ce�te� Pointe
16 Apartment complex? 16 Apartment complex. After figfiting with his girlfriend
17 MR. SAER: I object to the form of the '17 and his gi�lfriend's sister, he drew his fi�ea�m, went
1$ question. I hava no idea what that means, "connected 18 outside, conflicted with more people on the property,
19 with and" 19 continued on his a�ger across the street to the Citgo g: s
20 MR. CLELiAND: i'm sure the a�swer will 20 station where he shot a�d killed Dennis Winfield,
21 explain it. 21 shooting him 1 i times.
22 MR. SAER: Wel1, 1 wauld like io know what 22 Q. Now other serious crimes have involved Center
23 the question is. 23 Pointe as sanctuaries for crime, is that correct?
24 MAYOR WILLSON: Restate the question_ 24 A. That is correct.
25 MR_ CLEILAND: would like Officer Benner 25 Q. Would you describe a shootout, an actual gun
18 (Pages 69 to 72)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1J2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 73 Page 75
1 battle at Center Pointe that occurred in 2D067 questions of Lieutenant 8enner.
2 A. On June 13th 2006 at 3:47 p.m., afternoon, two 2 MAYOR WILLSON: Mr. LeFevere, 1 believe
3 groups of adult males begaa shooting each other. .45 3 that openS it up fof CroSS?
4 caliber handgun ammunition was found tfiroughout the south 4 MR. LEFEVERE: Yes. At some poini you may
5 parY of the property, right here with the highlighted 5 wanf to Yake a break.
6 {indicating), and the running gun battle started here, 6 MAYOR WILLSON_ Now there'S a good idea.
7 wen{ to the sireet righi here. One of ihe groups got in 7 MR. LEFEVERE: Maybe now is a convenient
8 the car a�d f1ed. The other group, who had a pit bull time? ThaYs one of your prerogat+ves. I just thought
9 with them, fied to the north, got in their car and fled. g i'd point that out
1fl As we continaed our investigations, we fou�d that at 10 MAYOR WILLSON: I will poA #he CounCil_
11 least four to five of the individuals involved in this 1 3 Do you want to take a break now or proceed?
12 shooting that were raising a pit buH at 2918 Northway 12 COUNCIL MEM$ER RYAN_ Cet'S take a
13 Drive, Apartment f03, wMich was a vacant unit, the 13 five break.
14 te�ants had been evicted and they were squatting Yhere, 14 MAYOR WILLSON: We'll take a five
15 raising two pit bulls. Officers found dog feces, animal 15 break.
16 food and conditions consistent with peopte squatYing a�d �6 {Bfeak taken ffom 7:47 to 7:56 p.m.)
17 raising twa pit bulls. We have not arrested a�ybody in 17 MAYOR WILLSON: Come back to ord8r.
�8 that case we have had no witnesses come forward to 18 Mr. LeFevere, if I understand correctly, this would be
19 +dentify who they are. 1 g Mr. Baer's time to cross wiih Lieutenant 8enner?
20 Q. Describe an incident at Yhe premises where a man 20 MR. LEFEVERE: Yes.
21 was attacked in February 2007_ 2� MAYOR WILLSON_ tieutenan# Benner, if you
22 A_ On February 3rd, 2007, at 1:30 in the moming, 22 wif� join us again, please? Mr. Baer?
23 a.m., a 50-year-old maie was attacked by five to six 23 MR. BAE#2: Thank you, Mr. Mayor.
24 males in the courtyard of 2900 Northway. The victim was 24 Mf2. �EFEVERE: Excuse me MByot'_
25 tackled, his pockets were ri#led through, and the 25 (Discussio� held ofF the record.)
Page 74 Page 76
1 suspects then fled into 2932 Northway Drive. Officers 1 CROSS-EXAMINATION
2 were across the street. Tfie suspects fled inio that 2 BY MR. BAER:
3 building and never were fou�d because of the maze. 3 Q. Lieutenant Benner, you're welcome to sit down.
4 Q. Describe a robbery inside the Center Pointe 4 A. Thank you.
5 complex that occurred in Ju�e 2007. 5 Q. What notes do you have in your hand, si�?
6 A_ June 96th, 2007. A 20-year-old male was robbed 6 A. 1 made notes of major cases that I just recited
7 in the hallway at 2932 Northway Drive on the third floor. 7 to, as well as the letter with regards to door lock
8 The suspect entered the building, he's not believed to 8 inspections.
9 live there, threatened the victim with a knife, took his 9 Q. Okay. You said Yhat you've been an officer here
10 wapet and his E8D card. He demanded his PIN number f� �r10 in Brooklyn Center for 18 years?
11 the EBD card and told him that if he called police he 13 A. That is correct.
12 would have gang members come back a�d kill him. That 12 Q. Did I hear you correctly tfiat there was some
i 3 suspect has not been arrested. 13 period ir� which the police department was given
14 Q. Describe an aitack on a biker who was dragged 14 authorization to Conduct building code inspec#ions?
15 into the Center Pointe Apartment complex in September 15 A. 7hat is correct.
16 2006_ 16 Q. When was that?
17 A. Okay. On September 1st, 2006, at 6:15 p.m. in 17 A. It was be#ore my time as administrative
18 ihe afternoon, a bicyclist was riding in the area of the 18 sergeant, so about eighY years ago, seven, eight years
19 2940 building, at which time three to four males 19 ago.
20 continced him to go into the building, into the 2p Q. yas it continued to today?
21 lower-level iaundry room. At that point he was met by 10 21 A. It has noY.
22 to 1 i maies total, who assaulted him as well as poioted a 22 Q. When did it end?
23 gun to his head, took his wa�let and shoes. O�e suspect 23 A. May of 2007.
24 fias been arrested in that case. 24 Q. And during that time, did you conduct any
25 MR_ CL.ELLAND: Thank you, I have no further 25 inspections at Center Pointe?
19 (Pages 73 to 76)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 77 Page 79
1 A. At Center Pointe? i Q: And thaYs what ihe buildrng code inspectors are
2 Q_ Yes, sir. 2 supposed to issue, right?
3 A. What was the time frame Yhat you're asking? 3 A. They can issue compliance orders and they can
4 Because, yes, have in the past. In the last year, no, 4 issue citations.
5 1 have not. 5 Q. Well, sir, was a compiiance order issued?
6 Q. We�l, at any time since January of 2007, when 6 A. Nof Yo my knowledge in regards to the repeated
7 the new iicense was issued, did you conduct any 7 violations.
inspections at Center Pointe? 8 Q. And was this videotape shown fo the owners?
9 A. I have visited the property, 1 have observed 9 A. It was not.
10 numerous violations. have noY written conesponder :gJ Q. lnstead it was provided to Mr. Clelland, nght?
1 i outside of the memo that you just discussed to the 11 A. That is correct.
12 owners. 1 have a staff that actually fiUs out the 92 Q. And ihe reason there was no compliance order and
13 complainYs and citations for violations that are noted_ 13 the reason this videotape wasn't shown was because the
14 Q. For violations of the building code? 14 police departmeni weren't interested in those inspections
15 A_ For parking violations, garbage, excessive 15 in solving the problem, they were i�terested in helping
16 garbage and exterior violations. 1fi Mr. Clelland buitd a case, correct?
17 Q_ And have any of those been issued by the police 17 A. That is incorrect.
18 departmenY to Center Pointe since Ja�uary of 2007? 18 Q. After you went out on August 9th and inspected
19 A. Yes, they have. 19 these doors that we saw in Tab 8, you wrote a memorandum
20 Q. What? 20 to Mr_ Clella�d, correct?
21 A. 1 don't have a list in front of ine. 21 A. 7hat is correct
22 Q. When this videotape we saw was made, you said 22 Q_ You didn't write it on August 8th or
23 that Officer Brian Peters was there manning the 23 August 9th, rather you wrote it on August 27th?
24 videotape, is that �ight? 24 A. That is correct.
25 A. That is CorrecY. 25 Q. In the intervening 18 days, did you talk to the
Page 78 Page 80
1 Q. And there were two other potice o�cers with 1 owners about what you had found?
2 him? 2 A. There was a meeting with Ke� Hertz and 1
3 A. Three other police officers. 3 believe one of the owners was to be at that meeting but
4 Q. Three others. You had four police o�cers out 4 was not a part of that meeting a�d O�cer Olson to
5 there making tfiis inspectio�? 5 discuss concems at that properiy. TMese are the same
6 A. That is co�rect. 6 concems that have been repeated throughout the year 200"
7 Q. And did someo�e at the end of that inspection 7 and 2006.
S write up a compliance order and provide it to the owners? 8 Q. Did you provide Mr. Hertz with a copy of the
9 A. For Yhe existing vioiations ihat have already 9 memo you wrote to Mr. Clelland?
90 baen given fo the owners, are you asking were they giv� :t10 A. I did not provide a copy of that memo to
11 another notice of this? 11 Mr. Hertz.
12 Q. My question was pretty clear, sir. After you 92 Q. Did you provide Mr. Flertz with anything in
13 made those inspections, and you made threa of them, �3 writing at this meeting you told us about?
14 right? One in April, one in May, one in June. 14 A. 1 did not provide that to Mr. Hertz or yourseff.
15 A. That is correct. 15 Q. Now is it true, sir, that there was a special
16 Q. After any one of those inspecYions, did someone 16 police detail earlier #his spring involving Center
17 from the police department write up a compGance order 17 Pointe?
18 and advise the owners o# the problems that you found? 18 A. That is correct
19 A. In the criminal complaint that was fiiled on i9 Q. And that was a detail that lasted for some 60
20 May 17th, 2007 against both of them, there is a Iist of 20 days, is that correct?
21 these violations. 21 A. That is incorrect, lt lasted from May 7tfi to,
22 Q. You know what a compliance order is, sir? 22 Pm sorry, March 7th to June 22nd.
23 A_ IYs a citation of complaint is what we issued. 23 Q. So more than 60 days7
24 Q. Do you know whai a compliance order is? 24 A. That +s co�rect.
25 A. Yes, do I. 25 Q. And during that pe�iod, there were four officers
20 {Pages 77 to 80)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
1'ublic Hearing lU/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL C�TY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 81 Page 83
1 assigned to the deiail, righk? 1 A. 1 did not personaUy look at the records_
2 A. Actuafiy there were more ofificers assigned to 2 Q. Did anyone ever telt you who ihe owners are?
3 tMe detail_ In the videotape you have four officers that 3 A. Yes_
4 were there at one time. We rotated officers through so 4 Q. Who is ihe owner?
5 we have continuing detaii th�oughout the week. 5 A. The owner of the property as a person or as a
6 Q. During that period, did you arrest any of the fi limited liabiliry partnership?
7 tenants of Center Pointe? 7 Q. Who owns the property?
8 A. Are you asking if 1 arrested or the detail? 8 A_ 1 would assume it would be the Srooklyn Center
9 Q. WeU, IeYs start with you. 9 teased Housing Authority, and ihe owners of that compam
i0 A. I arrested nobody. 10 would be either pominium Properties, as 1 was led to
11 Q. Did the detait arrest any of the tenants? 11 believe, or Jaweeds.
2 A. Yes, they have. i2 Q. How do you know that?
13 Q. Which tenants were arrested? i3 A. The staff at building inspections, the staf# at
14 A. I believe the testimony that will follow will be 14 city clerk and our city prosecuting attorney have
15 all the information contained by Officer Olson, who is 15 p�ovided me that information.
16 providfng the names of the people arrested at the 16 Q. They've told you that fhe Jaweeds own Brooklyn
17 property to the ma»agement staff on duty at the time. 17 Center Leased Housing Associates?
18 Q. My question was which tenants were arrested? 18 A. Yes, that is correct
19 A. ln your pamphlet you will have the names of 19 Q_ Do you know whethef thaYs true or not?
20 those people. 1 do not have them. 20 A. 1 trust the information 1 received under them to
21 Q. You can't identify them? 21 be reiiable and accurate.
22 A. 1 did not memorize that list of names. 22 Q. Do you know whether it's true or not?
23 Q. Were there people wha were not tenants of Center 23 A. I do not, 1 have not Iooked it up myself, no.
24 Poinie arrested as part o# the detail? 24 Q. And these criminal complaints that you swore out
25 A. Yes, there were. 25 against the Jaweeds, in #hose comptaints you allege that
Page 82 Page 84
1 Q. Were there crimes commiYted on the Center Pointe 1 they are the owners, correct?
2 property? 2 A. That is correct.
3 A. Yes, there were. 3 Q. And you made that allegation witfiout knowing
4 Q. Were there crimes committed by the owners of the 4 whether it was true or false?
5 Center Pointe property? 5 A. t believe the information i received from the
6 A. Are you referring to the criminal complaint of 6 people who told me they were the owners is reliable, as
7 May 17th of 2007? 7 information 1 received from them in the pasf had been
8 Q. I was no#, sir. 8 reliable and credible.
9 A. Okay, because that is a crime_ 1 just want to 9 Q. Let's talk a little bit more about those
10 make sure. rhat's the oniy one I'm aware of that they 10 complainks. You've sworn out complaints before, right?
11 were involved. 11 A. Yes, I have.
12 Q. So your criminal complaints are the only ones �2 Q. Do it on a regular basis?
'13 you're aware of tMat my clients committed? 13 A. i do not_
14 A. That is correct. 14 Q. Why did you do these?
15 Q. Now when you refer to the owners of the Center 15 A. These were criminal compiaints that came up fi�om
16 Pointe property, who are you referring to? 16 building inspections, code inspections thaY we've had in
17 A. Tfie people that have represented #hemselves in 17 our department, and that was the only scope tha# 1've ha�
18 the two meetings that I've held with, who I believe to be 18 outside of managing the Violent Offende�s Task Force ar d
19 the owners o# Center Pointe Apartments, that was Asgh �f 9 other crimes. I have staff thaY actually file their own
2� '4��- 20 complaints.
21 Q. ThaYs the only person that you know fo be an 21 Q. Are you teiling us that the complaints against
22 owner of Cenier Pante Apartments? 22 the Jaweeds are the only ones that you Qersonally have
23 A. 1 also was informed tiyder Jaweed was the owne� 23 sworn out in the last year?
24 Q. Did you ever look at the City's records to 24 A. That is correc#.
25 determine who the owners are? 25 Q. They got special attention, right?
21 (Pages 81 to 84)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 85 Page 87
1 A_ The complaint is accurate. 1 A, Are they responsibie for their guests?
2 Q_ Except you got the owner wrong, right? 2
Q. You need to answer my questions this evening,
3 A. 1 got the owner wrong? 3 s+r. Are you saying that tfie people who are tenants at
4 Q. Yes, sir. 4 Center Pointe shouldn't be allowed to have guesis?
5 A. think thaYs an opinion. 5 A. And my answer is the tenants should be
6 Q. Weli, you know, sir, That the ow�er is Brooklyn 6 responsible for their guests.
7 Center Leased Housing Associates, don't you? 7 Q. If I had a guest to my home who IeR my home and
8 A. i know the same information that that is the 8 wen{ and killed someone, 1 should be responsible for
9 owner as i do thaY Asgher and Nyder Jaweed are the 9 them7
10 owners. 10 A. Are they aliowed to store the frearm at your
11 Q. Because that also is something that you've just 1 i piace?
12 been told by others, nothing that you know from your own 12 Q. Is it +Ileqal for them to store a fire�rm at my
13 self? 13 place?
14 A. i'm confused on the questio�. 14 A_ Yss, a 17-year-old person that has a fefony
15 Q. 1'm sorry, sir? 15 conviction is not allowed to carry a firearm.
16 A. 1 don't understand your question. 16 Q. Why didn'i the police do something about that
17 Q. LeYs talk about these crimes Yhai you 17 17-year-o1d that was out there carrying a firearm?
18 reiterated for the Counci!_ Did 1 hear you correctly 18 A. We did arrest him and he has been convictecl.
19 that the homicide that you started with was in October of 19 Q. After he killed someone, right?
20 2004?
20 A- 7hat is correct_
21 A. That is correct. 21 Q. The police couldn't keep track of him unti�
22 Q. Were the Jaweeds even connected with this 22 after he kiNed someone, isn'# tfiat true?
23 property in October of 2004? 23 A. Yeah, that is true. We couldn't stop him from
24 A. ls Yhat a question you can answer? Because I 24 killing someone.
25 don't k�ow Yhe answer. 25 Q. But somehow Brooklyn Center leased Housing
Q. And the homicide that you talked about took Page 86 Page 88
1 Associates was supposed to monitor who the guests were of
2 place when someo�e went across the street and shot 2 the tenants and make sure fhat that person wasn't a felon
3 someone at a gas stakion, correct? 3 in possession of a firearm, is that your testimony?
4 A. That is cor�ect. 4 A. One of many cases_ By itself it doesn't have
5 Q. And that person that did the shooting was a 5 the same wei ht as if it ha
6 tenani of CenYer Pointe? 9 PPe�ed seve�al times. WhaY if
6 all the guests had friends that came over and killed
7 A. Was a guest of Center Pointe. 7 people? That's how 1 view this, is that you're
8 Q. Was the persor� that did the shooting someone 8 responsible for having some accountafiility of your
9 that ihe Brooklyn Center Police Department had arrested 9 tena�ts, and if there's no accountability of your
10 previously? 10 tenants, then you cannot prevent the crime thaf we're
11 A. Not to my knowledge_
11 seei�g now.
12 Q. Well, as you sit here today, is there any reason 12 Q. You said there was a bicyclist who was invited
13 at al! why you think that Brooklyn Center Leased Housing 13 into the laundry room and robbed and that suspect was
'14 Associates should have been able
to r
edict that th�
P is 14
arr
ested, right.
15 guest would go across the street and shoot someone?
15 A. That is correct_
16 A. in this particular case, this person was able to 16 Q. Was that suspect a tenant at Center Pointe?
17 walk i�to the 6uilding without any restriction, without a 17 A. 7hat suspect was a guest of a tenant at Center
18 key, walk ouf of the building without any restrictio�s 18 Pointe.
19 whatsoever and go across the street and take somebody' 19 Q. Was that suspect convicted?
20 life. The property is a contributing factor. 20 A. 1 do not know if he has been convicted yet.
29 Q. Lieutenant Benner, you say he was a guest, 21 Q. You do believe an arrest is different than a
22 right? 22 conviction, right?
23 A. That is correct. 23 A. i do_
24 Q. Are you saying that the people who are tenants 24 Q. From time to Yime, the police even arrest the
25 at Center Pointe shouldn't be aUowed to have guests? 25 wron
g person, right?
22 (Pages 85 to 88j
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc_
612-339-OS45
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 89 Page 91
1 A. Police departme�ts throughout the nation may lo� MAYOR WILLSON: What relevancy does this
2 that. 2 have with Center Pointe, piease?
3 Q. On June 16th of 2007, you said there was a 3 MR. BAER: Well, the relevancy, Mr. Mayor,
4 robbery on the third floor of the building? 4 is simply this. The police, and you as the Council, are
5 A. That is COfreCt. 5 being asked to hold my client responsibie for crime that
6 Q. Do you have a suspect for that? 6 occurs on ihe Center Pointe property.
7 A. Thare is a suspec# description. 7 MAYOR WILISON: Granted.
Q. BuT you've nevef be8� able to identify the 8 MR_ $AER: WMereas the police are�'t abie
9 p2�SOn? 9 to control crime across the street at the bus stop. It
10 A. That is correct. �o seems to me, sir, that it is absurd to take the position
1 Q- So you don t know whether that person fs a 11 that people who are not police o(ficers, people who are
12 tQitBnt O� �lOt? 12 in the business of running an apartment complex, ought to
'I 3 A. TMat is correct 3 be abie to do a better job of controBing crime in tfieir
4 Q. You don't know whethef they were a guest or not 14 apartment complex than ihe City can in a public bus stop.
15 8 guest? 15 ThaYs the relevance.
16 A. How Yhey got in the unsecured door, do not �6 MAYOR W1��SON: Thank you.
9 7 know. BY MR. BAER:
18 Q_ You don't know how they got into the building? i8 Q. i would like to go back to this meeting it�at you
19 A. That is correct. 19 testified about in February of'07.
20 Q. And on that date you don't know whether Yhe door Zo A. �kay_
29 was secured or not? 21 Q. Teli us again who was at fhis meeting?
22 A- 1'!n going to guess it probably wasn't SeCUred. 22 A. tt was Sergeant Frank Roth, myself, the city
23 Q. You're going ta guess. okay. There's a bus 23 manager Curt Boganey, Larry Martin irom Community
24 stop across the street from Center Pointe IS th2f2 TIOt? 24 Deveiopment, Brad Hoffman from Community Developmeot, and
25 A. Metro Transit, yes. 25 Asgher Aii.
Page 90 Page 92
1 Q. And the police department knows that that bus 1 Q. Wfio sorry?
2 stop is a source of a lot of crime, right? 2 A. 1'm sorry, that was ii.
3 A. It is one of the top five crime spots in our 3 Q. Who asked for the meeting?
4 city. 4 A. The city manager.
Q. To your knowledge, has the City petitioned the 5 Q. And did the city manager ask Mr. Asgher Ali to
6 Metropotitan Council to get rid of the bus stop? 6 attend?
7 A. At that location, or at SSth and Xences where it 7 A. 1 do not know how he was invited. I did not
8 formerly was, or the Brookdate bus stop before that? 8 invite him.
9 Q. The location where it is now, sir. 9 Q. Was anyone else connected to Center Pointe asked
10 A. No, it has not petitioned that iY be removed. 10 to attend?
Q. WeII, the City and the city police know that 11 A. i did not invite anybody. 1 was invited.
i 2 that bus stop is a center for crime, right? 12 Q. And i thi�k that Mc Cleiland had you testify
13 A. That address has a high call for service. 13 about two or three diiferent poinis #hat were raised with
14 Q. And despike that fact, that knowledge, the City 14 Mr. Ali at the meeting in February, right?
15 fiasn't been able #o get it under control, correct? 15 A. That is correct.
16 A. !n combination with the crime that it had shared 16 Q. Why don't you reiterate those points for us?
17 with Center Pointe, tfiat is co�rect. 17 A. What questions did you want me to reiterate?
18 Q. You haven't been able to get the bus stop under 18 Q. Well, for example, you said that you tried to
19 control. 1'm talking to you about the bus stop now, sir. 19 stress upon Mr. Ali that Center PoinYe should follow the
20 A. It's oMy been in place fo� two years. Center 20 Min�esofa Crime Free Multihousi�g?
21 Pointe has been there more than that. 18 years in my 21 A. That is cor�ect.
22 experience. 22 Q. !s that a task force repo�t?
23 MAYOR WILLSON: Mc Baer, what relevancy 23 A. Actually 1 believe you claim that you're a
24 does this have with Center POinte? 24 member, Center Pointe ciaims iYs a member of. Minneso ia
25 MR. BAER: Pardon me? 25 Crime Free Multihousing is an organization that shares
23 (Pages 89 to 92)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1I2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 93 Page 95
3 data between apartment comptexes or multifamily units on 1 A. Okay.
2 how to provide the safest environment for its tenants_
2 Q. There is no requirement in the statute of the
3 Q- And thai was something that you suggested to 3 ordinance requiring a camera anywhere on this property,
4 Mr. Ali that Center Pointe shouid adopt, right? 4 is there?
5 A. Some of ihe recommendations from it, yes. S A. No.
6 Q. And whicfi recommendatfons i� particular? 6 Q. So whlle you could make recommendations, you
7 A. Well, first thiog, it needs environmental 7 didn't have any abitity io require any of those things of
8 design, which is fencing. lt was promised in September 8 the owners of Center Poinie, isn't That nghf?
9 2005 ihat they were going to build fencing around the
9 A. Tfiat is correct.
�0 property to assist in directing the ilow of traffic as it
10 Q. And as to the reconfiguration of the parking
11 wanders around the property. Control of access 11 lot, isn't it true that Mr_ Asgher Aii asked, on a number
12 throughout ihe properly is i�strumenYal, prohibiting 12 of occasions, for the City's cooperation in decidino
13 people that are not welcome at the property or just 13 which of the entryways could be Gosed off and which
14 squatting at the property_ Tfiafs an environmental 14 could not?
15 design, one of many. 15 A. Are you aski�g me if Yhey asked the police
16 Another environmental design that was 18 departtnent or fire department? Because I know he daime i
17 recommended and discussed in Sepiember 2005 wifh Asghe� 17 he had asked the fire department, and I was not a party
18 Ali was they were going to reconfigure the parking lots 18 to that coqversation.
99 so they didn't have several points of e�try, rather just 1 g Q_ Did you go and check with the fire department
20 one point of entry_ A.gain you controi access to Yhe 20 and see2
21 property. 7hey were going to instaU a camera at that
21 A. 1 said there were no problems at aN.
22 ooe point of access, and by installing the camera they 22 Q. Did you go and check with the fire department
23 are abie to idenYify who is coming and going. In the 23 and see if wfia# Mr. AIi told you was true?
24 event there is a problem Lhey can idenii it, or it
fY 24 A. I did noi.
25 serves even a better deterrent by felling people we're 25 Q. And if ihe fire departmenT wouldnY aliow for
Page 94 Page 96
1 filming you, behave. ThaYs one. The second one 1 closing fhese entrances and exits into the ro e then
2 Q. Let me interrupt you there, sir. P m'
2 there was nothing tfiat the property owner could do about
3 A. Okay. 3 it, right?
4 Q. We'll come back to the sacond one_ 4 A. 1'm not aware that they said they could not, if
5 A. Sure. 5 that's your question_
s Q. Is fencing a requirement in the ordinances? 6 Q. You're not aware one way or the other, right?
7 A. No, it's a recommendation under Minnesota Crim 7 A. !Ys done now. They put Jersey barriers up at
8 Free Multihousing. 8 the time, so they did block it off. So Pm assuming it
9 Q. So the fact tfiat no fencing is there does not 9 was tasked by the fire chief because it was done.
i 0 violate any ardinance or any state faw, right? 1 p Q. The faci of the matter is they blocked off two
11 A. No, not that 1'm aware of. 11 of the entrances, correct?
12 Q. !t doesn't vioiate any condition of Yhe Iicense, 12 A. Three of the entra�ces.
i3 right? 13 Q. How many entrances in and out of that property
14 A. Not thaY !'m aware of. 14 are there? You can put the map back up if you'd like_
15 Q. likewise, this notion of reconfiguring the 15 A. 1'm counting them r9ght now, and t see four;
96 Qarking lot, that's not required by any state iaw 16 five.
17 ordinance? 17 Q. And two of them were blocked or you think it was
18 A. Thai is co�rect. 18 three?
19 Q. And there was no condition on the lice�se 19 A. 1 thought fhey blocked off a third one_ They
20 requiring reconfiguration of the parking lot? 20 blocked off the northeast corner one, which is right uf
21 A. Exactly. You're asking what fhe recomme�datio� a21 here, they biocked off the two lower ones right down
22 are from the Minnesota Crime Free Multifamily Housing 22 here. 1 believe this one is open, this one is open, this
23 and that's what i-- 23 one is open, this one is open, and thai one is open
24 Q_ Now 1'm asking you some different questions, 24 (indicating).
25 sir. Bear with me. 25 Q. So Yhere are five that are stiil open?
24 (Pages 93 to 96)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/i/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 97 Page 99
i A. Yes_ 1 Q. Jammed open with paper stuck in them, correct?
2 Q. And your recommendation was close them all 2 A. 7hat is correcf.
3 except for one and put a camera there, right? 3 Q. Sametimes the Iock was just smashed off,
4 A. Actualiy, no, that was his suggestion. 4 correct?
5 Q_ Was�'t tha# your recommendation? S A. That is correct
6 A. 1 supported it. 6 Q. Now you don't think Yhat the Jaweeds were
7 Q. Did you go to the fire department and say, look, 7 running around jammi�g coi�s and paper into those locks,
8 I've had a discussion with Mr. Ali and he and 1 think it 8 do you?
9 wouid be a good idea Yo close aH this except for one? 9 A. 1 don't believe they were.
10 A_ 1 can see where your confusion is in here, let 10 Q. And you observed, because you looked at these
11 me clarify. They did put Jersey ba�riers up immediately. 91 videotapes, that although Yhe coins and papers were
2 Jersey barriers_ I was told the reason they couldn't put 12 removed when the first inspection was done, when the
13 up the curbing was because of the fire department. Thes 13 poiice came back the next time there was more coins and
14 accesses were blocked with Jersey ba�riers, so 1 don't 14 papers in there, right?
15 understand why the fire department would �ot allow then 15 A. That is co�rect. This is the only prope�ty i�
16 to put up curbs but would allow them to put up Jersey 16 our city that has locked doors that seem to Fnd pennie s
�7 barriers, which a fiire truck cannot drive over. So I was 17 in the locks_
18 under the impression that it would have been approved. 18 Q. Is my client pu#ting the pe�nies in there?
19 Q. So now youYe festifying about something you 19 A. Again, don't know who's putting the pennies in
20 just told us you had no idea what you're talking about 20 there. 1 just know that your client should make sure tht-
21 because you never went and talked to the fire depariment, 29 per�nies are not being put in there.
22 righY? 22 Q_ And when the police spent 60 days with this
23 A. No, I remember this point was brought forward by 23 four-person detaii --1'm sorry, more Yhan that with
24 Asgher and he said he didn't get permission from the fire 24 this detail and more than 60 days, were you able to stop
25 departmenf, and ii doesn't make sense because the Jerse yL5 the coins and the paper from getting shoved into those
Page 98 Page 100
1 ba�riers we�e put up. t Iocks2
2 Q. The second recommendation that you discussed 2 A. Let me eiaborate oo that. We�e we able to
3 with Asgher Ali and you're complaining about that he 3 reduce ifie crimes to the compiex, identify who was
4 didn't follow, was it anything that was required by state 4 putting tfie coins in the locks, and #he transient people
5 law or City ordinance? 5 that were hanging in the laundry rooms in the complex,
6 A. Whlch one would tfiat be? 6 the answsr is yes.
7 Q. You told me there was a second one. 7 Q. Now answer my question, sir.
8 A. There are several recomrnendations. 1 told him 8 A. Have they returned? Yes.
9 that he need to have secured doo�s, he needs to have 9 Q. were you abte io stop coins and the paper from
10 exterior lights. 1 atso told him fie needs to sc�een his 10 getting shoved into the locks and jamming the doors open?
11 tenants, know who's living in his building. 11 A. No.
12 Q. And those things are aB required, right? 12 Q. If kepf happening even with ihe poiice out there
13 A. Yes, they are. 13 on a more or less consta�t basis for mo�e than 60 days,
14 Q. And was Center Pointe screening i[s tenants? 14 right?
15 A. 1 don'# know if Center Pointe knows who's living 15 A. For the time that the officers were spe�ding at
16 in their property. �S this property, they were able to reduce a lot of locked
7 Q. Was Center Pointe making effort after effort 17 doors, ide�tify a lot of the peopfe who were responsibie
18 after e#fort to lock the doors? 18 (or it, and even went so far as trespassing some of the
19 A. Are you asking my opinion? Secause absolutel �19 people at the request of the management that were causin�
20 not_ 20 the problems at this p�operty, but they were not able to
2� Q. Welt, we saw in the videotape a iittle bit, and 21 eliminate it; that is correct.
22 if the Council waTches the rest of it they'il see even 22 Q. Did you arrest people for sticking coins and
23 more, that many of the locks that were open had been 23 paper in ihe locks?
24 jammed open with Coins, right? 24 A. No, we did not. I'm not aware of a criminal
25 A. That is correct. 25 cfiarge for that offense being charged.
25 (Pages 97 to 100j
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
6 i 2-339-0545
Public Hearing i0/112007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 101 Page103
9 Q. You also testified, sir, that robberies in the 9 Q. Pardon me?
2 area went up, right? 2 A. They gave him an apartment to use at tfie
3 A. Robberies in #he area have gone up for about one 3 property {o do surveiilance to try to identify some of
4 and a half years, that is correct. 4 these people who were doing street-levei drug
5 Q. And identify "the area" for me. 5 transactions.
6 A_ The area around Cenier Pointe Apartme�t compi� x 6 Q. Who gave him an apartment7
7 all the way down to the Twin Lakes Apartment complex 7 A. The ownefs.
8 which is probably one-half miie south, to indude the 8 Q. The same people that aren't doing anything to
9 Metro bus stop_ 9 cooperate, they gave the police department an apartment
10 Q. And it went up over a period of about a year and 10 To use?
'13 a half, and I think you said the bus stop has been there 11 A. That is correct_ They gave us their former
12 two years? 12 security officer's apartment to use.
13 A_ I believe that is correct. I believe it was '13 Q. And you thought because they had provided an
14 November 2005. 14 apartment for the police departmen# Yo use, that gave the
15 Q: And as I understood your testimony, sir, your 15 police department the righY fo go in and out of these
16 biggest concern about the robberies in the area were thai 16 buildings at will with no warrant, is that right?
17 the people committing these robberies were then fleeing 17 A. Yes, I believe that is correci.
18 o�to the CenYer Pointe property, right? 18 MR. BAER: 1 don't have any o#her ques8ons
19 A. !n severai of the cases, that is correct, to 19 for you, sic
20 include aY the property. 20 MR. CLELIAND: Just briefly, Mr. Mayor.
21 Q. And once they fled onto the Center Pointe 21 MAYOR WlLLSON: Please.
22 prope�ty, the poGce were having a hard time apprehending 22 REDIRECT EXAMINATION
23 them because there are so many hiding places on that 23 BY MR. CLELLAND:
24 property, right? 24 Q. At the time that you have met with the Jaweeds,
25 A. Both hiding places, and also they're able to go 25 in particular
Page 102 Page 104
1 through the tunnels and get lost within the property. 1 MAYOR WILLSON: Mr. Clelland, 1 think
2 Q. Those tunnels, as yau described them, were there 2 you're going to have to use the microphone.
3 when the project was built, correct? 3 MR. CLELLAND: Oh, thank you.
4 A. was noi here when the project was built. 4 SY MR. CLELLAND:
5 Q. Well, have you reviewed the City records? 5 Q. At #he time you met with the Jaweeds, and
6 A. When they bui!# this compiex? 6 particuiarly in the meeting requested by the city
7 Q. Yes, sir. 7 manager, hosted by the city manager in February at which
8 A. 1 believe one of the slides teUs you, but I 8 Asgher Jaweed appeared, what apparent authority and
9 believe it was 1979. 9 decision-making authority did he indicate that he had to
0 Q. Have you reviewed to see whether these tunnels 10 act on behalf of the LLC or LLP, whichever one?
19 that you're compiaining about were #here? 11 A. AcYuaUy
12 A. No, I have not. 12 MR. BAER: ObjecT to the quesfion,
13 Q. Do you have any reason to think that my client 13 Mr. Mayor.
4 put tfiose tunnels there? 14 MAYOR WILLSON: Thank you, Mr. Baer, duly
15 A. I have no reason to #hink your clients had 15 noYed. Mr. Gelland?
16 anytfiing to do with building the property. 16 MR. BAER: May I be heard, Mr. Mayor, as to
17 Q. When Officer Peters went out and did the 17 what my abjection is?
18 videoiape, did he have a search wa�rant? 18 MAYOR WILLSON: Briefly.
19 A. He did not have a search warrant_ 19 MR_ BAER: My objeclion is that he started
20 Q. Did he fiave permission from the owne� to go into 20 his question with "when you had meetings with the
21 this prope�ty? 21 Jaweeds," and there is no testimony that he had a meeting
22 A. Yes, he did: 22 with the Jaweeds_ He met with one Jaweed on hvo
23 Q. How so? 23 occasions. ThaYs the only testimony_
24 A. They actuapy gave him an apartment to use for 24 MAYOR WILLSON: Thank you. Mr. Clelland?
25 surveillancQ. 25 MR. CLELLAND: Thank you. 1 would like the
�2b (Pages 101 to 104)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc_
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page l05 Page 107
9 witness and not counsel to testify. 1 envisioned plan for this property and his brother's
Z BY MR. CLELLAND: 2 property.
3 Q- How many Jaweed brothers have you met with? 3 Q. Now with regard to some environmental changes
4 A. 1 met with ane. 4 that were expected to bring down the high rates of crime
5 Q- Okay. And 5 and cails for service, what offer of financial assistance
6 A. 1 think I-- correct that. 1 fiave met with 6 did the City make?
7 7 A. There was discussion about the City offering
Q. AlI right. And during the time that you met 8 some tax increment financing monies. 1 believe there was
9 with them, just describe genera�ty ihe meeti�gs you had 9 an amount of $SQ000 to assist.
10 and what decision making they indicated to you, that is, 10 Q. These environmental changes to improve the cafis
i# how they wouid, as individuais, humans, make decisions 1 for service at this propeRy?
12 for Ihe entity that owned Center Pointe? 92 A. That would be correct.
93 A. I was deariy under the impression that they 13 Q. Now at any time, given the fact that these locks
14 owned the properiy. When i was given thai iniormation 14 can be jammed with someihing as simple as the insertion
15 abaut how they were going to put in tfie one entrance and 15 of a coin or a wad of paper, what plan has either Jaweed
16 the cameras when they took over the property in SepYembe 16 brother offered to replace iocks of a different or more
i 7 2005, t was actualiy very excited because it seemed to be 17 sophisticated type that can defeat such simpie vandalism?
�ery positive in the direction this meeting was going. 18 A. They had indicated that they were going to
19 There were some very simpte corrections 2hat were to be 19 purchase some magnetic-type locks or other types of
20 made at the property, which had been a problem property 20 locks. They knew what was problem was, that people were
21 for many years pasi, had corrected and gone back down 21 found it easy to stick a penny in the door, again
22 again, problems back up, and theo back down_ The 22 somefhing that was not common in other properties in the
23 directions and discussions that 1 fiad 1 thought were 23 city. I'm not aware of it at any other properties in the
24 quite healthy, and 1 thought that the promises ihat were 24 city which had locked doors, so obviously there is a
25 made were very reasonable. 25 working knowledge of how to defeat the locks at the
Page 106 Page 108
1 Q. And if those promises had been fulfilled, ihat 1 property. There was at one point some electronic key
2 would involve an expenditure of a considerable amount of 2 passes that were made, or a suggestion when the Days li n
3 money, is that correcf? 3 hotel was being demotisfied that those locks could have
4 A. It did involve a lot of money, and I think I was 4 been used, purchased at a relatively affordable or very
5 quoted by Asgher of about $50,000 fo� fencing alone. 5 cheap price and would in Lhis case rectify that problem,
6 Q. Now in the meeting hosted by The city manager in 6 or at ieast temporarify.
7 February 2007, what comments did Asgher Jaweed make that 7 Q. Your las# inspection that was the 9th oi August,
8 led you to believe ihat he had decision-making authority 8 were the same types of locks present that are so easily
9 for the entity that owns Center Pointe? 9 defeated by paper and/or coins?
10 A. The ierminology that he used was singular, and 1 p q. We11, yes, they were, with the exception of the
11 it was his property. i did �ot believe there were other 11 2802 buildi�g, which still dcesn't have a lock, and a
12 vested people in the property other than his brother, who 12 couple other doors that the tocks were broken. But the
13 I also got the imp�ession was a co-owner. My previous 13 broken locks could have occurred within a short period c i
14 contacts and dealings with both Asgher and Hyder stem 14 time.
75 back io almost a decade ago when they were fhe owners ot i5 Q. What efforts has the police department, i�
16 the Brookhaven Apartment complex, and i had known them 16 conjuncfion with the sheriff's depa�tment, made to try
17 through the Association o# Re�tat Managers meeti�gs that 17 and cut down on some of the transient crime at the bus
38 were monthly meetings that both attended at one time on a 18 stop whicfi is adjacent to Center Pointe?
19 very regular basis. 19 A. The question is wfiat have we done as far as
2� L�. Did either Nyder or Asgher Jaweed ever indicate 20 initiatives?
21 to you in any fashion that other human beings actuaity 21 Q. Yes.
22 were the owners or decision makers wiTh regard to Center 22 q. Very expensive endeavor. We dedicated two
23 Pointe? 23 officers and got the joint partnership with the Hennepin
24 A. No. Actuaily when we had the meeting in 24 County Sheriff's Office to have these four officers at
25 September 2005, it was very dear that it was his 25 all times, both at that property, at the bus hub, ai Twi�
27 (Pages 105 to 108)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 109 Page 11I
1 Lake Manor, a�d any other area in the city where there 1 MR CLELLAND: Okay_ 1 have no futther
2 may be a sudden outbreak in street robberies. We saw a 2 questions.
3 significant i�crease of street robberies in the City of 3 MAYOR WI�ISON_ don't believe we have any
4 Brooklyn Center, and this is a reaction to seeing an 4 further ones. So, Mr. Clelland, if you have a next
S increase_ We noticed a 1ot of people that were 5 witness?
6 constanily being meniioned as suspects or in the area of 6 MR. CLELLAND_ 1 do.
7 crimes were coming from the Center Pointe area. Not 7 MAYOR WILtSON: Another part of the
8 necessarily tenants, but they were coming from that area 8 process? Mr. Benner, 1 would like to thank you for your
9 or fleeing fo that area. 9 time.
10 Q. The bus hub is actually adjacent to, immediately '10 {Witness excused.)
11 adjacent to the Center Poinie complex, is that correct? 9 i MR_ CLE�LAND: Thank you. Call Officer
72 A. Yes, it is. 92 Terry Olson. Officer Olson, if you would come forward
13 Q. And what ties da you see with regard to the 13 and be swom, please?
14 cnmes or the persons commitYing cnmes that come to the 14 OFFICER TERRY OLSON,
15 bus hub and Center Pointe as a comp�ex? 15 duly sworn, was examined and testified as foliows:
16 A_ We see sVeet-level drug transactions where 16 DlRECT EXAMiNATION
17 peopie are laking tfie bus up to the hub and they are 9 7 BY MR. CLELLAND:
18 meeting people either on the south side of the Center 18 Q. Officer Olson, you are a(u11-time and licensed
39 Pointe Apartme�t complex or, as in just recently, tenants i 9 law enfarcement office� for the State of Minnesota and
20 from the Center Pointe Apartment complex are coming ove 2Q the Ciiy of 8rooklyn Center, is that correct?
21 and doing hand-to-hand drug transactions. Tfie people 29 A. Yes, sir, it is_
22 purchasing the drugs then get back on the bus and flee. 22 Q. How long have you been a law enforcement
23 !n several ot ihe robbery cases, drugs and the purchase 23 Officer?
24 of drugs have been a contributi�g factor in how the two 24 A_ For about 17 years.
25 parties met. 25 Q. How long with Brooklyn Center?
Page 110 Page 112
1 Q. Even though fencing isn'Y required, what was the 1 A. About seven years_
2 City's lhinking behind tfie recommendation that there be a 2 Q. Thank you. What generally have been your
3 fence betwee� the bus hub and the Cente� Pointe Apartment 3 assignments over your career?
4 complex? 4 A. i've worked as a patral officer, as one of two
5 A. it creates a barrier and that barrier at least 5 founding members oi the Community Policing Unit in the
6 is a deterrent for people that are, if they could just 6 8rooklyn Park Police in 8rooklyn Park when 1 was an
7 simply walk across the street and get Yheir drugs, thaYs 7 employee there. Recently I've been assigned to an
8 pretty easy. If you make them walk a half a block to get 8 initiaYive being developed known as the Problem Oriente� I
9 their drugs, they mostly go somewhere else or you 9 PoAce Unit.
10 displace this common practice. 1 p Q. What specifically is the Problem Oriented Police
11 Q. Now did the City have an actuai, inte�sive 11 Program?
12 enforcement aY #he bus hub itseif to cuY down this crime? 12 A. The concept of problem oriented policing
13 A_ We worked in partnership with the Metro Transit 13 surrounds the idea that a focused effort using resources
14 authorities as well as with the Hennepin County Sheriffs 94 other fhan those which are traditional law enforcement
15 Office_ As far as Metro Transit police, they provided us 15 might yield a better result when addressing crime and
16 limited assistance as far as otficers due to other 16 disorder.
17 pressi�g matters within the jurisdiction. 17 Q_ Have you, since March 2007, been specifically
98 Q. Approximateiy when did this iniensive patroi of 18 concemed with the high levels of crime a�d calls for
19 the bus hub take place, this joint law enforcement 19 service at the Center Pointe Apa�tment compiex?
20 effort7 20 A. Yes, io approximately March of 2007 was
21 A.
March 7th.
I 21 assigned or directed to wo�k on issues
surroundin not
22 Q. 2007?
9
22 onfy Center Pointe but several other properties as
23 A. That is correct. 23 problematic and in need o# atte�tion_
24 Q. And for how iong did it last? 24 Q_ The department has iracked statisiics for 53
25 A. To June 22nd, 2007. 25 apartment complexes within the ci that have five
28 (Pages 109 to 112)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BR
OOKLYN
CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page I13 Page 1]5
1 apartment units or more, is that correct? 1 property to a medium or a large-size property.
2 A. Yes, sir, thaYs correcf. 2 Q. Now in some cases the caNs for service can be
3 Q. This group of 53 has a little more than 3,200 3 higher per unit if the complex has a small number of
4 apartment units? 4 units, is that right?
5 A_ Yes, sir, it does_ 5 A. Yes, statistically a smalier compiex can have a
s Q. As Canter Pointe has 252 units, they comprise 6 much smaller �umber of ca11s tor service and it can ske w
7 7.7 pe�cent of the total units, apartment units in this 7 the stats_
8 group? 8 Q_ But in terms of the raw numbers, in 2004 there
9 A. I believe that's correct_ 9 were a totai of 544 caits to Center Pointe according to
�fl Q_ Okay. Do you have statistics to show all calls 10 tfiese statistics, is tha# correct?
11 for service for apartment complexes in this 53-group 11 A. Yes, sir, it is.
12 modei for the year 2Q04? 12 Q. I'm going to the year 2005. Is this an accurate
13 A. Yes, do. 13 compilation of the caNs for service as to al� the
14 Q. Would you put that on the screen, please? 14 apartment complexes in this 53-complex model?
MAYOR WiLLSON: And that would be Tab 15 A. Yes, it is.
6 MR. CLELIAND: And that is at Tab 9 in the 16 Q. And the calis for service increased from 544 to
17 book before the Councii. 17 683 at Center Pointe?
18 BY MR. CLELIAND: 18 A. Yes, sir, YhaYs correct.
19 Q_ And this is re what is at the second part of 19 Q. On what data did you base and compile this
20 Tab 9 is reproduced, that wouid be page 5 and beyond, is 20 exhibit?
2i that correcY? 21 A. These are records that are normaUy compiled an i
22 A_ I'm not sure 1 understand the qusstion, 1'm 22 maintained by various staff at the police department.
23 sorry. 23 They a�e derived from dispatching data called CAD
24 Q. Yes. There are a number of statisYics in the 24 records, computer-aided dispatching records.
25 book, correci? 25 Q. If there were a cal! and it proved that there
Page 1 14 Page I 16
1 A. Yes, that's correct. i was, there were no cali, wouid that be reflected in this?
2 Q. And whaY we're looki�g aY is the fifth page to 2 A. it would depe�d on the circumstances. !f they
3 the end of that tab, is that correct? 3 were saying unfounded complaint or reported crimi�ai
4 A. Yes, sir, it is. 4 activity, it would be reflected in khis number.
Q. Is this reproduced on the large screen here? 5
Q. This reflects, though, someo�e cal�ing for
6 A. Yes, it is_ 6 services?
7 Q. Now what does this tell the Council about the
7 A. In most cases it does_ However, it also
8 caAs for service at Center Pointe in reiationship to all 8 includes activities where an officer petforming the
9 other units here? 9
10 A. 1'11 work through the documeni and highlight a 10 orsome form of nvestigationsis for, say, a vehicle stop
11 bit first so you can follow my expla�afioa. in the 11 Q. And going to year 2006, cails at Center Pointe
'12 column on the left you'It see the various apartment 12 have �ow increased to 739, is that correct?
13 complexes or rental properties, in some cases they're 13 A. Yes, it is.
14 single buildings. 1n any svent, tfiey ali have more than 14 Q. And what is the extrapolation, the anticipated
15 four units, which is the basis for their being included 15 calls at Center Pointe for 2007 based on the figures
16 in this #racking. Across the top you'll see the month of 16 through August?
3 7 the year. in this column you'1! see the tofal calls for 17 A. Do you want me to bring that document up?
18 service. Now these numbers reflect raw data; in other 18 Q. Yes.
19 words, they refiect every call for service to each of the 19 A_ Through August of 2007 there are a total of 545
20 identified properties. 20 police calis. Statisticafly {hat represents
21 In this colum� you'!I see the number of 21 approximately two-thirds of the calendar year, meanin5
22 units that each property consists of, and in the last 22 the total wiH be somewhere in the neighborhood of 800 if
23 coiumn all tfie way to tMe right you'A see a ratio which 23 they continue at the same pace.
24 compares the number of cails for service to tfie number c f 24 Q. Okay. Going back to the first four pages of
25 units, and this allow for a comparison of a small
25 Exhibit 9_ The comparison?
29 (Pages 113 to 116)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Pagc117 Page 119
1 A. 1 apologize, 1 don't know which group was which in evidence.
2 there. i apologize_ Is this ihe document you're 2 MAYOR WILLSON: !'ll accept. That's
3 referring to? 3 Tab No. 9 there, Mr_ LeFevere.
4 Q. Yes. How was Center Pointe, Twin lake Manor, 4 BY MR. CLELLAND:
5 Twin Lake North and Melrose Gates selected to be the four 5 Q. What legal requirement does an apartment owner,
6 complexes ir� ihis comparison? 6 apartment compiex svch as Center Fointe and its owners
7 A. This is an analysis 1 prepared based on the four 7 have to supplying a current and accurate ienant register
8 largest rental properties in the city in terms of totai 8 to the ciry?
9 number of �entai u�its. in other words, none of these 9 A. Under city ordinance, they are �equired to
10 prope�ties was hand-selected; tfiis represents literally 10 provide an occupancy register when requested. There aa a
1 i the four largest rental properties_ 11 very specific requirements in the ordinance. I dor�'t
12 Q. And they're comparable as to the year of 12 have a copy i� front of ine, 1'm sorry. Among the
13 construct+on, Yhe number ofi apartment units and 13 requirements are the information relating to Yenants
i4 comparable in other similarit+es? 14 occupying the property, there's another requirement that
15 A. They are as reflected in the document. 15 repair requests made by tenants be provided on requesY
16 Q_ Now under the ca11s for service, what types of 16 and some other issues_
17 cails are represented in this cail for service 17 Q. What difficulty have you had securing from ihe
18 comparison? 18 Center Pointe awners an accurate fenant register?
19 A_ The numbers that you see reflected in this 19 A. 1 have had great difficutty. In fact, I've
20 portion of the document reflect raw calls for service; in 20 obtained portions of the occupancy register afte� making
21 other words, calls that are received by a dispatch, 24 several formal requests, but the property owner has yet
22 self-initiated officer activities, thi�gs of that sort. 22 to comply fully with the requirements of the ordinance.
23 Q. And the five-year average from 2002 throu h 2006 2
9 3 Q. Why is it important that the oJice have a�
P
24 is 898 calis fior Center Pointe? 24 accurate tenant register?
25 A_ Thafs correct. 25 A. Significant p�oblems at tfiis proper#y, a�d
Page 118 Page 120
1 Q. 537 for Twin Lake Manor? 1 certai�ly of any rental properties, but this one more
2 A_ That's correct. 2 prevalent than others, are people frequenting the
3 fl. 136 for Twin Lake North? 3 property who don't belong there. When we investigate
4 A. Yes, sir. 4 suspected crimina� activity, there's a need for us to be
5 Q. And 131 for Melrose Gates? 5 able to verify that suspects we've deYained actually have
6 A. Yes, sir. 6 some legal basis to be on the property. It allows us to
Q. On what basis have you projecfed that in 2007 7 furtfier our imestigations for those purposes.
8 there may be over 800 caHs for service to Center Pointe? 8 Q. What i�fiormation in this tenant register is
9 A. If you look at the documert thaYs been, or the 9 important for officer safety?
10 portion of the document thaYs highligfited, you'll see 10 A. Certainly being aware of who's on the property
11 that there have been 202 police caUs for service durim, 11 or who oughi to be on the property is a very important
l2 the months of January, �ebruary, March 2007. if you 12 part of our approach for officers to ensure or to
13 multiply that times four, since it represents a quarter 13 maximize their safiety to the extent tMat we can. Having
14 of the year, you receive a result of 808 pofice caUs for 14 specific infonnation aboui who belongs there allows us i�
5 service. 15 understand who it is ihat we're Iikely to be dealing
16 Q. Oka
Y
16 with.
17 MR. CIELLAND: Offer statistics in Tab 9. 17 Q. What specific personal co�tact Mave you had with
1$ MR. BAER: Object, Mr. Mayor, on the 18 either Hyder Jaweed or Asgher Jaweed with regard to yo�r
19 grounds that we don't have the underlying documents to 19 request for an accurate tenant register and their failure
20 compare this summary wi#h. 20 to provide it?
2'1 MR. CLELLAND: 1 think his testimony 2i A. I've submitted several requesYs, again formal
22 provides sufficient basis for these siatistics and the 22 requests to both of the Jaweeds in ihe form of letters
23 compilatio� to provide ap of the documents. It would 23 which were faxed and ma8ed to various locations and alsa
24 literally be thousands and thousands of pages for you to 24 hand-defivered to them in fhe rental office, and in no
25 look at_ i would ask the Council to accept this exhibit 25 instance have they fully complied.
30 (Pages 117 to 120)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 12l Page 123
i Q. What has been the shortcomings and some of their 1 believe, 2007.
2 excuses as to why you haven't received an accurate 2 Q. Who attended that?
3 register? 3 A. You were in attendance for the buik of tfie
4 A. As related directly from either the Jaweeds 4 meeting. Larry Martin with Community Development was i i
5 Q. Yes. 5 attendance for a portion af the meeting. Again I spent
A. or from staff ai the prope�fy? S the greatest amouni of time of all city staff with
7 Q_ BoYh, as to Jaweeds first and then their staff_ 7 Mr. Hertz.
8 A. in conversations with Asgher, he had informed tre 8 Q. What was the purpose of the meeting with
9 that he inte�ded to provide Yhose records, he agreed to 9 Mr. Hertz representing the Jaweeds on the 12th of July
10 do so, and in faci Yold me he would have the final name 10 2007?
11 to update those records and print them for me while 1 va a41 A. Our purpose was to discuss the ongoing issues
12 at the rentaf office. A short time tater, during khat 12 and problems. His invotvement in the meet+ng was in thai
13 same conversation, he said that he would send those 13 he represented the Jaweeds as owners of the property and
14 records to me the following day, and 1 have yet to 14 that he was inierested in receiving materials that we
15 receive anything from him directly. 1 S provlded previously because he couidn't get it from the
16 Q. When did that take place? 16 Jaweeds.
17 A. if i can refer to my notes, 1 can tell you the 17 Q. Did you or anyone on behalf of the City supply
18 date. 18 him with those materials?
19 Q. Yes. 19 A. Yes, we did.
20 A. The fi�st request for an occupancy register was 20 Q. Now what specifically did you discuss witfi Ken
29 sent in the form of a letter dated June 1st, 2007. Again 2i Heriz in that meet+ng regarding the t�igh levels of
22 that was faxed to the re�tal office, and 1 did receive 22 premises crime and calfs for service and ways that tfie
23 confirmation that the fax transmission was successfui. 23 City thought they could be reduced by affirmative action
24 It was also defivered to Asgher Jaweed in person af the 24 of ihe owners7
25 �ental office by a poGce cadet and a copy was maiied b; 25 A. We discussed a number of issues. First and
Page t22 Page 124
1 USPS to both the rental office and the Jaweed residenc 1 foremost, he received the document thaYs on the display
2 whicM is the address that they've provided o� the rental 2 �ight now, the four-part comparison, as a basis for our
3 license. 3 concern. We discussed specific crime prevention metho is
4 Q. And you've been involved with the Center Pointe 4 or Yechniques that the property owner might employ, suc i
5 property just since March 2007, co�rect? 5 as etiminating or controlling access to the property by
6 A. As a function of my cur�ent assignment, that's 6 eiiminating certain entrances, the installation of a
7 correct. 1've had previous coAtacts with various staff 7 fence, the implementation of a permit parki�g program,
8 and owners there. 8 the initiation of an on-site managemenY staff or other
9 Q. So your personai request of Hyder and Asgher 9 members o# staff to represen# the owners in monitoring
10 Jaweed would have taken place in the late spring, early 10 activities on the property, and some ofher environmental
11 summer of 2007, is Ihat correct? 11 design factors. He was provided with examples of sever. 1
12 A. That is correct 2 properties in Brooklyn Park where they've impleme�ted
13 Q. Do you feel there has still been noncompliance 13 tMese procedures and he indicated to me an interest in
14 with the legal obligation fo provide an accurate tenant 14 touring those proper#ies.
15 register and particulatly on a continuing basis? 15 Q. Now di�ecting the Gouncii's attention to Tab 6,
16 A. ThaYs been a continual problem. I have 16 and showi�g this to you, Officer 04son, did you
17 recently received again a portion of what is required by 17 contribute police reports and other data that went into
18 ordinance, but 1 can't say that they'�e fully in 18 this Notice of Abatement of Public Nuisances?
i9 compliance nor have they been in any of the requests. 19 A. 1 don't k�ow thaY i specificaily provided these
20 Q. Do you know that Kenneth Hertz indicates that he 20 materials or not. i'm certainly aware of these
21 is the attomey for one or bath ofi the Jaweed owners? 21 instances.
22 A. ThaYs yes, thaYs fiow he had identified his 22 Q. A�d I'm referring to Tab 14. Are #hese specific
23 involvement with the property. 23 police reports prepared by and mainYai�ed by the City of
24 Q. How do you know that? 24 Brooklyn Center regarding criminal offenses at the Center
25 A. i had a meeting with Mr. Hertz on July 12, 1 25 Pointe properties in the year 2007?
31 (Pages 121 to i 24)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 125 Page 127
1 A. Yes, Yhey appear #o be. 1 MR. CLELLANO: Yes_
2 Q_ Can you just look {hrough tfiere and identify 2 MAYOR WILLSON: Duly noted.
3 those, just that tfiese are police reports regarding 3 BY MR. CLELLAND:
4 various offenses kept in Yhe ordinary course of business 4 Q. Officer Olson, how co�sistenUy have you
5 of the police department? 5 informed both Jaweed brothers and their agents of the
A. Yes, they are. 6 continuing probiems, high ieveis of crime, types of crime
7 Q. Qo many of these offenses involve crimes 7 and other code violations existing at the Genter Pointe
8 regarding controlled substances? 8 property?
9 A. On cettain several of them do_ Having not 9 A. ThaYs occurred on a regular, ongoing and
10 reviewed every one of them di�ectly 1 can't speak to 10 continuing basis since my invoivement with the property
11 them, it would require more time, but 1'm looking at one 11 in March_
12 right now #hat does. 12 Q. Showing you various letters and communications
13 Q. You in fact provided these documents to me, is 13 at Tab 7, can you ide�tify all of these letters and
14 that correct? 14 parties to whom they were sent and the relationship of
15 A. 1 may have. 1 can'Y say thai 1 specifically 15 that pa�ty to the ownersfiip and management of Center
16 recall that. f apologize. 1 think thaYs iikely, give� 16 Pointe?
17 my assignment though. 17 A. Certainly. I�dividuaily by each documenf?
8 Q. One of your principai assignments is the rates 18 Q. Yes.
19 of crime and matters relaYed to that for the complex, is 19 A. Okay. The top document is dated March 19, and
20 that correct? 2D that correspondence was sent to Heather Dahline, who wa�
21 A. ThaYs correct. 2i the property manager for the complex at ifiat time.
22 MR_ CLELLAND: Offer 6 and 14. 22 March 2q a letter was sent to Ms. Dahline, again
23 MAYOR WILLSON: So noted. Mr. Baer, excuse 23 documentiog problematic and criminal tehavior, all of
24 me. 24 which violates the terms of the lease and rental
25 MR. BAER: Thank you, Mr. Mayor, i really 25 agreement. March 28th, another letter sent Yo Neather
Page 126 Page l28
"1 dOn mean to make a pest of myself. 1 Dahline. Aprii 2nd, another ietter sent to Ms. Oahiine
2 MAYOR WlLLSON: Part of yourjob. 2 regarding activities in the property. April 2nd, another
3 MR. BAER: When you shrug your shoulders 3 Ietter sent to Ms. Dahline on a related matter in tfiat
4 Gke that I think that perhaps you're perceiving me as a 4 she had made certain agreements on behalf of tfie property
5 pest and that's not my intention. 5 owners to provide informatio� a�d materials and take
6 MAYOR WILLSON: IYS part of your job, and 6 productive steps or measures to �educe crime and disorde�
7 1' just frustrated that i forgot to offer you the 7 on the property_ That letter in particular summarizes
8 opportunity fo object to these particular documents. 8 the promises she made to me and the Ciry, and her
9 MR. BAER: Thank you, 5ir. I do object io 9 failures to comply with any of the agreements that she
10 Tab No. 6, NotiCS of Abatement, beCause, like the 10 made, and also documents the promises and support that we
11 criminal aUegations that were previousiy moved into i provided to the property and our Iollow to
12 evidence by Mr. Cielland, these are aHegations. i 2 demonsY�ate that we have done everything that we agreed
13 Mr. CieHand has, and, in fact, threatened to use a clear 3 to do. Another leiter dated April 5 again se�t to
'!4 course of action thai would have taken these allegations aa Ms_ Dahtine. Letter dated April 1'1 seM to Asgherand
15 to a Court so that they Could be properly deCided. 15 Hyder Jaweed, again summarizing problematic and criminai
16 Ir�stead he just waots you to rely on the ailegations. �s activity on the property. That letter was sent to Asgher
3 7 IYs improper, the same as the crimina) complaints were 17 and Hyder Jaweed because Ms. Dahline leit employment with
18 improper. With �espect to Tab 14 1 h8ve no objeCtion. 18 the property, and as she explained to me, it was as a
9 MR. CLELIAND: And also if I haven't, 19 result of being assautted by another stafif inember.
20 Would reOffer 6_ I not sure if 1 did. Excuse me. No 20 April 9fi, another letter seni to, this time to Eric
21 I believe I did. i will make that offer of Tab 9— 21 Sytsma, who was the property manager in this instance.
22 exCUSe me, Tab 9-- whiCh iS the Crime sYatistics that 22 fNr_ Sytsma made simitar assurances and promises on behalf
23 were shown on the board. 23 of the property owners with respeci to providing a
24 MAYOR WILLSON: 6, 9 and 14 then, is that 24 summa of what the inte�ded to
�Y Y do wiih all of the
25 CorreCt? 25 peopie documented in the previous letters. He was
32 (Pages 125 to 128)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEET�NG
Page l29 Page131
1 provided not only witM this letter but ali of the 1 A. You'li see statistically they have not beert
2 previous tetters sent to Ms. Dahline because he toid me 2 reduced whatsoever.
3 hQ did�'t have them_ 3 MR. CLELLAND: Okay. I have no further
4 Q. In many case here these letters identified to 4 questions of Officer Olson.
5 Mr. Jaweed, Hyder and Asgher Jaweed, and their agents, 5 MAYOR W1L�SON: Thank you, Mr_ Clelland.
fi specific criminal activity committed by tenants, is that 6 Mr. Baer?
7 correct? 7 MR. BAER: O�e second, if I may.
8 A. Yes, they do. 8 (Brief pause in the proceeding.j
g Q. Okay_ And some of these letters actualiy sent 9 CROSS-EXAMINATION
10 to the agents were copied to the Jaweeds, is that 10 BY Mf2. BAER:
11 correct? 11 Q. Officer Olson, are you familiar with Section
12 A_ Thafs correct. There's another one dated 12 12-913 of the City's ordinances?
13 April 24th, again Yo Eric Sytsma, and again detailing 93 A. Yes, 1 am.
14 criminal and otherwise probiematic behavior on Yhe 14 Q. in fact, 12-913 is the ordinance that sets
15 property. A�other tetter dated Aprii 26 to Mr. Sytsma, a 15 Iimits on specific types of police caAs that apartment
16 letter dated May 7 to M�. Sytsma, and thaYs the last 16 buildings can have without faUing into the provisional
17 letter in tfie packet '17 license category, correc#?
i 8 Q. Now is that a representaYive sampie of how often 18 A. Yes
s�r.
19 you brought to #he attention of the Jaweeds the criminal 19 Q. And when Center PoinYe's ii�ense was renewed in
20 activities by the tenants and the other specific 20 January of this year, it was not given a provisionai
21 insta�ces of crime during late summer late spring, 21 license, was it?
22 early summer 2007? 22 A, That is my understanding.
23 A. Yes, it is. 23 Q. And if in fact Center Pointe was out of
24 Q. Nave you continued that practice? 24 compliance with Section 12-913, they would have only
25 A. in some cases 1 have. Nowever, it should be 25 gotten a provisional license, correct?
Page 130 Page 132
1 understood that on a monthly basis those responsible i�r1 A. 7haYs my understanding, yes.
2 rentat properties consisting of iive units or more in the 2 Q. So we can co�clude from the fact that Center
3 city receive a printout of all of the CAD dispatching 3 Pointe got a Iicense that was not provisional, that
4 records; in other words, they receive a monthly list of 4 Center Pointe was in compliance with 12-913, correct?
5 every single call for service to their property_ So 5 A. That is correct, based on the information
6 these letters supplement those documents that they ha �e6 available at the time the license was renewed.
7 been provided with fo� years. 7 Q. Okay. I noticed in all of the statistics tfiat
8 Q. These are kept as part of the ordinary business 8 you weni througfi YMere is no reference to 12-913.
9 records of the department? 9 Instead, there's a reference to CFS. CFS means calls for
10 A_ These have been kept as a function of this 10 service, correct?
11 particuiar property and our attempt to add�ess the issu! �11 A. Yes, sir.
12 there. 12 Q. And that inGudes many, many things tha# are nok
13 Q. You're the author o# these letters? 13 called 12-933 violatians, correct?
�4 '4' am" 14 A. Yes, sir, thaYs correct.
15 MR. CLELLAND: All right. Offer 7, 15 Q. And the reason that your statistics focused on
16 Mr. Ma r
Y
o.
16 calls for service is because m fact Center PoinYe is and
MR. BAER: No objection, Mr. Mayor. i 7 has been in com liance with 1-
P 2 913 corr
ect
MAYOR WILLSON: Duly noted. 18 A. Center Pointe was in comptiance until recently,
19 BY MR. CLELLAND: 19 that is correct.
2� Q. Now despite the conti�ued notice to the Jaweeds 20 Q. We'A taik about recently in a minute.
21 and their agents, particularty about crime and drug crime 21 A_ Yes, sir, we wii1.
22 commi#ted by their tenants, what reductions if any in 22 Q. Is there anything in the ordinance, because 1
23 calls for service and criminai activity have you 23 have not found it, that says that a� apartmen# complex
24 experienced or has the department experienced from tate 24 can only have X number of calls for service?
25 spring'07 to the present? 25 A. No, there's not.
33 (Pages 29 to 132)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COLJNCIL MEETING
Page133 Page 135
1 Q. And in fact, if there's a problem at the 1 other words, these are offenses which are specifically
2 eomptex, the police want to be called, don't they? 2 tracked in relation to that ordinance. In this coiumn
3 A. Tha£s true, yes. 3 you'il see the month and year, and across to the right
4 Q. So that you can address those probiems? 4 you'll see the total number of calis that a�e defined by
5 A. Certainty. Sut to be fair, we are inte�ested in 5 the 12-913 ordinance on the right column. 191 go to the
6 working in partr�ership with Lhose who have co�tro( of t �e6 next slide if you're ready?
7 property. In other words, we don't encourage people tc 7 Q. Go ahead, sir_
8 c{eate a high cal! or a high crime burden merely for the 8 A. The next siide demonstrates additionaf
9 enjoyme�t of responding to assist people. We p�efer tc 9 in#ormation which is extrapolated from tfiose columns
10 work collectively with people who own properties to soMEO which indicates 180 totai 12-913 ca�ls for service, 252
11 tfieir problems. 11 units in total, and a ratio, based on those two #acts, of
12 Q. Of course. Of course. And if there was 12 .71 cails for service per unit. The bottom portion on
13 something in my ques6on that suggested that the police 13 that document reflects the percent of total calls for
94 were acting as fools, that was not my i�tent_ I 14 service to 53 complexes that Center Pointe is responsif 1e
15 understand that the police are doing their job. But pa�t 15 for, and again we'll go back to the idea that Center
16 of the job is responding to calls whether they're at 16 Pointe represents approximatety 7.7 percent of ail rent� I
97 apartrnent units or anyplace etse in the city, correct? 17 units in the city, yet they consume 23.35 percent of
18 A. Yes, sir. 18 police resources as it relates to these specific offenses
19 Q. And when you compiled these statisiics on caNs 19 across the top, whicfi are again offenses defined in the
20 ior service as opposed to 12-913 calls, that gives a 20 92-913 ordinance.
21 disYorted picture. 2i q. Do you have anotfier slide?
22 A. don't believe it does. 22 A. Thafs the last slide. I apologize, 1 didn't
23 Q. Weli, where are the statistics on the 12-913 23 prepare these slides, although i'm famiiiar with the
24 calls? 24 informatioa contained.
25 A. They're certainly not in this compariso�. For 25 Q. You mentioned thaY #he Center Pointe complex
Page 134 Page i36
1 purposes of this comparison so you understand, thi 1 receives a monthiy report from the police that identifies
2 wasn't created in anticipation of future issues with the 2 the 12-913 calls, correct?
3 owners af any particutar property. In fact, this wasn't 3 A. Thafs correct.
4 created specificaily for our purposes as ihey relate to 4 Q. And it sets out specificalfy in that repori a
5 the Center Pointe property, and for our purposes ihis s 5 description of each call for service and then it also
6 an analysis tool that helps us to identify trends and 6 identifies which of those calls for service fafl into the
7 patterns that we feel may be successfully addressed 7 12-913 category, correct?
8 through othe� means. 8 A. ThaYs correct.
9 Q. Officer Olson, my question was where are tfie 9 Q. And when you prepared these statistics and came
10 statistics for the 12-913 calls? 10 to the conclusion that there was 0.71 12-913 calls for
i 1 A. The are ke t in a se
Y p parate file and compiled by 11 service at Center Pointe, did you compare those
i 2 other staff. 12 sfatistics against those monthly reports that the
13 Q. Did you bring them with you? 13 property was receiving?
14 A. 1 have some documents relating to them, yes. 14 A. Yes, in facY those are, those are the basis for
15 Q. May 1 see them? 15 our arriving at these totais.
16 A. Certainly. 1'lJ have to display them, i don't 16 (RespondenYs Exhibit No. 2 marked.)
17 have a hard copy for you. Would you like to see them 17 Q. Officer Oison, !'m handing you whaYs been
18 Q. Please. 18 marked as Respondent's Exhibit 2. Tfiis is the report
19 A. Tfiis is a summary of 12-913 calls, or calls for 19 that was provided io Center Pointe for September of 200fi
20 service as they relate to the 12-913 ordinance. This is 20 to track the 12-993 calls, correct?
21 the �esuli of a recent audit that was conducYed by poli :@1 A_ Yes, it appears to be.
22 department staff to ensure that our, not only our 22 1NR. BAER: Mr. Mayor, if I may provide one
23 methodology but our statistics are correct. In this 23 of these ta the Council?
24 document, you'U see across the top various offenses 24 MAYOR WIL�SON: (Nods head.)
25 which are specificaliy identified in that ordinance. In 25 MR. BAER: Mr. Ryan, did you get September
34 (Pages 133 to 136)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/i/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL
MEETING
Page 137 Page 139
1 or Ociober? Let me find a September for you. Did 1 identified in the ordinance, whereas we hadn't been pri� �r
2 everyone else get September? Sorry. Thank you, sir. 2 to Yhat audit.
3 BY MR. BAER: 3 Q. And the statisfics where you gave us before for
4 Q. Now on your statistics, you report [hat in 4 total calls for service, do you remember?
5 September 2006 Center Pointe had 29 12-913 caHs, 5 A. Yes, sir.
6 correct? 6 Q_ Did those incfUde just calis that occurred on
7 A. Yes, sir, do_ 7 tfie Center Pointe property or was it cails adjacent to
8 Q. On this report that was provided to Center 8 Center Pointe?
9 Pointe by the Brooklyn Ce�ter Poiice Departmen! in 9 A. No, those are caHs that are coded by dispatcfi
10 September, or for September a# 2006, how many i2-913 10 as occurring on the property.
11 calis are reported? 11 Q. And, for example, if the poifce were dispatched
12 A. Bear with me, 1'm working with somebody else's 12 to the bus stop thaYs adjacent to the property, did
13 writing. 13 those ca11s get counted in the calis for service for
14 Q. 1 count 15. 14 Center PoinYe?
15 A_ 171 definitely agree that the number differs on 15 A. No, they didn't.
16 this record as compared to the statistics on the board_ i6 Q. Youie ce�tain of that?
17 Q. Can you tell me which one is righi? 97 A. 1'm posifive of tfiat.
18 A. The one on the board is correct, sir. 18 Q. One ofi the thfngs you mentioned that came out of
19 Q• Well, why didn't Center Pointe get that correct 19 your audit recently was more attention to the fire
2D information then? 20 atarms, which is a violaYion under 12-913, right?
21 A. IYs unfortunafe Yhey didn't. We recently 21 A. ThaYs correct, sir_
22 audited calls for service a�d again, as 1 mentioned 22 Q. Would you do you have the ordinance there?
23 before, not only the statistical information that tMose 23 A. i don't have it in front of ine, no. 1
24 reports contained but also our methodology, and in doi i�4 apologize.
25 so we found that over the course of time people involve cp5 MR. BAER: Do we have a copy o# the
Page 138 Page 140
1 i� this process, and ii's been several employees have i ordinanCe?
2 come and go»e over the years, have changed the forms th< 2 MS. AWSUMB: iVot a ciean Copy.
3 we use to track certain offenses, ceftain types of events 3 THE WITNESS: 1 have one here, sir.
4 thai are described under the 12-913 ordinance. As an 4 MR. BAER: Didn't we make a copy of the
5 example, assaults weren't being counted u�til recently 5 whole Chapter?
6 when we've gone back and conducted a 12-month audit to 6 MS. AWSUMB: No.
7 arrive at the aumbers you see fiere. Another instance of 7 MAYOR WILLSON: Mc Baer?
8 an offense thaYs specifically addressed in that 8 MR. BAER: Yes?
9 ordinance that wasn't being tracked a�e damage to 9 THE WITNESS: 1've been provided a copy.
10 properties. Fire aiarms. 10 MR. BAER: Okay.
11 Q. !s the�e any time betore tonight that you told 19 BY MR. BAER:
12 the Center Pointe owner that you changed the rules? 12 Q. 12-913 of the ordinances provides that "Licensed
13 A. Well, I don't ihink thaYs a fair 13 muitipie dwelfings with five or more units that have
14 cha�acterization, but you are correct in saying that this 14 generated a� average of .65 or more police or fire calls
15 is probably ihe first time they have seen this particular 15 per dwe�ling in a preceding one period as specified
1s document. 16 below are eligible only for provisional ticenses." Oo
7 Q. Well, apart from September of 2006, which of the 17 you see where I'm reading?
18 other ones aren't what you told Center Poin2e at the 18 A. 1 missed the iast part, 1'm sorry.
19 time? 99 Q. Do you see where I'm reading?
20 A. 1 can tell you that they're all going;o 20 A. Yes, sir, 1 do_
2! probabty be di#ierent from what they were informed based 21 Q. And read it correctly?
22 on our audit. 22 A. Yes, you have.
23 Q. And your audit drove up the numbers, right? 23 Q. And then it goes on under 1.a. to tell us whaf
24 A. The numbers are higher than they had been
24 e
typ s of police and fire caQs are counted ri ht?
25 9
because we're tracki�g things that are specifically 25 A. Yes, it does.
35 (Pages 137 to 140)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-OS45
Public Heanng lU/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
I
Page 141 Page l43
1 Q_ And particularly under Section 12-g13 1.a., iii, 1 in the complex that need to be maintained properly.
2 is then a list of A through U of ail the different kinds 2 Q. Well, how would malfunction in a dryer reiate to
3 of offenses that are counted towards these 12-913 calls, 3 Section 5-112?
I 4 right?
4 A. 8ecause it causes a faise fire alarm.
5 A. Y
es
s�r, it does. 5 Q. And it's a false fire alarm because why?
6 Q. Fire alarms is down a# i#em P, correct? 6 A. Because there's no fire.
7 A. Yes, it is. 7 Q. Now when #he fiire department responds to these
I 8 Q. And it makes reference io City Ordinarrce 5-1 i2. 8 alarms, if it's a faise alarm, assume they record that
9 Do you see that? 9 in their report, correct?
10 A. Yes, 1 do. 10 A. 1 can't speak to how the fire department
1 Q. So do you agree with me that if it's not a 11 documents their records. I don't know that.
I 12 violation of 5-112, then iYs not a violation of 12-913? 12 Q_ 1Nell, did the polrce respond to these cal�s7
13 A. 1 think, not that 1— in just Lhis review I 9 3 A. in most cases, we do, yes.
14 think that's entirely open to some interpretation, but 14 Q. And when the police respond and iYs a false
15 there's a reference to that ordinance specifically_ 15 alarm, do the polfce record that iYs a faise aiarm?
16 Q_ And wfien you went through and did this audit to 16 A. In most cases, yes.
17 make sure that your 92-913 repo�ting was accurate, did 17 Q. So when we o throu h th r
9 e ecords and look
18 you look at Section 5-113 that de I 9 at
a s with I'm so
r 18
�Y al1 the ones that have b
een �denlified in your 12 913
19 5-112 thaYs referenced in 92-9'!3? 19 s#atistics as false alarms, we'II find someone has
20 A. No, 1 haven'Y. 20 written down in the report "false alarm," correct7
21 Q_ Do you have Section 5 there? 21 A. Yes.
22 A. 1 don't, 1'm sorry.
22 Res ond
enY
s Exhibit No
P 4 marked.)
23 MR. BAER: I'm going to pass one to the 23 MR. BAER: Again, Mc Mayor, if 1 might
24 Council, if we might, Mr Mayor? 24 distribute an exhibit?
25 (Respondeni's Exhibif (Yo. 3 marked.) 25 MAYOR WlLLSON: This will be No. 4, 1
Page 142 Page 144
I MR. BAER: RespondenYs Exhibit 3. 1 assume?
2 BY Mf2. BAER: 2 MR. BRER: This wi11 be No. 4.
3 Q. Have you looked at the second page, please, 3 MAYOR WILLSON: You certainly have prepared
4 Mr. Olson? 4 a lot of documentation_
5 A. I am. 5 MR. CLELtAND: Mc Mayor, I do have an
6 Q. Seciion 5-112 reads, "Tampering With Fire Alarm 6 objection unless the documents are also provided Yo me.
System and Issuing Fa1se Alarms. It shall be unlawful 7 Everything that has been given you has been denied me.
8 for any person to tamper with or in any way interfere 8 MR. BAER: Sorry, Mr. Clelland. I didn't
9 with any element of any fire aiarm system within the 9 mean to overlook you.
I 10 City_ 1{ shall be likewise unlawfu! for any person to 10 MAYOR WItISON: Du(y �ofed. Make sure ou
1i issue or y
cause to
be assued, an alarm of fire or other 11 get copies.
92 emergency condition when no fire or emergency condition 12 SY MR. BAER:
13 exists." Have 1 read it correctly? 13 Q. Showing you whaPs been marked as RespondenPs
14 A. Yes, you have. 14 Exhibit 4. Oflicer Olson, this is the report of 12-913
1 Q. When you did your audit for these 12-913 calfs, 15 calls for Center Pante for August of'07, correct7
16 did you determine whether all of the ones charged to fire 16 A. Yes, it is.
i 7 alarms were in fact a violatio� of Section 5-112? 17 Q. And the firs{ fire alarm designation is report
I 18 A_ Certainly. ThaYs the whole basis of the audit, 18 No. 28, correct?
19 a�d it comes down to a certain amouni of interpretatiork 19 A. Yes, it is.
20 In many cases yau91 see, if you review the i�formation 20 Q. And if we turn to the �ext pages, we see that
21 on those calis #or service, that very often those alarms 21 alongside of each of the darkened heading there's a
I 22 are soundings and malfunction, they are soundi�g as tl �2 number. Those numbers are put there by the police
23 result of improper dryer equipment and other thi
s in 23
9 department, correct.
24 the laundry room, other false alarms that relate to tfie 24 A. Yes, they are.
I 25 alarm system that �eed to be mainiained or other issue 25 Q. And if we go io the page thaYs marked 18 of 52
3b (Pages 14� to 144)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
I 612-339-0545
Public Hearing i0/i/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page i45 Page147
1 we find No. 28, right? 1 an examioatiom of the cails for service every month
2 A. Yes. 2 independenily audited calls for service for August of
3 Q. And here the indication is that #here was bumt 3 2007, and in doing so they had a disagreement. At some
4 iood on a stove? 4 point they arrived at a certain totai. The other member
5 A. Yes, it is. 5 audited ihat document, discussed it wiih the first staff
F Q. Doesn't say false alarm, does iY? 6 member, and they agreed that it actualty ought to reflect
7 A. No, it doesn't_ 7 one more call. That is something that developed since
Q. And in fact, it wasn't a false alarm, was it? 8 the document was provided to Mr_ Cfeila�d.
9 A. No. 8umt fiood would cause smoke artd would th er8 Q. So now come back to my summary. The first
10 �easonably seY off a fire alarm. ThaYs the purpose of 10 column there, "12-913 Calls on Hearing Exhibii," thafs
91 the alarm. 1 i up there, correct, witfi that one exception?
12 Q_ And thaYs something {�at the police department 12 A. Yes.
13 and fire department want to know about? 13 Q_ Second column, "12-g13 Calls on City-Prepared
14 A. Yes, it is. 94 Documents" +s what we found when we went through each of
15 Q. So you can respond to those caits? 9 5 these monthiy reports, such as Exhibit 4, and you told us
16 A. Yes, thaYs right. 16 that you're not surprised ihat there's a difference
7 Q. Do you know how many other times you've 17 between thesemonthly reports and these statistics that
18 indicated that somethi�g was a Section 5-112 violation 18 you provided tonighi, right?
19 but when you go through the reports it's not? 19 A. ThaYs true.
20 A. don't offhand, and I don't know quite frankiy 20 C�. Then the next column in red is the "12-913 'Fire
2i if I agree with the presumptio� that they're not 21 Alarm' Calis on Hearing ExhibiT or on the board that
22 accurate. 22 you put up tonight. And the column after that is the
23 {RespondenYs Exhibif No. 5 marked J 23 "Actua! iJumber of Section 5-� 92 Fire Calls" when we went
24 SY MR. BAER: 24 through and iooked at each oi the monthiy reports and
25 Q. Showing you what's marked as ftespondenYs 25 each oi the fire alarm calis that you recorded. That's
Page 146 Page 148
1 Exfiibit 5. This is a summary chart tfiat my office 1 all we found. 12 total for a year that said "false
2 prepared, Mr. Olson. 2 aiarm."
3 A. Okay. 3 A. Are you asking me a question? I didn't prepare
4 Q. You haven't seen it before, have you? 4 this document. I can't speak to it_
5 A. tVo, 1 haven'Y. 5 Q. Can you exQlain why you have 51 on tfie board and
6 fl. This covers the period from September 2006 fi whafs shown in these monthfy repo�ts is 127
7 through August 2007, a one-year period, correct? 7 A. 1 can #eN you as a recent and direct experience
8 A. It appears Yo. 8 in auditing tMese ca11s for service that there's a
9 Q. And in the first column thaYs red, you'll see 9 certain amount of interpfetation that is necessary, and
10 i 2-99 3 calls on what we refer to as the hearing exhibit, 10 +n cases whe�e staff is required to intefpret, we
11 because the report fhat you puf up there actually appears 11 interpret it in a conservative ma�ner, meaning we give
12 as part of Mr. CleJland's Exhibit 9. IYs the very last 12 the benefii of the doubt to the property. So as an
13 page of Mr. Clelland's Exhibit 9. Let me show it to you 13 example and I don't mean to answer this i� kind of a
14 since you didn't prepare it, sir. ThaYs ihe same as 14 roundabout way but I almost have to to be fair if we
15 the, as the slide you put up on The board, right? 15 respond, say, to a�oise compiaint, a loud stereo, and
16 A. It's not identical. It's very close. There's 16 officers ar�ive a�d we don't find the loud stereo, we
17 one statistica! difference that 1 see just in evaluating 17 don't count that as a disturbance caU. We only count
'18 it very quickly. 18 those ca!!s fhat we can validate through that audit base i
19 Q. Which difference is thai? 19 on the information i� the dispatchi�g recard. There are
20 A. Total cails for service on this document lists 20 a considerable number of instances where tfiere's not
21 as 873. On that document it lists as 874. 21 enough information to come to a fair conclusion tha# a
22 Q. Do you know why that would be different? Why 22 call ought to count, and again in those cases we provide
23 Mr. Clelland has something different in his book than 23 the be�efit of the doubt to the property. In this case,
24 what you put up on the board? 24 1 think, and 1 ca� tel! you in auditing these cads, I
25 A. I understand that the staff members that condu� t25 may audit caUs and three days later look at that imme�, ;e
37 (Pages 145 to i48)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page I49 Page 151
1 pile of data and arrive a# a different total because 1 Q. And she told you that she wouid gather the rest
2 there's a certain amount of g�ay area, so to speak. 2 of the information as required by the ordinance but it
3 Q. And the gray area here shows that if you reduce 3 was going to take her some time to get that orga�ized,
4 to the number of calis where the city reported false 4 right?
5 alarm as opposed to this audit process, you end up with 5 A. Yes, she did.
6 322 total calls as opposed to 18a that the city insists 6 Ci. And your response was we appreciate the
7 on? 7 cooperation. As long as you get them done, we're fine?
8 A. That's correct. 8 A_ Absoiutely.
9 Q. Which means statisticaAy when you do the math, 9 MAYOR WILLSON: Mr. Baer?
10 the 12-913 calis per unit is .48 as opposed to your .71, i0 MR. BAER: Yes, sir.
11 right? i 1 MAYOR WILLSON: tvts. Todd, ase you the new
12 A_ t see that �eflected here. 1 don't know that 12 manager in this compiex?
13 it's mathematicatly accurate. 1 have no reason to thinl 13 MS. TODD_ I'm one o# the new managers,
14 iYs noi, but i don't know that. i4 yes.
5 MR. BAER: We offer RespondenYs 15 MAYOR WILLSON: How many new managers are
16 Exhibits 2, 3, 4 and 5. 16 there?
1 MR_ CLELIAND: No objeciion. i 7 MS_ TODD: Two.
8 MAYOR WILLSON: So noted. 18 MAYOR WILLSON: Who is the other one?
9 MR. BAER: (To member af audience) DonY 19 MS. TODD: My husband, who was sitting to
20 leave. Come back for jusY one minute, please_ 20 the left of ine but had to teave unfortunately.
21 SY MR. $AER: 2i MAYOR WItISON: Okay_ Thank you.
22 Q. O�cer Olson do you know who this person is? 22 COUNCIL MEMBER RYAN: Mr. Mayor?
23 A. Yes, vue met_ 23 MAYOR WiLLSON: Covncil Member Ryan.
24 Q. When did you meet? 24 COUNCI� MEMBER RYAN: Could you give me his
25 A. We met in person. 25 full name?
Page I 50 Page 52
1 THE WITNESS: Was it eariier this week or 1 MS. TODD: Randy. Same last name.
2 late last week? 2 COUNCIL MEMBER RYAN: Thank you.
3 MS. TODD: last week. 3 MS. TODD: You're weicome.
4 A. 1t was late last week. 4 MR. BAER: May 1 proceed?
5 Q. Who is sfie? 5 COUNCIL MEMBER RYAN: Yes, sir. Thank you.
6 A. ThaYs Patricia Todd. 6 BY MR. BAER:
7 Q. Who is Patricia Todd7 7 Q. O#ficer Olson, the last thing i want to talk
8 A. She is a�liated with the management company 8 with you about is Tab 7 in Mr. CleUand's book, and I
9 that 1 understand is in the process of being contractec 9 think you kept referring to it as criminal and
10 with to take over managemenY functions of the proper yl0 problematic behavior_ O� criminal and problematic
11 Q_ And did you talk with her about these tenant 11 activities.
"!2 registnes that you testified about earlier? 92 A. Is Tab 7 the letters, the sequence of letters
13 A. Yes. 13 thatlsent?
94 Q. At�d the substance of that conversation was that 14 Q. They are.
15 Ms. Todd indicated she knew that you wanted them, 15 A. Thank you.
16 correct? 16 Q. Arn 1 remembering your words right?
17 A. ThaYs correct. 17 A. Yes, i think so.
18 Q. She had looked at tfie ordinance and knew what 18 Q. Because included in these letters is not just
19 was required, correct? 19 criminal behavior, right?
20 A. I don't know thaf she looked at the ordinance, 20 A. Yes.
21 but we had a conversation about wMat was required ai �81 Q. 8ut what you define as problematic behavior?
22 what isn't_ 22 A. TfiaYs correct.
23 Q. She brought you some information but not 23 Q. Which mea�s behavior that no one could be
24 everything required in the ordinance, correct? 24 arrested for, right?
25 A. That's correct. 25 A. 1n, in many instances thaYs true, yes.
38 (Pages 149 to i 52)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing IOJI/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 153 Page155
1 Q. And even many insYances what you're calling 1 A. ThaYs certainiy tMe decision the property owner
2 criminal behavior in ihese reports is stuff that no one 2 has Yo make.
3 was arrested for, rigMt? 3 Q. Now you mentioned Mr. Heriz in your prior
4 A. Yeah, thaYs correct. 4 testimony_ One of the things tfiat you and Mr. Hertz
5 Q. Part of the thinking of the City and the police 5 talked about was whether some of these folks should be
6 department in providing these reports in Tab 7 to Center 6 evicfed, rigfit?
7 Pointe was the hope that Center Pointe would do something 7 A_ Oniy in terms #hat he had indicated he is going
8 about these people that are identified in the letters, 8 to, he's i�terested in the information and the material
9 correct? 9 in the IeYters. He didn't ask for my opinion about who
10 A. Yes, sir. 10 needs to be evicted and who doesn't, if thai's what
11 Q. And in particular, what you were hoping is that 11 you're sugges#ing.
12 Center Pointe would either threaten to or actually evict i 2 Q_ I wasn't suggesting anything other Yhan one oi
13 ihese peoQle so that they no longer lived at Center 13 the things you talked to Mr. Hertz about was evicling
14 Pointe? 14 some of these tenants, correct?
15 A. No, i don't think thaYs a fair 15 A. Yes.
1& characferizat+on, no. 18 Q. And INr. Hertz said #hat on behalf of the
7 Q. Well, ce�tainly, even if it's only problematic 17 property owner he was prepared to go to court and bring
18 befiavio�, the police have the ability to give a stem 18 eviction aciions against some of these people thai you
19 lecture, right? 19 had identified as probiematic or criminal behavior,
20 A. Wel�, certainly it's something we would like, 20 righi?
21 but we have no autt�ority to make them comply with the 29 A. He told me he was in Yhe process of determining
22 rental ag�eement or the property ordinance. 22 whefher he had anything to work with_
23 Q. And you don't have any authority Yo require the 23 Q. And one of the things that he asked about was
24 property owner to comply with the rental agreement? 24 whether tfie police department would have its officers
25 A. I don't believe we do, no. 25 come down to tfie courthouse and give testimony to support
Page 154 Page I56
1 Q. So these are suggestions to the property owner 1 ihese incidents that are speNed out in the letters as io
2 to do what about this problematic behavior? Punish these 2 why these people ought to be punished in some fashion,
3 people in some way?
3 evicted or otheraise, right?
4 A. No, they are, thaYs information provided to the 4 A. Yes, he expressed an interest in that.
5 property owners so that they can effectively manage thei4 5 Q. And the City said we can'i do that?
6 property by enforcing the terms of the lease in the 6 A. The City d"+dn't say any such thing.
7 renfaf agreement. 7 Q. Did you send your officers?
8 Q. And the way Yhat they would enforce it is by 8 A. Na, refe�red him to Lieutenant Benner. 1
9 evicting these people, correct? 9 informed him that there's a procedure that he has to
10 A. Not necessarily. 10 compiy with to subpoe�a civil wit�esses and that 1 wasn't
11 Q. What else? WMen you say enforce the terms of 11 involved in lhat process or the decision making behind
92 Yhe rental agreement, what are you referring to? 12 i{. He was provided Lieutenant 8eoner's name, his
13 A. They can issue tenant warnings, they can counsel 13 telephone number and, as I understand it, he never
14 residents about their activities and in#orm them that 14 contacted Lieutenant Benner.
15 they're problematic, they can set mioimum expectations ��f15 Q. As you understand it from Lieutenant Benner?
i6 their tenants, and these are certainly things that are 16 A. ThaYs correct_
97 within the purview of Yhe property owner, fhe 17 Q. So you're saying
18 responsibility of the property owner, and well beyond the 18 A. Nobody associated with the property has asserted
19 authority that the government and the police depa�tme�t 19 othernise ever since.
20 fias. 20 Q. The Ciiy fiad no idea of these eviction actions,
27 Q. They can give them a stem lecture, say "don't 21 is that your testimony?
22 do that again"? 22 A. 1 understood fhat he was interested in pursuing
23 A. At a minimum, yes. 23 eviction actions. I don't know wfiai ou mean that 1 had
Y,
24 Q. And the "or else" is "or else you'!! get 24 intimate knowledge about each actio� he was entertaining'
25 evicted," right? 25 Q_ Are you aware as you sit here today, sir, thaY
39 (Pages 153 to 15b)
Paradigm Reporting Captioriing Inc.
E� i 2-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 157 Page 159
1 Center PoinYe, during 2007, sought to evict some of these 1 bring witnesses to bear after that, how much additiona!
2 tenants you idenf+fied in these letters that are part of 2 time he th7nks he's going to need as wei1, and the� this
3 Tab 7? 3 body is going to have to determine where we go from there
4 A. i'm aware thai he reached agreements with 4 based on those iwo a�swers.
5 several, evicted severa! others, iotaling some five whicl i 5 MR. CIE�LAND: if view of the hour, i'm
6 he's provided documentatio� on, and as you can see fn �m6 going to make my examination of Mr. Martin as quickly as
7 the letters, there are dozens of people who have been 7 possible and efficiently as possible. I would fike to
8 identified as engaging +n either criminal or problematic 8 fiinish with Mr_ Martin in about 15 minutes or so_ That
9 behavior that vioiates the lease. 9 will conc�ude that, plus the final offer of these
10 Q. Do you know how ma�y of ihose people are still 10 documents, wiil conclude the stafF's presentation_ 1
11 living at Center Pointe? 31 don't personally have an objection fo a recess then if
12 A_ 1 don't know that, no_ 1 do know that some who 12 there's going to be any lengthy prese�tation by the
1 s have been identified in those letters are still there. 13 owners. Given tfie fact that with cross-examination, I
14 Q. And you would agree, because you said a minute 14 suspect this wi11 take us past 10:30.
15 ago, you were�'t saying they should all be evicted, 15 MAYOR WILLSON: Mr. Baer?
16 right? 16 MR. BAER: See, Mr. Cielland and I do agree
17 A. No, it would be my #eeling, my personal position 17 on something. 1 expect the cross-examination wiil be
18 that they need to be dealt with effectively. 18 past 10:30 with Mr. Martin, and i do have, even without
19 Q. Do you know if ihey were? i 9 that, probabty an hour or better with the witnesses thai
20 A. 1 can't speak to thai as 1 sit here, no. 20 I intended to caN. Frankly, I think that, given the
21 Q. All you know is tfiat some of them are sti11 21 hour, it would be my preference to break after the
22 livi�ag there, correct? 22 current witness is finished ar�d Mr. Clelland has finished
23 A. That's correct. 23 his case and reschedule to come back another time. If
24 Q. But some of them are gone, right? 24 gets late and people aren't as sharp as they should be,
25 A. Certainly some are, yes_ 25 includ+ng me, so I would appreciate that indulgence.
Page 158 Page 160
1 Q. Some af them were evicted, you know ihat? 1 MAYOR WItLSON: Well, we might actually be
2 A. 1 don't know that they were literally evicted or 2 done at 10:30, 11, I'm looking #or direction from the
3 they reached agreements, you know, as a specifiic leg, i� 3 body saying should we hear the nex# witness, go through
4 process, an unlawful detainer necessarily, but 1 do kn� �w4 cross, and then determine after that when we begin for
5 they displaced some of the tenants or the tenants cho >e5 Mr. Baer, and i'm not sure which term you used, the other
6 to leave. 6 side give their part.
7 MR. BAER: Excuse me, Mr. Mayor. 7 COUNCIL MEMBER O'CONNOR: I would agree
8 Mr. LeFevere, did I get Exhibit 5 in? 8 with that.
9 MR. �EFEVERE: Yes. 2, 3, 4, 5 a11 9 COUNCiI. MEMBER RYAN: I have no objection
10 together. 10 to that, Mr_ Mayor_
19 MR. BAER: Thank you, sir. I have nothing 11 MAYOR WItLSON: Then the only other wrinkls
12 further for this witness. 12 probably is that when we meet again, we probably should
13 MR. C�ELLAND: 1 have no redireci. We can 93 think about that a liYtie bit as we're going through
74 proceed with our last witness tonight, �arry Martin. 14 testimony. i would hope that we could pull it together
15 {Witness excused.) 15 fairly quickfy, say Wednesday or Thursday perhaps even,
16 MAYOR WILLSON: Before we start, I would 16 to keep the process going.
9 7 like to fake a five-minu#e break. 17 MR. LEFEVERE: I'll be out for the rest of
18 (Break taken from 9:44 io 9:51 p.m.) 18 the week.
19 MAYOR WILLSON: If we're ready, I have a 19 MAYOR WIILSON: So we'il be looking into
20 couple of procedural fhings I would like to discuss 20 next week probably?
21 first. Mr. CIelland, we have about an hours worth of 29 MR. CtELLAND: Excuse me, and 1 wiil be out
22 time left per Cou�cil policy where we don't go past 11:00 22 next week. That is also your regular meeting, I tMink.
23 in the evening unless we take some extraordinary action, 23 MAYOF2 WILLSON: Yes, it is.
24 so I'm going to ask how long you think you stiN require 24 MR. CLELLAND: And 1 think it's appropriate
25 and then dovetail that with asking Mr. Baer, who also can 25 you have this on a nonmeeti�g night given your other
40 (Pages 157 to i 60)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-4545
Public Hearing 10/1>2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
1 agenda. �age l61 Page 163
1 Mr. Clelland?
2 MAYOR WILLSON: i agree, but !'m not
2 MR. C�ELLAND: Has Mr. Martin been sworn?
3 opposed to any other night of the week. 3
LAR
RY M
A
4 MR CLELIAND: 1 will be gone next week. RTIN,
4 duly swom, was examined and testified as foltows=
5 You're out ihe rest oI this week, Chariie? 5
6 MR. YELICH: Mr. Baer mentioned he had DiRECT EXAMINATION
7 another fiour with witnesses or testimony? 6 8Y MR. CLELLAND:
Q. Mr. Martin, you ara the building official for
MAYOR WILLSON: Once we ge# through the 8 the City of Brooklyn Center, is that correct?
9 next witness, you think you have an hour or so?
10 9 A. ThaYs correct.
MR. BAER: Or so. And ii's a little hard 10 Q. Describe briefly tha duYies of the buildi�g
11 for me to guess until I hear what the next witness has to 13 officiai?
12 say, bui I would anticipate it wouid be at least an hour
12 A. 1'm charged with the resoonsibilitiP� f4�
1:s atter we get through with this witness. 13 adminisYrating the state building codes and city
14 MR. YELICH: Given the constraints, I
14 ordinances as they pertain to building and housing
15 wouldn't be opposed to going to 1'1:30 as opposed to 95 maintenance.
16 waiting two weeks. 16 Q. That would include
7 MAYOR WILLSON: I tend to agree, rather 9 7 A. 1'm sor
�8 than waitin a Ion ry, and then as of June the 1st, we were
g g period of time in tryi�g to finish up 18 assigned with enforcing code compiiance #hroughout tl�e
19 the, both sides this evening, but thai does mean that we 19 city.
20 have to take an action to go past our 1 L00. Is there
21 any other discussion? Anyone else want to offer an Z� Q �'nor #o the transfer of code compliance
22 opinion?
29 comprehensively to Community Development, if was the
23 22 responsibility of tfie police, is that correct?
COUNCIL MEMgER O'CONNOR: 1 would rather do 23 A. That is correc{.
24 what you said originally, just to end after Ihe next 24 Q_ And that had been the situation for a number of
25 witness and then reschedule.
25 years, is that corract?
Page 162 Page 164
COUNCiL MEMBER RYAN: Council Member 1 A. Tha#'s correct_
2 O'Connor, I had heard eariier that you had not bee� 2
3 feeling we11. If thaPs a consideration Q- Showing you in the book before the Council at
4 COUNCiI MEMBER O'CONNOR: No, thaYs not 4 af O t ber, 2006, do you see that?rders dated the 5th
5 true.
5 A. Yes, sir.
6 COUNCIL MEMBER RYAN: Oka I was ust 6
Y 1 Q. Were these issued after a unit-by-unit
7 concerned that you were doing a11 right, but I'm
7 inspection of Cente� Pointe?
8 concerned about it being puf off. �f we can go through, 8 A. These do a
9 pefiaps that wouid be better, rather than having it set 9 issued, yes, p�ear to be tfie orders that were
10 off another coupie of weeks. Perhaps we couid take a 10 Q. You personally participated in and supervised
11 witness and then Mr. Baer, if you were kind enough, if 11 that inspection, is thai correct?
12 you could give us another estimate of time, if you '!2 A. Yes, sir.
i 3 encounter issues that you think might extend the 13 Q. And even though there was subs#antial compliance
14 proceedings, perhaps we couJd reconsider and have to go 14 by Center Pointe, on the 15th of November you issued
15 to a, into a recess. 15 additional compliance orders, is that correct?
16 MAYOR WILLSON: Weli, I would offer
16 A. Yes, sir.
17 midnight as a#ime. 17 Q. Were these issued as a condition of the license?
COUNCIL MEMSER RYAN: As an absolute? 18 A. No, they were, we basicail
19 MAYOft WILLSON: If we're done sooner than 19 days per compliance order. We were on tt+�
20 that, good. Then we go up to midnight 20
2 j MR. LEFEVERE: Counsei, see what it looks 21 D cembe� t address the ssu s from nal notice
22 like as you get closer to 11, or after staff is done with 22 that were sent ouY 15 Novembe�.
23 their case, and maybe get a better idea then about how 23 Q. And this docume�t speaking
24 everybody feels and where you are. 24 A. Let me refer you back to this compliance date of
25 MAYOR WIILSON: Lefs do that.
25 8 December.
4 i(Pages 161 to 164)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 165 Page 167
a Q. So the lasf two pages of Exhibit 2 are 1 A_ As of today I do not know if that work was
2 compiiance orders to Center PoinYe specificaily addressed
2 com leted.
3
fo H der
Jaweed the
Y 15th of N
ovembe�, 2006, with a 3 Q. But you knew by the middle of May 2007 it was
4 comptiance date of the 8ifi oi December, 2006?
4 not compieted?
S A. Yes, sir. 5 A. Yes, sir.
6 Q. What did the Jaweeds do that initialty appeared 6 Q. Showing you Tab 3, is this the compliance
7 to be compliance with this set of orders? 7 monitoring by the Minnesota Housing Finance dated the
A. 7hey had, from what i recall, they had addressed 8 23rd of May 2007?
9 aii but a few issues, and whai they provided me with ai 9 A. Yes, it is.
10 Yhe time was contracts showing intent that they would i0 Q. What does this document represent?
11 address the remaining four, five items thaf they had 11 A. it represents an inspection, compliance
12 outsianding_ 12 inspection {hat was conducted by tfie M;�nPC�ta u.,,,�;
3 Q. What were those four or five ifems outstanding? 13 Finance.
14 A. They were replace some garage doors, make some 14 Q. Do they co�duCk essenYiaily the same
15 structurai repairs to the garages, repair, repiace some 15 unit-by-unit inspection that you had?
16 ofi the exterior stucco covering_ They had a coniractor 16 A. No, they do the, 1 donY know what �umbers they
17 come i» and address some roof issues, and there was som 17 use, buY it appeared to be a spot inspection.
18 caulking that needed to be completed. 18 Q. In fact, they don't inspect tfie entire premises?
9 Q. Did they ever submit io you a roof maintenance 19 A. No, they do not.
20 pian?
20 Q. T
21 A. Noi a roof maintena�ce plan, but tfiey did submii 21 A. F�'om what i unde {a yyESPected 20 percent?
22 a documeni showing that they did hire a third party to 22 Q. Does this documenY set forth the housing
23 come out and inspect the roofs and conduct some repair. 23 maintenance violations determined by MNFA, the state
24 Q. Now with regard to ihose contractors that they 24 a enc
25 had hired and the coniracts that you've seen, did that g Y
25 A. It does.
Page 166 Page i68
1 work ever take place? 1 MR. CLELLAND: Offer 3 and 4, Mr. Mayor.
2 A. Yes and no. 2 Excuse me, 2 and 3, Mr. Mayor.
3 Q. What did not take place? 3 MAYOR WILLSON: Mr. Baer?
4 A. As of May, 1 believe it was earfy in May 1 had 4
MR. BAER: We have no objection with
5 contacted the overhead garage door company that they ha< 5 respect to Exhibit 2, other than the one that we've
6 submitted a contract, and tfiat work fiadn't bee� completed 6 already lodged, and believe Tab 2 has already been
7 yet. 7 admitted previously. Our objection to it is that it was
Q. Had it even started? 8 effectively ruled out by the Council's action in January
9 A. The work had oot started, nor had the contracto� 9 when a new license was granfed under the ordinance. As
0 been contacted to come back out or� site. That contract, 10 to Tab 3, we object 6ecause there is nothing in the
11 1 believe, was signed end of November_ 13 City's ordinances that require compliance by Center
12 Q'06? 12 PoinYe with MHFA rules and regulations.
13 A. Middle to the end of November of'06, yes, sir. �3
14 Q. And by May '07 that work had not et been MR. CLELLAND: Actually thaYs no# true.
Y 14 Your ordinances have a general, overall stipulation that
�5 started? 15 owners must abide by afl state and city laws.
18 A. To the best of my knowledge, no_ 16 MR. BAER: And Yhe MHFA is neither the
Q. Did you speak with those contractors that 17 sfate nor the city_
18 purportedly had been hired? 18 MAYOR WILLSON: 1 believe it's state or
19 A. t did speak with the garage door company, tfie 19 federal, if 1 recaU correctly. Duly noied.
20 contractors. 20 COUNCIL MEMBER O'CONNOR: Mr. Mayor?
21 Q. And were they eve� notified by tfie owners to do 2�
MAYOR WILLSON: Council Member O'Connor.
22 ihis work? 22 COUNCIL MEMBER O'CONNOR: What kind of an
23 A. No. 23 agency is this Minnesofa Housing Finance Agency?
24 Q. Does that work, to the best of your knowledge, Zq
MR. CtELLAND: I can have a witness testify
25 remain unfi�ished today? 25 to Yhis. It monitors the property to see that the
42 (Pages 165 to 168)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
L_
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 169 Page 171
1 property is in complia�ce with codes so thaY the tax 1 coniained a twapage attachment cailed Descrip#ion of
2 credits remain in effect. Any propertias that have ihe 2 Votation of Ordinance section, correct?
3 tax credit, iPs my understanding, have to comply with 3 A. Yes, sir.
4 siata laws and city codes. To the extent ihey're out of 4 Q. Are those the very things that were ordered Io
5 compliance, that may jeopardize the tax credits_ 5 be corrected in the February orders that were not
s COUNCIL MEMBER O'CONNOR: Are they state 6 cor�ected?
7 tax credits7 7 A. Yes, it would just be a repeat of the previous.
8 MR. CLE�LAND: I think staie and federal. 8 Q. it wasn't a new inspeciion?
9 I don't know about their reporting, but I believe they 9 A. 1t was not a new one.
10 would report to the IRS as weli. They have an 10 Q. Now when the compfiance date of the 25th of
11 i�dependent oversight, which is why separate from city 11 Apni came, what level of compliance did you and your
12 they conducted this inspeclion of Cenier Pointe. i2 staff determine?
13 BY MR_ CLEItAND: 13 A. My staff determi�ed there was stiil some
14 Q. Now referring to Tab 4, are these a senes of 14 ou#sta�ding issues, I believe one page.
15 compiiance orde�s that you caused to be issued to Hyder 15 Q. Entitled Descriptions of Violations of Ordinance
16 Jaweed? 16 section.
17 A. Yes. 17 A. And a compliance date was set fior April 30th.
1$ Q. Could you, looking at the entire exhibit, 18 Q. What was The result of the inspections afler the
19 describe the chronofogy, both as to why these inspections 19 30th of April with regard to these continu+ng vioiations?
20 took place, what violations were shown, what levels of 20 A. There was a discussion between the maintenance,
21 compiiance and rroncompliance were determined? 21 from whaY I understand, a discussion between maintena�a
22 A. These were, fhis inspectio� was initiated based 22 staff on the property and my housing inspector. Tfiey had
23 off of some complaints tfie Community Development direct >Q3 asked for an extension.
24 at the t+me had received from the police department 24 Q. Do you know if these violations have been
25 After meeting with them, it was determi�ed tfiat we should 25 corrected after ihe due dates of late Aprit?
Page 170 Page 172
1 conduct a walk-through o# the common areas. 1 A_ They were_
2 Q. The first compGancB order issued by your 2 Q. Corrected, however, not according to the terms
3 department is the 21st of February 2007, correct? 3 of tfie original February order?
4 A. ThaYs CorreCt. 4 A_ No, sir. As far as the time frame.
5 Q. And there are several pages ofi identified code 5 Q. Okay. Whai perso�at contact have you had wim
6 violations that you and your statf determined at Ifiat 6 Asgher Jaweed and Hyder Jaweed regarding their
7 time, is that correCt? 7 imolveme�t in the property and their decision making and
8 A. ThaYs not correct. It was my staff. 8 their �epresentation as being owners?
9 Q. All right. Persons working under your 9 A. Just from casual conversation. During ihe
10 direction? 90 November inspection Hyder Jaweed waiked around the
11 A. Yes, sir_ 11 exierior of Yhe site with me. did have Mr. Jaweed's
12 Q. Persons you know to be Competent inspectors? 12 cell phone number where I could contaci him if we had
i 3 A. I believe Yhey are. 13 housing mai�tenance issues out there, which 1 had used o�
14 Q. Okay. Then a compliance date was set for the 14 several occasions when we weren't getti�g any response
15 Sth of March, 2007? 15 from ihe staff on site.
16 A. That's correct. 16 Q. The last nine pages of Exhibit 5 represent a
17 Q. What level of complia�ce and noncompliance did 17 criminal complaint that you signed against Hyder Jaweed
1$ you and your staff dete►mine after that? 18 for no�compliance wiih these code violations and
19 A. My staff had determined after a reinspection on 19 compliance orders, is that correct?
20 the Sth that some of the work had been completed, no 20 A. ThaYs correct.
21 all, and therefore orders were sent out again are 21 Q. Okay.
22 these chronologica! on April 17th. There was an 22 MR. CLELLAND: Offer 4 and the uno#fered
23 inspection, I would assume, within a day or two prior t�3 poRion of 5.
24 that date. 24 MR. BAER: I have no objection io 4. We do
25 Q. TMe compliance order daied the 17th of Apri4 25 object to 5 on ihe basis previously stated, which is
43 (Pages 169 to 172)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 173 Page 175
1 these criminai complaints are aBegations and not proven 1 in, according to City records, when was the last time in
2 facts and they shouid not be offered as evidence. 2 2006 ihat the Center PoinTe owners paid the City for any
3 MAYOR WILLSON: �fhank you. Enter 4 and S. 3 utilities?
4 BY MR. CIELLAND: 4 A. I betieve it was September of 2006.
5 Q_ In Tab 6, after the Notice af Abatement, as part 5 Q. You became aware that the Center Po+nte owners
6 of a plan for addressing issues there is another 6 then brought the utiiities curre�t during the fiist week
7 compliance order from your compliance officiat, John 7 oi August 2007, is that correct?
8 Rued, dated the 30th of April 2007 without a compGance 8 A. ThaYs correct.
9 date, and a two-page attachment, is that correct? 9 Q< Looking at the last six or seven pages, are
10 A. That is correct i 0 these cash receipts from the City of Brookiyn Center as a
11 Q_ There's a fax here from John Rued dated 6/8l07 11 public and business record dated 8/7/2007?
12 to Asgher. Explain that, piease. 12 A_ They do appear #o be, sir.
13 A. These were the outstandi�g, these were what w i93 Q. Does this document the payments?
14 ieft of the outstanding items from the February 14 A_ Yes.
15 inspection, and Mr. Rued faxed these items to Asgher otfi Q_ Is it true that by the time payment was made in
16 6/8107. 16 Augusi 2007, that Center Pointe owed ihe City more than
17 Q. Does that indicate to you that these items were 17 $76,fl00 in deGnquent utiiities?
i 8 stiii uncorrected by 6/8/07? 18 A. It was.
9 A. Yes, they were. 19 MR. CIELLAND: Offer those pages of 6,
20 MR_ CLEILAND: Offer these po�tions of 20 Mr. Mayor; the last 10 or 12 pages.
21 Exhibit 6, Mr. Mayor_ 21 MR. BAER: Mr. Mayor, it would be easier
22 MR. BAER: Same objections as previously 22 for me to make an objection or not if I knew whaY exactiy
23 stated with respect to Exhibit 6. 23 Mr. Gelland was of#ering.
24" MAYOR WILLSON: Thank you, duly noted. Is 24 MR. C�ELLAND: We're offering the records
25 ifiat all of 6 ihen? 25 of payment that show that on the 7th of August, 2t?07, the
Page I74 Page 176
1 MR. CLELLAND: Yes, it would include all of 1 delinquent utility bills to the City were finally paid.
2 6. There's one more portion I wili provide #estimony. 2 MAYOR WILLSON: And thaYs in item 10?
3 BY MR. CLELLAND: 3 MR. CLELLAND: ThaYs in item 6, and is ihe
4 Q. Were you aware that the owners were delinquent 4 last
5 in tfie CenterPoint Energy natural gas payments? 5 MAYOR V1/ILLSON: portion of 10, I assume?
6 A. I was aware somebody was delinquent, yes, sir. 6 MR. CLELIAND: Yeah, iYs the last ten
7 Q. How did thai come to your attention? 7 pages of Exhibit 6 that shows the receipts of payment To
8 A. We started receiving calls in our office from 8 CenterPoint Energy and the City_
9 the tenants. 9 MR_ BAER: As to the Iast ten pages of
1D Q. Cails to what extent? 10 Exhibit 6, Respondent does not have any objeciion.
11 A. Calls from, 1 don't recall whether they were 19 8Y MR. CLELLAND:
92 served notices or just word of mouth tfiaY the utilities 12 Q. Did you, at my request, review the City records
13 were, the gas in particular was going to be shut down otii shown here, the first page of Exhibit 1D, showing an
14 the property. 14 unpaid bond administration fee?
15 Q. Did Kenneth Her#z, one of the Jaweed attorneys, 15 A. 1 did.
16 fax to the City a payment receipt dated 8/8/2007 showing 16 Q. And this last city invoice of 5/31/2007 showing
17 a paymen# to CenterPoint Gas of $69,197.50? 17 a balance due of 8,181.25?
98 A. I believe that was the payment. 1 am not aware 18 A. It is, yes.
19 of who it was from. 19 MR. CLELLAND: Offer page 1 ofi Exhibii 10
20 Q. Did you, at my request, review the deli�quent 20 and the remainder of records in Exhibit 10.
21 bills on behaif of what is owed by Center Pointe to the 21 MR. 8AEf2: No objection, Mr. Mayor_
22 City of Brooklyn Center for unpaid sewer and water 22 MAYOR WILLSON: Duly noted.
23 utilities? 23 BY MR. CLELLAND:
24 A. 1 did, sir. 24 Q. Mr. Martin, did i ask you to review at Tab 11 a
25 Q. Referring to the record at Tab 10, third page 25 letter Notice of Defiault addressed to Brooklyn Center
44 {Pages 173 to 176)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 177 Page 179
1 Leased Housing Associates Limited Partnership from the 1 commonatity is it's the Jaweeds, and these properties
2 attomey at Oppenhe+mer for the trustee? 2 suffer from the same deplorable conditions as does Center
3 A. You did, sir. 3 Pointe, and there is a concept in criminal Iaw cailed
4 Q. Just Iooking at this, assuming and accepting it 4 Spreigei evidence where courts do allow evidence of other
5 at #ace value, this is a demand for payment by them and a 5 offenses and r.�imes to show various things such as lack
S notice o# default, is that correct? 6 of inadvertence, iack of mistake, common scheme or pian,
7 A. ThaYs what if appeared to be. 7 common plan of action, motive, intent and fhe like. What
8 MR. CLELLAND: Ali nght. O�fer 11, 8 it shows is, and this is the purpose for which it's
9 tvlr. Mayor_ 9 offered, is Center Pointe suffers from the problems
10 MR. BAER: No objection to 11. 10 because the Jaweeds wiil not operate their properties in
11 MR_ CLELIAND: Mc Mayor, as a matter of 11 conformity with law, and these are recent examples of
12 public record, i offer 92, which is a decision and a 12 sister eommunities, and I trusk the veracity of the
13 matter of record of the City of Minneapolis Licensing 13 public o�ciais who dealt with fhose problems there.
14 Board revoking the re�tal dwelling license held by an LLC 14 Now in accepting it you can decide to give +t any weighY
15 in which tfie Jaweeds are principals at 729 8th Avenue 15 you wa�t; you can give it great weight, you can give it
16 Southeast in the City of Minneapolis for �ontinuing drug 16 no weight. I'm just asking you to receive it and reserve
17 activity, and 1 offer as 13 documen#s comprising public 17 for yourself the right to determine if you find #his is
18 records received from the City of Robbinsdale regarding 18 relevant in your consideration of Yhis issue.
39 property in whicM Jaweeds are principals commonly k�own 19 MR. BAER: Mr_ Cieiland managed to mix two
20 as Robinwood. These are public records. I didn't have 20 interesting issues there. O� the one hand he wants io
21 the opportunity to have officials from the City of 21 tatk about Spreigel evidence tha# can be used in a
22 Minneapoiis attend here tonight, but they are public 22 criminal proceeding; on the other hand, he wants to iell
23 records that were fumished to us and they're clearly 23 you you don't actuaily need evidence, I can just give you
24 admissible. 24 this because i trust the guys over in the next city. If
25 MAYOR �1VILLSON: And those were numbers? 25 this were a crimir�ai proceedi�g where the concept of
Page 178 Page180
i MR. CLELLAND: It would be 12 and 93. 1 Spreigel evidence wouid be appiicable, we would�'t have
2 MAYOR WILLSON_ Okay. 2 done many of the things we've done here tonight. The
3 MR. BAER: Mr. Mayor, I made reference to 3 accused would have had an opportunity to know exactly
4 these in my opening this evening, and 1 still object to 4 what it was they are being charged with, and #haY hasn't
5 these. First, there's no foundatfon for #hem. Second, 5 happened. The accused would have an opportunity to
6 even if there were foundation, they are noi releva�t to 6 cross-examine anyone who's going to offer evidence, and
7 any issue before the Council. They don't deal with 7 that hasn't happened. So to suggest somehow that because
8 Center Pointe, they don't dea! with Brooklyn Center 8 there's a rule of evidence in a criminal proceeding thai
9 Leased liousing Associates, and they weren't provided to 9 this ought to come in ignores the fact that you have not
10 me by Mr. Clelland despite my specific requesi ihat he 10 afforded my rights of my clients, the rights that would
11 provide me wi#h the evidence #hat he intended to use 11 be afforded to them i� any civil proceeding, much less a
12 tonight. 12 criminai proceeding.
13 MR_ CLE�IAND: They're relevant because 13 MAYOR WILLSON: We'll enter them into the
14 MR. BAER: And 14 record. 12 and 13.
15 MR. CLELLAND: Excuse me. 15 MR. CLEL�AND: i have no further questions
16 MR. BAER: These are actions, or 16 of Mr. MaRin then.
'17 allegaTions in some instances, by other municipalities 17 MAYOR W1�LSON: Mr. Baer, 1 believe you can
18 that have nothing to do with the property that we're here 18 cross.
'!9 to discuss. And if #his is an attempt, and I believe it 19 MR. BAER: Thank you, sir.
20 to be so, by Mr. Clelland to simply smear people that are 20 CftOSS-EXAMINATION
21 associated with Center Pointe and suggest that somehow 21 BY MR. BAER:
22 because they aliegedly misbehaved before {hey must be 22 Q. Mr. Martin, are the utilities paid now?
23 misbehaving now, that is improper and it should no1 be 23 A. don't know, sir.
24 admitted. 24 Q. You didn't check that before you came here
25 MR. C�ELLAND: My response is the 25 tonigh2?
45 (Pages 177 to 180)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 181 Page 183
3 A. No, didn't. 1 A. You know, sir, quite frankly 1 wouldn't care_
2 Q. Mr. Clelland didn't ask you to find out? Z My job has been to enforce the state building codes a id
3 A_ No, he didn't. 3 buiiding housing main#enance ordinances.
4 Q. So you can tell us the utilities weren't paid 4 Q. Okay_ So whether they were paying the bond,
5 when, back in May? 5 that wasn't
6 A_ 1 believe it was back in May/June time frame. fi A. The building development director deals with
7 Q. And you know that they were brought current at 7 those issues.
8 that point? 8 Q. Okay. I was confused because Mc Clelland
9 A. At one point i had been led to believe they have 9 raised it through you. thought you were tfie person #o
10 been brought currenY up until like 1 don't know wher 10 ask.
11 tfis curre�t rlate is, sir. As of today, don't know. 11 A. And i don't know why he did it, sir. was
12 Q. When you say you've been led to believe, what 12 confused, too.
13 does that mean? 13 Q. Okay, aIl right. If I understood your testimony
14 A. Well, I don't know, once again I don't know whai 94 correctly, when the City went out and inspected, when
15 the current date was. 15 your staff went out and inspected last October, they
6 Q. Okay. So you know that 16 found pages of violations, right?
17 A. That would be a matter of recordkeeping down k n17 A. There was more Yhan one page, yes, sir.
18 the finance department, sir. 18 Q_ And some of those violations were serious,
19 Q. 1'm sorry, 1'm having a hard time hearing. 19 right?
20 A. That wouid be a matter of recordkeeping down i �i20 A. woWd say that depends on what you deem as
21 the finance department. 21 serious. If you could be more specific_
22 Q. At some point you know that Center Pointe was 22 Q. Would you agree #hat some of them weren't very
23 befiind on its utility payments? 23 serious?
24 A. AY some point. 24 A_ There again, you know, what is not very seriou!
25 Q. In facf, they were very substantially behind7 25 Q. Weil, for example, a m+ssing refrigerator sfielf,
Page (82 Page184
1 A. Right now, 1 do�'t know, sir. At one point they i would that be serious?
2 were, yes, sir. 2 A. IYs a matter of opinion, sir. In my opinion?
3 Q. All right. And whether they are or not today, 3 Q. Yes, sir, as ihe building o�cial_
4 you don't know whether they were last week or last month 4 A. In my opinion, no, it probably wouldn't be
5 even?
5 considered serious.
6 A. 1 do not, sic 6 Q. And in those pages, how many times was it listed
7 Q. And the bond fee that was part of one of those 7 that there was a refrige�ator shelf missing?
8 exfiibits that Mc Clelland used, you know that that was 8 A. I do not know, sir.
9 paid, right? 9 Q. Dozens, right?
10 A. I know that Yhe�e was don't know if that 10 A. 1 do not know, si�. More than once, more than
91 was paid. 1 once.
12 Q. Did you find out? 12 Q. The purpose of the inspection lasf October was
i3 A. Pardon me? 13 because a new license application had been filed, right?
14 Q. Did you do anything to find out? 14 A. ThaYs correct.
15 A. No, 1 did not 15 Q. And before the iicense can be aHowed under the
16 Q. What about the payments on the bands, ihe bond 16 city ordinances, the property has to be in compliance
17 payments? Mr_ Cleqand entered #he letter of default 17 with the city ordinances and state faw, correct?
18 from the Oppenheimer firm? 18 A. Yes, sir.
19 A. Um-hum. 19 Q. And so #he purpose of going out and doing this
20 Q. Did you do any investigation to find out what 20 inspecYion was to make sure the property got in
21 caused that default or whether it's been cured? 21 compliance with the city ordinances, correct?
22 A. No, 1 did not. 22 A. Correct, sir.
23 Q. If I told you that #hat deiault occuaed because 23 Q. And then you had your staff foliow up and make
24 the automatic withdrawat that had been in place for years 24 sure that anything that didn't get done the first time
25 somehow ended, would thai be news to you? 25 around got done, right?
46 (Pages 181 to 184)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc_
612-339-0545
Public Hearing� 10/1/20D7
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 185 Page 187
1 A. We hoped thaYs what happened, yes, sir. 1 Q. Did you fax a letter in response to that inquiry
2 Q. Weif, iYs more than hope; you send peopie out 2 saying here's the outstanding issues?
3 to iook at it, right? 3 A_ No, i didn't, sir.
4 A. We do. We do_ 4 Q. Did someone tell you not to tell Center Pointe
5 Q. And in th+s instance, when you got fo January, 5 what the outstanding issues were?
6 there was still, 1 think you said, four items that had 6 A. No, nobody did, sir.
7 not been compieied to your satisfac5on but you were 7 Q. I want to draw your attention to Tab 4 in
8 shown some contracts with respect to those items, right? 8 Mr. Clelland's book, Mr. Martin. Since I don't have
9 A. i believe 1 said that, yes. 9 another copy of it, fm going to stand here with you, if
1� Q. Okay. And they were garage doors, stuccq some 10 IhaYs all right?
1 J stucco on some of the buildings? 11 A. TfiaYs fine.
12 A. Yes, sir. 2 Q. Mr. Clelland talke�i w�th �?n� ti,+„
13 Q_ Roofing and caulking, correct? Y-- LT this .z.,,
13 you remember?
14 A. Sounds correct, yes, sir. 14 A. Ne did.
15 Q_ AII right. And the garage doors, you said, at 1 S Q. And he asked you about the various times when
16 least by mid-May hadn'i been done? 16 you went out and inspected and then reinspected, right?
17 A. Not that I'm aware of, sir. 17 A, ThaYs correct.
18 Q. Now after mid-May and up until today, the 1st of 18 Q. And you went through, there were a number of
19 October, has anyone from your department gone out to see 19 compliance orders correct?
20 ii this work has been done? 20 A. That's correct.
21 A. Nobody has called for inspection, sir, so, no, 21 Q. Now each of these compliance orde�s on the
22 we have not. 22 second page indicate the date of ihe inspection that led
23 Q. Okay. Within the last month, have you heard 23 to this, right?
24 from Patricia Todd? 24 A. Yes, sir.
25 A. Within the last month, yes. 25 Q. So under Tab 4 of the book, the first compliance
Page 186 Paget88
1 Q. A�d has she asked you during that period whether 1 order is dated April 25 with a compliance date of
2#here was any outstanding issues, compliance issues that 2 April 30.
3 the property needed to address? 3 A. That is not the first compliance order.
4 A. i received a voice mail from her just the other 4 Q. I meant the first under Tab 4.
5 day. 5 A. Oh.
6 Q. Asking that? 6 Q. I know there were earlier compliance orders.
7 A. Asking that, yes. 7 A. Okay.
8 Q. And did you get back to Mer? 8 Q_ Okay?
9 A. 1 attempted, yes, sir. 9 A. Making sure we're on the same page.
10 Q. And did you te�l her whether there were any 10 Q_ We are.
11 ouistanding issues? 11 A. Yes, you are correct.
12 A. She wasn't in the office when 1 returned the 12 Q. So the first one under Tab 4--
13 call, sir. 13 A. First one under Tab 4.
�4 C2. Did you teave a message telling her there were 14 Q. is dated April 25 with a compliance date of
95 any other issues? 15 Aprii 30.
16 A. did leave a message, yes, sir. 16 A. That is correct, sir.
17 Q. What was yaur message? 17 Q. And when you turn to the second page of fhat
18 A_ I don't, I don't recaU what it was word for 18 compliance report, it indicates that the inspection that
19 word, but she was more than welcome, 1'm retur�ing f etg Ied to tfiat compl+ance report was done on February 8,
20 caA, and I asked her staff to give me a call to discuss 20 correct?
21 what outstanding issues ihere were out there that I w: �1 A. It does say that, yes_
22 aware of. 22 Q. Is that accurate or inaccurate?
23 Q. Did you Tell her in this message of any 23 A. 1 believe it is accurate.
24 outstanding issues at a!I? 24 Q. AH right. And then if you go another page,
25 A. No, didn't, si�. 25 this is an April 17 compliance order, correct?
47 (Pages 1$5 to 188)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEET�NG
Page189 Page (91
1 A. It is. done on the properties?
2 Q. Requiring compliance by April 25? 2 A. They are inspected to HUD guideiines.
3 A. ThaYs correct, sir. 3 Q. And were compliance orders issued?
4 Q. And tum the page, it also indicates that the 4 A. A compliance order is the HUD inspection form.
5 inspection was do�e on February 8, correct7 5 Q. Okay_ Was that issued, this inspection that was
6 A. February 8, yes, sir. 6 done within the last week?
7 Q. Well, did someone go back out in between to see 7 A. i don't know, sir.
8 what had been done a�d what hadn't? 8 Q. Were tfie issues tMat were identified by your
9 A. Yes. 9 inspector completed7
10 Q. When was that inspection done? i0 A. On the Section 8 inspectioa?
11 A. 1 don't k�ow the exact dates. My staff worked 11 Q. Yes, sir.
12 with the tnaintenance staff on site and conducted the 12 A. 1 don't know.
13 inspections. i 3 Q. When is the last time that there was an
14 Q. Why isn't it reported anywfiere that another 14 inspection done at Center Pointe with which Center Pointe
15 inspection was done? 15 didn't comply?
16 A. !t might be reported on his schedule, �eported 16 A. 1 coutdn't give you an accurate date, sir.
17 as his schedule. These ouistandi�g iYems here are 17 Q. is it fair to say, Mr_ Martin, that your
'I8 forwarded to Yhe staff. 18 experience with Center Pointe owners over the )ast couple
19 Q. When is the last time that any inspectio� was 19 ysars has been that they are, they don't necessarily
20 done at Center Pointe? 20 comply as quickly as you would like them to, but they
21 A. What type o# inspecYion are you referring to, 21 work on the issues and they get them fixed?
22 sir? 22 A More often than not.
23 Q. Inspection by the building department, by your 23 MR. BAER: I don't have anything else for
24 staff. 24 you today. Thank you, Mr. Martin.
25 A. Could have been today, sir. 1 don't know. 25 MR. CLELLAND: And I have no further
Page 190 Page 192
1 Q. Well, when is the last time you know of? 1 questions for him, so ihe city staff rests in this
2 A. WiYhin the iast week an inspector had been on 2 proceeding.
3 site. 3 (Wiiness excused.)
4 Q. That was Mc Rued? 4 MAYOR WILtSON: Mr. Baer?
5 A. Possibly. 5 MR. BAER: Mr. Mayor, at this point I fiave
6 Q. Was he doing Section 8 inspections? 6 a serious problem that would ask the Council to
7 A. Possibly. 7 address, a�d that is we heard from Mr. C1elland that
8 Q. LeYs tell the Council what Section 8 8 somehow during the course of this proceeding he was going
9 inspections are. Section 8 is another government funding 9 to show us what the allegaYions were that had been made
10 program, correct? i 0 against my clie�t that we were supposed to be responding
11 A. ThaYs correct_ 11 to. There is no evidence in the record, none that
12 Q_ And provides vouchers to low-income people fo be 12 identifies the charges tha# were made against my client
13 able to afford the rent? 13 that brought us here tonighY. This is the issue that I
14 A. Thafs correct. 14 raised with you firsY thing this evening, ifs the issue
15 Q. And in order to receive tMose vouchers, the 15 that was number one on my list last Friday when I sent
16 property has to be kept in a conditio� in compliance with 16 out iMe objections of the respondent.
17 the Section 8 requirements, right? 17 The City has failed, utterly failed to introduce
18 A. Tfiat's correct. 18 any evidence of the notice that was provided to my client
19 Q. Do city inspectors do the Section 8 inspections? 19 that identifies the issues to be addressed in this
20 A_ We do under co�Iract, sir. 20 hearing. Now we heard earlier that the Council should
21 Q. And when you say that an inspection was done 21 accept this evidence and then weigfi it against what the
22 withi� the last week, was it a Section 8 inspection? 22 charges were. Tha# wa y you would know whether the
23 A. 1 would assume so, yes, sir. 23 evidence was responsive to those charges or not. You
24 Q. So that was for a ceriain property an inspector 24 can't do Yhaf because Mr. Clelland just rested and there
25 goes out and figures out what, if anything, needs to be 25 is nothing before you that tells you what ihe charges
48 (Pages 189 to 192)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc_
612-339-0545
Public Hearing i0/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
�age 193 Page 195
1 were that were made against my client. That's the 1 rents.
2 probiem 1've been having_ I don't know how to respond to 2 Q. So the higher the occupancy and the more re�t
3 this because Mr. Clelland didn't, either prior to this 3 you collec{, the more money you get paid?
4 proceeding and now throughout the proceeding, identify 4 A. ThaYs exactiy right
5 for us what the specific atlegations are so ihat i know 5 Q. So you have, Paramark has a signifcant
6 how to respond to them and so ihat you know how to weigh 6;ncentive to make this projeci successfut, correct?
7 the evidence. Witfiout that, this is an improper 7 A. ThaYs correct.
8 proceeding and I submit that it ought to be dismissed 8 Q. Describe for the Council, piease, what your
9 now_ 9 personal experience is in the property management
10 MAYOR WILLSON: Wili that complete your 10 business?
91 remarks then, Mr. Baer? 11 A. Weli, the company was started in 1971, and 1 was
'!2 MR. BAER: i have examination of my 12 born in 197i. My faLher started the company with
13 witnesses if the Cou�ci! intends to proceed. 13 partners Joe and Jean Weiss from Weiss Builders, a
14 MAYOR WILLSON: Su�e. We do. 14 nationally know� consfruction company, so i've been
15 MR. BAER: Would you like me to call my 15 involved with the business most of my life, have been
16 witnesses or are we going to break for the evening? 16 o�cially empioyed•by the company through high schooi a<
i 7 MAYOR WItLSON: Yes, sir, call your 17 a handyman and leasing ageni, and then later on in my
18 witnesses. 18 professional career 1 started in 1999 as a propefty
19 MR. BAER: Thank you. Respondent caNs 19 ma�ager_ in 20001 became the owner.
20 Mr. Busch. 20 Q. And aiso describe for the Councii, please, what
21 MAYOR WILLSON: State your address for the 27 Paramark does, apart from managing Center Pointe?
22 record? 22 A. The company is based in Rochester, Minnesota.
23 TNE WITNESS: 2016 Bailey Heights Drive 23 We've been managing since 9971, as I said_ Our company
24 Southwest, Roches[er, Minnesota 55902. 24 is focused on managing residential real estate as weii as
25 25 commercial real estate, and we do buy and seil buildings
Pagel94 Page 196
1 MICHAEL BUSCH, 1 on top of that. Our primary thrust is in the residentia!
2 duly sworn, was examined and tes5fied as follows: 2 management oi multifamily housing, and within that area
3 DIRECT EXAMINATION 3 oi our business we manage everything from affordable
4 BY MR_ BAER: 4 housing to conventionalty financed housing.
5 Q. Mr. BusCh, with whom afe you employed? 5 Q. When you say affordable housing, does that
6 A. Paramark. 6 indude projects similar to Center Pointe7
7 Q. What is Paramark? 7 A. Absolutely.
8 A. Paramark is a reai estate management company. 8 Q. Can you describe an instance where Paramark has
9 Q. What, if anything, is the relationship between 9 been involved in a project that you would say was
90 Paramark and the Center Pointe property ihat we've been 10 similar, at least in some respects, to Center Pointe?
11 talking about tonight? 11 A_ Well, we did manage a property in Rochester
12 A_ We've been hired to be the management agent fo 12 called Rochester Yillage, which is a 412-unit property,
13 this property. 13 and iYs simllar in size, iYs similar in type of
14 Q. And when did Paramark begin its management 14 property, iYs similar in that there are, the�e were some
15 duties? 15 etements of problems that we encoa�tered when we took
16 A. The montM of September 2007. 96 over the property. It was a distressed property with
17 Q. 1s tfiat Qursuant to a contract? 17 occupancy around 65 percent, a�d we were hi�ed in 2004 t�
18 A. Yes. 18 tur� that property around. And to turn a property around
19 Q. And tha co�tract term is for how long? 19 means to improve occupancy, to raise rents, Yo improve
20 A. It's for a year and three months_ 20 tfie quality of the tenants and to reduce crime, and we
2i Q. Paramarlc is paid to provide these manageme�t 21 did tfiai successfully. And 1'm happy to report over the
22 services, is that right? 22 last three years we improved occupancy from 65 percenf u�
23 A. ihaYs correct. 23 to 95 percent i� 2007, and we were able to reduce crime
24 Q. And how is the amount of your pay determined? 24 significantly. And in addition, we were able to raise
25 A. IYs based on occupancy and coHections of 25 rents and we were very successful. As a matter of fact,
49 (Pages 193 to 196)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page i97 Page 199
1 the property was just sotd Iast week for a profii. 1 objectives, we can organize work to be done very quickly,
2 (RespondenYs Exhibit No. 6 marked_) 2 and iY really does come down io whaf's deemed necessary.,:
3 Q. Showing you what's marked as Respondent's 3 boih to be in compliance with state agencies and/or iocal
4 Exhibit 6. Can you identify that, please? 4 code, as weJi as meeYing the owner's goais to make his
5 A. Yes. 7his is a letter from the Mayor of S rentai housi�g the most successful return on his
6 Rochester memorializi�g our services for the community oi 6 investment.
7 Rochester, M9nnesota over the last 36 years, and drawing 7 Q. In the last month, while you've been responsible
8 attention to our successes in the marketplace as a 8 for the management of Center Pointe, has a report been
9 quafity management firm. And I will mention that our 9 provided to the NM Pm sorry MHFA, Min�esota
10 tompany is Lhe iargest compa�y in Rochester, Minnesota. 10 Nousing Finance Authority, with respect to the i�spection
11 We manage about 6,500 apartment units. 11 report that was written earlie� this year?
12 MR. BAER: Mc Mayor, if I might? 12 A. Yes. One of the first ihings thaL we took on
13 MAYOR WlLLSON: Mr_ CleHand? 13 was to determine what issues were ouisianding with
14 MR. CLELIAND: I don't have an objection. 14 respect to the property, and we became aware ofi a
35 MR. BAER: We have offered No. 6, 15 Minnesota Housing Finance Agency compliance report W�
16 Respo�denYs No. 6. 16 quickty determined what the issues were and we went
i 7 MAYOR WlLLSON: So entered. 17 Yhrough to ensure that aU items had been corrected_
1$ (RespondenYs Exhibil No. 7 marked_) 18 We've been communicatiAg batk and forth with MHFA on a
19 Q. Let me also show you whaYs marked as 19 daily basis to ensure that everybody knows whafs been
20 RespondenYs Exhibit 7. Can you identify that for us, 20 done a�d what needs to be done. And as of today, this
21 please? 21 afternoon at 5 p.m., we have compleYed all but one item
22 A. !Ys a letter from the Rochesfer City Building 22 on ihei� list.
23 aod Safety Department acknowledging inspections thai we� �23 Q. Now the report thai the Council fias been
24 completed aY a property we manage in Rochester that had 24 provided has a compliance date thafi has gone and passed.
25 significant issues and with our management expertise had 25 To your knowledge, did ihe MHFA grant a� exiension of
Page 198 Page Z00
1 been corrected, and I quote from the body, "We have seen 3 that compliance date?
2 very favorabie progress in Yhe condition of this 2 A. Yes.
3 apartment complex in the very sfiort time since Paramark 3 Q. And the compiiance date now is when?
4 has taken over management and hope this progress will 4 A. October 5th.
5 co�tinue." 5 Q. And as of today, October i, you've got one issue
6 MR. BAER: Mc Mayor, we offer RespondenYs 6 1eR to complete?
7 Exhibit 7_ 7 A. ThaYs correct.
8 MR. CLELLAND: No objection. 8 Q. WhaYs that issue?
9 MAYOR WILLSON: Duly noted. 9 A. There's o�e apartme�t that needs to have �ew
10 BY MR BAER: 10 carpet and sheetrock replaced, and some mino� repairs t>
11 Q. !n the relaiionship that Paramark has developed 11 ihe u�it. IYs currently vacant.
12 with Brooklyn Center Leased Housing Associates, have you, 92 Q. Do you see any difficulty in getting that done
13 has Paramark required thak Brooklyn Center Leased Housing i 3 by October 5th?
14 Associates deposit money that is available for repairs or 14 A. 1 do not
15 maintenance issues thai arise at the property? 5 (RespondenYs Exhibit Nos. 8 and 9 marked.)
16 A. We have. 16 Q. Showing you what's marked as Respondeni's
17 Q. And how much money is on deposit? 17 Exhibit 8, Mr. Busch, can you tell us what that is,
18 A. We have $50,000 as a minimum batance that needs 18 please?
19 to be required through the rehab andlor repair phase of 19 A. This is a response provided by Paramark to
20 our managemeni contract. 20 Minnesota Nousing Finance Agency addressing fhe
21 Q. And you anticipate that rehab or repair phase to 29 out-of-compGance issues as they �elate to the physicat
22 last how long? 22 inspection.
23 A. I can't say for sure, but i can tel! you that we 23 Q. And also Exhibit 9, could you identify that for
24 wifl get it done as quickty as possible, and in our 24 us, please?
25 ezperience, depending on the owner's goals aad 25 A_ This is a tetter written by Minnesota Housing
50 (Pages 197 to 200)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing i0/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 201 Page 203
1 acknowledging receipt o# our report, acknowledging at the 1 that'S not Paramaric'S praCtice7
2 6me of wrifing tMis report they stiil had three issues 2 A. CorreCt.
3 outstandi�g that had not been completed or could not 3 Q. And likewise, with reSpeCt to unpaid bOnd fees,
4 verify had been completed_ 4 that wouldri t be Paramark's practice?
s p. And then subsequent to this Exhibit 9, you 5 A. Correct_ And I wiU add that lhere was some
6 received further communicaiion? 6 comment about bilis being paid in longer days than
7 A. Yes_ We traded e-mails_ However, Minnesota 7 nprmal. Our company pays every tvro weeks and can c �t
8 Housing Finance Agency ran out of time due to their other special checks On demand.
9 Gme co�straints, but they acknowledged receipt of my 9 Q. AS you sit here tonight, Mr. BuSCh, do yoU haVe
10 ofher supporting documentation showing that there was 10 any reason to believe that Paramark will noY be able to
11 oMy o�e item left They promised me they wouid review 11 operate this property in a#ashion that will make the
12 it as soo� as possible, and at the lafest by the Sth of 12 City happy?
13 October. 13 A. 1 think my largest limitation will be my ability
14 MR. BAER: We'll offer Exhibits 8 and 9. 14 to rent units, and to rent units means to raise income tc
15 MR. CLE�LAND: No objection. 15 be able to afford the day-to-day operations, and as lon<
1s MAYOR WILLSON: Duly noted. 16 as there's mo�ey to do the job, I mean that is to say,
17 BY MR. BAER: 17 rent units and have funding lrom the owners to suppor
18 Q. Now, Mr. Busch, what is the relationship between 18 any kind ofi deferred and/or tuLure maintenance
19 your organization, Paramark, and the Minnesota Housing i 9 requirements, 1 Yhink we'll do just fine.
20 Finance Agency? Do you work with them trequently? 20 Q. And the funding irorrt the owners issue is, at
21 A. We do. We have a great reiationship with MHFA. 21 leasY for now and for the foreseeable future, under
22 We manage many aHordable housing projects throughout the 22 conYrol because you've got $50,000 in the account, right?
23 siate of Minnesota and have worked with them for many, 23 A. And if's a rttinimum balance, So we See If as a
24 many years, longer than I've been involved with the 24 proteCtion, yes.
25 company as a matter of fact, and iYs a wonderful 25 Q. So by minimum baiance, you mean when you spend
Page 202 Page 204
1 �elationship because they know they can depend on us t� 1 $10,000 of that, iYs required to be pumped back up?
2 get the job done. And every si�gle project that we have 2 A. That's rigMt.
3 with them is in good #avor with them. 3 MR. BAER: lf l might have one minute,
4 Q. Have you communicated with anyone at MHFA about 4 Mr. Mayor?
5 the fact that Paramark is now managing tfie Center Pointe 5 {Pause in the proceeding_)
6 project7 6 BY MR_ BAER:
7 A. Absolutely. 7 Q. You mentioned before, Mr. Busch, that you
8 Q_ And what has been the response from MHFA about 8 addressed these issues of maintenance with your on-site
9 that fact? 9 staff?
10 A. They were elated, delighted, satisfied, 10 A. That's correct.
11 surp�ised by it, pleased, you name it. They thought it 11 Q. And you've hired on-site staff for this projecY?
12 was the best Yfiing that could happen to the project. 12 A. ThaYs correc#.
13 Q. Under this management contract that Paramark has 13 Q. And who are ihey?
14 for Center Pointe, who has responsibiiity for maintenance 14 A. Patricia Todd and Randy Todd.
15 of the project; you, that is Paramark, or someone else? 15 Q. And they're sitting here in the audience, right?
16 A. Our company is ultimately responsible for the 16 A. ThaYs correct.
17 maintenance, and we hi�e managers on site and staff on 17 Q, yow long have Patricia and Randy Todd been
'!8 site as Paramark empioyees to take ca�e of that 18 associated with Paramark?
19 responsibility. 1g A. For five years.
20 Q. And in this relationship, who is responsible for 20 Q. And have you personally worked with them before?
21 payi�g the biHs? 21 A. 1 have nof. M
y partne� has.
22 A. Our company is responsible for payi�g the biHs 22 Q. And have you goYfen repo�ts on their
23 on behatf of the owner. 23 perfoRnance?
24 Q. And so to the extent tfiat we've heard testimony 24 A. Exceptional performance. ThaYs why they were
25 this evening about �npaid utifity bills, I take it that 25 offered this job.
51 (Pages 201 to 204)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
b 12-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1I2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 205 Page 207
1 Q. 1 your on-site managers moved onto the 1 A. Yes.
2 properYy? 2 Q. And that could be terminable at the wili of the
3 A. They are in ihe process and they are just one 3 Jaweeds, is #fiat correct?
4 step away from living there. 4 A. Yes.
5 Q. And thafs your expectation of them, that they 5 Q. Now what dispute resolution mechanism is there
6 will live on the property? 6 if you recommend any repairs to properties for which the
7 A. IYs a requirement. 7 Jaweeds do not wish to pay?
8 Q. So there will be staff there 24 hours a day, 8 A. If it needs to be done, it needs to be done. If
9 correcY? 9 they don't want to pay, we would have the right to make
10 A. There will be staff living there 24 hours a day, 10 strong recommendations. If we felt that it pui our
91 and hopefulty someone will be there almost every hou i.11 reputation or the property at risk in a way that we
12 And �or those hours we don't have covered, we have 12 didnY feel was appropriate, we could give them notice.
13 security guards. 13 Q. !n other words, the Jaweeds retain the auihority
14 MR_ BAER: i don't have any further 14 to spend money or not spend money, don't they?
15 questions for you. Thank you, Mr. Busch. 15 A. They do.
6 CROSS-EXAMINATION 16 Q. And ihey've given up none o# that authority in
17 BY MR. CLELLAND: 17 this contract, have they?
i8 Q. Mr. Busch, please, sir. 18 A. Correct.
i9 A- Oh, 1'm sorry. 19 Q. Did you review the compliance orders, the
20 Q. Did you negotiate tMis contrac# with either of 20 23-page compliance order Yhat the City issued on this
21 Yhe Jaweed owners? 21 properfy last fali?
22 A. did. 22 A. 1 have not seen it.
23 Q. Did they have the decision-making authoriiy to 23 Q. Why wouldn't you look at that?
24 enter in#o this contract? 24 A. Weli, actuaUy we made attempts to get
25 A. IYs my understanding that they did. 25 information from the City, and to my knowledge it has n't
Page 206
Page 208
1 Q. Did anyone else have decision-making authority 1 been provided to us directly.
2 other ihan fhe Jaweeds? 2 Q. 1'I! show you what the Council has received in
3 A. Not to my knowledge. 3 evidence, and iYs thaY compliance order. tooking
4 Q. Did they represent that they were the owners of 4 specificaily at Tab 2, do you see the compliance order
5 any busi�ess entity lhat owns the Center Pointe property? 5 addressed to Hyder Jaweed on the 5th of October, 2006?
6 A. Could you repeat that question? 6 A. Yes.
7 Q. Right. You know that corporafions, LLCs don't 7 Q. Do you see ail of the ordinance descriptions and
8 operate on their own, don't you? 8 legal vioiations here?
9 A. Generally they're made up of people. 9 A. I do.
10 Q. Right. 10 Q. Do you see that it runs for 23 pages?
11 A. Correct. 11 A. 1 do.
12 Q. And the humans have to make the decision for the 12 Q. Does a responsible property owner allow property
13 LlC to do anything, don't they? 13 to decline to this state?
14 A. Yes. 14 A. I can tell you 2hat under our watch nothing like
15 Q. Does it appear thaY the Jaweeds are the humans 15 that will happen.
16 to decide what the business entity owning Center Pointe 16 Q. My question was does a responsibie owner allow a
17 will do or not do? 17 property to dedine to this state?
78 A. Yes. 38 A. I would not atlow it to happen.
19 Q. Did you review the strike that. Is there a 99 Q. Okay. You ihink iYs irresponsibie for a
20 termination ctause in your contract? 20 property owner to allow a property to suffer this?
21 A. Yes. 21 A. I woutd not allow that to happen, 1 just think
22 Q_ Is it a 30-day clause? 22 it's not great.
23 A. i beiieve it might be 90. 23 Q. is there a reason you don't want to answer that?
24 Q. Okay. So in effect it could be a 90-day 24 A. You're putting words in my moutfi
25 conYract instead of a 15-month contrac#? 25 Q. Not at a11.
52 (Pages 205 ta 208)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-OS45
Public Hearing i0/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 209 Page 21 I
1 A. and I think it's obvious Yhat you would wa�t 1 A. Yes.
2 to correct those things when #hey come up as soon as 2 Q. Haven't you seen those doors?
3 possibie, and it is Paramark's policy to respond to 3 A. I have.
4 anything like that that invoives inspections or city 4 Q. Are those doors defective?
b officials with aU seriousness and taken care of S A. I don't know that they're defective so much as
6 immediately. 6 they're being fampered with by tenants, which is a
7 Q. !sn't it the responsibility of an owner to 7 problem and #hai needs to be corrected.
8 prevent this from even occurring? 8 Q. What action do you have to replace locks or
9 A. Yes. 9 rebuild locks or doors so they're not subject to this
10 Q. Did you see the crime statist+cs? 10 simple vandalism and therefore the building lacks
11 A. This is the first Yime I've seen them, i 1 security?
12 Q. Right, but did you see them as Yhey were 12 A. What I can tell you is we don't have a plan in
13 portrayed on the screen tonight? 13 place yet bui thaYs one of our flrst prioritiss.
14 A. Yes. 14 Q. Do you agree with the police the fact that the
15 L2. Okay. Do you ihink Yhat iYs a ciean, decent, 15 buildings are all unsecured contributes to the high cal�s
16 safe place for tenants wi#h 252 units to have over 800 16 for service and crime rate?
17 calls estimated this year, caAs for service by the 17 A. l think !'m going to ask you to resiate that
18 police? 18 question or state it again_
19 A. think thaYs an area that we can improve for 19 Q. Yes. Do you agree with the police ihat the
20 sure. 20 common knowledge that the buildings are unsecured, ihey
21 Q- My question is do you think that's a reasonable 2i can be entered at any time by anybody, contributes to the
22 operation of the complex? 22 high crime rates at Cen#er Pointe?
23 A. When I looked at all the other statistics a�d I 23 A. 1 don't know tfiat can say that for certain.
24 looked at the calls for service and the numbe� of units 24 Q. Why not?
25 as it compared Yo the rest of Yhe properties, noticed 25 A. What 1 can say for certain is thaf if a door is
Page 210 Page 212
1 there were other properties that were much worse. 1 open, someone can waik through it more easily than if
2 Q. That happens in we1i, not higher calls but 2 iFs locked.
3 maybe higher ratios, is that wfiat you're saying? 3 Q. RigMt. And if iYs common knowledge, wifl that
4 A. Correct. 4 draw peop�e to the complex to commit crimes?
5 Q. My question to you is this. With 252 units, has 5 A. Perhaps.
6 this property been properly managed to have calls in 6 Q. Has that been your experience with the omer
7 exCess of seven or 800 a year? 7 disiressed properties?
8 A. You know, I think there's a reason why we've 8 A. 1 think that's an area that we w
ould alwa s look
Y
9 been hired to manage this property. 1 think they think 9 at very quickly and closely; what can we do to make th�s
10 we can improve their operation of the property. 10 piace more secure.
11 Q. Why didn't they improve it fhemselves? 91 Q. 8ut there is no plan to feplace those locks with
12 A. Maybe they weren't able to. 12 locks thaf can't be easily defeated, is that your
13 Q. Weli, do you know of any steps they took to 13 testimony?
14 reduce the caJls far service? 14 A. No, iYs not my testimony. Ii's my testimony
i 5 A. I do not. 15 tfiat we're still determi�ing what our plan is. We've
16 Q, Did you inquire? 16 just begun_
17 A. have not 97 Q. Now iYs true that MHFA advised you that they
18 Q. Did you see the iilm showing the defective 18 don't inspeci ihe premises, do they? In other words,
19 doors, the broken locks, the missing locks, the locks 19 they'11 just take your word for it ihat you fixed these
20 That could be easily defeated witfi the insertion of coin 20 items?
21 or paper? 21 A. Yes, and they have asked for supporting
22 A. have not unti) tonight. 22 documentation to make it more obvious to them that it has
23 C2_ But you saw it tonight? 23 bee� completed, and they asked for the owner or ma�agin<
24 A_ Yes_ 24 age�Ys certification that it has been completed.
25 Q. Haven't you seen this property? 25 Q. Is that ceriified under oath7
53 (Pages 209 to 212)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
1'ublic Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 2l3 Page 215
1 A. No. 1 {Witness excused.)
2 Q. And so if you show a receipt for a window, they 2 MAYOR WItLSON: Do you have any other
3 don't know if iYs a window placed at Center Pointe or 3 witnesses?
4 somewhere else, do they? 4 MR. BAER: I do. Do you want to continue?
5 A. Correct. 5 MAYOR WILISON: Yes, sir.
6 Q. Did you review those reports from MHFA2 6 MR. BAER: Okay_ Patricia Todd, please.
7 A. did_ 7 PATRIGA TODD,
8 Q. Would a responsible owner have allowed the 8 duly swom, was examined and testified as fo�lows=
9 property to again deciine svch as suffered from those 9 DIRECT EXAMJNATION
10 violations that MHFA noted? 10 BY MR. BAER:
91 A. I 2hink the things that MHFA noted in their 11 Q. Have a seat, Ms. Todd. Where do you live?
12 report could happen to any given property at any given 12 A. 3907 65th Avenue North, Apartment 306.
13 time. 93 Q_ Is that the Center Pointe Apartment projeci?
14 Q. How would response 14 A. No, iYs a temporary Iocation until we move inYo
15 A. And they do, they happen afl the time. I mea� 15 Center Poi�te_
16 someone can break something on a property in a heartbeat '16 Q. And when is that?
17 like a iever to a door, and MHFA, or any other inspector 17 A. We anticipate within the next six days.
18 for that matter, wili come to a property and they'II 18 Q. And why have you not moved in already?
99 inspect, and whatever the condition is at that exact 19 A. Because as a management team we took on a
20 moment is whaYs noted, and you could have fixed it two 20 project where we �eeded to address some issues with th
21 hours prior to the inspection and it could be broken. So 21 property and we made tfiat a priority before putting our
22 we observe that ail the time, and iYs a frustration to 22 apartment first.
23 owners and managers, but we just deal with it and we fix 23 Q. Is it your inYention by Yhe end of Yhe week
24 it. 24 youYe going to be tiving at Center Pointe?
25 Q. Did MHFA also note that the exterior door locks 25 A. Yes.
Page 214 Page 216
3 were often broken and the buiidings were not secure? 1 Q. And you are the on-site manager at Cenier Poi�te
2 A. Yes, I've heard that for 15-plus years in 2 now?
3 properties. 3 A. 1 am one of the two on-site property managers
4 Q. And thaYs a continuing violation at Center 4 for Center Pointe.
5 Pointe, isn't it? 5 Q_ Md the second ls?
6 A. It sounds like thaYs an issue we need to deal 6 A_ My husband, Randy.
7 with directly. 7 Q. And you and Mc Todd have been working for
8 Q. Wou1d you consider that to be a very serious 8 Paramark for five years now?
9 shortcoming in the security of the buildings, that the 9 A. Yes.
10 doors are not Iockable and the door locks are not such 10 Q. Tell me whether the doors, the extenor doors at
11 that ihey can withstand this vandalism? 19 Center Pointe are functioning.
12 A. Weil, I guess, maybe to back up, iYs my 12 A. 1 would have to say Yhat the doors are
13 understanding that almosY ali the doors are functioning 13 functioning. We do, we have experienced some areas whe; e
14 the way they are supposed to function right wow as we 14 we need to work on a few of them. We are working
15 speak. 15 diligenily with some door i�stallers because not
16 Q. WhaCs bee� done since you saw the videos in 16 everybody does it all together, so you need a door guy,
17 April, May and June to show thaYs �ot fhe case? i7 you need a locksmith, and then you may need someone els�
18 A. Our managers have inspected every single door 18 to do the framing and tfie glass, so we're deali�g with
19 and have changed locks on some of the doors already an i19 severa! different trades or suppiiers or vendors in order
20 have observed thai some of the locks have been fixed, ar d20 to get whai some of you might perceive fo be a simple
21 at this point in fime, to my knowledge, we're very close 21 task, just f x a door. That's not the case. 8ut we do
22 to having 100 percent compliance with wo�king locks. 22 have a few that we do need to get up and running, and we
23 MR. CLELLAND: I have no further questions. 23 are working with those trades to get it done.
24 MR. BAER: I have no further questions for 24 Q. Mc CleHand has asked some quesiions about
25 this witness. 25 whethe� the doors are going to be replaced with some, I
54 (Pages 2l3 to 216)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 217 Page 219
1 guess, high-tech door khat can't be jammed. Now you've 1 Q_ WhaYs the job of the caretakers?
2 worked for Paramark for five years. Were you in the 2 A. Caretakers' responsibility is to dean the
3 reciamation business longer than that? 3 eniryways, tfie foyers, Lhe hallways, ihe laundry rooms.
4 A. Yes. 4 It is a big complex, so we can star# on one end of the
5 Q. All right. And in your experience, have you 5 building, work your way towards the 2800 buiiding and
6 seen any exterior doors that can't be jammed? 6 you've gat peopie dropping things behind ihem and, you
7 A. Personally i don't know of a�y magic doors, but 7 know, whatever you may do on one day, it may jusi show u�
8 if he could recommend some, that would be great. 8 again. So every day the grou�dskeepers are responsibie
9 Q. Is it a continuing problem at Center Pointe ihat 9 for walking through the buildings and picking up the
10 people put cans in the doors or paper in the doors to 10 smaB things a�d the caretakers are responsibie ior
11 keep them from closing and locking? i 1 cleaning.
12 A. We are finding that to be a practice on a few 12 Q. When you came on the project ia early SeQtember,
13 select buildings, but not throughout the entire complex 33 was there a guard service employed?
14 no. 14 A. Yes, there was.
15 Q. And in those buildings wMere you find it to be a 15 Q_ And have you repiaced that guard service?
16 practice, what have you already done or what are you 16 A_ Yes, we did.
i 7 planning to do ta address that problem? 17 Q. And have you also increased the amount of time
18 A. The plan of action was to replace the existing 18 that guards are on duty there?
99 locks, wo�k with the lock company to find the magic loc k39 A. Yes, we did.
20 so ihat people cannot iamper with them, and iYs taking 20 Q. TeU the Council, please, what your arrangement
29 us some time to work on that. 21 is now with tfie private security company_ First, who is
22 Q. Teli the Council about the staff that you have 22 the company?
23 on board now to assist with maintenance and the 23 A_ Initially it was Grade A Security, and although
24 managemen# of the Center Poinie Apartments, besides you 24 they were doing their job, we fett that they were
25 and your husband. 25 becoming too familiar of a tace, and as a �ew managemeni
Page 218 Page 220
1 A. la the way of how many? 1 company we wanted to cha»ge it up, so to speak. So we
2 Q. Who else is involved? 2 implemenfed and interviewed several differe�t security
3 A. 1 have Theresa Rotamau (ph), she is my office 3 companies tfiroughout the metro area, and we decided on
4 assistant, and 1 have a new hire, Chrisiine, and 4 company that happe�s to be our �eighbor right across the
5 unfortunately her last name escapes me, but she is also 5 street, Per Mar Secu�ity. We reached a mutual agreement
6 an office assistant. In te�ms of maintenance staff there 6 that they agreed that what was happening in their
7 is my husband Ra�dy, Carl Chiids, there is Scott Maches�e 7 backyard was something that they were interested in
8{ph�, and Theo Griffin, who is also a licensed boiler 8 assisting us with, and we agreed that they fit the bili.
9 e�gineer. We aiso have two groundskeepers, Dan and 9 We increased the security time on site. 8ecause of the
10 Taylor, a�d we have two caretakers, Mina and Alex, l 10 nonworking doors and/or the coins in the doors and the
11 believe. 11 problems with the doors, we wanted to make sure Yhat our
12 Q. What's the job of the groundskeepers? 12 tenants knew that we increased the security to make them
13 A. The grou�dskeepers' responsibility is to, well, 13 feel safe a�d secure.
14 they do the groundwork. They walk around the complex an 114 Q. In the last month have you been in contact with
15 make sure they pick up alf the garbage, which was one of 15 various city o�cials to explain who you are and whai
16 ou� priorities. IYs really important for our property 16 you're going to do?
17 to have curb appeal. If you don't fike what you see, 17 A. did. I made a phone call to the City and
18 you're not going to want to rent there. So we stepped it 18 introduced myself and said I'm one of the new on-site
19 up a notch and made sure these guys were walking around 19 property managers, my name is Patricia Todd, 1'm from
20 the complex and really picking it up, showing the tenants 20 Paramark, and I was referred to several other departme�ts
23 that we care. So o�ce you show them that we care and 21 to introduce myself. And 7erry Olson, 1 believe tfiaYs
22 instill that upon them, which is going to take us some 22 his last �ame, he sent an e-mail to everyone 1etti�g tMem
23 time there, we are in our infancy stage over there, to 23 know that i had made contact with him and we would be a
24 clean up the complex and around the buildings, and we do 24 link to each other beiween the City and Center Pointe
25 it on a Monday-through-Friday basis. 25 Apartments.
55 (Pages 217 to 220)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
b 12-339-0545
Public Hearing i0/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 221 Page 223
1 Q. Have you also had contact with Mr. Martin or 1 Q. Have you ieamed anything in the last month that
2 anyone else in the building department? 2 makes ou b Ii v
y e e e ihat you wdi not et the su ort of
9 PP
3 A. Yes, 1 d�d_ had a really nice conversation 3 Brooklyn Center �eased Housing Associates as necessary to
4 with larry Mlartin, he offered his services at any time, 4 operate this property?
5 and that John Rued, the building inspector, would be 5 A. No.
S stopping in from time to time or scheduling appointme� ts6 Q. Your primary dealings have been with Mc Asgher
7 to follow up on any Section 8 inspections or 7 Jaweed, is that right?
8 noncompliance. 8 A. Yes_
9 Q_ And have you attempted to learn from the 9 Q. And has Mt Jaweed been supportive of you?
90 buiiding department whether There are any outsYanding 10 A_ Absolutely.
1 i issues Yhat need to be addressed? 11 Q. Has he indicated that he wants you to take
12 A. In the midsf of working on everything, yes, I 12 charge of this property and make the City happy?
13 have made that attempf. 13 A. Yes, he did, wiih smiles.
14 Q. And did you get a response? 14 MR. BAER: Noihing further.
15 A. The response that we got was not to me because I 15 MR_ CIELLAND: 1 fiave no questions.
16 happened to not be available, but it went to Theresa, th� 16 MAYOR WIL�SON: Thank you.
17 secretary, and a few faxes were received in terms of 17 (Witness excused.�
18 noncompliance, but I didn't fee! Yhat it was everything i 8 MR. BAER: i have no further witnesses.
99 that was out there. 19 MR. CLELLAND: And we have no rebuttal.
20 Q. And so what did you do? 20 MAYOR WILLSON: Very good. The �ext time 1
21 A. t made another caU to Larry a�d I know that we 21 assume we'll get together, it sounds like we're a couple
22 played phone tag, and then 1 sent a fax to him askin fc 22 weeks out based on our sch
9 y edule and erha s the
p P
23 any additional information. 23 schedules here?
24 Q. Once you get that additional information from 24 MR. tEFEVERE: Well, i guess, AAr. Mayor,
25 the City, wha# is your plan as far as addressing any 25 the Council has let me get organized here. t don't
Page 222 Page 224
1 outstanding issues? 1 want to spend any time going into defail here about what
2 A. Put it in order of priority, whaYs most 2 the evidence was and so forth. Basically your charge is
3 important, take care of those first, and execute them 3 fo decide whether, ai the outset whefher there is a basis
4 like we did with MHFA. 4 for suspension or revocation under the grounds stated in
5 Q. Tell me what your role was with respecf to the 5 the ordinance, Section 12-930.
6 MHFA report that we saw and marked as Exhibit 8? 6 MAYOR WILLSON: Does provisional fall in
7 A. 1 cracked the whip and made sure it got done. 7 tfiere somewhere?
8 My role was to make sure ihat whatever was on the MHFA 8 MR. LEFEVERE: Pardon me?
9 for noncompliance was actually executed by mainteoance 9 MAYOR WILLSON: Does provis+onal falt
10 and staff, and it was my Job Lo make sure the photographs 10 MR. IEFEVERE Oh, provisional. No, there
11 were done to ensure that they were actually broughY into 11 is no it does not. There was a great deal of evidence
12 compliance, and then 1 prepared a report and forwarded it 12 about the provisional Gcense sYatistics and so on and so
13 on to Mike Busch for his final review. 13 forth. They're not currently under provisional iicense,
14 Q. Mr. Cielland, in his questions of Mc Busch, 14 theyYe not required to, fhey have not lost their
15 suggested that maybe the MHFA repori was doctored because 15 eligibiiity for a regular license until the cnme calls
)6 it wasn't done under oath. Is the information provided 16 get to a certain Ievel, the Council makes a determination
17 to MHFA accurate? 17 they're no longer eligible. That hasn't haQpened yei, it
18 A. I would say absolutely. 18 may not happen in the fuiure, but thaPs noi the issue
19 Q. Did you personally inspeci the property and make 19 here. They haven't been required to submit a mitigation
20 sure tfie things thai you were reporti�g to MHFA had been 20 plan for that, under thai section, provisiona! license
21 corrected had in fact been corrected? 29 section, and so thaYs noi, iPs not a violation of the
22 A. 1 did. 22 ordinance that they have exceeded or may have exceeded or
23 Q. Are there any issues today at Center Poi�te that 23 have allegedly exceeded for some period of time that
24 you #eel are �ot manageable by you and your husband? 24 threshold. ThaYs another proceeding and we're not ihere
25 A. Absolutely not. 25 yet, thaYs noi what we're talking about.
56 (Pages 221 to 224j
Paradigm Reporting Captioning �nc.
612-339-054�
Public Hearing 10/1/2Q07
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 225 Page 227
1 But the qvestion is, really the only thing that 1 so you wili have that, along with the evidence thaYs
2 was noticed is the revocation or suspension question, and 2 been presented, your no#es, when you get back together
3 the Council has a good dea! of evidence, some of which
3 again. AdditionaNy, if poss+bie, I don'# know
4 you haven't even seen yet, ifs been introduced and 4 Counsel, do you intend to have a transcript made?
5 hasn'i been reviewed_ You have a Iot to read, you have 5 MR. BAER: do.
fi tapes to look at, and the Councii is going to have to g
MR. LEFEVERE: And wouid you be willing to
7 determine a iot of thi�gs; what is true and accurate and 7 make that avaifable to ihe Cit
8 com iete evidenc Y
P e, evidence thaYs suificien 1
t
Y 8
MR. BAER. Abs
olutely.
9 probative, not und
er tfie technicat ruies of evidence but 9 MR. LEFEVERE: That wouid be certainfy
10 sufficie�tiy probative of relevant facts so that in a 10 helpfu! to me, and maybe to the Council as weA, and in
i i matter as important as this you would assign it 11 ihis da and a e the can be done rett
12 sufficienf credibility to act on it. You have to decide, y g y P Y 9uickly but not
12 overnighi.
13 sort out whaYs a violaTio� of the code and whaYs not. 13
14 Bad management may be relevant #or some other purposes, 14 midnight w e Bwe' e d eeciaNy not when iYs
15 but iPs not i� and of itself grounds for revocation. 15 MR. LEFEVERE: No. 1s there some idea how
16 Some evidence may be relevant not for purposes of �6 long it might iake to complefe the transcript?
'17 determining what, whether there's grounds for revocation, 7
(Discussion held off the record.)
i 8 but if there is grounds for revocaYion, what the j g
MR. LEFEVERE: What is a reasonabie
19 appropriate sancYion would be, if any; a suspension, a 19 schedule for additionat briefs of the parties? I guess,
20 revocation, some sort of conditional revocation or 20 in fiaimess, it is typical in a judicial proceeding, this
21 suspension, no action at all. Those are options that the 21 is not a judiciaf proceeding, but 7Ys an important
22 City Council has_ 22 matter and you stifl want ihe besi information ou can.
23 Y
The Ci
Co
uncii has
�Y to decide what i
s wh
at of 23 1 would �ecommend that each party be given a period of
24 Yhe evidence and what of the charges are important and 24 time to submit simultaneous brief and then an addiYional
25 what are �ot, and there are Gea�ly some alleged 25 period of time for each party to respond to the brief of
Page 226 Page 228
1 violations here that are more importanY ihan others, and 1 the other party, a post-triai brief making whatever
2 different people migh# differ about whaYs important and 2 arguments they think is appropnate following the hearing
3 whaYs not, but all of those things have to be weighed 3 in the matter.
4 and so�ted out, because the ultimate result of this, if 4
5 any action is taken for revocation or suspension, you 5 judges do and the ru es do, can be some page
6 have to have findings stating the reason for your 6 limitations. You've heard a lot, you have a loi to read,
7 decision, and those have to be linked back into grounds, 7 iawyers tend to be redundanY. 1 think ii will serve your
8 specific g�ounds that can be the basis for suspension or 8 interests to require the lawyers to focus on issues, and
9 revocation. So basicaUy those grounds indude failure 9 therefore to consider some page �imitat+ons, if you wiN.
10 to comply with the requirements of the code. So if 10 And a reasonable schedule, if you would like #o apply,
11 there's been a failure, you have to go back and figure 11 thaYs fine, i do like the idea of simuitaneous
12 out what, what the failure was and what the code 12 submission of briefs and then simultaneous replies by
13 provision is that was violated. There's a lot of work to 13 certain dates, and
14 do. 14 MR. LEFEVERE: !s iwo weeks far brie£
15 1 think both counsel for staff and for the 15 doable?
16 licensee fiave more that they would like to offer, not in 16 MR. CtEILAND: ThaYs fine with me.
17 terms of direct evidence here but in ferms of argument, 17 MR. tEFEVERE: Does tha# work for the
18 attempting to assist you in sorting througfi at1 this 18 Council?
19 evidence. Mr. Baer submitted written objections that 19
MAYOR WILLSON: What I was going to offer
20 Mr. CleAand has not yet had an opportu�ity to respond 20 earlier, we have a regular Council meeting a week from
21 to. He may wish to respond to tfiose in writing. 21 today. Perhaps counsel can get together and determine
22 So I guess what I wouid suggest is tfiat, as a 22 when after that?
23 starting point, Council set a briefing schedufe so that 23 MR LEFEVERE: After we meet, right
24 staff can submit additionat arguments that they wisfi to 24 MAYOR WlLLSON: And then we can dea! with
25 submit, counsel �or the licensee can do the same thing, 25 thaT at our next meeting and then it gets posted and ifs
57 {Pages 225 to 228)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
b 12-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 229 Page 231
1 in the record and ail tha# stuff. i MR_ CIELLAND: Okay.
2 MR. LEFEVERE: 1n the meantime we'H 2 (v1R_ LEFEVERE: And before we all leave the
3 circulate to the Counci! as soon as +Ys available the 3 room, if we could just doubie-check and make sure Yhat
4 transcript so you wiil have the entire body of the record 4 we've accounted one way or the other fo� all of the
5 of proceedings. And Yhen in two weeks when the briefs 5 exhibits offered_ It wiil only take a moment, I think.
6 come in, again I guess if you submit them to me, I'B 6 MAYOR WILLSON: d have a running tally, 1
7 make sure that they're c+rculated, and submit them 7 through '14 I have ail checked off.
8 simuitaneously to each other, and then 1 would say seven 8 MR. IEFEVERE: You have 14 checked otf?
9 days after that. If that schedule is foAowed, then 9 MAYOR WILLSON: I do_
10 we're three weeks out before you have their submittals, 10 MR. LEFEVERE: And was 1 the agenda for
i 1 and at that point you wi�( have had some time to 11 tonight that was submitted to the Councii, that you got
12 co�sider, by early next week you wili probabiy have all 12 today that went to the Council on Friday? Was that 1?
13 of this to go over, in a couple weeks you'll have the 13 MR. BAER: 1 was my letter to the Council
14 first briefs ihat you can review a few days after that, 14 and the objections that I sent out last Fnday.
15 so your piate wiA be ful1, you have some homework to do, 15 MR. LEFEVERE: Okay.
16 buY you also have some time to do i# on that schedule. 16 MAYOR WILLSON: And another copy.
17 That would put the decision out at least a month but you 17 MR. SAER: I don'k beiieve the agenda for
98 don't have fo decide tonight when you're going to meet fo 18 this eve�ing was marked but I wouid ask that it be marked
19 deliberate. You can decide that laier. 19 and induded in the record, Mr. Mayor, and i would aiso
24 MR. CLELLAND: Mr_ LeFevere, couid we pick, 20 ask that the transcript that's going to be prepared be
21 instead of just 14 days or seven days, pick the prec+se 21 considered as part oi the record.
22 dates on which they're due so there's no controversy? 22 MR. LEFEVERE: WeY! cali that Exhibi# 10
23 Sometimes we count differently, does the first day of the 23 will be the agenda, the packet that went out.
24 period count or the second. 8ut if we have fixed dates 24 (Respondent's Exhibit No. 10 marked.)
25 we'll know ihe briefs wiil be due io Charlie and opposing 25 MAYOR WILLSON_ There's an audio? 1'm
Page 230 Page 232
1 counsei on a certain day and then by close of business at 1 assume thaYs marked as something?
2 another time. 2 MR. LEFEVERE: The what?
3 MR. SAER: WhaYs Tuesday, two weeks from 3 MAYOR WlLLSON: The audio.
4 tomorrow? 4 MR. SAER: If someone is going to
5 COUNCIL MEMBER O'CONNOR: It's the 15th, 5 transcribe it, I think that would make sense. i# no
6 isn't it? 6 one's going to transcribe it, 1'm nof sure it makes any
7 MR. BAER: The 16th. 7 sense at ah_
8 MR. LEFEVERE: The 16th is Tuesday. 8 MfZ. LEFEVERE: Ysah, lefs reserve judgment
9 MR. CIEtLAND: C�ose of business by the 9 on that.
10 16th of October? 1Q {Discussion held off the record.)
1 MR. LEFEVERE: Okay. Not maiied but 11 MR. �EFEVERE: Traditionally a written
12 received? 12 transcript is sart of the gold standard, but before you
13 MR. CLELLAND: WeU, !'ll probably fax and 13 decide whether you're going to accept that, IeYs see it,
14 maii so the parties witl have it or� the 16th. 14 see if anyone has any serious objections to it, to the
15 MR. tEFEVERE: Parties wili have it o� the 15 quality or what's in it. We'il have the tape-recordings
16 16th? 16 that we can back up to see if there realiy is any
1 MR. CLEILAND: Right. 7 objection. f don't expect any, but you don't have to
18 MR. BAER: Fine. 18 accept ihe transcript at this point that you haven't
9 MR. LE�EVERE: And then the repiy would be 19 seen. Does that work for everybody?
20 a week after tfiat? 20 MR. BAER: It does, thank you.
21 MR. BAER: 23rd. 21 MR. CLELLAND: Thank you.
22 MR. LEFEVERE: 1'm sorry? 22 COUNCIL MEMBER RYAN: Mr. Mayor, I just
23 MR. BAER: 23rd. 23 have one question. There is this document that you sent
24 MR. LEFEVERE: 23rd. 24 ea�lier--
25 MR. BAER: Okay. 25 A/1R. BAER: Yes, sir.
58 (Pages 229 to 232)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/U2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COITNCIL MEETING
Page 233
COUNCIL MEMBER RYAN: and distributed
2 tonight. Just perusing it very supe�ciaBy, it appears
3 fo be identicai.
4 MR. BAER: 1 sure hope it is. I didn't
5 compiie it but that was Yhe intention.
6 COUNCII MEMBER RYAN: Yes, i didn't
7 indicate any, or notice any changes.
8 MS. AWSUMB: The only add+tion is a Notice
9 of Mailing or Affidavit of Service, an Affidavit of
10 Maiiing. Otherv✓ise iYs identical.
COUNCIL MEMBER RYAN: Just identifies the
12 date that it was sent?
i3 MS. AWSUMB: Exactly.
14 COUNCIL MEMBEft RYAN: move we adjoum.
MAYOR WILLSON: All in favor? Everyone all
6 in favor say aye_
1 COUNCIL MEMBERS: Aye.
j8 MAYOR WlLLSON: AH opposed say nay_
19 (No response.)
2 MAYOR WILLSON: Hearing is adjoumed.
2 (Proceedings conciuded at 11:31 p.m.)
22
23
24
25
1
Page 2J4
REPORTER'S CERTIFICATE
2
3
4
5 I, Eiizabeth J. Gangi, a Registered Professionai
6 Reporter in the State of Minnesota, do hereby certify
7 that the foregoing pages of typewritten material
8 constitutes an accurate verbatim record transcribed from
9 the stenotype notes taken by me of the proceedings
10 aforementioned before the Srookiyn Genter City Council on
11 the 1 st day ofi October 2007, at the times and place
12 specified.
13
14
i6
17 DATED: October 4, 2007
18
i9
20
2 Eiizabeth J. Gangl
22 Regisiered Professional Reporter
23
24
25
59 {Pages 233 to 234)
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 1
A 223:10 227:8 179:7 211:8 204:20 221:25 234:10
abate 35:13 61:25 absurd 91:10 217:18 225:2 i adequate 16:22 after 9:9 19:8 27: I 1
abatement 4:11 accept i 8:18 48:17 226:5 34:12 35:25 36:13 27:17,22 36:2,3
21.1730:18 7i:22 52:5;8 56:25 actions 155:18 adjacent 108_18 39:23 42:4 53:19
124:18 126:10 b6:24 1 I 8:25 15b:20,23 178: i 6 109:10,11 139:7 56:16 57:13 62:16
173.5 1i9:2 i92:2i activities 116:8 139:12 68:17 69:12 70:11
abide 168_1� 232:13,18 117:22 124:i4 adjourn 233:i4 72:16 7$:12,16
abiiity 95:7 153:18 acceptable 18:5 128:2 129:20 adjourned 233:20 79:18 87:19,22
203:13 accepted 12.7 52: I 5 152:11 154:14 administer 47:23 98:17,18 1 i 9:20
able 9:20 27:17 accepting 66:11,17 activity 25:21 45:1 administered 10:10 147:22 159:1,2 i
28:7 63:22 69:5 177:4 179:14 116:4 120:4 administrating 160:4 161:13,24
86:14, i 6 89:8 access 21:5 232 128:16 129:6 163:13 162:22 164:6
90:15, i 8 91:8,13 b9:� 93:11,20,22 130:23 i 77: i 7 administration 169:25 170:18,19
93:2399:24 i00:2 124:5 acts29:13 35:10 i76:14 171:18,25 173_5
i00:9,16,20 accesses 97:14 actua126:15 72:25 administrative 185:18 228:22,23
101:25 i20:5 according 67:20 1 t0:11 147:23 76:17 229:9,14 230:20
190:13 196:23,24 115_9 172:2 175:1 actaaity 22:24 admissible i77:24 afternoon 37:23
203:10,15 210:12 Accordingly 45:16 44:1 S 47:15 50:22 admit 51:21 73:2 74:18 199:21
about 7:15 i 1:17 account 69:10 54: t0,i 1 61:20 admitted 16$:7 again 30:15 31:3
13:10 20:14 29:17 �03:22 67_7,i3 68:2 178:24 32:7 39:21 49:24
30:14 31:8 37:16 accountability 88:8 77:12 81:2 84_ 19 admitting 51:18 55:4 75:22 91.21
39:5,20,22,22 88 92:23 97:4 102:24 adopt 93:4 93:20 99:19
40:11 4223 44:19 accounted 231:4 104:11 105:17 adopted 7:16 105:22 107:21
46:1 48:14 51:17 accounts 24:12 106:21,24 109:10 adopts 47: i 120:21 121:21
55:14 61 _3,15 accurate 69:10,20 1 Z0:5 129:9 adult 73:3 122:17 123:5
63:14 76:18 80:1 g3:2 i 85:1 115:12 146:11 147:6 adversarial 33:24 127:22 i28:13,15
i 19:7 18 24
80:13 84:9 85:17 153:12 160:1 34:1 129:i3,13 i35:15
86:187:169fl:19 i20:i9121:2 164:191b8:13 adversary10:4 135:19137:22
91:19 92: i 3 962 122: i4 141:17 179:23 207:24 12: i0,12 i43:23 148:22
97:19,20 98:3 145:22 149:13 222:9,11 advice 12:14,15 154:22 160:12
101:3,10,1b 1g8:2z,23191:16 add203:5 16:16 170:21181:14
102.11 105:15 222: i 225:� addition 196:24 advise 19:5 39:5 183:24 211:18
t06:5 107:7 234:8 233:8 42:17 78:18 213:9 219:8 227:3
111:24 i 12_ 1 accused 3b:5 180:3 additional 9:18 advised 21:25 22:17 229:6
114:7 120:14 �g0:5 10:19 36:1 50:11 33:3 61:24 212:i7 against 21:15 28:1 I
130:21 13220 acknow(edged 58:23 135_8 159:1 advisement 46:5 b4:22 65:5 78:20
145: i3 150:11 12 201:9 164:15 221:23,24 advises 35:18 83:25 84:21
150:21 152:8 acknowledging 226:24 227:19,24 advising 10:3 22:5 136:12 155:18
153:8 154:2,14 197:23 201:1,1 Additionaliy 227:3 25:13 172:17 192: ifl,12
155:5,9,13,23 across i8:6 63:1 I address 13:1 14:22 advisor 10:5 192:21 i93:1
156:24 158:2 i 72:19 742 85:2 26:16 49:12 54:2 advocates 20:10 age 227:11
159:8 160:13 g6:15, i 9 8924 58:19 90:13 122:2 affect 48:19 58:2 agencies 199:3
162:8,23 1b9:9 91:9 110:7 114:16 130:11 133:4 Affidavit 233:9,9 agency 20:8,9
179:21 182:16 13424 135:3,19 16421 165:11,17 affi(iated 150:8 16724 168:23,23
187:12,1 S 194: i i 22�=4 186:3 192:7 af6rmative 57:24 199:15 200:20
197:11 202:4,8,25 act 10:5,8 104:10 193:21 215:20 123:23 201:8,20
203:6 216:24 225:12 217:17 affirmatively45:21 agenda 5:19 37:14
217:22 224:1 i2 acting 8:23,24 addressed 29:25 47:4 38:1 S 161:1
22425 226:2 133:14 30:10 34:24 134.7 afford 8:19 190:13 231:10,17,23
aboveground 54:10 action 4:21 8:4,20 138:8 1652,8 203:15 agent 194:12
absent 6:17 22=20 26:11 39:12 176:25 192:19 affordabte 108:4 195:17
abso(ute 1b2:18 41: i3,24 56:17 204:8 208:5 196:3,5 201:22 agents 21:25 22:5
absolutely35:18 123:23 126.i4 22i:11 afforded i80.10,11 47:22 127:5 129:5
98:19 1 S 1:8 196:7 156:24 158:23 addressing 47:13 afieid 48.9 129:10 130:21
202_7 222.i8,25 1b120 168:8 ll2:15 173:6 aforementioned agent's 212:24
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Pubiic Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 2
aging 69:1 213:8 198:21 215:17 39:15 413 45:5,7 209:19 212:8
ago 17:8 76.18,19 allowing 63:24 anticipated 116:14 51 _8 ZZ0
106:15 157:15 64:17 anticipation i 342 appeal 218:17 areas 23:4 45:24
agree i 9_ 15 43:8 allows 120:6,14 anybody 73:17 Appeals 27:10 42:5 63:17 170:1
137:15 i41:I i almost63:6 b5:13 92:11 211:2i appear 54:10 125:1 216:13
145:21 i57:14 106:15 148: i4 anybody's 32:21 164:8 175: i2 argument 27:20
159_ i 6 160:7 2�5:11 2 i4_ i 3 anyone 4 i:9 42:18 206:15 226: i 7
161:2,17 183:22 alone 35:24 iQb:S 83:2 92:9 123_17 appearances 2:6 arguments i2:15
211:14,19 along 7:17 52:14 161:21 180:6 7:24 226:24 228:2
agreed 45:23 121:9 227: i 185:19 202:4 appeared 104:8 arise 19$:15
i 28:12 147:6 alongside 14421 206:1 221:2 165:6 167:17 around 30:13,1 S,1 b
220:6,8 already 26:8 78:9 232:14 177.7 62:20 63:25 93:9
agreement i2725 168:6,6 214:19 anyplace 133:17 appears 136:21 93:11 99:7 101:6
1�3:22,24 154.7 Z 15_ 18 217:16 anything 41:18 66:1 146:8,i 1 2332 172:10 184:25
154: i2 220_5 altered 44:25 66:8 80:12 98:4 applicable 40:3 196:17,18,18
agreements 128:4,4 although 99:11 102:16 103:8 I 80:1 218:14,19,24
157:4 158:3 135:23 219:23 121:15 132:22 appticant 34:9 arrangement
agrees 36:20 47:18 always 46:7 63:18 I 55:12,22 182:14 application 47:19 219:20
ahead 72:6 135:7 212:8 18424 190:25 184:13 arrest 81:6,11
alarm 142:6,9,ll,25 ammunition 73:4 191:23 i94:9 apply 228:10 87:18 8821,24
143:4,5,8,15, i 5 among 9:10 13:13 206:13 209:4 appointments 221:6 100:22
143:20 144: i7 52:4 1 i9:12 223:1 appreciate 27:3 arrested 73:17
145:6,8,i0,11 amount 106:2 107:9 anywhere 64:1 953 37:6 15t:6 159:25 74:13,24 81:8,i0
147:21,25 148:2 123:6 142:19 189:14 apprehended 23:7 81:13,16,18,24
149:5 148_9 149:2 apart 138:17 apprehending 86:9 88:14 152:24
atarms 138:10 i94:24 219:17 195:21 101:22 153:3
i 3920 141:6 amounted 25:2,3 apartment 23:19 apprehension 63:22 arrive 3125 i 38:7
142:7,17,21,24 analysis l i 7:7 24:7,7,9,11 44:8 apprehensions 148:16 149:1
143:8,19 134:b SS:3 61:1 6220 64:i 1 arrived i 1:24 147:4
albeit 3fl:5 Andre 72:12,14 63:10,24 67:10 approach 23:25 arriving 13b:15
Alex 21$:10 and/or 35:12 108:9 70:16 71:2 72:16 120:12 Asgher 22: i 1 59:22
Ali b0:10 64:16 i98_19 199:3 73:13 74:15 91:12 appropriate 13:16 60:10,11,15 61:3
65:5 82:20 91:25 203:18 220:10 91:14 93:1 101:6 16:4 17:18 19:13 61:24 62:7 64:16
92:5,14,19 93:4 anger 72:19 101:7 102:24 26:17 27:9 160:24 64:16 b5:5 82
93:18 9
.19
5.11,23 anima173:15 103:2,6,9,12,14 207_12 225:19 85:9 91.25 92.5
97:8 98:3 annua125:5 106:16 109:19,20 228:2 93:17 95:11 97:24
allegation 66:1 84:3 another 58:18 67:4 110:3 ll2:19,25 approve 57:9 98:3 104:8 i06:5
allegations 28: i0 78:11 93:16 11 i:7 113:1,4,7,i 1 approved 97: i8 106:7,14,20
30:2 i 40:14 41:1 119: i4 127:25 114:12 115:14 approximately 120:18 121:8,24
41:22 6525 66:6 i 28:1,2,13, i9,20 117:13 119:5,6 110:18 112:20 122:9 128:14,16
68:16 126:11,12 129:12,15 135:21 131:15 132:23 116:21 135:16 129:5 172:6
126: i 4,16 173:1 138:7 159:23 133:17 197: ll Apri120:18 35:7 173:12,15 223:6
178:17 192:9 161:7 i 62:10, l2 198:3 200:9 44:16,20 45:3 Asgher's 65:11
193:5 173:6 187:9 215:12,13,22 78:14 128:1,2,13 asked 8.7 i 9:24
ailege 8325 188:24 189:14 apartments 1:9 128:i4,20 129:13 28:3 30:3 39:4
alteged 8:19 10:2 190:9 221.21 6:20 7:7 29:18,20 129:15 i 70:22,25 91:5 92:3,9 95:1 i
34:9 225:25 224:24 230:2 31:14,15 45:25 171:11,17,19,25 95:i5,i7 155:23
altegedly i7822 23i:16 53:14 64:7 82:19 173:8 188:1,2,14 171:23 18b:1,20
224:23 answer 1b:4 39:24 8222 217:24 188:15,25 189:2 187:15 212:21,23
allow 21:5 95:25 70:20 85:24,25 220:25 214:17 216:24
97:15,16 114:25 87:2,5 100:b,7 apologize 117:1,2 area b2:19,20,23,25 asking 14:24 26:5,6
179:4 208:12,16 i48:13 208:23 125:16 135:22 63:2 64:6 74_18 77:3 78:10 81:8
208:18,20,2i answers 159:4 139:24 i01:2,3,5,6,15 94:21,24 95:15
allowed 58:1 86:25 Anthony 2:15 apparent 104:8 i09:1,6,7,8,9 9$:19 i48:3
8?:4,i0,15 184:IS anticipate 161:12 apparent1y28:10 149:2,3 196:2 158:25 179:16
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
I
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 3
186:6,7 221:22 atYendance 22:12 2 i 5:12 59:5,7 65:19 70:3 basis 24:23 26:5
assaulted 74:22 123:3,5 average 117:23 70:17,22 71:9,20 34:15 47:9,25
128=19 attended 5921 60:6 140:14 72:1 75:22,23 51:5 84:12 100:13
assaults 138:5 i06:18 1232 averment 16:i3 76:2 9023,25 106:19 114:15
assert 33:1 attendees 6:2 avoid 22:9 63.22 91:3,8,17 103:18 i 16:9 118_7,22
asserted i 56:18 attention 2120 aware 32:24 55:1 104: i 2,14,16,19 120:6 122:15
assessments 35:9 31:4 84:25 ll2:23 55:18 57:10 82:10 118:18 i2523,25 124:2 127:10
assign 225: i 1 124:15 129:19 82:13 94:11,14 1263,9 130:17 130.1 136: i4
assigned 81:1,2 139:19 i74:7 96:4,6 100:24 131:6,7,10 136:22 i42:18 172:25
112:7,21 163:18 187:7 197:8 107:23 i20:10 136:25 137:3 i99:19 2i8:25
assignment 122:6 attorney 7:9 82 124:20 t5625 139:25 140:4,7,8 224:3 226:8
125:17 21:15,1$36_i1 157:4174:4,6,18 140:10,11141:23 battle73:1,6
assignments 112:3 41:2 42:11 48:8 175:5 185:17 142:1,2 143:23 BCLHA 5:24
125:18 49:10 6720,23,24 186:22 199:14 144:2,8,12 145:24 bear 94:25 137:12
assist 10:6 51:7 68:6 69:13 $3:14 away 8:21 3 l: i,2 149: i 5,19,21 i 59: i
93:10107:9133:9 122:211772 205:4 151:9,10152:4,6 became62:17175:5
217:23 226:18 attorneys 21:22 Awsumb 2:15 8:6 158:7,11,25 195:19 199:14
assistance6224 3424174:15 140:2,6233:8,13 159:15,161b�:5 become29:7,7
107:5 110:i6 audience 149_i9 aye 18:23,24 233_16 Ib1:6,10 162:ll 54:24 64_18
assistant 10:10 204:15 233:17 168:3,4,16 172:24 becoming 21925
218:4,6 audio 231:25 232:3 a.m 67_ 14 73:23 17322 175:21 before 2:2 722 8:20
assisted 50:25 audit 134:2 i 138:6 176:9,21 177:10 9:1,4,5,23 1225
assisting220:8 138:22,23 139:2 B____.____.._ 178:3,14,16 13:12,i516:11
associated 156:18 139:19 141:16 B 38:22 59:5 179:19 180:17,19 17:3 19:25 23_3
178:21 204:18 142:15,18 148:18 back 24:4 27:10 180:21 191:23 28:6 30:13 34:6
Associates i:7 2:13 148:25 149:5 30:13 37:1 39:10 192:4,5 193:i i,12 40:17,22 42:7,19
5:1 6:20 7:b 27:5 audited i37:22 42:4 67:2 74:12 193:15,19 194:4 48:11 493 55:5
38:19,24 83:17 147:2,5 75: i 7 91:18 94:4 197.12,15 i 98:6 57:25 65:3 6'7:19
85:7 86:14 88:1 auditing 148:8,24 96:14 99:13 198:10 201:14,17 76:17 84:10 90:8
177:1 178:9 August 23:14 24:1 105:21,22,22 204:3,6 205:14 113:17 137:23
198:12,14 223:3 24:25 30:4 34:25 106:15 109:22 214:24 2i5:4,6,10 138:11 i39:3
Association 106:17 35:3 38:9, i4,22 1 i 6:24 135:15 223:14,18 225_ 19 145:4 158:16
assume 83:8 143:8 39:9,14,17,23,25 138:6 147:9 227:5,8, i3 230:3 164:2 178:7,22
144:1 i7023 67:i1,1379:18,22 149:20159:23 230:7,18,21,23,25 180:24184:15
176:5 190:23 79:23,23 108:7 164:24 i 66:10 231:13, i 7 232:4 192:25 204:7,20
223:21 232:1 116:16,19 144:15 181:5,6 18b:8 23220,25 233:4 215:21 229:10
assuming 70:6 96:8 146:7 147:2 175:7 189:7 199:18 Baer's 75:19 231:2 232:12
177:4 175:16,25 204:1 214:12 Bailey 193:23 234:10
assurance 69:12 anthenticity 52:1 226:7, i 1 2272 balance i 76:17 began 73:3
assurances 128:22 author 130: i 3 232:16 198:18 203:23,25 begin 20:12 160:4
assure 29:5 authorities i 10:14 backyard 220:7 bantering 37:1 194:14
attached 524 2 i:21 authority 28:15,17 bad 29:13 225:14 barrier 110:5,5 beginning 53:9
37:25 65:12 28:18 46:4 83:9 Baer 2:14,15,21 3:4 barriers 9b:7 97: i 1 55:23 62:9
attachment 171:1 iO4:8,9 106:8 3:9,12,15,17,20 97:12,14,17 98: i begins 27:23
1 153:21,23 1S4:i9 8:5,5 10:16 i2:22 Barton 60:9 begun 212:16
attack 74:14 199:10 205:23 13:3,3,7,9,23,23 base 9:3 1 i 5:19 behatf 2:8,13 8:2,5
attacked 73.21,23 206:1 207:13,i6 14:1,2,10 17:13 based 23:23 24:1,6 10:3 1223 1724
attempt 130:11 authorization 76:14 17:15,22 26:19,23 115:15 117:7 27:4 38:16 68_3
178:19 221:13 authorize 48:1 26:25 33:3,17, i 8 i 32:5 i 35: ll 104:10 123: i 7
attempted 186:9 authorized47:24 34:20 35:2 36:2 i38:21 148:18 128:4,22 i55:16
221:9 automatic 182:24 36:23,25 37:4,17 159:4 159:22 174:21 202:23
attempting 22b:18 avaiiable 132:6 37:24 45:4 47:13 194:25 195:22 behave 94: i
attempts207:24 198:14 221:16 48:15 51:3,22 223:22 behavior i2723
attend 15:22 92:6 227:7 229_3 53:3,9,i0 56:10 basically 164:18 129:14 152:10,i9
92:10 177:22 Avenue 1:24 i77:15 56:11,12 �7:4 224:2 22b:9 152:21,23 153:2
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc_
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1 /2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 4
153:i8 154:2 202:12 227_22 62:19 65:7,8 178:8 198:12,i3 194:1,5 200:17
155:19 i 57:9 better 3120,21 68:13 78:20 223 3 234: i 0 201: i 8 2fl3:9
behind 110:2 32:6 34:5 91:13 101:25 105_7 brother 106:12 204:7 205:15,18
156:11 18 i 23,25 93:25 1 i 2:15 106:14,18 108:25 107:16 222:13,14
219:6 159:19 162.9,23 120:22 121:7 brothers 105:3 business 821 59:1
being 6:24 15:2 betrvee� 21:8 23:17 122: t,2 127:5 127:5 91:12 125:4 I30:8
27:23 55.10,11 23:22 34: i 0 55:15 16 I:19 169:19 brother's 107:1 175:11 195: i0,15
57:15 b8:179i:5 63:493_1 110:3 199:3 226:15 brought 10:19 17:1 196:3 206:S,i6
99:2 i 10025 147:17 171:20,21 bottom 135:12 21:14 3b:14 97_23 217.3 2313:1,9
108:3 i09:6 l 12:8 i89:7 i94:9 bound 48: i4 129:19 150:23 buy 195:25
114:15 120: i 0 201:18 220:24 box 69_4 i 75:b 181:7,10
128:19 i38_5,� beyond 61:13 Brachman 3$:I 1 i92_13 222.11 C
50:9 162:8 172:8 113:20 154:18 Brad 22:13 60:9 build 79:16 93:9 C 39:8
180:4 203:6 211:6 bicyclist 74:18 91:24 Buiiders 195:13 CAD 115:23 130:3
beings 106:21 88:12 break 75:S,i 1,13,15 building 5:14 22:13 cadet 121:25
believe ll:25 12:2 big 37:9 2 i 9:4 75:16 158:17,18 46:3,25 47:1 calendar I 16:2 i
12:21 17:13 19:12 biggest i 01:16 159:21 193:16 54:14,16 63:23 caliber 73:4
53_5 65:11 6b:14 biker 74:i4 213:16 64:3 68:19,20 ca115:1,7 10:21,24
67:24 75:2 80:3 bili 724 220:8 brevity 50:8 69.3,6 74:3,8,19 43:18 90:13
81:14 82:18 83:11 bills 4:1$ 174:21 Brian 44:7 45:6 74:20 76:14 77: i4 1 I 1:11 114:19
84:5 88:21 92:23 176:1 202:21,22 49:24 50:17 77:23 79:1 83: i 3 84:16 115:25 116:1
96:22 99:9 101:13 202:25 203:b brief 48:7 49:2 86:17,18 89:4,18 117:17 130:5
101:13 102:$,9 binder 6:5 i 31:8 227:24,25 98:11 102:16 133.8 136:5 147:7
103.17� 106�.8, ll bird's-eye 53:24 228:1,14 108:11 163:7, i 0 i 48:17,22 159:20
i07:8 i i 1:3 113:9 bit 43:11 49:23 84:9 briefing 226:23 163:13,14 183:2,3 18b:13,20,20
123:1 126:21 98:21 114:I 1 briefly 17:16 37_21 183:6 184:3 193:15,17 220:17
133:2215325 160:13 50:3103:20 i89:23197:22 221:2123122
164:20 16b:4,11 bits 49:22 104:18 163:10 211:10 219:5,5 calted 15:23,24
168:6,18 169:9 blight 29:8 briefs 49:12 227:19 221:2,5,10 38:1 i 59:16,22
170:13 171:14 block 96:8 110:8 228:12 229:5,14 buildings 21:9 60:1 7�:7 74:11
174:18 175:4 blocked 96:10,17,19 229:25 22:23 23:4,11,13 115:23 132:13
178:19 180:17 96:20,21 97:14 Brierton 38:11 35:11 54:1,4,7,7,9 133:2 i71:1 179:3
18L•6,9,12 185:9 blocks 63:14 bring 19:24 21:19 54:12 55_lb b3:21 18521 i9b:12
188:23 203:10 board 18:7 126:23 36:18 62:1 i07:4 64:10 b9:13 calling i0:15 116:5
206:23 218:11 137:16,18 146:15 116: U 134: i 3 103:16 114:14 153:1
220:2 i 223:2 146:24 147:21 155:17 159:1 13 i: l6 185. i 1 catls� 5:8, i 0 21: i 1
231:17 148:5 i77:14 broken 22:24 23:13 195:25 21 i:15,20 23:22,24 24:1,4
believed 74:8 2 i 7.23 68:17,22 108: i 2 214:1,9 217:13,15 24:12, i 5 26: i 4
belong 45:13 i20:3 body 66:13 159_3 108:13 210:19 218:24 219:9 43:12 53:21 b0:3
betongs 120:14 1603 i98:1 229:4 213:21 214: i build-up 68:24 60:22,24,25 72:7
betow 140:16 Boganey 622,23 Brookdale 63: i 2 built 23:20 102:3,4 107:5,10 112: i 8
bene�t 148:12,23 37:10 57:8,10,14 90:8 102:6 I] 3:10 1 i 4:8,17
Benner 3:7 22: i4 57:18 60:8 91:23 Brookhaven 25:3 balk 123:3 i 1424 115:2,6,9
23:8 43:19,20 boiler 218:8 25:11 106:16 bull 73:8,12 115:13, i b 116:11
44:1,5,12 49:14 bond 4:18 2S_5 Brooklyn 1:1,7 2:1 6uHs 73:15,17 116:15,20 I i 7:16
52:11,24 58:22 35:10 176:14 2:2,i3 5:1,24 6:19 burden 133:8 117:17,20,2i,24
59:12 67:9 70:13 182:7,16 183:4 7:6,22 8:11 27:5 burnt 145:3,9 118:8,11,14
70:25 72:3 75:1 203:3 38:18,24 39:1 bus 63:10 89:23 123:22 130:23
75:19,21 76_3 bonds 182:16 41:17 53:17 7b:10 90:1,6,8,i2,18,i9 131:15 132:9,16
86:21 111:8 156:8 book 55:25 113:17 83:8,16 85:6 86:9 91:9,14 i01:9, i i 132:24 133:16,19
156:14,15 113:25 146:23 86: i 3 87:25 i 09:4 108: i 7,25 i09:10 i 33:20,24 134:14
Benner's 156_ 12 152:8 164:2 187:8 111:20,25 112:6,6 109:15,17,22 134:19,19 135:4
besides 217:24 187:25 124:12,24 13 7:9 110:3,12,19 135:10,12,13
best 16:17 61:21 born i95:12 Ib3:8 174:22 i39:12 1362,6,10,20
62:12 166:16,24 both 12:16 59:1,19 175:10 176:25 Busch 3:16 193:20 137:5, i 1,22 139:4
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing i 0/ 1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETiNG
Page 5
139:6,7,9,13,i3 casuai 172:9 135:25 136:11,19 233:7
i40:14,24 141:3 cate or 131:17 36:10,16,17 37:20
g Y 137:5,8,9,19 chapter 5:6 45.18 38:2,6,7,16,17
142:15,21 143:12 136:7 138:12,18 i39:7,8 46:2,13,14,18,22 39.i,1040:3
144:15 145:15 caulking Ib5:i8 139:14 144:15 140:5
146:10,20 147:1,2 185:13 41:12,14,24 462
147:i0,13,21,23 cause31:11 47:24 157:�,11�163 8 ��138 14 48:8 S�0 16,1$����
147:25 148:8,18 49:23 66:14 164:7,14 1b5:2 charge 40:8 100:25 55: I 56:15 5725
i48.24,25 149=4,6 142:11 i45:9 168:1 i 169:12 223;12 224:2 58: i4 59:2,21,25
149:10 174:8,10 caused 169:15 174:21,22 1752,5 charged64:17 60:8,14,14,19
174:11 193:19 182:21
175:1
0, i 6 17625 100:25 14
209:17,i7,24 �•�s 70.i483:14,14
causes 143:4 178:8,8,21 179:2 163:12 180:4 90:4,5,11,11,14
210:2,6,14 21 i: i causing 63:2 100:19 179:9 I 81:22 charges 17:1 30:20 91:14,22 92:4,5
224: I S CD 20:15 50:3 187:4 189:20 30:21,24 32:22 98:5 99: i 6 102:5
came 39:16,24 ceded 28:15 19I:14,14,18 33:19,22 342,11 104:6,7 106:6
84:1588:699:i3 ce116_3 172_12 194:10 i95:21 34:i4192:12,22 107:6,7,23,24
136:9 139:iR center i:1,7,9 2:1,2 196:b,10 198:12 192:23,25 225:24 109:1,3 110_I l
17 i:11 180:24 2:13,16 4:3, i 3 5:1 198:13 199:8 Chariie 161:5 i 11:20 112:25
219:12 5:24 6:19,20 7:6,6 202:5,14 20b:5,16 229:25 117:8 119:8,9
camera 49:17,22
22 8: i 1 20:2,9 211:22 2133 chart 146:1 123:6,17,23
50:23 93:21,22 20:17 2222 23:2 214:4 215:13,15 chea 108:5
95:3 97:3 23:17,22 24:4,10 215:24 216:1,4,11 check 95:19,22 1303 1331
cameras 105:16 24:10 25:2 27:5 217:9,24 22024 180:24
ca acit 8:24 135: i 7 141 B
P Y 29:18 31:i0 38:18 222:23 223:3 checked23i:7,8 142:10 i49:4,6
CAPTIONING 38`.24 39:1 41:17 234:10 checks 203:8 153:5� i56:5,6,20
1:23 44:8 52:25 53:14 CenterPoint 25:8 chief 96:9 163:8,13,19
car 73:8,9 53:17 55:2 61:1,4 174:5,17 176:8 Chiids 218:7 168:15,17 169:4
card 74: i 0,11 62:13,19 63:5,10 certain 7:3 8: I 2 choose 35:20 72:8 169:11 174:16,22
care i83:1 202:18 64:1� 67:10 70:15 9:18 15:6 1922 chose 158:5 175:i,2,10,16
209_S 218:21,21 71:2,4,12,13,24 22:19 124:6 125:9 chosen 3024 176:1,8,12;16
222'3 �2:15,22 73: i 28:4 138:3,3 Christine 2 i 8:4 177:13, i 6,18,2 i
career112:3 195:18 74:4,15 76:i0,25 139:16 i42:19 chronological 179:24 1$3:14
caretakers 218:10 77:1,8,i8 80:16 147:4 148:9 149:2 17p;22
219:1,2,10 184:16,17,21
81:7,23 82:1,5,15 190:24 211:23,25 chronology 169:19 i90:19 192:1,17
Carl 218:7 82:19,22 83:8,17 224:16 228:13 circulate 229:3 197:22 203:12
carpet 200:10 85:7 86:6,7,9,13 230:1 circulated 229:7 207:20,25 209:4
carries 19:2 86:25 87:4,25 certainly 725 39:10 circumstances 220:15,17,24
carry87:15 88:16,17 89:24 120:1 10 124:
20 11
carrying 87:17 90:12,17,20,24 127:17 133:5,25 citat on 78:23 225:22,23 227:7
Carson 2:10 11:21 91:2,6 92:9,19,24 134:16 142:18 citations 77: i 3 79:4 234:10
case 10:14,22 12:13 93:4 95:8 98:14 144:3 153: i 7,20 cited 48:25 City's 6:25 28:1 S
18:13 19:19 34:11 98:15,i7 101:6,18 154:16 155:1 Citgo 72:19 29:25 37:21 56:12
42:7 65:14 73:18 101:21 105:12 157:25 227:9 city 1:1,2 2:1,8 4:1 82:24 95:12 1102
74:24 79:1b 86:i6 106:9,22 1fl8:18 CERTIFICATE 4:20,22 5:6,19,24 13i:12 i68:ll
i 08:5 129_4 109:4,7,11,15,1 g 234: I 6:2,4,23 7: i,4,8,8 City-Prepared
148:23 159:23 109:20 110:3 certification 212:24 7:9,22 8:2,11,16 147:13
162:23 214:17 111:20,25 112:19 certified 212:25 10:4,6 17_7,9 18:2 civil 156:10 180:1
21621 i
11222 113:6 certify 234:b 18:13 1924 2fl:7 claim 92:23
cases 26:7 64:8,13 114:8 I 15:9,17 CFS 132:9,9 20:23 21:14,24 claimed 95:16
76:6 88:4 10 i:19 116:11,15 117:4 challenge 52:1 22:10, i 2,16 23:19 claims 92:24
i09:23 114: i3 117:24 i 18:8 Chambers 22 24:7,9, i 1,20,21 clarify 13:22 34:5
115:2 ll6:7 1 i9:6,18 122:4 chance 10:18 3b_b 24:24 25:1,5,15 97:1 i
129:25 i42:20 124:24,24 127:7 change 220:1 25: i9,22,25 26:1 ciause 206:20,22
143:13,16 148:10 127:15 13 I:19,23 changed 138:2,1 Z 26:5,10,12,22 clean 1402 209:1 S
14822 132:2,4,i6,18 214:19 27:25,25 29:5,23 21824 219:2
cash 175:10 134:5 135:14, i 5 changes 107_3,10 30:1 3122 3b:10 cleaning 219:1 I
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-OS45
Public Hearing 10/i/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 6
clear 11:9 2021 176:3,6,1 t,19,23 coins 9824 99:7,11 communicated 1 �Z:1
37_16,18 78:12 177:8,11 178:1,10 99:13,25 100:4,9 202_4 com��aints4:9
106:25 126: i3 178: i3,15,20,25 100:22 108:9 communicating 20:10 21:14 41:1
ciearly 11: i i 21: l9 179:19 180:15 217:10 220:10 99:18 57:1 64:15,21,22
38:23 105:13 i 81:2 182:8,17 collect 195:3 communication 65:2,7,8,10,12,17
177:23 225:25 183:$ 187:12 collections i94:25 201:6 6520,21 66:3,7
Clelland 2:9,i0 3:3 191:25 192:7,24 collectively 20:14 communications 77:13 82:12 83:24
3:8,9,11,i4,18 193:3 i97:13,14 133:10 i27:12 83:25 84:i0,10,15
7:25 8:1 10:2,IS i98:8 201:15 coiumn i14.12,17 communities 84_20,21 126:17
10:17,21,22,25 205:17 214:23 114:21,23 1352,5 179:12 169:23 173:1
ll:21 12:2,5,8,10 216_24 222: i4 146:9 147:10,13 community 29:9 compiete 27:18,19
12:2�,23 14:19,21 223:15,19 226:20 147.20,22 60:9,10,i8 9L 193:10 200:b
1�:1 16:19 19:3,4 228:4,i6 229:20 columns 135:9 9124 112:5 123:4 225:8 227:16
19:2� 27:15,20,24 230:9,13,17 231:1 combination 90:16 163:21 169:23 completed 9:9,15
28:3,7 29:14, i 6 23221 come 32:15 38:18 197:6 1022 165: i 8
30:2,13,24 32:10 Cielland's 146:12 38:19 40:16 42.4 companies 220:3 166:6 1672,4
32:25 33:16,24 146:13 1 S2:& 43:20 45: i 7 54:12 company 25:9 170:20 185:7
34:18,22 38:15,23 187:8 63_ 18 64:1,2,4 2922 38:1 i 83_9 i91:9 197:24
39:2,5,9,20,21,22 clerk 10:10 37:12 73:18 74:12 75:17 150:8 166:5,19 199:21 2413,4
40:1741:1,2� 83:14 94:4109:14 194:8195:11,12 21223,24
43:16,17 44:4 client 27:4 28:1 111:12 138:2 195:14,15,22,23 comptetely 54:16
45:18 46:16,i9 40.14 68:4 9I_5 147:9 148:21 197:10,1fl 201:25 comp(ex 23:7,25
47:14 49:19 50:2 99_18,20 i02:13 149:20 155:25 202:16,22 203:7 44:8,10 53:24
50:7,13,14 S 1:23 192:10,12,18 159.23 IbS:17,23 217:19 219:21,22 55:3 6 i:1,8 63:5
51:24 52:7,9,10 193:1 166:10 174:7 220.1,4 63:10 64_9 67:10
52: i6,18,2i,23 clients 27:9 28:9 180:9 199:2 209:2 comparable 23:20 67:17 70:16 712
53:3,7,11 SS:S,b,9 33:7 35_14 38:18 213:18 229:6 23:21 117:12,14 72:16 74:5,15
55:13,17 56:3 3$:19 45:14 82:13 comes 142:i9 compare i 18:20 91:12,14 100:3,5
57:5,2158:18,20 102:15180:10 coming672,3 136:ll 101:6,7102:6
5821 59:4,9,10 client's 31:2 40:2 93:23 109:7,8,20 compared 137:16 106:16 i09: i 1,15
59:11 65:17 66:9 51:19 commence 26:3 209:25 1�9:19,20 i 10:4
66:10,25 67:3,8 close 920 32:7 commencing 1:19 compares 114:24 1 i2:19 115:3,5
69:21,23 70:12,20 63:15 97:2,9 2:1 comparison 5:10 119:b 125:19
70:25 71:7,18 14b:1b 214:21 comment32:13 23:17 114:25 127:21 132:23
72:5 74:25 79:10 230: i,9 48:7 66:23 203:b i 16:25 117:6,18 133:2 135:25
79:16,20 80:9 closed 95:13 commentary 45:9 i 24:2 133:25 143: i 1S 1:12
92: i 2 103:20,23 closely 212:9 comments 14:19,24 134:1 1983 209:22
104:1,3,4, i 5,24 cioser 162:22 18:4 32:11 106:7 comparisons 4:17 212:4 217:13
104:25 105:2 closing 96:1 217:1 t commerciai 195_25 competent 170:12 218:14,20,24
111:1,4,b, l l, i 7 code 6:25 7:22 8:11 commit 21:6 212:4 compilation 24:2 219:4
113:16,18 118:17 8:14,1 b 22:6 committed 82:1,4 50:10 115:13 complexes 23:19
1 18:2 i 119:4 25:24 46:23,25 82:13 129:6 118:23 24:7,8 59:20
125:22 i26:12,13 47:1 58:2,24,25 130:22 compile 115:19 62:2093:1 112:25
126:19 127:1,3 59:13,18 61:25 Committee 22:13 233:5 113.11 i 14:13
130:15,19 1313,5 76:14 77:14 79:1 4 i:13,14 compiled 41:4,5 115: i4 117:6
i44:5,8 146:23 84:16 127:7 committing 23:6 1 i5:21 133:19 135:14
147:8 149:17 i 63:18,20 i 70:5 I 01:17 1 D9:14 i 34:11 compliance 4:5,8
158:13,21 159:5 172:18 i99:4 common 23:4 45:24 complain 40:11 5:16 20:3,23,24
159:16,22 160:2 I 225:13 226:10,12 107:22 110:10 complainant 64:15 21:16 35:5,7
160.24 1 b 1:4 coded 139:9 170:1 179:6,7 complaining 98:3 47:22 55:19 56:4
163:1,2,b 168:1 codes46:4 47_2 211:20 2i2:3 102:11 56:14 58:5,6,24
168:13,24 169:$ 163:13 (69:1,4 commonality 179:1 complaint65:5,1 l 58:24,25 7$:8,17
i69:13 172:22 1832 commonly t77:19 65:25 66:8 78:19 78:22,24 79:3,5
173:4,20 i 74:1,3 coin 23:1 1Q7:15 communicate 39:3 7823 82:6 85:1 79:12 122:19
175:19,23,24 21020 39_4 116:3 i48:15 13�:24 132:4,17
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 7
132:18 163:18,20 conditiona1225:20 constantiy i 09:6 90: i 5,19 91:9 89:10,13,19 90:15
i64:3,13,1S,19,24 conditioned 58:4 cor�stitutes 234:8 93:11,20 i33:6 90:17 92:15,21
1652,4,7 167:6 conditions 7:3 constraints 161:14 203:22 94:18 95:9 95: ll
167:11 168_11 20_19,20 32:2,3 201:9 controlled 125:8 98:25 99:1,2,4,5
169:1,5,15,21 44:$ 51:25 52:25 construction 117:13 controlling 91: i 3 99:15 100:21
17�2,14,17,25 73:16 179:2 195:14 124:5 10i:4,i3,19 i02:3
171:10,11,17 conduct 76:14,24 consult 46:21 controversy 229:22 103. 1,17 1fl5:6
172:19173:7,7,8 77:7146:25 consume135_i7 convenient75:7 106:3107:12
184:16,21 186:2 165:23 167:14 contact 120:17 co►�ventiona(ly 109:11 110:23
187:19,21,25 170: i 172:5,12 220:14 196:4 i 11:20 113:1,2,9
188:1,3,6,14,18 conducted 134:21 220:23 221:1 conversation 95.18 113:21,25 114:1,3
188:19,2� 1892 138:6 167:12 contacted 156:14 121:13 150:14,21 115:10,18 116:12
190:16 191:3,4 169:12 189:12 166:5,10 172:9 22 i.3 1 i 7.25 1182
199:3,15,24 200:1 confirm 56:1 contacts 106:14 conversations 62:3 122:5,7,11,12
200_3 207:19,20 con�rmation23:9 122:7 121:8 125:14,20,2i
208:3,4 214:22 121:23 contained 81:15 convey 68:7 i 26:25 129:7,11
222=12 conflicted 72:18 135:24 137:24 conveyed 60:13 129:12 131:17,25
complied 17:11 conformity i 79:11 171:1 conveying 33:4 132:4,5,10,13,14
120:25 confused 85:14 containing 37:25 convicted 72_ 13 132: i7,19 133: i7
complies 53:25 1$3:8,12 context 65:13 87:18 88:19,20 134:23 136:2,3,7
compiy35:5,7,10 confus�on 97:10 continuat 122:16 conviction 87:15 136:8,20 137:6,18
39_ 10 11922 conjunction 1�8: lb continually 21:25 8822 137:19 138:14
128:9 153:21,24 connect 54:6 continue 9:2 i 13:13 convinced 74:20 139:21 141:6
156:10 169:3 connected 54:10 116:23 198_5 cooperate 103:9 143_9,20 144.15
191:15,20 226:10 70:1S,i8 72:8 215:4 cooperation 30.1,3 144:18,23 146:7
comprehensively 85:22 92:9 continued 9:16,17 30:8 31:2 i 95: i Z 147:11 149:8
163:21 connection 63:4 9:18 22:5 26=9 151:7 150:16,i7,19,24
comprise 113:6 71_3,24 69:1 72:19 73:i0 copied 129:10 150:25 15222
comprising 177:17 connects 54:9 76:20 129:24 copies 220 5:24 153:4,9 154:9
computer-aided consent 45:20 47:5 130:20 i4:4,13 28:4 155:14 156:16
115:24 consents 47_3 continuing 63:12 35:14 4423 15722,23 163:$,9
concept 112: i 2 conservaYive 148:11 8 I:5 122:15 127:6 144:11 163:22,23,25
179:3,25 consider 9:22 l l:4 127:10 171:19 copy6:3 32:17,22 164:1,11,15 170:3
concepts 61:15 18:10 19:21 20:16 177:16 214:4 38:8 80:8,10 170:4,7,8,1b
concern 25:15 28:12 31:18 32:1 217:9 l 19.12 121:25 171:2 172.19,20
101:16 124:3 32:8 36:7 48:16 contract 166:b,10 134:17 139:25 173:9,10 175:7,8
concerned ll.3 56:20 214:8 228:9 190:20 194.17,19 140:2,4,9 187:9 177:6 184:14,17
36:9 112:18 162:7 229:12 198:20 202:13 231:16 184:21,22 185:13
162:8 considerable 22:16 205:20,24 206:20 corner 6:5 962fl 185:14 187:17,19
concerns 29:25 30:9 i06:2 148:20 206:25,25 207: i7 corporations 2Q6:7 187:20 188:1 i,lb
60:16 80:5,6 consideration 8:4 contracted 150:9 correct 11:21 12:4 188:20,25 189:3,5
conclude 132:2 15:5 19;23 48:23 contractor Si:l2,14 12:18 14:8 17_12 190:10,11,14,18
159:9,10 162:3 179:18 165:16 166:9 44: i 7,18,21 45: l 19423 195:6,7
conduded 233:21 considered 19:14 contractors 165:24 54:2,3,17 55:13 200:7 2032,5
concluding 2b:19 27:13,15 56:2 166:17,20 55:2i,22 57:19,24 204:10,12,i6
conclusion 136:10 184:5 231:21 contracts 165:10,25 59:2,23,24 60:12 205:9 20b:11
148:21 considering Ib:2 185:8 65:4 67:12 68:1,4 207:3,18 209:2
conclusively 56:18 consistency 58:8 contrast 23:21 68:5 69:9 72:23 210:4 Z 13:5
condition 29:18,20 consistent 9: i4 contribute 61:2 72:24 76:1 i,15 corrected 105.21
35:6 45:19,22 73:16 124:17 77:25 78:6, i 5 171:5,5,25 172:2
53:1,13 58:7,24 consistently 24:12 contributes 211:15 79:1 �,16,20,21,24 198:1 199: i7
69:1 i 94: i2,19 58:13 127:4 211:21 80:18,20,24 82:14 211:7 222:21,2 i
142:12,12 164:17 consisting 130:2 contributing 21_10 83:18 84:1,2,24 correction 55:20
190:16 198:2 consists 114:22 86:20 109:24 85:21 86:3,4,23 corrections 105:19
213:19 constant i00:13 contro132:4 64:18 87:20 88:15 89:5 corrective 22:19
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 8
26:11 Councii's 56:17 crime 20:4,5,5 curbs 97:16 80:20,23 99:22,24
correctly 27:8 124:15 168:8 23:16 26:15 35:13 cure 31:7,10 41:11 100:13 108:2
3320 34:7 75_ 18 counsel 10:5,22 60:23 61.18 622 cured 182:21 148:25 164:19
76: i 2$5: i 8 12:12,15 15:24,24 62:18 63:1,2 71:6 current 2323 24:23 203.6 2 i 5:17
140:21 142: i 3 19:6 34:7,23 72:13,23 82:9 35:8 119:7 122:6 229:9,14,21,21
168:19 1$3:14 36:20 37:21 39:2 88:10 902,3,12 15922 175:6 day-to-day 203:15
corretation 2 i:8 39:4 48:1 i 49:12 90:16 91:5,9,13 i 81:7,10,11,� 5 deal i 7:19 32:15
corresponclence 105:1 154:13 92:20,25 94:7,22 currentty 35:9 178:7,8 21323
4:13,23 77:10 16221 226:15,25 107:4 108:17 50:18 200:11 214:6 224:11
12�2� 227:4 228:21 I 10:i2 112:15,i8 224:13 225:3 228:24
Council 1:2 2:1 230:1 123:22 124:3 Curt 60.8 9123 dea(ing 120:IS
5:20 6:2,4,8,9, count 137: i4 125.19 i26:22 cut 108:17 i i0:12 216. i 8
6:11,12,13,16,23 148:17,17,22 127:6,6 128:6 203:7 deatings i06:14
7:8,9,13,14,14 8:1 229:23,24 12921 130:21,21 223.6
8:17,23 10:4,6,8 counted 138:5 133:8 196:20,23 D__ deals i41:18 183:5
11:18,19,2� 12:9 139: i 3 140:24 209:10 2 i 1:16,22 D 39:19,22 dealt 13:13 42:5
12:16,19 13:I0,17 141:3 224:15 Dahline 127:20,22 157_18 i79:13
15:4,8,9,10 i 6:8 counting 96: i 5 crimes 21:6 23:6 128:1,1,3,14,17 debris 68:23
17:7,9 i 8:15,15 country 61:22 51:1 58:12 b2:22 129:2 decade 106:1 S
18:17,21,24 19: i County Sfl25 62:24 64:17 7fl:14 71:1 daily 199:19 December 164:21
19:5,25 26:17 108:24 110:14 7124 72:22 82:1 damage 138:9 164:25 165:4
27:3 32:14,21 couple 33:20 48:10 82:4 84:19 85:17 Dan 2 i 8:9 decent 29:5 209:15
3421 36:9 37:4 108:12 158:20 100:3 1fl9:7,14, i4 darkened 144:2 i decide 9:11 27:17
38:2,7 41:13,25 162:10 191:18 125:7 179:5 212:4 data 93:1 114:18 30:23 48:17
42:16,25 43:1,7 223:21 229:13 criminat4:9 21:13 115:19,23 124:17 179:14 206:16
43:1$ 44:16 45:23 courier 36:4 26:13 30:19 40.25 149: I 224:3 225:12,23
46:8,10,1 i,12,17 course9:6 3322 64:15 6521,25 date9:lb,17 11:9 229:18,19 232:i3
48:4,5,6,22 49_3,5 4124 125:4 66:3,7 78:19 82:5 38:14 57:11,13 decided 26:8 126:15
49:7,8 55:15 126:14 133:12,12 82:12 83:24 84:15 89:20 12 i: i 8 2203
56:20,24 57:6,7,8 i37_25 192:8 100:24 i 16:3 164:24 165:4 deciding 31:18
57:10, I3,1 b,20 court 8:7 10:13 120:4 124:24 17fl:14,24 171:10 48: i6 95:12
65:22 65:3,19,20 11:4,6,15 14:5 126:11,17 12723 171:17 173:9 decision 9:2,3,7,i0
66:21 71:11 75:10 27:10 30:19 31:1 128:15 129:6,14 181:11,15 187:22 9:14 10:8 16:3,i6
75:12 85:18 90:6 42:5 �2:3 65:3,9,9 129:19 i30:23 i88:1,14 i91:16 17:4 26:6 28:13
91:4 98:22 113:17 65:10 66:4 126_ 15 i 52:9,1 fl,19 153:2 199:24 200:1,3 30:24 34:8 105: i 0
114:7 118:25 155:17 155:19 157:8 233:12 106:22 i 55:1
136:23 141:24 courthouse 155:25 172:17 173:1 dated 34:25 38:7,9 156:11 172:7
i5122,23,24 courts 30:16 179:4 179:3,22,25 i 80:8 38:22 58:5 i 2 i:21 177: i 2 206:12
152:2,5 158:22 courtyard 7324 180:12 127:19 128:13,14 226:7 229:17
160:7,9 161:23 cover 10: i 8 Criminals 23:1 129:12,15,16 decisions 27:22
i 62: i,1,4,6,18 covered 205:12 cross 75:3,19 160:4 164:3 167:7 105:11
164:2 168:20,21 covering 165:16 180:18 170:25 173:8,11 decision-making
168:22 169:6 covers 146:6 cross-examination 174: i6 175:11 104:9 i06:8
178:7 190:8 192:6 co-owner l Ob:13 3:9,12, I 5, i 8 188:1,14 234: U 205:23 206:1
192:20 193:13 cracked 222:7 10:20,24 48:19 dates 171:25 189:1 I decline 208:13,17
195:8,20 199:23 create 133:8 71:19,21 722 228:13 229:22,24 213:9
2082 217:22 created 14:4 134:2 76:1 131:9 159.13 day 25: i l 30:5 deciining 24:15
219:20 223:25 134:4 159:17 180:20 31:23 39:14,25 dedicated 6222
224:16 225:3,b,22 creates 29:9 110:5 205:16 61:14 b5:8 66:3 108:22
225:23 226:23 credibility 11:5 cross-examine 67:18 121: i4 deem 183:20
227:10 228_18,20 48:20 225:12 i0:17 45:7 51:7 170:23 186:5 deemed 199:2
229:3 230:5 credible 84:8 180:6 205_8,10 2i9:7,8 default4:19 40:3
231:11,12,13 credit 5:16 169:3 Cub 63:13 227: ll 229:23 41:8 176:25 177:6
232:22 233:1,6,11 credits i69:2,5,7 curb 218:17 230:1 234:11 182:17,21,23
233:14, i 7 234:10 Creek 2:2,10 curbing 97:13 days 16:11 7925 defeat 107:17,25
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc_
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1I2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETiNG
Page 9
defeated 108:9 i69_24 170:3 170:6,19 171:13 i23�20 158:20 117_20 i18:9,1�
210:20 212:12 181:18,21 185.19 194:24 199:15 i 7$:19 i 86:20 124:1 127:17,19
defective 2 i 0:18 189:23 19723 determining 155:21 discnssed 34:1 134:24 i 35:13
2i1:4,5 221:2,10 212:15 225:17 77:11 93.17 98:2 138:16 i45:20,21
defects 55:20 departments 89:1 deterrent 93:25 i2325 124_3 147:5,8 148.4
defendants 26:8 220:20 110:6 i47:5 164:23 165:22
deferred 203: i 8 department's 64:18 devetoped 112:8 discussion 18.22 167:10,20,22
define 152:21 depend 116:2 202:1 147:7 198_11 42:7 53:18 75:25 175:13 232:23
defined t35:4,19 depending48:21 development22:13 97:8 107:7 161:21 documentation
definitely 137:15 19825 60:9,10,19 91:24 171:20,21 227:17 39:13 144:4 157:6
detay 48:6 depends 183:20 91:24 123:4 232:10 20 i:10 212:22
delayed 65:6 deplorable 179:2 163:21 169:23 discussions 51 10 documented 128:25
delaying 27:7 deposiY 198:14,17 183_6 105:23 documenting
delete 66:22 deputies 51:1 62:25 differ 2262 disincentive 29:9 i2�:23
deliberate 9:10 DEPUTY 37:12 difference 146:17 disinterested 33:2 documents 4:7
20:16 229:19 derived 115:23 146:19 147:16 dismissed 193:8 1922 26:2,4 33:4
detiberation 9:23 describe b3:8 68:13 different 30:5 54:16 disorder 20:6 35:13 33:6 35:23 36:4,8
deliberations 921 71:3 72:25 73:20 88:21 92:13 94:24 i i2_l6 128.6 1 i8:19,23 125:i3
deliberative66:13 74:4,14 105:9 107:16 138:21 dispatch 117:21 126_8 128:1fl
delighted 202:10 163:10 169:19 141:2 146:22,23 139:9 130:6 134:14
delinquent 25:13 i95:8,20 196:8 149:1 216:19 dispatched 139:11 143: i i 144:6
174:4,6,20 175:17 described 28:22 2202 226:2 dispatching 115:23 147:14 159:10
175:1 102:2 138:4 differently 22923 115:24 130:3 177:17
deliver 19:6 description 89:7 differs 137:i5 148:19 dog 73:15
delivered 2:20 136:5 171:1 difficulty 119:17,19 displace I 10:10 doing 103:4,8
121:24 descriptions 171:15 200:12 displaced 158:5 10921 133:15
demand i77:S 2fl8:7 diligently2lb_15 display 124:i 13724 147:3
2�3:g design 61 _9,9 93:8 direct 3:8,11,14,17 134:15 162:7 184:19
demanded 74:10 93:15,1 b i 24:1 I 320 9:13 26:11 dispositive 35:25 i 90:6 21924
demolished 108:3 designated 4722 4125 44:3 111:16 disproportionately Dominium 34:25
demonstrate 128:12 designation 144:17 148:7 163:5 194:3 20:5 21: i 1 38:12 83:10
demonstrated designed 21:19 215:9 226:17 dispute 207:5 done 8:9 ifl:20 17:8
29:14,1b desk 11:24 directed 112:21 disputes 38:25 27:8,11 44:6 49:5
demonstrates 135:8 despite 90:14 directing 93:10 disrepair 54:21 96:7,9 99:12
denia17:2 130:20 178:i0 124:15 distance 63:15 108:19 128:12
denied 144_7 detail 80_16,19 $1:1 direction 18_3 63:6 distinction 34:10 151:7 16fl:2
Dennis 72: i 1,20 81:3,5,8,11,24 63:16 105:18 distorted 13321 162: i 9,22 180:2,2
department 8:3 99:23,24 224: i 160:2 170:10 distressed 196:16 184:24,25 185:16.
21:24 22:15,17 detailing 35:3 directions 64:7 212:7 185:20 188.19
36:17,18 41:13 i 29:13 105:23 distribute 143:24 189:5,8,10, i 5,20
48: i 59:13, I S detained 120:5 directly 31:2 58:2 disYributed 233:1 190:21 191:1,6,14
60:8,21 6i:6 detainer 158:4 58:12 71:22 121:4 distribution 2:21 19824 199:1,20
62:22 68:2 7b: 13 deterioration 29:8 121:15 125:10 district 10:13 11:4 199:20 200:12
77:18 78:17 79:14 determination 208:1 214:7 65:3 2p2.2 2p�_g g
84:17 86:9 90:1 13:17 16:22 66:4 director 22:13 disturbance 148:17 214: i 6 215:23
95:16, i 6,17,19,22 224:16 169:23 183:6 division 51:1 65:9 217:16 222:7,11
95:25 97:7,13,15 determine 31:23,24 disabled 23:13 65:10 222:16 227_ 11,14
97:21,25 103:9,14 42:16,17 82:25 disagree 27:16 doable 228:15 door 4: i 5 63:24
1 �3: i 5 108:15,16 142:16 159:3 disagreement 1473 doctored 222:15 64:2 68:16,18,21
ll2:24 115:22 1b0:4 170:18 disappear23:3,5 document 12: t,3 68:22 69:1,i I,l&
125:5 130.9,24 171:12 i79:17 disappeared 63:19 17:21,23 33:5 7b:7 89:16,20
134:22137:9 199:13225:7 disc50:952:1b 3b:442:9,10 107:211b6:5,19
143:7, i 0 144:23 228:21 disctosure 39: i 1 55:23 56:2 51:19 21 l:25 213:17,25
145:12,13 153:6 determined 40:4,7 discomfort 49:23 64:24 114:10 214:10,18 216:15
154_19 t55:24 t67:23 1b9:21,25 discuss80:5 123:ll 116:i7 117:2,15 216:16,21217:1
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing l0/l/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 10
doors 21:4,5 22:23 duty 17:6 44:2 effectively 154:5 17b.8 22�:13
23:10,13 35: i 2 51:22 57_4 59:7 157:18 168:$ enforce 46.3 47:23 Esq 2:9,14, i5
53:1,2,14,1 S 104:14 1 i i:15 efficiently 159:7 154:8,1 I 183:2 essentiatiy 14:12
54:14,20,20 58:10 127:2 130:18 effort 22:9,9 98:17 enforcement 46:24 167:14
61:10 62:5 64:3 144:10 163=4 98:17,18 110:20 59:14 i 10:12,19 establish 65:25
67:12,16,1b,21 168_�9 173.24 112:13 111:19,22 i 12:14 established 66:14
b8:8,14 69:5,11 175:22 194:2 efforts 108:15 enforcing 154:b estate 194_8 195:24
69:14 79:19 98:9 198:9 20 i:16 eight 44:20 76: l 8 163:18 195:2�
98:18 99:16 215:8 76:18 engage 72:1 estimate 162: I2
100:10,17i07:24 duration22:16 either9:12,1915:24 engaging157:8 estimated209:17
108:12 165:14 during 63 9:6 19:16 36:10,10 engineer 218:9 evaluate 16:24
185:10,15 210:19 44:10 76:24 80:25 5 t:13 b3:9,23 enjoyment 133:9 evaluating 146:17
21 i:2,4,9 214:10 81:6 105:8 i 18:11 71:2 83:10 106:20 enough 28:24 48:12 even 7:22 35:1
214:13,19 216:10 121:12 12921� 107:15 109:18 148:21 162:11 57:24 b4:5,12
215: i0,12,25 157:1 172:9 175:6 120:18 121:4 ensure 12�_ 12 85.22 88:24 93:25
217:6,7,10,10 186_1 i92:8 i53:12 i57:8 134:22 199:17,19 98:22 100:12,18
220_IO,i0,1 i dust 6823 193:3 205:2fl 222:1 i 110:1 153:1,17
double-check 231:3 duties 1b3:10 elaborate 100:2 enter 23:S,b 48:2 159:18 160:15
doubt 148:12,23 194:i5 eiated202:10 63:21 173:3 164:13 166:8
dovetail i58:25 duty 57:24 81:17 electronic 108:1 180:13 20524 178:6 182:5 2098
down b2:1 68:15 219:18 element 142:9 entered 45:12 64:10 225:4
76:3 96:21 101:7 DVD 4:3 44:24 elements 9:1 19b:15 74:8 182: i 7 evening 6:5,24 7:11
105:2i,22 107:4 dwelling 47:7,25 elicit 71:20 197:17 211:21 7:25 8:5 27:2
108:17 110:12 140:15 177:14 elicited 22: i 9 enters 54:13 29:12 31:5 4fl:16
141:6 142:19 dweilings 140:13 eligibility 224: i5 entertaining 156:24 87:2 15823
i43:20 155:25 eligible 140:1b entire40:2 50:5 161:19 178:4
174:13 181: i 7,20 E______._ 224:17 692 167:18 192: i4 193: i 6
199:2 E 34:19,22 39:22,25 eliminate 100:21 169:18 217:13 202:25 231: i 8
dozens i5�:7 184:9 each 54:1 60:17 eliminating 124:S,b 229:4 event 93:24 114:14
drag 18:5 70: i 1 73:3 ll4:19 Elizabeth 1:22 2:2 entirely 141:14 events 56:2 i,25
dragged 74:14 114:22 127:17 234:5,21 entirety•20:13 138:3
drain 24:14 136:5 144:21 elsewhere 71:15 entitled 71_20 ever 41:18 58:3
dramatic23:21 147:i4,24,25 else's 137:12 171:15 82:24 83:2 106:20
draw 187:7 212:4 156:24 187:2t emergency 142:12 entity 105:12 106:9 156:19 1b5:19
drawing 197:7 220:24 22723,25 142:12 206:5,16 166_i,21
drew 72:17 229:8 employ 124:4 entrance 105:15 every 33:4 35:4
dries 31:17 earlier 37:6,25 38:4 employed 13:1 i entrances 96:1,1 i 42.9 43:4 63:6
drive 1:10 6:21 7:7 67:19 80:16 i50:1 194:5 195:16 96:12,13 124:6 69:5 114:19
13:4 73:13 74:1,7 150:12 i62:2 219:13 entry 46:25 93:19 125:10 130:5
97:17 193:23 188:6 i92:20 employee 112:7 93:20 i47: t 2022 203:7
dropping 219:6 199:11 228:20 employees 138:1 entryways 95:13 205:11 214:18
drove 13823 232:24 202:i8 219:3 219_8
drug 2521 103:4 early 122: i0 129:22 employment 128:17 environment 932 everybody 162:24
i09:16,21 130:21 166:4 219:12 empty 31:14 environmental61:9 164_18 199:19
177:16 229:12 encounter 162:13 61:9 93:7,14,16 216:16 232:19
drugs i09:22,23,24 easier 17521 encountered 196:15 107:3,i0 i24:10 everyone 137:2
1 i 0:7,9 easily 34:19 69:18 encourage 133.7 environments 61:22 220:22 233:15
dryer 142:23 143:2 108.8 21fl:20 end 25:6 30:4 31:23 envisioned 107:1 everything 8:9
due 720,20 820 212:1,12 76:22 78:7 114:3 equal 12:17 128:12 144:7
9_1 16:1,14 25:1 east 54:8 68:20 59:2 149:5 161:24 equipment 142:23 150:24 196:3
27:9 28:i 35:9,i6 easy69:16 i07:21 166:11,13 2I5:23 Eric i28:20 129:13 22i:i2,i8
53:20 65:22 66:18 110:8 219:4 escaped 71:5 evict 153:12 157:1
110:16 171:25 EBD 74:10,1 i endeavor 108:22 escapes 218:5 evicted 73:14
176:17 20 �:8 echo 34:22 ended 182:25 escrow 25:15, i 6 154:25 155:6,10
229:22,25 effect 169:2 206:24 Energy 25:8 i 74:5 especially 57:23 15b:3 157:5,15
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 11
158:1,2 85:2 97:3,9 expenditure lOb:2 196:25 20125 12122 i73:15
evicting 154:9 exception 15:15 expensive 108:22 202:5,9 21 i:14 faxes 221:17
i 55: i 3 65:13 108:10 experience 90:22 222:21 February 22:11
eviction 155:i8 147:11 148_7 191:18 factor 86:20 109:24 5922 7321,22
156:20,23 Exceptional 2Q4:24 195:9 19825 factors 124:11 9i:19 92:14 104:7
evidence 8:3 9:3,7 exceptions i 5:16 212:6 217:5 facts 135:11 173:2 lOb_7 i 18:12
9:18 10:2 ll 2,3,5 excess 210:7 experieaced 130:24 225:I0 1703 171:5 172_3
12:1,7 14:7,8;10 excessive 77:15 130:24 216:13 failed 25:8 i92.17 173:14 i88:19
14:18 15:22,23,23 excited 67:19 expertise 19725 192:17 189:5,6
1620 19:9 20:11 105:17 explain 7:17 48:13 failing 35:9 feces 73:15
20:25 21:23 23:3 excuse 12:22 34:21 70:21 148:5 faits 8:13 federal 1b8: i9
24:24 25:7 27:13 52:13 53:3 55:4 i 73:12 220:15 failure 20:1 21:8,15 169:8
27: i4,20 28:4 67.1 75:24 125:23 explained 128:18 24:19 35:4,6,7,8 fee 25:5 35:10
30:20,22 31:9 126:20,22 158.7 expianation 17:17 35:10,11,13 176:14 182:7
40:17 41:20 42:8 160:21 168:2 17:19 i 14:11 120:19 22b:9, i 1 feel 7:16 122:13
42:13,14,22 43:2 178:15 expressed 156:4 226:12 134:7 207:12
45:21 47:5 48:15 excused 111: i 0 extend 162: i 3 failures 203 128:9 224:13 221: t 8
48:17,20,2149:6 i58:15 1923 extension 17i:23 fair22:1027:13 22224
50_9 51:4 523,4,5 215: i 223:17 199:25 28:9 32,1 3b:13 feeling 157:17
56:25 66:7,12,13 excuses 121:2 extent 28:17,19 41:19 42:18 51:19 i 62:3
66:18,22 119:1 execute 2223 29:24 40:2 12fl:13 133:5 138:13 feels 16224
126:12 1732 executed 222:9 169:4 174:10 148:14,21 153:1 S fees 4:18 203:3
178:11 179:4,4,21 exhausts i0:25 202:24 191:17 felon 88:2
179:23 180:1,6,8 e�t►ibit 524 17:24 exterior 21:4 22:23 fair(y 160:15 fe(ony 87:14
192:11,18,21,23 17:25 38:21 39:9 23:10 35:12 53:1 fairness 7:21 26:8 felt 207:10 219:24
193:7 208:3 224:2 39:19 52: i 8 55:6 53:14 54:20 59:18 36:10 227:20 fence 1103 124:7
224_ i 1 225:3,8,8 55:4 115:20 61:11 67:12,16 fall 136:6 207:21 fencing 63:25 93:8
225:9, 116:25 i 1$:25 68:8,13 77:15 224:6,9 93:9 94:6,9 106:5
226:17,19 227:1 136:16,i8 141:25 98:10 165:16 fa(ling i31:16 110:1
exact 189:1 i 213:19 142.1 143:22,24 172:11 2 i 3:25 false 84:4 142:7,24 few 17:8 165:9
exactly 94:21 144:14 i45:23 216:10 217:6 143:4,5,8,14,15 2 i6:14,22 217:12
i 75:22 1803 146:1,10,12,13 extraordinary 143:19,20 145:6,8 22 i:17 229:14
195:4 233:13 147:10,15,21 24:14 158:23 148:1 149:4 �fth 114:2
examination 3:8,9 158:8 165:1 168:5 extrapolated 135:9 familiar 10:14 fighting 72:16
3:11,14,17,20 169:18 172:16 extrapolation 24:17 52:24 53:12,19 figure 226:1 i
44:3 103:22 17321,23 i76.7 I16:14 131:11 135:23 figures 116:15
111: i6 147:1 176:10,13,19,20 e-mail 37:22,23,24 2 i9:25 19025
159:6 163:5 197:2,4,18,20 37:25 220:22 far 112 13:11 fle 59:8 84:19
193:12 194:3 198:7 200:15,17 e-mails 201:7 24:14 26:14 48_9 134:11
215:9 200:23 201:5 100:18 108:19 �led 12:23 13•9
examine 51:15 222:6 231:22,24 __F____.__ 110:15,16 172:4 27:6 3420 66:8
examined 44:2 exhibits 4:1 5:1,24 face 177:5 219:25 221:25 78: i9 184:13
111:15 163:4 i49:16 182:8 facility 31:17 Fargo 2_ 16 fitis 77:12
1942 215:8 201:14 231:5 facsimile 38: i0,12 fashion 28:21 32:5 film 210:18
Exacnining 56:2 existed 56:18 fact 27:22 3b:15 44:25 106:21 filming 94:1
64:24 existence60:17 48:1i,i8 66:8 156:2 203:11 fina112i:10 159:9
example 51:12 existing 57:1 78_9 90: i4 94:9 96:10 father 195:12 164:2 i 222:13
92:18 138:5 127:7 217:18 107:13 119:19 favor 18:23 202:3 finally 9:10 24:25
139:1 i 148:13 exists 142:13 121:10 125: i 3 233:15,16 176:1
i83:25 exits 54:18 96:1 126:13 13 t:14,23 favorable 198:2 finance 20:8 21:1
examples 124:11 expect 2324 159: i 7 132:2,16 133:1 fax i:25 39:24 167:7,13 i68:23
179:11 232:17 134_3 136:14 i21:23 173:1 181:18,21 199:10
I exceeded 224:22,22 expectation 205:5 142:17 145:8 i74:16 187:1 199:15 20020
224:23 expectations 154:1 159:13 167:18 221:22 230:13 201:8,20
except 47:8 66: i expected 7:11 107:4 180:9 18 I:25 faxed 120:23 6nanced i9b:4
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
i
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 12
financia124:19 73:23 90_3 96:16 formatly Si:4 7:19 11:21,22 15i_25 229:15
i07:5 96:25 ll225 former 103:11 122 17.5,9 i$:2 fully 119:22 12�:25
financing 25:14 130:2 140:13 former1y90:8 20:2,1Q 222,19 122:18
107:8 i 57:5 165;11,13 forms 1382 23:9 24: i4,16 full-time 6223
find 2923 42:20 204:19 216:8 forth 10:25 16:16 25:12,22,24 26:9 i 11:18
60:3,22 99:16 217:2 35:1 37:1 69:8 26:i4,22 29:10,15 function 122:6
137:1 143:19 five-minate 75:13 167:22 199:18 2921 33:4 35:2 130:i0 214:14
145:1 i48:16 75:14 158:17 2242,13 38:6 41:4,5,13 functionai 68: l i
179:17 1812 �ve-year 117:23 forum 30:25 44.20 45:15,23 functioning 2 i4: i3
182:12,14,20 fix 69:18 213:23 forward I 3:20 48:7 60:2,7,9,9,17 216:11,13
217:15,19 216:21 29_21 31:8 32:2 61:6 62:19,24 functions I50:10
finding 217:12 fixed 23:10 191.21 32:12 43:10,20 63:3,b,17 65:1 i fundamenta17:21
findings 9:12,13,13 212:19 213:20 49:20,21 52:5 66:17 72:8 75_ 16 8. i9
69:7 226:6 214:20 229:24 54:25 73: i 8 97:23 78:17 $021 84:5 funding 190:9
finds 57:25 fled 64:6,9 73:8,9,9 111:12 84:7,i5 85:12 203:17,20
fine 151:7 187:11 74:1,2 1Q1:21 forwarded 189:18 8723 88:24 8924 furnished 177:23
203:19 228:1 i,lb flee 10922 222:12 91:23,24 93:5 farther 18:22 58:3
230: i8 tleeing 7 i:15 fosters 29:8 94:22 97:24 99:25 58:8 74:25 i i 1:1
finish �59_8 16i.18 101:17 1099 found 23:12 68:i4 100:9 102:2D 111:4 i20.7 13i3
finished 159:22,22 flight 63:6 69:2,11 73:4,10 109:7,8,24 ll 5:16 158:12 180:15
fire 69:4 95:16,17 flimsy 22:25 73:15 74:3 78:18 115:23 117:23 19 i 25 201:6
95:19,22,25 96:9 floor 74_7 89:4 80:1 107:21 l 1b:9 119:17 121:4,6,15 2Q5_i4 214:23,24
97:7,13,15,17,2 i flow 93:10 132:23 137:25 123:15 i 30:24 223:14, I 8
9724 13$:10 focus 24:16,18 31 _6 147:14 148: i 132:2 135:9 136:1 Furthermore 45:11
139:19 140:14,24 228:8 183:16 138:17,21 146:6 fature 9:16,17 11:9
141:6 i42:6,9,11 focused i 12:13 foundation 22:3 156_15 i57:6 134:2 203:18,2i
142:i2,16 i43:4,5 132:15 195:24 178:5,6 158:18 159:3 224:18
143:6,7,10 144:17 folks 30:25 155:5 founding 112:5 i 60:2 16421
5:10,13 147:20 foilow Sl:i4 92:19 four 23:14,23 58:14 165:8 167:21 __________G
47:23,25 98:4 114:11 73:11 74:19 78:4 169:11,24 171:21 G 2:9
�rearm 72:17 87:10 184:23 221:7 8025 81:3 96_ 15 172:9,15 173:7,11 Gabler 50:24
87.�2,15,17 88.3 followed 31:25 32:9 10824 114:15 173.14 174:8,i 1 gain 23:1
6rm 182:18 197:9 42:3 229:9 11624 117:5,7,11 i74:19 175_10 gang 74:12
first 10:1,15 i8:2 following 7:11 118:13 165:11,i3 i77:i,18,21 l79:2 Gangi 1:22 2.2
19:9 23:i6 27:3 16:23 3925 49_5 185:6 i79:9 182:18 234:5,21
30:5 3423 40:25 12i:14 228:2 four-item 38:5 185:i9,24 186:4 garage i65:14
43:19 44:20 46:15 foliows 44:2 111:15 four-part 124:2 192:7 195:13,21 16b:5,19 185:10
46:19 57:22 62:13 163:4 194:2 215:8 four-person 99:23 196_3,22 i97:5,22 185:15
66:5 68:19,21 follow-through foyers 219:3 198:1 202:8 garages 165:15
71:18 93:7 99:12 128:11 frame 68:23 77_3 203:17,20 205:4 garbage 77: I5,16
114:11 116:24 foiiow-up 37.24 172:4 181:6 207:25 209:8 218:15
121:7,20 123:25 food 73:16 145:4,9 framing 216:18 213:b,9 217:11 garbled 71: i6
138:15 144:17 Foods 63:13 Frank 60:7 9 i:22 220:19 22 i:6,9,24 gas 25:9,9,1 i 72:19
146:9 147:5,9 fools i 33:14 frankly 17:2 145:20 228:20 230:3 86:3 174:5,13,17
IS&:2i 164:3 footage 50:5 159:20 183:1 234:8 Gates 23:18 117:5
170:2 175:6 force 84:18 92:22 fraud 51:1 front 6:6 12:1 30:16 118:5
176:13 178:5 foregoing 234_7 free 7:16 4223 30.20 40:5,18 gather 151: I
18424 187:25 foremost 124: i 61:18 92:20,25 46:20 63:24 65:8 gave 29:16 102:24
188:3,4,12,13 foreseeable 2fl3:21 94:8,22 69:20 77:21 1032,6,9, I I,14
192: l4 199:12 forgot 41: i 0 126:7 frequenting 120:2 119: i Z i 39:23 139:3 164:18
209:11 211:13 form 70:17 116:10 frequently 201:20 frustrated 126:7 general 168:14
215:22 219:2i i20:22 i21:21 Friday 37:13 56:23 frustration 213:22 generally 10:7 18:1
222:3 229.14,23 191:4 192:15 231:12,14 fulfilled 22:20 105:9 112:2 20b:9
fit 15:15 220:8 forma17:16 48:15 friends 88:6 106:1 generated 140:14
five 24:8 54:7 73:11 119:2 i 120:21 from S: i 1,13,18 full 6:3 14:12 40:13 gentlemen 27:2
Faradigtn Reporting Captioning Inc.
6 i 2-3 39-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 13
38 i7:14 18:6 20:12 Griffin 218:8 hand-to-hand 1922p 22g_2
germane 34:11 49:2 20:12 23:1 26:3 ground 8:19 35:4 109:21 233:20
gets 159:24 22825 26:20 27:21 28:4 grounds 16: i 5,19 hanging 100:5 hearsay 48:14 51:5
getting 32:10 37:2 28:11 29:17,19,20 34:9,i0,I3,16 happen 31:19 heartbeat213:1b
9925 100:10 3�:6, I S,15,17,21 35:18,19,2Q21 202:12 208:15,18 Heather 127:20,25
172:i4 ZOa:12 31:6,7,8,ifl 32:2,6 3R_1642:12,15 20821 213:I2,15 Heights i93:23
girifriead 72:14,16 32:15,19 33:23,25 65:2fl 118:19 224:18 held 2:1 624 53:18
girlfriend's 72:15 34:11 37:2 40:8 224:4 225:15,17 happened 48:3 75:25 82:18
72 =17 40:11,1242:13,14 225:i&226:7,8,9 72:1388:5180:5 177:14227:17
give 10:16 26:20 43:10 44:19 45:7 groundskeepers 180:7 185: i 232:10
28:1 36:7 45:8 45:8 52:14 53:5 218:9, i 2,13 219:8 221:16 224:17 help 63:1,2
58:15 66:13 58:3,8 67:5 71:16 groundwork 218:14 happening 71:11,13 helpfal 71:17
148:11 151:24 72:9 89:22,23 group 24:13 73:8 71:14 100: i 2 227: i0
153:18 154:21 93:9,18,21,23 113:3,8 i 17:1 220_6 helping 79:15
155:25 160:6 1042 105:15,18 groups 73:3,7 happens 2 i02 helps i 34:b
162: i2 179:14,15 ]07:18 115:12 guarantee 40:23 220:4 Hennepin 50:24
i79:15,23 18620 1 i6:11,24 138:20 guard 2i9:13,15 happy 30:14 4024 62:24 108:23
191:16 207:12 141:23 i51:3 guards 205:13 19b:21 203:12 ll0:14
given 16:11,14,18 1 SS:7 158:24 2 i 9:18 223: i 2 her 128:8 150:11
32:9,18 34:12 159:2,3,6, i 2 guess 12:8 13:21 hard 101.22 134:17 1513 186:4,8,10
7b:13 78:10,i0 150:13,16 161:i5 153 32.14 43:5 16i:10 181:19 186:14,19,20,23
105:14 107:13 174:13 180:6 4824 56:4,9 having 14:i3 30:8 218:5
125:i6 i3120 184:19 187:9 89:22,23 16i:11 59:15 6i:10,22 Hertz21:22 38:i3
144:7 159:13,2a 192:8 193:i6 214:12 217:1 71:3 88:8 10122 38_13 67:24,25
i50:25 161:14 211:17 215:24 223:24 226:22 120:13 125:9 68:1,3,6 69:13
207:16 213:12, i 2 216:25 218:18,22 227:19 229:6 162:9 1$1:19 $0:2,8, i 1, i 2,14
227.23 220:16 224:1 guest 86:7,15,21 193:2 214:22 122:2Q25 i23:7,9
gives 46:2 133:20 225.6 228:19 87:7 88: i 7 89:14 head 7423 136:24 123:21 155:3,4,13
giving 30:18,19 229: i8 231:2� 89:15 heading 144:21 155:16 174:15
66:12,18 232:4,6,13 guests 86:25 87:1,4 heads 22:17 hiding 101:23,25
glass 21b:18 gold 232:12 87:6 88:1,6 heaithy 105:24 high 20:4,5 21: i 1
go 7:17 13:20 18:10 Go(den 13:4 guidelines 191:2 hear 9:6 17:19 182 58:12 60:22 b2:1
28:5 30:7,15,15 gone I 01:3 105:21 uilt 65:24 6:
g y 6 15 19:13 22:8 49:6 62:18 90:13 107.4
42:3 46:14 47:20 138:2,6 157:24 66:15 67:19 72:1 76:12 112:18 123:21
52:14 54: i l 64:3 161:4 185:19 gun 72.25 73:b 85:18 160:3 127:b 133:8,8
69_17 72:6 74:20 199:24 7423 151:11 i95:16 211:15,22
86:15,19 91:18 good 7:25 8:5 27:2 guy 216:I6 heard 9:5 17:16,17 higher 115:3 i38:24
95:19,22 97:7 29:20 70:10 75:6 guys 179:24 2 i 8:19 27:1 33:13 56:10 195:2 210:2,3
101:25 i02:20 97:9
162:2
0 202:3 104.16 162.2 highlight 114:10
103:15 i 10:9 22320 2253 185:23 192:7,20 highlighted 73:5
135:5,7,15 143:17 gotten i 3125 half 67:18 101:4,11 202:24 214:2 118:10
i44:25 i45:19 204:22 110:8 228:6 high-tech 217:1
i 155:17 158:22 government 154:i9 Ha112:1 72.12,14 hearing 1:162:1 4:1 him i2:11 22:19
159:3 i 60:3 190:9 hallway 49:17 74:7 6:19 7:3,12,15,18 30:25 31:1 33:3,4
161:20 162:8,14 Grade 219:23 hallways 219:3 8:19 9:5,8,9, i 5,17 35:2,14 363,6
162:20 188:24 grant 57:1 199:25 hand 1 I:12 76:5 9:20,25 12:20 50:23 51:13 61:7
189:7 22b: i 1 granted 56:13, t4 179:20,22 15:17,18 16:6,9 72:21 74:11,12,20
229:13 Sb:16,20 57:11,12 handgun 73:4 16:11 1823 27:13 74:22 78:2 87:18
goal 27:12 91:7 168:9 handing i 35:17 27:18,19 282,3 87:21,23 92:8
goals 19825 199:4 granting 56:17,21 handout 11:20,22 32:8 3324 35:1,4 98:8,10 102:24
goes 29:10 34:6 gray 149:2,3 handyman 195:17 35: i8,22 3721 103:2,6 121:15
35: i4 40:8 140:23 great 1 19:19 179:15 hand-delivered 39:6 40:6 42:2 123:18 156:8,9
190.25 2� 1:21 208:22 l 20:24 43:2 46:7 49:5 i 72:12 192:1
going 7:17 1320 217:8 224:11 hand-selected Si:9 6623 146:Ifl 220:23 221:22
14:21 16:20,20 greatest i23:6 1 i7:10 147:i0,2i 18i:i9 hire 165:22 202:17
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 14
218:4 humans 105:11 implemented increase 26:15 initiatives 10820
hired 62:13 165:25 206:12,15 124:12 220:2 b0.25 6221 109.3 Inn 108:2
166:18 t94:12 husband 151.19 importance 57:21 109:5 innocence 66:1 t
196:17 204:11 216:6 217:25 important 8.21 1 i:8 increased 24:16 innocent 6524
210:9 218:7 222:24 I 6:2 21:3 26:18 115: i 6 11 b:12 input i 6:3,4
hiring 62:4 Hyder 55:21 56:5 52:4 62:3 I 19:23 219: i 7 220:9,12 inquire 2 i0:16
HM 199:9 64.16 8223 85:9 120:9,11 218:16 increment 107:8 inquiry 187:1
Hoffman 22: i3 106:14,20 12Q:18 222:3 225:11,24 indeed 31:1 i insecured 58:11
60:9 9124 122:9 128:15,17 226:1,2 227:21 independent T69:11 insertion 107:14
hold 91:5 129:5 165:3 importantly 582 independeutly 21020
holder47:2 159:15 i72_6,10 61:11 147:2 inside74:4
holding 25: i 8 45:19 172:17 208:5 imposes 8:12 INDEX 3:1 insists 149:6
home 87:7,7 imposing 32:2 indicate 104:9 inspect 46:3,13
homework 229:15 I impossibie 2721 106:20 173:17 67:1 i 16523
homicide 71:25 idea 70:18 75:6 impression 38:3 18722 233:7 167:18 212:18
72:10 85: i9 86:1 97:9,20 112:13 49:10 97:18 indicated 105:10 213:19 222.19
Honor43:18 135.1515620 105:13106:13 i07:18124:13 inspected23:12
hope 65:23 153:7 i 62:23 227: i 5 improper 27:14,20 145:18 150:15 79:18 167:20
1b0:14 1852 228:11 28:21 4123 45:1� 155:7 223: i 1 183:14,15 187:16
198:4 233:4 identicai 65:13 4_5:16 56:20 66:2 indicates 23:11 191:2 2 i4:18
haped 185:1 146:1b 2333,10 66:7 126:17,18 122:20 135:1fl inspection 5:16
hopefuliy 205:11 identified 35:23 142:23 178:23 188:18 I89:4 21: I 23:9 47:4
hoping 68:18 57: iS 114:Zq 193:7 indicati�g 63:20 4824 55:2 67:10
153:1 l 122:22 129:4 improve 107:10 64.4 73:6 96:24 b7:16 68:13 69:15
hosted 22: i 0 104:7 i 34:25 139:1 196:19, I 9 209:19 indication 145:3 78:5,7 99:12
106:6 143:18 153:8 21 o:10,11 indisputable 3b:12 108:7 164:7,11
hotei 108:3 155:19 157:2,8,13 improved 62:5 individual 4525 167:11,12,15,17
hoar 47:12 67:19 170:5 i 91:8 196:22 Individually 127: i 7 169:12,22 170:23
159:5,19,21 161:7 identifies 136:1,b improvement 16:7 individuals 73:11 171:8 172:10
161:9,12 205:11 192:12,19 233: i 1 inaccurate 188:22 105:1 i 173:15 i 84:12,20
hours 62:25 205:8 identify 11:13 35:17 inadvertence 179:6 indulgence 159:25 185:21 187:22
ZO5:10, i 2 213:21 58:23 63:2 73:19 INC 1:23 infancy 218:23 188:18 189:5,10
hour's 158:21 8121 89:8 93:23 incentive 195:6 influence 29:8 189:15, i 9,21,23
housing 1.7 2:13 93:24 100:3,17 incident4:24 63:9 inform 154:14 190:21,22 191:4,5
5:1- 6: I 9 7:6 8: i 2 i 01:5 103:3 125:2 73:20 inforrnally 43:11 191:10,14 199:10
20:6,8 21:1 25:24 i27:13 134:6 incidentaliy 41:10 information 18:12 200:22 213:21
27:5 28:16 29:1,5 193:4 197:4,20 incidents 156:1 60:13 61:7 68:6 inspections 4:3,15
38:18,24 44:7 200:23 include 16:13 i0i:8 51:15 83:15,20 45:20,23,24 47:3
46:3 47: i SS:20 identifying 22:3 101:20 i39:6 84:5,7 85:8 47:6,19,25 59:19
83:9,17 85:7 ignores 180:9 163:16 174:1 105:14 119:13 76:8,14,25 77:8
86:13 87:25 94:22 iii 141:1 196:6 226.9 120:8,14 128:5 78:13,16 79:14
163:14 i67:7,12 illega145:15 46:1 included 38:5 i32:5 135:9,24 83:13 84:ib,i6
167:22 i6823 87:12 114:15 152.18 137:20,23 142:20 169:19 i71:18
17 i_22 172:13 iliegally 45:11 231:19 148:19,21 15023 189:13 190:6,9,19
177:1 i 78:9 183:3 illustrative 55.7 includes 37:7 46:23 151:2 154:4 155:8 19723 209:4
196:2,4,4,5 immediately 68:15 61:10 116:8 207:25 221:23,24 221:7
i98:12, l3 199:5 68:17 97:11 i 32: i 2 222:16 227:22 inspector 5:14
199: iQ 15 200:20 109:10 204:6 including 2b:11 informed 82:23 17122 1902,24
200:25 201:8,19 immense 148:25 27:14 29:21 30:2 12i:8 127:5 191:9 213:17
201:22 2233 imminent25:10 59:14 60:14 71:25 138:2i 15b:9 221:5
hub b3:11 10825 45:15 t 59:25 initially 165:6 inspectors 4b:23,25
109:10,15,17 impartial 9:2 income 203:14 219:23 79:1 170:12
110:3,12,19 impinges 3 I:2 incomplete 20:24 initiated 169:22 190:19
HUD i91:2,4 imptementation incorrect 79:17 initiation 124:8 insta1193:21
human 106:21 124:7 80:21 initiative 112:8 installation 124:6
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 15
instailers 2 i6:15 introducing 40:17 186:15,21,24 123:9,13,16 179:16,23 18b:4
installing 93:22 investigate 120:3 1872,5 191:8,2I 129:10,19 130:20 192:24 197:1
instance 16:6 investigation 192: i 9 197:25 165:6 177: i 5,19 203:19 205:3
i20:25 128:21 116:10 182:20 198:15 i99.13,16 179:1,10 20b:2,15 208:21 212:16,19
138:7185:5195:8 investigations73_10 200:2120i:2 207:3,7,13 213_23216:21
instances i 24:21 120:7 204:8 215:20 Jaweed's 172: I 1 219:7 229:2 i
i29:21 148:20 invest�ent 199:6 221:ll 222:1,23 dean 195:i3 2313 232:22
i52:25 153:1 invitation 26:1� 1 228:8 ,{eopardize i69:5 233:2,11
178:17 45:25 issuing 58:14 142:7 Jersey 96:7 97:11
instead 29:3 30:8 invite 49:1 92:8,11 item 6:18 38:6 52:7 97:12,14, i6,25 __K
79:10 126:16 invited i5:2i 88:12 56:6,8 14i:6 job 91:13 i26:2,6 keep 14:12 36_25
132:9205:25 92:7,11 176:2,3199:21 133:15,i6�183:2 87:2116a:ib
229:21 invites 47:9� 201: i 1 202:2 203:16 217:11
instill 218:22 invoice 25:6 176:16 items 10:19 165:11 204:25 218: i2 Ken 21:22 80:2
instrumental 93:12 involve 106:2,4 165:13 173:14,15 219:1,24 222:10 i 23:20
intelligibie 11:i0 125:7 173:17 i85:6,8 Joe i95:13 Kenneth 38:13
intend 21:7 38.17 involved 72:22 189:17 199:17 John 173:7,i 1 57:25 b8:1,3
227:4 73:11 82:11 122:4 212:20 221 _5 69:13 12220
intended 121:9 137:25 156:11 join 75:22 174:15
128.24 159:20 195:i5 196:9 _J. joint 108:23 110:19 kept 100:12 125:4
178:11 2�124 2182 J 1_22 2:2,14 234:5 judge 8:25 30:22 130:8,1fl 134:11
intends 193:13 invotvement 122:23 234:21 65:3,7,9 66:4 152:9 190:16
intensive 110:11,18 123:12 127:10 jammed 22:25 judges 228:5 Kevin 3:7 43:19
intent 133:14 172:7 98:24 99:1 107:14 judgment 18:14 44:1
165:10 179:7 involves 209:4 217:1,6 232:8 key 69:3,4,4 86:18
intention 126:5 involving 80:16 jamming 99:7 judgments 32:19 108_ 1
21523 233_5 irresponsible i00:10 judicia! 227:20,21 ki1174:12
interconnection 208:19 Janaary 57:9 6020 July 122:25 123:9 killed 72:20 87:8,19
55:15 IRSi69:10 77:6,18118:12 June20:1844:i6 87:2288:6
interest 124:13 Isiand 13:4 13120 168:8 50:3 732 74:5,6 kiiling 87:24
156:4 issue 36.15 79:2,3,4 185:5 78: i4 80:22 89:3 kind i 82 2824
interested 20:1 i 142:11 154:13 Jaweed 21.22 22: 1 110:25 12 i:21 47:15 48:12
79:14,15 123:14 178:7 i 79_ 18 22:17 25:20,23 163.17 214:17 148:13 i 62:11
133:5 155:8 192:13,14 200:5,8 34:24 55:21 56:5 jurisdiction 110: i 7 16$:22 203: i 8
156:22 220:7 203:20 214:6 59:22 60:11, i 5 j ury 30:23 66:4,16 kinds 32:18 14 i:2
interesting 179:20 224:18 61:3,24 62:7 just 6:4 7:23 8:17 knew 41:21 107:20
interests 50:8 53:4 issued 20:23 21:18 64:16,16 67:23 12:8 13:20 17:23 150:15, I 8 167:3
228:8 35:6 47:17 58:4,8 82:23 85:9 1a4:8 19:18 25:12 28:1 175:22 220: i2
interfere 142:8 77:7,17 78:23 104:22 105:3 29: i 5 30:b,7 knife 74:9
interpret 148:10,11 79:5 142:11 164:6 106:7,20 107:15 32:14 37:2,15 knock 69:4
interpretation 49:1 164:9,14,17 120:18,18 121:24 43:10 46:20 50:3 know 14:11 16:19
14i:14 142:19 169:i5 i7fl:2 122:i,10,21 127:5 55:7,i4 56:1 63:1 16:20,23 23:1
148:9 191.3,5 207:20 128:15,17 129:5,5 65:21 66:6 75:8 32:14,21 34:10
interrupt 94:2 issues 7:5 17:1 I 165:3 169:16 76:6 77:11 82:9 35:15 36:24 42:14
intervening 62:17 31:4 32:15 41: i 9 172:6,6,10,17 85:11 93:13,19 42:17,19 43:12
79:25 42:18, i9,20,20 174:15 205:21 97:20 99:3,20 46:12,17 53:20
intervention 26:12 48:9,11 57:2 208:5 223:7,9 103:20 105:9 b i:12 63:23 65:14
interviewed 2202 58:25 1 i 2:21 Jaweeds 20_ 1,24 109:19 110:6 70:22 71: t0,11
intimate 15G24 119.16 123:11,25 21:9,15 22:10 122:5 125:2,3 78:22,24 82:21
introduce 17:14 130:11 (342 24:20 25:8 45:22 126:7,1b 139:6 83:12,t9,22 85:6
192:17 220:2 i i42:25 i62:13 68:4,7 59:13 141:13 14b:17 85:8,12,25 8820
introduced 11:25 164:21 165:9,17 83:11,16,25 84:22 149:20 152:18 89_ 11,14,17,18,20
14:8,10,11 40:19 171:14 172:13 8522 99:b 103:24 161:24 1b2:6 90:11 92:7 95:i6
55:12 220.18 173:6 179:20 104:5,2i,22 171:7 172:9 98:11,15 99:19,20
225:4 i83:7 186:2,2,i l 120:22 12i:4,7 174:12 177:4 117:1 122:20,24
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Yublic Heanng lU/1/2UU7
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page i 6
1��_ 19 i43:11 Larry 22:14 60_8 lay 48:13 23 L liability 83:6
145:13,17,20 9 i:23 123:4 taying 223 232:2,8,11 liaison 59:16,18
146:22 149:12,14 158:14 163:3 layout 53:24 54:1 LeFevere's 17:17 license 7:1,2 8:16
i49:22 150:2� 22 i:4,21 leads 6:18 teft 87:7 114:12 8:18,22 25:18,20
156:23 157:10,12 Lasmar 6:16 leaning 18:2 128:17 151:20 31:10,12 34:13,17
157:12,i9,2 i iast 25:6 29:23 iearn 221:9 158:22 i 73:14 35:6 39: i2 45:19
1�8:1,2,3,4 167:1 30:17 38:22 53:13 iearned 223:1 200:6 201: i 1 45:22 47:3,17
167:16 169:9 54:23 58:22 72:8 lease 127:24 154:6 lega! 10:5 12:12,15 56:13,13, i 5,17,19
170:12 171:24 77:4 84:23 108:7 157:9 12:15 46:4 119:5 56:21 57:1,9,11
18fl.3,23 I 81:7,10 1 i4:24 114:22 Leased 1:7 2:13 5:1 120:6 122:14 57:12,17, i 8 58_4
18 I: I 1,14,14,16 129:1 b 13522 6:19 7:6 27:5 158:3 208:8 58:7,14 60:20
181:22 182:1,4,8 140:18 146:12 38: i 8,24 83:9,17 iegislative 16:3 77_7 94:12,19
182:10,10 183:1 150:2,3,4 152:1,7 85.7 86:13 87:25 legitimacy 46:4 122:3 131:17,19
183:11,24 184:8 158:i4 165.1 177:1 178:9 lengtf►y 159:12 131:21,25 i32:3,6
184:10 188:6 172:16 175:1,9,20 i 98: i 2,13 223:3 tess 66:6 100:13 164:1 168:9
189:11,25 190:1 176:4,6,9,16 leasing 195: i 7 180:11 177:14 184:13,15
191:7,1219222 182:4,4183:15 ieast7:1440:20 Iet30:23,253i:1 224:12,13,i5,20
193:2,5,6 202:1 184:12 185:23,25 42:16 65:23 73:1 i 43: ll 46:20 70:9 iicensed 8:12
206:7 214:8,13 189:19 190:1,2,22 i08:b 110:5 94:2 97:10 100:2 111:18 i4fl.12
211:5,23 213:3 191:6,13,18 161:12 1$5:16 137:1 14b:13 2188
217:7 219:7 192: i 5 196:22 i 96:10 203:21 164:24 197:19 licensee 8:13,13
220:23 221:21 197:1,7 198:22 229:17 22325 10:23 i5:25 16:2
227:3 22925 199:7 207:2 i leave 26:16 36:7 letter 5:11,13, i 8 16:14,19,25 42:9
knowing 84:3 218:5 220:14,22 149:20 15 i 20 16:9 25_ 12 3423 42:12,21 226:16
knowledge 16:18 223:1 231: i4 158:6 186:14,16 35:1,3,13,17,24 22b:25
59:3 62:12 79:6 lasted 80:i9,21 231:2 36:2,3,3 37:7 38:9 licenses 140:16
86: i 1 90:5,14 late 9:22 21:2 22:11 lecture 153: i 9 38:17,22 39:5, i 5 Licensing 177:13
107:25 156:24 64:14 122:10 154:21 39: 1b,22 40:1 Lieutenant 3:7
166:16,24 199:25 129.21,21 i30:24 led 83:10 106:8 42:10 b7:18,21,23 22:14 23:7 43:19
2�6:3 207:25 150:2,4 159:24 181:9,12 187:22 68:7 76:7 121:21 43:20 44:1,S,i2
211:20 212:3 171:25 188:19 12722,25 128:1,3 52:11,24 67:9
214:21 later 9:24 18:11 LeFevere 7:9,13 128:7,13,14,16,20 70:13 75:1,19,21
known 60:11 64:16 19:24 32:20 8:10 11:23 12:6 129: i,15, i 5,17 76:3 86:21 156:8
106:16 112:$ 121:12 148:25 �12:11,18 13:21 17625 182:�7 156:12,14,i5
177: i9 195:14 i95:17 229:19 i4:2,7,14,23 15:3 187:1 197:5,22 life 86:20 195:15
knows 392 90:1 latest 22:21 201:12 15:13 16:12 i7:b 200:25 231:13 lighting 51: I 1 62:6
98:15 199:19 latter 24:2 17:12 18:8 19:5 letters 22:4 33_2,4 lights 98:10
K9 64:12 laundry 21:4 53:2 19:10,12,16 27: i 6 36:1 41:9 i 20:22 like l3_ 1,12,19,21
53:15 54:6,9,1 i 28:24 32:12,13 i27:12,13 128:25 13:24 14:3,6 19:7
L--- 54:14,15,20 74:21 33:9,12,15,18,22 129:2,4,9 130:6 26: i b,23 27:1
lack 16:25 21:4 88:13 i00:5 34:5 37:6,14,19 130:13 i52:i2,12 36:21 43:9 45:8
179:5,6 14224 219:3 42:6 43:3 48:10 i52:18 153:8 47:12 48:7 49:15
(acks 211:10 LAURENCE 3:13 49:9 S 1:6 52:2,13 155:9 156:1 157:2 59:9 70:22,25
ladies 27:2 law 15:14 17:10 52:17,20,22 55.4 157:7,13 71:10,11 91:18
Lake 109: I 117:4,5 20:3,21 21:16,20 55:7,10 56:6,8 letting 220:22 96_ 14 104:25
118:1,3 22:7 35:24 38: i3 67:1 69:25 70:2,4 let's 30:9 37:18 i 11:8 126:4,10
Lakes 23:17, i 8 47:7 61:4 94:10 70:8 75:2,4,7,18 49:20 75:12 81:9 134_ i 7 153:20
101_7 94:16 98:5 110:19 75:20,24 119:3 84:9 85:17 162:25 158:17,20 159:7
land 8_6� 1 i 1:19,22 112:14 158:8,9 1b0:17 190:8 232:8,t3 162:22 179.7
iandlords61:21 179:3,11 184:17 162:21 223:24 level62_i8 170:17 t81.i� 191:20
iarge 114:5 laws 40:3 56:15 224:8,10 227:6,9 171:11 224=16 193:15 208:14
largest 23:19 117:8 168:15 i 69:4 227:15,18 228:14 levels 21:11 112:18 209:4 2 i 3:17
117:11 197:10 lawyer 38:19 39:1 228:17,23 229:2 123:21 i2Z6 214:6 218:17
203:13 lawyers 10:13 228:7 229:20 230:8,11 169:20 222:4 223:21
large-size 115:1 228:8 230: t 5,19,22,24 (ever 2 i3:17 226:16 228:10,11
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/20Q7
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 17
likety 120:15 69:1 l, i 8 9823 made 9:2,11 14:13 i 59:6 1b5:14 213:23 214:18
125:1b 99:7,17 100:1,4 16:17 i8:9 23_8 175:22 i84:20,23 216:3 220:19
tikewise 94:15 100:10,23 107_ 13 23:14 24:25 25:�16 195:6 199:4 managing 84:18
142:10 203:3 107: i 6,19,20,25 28: i i 4 i:1 44: i 3 203:11 206:12 195:21,23,24
timit 9:7 16: i 0 108 3,8,12,13 44:14 47:6 51:4 207:9 212:9,22 202:5 21223
limitation 40:10 210:19,19,19 51 18 66:1 67:9 218_ 15 220.11,12 manner 148: ll
203:13 211:8,9 212:11,12 68:13 76:6 7722 222:8,10,19 manning 77:23
limitations 228:6,9 2 i 3:25 214:10,19 78:13,13 84:3 223:12 227:7 Manor 23:18 i09: i
limited2:13 11:3� 2i420,22 217:19 105:20,25 1082 229_7 231:3 232.5 117:4 118:1
28:16 38:25 64:12 locksmith 215: i 7 108:16 119:15 maker 10.8 many 20:10 22:23
83:6 110_16 177:1 iodged i68:6 128:4,8,i0,22 makers i06:22 22:24 26:7 33:6
limits 131:15 long 7:19 35:15 175:15 178:3 makes 141_8 223:2 52:12 58:9 b2:15
link 220:24 I 1024 I i 1:22,25 192:9,12 193:1 224:16 2326 64:12 88:4 93:15
iinked 23:4 226:7 151 _7 158:24 206:9 207:24 making 1b:21 43:7 9b:13 98:23
list40:13 77:21 16L 194:i9 215:21 2i8:19 61:8,10,11 64:11 10i:23 105.3,21
78:20 8 i:22 i 30:4 198:22 203:15 220:17,23 221:13 78:5 98: i 7 105:10 125:7 i 29:4
141:2 192:15 204:17 227:16 22121 222:7 1 i9:20 I Sb: l i 132: i 2,12 137:10
19922 lflnger 34:6 153:13 227:4 172:7 188:9 228:1 142:20 145_ 17
listed 15:11 184:6 20124 203:6 magic 217=7,19 male 73:23 74:6 151:15 152:25
lists 146:20,21 217:3 224:17 magnetic-type males 73:3,24 74:19 153: i 157:10
literally 117: i0 look 20:15 29:10 107:19 74:22 1802 184:6
118:24 158:2 33:2 34:19 35:19 mai138:10,13 186:4 malfunction 142:22 201:22,23,Z4
littie 43:11 49:23 36:1 56:1 8224 230:14 1432 218:1
84:9 9821 113:3 83:1 97:7 118:9� mailed 120:23 Mall 63:12 map 55:10,1 i 63:14
160:13 i61:10 118:25 125:2 121:25 230:11 man 73:20 96.14
live 13:4 20:20 60_5 141:18 143:17 Mailing 233:9,10 manage 154:5 Mar 220:5
6i:8 74;9 205:6 148:25 1$5_3 maintain 35:8 196:3,11 197:I1 March 62:9,10,11
215:11 207:23 212:8 maintained 29:6 i9724 201:22 80:22 110:21
lived 153:13 225:6 115:22 124:23 210:9 ll2:17,20 118:12
iiving 6 i:12,13 iooked 83:23 99:10 142:25 143:1 manageable 222:24 122:5 127:11,19
98:11,15 157: i 1 142:3 147:24 maintenance 20:6 managed 51:10 127:22,25 170:15
157:22 205:4,1fl 150:18,20 209:23 31:17 46:3 47:2 i79:19 210:6 mark 17:23
215:24 209:24 55:20 64:19 69:17 management 29:21 marked 4:1,2 5:2
LLC 1:7 6:20 7:6 looking 40:20 58:22 163:15 165:19,21 38:12 61:13 81:17 17:25 38:20
104: lfl 177:14 61:7 68:23 114:2 i67:23 171:20,2 i 100:19 124:8 136:16,18 141:25
206:13 125:11 160:2,19 172:13 183:3 127:15 150:8,10 143:22 144: i 3,25
LLCs20b:7 169;18 i75:9 189:12 198:15 194:8,12,i4,21 145:23,25 1972,3
LLP 104:10 177:4 208:3 202:14,17 203:18 i95:9 19b:2 197:9 197:18,19 200:15
tocal 199:3 looks 162:21 204:8 217:23 197:25 198:4,20 200:16 222:6
located 6:6 7:7 tost 30:16 65:10,15 218:6 222:9 i 99:8 202:13 231:18,18,24
location 90:7,9 102:1 224:14 major 76.6 215:19 21724 232:1
215:14 lot 90:2 94:16,2fl make 13:17,24 14:3 21925 225:14 marketplace 197:8
locations 120:23 95: i 1 100:16; i 7 17:3 i 8:3 26:6,24 manager 8:17 22:10 MARQUETTE
lock4:i5 6821 69:1 106:4 109:5 144:4 27:7,12,22 30:24 22:12,17 2525 1_24
76:7 98:18 99:3 225:5,7 226:13 32:18,19 33:7 26:12 36:11 38:2 Martin 3:13 22_ 14
108:11 217:19,19 228:6,6 37:18 43:12,13 38:6 47:21 59:21 91:23 123:4
tockable2i4:10 tots93:18 47:10S1:i060:4 59:2560:8,14 158:14159:6,8,18
iocked 54: i 5 61:10 loud 148:15,16 b 1:16,25 66:4 91:23 92:4,5 ib32,3,7 176:24
62:5 67:22 99: i6 lower 96:21 67:1 S 72:13 82: lfl 104:7,7 106:6 180:16,22 187:8
IOO:Ib 107:24 tower-leve174.21 88:2 95:6 9725 127:21 128:21 i91: t7,24 221:1,4
2122 1ow-income 190:12 99:20 105:11 151: i2 195:19 material 155:8
locking 54:22 106:7 107:6 11fl:$ 2161 234:7
217:1 i M 126:1,21 140:4 managers 4:13 materials 123;14, i 8
locks22:24,24,25 M2:15 i41:17144:i0 106:17151.13,15 124:20128:�
35:12 68:16,18 Machesne 218_7 153:21 155:2 202_ t 7 205: i math i 49:9
Parac�igm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/iI2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 18
mathematicaliy 53:8 Sb:6,10, i 1 meant 188:4 memorandum 4:15 minimum 154:15,23
149:13 57:4,6,7 58:18 measures 128:6 38:5 69_8 79:19 198:18 203_23,25
matter 8:21 2Q_ 16 59:6,7 65:19 mechanism 68:21 memorializing Minneapolis i:24
71:19 96:10 1283 66:19,20,23 67:5 207_S 197:6 2:11,17 4:20
177: i 1,13 181:17 69:22 70:1,3,6,10 medium I i 5: I memorize 81:22 25:20 41=15
181:20 184:2 70:24 71:9 72:3 meet 7:19 8:14 mention 197:9 177: i 3, I 6,22
i96:25 201:25 75:2,6,1Q14,17 14924 160: i2 mentioned 33:18 Minnesota 1:24 2:2
213:18 225:11 75:21,23,24 90:23 22823 229:18 109.6 135:25 2:3,11,17 20:8
2z�=22 22g=3 91:1,3,7,16 meeting 12 5:20 137:22 139:18 21:i,i9 61:18
matters 19:22 26:6 103:20,21 104:1 6:1,3 8:4 9:24 155:3 161:6 204_7 92:20,24 94:7,22
26:7,18110:17 iO4:i3,14,16,18 IS:11,i4,1716:5 merely12:1133�.8 11i:19167:7,12
125:19 104:24 111_3,7 17:6,7,9,10 22: i message 186:14,16 16823 193:24
maximize 120:13 113:15 118: L 8 22:16 30:5 38:1 18b:17,23 195:22 197:7,10
may 9:9 20:18 21:2 119:2 125:23,25 43:7 59:21 bD:1,6 met 7:3 32=2,3 199:9, i 5 200:20
23:25 25:6 34:16 126:2,6,24 127:2 60:15 61:3 80:2,3 74:21 103:24 200:25 201:7,19
36_23 44: i6 45:18 130:16,i7,18 80:4,13 91:18,21 104:5,22 I05:3,4 20 i 23 234:6
48:9,19,2fl 4921 13 I:5 136:22,24 92:3,14 104:6,21 105:6,8 109:25 minor 200:10
49:24 59:17 75:4 i4�:7 141_24 105:18 106:5,24 149:23,25 minute 132:20
76:23 78:14,20 143:23,25 144:3,5 109:18 12225 methodology i4920 157:i4
80:21 82:7 89:1 144:10 i49:18 123:4,5,8,12,21 134:23 i3724 204_3
104:16 i092 151:9,1i,15,18,21 16022 169:25 methods 124:3 minutes20:14
i 18:8 125:15 1 S 1:22,23 158:7 i99:4 22$:20,25 metro 63:10 89:25 4420 69' 16 159:8
129:16 131:7 158:16,19 i 59:15 meetings 43:7 68:2 101:9 110:13,15 mirror 47:7
134:7;15 136:22 160:1,10,11,19,23 82:18 104:20 220:3 misbehaved 178:22
14825 152:4 1612,8,17 i 62:16 105:9 l Ob:17,18 Metropolitan 90:6 misbehaving
166:4,4,14 167:3 162:19,25 168:1,2 Metrose 23:18 Mexico 50:19 i7823
167:8169:5181:5 168:3,18,20,21 117:5118_5 MHFA4:75:18 misdemeanor54:17
214:17 216:17 1733,2 i,24 member 6:8,9,10,1 I 20:8 35:11 58_ 13 miss 67:1
2 i 9:7,7 224:18,22 175:20,2 i i 76:2,5 6:12,13,16 7:14 167:23 168:12,16 missed 140:18
225:14,16 226:21 176:2 i,22 177.9 11:18,19,20 12:9 199:9,18,25 missing 2224
maybe 32:20,20 1�7:11,25 178:2,3 12:16,19 15:8,9 201:21 2fl2:4,$ 183:25 184:7
33:9 36:20 38:3 180:13,17 192:4,5 15:10 16:8 18:15 212:17 213:6,10 210:19
75:7 162:23 210:3 193:1Q14,17,2� 18:16,17,2i 19:1 2i3:i 1,17,25 mistake i79:6
210:12 214:12 197:5,12,i3,17 34:21 42:25 43:1 222:4,b,8,i5,17 mitigatior►21:21,23
222: i S 227:10 i 98:6,9 2� 1:16 46:10,11,12,17 222:20 224: i 9
mayor 5: I 1 6:1,14 204:4 215:2,5 48:4,5,6 49:7,8 MICHAEL 3:16 mix 179: i9
6:15,18,23 7:8,13 223:16,20,24 57:6,7,8,10,13,i5 194:1 modei
8:1,10 10:7 11_18 224:6,9 228:19,24 57:20 66:19,20,21 microphone 104:2 ll3:i2 i 15:14
11:19 12:20,22,25 231:b,9,i6,19,25 75:12 92:24,24 middie 165:13 moment213:20
13:5,8,19 14:16 232:3,22 233:15 128:19 147:4,6 167:3 231:5
15:3,8,9 i 7:5,13 233:18,20 149:19 151:22,23 midnight 162:17,2fl Monday-through...
17_15,16,21 18:1 May/June 181:b 151:24 152:2,5 227:14 21825
18:15,1b,20,22,25 maze 54:1 i 74:3 160:7,9 16 i:23 midst 221:12 money 106:3,4
19:2,4,10,11,15 mean 18:540:10 162:1,1,4,6,18 mid-May 18S:i6,18 i95:3 198:14,17
19:18 2b:23,25 66:15 12b:1 144:9 168:20,21,22 might i7:lb 24:17 203:16 207:14,14
32: i 1,24 33:11,13 148:13 156:23 169:6 230:5 56:10 112:15 monies i07:8
33:1734:S,t8 lbi:i9181.13 232:22233:1,6,11 124_4141:24 monitor88:i
36:24 37:1,8,15 2fl3:16,25 213:15 233:14 143:23 160:1 monitoring 5:16
38:7 42:6,25 43:3 meaning i 1621 members 6:24 7:8 i62: i3 189:16 i24:9 i67:7
43:6,12, i 6,18 148:1 l 7:13 8:1 18:24 197:12 204:3 monitors 1 b825
45:4 4b:10, i 1 means 31:12,13,14 19:4 38:2 43:7,18 206:23 216:20 month 29:22,23
47: i3 48:4,5 49:7 3I:15 40:10 51:6 74:12 112:5 124:9 226:2 227:16 114:16 135:3
49:8,14 50:2,7,12 70:1 S 132:9 134:8 146:25 233:17 Mike 222:13 147:1 182:4
50:15,20 51:2,3 149:9 iS2:23 memo69:19 77:11 mite 101:8 185:23,25 194:16
51:22 52:6,15 196:19 203:14 80:9,10 Mina 218:10 199:7 22014
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COCINCIL MEETING
Page 19
223:1 229:17 93 1 94:22 1962 190:25 198:18 63:19 73:9 1 t 7:5 174:12
monthiy 106:18 Multihousing 61:18 199:20 200:9 1183 215:12 notified 3823
130:1,4 136: i,12 92:20,25 94:8 207:8,8 211:7 northeast 96:20 166:21
i 47_ 15, i 7,24 multiple 14fl:13 negotiate 205:20 Northway l: l O b:21 noting 55:19
148:6 multiply i 1g:13 neighbor 220:4 7:7 73: i2,24 74:1 notion 32_7 94:15
months 33:7 58: i4 municipalities neighborhood 29:7 74:7 November 35:5
b2: i 6,17 118:12 178.17 59_ 16, t 7 i i622 Nos 200:15 58:5 101:14
19420 murdered 72:11,12 neither 168:16 notabie 62:3 164_ 14,22 165_3
more 18:12 24:8,9 must 8:19 9:2,3 never 28:6 33:21 Notary 2:3 166:1 t,13 172:10
252,4,14 35:1b 34:8 47:4 168:15 39:16 40:12,13 notation 21:2 nowhere 62:15
40:12,12 43:11 178:22 41:15 57:25 58:1 notch 218: i 9 nuisance 29:7 b4:1$
63:13 72:18 80:23 mutaal 220:5 63:18 74:3 89:8 note 2:20 7:23 27:3 b4:19
81:2 84:9 90:21 myself 34:6 60:8 97:21 156:13 27:6 2$:23 38:14 Nuisances 4:11
98:23 99:13,23,24 83:23 91:22 126:1 Nevertheless 11:4 213:25 t24:18
100:13,13 107: i 6 220:18,21 new 29:21 77:7 notebook 28:5 number b:19 28:6
113:1,3 114_14 151:11,13,15 29:15 b9:19 7i:23 74_i095:11
120: I 125:1 I N 168:9 171:8,9 noted 20:7 46:8 113:24 i 14:21,24
130:2 139:19 name 13:1,3 65:14 184:13 200:9 48:22 51:23 57:5 11424 115:3,6
i40:13,14 147_7 15i:25 152:1 2i8:4 219:25 58:9 59:8 69:19 i 16:4 i 17:9,13
174:2 175:16 156:12 202:11 220:18 77:13 104:15 I 23:25 i 32:24
183.17,2 i 184:10 218:5 220:19,22 news 182:25 125:23 127:2 135:4 137:15
184:10 185:2 named 38:1fl newspaper t5:12 130:18 144_ 10 144:22 147:23
186:19 191:22 names 8 i:16,19,22 next 39:8 4924 149:18 168:19 148:20 149:4
i 95.2,3 2 i2:1,10 i 21:10 52:7 99:13 111:4 173:24 176:22 1 Sb:13 1 b324
212:22 226:1,16 narrating 44:9 135:6,8 144:20 198:9 20 i:16 172:12 187:18
morning 69:12 nation 89:1 147:20 160:3,20 213: i0,11,20 192:15 209:24
72:11 7322 nationaliy 195:14 160:22 i61:4,9,11 notes46:21 76:5,6 numbered54:2
most 21:3 22:21 na#ural 20:1 25:9,9 161:24 179:24 121:17 227:2 numbers l 14:18
26:4 32: i 52:4 174:5 215:17 223:20 234:9 115:8 117: i9
61:21 b2:3 70:13 naturally 3 i:14 228:25 229:12 nothing 12:21 17:3 138:7,23,24
7fl: i 4 71:1 72:9 nature $:25 nice 221:3 29: l, l l 42:4 46:1 14422 167:16
116:7143:i3,1b nay18:2519:1 night37:2160:25 85:1296:2158:11 177:25
195: i 5 199:5 233:18 1 b 1:3 168: i 0 178:18 numerous 77:10
222:2 near 62:15 nine 69:16 172:16 192:25 208:14
mostly 110:9 necessariiy 15:20 nine-minute69:1S 223:14 O
motion 192 49:22 34:14 109:8 nobody 81:10 notice 4:11,19 8:18 oath 10:9,9 40:24
51:3 154:10 158:4 156:18 18521 13:14 i5:20,21 212:25 222:16
motions 43:4,14 191.19 187.6 16: 4,18,22 i 7: l object 70:17 104: i 2
motive 179:7 necessary 31:16,24 Nods 136:24 21:17,23 26:9 I 18:18 126:8,9
mouth 174:12 43:4 148:9 i99:2 noise 148:15 28:1 30:18 32:17 i68:10 17225
208:24 2233 noncompliance 32:22 33:19,22,25 178:4
move i 8: l 3, i 7, i 8 need 14:12 50:4 122:13 169:21 34:9,12 35:2 S objected 48:11
31:14 32:12 43:1 87:2 98:9 112:23 170:17 172:18 36:13,13 38:15 objection 14:9,i 1
49:20,21 52:7 120:4 i 42:25 221:8,18 222:9 40:5 41:7,11,19 I 4:25 15: i 1$:6
55:5 59:9 66:24 143:1 157:18 none 18:23,23 42:2,12,15,18,21 45:4 4b:8 48:13
215:14 233: i 4 159:2 i 79:23 22:20 66:24,24 71:22 78:11 48:14,22 51:5,20
moved 126:11 2i4:6 216:14,1b 117:9 i92:11 124:18 126:10 56:24 703 Ifl4:17
205:1 2 i 5:18 216:17,17,22 207:16 130:20 164:21 104:19 126:18
moving 31:8 52:6 221:11 nonmeeting i60:25 173:5 176:25 13p:17 144:b
much 27: i4 34:6 needed 15:11 nonworking 220:10 177:b 192:18 149:17 159:1 i
35:15 43:17 66:5 155:18 186:3 normal 37:14 203:7 207:12 233:7,8 160:9 168:4,7
115:6 159:1 2i520 normally 115:21 noticed 17:630:5 172:24 i75:22
180:11 198:17 needs 31:21,21 Norman 2:14,21 8:5 109:5 132:7 176: i Q21 177:10
210:1 211:5 40:14 93:7 98:9 13:3 209:25 225:2 197:14 198:8
multifamily 59:20 98:10 155: i 0 north 23:18 63:17 notices 35: i 5 201:15 232:17
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 20
object►ons 5:3 53:18 75:25 95:13 134:9 136:17 i42.4 144:14 i27:9
12:24 13 :10,12,13 96:8,10,19,20,21 144:14 149:22 14b:2 149_22 only 9: i 1 11:10,13
13:18,23,24 14:3 99:3 145:10 152:8 152:7 i 52:7 220:21 14:23 20:6 24:4
14:17,22 15:5,6 162:10 169:23 officers 51:8 6223 once 27:11 63:21 28:17,19 47:6
16:i3 17:17,22 227:i7 231:7,8 73:15 74:1 78:1,3 i01:2i 161:8 51_7 56:14 68:22
i 8:9,14,18 19:9 232�_ 10 78:4 8�:25 812,3 18 i:14 184:10,11 82:10,12,21 84: i 7
19:13,14 26: t 7 Offenders 84:18 $1:4 91:11 100:1 S 218:21 221:24 84:22 40:20 99:15
27:b,17 28:12 offense 100:25 108:23,24 1 ifl:16 one 8:15 11:13 14:5 104:23 11222
34:19 37:22 38:21 138:8 120.12 148:16 i9.3 2i:21 31_12 129:1 13i24
56:22,23 59:b offenses 29:3 155:24 156:7 32:13,17 33:2 i,21 i 32:24 134:22
70:7 173:22 124:24 125:4,7 of�cer's 103:12 34:24 37:8,9,9,10 i37:23 140:16
192:i6 226:19 I34:24 i35:1,18 offices 38:13 60:19 37:12,16 38:6 148:17 153:17
231:14 232:14 135:19 138:3 official 15:11 17:9 39:19,21 50:23 155:7 �160:1 i
objectives i 99:1 141:3 179:5 22:14 47_22 163:7 S 1:9 54:2,14,17 201:11 225: i
objects 47:4 65:20 offer 20:25 23:15 163:11 173:7 56:22 6i:17 64:1 231:5 233:8
obligation 28:1 50:3 56:3 59:4 184:3 64:2,6,7 65:i0 onto 71:15 i01:18
122:14 b5:17 b6:9 �69:21 officially 195:16 73:7 74:23 75:8 101:21 205:1
obiigations 8:13,14 107:5 118: i 7 officials 29:23 30_ 1 78: i 4,14,14,16 on-site 61:i 3 124:8
observe 2 i 3:22 125:22 126:7,21 31:22 60:14 80:3 81:4 82:10 204:8,11 205:1
observed 77:9 130:15 149:15 177:21 179:13 88:4 90:3 93:15 216:1,3 220:18
99:10 214.20 i 59:9 161:21 209:5 220: I S 93:20,22 94:1,1,4 open 15:13,14,16,17
obtained 45:11 ib2:16 168:1 often 54:19 63_17 96:6,19,20,22,22 15:18 16:5 17:10
11920 172:22 173:20 129:18 142:21 96:23,23,23 97:3 2225 9b:22,22,23
obvious 54:24 60:16 175:19 176:19 191:22 214:1 97:9 98:6,7 101:3 9b23,23,25 98:23
209:1 212:22 177:8,12,17 180:6 Oh 33:16 37:9 102:8 104:10,22 98:24 99:1 100:10
obviously 55_14 198:6 201:i4 104:3 188:5 105:4,15 106:1$ 141:i4 212:1
107:24 226:16 228:19 205:19 224:10 108:1 i 12:4 i20:i opening 32 14:22
occasion 50.24 offered 4:2 5:2 okay 13:21 18.4 122:21 125:10,1 i 19:6 26:19,24
occasions 95:12 44:16 70:2 107:16 33:16 37:15 44:19 125:18 129:12 29:15 40:6 i 78:4
104:23 172:14 1732 179:9 45:3 49:21 Si:2 131:7 136:22 opens 75:3
occupancy 1 i9:10 197:15 20425 53:23 54:19 55:1 137:17,18 139:18 operate 20:2 21:15
11920 12i:20 221:4 231:5 55:7,16 60:13 140:3 141:23 52:2 58:11 i79.i0
194:25 195:2 offering 26_2 107:7 65:16 68: i5 72:7 i46:17 147:7,11 203:11 206:8
196:17,19,22 175:23,24 74:17 76:9 82:9 149:20 151: i 3,18 223:4
occupying 119_14 of#hand 145:20 89:23 91:20 94:3 152:23 i53:2 operated 29:6
occur 58:3 office 38:1 S 50:25 95:1 105:5 111:1 155:4,12,23 168:5 operating 20:2
octurred 29:19 62:24 i08:24 113:10 116:24 171:9,14 174:2,15 47:17 62:13
49:4 58:1 b4.9 110:15 i 2024 1 i 8:16 127:19 i79:20 181:9 operation 31:17
70:14 71:2 73:1 i2i:12,22,25 129:9 131:3 132.7 182:1,7 183:17 209:22 210:i0
74:5 108:13 127:9 122:1 146:1 174:8 140:10 146:3 188:12,13 192:15 operations 203:15
139:6 182:23 186:12 218:3,6 151:21 162:6 199:12,21 200:5,9 opinion 13:16 85_5
occurring 5b:21,25 officer 3:10 222 170:14 172:5,21 ZOi:i 1 204:3 98:19 i55:9
139:10 209:8 23:15 24:3 44:7,9 178:2 18 i:1 b 205:3 2 ll:13 1 b 122 1842,2,4
occurs 91:6 45:6 46:6 48:12 183:4,8,13 185:10 216:3 218:15 Oppenheimer 177:2
October 1:18 2:1 48:18 49:24 50:16 185:23 188:7,8 219:4,7 220:18 182:18
i 6:9 35:5 55:18 50:17,18,21,24 191:5 206:24 231:4 232:23 opportunity 10:17
56:5,16,19 57:22 53:6, lb 58:22 208:19 209:15 ones 82:12 84:22 10:23 27:4 28:9
58:10,i6 72:10 59:i2,16,18 64:4 215:6 230:11,25 96:21 111:4 45:6 51:7,15,16
85:i9,23 137:i 70:25 76:9 77:23 231:1,15 138:18 142:16 126:8 177:21
1 b4:4 1$3: i 5 80:4 81:15 102:17 Olson 3:10 22:2 143:18 1803,5 22620
184:12 185:19 lll:il,l2,14,18 23:1624.3 80:4 one's232:6 opposed i8:25
200:4,5,13 201:13 111:19,23 112:4 81:15 111:12,12 one-half 10i:8 i33:20 149:S,b,iO
2fl8:S 230:10 116:8 117:22 111:14,18 124:16 one-year140:i5 161:3,i5,15
234:11,17 120:9 124.16 127:4 i31:4,1i 146:7 233_18
off 6:2 18:11 25:11 12�:4 13 I:4,11 134:9 136: i 7 ongoing 123:11 opposing 229:25
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 21
optimistic 68:18 orient 55:15 64:1,2,4,6 75:9 overnight 227:12 161:23 1622,4
options 22521 oriented 112:8,10 77:12 78:4 79:18 oversight 20:9 16820,21,22
order 6_1 i0:12 112.12 83:24 84:10,23 169:11 i69:6 230:5
25: i 9 31 _20 55:19 original 2:20 5:24 86:18 87: i 7 96:13 overview 7:10 O'Connor's 47:14
56:5 75:17 78:8 5:24 4421,23 100:12 102:17 owe 25:5
78:17,22,24 79:5 172:3 103:15 i31:23 owed 174_21 175.16 P
79:12 ib4:19 originaily 161:24 136:4 139:18 own 20:1 24:24 P 141:6
170:2,25 172_3 Osttund 2:i5 156:i 160:17,21 57:2 83:16 84:19 pace 116:23
173:7 188:1,3,25 other 1122,23 12:9 161:5 164:19,22 85:12 133:10 packet 6:4,4,5
190: i 5 191:4 13: i 3 20:11 22:17 165:23 166:10 206:8 28:23 34:23 37:5
207:20 208:3,4 2323 25:3 35.20 168:8 169.4 owned 105:12,14 37:9,14 38.1
216_ 19 222:2 38:8 51:8,1 i 170:21 i 72:13 owner 8:6 21:20 129:17 231:23
ordered 171:4 54:12 65:22 66:8 181:2 182: i2, l4 29:3 45:16,20,20 packets 44:24
ordering 55:19 66:23 7222 73:3 182:20 183:14,15 46:15 47:3,4,i8 page 3_7 37:18
orders 4:5,8 20:23 73:8 78:1,3 84:19 184:19 1852,19 65:19 82:22,23 11320 114:2
35:5,7,11 57:22 96:6 103:18 186:21 i87:16 83:4,5 85:2,3,6,9 142:3 144:25
58:5,7,10,16,24 lOb:11 189:7 19Q:25,25 9b:2 102:20 i�9:5 14G:13 i71:i4
79:3 164:3,8,15 107:19,22,23 192:16 201:8 119:21 124:4 174:25 176:13,19
165:2,7 169:i5 108:12 i09:1 221:19223:22 138:12 153:24 183:17187:22
170:2i i71:5 1�10:16 112�14,22 225:13 226:4,12 i54:1,i7,18 155:1 18$:9,17,24 189:4
172:19 187:19,21 i14:9,i8 117:9,14 229:10,17 231:i4 iS5:17 i95:19 228:�,9
188:6 191:3 117:21 119: i 6 231:23 202:23 208:12,16 pagers 6:3
207:19 124:8,10,17 127:7 outbreak 1092 2�8:20 209:7 pages 58:1,23
ordinance 5:4,6 129:20 130:4 outcome 7: ll 21223 213:8 116:24 118:24
16:7,13 27:24,25 133:7 134:8,12 outiine 7:10 owners 12:23 21:25 144:20 165:1
28:22,25 29:4,11 135:1 i38:18 outset i52 2$:13 22:4,5 23:10 i70:5 172:16
31:13 34:8 47:15 142:1 i,23,24,25 33:8 36:7,i9 2423 25:13 57:22 175:9,19,20 176:7
47:24 48:25 57:2 145:17 147:4 224:3 58:1 77:12 78:8 i76:9 183:16
94:10,t7 95_3 151:18 155:12 outside 9:5,6 72:18 78:10,18 79:8 184:6 208:10
98:5 119:9,11,22 160_5,11,25 1b1:3 77:11 84:18 80:1,3 82:4,i5,19 234:7
122:18 i 31:14 161:21 168:5 outstanding i 65: i 2 82:25 $3:2,9 84:1 paid 175:2 176: i
132:22 134:20,25 178:17 179:4,22 165:13 171:14 84:6 85:10 95:8 180:22 i81:4
135.2,5,20 138:4 18b:4,15 201:8,10 173:13,14 18b:2 103:7 106:15,22 182:9, ll 194:21
138:9 139:1,22 206:2 207:13 186:11,21,24 i 19:6,18 122:8,21 195:3 203:6
140:1 i41:8,15 209:23 Z 10:1 187:2,5 189:17 123:13,24 124:9 pamphlet 81:19
150_ 18,20,24 212:6, i 8 213:17 199: l 3 201:3 128:5,23 1343 panel 43:6
151:2 153:22 215:2 220:20,24 221:10 222:1 154:5 159:13 paper 23:1 99:1,7
i68:9 171:2,i5 225:i4 228:1 out-of-compliance 16621 1b8:15 99:25 i0fl:9,23
208:7 224:5,22 229:8 231:4 200:21 172:8 174:4 175:2 107:15 108:9
ordinances 6:25 7:1 others 30:2 78:4 over 12:21 20:9 175:5 191:18 210:21 2i7:14
8:11 2422 28:20 85:12 120:2 157:5 27: I S 29:23 31:16 203:17,2� 20521 papers 99: i 1,14
28:22 38:8 39: i 1 22b:1 37:10 53:13 S4: i 9 206:4 213:23 PARADIGM 1:23
403 42:1 4620 otherwise 1320 68:3 88:6 97:17 ownership 127:15 paragraph 35:17
56: i 2,15 94:6 129:14 156:3, i 9 101:10 105:16 owner's 19825 40:9
i 31:12 140: i 2 233:10 109:20 112:3 199:4 Paramark 5: i 1,13
163:14 168:11,14 ought 17:19 32:8 1 I 8:8 137:25 owning 206: 6 5: i 8 194:6,7,8,10
i83:3 184:16,i7 33:23,25 9t:12 138:2 150:10 owns 83:7 106:9 194_14,21 195:5
i84:21 120_il 147:6 i79:24191:18 206_5 195:21196:8
ordinary59:1 125:4 148:221562 i96:i6,21197:7 O'Connor6:8,9 1983,11,13
130:8 180:9 193:8 198.4 209:16 11:18, 12.9 200:19 241 19
organization 92:25 out 14:4 17:23 I 8:5 218:23 229: i 3 i 2:1 b,19 15:8,9 202:5,13,15,18
201:19 27:22 28:20,25 overall 8:23 168:14 15:10 16:8 19: i 203:10 204:18
organize 199:1 29:24 30:8 31:15 overhead 55:11 46:10,11,12,17 216:8 217:2
organized 151:3 37:5 38:15 42:20 166:5 57:6,7,8,13,16,20 22020
223:25 45:12 54:iS 60:3 overlook 144:9 6b:19,20,21 ib0:7 Paramark's203:1,4
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc_
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2047
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 22
209:3 past 29:3,13,17 77:4 164:19 220:5 48:12,18 4925 134:18 i42:3
Pardon 13:7 90:25 84:7 105:21 perceive21b:20 50_15,17 Si:7,i0 149_20 173_12
103:1 182:13 158:22 i59=14,18 perceiving 12b:4 51:14,17 77:23 195:$,20 197:4,21
224 161:20 percent 24:1 l, l2 102:17 200:18,24 205:18
Park i 12:6,6 Patricia 3: i 9 150:6 i 13:7 135:13, I 6 petitioned 90:5,10 21 S:6 219:20
124_12 150:7 185:24 135:17 16720 ph 72: i 1 2i83,8 pleased 202:11
parking 77:15 204:14, I7 215:6,� 196: U,22,23 phase 198:19,21 ptus 159:9
93: i 8 94:16,20 220:19 214:22 phone 172:12 PM 1:19
95:10 i24.7 patro16225 110:18 perceptible 26:15 220:17 22i22 pockets 73:25
Parkway 2:2,10 112:4 116:9 performance phones 6:3 point i 1:25 12:6
part 13:24 14:3 patterns 134:7 204:23,24 photographs 13:6,8,9,25 16:17
18.18 19:23 24_2 pause 131_8 Zfl4:5 performing ll6:8 222:10 17:1 18:11 19:�4
32:21 37:2 58:16 pay 24:23 25:8,17 perhaps t l:l 13:25 physical 52:25 19:21 29:21 32:16
66:22 70:15 71:12 31:4 35:8,9 47:14 49:11 71:9 200:21 32:19,23 48:8
71:14 73:5 $0:4 19424 207:7,9 126:4 160: i 5 pick 218:15 229:20 50:7 59:8 62:22
81:24 1 i 1:7 paying 24:21 183:4 162:9,10,14 212:5 229:21 56:16 74:21 75:4
113:19 12fl:12 202:21,22 223:22 228:21 picking 21820 75:9 93:20,22
126:2,b 130:8 payment 25:14 period 76:13 80:25 219:9 97:23 i08: i 147:4
i 33: i 5 140:18 174:16,17,18 81:6 101:10 picture 133:21 181:8,9,22,24
146: i 2 153:5 175.15,25 176:7 108_ 13 140:15 pile i49:1 182_ 1 192:5
157:2 160:6 173:5 177:5 146:6,7 161:18 PIN 74:�10 214:2i 22623
182:7 23 I:2 i payments 25:1,15 186:1 224:23 pit'73:8,12,15,17 229:11 232:18
participate 15:22 25:16 35:8 174:5 227:23,25 229:24 ptace 23:2 282 Pointe i:9 4:4,13
participated 164: i 0 175:13 i 81:23 permission 45:15 29:22 60:4 61:8 6:20 7:7 20:2,9,17
participating 37:20 182:16,i7 97:24 102:20 66:5 86:2 87:11 22:22 232,17,23
particular 17:7 pays 2fl3:7 permit47:19 i24:7 87:13 90:20 24:4,10,10 25:2
42:9 86:16 93:6 penalize 29:2 perpetrate 71:5 110:19 121:16 29:18 31: i0 44:8
iO3:25 126:8 penatty 32_3 perpetrators 64:9 122:10 ib6:1,3 5225 53:14 55:2
128:7 130:11 pennies 69:18 99: i6 persistent 22:6 61:4 169:20 182:24 61:1,4 62:13,20
134:3 138:15 99:18,i9,21 person 11:13 34:14 209:16 211:13 63:5,10 64:10
153:11 174:13 penny 107:21 50:21,23 59:16 212:10 234:i 1 67:10 70:15 712
particularly 21:6 people 11:11 i 5:23 69:17 82:21 83:5 placed 213:3 71:4,12,13,24
53:I,i4104:6 30:2331:1449:23 86:5,8,1687:14 places40:181fl123 72:15,2373:i
122:15 130:21 51:11,16 61:8 88:2,25 89:9,11 i01:25 74:4,15 7b:25
141: i 72: i S 73:16 81:16 12 i 24 142:8,10 plain 33:8 77. i,8,18 80:17
parties 2:21 7:21 8 i:20,23 82:17 149:22,25 183:9 plainclothed 50:20 81:7,24 82:1,5,16
9:19,19 19:6 84:6 86:24 87:3 personal 67:9 plainclothes 50:22 82:19,22 86:6,7
20:11 32:17 33:2 88:7 91:11,1 l 120:17 122:9 plan 21:21,23 29:20 86:25 87:4 88:16
49:2 64:22 109:25 93:13,25 100:4,17 157:17 172:5 31:8 32:21 71:5 88: i 8 89:24 90:17
127:i4227:19 lOQ:19,22101:17 I95:9 107:1,151b5:20 90:21,2491:2,6
230:14,15 103:4,8 106:12 personatly 83: i 165:21 i 73:6 92:9,19,24 93:4
partner 204:21 10720 109:5,17 84:22 159:11 179:6,7 211:12 95:8 98: i 4, i 5,17
partners l 95:13 109:18,21 1 i 0:6 164:10 204:20 212: l 1,15 217:18 i 01:6, i 8,2 I
partnership 2:13 120:2 128:25 217:7 222:19 221_25 224:20 105:12 106:9,23
38:2583:6108:23 133.7,9,10137:25 personnel3425 planning217:17 108:i8109:7,11
110:13 133:6 153:8,13 154:3,9 persons 20:1 21:6 plate 229:15 109:15,19,2fl
1 1�5:18 156:2 23:5 109:14 170:9 played 221:22 110:3 112:19,22
party 39:2,3 95:17 157:7,10 159:24 170:12 piaying 49:18 50:1 113:6 114:8 i 15:9
i 27:15 165:22 178:20 185:2 perspective 17:5,10 50:6 1 i 5:17 116: i 1, I 5
227:23,25 228:1 190:12 2fl6:9 60:2,t8 b1:6 please 6:7,22 i3_6,8 117:4,24 118:8
pass 14:4 141:23 2 I 2:4 217:10,20 pertain 163:14 36:24 43:21 45:3 i i 9:6, I 22:4
passageways 23:5 219:6 226:2 perusing 233:2 49:15 51:23 b3:8 124:25 127:7,16
passed 17:23 per 62:25 115:3 pest 126:1,5 71:8 72:4 75:22 131:23 132:3,4,16
199:24 135:12 140: i5 PeYers 44:7,9 45:6,7 91:2 103:21 132:18 134:5
passes 108:2 i49:10 158:22 45:9,12 46:6 111:13 113:14 135:14,16,25
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 23
136:i1,19137:5,9 155:24 i63:22 32:2536:i440_i4 21�:21 180:11,12 192:2,8
137:19 138:12,18 169:24 209:18 45:5 I 17:7 12423 probable 66:14 193:4,4,8 204:5
139:7,8,14 144:1 S 211: i 4,19 136:9 144:3 146:2 probably 43:3 224:24 227:20,21
153:7,7,12,14 policing 112:5,12 155:17 222:12 47:10 89:22 i01:8 proceedings 8.8 9:6
157:1,11 164:7,14 policy 15822 209:3 231:20 138:15,21 159:19 9_7 10:12,12
i65_2 1b8:12 po1175=10 preparing t1:15 i60:12,12,20 13.11,25 14:4
ib9:12 1742i portion 117:20 prerogatives 75_8 184:4 229:12 15:6,14 1b:23
1752,5,16 178:8 I 18:10 122:17 present 15:22,23 230:13 22:9 32:20 48:7
178:21 179:3,9 123_5 135:12 19:8 42:13 108:8 probaYive 225:9,10 162:14 229:5
181:22 187_4 172:23 174:2 13025 problem 30:3 31:11 233:21 234:9
189:2019i:14,i4 i76:5 presentation159:10 3i:1140:152:8 process7_10,15,20
19i:18 194:10 portions 26:21 159:12 58:13 79:15 93:24 8:20 9:1 10:25
1952i 196:6,10 119:20 173:20 presented9:8 11_b 105:20 107�:20 13:1fl,201b:1,15�
i99:8 202:5,14 portrayed 209:13 16:21 32:17 4221 108:5 112:8,10,I2 I8:1,5 2i:18 27:7
206c5,16 211:22 position 91:10 227:2 122:16 133:1 27:8,9,23 30:7
213:3 214:5 157:17 presenting 8:3 10:2 192:6 193:2 211 _7 3125 35:16 40:2
2i5:13,15,24 positive105:18 12:t318:i3i9:19 217:9,17 4i:2342.443:t1
216:1,4,11 217:9 139: i 7 presents 42:13 problerriatic 112_23 51:15,20 65:22
217:24 22024 possession 33:5,7 preside 10_7 43:12 127:23 i28:15 68:25 111:8 138_i
222=23 gg=3 presided22:i2 i29:14152:10,10 i49:5150:9
pointed 74:22 possibility 33:1 S pressing 110:17 152:21 153: i 7 1552 i 155: i 1
Pointe's 131:19 possible 8:15 16:24 presamed 65:24 154:2,iS 155:19 158:4 160:16
points 18:b 47:11 17:2 159:7,7 presumption 66:14 157:8 205:3
48:15 92:13,16 198:24 201:12 145:21 probleins 31:7 produce 2721 28:5
93:19 209:3 227_3 pretty 78:i2 110:8 56:18 60:16 78:15 28:7
potice 8:3 20. i9 Possibly 190:5,7 227:1 i 95:21 100:20 productive 128:6
21:7,11,24 22;15 posted 17:8 228:25 prevalent 120:2 105:22 1 i9:25 professiona12:3
23:6,22,24 24:2 post-hearing 33:1 prevent 57:24 65:11 123:12 127:6 195:18 234:5,22
24:12,14 2b:22 33:10 36:21 47:11 66:17 88:10 209:8 133:4,11 179:9,13 pro�t 197:1
36:17,17 46:23 post-trial 228:1 prevention 124:3 19b:15 22�:11 profound 20:3
48: i 50:18 53:16 practice 110:10 previous 106:13 procedurat 7:2Q program 112:11
59:13,15 b0:2,3,7 129:24 203:1 122:7 128:25 8:20 9:1 1 b: i 27:6 124:7 190:10
60:18,21 61:6 217:12,16 129:2 171:7 27:9 65:22 158:20 progress i98:2,4
62:22 64:11 b6:1 preceding 140:15 previously 8b:10 procedure 7:16 prohibiting 93:12
68:2 74:11 76:13 precise 35:17,19 123:15 126:11 8:23 9:25 31:1 project 46:24 102:3
77:17 78:1,3,4,17 229:21 168:7 17225 32:9 42:3 43: i 0 102:4 195.6 19b:9
79:14 80:16 86:9 precisely 20:19 i 73:22 156:9 2fl2:2,6,12,15
87:16,21 88:24 predict 86:14 price 108:5 procedures 7:18 204:1 I 215: i 3,20
89:i 90:1,11 91:4 prefer 133:9 primary 196:1 1fl:7 i24:13 219:i2
91:8, i 1 95:15 preference 159:21 223:6 proceed 12:8 13: i 5 projected 118:7
99:13,22 1fl0:12 prejudiced 16:25 principal 125:18 14:6 15:5 26:20 projects 19b:b
101:22 103:9,14 premises 20:2,4,4,5 principals 177:15 26:21 2$:13,14 201:22
103:15 108:15 21:1,5,12,16 177:19 36:21 42:23 43:2 prolong 42:7
i 10:15 ll 2:6,9,10 22:18 23:12 35:13 print 121:11 47:1fl,12 49:6,11 promise 62:7
115:22 116:20 45:13,13 52:25 printout 130:3 49:15 50:10 71:8 promised 93:8
118:11,14 t 19:23 54: i 3,20 58:11 prior 4:1 56:2 i 57:3 75:11 152:4 201:11
12 I:25 124:17,23 60:23 61:5,16 139:1 155:3 i 58:14 i 93:13 promises 22: i 9
125:3,5 131 1� 62:1,8,18 73:20 163:20 170:23 proceeded 34:$ 61:25 105:24
1332,13,15 i 23:22 167:18 193:3 213:21 proceeding 9:1,4 i06:1 128:8,10,22
134:21 135:18 212:18 priorities 211:13 11:9 13:15,i5 proper 13: i4 ib:25
136:1 i37:9 prepare 9:13 28:10 218:16 18:19 i9:25 29:2 27:13 32:9 34:3
139:11 140: i4,24 35:22 41:22 55:25 priority 215:21 30: i9 33:24 34:1 4124 42:2,2 66:5
143:12,14, i 5 i 35:23 146:14 222:2 34:4 39:13 4120 proper(y 30_ l 8
144:22 145:12 148:3 privacy 47:8 43:5 �3:9 131:8 58:1 i 93: I Z
153:5,18 154:19 prepared 9:13 private 45:13 48:2 179:22,25 180:8 126:15 143:1
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 24
210:6 177_ 19 178 18 192:18 199:9,24 144:22 146:11,1 raise 11:12 196:19
properties 24:24 184:16,20 186:3 200:19 208: i 146:24 147:22 195:24 203:14
59: i 9 83:10 190:16,24 194:10 222:16 162:8 207:10 raised 7:5 48:15
107:22,23 112:22 194:13 195:9,18 provides 7:1 8:14 217:10 222:2 42:13 i 83:9
114_13,20 li7_8 196_11,12,14,i6 46:22,24 47:2 229:17 192.14
117:10, 1 120:1 i96:1 b,18,1_8 b I 21 1 i 8:22 putting 99: i 8, i 9 raising 73: t2,15,17
124:12,14,25 i97:1,24 i98:15 140:12 190_12 IOQ:4 208:24 ran 63:19 64:1
130:2 133:10 i 99:14 203:11 providing 41:6 215:2 i 201:8
i 38:10 169:2 205:2,6 206:5 81:16 128:23 P.A 2: I S RAND 124
179: I,10 191:1 207:11,21 208:12 153:6 p.m 2:1 73:2 74: i 7 Randy 152:1
207:6 209:25 208:12,17,20,20 provision 226:13 75:16 i 58:18 204:14, i 7 216:6
210:1 212:7 214:3 210:6,9,10,25 provisionat 131:16 199:21 233:21 2i8_7
property 4:i3,17 213:9,12,16,18 131:20,25 132:3 rate 58:12 2ll:16
5:9 16:2 2125 215:21 216:3 140:16 224:6,9,10 :___2_ rates 60:22 62:1
25:3,2i,23 29:3 218.16 220:19 224:12,13,20 quality i9b:20 107:4 125:18
30:13 31:20 32:5 222:19 223:4,12 provisions 47:23 197:9 232:15 211:22
32:6 45:16 46:13 proposed 32:3 public 2:3 4:11 quarter 118:13 rather 12:12 18:5
48:2 53_ 19,20,21 34:13,17 39:12 15:10,16, i 7,18,19 quasi-judicial &:24 79:23 93_ 19
54:756:14,16 prosecuting8:2 i5:20,21,21 i6:3 question7.1712_i0 161:i7,23
57:23,23 60:17 2 i:14,18 36:1 i 16:4,5,6,7,7 17:6 16:5 34:12 42:8 ratio I 14:23 135:11
6 i: i 2,13,17 62:5 41:2 83:14 26:7 41:13 64:18 42:11 47:14 49.3 ratios 210:3
63:3,18,25 64:17 prosecution 26:1,13 64:19 91:14 So:12 53: i 2 6Z6 raw 114:18 1 i 5:8
65:19 67:20 69:2 prosecutor 26:1 124:18 i 75:1 i 70:18,23,24 71:13 1 i 720
69:3 71: i 3,15 protecting 21:9 177: i2,17,2Q,22 71:14,25 78: l2 re 113: t9
72:9,i8 73:5 77:9 protection 203:24 179:13 81:18 85:14,16,24 reached 157:4
80:5 81:1? 82:2,5 protoco161:24 pu1169:18 160: i4 96:5 100_7 104:12 158:3 220:5
82:1b 83:5,7 proved 115:25 pumped 204:1 104:20 108:19 reaction 109:4
85:23 86:20 91:6 proven 65:24 66:6 punish 29:12 154:2 1 i3:22 133:13 read 47:15 140:2i
93:10,11,13,14,21 173:1 pnnished 156:2 134:9 148:3 206:6 142:13 225:5
95:3 96:1,2, provide 7:9 8.25 purchase 107_19 208:16 209:21 22$:6
98:16 99:15 14:5 28:4,8 36:$ 109:23 210:5 211:18 reading 1 l: i0
100:16,20 101:18 39:12 41.10 54:21 purchased 108:4 225:1,2 232:23 140:17,19
101:20,22,24 61:7 7$:8 80:8,10 purchasing 10922 questions 10:6 reads 142:6
i02:1,16,21 103:3 80:12,i493:2 purportedly 166:18 i1:17 12:2039:24 ready 135:6 158_19
105:14,16,20,20 1i8:23 119:10 purpose 14:17 42:23 52:12 71_10 real 194:8 19524
106:11,12 107_1,2 12020 121:9 15:19 27:7 28:25 7i:21 75:1 87:2 195:25
i 07:11 108: i,25 122:14 128:5 29:2,4,12 59:25 92:17 94:24 reatiy 52:1 12525
114:22 115:1,1 136:22 148:22 67:15 123:8,11 103:18 I l L 199:2 218:16,20
119.14,21,25 174_2 178.i 1 145:10 179:$ 131.4 180:15 221:3 225:1
120:3,6,10,11 19421 i 84:12,19 i 92:1 205:15 232:16
121:6 122:5,23 provided i3:i4 purposes 14:18 2i4:23,24 21624 reason 9:15,20 23:8
123:13 124:4,5,10 28:23 29:15 37:5 16:15 55:8 120:7 222:14 223: i 5 26:12,13 3fl:11,12
127:8,10,21 i28.2 40:12,1341:7,15 134:1,4,5225:t4 quick72:i4 35:148:13b9:i5
128:4,7,11,16,1$ 4i:18,19,20,21 225:16 quickly 146:18 79:12,13 86:i2
128:21,23 129: t 5 56:23 79:10 83:15 pursuant 47:19,20 159:6 i 60: l5 97:12 102:13,15
i30:5,11 133:7 103:13 11fl:15 194:17 191_20 198_24 132:15 149:13
134:3,5 136:13 119:15 1222 pursuing 155:22 199:i,16 212:9 203:10 20823
139_7,10,12 123:15 124:11,19 purview 154_17 227:11 210:8 22b:6
148:12,23 i 50:10 125:13 i 28:11 put 18:11 20: i 7 quite 38:23 68.25 reasonable 33_ 10
153:22,24 154:1,5 129:1 130:7 30:20 33:25 40:23 105:24 i45:20 10525 209:21
154:6,17,18 155: i i 36:19 i 37:8 53:23 69:7,19 183:1 227: I 8 228:10
155:i715b:18 i40:9144:6147:8 96:7,i497:3,11 quote40:2198:1 reasonab1y34:15
16420 168:25 147:18 154:4 97:12,16,16 98:1 quoted 34:7 lOb:S i45:10
169:1 171:22 156:12 157:b 99:21 102:14 reasons 28:2 33:3
172:7 174:14 1b5:9 I78:9 105:15 113:14 _R 39:11,17 40:5
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETiNG
Page 25
rebuild 21 i:9 93:5,6 94.21 95_6 178:3 143:2 200:21 lOb:17 114_13
rebuttal 223:19 98:8 207:10 referenced 41:9 reiated 7:S 4 L 117_8,9,1 i 120:1
recall i25:16 165:8 recommended 141:19 121:4 125.i9 120_24 121:i2,22
168:19 174:11 93.17 referred 8:17 52:1$ 128:3 i21:25 122:1,2
186:18 reconfiguration 55:11 156:8 relates 2825 127:24 i30:2
receipt 174:16 94:20 95:10 22020 135:18 135:16 153:22,24
201:1,9 213:2 reconfigare 93:18 referring 1323 reiating 119:13 154:7,12 177:14
receipts 175:10 reconfiguring 94:15 82:6,16 117:3 134:14 199:5
17b:7 reconsider 162:14 124:22 152:9 relation 135:2 rents i95:1 196:19
receive 15:4 50:9 record 7:23 8:8,9 154:12 159:14 relationship 114:8 196:25
51:4 58:16 59:8 9:4 11:8,14,16 i 74:25 i 89:21 127:14 194:9 reoffer 126:20
118:14 i21 15,22 13:2,24 14_ 12,15 refers 47:16 198:11 201:18,21 repair 35:12 62_4
130:3,4 i 79:16 14:25 i 8: i 8 26:7 refiect 114: i 8,19 202:1,20 I 19.1 S 165:15,23
190:15 36:12 53:18 75:25 11720 147:6 relatively 69:18 198: i9,21
received 42 5:2 b:4 137:15 143:8,15 reflected i 15:1,4 tfl8:4 repaired 6721 b8:9
12:713:2214:17 148:i917425 117:15,19149:12 relevance57:21 68:i7,18,25
14:25 23:9 25:12 175:11 177:12,i3 reflects 116:5 91:15 repairs 1b5:15
26:9 27:9 30:1,2 t80:14 192:11 135:13 relevancy 9023 198:14 20fl.10
33:21 34:2 35.25 193:22 227:17 refrigerator 183:25 9i:1,3 207:6
37:10,12 42:12,14 229:1,4 231:19,21 184:7 relevant 16:4 58: i5 repeat 171:7 206:6
42:18 67:18 70:4 232:10 234:8 regard 12:1 i 71:25 178:b,13 repeated 25:24
70:5 83:20 84:5,7 recorded 147:25 106:22 107:3 179: i 8 225:1 �,14 26:10 79:6 80:6
117:21 121:2 recordkeeping 109:13 120:18 225:16 repetitive 20:21
122:17 124:1 i 8�:17,20 165:24 171:19 reiiability 1 I:5 replace 107:16
169:24 177:18 records 24:20 25:4 regarding 68:8 48:20 165: i4,15 21 i:8
186:4 2Dl:b 208:2 25:22 41:4,5,6 123:21 124:24 reliable 48:17 83:21 212:1 i 217:18
221:17 230:i2 59:1 82.24 83:1 125:3,8 1282 84:6,8 replaced 200:10
receives 136:1 1fl2:5 11521,24 172:6 177:18 rety 126:16 216:25 219:15
receiving 39:23 115:24 i21:9,11 regards 76:7 79:6 remain 166:25 repiacement 35:12
45:22 69:12 121:14 130:4,9 register 119:7, i 0,18 1692 replies 228:12
123:14 136:13 143:11,17 i64:20 119:20,24 120:8 remainder 176:2� rep1y45:1$ 230:19
174:8 175:1,24 176:12 120:19 121.3,20 remaining 165:11 report 5:16 22:21
recent 134:21 148:7 176:20 177:18,20 122:15 remarks 193:11 23:1 i,14 69_21
179: i 1 177:23 registered 2:2 38:10 remember 52:14 92:22 136:1,4,18
recently 70_ 14 recreate 1 i:16 38:13 234:5,22 70:11 97:23 139:4 137:4,8 143:9,20
109:19 112:7 rectify 108:5 registries 150:12 187:13 144.14,17 i46:11
i22:17 i32:18,20 red 14b:9 147:20 regular84:i2 remembering 169:10 188:1$,19
137:21138:5 redirect3:9103:22 106:19127:9 152:16 196:21199:8,ll
139:19 158:13 160=22 224: i 5 remind 35:14 199: i 5,23 201:1,2
recess 159:1 i redone 27:11 228:20 removed 90:10 213:12 222:6,12
i 62: i 5 reduce 60:3 63:1 regulate 28:15,17 99:12 222. i 5
recite 71:1 100:3,16 128:6 28:19,21 renew 51:5,20 reported 1:22 14:13
recited 7b:6 149:3 i9b:20,23 regulation 20:9 5624 116:3 137:11
recites 71:23 210:14 regulations 2820 renewal 7:2 35:6 149:4 i89:14,16
reciamation 217:3 reduced 123:23 168:12 57:17 189_ 16
recognized i 1:12 13 i:2 Regulatory 41:14 renewed 47:17 reporter 2:3 8:7
61:21 reduction 26:14 rehab 198:19,21 b0:20 131:19 11:6,15 14:5
recommend7:18 60:21,24 reinspected i87:i6 132:6 234:6,22
10:1,ii 14:16 reductions 13022 reinspecfion 1'J0:19 rent 190:13 195:2 REPORTER'S
15:443:5207:6 redundant228:7 reinvest29:9 203_i4,14,17 234:1
217:8 227:23 reexamine 10:18 reiterate 92:16,17 218:18 reporting 1:23
recommendation refer 82:15 121:17 reiterated 85:18 renta14:17 5:9 7:2 i41:17 169:9
25:25 36:18 94:7 146:10 164:24 reject 66:9 8:12 25:20 28:16 222:20
97:2,5 98:2 11�:2 reference S 1:10 relate 58:12 134:4 28:25 31:10 45:19 reports 4:24 58:13
recommendations 132:8,9 i41:8,15 134:20 142:24 47:18,25 56:13 i24:17,23 125:3
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 2b
136:12 13724 119_ 11,13,22 178:25 187:1 177:14 622 i 63:5 64:8
145:19 147_15,17 190:i7 203:19 200:19 202:8 re-Iet3i:13,15 IOL
147:24 148:6 226: i 0 213:14 221:14,15 Rick 50:24 i 09:2,3
i 532,6 204:22 requires 8: i 1 233:19 rid b3:2 90:6 robbery 63: ib 74:4
213:6 requiring 94:2fl responsibilities riding 74:18 89:4 109:23
represent 124:9 95:3 189:2 59:13 163:12 rifled 7325 Robbinsdale 422
1b7:10 172:16 reschedule i5923 responsibility 59:17 right 19:20 32:5 25:23 177:18
206:4 1bi:25 iS4:18 1b3:22 33:2346:2,24 Robinwood 177:20
representation reserve 18: i 4 202:14,19 209:7 49:17 50:19 �9:4 Rochester 5: i 2,14
172_8 179:16 232_8 218:13 219:2 63:1 i,11,i2 65.2 19324 195:22
representative residence 122:1 responsible 87:1,6,8 65:22,24 68:10 i96:1 i,12 197:6,7
i 29:18 residential 29:5 88:8 91:5 100:17 71:21 73:5,7 197:10,22,24
represented 37:20 47:1 57:23 59:19 130:1 135:14 7724 78:14 792 role 602 222:5,8
82= i 7 117:17 63:17 i 95:24 199:7 202:16,20 79:10 81:1 84:10 roles 10:1
123:13 196:1 202:22 208:12,15 $4:25 85_2 86:22 ro116:7
representing 36:15 residents 60:4 213:8 219:8,10 87:19 8$.14,22,25 roof 165:17,19,21
38:24 123:9 154:14 responsive 192:23 90:2,12 92:14 Roofing 185:13
represents 24:8 resolution 207:5 rest 9822 151:1 93:4 94:10,13 roofs 165:23
116:20 117:10 resoived 30:19 160:17 161:5 9S_8 96:3,6,15,20 room 53_2,15 54:15
118:13 135:16 34:19 56:18,19 209:25 96:21 97_3,22 74:21 88: i 3
167: i 1 57_3 b6:16 restate 7024 98:12,24 99:14 142:24 231:3
reproduced 20:14 resources 24:14 21 I:17 100:14 lfl 1:2,18 rooms 54:6 100:5
64:21,23 113:20 112:13 i35:18 rested 192:24 101:24 103:15,16 219:3
114.5 respect 3825 56:25 resYriction 69:6 1�5.8 114:23 Rotamau 218:3
reproduction 50:4 i26:18 128:23 86:17 i 15.4 124:2 rotated 81:4
reputation 207:11 168:5 i 73:23 restrictions 86:18 125:12 130:15 Roth 22:15 60:7
request 420 7:4 185:8 199: i0,14 rests 192:1 135:3,5 137:17 91:22
9:19 11:7 28:12 203:3 222:5 result 30: i4 41:23 138:23 139:20 roundabout 1322
41:12 44:12,14 respectfally 27:16 112:15 118:14 140:24 141:4 148: i4
100:19 119:15 28:11 31:4 128:i9 134:21 145:1,i6 145:15 RPR 1:22
120:19 121:20 respects 196:10 142:23 171:18 147.18 i49:11 Rued i73:8,11,15
122:9 174:20 respond 18:9 28:10 226:4 151:4 152:16,19 190:4 22i:5
176:12 178:10 3b:6,23 40:15 resume 52:12 152:24 153:3,19 rule 17:2 42:22
requested 41:6 4 i:22 143: I 2,14 retain 207:13 i 54:25 155:6,20 180:8
62:23 104:6 145:15 148:15 return 199:5 155:3 157:16,24 ruled 168:8
119:10 193:2,6 209:3 retunied 5:24 100:8 1b2:7 170:9 177:8 rules 7:16 1 i:2,3
requests 6:2 26:10 226:20,21 227:25 i86:12 179:17 182:1,3,9 48:15 52:3 138:12
1 i9.i5,21 120:21 responded 3721 returning 186:19 i83:13,1fi,19 ib8:12 225:9
120:22 122:19 respondent 17:24 revenue 31:16,21 184:9,13,25 185:3 228:5
require 2 i:20 2422 17:25 176:10 review 26:5 40:18 185:8,15 187:10 ruling 13: i 2
39:11 95:7 125:1 i 192:16 193:19 141:13 142:20 187:1b,23 i88:24 run 20: i4 43:6,7
153:23 158:24 Respondent's 164:20 174:20 190:17 194:22 44:19 45:3 64: i
L68:1 i 228:8 136:16,18 14125 176:12,24 201: I 1 i95:4 203:22 running 45:9 63:15
required 8:25 9:12 142:1 143:22 206:19 207:19 204:2,15 206:7,10 73:6 91:12 99:7
15:14 18:8 42:1 144:13 145:23,25 213:b 222:13 207:9 209:12 216:22 231:6
94:16 98:4,12 149:15 1972,3,16 229:14 212:3 214:14 runs 208:10
110:1 119:9 197:18,20 198:6 reviewed 102:5,10 217:5 220:4 223:7 Ryan 6:10,11 1821
122:17 148:10 200:15,16 231:24 125:10 225:5 228:23 230:17 34:21 48:4,5,6
I50:i9,21,24 responding 133:9 revocation 7:2 8:i6 rights 162 20:4 49:7,8,9 75:12
151:2 198:13,19 133:16 192:10 31:9,12 32:4 31:3,3 51:19 i 36:25 i 5 i:22,23
204:1 224:14,19 responds 143:7 34:13 224_4 225:2 180:10,10 151:24 152.2,5
requirement 25:18 response 5:17 7:S 225:15,17,18,20 ring 6:S 1t0:9 162:i,6,18
94:6 95:2 119:5 19:13 21:21 30:12 22520 226:5,9 risk 207:11 232:22 233:1,b,11
119_ 14 205:7 39:24 64:5,12 revoke 8:18 9:11 robbed �4:6 88: i3 233:14
requirements 7:20 151:6 172: t4 revoking 25:20 robberies 62:19,21
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc_
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/i/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 27
S__ Scott 218:7 i42:20 144:20 136:19,25 137:1,2 Seventh 2:16
Safar 38:11 screen 53:23 98:10 146:9,17 149:12 137:5,10,10 severai 53:13 54:17
safe 29:6 542 i 113:14 114:5 157:6 159:16 138:17 146:6 57:22 58.22 64:15
6I :22 209:15 209: i 3 162:21 164:4 175:4 194:16 88:5 93:19 98:8
220:13 screening98_14 168:25 185:19 219:12 Ifl1:19 109:23
safer 60:4 61:8,i6 search i02:18,19 189:7 200_i2 sequence 152:12 11222 119:21
safest 93:2 seat 2 i 5:11 20323 208:4,7,10 sergeant 22:14 60:7 120:21 124:11
safety5:i4 2i:10 second 10:21 18:20 209:10,12 2�0:i8 76_I8 91:22 i25:9 138:I IS7:5
41:14 120:9,13 1g=21 27:6 37:22 218�17 232:13,14 series20:22 i69:14 157:5 170:5
197:23 40:9 94:1,4 98:2,7 232:16 serious 21:2,3 22:1 172:14 216:19
same 10.13,23 113:19 131:7 seeing 18:23 66:24 22:18,22 61:3 22p:2,2fl
37:18 39:14 59:6 i423 147:13 88:1 1 109:4 70:14 71:1,24 sewer 24:21 174:22
65:8 67:18 80:5 178:5 I87:22 seem 99:16 72:9,22 183:18,21 Shannon 2:15 8:6
85:8 8$:5 103:8 1gg:17 216:5 seemed 105:17 183:23,24 184:1,5 shared 90:16
i08:8 116:23 229=24 seems 48:25 91:10 192:6 214:8 shares 92:25
121:13 126:17 secretary 221: i 7 seen 10:4 i 6:18 232:14 sharp 159:24
146:14 152:1 section 5:7 6:24,25 25:6 28:6 36:5 seriousness 209:5 Sheet 5:5
167:14 173:22 8:16 29:4 38:8 40:22 42:9 58:10 serve 228:7 sheetrock 200:10
179=2 188:9 47:15,16,19,20,21 64:25 138:15 served41:8 174:12 shelf 183:25 184:7
226:25 58:19 59:5 131:11 146:4 165:25 serves 93:25 sheriff's 50:25
sample 129:18 i 31:24 141:1,18 198:1 207:22 service 5:8 23:22 62:24 108:1 b,24
sanction 34:17 141:21 142:b,17 209:11 210:25 24: i, i 6 26:15 110:14
225:19 143:3 145:18 211:2 2 i 7:6 225:4 53:20 60:4,22,25 Shingle 22,10
sanctions 8:14,15 147:23 i71:2,16 232:19 60:25 63:1 90:13 shoes 7423
sanctuaries 72:23 190:6,8,9,17,19 sees 44:10 107:5, I� 112:19 shoot 86:15
sanctuary 71:4,5 190:22 191:10 setect 217:13 113:1 i 1 i4:8,18 shooting 72:21 73:3
sanitary 29:6 221=7 224:5,20,21 selected 117.5 114:19,24 115:2,5 73: i 2 86:5,8
satisfaction 185_7 sections 38:9 48:25 self 85:13 i 15:13, i6 117: ib shootout 72:25
satisfied 202:10 secure 21:9 22:23 setf-initiated 117:22 1 i7:17,20 118:$ short 3b25 108:13
saw51:17 77:22 35:11 54:22 61:16 selt i95_25 118:11,15 123:22 121:12 198:3
79: i9 9821 109:2 212:10 214:1 send 27: i0 28:24 130:5,23 132: i0 shortcoming 214:9
210:23 214:16 220:13 121:13 i56:7 132:1b,24 133:20 shortcomings 121:1
222:( secured 21:4 23:11 185:2 134:20 i35:10,12 shortiy2b:3
saying 16:9 34:3 61:10 69:14 89:21 sending 36:3 135: i4 136:5,6,11 shot 72:20 86:2
39:10,23 8624 g9:22 98:9 sense 97:25 232:5,7 13722 139:4,13 shoulders 12b.3
87:3 116_3 138:14 securing 23:13 sent 16:8,10 22:4 142:21 14b:20 shoved 99:25
156:17 157:15 �i9:i7 37:5,22 38:1,9,15 147:1,2 148:8 100:10
160:3 i872 214:3 security 62:4,8,13 3821 39_ i5 5520 209:17,24 210:14 show 20:13,18,20
says 29:1,4, i 2 30:8 63:25 103:12 67:21,23 121:21 2ll :16 219:13,15 20:22 21:23 23:3
34:8 39:17 40:22 205:13 211:11 127:14,2fl,22,25 233:9 23:17 24:15,20,25
43:8 46:13 47:2 i Z j 4:9 2 i 9:21,23 128:1,3,13,14,16 services 38:12 25:4,7 26:20
132:23 220:2,5,9,12 128:20 129:2,9 4 i:14 116:6 35:23 36:7 45:24
schedule i 89:16,17 see i4_ 14 172 152:13 164:22 194:22 197:6 50:2 51:9 53:24
223:22 226:23 20:19 21:13,17 170:21 192:15 221:4 58:3,8 b9:16
227:19 228_ 10 29:1 I 30:7,9 39.9 220:22 221:22 set 8:8 42:1 69:8 113:10 14b:13
229:9,16 46:9 50:4 52:5 231:14 232:23 145:10 154:15 175:25 179:5
schedWed 7_4 9:23 95:20,23 96:15 233: i2 162:9 164:3 165:7 192:9 197:19
39:6 47:6,25 97:10 98:22 sentence 40:7 Ib7:22 170:14 208:2 213:2
schedules 223:23 102:10 109: i3,16 separate 27:22 171:17 226:23 214:17 218:21
scheduling 221:6 1 i4:12,16,17,21 134:11 169:11 sets 2824 34:25 219:7
scheme 179:6 I i4:23 117:19 September S:S 38:15 131:14 showing 25:23
school 195:16 118:10 13 l:1 24:22 38:7 39:7 136:4 S 1:25 124:16
Schreder 2:10 i34:15,17,24 41:8 54:24 74:15 seven 44:20 7b:1$ 127:12 144:13
11:21 135:3,4 138:7 74:17 93:8,17 I 12:1 175:9 210:7 145:25 164:2
scope 84:17 140:17,19 141:9 105: i 6 t 06:25 229:8,21 165:10,22 167:6
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 28
174:16 176:i3,16 85:15 87:3 90:9 sma1149:22 114:25 192_8 Southeast 177_16
197:3 200:16 90:19 91:i0 94:2 115:3 219:10 someone 11:10 Southwest i93:24
20i:10 210:18 94:25 100:7 101:1 smaller i 1S:S,E 29:12 54:13 71:4 speak ll: i 1 i9:9
2 i 8.20 i01:15 102:7 smashed 99_3 71:5,15 7$:7,16 26:18 27.4 125:10
shown 79:8,13 103:19 111:21 smear 178:20 86:2,3,8,15 87:8 143:10 i48:4
i26:23 148:6 i 13:2,5 t 14:4 smiles 223: t 3 87:19,22,24 116:5 i49:2 157:20
16920 176:13 115:11,18 118:4,6 smoke 145:9 143:19 187:4 166:17,19 2I4: i 5
85=$ 126:9 131: i 8 sold 197:1 189:7 202:15 220: i
shows23:21 24.3 132:11,14,21 solve 133:10 205:11 2i221 speaking 11:13,14
25:7 36:3 54:1 133:18 135:7 so(ving 79:15 213:16 216:17 164:23
149:3 167:20 137:2,7,18 i39:5 some7:14,189:15 232:4 speaks51:24
176:7 179.8 13921 140:3,20 9.19 11:9 15:15 something Ib:l 1 special i:2 5_19
shrug 126:3 141:5 146:14 16:25 19:20 26:18 i 7:14 3 i:24 49:4 17:7 80: t 5 84:25
shut 25:11 174:13 151:10 152:5 29:25 32:16,19 85:11 87: ib 93:3 203:8
shutoffs 25:9 153:10 156:25 33:6 40:10,20 97:19 107.14,22 specific 33:3 35:16
side 11:22,24 18:2 158:11 164:5,12 41:4 48:9 49:1 i33:13 i45:12,18 57_i 1 67:15
54:8,8 68:20 69:2 164:16 165:5 54:6 66:16 68:2 i46:23 147:7 119:ll 120:14,i7
109:18 160:6 166:13 167:5 68:25 70:13 71_1 153:7,20 159:17 124:3,22 129:6,20
sides 161:19 i 7�:11 17 i:3 75:4 76:12 80:19 213: i b 220:7 131:15 135:18
sign 64:15 172:4 174:6,24 88:8 93:5 9424 232:1 158:3 178:10
signed 6422 65:3,7 175:12 177:3 100:18 iO3:3 sometimes 70:8 18321 193:5
65:8 166:11 180_19,23 i81:11 105:19 107:3,8,19 99:3 229:23 226:8
172:17 181:18 182:1,2,6 108:1,i7 ll4:13 somewhere 110:9 specifically29:24
significant 109:3 183:1,11,17 184:2 115:2 116.10 116:22 213:4 35:3 61:2 b7_11
119:25 i 95:5 184:3,8,10, t 8,22 119: i 6 120:6 224:7 68:7 7123 112:10
197:25 185:1,12,14,17,21 121:1 124_1Q soon 2fl1:12 209:2 112:i7 123:20
significantty 19624 186:9, i 3, I 6,25 129:9,25 134:14 229:3 124:19 125:15
similar 128:22 187:3,6,24 188:16 141 14 147:3 sooner 32.20 134:4,25 135:1
196:6,1fl,13,13,14 i89:3,6,22,25 150:23 151:3 162:19 136:4 i38:8,25
similarities 117:14 190:20,23 191:7 154:3 155:5,14,18 sophisticated 141.15 165:2
simple 105:19 191:11,16 193:17 156:2 157:1,5,12 107:17 208:4
i07:14, i 7 211:10 205:18 215:5 157:21,24,25 sorry 14:23 39:2 i specified 16:12
216=2fl 232:25 158:1,5,23 165:14 52:13,22 53:10 140:15 234.12
simply 14:9 18:12 sister 72:15,17 165:14,15,17,17 55:4 69:25 70:8 specify 56:12
6b:7 69_17 91:4 179:i2 1b5:23 169:23 80:22 85:15 92:1 spell 28_20
110:7 178:20 sit 76:3 86:12 170:20 171:13 92:2 99:23 113:23 spelled 156:1
simultaneous i5b:25 157:20 178:17 181:22,24 119:12 137:2 spend 203:25
227:24228:11,12 203:9 183:t8,22185:8 140:18141:1$,22 207:14,14224:1
simultaneousiy site 166:10 172_ l 1 185:10,11 196:10 144:8 163:17 spending 100:15
229:g 172:15 189:12 196:14 200:10 181:19 199:9 spent 99:22 123:5
since 24:10 30:4 190:3 202:17,18 203:5 2i4:19,20 205:19 234:22 spoke 3921,22
43:5 45:7 46:6 220:9 215:20 216:13,15 sort 43:b 117:22 spokesperson 36:19
51:3 77:6,18 sitting 15 i:19 216:20,24,25 225:13,20 232:12 spot 167:17
112:17 118:13 204:15 217:8,21 218.22 sorted 226:4 spots 90:3
122:5 127:10 situaYion 163:24 224:23 225:3,14 sorting 226:18 Spreiget 179:4,21
146:14 147:7 six 54:8 73:23 175:9 225:16,20,25 sought 157:1 180: i
15b:19 187:8 2 i 5.17 227: i 5 228:4,5,9 sounding 142:22 spring 64: i4 80:16
19523 198:3 size23:21 196:13 229:11,IS,16 soundings 142:22 122:10 129:21
214: i 6 skew 115:6 somebody 11:16 sounds 68:1 185: i4 130:25
single 1 i4:14 130:5 skipped 67:6 43:$ 63:23 137:12 2 i4:6 223:21 squatting 73:14,16
2fl2:2 214:18 siide 135:6,8,21,22 174_6 source 90:2 93:14
singular 106: i0 146:15 somebody's 86: i 9 sources 61: i 7 staff 7:4 8:2 10:3
sir 37:17 7b:5 77:2 siides 102:8 135:23 somehow 65:10 south 1:24 2:16 i 2:13 15:24 19:24
78:12,22 79:5 siightly 24:9 87:25 i 78:21 63:13,18 73:4 20:7,23 21:24
50:15 82:8 85:4,6 stowfy tl:ll i80:7 182:25 101:8 109_18 26:b,22 36:IQib
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 29
36:17 38:16,17 station 7220 86:3 72:19 73:7 74:2 25:17 118:22 209:20 218:15,19
42:12,13 462 statistical 137_23 86:2,15,19 89:24 225:12 220:11 222:7,8,10
55:1 77:12 8i:17 i46:17 91:9 109:2,3 sufficiently 225:8 222:20 229:7
83:13,13 84:19 statistically 115:5 110:7 220:5 225:10 231:3 232:6 233:4
115:22 121:5,7 116:20 131:1 street-level 103:4 suggest 3620 43:15 surfaces 58:13
122:7 123:6 124:8 149:9 109:16 47: ifl 178:21 surge 63:4
124:9 128:19 statistics 23:16,24 stress 92:19 180:7 22622 surprised 147:16
134:12,22 146:25 24_3,15 41:3 strict 52:3 suggesYed 33:9 93:3 202:1 i
147:5 148:10 112_24 1 i3:10,24 strike 27:24 206:19 133:13 222:15 surrounding 1 i2:21
62:22 170:b,8,18 115:10 1 i 8_ 17,22 strong 21:8 207:10 suggesting 155: i 1 surrounds 1 i 2:13
170: i 9 171:12,13 126:22 132:7,15 structurat 165:15 155:12 228:4 surveillance 102:25
i7i:22 172:15 133:19,23 134:10 stucco 165:16 suggestion 27:16 103:3
183:15 184:23 134:23 136:9,12 185:10,11 32' 14 33:11 34:16 suspect 63:7,9 64:6
186:20 189:11,12 137.4,16 139:3 �stuck 99:1 71:1 S 97:4 1082 74:8,13,23 88:13
189:18,24 192:1 143:19 147_ 17 stuff 1532 229:1 suggestions 43:8,13 88. ib,17, l9 89:6
202: i 7 204:9,11 209:10,23 224:12 subject 10:24 43:12 154:1 89:7 159:14
205:8 10 2
17.22 stats 1 iS.7 46.7 48_18 49:1 Suite 2:10 suspected i20:4
218:6 222:10 status 50:16 72:2 21 i:9 summarizes 128:7 suspects 74:1,2
226:15,24 statute 21:19 95:2 sabmission 33:1, l� summarizing 109:6 120:5
staff's 159:10 staying 72:14 35:20 362,21 128:15 suspend $:18 9:11
stage 2 i 8:23 stem 106:14 47:11 228:12 summary 118:20 suspension 7:1 8:15
stand 11:12 40:4 stenotype 234:9 submit 27: i 8 28:18 128:24 134:19 31:9,12 32:4
52:1 i 187_9 step 43:4 205:4 30:11,21 31:9 146:1 147:9 224:4 225:2,19,21
standard 232:12 stepped 218:18 32:8 33:20 34:2 summer 25:10 226:5,8
stands 40:19 steps 31:6 128:6 41:23 52:4 72: i 59: i4 68:3 122:11 suspicion 45:14
start 7:24 10:14 210:13 i65:19,21 193:8 129:21,22 sustained 26:9
19:18 40:1,9 72:9 stereo 148:15,16 224:19 226:24,25 super�cially 233:2 Sween 38:11
81:9 158:i6 219:4 stern 153:18 154:21 227:24 229:b,7 sapervised 164:10 swore 83:24
started 68:20 73:6 stick 107:2i submittals 229:10 supplement 130:6 sworn 10:16 43:21
85:19 104:i9 sticking 100:22 submitted 1923 supplied 36:2 44:2 53:5,6 84:10
16b:8,9,15 174:8 still 25:7 60:17 21:22 30:22 35:2 suppliers 216:19 84:23 111:13,15
195:11,12,18 96:25 108: i i 120:21 166:6 sapply 123:17 163:2,4 194:2
stariing 226:23 122:13 i57:10,13 226:19 231:11 supplying 1 i9:7 215:8
state 2:3 12:13 i3:1 157:21 158:24 subpoena i56:10 support 2b:4 6523 system 54;9,11
13:5,8 i6:15,20 171:13 173:18 subsequent46:7 65:23 128:10 i42:7,9,25
20:8 22:6 28:18 178:4 185:6 201:2 57:14 201:5 155:25 203:i7 Sytsma 128:21,22
40:3 47:7,16 212:15 227:22 subsequently 3b:8 223:2 129:13, i 5,16
56:15 94:10,16 stipulation 168:14 49:12 supported 97:6
:4 ll l: i 9 stomach 49:23 substance 150:14 supporting 22:3 T____
163:13 167:23 stood 39:20 substances 125:8 39:13 201:10 tab 20:15,22,25
168:15, i 7,18 stop 87:23 89:24 substantial i 64:13 2 i 2:21 21:13,17 22: i,21
159:4,6,$ 1832 90:2,6,8, i 2, i 8,19 substantially sapportive 223:9 23: i 6 24:2,20
184:17 193:21 91:9,14 99:24 i 81:25 supposed 3023 25:12,19,22 34:19
199:3 20123 100.9 101:9,1 i substantive 38:6 79:2 88:1 i92:10 34:21,22 38:22
208:13,17 211: i 8 108:18 i 16:9 successes 197:8 214:14 39:8,8,25 40:25
234:b 139:12 successful 64:10 suppasedly 51:13 41:3,7,12,16
stated 15:2 17:22 stopped 24:2 i 121:23 i 95:6 sure 13:3 18:6 27:8 52:16, i 7,20 55:24
34: i4 5622 stopping 221:6 196:25 199:5 27:12 37:18 41:8 Sb:4,8,9 58:17,23
172:25 173:23 store 87:10,12 successfully 72:12 41:16 b 1:10,12 59:5 6423 65:18
224:4 stove 145:4 134:7 196:2 i 70:20 82:10 88:2 b9:8,2 i 70:1,5,11
sta
tement 1422 strategy 61:17 sudden 109:2
94:5 99:20 1 i3:22 71:23 79:19
19:7 26:19,24 straying 48:8 suffer 179:2 208:2fl 12620 141:17
113:15,16,20
34:15 stream 31:1b suffered 213:9 144:10 160:5 114:3 118:17
STATEMENTS 3:2 street 2:16 62:21 suffers 179:9 184:2Q24 188:9 119:3 124:15,22
stating 14:17 226:6, 63:11,16 C�4.8 sufficient 16:14 193:14 i9$:23 126:10,18,21,22
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
b 12-339-0545
Public Hearing 10IU2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 30
127: i3 152:8,12 4b:5,9 49:24 50:3 157:2 158:5,5 131:5 137:2 bb21 67:6 71: i 1
153:6 157:3 154:3 S 1:18,21 52:2,4 174:9 19620 151:21 1522,5,15 71:15 85:5 85:13
167:6 168:6,10 tapes 20:15,17 209:16 211:b 158:11 173:3,24 92:12 96:17 97:8
169:14 173:5 44:15 45:23 225:6 218:20 220:12 180:19 191:24 99:6 i01:11
174:25 176_24 tape-recording 11:7 tend 161:17 228:7 193:19 205:15 102:13,15 104:1
187:7,12,25 188:4 tape-recordings tenets 8:20 223:16 232:20,21 105:6 106:4
188:12,13 208:4 232:15 ten-second 64_S their i i:12 20:13 118:21 125:16
table 41:25 task 84:18 92:22 term 34:7 57:19 21:15,25 23:24 126:4 13$:13
tackled 73:25 216:21 160:5 194:19 25:3,14 36:i9 i41:13,14 148:24
tag 221 _22 tasked 59: i 5 96:9 terminabte 207:2 39:4 7:9,17 i 49:13 152:9,17
tainted 27:19 tax 5:16 25:16 terminate 50:8 64: i 8 66:3,15 I 53:15 158:24
take 12:14 15:5,7 107:8 169_ 1,3,5,7 termination 20620 73:9 84:19 87:1,6 15920 160:13,22
29:1� 3b:15 372 taxes 24:23 25:16 terminology i06:10 91:13 98:16 160:24 161:9
43:11 46:5 48:9 25:17 35:9 terms 10:1 20:4 103:11 110:7,9 162: i 3 169:8
52:11 54:17 Sb: l Tay(or 218:10 35:16 48:13,24 114:15 120:13,19 185:b 203:13,19
75:5,1i,12,i4 team215:19 115:8117:8 121:1,7127:5 208:19,21209:1
86:19 91:10 technicai 225:9 12724 154:6,11 129:5 130:5,21,22 209: iS,19,21
ll 0:19 121:16 techniyues 61:22 155_7 172:2� 218:6 133:1 i,15� 143:9 210:8,9,9 211:17
128:5 150: i 0 124:4 221:17 226:17,17 143:11 154:5,14 212:8 213:11
151:3 158:17,23 telephone 156:13 Terry 3:10 22:2 154:16 160:6 226: i5 228:2,7
159:14 1612� te1123:b 39:16 83:2 111:12,14 220:21 162:23 169:9 231:5 232:5
162:10 166:1,3 9121 114:7 testified 44:2 55: i3 172:6,7,8 179:10 thinking i 10:2
202:18,25 212:19 121:17 137:17 91:19 101:1 199:22 201:8 153:5
21822 222:3 13820 140:23 111:15 150:12 204:22 206:8 thinks 26:17 30:25
223:11 227:16 148:7,24 179:22 163:4 194:2 215:8 210:10 2 i 3:11 159:2
231:5 181:4 186:10,23 testify 10:9 21:7 219:24 220:6 third 74:7 89:4
taken 1: i 8 31 _7 187:4,4 19�:8 23:8 24:3 40:24 224:14 229:10 96:19 i 65:22
44: l b 48:22 49:24 198:23 200: i 7 45:8 46:7 92:12 themselves 11:14 174:25
75:16 122:10 208:14 21 i:12 105:1 168:24 82:17 210:11 though 12:25 50:13
12b:14 158:18 2 i 6:10 217:22 testifying 97:19 Theo 218:8 110:1 116:5
198:4 209:5 226:5 219:20 222:5 testimony 10:16 Theresa 218:3 125:17 164:13
234:9 telling41:4 61:3 15:19 19:8 22:2,8 221:16 thought 75:8 96:19
takes 8:20 84:21 9325 25:10 26:3,22 thing 10:24 14:23 103:13 105:23,24
taking 8:21 i5:19 i86:14 36:8,22 49:11 29:17 31:12 93_7 123:23 183:9
49:22 109:17 tells 68:24 102:8 50:11 55:14 58:6 152.7 156:6 202:11
i���25 7120 81:14 883 192:i4 202:12 thousands 53:22
talk 31:7 S l: i 2,13 temporarily 108:6 101:15 104:21,23 225:1 226:25 118:24,24
51: l6 6 i:15 79:25 temporary 215:14 118:21 155:4,25 things 7: i 8 13:14 threaten 153:12
84.9 85:17 132:20 ten 176:6,9 156:21 160:14 1624 28:6 40:11 threatened 74:9
150:11 152:7 tenant 21:10 45:25 161:7 174:2 44:10 70`.9 95:7 126:13
179:21 47:9 86:6 88:16 183:13 20224 98:12 i 17:22 three i9:2 44:15
ta(ked 39:20 86:1 88:i7 89:12 119:7 212:13,i4,14 132:12 138:25 58:14 74:19 7$:3
97:2 I I 55:5, t 3 119:18,24 120:8 text 3723 139:18 i 42:23 78:4,13 92:13
187:12 120: i9 122:14 thank 8:10 12:19 154:16 155:4,13 96:12,18 148:25
talking 37: i 6 4�:21 150:11 154:13 14.2 17:15 26:25 15523 158:20 194:20 196:22
48: i 4 90:19 97:20 tenants 20:10,10,20 32:10 37:17 43:16 i 7 i:4 i 79:5 180:2 201:2 229_ i 0
i94:11 224:25 47:8 58:3 61:16 43:17 49:9 51:2 i 99:12 209:2 threshold 224:24
talks 40:19 6123 71:12 73:14 5122 52:9,22 2 i 3:11 219:6,10 through 7:15 23:15
tally 231:6 81:7,11,13,18,23 57:4,20 58:20 222:20 225:7 24:1 25:6 28:5
tamper 142:8 86:24 873,5 88:2 59:7,10 66:25 226:3 29:14 30:7,19
2 l 7:20 88:9,10 93:2 69:22 74:25 75:23 think 17: i$ 19:21 372 42:3 54: i 1
tampered 211:6 98;1 i,14 109:8,19 76.4 91:16 104:3 33:9,13,19 34:18 59:14 61:9 b7:3
Tampering i42:6 119:13,15 129:6 104:14,24,25 35:24 36:11 42:19 59:1,17 73:25
tape 44:6,2�,22,23 129:20 130:22 111:8,11 112:2 42:23 43:13 49:2 81:4 102:1 106: i 7
45:3,5,8,9,1 l,lb 154:16 155:14 12525 126:9 51:24 53:3 66:18 1 i4:10 i 16:16,19
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-3 3 9-0545
Public Hearing 10/i/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 31
1 i7:23 1252 220:9 221:4,6,6 i27:19 i34:24 147:19 152:25 U
132:8 134:8 141:2 223:20 224:1,23 135:19 196:1 162:5 1b8:13
141:16 143:17 227:24,25 229:11 total 23:22 74:22 i 75:15 212: i 7 U 1412
145:19 146:7 229:16 2302 113:7 114:17 225.� ultimate 22b:4
147:14,24 148:18 timed b9:16 115:9 116:19,22 trust 83 20 179:12 °Itimately 202:16
i60.3,13 16i:8,13 times 33:20 52:12 I 17:8 i35:4,i0,ll 179:24 �m-hum 182_19
i62.8 183:9 5322 72:21 88_5 135:13 139:4 trusYee 25:13 1772 uncorrected 21:3
187:18195:i6 108:251i8:13 146:20147:4 try30:1742:7,17 ��-1,6,�825:2i
198:19 199:17 145:17 184:6 148:1 149:1,6 52:14 602 63:1 25:24 173:18
212:1 219:9 187:15 234:11 totalin 157:5 70:10 10 under 6:24 7:3 8:16
g 3.3
10:9 i5:5
226: l8 231:7 toda 28:23 37- ,13,15
.5 19 t
Y otals 13
6 15 i08:1b 27:24,25 3i:13
throughout 44:10 37:25 38:3 40:4 touring 124:14 trying 61:7 161:18 39:25 40.3,23,25
73:4 80:6 81:5 76:20 86:12 towards 183 141:3 Tuesday 230:3,8
89:1 93:12 163:18 156:25 166:25 219:5 tunne(s 102:1,2,10 41:3,7,12,1642:1
193:4 20122 167:1 181:11 TOWER i:24 102:14 4 �=18 46:5 4823
217_ 13 220:3 182:3 185:18 track 87:21 136:20 turn 6:2 12_21 �2:3 56:9 64: i 8
thrust 196:1 189:25 i91:24 138.3 38:20 39:8,19 g3:20 90:15,18
T hurs day 160:15 199:20 200:5 tracked 1 t2:24 144:20 18$:17 9 4: 7 9 7: 1 8 1 0 5: 1 3
tied 54:4 71:22 222:23 228:2i i35_2 138:9 i89:4 196:18,18 117:16 119:9
ties 109:13 231:12 tracking 5:4 i 14:16 turned 65:9 138:4 139:20
time 9:22 11:13 Todd 3:19 i50:3,6,7 138:25 turns 30:8 i40:23 141:1
14:8 15:7 16:10 ISO:iS 151:1 i,i3 traded 20i:7 Twin 23:17,i8 i68:9 170:9
16:10,12 18:12 151:17,19 152:1,3 trades 216:19,23 101:7 10825 �g 5 187:25
19.7 22:12 25:1 185:24 204:14, i4 traditional 19:5 1 i 7:4,5 118:1,3 i 88:4,12,13
26:1�,20,24 27:19 204:17 215:6,7,11 59:12 112:14 two 5025 51:8 �90:20 202:13
203:21 208:14
28:2 30:17 18
216.7 220:19 Traditionally 54.23 62:3,23,25 �i2:25 222:16
31 16 33:6 35:15 together 28:8 54:4 232:11 63: i4 64:21,22,25 224:4,13,20 225:9
39:6 42:2 44:11 65:12 69:7 71:16 traffic 93:10 65:2, i 7 7 i:10 underground 23:4
49:6 51:18 59:8 158:10 160:14 transactions iO3:5 72:8 73:2,15,17
62:15 64:4 68:25 216:16 22321 109:16,21 78:1 82:18 90:20 54:5,9
74: i 9 75:8,19 227:2 228:21 transcribe 232:5,6 92:13 96:10,17,21 underlying 25:14
76: i7,24 77:3,6 told 30:4,6 40:6 transcribed 234:8 101:12 104:22 118: i9
81:4,17 88:24,24 51:12,13 74:11 transcript 2:20 5:24 108:22 i09:24 understand 34:15
96:8 99:13 100:15 80:i3 $3:16 84:6 11:15 227:4,16 112:4 135:11 37:4 75:18 85:16
141:22 10324 85:12 95:23 97:12 229:4 231:20 151:17 159:4 97:15 i 13:22
104:5 i05:8 97:20 98:7,8,10 232:12,18 i61:16 165:1 120:15 133:15
106:18 lq7:13 121:10 129:2 transfer 163:20 170:23 179:19 134:1 14b:25
108:14 1 ll:9 138:11,18 147:1 S transient 100:4 203:7 2 150:9 156:13,15
13:20 167:21 171:21
121:12 l 23:6 15 l: l 155:21 108:17 216:3 218:9,10
125:11 127:21 182:23 Transit 63: i 0 89:25 228:14 229:5 understanding
128:20 132:6 tomorrow 230:4 110:13,15 230:3 131:22 132: I
137:25 138:11,15 tonight 8:7 9:15,21 transmission two-page 35:3 169:3 205:25
138:19 151:3 9:21 2b:13 30:21 121:23 171:1 173:9 214:i3
i 58:22 159:2,23 35:20 38:17 46:6 trave163:16 two-sided 19:17 understood 101:15
161:18 i 62: i 2, i 7 50:5 51:9 138:11 traverse 54: i 4 two-thirds 11621 130: i 156:22
165:10 169:24 147:18,22 158:14 trends 134:6 two-year 57:17,18 i 83:13
170:7 172:4 i 75:1 17722 178:12 trespassing 100:18 type 8:22 29:2 undertake 2b: i
175:1 S 181:6,19 180:2,25 192:13 tribunal 9:3 61:19 107: i 7 �ndertook 55:2
i 84:24 189:19 194:11 203:9 tried 30:16 92:18 189:21 196:13 unfairness 36:5
190:1 191:13 209:13 210:22,23 trip 67:19 types 107:19 108:8 unfinished 166:25
198:3 2012,8,9 229:18 23i:11 truck97:17 117:i6 i27:6 unfortunate 137:21
unfortunatel
209:11 21i:21 Y
233:2
true 44:21 69:10 131: i5 1383 151:20 218:5
213: i3,15,22 tonight's 3$: i 80:15 83:19,22 140:24
214:2 i 21721 tool 134:6 84:4 87:22,23 typewritten 234.7 unfounded 116:3
2i8:23 219:17 top 90:3 1 i4:16 95:11,23 133:3 typical 227:20 uniform 50:21
unit 47:18 73:13
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-3 3 9-0545
Public Hearing 10/ 1 /2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 32
i12:5,9 115:3 utter 19:25 vioiate94:10,12 133:2 i45:13 Weiss 195:13,13
135:12 149:10 utterty 192:17 violated 226:13 152:7 16121 welcome 76:3 93:13
200:11 violates 127:24 179:15 187:7 i52:3 i86:19
units 24:8,9, i l 47:7 157:9 207:9 20823 we119:24 11: l 17:9
48:1 93:1 113:1,4 vacant 73:13 violating 51:19 209:1 215:4 18:$ 24:20 30:6
113:6,7,7 114:9 200:11 violation 10.3 51:14 218:18 224:1 4022 45:24 48:10
114:15,22,25 vatidate 148:18 58:9 59:18 139:20 227:22 5321 62:23 b7:6
i 15_4 117:9,13 Valley 13:4 141:12,12 142:17 wanted 14:14,15 70:22 74:22 76:7
130:2 133:17 valuable 31.3 145:18 171:2 55:14 69_ 16 77:6 79:5 81:9
135:11,17 i40:13 value 177_5 214:4 224:21 150:15 220:i,1 i 85:6 86:i2 90:11
197: i 1 203:14,14 vandalism l07_ 17 225:13 wants 30:20 39:3 91:3 92:18 93:7
2�3:17 209:16,24 211:10 214:11 vio(ations 20:6,21 126:16 179:20,22 98:21 102:5
210:5 various 35:23 21:3,20 22:1,6,18 223:11 108:10 110:14
unit-by-unit 55:2 114:12 115:22 22:22 25:24 26:10 warnings 154:13 133:23 137:19
lb4:b 167:15 120:23 122:7 35:24 49:4 57:15 warrant 45:14 48:2 i38:13,17 143:2
unlawCu(142:7,10 125:4127:i2 57.2458:2,961_4 102_18,19103:i6 143:12153:17,20
��g:4 134:24 179:5 62:1 77_ 10,13,14 wasn't 30: �4 36:9 154:18 159:2
uniess i 5:6,15 187:15 220:15 77: i 5, I 6 78:9,21 58:6 68:22 79:13 160: i i 62:3,16
26:i9 47:18 144:6 vary 7:19 79:7 127:'7 i32:i3 88:2 89:22 97:5 169:1fl 18i:14
i58:23 VCR44:6 167:23 Ib9:20 134.2,3 i38:9 183:25 185:2
unmistakable 2fl:21 vehide i 16:9 170:6 171:15,19 145:8 155:12 189:7 190:1
unmistakabty22:1S vendors216:i9 171:24172:18 15b:10171:8 195:11,24196:11
unoffered 17222 veracity 179:12 183_ 16,18 208:8 183:5 186:12 199:4 20724
unpaid 25:7 174:22 verbatim 234:8 213:10 226:1 222:16 210:2,13 214_12
i 76: i 4 242:25 verdicY 66:16 violent 51:1 62:21 watch 208:14 2 i 8:13 223:24
203:3 verify 120:5 201:4 84:18 watches 98:22 227:10 23fl:13
unrestrained 21:5 very 20:4 21:2,8 virtually 23:12 water 242 i 174:22 Weiis 2: i 6
unsecured 89:1b 27:23 43:17 53:19 visited 77:9 way 13:22 14:5 went 27:15 30:13
211:15,20 5424 63:15 64:12 vis-a-vis 23:23 16:21,25 96:6 38:3,3 42:10
untii 1�:22,25 18:11 70:1� 71:23 72:14 voice 186:4 101:7 114:23 68:15,19 72:17
27:17 42:13 59:16 105:17,18,19,25 votumes 53:20 142:8 148:14 73:7 79:18 86:2
b524 8�:21 106:19,25 108:4 vote 43:9,10 154:3,8 192:22 87:$ 97:21 100:18
132:18 138:5 108:22 119:11 vouchers 190:12,15 207:11 214:14 10i:2,10 i02:17
161:11 181:10 12fl:11 142:21 2 t 8:1 219:5 231:4 124_ 17 132:8
185:18 21022 146:12,16,18 ways 123:22 141:16 147:14,23
215:14 224.15 171:4 18i:25 wad 23:1 107:1� website 6]:20 183:14,15 187:1b
update 121:1 i 183:22,24 i96:25 waiting 12:8 161:16 Wednesday i60:15 187:18 199:16
use 34.6 38:17 66:7 198:2,3 199:1 161:18 week 38:22 63: i 221:16 23 i:12,23
102:24 103:2,10 2 i 2:9 214:8,21 walk 86:17,18 81:5 150:1,2,3,4 were 10:19 16:8
103:12,14 104:2 223:20 233:2 i 10:7,8 212:1 160:18,20,22 22:4,12 23:10,11
126:13 138:3 vested 106:12 218:14 151:3,4,5 175:6 23:20 25:9 2Z6
i67: i7 178:11 VHS 44:23 walked 68:21 182:4 190:2,22 28:23 40:20,21
used 106:10 108:4 victim 73:24 74:9 172:10 191:6 197:1 4i:19 51:8 55:1
160:5 172:13 video 44: i3 49:18 waiki�ig 21$:19 215:23 228:20 55:18 56:19 57:2
179:21 182:8 50:1,6 219:9 229:12 230:20 58:7 60:16,16,17
using 33:19 66:17 videos 50:10 214:16 walk-through 170:1 weekend 37:11 61:6 64:10,17
112:13 videotape 26:21 wallet 74:10,23 weeks 17:8 161:16 65:7,8,13 66:5
USPS 122:1 77:22,24 79:8,13 wanders 93:11 1 b2:10 203:7 b7:21 68:9, i 8
utilities 24:22,23 81 _3 98:21 102:18 want 11:8 19:9,18 223:22 228:14 72:8 73:12,14,25
25:1,3 174:i2,23 videotapes 20:12 27:3,5 31:19,2fl 229:5,10,13 230:3 74:2,3 78:1,i0
175:3,6,17 180:22 99:1 i 32:4,1 33:7 36:6 weigh 192:2 i 193:6 79:15 80:25 812
181:4 videotaping 44:9 36:9 37:15,17 weighed 226:3 81:4,13,18,23,23
utitity 4:18 35:8 view 47:12 48:19 40:23 42:6 51:5 weight 58:15 66:12 81:25 82:1,3,4, i i
176:1 181:23 5324 88_7 159:5 56:24 75:5,11 6b:18 88:5 179:14 84:6,15 $5:22
202:25 Viliage196:12 82:992:17116:17 179:15,i6 88:189:1492:13
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/1/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 33
93:9,18,21 9521 66:24 75:14 94:4 57:4,7 59:7 66:20 10:24 53:5 73:18 wrorig 42:10 85:2,3
96:17 97:14 98: i 13220 135:15 6b:23 67:5 69:22 156:10 159:1,19 88:25
98:23 99:6,9,11 143:19 i 60:19 70:1,6, i 0,24 72:3 161 _7 i 93:13,16 wrote 37:19 39:9,15
99:24 10(�:2,5,9 180:13 201: i4 752,6,10,14,17 193:18 215_3 3920 79:19,23
IOO:i5,16,17,19 203:19 223:21 75:21 9023 91:1 223:I8 gp:9
100:20 101:16,17 229:2,25 231:22 91:7,16 103:21 wonder 7:23
10122 102:2,1 I 232: i 5 104:1,14,18,24 wonderfu120125 _X
103:4 105:15,19 we're 14_ i 3 23:15 1 I 1:3,7 113: i 5 word 11:11 53:4 X 132:24
105_ 19,23,24,25 26:12 31:6,7,8 119:2 125:23 174:12 186:18,19 Xerxes 90:7
106:1 i,15,18,22 37:16,18 40:7,11 126:2,6,24 1272 212:19
107:4,18,20 i(38_2 48:8 53:5 5$:3,8 130:18 131:5 words 33:19 114:19 1'______._
108:8,10,12 109:5 71:19 88:10 9325 136:24 140_7 117:9,2 i i 30:4 Yeah 51:24 87:23
109:7,81i5:9,25 1i4:2120:i5 143:25144:3,1fl i33:7135:1 153:4176=b232:8
1�16:i,3 �20:23 138:25 151:7 149:18 151:9,11 152:16207:13 year2320,2535:10
123:3 126:11,17 158:19 160:13 15 L 15,18,2 �,23 208:24 212:18 77:4 80:6 84:23
126:23 12`7:14 162:19 175:24 158:16,i9 159:15 work i 12:21 114:10 101:10 ll3:12
129:10133:14 178:18188:9 160:1,1i,19,23 i33:1415522 li4:i7115:i2
138:21 i39:i1 212:15214:21 161:2,8,171b2:16 166:1,6,9,14,22 ii6:11,21 117:12
142:17 i 53:11 216: i 8 223:21 162:19,25 168.3 1b6:24 167:1 i 18:14 124:25
157:19 158:1,2 224:24,25227:14 168:18,21 173:3 170:20 i85:20 13120 135:3
i 62:7,11 163:17 229:10 173:24 176:2,5,22 191:21 199: i 148:1 194:20
164:6,8,17,18,19 we've 8:7 14:4 177:25 178:2 201:20 21 b:14 i 99:11 209: t 7
164:22 165:13, i 4 20:14 27:11 30:1 180:13,17 192:4 217:19,2 i 219:5 210.7
166:21 16920,21 30:2,4,6 35:22 193_ 10,14, i 7,21 226: i 3 228:17 years 24_ 13 53:13
169:22 170:21 48:10 84:16 120:5 197:13,17 198:9 232:19 53:16,20 54:19,23
i 71:4,5 172:1 138:b 168:5 i 80:2 201:16 215:2,5 worked ll 0:13 72:8 76:10,18, i 8
173:13, I 3,17,19 194:10,12 195:23 223:16,20 224:6,9 112:4 i 89: i 1 90:20,21 101:4,12
174:4,4,1 i,i3 199:18 202:24 228:19,24 231:6,9 241:23 204:20 105:21 11124
176:1 177:23,25 210:8 212:15 231:16,25 232:3 217:2 112:1 130:7 1382
178:6 179:25 231:4 233:15,18,20 working 8:8 12:2 16325 182:24
181:7,25 i82:2,4 whatsoever 86:19 window 2132,3 29:23 107:25 19i:19 196:22
183:4,9,18 185:7 i 312 Winfield 72_ 11,20 133:6 137:12 197:7 2� 1.24
185:10 186:10,14 whichever 104:10 wish 9:22 15:7 18:3 170.9 214:22 204:19 214:2
186:21 187:5,18 while 40:21 44:8 18:10 4224 43:13 216:7,14,23 216:8 217:2
188:b 191:3,8,8 95:6 121:11 199:7 58: t 6,19 207:7 221:12 Yelich 6:12,13
192:9,10,12,22 whip 222:7 226:21,24 Worley 6:6,7,8,10 18:15, l b,17 42:25
193:i,1 196:14,17 whole 10:8 140:5 wishes 9:14 2b:19 6:12,14,i6 37:i2 43.1,15 161:6,i4
196:23,24,25 142:18 49:5,12 worse 31: i 1 32:6 yield 112:15
197:23 19�:13,16 wholly 66:2 withdraw 45:21 210:1
:10 204:24 wide-open 28:16 47:5 worth 158:21
06:4 209:12 William 2:9 8:1 withdrawal 182:24 wouldn't 42:17 $10,000 204: I
210:1,1 214: i,l willing 227:6 withstand 2 i4:ll 95:25 161:15 $131,000 25:14
217:2 218:19 Witlson 6:1,14,15 witness 10:15,15, i 7 180: I 183:1 184:4 $i8,000 25:4
219:24,24 220:7 6:18 i i:19 12:20 10.18,21 43:19 203:4 207:23 �50,000 106:5 107:9
221:17 222:11,11 12:25 i 3:5,8,19 49:16 50:17,22 wrinkle 160:11 198: i 8 20322
22220 15:9 17:5,13,21 53:25 67:4 105: i write 78:$, U 79:22 $69,197.50 174:17
weren't 41:18,20 i 8:1,16,20,22,25 111:�,10 140:3,9 writing 18:10 19:24 $76,000 25:2 175:17
79:14138:5 19:2,11,15,18 150:1158:12,14 80:13137:13 �8,181.2525:5
157:15 172:14 2b:23 32:11,24 158:15 159:22 201:2 22b:21
178:9 i81:4 33:11,13,17 36:24 160:3 161:9,11,i3 written 8:18 9:12 fl
i83:22 210:12 37:1,8,15 42:25 161:25 162:1 i 11:8,10 23:9 34:9 a.71 136:10
west 54:8 b3:14 43:16 4b:1 I 48:5 168:24 192:3 35:19 36:12 56:23 04 72:10
we'll 7:10 12:21 49:8,14 50:12,15 193:23 214:25 77:10 i43:20 06 166:12,13
17:23 39:17 43:18 50:20 51:2,22 215:1 223:17 199:11 200:25 07 44:7 91:19
49:21 50:3,8 52:6 53:8 56:b,11 witnesses 3:6 i0:9 225:19 232:11 130:25 144:15
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/iI2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETiNG
Page 34
166:14 38.8 224:5 i724:8,10 38:7,9,i4 39:14 29 137:5
12-913 5:4,8, i 0 173 4:8,10 44_ 16,21 57:9 2900 73:24
1 131:12,14,24 175 4:12 59:14,17,22 60:21 2900-2940 1:10
13:74_35:317:24 132:4,8,13,17 1764:12,18,18 62:10,1i,1464:14 621
17:2520_1538:21 13320,23134:10 1774:i9,19,21,23 b7:i1,1373:21,22 291873_i2
39:9 50:9 52:16 134:19,20 135:5 18 53:16,19 76:10 74:5,6 76:23 77:6 2932 74:1,7
52:17,19,20 135:10,20 136:2,7 79:25 90:21 77:18 78:2� 80_6 2940 74:19
176:19 240:5 136:10,20 137:5 144:25 82:7 89.3 106:7
231:6,10,12,13 137:10 138:4 18th 41:8 110_22,25 112:17 3_
lst 1:1�8 2:1 16:9 139:20 140:12 180 3:15 4:21,23 1 i2:20 116:15,19 3 3:13 4:7 5:6 6:19
74: t 7 121:21 141: i,3,12,17,19 135:10 149:b 118:7,12 121:21 20:25 46:2 67: l,b
163.17185:18 142.15143_1$ 193:35:3,3127:i9 122:5,11 123:1,10 141:25142:1
234:11 144:14 14b:10 194 3:17 12425 i29:22 i49.1� 158:9
i 23:25 i47:10,13,20 197 5:12,12,12,14 146:7 1473 1 �7:1 167:6 168:1,2,10
1,500-plus 72:7 149:10 1971 195:11,12,23 167:3,8 170:3,15 3rd 7322
l.a 140:23 141:1 12:413723 1979102_9 173:8 175:7,16,25 3,20024:9 113:3
1/800/545-9668 122 149:6 198 5:14,14 194: ib 196:23 3-102 4622
1:25 125 4:11,24 1999 195:18 234:11,17 3:10 72:11
1:3073:22 1264.i7 2015:i7,17,18,i8 3:47732
1� 4:18 5:19 24:2,20 127 4:11,17,24 2016 193:23 30 16:11 164: i 8
49:21,24 74_21 134:22 25:22 41:16 2 3:10 4:5 5:4 20:22 202 118:11 1882,15
174:25 175:20 177:17 178:1 35:17 5524 56:4 205 3.18 30th 17i: i7,19
176:2,5, i 3,19,20 180:14 56:7,8,9 58:17,23 21 38:22 173:8
231:22,24 13th 732 59:5 65:9,10 21st 1703 30-day 206:22
10-5 72:10 130 4:13,13 i 36:16,18 149:16 215 32� 305 2:10
10/1/07 5:20 131 3:12 118:5 158:9 164:3 i65:1 22nd 59:22 80:22 30b 215:12
10:30 159= i4,18 136 5:5 ll 8:3 i 68:2,5,6 208:4 110:25 36 197:7
1602 14 4:24 i 24:22 2A 56:4 23 58:1 208.10 3600 2: I 6
1002i4:22 i25:22 126:18,24 2nd 128:1,2 23rd 167:8230:2i 3907215:12
103 3:9 73: i 3 229:21 231:7,8 20 127:22 167:20 230:23,24
114:19 25:12 41:7 1400 1:24 20-year-old 74:6 23- a e 55: i9,23 4
P g
54:7 67:14 72:21 141 5:7 200 5:17,18 56:4 207:20 4 3:16 4:8 5:8 67:2
74:22 128: i4 ld3 S:9 2000 195:19 23.35 135:17 67:6 143:22,25
160:2 ib2:22 145 5:10 2002 30:14 117:23 231 520,20,20 144:2,14 147:15
17624 177:8,10 1465 13:4 2004 24:16 25:24 24 24:12 38:9,14 149:16 158:9
11:00158.22 1495:5,5,7,7,9,9,10 85:20,23113:i2 39:9,23205:8,i0 168:1169:i4
161:20 5. i0 i 15:8 196:17 24th 34:25 39:7,14 17222,24 173:3
11:30 i61:i5 15 i37:14 159:8 200524:16 5424 39:17 129:13 187.7,25 i88:4,12
11_31233:21 1b4:22 93:9,17 101:14 2535_7 188:1,14 188:13 234:17
111 3:1 i i5th 58:5 164:14 105:17 10525 1892 4/12 44:7
118 4:17 165:3 230:5 115:12 25th 171:10 4:30 61:14
119 4:17 15-month 20b:25 2006 5:5 24:17,22 252 24: i0 113:b 412-unit 196:12
124:2025:1941_12 15-pius2i4:2 25:2135:SSS:i9 i35:10209_16 443:8
45:19 122:25 16 128:20 56:5,16,19 58:5 210:5 45 20:14 73:3
148:1,6 175:20 16th 74:6 89:3 73:1,2 74:i6,17 26 129:15 48 149:10
177:12178:1 230:7,8,t0,14,16 80_711b:11 273:4
i80:14 160 6225 117:23 136:19 27th 23:14 b7:11
lZth 123:9 163 3:14 137:5, (0 138:17 79:23 5 3:19 4:9 5:6,10
12-month 138:6 168 4:7,7 146:6 164:4 165:3 28 38:7 39:25 21:13 40:25 56:5
12-100147:20,20 17 5:3 111:24 165:4 175:2,4 144:18 145:1 56:16,i9 64:23
47:21 188:25 208:5 28th 35:2 127:25 65:i8 67:6,7
12-900 28:22,24 17th 78:20 82:7 2007 i:18 2:1 5:9 2800 219:5 i 13:20 i 28:13
29:1 170:22,25 20:18 21:2 22:11 2802 68:20 108:11 14i:21 145:23
12-90647:2,16 17-year-oid87:14 23:2�24:1,i8,2S 2802-28341:1fl 146:1149_16
12-910b:24 8:15 87:17 25:25 35:7,10 6:20 158:8,9 172:i6,23
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545
Public Hearing 10/i/2007
CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Page 35
172:25 173:3 683 24:16 115:17 90-day 20b:24
14921 69 4:15 900 24:17
Sth SS:l8 72:Ifl 698 117:24 95 i96:23
164:3170:15,20
200:4,13 201:12 7
208:5 7 4:13 5:13 22:1
5-112 S:7 141:8,12 127:13 129:16
141:19 142:6,17 130:15 152:8,12
143:3145.18 153:6157:3
147:23 197:18,20 198:7
5-113 141:18 7th 80:21,22 1 i0:21
5/31/2007 176_ 16 17525
50 4:4� 7.7 24_ 10 113:7
50-year-o1d 73:23 135:16
51 148:5 7:47 75:16
52 4:4 144:25 7:Sb 75:16
527 124 70 4:15
53 24:6,7 112:24 7i 135:12 149:10
113:3 135:14 729 177:15
53-complex 115:14 739 24:16 1 i 6:12
53-group 1 i3:11 76 3:9
537 1 i8: I 763-561-280 2:11
54424:ib 115:9,16
545116:i9
SSth 90:7 8 4: i 5 5:16 22:21
55402 2:17 69:8,21 70:1,5
55402-13311:24 79:19164:25
55430-2190 2:11 188:19 189:5,6
55902 193:24 190:6,8,9,17,19
564:5 190:22 191:10
59 4:5,6,6 200:15,17 201:14
221:7 222:6
6__-__- 8th 79:22 165:4
64:11 5:1i 21:17 177:15
71:23124:15 8,181.25176:17
125:22 i 26: i 0,20 S/7/2007 175: i 1
126:24 173:5,2 i 8/8/2007 174:16
173:23,25 174:2 8fl0 i 16:22 118:8
175:19 176:3,7,i0 209:16 210:7
197:2,4,15,16 808 118:14
6,500 197: i i 873 146:21
b/8/0'1 173:11,16,18 874 146:2 i
6:02 i:i92:i
b:15 74:17 -__9
60 80:19,23 99:22 9 4: l7 5:18 23:16
99:24 100:13 41:3 67:13 113:16
612-349-6969 2:17 i 13:20 116:25
6i2/337-5575 1:25 1 i8:17 119:3
b i 2/339-0545 1:25 126:21,22,24
6300 2:10 146:12,13 200:15
6301 2:2 200:23 201:5,14
65 4:9 140:14 9th 79:18,23 108_7
196:17,22 9:44158:18
65th 215:12 9:51 158:18
66 4:9 90 2: ib 206:23
Paradigm Reporting Captioning Inc.
612-339-0545