Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2011 08-22 CCP Regular Session AGENDA CITY COUNCIL STUDY SESSION August 22, 2011 6:00 p.m. City Council Chambers A he pu blic. The packet ring binder is co of the full City Council packet is available to bl p g AY Y p p located at the front of the Council Chambers by the Secretary. 1. City Council Discussion of Agenda Items and Questions 2. Miscellaneous a. Pull Tabs Request — Oak City b. Schedule City Manager's Performance Review 3. Discussion of Work Session Agenda Items as Time Permits 4. Adjourn • • i CITY COUNCIL MEETING City of Brooklyn Center • August 22, 2011 AGENDA 1. Informal Open Forum with City Council — 6:45 p.m. - provides an opportunity for the public to address the Council on items which are not on the agenda. Open Forum will be limited to 15 minutes, it is not televised, and it may not be used to make personal attacks, to air personality grievances, to make political endorsements, or for political campaign purposes. Council Members will not enter into a dialogue with citizens. Questions from the Council will be for clarification only. Open Forum will not be used as a time for problem solving or reacting to the comments made but, rather, for hearing the citizen for informational purposes only. 2. Invocation — 7 p.m. 3. Call to Order Regular Business Meeting -The City Council requests that attendees turn off cell phones and pagers during the meeting. A copy of the full City Council packet is available to the public. The packet ring binder is located at the front of the Council Chambers by the Secretary. 4. Roll Call 5. Pledge of Allegiance • 6. Approval of Agenda and Consent Agenda —The following items are considered to be routine by the City Council and will be enacted by one motion. There will be no separate discussion of these items unless a Councilmember so requests, in which event the item will be removed from the consent agenda and considered at the end of Council Consideration Items. a. Approval of Minutes 1. August 3, 2011 — Joint Work Session with Financial Commission 2. August 8, 2011— Study Session 3. August 8, 2011— Regular Session 4. August 8, 2011 — Work Session b. Licenses C. Resolution Changing Polling Location for Precinct 1 d. Resolution Declaring a Public Nuisance and Ordering the Removal of Diseased Trees e. Resolution Calling for a Public Hearing on Proposed Special Assessments for Delinquent Public Utility Service Accounts • CITY COUNCIL AGENDA -2- August 22, 2011 • f. Resolution Accepting Bid and Awarding a Contract, Improvement Project No. 2011 -10, West Palmer Park Building Replacement g. Resolution Approving Final Plat for BRI MAR SECOND ADDITION 7. Presentations / Proclamations /Recognitions/Donations None. 8. Public Hearings -None. 9. Planning Commission Items —None. 10. Council Consideration Items a. Mayoral Appointment of Member to Serve on Housing Commission Requested Council Action: — Motion to ratify Mayoral appointment. b. Resolution Approving a Type III Rental License for 7018 Brooklyn Boulevard • Requested Council Action: — Motion to adopt resolution. C Consideration of Type IV 6- Month Provisional Rental License for 6765 Humboldt b t Ave N Requested Council Action: — Receive staff report. — Motion . too en hearing. g — Receive testimony from applicant. — Motion to close hearing. —Take action on rental license application and mitigation plan. d. Consideration of Type IV 6 -Month Provisional Rental Licenselor 3513 47 Ave N Requested Council Action: - Receive staff report. - - Motion to open hearing. Receive testimony from applicant. — Motion to close hearing. —Take action on rental license application and mitigation plan. • CITY COUNCIL AGENDA -3- August 22, 2011 • 11. Council Report 12. Adjournment Agenda Items Tabled or Continued An Ordinance Amending Chapter 4 of the Brooklyn Center City Charter, Sections 4.01 and 4.02 —This item was first read on April 12, 2010; was published in the official newspaper on April 22, 2010; and the Public Hearing was continued at the May 10, 2010, meeting until such time as the Charter Commission makes its recommendation to the City Council. • • AGENDA CITY COUNCIL /ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY WORK SESSION August 22, 2011 S Immediately Following Regular City Council and EDA Meetings Which Start at 7:00 P.M: Council Chambers City Hall A copy of the full City Council packet is available to the public. The packet ring binder is located at the front of the Council Chambers by the Secretary. ACTIVE DISCUSSION ITEMS 1. Public Art Proposal 2. Presidential Invite 3. Graduated Sanitary Utility Rate Study PENDING LIST FOR FUTURE WORK SESSIONS Later /Ongoing 1. National League of Cities Service Line Program 2. Progress Reports on Achievement of Strategic Goals 3. School District Discussions /BC Strategic Plan Report • 4. Sister City Update 5. Active Living Program 6. Annual Department Year End Reports 7. Garbage Hauler Organized Collection Update — October 8. Youth Participation Request — October 9. Neighborhood Designations — December 10. Highway 252 Update — 2012 • City Council Agenda Item No. 6a I� • MINUTES OF THE PROCEEDINGS OF THE CITY COUNCIL • OF THE CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER IN THE COUNTY OF HENNEPIN AND THE STATE OF MINNESOTA JOINT WORK SESSION WITH FINANCIAL COMMISSION AUGUST 3, 2011 CITY HALL - COUNCIL CHAMBERS CALL TO ORDER The Brooklyn Center City Council met in Joint Work Session with the Financial Commission and the session was called to order by Mayor Tim Willson at 6:30 p.m. ROLL CALL Mayor Tim Willson and Councilmembers Carol Kleven and Kay Lasman. Councilmember Dan Ryan arrived at 6:35 p.m. Councilmember Tim Roche was absent and excused. Also present: City Manager Curt Boganey, Fiscal and Support Services Director Dan Jordet, BCS Director /Assistant City Manager Vickie Schleuning, and Deputy City Clerk Maria Rosenbaum. Others present were Financial Commissioners Steve Landis, Rex Newman, and Dean Van Der Werf. • PROCESS POLICIES LEGISLATION AND ASSUMPTIONS City Manager Curt Boganey informed that this evening's meeting was to consider what direction staff should proceed with in developing the 2012 property tax levy proposal and operating budgets for the funds receiving those property taxes. He informed that the additional handout provided this p evening was an updated copy of the Strategic and Ongoing Goals identifying updated time periods and that nothing else had changed. The Council and Financial Commission members present discussed the materials provided with the agenda which included an outline for understanding the budget process for 2012, policies that govern the budget development, the impact of State Legislation, and assumptions that effect initial budget development. As part of this discussion it was asked whether or not the budget preparation should include an increase levy by rate of inflation 2011 -2012 of $302,614, an increase levy by additional tax capacity (then rate of inflation) of $521,376, or a combined General and Police/Fire (then rate of inflation) of $354,181. It was the consensus to develop a budget proposal with a levy that should not increase $521,376. Also, it was noted that options for the use of Local Government Aid (LGA) be provided for further discussion. ADJOURNMENT Councilmember Lasman moved and Councilmember Kleven seconded to adjourn the Work Session • at 8:00 p.m. Motion passed unanimously. 08/03/11 -1- DRAFT MINUTES OF THE PROCEEDINGS OF THE CITY COUNCIL • OF THE CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER IN THE COUNTY OF HENNEPIN AND THE STATE OF MINNESOTA STUDY SESSION AUGUST 8, 2011 CITY HALL — COUNCIL CHAMBERS CALL TO ORDER The Brooklyn Center City Council met in Study Session called to order by Mayor Tim Willson at 6 :00 p.m. ROLL CALL Mayor Tim Willson and Councilmembers Carol Kleven, Kay Lasman, Tim Roche (arrived at 6:07 p.m.), and Dan Ryan. Also present were City Manager Curt Boganey, Director of Business and Development Gary Eitel, Police Chief Kevin Benner, EDA/HRA Specialist Bublitz, Police Commander Brian Peters, Assistant City Manager/Director of Building and Community Standards Vickie Schleuning, and Carla Wirth, Timesaver Off Site Secretarial, Inc. CITY COUNCIL DISCUSSION OF AGENDA ITEMS AND QUESTIONS Councilmember Ryan requested discussion on Consent Agenda Item 6f, Application and Permit • for Temporary On -Sale Liquor License submitted by City of Lakes Nordic Ski Foundation, for an event to be held at Surly Brewing Company, 4811 Dusharme Drive, on September 10, 2011, specifically relating to an event held earlier that had attracted a large crowd. He asked whether there had been any public safety issues with that event. City Manager Curt Boganey stated he was unsure about the event mentioned but the feedback from the Police Department, historically, has indicated these activities are well controlled. MISCELLANEOUS Councilmember Lasman asked whether the Council had been invited, to attend the Safety Camp graduation. Mr. Boganey stated the Council is always welcome and he will check to determine if an invitation was mailed. Councilmember Roche arrived at 6:07 p.m. Councilmember Ryan reported that he has two surgeries scheduled prior to the end of the year, which will necessitate missing some meetings but he will make every attempt to minimize his absences. Councilmember Roche announced his resignation from the Brooklyn Center City Council to pursue new opportunities. He thanked staff and the citizens for the opportunity to serve this community, which he has found rewarding. Councilmember Roche indicated that he is the last • 08/08/11 -1- DRAFT • Roche to live in Brooklyn Center but has every confidence the City will thrive and remain dynamic. He acknowledged the expertise of staff to further the City's progress and rebirth as evidenced by recent redevelopment projects. Mayor Willson noted Councilmember Roche had this dream for years and wished him well in his new ventures. He encouraged Councilmember Roche to make this announcement during Council Reports. Mr. Boganey indicated that in anticipation of this announcement, the City Clerk prepared a resolution that would declare the vacancy, specify the date of the vacancy, and the date of the special election. If desired, the Council could add this item to tonight's agenda. The Council discussed the process and indicated support to amend tonight's City Council agenda to consider that action since Councilmember Roche has made his decision and announcement. In addition, it would allow the Council to move forward to fill the vacancy. DISCUSSION OF WORK SESSION AGENDA ITEMS AS TIME PERMITS PUBLIC ART DISCUSSION Director of Business and Development Gary Eitel explained the Brooklyn Center School District, in conjunction with Mentoring Peace Through Art, has requested to paint an artistic mural along the sound wall between Highway 100 and Earle Brown Elementary School that has been subject to repeat graffiti and vandalism. To consider such an action, Mn/DOT requires a resolution from the City to allow painting the mural and a permit to work within the right -of- way. This permit would be submitted by the Brooklyn Center School District. He displayed slides depicting the location and alignment of the Highway 100 sound wall and location along the trail where the mural would be painted. Mr. Eitel advised that all associated costs including maintenance would be borne by the School District or others, not the City. He noted the City's Sign Ordinance does not address the painting of such a mural and reviewed policy issues related to public art for consideration by the City Council. Councilmember Kleven asked if the quilt mural design has been selected and if there was a safety issue such as distracted drivers. Mr. Eitel stated he is unsure if the pattern has been selected and clarified that the mural, if approved, cannot be viewed from Highway 100. Mr. Boganey stated the final design is an issue the Council can determine as part of its approval process. Councilmember Roche stated he would not consider the mural to be a sign but, rather, public art. He stated the City supports a corporate atmosphere on the freeway side of the sound wall, as exists, but on the other side is .an elementary school with a diverse population and more aligned with this type of public art. He advocated for each request to be considered on its individual merits and indicated he would support this request because the location is appropriate and may stimulate creativity, especially during winter weather conditions. • 08/08/11 -2- DRAFT Councilmember Kleven supported a contest format to select the mural pattern and asked if each • grade could be allowed to paint a portion of the wall so all participate. Mayor Willson suggested that decision be left up to the School District. Mayor Willson stated concern with the next mural request and stated support for the current restrictions against branding and trade names, or commercial promotion. He indicated he would not want the Council to act as the art critic. Councilmember Lasman indicated she would want the Council to see the design prior to implementation. She agreed the mural should have no advertisement or persuasion and be of a neutral nature so all can identify with no factions. Councilmember Lasman stated she likes the quilt pattern design with hand prints that could allow participation by each student in some form. She questioned the durability of the paint and whether it would withstand Minnesota's inclement weather conditions. Jimmy Longoria, representing Mentoring Peace Through Art, explained the paint is exterior grade and guaranteed for 20 years. To prepare the surface, all fissures are caulked and the area painted with two coats of primer. ADJOURN STUDY SESSION TO INFORMAL OPEN FORUM WITH CITY COUNCIL Councilmember Lasman moved and Councilmember Roche seconded to close the Study Session at 6:45 p.m. • Motion passed unanimously. RECONVENE STUDY SESSION Councilmember Roche moved and Councilmember Ryan seconded to reconvene the Study Session at 6:51 p.m. Motion passed unanimously. PUBLIC ART DISCUSSION — CONTINUED Mayor Willson stated he would not want the Council in a position to judge what "art" is and noted a segment of the population may not support this type of public art. He recommended the Council review the ordinance to determine if it should be amended and, if so, appropriate locations for murals. Mr. Boganey stated that Mr. Eitel had indicated the City does not believe the current ordinances address the issue of public art and the Sign Ordinance does not apply to public art. It is before the Council because a request was received from the School District and Mn/DOT that requires an approval by Council resolution. If the Council does not support this project, Mn/DOT would not allow this request. • 08/08/11 -3- DRAFT r . Councilmember Lasman supported consideration of public art requests to occur on a case -by- case basis with no area being generally open for this activity. She noted the requested location is isolated by a park, a school, and a trail which is an unusual circumstance. Councilmember Lasman felt that whether public art requests are considered via policy or ordinance, it needed to be specific to assure that approval of this request would not set precedence. Councilmember Roche stated his concurrence that it should be a case -by -case consideration based on the specific area and set of circumstances. Mayor Willson stated he is not suggesting the ordinance be changed for this particular request but to set parameters should future requests be received for consideration. Mr. Boganey advised that a policy would also be appropriate for this consideration. He presented options before the Council to adopt an ordinance addressing public art, to establish a policy in how to address public art requests in the future, and/or to approve this permit specifying the basis for that decision to assure it is not a precedence setting action. ADJOURNMENT Councilmember Lasman moved and Councilmember Kleven seconded to close the Study Session at 6:59 p.m. • Motion passed unanimously. • 08/08/11 -4- DRAFT MINUTES OF THE PROCEEDINGS OF THE CITY COUNCIL • OF THE CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER IN THE COUNTY OF HENNEPIN AND THE STATE OF MINNESOTA REGULAR SESSION AUGUST 8, 2011 CITY HALL — COUNCIL CHAMBERS 1. INFORMAL OPEN FORUM WITH CITY COUNCIL CALL TO ORDER INFORMAL OPEN FORUM The Brooklyn Center City Council met in Informal Open Forum called to order by Mayor Tim Willson at 6:45 p.m. ROLL CALL Mayor Tim Willson and Councilmembers Carol Kleven, Kay Lasman, Tim Roche, Dan Ryan. Also present were City Manager Curt Boganey, Director of Business and Development Gary Eitel, Assistant City Manager/Director of Building and Community Standards Vickie Schleuning, Police Chief Kevin Benner, EDA/HRA Specialist Tom Bublitz, Police Commander Brian Peters, Fire Chief Lee Gatlin, City Attorney Charlie LeFevere, and Carla Wirth, TimeSaver Off Site Secretarial, Inc. • Mayor Tim Willson opened the meeting for the purpose of Informal Open Forum. Bee Yang of 7224 Major Avenue N., and Diane Sannes of 7006 Willow Lane introduced themselves and reported on the farmer's market and community garden plots, noting both programs are going strong and produce sells out each week. Ms. Sannes also commented on geocaching activities and suggested the finds be registered with the City. Ms. Sannes stated she speaks for many residents who want to thank the Roche family for serving the City of Brooklyn Center for over 50 years. Ryan Sibinski, 8324 Hampshire Avenue N., Brooklyn Park, stated his opposition to the demolition of the Brookdale Mall, reported there is a lot of public opposition, and he believed it was not too late to reverse that decision. Councilmember Roche moved and Councilmember Lasman seconded to close the Informal Open Forum at 6:51 p.m. Motion passed unanimously. 2. INVOCATION • 08/08/11 -1- DRAFT • At the invitation of Councilmember Lasman, Dave Johnson, Administrator of St. Alphonsus Parish, provided the Invocation. 3. CALL TO ORDER REGULAR BUSINESS MEETING The Brooklyn Center City Council met in Regular Session called to order by Mayor Tim Willson at 7:00 p.m. 4. ROLL CALL Mayor Tim Willson and Councilmembers Carol Kleven, Kay Lasman, Tim Roche, and Dan Ryan. Also present were City Manager Curt Boganey, Director of Business and Development Gary Eitel, Assistant City Manager/Director of Building and Community Standards Vickie Schleuning, Police Chief Kevin Benner EDA/HRA Specialist Tom Bublitz Police Commander Brian Peters, Fire Chief Lee Gatlin City Attorney Charlie LeFevere and Carla Wirth Y Y > Timesaver Off Site Secretarial, Inc. 5. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE The Pledge of Allegiance was recited. 6. APPROVAL OF AGENDA AND CONSENT AGENDA Councilmember Lasman moved and Councilmember Roche seconded to approve the Agenda, as pp g amended to add Item 10a Resolution Calling Special Election to Fill a Council Vacancy, and Consent Agenda, and the following consent items were approved: 6a. APPROVAL OF MINUTES 1. July 25, 2011 Study Session 2. July 25, 2011— Regular Session 3. July 25, 2011— Work Session 6b. LICENSES AMUSEMENT DEVICES American Amusement Arcades 2100 West 96 Bloomington Dandy Amusements International, Inc. 2265 Ward Avenue, Simi Valley, CA Metro Coin of Minnesota 14940 28 Avenue N., Plymouth Theisen Vending Company 2335 Nevada Avenue N., Golden Valley MECHANICAL Ben Franklin Plumbing 14242 nd Street N., Minneapolis DeZiel Heating & A/C 1612 Third Avenue NE, Buffalo Dietrich Mechanical 4353 Sequoia Drive, Eagan • Heating & Cooling Two, Inc. 18550 County Road 81, Maple Grove Knight Heating & Air 13535 89 Street NE, Otsego 08/08/11 -2- DRAFT Liberty Comfort Systems 627 East River Road, Anoka • RENTAL — CURRENT RENTAL STANDARDS INITIAL (TYPE III — one-year license) 3207 64t Avenue N. Willard Weisberg 5436 Logan Avenue N. Shane Mclean INITIAL (TYPE II — two-year license) 1342 67 Lane N. Christian Mayer 5446 72 Circle Michael Ditto 6706 Drew Avenue N. Yang Yang Zheng 5550 France Avenue N. Belinda Gonzalez RENEWAL (TYPE III —one-year license) 5118 66 Avenue N. Scott Hanson RENEWAL (TYPE II — two-year license) 1201 57 Avenue N. Edward Doll 2200 55 Avenue N. HNA Properties, Inc. RENEWAL (TYPE I — three-year license) 4819 Azelia Avenue N. Penelope Brown 5324 -26 James Avenue N. Steven & Debra Elhardt • 5320 Queen Avenue N. Steven Heinz 5400 -02 Russell Avenue N. Tai Pham 6300 France Avenue N. Wade Klick 5405 Girard Avenue N. Jef Mehr 5528 Humboldt Avenue N. Bruce Goldberg 5307 Penn Avenue N. Ben Dossman 6e. RESOLUTION NO. 2011 -107 CALLING FOR A PUBLIC HEARING ON PROPOSED SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS FOR DELINQUENT NUISANCE ABATEMENT COSTS, DELINQUENT ADMINISTRATIVE FINES/ CITATIONS, ' AND DELINQUENT ADMINISTRATIVE VACANT BUILDING REGISTRATION 6d. RESOLUTION NO. 2011 -108 APPROVING SUBRECIPIENT AGREEMENT FOR HENNEPIN COUNTY NEIGHBORHOOD STABILIZATION PROGRAM (HUD NSP 3 AND MHFA NSP 3) 6e. RESOLUTION NO. 2011 -109 APPOINTING ELECTION JUDGES TO SERVE IN SPECIAL ELECTIONS 6f. APPLICATION AND PERMIT FOR TEMPORARY ON -SALE LIQUOR LICENSE SUBMITTED BY CITY OF LAKES NORDIC SKI 08/08/11 -3- DRAFT • FOUNDATION, FOR AN EVENT TO BE HELD IN SURLY BREWING COMPANY, 4811 DUSHARME DRIVE, ON SEPTEMBER 10, 2011 Motion passed unanimously. 7. PRESENTATIONS / PROCLAMATIONS /RECOGNITIONS/DONATIONS 7a. PROCLAMATION DECLARING AUGUST 20, 2011, TO BE BROOKDALE CHEVROLET DAY Councilmember Roche moved and Councilmember Lasman seconded to approve Proclamation Declaring August 20, 2011, to be Brookdale Chevrolet Day. . g Y Mayor Willson read in full a proclamation declaring August 20 2011 to be Brookdale Chevrolet Y p g t� � , Day. Motion passed unanimously. 8. PUBLIC HEARINGS 8a. RESOLUTION NO. 2011 -110 APPROVING MODIFICATION OF TAX INCREMENT FINANCING PLAN FOR TAX INCREMENT FINANCING DISTRICT NO. 2 AND MODIFICATION OF THE REDEVELOPMENT PLAN FOR HOUSING DEVELOPMENT AND REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT NO.1 City Manager Curt Boganey introduced the item and reviewed the action items before the Council. Director of Business and Development Gary Eitel explained that Tax Increment Financing (TIF) District No. 2 was created in 1985 and would expire on December 31, 2011. At that point increment will be redistributed so a Plan amendment is being considered to allow that increment to be used for other City projects. Jennifer Wolfe, Springsted, provided a presentation on the history of TIF District No. 2 that was created in 1985 for the Earle Brown Redevelopment projects, which have been completed. It was noted the Government Obligation bonds were repaid in 2004, there is no existing obligations, and has been no spending activity, other than debt, since the early 1990s. The District expires on December 31, 2011, and the proposed modification would allow increments to be used for qualifying projects. Ms. Wolfe described anticipated project opportunities and presented the proposed budget modification that, if approved, would be submitted to the State of Minnesota. Councilmember Lasman moved and Councilmember Ryan seconded to open the Public Hearing. Motion passed unanimously. 08/08/11 -4- DRAFT Councilmember Roche moved and Councilmember Ryan seconded to close the Public Hearing. • Motion passed unanimously. Councilmember Lasman moved and Councilmember Ran seconded to adopt RESOLUTION Y P NO. 2011 -110, Approving Modification of Tax Increment Financing Plan for Tax Increment Financing District No. 2 and Modification of the Redevelopment Plan for Housing Development and Redevelopment Project No. 1. Motion passed unanimously. 9. PLANNING COMMISSION ITEMS - None. 10. COUNCIL CONSIDERATION ITEMS 10a. RESOLUTION NO. 2011 -111 CALLING SPECIAL ELECTION TO FILL A COUNCIL VACANCY Councilmember Roche offered his resignation from the Brooklyn Center City Council. He explained that his family has agreed, by consensus, to take advantage of opportunities and chosen to relocate to the West Coast. • Councilmember Lasman moved and Councilmember Ryan seconded to accept the resignation of Councilmember Roche. Mayor Willson recognized Councilmember Roche for the excellent job he has done, noting he had made good decisions on behalf of the City and has a strong passion and love of Brooklyn Center. He stated it had been pleasure to serve with Councilmember Roche on both the Planning Commission and City Council. Motion passed unanimously. Councilmember Roche moved and Councilmember Lasman seconded to adopt RESOLUTION NO. 2011 -111, Calling Special Election to Fill a Council Vacancy. Mayor Willson read the Resolution in full. Motion passed unanimously. 11. COUNCIL REPORT Councilmember Roche commented on the emphasis his family places on service to community and country, indicating his family had stepped up to serve the community. He challenged , residents to now do likewise and take the opportunity to lead the City in the 21 Century. 08/08/11 -5- DRAFT • Councilinember Roche stated he has been honored and privileged to serve the City and was elated with the progressive redevelopment that is underway. - Councilmember Roche extended his appreciation to fellow Council Members and staff and stated he will be forever thankful for the opportunity to have served. Councilmember Lasman reported on her attendance at the following: • July 28, 2011, BCBA luncheon where Mr. Eitel was guest speaker to address the City's dynamic development activities • August 3, 2011, the entire City Council attended a Budget Work Session with the Financial Commission and staff Councilmember Lasman stated she had missed the National Night Out Kickoff Party and neighborhood visits because she was at a conference. Councilmember Kleven reported on her attendance at the following: • July 27, 2011, delivered welcome bags to new residents • July 29, 2011, American Love Drive for Africa • July 30, 2011, St. Alphonsus' Fun Fest • August 12011, National Night Out Kickoff Party • August 2, 2011, National Night Out visits to eight welcoming neighborhoods • August 3, 2011, Budget Work Session • • August 6, 2011, Brookdale Chevrolet's antique car show Councilmember Ryan reported on his attendance at the following: • July 26, 2011, Advisory Committee, organized by the League of Cities, on local economic development • July 27, 2011, first of three Advisory Committee meetings on fiscal management and City finances. • August 1, 2011, National Night Out Kickoff Party at the Civic Center • August 2, 2011, rode with Police Officer Michael Johnson to visit several National Night Out neighborhood parties. • August 3, 2011, Budget Work Session Mayor Willson reported on his attendance at the following: • July 27, 2011, was again honored to be part of the cable show "In the Know" for the Northwest Region • July 28, 2011, met with Brooklyn Center booster former Mayor Cohen and Chris Johnson from Luther Auto to work on plans for the August 20, 2011, celebration of Brookdale Chevrolet Day • August 1, 2011, Kickoff Party for National Night Out • August 2, 2011, visited many National Night Out events with Police Chief Benner and City Manager Boganey. He noted that he was not asked what the City intends to do with Brookdale Mall and all are excited about Shingle Creek Crossing. Mayor Willson stated • this will be excellent redevelopment that well serves Brooklyn Center. 08/08/11 -6- DRAFT • August 3, 2011, featured speaker with the Minnesota Shopping Association attended by • about 200 people. He thanked Mr. Eitel for his assistance with a PowerPoint presentation, noting that Mr. Eitel and Mr. Boganey had also attended. Mayor Willson thanked Councilmember Roche for his service and wished him well. 12. ADJOURNMENT Councilmember Lasman moved and Councilmember Ryan seconded adjournment of the City Council meeting at 7:31 p.m. Motion passed unanimously. • • 08/08/11 -7- DRAFT MINUTES OF THE PROCEEDINGS OF THE CITY COUNCIL/ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY OF THE CITY OF BROOKLYN CENTER IN THE COUNTY OF HENNEPIN AND THE STATE OF MINNESOTA WORK SESSION AUGUST 8, 2011 CITY HALL — COUNCIL CHAMBERS CALL TO ORDER The Brooklyn Center City Council/Economic Development Authority (EDA) met in Work Session called to order by Mayor/President Tim Willson at 8:12 p.m. ROLL CALL Mayor/President Tim Willson and Councilmembers /Commissioners Carol Kleven, Kay Lasman, Tim Roche, and Dan Ryan. Also present were City Manager Curt Boganey, Director of Business and Development Gary Eitel, Assistant City Manager/Director of Building & Community Standards Vickie Schleuning, Police Chief Kevin Benner, EDA/HRA Specialist Tom Bublitz, Police Commander Brian Peters, City Attorney Charlie LeFevere, and Carla Wirth, Timesaver Off Site Secretarial, Inc. • PUBLIC ART DISCUSSION — CONTINUED FROM STUDY SESSION Mayor/President Willson stated he thinks his concerns can be addressed and that the requested public art project would well serve the School District and Elementary School. If approved, he supported participation by children, which would create a legacy and be a good community builder. City Manager Curt Boganey explained the City Attorney has not yet been able to address the Sign Ordinance relating to public art. He suggested this consideration be continued to allow time for the City Attorney to conduct further review of the ordinances and determine whether approval of this mural would somehow impact the City Council's ability to address similar murals that are defined as signs. City Attorney LeFevere stated the City would not want murals permitted as a matter of the landowner's whim anywhere in the City and the only thing stopping that from occurring is that a mural fits within the Code definition of a sign, which requires a permit under allowable categories. In this case, the landowner (Mn/DOT) is asking the City Council to make the decision. City Attorney LeFevere stated if the City Council wants to have some control over murals and the Sign Ordinance does not have a broad enough definition to address murals, the Sign Ordinance should be amended to assure control. City Attorney LeFevere explained that prior to this discussion it seemed that a possible avenue to . allow some murals, without it getting out of control, was to define situations in which public art and only public art, may be permitted by the City Council. That can be done by zone. However, 08/08/11 -1- DRAFT the first amendment may be an issue, so he would like additional time to review that issue before • offering an opinion. City Attorney LeFevere stated the City Council could allow public art that is on public property, created and maintained under authority of the property owner, and then leave it to the various public entities to make good decisions. He noted that Mn/DOT has come to the City to ask permission of the City Council by resolution, and he felt most other public entities will also have concern about public opinion and be reluctant to put "art" on public buildings /walls. City Attorney LeFevere stated he would like to conduct additional research so the City Council knows all of its options. Mayor/President Willson stated it may be an opinion to consider a moratorium until the ordinance is defined and that issue is resolved. City Attorney LeFevere advised the City Council would not need a moratorium because the only proposal on the table is from Mn/DOT and it is leaving the decision to the City Council. Thus, there is no vested right for creating a mural while the City Council considers the ordinance. In addition, to gain entitlement to maintain a grandfathered use it needs to be a significant property (bricks and mortar), not just paint. City Attorney LeFevere referenced the Sign Ordinance and read the definition of "sign," noting it is pretty broad but does not cover purely artistic murals so it could be broadened. Councilmember /Commissioner Ryan stated he would like further legal clarification prior to consideration of this request. He noted the City Council needed to be cognizant of the fact that • some identify art as a commercial representation while others identify it as instances of fine art, referencing Andy Worhol's use of Campbell's soup cans in his art. Councilmember /Commissioner Ryan noted this is a long stretch of wall that may present interesting problems for the School District supporting this effort. He also noted the intended location is close to the bike trail, which may entice graffiti vandalism, and asked staff to obtain information on how effective this type of public art has been to reduce instances of graffiti. City Attorney LeFevere advised that the first amendment provides the greatest degree of protection to free ideas and more ability to regulate commercial speech than other types of speech. He noted that in residential neighborhoods and commercial areas, people would rather not have a lot of free expression on signs and billboards and the City has gone as far as it can in e that it is easier to imagine th explained g limiting ee expression signs. City Attorney LeFevere p g p � Y Y effect when it is a written message; however, the same messages can be conveyed via images. He stated if the Council finds it to be permissible to allow public art only in public spaces and on may be enough of a self limiting public prop that g g rotection but he would like to research p p p p Y Y that issue. Councilmember /Commissioner Ryan stated the Council would have the authority to approach restrictions to public spaces through the ordinance. Councilmember /Commissioner Lasman asked if it is possible to create strict parameters, noting She asked if parameters can be drawn to identify like cases have to be treated fairly and equally. p • 08/08/11 -2- DRAFT uniqueness of location (i.e., location by elementary school /trail), and attributes that make it appropriate to assure a precedence is not established. City Attorney LeFevere stated the City Council probably has more latitude than normal because "similarly situated landowners would be public entities. He explained that if there are certain elements of this request that make it acceptable and the City Council can identify those elements, it can then determine that other requests without those elements would not be appropriate. Mr. Boganey asked about a scenario whereby the City is responsible for making the decision to paint the mural. City Attorney LeFevere noted that is the current situation because Mn/DOT will not allow the mural without the City's approval. City Attorney LeFevere noted the City also has to abide by its ordinances and if a mural is not defined as a "sign" under the ordinance then that is the case for all. However, the Council may determine to allow a mural under specific circumstances, such as public art, maintenance by a public entity, the mural not being lit, and/or defined structural characteristics such as it not being freestanding. The majority consensus of the City Council was to continue consideration to allow time for the City Attorney to review the City's ordinances and offer an opinion. PRESIDENTIAL INVITE — COUNCILMEMBER ROCHE Councilmember /Commissioner Roche thanked Mr. Boganey for drafting the invitation to g Y g President Obama and agreed 2012 plays better into the schedule and would speak to Councilmember ' /Commissioner Lasman s concern relating to respect for the work of the Centennial Committee. The City Council/EDA discussed the estimated $150 million of redevelopment projects in Brooklyn Center. It was suggested that the demolition of Brookdale Mall and building of Shingle Creek Shopping Center and the Earle Brown Heritage Convention Center also be featured in the invitation. The City Council/EDA considered whether businesses should be highlighted, such as Surly Brewing Company and/or Caribou since its headquarters are located in Brooklyn Center Councilmember /Commissioner Lasman expressed concern with naming some businesses without naming all. The City Council/EDA discussed how the invitation could be worded and agreed that the business owners should be asked permission and review the draft invitation prior to it being sent. With regard to the availability of mutual aid to facilitate a visit by the President, Mr. Boganey indicated it is likely to be very expensive. It was acknowledged that a visit to Brooklyn Center may be part of a Presidential re- election campaign visit to the State of Minnesota. 08/08/11 -3- DRAFT Councilmember /Commissioner Roche stated City Council /EDA consensus had been reached . previously to send the invitation. He noted signatures from elementary students have already been collected. Once approved, he suggested the invitation be forwarded to City, State, and Federal delegation to gain their support. Councilmember /Commissioner Roche urged the City Council/EDA to dream big" and move ahead because such a visit would greatly impact the City's rebranding effort. The majority consensus of the City Council/EDA was to direct staff to provide several drafts 'of the invitation (with and without mention of business names) for the Council's consideration. ADJOURNMENT Councilmember /Commissioner Roche moved and Councilmember /Commissioner Ryan seconded adjournment of the City Council/Economic Development Authority Work Session at 8:59 p.m. Motion passed unanimously. • 08/08/11 -4- DRAFT City Council Agenda Item No. 6b • • COUNCIL ITEM MEMORANDUM . DATE: August 16, 2011 TO: Curt Boganey, City Manager FROM: Maria Rosenbaum, Deputy City Clerk „ SUBJECT: Licenses for City Council Approval Recommendation: It is recommended that the City Council consider approval of the following licenses at its August 22, 2011, meeting. Background: The following businesses /persons have applied for City licenses as noted. Each business /person has fulfilled the requirements of the City Ordinance governing respective licenses, submitted q Y g g P appropriate applications, and paid proper fees. Applicants for rental dwelling licenses are in compliance with Chapter 12 of the City Code of Ordinances, unless comments are noted below the property address on the attached rental report. AMUSEMENT DEVICES • Mendota Valley Amusement, Inc. 220 Hardman Avenue S, South St. Paul MECHANICAL Appliance Installers of MN 14105 Rutgers Street NE, Prior Lake Residential Heating & Air 1815 E 41 Street, Minneapolis Statewide Gas Service 201 W Main Street, Waconia RENTAL See attached report. SIGN HANGER A -Sign & Screen Printing Co. 708 Lowry Avenue N, Minneapolis • Mission: Ensuring an attractive, clean, safe community that enhances the duality of life and reserves the public trust COUNCIL ITEM MEMORANDUM Rental License Category Criteria Policy — Adopted by City Council 03 -08 -10 • Property Code and Nuisance Violations Criteria License Category Number of Units Property Code Violations per (Based on Property Inspected Unit Code Only) Type I — 3 Year 1 -2 units 0 -1 ± umt d 4 7 Type II — 2 Year 1 -2 units Greater than 1 but not more than 4 , 5 Type Greater than 0 nQt more than 1,5. Type III — 1 Year 1 -2 units Greater than 4 but not more than 8 3 +ats M x e�er than 1 5 b�zt natnoe loan Type IV — 6 Months 1 -2 units Greater than 8 34 Y uT11tS eater than . . License Number of Units Validated Calls for Disorderly Conduct Category Service & Part I Crimes (Calls Per Unit/Year) No Category 1 -2 0 -1 Impact 3 amts 0' =0 25 5 or more units 0 -0.35 • Decrease 1 1 -2 Greater than 1 but not more than 3 Category 3 amts ._ ... : .:xeatexth� Q 25, but ntit ri'ibre than.l"': 5 or more units Greater than 0.35 but not more than 0.50 Decrease 2 1 -2 Greater than 3 Categories 3 77777,-1 #ban 1 5 or more units Greater than 0.50 Budget Issues: There are no budget issues to consider. • Mission: Ensuring an attractive, clean, safe community that enhances the quality of life anal preserves the public trust Property, . Final Dwelling Renewal Code: License. Police License_, Unpaid Unpaid f ' Property Add "Tess Type 6tAnitial,. Owner V �olations Type < .CFS * Type * *, Ufiilities Taxes w, 4309 63rd Ave N Single Family Initial Kyle Dalton 0 11 N/A II OK OK 5306 Eleanor Ln Single Family Initial Cheryl Petersen 2 L1 N/A II OK OK 5243 Ewing Ave N Single Family Initial Gary Scherber 1 II N/A II OK OK 5248 France Ave N Single Family Initial Gary Scherber 1 II N/A II OK OK 6819 Humboldt Ave N A103 Passed w /Weather Deferral Single Family Initial Raymond Charest 1 II N/A .11 OK OK 5318 Irving Ave N Single Family Initial Nathaniel LoChe 2 II N/A II _OK OK 6436 June Ave N Single Family Initial Jenny Pham 0 11 N/A 11 OK OK 5307 Knox Ave N Single Family Initial Abraham Montemayor 1 11 N/A 11 OK OK 4714 Lakeview Ave Single Family Initial Gary Scherber 1 II N/A II OK OK 6613 Xerxes PI N Single Family Initial Mukhtar Musa 3 11 N/A II OK OK 6737 Humboldt Ave N 2 Bldg 5 2 Humboldt Square Apts 18 Units Renewal Humboldt Properties LLC .28 /Unit I .11 /Unit I OK OK 2307 -09 54th Ave N Two Family (2) Renewal Robert Messersmith 0 1 0 1 1 OK OK 5338 Queen Ave N Two Family (1) Renewal Robert Messersmith 0 1 0 1 OK OK 3706 55th Ave N Single Family Renewal Mains'I Properties 0 1 0 1 OK OK 507 69th Ave N Single Family Renewal Outreach Six Acres Inc. 0 1 0 1 OK OK 4416 69th Ave N Single Family Renewal Eugene & Diane Wright 1 I 0 1 OK OK 4707 Eleanor Ln Single Family Renewal Todd Vlasaty 8 111 0 III OK OK 5637 Emerson Ave N Single Family Renewal Douglas Pederson 7 III 0 111 OK OK 5006 France Ave N Single Family Renewal Michael Mohs 0 1 0 1 OK OK 5442 James Ave N Single Family Renewal Gerald Stigsell 0 1 0 1 OK OK 3812 Janet Ln Single Family Renewal Mains'I Properties 0 1 0 1 OK OK 5740 Logan Ave N Single Family Renewal Lin Shuang LLC 1 1 0 1 OK OK 6424 Marlin Dr Single Family Renewal Charles Jing Bright 1 1 0 1 OK OK 5201 Winchester Ln Single Family Renewal Yolanda Michelle Jackson 1 1 0 1 OK OK * CFS = Calls For Service for Renewal Licenses Only (initial Licenses are not applicable to calls for service and will be listed N /A.) ** Final License Type Type 1 = 3 year Type 11 = 2 year Type III = 1 year City Council Agenda Item No. 6c • COUNCIL ITEM MEMORANDUM DATE: August 8, 2011 • TO: Curt Boganey, City Manager FROM: Sharon Knutson, City Clerk SUBJECT: Resolution Changing Polling Location for Precinct 1 Recommendation: It is recommended that the City Council consider adoption of Resolution Changing Polling Location for Precinct 1. Background: On August 4, 2011, I received notification from The Lutheran Church of the Triune God, 5827. Humboldt Avenue North, that it wished to cease serving as a polling location for Precinct 1. The boundaries of Precinct 1 are as follows: • South boundary: commencing at the southeast City limits at the Mississippi River and the centerline of 53rd Avenue North west to Shingle Creek. • West boundary: commencing at the centerline of 53rd Avenue North and Shingle Creek north to the centerline of County Road 10. • North boundary: commencing at Shingle Creek and the centerline of County Road 10 east to the centerline of Logan Avenue North, north along the centerline of Logan Avenue North to the centerline of 59th Avenue North, east along the centerline of 59th Avenue North to the centerline of Dupont Avenue North, south along the centerline of Dupont Avenue North to the centerline of 57th Avenue North, east along the centerline of 57th Avenue North extended to the east City limits at the Mississippi River. • • East boundary: commencing at. the east City limits at the Mississippi River south from the centerline of 57th Avenue North to the southeast City limits at the centerline of 53rd Avenue North. There are no other locations within the boundaries of Precinct 1 that would meet the requirements of serving as a polling location. Therefore, I've selected Earle Brown Elementary School, which lies within Precinct 2 on the north boundary of Precinct 1 to serve as the polling location. Brooklyn Center School District Superintendent Keith Lester and Earle Brown Elementary School Principal Randy Koch have been notified. The September 13 special primary and October 18 special election to fill Sen. Scheid's vacant seat will be held at the current polling location, as a polling place cannot change within 90 days prior to any election. Adoption of the polling place change would allow for the new polling place to be used for any subsequent special elections held after November 20, 2011. The requirements to change a polling location are that the governing body of the City shall adopt a resolution designating the polling place for the precinct. A notice must be sent to every affected household with at least one registered voter in the precinct stating the location of the new polling place and must be sent at least 25 days before the next election. If the change is approved, an article informing affected voters will appear in the Brooklyn Center Sun -Post. Budget Issues: There are no budget issues to consider. mission—Ensuring an attractive, clears, safe community that enhances the quality of life and preserves the public trust Member introduced the following resolution and moved its adoption: • RESOLUTION NO. RESOLUTION CHANGING POLLING LOCATION FOR PRECINCT 1 WHEREAS, Minn. Stat. §204B.16, subd. 1 requires the governing body of a municipality to designate polling places for each election precinct; and WHEREAS, the current polling place for Precinct 1, located at The Lutheran Church of the Triune God, 5827 Humboldt Avenue North, has requested to cease serving as a polling place for elections; and WHEREAS, the City Council is desirous to change the location of the polling place to Earle Brown Elementary School, 1500 59th Avenue North, which meets all legal requirements. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Brooklyn Center, Minnesota, that the polling location for Precinct 1 be changed to Earle Brown Elementary School, 1500 59th Avenue North effective for elections held after November 21, 2011. August 22, 2011 Date Mayor ATTEST: City Clerk The motion for the adoption of the foregoing resolution was duly seconded by member and upon vote being taken thereon, the following voted in favor thereof: and the following voted against the same: whereupon said resolution was declared duly passed and adopted. • City Council Agenda Item No. 6d • COUNCIL ITEM MEMORANDUM DATE: August 22, 2011 TO: Curt Boganey, City Manager FROM: Vickie SchleuningM sistant City Manager /Director of Building & Community Standards SUBJECT: Resolution Declaring a Public Nuisance and Ordering the Removal of Diseased Trees Recommendation: It is recommended that the City Council declare a public nuisance and order the removal of diseased trees for certain properties as listed in the resolution. Background: The attached resolution represents the official Council action required uired to expedite removal of diseased trees that were recently arked b the City tree inspector. The City of Brooklyn Center Y Y tY p tY Yn • has maintained a policy of removing and properly disposing of diseased trees in order to prevent tree diseases from spreading throughout the community. The removal of diseased trees is defined in City Ordinance Chapter 20 -301to 20 -306. Although the City has historically focused on Dutch Elm disease, other transmissible diseases and infestations are addressed as well. Property owners are given the opportunity to remove the diseased tree on their own or enter an agreement to allow the City to remove the diseased tree. Where an agreement with the property owner is executed, a minimal administrative charge of $50 is applied to the costs associated with the tree removal. After a diseased tree is declared a public nuisance by the City Council, another Compliance Notice will be provided to the property owner allowing additional time, at least five days, for voluntary correction, again providing an option for an agreement with the City. If the property owner does not correct the violation or enter into an agreement, the City will remove the diseased tree. An administrative abatement service charge will be charged based on the cost of the abatement, with a minimum charge of $150. Budget Issues: The City's share of the cost of removal for diseased trees within the public right -of -way and on City property is included in the 2011 budget under the Public Works Forestry operating budget. The cost of removal for diseased trees located on private property is the responsibility of the respective property owner, and if unpaid, is specially assessed to the property. Mission: Ensuring an attractive, clean, safe community that enhances the quality of life and preserves the public trust COUNCIL ITEM MEMORANDUM Council Goals: Strategic: We will encourage city -wide environmental sustainability efforts. Ongoing: We will provide streamlined, cost effective, quality services with limited resources. r • • Mission: Ensuring an attractive, clean, safe community that enhances the quality of life and preserves the public trust • adoption: Member introduced the following resolution and moved its RESOLUTION NO. RESOLUTION DECLARING A PUBLIC NUISANCE AND ORDERING THE REMOVAL OF DISEASED TREES AT CERTAIN PROPERTIES IN BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA WHEREAS, Brooklyn Center City Code Section 20 -301 declares any diseased tree a ublic nuisance ce and provides for abatement by the City if not corrected by the property owner; and WHEREAS, removal of diseased trees and abatement of the public nuisances is necessary to prevent the spread of tree diseases and to protect the environmental quality and desirability of neighborhoods; and WHEREAS, a Notice to Abate Nuisance and a Diseased Tree Removal Agreement has been issued to the owners of certain properties in the City of Brooklyn Center giving the owners twenty (20) days to remove diseased trees on the owners' property; and WHEREAS, the City can expedite the removal of these diseased trees by declaring them a public nuisance. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Brooklyn Center, i y Minnesota, that: 1. The diseased trees at the following addresses are hereby declared to be a public nuisance. Property Owner Property Address Tree Type and No. Valerie Bauer 5255 Twin Lake Blvd E Elm 49 Neil White 5261 Twin Lake Blvd E Elm 50 Mark Carrell 5341 Brooklyn Blvd Elm 51 " Entrust Midwest LLC 4512 63 Ave N Elm 53 St. Alphonsus Church 7025 Halifax Ave N Elm 54 Elm 55 Amir Chaboki 3819 Bur quest Lane Elm 57 Tong Yang 6021 Fremont Ave N Elm 58 Susan Flores 7042 Regent Ave N Elm 59 Anjaleen Dolphis 5813 Aldrich Ave N Elm 61 Brian Bloomquist 6306 Perry AveN Elm 62 Elm 63 Dorothy Yarbrough 6007 Vincent Ave N Elm 64 • Melrose Gates LLC 6305 Camden Ave N Elm 66 2. After twenty (20) days from the date of the initial notice, the property owner(s) will • receive a second written notice providing five (5) business days in which to contest the determination of the City Council by requesting, in writing, a hearing. Said request shall be filed with the City Clerk. 3. After five (5) days, if the property owner fails to request a hearing, the tree(s) shall be removed by the City. The cost of abatement shall be recorded and become the personal responsibility of the owner of record. If unpaid, the costs shall be specially assessed to the property in accordance with City Codes and Minnesota Statutes Chapter 429. Date Tim Willson, Mayor ATTEST: City Clerk The motion for the adoption of the foregoing resolution was duly seconded by member and upon vote being taken thereon, the following voted in favor thereof: and the followin g g voted against the same: • whereupon said resolution was declared duly passed and adopted. • City Council Agenda Item No. 6e s • COUNCIL ITEM MEMORANDUM • DATE: 15 August 2011 TO: Curt Boganey, City Manager FROM: Daniel Jordet, Director of Fiscal & Support Services SUBJECT: Resolution calling for a Public Hearing on Pro se Special Assessments for Delinquent Public Utility Service Accounts Recommendation: It is recommended that the City Council consider adoption of a resolution calling a public hearing for Monday, 12 September 2011 on the matter of unpaid public utility service accounts. Background: One of the City's methods for collecting unpaid utilities is to assess them to the property served by the utility. Under Minnesota Statutes (M.S. 444.075, Subd. 3f) municipalities are allowed to certify unpaid utilities to the property taxes for the parcel served by the utility. City Code Section 4 -105 confirms the City's expectation that this method of collection will be used for delinquent, unpaid utility charges. For the Fall Assessment of 2011, accounts included in the preliminary assessment roll attached . to this memorandum include those delinquent and unpaid as of 30 June 2011. They include a full year's listing of unpaid accounts as the City decided to try a single assessment process for the 2011 fiscal year and did not certify unpaid accounts to assessment rolls in the Spring of 2011. The list is sorted and presented by address number of the customer. There are 844 accounts totaling $ 419,519 in unpaid utility charges, penalties and interest. With the adoption of this resolution, a letter will be sent to each of these accounts informing them of the amount due on their account, the potential assessment of the amount to their property taxes, and informing them of the Public Hearing location, date and time. Following the Public Hearing on 12 September 2011 the Council will be asked to consider a resolution certifying overdue, unpaid accounts for assessment against 2012 property taxes. Budget Issues: There are no exceptional budget issues !Mission: Ensuring an attractive, clean, safe conununity that enhances the quality of life and preserves the public trust Property ID # Account # Name Service Address Certification Balance Cycle 2511921320001 0022390004 RICK PHA 110173RD AVE N $400.76 Cycle 2 3611921330017 0088870003 CHRISTY HAYES 1112 62ND AVE N $555.24 Cycle 4 2511921330015 0022050004 CHRISTIANA RUE 1112 EMERSON LA $612.09 Cycle 2 3611921330063 0001000000 TIFFANY LATTIER 1201 63RD LA N $120.00 Cycle 4 3611921330064 0001010009 ROSE NDUNGU 1205 63RD LA N $155.22 Cycle 4 3611921330070 0001070003 EMMANUAL PAYMAH 123163RD LA N $630.59 Cycle 4 2511921320043 0021210005 BRENDA ROBERTS 130172ND AVE N $734.94 Cycle 2 3611921220113 0060170409 MARIE HAMMONDS 1315 67TH LN N $731.93 Cycle 2 3611921220059 0060181901 RESIDENT 1316 68TH LN N $702.93 Cycle 2 3611921220116 0060170706 JEAN SCHUSTER 1327 67TH LN N $168.35 Cycle 2 3611921220090 0060181604 LISA VITA 1328 68TH LN N $648.54 Cycle 2 3611921330080 0001170001 EMILY JOHNSON 1333 63RD LA N $585.03 Cycle 4 3611921220097 0060180804 MARY KAY REVARD 1333 68TH LN N $626.45 Cycle 2 0111821230007 0088410008 GREGORY COLEMAN 1400 57TH AVE N $649.06 Cycle 4 2611921410069 0014680008 DAVID BOURGEOIS 1512 72ND AVE N $311.69 Cycle 2 3511921110044 0060790800 HEIDI NERMOE 1600 68TH LN N $560.26 Cycle 2 3511921110056 0060790404 JERMAR LARKINS 160167TH LN N $591.28 Cycle 2 3511921110048 0060790305 MIESHA AKPAN 160168TH LN N $147.90 Cycle 2 2611921410092 0014350008 CHAD MOREN 1607 73RD AVE N $607.12 Cycle 2 2611921410004 0014430008 SHAWN M THORP 1700 WOODBINE LA $499.87 Cycle 2 3511921420010 0060460107 HANSEN BROS 1701 JAMES CIR N $1,229.79 Cycle 2 2611921440040 0012980004 KHAMPHET KEOHAVONG 1707 70TH AVE N $581.58 Cycle 2 2611921440081 0012800004 CRAIG HANSON 1720 IRVING LA N $145.46 Cycle 2 2611921440024 0013010009 SANGBAN W NGAIMA 180170TH AVE N $911.83 Cycle 2 2611921440089 0012780008 SEAN WILLIAMSON 1820 IRVING LA N $582.26 Cycle 2 0211821440031 0073060003 SCOTT HOLTHUS 182155TH AVE N $413.28 Cycle 6 2611921440092 0012770009 UZOMA PRINCE ABANONU 1821 IRVING LA N $180.35 Cycle 2 0211821420111 0076180006 LUIS JUAREZ - FERRER 1900 BROOKVIEW DR $694.02 Cycle 6 2611921420026 0011740003 RICHARD VANDENBOS 1906 71ST AVE N $163.51 Cycle 2 0211821430075 0072150003 CYNTHIA SWEATS 2018 55TH AVE N $446.29 Cycle 6 0211821420099 0076850004 AMOS RETIC 2024 ERICON DR $830.30 Cycle 6 2611921430077 0010780000 DRAKE M BELL 210171ST AVE N $325.03 Cycle 2 3511921130006 0060710006 MANGO TANGO 2101 FREEWAY BLVD $2,611.30 Cycle 2 2611921430030 0010600109 DAMU MCCOY 2106 69TH AVE N $73.14 Cycle 2 0211821420101 0076830006 JAMES SNOW 2106 ERICON DR $369.96 Cycle 6 0211821430118 0072020008 FRANCISCO HERNANDEZ JR 2107 55TH AVE N $436.04 Cycle 6 2611921430098 0010670003 JEFFREY SIMON JR 2107 70TH AVE N $441.04 Cycle 2 2611921430104 0010590102 JOYCE 0 HACK 2112 69TH AVE N $1,285.33 Cycle 2 0211821420103 0076810008 WESLEY YOUNG 2118 ERICON DR $564.43 Cycle 6 2611921340003 0010050008 RYAN LOVLEIN 2200 69TH AVE N $91.34 Cycle 2 0211821420049 0077120001 TODD CANNON 2205 BROOKVIEW DR $143.84 Cycle 6 0211821430127 0071930009 MARY BETH DAVIDSON 2206 54TH AVE N $570.44 Cycle 6 0211821310036 0076750006 KEVIN SMITH 2306 ERICON DR $702.50 Cycle 6 - 0211821310008 0077180005 MATTHEW HAWTON 2307 BROOKVIEW DR $118.18 Cycle 6 0211821340011 0071640004 ELIZABETH YARWEH 2330 55TH AVE N $556.97 Cycle 6 0211821310038 0076560009 KENNETH SCOTT 2331 ERICON DR $578.62 Cycle 6 0211821310047 0076570008 MARK FOLLMER 2348 BROOKVIEW DR $549.61 Cycle 6 3511921310015 0034710003 PAULTYANG 260165TH AVE N $189.76 Cycle 5 3511921320050 0034660000 ERVIN WRIGHT 2606 64TH AVE N $356.23 Cycle 5 3511921320082 0034340009 DALE CERNOHLAVEK 2700 OHENRY RD $635.08 Cycle 5 3511921320086 0034090000 RESIDENT 2701 OHENRY RD $763.50 Cycle 5 3511921320045 0034610005 ROBIN HALL 2712 64TH AVE N $444.91 Cycle 5 3511921320080 0034320001 DIANE M OLSON 2712 OHENRY RD $145.46 Cycle 5 3511921320079 0034310002 MAJEEDAH LIPFORD 2718 OHENRY RD $160.14 Cycle 5 3511921230086 0016420109 FRANZ ENG 2781 FREEWAY BLVD $742.41 Cycle 1 3511921330033 0037490009 ROXANNE HAMILTON 2806 NASH RD $259.25 Cycle 5 3511921320115 0035090009 GLENN PEIRSON 2807 66TH AVE N $308.18 Cycle 5 351192.1330037 0037620001 SHELLEY JOHNSON 2807 NASH RD $340.42 Cycle 5 3511921320092 0034150002 BEN ABRAM LLC 2807 OHENRY RD $192.30 Cycle 5 3511921230015 0016320309 KIMBERLY HOODIE 2812 67TH LN N $623.63 Cycle 1 3511921330049 0037670006 DANA BACKSTROM 2812 MUMFORD RD $11735 Cycle 5 3511921320074 0034260009 RORY PURNELL 2818 OHENRY RD $263.66 Cycle 5 3511921230017 0016320507 NANCY BLOM 2820 67TH LN N $446.77 Cycle 1 3511921230019 0016320705 CHAD THOMAS 2828 67TH LN N $589.66 Cycle 1 3511921230034 0016321406 BUILD BY DESIGN INC. 284167TH LN N $169.88 Cycle 1 3511921320017 0034900000 HENRY R SCHWARTZ 2906 65TH AVE N $461.22 Cycle 5 3511921230008 0035110203 ROLAND LIVINGSTONE 2906 66TH AVE N $720.54 Cycle 5 3511921330024 0037370003 GEORGE BROWN 2907 63RD AVE N $602.97 Cycle 5 3511921320096 0034190008 DENNIS BUTENSCHOEN 2907 OHENRY RD $539.16 Cycle 5 3511921320019 0034880004 MARVETTA ADAMS 2918 65TH AVE N $636.69 Cycle 5 3511921220024 0016291104 ERIK TAMTE 2925 69TH LN N $139.35 Cycle 1 3511921220018 0016290502 SARAH ROSSMAN 2932 69TH LN N $458.18 Cycle 1 3511921230042 0016311100 JODIE ORTA 2935 67TH LN N $580.29 Cycle 1 0311821440025 0071050006 CHERZON RILEY 3000 53RD AVE N $551.65 Cycle 6 3411921410017 0033150003 JENNIFER LAYMAN 3000 64TH AVE N $804.48 Cycle 5 3411921140001 0008740001 MICHAEL SCHMITZ 3001 THURBER RD $189.74 Cycle 1 3411921410081 0033510008 PA YANG 3007 OHENRY RD $699.08 Cycle 5 2511921430019 0050070007 ROBIN KEATON 30170TH AVE N $762.29 Cycle 2 3411921140008 0008480004 SHERRAL LUNDQUIST 3012 67TH AVE N $658.86 Cycle 1 3411921440103 0035450005 GHANA MBAYE 3013 62ND AVE N $139.35 Cycle 5 3411921440038 0036870003 DARLENE PASLEY 3013 NASH RD $798.44 Cycle 5 3411921410126 0032490004 ROBERT W STRAUCH 3013 QUARLES RD $919.80 Cycle 5 3411921140081 0032440009 MARYANN GARDING 3016 QUARLES RD $674.61 Cycle 5 0311821110014 0038420005 CHRISTOPHER P FAHEY 3018 61ST AVE N $767.01 Cycle 5 3411921410064 0033460006 ROSA VELAZQUEZ RAMOS 3018 OHENRY RD $175.98 Cycle 5 3411921140014 0008420000 KRISTEEN GOSSEN 3019 67TH AVE N $644.39 Cycle 1 3411921410127 0032500000 TIMUTI NEEPAY 3019 QUARLES RD $212.68 Cycle 5 3411921140084 0032510009 JEFFREY JOHNSON 3025 QUARLES RD $665.21 Cycle 5 3411921110074 0009020007 ANNIE T GAILAH 310168TH AVE N $334.17 Cycle 1 3411921410084 0033540005 NATHAN EAGLE 3101 OHENRY RD $667.95 Cycle 5 3411921440006 0036990009 GORDON HINES 3107 63RD AVE N $209.70 Cycle 5 3411921410112 0032870007 XAY XIONG 3107 65TH AVE N $649.32 Cycle 5 3411921140017 0008390005 VERONICA AMAYA - MENDEZ 3107 67TH AVE N $526.42 Cycle 1 1011821140020 0069350004 TERRY LARSON 3112 49TH AVE N $608.28 Cycle 6 3411921140004 0008520007 ADOLF ZYDOWICZ 3112 67TH AVE N $437.70 Cycle 1 3411921140058 0032210006 PHILIP JUDGE JR 3113 66TH AVE N $651.42 Cycle 5 3411921140018 0008380006 RENEE WHITTAKER 311367TH AVE N $150.34 Cycle 1 3411921440108 0035500007 PERRY MARTIN 3117 LAWRENCE RD $715.90 Cycle 5 0311821110010 0038380001 FOLUSO FAMUYIDE 3118 61ST AVE N $687.54 Cycle 5 3411921140044 0032070004 LONNIE RICKHEIM 3118 66TH AVE N $716.60 Cycle 5 3411921440078 0035770006 RENEE T PETERSON 3119 62ND AVE N $744.35 Cycle 5 • • • 3411921140059 0032220005 TINA KNUTH 3119 66TH AVE N $898.89 Cycle 5 3411921140088 0032550005 NICHOLAS HALUBAR 3119 QUARLES RD $260.94 Cycle 5 3411921140060 0032230004 FUE MOUA 312566TH AVE N $686.18 Cycle 5 3411921440024 0036780004 BRUCE WILSON 3200 MUMFORD RD $138.69 Cycle 5 3411921410060 0033420000 ROBYN JANUSZEWSKI 3200 POE RD $646.57 Cycle 3411921440080 0035790004 SHARON FINGER 320162ND AVE N $163.88 Cycle 5 3411921140029 0032710005 JENNIFER KURTH 3206 65TH AVE N $294.45 Cycle 5 3411921440025 0036370004 BRANDON LOGEMANN 3206 MUMFORD RD $622.45 Cycles 3411921140030 0032700006 TANYA HOSKINS 3212 65TH AVE N $632.70 Cycle 5 3411921440082 0035810000 AISLIN FRANKLIN 3213 62ND AVE N $685.64 Cycle 5 3411921140091 0032580002 KIONNE ROBINSON 3213 QUARLES RD $919.01 Cycle 5 3411921410012 0033820001 AFOLAKEMI HUFF 3218 63RD AVE N $445.20 Cycle 5 3411921410047 0033290007 TRIA VANG 3225 64TH AVE N $177.51 Cycle 5 0311821110005 0038330006 NICHOLE CHRISTENSEN 3300 61ST AVE N $389.46 Cycle 5 3411921140033 0032670001 ELIZABETH WORSEHLEAY 3300 65TH AVE N $66.38 Cycle 5 3411921140071 0032340001 DAVID GLAUVITZ 3300 QUARLES RD $626.00 Cycle 5 1011821140052 0069210000 BRANDON FLEEMAN 330149TH AVE N $146.06 Cycle 6 3411921140025 0008310003 EDWARD MUNN 330167TH AVE N $161.33 Cycle 1 3411921440060 0035990000 THOMAS CORWIN 3306 62ND AVE N $268.14 Cycle 5 3411921410053 0033350009 STEVEN LEBLANC 3306 POE RD $153.01 Cycle 5 3411921110056 0008930008 DONALD STEG MAN 3313 68TH AVE N $50.54 Cycle 1 3411921410069 0033650002 ALBERT D COOKE 3313 POE RD $584.74 Cycle 5 3411921140095 0032620006 JACKIE PASTORET 3313 QUARLES RD $369.12 Cycle 5 0311821140016 0040560004 DON THAYER 3315 59TH AVE N $197.16 Cycle 5 3411921440016 0037090007 LINDA ROBERTS 3319 63RD AVE N $344.15 Cycle 5 3411921140067 0032300005 SHARLYN OCONNOR 3319 66TH AVE N $606.21 Cycle 5 1011821130008 0069800008 RESIDENT 3328 49TH AVE N $298.15 Cycle 6 3411921130012 0031190006 SOLOMON FRANKSAWARI 3400 66TH AVE N $483.62 Cycle 3 1011821420038 0063820002 CLOVER MGMT 340147TH AVE N $1,876.40 Cycle 6 1011821120001 0068000006 KATHLEEN J BARCLAY 340153RD AVE N $337.78 Cycle 6 3411921430026 0035950004 JOE PETRIE 3412 62ND AVE N $597.80 Cycle 5 1011821130032 0068310009 NICHOLAS RAMNARACE 3416 50TH AVE N $273.50 Cycle 6 3411921130044 0030980001 BRYAN COFFEE 350166TH AVE N $146.06 Cycle 3 3411921130017 0030730000 DONALD EKBERG 3508 66TH AVE N $591.44 Cycle 3 0311821130045 0044450004 WASIU AKINPELU 3508 ADMIRAL LA $453.81 Cycle 5 2711921420048 0011880000 KIMBERLY HOLLIE 3513 WOODBINE LA $709.60 Cycle 1 1011821420012 0063110008 MILTON GRANQUIST 3515 48TH AVE N $1,882.57 Cycle 6 3411921120002 0008130005 MOUND CEMETERY 3515 69TH AVE N $216.74 Cycle 1 2711921420082 0011340005 CHARLES R LINDBERG 3519 72ND AVE N $706.80 Cycle 1 2711921420073 0011620000 MICHAEL BAUERMEISTER 3600 72ND AVE N $327.93 Cycle 1 0311821130044 0044460003 JEROME MOOT_ 3600 ADMIRAL LA $648.29 Cycle 5 2711921420050 0011860002 PAT QUINN 3601 WOODBINE LA $67.14 Cycle 1 0311821430058 0046640008 MARY ST CLAIR 3606 53RD AVE N $790:54 Cycle 5 0311821430005 0046130000 KHON THOEUK 3606 54TH AVE N $119.94 Cycle 5 3411921130021 0030590008 TODD NOEL 3608 66TH AVE N $142.73 Cycle 3 2711921420122 0011080007 ERICK EDSTROM 3616 VIOLET AVE $672.57 Cycle 1 0311821430060 0046620000 STEPHEN REICHEL 3618 53RD AVE N $300.56 Cycle 5 0311821130060 0044100005 SUSAN MIELKE 3633 ADMIRAL LA $600.81 Cycle 5 3411921130024 0030560001 JOHN OCONNOR 3700 66TH AVE N $141.62 Cycle 3 3411921130027 0030440006 VICTOR OGUNBANWO 370166TH AVE N $558.08 Cycle 3 3411921120041 0007820002 JOANNE WERNER 370169TH AVE N $485.64 Cycle 1 0311821120079 0042110006 LAURARELLE PATTERSON 3707 61ST AVE N $122.97 Cycle 5 2711921420089 0011270004 KHAMPHA CHANTHAVONG 3707 72ND AVE N $356.80 Cycle 1 2711921420090 0011260005 SUNNIATHOMAS 3713 72ND AVE N $711.32 Cycle 1 2711921420057 0011790001 AYUB K GENEMO 3713 WOODBINE LA $218.79 Cycle 1 2711921420099 0011170006 DAVE KRAUSE 3724 VIOLET AVE $674.18 Cycle 1 0311821310071 0045400008 DEAN MORGAN 3800 ECKBERG DR $633.16 Cycle 5 1011821210009 0065350008 ANN SOUTHARD 380153RD AVE N $278.22 Cycle 6 3411921340074 0027200009 ELLEN DOREE 380162ND AVE N $525.77 Cycle 3 1011821240019 0066230001 TODD TEVOGT 3807 51ST AVE N $281.83 Cycle 6 0311821310055 0045240008 MARTY LANDSEM 3807 56TH AVE N $671.23 Cycle 5 0311821240042 0044860004 ANDREW DAVIS 3807 FRANCE PL $139.35 Cycle 5 0311821240040 0044670007 KATHLEEN SHERIDAN 3808 FRANCE PL $657.12 Cycle 5 0311821310051 0045200002 MICHAEL GOUDE 3812 56TH AVE N $366.69 Cycle 5 2711921430063 0009820000 RESIDENT 3813 URBAN AVE $589.89 Cycle 1 0311821310050 0045190005 THOMAS BARIBEAU SR 3818 56TH AVE N $307.95 Cycle 5 0311821210105 0026780001 SHERMAN KHO 3818 61ST AVE N $672.40 Cycle 3 0311821310049 0045180006 ADEM H RABSA 3824 56TH AVE N $527.08 Cycle 5 I 1011821240022 0066200004 KECIA HAYSLETT 3825 51ST AVE N $428.00 Cycle 6 1011821210060 0067290004 STEVE WISE 3834 OAK ST $564.76 Cycle 6 1011821210052 0067400009 LYNN DORMOND 390152ND AVE N $478.01 Cycle 6 3411921340071 0027230006 TAMMY LENOIR 390162ND AVE N $608.99 Cycle 3 0311821310041 0045100004 EDWIN NGANG 3901 BURQUEST LA $182.96 Cycle 5 0311821310047 0045160008 DAWN TREBBY 3906 56TH AVE N $627.49 Cycle 5 0311821210108 0026760003 LUCKY I IGBINOBA 3906 61ST AVE N $444.06 Cycle 3 0311821310029 0044980000 LAURIANTAZANGUE 3906 BURQUEST LA $629.42 Cycle 5 0311821310028 0044970001 VICKEY KORLEWALA 3912 BURQUEST LA $655.28 Cycle 5 1011821210054 0067370004 KATHRYN A LEE 3919 52ND AVE N $172.63 Cycle 6 3411921340105 0027600000 KPOLUNWON DAHN 4001 JOYCE LA $544.60 Cycle 3 1011821310029 0061150006 LTF CLUB OPERATIONS CO INC 4001 LAKEBREEZE AVE $10,961.45 Cycle 6 0311821240014 0048160005 FRANCESCA MORRIS 4007 58TH AVE N $165.48 Cycle 5 1011821320002 0060860001 DANIEL DUFOUR 4100 LAKESIDE AVE $277.92 Cycle 6 2711921310080 0013460009 DAN OCONNELL 4106 WOODBINE LA $671.04 Cycle 1 3411921340078 0027740004 LOWELL D JANSEN 4200 JOYCE LA $320.71 Cycle 3 0311821210120 0043370005 KATHLEEN TULLY 420161ST AVE N $630.56 Cycle 5 3411921240049 0028740003 JENNIFER GARDNER 4206 65TH AVE N $75.45 Cycle 3 3411921340003 0027050008 LAWRENCE E THOMAS 4206 JANET LA $171.10 Cycle 3 3411921340114 0028030009 ALEXANDER TOPAH 4207 63RD AVE N $466.52 Cycle 3 3611921120031 0056240000 EAST BROOK ESTATES 42169TH AVE N $129.28 Cycle 2 3411921340042 0027380009 LORNA FORTUNE 4212 62ND AVE N $133.85 Cycle 3 3411921240048 0028750002 KARLI HAMMES 4212 65TH AVE N $269.94 Cycle 3 1011821320063 0060480008 EKAH ITA 4216 LAKEBREEZE AVE $548.32 Cycle 6 3411921340040 0026640007 JOHNSON OGBORU 4218 61ST AVE N $666.48 Cycle 3 3411921230065 0028780009 RESIDENT 4306 65TH AVE N $609.26 Cycle 3 3411921230004 0029810003 CHAD LASHINSKI 4306 66TH AVE N $373.70 Cycle 3 2711921320106 0015590001 WLEH TOGBA TOE 4307 WOODBINE LA $90.55 Cycle 1 3411921230046 0029400003 AUDREY HALSTEAD 4400 WINCHESTER LA $555.97 Cycle 3 3411921320108 0025680004 OMAR SANNEH 440165TH AVE N $654.42 Cycle 3 2711921320124 0013790009 MARCEL GAGNON 4407 71ST AVE N $1,016.27 Cycle 1 2711921320062 0014980005 KEN HUISINGA 4413 71ST AVE N $259.64 Cycle 1 3411921230082 0028850000 KIA THAO 4500 65TH AVE N $219.04 Cycle 3 3411921230081 0028860009 ADRIENE C LUXFORD 4506 65TH AVE N $402.00 Cycle 3 3411921230033 0029440009 JAMES VISETSIN 4506 WINCHESTER LA $147.32 Cycle 3 2711921320059 0014950008 ROGER ZIERKE 4507 71ST AVE N $730.40 Cycle 1 3411921230073 0029070004 WILLIAM SCHMIDT 4613 WINCHESTER LA $174.54 Cycle 3 1011821320013 0060560007 JEFFREY MCILRATH 4703 LAKEVIEW AVE $148.01 Cycle 6 1011821320012 0060570006 NANCY WILCOX 4705 LAKEVIEW AVE $561.54 Cycle 6 3311921410029 0023340007 MORTON J COBB 4706 63RD AVE N $721.34 Cycle 3 2811921410140 0014780009 TALATA BAYSAH 4706 WINGARD LA $340.17 Cycle 1 2811921410140 0014780009 SPECIALTY CONTRACTING SERV 4706 WINGARD LA $495.07 Cycle 1 2811921410207 0014760001 VIOLA GOBAH 4714 WINGARD LA $546.80 Cycle 1 1011821320040 0060530000 THERESA COOPER 4718 TWIN LAKE AVE $168.69. Cycle 6 1011821320039 0060520001 MIA THOMAS 4734 TWIN LAKE AVE $439.37 Cycle 6 2811921410019 0004170104 JENNIFER IVERSON 4801 WINGARD PL $163.77 Cycle 1 1011821320061 0060460000 RESIDENT 4806 TWIN LAKE AVE $387.10 Cycle 6 2811921410016 0004170401 ABDULAHI MOHAMED 4807 WINGARD PL $157.67 Cycle 1 2811921440014 0004750004 ALONZO ROBINSON 4812 69TH AVE N $264.05 Cycle 1 1011821320202 0060410005 MICHELLE YOUNG 4821 TWIN LAKE AVE $425.50 Cycle 6 1011821320203 0060510006 MICHELLE YOUNG 4823 TWIN LAKE AVE $129.41 Cycle 6 1011821130069 0063900002 PET CENTER 4900 FRANCE AVE N $411.88 Cycle 6 3311921140049 0019160005 ANNIE FORSTER 4900 HOWE LA $561.72 Cycle 3 1011821140021 0069530001 LIZABETH MUTKA 4900 ZENITH AVE N $618.15 Cycle 6 1011821130069 0063900101 PET HOSPITAL 4902 FRANCE AVE N $4,225.38 Cycle 6 3311921140036 0020420000 JEANNE THEIS 4906 65TH AVE N $602.27 Cycle 3 1011821130022 0069100003 RANDY J LAN HART 4907 BEARD AVE N $396.56 Cycle 6 2811921410032 0004200208 JOHN POHTILLA 4907 WINGARD PL $432.40 Cycle 1 1011821140039 0069660006 KELLY KROGH 4908 ABBOTT AVE N $551.31 Cycle 6 1011821140018 0069390000 BRIAN VAN HAVERMAET 4911 BROOKLYN BLVD $383.91 Cycle 6 3311921140024 0020470005 FURMENCIONTAPIA MENDOZA 4913 WINCHESTER LA $507.93 Cycle 3 1011821140012 0069430004 RUSTY SMITH 4937 BROOKLYN BLVD $707.60 Cycle 6 1011821140071 0068780003 CAROLYN A WINSTON 5001 BROOKLYN BLVD $137.18 Cycle 6 3311921140069 0019670003 BILL CARMICHAEL 5004 66TH AVE N $148.28 Cycle 3 3311921410085 0020690008 VICTORIA KROOK 5006 63RD AVE N $226.59 Cycle 3 1011821140083 0068920005 WARD S MONROE 5006 ABBOTT AVE N $647.60 - Cycle 6 3311921410104 0021650001 JOHN WETTERHAHN 5007 65TH AVE N $611.40 Cycle 3 2811921410056 0004250104 TAMRAJ ELKINS 5007 WINGARD PL $156.45 Cycle 1 1011821140084 0068930004 PAUL BLESI 5012 ABBOTT AVE N $256.44 Cycle 6 1011821130030 0068340006 CECELIA SEWARD 5012 LILAC DR N $666.04 Cycle 6 3311921140066 0019640006 KELLY BACHOFER 5016 66TH AVE N $339.48 Cycle 3 1011821140069 0068760005 DELORES RILEY 5017 BROOKLYN BLVD $453.05 Cycle 6 2811921430023 0005940000 LORI WHEATON 5024 71ST AVE N $1,875.62 Cycle 1 1011821140076 0068830006 LAURENCE A SCHMIDT 5024 ZENITH AVE N $86.07 Cycle 6 1011821130048 0064490003 RYNE JACKSON 5025 DREW AVE ,N $137.86 Cycle 6 1011821130039 0065030006 VIOLET W BRUNNER 5025 EWING AVE N $176.58 Cycle 6 1011821140066 0068380002 STEVE MASLOWSKI 5036 LILAC DR N $434.81 Cycle 6 1011821120078 0065160001 SUSAN MCKELVEY 5048 FRANCE AVE N $615.30 Cycle 6 1011821120077 0064990002 ARCHIBALD F MENORKPOR 5049 EWING AVE N $353.19 Cycle 6 1011821120055 0064140004 LORRAINE SETHER 5100 DREW AVE N $80.51 Cycle 6 3311921140056 0019090004 RENEE G KOJETIN 5100 HOWE LA $198.55 Cycle 3 3311921140020 0020020008 THONG VUE 5100 WINCHESTER LA $2,245.53 Cycle 3 3311921430001 0017840004 ASHAKI GRANT 510163RD AVE N $277.09 Cycle 3 1011821210069 0067230000 BRETT MYHRE 5101 FRANCE AVE N $137.18 Cycle 6 2811921430032 0006030009 ROBERTO CASTRUITA 5106 70TH AVE N $737.54 Cycle 1 1011821210068 0067220001 KAREN RODRIGUEZ 5107 FRANCE AVE N $561.62 Cycle 6 3311921130055 0020340000 SKROGSTAD CORP HOLDINGS LLC 5112 65TH AVE N $250.42 Cycle 3 3311921420005 0020760009 JOHN HOOK 5113 ELEANOR LA $141.40 Cycle 3 3311921130082 0019350002 HEIDI VANDERVELDEN 5113.HOWE LA $593.89 Cycle 3 1011821120040 0064630004 THERESA GASMAN 5116 EWING AVE N $485.69 Cycle 6 3311921130053 0020320002 RESIDENT 5124 65TH AVE N $618.11 Cycle 3 3311921130060 0019050008 CHARLES E TURNER 5124 HOWE LA $642.63 Cycle 3 1011821120073 0064950006 WILLIAM KRIER 5125 EWING AVE N $604.29 Cycle 6 1011821210005 0065750009 JAMES M CURRY 5125 TWIN LAKE BLVD E $134.96 Cycle 6 1011821210004 0065740000 CHRISTOPHER FEALY 5127 TWIN LAKE BLVD E $63.87 Cycle 6 3311921130085 0019380009 STEVEN THAO 5131 HOWE LA $512.13 Cycle 3 1011821120071 0064930008 JEWEL BARSALOUX 5137 EWING AVE N $588.89 Cycle 6 3611921430033 0093830000 TOUSSAINT CHEATOM 515 62ND AVE N $158.89 Cycle 4 3311921130051 0020300004 GENE RATTEI 5200 65TH AVE N $266.57 Cycle 3 1011821110023 0070070054 TREMAYNE WILLIAMS 5201 XERXES AVE N $121.59 Cycle 6 1011821120010 0064230003 LYDIA JERNIGAN 5206 DREW AVE N $297.10 Cycle 6 1011821120019 0064360008 DESIREE SAYERS 5207 DREW AVE N $432.73 Cycle 6 3311921130008 0019810005 BRIAN MADDEN 5213 66TH AVE N $144.95 Cycle 3 1011821120023 0064730002 MELISSA SELIGER 5214 EWING AVE N $349.81 Cycle 6 1011821120060 0064870006 TISHAURA HOSKINS 5219 EWING AVE N $288.79 Cycle 6 1011821120017 0064340000 ASHLEY SOMMER 5221 DREW AVE N $256.08 Cycle 6 1011821210019 0065460005 COLLEEN GARCIA 5222 GREAT VIEW AVE $1,054.17 Cycle 6 3311921130047 0020260000 CHARLENE BALLARD 5224 65TH AVE N $439.48 Cycle 3 1011821120059 0064860007 JEFF STEPP 5225 EWING AVE N $146.06 Cycle 6 3311921130091 0019440001 CHOU YANG 5231 HOWE LA $625.91 Cycle 3 1011821120015 0064320002 SOUPHAPHONE STEWART 5233 DREW AVE N $233.02 Cycle 6 1011821120026 0064770008 XIA JENNINGS 5240 EWING AVE N $169.95 Cycle 6 1011821210022 0065500008 JAMES COTTINGHAM 5244 GREAT VIEW AVE $545.55 Cycle 6 1011821210021 0065510007 GREGORY L OLSON 5250 GREAT VIEW AVE $608.88 Cycle 6 1011821210033 0065640002 BRIAN SOMKHAN 5256 TWIN LAKE BLVD E $247.64 Cycle 6 2811921430095 0006384703 MYRNA HUBERT 5300 70TH CIR $170.95 Cycle 1 0111821340083 0083350006 MAURICE KENDALL 5300 COLFAX AVE N $146.06 Cycle 6 3311921430031 0017160007 BENNIE KYLES 530162ND AVE N $906.09 Cycle 3 0311821440017 0046940002 PHILIP J ROCHE 5301 BROOKLYN BLVD $68.24 Cycle 5 0111821340087 0083720000 EDWARD J WEBER 5301 COLFAX AVE N $514.44 Cycle 6 0211821440032 0074320000 NORTH LLC 5301 HUMBOLDT AVE N $548.71 Cycle 6 0211821430040 0072870006 CHRISSIE CARVER 5301 LOGAN AVE N $586.43 Cycle 6 0211821430022 0072330001 MICHAEL SIMS 5301 NEWTON AVE N $633.15 Cycle 6 0111821330125 0084530002 GREGORY A TOROK 5302 FREMONT AVE N $141.62 Cycle 6 0111821340078 0083310000 SHERITTA SCROGGINS 5305 BRYANT AVE N $626.33 Cycle 6 0211821430041 0072880005 KIAH A SMITH 5305 LOGAN AVE N $245.68 Cycle 6 2811921430096 0006384802 MARIANNE WASNICK 5306 70TH CIR $362.13 Cycle 1 3311921130069 0018960009 DEREK PRZYBYLA 5306 HOWE LA $142.73 Cycle 3 0211821430028 0072310003 LAWRENCE HECK 5306 OLIVER AVE N $722.42 Cycle 6 3311921420110 0022060002 SERGIO RAMIMEZ 5307 ELEANOR LA $554.98 Cycle 3 0311821440016 0046950001 DOUG CLIFTON 5309 BROOKLYN BLVD $461.68 Cycle 5 0111821340072 0083290004 GLEN PETERSEN 5309 BRYANT AVE N $258.85 Cycle 6 0211821440062 0073570001 TINA BROWN 5310 KNOX AVE N $539.23 Cycle 6 3311921120050 0000600005 YANG VANG 5313 67TH AVE N $548.91 Cycle 1 2811921430092 0006384406 SAMUEL CLARK 5313 70TH CIR $267.94 Cycle 1 2811921430170 0006392003 FELICIA CEBALLOS 5314 71ST CIR $333.76 Cycle 1 0. 0 0111821330143 0084070009 KRISTOFFER KIPHUTH 5315 DUPONT AVE N $560.11 Cycle 6 3311921120056 0000350007 DESIREE WILKERSON 5318 68TH AVE N $822.33 Cycle 1 2811921430098 0006385007 RUSSELL L WHITTEMORE 5318 70TH CIR $290.78 Cycle 1 3311921420079 0021880004 BEVERLY KILLEBREW 5318 ELEANOR LA $631.71 Cycle 3 0111821340014 0082800001 SANTA PIRIN - CORTES 5319 CAMDEN AVE N $469.13 Cycle 6 0111821340076 0083360005 DEREK HOLMLUND 5320 COLFAX AVE N $356.66 Cycle 6 2811921430164 0006391401 TYRONE GERLOFF 532171ST CIR $660.93 Cycle 1 0211821440058 0073640002 MARIE A BOYD 5321 JAMES AVE N $497.65 Cycle 6 0111821430065 0082400000 STEPHANIE WEHMAN 5323 4TH ST N $262.07 Cycle 6 0111821330149 0084140000 MARY CARLSTROM 5324 EMERSON AVE N $319.61 Cycle 6 0211821330016 0070840001 DONN BURSETH 5324 LILAC DR N $584.14 Cycle 6 0111821330028 0085300009 MICHAELJOHNSTON 5326 HUMBOLDT AVE N $276.17 Cycle 6 2811921420057 0006396103 KATHRYN WORRE 5329 72ND CIR $595.90 Cycle 1 3311921430080 0017290002 DEKETA EVANS 5330 62ND AVE N $799.20 Cycle 3 0211821440108 0073890003 REED OLSON 5332 JAMES AVE N $548.52 Cycle 6 0211821440100 0073530005 NICK CLARITY 5332 KNOX AVE N $400.49 Cycle 6 2811921430162 0006391203 ANNIE DELIS TIDWELL- JORDAN 5333 71ST CIR $154.00 Cycle 1 0111821330139 0084030003 THOMAS SPENCER 5333 DUPONT AVE N $540.59 Cycle 6 0111821330022 0085200001 ALISON WALK 5333 GIRARD AVE N $655.42 Cycle 6 0111821330161 0084450003 STEPHEN JARNOT 5335 EMERSON AVE N $153.83 Cycle 6 0211821330013 0070870008 JOWHARAH HARRIS -REID 5336 LILAC DR N $599.15 Cycle 6 0211821440117 0074240000 TMC MANAGEMENT CORP 5338 IRVING AVE N $101.33 Cycle 6 0211821340037 0071490004 MARY JACKMAN 5339 QUEEN AVE N $826.70 Cycle 6' 0111821340067 0083390002 CARLOS ALFREDO TREJO 5340 COLFAX AVE N $514.83 Cycle 6 0211821340039 0071250002 EUGENE FOLLMER 5341 PENN AVE N $799.39 Cycle 6 0211821440004 0073320001 BARBARA J RETIC 5343 KNOX AVE N $137.08 Cycle 6 2811921430173 0006392508 SUSAN GRIEP 5344 71ST CIR $168.66 Cycle 1 0111821430083 0082560001 RITA A GASMAN 5344 CAMDEN AVE N $68.73 Cycle 6 0111821330133 0084600003 ANDREA ZIEBARTH 5344 FREMONT AVE N $536.39 Cycle 6 0211821440110 0073870005. REBECCA BYSTROM 5344 JAMES AVE N $626.31 Cycle 6 0211821440097 0073680008 SCOTT VINCENT 5345 JAMES AVE N $883.21 Cycle 6 0211821430107 0072400002 LAURA RUPP 5345 NEWTON AVE N $624.66 Cycle 6 0311821430042 0046840004 SCOTT C HUGHES 5348 NORTHPORT DR $585.23 Cycle 5 0111821430082 0082570000 DEREK EMERY 5350 CAMDEN AVE N $329.88 Cycle 6 0111821340066 0083420007 GREGG HASSLER 5350 COLFAX AVE N $133.85 Cycle 6 0211821440009 0073140003 KAREN BRADY 5350 LOGAN AVE N $131.63 Cycle 6 0111821430061 0082350007 HELENA YEAH 53514TH ST N $563.70 Cycle 6 0311821440012 0047000103 DEBBORAH L DUNCAN 5353 BROOKLYN BLVD $161.44 Cycle 5 3311921120034 0000520005 JESSE MUNOZ 5400 67TH AVE N $295.41 Cycle 1 0111821430084 0082580009 ERIC KOTWITZ 5400 CAMDEN AVE N $635.21 Cycle 6 0211821340032 0071420001 JAMES KIEHL 5400 QUEEN AVE N $132.74 Cycle 6 3311921430081 0017000005 JOHN SCHWARZ 540163RD AVE N $275.98 Cycle 3 0211821440093 0073700004 MICHELLE DYMOND 5401 JAMES AVE N $595.01 Cycle 6 0211821340035 0071510009 GREGORYJONES 5401 QUEEN AVE N $628.00 Cycle 6 0111821340103 0083610003 CAROLYN CARSON 5403 COLFAX AVE N $134.96 Cycle 6 0111821330083 0084220000 PAM KREUTER 5404 EMERSON AVE N $136.00 Cycle 6 2811921420051 0006395501 LEE ROSS 5405 72ND CIR $422.47 Cycle 1 0111821340061 0083440005 CINDY GRANQUIST 5406 COLFAX AVE N $577.08 Cycle 6 0211821440091 0073840008 LYNDON D HOLTE 5406 JAMES AVE N $592.60 Cycle 6 0311821440010 0047020002 JOEL ANDERSON 5407 BROOKLYN BLVD $500.91 Cycle 5 0211821440088 0074070001 MARK GONZALES 5407 IRVING AVE N $218.82 Cycle 6 0111821340106 0083860004 PETER BERGLUND 5408 DUPONT AVE N $274.84 Cycle 6 0211821340017 0071580002 RALPH SCHLUTER 5408 RUSSELL AVE N $509.75 Cycle 6 0111821340059 0083460003 STEVEN SWANSON 5412 COLFAX AVE N $569.04 Cycle 6 0211821440140 0074080000 CHRISTINE HENSLEY 5413 IRVING AVE N $146.06 Cycle 6 0211821440015 0073470004 DAVID HUSET 5414 KNOX AVE N $96.06 Cycle 6 2811921430108 0006386005 REYNA CRUZ 5418 70TH CIR $247.80 Cycle 1 0111821430058 0082320000 JULIE OLSON 54214TH ST N $62.53 Cycle 6 0111821330066 0085360003 RAVEN DEFILIPPO 5422 HUMBOLDT AVE N $624.53 Cycle 6 0111821330086 0084250007 TOMMY MUNSON 5424 EMERSON AVE N $81.57 Cycle 6 0111821330169 0099990071 LUXOR PROPERTIES LLC 5424 FREMONT AVE N $574.47 Cycle 6 2811921430153 0006390304 PRASERTH YANG 5427 71ST CIR $405.58 Cycle 1 0111821430054 0082620003 GRACE EDWARDSON 5430 CAMDEN AVE N $97.18 Cycle 6 0211821430081 0073030006 ANDREATIERNEY 5431 LOGAN AVE N $572.24 Cycle 6 0111821340111 0083870003 MICHELLE WHITAKER 5432 DUPONT AVE N $48.61 Cycle 6 0111821430056 0082300002 BELEN MARTINEZ -ORTIZ 5433 4TH ST N $160.49 Cycle 6 0111821330094 0084340006 DUANE ENNINGA 5435 EMERSON AVE N $580.45 Cycle 6 0211821440121 0073790005 SARAH COLLANDER 5436 JAMES AVE N $141.62 Cycle 6 0111821340109 0083880002 HOUM'PHENG BOUNSAVATH 5438 DUPONT AVE N $482.34 Cycle 6 0111821330076 0083940004 DANIEL ODOLE 5441 DUPONT AVE N $286.46 Cycle 6 0211821440081 0074130003 LATOYA PERKINS 5443 IRVING AVE N $193.29 Cycle 6 0111821340049 0083160009 ANNE WALASZEK 5447 BRYANT AVE N $159.42 Cycle 6 0111821330075 0083930005 HELEN EVANS 5447 DUPONT AVE N $592.66 Cycle 6 0111821330093 0084330007 GERALD W KAMROW 5447 EMERSON AVE N $554.42 Cycle 6 0111821330109 0084710000 BENJAMIN HAWKINS 5452 FREMONT AVE N $595.65 Cycle 6 0111821340051 0083520004 WAYNE FINLEY 5454 COLFAX AVE N $215.00 Cycle 6 0111821310061 0080600007 N AND G PROPERTIES LLC 5500 BRYANT AVE N $2,210.36 Cycle 6 0111821310075 0080010009 TIANDRA ROBINSON 5501 COLFAX AVE N $681.69 Cycle 6 0111821320098 0079300007 SARAH KENDEMA 5504 FREMONT AVE N $613.94 Cycle 6 0111821320123 0079680002 LYNN LOGAN 5510 EMERSON AVE N $784.27 Cycle 6 0111821320097 0079340003 BRUCE WHITTAKER 5511 EMERSON AVE N $376.69 Cycle 6 0311821340024 0045860003 DAVID SITLER 5513 FRANCE AVE N $607.52 Cycle 5 0211821410110 0075380003 BARBARA MCLAUGHLIN 5516 KNOX AVE N $569.28 Cycle 6 0211821420088 0077010004 KATHRYN ENDICOTT 5518 JUDY LA $589.66 Cycle 6 0211821410024 0074750008 NHIA SHOVA YANG 5524 IRVING AVE N $317.89 Cycle 6 0211821420089 0077000005 RESIDENT 5524 JUDY LA $397.25 Cycle 6 0211821410104 0075120003 ESSELL DAVIS 55251AMES AVE N $156.05 Cycle 6 0211821410002 0074530004 RESIDENT 5527 HUMBOLDT AVE N $143.84 Cycle 6 0211821410023 0074740009 MARTIN GIL- SANDOVAL 5530 IRVING AVE N $161.60 Cycle 6 0211821410030 0074860005 FRANK HENRY 5533 IRVING AVE N $143.62 Cycle 6 0111821310081 0079950009 LOLA I NELSEN 5540 DUPONT AVE N $596.87 Cycle 6 0211821410021 0074720001 MORRIS DAVIES 5542 IRVING AVE N $213.25 Cycle 6 0111821320026 0078040000 DIETER KRAUSE 5543 FREMONT AVE N $396.37 Cycle 6 0111821320075 0077720206 LUMARIE OROZCO 5547 GIRARD AVE N $565.45 Cycle 6 0111821320037 0077910005 BERISSO BEKUTO 5548 GIRARD AVE N $203.02 Cycle 6 0211821310013 0077420005 MARGARET ZELEE 5548 LILAC DR N $560.23 Cycle 6 0211821420021 0076200002 RICK NESTEBY 5548 MORGAN AVE N $535.53 Cycle 6 0311821420018 0046130109 MARY ANN SNOW 5549 BROOKLYN BLVD $598.72 Cycle 5 0211821410020 0074710002 WILLIAM BAILEY 5600 IRVING AVE N $413.61 Cycle 6 0111821310111 0080970004 DAN IEL`E WACHTER 5601 CAMDEN AVE N $99.80 Cycle 6 0211821410059 0075170008 BERNADETTE ANDERSON 5603 JAMES AVE N $1,129.60 Cycle 6 0211821410006 0074580009 MICHAEL WOLF 5605 HUMBOLDT AVE N $248.75 Cycle 6 0111821310113 0080950006 YADETA MOUSSA 5606 ALDRICH AVE N $579.82 Cycle 6 0111821310028 0080100008 DAVE RUMPLE 5607 COLFAX AVE N $596.94 Cycle 6 0111821310033 0080220004 MELINDA FOX 5608 COLFAX AVE N $226.26 Cycle 6 0111821320068 0077540000 JOHN D HANSON 5610 HUMBOLDT AVE N $185.41 Cycle 6 0311821310009 0048040009 MICHELE KLEIN 5611 INDIANA AVE N $68.47 Cycle 5 0211821310010 0077390000 ESTHER KAMARA 5612 LILAC DR N $153.71 Cycle 6 0111821310027 0080110007 KATHLEEN HUNTER 5615 COLFAX AVE N $572.60 Cycle 6 0311821310086 0047720007 DEB OLSON 5615 HALIFAX AVE N $338.40 Cycle 5 0211821420006 0075830007 TASIANA WHEELER 5617 LOGAN AVE N .$56.05 Cycle 6 0211821410016 0074670008 ANGELA WARREN 5624 IRVING AVE N $245.55 Cycle 6 0111821320004 0079800006 JESSE SALAZAR 5625 DUPONT AVE N $680.82 Cycle 6 0111821320022 0079090004 AMINA DIOURY 5625 FREMONT AVE N $627.57 Cycle 6 0211821410079 0075610003 CHRISTOPHER HAMMOND 5626 LOGAN AVE N $284.89 Cycle 6 0111821310096 0080500009 RESIDENT 5630 BRYANT AVE N $517.85 Cycle 6 0211821310007 0077360003 GARY FORD 5630 LILAC DR N $539.84 Cycle 6 0111821310037 0080430009 TAVIA ANDERSON 5631 BRYANT AVE N $767.71 Cycle 6 0211821410048 0074990000 MORRICE FADINA 5632 JAMES AVE N $147.17 Cycle 6 0211821420005 0075840006 FRANCISCO CAJINA 5633 LOGAN AVE N $226.63 Cycle 6 0111821310015 0080140004 OVALL ROOFING & CONSTRUCTION 5637 COLFAX AVE N $74.24 Cycle 6 0111821320017 0079540008 LECESTER GLOVER 5642 EMERSON AVE N $616.01 Cycle 6 0111821320076 0077490008 CARLOS ZHAGUI MOGROVEJO 5642 HUMBOLDT AVE N $149.09 Cycle 6 0111821320043 0077860002 DARYL GRAVES 5646 GIRARD AVE N $151.61 Cycle 6 0111821320047 0077480009 MEGHAN KLINE 5650 HUMBOLDT AVE N $157.49 Cycle 6 0111821320001 0079840002, JULIO C SEGURA 5651 DUPONT AVE N $1,205.40 Cycle 6 0211821410053 0075230000 JENNIFER DILLON -JONES 5651 JAMES AVE N $564.99 Cycle 6 0311821420017 0047210009 ROBERT BATTA 5655 BROOKLYN BLVD $621.77 Cycle 5 021182141 0068 0075560000 RORY MYSLIWIEC 5659 KNOX AVE N $536.23 Cycle 6 0111821240062 0091760001 JANET JOHNSON 5700 BRYANT AVE N $641.85 Cycle 4 0311821240007 0048100001 MICHAEL F ONEILL 5701 HALIFAX AVE N $716.18 Cycle _5 0311821230002 0049610008 BRIAN ANDERSON 5701 MAJOR AVE N $462.98 Cycle 5 0111821240106 0094300003 WILLIAM R FULLER 5705 CAMDEN AVE N $494.43 Cycle 4 0211821140078 0087140002 RYANNE LINK 5707 IRVING AVE N $725.16 Cycle 4 0111821230016 0088220001 EDYTHE G POTTER 5712 GIRARD AVE N $634.82 Cycle 4 0211821140008 0086540004 PAO "ZE" THAO 5715 KNOX AVE N $611.24 Cycle 4 0111821230032 0089220000 SAMUEL OPARE -ADDO 5725 EMERSON AVE N $632.05 Cycle 4 0211821140092 0087460004 DAWN M FLORY 5727 HUMBOLDT AVE N $569.59 Cycle 4 0311821230004 0049560005 JUDY CABRAL 5727•MAJOR AVE N $689.86 Cycle 5 0111821240045 0091780009 RENAE SAUTER 5728 BRYANT AVE N $291.11 Cycle 4 0211821140093 0087190007 DEXTER WILLIAMS 5728 IRVING AVE N $563.95 Cycle 4 0111821230034 0088460003 ORTENCIA RAMIREZ 5730 FREMONT AVE N $630.80 Cycle 4 0211821140039 0086630003 JEFFREY LEWIS 5732 KNOX AVE N $635.72 Cycle 4 0111821230035 0088470002 WILLIAM N ONYSHUK 5736 FREMONT AVE N $108.38 Cycle 4 0311821130071 0044500006 SHAWN M BROWN 5737 DREW AVE N $694.27 Cycle 5 0111821230088 0088360005 JACKIE PERRY 5737 GIRARD AVE N $320.08 Cycle 4 0111821240047 0091640005 LEANNE DIMOND 5741 BRYANT AVE N $247.95 Cycle 4 0211821140064 0086920008 DEEDEE BERGQUIST 5742 JAMES AVE N $620.66 Cycle 4 0111821230029 0089190005 RANDALLJOHNSON 5743 EMERSON AVE N $721.15 Cycle 4 0211821140100 0086370105 SAEED JIBRELL 5744 LOGAN AVE N $710.26 Cycle 4 0111821240043 0091810004 HAROLD J SCOTT 5750 BRYANT AVE N $114.46 Cycle 4 0111821240049 0091620007 JOHN E KELLEY 5759 BRYANT AVE N $611.83 Cycle 4 0311821130019 0040680000 TONY BUSS 5800 DREW AVE N $81.48 Cycle 5 0111821240025 0090050008 AMOS GUAR 5800 DUPONT AVE N $695.26 Cycle 4 0111821230098 0089330007 ANTHONY MORRIS 5800 EMERSON AVE N $1,125.77 Cycle 4 0311821230027 0049280307 SUSAN M JOHNSON 5805 SHORES DR $146.68 Cycle 5 0211821140050 0086940006 WILLIAM STAGE 5806 JAMES AVE N $632.50 Cycle 4 0311821240113 0043610004 SARAH BOHRER 5806 JUNE AVE N $648.41 Cycle 5 0111821230096 0089890000 CORINNE TIFFANY 5807 DUPONT AVE N $681.01 Cycle 4 0111821230075 0089170007 CHEETARAH 5807 EMERSON AVE N $615.20 Cycle 4 0311821240103 0042860006 TIM DALY 5807 HALIFAX AVE N $611.67 Cycle 5 0211821140021 0086490002 DEAN DUNN 5807 KNOX AVE N $625.67 Cycle 4 0111821240026 0090060007 KIMBERLY LACHAPELLE 5808 DUPONT AVE N $707.07 Cycle 4 0111821230078 0088500006 THOMAS LYMAN 5808 FREMONT AVE N $513.49 Cycle 4 0311821230039 0049240202 RE COOPER 5811 LAKE CURVE LA $566.45 Cycle 5 0311821240112 0043600005 JEFF BACON 5812 JUNE AVE N $479.43 Cycle 5 0311821130032 0040830001 CHRISTANYA WILLIAMS 5814 EWING AVE N $125.86 Cycle 5 0311821130037 0042690007 CARLOS LEON 5815 EWING AVE N $625.60 Cycle 5 0211821140065 0087400000 CHESTER JULIN 5815 HUMBOLDT AVE N $468.86 Cycle 4 0111821240027 0090070006 TIMOTHY DEHN 5816 DUPONT AVE N $678.80 Cycle 4 i 0111821240022 0090760002 TROY DAVIS 5817 COLFAX AVE N $156.45 Cycle 4 0111821230045 0088090008 ABDI OSMAN 5819 FREMONT AVE N $662.94 Cycle 4 0311821230034 0049270605 CPI HOUSING FUND 5819 SHORES DR $160.99 Cycle 5 0111821230093 0089860003 PAL YANG 5825 DUPONT AVE N $189.74 Cycle 4 0111821240110 0091570004 JUAN F ACOSTA 5827 BRYANT AVE N $704.87 Cycle 4 0311821230014 0043680007 MATTHEW BENNEWISE 5831 JUNE AVE N $240.24 Cycle 5 0311821230048 0049250300 JOANN GILBAUGH 5833 SHORES DR $662.28 Cycle 5 0211821230005 0039020002 LERNELL D JAMES 5836 WASHBURN AVE N $704.69 Cycle 5 0211821140098 0086730001 BILL ASHFORD 5837 JAMES AVE N $151.23 Cycle 4 0311821140002 0039310007 PHULMATIE RAMDIN 5841 XERXES AVE N $639.05 Cycle 5 0211821140056 0087000008 LYNDA DUNCAN 5842 JAMES AVE N $154.00 Cycle 4 0111821240093 0091910002 RENATO JAPOR 5848 BRYANT AVE N $612.93 Cycle 4 0111821240031 0090110000 DENISE ANDERSON 5848 DUPONT AVE N $530.20 Cycle 4 0111821240094 0091540007 KATHLEEN BRENNAN 5851 BRYANT AVE N $394.98 Cycle 4 0311821220033 0049230302 GEVONEE FORD 5851 LAKE CURVE LA $597.61 Cycle 5 0311821220032 0049230203 IDA DONLEY 5853 LAKE CURVE LA $527.08 Cycle 5 0311821210081 0043540003 CODY MILLER 5900 JUNE AVE N $603.29 Cycle 5 0111821220008 0089830006 ANGEL GABRIEL AGUILAR GUERRERO 5901 DUPONT AVE N $682.16 Cycle 4 0211821220043 0038790001 JOYCE TEEKAYE 5901 VINCENT AVE N $482.96 Cycle 5 0311821110083 0039960009 PAMELA ARNESON 5901 ZENITH AVE N $625.65 Cycle 5 0111821220023 0089110003 PAO VAN 5903 EMERSON AVE N $163.77 Cycle 4 0111821210009 0093450007 JUSTIN LUNEMANN 5905 CAMDEN AVE N $674.06 Cycle 4 0311821120065 0042630003 LARRY E CARLSON 5905 EWING AVE N $154.00 Cycle 5 0311821110085 0040220005 ZACH ZAJICEK 5906 ABBOTT AVE N $259.09 Cycle 5 0311821110100 0039650006 TIMOTHY JACKSON 5907 YORK AVE N $246.31 Cycle 5 0111821210059 0090150006 KRISTEN LINDQUIST 5912 DUPONT AVE N $648.36 Cycle 4 0311821210079 0043520005 MARK K JOHNSON 5912 JUNE AVE -N $653.84 Cycle 5 0311821110117 0039340004 DEB TALATALA 5913 XERXES AVE N $701.34 Cycle 5 0311821120027 0040880006 BERNICE PENDY 5916 EWING AVE N $118.52 Cycle 5 0311821120099 0042830009 MAE GENEKPEIN 5918 ADMIRAL LA $412.03 Cycle 5 0211821220069 0038560008 PATRICIA HOLCOMB 5918 UPTON AVE N $631.47 Cycle 5 0311821210008 0042230002 GEBRETHADIK GETACHEW 5919 ADMIRAL LA $662.47 Cycle 5 0311821110116 0039350003 ELENA J MACARIO 5919 XERXES AVE N $532.32 Cycle 5 0311821120050 0042840008 JEREMIAH ANDRESEN 5924 ADMIRAL LA $395.94 Cycle 5 0 ! ! 0311821110071 0040510009 MOUNIRATOU SEGBAYA 5924 BEARD AVE N $592.76 Cycle 5 0111821210033 0092450008 JAMES CARLSON 5927 ALDRICH AVE N $314.30 Cycle 4 0111821220005 0089800009 JUSTIN HOFSETH 5927 DUPONT AVE N $653.01 Cycle 4 0311821120051 0042490002 TOURIYA DIOURY -JENKE 5928 ADMIRAL LA $817.47 Cycle 5 0111821120022 0093650002 MATTHEW JOSEPH 5930 CAMDEN AVE N $368.82 Cycle 4 0311821110125 0039540009 JOHN H STOKER 5930 YORK AVE N $308.54 Cycle 5 0311821210035 0041540005 FRANCISCO DURAN CORTES 5931 PEARSON DR $537.86 Cycle 5 0211821220020 0039100002 LEE VANG 5931 WASHBURN AVE N $274.20 Cycle 5 0311821110078 0040010000 JUDITH NDUBISI 5931 ZENITH AVE N $733.35 Cycle 5 0311821210048 0041940007 BILL FORDER 5936 HALIFAX PL $259.01 Cycle 5 0311821220020 0043780005 SOUNDRA SOMPHAENG 5937 JUNE AVE N $740.49 Cycle 5 0211821210014 0008740004 GOLDEN TIGER COMPANY 5939 JOHN MARTIN DR $715.07 Cycle 4 0111821210031 0092430000 JAMES DALEY 5941 ALDRICH AVE N $129.71 Cycle 4 0111821210018 0090630007 DUANE MURSCHEL 5943 COLFAX AVE N $563.85 Cycle 4 0111821120012 0094030006 TONY CARLSON 5945 LYNDALE AVE N $643.03 Cycle 4 0211821220017 0039130009 EVERRENE BONNICK 5949 WASHBURN AVE N $1,089.11 Cycle 5 0311821110001 0040470006 PAMELA DONABY 5956 BEARD AVE N $150.34 Cycle 5 0111821120025 0093680009 SCOTT FOSTER 5958 CAMDEN AVE N $122.65 Cycle 4 0311821120020 0041040006 DONALD WILLMAN 6001 BROOKLYN BLVD $568.91 Cycle 5 0311821210057 0043050003 SUZANNE BUSS 6001 HALIFAX PL $651.06 Cycle 5 0111821220083 0087790004 RESIDENT 6007 GIRARD AVE N $205.49 Cycle 4 0311821210056 0043060002 GILBERT SHANNON 6007 HALIFAX PL $525.79 Cycle 5 0111821210083 0092400003 KART JIMENEZ 6009 ALDRICH AVE N $670.71 Cycle 4 0111821430106 0082860104 PHILLIP BERGLIN 601 BELLVUE LA $946.98 Cycle 6 0111821210015 0090600000 HECTOR HERNANDEZ 6013 COLFAX AVE N $697.83 Cycle 4 0111821220051 0089010005 NICHOLAS SHOPEK 6013 EMERSON AVE N $661.50 Cycle 4 0311821120017 0041070003 GLORIA POINTER 6019 BROOKLYN BLVD $115.73 Cycle 5 0111821210066 0093340000 INANG EFFIONG EKAH 6019 CAMDEN AVE N $145.46 Cycle 4 0311821220008 0043830008 JOHN NICKELL 6019 JUNE AVE N $636.29 Cycle 5 0311821210031 0041500009 ROBERTA OLSON 6019 PEARSON DR $706.61 Cycle 5 0111821220041 0089510004 CHAD TESMER 6020 EMERSON AVE N $143.28 Cycle 4 0111821210097 0091410003 GLENN KURKE 6021 BRYANT AVE N $422.44 Cycle 4 0111821120031 0093970004 RENEE KLICK 6023 LYNDALE AVE N $763.16 Cycle 4 0311821220007 0043840007 PATRICIA SEVERSON 6025 JUNE AVE N $423.81 Cycle 5 0111821220073 0087850006 RAY WARREN 6026 GIRARD AVE N $710.80 Cycle 4 0111821220064 0088000007 LAWRENCE GRIVNA 6027 FREMONT AVE N $106.78 Cycle 4 0111821210087 0092040007 DIANA WHITAKER 6028 BRYANT AVE N $544.42 Cycle 4 0111821210124 0091080103 RUKAYAT OYEDELE - OLOGBONORI 6030 COLFAX AVE N $855.88 Cycle 4 0311821120015 0041090001 ROCKWELL INVESTMENTS LLC 6031 BROOKLYN BLVD $753.94 Cycle 5 0311821210085 0043250009 PHIA LEE 6031 HALIFAX AVE N $486.85 Cycle 5 0111821220074 0087860005 DUSTIN LEE 6032 GIRARD AVE N $693.82 Cycle 4 0111821210046 0090280001 KEAN STENBERG 6042 DUPONT AVE N $632.70 Cycle 4 0311821120085 0041140004 SEE XIONG 6042 EWING AVE N $557.04 Cycle 5 0111821210010 0090550007, JAMES C WHITE 6043 COLFAX AVE N $317.63 Cycle 4 0111821130029 0094090000 SAM MUKHERJEE 605 59TH AVE N $622.69 Cycle 4 3611921330024'0089670006 EARL WASHINGTON 6101 DUPONT AVE N $155.22 Cycle 4 3611921340023 0091100000 JOHN CUMMINGS 6106 COLFAX AVE N $920.80 Cycle 4 3611921340096 0092330002 MONICA SHOCKENCY 6107 ALDRICH AVE N $641.15 Cycle 4 3611921430023 0093890004 HONEY LOCKARD 6109 LYNDALE AVE N $261.10 Cycle 4 3311921440033 0018000004 NOU THOU VANG 6113 QUAIL AVE N $539.59 Cycle 3 3611921340012 0092090002 BILL KOLBE 6114 BRYANT AVE N $638.32 Cycle 4 3311921440045 0018270003 WILLIAM A SMITH 6119 PERRY AVE N $514.83 Cycle 3 3411921340017 0027190002 GABRIEL SAYEE 6121 FRANCE AVE N $683.19 Cycle 3 3411921330099 0025400007 HOUA LEE 6124 LEE AVE N $173.83 Cycle 3 3311921440018 0018190003 TELLY NICKENS 6124 QUAIL AVE N $105.93 Cycle 3 3611921330020 0089630000 LARRY SCHULTZ 6125 DUPONT AVE N $729.62 Cycle 4 3611921430021 0093870006 KAREN HOLTER 6127 LYN DALE AVE N $267.46 Cycle 4 3611921340014 0092110008 KELLY KROGH 6130 BRYANT AVE N $295.18 Cycle 4. 3611921340026 0091130007 TRENT BOLDT 6130 COLFAX AVE N $295.38 Cycle 4 3311921430019 0017710009 PAUL A SAARI 6130 SCOTT AVE N $510.88 Cycle 3 3311921440058 0017940002 DEMARCUS BROWN 6136 REGENT AVE N $625.31 Cycle 3 3411921330054 0024290003 MOLINNA PHOMPHACKDY 6137 LEE AVE N $157.16 Cycle 3 3311921430021 0017690003 ALVINA LOPEZ 6142 SCOTT AVE N $145.45 Cycle 3 3611921430036 0093180000 DON FETT 6200 CAMDEN AVE N $596.49 Cycle 4 3411921430007 0031900008 BRIDGEMANS 6201 BROOKLYN BLVD $2,385.87 Cycle 3 3411921430028 0037270005 RESIDENT 6207 CHOWEN AVE N $331.36 Cycle 5 3411921330051 0024260006 ROMEO GONO 6207 LEE AVE N $614.26 Cycle 3 TT AVE N $641.53 Cycle 3 3311921430024 0017660006 WILLIAM LORENTZ 6212 SCO Y 0 3311921430079 0017300009 MATTHEW SLIND 6212 UNITY AVE N $135.64 Cycle 3 3411921330028 0025890009 DEAN ONDICH 6213 KYLE AVE N $150.50 Cycle 3 3611921330006 0088800000 CARLA NELSON 6214 LILAC DR N $464.10 Cycle 4 3611921340045 0093050005 GERALDINE WILKIE 6215 CAMDEN AVE N $156.45 Cycle 4 341192133006S 0023790003 CHRISTOPHER HAGEN . 6217 MAJOR AVE N $507.91 Cycle 3 3411921330018 0026110001 TERESA A CLARK 6218 KYLE AVE N $156.05 Cycle 3 3611921330001 0088810009 SAUL HEU 6218 LILAC DR N $323.77 Cycle 4 3411921330060 0024000006 MICHAEL LUTZ 6218 MAJOR AVE N $182.03 Cycle 3 3311921440027 0018060008 OLUBUNMI OLABIYI 6219 QUAIL AVE N $649.68 Cycle 3 3611921340044 0093060004 ALFREDO HERNANDEZ 6221 CAMDEN AVE N $648.32 Cycle 4 3411921330037 0025480009 CHRISTINE BROWN 6224 LEE AVE N $628.72 Cycle 3 3611921340049 0091270001 RECIFE PROPERTIES INC 6225 BRYANT AVE N $837.22 Cycle 4 3411921340091 0027870009 JOSHUA KIDD 6225 FRANCE AVE N $741.15 Cycle 3 3411921330048 0024230009 TOM CRAMER 6225 LEE AVE N $579.74 Cycle 3 3511921330008 0035350007 ALYSSA WILSON 6228 BROOKLYN DR $528.50 Cycle 5 3411921330020 0026130009 RAUL SIGALA PRADO 6230 KYLE AVE N $129.41 Cycle 3 3411921330036 0025490008 JASON STANFORD 6230 LEE AVE N $710.04 Cycle 3 3611921340079 0092180001 LUIS QUINTUNA 6234 BRYANT AVE N $669.19 Cycle 4 3411921330061 0023750007 JASON BLANSKI 6241 MAJOR AVE N $573.68 Cycle 3 3311921430002 0017610001 VICKI CHARLES 6242 SCOTT AVE N $571.69 Cycle 3 0111821130042 0093600007 LANETTE LAWVER 625 59TH AVE N $294.19 Cycle 4 3311921420116 0022210003 JOAN BOURASA 6300 UNITY AVE N $101.68 Cycle 3 3411921420007 0031820008 DONALD M BLOM 6301 BROOKLYN BLVD $433.92 Cycle 3 3411921310047 0028370009 JAMES HESTER 6301 INDIANA AVE N $652.59 Cycle 3 3411921420009 0031730009 PATTI LAUER 6306 FRANCE AVE N $82.00 Cycle 3 3411921320085 0025530001 TAYLOR MCDONALD 6306 LEE AVE N $229.02 Cycle 3 3411921310020 0031700002 MIKEAL ABBOTT 6307 FRANCE AVE N $139.40 Cycle 3 3511921320085 0034080001 NICOLE STEWART 6309 BROOKLYN DR $72.22 Cycle 5 3411921320081 0025810007 GILFORD SUNDEEN 6313 KYLE AVE N $246.30 Cycle 3 3311921410044 0022500007 WILLIAM A HILL 6313 ORCHARD AVE N $677.65 Cycle 3 3511921320052 0034350008 DENNIS SMALL 6319 BROOKLYN DR $622.86 Cycle 5 3311921410077 0020610006 ZOZANNE DIZAYEE 6319 PERRY AVE N $423.12 Cycle 3 3611921320066 0098810007 BOBBI WILLIAMS 6324 HUMBOLDT AVE N $426.18 Cycle 4 3411921420004 0031780004 NHI FUNG 6325 BROOKLYN BLVD $142.73 Cycle 3 3411921410034 0033160002 CHADROUTIE RAMDIN 6325 XERXES AVE N $397.44 Cycle 5 3611921420020 0000930108 CROWN BRAWLEY LLC 6330 CAMDEN AVE N $2,184.06 Cycle 4 3411921320662 0026420004 ALAN MILLER 6331 JUNE AVE N $506.05 Cycle 3 3311921410113 0021100007 MICHELLE MARES 6332 REGENT AVE N $574.30 Cycle 3 3311921420030 0021250000 TROY BAKER 6333 REGENT AVE N $599.48 Cycle 3 3311921410015 0022590008 ADAN C DOMINQUIZ 6336 ORCHARD AVE N $290.10 Cycle 3 3611921320002 0099750004 LUCAS CARPENTER 6337 DUPONT AVE N $563.39 Cycle 4 3611921320063 0099020002 TANYA HAYES 6337 GIRARD AVE N $312.65 Cycle 4 3611921320050 0099110001 ANGELA WUENSCH 6400 GIRARD AVE N $891.85 Cycle 4 3311921410017 0022610004 BEE YANG 6400 ORCHARD AVE N $238.76 Cycle 3 3411921320008 0023220001 JOSEPH SCHORN 6401 LEE AVE N $616.04 Cycle 3 3611921310004 0000060005 SHARI MANIER 6406 COLFAX AVE N $727.64 Cycle 4 3611921320029 0099370001 SAMIR KAKISH 6406 FREMONT AVE N $83.58 Cycle 4 3411921310074 0028630006 MOHAMMAD KALAM 6406 INDIANA AVE N $461.30 Cycle 3 3411921320101 0026250005 CALVIN LEE 6406 KYLE AVE N $171.05 Cycle 3 3311921410018 0022620003 LEONARD SCOTT 6406 ORCHARD AVE N $585.57 Cycle 3 3511921310013 0034690007 MOHAMED D HASSAN 6407 BROOKLYN DR $130.87 Cycle 5 3411921320114 0025740006 DENNIS WELLS 6407 KYLE AVE N $732.25 Cycle 3 3411921320007 0023210002 JEREMY BOUCHER 6407 LEE AVE N $211.40 Cycle 3 3311921410071 0020550004 GARY DAVIS 6407 PERRY AVE N $267.48 Cycle 3 3411921320028 0022870004 GUILLERMO JIMENEZ 6412 NOBLE AVE N $198.44 Cycle 3 3311921410055 0022320000 MARY ROONEY 6412 PERRY AVE N $568.24 Cycle 3 3611921320017 0099710008 DANA BAILEY 6413 DUPONT AVE N $620.77 Cycle 4 3411921320097 0026370001 ANGELA MARQUES 6413 JUNE AVE N $571.04 Cycle 3311921410006 0022740009 SUSAN BATES 6413 NOBLE AVE N $180.78 Cycle 3 3411921310106 0030150001 ARENA LEARNING CTR 6415 BROOKLYN BLVD $4,599.92 Cycle 3 3411921310071 0028600009 JEREMY ZIEBARTH 6419 MARLIN DR $269.25 Cycle 3 3411921320014 0023120003 CHARLES HARGROVE 6424 MAJOR AVE N $680.16 Cycle 3 3311921410108 0021140201 MICHAEL LAFAVE 6424 REGENT AVE N $635.39 Cycle 3 3311921410004 0022720001 GERALD R RAMALEY 6425 NOBLE AVE N $143.84 Cycle 3 3311921420037 0021360007 THONG YANG 6425 SCOTT AVE N $689.00 Cycle 3 3611921320036 0099160006 ROB DARSOW 6430 GIRARD AVE N $650.96 Cycle 4 3611921320044 0098900006 TODD DOONAN 6430 HUMBOLDT AVE N $254.77 Cycle 4 3411921320019 0022950004 JON L HUDLOW 6431 MAJOR AVE N $146.06 Cycle 3 • • , 3311921410067 0020510008 LUIS MUNOZ 6431 PERRY AVE N $164.10 Cycle 3 3411921310079 0028680001 HARRY NARINE 6436 INDIANA AVE N $90.50 Cycle 3 3411921320093 0026330005 TINA ROBINSON 6437 JUNE AVE N $179.59 Cycle 3 3611921410009 0001360008 RYAN MCGINNIS 6448 WILLOW LA N $155.22 Cycle 4 3411921130084 0030370005 MAE PROPERTIES LLP 6500 BROOKLYN BLVD $2,036.73 Cycle 3 3511921310009 0035060002 MARK HACKETT 6501 BROOKLYN DR $577.23 Cycle 5 3411921130070 0031080009 SOLANGE DAVIS - RIVERA 6512 CHOWEN AVE N $423.70 Cycle 3 3411921130064 0031140001 JAY VAUGHAN 6519 BEARD AVE N $135.18 Cycle 3 3311921130079 0018860001 RESIDENT 6523 UNITY AVE N $588.50 Cycle 3 3311921130014 0019870009 JED RANCOUR 6524 UNITY AVE N $657.61 Cycle 3 3311921140002 0029010000 RESIDENT 6530 ORCHARD AVE N $129.41 Cycle 3 3411921130045 0030970002 EBRIMA TOURAY 6537 CHOWEN AVE N $621.05 Cycle 3 3411921130042 0030610004 THERESA SAYE 6538 EWING AVE N $302.16 Cycle 3 3411921130060 0031180007 JANIS SALO 6543 BEARD AVE N $629.78 'Cycle 3 3611921130128 0055430008 ABHISHEK MEHTA 6543 RIVERWOOD LA $884.85 Cycle 2 3611921130105 0056720209 ANTHONY DOUGLAS 6601 CAMDEN DR $294.06 Cycle 2 3411921240056 0030480101 MIKE BELL 6607 FRANCE AVE N $554.83 Cycle 3 3611921240058 0058810008 SHEILAJOHNSON 6610 COLFAX AVE N $666.77 Cycle 2 3611921130096 0056710200 JAMIE EDWARDS 6620 CAMDEN DR $579.55 Cycle 2 3611921240016 0058230009 TROY KOUBSKY 6626 BRYANT AVE N $839.53 Cycle 2 3611921240045 0059350004 ALYN EASTIN 6642 DUPONT AVE N $183.09 Cycle 2 3611921130087 0056700201 CYRUS MCCLAIN 6644 CAMDEN DR $63.77 Cycle 2 3611921240052 0058470001 MARIAM IBRAHIM 6645 BRYANT AVE N $473.56 Cycle 2 3411921120017 0007650003 WILLY FRANKLYN 6700 EWING AVE N $714.21 Cycle 1 3311921110087 0001640000 DEBORAH SALITERMAN 6700 QUAIL AVE N $271.24 Cycle 1 3511921110058 0060820300 LISA JOHNSON 6704 IRVING PL N $581.88 Cycle 2 3411921120026 0007950007 MICHELLE MURCH 6707 DREW AVE N $559.38 Cycle 1 3311921110078 0001360005 DARIUS GILES 6707 QUAIL AVE N $787.46 Cycle 1 3611921220050 0059800305 KHALID ELJARUSHI 6712 EMERSON AVE N $699.63 Cycle 2 3311921120044 0000660009 STACY DAVIS 6712 TOLEDO AVE N $736.28 Cycled 3611921210049 0059060009 KENNETH KING 6713 COLFAX AVE N $849.05 Cycle 2 3311921120038 0000480002 RESIDENT 6713 TOLEDO AVE N $596.76 Cycle 1 3411921210012 0007320003 PAUL GALLUP 6715 FRANCE AVE N $712.81 Cycle 1 3611921210093 0061160003 LAKIESHA FLY 6718 ALDRICH AVE N $61.86 Cycle 2 3611921210079 0061010000 TIMOTHY FRANKLIN 6718 BRYANT AVE N $664.35 Cycle 2 3611921210100 0061220005 GREG FORSBERG 6719 CAMDEN AVE N $186.68 Cycle 2 3411921120024 0007930009 NANCY XIONG 6719 DREW AVE N $156.45 Cycle 1 3311921110076 0001380003 DENNA RUCKER 6719 QUAIL AVE N $157.67 Cycle 1 3611921120056 0056780005 KIM CARTIER 67215TH ST N $118.74 Cycle 2 3411921120013 0007690009 ELLEN HANSEN 6724 EWING AVE N $151.56 Cycle 1 3611921120015 0055100007 TERRANCE MAGALIS 6724 WILLOW LA N $659.21 Cycle 2 3311921120100 0001070000 KRISTEN SCHMITTOU 6725 REGENT AVE N $509.18 Cycle 1 3411921210019 0007130006 BOBBY FIELDS 6728 GRIMES AVE N $291.75 Cycle 1 3311921110098 0001290004 KAREN HAVERTY 6730 REGENT AVE N $143.01 Cycle 1 3311921120075 0000970002 ROBERT M OLSON 6730 SCOTT AVE N $74.65 Cycle 1 3611921220035 0060050007 JOHN E LEE 6733 EMERSON AVE N $225.54 Cycle 2 3611921210037 0057720000 FRANCES AKINDELE 6736 COLFAX AVE N $778.86 Cycle 2 3311921110081 0001580008 RESIDENT 6736 QUAIL AVE N $2,868.68 Cycle 1 3311921120040 0000700003 KIMBERLY SYKES 6736 TOLEDO AVE N $780.56 Cycle 1 3311921110096 0001270006 DIANA WILLIAMS 6742 REGENT AVE N $198.19 Cycle 1 3311921110015 0002170007 IRNESTO GUERRERO 6800 ORCHARD AVE N $675.48 Cycle 1 3311921110065 0001560000 KAREN ANTHONY 6800 QUAIL AVE N $666.35 Cycle 1 3411921120047 0007880006 MICHAEL MILLER 6801 DREW AVE N $790.54 Cycle 1 3311921120072 0000790004 KAREN EDEBURN 6801 SCOTT AVE N $688.94 Cycle 1 3611921220079 0060170102 GREGORYTONGE 6805 FREMONT PL $165.47 Cycle 2 3411921110038 0009490002 EUGENE SUGGS 6806 BEARD AVE N $733.24 Cycle 1 3411921120049 0007740002 SAMUEL B BODLEY 6806 EWING AVE N $127.00 Cycle 1 3411921120069 0007440009 RESIDENT 6806 FRANCE AVE N $617.51 Cycle 1 3411921120046 0007870007 CARMEN CATTLEDGE 6807 DREW AVE N $792.42 Cycled 3411921120050 0007750001 GEORGE MARSHALL 6812 EWING AVE N $633.35 Cycle 1 3311921110013 0002150009 RAUL ERICKSON 6812 ORCHARD AVE N $620.72 Cycle 1 3311921120062 0000920007 SHANNON GARRITY 6812 SCOTT AVE N $150.55 Cycle 1 3411921110061 0009290006 ELIZABETH PARADES PAULINO 6812 ZENITH AVE N $531.48 Cycle 1 3611921210010 0058040002 JOE FALKOWSKI 6816 BRYANT AVE N $479.86 Cycle 2 3611921220075 0060190803 RIGOBERT NZIMI 6816 FREMONT PL N $274.30 Cycle 2 3611921220022 0059760004 SALIMATU BUTLER 6818 EMERSON AVE N $718.61 Cycle 2 3411921120051 0007760000 LORRAINE SENESCALL 6818 EWING AVE N $206.63 Cycle 1 3311921110062 0001530003 JOEY C NIENABER 6818 QUAIL AVE N $693.75 Cycle 1 3611921220031 0060090003 JOHN SOLOMON 6819 EMERSON AVE N $769.46 Cycle 2 3611921210032 0058110003 LEMUEL PORTER 6823 BRYANT AVE N $635.54 Cycle 2 3411921120043 0007840000 DREANNA ALSTON 6825 DREW AVE N $619.68 Cycle 1 3611921220072 0060190506 ZOUA LEE 6828 FREMONT PL N $61.81 Cycle 2 3411921120042 0007830001 DAVID GARDNER 6831 DREW AVE N $152.78 Cycle 1 3611921210015 0059160007 RESIDENT 6835 COLFAX AVE N $99.96 Cycle 2 3311921110009 0002110003 ROBERT SHAW 6836 ORCHARD AVE N $720.79 Cycle 1 3311921120066 0000850006 JESSICA STEGBAUER 6837 SCOTT AVE N $656.14 Cycle 1 3611921220101 0060172306 KEVIN P GUSTAFSON 6839 FREMONT PL N $573.64 Cycle 2 3311921110038 0001790003 MICK MAGUIRE 6839 PERRY AVE N $882.13 Cycle 1 3411921120028 0008110007 MICHAEL HOEMBERG 6842 DREW AVE N $509.82 Cycle 1 2611921430105 0010590003 GENARO M VASQUEZ 6900 OLIVER AVE N $653.17 Cycle 2 2611921430018 0011260002 COMFORT BROPLEH 6901 MORGAN AVE N $555.26 Cycle 2 2711921330030 0004020002 SCOTT PHILLIPS 6906 MAJOR AVE N $169.88 Cycle 1 2811921430009 0006100000 PHILL SMOGER 6906 SCOTT AVE N $734.21 Cycle 1 2711921430102 0009960004 JOEL VANDENBOOM 6907 PALMER LAKE DR W $642.79 Cycle 1 2811921430049 0006380305 REBEKAH POULIOT 6908 UNITY AVE N $563.72 Cycle 1 2711921340013 0014230005 WANDA SANVIK 6913 HALIFAX AVE N $575.02 Cycle 1 2611921430016 0011280000 KIM BOIKE 6913 MORGAN AVE N $289.19 Cycle 2 2811921430005 0006060006 KHADRA FARAH 6913 REGENT AVE N $190.73 Cycle 1 2711921330042 0004060008 DAN DEMPSEY 6915 MAJOR AVE N $600.32 Cycle 1 2711921330013 0003800008 DEAN LITTLE 6927 BROOKLYN BLVD $651.36 Cycle 1 2711921340039 0013130008 SONYA HERR 6930 HALIFAX AVE N $569.10 Cycle 1 2711921340021 0014170003 PAUL ROWE 6930 INDIANA AVE N $160.11 Cycle 1 2511921430032 0050080006 MARIA RAJ 6931 DALLAS RD $141.20 Cycle 2 2811921440005 0004670004 MICHAEL NACHTWEY 6931 PERRY AVE N $295.07 Cycle 1 2511921430025 0051600000 JEAN EMMANUEL 6931 WILLOW LA N $936.75 Cycle 2 2711921330035 0003970009 JONATHAN EVARTS 6936 MAJOR AVE N $715.59 Cycle 1 2711921340002 0014060006 DIANE CANFIELD 6937 INDIANA AVE N $106.78 Cycle 1 2611921440098 0012870007 BRUCE SHERWOOD 6939 IRVING AVE N $638.51 Cycle 2 2711921330102 0099992145 J & P INVESTMENTS LLC 6940 BROOKLYN BLVD $1,222.71 Cycle 1 2711921340073 0012550008 JOAN M PAVLIK ., 6942 GRIMES AVE N $476.51 Cycle 1 2711921430021 0010630000 JOHN OTTO 6943 DREW AVE N $160.11 Cycle 1 2711921430093 0011000005 DAVID WYLIE 6943 PALMER LAKE DR W $699.67 Cycle 1 2511921430007 0050510002 LUIS MORALES 7000 DALLAS RD $265.55 Cycle 2 2811921440025 0004850002 CHRIS BOWE 7000 QUAIL AVE N $161.33 Cycle 1 2511921330033 0021570002 EMMANUEL NKETAH 7001 EMERSON AVE N $272.96 Cycle 2 2811921440047 0005700008 JODI BRADFORD 7001 QUAIL AVE N $816.06 Cycle 1 2711921430044 0010390001 KARI DRISTE 7007 EWING AVE N $610.07 Cycle 1 2711921430032 0010470001 ANNA THOMAS 7012 EWING AVE N $630.57 Cycle 1 2611921440021 0014020007 PAUL CAVALLARO 7013 KNOX AVE N $684.62 Cycle 2 2811921430115 0006382806 BRENDA LTRAFTON 7017 UNITY AVE N $225.64 Cycle 1 2711921330005 0013840002 THOMAS SCHAFF 7018 BROOKLYN BLVD $101.68 Cycle 1 2611921440056 0013230003 OMAR ADAMS 7018 IRVING AVE N $604.54 Cycle 2 2611921430054 0011780009 JOYCE A JALLAH 7018 MORGAN AVE N $369.69 Cycle 2 2811921430079 0006382608 JOY REINHART 7020 UNITY AVE N $140.51 Cycle 1 25,11921330038 0021510008 ANTHONY BROWN 7024 FREMONT AVE N $662.90 Cycle 2 2811921440058 0005880008 BEST ASSETS 7024 REGENT AVE N $97.95 Cycle 1 2511921330061 0021130005 KELLY DAVIS 7025 FREMONT AVE N $640.48 Cycle 2 2611921440063 0013300004 LATRICE DAVIS 7025 HUMBOLDT AVE N $651.11 Cycle 2 2611921430042 0012020009 DR. CHIKE ONYEKABA 7025 LOGAN AVE N $157.00 Cycle 2 2711921330082 0014470007 ANDREA WALKER 7030 BROOKLYN BLVD $687.12 Cycle 1 2611921430074 0011120008 LAMAR WALKER 7030 NEWTON AVE N $151.56 Cycle 2 2511921330028 0021620005 AGHARESE AGHAYEDO 7031 EMERSON AVE N $578.30 Cycle 2 2611921440062 0013310003 CHRIS BANGS 7031 HUMBOLDT AVE N $163.77 Cycle 2 2611921440033 0013090001 ANNABELLE GREGORY 7031 JAMES AVE N $592.35 Cycle 2 2711921430002 0010750006 JEFFREY GRANDELL 7036 DREW AVE N $156.45 Cycle 1 2711921430014 0010560009 TIMOTHY J GRAHAM 7037 DREW AVE N $644.44 Cycle 1 2511921330059 0021150003 EDWINA MCGILL 7037 FREMONT AVE N $658.35 Cycle 2 2711921330084 0014480006 YA VANG 7038 BROOKLYN BLVD $936.91 Cycle 1 2611921440004 0012370008 MARGARET GREEN 7042 LOGAN AVE N $169.88 Cycle 2 2711921420021 0010190005 ALONZO MCCLENDON 7048 FRANCE AVE N $504.29 Cycle 1 2511921320088 0021650002 DAVID FIEDLER 7049 EMERSON AVE N $884.88 Cycle 2 2711921330091 0014510109 ALBRECHT LTD 7066 BROOKLYN BLVD $734.99 Cycle 1 2811921430140 0006389009 ROGER ADJETE 7073 UNITY AVE N $173.54 Cycle 1 2811921430141 0006388902 ROSIE TIMS 7077 UNITY AVE N $130.47 Cycle 1 2511921320064 0020160003 SUSANNAH K GONO 7100 HUMBOLDT AVE N $219.46 Cycle 2 2811921410197 0004240105 MS. JOHNNIE HARVEY 7100 QUAIL CIR W $356.32 Cycle 1 • • 0 0 2511921320040 0020510009 JAMES PAJIBO 7101 GIRARD AVE N $104.72 Cycle 2 2711921310042 0013300007 DIONYSIUS APOSTOLOU 7106 HALIFAX AVE N $582.43 Cycle 1 2711921320103 0015730003 BRETT ROBIDEAU 7112 JUNE AVE N $658.58 Cycle 1 2811921410021 0004180202 CHRISTOPHER KILBURN 7112 PERRY PL $510.61 Cycle 1 2511921320038 0020530007 FLORA HILL 7113 GIRARD AVE N $591.31 Cycle 2 2711921320115 0015690009 BETH CARTER 7113 JUNE AVE N $705.00 Cycle 1 2711921320013 0015260001 DELARNAS MCGHEE 7118 LEE AVE N $1,033.06 Cycle 1 2711921320035 0015050006 PA N VANG 7118 MAJOR AVE N $168.66 Cycle 1 2611921420047 0011070005 MARK EDSON 7118 NEWTON AVE N $735.65 Cycle 2 2711921310037 0012920003 YAI GBAMY 7119 GRIMES AVE N $180.67 Cycle 1 2511921320085 0021420000 LARRY LEAKS 7124 FREMONT AVE N $764.91 Cycle 2 2711921310045 0013330004 ROBERTTHATCHER 7124 HALIFAX AVE N $455.10 Cycle 1 0111821240035 0092650003 NATASHA L GUNDERSEN 713 58TH AVE N $680.62 Cycle 4 2711921320093 0015520008 BRETT CORBITT 7130 KYLE AVE N $649.98 Cycle 1 2811921420013 0006387805 GERALDINE KAPEY 7133 UNITY AVE N $286.11 Cycle 1 2511921320087 0021400002 GREG LARSON 7136 FREMONT AVE N $601.60 Cycle 2 2611921420050 0011040008 PAUL PHILBEN 7136 NEWTON AVE N $163.77 Cycle 2 2711921310050 0012250005 DR. FAYE LARRY 7137 FRANCE AVE N $586.22 Cycle 1 2711921310034 0012890008 TERESA BLANCHARD 7137 GRIMES AVE N $519.64 Cycle 1 2711921310064 0012710008 TONI JESINOSKI 7142 GRIMES AVE N $674.07 Cycle 1 2811921420037 0006394207 JULIE M SAMPSON 7176 UNITY AVE N $607.56 Cycle 1 2811921420038 0006394306 LEE STEWART 7180 UNITY AVE N $602.65 Cycle 1 2811921420097 0006400103 KIMBERLY CARPENTER 7189 UNITY AVE N $576.27 Cycle 1 2711921320048 0014590002 DEWEY R LEDIN 7200 NOBLE AVE N $883.30 Cycle 1 2611921420076 0018860000 MARY ZILKE 7201 NEWTON AVE N $628.25 Cycle 2 2811921410150 0004370308 FAIZA LKHAN 7201 PERRY CT E $314.87 Cycle 1 2811921410090 0004360309 BARBARA LATHAM 7204 PERRY CT E $697.67 Cycle 1 2511921320080 0021670000 DOROTHY WHITE 7207 EMERSON AVE N $653.54 Cycle 2 2511921320031 0020580002 VEOPHETLANG KHAMVONGSOUK 7207 GIRARD AVE N $308.15 Cycle 2 2811921410182 0004320105 TRINA TAYLOR 7207 PERRY CT E $811.67 Cycle 1 2811921420101 0006400509 CHARLEEN MALLORY 7209 UNITY AVE N $613.23 Cycle 1 2511921420039 0050420004 DAN WHITTENBURG 7211 DALLAS RD $776.25 Cycle 2 2511921310040 0023010007 KEVIN J O'HARA 7212 ALDRICH CT $657.09 Cycle 2 2511921320056 0020060005 WILLIAM CORWIN 7212 HUMBOLDT AVE N $691.69 Cycle 2 2711921320039 0015090002 SHELIA HOLLEY 7212 MAJOR AVE N $423.23 Cycle 1 2511921320102 0022300003 ELLIOT 0 SUNDLEE 7213 DUPONT AVE N $625.53 Cycle 2 2711921310105 0015870007 STEPHEN LONG 7213 INDIANA AVE N $168.00 Cycle 1 2811921420102 0006400608 BRIAN UHRIG 7213 UNITY AVE N $143.01 Cycle 1 2511921310083 0022920008 ALYATTU CAPEHART 7217 CAMDEN AVE N $478.03 Cycle 2 2511921320109 0021880005 JOHN A LITZAU 7218 EMERSON AVE N $771.11 Cycle 2 2711921320007 0015320003 MARTIN PERUSSE 7218 LEE AVE N $305.37 Cycle 1 2511921310049 0023150001 RESIDENT 7219 BRYANT AVE N $619.62 Cycle 2 2711921310021 0012840003 JAMES EDWARDS 7219 GRIMES AVE N $544.45 Cycle 1 2511921320005 0021340000 YOLANDA MARIN 7224 FREMONT AVE N $635.04 Cycle 2 2811921410163 0004290308 KATIE JANASZAK 7226 PERRY CT E $460.90 Cycle 1 2511921320012 0021270009 STEPHEN R GANDSEY 7229 FREMONT AVE N $593.33 Cycle 2 2511921320052 0020020108 ADAM VERZALIK 7234 HUMBOLDT AVE N $776.71 Cycle 2 2611921420100 0010240005 LEROYCE WALKERFIELDS 7237 OLIVER AVE N $337.01 Cycle 2 2511921410039 0051020001 ALIRENA BROWN 7237 WILLOW LA N $608.12 Cycle 2 2511921420032 0050700009 LOUIS A SIMBANA PEDRO 7242 DALLAS RD $681.44 Cycle 2 2511921310045 0022790005 DORIS JEFFERSON 7243 BRYANT AVE N $656.91 Cycle 2 2711921310001 0012160006 KERRY GOVAN 7243 FRANCE AVE N $633.63 Cycle 1 0111821310006 0081040005 GERALD MELLESMOEN 80157TH AVE N $156.11 Cycle 6 0111821310150 0080620005 MIKE DONNELLY 806 55TH AVE N $550.62 Cycle 6 3611921240013 0058200002 KATHY WILLIAMS 81167TH AVE N $617.10 Cycle 2 2511921340005 0023410009 ERIN WIXSTEN 824 69TH AVE N $166.69 Cycle 2* 2511921310011 0022680008 DASHINA POWELL -WHITE 824 WOODBINE LA $496.33 Cycle 2 0111821310084 0080870006 JULIE SUCKOW 827 57TH AVE N $146.06 Cycle 6 2511921340009 0023480002 CAROLYN ITTNER 86170TH AVE N $143.01 Cycle 2 2511921340015 0023510006 ROBERT B LOGAN 88170TH AVE N $662.16 Cycle 2 0111821310009 0080460006 LAWRENCE PARRET 907 57TH AVE N $348.03 Cycle 6 2511921310014 0022500008 JOHN MASTER 907 73RD AVE N $281.56 Cycle 2 844 $419,519.74 Member introduced the following resolution and moved its adoption: RESOLUTION NO. RESOLUTION CALLLING FOR A PUBLIC HEARING ON PROPOSED SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS FOR DELINQUENT PUBLIC UTILITY SERVICE ACCOUNTS BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Brooklyn Center that: 1. A hearing shall be held on the 12th day of September, 2011, in City Hall at 7:00 PM or as soon thereafter as the matter may be heard, to pass upon the proposed assessments for Delinquent Public Utility Service Accounts. 2. The City Clerk, with the assistance of the Director of Fiscal & Support Services, shall forthwith prepare assessment rolls for the above charges and shall keep them on file and open to inspection by any interested persons. 3. The City Clerk is directed to cause a notice of the Public Hearing on the proposed assessment to be published once in the official newspaper at least two weeks prior to the hearing. • 4. The City Clerk shall cause mailed notice to be given to the owner of each parcel described in such assessment rolls not less than two weeks prior to the hearing. August 22, 2011 Date Mayor ATTEST: City Clerk The motion for the adoption of the foregoing resolution was duly seconded by member and upon vote being taken thereon, the following voted in favor thereof: and the following voted against the same: whereupon said resolution was declared duly passed and adopted. • Sewer Rate Impacts City Council Work Session Monday, 22 August 2011 Fixed Base Charge: 9.83 18.12 36.25 Commodity Chagre: 2.65 3.26 2.96 2.22 Flat Rate Charge: 67.76 Flat 12%/88% 20%/80% 40%/60% Winter Qtr. Rate New New New Use 2012 Charge Charge Charge Residential Family (5) 19 67.76 71 .77 74.36 78.43 Couple 21 67.76 78.29 80.28 82.87 Couple 6 67.76 29.39 35.88 49.57 Family (5) + visitors 33 67.76 117.41 115.80 109.51 Family (4) 26 67.76 94.59 95.08 93.97 Couple 12 67.76 48.95 53.64 62.89 Single Person 4 67.76 22.87 29.96 45.13 Break Even Consumption: 17.77 16.77 14.19 Manufacturing 64 169.60 218.47 207.56 178.33 Manufacturing 135 357.75 449.93 417.72 335.95 Restaurant 265 702.25 873.73 802.52 624.55 Bus Garage 1 ,251 3,315.15 4,088.09 3,721 .08 2,813.47 $4,000.00 $3,500.00 $3,000.00 $2,500.00 -Base Rate 9.83 $2,000.00 -Base Rate 18.12 Base Rate 36.25 -Flat Rate 67.76 $1,500.00 $1,000.00 $500.00 $- 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65 70 75 80 85 90 95 100 $300.00 $250.00 $200.00 Base Rate 9.83 $150.00 .Base Rate 18.12 Base Rate 36.25 Flat Rate 67.76 $100.00 $50.00 0 5 10 15 20 25 • City Council Agenda Item No. 6f • COUNCIL ITEM MEMORANDUM DATE: August 16, 2011 TO: Curt Boganey, City Manager FROM: Steve Lillehaug, Director of Public Works /City Engineer S f SUBJECT: Resolution Accepting Bid and Awarding a Contract, Improvement Project No. 2011 -10, West Palmer Park Building Replacement Recommendation: It is recommended that the City Council consider approval of the resolution accepting bid and awarding a contract, Improvement Project No. 2011 -10, West Palmer Park Building Replacement. Background: Bids for the West Palmer Park Building Replacement, Project No. 2011 -10 contract were received and opened on August 11, 2011. The bidding results are tabulated below: BIDDER TOTAL Parkos Construction $234,400.00 Ebert Construction $247,200.00 Hunerberg Construction $251,766.00 American Liberty Construction $272,000.00 Michlitsch Builders $278,900.00 L.S. Black Constructors $280,000.00 Gopher State Contractors $296,016.00 Lund Martin Construction $308,950.00 C & M Construction $311,800.00 GA Construction $321,000.00 Langer Construction $324,000.00 Merrimac Construction $348,690.00 Architect's Estimate $296,000.00 Of the twelve (12) bids received, the lowest bid of $234,400.00 was submitted by Parkos Construction. However, Parkos Construction has indicated they made an error in their bid and due to their claimed error, the bid has been deemed not responsible. Ebert Construction from Corcoran, Minnesota with the second lowest bid of $247,200 has been declared the lowest responsible bidder. Ebert Construction has the experience, equipment and capacity to qualify as the lowest responsible bidder for the project. Budget Issues: The bid amount of $234,400.00 is a decrease from the 2011 budgeted amount (see attached Resolution — Costs and Revenue tables). The total budget contained in the 2011 Capital Improvement Plan was $300,000 and is amended to $306,580 an approximate 2.2 percent increase. Mission: Ensuring an attractive, clean, safe community that enhances the quality of life and preserves the public trust COUNCIL ITEM MEMORANDUM Council Goals: Strategic: 5. We will continue to maintain and upgrade City infrastructure improvements Ongoing: L We will provide streamlined, cost effective, quality services with limited resources I I i I I ?Yfission: Ensuring an attractive, clean, safe community that enhances the duality of fife and preserves the public trust • its adoption: Member introduced the following resolution and moved RESOLUTION NO. RESOLUTION ACCEPTING BID AND AWARDING A CONTRACT, IMPROVEMENT PROJECT NO. 2011 -10, WEST PALMER PARK BUILDING REPLACEMENT WHEREAS, pursuant to an advertisement for bids for Improvement Project No. 2011 -10, bids were received, opened, and tabulated by the City Clerk and Engineer on the 11 m day of August, 2011. Said bids were as follows: BIDDER TOTAL Parkos Construction $234,400.00 (not responsible) Ebert Construction $247,200.00 Hunerberg Construction $251,766.00 American Liberty Construction $272,000.00 Michlitsch Builders $278,900.00 L.S. Black Constructors $280,000.00 Gopher State Contractors $296,016.00 Lund Martin Construction $308,950.00 C & M Construction $311,800.00 GA Construction $321,000.00 Langer Construction $324,000.00 Merrimac Construction $348,690.00 WHEREAS, it appears that Ebert Construction of Corcoran, Minnesota is the lowest responsible bidder. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Brooklyn Center, Minnesota, that: 1. The Mayor and City Manager are hereby authorized and directed to enter into a contract with Ebert Construction of Corcoran, Minnesota in the name of the City of Brooklyn Center, for Improvement Proj ect No. 2011 -10, according to the plans and specifications therefore approved by the City Council and on file in the office of the City Engineer. RESOLUTION NO. 2. The estimated project costs and revenues areas follows: Amended COSTS CIP Budget per Low Bid Building Contract $ 240,620.00 $ 247,200.00 Miscellaneous Costs $ 28,480.00 $ 28,480.00 Contingency $ 15,000.00 $ 15,000.00 Subtotal Construction Cost $ 284,100.00 $ 290,680.00 Admin/Legal/Engr. $ 15,900.00 $ 15,900.00 Total Estimated Project Cost $ 300,000.00 $ 306,580.00 Amended REVENUES CIP Budget _ per Low Bid Capital Improvements Fund (40100) $ 300,000.00 $ 306,580.00 August 22, 2011 Date Mayor ATTEST: City Clerk The motion for the adoption of the foregoing resolution was duly seconded by member and upon vote being taken thereon, the following voted in favor thereof and the following voted against the same: whereupon said resolution was declared duly passed and adopted. City Council Agenda Item No. 6g • • COUNCIL ITEM MEMORANDUM • DATE: August 16, 2011 TO: Curt Boganey, City Manager FROM: Steve Lillehaug, Director of Public Works /City Engineer 5jl- SUBJECT: Resolution Approving Final Plat for BRI MAR SECOND ADDITION Recommendation: It is recommended that the City Council consider approval of the resolution approving final plat for BRI MAR SECOND ADDITION. Background: The Brooklyn Center City Council approved the proposed preliminary plat based upon certain conditions (see attached conditions of approval, City Council Resolution No. 2011 -92). The attached final plat for BRI MAR SECOND ADDITION was developed and would combine the following existing properties: Lot 1, Block 1, Chrysler Realty Addition; Lot 1, Block 1 and Lot 2, Block 1, Bri Mar Addition and parts of Lot 3, Auditors Subdivision Number 25. The new plat will form two lots with shared parking. The applicant is now seeking final plat approval from the City Council. The final plat is recommended for approval subject to the conditions established by the City Engineer, conditions established by the City Attorney based on a review of an updated title commitment provided by • the applicant (within the past 30 days), conditions as previously approved by the City Council, and any conditions established by Hennepin County for recording of the plat documents. Budget Issues• The applicant has paid a final plat application fee of $125 and must reimburse the City for any additional engineering, administrative, legal or other fees associated with the filing and recording of the final plat. Council Goals: Strategic: 2. We will proceed aggressively with implementation of City's redevelopment plans • Mission: Ensuring an attractive, clean, safe community that enhances the quality of life and preserves the public trust its adoption: Member introduced the following resolution and moved •' RESOLUTION NO. RESOLUTION APPROVING FINAL PLAT FOR BRI MAR SECOND ADDITION WHEREAS, the Planning Commission has recommended approval for the final plat for BRI MAR SECOND ADDITION based on certain conditions as set forth in the City Council Resolution No. 2011 -92; and WHEREAS, the applicant has applied for approval of the final plat for BRI MAR SECOND ADDITION as required by City Code. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Brooklyn Center, Minnesota that the final plat for BRI MAR SECOND ADDITION is hereby approved, subject to the following conditions: 1. Conditions as previously recommended by the Planning Commission Resolution Nos. 2011 -10, and/or as revised and amended by City Council actions taken on said development's Preliminary Plan approval in accordance with City Council Resolution No. 2011 -92. 2. The final plan must incorporate the conditions of approval as indicated in the Preliminary Plan Review Memorandum dated May 20, 2011, or as required and approved by the City Engineer. 3. Property owner must provide an executed and certified recorded copy of a cross access and cross parking agreement between Lot Y and Lot 2, Block 1 of Bri Mar Second Addition. 4. Property owner must provide an executed and certified recorded copy of a shared access agreement between Lot 1 and Lot 2, Block 1 of Bri Mar Second Addition. 5. Property owner must provide an executed and certified recorded copy of an overall utility facilities easement agreement for all private utility facilities that will connect into the City's utility system. 6. Property owner must provide executed and certified recorded copies of all easements required for drainage, utility, streetscape, trail, roadway and signal system purposes. i • RESOLUTION NO. 7. Existing public easements that are being granted on the final plat must be released and terminated. 8. Evidence of title satisfactory to the City Attorney and City Engineer. 9. Any other conditions as established by Hennepin County for recording of said Final Plat. 10. Prior to release by the City of the final, approved plat, the owner must reimburse the City the full amount of legal fees incurred by the City in obtaining a review or opinion of title. August 22, 2011 Date Mayor. ATTEST: City Clerk The motion for the adoption of the foregoing resolution was duly seconded by member and upon vote being taken thereon, the following voted in favor thereof: and the following voted against the same: whereupon said resolution was declared duly passed and adopted. • i Member Dan Ryan introduced the following resolution and moved its adoption: RESOLUTION NO. 2011 -92 • RESOLUTION REGARDING DISPOSITION OF PLANNING COMMISSION APPLICATION NO. 2011-013, SUBMITTED BY LINDA MCGINTY FOR THE LUTHER COMPANIES, LLLP WHEREAS, Planning Commission Application No. 2011 =013 submitted by Linda McGin ty PanY on behalf of The Luther Company, requests LLLP re approval of a Preliminary.Plat PP approval of a subdivision to be titled.Bri Mar 2nd Addition, which is a replat of five contiguous lots .. located on the easterly side of Brooklyn Boulevard between I -94 and 60 Avenue North and addressed as 6700 Brooklyn Boulevard, 6800 Brooklyn Boulevard, 4215 69 Avenue North, and 4101 69 Avenue, 401169* Avenue North; and WHEREAS, this plat is being requested to create three (3)_ separate lots for the benefit of a new Luther Brookdale 'Honda dealership and new Toyota City of Brooklyn Center dealership; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission held'a duly called public hearing on May 26, 2011, at which time a staff report and. public testimony regarding the preliminary plat of Bri Mar 2 Addition were received; and WHEREAS, the review of this preliminary plat. submitted with Planning Application No: 2011 -013, even. with the minor lot line revisions is in general conformance with the original plat approved by the City Council on July 28, 2008, in acceptance of Planning Application No. 2008 -004; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission has determined these plat revisions are not significant enough or diminishes the original intent and desired effect in the platting of this. � g P g redevelopment site; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission determined during the review of this plat application that the building and site modifications previously approved under the: 2008 Planned Unit Development (PUD) plan as comprehended under the original Planning Application No. 2008 -005, and adopted by. the City Council under Res. No. 200881, is in substantial compliance and conformity with this approved PUD and overall development plan; and WHEREAS, the Planning Advisory Commission of the City of Brooklyn Center recommended approval of Application No. 2011 -030 submitted by Linda McGinty on behalf of Luther Companies'LLLP by adopting Planning Commission Resolution No..2011 -10 on May 26, 201.1; and WHEREAS, the City Council considered Application No. 2011 -013 at its June 13, 2011, meeting considered the- Preliminary Plat in light of all testimony received and the Plannin g Commission's recommendations. RESOLUTION NO. 2011 -92 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of. the City of Brooklyn Center that Application No. 2011 -013; submitted by Linda McGinty on behalf of Luther Companies LLLP be approved with the following conditions: 1. The final plat is subject to review and approval by the City Engineer. 2. The final plat is subject to the:.provisions of Chapter 15 of the City Ordinances. 3. Approval of this preliminary plat is contingent upon those condtions and considerations approved under Planning Commission Application No. 2008 -005 and memorialized in adopted City Council Resolotion No. 2008 -81, dated. July 28 2008. 4. Appropriate cross access and cross parking agreements and a dedication binding Lot 1, 2, . . and 3, Block 1 of Bri Mar 2 d Addition, and as approved by the City Atttorney shall be developed and filed with the titles to the property. 5. The applicant shall provide the city with an executed copy of shared access easement between the proposed Lot 1, 2 and 3, Block 1 of. Bri Mar 2 ' ' Addition prior to final plat approval to be filed with the titles to the properties. 6. The applicant shall execute all easements required by the City Engineer for drainage and utility purposes prior. to final plat approval. 7. _ The applicant shall provide written certification from a licensed land surveyor that the existing sidewalk along Brooklyn Boulevard does not encroach.into the boundaries of the proposed Lots 1 and 2 or provide the appropriate sidewalk easement dedication along with the final plat. .8. Building permits for construction of any of the buildings, comprehended under Planning Commission Application No. 2008 -005 shall not be issued until the plat has been given final approval by the City Council and filed with Hennepin County. e June 13, 2011 Date Mayor ATTEST: City Clerk The motion for the adoption of the foregoing resolution was duly seconded by member I Tim Roche and upon vote being taken thereon, the following voted in favor thereof Tim Willson, Carol Kleven, Kay Lasman,.Tim Roche, and Dan Ryan; and the following voted against the same: none; whereupon said resolution was declared duly passed and adopted. Member Morey introduced the following resolution and moved its adoption: PLANNING COMMISSION RESOLUTION NO. 2011 -10 RESOLUTION REGARDING THE RECOMMENDED DISPOSITION OF PLANNING COMMISSION APPLICATION NO. 2011 -013, A REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY PLAT APPROVAL OF BRI MAR 2 ADDITION SUBMITTED BY THE LUTHER COMPANIES LLLP WHEREAS, Planning Commission Application No. 2011 -013 submitted by Linda McGinty on behalf of The Luther Company, LLLP requests approval of a Preliminary Plat approval of a subdivision to be titled Bri Mar 2nd Addition, which is a r!Rlat of five contiguous lots located on the easterly side of Brooklyn Boulevard between I -94 and 69 Avenue North and addressed as 6700 Brooklyn Boulevard, 6800 Brooklyn Boulevard, 4215 69P Avenue North, and 410169' Avenue, 4011 69 Avenue North; and WHEREAS, this plat is being requested to create three (3) separate lots for the benefit of a new Luther Brookdale Honda dealership and new Toyota City of Brooklyn Center dealership; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission held a duly called public hearing on May 26, 2011 at which time a staff report and public testimony regarding the preliminary plat of Bri Mar 2nd Addition were received; and WHEREAS, the review of this preliminary plat submitted with Planning Application No. 2011 -013, even with the minor lot line revisions is in general conformance with the original plat approved by the City Council on July 28, 2008 in acceptance of Planning Application No. 2008 -004; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission has determined these plat revisions are not significant enough or diminishes the original intent and desired effect in the platting of this redevelopment site; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission has determined during the review of this plat application that the building and site modifications previously approved under the 2008 Planned Unit Development (PUD) plan as comprehended under the original Planning Application No. 2008 -005, and adopted by the City Council under Res. No. 2008 -81, is in substantial compliance and conformity with this approved PUD and overall development plan; and NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Planning Advisory Commission of the City of Brooklyn Center to recommend to the City Council that Application No. 2011 -013 submitted by Linda McGinty on behalf of The Luther Company, LLLP be approved based upon the following considerations: 1. The final plat is subject to review and approval by the City Engineer. 1 i 2. The final plat is subject to the provisions of Chapter 15 of the City Ordinances. 3. Approval of this preliminary plat is contingent upon those condtions and consideratins approved under Planning Commission Application No. 2008 -005 and memorialized in adopted City Council Resolotion No. 2008 -81, dated July 28, 2008. 4. Appropriate cross access and cross parking agreements and a dedication binding Lot 1, 2 and 3, Block l of Bri Mar 2 nd Addition, and as approved by the City Atttorney shall be developed and filed with the titles to the property. 5. The applicant shall provide the city with an executed copy of shared access easement ro between the proposed osed Lot 1 2 and 3 Block 1 of Bri Mar 2 nd prior rior to final plat approval to be filed with the titles to the er ro nes. P P 6. The applicant shall execute all easements required by the City Engineer for drainage and utility purposes prior to final plat approval. 7. The applicant shall provide written certification from a licensed land surveyor that the existing sidewalk along Brooklyn Boulevard does not encroach into the boundaries of the proposed Lots 1 and 2 or provide the appropriate sidewalk easement dedication along with the final plat. 8. Building permits for construction of any of the buildings comprehended under Planning Commission Application No. 2008 -005 shall not be issued until the plat has been given final approval by the City Council and filed with Hennepin County,. Date Chair ATTEST: Secretary The motion for the adoption of the foregoing resolution was duly seconded by member Schonning and upon vote being taken thereon, the following voted in favor thereof: Chair Pro Tem. Kuykendall, Commissioners Leino, Morey, Morgan, Parks, and Schonning and the following voted against the same: None whereupon said resolution was declared duly passed and adopted. i 2 BRI MAR SECOND ADDITION R.T. DOC. NO CA. IOC. NO. KNOWALLPERSONS BY THESE PRESENTS: ThunwLud=Cepeny.LLLP,a Mtomonta Limbed Li W],WL'mired.PsrmarM1ip&aownerofd foSowbg&—bedprapcggwdd ISmRC.Tmemdoboebymdyd tddsptty ep pwWbymeorwA Wd'iwmpet,Il dmlmaduly Limum Lmd Smveyrciodw SwhofMhv - ,dwdiephtises in the Cnedy dHeuepio, Sons dM®mmu, m wits mrtml mpeuepesCm of the bawWM survey; that d— &_.tied4. end bbdb sb—mdy keipWd m Ses, pleF, Wu d mmmmte depicted m Set ple, be. bee m will be mertcdy sm within ou y— „ don .11w.esr bmodmu.n idwat lends, u defind M-- in M Sesmme, Shim 505,01,Sob&3,u ddro due dthb cwdRmte am own .h sd beetled this pm ands” 77mt pemofLpt 3, Audible Subdivisim Na 25, Hemropb CmMy, Minn. dmdhdu mllowa: publie wrys us, shown end labeled . *is 11.1 CmmxmB•tapointm SeeBaM IinededdLa3, 289.74 bMBmW dSeemumSon f*roCoumyft 4d-. We pmEdwibboe•dm Eneof WdClmty Rod.dimnecof 131,02 faMbe point mkeueed fee don Pe dhegimbgdWepmpedyhembycmveyed ,Seems, WeMgrallolwilhihe a lboofnUC— tyRad.dieteeceofiSO34 fmk DMdtbb deyof ,20_ bean NmWpen0d with the E"' line of "id Lm 3 btbe meta lbe a[uid Ces Band trmBeg tiro WdrmtLdComety Reedu don Need, lb,fWdLM3 Seems, Feet along " tiro center 'its ofuid County Reed a diste —f 15034 Sees, bcasseSmm b WOppfmtebcn u ed torten Plem of beSinningmdepmpmtybmebyenveyd Tonne Pontoons: Cenifimw Na 1219701 Sam use Lic Smvnym M inneonte Limua 47465 AND That pemofWt3, Auditor's Subdivuios He en d mpis Curtly, Miaceibed. W — Commmc tog.tepoiMes Uw Bul Wb ofWd Let 3,299.74 drat Sadh of We onser Use cflhe County ROdwhkh point is mukd by.Judidd ludmadlt dWm WWponadvithd,e STATE OF MINNESOTA s old Co meofe.tdCmty Roads WUonmd60136 fmL�bepelet ofeammemmuotofdtelmsdtohMab. dmdu�bemmeWinMogWeMpvagdwilhbeeaobrlmoof COUNTY OF HEN7EPIN M Come" Reset. 150.357 fang theses Noshpmllsl Whit the Butlive ofWdLa3m We eetmBneefuidc -cov =.* =,=s Wdoetmiine dtlwwmtyroeduson The forego'v Surveyme. CeNRmts once admowledgedbo mt 6.s, day of 20_ by Sam C. Tkosers Lend Surveyor. SmdWd Lot 3: then" fi— longtibeeetmlimofesid Comtyltend letuemtim wilha limtmvbgNmlhvly.dpaaddwldt the Putlmeo[WdlmlflmvSeep�mf moment ofdw led dmenTted lemoiry'WCnm gout along WC WtmcWondpeWlcl l' ewbtlmpdMOfsamn�onmmcolo (boleddsecnbd0acin. Team. Pmpamy: Cmtifimts Na 1321555 NMary m H.Pir Cooly, Minvmble My Co mmwd 8rp'vu AND LM 2, Blink 1, Ed M.Addidm. The Mice iog pardon d wid lend is mgietmd u evidmcal by Cedificem cfTkI s Ne. 111 015m La12. Block 1, Sri Met Addides, except San Feet dwmdlyiog suuthdy ofbe swA lute of7hMA, Rogimmd Lased Smvsy Na 595 sd its seemed— BROOKLYN CENTER, MINNESOTA AND This PW dBRI MAR SECOND ADDITION wee yprmod se emcpeed by do City CouncB Mmmota,Ma mgulermmfmgdlemofMSd this _dryd . 20�IfapPlhwblo, d. vlM. comments W rmmmendntues, eComWseimero[lbaspmesdpn andtim County Higbwry Bnghumbevebae noroivedby Led 1, Block 1, Cby.kr Redly Addition. tiro City m do plvemibd 30 tiny peril Iota depend wiOmMmmipt afeoeh emmme, and memnmcddonA tspmvidcd by Mims Sts Section 505.03, Sub& I Tom -Pap M: C<nifi —No. 740550 Cff Y COUNCIL OF BROOKLYN CNi78lL klQBdESMA Ad Wet Bmokllm la.tvg, LLC, a klavewY l.imtd L'vb'Iity Campesy gW Ownv of the bgoWmgdmdbdtavpv0' eiouwd le the CmmN dHmneple, BtmdMmvawh, mwik M-3- By Msuga Lot 1, Blink 1, Bri Mu Addition T— PmpWty: Cerdgmu Na 132I554 New mu.md th awmmbomrveydudplsmodts BRI MAR SECONDA R Uddoh by doom and ddimm mWc puhlie felpeblie mef dneven edownmb ter TAXPAYER SERVICES DEPARTMENT, Batteries, fbmry, Mmmmta dmWpe esdotllity Pmpmaa u.hpWad We Flu mwieswwhepfwid The LUSeee Corngoy. LLLP,ahiimceole Limited LuMlby Limited Pumenhip.hu c.uud Seine Pmemtebh sigmdbyiwpmpevotfice Wb dnyd . 20_md WdBmddye U.i.&LLC,.bfimuota Limed LiabOHy COmpmy M.muedtherep—to I beuby cuufydwt tuts payable in 20 sd psmyeen have bmnpdd brhdduenbdmdde p5m. DYd Win dnyd . 20_. be,ipdbybapmperofitcmthi. dsyof . 20_ B1LAIveesoq Heosple C-c Adimr BY DePmY THE LUTHER COMPANY. LLLP, A MINNESOTA LBAITED tv.w rrY LIHrRD PARTNERSHIP Name Tide SURVEY DIVISION, Haescple an Mom County, emte STATE OF paean to Milestones Sesbtm 383B. 565( 1969) tide plat less ban approved thie_dny d 20 . COUNTY OP The forgoing immesentwu ecmiowidgd 6dpmtm thi dnyd 20_by a les n o Led- Cepnty, LLLP, e. Wallets RBrown, County SUrveym BY Mime to Limited Ij bifily Li mitd Pamimleip, m bduVofbe pertmehip. Nmtny Publlo Luny REGISTRAR OF TITLES, Hemmian County, Mimuds My Commbden Repha Iherohy notify dutdro wihb pletdHR1 MAR SECOND ADDITION once filed is tldepSim title _day of 20_,u ddmk_M. BROOKLYN LEASING,LLC. A MINNESOTA LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY Miotud H:Cumiff Rogimmd75dee By ,its_ Nero Title COUNTY RECORDER,liemptn County. M mabLL STATE OF COUNTY Oi+ T hmcby mrNy dot fies"Wr plot ofBRI MAR SECOND ADDITION vets Ned in tltie dfina thle dnyd .7A_,nt oclmk_M The peeping townsmen was ec4nowkdged belie me this dry of . 20_, by its , Brooklyn lsasits LLC,a Mmneonw ' Limited Lubifily Company,. b*ff fSommpsey. MieMd H.!]umiR, CauMyASmNi HY Nntuy Public Cmty • • My COmmbstm Eapim • • L A N D F O R M hoot SM to Holds • e w w SHEET 1 OF 2 SHEETS • 0 BRI MAR SECOND ADDITION D OC. NO CR DOC. NO p, JiiY.iiEE u, xsi T I S03 ° 50' 35 211ii �� oOLO •, .. .. .. . -.� I l e h 304.68. _ — I S03 °45'45 "E �--- • -T 289.74 NOS °45'45 "W ---------- -- - - - - -� —� 617.32 - - -- us.e - - -- '— I .. b ° Z E P4s eLLEL MM ME F]sT LM OF Lm ] —" I .za I k-- ° s clj oFi i I I a�I. sI � I "og . Qt . _j /l 5 si F PMNLEL rAM M[ EAST UxE sP Lm a ' I I 9 € I / ¢ DETAIL B .¢.,...b.;.„! V 1 A'as °]'E a56.e1 - - -�I' a 1 §l' .W ' /LJ 0 i _ —� � -- <P4 � I � I HmT /. 5K 09 \: g5 i &R28„`,x� .. g I >. I x s y ! I / � g5 1 zg `. �, f - ;, I DETAI AA — II FmL . gg. 96 5 B / / DRAINAGE AND UTIUTY EASENENTS BEARINGS ARE ASSUMED 9 ARE SHORN THUS u DENOTES IRON MONUMENT POUND DENOTES 1/2 INCH BY 14 INCH IRON PIPE WITH MICH HAS a 27 A r]� '/ / SET OR WI SET IN C BEEN LL ORDA CE WITH UL -- S20°p5 p8" / Ms 505.G21, sue0. 1D. NORTH / 10. FEET IN WON AND ADJOINING RIGHT OF WAY LINES UNtE55 OTHERRISE INDICATED O 66 H2O • • / L A M D F O R M I , Dam Site W RnM ° I / N. ,: SHEET 2 OF 2 SHE • City Council Agenda Item No. 10a • • COUNCIL ITEM MEMORANDUM DATE: August 15, 2011 • TO: Curt Boganey, City Manager FROM: Sharon Knutson, City Clerk SUBJECT: Mayoral Appointment of Member to Serve on Housing Commission Recommendation: It is recommended that the City Council consider ratification of the Mayoral appointment of Penny Lynn, 1912 55th Avenue North, to the Housing Commission with term to expire December 31, 2011. Background: The Housing Commission is composed of a chairperson and six members. There is one vacancy on the commission. Notice of vacancy on the commission was posted at City Hall and Community Center and on the City's website and aired on Cable Channel 16 since March 23, 2011. Announcement was made several times in the Brooklyn Center Sun -Post. A letter was sent to those persons who previously had submitted an application for appointment to a Brooklyn Center advisory commission informing them of the vacancy and requesting that they call the City Clerk if they are interested in applying for the commission. They were given the choice of either submitting a • new application or having their application previously submitted considered. Notices were also sent to current advisory commission members. Members in the August 5 , A co of the application received was forwarded to City Council gu PY pp Y 2011, update. Attached for City Council Members only is a copy of the application received: Peggy Lynn 1912 55th Avenue North An e -mail was sent to the applicant notifying her that her application for appointment would be considered at the August 22, 2011, City Council meeting Mayor Willson recommends appointment of Peggy Lynn. As previously requested by the City Council, the City Advisory Commission Bylaws are not included in . the materials but can be found on the City's website at www.cityofbrooklyncenter.org The membership roster is also available at this site and in the City Council Reference Book. Budget Issues: There are no budget issues to consider. �:Hission: Ensuring an attractive, clean, safe community that enhances the quality of life and preserves the public trust City of Brooklyn Center Housin g Commission • Geographical Distribution (Chairperson and Six Members) Current Members August 15, 2011 Neighborhoods lieht(sk s - Current Members Southeast Peggy Lynn Tracy Groves Northeast Northwest Kathie Amdahl Chereen Norstrud West Central Kris Lawrence - Anderson Central Judy Thorbus Southwest Ephraim Olani One vacancyg City Council Agenda Item No. lOb • • COUNCIL ITEM MEMORANDUM • DATE: August 22, 2011 TO: Curt Boganey, City Manager FROM: Sharon Knutson, City Clerk j6W 4 U jb N_ SUBJECT: Type III One Year Rental License for 7018 Brooklyn Boulevard Recommendation: It is recommended that the City Council consider approval of the resolution and issuance of a Type III One Year Rental License and action plan for 7018 Brooklyn Boulevard. If the Council chooses to not issue the license, it is recommended that the motion be to direct staff to prepare proposed findings for denial of the rental license and draft said resolution for the next Council meeting. Background: The property owner received a Type III Rental License on January 11, 2011 on condition of adherence to the Action Plan. The owner has failed to comply with the Action Plan. According to City ordinances, if the requirements of the license category and the Action Plan are not met, the license renewal category remains a Type III. • City Ordinance Section 12 -901.2 requires a licensee of a Type III Rental Property to complete Phase II of the Crime Free Housing Program. City Ordinance Section 12- 914.2.b requires an owner (or authorized representative) to attend a minimum of 25 percent of Owners/Managers Association Meetings. The property owner has not attended any of these meetings. The following is a brief history of the license process actions: Prior Type III license approval activities: 05 -15 -10 Nelia Schaff applied for a renewal of the rental dwelling license for 7018 Brooklyn Boulevard, an eight unit, multi - family residential property. 07 -13 -10 The scheduled inspection was unable to be completed since owner did not attend. 07 -28 -10 An initial rental inspection was conducted (26 orders cited, see attached rental criteria). 08 -27 -10 An extension was granted for certain corrections. 09 -30 -10 A second rental inspection was conducted and passed. 10 -04 -10 A letter was sent stating an action plan must be submitted. 11 -30 -10 Another reminder letter was sent stating an action plan must be submitted. 12 -27 -10 A phone call was placed to the owner regarding action plan. 01 -11 -11 A Type III rental license was issued. 01 -12 -11 An Action Plan was approved. 01 -20 -11 An email reminder was sent to the owner regarding attendance at ARM meetings. 04 -15 -11 A phone call reminder was made to the owner regarding attendance at ARM • meetings. Mission: Ensuring an attractive, clean, safe community that enhances the quality of life and preserves the public trust COUNCIL ITEM MEMORANDUM 05 -18 -11 The owner was notified by phone that the license will remain a Type III due to missing ARM meetings. Current rental license approval activities 4 -27 -11 A rental license application was received. 5 -23 -11 An inspection was conducted noting seven violations. 7 -21 -11 A reinspection was conducted and passed. If approved, after one year, a new rental license will be required. The license process will begin in approximately nine months. The new license will be based on the property code violations found during the initial renewal license inspection and the number of validated police calls for services for disorderly activities and nuisances as defined in 12 -911. The terms of the Action Plan must also be met. • • Mission Ensuring an attractive, clean, safe community that enhances the quality of life and preserves the public trust COUNCIL ITEM MEMORANDUM . Excerpt from Chapter 12 of Citv Code of Ordinances: Section 12 -914. CRIME FREE HOUSING PROGRAM. For the purpose of this Chapter, the Crime Free Housing Program shall mean the nationally recognized program, unless otherwise indicated. The phases of the program include, but are not limited to, the conditions set forth below. 1. Phase I. For license categories other than Type 1, an owner, manager, or local agent responsible for the operation of the rental property must complete the Phase I training of the Crime Free Housing Program or a similar course approved by the City Manager. Certification as a rental property manager may also satisfy this requirement. Phase I includes the following: a. Attend an eight -hour crime -free housing course presented by police, fire, public housing and others. b. Use a written lease including the Minnesota Crime Free Housing Lease Addendum. C. Check the criminal background of all prospective tenants and, upon request, provide a copy of Third Party Background Check procedures for Tenants. • d. Actively pursue the eviction of tenants who violate the terms of the lease and /or the Crime Free Lease Addendum. 2. Phase II. Includes Phase I plus the following: a. Complete a Security Assessment and complete the security improvements recommended. This phase will certify that the rental property has met the security requirements for the tenant's safety. b. Attend a minimum of 25 percent of Owners/Managers Association Meetings. 3. Phase 111. Includes Phases I and 11 plus the following: a. For properties with more than four units, conduct resident training annually for the residents where crime watch and crime prevention techniques are discussed. b. For properties with more than four units, hold regular resident meetings. C. Attend a minimum of 50 percent of Owners/Managers Association Meetings. d. Have no City Code t d violations that were not resolved in accordance with compliance orders within the past year. Mission: Ensuring an attractive, clean, safe community that enhances the quality of life and preserves the public trust COUNCIL ITEM MEMORANDUM Section 12-120 1 B. ACTION PLAN. The Compliance Official may require an a c do n plan to be completed by the licensee, manager, or local agent in a designated time frame that indicates the steps taken to correct identified violations and the measures to be taken to ensure ongoing compliance with City Ordinances and applicable Codes. Rental License Category Criteria Policy — Adopted by City Council 03 -08 -10 1. Determining License Categories. License categories are based on property code and nuisance violations noted during the initial or renewal license inspection or for a category verification inspection, along with excessive validated police service calls occurring over a year. License categories are performance based and more accurately depict the condition of the property and the City costs of service. 2. Fees. Fee amounts are determined by the costs of the city to license, inspect, monitor and work with the property to ensure category conditions are met. License fees do not include reinspection fees, late fees, charges for criminal or civil enforcement actions, or other penalties. 3. Category Conditions. • The licensee or designated agent must meet the category conditions in the time period specified by the City. A licensee must meet all original conditions required by the License Category, even if a subsequent license category is achieved. 4. License Category Criteria. a. Property Code and Nuisance Violations. Property code violation rates will be based on the average number of property code violations per unit identified during the licensing inspection or category verification inspection. Property code violations for purposes of determining licensing categories shall include violations of property code and nuisances as defined in Chapter 12, 19, 7 and other applicable local ordinances. The City may, upon complaints or reasonable concerns that the establishment no longer complies with the license category criteria, perform a category verification inspection to the same standards as the license renewal inspection as indicated below. Inspections will be conducted in conjunction with established department policies. In cases where 100 % of the units are not inspected, the minimum inspection standards will be established as follows: • At least 75% of units will be inspected for properties with 15 or less units. • At least 25% of units, to include a minimum of 12 units, will be inspected for properties with 16 or more units. Mission: Ensuring an attractive, clean, safe community that enhances the quality of life anal preserves the public trust COUNCIL ITEM MEMORANDUM Property Code and Nuisance Violations Criteria License Category Number of Units Property Code Violations per (Based on Property Inspected Unit Code Only) Type I — 3 Year 1 -2 units 0 -1 3 ±1nits 0 -0:75 Type II — 2 Year 1 -2 units Greater than 1 but not more than 4 3 ±units; Greater than 0.75 but not more than 1.5 Type III —1 Year 1 -2 units Greater than 4 but not more than 8 3 ±units Greater than 1.5 but not more than 3 Type IV - 6 Months 1 -2 units Greater than 8 3± units' Greater than 3 ,. b. Police Service Calls. Police call rates will be based on the average number of valid police calls per unit per • year. Police incidences for purposes of determining licensing categories shall include disorderly activities and nuisances as defined in Section 12 -911, and events categorized as Part I crimes in the Uniform Crime Reporting System including homicide, rape, robbery, aggravated assault, burglary, theft, auto theft and arson. Calls will not be counted for purposes of determining licensing categories where the victim and suspect are "Family or household members" as defined in the Domestic Abuse Act, Minnesota Statutes, Section 51813.01, Subd. 2 (b) and where there is a report of "Domestic Abuse" as defined in the Domestic Abuse Act, Minnesota Statutes, Section S 1813.01, Subd. 2 (a). License Number of Units Validated Calls for Disorderly Conduct Category Service & Part I Crimes (Calls Per Unit/Year) No Category 1 -2 0 -1 Impact 3- 4 units. 0 -0.25 5 or more units 0 -0.35 Decrease 1 1 -2 Greater than 1 but not more than 3 Category 3 4units = Greater than 0;25 but not,more than 1 5 or more units Greater than 0.35 but not more than 0.50 Decrease 2 1 -2 Greater than 3 . Categories 3-4 units Greater than 1 5 or more units Greater than 0.50 Mission: Ensuring an attractive, clean, safe community that enhances the quality of life and preserves the publictrust COUNCIL ITEM MEMORANDUM Budget Issues: . There are no budget issues to consider. Council Goals: Strategic: We will ensure a safe and secure community We will stabilize and improve residential neighborhoods Attachment - Copy of Action Plan Pertaining to January 11, 2011 Type III Rental License Approval - Resolution Approving a Type III Rental License for 7018 Brooklyn Boulevard • • Mission: Ensuring an attractive, clean, safe community that enhances the quality of life and preserves the public trust Cr�l Dv- C' \A— City of Brooklyn Center Phone: 763 569 -3300 6301 Shingle Creek Parkway =1071m 711 Brooklyn Center, MN 55430 -2199 Am -569 -3494 yvww ckyotbrooklyn center org M. Rental License Action Plan (Type III License) Handrvretten plans will not be accepted Please type or use fellable form on City website. PXopeity �ldtess . Owner Name, ThamaS 8 Nelia Schaff Local t4gent Same bVener Address Aerrt Address i $ ,� _ 7551 �voodslde ct ne Fridley,N 55432 Sale W ter PhQhe 8124181935 Agenit Phone Same "f OwnerEmail nelia�gh�fl @camcastn�t �SentEmail Seme The above referenced property qualifies for a Type III Rental License. An Action Plan must be completed and reviewed by City staff An Action Plan allows the owner and the City to review concerns and identify possible solutions to improve overall conditions of the property. ++ ��. M � � S R n * �� , �� t {'` 'S3 y ,���5 ■�. �egjo T . " �.� ^�f" - y, �., - r Submit the following documents with the Action Plan for approval: 1. Crime Free Housing Program Training Certificate � J 2. Copy of Lease including Minnesota Crime Free Housing Lease Addendum • �✓ 3. Signed & Completed Action Plan ✓� 4. Security Assessment Report (Performed by the Brooklyn Center Police Department) gi ,"' i+�°m "a,'3 .3c i *r •- ";a.4t u' -x. - vt r S. ��.�c�x3�rs YS�`,��: <�E i.. Phase I 1. Use written lease including Crime Free Housing Lease Addendum. 2. Conduct criminal background check for all prospective tenants. Provide documentation to City if requested. 3. Pursue the eviction of tenants who violate the terms of the lease or any addendums. 4. Attend City approved eight hour Crime Free Housing course. Date Course Completed: 1110912008. Date Course Scheduled: Phase II I will attend a minimum of 25% of the ARM meetings (two). I will attend the ARM meetings scheduled for: & Complete Security Assessment and implement all security improvements recommended by the Brooklyn Center Police Department Date Completed: Improvements to be completed by: 011311201 Page 1 Type III Action Plan 9 -10 • Date Last Replaced Future Replacement Date Furnace /AC 01/01/1998 12/03/2020 Water Heater 01/01/2005 12/03/2015 Kitchen Appliances 12/03/2010 12/03/2011 Laundry Appliances 01101!2005 01/10/2011 Exterior -Paint/Siding 10/01/2010 07/30/2011 - Windows 10/0112010 07/3012011 -Roof 06/0112007 06/0112022 - Fence 01/0111998 07/30/2011 -Shed 10/01/2010 10/01/2013 - Garage 10/0112010 10/01/2013 - Driveway 01/01/1998 07/30/2011 - Sidewalks 01/01/1998 07/30/2011 i Smoke Alarms & Carbon Monoxide Alarms 09/01/2010 09/01/2015 Other: Sect�On:, ..ate ,s.a TWO "emenEncYan�liboigs of {Pro Implementing the following best practices may assist in the management of your property. By checking the boxes below you agree to: Check in with tenants every 30 days. Drive by property to check for violations., a r Evict tenants in violation of the lease and all addendums. • Q Provide lawn/snow service. t r Provide garbage service. Install security system. M Provde maintenance service plan for appliances. Name of service company: see other Other: Nardini, Center point, Adams Heating & Cooling Please attach additional information if necessary. If the Type III Rental License is approved by the City Council, the Licensee must comply with the approved Action Plan and all applicable city codes. An Action Plan may be requested outside of the license review process to establish a plan for long term property management solutions. I verify that all information provided above is true and accurate. I understand that if I do not comply with an approved Action Plan, enforcement actions such as citation, formal complaint or license review may result. Page 2 Type III Action Plan 9 -10 • Owner or Agent Signature / Title Date � " - C>\ D-A Additional Owner or Agent Signature / Title ate �.f Plic l 1 Department / Title Date Built *'& Community Standards Department /Title Date • Page 3 Type III Action Plan 9 -10 • Member introduced the following resolution and • moved its adoption: RESOLUTION NO. RESOLUTION APPROVING A TYPE III RENTAL LICENSE FOR 7018 BROOKLYN BOULEVARD WHEREAS, City Ordinance Sections 12 -900 to 12 -916 set forth requirements for licensed rental properties; and WHEREAS, the property located at 7018 Brooklyn Blvd, was issued a Type III Rental license on January 11, 2011; and WHEREAS, City Ordinance Section 12 -901.2 requires a property owner who receives a Type III Rental License to complete Phase I and II of the Crime Free Housing Program; and WHEREAS, City Ordinance Section 12- 914.2.b establishes the requirement for an owner of a Type III rental property to complete Phase II of the Crime Free Housing Program, including attendance at a minimum of 25 percent of Owners/Managers Association Meetings; and WHEREAS, the property owner of 7018 Brooklyn Boulevard, Brooklyn Center • failed to attend any Owners/Managers Association Meetings; and NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Brooklyn Center, Minnesota, that a TYPE III Rental License is hereby approved for the property at 7018 Brooklyn Boulevard. August 22, 2011 Date Mayor ATTEST: City Clerk The motion for the adoption of the foregoing resolution was duly seconded by member and upon vote being taken thereon, the following voted in favor thereof: and the following voted against the same: whereupon said resolution was declared duly passed and adopted. s City Council Agenda Item No. 10c • COUNCIL ITEM MEMORANDUM . DATE: August 22, 2011 TO: Curt Boganey, City Manager FROM: Sharon Knutson, City Clerk C SUBJECT: Type IV 6 -Month Provisional Rental .License for 6765 Humboldt Ave N Recommendation: It is recommended that the City Council consider approval of the issuance of a Type IV 6 -Month Provisional Rental License and mitigation plan for 6765 Humboldt Ave N. If the Council chooses not to issue the license, it is recommended that the motion be to direct staff to prepare proposed findings for denial of the rental license and draft said resolution for the next Council meeting. Background: This owner is applying for a renewal rental license. This property qualifies for a Type IV provisional rental license based on ten property code violations found during the initial rental license inspection and zero validated police incidents /nuisance calls for the past 12 months. Staff from Administration, Building & Community Standards and Police Departments worked with the property owner regarding a mitigation plan, which requires Phase I, II and III of the Crime Free Housing Program, and other items included by City ordinance for a Type IV License. A Mitigation Plan has been developed addressing the requirements of the ordinance and any issues specific to the property. Therefore, staff is recommending approval of the Type IV Rental License on condition of adherence to the Mitigation Plan. Please refer to the attached copy of the Mitigation Plan for more information. The following is a brief history of the license process actions: 3 -1 -11 Moeen Masood applied for a renewal of the rental dwelling license for 6765 Humboldt Ave N, a single - family residential property. 4 -4 -11 An initial rental inspection was conducted (ten orders cited, see attached rental criteria). 5 -17 -11 _An inspection was conducted and passed with weather deferral. 6 -7 -11 A letter was sent to owner notifying of qualification for Type IV 6- Month Provisional Rental License, including additional requirements to obtain a rental license (submit mitigation plan, completion of Phases 1, II, and III of Crime Free Housing Program, etc.). - 6 -30 -11 A weather deferral inspection was conducted but did not pass. Staff will continue to follow up on this 7 -20 -11 A mitigation plan was received. 8 -12 -11 A mitigation plan was approved. Mission: Ensuring an attractive, clean, safe community that enhances the quality of life anal preserves the public trust COUNCIL ITEM MEMORANDUM If approved, the process for rental license renewal will commence immediately. The new license . will be based on the property code violations found during the initial renewal license inspection and the number of validated police calls for services for disorderly activities and nuisances as defined in 12 -911. The terms of the mitigation plan must also be met. Excerpt from Chapter 12 of City Code of Ordinances: Section 12 -913. TYPE IV PROVISIONAL LICENSES. I . Rental properties that meet the provisional licensing criteria as described in Section 12- 901 are eligible only for provisional licenses. 2. The City will provide by mail to each licensee a monthly report of any police and fire calls and incidents and applicable property Code violations as described in Section 12- 901. 3. Mitigation Plan. The applicant for a provisional license must submit for Council review a mitigation plan for the license period. The mitigation plan shall describe steps proposed by the applicant to reduce the number of police and fire calls and/or the property Code issues described in Section 12 -901 and 12 -911 to a level that qualifies for a Type 1, II, or III license. The mitigation plan may include such steps as changes in tenant screening procedures, changes in lease terms, security measures, rules and • regulations for tenant conduct, security personnel, and time frame to implement all phases of the Crime Free Housing Program. 4. Council Consideration. The application with a proposed mitigation plan will be presented to the City Council together with a recommendation by the City Manager or the Manager's designee as to the disposition thereof. After giving the applicant an opportunity to be heard and present evidence, the Council shall approve, disapprove, or approve with conditions the application and the mitigation plan. If the Council disapproves an application and mitigation plan or approves it with conditions, it shall state its reasons for so doing in writing. In evaluating a mitigation plan, the Council will consider, among other things, the facility, its management practices, the nature and seriousness of causes for police and fire incidences and/or property Code issues and the expected effectiveness of measures identified in the plan to reduce the number of police and fire incidences and /or property Code violations. In evaluating a mitigation plan submitted by an applicant already under a provisional license, the Council will also consider the effectiveness of measures identified in the applicant's previous mitigation plan and the need for different or additional measures to reduce police and fire incidences and /or property Code violations. 5. Compliance with Mitigation Plan. The licensee shall comply with the mitigation plan as approved or modified by the Council. No later than the tenth day after each calendar month, the licensee shall mail or deliver to the City Manager a written report describing all steps taken in furtherance of the mitigation plan during the preceding month. • Mission: Ensuring an attractive, clean, safe community that enhances the quality of life and preserves the public trust COUNCIL ITEM MEMORANDUM • Rental License Category Criteria Policy — Adopted by City Council 03 -08 -10 1. Determining License Categories. License categories are based on property code and nuisance violations noted during the initial or renewal license inspection or for a category verification inspection, along with excessive p g rY P validated police service calls occurring over a year. License categories are performance based and more accurately depict the condition of the property and the City costs of service. 2. Fees. Fee amounts are determined by the costs of the city to license, inspect, monitor and work with the property to ensure category conditions are met. License fees do not include reinspection fees, late fees, charges for criminal or civil enforcement actions, or other penalties. 3. Category Conditions. The licensee or designated agent must meet the category conditions in the time period specified by the City. A licensee must meet all original conditions required by the License Category, even if a subsequent license category is achieved. . 4. License Category Criteria. a. Property Code and Nuisance Violations. Property code violation rates will be based on the average number of property code violations per unit identified during the licensing inspection or category verification inspection. Property code violations for purposes of determining licensing categories shall include violations of property code and nuisances as defined in Chapter 12, 19, 7 and other applicable local ordinances. The City may, upon complaints or reasonable concerns that the establishment no longer complies with the license category criteria, perform a category verification inspection to the same standards as the license renewal inspection as indicated below. Inspections will be conducted in conjunction with established department policies. In cases where 100% of the units are not inspected, the minimum inspection standards will be established as follows: • At least 75% of units will be inspected for properties with 15 or less units. • At least 25% of units, to include a minimum of 12 units, will be inspected for properties with 16 or more units. Mission: Ensuring an attractive, clean, safe community that enhances the quality of life and preserves the public trust COUNCIL ITEM MEMORANDUM Property Code and Nuisance Violations Criteria License Category Number of Units Property Code Violations per (Based on Property Inspected Unit Code Only) Type I — 3 Year 1 -2 units 0 -1 3+ units 0 -0.75 Type II — 2 Year 1 -2 units Greater than 1 but not more than 4 3± units Greater than 0:75: but nqt more than `1.5 Type III —1 Year 1 -2 units Greater than 4 but not more than 8 3 +units Greater than 1.5 but not more- than 3 Type IV — 6 Months 1 -2 units Greater than 8 3 +units Greater than 3 b. Police Service Calls. Police call rates will be based on the average number of valid police calls per unit per year. Police incidences for purposes of determining licensing categories shall include disorderly activities and nuisances as defined in Section 12 -911, and events categorized • as Part I crimes in the Uniform Crime Reporting System including homicide, rape, robbery, aggravated assault, burglary, theft, auto theft and arson. Calls will not be counted for purposes of determining licensing categories where the victim and suspect are "Family or household members" as defined in the Domestic Abuse Act, Minnesota Statutes, Section 518B.01, Subd. 2 (b) and where there is a report of "Domestic Abuse" as defined in the Domestic Abuse Act, Minnesota Statutes, Section 518B.01, Subd. 2 (a). License Number of Units Validated Calls for Disorderly Conduct Category Service & Part I Crimes g Calls Per Unit/Year) No Category 1 -2 0 -1 Impact 3 4 units! 0 -0.25 5 or more units 0 -0.35 Decrease 1 1 -2 Greater than 1 but not more than 3 Category 3 -4 units Greater: han 0.25 but not more, an 1 ` 5 or more units Greater than 0.35 but not more than 0.50 Decrease 2 1 -2 Greater than 3 Categories 3 -4 units Greater!.than 1' 5 or more units Greater than 0.50 • Mission: Ensuring an attractive, clean, safe community that enhances the quality of life and preserves the public trust COUNCIL ITEM MEMORANDUM • Budget Issues: There are no budget issues to consider. Council Goals: Strategic: We will ensure a safe and secure community We will stabilize and improve residential neighborhoods Attachment Copy of Mitigation Plan • Mission: Ensuring an attractive, clean, safe community that enhances the quality of life and preserves the public trust • City of Brooklyn Center Phone: 763 - 569 -3300 6301 Shingle Creek Parkway 77YIVoice 711 Brooklyn Center, MN 55430 -2199 Fax,- 763 - 569 -3494 www.cityotbrooklyncenter org Rental License Mitigation Plan (Type IV License) Handwritten plans will not be accepted Please type or use fellable form on City webs{te. Property Address: 6765 humbolt ave N, Brooklyn Center, MN 55430 Owner Name: MOeefl . MBSOOCI Local Agent: Owner Address: Agent Address: 3613 Clare Downs Path;.Rosemount, MN 55068 Owner Phone: 6512613638 Agent Phone: Owner Email: moeeniri @yahoo.com Agent Email: The above referenced property qualifies for a Type IV Rental License. A Mitigation Plan must be completed and reviewed by City staff before the rental license application can be considered for approval by City Council. A Mitigation Plan should indicate the steps being.taken to correct identified violations and the measures that will be taken to ensure ongoing compliance with City Ordinances and applicable Codes. The Mitigation Plan provides an opportunity to review property concerns and possible solutions to improve the overall conditions of the e" e..Docuuients Submit the following documents with the Mitigation Plan for approval: 1. Crime Free Housing Program Training Certificate (if completed, if not completed, please include • scheduled date in Section B. 2. Copy of Lease including Minnesota Crime Free Housing Lease Addendum 3. Submit written report by 10"' of each month (after license approval). i Section B — RWng Program Re i rements Phase I 1. Use written Iease including Crime Free Housing Lease Addendum. 2. Conduct criminal background check for all prospective tenants. Provide documentation to City if requested. 3. Pursue the eviction of tenants who violate the terns of the lease or any addendums. 4. Attend City approved eight hour Crime Free Housing course. / Date Course Completed: Date Course Scheduled: 9 / // f ? Phase II © Complete Security Assessment and implement all security improvements recommended by the Brooklyn Center Police t / Department. Date Scheduled: Improvements to be completed by: R�'r�e2 c"iPi — RCS' 't Page 1 ° "� r � Type IV Mitigation Plan 411 s • • Phase III EZI will attend a minimum of 50 of the ARM meetings (two). I will attend the ARM meetings scheduled for & / n M I will have no repeat code violations previously documented within the past year. For properties with four or more units: 0 1 will conduct resident training annually that includes crime prevention techniques. I will hold regular resident meetings. Section C - Lon Term Capital Improvements Plan Date Last Replaced Future Replacement Date Fumace/AC 06/30/09 G ZO9O Water Heater 6130!2009 0 Zd23' Kitchen Appliances 6130/2009 ! a e Laundry Appliances 6130/2009 dG, Exterior - Paint/Siding 913012009 Q ter/ - Windows 6/30/2009 D p -Roof O e9 2Zgcx' -M ZOZ�y -Fence 0/110// / MOO O ! 2© t► - Shed -Garage b I o / / I^5� 0 /42 " o 9— - Driveway eS1 p �,� p2_ / p - Sidewalks Smoke Alarms & Carbon Monoxide Alarms 6/30!2009 Other: Section D — Steps to Improve Management and Conditions of Prope Implementing the following best practices may assist in the management of your property. By checking the boxes below, you agree to: ,/ Check in with tenants every 30 days. ✓ Drive by property to check for violations twice a month. V Evict tenants in violation of the lease and all addendums. Provide lawn/snow service. Provide garbage service. Install security system. =rovide maintenance service plan for appliances. Name of service company: I am and will remain current on payment of utility fees, taxes, assessments, fines, penalties and other —R financial claims due to the City. ,o, Other: AS per the lease the tenant is responsible for the boxes unchecked If the Type IV Rental License is approved by the City Council, the Licensee must comply with the approved Mitigation Plan and all applicable city codes. No later than the I& of each calendar month, the licensee must submit to the Building and Community Standards Department a written report describing all steps taken to comply with the Mitigation Plan. I verify that all information provided above is true and accurate. I understand that if I do not comply Page 2 Type IV Mitigation Plan 4 -11 • i with an approved Mitigation Plan, enforcement actions such as citation, formal complaint or license review may result. Moeen Masood Owner or Agent Name and Title (Please Print) �' � 201► Owne r Agent Signature Date Additional Owner or Agent Name and Title (Please Print) (if applicable) Additional Owner or Agent Signature (rf applicable) Date 'Police Department / Title Date Bung & Community Standards Department / Title Date i i Page 3 Type IV Mitigation Plan 4 -11 City Council Agenda Item No. 10d COUNCIL ITEM MEMORANDUM • DATE: August 22, 2011 TO: Curt Boganey, City Manager FROM: Sharon Knutson, City Clerk SUBJECT: Type IV 6 -Month Provisional Rental License for 3513 47 Ave N Recommendation: It is recommended that the City Council consider approval of the issuance of a Type IV 6 -Month Provisional Rental License and Mitigation Plan for 3513 47t Ave N. If the Council chooses to not issue the license, it is recommended that the motion be to direct staff to prepare proposed findings for denial of the rental license and draft said resolution for the next Council meeting. Background: This owner is applying for a renewal rental license for an eleven unit apartment complex. This property qualifies for a Type IV provisional rental license based on eighteen property code violations found during the initial rental license inspection and four validated police incidents /nuisance calls for the past 12 months. Staff from Administration, Building & Community Standards and Police Departments worked with the property owner regarding a • mitigation plan, which requires Phase I, II and III of the Crime Free Housing Program, and other items included by City ordinance for a Type IV License. A Mitigation Plan has been developed addressing the requirements of the ordinance and any issues specific to the property. Therefore, staff is recommending approval of the Type IV Rental License on condition of adherence to the Mitigation Plan. Please refer to the attached copy of the Mitigation Plan for more information. The following is a brief history of the license process actions: 02 -15 -11 Richard Grommes applied for renewal of the rental dwelling license for 3513 47 Ave N, an eleven unit apartment complex. 03 -30 -11 An initial rental inspection was conducted. (eleven orders cited, see attached rental criteria) 05 -09 -11 A second rental inspection was conducted and it passed with weather deferral. 05 -18 -11 It was determined that there were four validated police calls for the property over the past 12 months. These calls consisted of one theft and three criminal damage to property calls. 05 -18 -11 Letter to owners notifying of qualification for Type IV 6 -Month Provisional Rental License, including additional requirements to obtain a rental license 06 -06 -11 A phone call reminder was made to the owner relating to the Mitigation Plan requirements. 06 -15 -11 A third inspection was conducted for the weather differed items and the inspection failed. • 07 -11 -11 A phone call reminder was made to the owner relating to the Mitigation Plan requirements. Mission: Ensuring an attractive, clean, safe community that enhances the quality of life and preserves the public trust COUNCIL ITEM MEMORANDUM 07 -12 -11 The Mitigation Plan was received and an inspection was conducted, the property • passed the weather differed items. 07 -19 -11 The Mitigation Plan was finalized. 07 -14 -11 It was verified that the owner or representative attended the ARM meeting as stated on the Mitigation Plan. 08 -11 -11 The owner attended the Crime Free Housing Certificate Training Course and has provided a copy of the certificate. If approved, after four months, a new rental license will be required. The license process will begin within the next month. The new license will be based on the property code violations found during the initial renewal license inspection and the number of validated police calls for services for disorderly activities and nuisances as defined in 12-911. The terms of the Mitigation Plan must also be met. Excerpt from Chapter 12 of City Code of Ordinances: Section 12 -913. TYPE IV PROVISIONAL LICENSES. 1. Rental properties that meet the provisional licensing criteria as described in Section 12- 901 are eligible only for provisional licenses. 2. The City will provide by mail to each licensee a monthly report of any police and fire calls and incidents and applicable property Code violations as described in Section 12- 901. 3. Mitigation Plan. The applicant for a provisional license must submit for Council review a mitigation plan for the license period. The mitigation plan shall describe steps proposed by the applicant to reduce the number of police and fire calls and/or the property Code issues described in Section 12 -901 and 12 -911 to a level that qualifies for a Type I, I1, or III license. The mitigation plan may include such steps as changes in tenant screening procedures, changes in lease terms, security measures, rules and tenant conduct, security personnel, and time frame implement all to im regulations for nan o y p p phases of the Crime Free Housing Program. 4. Council Consideration. The application with a proposed mitigation plan will be presented to the City Council together with a recommendation by the City Manager or the Manager's designee as to the disposition thereof. After giving the applicant an opportunity to be heard and present evidence, the Council shall approve, disapprove, or approve with conditions the application and the mitigation plan. If the Council disapproves an application and mitigation plan or approves it with conditions, it shall state its reasons for so doing ill evaluating a mitigation ion the Council un i writing. In eva n g g g plan, consider, among other things, the facility, its management practices, the nature and seriousness of causes for police and fire incidences and/or property Code issues and the expected effectiveness of measures identified in the plan to reduce the number of police and fire incidences and/or property Code violations. In evaluating a mitigation plan. . Mission: Ensuring an attractive, clean, safe community that enhances the quality of life and preserves the public trust COUNCIL ITEM MEMORANDUM • submitted by an applicant already under a provisional license, the Council will also consider the effectiveness of measures identified in the applicant's previous mitigation plan and the need for different or additional measures to reduce police and fire incidences and /or property Code violations. 5. Compliance with Mitigation Plan. The licensee shall comply with the mitigation plan as approved or modified by the Council. No later than the tenth day after each calendar month, the licensee shall mail or deliver to the City Manager a written report describing all steps taken in furtherance of the mitigation plan during the preceding month. • • Mission: Ensuring an attractive, clean, safe community that enhances the quality of life and preserves the public trust COUNCIL ITEM MEMORANDUM Rental License Category Criteria Policy — Adopted by City Council 03 -08 -10 • 1. Determining License Categories. License categories are based on property code and nuisance violations noted during the initial or renewal'license inspection or for a category verification inspection, along with excessive validated police service calls occurring over a year. License categories are performance based and more accurately depict the condition of the property and the City costs of service. 2. Fees. Fee amounts are determined by the costs of the city to license, inspect, monitor and work with the property to ensure category conditions are met. License fees do not include reinspection fees, late fees, charges for criminal or civil enforcement actions, or other penalties. 3. Category Conditions. The licensee or designated agent must meet the category conditions in the time period specified by the City. A licensee must meet all original conditions required by the License Category, even if a subsequent license category is achieved. 4. License Category Criteria. • a. Property Code and Nuisance Violations. Property code violation rates will be based on the average number of property code violations per unit identified during the licensing inspection or category verification inspection. Property code violations for purposes of determining licensing categories shall include violations of property code and nuisances as defined in Chapter 12, 19, 7 and other applicable local ordinances. The City may, upon complaints or reasonable concerns that the establishment no longer complies with the license category criteria, perform a category verification inspection to the same standards as the license renewal inspection as indicated below. Inspections will be conducted in conjunction with established department policies. In cases where 100% of the units are not inspected, the minimum inspection standards will be established as follows: • At least 75% of units will be inspected for properties with 15 or less units. • At least 25% of units, to include a minimum of 12 units, will be inspected for properties with 16 or more units. • Mission: Ensuring an attractive, clean, safe community that enhances the quality of life and preserves the public trust COUNCIL ITEM MEMORANDUM Property Code and Nuisance Violations Criteria License Category Number of Units Property Code Violations per (Based on Property Inspected Unit Code Only) Type I — 3 Year 1 -2 units 0 -1 3+ units 0 -0.75 Type II — 2 Year 1 -2 units Greater than 1 but not more than 4 3 +units Greater than 0.75 but not: more than 15, Type III —1 Year 1 -2 units Greater than 4 but not more than 8 3 ±units Greater than l . 5 -but riot more than 3 Type IV — 6 Months 1 -2 units Greater than 8 3 ± units Greater than 3 b. Police Service Calls. Police call rates will be based on the average number of valid police calls per unit per year. Police incidences for purposes of determining licensing categories shall include • disorderly activities and nuisances as defined in Section 12 -911, and events categorized as Part I crimes in the Uniform Crime Reporting System including homicide, rape, robbery, aggravated assault, burglary, theft, auto theft and arson. Calls will not be counted for purposes of determining licensing categories where the victim and suspect are "Family or household members" as defined in the Domestic Abuse Act, Minnesota Statutes, Section 51813.01, Subd. 2 (b) and where there is a report of "Domestic Abuse" as defined in the Domestic Abuse Act, Minnesota Statutes, Section 51813.01, Subd. 2 (a). License Number of Units Validated Calls for Disorderly Conduct Category Service &Part I Crimes Calls Per Unit /Year No Category 1 -2 0 -1 Impact 3 -4 units 0 =0.25 , , ti 5 or more units 0 -0.35 Decrease 1 1 -2 Greater than I but not more than 3 Category 3. -4; unit`s Greater than 0;25 but not more than" 1- 5 or more units Greater than 0.35 but not more than 0.50 Decrease 2 1 -2 Greater than 3 Categories 3 -4 units , . Greater than L , - 5 or more units T Greater than 0.50 • Mission: Ensuring an attractive, clean, safe conununity that enhances the duality of life and preserves the public trust COUNCIL ITEM MEMORANDUM Budget Issues: • There are no budget issues to consider. Council Goals: Strategic: We will ensure a safe and secure community We will stabilize and improve residential neighborhoods Attachment - Mitigation Plan • Mission: Ensuring an attractive, clean, safe comnnunity that enhances the quality of life and preserves the public trust city Qf 9renldyn Center 6301 Shingle Creep Parkway Brooklyn Center, MN55436].2199 Fes 763- 569 - .1494 rt.�t���nrrueak��rx*at�r.,�, Rental License Mitigation Plan Qy]n IV License) Hand'writt'en P lans W11 not be accepted: Pl I'r'e or ttAb fil'farb1e form on 0. prebsfte. Properly Addrm: 3513 47th Ave. N. OvvmrNsmeo Bryant, LLC [-,opal Agent Hou sing Pius, Richard Grammes Owner Address: Agent address; $0 65 Jerson St_ NZ,,, umbla HeIgh#s UN 35421 HowSing Plu3 25V Perin Ave K, RAnnesrm]is MN W1 O wner Phone. � -� � -��1�� Agent l'ltottc O wner Em a 1 l: housing1 lus6co east.ne# ► crti l�iita It itadtaslrt p t!u rn t.rt t The above re.t�rejtced property qualii cs for a Type IV Rental License. A Mitigation Plan mosi bic completed and reviewed ley Citystaf'f' b6orc the rental lice -pt*e application can be considered for approval by City Council- A Mitigation Plan should ittd:icate the steps bein takers to correct WentiCted iol4tons and the measures that will lie take ii to ensure ongoing compliance with City C 411ance.s and applicable Codas, Tltc Mitigation Plait provider. an opportunity to review prop conowis an-d identi possible solutions to imp rove rave the ov ialt conditions of the .i 5 Yi� U13n it the following documents will.: the Mitigation Plan for approved. 1. Crime Fret Nousing Program Training Certificate (if completed. if not completed, please include • �� scheduled date in Section B. I Copy of Lease including Knoesola Crime Free Housing Lease Addendum - 3. Submit uTinen report by tO of each month (after license approval), ens . ,.; _. 1�3t�se p 1. [Ise written lEase ITICALGdin.gCrime Free Housing [.ease t`iddNttlr1111. 2. Coridree crionina.t ba-A round chook for all prospective- teraarats. Provide documentation to City if reqaested, 3. Pttrstee the evict art I teptiaitts wlto v'iol!ate tl terra$ ofMe leas- or any addendums. 4. Attend City approved eight )tour Crinte T e Housing course. Bate Curse Completed: DateCour3e Schedu led: : 1V11111 Phase [l Complete, Secunly Assessment and implement all security itttprowements recommended b y the Brooklyn Center Police Department. Comte Scheduled.: GWI 1 tittpTovera eatstct beacontpleted by: 110131/11 page I Type W Mitigation Plan 4-11 i [will attend .n m- inimtarn of 50 of the ARM mertiings (fiYc) i. [ „ 6iadul�cd 7 t �] attend the � � for 'ca � � � �� _ _ � iine t n�_ rr�r�_ I wiI1 havc no repeat code violations previowdydm within the past scar_ For prop riks nr ith fow or nwre r,rults I wi ecaiidact tesident tiu1ing annually that includcs +cran3c previention tm-liniques. i wi fiald rtgular resident meeliiVs. Date Last Rcplaced Futare Replacement Date FurnarcJAC WaW.r Ilealta t td��ij Laundry App lianccs + ro 4tnw NIA -Sher! NIA • .04-wage, 14had * kde%w N - - Fl spirt' sae d OlhCr_ _Ii '1 albs" Ilfii, - _�KI'^pi�l t?iat�+i,ill' Iinplamenting 11w following best pfmices mina assist it] the inana Bement of your prbper _ By rhecki z eke bore hWaw, yotj -agrw raj: Viheek; jo witl3 tenairils a % • 30 48) _ rEtie by pwparty to CIK% For violations twit u rricarttl _ ENlet tenants: in wiuiatirri of the, lease and in i addendiims. Elio -vl service Fliesride &ubage wtvice, _ Install S stern. wide nvirntwanm service plan for appl iances Name of wry ice company« I ant and will retitaiii etarreiit on pyiyrris -rat of Utility fares, tames. nssessnl €m Ane5. peopicies ansl t Item *+ fuwncial Claims clue W the Cityi Othef .f—aiiaw- Ho uslna Pius we two amachad i If 0 TMw IV Re I License is appronvd by the City Obunci the Lioensee crust comply w ith ibe approved istlitigMion P1 an. and all app! [cable city Mies. No knor thari tlic I e- of each calendar munth. ific licrosm roust subinh io the Building and Comijaiinci:y Saaadar* Deparimcm a written report desdribiAg al i saeps taken to oamps - with the Mitigation Plan- ] Vmify that all information pravided abo% is (r.L c and aciourate. f understand that Irl ale tart comply Rage 2 Type IV Mitigation Plan 4 11 • • with arl Ap rm ifigati; Pl an enforcume nt ac ions such as ciu- rion, format complaint or license m iew may result, Richa Grommes, President. Hout ng Plug Owner or Agent Nees and Title (PIMse Pdo Maw Pate 3 T% , Pc- 1V NINuation Pbut 4-1 • Housing l • fiajusIrW mn agenw a awkes Oce 1979, rental, repair & dab Rental Screening-Procedu I At Ic-ast ihFw +cars of indepseraleiit rental hlsi ary (not renting from friends or rcladv%) wrilr at lost a Ye U $t crich address if multiple addr s_ a No lords vful detainers iin the pas[ Fite gears. (fit W gptiow.can be made for one explainable UD). significant atrimirtil arm t gord in ai last fnTy=& carpans, driA s. ai As qualify applicant ffram any of our a'++'ail tple apuffl nis) . felrrny convictions in the last 5 years Irr4o me wliftlt` aF(nrdablse housing, guidelines (approx. 3 tires tem lot groan, monthly lrwamc) Ap plktlibn VW40 do-ri as Verify ownership of the piopmy that ;applicant says they Its been living at. This is usually deme thtoogb 1=lennepirt County Property TaA MI lm m�ent toad hrlirtnr; i* Rental LAct rse Ddi) -.trtn rtr. If 10 Minng*pt N5, tl - ptoperty must have A current m alal Ikense. We must be able to trbtain good refcrenc^cs from the menial propdM, owner or !heir m ent company— Obtain it 911 ` P flat the p" Clue appLicant is moving lam, Ariy party Calls. 10%l l Music 0 lfOM donmsde lssucs, narMtics, wcapons. or other criminal beheu+ior &0& would rlisquiilify the applicant from .a of our available apartrmnts. • Check for any crinyinaI history or arm at records. Verify employment arxVor it?conie source. OWIP a art from Rental Raw -arch SCFV6M to VIMiily. A&IMSWS a PM'04t lIU$ l'VO l at. rflt hlstcr Y- "a' Wf ril deisinars filed. autd' any known publ is recrmds, Any false information is. aurtcarnatic .grounds for lejeVion. Th relercores are generally more difficult to check. hou r the saTm laic pure outlined above is still used. If ownership of property cAn that be veri fied ownugh city or oaunq mdrdt, praperty tax Slaternewi3 or pfpeTty deed, we can not e'er an applicant an arpa[trr ent. Criminal history clrecltia sire�obiMr&We thirtugh se%wal screening sources and 911 Recap repeats are sometimes auayal�le_ rimina-1 History Check (Minneapolis-) - 671- Community Crime 1'tevendoWS - 67-1-3015 Minmapolis 9 11 Reap - 675 Hennepin Courity Property `fox Mpsn - 3413 -3411 Ramsay County I'rota rly Ixpt, — 651-266-2 Minneapolis Rental l mnse D ept_ - 673 -5B% %m€rnl al3ca 6tl flirt cl • (612) 522-W94 I-1oWng Plus Fax: (612) 521-:M4 a =- Penn Ave.. N. E-Ma. gmrrtmesdi@cs.com 11?l nneaptdls WIN 55412 AGENDA CITY COUNCIL /ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY WORK SESSION August 22, 2011 Immediately Following Regular City Council and EDA Meetings Which Start at 7:00 P.M: Council Chambers City Hall A copy of the full City Council packet is available to the public. The packet ring binder is located at the front of the Council Chambers by the Secretary. ACTIVE DISCUSSION ITEMS 1. Public Art Proposal 2. Presidential Invite 3. Graduated Sanitary Utility Rate Study PENDING LIST FOR FUTURE WORK SESSIONS Later /Ongoing 1. National League of Cities.Service Line Program 2. Progress Reports on Achievement of Strategic Goals 3. School District Discussions /BC Strategic Plan Report • 4. Sister City Update 5. Active in Liv g Prog ram 6. Annual Department Year End Reports 7. Garbage Hauler Organized Collection Update — October 8. Youth Participation Request — October 9. Neighborhood Designations — December 10. Highway 252 Update — 2012 • Work Session Agenda Item No. I i i MEMORANDUM - COUNCIL WORK SESSION DATE: August 22, 2011 TO: Curt Boganey, City Manager FROM: Gary Eitel, Director of Business and Development' Brian Peters, Police Commander SUBJECT: Continued Discussion on the Public Art Proposal Recommendation: It is recommended that the City Council consider providing direction to staff regarding Public Art ,Proposal by the Brooklyn Center School District to have an art mural painted on the interior face of the MnDOT Sound Wall adjacent to the Earle Brown' Elementary School. Background: On August 8, 2011, the City Council discussed a proposal by the Brooklyn Center School District in conjunction with Mentoring Peace Through Art to paint an anti - graffiti art mural on approximately_ 1400 linear feet of the interior face of the MnDOT Sound Wall adjacent to the Earle Brown Elementary School and Grandview Park. The Council discussed the provisions of the existing sign ordinance; the proposal to place an art mural on the Hwy. 100 sound wall adjacent to the Earle Brown Elementary School and Grandview Park; the requirements by MnDOT for City approval and future maintenance responsibilities, potential issues associated with the First Amendment (freedom of speech), and discussion on amending the sign ordinance to allow public art in public spaces. . The consensus of the Council was to continue consideration to allow the City Attorney to review the City's Ordinances and offer an opinion on the Public Art Proposal. Attached for your reference is a copy of the August 8th Work Session staff memorandum and PowerPoint related to this discussion. Amending the Sign Ordinance to Allow Public Art: Enclosed is a copy of the information provided by the City Attorney which comments on the First Amendment (freedom of speech) and how this amendment relates to both signage and the free expression through artwork. The memo indicates that if the Council feels that it is in the public interest to allow murals to be displayed as public artwork, that an amendment to the sign ordinance could be created which would make an exception only for public art murals prepared, created, and maintained by a public entity. The City Attorney does indicate that the Council would be very limited in its ability to regulate • the contents of the art and the protection against the display of material that might not be in the Mission: Ensuring an attractive, clean, safe community that enhances the quality of life andpreserves the public trust MEMORANDUM - COUNCIL WORK SESSION public interest would rely on the ability of public bodies proposing the art mural to exercise • reasonable judgment in the public art that they display. The example of a sign ordinance amendment provided by the City Attorney included the following provisions: 1. That the art is displayed on property owned and controlled by a political subdivision of the State of Minnesota, 2. That the art is approved and authorized by a political subdivision of the State, 3. That the political subdivision has accepted responsibility for the maintenance of the artwork, 4. That the location of the artwork is limited to locations (the example provided was a distance or view from residential land uses): Public Art Proposal by Brooklyn Center School District: Superintendent. Keith Lester has provided' the attached correspondence relating to their proposed application to MnDOT and acknowledgement that the School District would be responsible for the surface maintenance, including removal of any future graffiti Superintendent Lester has also indicated that the School District will maintain control on this proposed public art project and has indicated that they will not allow anything that doesn't "fit" Earle Brown and the City. Policy Issues: Does the City Council support an amendment to the sign ordinance that would allow the public art with specific provisions? Council Goals: Ongoing: 5. We will improve the image of the City with citizens and those outside of the City's borders • Mission: Ensuring tin attractive, clean, safe coinmun t)J that enhances the quality of life andpreserves the public trust • 0 Gary Eitei From: LeFevere, Charlie L. [clefevere @Kennedy- Graven.com] Sent: Tuesday, August 16, 2011 11 :02 AM_ To: Gary Eitel Cc: Curt Boganey; Vickie Schleuning Subject: Murals Attachments: Duluth mural source of controversy MPR.mht; LA Sign Ordinance.doc; New Motion Seeks To Identify L_A_'s Murals As Art, Not Signs Departures.mht; West Palm Beach ordinance - Art in Public Place.mht Gary, At the last council meeting I said would review and give further consideration to the question whether the city could amend its ordinances in some way that would allow the painting of murals as an exception to the City's sign ordnance. Following this email is an email from Melissa Manderschied of my office that provides some information about the attachments to this email. The attached materials may be of interest to staff or the Council, but I believe that the immediate question is simply whether the City can amend its sign ordinance to allow a proposed mural. It appears that there are a number of cities that allow painting of murals on buildings. However, the First Amendment protection that is given to freedom of speech greatly limits the ability of government to limit speech (which would include free expression through artwork) on the basis of its content. The government can place reasonable restrictions on the time place and manner of speech, but with very few exceptions, cannot regulate the content of that speech. I assume that it is for that reason that most cities (at least in my experience) impose limits on signs. If a city prohibits all murals, its regulation is not specific to content and therefore may be permissible if it is reasonable and has a legitimate public purpose. A city could allow murals without regard to content under limited circumstances such as limiting the zones where they are allowed, size of murals, setbacks from streets, and the like — again without regulating the signs based on content. However, if the Council felt that it was in the public interest to allow murals to be displayed as public artwork but not to open the door to allow murals to be erected by private property owners, we believe that it would be permissible for the Council to make an exception to the sign ordinance only for public art murals prepared, created and maintained by a public entity. The Council would still be very limited in its ability to regulate the content of the art, but it would be some protection against the display of material that might not be in the public interest if the exception applied only to public bodies, which might be expected to exercise reasonable judgment in the public art that they displayed. For example, the City could adopt an ordinance that would exempt signs that were works of public provided that: 1. The art is displayed on property owned and controlled by a political subdivision of the ' State of Minnesota; 2. The art is approved and authorized by a political subdivision of the State; 3. The political subdivision has accepted responsibility for the maintenance of the artwork; 4. The location of the artwork is limited to, for example, locations that are not within a certain distance from, or perhaps are not visible from properties that are zoned or used for residential purposes. Let me know if you have any follow -up questions. Charlie Charles L. LeFevere Kennedy and Graven, Chartered 470 U. S. Bank Plaza 1 Gary Eitei From: Keith Lester [KLester @brookcntr.k12.mn.us] Sent: Monday, August 15, 2011 5:18 PM To: Gary Eitel Subject: Letter To whom it may concern: Brooklyn Center Schools is excited and proud to be participating with Jimmy Longoria and Connie Fullmer with "Mentoring Peace Through Art" with the painting of the sound barrier wall behind Earle Brown Elementary School. To be able to take a frequently vandalized wall and use it to express art and the Brooklyn Center Community is very fitting for a Community School District. It is my understanding that the Minnesota Department of Transportation would like confirmation that we would maintain the wall after it has been painted. We will be happy to do so with the understanding that we will maintain only the surface area painted by "Mentoring Peace Through Art and their volunteers. We feel strongly that we want the message and the aesthetics considered in this project to be maintained at the highest levels. Structural maintenance would continue to be the responsibility of the DOT. Brooklyn Center Community Schools has had the pleasure of partnering with a variety of agencies— public, non - profit and for - profit — in making our schools a better place for our children. It is a pleasure to join with the City of Brooklyn Center and the Minnesota Department of Transportation in partnership to make our city an even better place to live, work and attend school. Thank you. Keith E. Lester, Superintendent Brooklyn Center Community Schools 6500 Humboldt Ave. N. Brooklyn Center, MN 55430 Phone: (763) 561 -2120 x1000 Fax: (763) 560 -2647 1 i k j MEMORANDUM - COUNCIL WORK SESSION •` DATE: August 8 2011 TO: CurtBoganey, City Manager FROM: Gary Eitel, Director of Business & Development Brian Peters, Police Commander SUBJECT: Allowance of Public Art on State Sound Walls Recommendation: It is recommended that the City Council provide direction to staff regarding the approval of public art on a sound wall. Background: Staff has received a request to paint an artistic mural along the sound wall between Highway 100 and Earle Brown Elementary School. This sound wall has been subject to repeat graffiti and vandalism. The Brooklyn Center School District in conjunction with Mentoring Peace Through Art is proposing to paint a mural on the wall facing the school with the intention of preventing further vandalism. Another project goal is to promote student, parent and community involvement as they participate in planning and painting the mural. Prior to painting the wall, Minnesota Department of Transportation requires a resolution from the City approving the mural and a permit for Miscellaneous Work on Trunk Highway Right of Way. The permit would be submitted by Brooklyn Center School District. The following is a summary of the proposed public art project: • The wall is approximately 1400 feet long by 8 feet high. The mural would extend along this whole area. • The wall is located behind Earle Brown Elementary School, extending to the City owned property. Please refer to the attached location map. • The mural would reflect a quilt pattern style that was designed by the students based on previous art work. No words would be used or offensive images. Please refer to the attached photo for an example.'Mentoring Peace Through Art has produced many designs like this around the metropolitan area. Some examples include the Hopkins Arts Building, Cristo Rey Jesuit High School and walls at 38 Ave. S. /Bloomington Ave. S. and Lake Street/ Clinton Ave. S. • The costs of labor and materials for the mural project would be assumed by the school district and other private funds. • Any required maintenance of the mural would be the responsibility of the school district and Mentoring Peace Through Art. The existing sound wall would need some preparation prior to painting, which would be completed by Mentoring Peace. i Mission. Ensuring an attractive, clean, safe coznnutido� that enhances the 2ualiy of life and preserves the prcblic trztst i MEMORANDUM - COUNCIL WORK SESSION Policy Issues: r •:� What are the regulations pertaining to this request? Is this mural considered a sign? •e• How will this type of public art affect the image of the city? I.e. Reduction of graffiti versus aesthetics and message of murals. Where and under what circumstances should murals of this type be allowed? I.e. State sound walls •:� What precedent, if any, will approval of this project set? Council Goals: Ongoing: 5. We will improve the image of the City with citizens and others Attachments: - Location Map - Photos • Mission: Ensuring an attractive, clean, safe •community that enhances the quality of life and preserves the public trust i i MEMORANDUM - COUNCIL WORK SESSION Attachment- Location Map The red line indicates the location of the sound wall. 1DD .� .. . f !� V rr i Allssion: Ensue tg an aftrac'tive, clean, safe conmxtuity that enhances the quality of life and preserves the public hest MEMORANDUM - COUNCIL WORK SESSION Attachment H: Photos F . VI ♦ r .p a y i 1' • A6lission: Ensuring 1u1 auractiYL', clean, safe CO1111111111141' that enhances the grlalio) of life andpresen es thepublic trust �.� � _ '� �• •'a i �.� y } I K�y� ti�� e w _ �� •� � • Quilt Pattern Design Example: I � M r f +t�. l ip• �� * ��'' t i � � T ���x ' l�� i r ' ax Rte �•' - rt+�:i v ,: y� >t ^T•J��� lam- 1 .Y ..�.� - -� '•- '��li.`.�„_v� 4J.�I • PUBLIC ART DISCUSSION Ci Council ork Session August 8, 2011 (MnDOT Sound Wall /Earle Brown Elementary School) WliiU IJh 'JJIJWOJJIGIWJJi EMMSMIMMENEEMMEMOMINOMMOMM MD k D o � O aC iro u 0 ❑ The Brooklyn Center School District in conjunction with Mentoring Peace Through Art is proposing to paint a mural on the wall facing the school with the intention of preventing further vandalism. ❑ Another project goal is to promote student, parent and community involvement as they participate in planning and painting the mural. ❑ Minnesota Department of Transportation requires a resolution from p p q the City a p p r oving ty pp g oven the mural and a permit for Miscellaneous Work on Trunk Highway Right of Way. ❑ The permit would be submitted by Brooklyn Center School District • • 'Ili�� Iu:' Illiu IA 'I;I,LCIUWII ICG;LL'IIW'I' ' i IC; 10� i [It 1111 a u I 1 A 1 1 �IIII�ll�N���I�IIII�V�III�Ii�I�B818111�11111IDWlil�l�fl�@ II�IIIIIIII111111��iII�I�II�III�11 1P��mauur�i�uu�uauu�mii�u�im�ui�iii�u�u� »�iii�u�i MnDOT SOUND a� r WALL • ti (red solid line) J ' 4 ". • 415 —ft. R�23, is f A o s o o o feet adjoins s a ,p Earle Brown 1°YS Elementary s t % 415 feet adjoins Grand View � nw irk G' nJv Park Do �n Jars -., "�. ! Barn arc u } } r r� wk I:u ecn 7n:4Mdt�5 Cad 9'L -•-_ „`[. -_�. ,.�., _ ,..�1:.. _ ..a.!!D._ `� . ?-e .... .:. :: ;.: r....ill! {� +, {I {ai �tl i {{ i {li {iuI•. �.� ! {1 I,nt { 611II I,IIi ,, I, till ll�1llV�0, ��I�l��I�I�II�I�II�HgI�IJII�➢ I��IIIIIIIIIIiiV�mllVilillliiiilloilllVVuitlullillllililiiliG��uu��umuimm�uumum ° 111111 ° "� � �j �� MnDOT Wall — Hwy loo (Outside) View 1 I SAW 5 � r • ,rte ��• �� •y, tB S'. d' '� �' •.!� S "°''� ��"..� ,�•� Mo ,� y' s� �,•_ ' ; i 4 ,� r .� -`�a � J:' t J�. t;. y Rd 13 .�d ` ��t�� (v�� �i S ���� �' 7 t � � t O • - ��" ...I r; v, Gt b J �i1. r y F 1 a •t 4 fi t; A� J � � i � � J�?,, "` .. �A Spa{ 4+:��;, � �� ���..'.� ,_ _ h: MnDOT • Insi Tr mot . 1 ♦ - x F �.I 9 �-.� � m ak Ilk _ t ,' '� ,�'rl� _ � �, ' ... - � seer•' ".,,1.,. _-ice — •� • a• rte, ,e 'h III IIIit frf` {6f t.C�`IIEE� t.{IG�G'16iliI�I'I' I(( I( IIIiIINI�IBf�IIIIIII IIII ;' '� � " " " ° "'� �' ' �'�' � � i� �' i l� Pedestrian Ramp & Bridge over Hwy. 100 w. 'uW, dd' ''iu. wn IL "'f.iLil.ilr,IlWL u.,y:Cll .hill 'u -'F l,wuwllilill,,luili / �. innn,uum.uu:���uu,,,,,,,mii ua „ei wm:anaewnuu .um wuw mnum m:u um uu au .::u ,:mua:u::nu� ti: umuunu nnu muny�!i�.��, :n l!�; I, L !i1 1 t.t a; Trail Connector into Earle Brown Elem. pip” Impom r 1 10zOa 1 10 c 4 :r i Clean Interior Wall w/ Areas I . y Nr_. aA Ln ✓ K+1'.� ��� � ': 't h . 9 � -i 4 � . � � 3 1 ,�+ .. � � f p� � -� �i � "+ r Kra q r♦ ,. � ,� � : � t , ` , � ,: u�c1„ �4�,�: o-1,:i l - � !tnm�:, t i G .�.,�.iu,�itWU t dl f tl,�IiilluPu,iliillu�lilllll 1U�UIUILnIL II I tItIUIIII illimi6,Ill f iIlIUIItIitIWI1NINIli I11111IIII I i fl II IiIIIIi, IUIIIIII11116II ' ilil 11111111 i IIW 111111 li I i I II ;11 i � U IOUd II II II II I U UUII W II �'. � "3 uutumntnm I nn ttmuunmu wt mw tmtt nt t ttt i t tni t u t 4 III7glITILII U 11' i" IIu�NJIllII�V�IIIV�I�I�illil�)> P1 �11�111101��! �V81»]1 ��) l> IP�I��I��ID�lll���mii�umnumuiiiiiruiiiiiiiii�iuui�iimiiiuuimum�� pu Field Fencing I I I _ I e —s ;!i I i HlMi I RR U UT I mm Interior Wall w/ adjacent trail & ball field fencing EA57 WEST � Humboldt Ave v,�� Yo *� -'r ��: F..��(��Y���i *mot [ 5 � t 4.:} i �` � �- 9�.. f ' i — C . i i µ • .•t •. ", J". }.�� of I j •ls , � . _ „".�.�'t�l 7 ,i gt a�!c �i� 1�1 - �7�•,� � ['. 1 �y ' � �' )l, i()i �l - iN 1 Y f ? 07/ 1 '`."., . ok 1 i • '� F "` 3t Y� sl � � M t y wv t lo,J � ; ' 1 a (f /i1 k � i - ML•y L� �. ♦ � r ��`� -_�'.. �, .` ! jF� ,lq I lk l it q Alf c� ,I h t { 4j t _ �� � � � is a � a' a'. •�"Z�r� ` � ". � � i ; �iS�� ". .; , � tip. ; �, , }�,• � .� � � � . cF•,• :� � s� ,, "v -- i t ti `t , a t'`c ,j a � a � �L. � •, ,fi � ja t I \ � r 1 k A k• L ��• =4T a�1 -�5 �� 11i• �.� L.� ?Tt �r , l � �, { � �,�+ 1 IL f C ' "A. �.+ �'• `{.. tai t `('� - • i • Vm�,�!uia!,�uii�!1111 1711',' 11lllllllll�lllIIIIIIGIII! I! I! I! I! I! I! 1pVllPlnlu l4�lllViliiifiill�iillNl�! �lll( �Il�! I�����uumuuumu�u�mm��uumu��uitiva�u�u�i� ..����u�.,H��,� „ul,l� flit �� 1 „ �,, SIGN ORDINANCE S ign — Any publicly displayed message- bearing device for visual communication or any attention attracting device that is used primarily for the purpose of bringing the subject thereof to the attention of the public including any banner, pennant, symbol, valance or similar display. Section 34 -130. PROHIBITED SIGNS. 2. Signs within the public right -of -way or easement; provided, however, that the following signs in the public right -of -way or easement are not prohibited: a. government installed signs. b. signs denoting an architect, engineer, contractor, or owner meeting the requirements of Section 34- 140.2.d. c. campaign signs meeting the requirements of Section 34- 140.2.f. d. real estate signs meeting the requirement of Section 34- 140.2.1.1. e. rummage sales signs meeting the requirements of Section 34- 140.2.m. f. noncommercial opinion or expression signs meeting the requirements of Section 34-140.2.n IIulWilii4iN(iW!i!tlWlil k!!!iu!il!l!!h!li lll!: In! H: 14 !11412r.!n!!!nu.11lllll!lullll duunliuuA!dnw Nln.nl� IILi !IF u, t !i;id:iUtN.illiniinlll!InAi!iHW � ;y l ip , �VIII��Gl �lilll�l ll�➢ IIIIIIIIill P11�11�1��1�lilGll�ll11�11ll ll�i{ �Illlllllllll➢ II�IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIVIIVII�III�II��uumiiiiimmuiiiiiiiiiiuuuiimiiiiiuu�iiiiimiiiii�iimiiimuiim , ii PROHIBITED SIGNS (Continued) 11. Off - Premises Advertising Signs except as otherwise permitted by Section 34 -140 and Section 35 -800 of the City Ordinances. Signs advertising a business no longer operating on the premises shall be deemed off - premises advertising signs and must be abated in accordance with Section 34- 140.1.j. 12. Signs painted directly on building walls. 13. All other signs not expressly permitted by this ordinance. NOTE: Public Art or similar is not defined or regulated in the Ordinance � • i ❖ The mural would reflect a quilt pattern style that was designed by the students based on previous art work. No words would be used or offensive images. The following photo provides an example. ❖ Mentoring Peace Through Art has produced many designs like this around the metropolitan area. Some examples include: • the Hopkins Arts Building; • Cristo Rey Jesuit High School; and • walls at 38th Ave. S. /Bloomington Ave. S. and Lake Street/ Clinton Ave. S. ❖ The costs of labor and materials for the mural project would be assumed by the school district and other private funds. ❖ Any required maintenance of the mural would be the responsibility of the school district and Mentoring Peace Through Art. The existing sound wall would need some preparation prior to painting, which would be completed by Mentoring Peace. Y , • wd � w ; :�� F i r c ;k biO I, - v I C 4_j r---1 � yr, .r • � � •. � :1. ° a �. •, �� , ,� t a � �I LI .t a q2 may _ .• '� �. f �, - r . 1 - r _ Brighten the future of B {Center! Jain Mentoring Peace Through Art and Brooklyn Center community leaders as we paint the sound wall behind Earle Brown School with images of children's art and imagination, while at the same time blocking out gang graffiti. Bring your family, friends, and neighbors to fill in the bright future of your city. Visit our web site or call us for more details on the project: Mentoringpeace.org 952935 -4717 i itUll�lti"{ i„ yp� ,Uiµp'vi�IM'�UIU...iHki'eNilt WIIIAII9Ui� NUI➢ 4clHfliII111N1AH{: NW! uUNt1i�WI�: 01LgA {litlNtl @IBNNdINiIiNNfl9Nitl:ININ fiflW !LWWININiIII {flilUilfNINtUU!NN IINIIIIIIIaiNIN111111iII11II; Ili11NAM�I11II1�1111i�i {01NtN011ii111 {NItNI1AI IIINAI IA {IWI {IHIIINI!IINIHfIiBiGHl!II Ai8 {illNifP.11N Policy ❖ ""hat are the regulations pertaining to this request? Is this mural considered a sign? ❖ How will this type of public art affect the image of the city? (i.e. reduction of graffiti versus aesthetics and message of murals.) ❖ Where and under what circumstances should murals of this type be allowed? (i.e. State sound walls) ❖ What precedent, if any, will approval of this project set? Duluth mural source of controversy I State of the Arts Minnesota Public Radio Page 1 of 3 NEWS THE CURRENT CLASSICAL Archive Events Member info Support Shop About us ISearch MPR GO ews Friday, August 12, 2011 Mobile 69° in Twin Cities Newsletters (more cities) RSS Feeds Weather Report) Podcasts Member Supported Join Now) Traffic Report, State of the Arts° with Marianne Combs ► < MN Poetry. Rao Phi's "Waiting for a Cyclo in the Hood" I Main I Northern Clay Center names Sarah Millfelt as new director> Duluth mural source of controversy Posted at 3:29 PM on August 4, 2011 by Marianne Combs (5 Comments) Filed under. Arts around the state, Public Art Evidently one man's art is another man's "inner city crap." Bob King/ rking @duluthnews.com Christa Lawler of the Duluth News Tribune reports work has been stalled on a mural in Cascade Park titled "Unity in Community" because, well, the community doesn't think it's very pretty. "It's the same kind of things that they arrest people for," said Dan Williams, who owns rental property across the street from Cascade Park where work on the mural began last week. "It's graffiti. It's not a craft. It's not art. If it was a mural of quality I wouldn't say anything about it." "It's going to affect my property value," Williams goes on to say later in the article. "It's going to look like inner -city crap." According to Lawler's story, the mural - painted mostly by children - is based on a similar technique employed by St. Paul artist Ta- Coumba Aiken, who painted a mural in the student union at the College of St. Scholastica this winter. The mayor has called a meeting with folks on both sides of the debate to determine whether the project should move forward, or be painted over. My colleague Bob Collins is taking votes on whether or not the unfinished mural is art. What do you think? Art or eyesore? (Poll Closed) Art 63.04% 016 votes) Eyesore 28.8% (53 Votes) I don't know 8.15% (15 votes) • Total Votes: 184 mhtml:file: / /C:\Documents and Settings \geitel \Local Settings \Temporary Internet Files \Co... 8/16/2011 New Motion Seeks To Identify L.A.'s Murals As Art, Not Signs I Departures I SoCal Focu... Page 2 of 13 New Motion Seeks To Identify L.A.'s Murals As Art, Not Signs http: / /www.kcet.org /updaily /socal focus /departures /new -motion -seeks -to- identify -las- mura Is-as -art- not- signs- 34436.html) by Ed Fuentes (http: / /www.kcet.org /user /profile /efuentes) on June 15, 2011 5:25 PM f �T *p This post is in support of Departures ( http:/ /www.kcet.orglsocalldeparturesl) KCET's oral history D and interactive documentary project about Los Angeles neighborhoods. The series comments on cultural history and urban issues through the lens of community profiles, such as Venice (http: //www. kcet. orp/socal /departures /venice/) The art of large -scale storytelling is struggling in the very city that shaped the craft. Cultural identity in Los Angeles was once about neighborhoods having a voice on walls. But those urban canvases have been shadowed by commercial media, and the decades -old imagery has faded under sun, painted over by red tape, or tagged into oblivion. All told, L.A. streets as a source and inspiration for outdoor murals is vanishing. • mhtml:file://C: \Documents and Settings \geitel \Local Settings \Temporary Internet Files \Co... 8/16/2011 New Motion Seeks To Identify L.A.'s Murals As Art, Not Signs I Departures I SoCal Focu... Page 3 of 13 Now artistic and civic Angelenos want to restore the silent walls, despite being buried under ordinances that came from legal clutter interpreting free speech. • The current charge up the hill is led by City Councilmember Bill Rosendahl, whose District 11 includes Venice (http: / /www.kcet.org /socal /departures /venice /) home to the grand mural tradition (http: / /www.kcet.orcilsocal/ departures /vouthvoices /venice /murals /) with works from artists and institutions like Rip Cronk, Jane Golden, Los Angeles Fine Arts Squad, Emily Winters, and the Social and Public Art Resource Center (SPARC). On June 1, Rosendahl introduced a motion ( http:// cityclerk. lacity. orci/lacityclerkconnectrindex.cfm? fa= ccfi.viewrecord&cfnumber -11 -0923) to have the city of Los Angeles develop a "legally- defensible method" that would encourage murals to be created; in part by defining mural content as art, separating it from commercial signage. If the city departments of Planning, Building and Safety, Cultural Affairs, and the City Attorney come to a consensus on how outdoor images with commercial intent, "supergraphics" and billboards would not overlap with those containing artistic intent. As of now, the term mural is forced to share an identity with large -scale outdoor advertising, thanks to a 2002 ordinance that refers to the outdoor visual medium as "mural signs." "Advertising may be artful, but it is not the same as art," said Rosendahl days after his motion was filed. "They deserve to be viewed separately from commercial signage. It's not about selling soap. Murals are an expression - -the stories - -of communities." • Watch one more video of Emily Winters in Departures: Venice here ( http : //www.kcet.ora /socaUdepartures /venice /artsand- beatslemily- winters - -- muralistand- activist.htmll Emily Winters ( http: / /www.kcet.org /socal /departures/venice /arts- and - beats /emily- winters - -- muralist -and- • activist.htmil is the renowned Venice -based muralist known for "Jaya" (1975) and "Endangered Species" (1990), two murals produced through the SPARC's Neighborhood Pride Program and the Cultural mhtml:file://C: \Documents and Settings \geitel \Local Settings \Temporary Internet Files \Co... 8/16/2011 Work Session Agenda Item No. 2 • 1 _ COUNCIL ITEM MEMORANDUM • DATE: August 22 2 g 011 . TO: Curt Boganey, City Manager FROM: Vickie Schleuning, Assistant City Manager/Director of Building & Community Standards SUBJECT: Continued Discussion Invitation to President Obama Recommendation: It is recommended that the City Council consider providing direction to staff regarding a new draft of the letter inviting President Obama to the city of Brooklyn Center. Background: The City Council has previously directed Staff to prepare a letter inviting President Obama to the city. A second draft of the letter is provided that incorporates suggestions by the City Council at the August 8; 2011 Work Session. A copy of the first draft is also included for reference. Please provide additional feedback and direction. • Budget Issues: There are no budget issues to consider. Attachments: • Invite Letter Draft 1 • Invite Letter Draft 2 Mission: Ensuring an attractive, clean, safe community that enhances the quality of life and preserves the public trust DRAFT #2 • August 23, 2011 President Barack Obama Email: comments @whitehouse.gov The White House 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington, DC 20500 Dear President Obama: On behalf of the City of Brooklyn Center, I would like to cordially invite you to visit our City. In many ways, we represent the All American City. We are a first -ring suburb of Minneapolis with a diverse population of 30,000. This year, the City celebrates its 100 years of incorporation with a year -long community celebration. Although we are experiencing some of the same challenges as other cities in our country, we are also successfully meeting our goals in the spirit of strategy, innovation and dedication. A few reasons to visit us include: ➢ The Regional FBI Field Office is under construction with completion anticipated in • p p February 2012. It will meet the new federal design standards. ➢ Federal stimulus funds were used to help maintain infrastructure as well as stimulate economic development through our Bass Lake Road Streetscape project. Other aspects incorporated into the project included livable community features such as trails, pedestrian areas, and environmentally - friendly design. ➢ Along the Bass Lake Road Streetscape project, an 800,000 square foot redevelopment project is underway, one of the few retail development projects to occur in the metropolitan area within the past three years. ➢ Our community has been recognized many years for our citizen engagement programs, from National Night Out events to Multicultural Resource Programs. ➢ Innovative neighborhood approaches based on a Four -Step Foreclosure Strategy are helping to revitalize neighborhoods through maintenance efforts, home purchase programs and Neighborhood Stabilization Preservation programs. ➢ Tour the historic Earle Brown Heritage Center, a premier conference and event center beautifully restored to preserve the city's rich history, yet providing modern technology and conveniences. ➢ Enjoy a cup of coffee or brew at Caribou Coffee, headquartered in Brooklyn Center or Surly Brewing, a successful entrepreneur. The City has a mix of local to global businesses. • . President Barack Obama August 23, 2011 Page 2 Our city motto A Great Place to Start, a Great Place to Stay is a befitting description. We would be honored by your visit and would be excited to provide a tour of our City. For more information, please contact me at (763) 569 -3300 or mayorwillsonkci.brooklyn- center.mn.us Respectfully, Mayor Tim Willson cc: Senator Amy Klobuchar Senator Al Franken Representative Erik Paulsen • �- DRAFT #1 August 23, 2011 President Barack Obama Email: comments @whitehouse.gov The White House 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington, DC 20500 Dear President Obama: On behalf of the City of Brooklyn Center, I would like to cordially invite you to visit our City. In many ways, we represent the All American City. We are a first -ring suburb of Minneapolis with a diverse population of 30,000. This ear, the City celebrates its 100 ears of incorporation Y � �' years with a year -long community celebration. Although we are experiencing some of the same challenges as other cities in our country, we are also successfully meeting our goals in the spirit of strategy, gy, and dedication. A few reasons to i ' v srt us include: ➢ The Regional FBI Field Office is under construction with completion anticipated in February It will ary meet the new federal design standards.. ➢ Federal stimulus funds were used to help maintain infrastructure as well as stimulate economic development through our Bass Lake Road Streetscape project. Other aspects incorporated into the project included livable community features such as trails, pedestrian areas, and environmentally - friendly design. ➢ Along the Bass Lake Road Streetscape project, an 800,000 square foot redevelopment project is underway, one of the few retail development projects to occur in the .metropolitan area within the past three years. ➢ Our community has been recognized many years for our citizen engagement programs, from National Night Out events to Multicultural Resource Programs. ➢ Innovative neighborhood approaches based on a Four -Step Foreclosure Strategy are helping to revitalize neighborhoods through maintenance efforts, home purchase programs and Neighborhood Stabilization Preservation programs. Our city motto A Great Place to Start, a Great Place to Stay is a befitting description. We would be honored by your visit and would be excited to provide a tour of our City. For more information, please contact me at (763) 569 -3300 or mayorwillson @ci.brooklyn- center.mn.us Respectfully, Mayor Tim Willson cc: Senator Amy Klobuchar • Senator 1 A Frank en Representative Erik Paulsen • Work Session Agenda Item No. 3 MEMORANDUM - COUNCIL WORK SESSION DATE: 18 August 2011 TO: Curt Boganey, City Manager FROM: Daniel Jordet SUBJECT: Consumption sed Sewer Rate Project Update Recommendation: This memorandum is an update on the issues involved in converting from a flat rate sanitary sewer charge to a rate based on water consumption. Background: Water meter readings have become much more accurate since the installation of remote read meters throughout the City. The City Council has discussed developing a sanitary sewer utility rate based on use of water determined by those readings rather than the flat rate currently in place with a discount for senior citizens. When this project was last discussed with the Council, the desire for a rate heavily weighted toward consumption was discussed. Since then staff has been reviewing Brooklyn Center's documents including the 2005 rate study performed by Progressive Consulting Engineers. Staff has also obtained information from Bloomington about their rates and a copy of their recent study. In addition, a method for determining the water usage to be used as a basis for sewer charges must be determined. For many years, residential rates have been a flat fee per quarter, currently $ 63.87 per quarter ,for single family residential ($ 21.29 per month), $ 44.71 per quarter for apartments ($ 14.90 per month), and is discounted for senior citizens over age 62 with nor more than 2 people in the residence to $ 35.13 per quarter ($ 11.71 per month). Commercial and Industrial customers pay $ 2.57 per 1,000 gallons of water metered each quarter. Moving to a new rate based on consumption of water raises some issues for which alternative solutions should be considered. • Should all billing be calculated on metered water consumption or should the rate carry a fixed component? • Should the fixed component be different for residential than for Commercial and Industrial customers? • Should a Senior Rate continue to be offered? • How much shift will there be in the payment responsibility for sanitary sewer charges with a new system based on consumption? • How will such things as lawn watering and car washing for which metered water does not go into the sanitary sewer be addressed in the calculation of the sanitary sewer rate? • If a "winter quarter" rate is established, when will the winter quarter be? • • Will there be a minimum charge if the "winter quarter" shows no water usage? • Should the rate be progressive in the same manner as water rates? ?{Mission: Ensuring are attractive, clean, safe community that enhances the duality of life anti preserves the public trust MEMORANDUM - COUNCIL WORK SESSION • If summer use is lower than winter use should billing be adjusted to reflect the lower use? • Should "winter quarter" be used simply to establish the next four quarters of billing for • each customer based on their pattern of water usage? • Will the billing software support the rates that the City is considering? If not, is the City willing to pay for software modifications? Addressing these questions will require the development of some models that will demonstrate the differences between the current flat rate billing and a dynamic billing based on water consumption. Some of these models have been developed and will be presented for discussion at the 22 August 2011 City Council Work Session. Preferences of the Council determined during this work session will be used to develop the final rate structure proposal to be adopted with the I 2012 sanitary sewer budget and implemented as soon as is practicable. Budget Issues: Revenues must be stable and predictable in order to accomplish the operational and capital goals of the Fund. Changes in the rate structure that keep the revenues stable and lower the net charge for some customers will necessarily have to raise the net charge for others. Cost will be shifted rather than eliminated. The degree to which this will happen is an important factor in the rate considerations. Council Goals: 1. We will ensure the financial stability of the City. • • Mission: Ensuring an attractive, clean, safe community that enhances the qualitb' of life and preserves the public trust